Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Section 1:
Non-statutory guidance on dealing with complex psychological and An outline of
the key issues
emotional needs from the National Mental Health Development Unit
and the Department for Communities and Local Government Section 2:
Case studies
Section 3:
Acknowledgments Definitions and
We are very grateful indeed to the many colleagues around the country weblinks
who contributed so much to this guide. Section 4:
Particular thanks are offered to: Guidance and
good practice
Dr Nick Maguire, Chartered Clinical Psychologist and Deputy Director,
PG Dip/Cert in Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, University of Southampton Section 5:
Research
Robin Johnson, RJA Consultancy
Section 6:
Panos Vostanis, Professor of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, University of Leicester
Glossary
For further information on any aspect of the good practice guide please contact:
helen.keats@communities.gsi.gov.uk
1
Mental health
Good practice guide
Document map
Document map
This document is interactive and has been linked for easy navigation and use.
Link through pages using the document map below or the colour coded menus. Introduction
Section 1:
Introduction J New Directions Team Assessment 35 An outline of
The purpose of the guide 4 J Homeless Link Outcomes Programme 42 the key issues
Who is this guide for? 4 Schemes for young people 44
Section 2:
How to use the guide 5 J Intensive Fostering – Youth Justice Board 44
Case studies
J Family liaison pilots – Youth Justice Board 45
Section 1: An outline of the key issues J High support hostels – Depaul UK 46 Section 3:
The national policy context 8 Definitions and
J Kids Company, London 49
Importance of agencies working together 11 weblinks
J The Zone, Plymouth 51
New research and practice from pilot projects 13
High support schemes for adults 53 Section 4:
Issues for accommodation and support providers 15 J 90 Lancaster Street, Multiple Needs Unit, Guidance and
Importance of well-trained frontline staff 19 Birmingham 53 good practice
The Psychologically Informed Environment J Home Base – Community Housing and Therapy 55
approach (PIE) 20 Section 5:
J St George’s Crypt, Leeds 57
Drugs and alcohol 21 Research
J Leeds NFA Health Centre 59
Best practice tips 22 J Lifeworks – St Mungo’s psychotherapy service 60 Section 6:
Section 2: Case studies J Leicester Homeless Mental Health Service 63 Glossary
Clinical assessment tools 24 J The Old Theatre, Broadway, London 66
J Leeds Holistic Framework 25 Staff capacity building and support 68
J New Directions Assessment – J Coaching Skills Training Course – Foyer Foundation 68
South West London Mental Health NHS Trust 28 J Westminster Cognitive Behaviour Therapy Project 69
Å back more Æ 2
Mental health
Good practice guide
Document map
Document map
J The Department of Health's Knowledge and Section 4: Guidance and good practice
Understanding Framework 71 The psychologically informed environment (PIE) 88 Introduction
J Behaviour Support Service, Brighton and Hove 72 Reflective practice 91
J Art of Defusing training, Bedford 75 Personalisation pilots and invest to save 92 Section 1:
J Novas Scarman psychological skills training 76 J 1. Case studies from around England 93 An outline of
J Framework Housing Association, Nottingham 78 J 2. The case for investment 101 the key issues
J Young People in Focus: J 3. Longitudinal studies and evidence 108 Section 2:
health and wellbeing scheme 80
Working with people with complex needs 109 Case studies
Section 3: Definitions and weblinks CBT project, Derby Road, Southampton 113
Section 3:
Psychological disorders which can predict The use of medication 116
Definitions and
homelessness – some key definitions 81 Childhood experiences 116 weblinks
J Complex trauma 80 Collaboration models for complex trauma and
severe social exclusion 117 Section 4:
J Personality disorder 80
Guidance and
J Post traumatic stress disorder 81 Section 5: Research good practice
J Conduct disorder 81 Cognitive and behavioural therapeutic interventions
J Oppositional disorder 82 to tackle homelessness – research synopsis 122 Section 5:
J Persistent, pervasive problems 82 How psychological factors related to traumatic Research
J Co-morbidity 83 experience and personality disorder are Section 6:
J Attachment 83 associated with chronic homelessness 131
Glossary
J Emotion regulation 84 Research synopsis 138
Psychological techniques and approaches – Section 6: Glossary
useful weblinks 86 Glossary of acronyms 142
Å back 3
Mental health
Good practice guide
Introduction
Click to go to Æ
Document map
The purpose of the guide Who is this guide for? The purpose of
the guide Introduction
This guide describes effective ways of recognising The good practice guide is designed to assist: Who is this guide for?
and meeting the psychological and emotional needs • Supported accommodation key workers and managers How to use the guide Section 1:
of people who have experienced homelessness, are
sleeping rough or living in insecure accommodation,
• Local authority housing options teams and managers An outline of
in particular young people and rough sleepers with • Supported accommodation providers the key issues
histories of complex trauma (see below for a definition • Day centre staff Section 2:
of complex trauma). The guide outlines the national • NHS homelessness healthcare services Case studies
policy context, the research evidence which informs
developing practice, and explores the issues for service
• Social workers
sleepers and young people which address emotional and • Hospital discharge coordinators
good practice
psychological problems. These illustrate the wide range • Psychiatrists and psychologists Section 5:
of techniques and approaches that are commissioned • GPs and practice managers Research
across the country, with contact details. For further • Health visitors Section 6:
information on any aspect of the guide please contact:
helen.keats@communities.gsi.gov.uk • Community Psychiatric Nurses (CPNs) Glossary
• Local commissioners of housing,
health or support services
• Local councillors
Å back more Æ 4
Mental health
Good practice guide
Introduction
Click to go to Æ
Document map
• Issues for accommodation and support providers • Some useful weblinks to give you more Section 3:
information on psychological techniques
• Importance of well-trained frontline staff and approaches
Definitions and
• The Psychologically Informed Environment weblinks
approach (PIE) Section 4: Guidance and good practice Section 4:
• Drugs and alcohol Some very helpful papers that outline more on Guidance and
The Psychologically Informed Environment (PIE) and good practice
Section 2: Case studies reflective practice – as well as some strong stories about
individual clients and good practice around the UK. Section 5:
There are four groups of wide-ranging case studies
showing good practice in action that cover: • The psychologically informed environment (PIE) Research
Å back more Æ 5
Mental health
Good practice guide
Introduction
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Section 5: Research The purpose of
Some key papers (presented in their original form) that the guide Introduction
offer top-level research to help commissioners explore a Who is this guide for?
wide range of issues surrounding complex trauma. Section 1:
How to use the guide
• Collaboration models for complex trauma and severe An outline of
social exclusion the key issues
• Cognitive and behavioural therapeutic interventions
Section 2:
to tackle homelessness – research synopsis
• How psychological factors related to traumatic Case studies
experience and personality disorder are associated Section 3:
with chronic homelessness – a paper
Definitions and
• Bio-psychosocial influences in complex trauma and weblinks
repeat homelessness: the evidence base and the
implications for future research and practice – Section 4:
a synopsis Guidance and
good practice
Section 6: Glossary
Section 5:
Acronyms spelled out.
Research
Section 6:
Glossary
Å back 6
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 7
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 8
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 9
Mental health
Good practice guide
There is an increasing recognition in the UK about the These local commissioning arrangements to meet the Importance of agencies
importance and cost benefits of preventive services. newly-identified needs will enhance the capacity and working together Section 1:
the potential for innovative approaches such as: New research An outline of the
Joint Strategic Needs Assessment • practice-based commissioning and and practice from
pilot projects
key issues
Responsibility for the assessment of health needs fits social prescribing Section 2:
within the remit of the local primary care trust (PCT) • to be able to intervene earlier Issues for Case studies
working in partnership with other agencies, most
notably local authorities. The statutory framework
• greater needs-led flexibility. accommodation and
support providers Section 3:
for needs assessment within a local area is the Joint The impetus of World Class Commissioning in the Definitions and
Importance of
Strategic Needs Assessment (JSNA) which is led by NHS, the outcomes of JSNAs across local authorities weblinks
well-trained
local authorities with input from primary care trusts. and primary care trusts and the transformation frontline staff
www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/ programme for adult social care have also helped Section 4:
PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/DH_081097 to sharpen the commissioning focus on a range of The Psychologically Guidance and
socially excluded groups, including people who are Informed Environment good practice
The JSNA in turn feeds into the local planning system homeless or living in insecure accommodation or approach
through the mechanism of Local Area Agreements Section 5:
individuals who may have experienced difficulty Drugs and alcohol
(LAAs). In an area of commissioning such as complex accessing services by virtue of diagnoses such Research
trauma it would be good practice for agencies to work Best practice tips
as personality disorder or complex trauma. Section 6:
together in the needs assessment phase and in taking
forward commissioning plans for new services to meet Inclusion Health – Improving Primary Care for Socially Glossary
the identified needs. Equally, existing services could be Excluded People is a practical guide aimed at supporting
refocused to reflect the recognition of complex trauma PCTs to commission improved access to high quality
as an issue for clients. www.dh.gov.uk/en/SocialCare/ primary care services for socially excluded people.
