Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Demand.
New Opportunities for Canadian Companies
At a Glance
The experience of three Canadian companies doing business in China shows that
firms can succeed by finding niches, having a local presence, adapting to the culture,
and developing relationships.
Foreword
For 150 years, HSBC has been at the forefront of helping small, medium and
large companies to growconnecting them to opportunities and helping them to
compete on the international stage. Global trade is in our DNA and we are keenly
aware of the positive links between exporting more of a countrys goods and
services to global markets and greater economic growth. We also see companies
who stall by outgrowing their market and failing to expand internationally.
Canada has benefited from Chinas seemingly insatiable demand for natural
resources over the past decade. The value of exports to China grew at a double
digital pace, lifting it to rank second among Canadas export markets. Although
Chinas economic growth has been easing in recent years compared to its
earlier rapid growth, the country continues to be one of the largest and fastest-
growing economies in the world, offering tremendous opportunities for Canadian
companies. Opportunities that would be escalated with a possible Canada
China free trade agreement.
In order to help our customers learn and grow, we regularly produce insights
gleaned from talking to successful international businesses. In 2015 report,
Selling to the World, we asked the Conference Board of Canada to look at the
key attributes of businesses that succeed on a global stage. And in this latest in
our series of reports, we asked them to look more specifically at what industries
are best prepared to serve the Chinese market. Shifting Chinese Demand
profiles three Canadian companies that have used effective strategies to propel
their growth in China. The research not only includes what worked best, and
what could work for others, but also offers tactics to build further success for
the future.
The research identified the best sectors for Canada that have the right
combination of: high growth potential for Chinese demand; openness to foreign
commercial activities; competitiveness of the Canadian industries producing
the identified goods and services; and, capacity of these industries to increase
production. According to this research, Canadas natural resources sectors,
services sectors and the food manufacturing sector are best positioned to meet
Why should Canada look beyond its borders? Because we can. More importantly,
because doing so allows our country to regain lost ground in productivity,
innovation and competitivenessall key indicators of a healthy, prosperous
economy. The more Canadian firms tap into the worlds opportunitiesincluding
those in Chinathe greater the odds of ensuring our long term economic health.
Linda Seymour
Executive Summary
Although Chinas economy has grown more
slowly in recent years in comparison to its
very rapid growth in the 1990s and the 2000s,
it is still one of the largest and fastest-growing
economies in the world, offering tremendous
opportunities for Canadian companies. These
opportunities will increase if a Canada-China
free trade agreement is signed in the near future.
The historically resource-intensive trade between Canada and China is
projected to shift as China moves from an investment economic model
to a consumption-led one to meet the needs of a growing middle class.
Although commodities are still expected to account for a large share of
Chinese imports, other goods will likely represent an increasing share of
the mix. Furthermore, more opportunities in services sectors will likely
emerge as the rebalancing of the Chinese economy progresses.
The research shows that the most promising sectors for Canada in
China are natural resources industries (including some mining products
Table 1
Sweet Spot Sectors: Canadian Industries Best-Prepared to Meet
Growing Chinese Demand
Scientific research and development services
Mining
Crop production
Animal production
Fishing, hunting, and trapping
Finance and insurance services
Computer and information services
Food manufacturing
Other commercial services
The insights from Clearwater and Hatch reflect these firms long-time
presence in China, whereas those from IJW