Socialcarereform/Localareaagreements/index.htm www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/
PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/DH_114067
Å back more Æ 10
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 11
Mental health
Good practice guide
In the past, it was thought that problems associated provides guidance for commissioners by reviewing Importance of agencies
with personality disorder were untreatable. Evidence what is known about personality disorder, government working together Section 1:
from a number of pilot projects funded by the policy, clinical approaches and learning from the New research An outline of the
Department of Health and two sets of guidelines pilots, and sets out a series of recommendations. and practice from key issues
from the National Institute for Clinical Excellence www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/ pilot projects
(NICE) issued in 2009 is changing that. Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/ Section 2:
Issues for Case studies
http://guidance.nice.org.uk/CG78 DH_101788
accommodation and
support providers Section 3:
Ground-breaking therapeutic programmes are making Making public money work harder
real and lasting improvements to families, prisoners, Importance of Definitions and
through ‘health check’ pilots well-trained weblinks
‘untreatable’ psychiatric patients and others who
experience extreme social exclusion. This guide There are strong spend-to-save arguments for health, frontline staff
the criminal justice system and the homelessness Section 4:
outlines many examples of effective practice emerging The Psychologically
sector in favour of tackling complex trauma, Guidance and
within housing services (see Section 2: Case studies Informed Environment
particularly in excluded and vulnerable groups. good practice
and CBT project, Derby Road, Southampton). approach
This can be achieved by partnership working
through the LAA process and by looking at Section 5:
Drugs and alcohol
Applying the learning from the pilots ways of joining up individual local funding Research
The challenge now is for commissioners to apply streams to achieve better outcomes. Best practice tips
the learning from the pilots and the developing Section 6:
evidence base to ensure that people experiencing Total Place is a new approach to local public service Glossary
complex trauma are treated by skilled and specialist delivery, encouraging local partners to put the citizen
staff working together across agencies. Recognising at the heart of service design in delivering service
Complexity, commissioning guidance for personality improvements and savings. The Total place report,
disorder services from the Department of Health, published alongside the 2010 Budget, draws on the
Å back more Æ 12
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 13
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 14
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 15
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 16
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 17
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 19
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 20
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 21
Mental health
Good practice guide
• The Zone, Plymouth • Behaviour support service, Brighton and Hove Glossary
• Art of defusing training, Bedford
High-support schemes for adults • Novas Scarman psychological skills training
• 90 Lancaster Street, Multiple Needs Unit,
Birmingham
• Framework Housing Association,
Nottingham
Å back 22
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 23
Mental health
Good practice guide
by individuals with such difficulties. It also helps to •How do they view these people? Section 5:
identify problems without any suggestion that these •What influence do others have on the client?
Research
problems are a matter for healthcare, social care or
support services. 2 Beliefs and thoughts about: Section 6:
Themselves (their identify) Glossary
It is particularly useful for services that may be • How would the client describe himself or herself?
commissioned and funded by diverse funding streams. • How do they think and feel about themselves?
• How does the client think other people see them?
The questions in the Leeds Holistic Framework are
outlined in more detail opposite.
Å back more Æ 24
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 25
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 26
Mental health
Good practice guide
New Directions Assessment – actually be serving based on real case studies. At initial Clinical
meetings it was clear that while all members could assessment tools Introduction
South West London Mental Health identify potential clients for the new team there was a
Schemes for
NHS Trust range of perspectives.
young people Section 1:
Snapshot summary Early discussions and a review of the relevant research High support An outline of
showed that a high proportion of people with multiple schemes for adults the key issues
The New Directions Team aims to provide an early needs tended to have mental health problems, often Staff capacity Section 2:
intervention for residents from the London Borough of in combination with substance use or personality building and support Case Studies
Merton who are not engaging with frontline services, disorder. While local case studies were being developed,
resulting in multiple exclusion, chaotic lifestyles and a brief review of the literature about people who Section 3:
negative social outcomes for themselves, their families did not engage, or were rejected by mental health
and communities. The team reports to a multi-agency services, was also carried out to identify key individual Definitions and
partnership group. characteristics. weblinks
Section 4:
Background What we do and how we do it Guidance and
During the development phase a local ‘Chaos Index’ good practice
Development of the Chaos Index
was agreed to help identify individuals or groups that The multi-agency partnership was keen for the Chaos Section 5:
the New Directions Team (NDT) could target. Index to focus on behaviours. The local case studies Research
were analysed to ascertain consistent behaviours and
It was important from the start to understand the to understand the level of impact of these behaviours. Section 6:
different perspectives of the multi-agency partnership Standardised assessments were drawn on to support Glossary
which included social services, primary care, mental the development of the Chaos Index but the essential
health services, housing, youth inclusion services, the element was ensuring that the index reflected the range
police, drug and alcohol services, Jobcentre Plus, the of behaviours identified through the local case studies
Learning and Skills Council and the volunteer centre thus reflecting the local population of Merton.
and find out who they considered the new team would
Å back more Æ 27
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 28
Mental health
Good practice guide
Section 3:
Table 1: Referral sources and numbers, accepted referrals, gender and ethnicity Definitions and
weblinks
Referral Total Gender Ethnicity Accepted Gender Ethnicity
source referrals (% male) (% white) referrals (% male) (% white) Section 4:
Police 13 38 85 9 33 100 Guidance and
Probation 1 100 100 1 100 100 good practice
General hospital 1 100 100 0 - -
Section 5:
Adult mental health 3 67 33 2 50 50
Research
Older people team 1 100 100 0 - -
Housing 2 100 50 2 100 50 Section 6:
Drug services 4 75 75 2 50 50 Glossary
YMCA 2 50 50 1 100 100
Faithin Action 1 100 100 1 100 100
Physical disability team 1 0 Not stated 1 0 Not stated
A relative 1 0 100 1 0 100
TOTAL 30 57 82 20 50 89
Å back more Æ 29
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 30
Mental health
Good practice guide
* Engagement with frontline services is not ranked as all clients have to achieve a score of 3 or more to be eligible to continue
the assessment.
Å back more Æ 31
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 32
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 33
Mental health
Good practice guide
New Directions Team Assessment Criterion 1, engagement with frontline services, tests Clinical
the basic eligibility for New Direction team, if a score assessment tools Introduction
Instructions of 0 – 2 is achieved then the person is not eligible to
Schemes for
complete the assessment or be considered for the team.
The New Directions Team assessment is used young people Section 1:
in assessing whether someone referred to the High support An outline of
New Directions Team is appropriate for the service. Client Name
schemes for adults the key issues
Date of birth
The assessment will not be the only criterion to be used Staff capacity Section 2:
Address building and support
in determining service eligibility, and certain vulnerable Case Studies
groups of people will be given priority:
• care leavers, particularly those with multiple risk
Section 3:
Definitions and
factors e.g. school exclusion
Home telephone
• young offenders
weblinks
Å back more Æ 34
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 35
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 36
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 37
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 39
Mental health
Good practice guide
TOTAL SCORE / 48
Contact: Miles.Rinaldi@swlstg-tr.nhs.uk
Å back more 40
Mental health
Good practice guide
Homeless Link Outcomes Programme • increase awareness of good practice in outcomes Clinical
approaches assessment tools Introduction
Snapshot summary • improve services for vulnerable people who may be Schemes for
at risk of homelessness within other sectors; and young people Section 1:
The aim of the Homeless Link Outcomes Programme is
to support organisations to improve their services to
• enable the sector to improve its services through High support An outline of
good outcomes data.
end homelessness. schemes for adults the key issues
Staff capacity Section 2:
We see the programme as a major opportunity The Outcomes Star System building and support Case Studies
to promote the value of an outcomes approach in The Homeless Outcomes website has comprehensive
helping services to focus on the needs, potential and guides for staff and clients in how to use the star. Section 3:
development of each individual person. Organisations can create and then store stars online. Definitions and
The website content is all free. weblinks
Background
The website also allows the reporting of outcomes for Section 4:
Homeless Link has run the Outcomes Programme Guidance and
which includes the Outcomes Star tool and the online individuals, projects or for the organisation as a whole.
It also allows you to: good practice
Outcomes Star System since June 2008.
• show service users a picture of their progress at the Section 5:
The Outcomes Star is widely recognised as an example touch of a button
Research
of good practice. • summarise your outcomes in a simple visual format;
Section 6:
and
Through our outcomes programme we aim to: • benchmark your performance with other similar Glossary
• encourage organisations to have a shared philosophy organisations.
of an outcomes approach
• enable homelessness agencies to access and use
outcomes measurement tools that meet their needs
Å back more Æ 41
Mental health
Good practice guide
Section 3:
Definitions and
weblinks
Section 4:
Guidance and
good practice
Section 5:
Research
Section 6:
Glossary
Å back 42
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 43
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 44
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 45
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 46
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 47
Mental health
Good practice guide
Kids Company, London Services are extremely fragmented and are Clinical
often experienced by our children and young assessment tools Introduction
people as being too complex for them to navigate.
Snapshot summary Schemes for
They require a comprehensive system of care that is
young people Section 1:
Kids Company is a charity which provides practical, child/young person-centred and that addresses the
emotional and educational support to marginalised psychological, emotional and social fragmentation High support An outline of
and vulnerable inner-city children and young people. that they struggle with when engaging with current schemes for adults the key issues
Kids Company currently assists approximately 14,000 statutory services. Staff capacity Section 2:
children with therapeutic and practical interventions building and support Case Studies
through street level centre that operate predominantly A sample of the case histories of young people
on a self-referral basis, through an educational accessing one of the Kids Company’s street level Section 3:
academy, a therapy house as well as in 38 inner city centres shows the type of problems they experience:
Definitions and
London schools. • 84% – homelessness weblinks
• 82% – substance misuse
Background • 81% – criminal involvement, often to feed and Section 4:
Guidance and
clothe younger siblings
The children and young people who come to Kids
Company typically present with a lack of basic life skills • 83% – sustained complex trauma in childhood good practice
and disorganised emotional development. As a result • 87% – emotional difficulties and mental Section 5:
they are often unable to organise themselves around health problems Research
social or welfare activities that would sustain them; • 39% – young carers struggling to cope
Section 6:
for example, maintaining financial support through
applying for benefits when they are not in paid At the two street level centres, 50-60% of the Glossary
employment, or managing their finances to prevent males using the service from age 13 upwards have
them from getting into arrears and spiralling into debt. been excluded from school and before engaging
Gaps in current statutory service provision do not with Kids Company were not in education
accommodate these developmental challenges. or employment.
Å back more Æ 48
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 49
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 50
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 51
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 52
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 53
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 54
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 55
Mental health
Good practice guide
St George’s Crypt, Leeds needs be, the centre itself has 12 beds of Supporting Clinical
People-funded accommodation, plus three respite beds assessment tools Introduction
funded independently, and therefore with no eligibility
Snapshot summary Schemes for
strings, for up to six weeks.
young people Section 1:
St George’s Crypt offers a range of services during
the day and night to homeless and destitute people The Crypt service operates on a principle of ‘elastic High support An outline of
in Leeds. tolerance’ that can confront inappropriate behaviour, schemes for adults the key issues
but will never reject the individual. So, for example, Staff capacity Section 2:
those who act up at the Centre might be barred for building and support Case Studies
Background a specific period but will always have the option of
St George’s Crypt is not so much a place as a network. returning and negotiating, through, for example, Section 3:
Combining direct access with various supported changes to their behaviour, why they should be allowed Definitions and
accommodation options and a social enterprise work to try again. weblinks
scheme, plus good links with other agencies in the area,
the Crypt has developed a network of pathways which Long-stay accommodation for street drinkers Section 4:
are carefully attuned to the needs and capacities of the In addition, Regent Terrace, a wet hostel, provides Guidance and
service users. long-stay accommodation with 24-hour cover for 10 good practice
street drinkers with long-term alcohol dependency
and entrenched high-support needs: a ‘wraparound’ Section 5:
What we do and how we do it service at the border of palliative care. Care plans here Research
At the heart of the Crypt’s service is the Care Centre, are slow-paced and long-term, and can include a detox,
but the core principles are harm minimisation, with the Section 6:
which by day offers lunch, showers, clean clothes and
opportunity to live with dignity. Glossary
advocacy to street homeless and destitute people in
Leeds. By night, the centre can offer food and shelter,
but also a needs and risk assessment; and where Move-on service for detoxed residents
possible individuals will be referred on directly to For move-on within the service, the Crypt has now
vacancies in other direct access hostels nearby. But if developed Faith Lodge, a 15-bed unit for detoxed
residents wishing to manage without drink or drugs.
Å back more Æ 56
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 57
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 58
Mental health
Good practice guide
• Person-centred counselling.
There is strong evidence for the link between complex
Definitions and
weblinks
But the staff team also stress that specific techniques needs, complex trauma and homelessness.
Section 4:
are not the key to successful engagement.
Guidance and
Of Lifeworks’ clients:
good practice
Contact: nigel.dawson@nhs.net
• 52% lost a primary carer in early childhood
Section 5:
(often violently, e.g. murder or suicide)
• over half were abused as children – and most have Research
histories of chronic trauma since
Section 6:
• 43% have been in prison
Glossary
• 70% – 80% have mental health problems
• two-thirds use three or more substances
• all have either been in a psychiatric hospital or
a hostel.
Å back more Æ 59
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 60
Mental health
Good practice guide
change movement
articulate:
60% schemes for adults the key issues
Cycle of
Staff capacity Section 2:
"I was drinking and using drugs for a building and support Case Studies
long time; I …lost it and ended up sleeping 100%
rough. I had a lot of family problems and Section 3:
for a long time, thought it was all my fault. Inactive 20 40 60 80 100
Definitions and
Through my work with Lifeworks I now know to active weblinks
% of all clients movement
it wasn’t just me, it was all of us… if my Section 4:
parents had used this service things may have Guidance and
turned out different. I think it could have The above graph compares data from Outcomes Stars for good practice
helped them. I now realise that the drink, 58 St Mungo’s accommodation-based clients who had
participated in Lifeworks with those for 825 St Mungo’s Section 5:
the drugs, [losing] the flat, the family, it’s all
accommodation-based clients who had not participated. Research
linked… If it wasn’t for Lifeworks I’d be dead
by now, no word of a lie." The graph shows the percentage of clients who Section 6:
progressed from an ‘inactive’ phase on the stages of Glossary
Lifeworks client change – either pre-contemplation or contemplation
– to an ‘active’ phase – preparation, action or
Contact: Peter.Cockersell@MUNGOS.ORG consolidation. It takes those clients’ first star reading on
that scale and compares it to their latest reading at the
time of the analysis.
Å back more Æ 61
Mental health
Good practice guide
Leicester Homeless Mental There is an additional STR (support worker) post that Clinical
is funded by PCTs and managed by the mental health assessment tools Introduction
Health Service charity Rethink in partnership with Leicestershire
Schemes for
Partnership NHS Trust (LPT).
young people Section 1:
Snapshot summary
This collaborative partnership has been sustained High support An outline of
The Leicester Homeless Mental Health Service (HMHS) over several years. The Rethink worker works within a schemes for adults the key issues
provides assessment, treatment and support to recovery model to support clients with their life choices.
homeless adults over the age of 16 with mental health Staff capacity Section 2:
This post was developed in order to extend service building and support
difficulties across the city of Leicester. In addition to Case Studies
provision in Leicestershire and map further gaps in
providing direct mental health services, the team also the service.
aims to improve access to all mainstream social and Section 3:
health care services for single homeless people in the Definitions and
locality by advocating with mainstream mental health, What we do and how we do it weblinks
social care and primary care providers and We have developed a service which is able to respond to
commissioners. Section 4:
clients’ needs as they arise and when the client is ready
Guidance and
to engage.
good practice
Background
We aim to: Section 5:
The team consists of: Improve the quality of life for homeless people in Research
• three full-time Registered Mental Health Nurses Leicester by:
• one part-time Associate Specialist Psychiatrist • providing appropriate, personalised mental health
Section 6:
Glossary
• one full-time psychologist assessment and access to treatment services
• one half-time admin worker; and • assisting service users to access appropriate
• sessional input by a Consultant Psychiatrist •
accommodation
facilitating access to mainstream mental health and
(supervision).
other services
Å back more Æ 62
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 63
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 64
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 65
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 66
Mental health
Good practice guide
These were:
• engagement in change
Å back more Æ 68
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 70
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 71
Mental health
Good practice guide
•clients who, in their experience, have non-practical • dealing with overwhelming emotions, fear and anxiety,
blocks to ‘move-on’ or have had an unsuccessful low mood, guilt and shame, managing our own stress
attempt at move on. • positively managing risk and challenging behaviour
• ending a key working relationship with a service user.
Å back more Æ 72
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 73
Mental health
Good practice guide
Art of Defusing training, Bedford • relationship building between the trainees that has Clinical
resulted in ‘added’ benefit to the clients of their assessment tools Introduction
respective services. For example, easier sharing of
Snapshot summary information around the client’s support needs.
Schemes for
young people Section 1:
For the past three years this training course has been
made available to staff working in hostels in Bedford. The feedback highlighted: High support An outline of
It has been run by Jo Bunker, a qualified trainer with
experience in this field and has equipped more than 50
• how valuable the training was in personally equipping schemes for adults the key issues
staff – and in some cases bringing about changes to Staff capacity Section 2:
frontline workers to deal effectively with conflict in a policy and procedures for hostels building and support Case Studies
residential setting.
• that staff related much better and more effectively
Section 3:
across agencies than before with sideways referrals
Background happening, where appropriate, to prevent evictions. Definitions and
The course was funded by the council as a result of the weblinks
Rough Sleepers Reduction Plan which outlined the need Outcomes from the course Section 4:
to reduce evictions from hostels due to anti-social
From April 2007-March 2008 43 people were evicted Guidance and
behaviour. This plan was produced by a multi-agency
for anti-social behaviour (ASB) from Supported Housing good practice
task group from the Bedfordshire Supported Housing
in Bedford.
Forum, following the 2007 Rough Sleepers Count. Section 5:
After the first course in November 2007, and two Research
Impacts of the course further courses in November 2008, the number of Section 6:
The course has had a number of positive impacts since evictions for ASB dropped to 25 by April 2009; nearly a
Glossary
its introduction including: 50% reduction.
• the opportunity for hostel workers from different The service with the highest number of evictions in
agencies to train and network together 2007 invested time training all their staff on this course
• enabling good practice to be shared within the and saw a 68% drop in their evictions for ASB, from 22
context of training in 2007 to only 7 by October 2009.
Å back more Æ 74
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 75
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 76
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 77
Mental health
Good practice guide
Contact: graeme.green@frameworkha.org
Å back 79
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 80
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 81
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 82
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 83
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 84
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 85
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 86
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 87
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 88
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 89
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 90
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 91
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 92
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 93
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 94
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 95
Mental health
Good practice guide
Kirklees have identified three particularly Stabilising Sammy’s accommodation will make a
entrenched rough sleepers for whom tailored significant contribution to levels of anti-social behaviour
options will be needed. in the town centre, and deliver savings against the
criminal justice budget by reducing his level of offending.
Å back more Æ 96
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 97
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 98
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back more Æ 99
Mental health
Good practice guide
Jon’s story prison sentences. He has poor physical health and The psychologically
suffered a minor heart attack in 2007. informed environment Introduction
‘Jon’ was one of the highest scoring individuals when (PIE)
first assessed using the New Directions Index. His case He was referred to the Safeguarding Vulnerable Adults
Reflective practice Section 1:
study has been compiled by Cambridge County Council Team by the council’s Rough Sleeping Coordinator after
and shows how despite resource intensive interventions, an exercise in which he was identified as one of Personalisation pilots An outline of
when a “whole public purse” perspective is taken, the the most difficult to engage people sleeping rough – and invest to save the key issues
costs of individuals to their wider community can be in February 2009 Working with people Section 2:
mitigated and reduce.
with complex needs
A homeless application was made and temporary Case studies
Jon is 45 years old. He was taken into care as a baby accommodation (TA) and support arranged in June CBT project
Section 3:
following a head injury and was diagnosed with a 2009. However, before he was able to move into the TA The use of medication
he was sent back to prison. When he came out of prison Definitions and
specific learning disability in 1997. He experienced sexual
his expectation was to go straight into the TA, but early Childhood experiences weblinks
abuse as a young person and has self-harmed since he
was nine years old (cutting and burning). From the age discharge meant this was not available on the day. Collaboration models Section 4:
of 13, Jon has misused alcohol and solvents; currently he for complex trauma and Guidance and
only uses alcohol. He became homeless at 16. For 12 days in June 2009 he slept rough and was severe social exclusion good practice
arrested eight times. Jon told the Street Outreach Team
Jon is a risk to others – becoming aggressive when drinking worker that: “This always happens – people always Section 5:
and has committed offences of assault, affray and promise help but there’s always a reason they don’t”. Research
criminal damage. He has been subject to several ASBOs. Jon indicated he finally wanted to work with support
services, and find a way out of his current situation. Jon Section 6:
Jon is equally at risk from others and has been was sent back to prison for the offences in June. Glossary
financially and physically abused, requiring the use
of A&E after assaults on the streets During his time in custody, a Safeguarding Vulnerable
Adults case conference was arranged. This time on his
Since 1996 Jon has committed around 400 offences, release, Jon was housed in temporary accommodation
appeared in court 260 times and served 120 short term with a raft of support in place from the learning
• £132 ( at £16.50 per hour for housing options advice • £1,000 (for direct access hostel for four weeks assuming
went to a local church group that referred them to a direct • £1,000 per annum for replacing furniture/ carpets
Childhood experiences
Definitions and
weblinks
hostel in a neighbouring town. They slept rough there for • £10,400 (support worker with alcohol specialism
Collaboration models
a further two nights, awaiting a vacancy, and had their visiting two hours per day Monday – Friday, at £20 Section 4:
belongings stolen/damaged by rain. As they were out of per hour – outside London) for complex trauma and Guidance and
their local support network, and had found the experience • £5,460 (generic support worker visiting for 1 hour severe social exclusion good practice
traumatising, they were unable to maintain their part- each day, 7 days a week, at £15 per hour – may be
time job and needed help to start benefit claims, including more in London) Section 5:
a crisis loan, and to rebuild their confidence.
• £520 (community alarm at £10 per week) Research
Section 6:
This does not assume any contact with the criminal However, the costs of the status quo (i.e. continued
justice system or a deterioration in physical or mental Glossary
rough sleeping and chaotic lifestyle) are in the region of
health/ assault requiring use of A&E during the period £25,500, based on the following assumptions:
sleeping rough.
• £15,000 per annum for policing (for moving
individual on when street drinking; arresting for
Minimum saving per person achieved by timely
aggressive begging; court proceedings and short
prevention option: £3,300.
Å back 107
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 114
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 115
Mental health
Good practice guide
Å back 120
Mental health
Good practice guide
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Current policy Mental health and homelessness Cognitive and
Current Government policy focuses on tackling and A significant factor contributing to someone becoming behavioural therapeutic Introduction
preventing homelessness as early as possible, through a homeless is mental health problems, many of which interventions to
combination of housing advice, tools such as mediation remain undiagnosed. The prevalence of psychotic tackle homelessness –
research synopsis Section 1:
or rent deposits and housing related support funded disorders in the homeless population (i.e. those
through the Supporting People (SP) programme. An outline of
associated with diagnoses such as schizophrenia) How psychological
However SP excludes financial support for therapeutic the key issues
varies between 4% and 40%, depending on factors related to
services, such as psychotherapeutic input. assessment methods and populations investigated. traumatic experience Section 2:
and personality disorder Case studies
The £90m Hostels Capital Improvement Programme There is no published literature describing the are associated with
(HCIP) currently in place aims to make hostels places of prevalence of personality disorders, although an chronic homelessness Section 3:
change rather than containment. unpublished doctoral thesis found that 59% of a Definitions and
It focuses on ensuring that homeless people are given Research synopsis
hostel population reached diagnostic levels. weblinks
the opportunity to change their expectations and
their lives, through access to a range of services, which The lack of research data may be partly due to the Section 4:
could include psychotherapeutic interventions where difficulties in diagnosis and treatment, but may also Guidance and
available and appropriate. be due to the ‘treatability’ clause still in operation good practice
due to the 1983 Mental Heath Act. This states that
any patients to be ‘sectioned’ under the Act must be Section 5:
There is evidence that unless the underlying causes
‘treatable’, meaning that individuals diagnosed with a Research
of homelessness, such as drug or alcohol misuse,
anti social or violent behaviour or mental health PD could not be sectioned as an inpatient solely
due to their diagnosis as PD was not deemed Section 6:
problems are tackled, some people will continue
treatable when the Act was published. It is useful Glossary
to be at risk of rough sleeping or of repeatedly
losing their accommodation. There is also evidence to consider PD as a serious and enduring
of a link between mental health problems and mental health problem, which can have long-
substance misuse, with some people using drugs term negative effects on the way in which a
and alcohol to “self-medicate”. person interacts with their environment.
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
8 Inappropriate or uncontrollable anger Cognitive and
Other mental health problems that may be 9 Transient stress-related paranoid ideation or severe behavioural therapeutic Introduction
implicated are post traumatic stress disorder dissociative symptoms (i.e. paranoia induced by interventions to
(PTSD), anxiety and depression, in addition to drug stress, and ‘dissociation’ – a process of ‘removing’ tackle homelessness –
and alcohol problems. PD is characterised by a research synopsis Section 1:
oneself from reality typically learned during
number of emotional, cognitive and behavioural episodes of early abuse) An outline of
How psychological
factors which can be seen to contribute to the key issues
factors related to
repeated tenancy breakdown. Observations indicate that a proportion of homeless traumatic experience Section 2:
people, particularly rough sleepers or those living in and personality disorder Case studies
hostels or night shelters, exhibit behaviours which are associated with
The diagnostic criteria for borderline personality frequently result in eviction. Typically, this is behaviour chronic homelessness Section 3:
disorder (BPD) are particularly useful when considering which contravenes the rules of the establishment, Definitions and
such factors. The following are the diagnostic criteria e.g. consuming alcohol on the premises or returning Research synopsis
weblinks
associated with BPD set out by the North American obviously intoxicated, owning, obtaining, or consuming
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM): illegal substances and violent or aggressive behaviours. Section 4:
These latter behaviours can be functionally related to Guidance and
1 A pattern of intense and unstable interpersonal forms of substance abuse, e.g. to obtain substances or good practice
relationships as a result of injesting them.
Section 5:
2 Frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined
These behaviours can be seen to be similar to a number Research
abandonment
of behavioural factors associated with personality
3 Identity disturbance or problems with sense of self disorders. It is argued that most of these can be traced Section 6:
4 Impulsive behaviour that is potentially to abusive experiences in critical developmental stages, Glossary
self-damaging i.e. childhood and adolescence. There is evidence of an
5 Recurrent suicidal or parasuicidal behaviours association between having been brought up in care and
6 Affective (emotional) instability later homelessness. Additionally clinical observations
indicate a high prevalence of early neglect and abuse in
7 Chronic feelings of emptiness
the homeless population.
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Possible pathway to homelessness Cognitive and
behavioural therapeutic Introduction
Abusive interventions to
Negative childhood tackle homelessness –
Survival, research synopsis Section 1:
view of self,
world and coping An outline of
strategies How psychological
others the key issues
factors related to
traumatic experience Section 2:
Negative and personality disorder Case studies
ruminations are associated with
chronic homelessness Section 3:
Research synopsis Definitions and
weblinks
Difficult Section 4:
emotions Guidance and
good practice
Section 5:
Substance Research
misuse
Antisocial Section 6:
behaviours
Glossary
Repeated
tenancy
breakdown
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
It is being proposed here that repeated tenancy (NICE) recommends that CBT should be a treatment Cognitive and
breakdown and eviction can be formulated, taking into option for those with suffering schizophrenia along behavioural therapeutic Introduction
account a number of individual historical, cognitive, with medication. interventions to
emotional and behavioural factors. These are described tackle homelessness –
in the diagram below. The research literature examining models and research synopsis Section 1:
treatment of personality disorders has not been so An outline of
How psychological
Early abusive experiences can result in difficult thought fruitful. The evidence so far is mixed in terms of its the key issues
factors related to
processes and rumination and concomitant intolerable findings regarding personality disorders generally.
traumatic experience Section 2:
emotions. The easiest method of altering these in the Methodological, design, population and research setting
and personality disorder Case studies
short-term at least is to take some form of substance, problems mean that definitive conclusions can not yet
are associated with
i.e. drugs or alcohol. This is more likely to happen be made. There is however some evidence that a variant Section 3:
chronic homelessness
when skills in regulating emotion have not been learnt of behavioural therapy, dialectical behavioural therapy
in childhood. These, in combination with aggressive (DBT) is effective in reducing self-harming behaviours Research synopsis Definitions and
behaviours learnt in childhood and adolescence, of those suffering borderline personality disorder (NICE weblinks
result in antisocial behaviours and repeated tenancy now recommends DBT as a psychological treatment for Section 4:
breakdown. Where more adaptive interpersonal skills borderline personality disorder).
Guidance and
have not been learnt, more destructive ones which
good practice
have previously been successful to some extent Supervision
(e.g. aggression) are used. The problems that people within the homelessness Section 5:
population suffer are complex and often of an Research
Therapeutic interventions interpersonal nature. This means that interpersonal
In the last twenty years a great deal of progress has interactions can be difficult due to inherent ambiguities Section 6:
been made in terms of the treatment of severe mental in human communication and sensitivities of clients Glossary
health problems, particularly those associated with associated with childhood neglect and abuse. Some
cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) and its variants. The may interpret others’ attitudes as rejecting and
research examining cognitive models and treatment neglectful easily, and become depressive or angry,
of psychosis in particular have progressed to such an behaving accordingly.
extent that the National Institute of Clinical Excellence
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Frontline workers are expected to deal first hand The Southampton experience Cognitive and
with such difficult interactions, without the aid of behavioural therapeutic Introduction
taught psychological skills and frameworks to work Single men’s homelessness CBT project interventions to
with. Frameworks and methods of working with In Southampton between 2001 and 2004 a project tackle homelessness –
interpersonal difficulties are best learnt through case to deal with clients who had proved most difficult research synopsis Section 1:
discussion in a group format. There should be ongoing to maintain in tenancies was commissioned, funded An outline of
through the then Homelessness Directorate. This How psychological
clinical supervision, provided regularly (e.g. once every the key issues
was a four-bed house (leased from a local housing factors related to
fortnight) and facilitated by a qualified practitioner.
association) with dedicated support workers provided traumatic experience Section 2:
by a local homelessness charity (Society of St James), and personality disorder Case studies
and psychologist time bought from the local NHS trust. are associated with
In addition, supervision within a cognitive Section 3:
In addition to the Society of St James and NHS Trust, chronic homelessness
behavioural framework focuses on facilitating
workers to enable cognitive, emotional and Southampton City Council and Rough Sleepers Initiative Research synopsis Definitions and
behavioural change, and deal with the difficult (now Southampton Street Homeless Prevention Team) weblinks
interactions which are inevitably experienced. were involved in the collaboration. The arrangement of
tenancies meant that clients with greater difficulties Section 4:
These are described in terms of the beliefs about
could be taken on, and typical referrals were people Guidance and
the interactions, and associated emotions. For
who had been evicted from all or most other projects in good practice
example many staff have thoughts about not
being effective when clients relapse in terms of the city, had poly-drug and alcohol abuse issues, some
Section 5:
a particular behaviour that has been worked on. having prison records.
Research
These beliefs are made explicit and alternative
thoughts about what is happening developed. The psychologist provided CBT input for two and a Section 6:
half days a week, comprising individual sessions with
Glossary
residents and group supervision with support workers.
One possible outcome of regularly attending to Attempts were also made to engage clients in the
staff clinical practice and emotions is fewer staff running of the house through house meetings.
experiencing burnout and less staff turnover.
This may save money in the long term.
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Between September 2001 and April 2004, 23 people DBT and Domestic Violence Project Cognitive and
were resident in the project. Fourteen of these had behavioural therapeutic Introduction
previously been street homeless, two came straight A joint project between Hampshire Partnership interventions to
from prison, two were street homeless and referred via NHS Trust and Women’s Aid was funded by the tackle homelessness –
the local detox unit, and five came from direct access Homelessness Directorate to find ways of preventing research synopsis Section 1:
hostels, having been evicted. repeat homelessness in women who have experienced An outline of
domestic violence. How psychological
the key issues
factors related to
The average stay for all clients was 17.5 weeks (range 2 –
The project tested the idea that if the women involved traumatic experience Section 2:
62 weeks). In terms of move-on, nine went to their own
could feel more in control of their lives they would be and personality disorder Case studies
residence, three went to residences out of area, two
more able to solve day to day problems and hence be are associated with
were referred back to direct access hostels, three went Section 3:
more able to maintain their tenancies. The project used chronic homelessness
back to prison, two moved away and lost contact, and
a short-term group based on DBT. DBT is a therapeutic Research synopsis Definitions and
two returned to street homelessness. Two clients were
intervention which focuses on teaching skills such as weblinks
murdered, one after having left the project and one
shortly after having moved in. managing emotions, problem solving, distress tolerance Section 4:
and assertiveness.
Guidance and
The project and psychological therapy was effective in
The project comprised a 12-week group for the women good practice
terms of enabling 14 out of the 23 clients to find and
sustain accommodation, despite their previous history and training for the staff at Women’s Aid so that they Section 5:
of repeat homelessness. The rest were either difficult to could continue to support the women both between Research
engage and / or their continued antisocial behaviours sessions and after the group had finished.
resulted in eviction. Section 6:
Results from the group showed improvements in Glossary
self-esteem, mood and feelings of control. Comments
from the women themselves suggested that the group
was well received, and that they found they could deal
with problems and negotiate with professionals and
systems more effectively. Almost half of the group
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
members moved out from the hostel during the course • Thought must be given to the type of property and Cognitive and
of the group and were able to establish themselves tenancy agreement made available to clients of the behavioural therapeutic Introduction
independently. There was no evidence that any of the service. interventions to
women went back into their abusive situations. • Because of the chaotic nature of many of the tackle homelessness –
research synopsis Section 1:
clients, services should be provided within the
Developing ways in which such groups could become accommodation rather than through traditional out An outline of
How psychological
more readily available is the challenge of the future. patient services. the key issues
factors related to
Training the staff of the hostel to provide the
intervention is one way forward, but requires time and • Levels of engagement can vary considerably and traumatic experience Section 2:
services must be flexible enough to manage this. and personality disorder Case studies
ongoing supervision if it is to be successful. However,
such therapeutic approaches have wide ranging benefits • Hostel staff must be offered training in the CBT/DBT are associated with
chronic homelessness Section 3:
for those who go through them and could in the long approach (as opposed to delivery of the therapy) so
term be very cost effective in preventing the cycles of that they have an understanding of the models and Research synopsis Definitions and
behaviour which keep people stuck and dependent can reinforce key messages consistently. This may be weblinks
on services. difficult to sustain, given the traditionally high staff
turn-over rates in the sector. Section 4:
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
to be offered psychological therapies if they are Useful reference Cognitive and
currently using substances or alcohol. It could be that NICE Guidelines, Mental Health: behavioural therapeutic Introduction
this would be a fruitful area for investment in primary www.nice.org.uk interventions to
care psychology for primary care trusts to consider. tackle homelessness –
Section 1:
• Identifying shared outcomes such as a reduction in research synopsis
An outline of
the use of A&E and mental health crisis services / How psychological
admissions, reduced re-offending, reduction in anti the key issues
factors related to
social behaviour, reduction in evictions, reduced traumatic experience Section 2:
numbers rough sleeping, harm minimisation etc can and personality disorder Case studies
be an effective way of encouraging multi agency are associated with
buy-in. chronic homelessness Section 3:
Research synopsis Definitions and
Conclusions weblinks
Undiagnosed and / or untreated severe and enduring
mental health problems can contribute to repeated Section 4:
tenancy breakdown and therefore homelessness. Guidance and
Psychological therapies have proved an effective good practice
intervention for chaotic and challenging clients and
Section 5:
have reduced time spent homeless.
Research
Psychological therapies should be specifically funded and Section 6:
delivered within accommodation rather than through out
patient services, to maximise take up and engagement. Glossary
Å back 129
Mental health
Good practice guide
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
who experience repeat homelessness experience such There is a reasonable literature on the prevalence of Cognitive and
problems. For example, US research indicates that personality disorders (PD) in the homeless population,8 behavioural therapeutic Introduction
approximately 91% of a homeless sample had received but the extent to which PDs may be implicated in the interventions to
some form of primary psychiatric diagnoses, with about aetiology and/or maintenance of homelessness is not tackle homelessness –
40% suffering psychoses and 29% chronically misusing yet certain. Although few studies have systematically research synopsis Section 1:
alcohol.5 In the UK, schizophrenia is present in an diagnosed personality disorders, unstructured clinical An outline of
How psychological
estimated 31% of the homeless population;6 Axis I assessments suggest rates up to 70% (although rates the key issues
factors related to
disorder (e.g., depression, anxiety) in an estimated are highly varied;9) with schizoid, borderline, dependent,
traumatic experience Section 2:
50-75%,7 and Axis II problems (personality disorder; PD) and antisocial features often identified.10 Antisocial
and personality disorder Case studies
present in up to 70% (PD is considered in more detail personality disorder has received some attention,
are associated with
shortly). Many of these different problems are with estimated rates of 10-40% in the homeless Section 3:
chronic homelessness
commonly co-morbid in homeless people. population.11 Recent evidence investigating the
prevalence of PD in a UK population of street homeless Research synopsis Definitions and
Thus, homelessness may be more than simply not having and hostel dwelling adults found that 58% reached weblinks
somewhere to live owing to unforeseen circumstances. diagnostic levels (Maguire, Munwar, Levell, McClean & Section 4:
The experience of agencies working with homeless people Matthews, in preparation12).
Guidance and
is that unless and until the underlying psychological
good practice
issues behind the presenting problem are identified and
addressed, homelessness is likely to be repeated. This Section 5:
means that the problem of homelessness cannot be Research
solved by the provision of accommodation alone.
Section 6:
8 e.g. Fazel, Khosia, Doll & Geddes, 2008 Glossary
9 Fazel et al, 2008
10 Tolomiczenko, Sota & Goering, 2000
11 Caton, Hasin, Shrout, Opler, Hirschfield et al. 2000
5 Bassuk, Rubin & Lauriat, 1984 12 For a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis of the
6 Timms & Fry, 1989 mental health literature, the reader is referred to Fazel, Khosla,
7 Drake, Osher, & Wallach, 1991 Doll & Geddes (2008); Rees (2009).
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Research shows that PDs are often the product of meta-engine EBSCO Host, which searches CINAHL, Cognitive and
traumatic childhood and adolescent experiences. The MEDLINE, PsycARTICLES and PsycINFO, was also behavioural therapeutic Introduction
experience of sustained exposure to traumatic events employed. Search terms included combinations of the interventions to
has recently been termed complex trauma13. This following, where an asterisk (*) denotes any subsequent tackle homelessness –
sustained exposure to toxic experience distinguishes string of characters (e.g. homeless* would include research synopsis Section 1:
complex trauma (or Type II Trauma) in principle from homeless and homelessness): homeless*, aetiology, An outline of
How psychological
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD, or Type I Trauma), complex trauma, personality disorder, antisocial, the key issues
factors related to
which describes cognitive, emotional and behavioural borderline, child* neglect, child* abuse, childhood,
traumatic experience Section 2:
reactions to a single event. Although circumstantially psychology*, impulsivity. In addition, experts in the
and personality disorder Case studies
complex trauma makes clinical sense in terms of a field were consulted to contribute papers that were not
are associated with
high prevalence of childhood abuse and neglect in the identified in the first search. Similarly, the reference Section 3:
chronic homelessness
entrenched homeless population, very little research lists of recent reviews were trawled for papers not
has been conducted on how the resulting personality initially identified. Research synopsis Definitions and
disorders lead to entrenched or repeat homelessness. weblinks
These search strategies yielded 154 papers for inclusion. Section 4:
Literature search strategy The inclusion criteria were that 1) the papers had been
Guidance and
The aim of the literature review was to identify all published in peer-review journals; and 2) the papers
good practice
relevant published work emanating from the scientific were empirical in content, i.e. including quantitative
and mainstream communities on personality and and/or qualitative data. Purely theoretical papers were Section 5:
psychological factors (including complex trauma) excluded, as were books and book chapters which Research
thought to be implicated in repeat homelessness. To summarized original research. Because this is the first
maximise transparency, a formal search strategy was attempt to identify all empirical papers investigating Section 6:
adopted. Two major search engines were used (Web of the link between complex trauma and the aetiology and Glossary
Science and Google Scholar), in addition to which the maintenance of entrenched / repeat homelessness, all
identified papers have been included in the final table.
13 Herman, 1992
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Results
• There is a complex relationship between traumatic Cognitive and
experience, mental health issues, behavioural factors behavioural therapeutic Introduction
The results are broken down into five main areas: and homeless status. Although a number of models interventions to
have been proposed, few have been empirically tackle homelessness –
1 Links between complex trauma and Section 1:
evaluated.17 research synopsis
homelessness
2 Trauma in relation to other factors in • Evidence from research with young homeless people How psychological
An outline of
the key issues
supports the complexity of the relationship between factors related to
homelessness
multiple traumas, homelessness, and mental health traumatic experience Section 2:
3 Mental health and homelessness outcomes. Young people are more likely than adults and personality disorder Case studies
4 Interventions to have experienced earlier trauma, abuse, or neglect are associated with
5 Limitations of reported studies and been accommodated in care; but are also more chronic homelessness Section 3:
likely to experience similar traumas in later life.18 Definitions and
Research synopsis
weblinks
1 Links between complex trauma and 2 Trauma in relation to other factors in
homelessness homelessness Section 4:
• It is clear from the vast majority of the literature that •Early traumatic experiences are associated with such Guidance and
there is strong and consistent evidence supporting factors as low levels of social support, low levels of good practice
an association between homelessness and complex family support, and ‘deviant’ peer associations.
Section 5:
trauma. Some papers investigated homelessness
as a risk factor for trauma,14 whereas others noted •There is an association between traumatic experience Research
and maladaptive behaviours such as: drug and
that trauma precedes homelessness.15 Other studies alcohol abuse; conduct disorders; sexual risk Section 6:
quantified this relationship16 found that for almost taking (and other sex-related behaviours). Other
three-quarters of cases, PTSD preceded the onset of Glossary
behavioural factors include sexual victimization,
homelessness). increased use of health and social services, and
reduced participation in the labour force.
14 e.g. Goodman et al., 1991
15 e.g. Taylor & Sharpe, 2008 17 e.g. Martijn & Sharpe, 2006
16 e.g., North & Smith, 1992 18 Taylor et al., 2006
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
3 Mental health and homelessness 4 Interventions Cognitive and
• There are higher rates of mental health problems, •A number of forms of intervention have been behavioural therapeutic
interventions to
Introduction
both Axis I (anxiety disorders, depression, dementia found to be useful in treating homeless youths and
and psychosis disorders) and Axis II (personality adults. These include family therapy, therapeutic tackle homelessness –
research synopsis Section 1:
disorders) than non-clinical populations. Evidence communities, behavioural contingency programmes,
indicates that rates are comparable with psychiatric cognitive-behaviour therapy, psychodynamic An outline of
How psychological
populations. However these data were mixed, with psychotherapy, 12-step programmes, and generic the key issues
factors related to
some studies finding no significant differences for counselling in the context of supported housing. traumatic experience Section 2:
schizophrenia between homeless and non-homeless There is as yet no evidence to support the suggestion and personality disorder Case studies
groups.19 Young homeless people are more likely of a single treatment of choice. are associated with
than adults to present with emotional disorders
(anxiety and depression), substance abuse, self-harm
•Although a number of forms of intervention are chronic homelessness Section 3:
highlighted as useful, the research in this field is Definitions and
and attachment disorders (from which full-blown Research synopsis
generally poor in terms of design. There are few weblinks
personality disorders may emerge). controlled trials and no randomised control trials
• Some evidence indicates that psychiatric (RCTs). Section 4:
hospitalisations are higher than other clinical
populations for homeless adults, but psychological
•The literature often does not clearly define the Guidance and
good practice
intervention models used or the settings in which
disorders in this population also tend to remain interventions are practised. These two factors
untreated20 suggesting that hospitalisation measures Section 5:
are often conflated. Many studies do not specify
underestimate prevalence. Young homeless people Research
outcomes in detail or discuss the reliability or validity
find it particularly difficult to access services, because of their measures, and very few (if any) attempt to Section 6:
they usually fall between the remit of adolescent and establish the process underlying observed change.
adult mental health services. Glossary
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
5 Limitations of reported studies diagnoses identifiable from mainstream medical and Cognitive and
• The term ‘trauma’ is generally poorly defined in the psychological research. This may reflect the different
approaches of the respective funding bodies.
behavioural therapeutic
interventions to
Introduction
literature. A number of terms are used in addition
to trauma, e.g. ‘psychological trauma’, ‘PTSD’, • The majority of published research in this area tackle homelessness –
research synopsis Section 1:
‘traumatic experiences’, ‘traumatic events’. Some originates from the USA. Around three quarters of
of these terms are used as outcome variables and papers identified were from the USA, the remainder An outline of
How psychological
some are confounded with historical variables, e.g. from the rest of the world. Around 10% of papers the key issues
factors related to
‘victimization’, ‘abuse histories’, ‘childhood abuse’. identified were published in the UK. Although the traumatic experience Section 2:
No papers discriminate between Type I and Type II North American research is strongly suggestive of a and personality disorder Case studies
trauma, or PTSD and complex trauma. These terms link between trauma and homelessness, the extent are associated with
and constructs need to be defined and validated. to which results obtained overseas are completely chronic homelessness Section 3:
• Figures for the prevalence of specific disorders and generalisable to UK populations remains to be
determined. Research synopsis Definitions and
other constructs are greatly dependent on the type of weblinks
assessment used (e.g., Fazel et al, 2008, the reported
prevalence of personality disorders is highly variable, Section 4:
possibly owing to a reliance on clinical diagnosis). Guidance and
This suggests that the type of assessment used good practice
should be carefully considered in terms of validity
and reliability. Section 5:
Research
• Literature in the area of mental health is generally
sophisticated, using such methodological techniques Section 6:
as meta-analysis,21 factor analysis22 and path
Glossary
analysis23. Homelessness research has not to date
been framed within the tightly defined constructs and
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Recommendations 4 Any intervention or management projects, whether Cognitive and
existing or newly commissioned, should be carefully behavioural therapeutic Introduction
1 Further research is necessary to map the causal evaluated, with clear outcomes and controlled interventions to
relationships between complex trauma and designs. tackle homelessness –
homelessness. Psychological research methods, research synopsis Section 1:
5 The settings in which such services are delivered
including longitudinal designs, path analysis, and should receive careful consideration in terms of An outline of
How psychological
structural equation modelling can all be used to gain practical and therapeutic variables, in addition to the key issues
factors related to
a better understanding of the processes involved. service-user defined outcomes. traumatic experience Section 2:
1 The extent to which ‘complex trauma’ acts as both 6 Services for young homeless people need to pay and personality disorder Case studies
a causative and maintaining factor for homelessness particular attention to the transition between are associated with
should be addressed and a common understanding children/young people and adult agencies, and chronic homelessness Section 3:
generated. to provide interventions tailored to the clients’ Definitions and
Research synopsis
2 The measures used to assess complex trauma developmental needs. weblinks
should be specified and their reliability and validity 7 In order to facilitate robust research programmes
established. addressing aetiology, maintenance and treatment Section 4:
3 There is a clear case for promoting models of issues, research funding from a number sources Guidance and
intervention and clinical management which are should be sought, e.g. government departments, good practice
designed to address the problems associated research councils, health and social care
Section 5:
with complex trauma and PD (e.g. attachment, organisations.
Research
emotional regulation, interpersonal skills, social 8 Given the conclusions of the review, it will
problem solving). These therapeutic frameworks be important to consider the emotional and Section 6:
are particularly important for young people, in psychological needs of frontline homelessness Glossary
preventing more entrenched behaviours and staff, which should be recognised, quantified, and
emotional dysregulation. addressed.
Å back 136
Mental health
Good practice guide
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
For this reason, it has been suggested, services working least, markedly less responsive or amenable to change Cognitive and
with and supporting individual’s with the more deeply via later influences and experiences. However, this is behavioural therapeutic Introduction
entrenched forms of complex trauma – whether as then counter-balanced and possibly contradicted by interventions to
children or as adults – need to pay particular attention other strands in contemporary neuroscience that by tackle homelessness –
to consistency, coherence and clarity in their work. contrast stress neural regeneration, plasticity, on-going research synopsis Section 1:
Approaches such as the therapeutic community, neurological self-organisation, and so allow more scope An outline of
How psychological
Nidotherapy, re-parenting, and other “wrap-around” for later adaptive (or maladaptive) learning. the key issues
factors related to
environments may be a reflection of this need.
traumatic experience Section 2:
The explanatory frameworks that neuroscience currently
and personality disorder Case studies
What can the evidence of recent offers do not however appear to fit or confirm the
are associated with
neuroscience tell us? formal diagnostic categories of personality disorder with Section 3:
chronic homelessness
any great precision. If these clinical patterns are in fact
There is a rapidly growing body of neuroscience Research synopsis Definitions and
valid, there would appear to be some other, or further,
providing evidence for stress and trauma at critical weblinks
processes of shaping or selection of the presentations
developmental stages producing high levels of chemical
and behaviours that medical services have identified. Section 4:
triggers leading to anomalous brain development in
the infant, features which are associated with later Guidance and
behavioural problems. Although dysfunctional for the What can the evidence of other disciplines good practice
individuals concerned, this appears to be a natural tell us?
developmental process, which may even have its Psychology focuses primarily on learning and function Section 5:
origins in evolutionary survival advantage in adaptation rather than diagnosis of pathology; and models of Research
to adverse conditions (significantly, some studies distress and dysfunction in psychology seem to reflect
Section 6:
on the impact of stressful neighbourhoods indicate the neuroscience findings of underlying process more
an independent and additional impact from wider closely than the medico-diagnostic formulations Glossary
environmental influences). of pathology. There are also many studies from
social psychology that stress the role of repetitive
The neuroscience of childhood trauma tends to re-enactment and cyclical re-enforcement of early
suggest that the developmental “damage” of stress traumas and schemas – cycles which can in principle be
and trauma in childhood may be irreversible; or at interrupted if managed with care.
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
These approaches echo earlier studies from sociology Finally there is some evidence of what works both Cognitive and
exploring the role of social processes in the management in treatment environments and in homelessness behavioural therapeutic Introduction
of deviance, including the attitudes and beliefs of staff, resettlement. In either context, the keys to success interventions to
as itself impacting significantly upon the course and seem to involve engagement, safe containment, tackle homelessness –
outcome of dysfunctional behaviour. Micro-social practical and emotional skills learning. These are research synopsis Section 1:
processes, societal reaction, stereotyping and exclusion, precisely the areas where the neuroscience findings An outline of
How psychological
the institutional “processing” of discordant behaviour, have suggested that early childhood trauma may the key issues
factors related to
and the wider shifts in the economy which impact upon have the greatest problematic impact; but they also
traumatic experience Section 2:
social norms and acceptability, all shed further light on suggest that constructive and remedial engagement
and personality disorder Case studies
the frameworks of society’s response, and the services in later life, though difficult, can be achieved.
are associated with
which are available, to “remedy” the problems. Section 3:
chronic homelessness
Research synopsis Definitions and
What does the evidence of practitioners What does the evidence taken as a whole weblinks
tell us? tell us?
Meanwhile, the experience of clinicians, resettlement These studies, both the neuro-biological and the Section 4:
staff and others of “what works”, and what remains psycho-social, converge in indicating strong associations Guidance and
problematic, offers further evidence of a different with attachment difficulties, emotional disregulation, good practice
kind of the possibility of behavioural adaptation in poorer social problem-solving as the underlying
later life, given the right conditions or environment; behavioural issues – all of which are implicated and Section 5:
but also of the difficulty of “getting it right”. The readily identified with a diagnosis of PD, but they also Research
evidence from healthcare on specific interventions seem to point towards a more malleable and potentially
Section 6:
for specific personality disorders is notably equivocal treatable underlying condition; and all indicating
– but it is still incompatible with the “therapeutic the possible necessary focus of remedial work. Glossary
nihilism” of the past. This is at least consistent
with the messages from relatively successful Both the “hard” and “softer” evidence now suggest
psycho-educational treatment modalities such that emotional and behavioural change is possible;
as “Stop and Think” with ex-offenders, and peer but that it may be significantly harder for individuals
support, including via therapeutic communities. traumatised in early years. This may be in part due
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
to such individuals’ greater reliance on a limited and range of influences and interventions in support of Cognitive and
inflexible repertoire of stress-scenario responses; in part the therapeutic or remedial task than more standard behavioural therapeutic Introduction
due to the close inter-connected-ness of beliefs and approaches such as medication, counselling or interventions to
feelings underlying such behavioural repertoires. But it behavioural therapy alone. The social context in tackle homelessness –
may also be due in part due to the powerful dynamism particular, and the worker/client relationship, may be research synopsis Section 1:
of re-enactment of such early traumatic schemas, critical for effective interventions; and for those most at An outline of
How psychological
which tends to evoke punitive or rejecting responses risk, the whole environment may need to be working in the key issues
factors related to
in others, so perpetuating rather than breaking the re- tune with the therapeutic aims.
traumatic experience Section 2:
enforcement cycle.
and personality disorder Case studies
This has considerable implications for the way that,
are associated with
Two key principles or features of success are for example, homelessness resettlement services Section 3:
chronic homelessness
recognising: need to be able to work. From this we can therefore
Definitions and
• the slow pace of the change process for some, and claim to have derived an indication of the potential Research synopsis
weblinks
• the need for personal and organisational resilience
value of novel interventions in resettlement services.
There remains some uncertainty over how far the Section 4:
within the service. That is to say, resilience is needed
maladaptive behaviour characteristic of PD, CD, CT
both in the resources and skills of the workforce, Guidance and
etc is embedded in the personality through early
and in the way that the service as a whole operates good practice
trauma in critical development periods, how far they
– the formal structure of roles, rules and times, the
remain malleable through constructive, containing and Section 5:
informal social structures of meeting places and
enabling experiences later in life, and how far the failure Research
friendship groups, and in the nature and design of
to develop reflects unintentional mismanagement by
buildings, etc.
welfare and correction agencies. Section 6:
Implications and approaches Glossary
These are not options and hypotheses that are easily
In short – what evidence there is suggests that tested in laboratory conditions. We suggest therefore
personal change work is a harder task with PD and that practice in homelessness resettlement and in
“complex” trauma: but change is possible, though it community mental health alike needs to be informed
may be necessary to enlist a wider and more creative by new developments in research and theory; but that
Section 5: Research
Click to go to Æ
Document map
research and theory development also has much to References Cognitive and
learn from studies of (emerging) practice. APA. (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: behavioural therapeutic Introduction
Fourth Edition, Text Revision (4th ed.). Washington DC: American interventions to
The case studies on this site give an indication of the Psychiatric Association. tackle homelessness –
kind of ground-breaking work being done in some areas CLG. (2008). No one left out: Communities ending rough sleeping.
research synopsis Section 1:
London: Communities and Local Government.
to respond to these needs in innovative ways. The An outline of
Hayes, S. Strosahl, K.D. & Wilson, K. (2004) Acceptance and How psychological
hostel and “managed network” services described in Commitment Therapy: An Experiential Approach to Behaviour the key issues
factors related to
the practice section provide ample scope for studies to Change. New York: Guildford.
Hyler, S.E. (1994) Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire – 4+.
traumatic experience Section 2:
enhance our understanding of the maintaining factors
New York: New York State Psychiatric Institute. and personality disorder Case studies
of PD/CT in later life. A more collaborative and inter-
Millon, T., Davis, R., Millon, C. & Grossman, S. (1994) Millon Clinical are associated with
disciplinary approach to research is likely to be most Section 3:
Multiaxial Inventory III. Pearson Assessments: San Antonio. chronic homelessness
productive of new insights; and the homelessness sector Segal, Z.V., Williams, J.M. & Teasdale, J.D. (2002) Mindfulness-based
would appear to be a particularly useful testing ground Research synopsis Definitions and
Cognitive Therapy for Depression: A New Approach to Preventing
for more rounded frameworks of understanding. Relapse. New York: Guildford. weblinks
WHO (1994) International Classification of Diseases – 10.
World Health Organisation.
Section 4:
Guidance and
good practice
Section 5:
Research
Section 6:
Glossary
Å back 141
Mental health
Good practice guide
Section 6: Glossary
Document map
A D Section 1:
ACE Adverse Childhood Experience/Adults Facing DAAT Drug and Alcohol Action Team An outline of
Chronic Exclusion DBT Dialectical Behaviour Therapy the key issues
ADHD Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder DH Department of Health Section 2:
ACT Acceptance and Commitment Therapy DSM Diagnostic and Statistical Manual Case studies
APA American Psychiatric Association
ASB Anti-Social Behaviour H Section 3:
ASBO Anti-Social Behaviour Order HCA Homes and Communities Agency Definitions and
HMP Her Majesty’s Prison weblinks
B
I Section 4:
BPD Borderline Personality Disorder
Guidance and
C IAPT Improved Access to Psychological Therapies good practice
IPT Interpersonal Therapy
CAHMS Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services Section 5:
CAT Cognitive Analytic Therapy J Research
CBT Cognitive Behavioural Therapy JSNA Joint Strategic Needs Assessment
CJS Criminal Justice System Section 6:
CPN Community Psychiatric Nurse K Glossary
CHT Community Housing and Therapy
CORE Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation KUF Knowledge and Understanding Framework
CPD Continuing Professional Development
Section 6: Glossary
Document map
L S
Introduction
LAA Local Area Agreement SP Supporting People
LHF London Housing Foundation
LSP Local Strategic Partnership T Section 1:
TA Temporary Accommodation An outline of
M the key issues
TC Therapeutic Community
MBCT Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy Section 2:
MI Motivational Interviewing W
Case studies
MTFC Multi-dimensional Treatment Foster Care WHO World Health Organisation
Section 3:
N Y Definitions and
NDT New Directions Team weblinks
YOS Youth Outreach Services
NICE National Institute for Clinical Excellence YOT Youth Offending Team Section 4:
NIMHE National Institute of Mental Health in England
NLP Neuro-Linguistic Programming Guidance and
NTQ Notice to Quit good practice
P Section 5:
Research
PCT Primary Care Trust
PD Personality Disorder Section 6:
PDQ Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire Glossary
PIE Psychologically Informed Environment
PSA Public Service Agreement
Å back 143
Communities and Local Government
Eland House
Bressenden Place
London
SW1E 5DU
Telephone: 030 3 444 0000
ISBN: 978-1-4098-2243-5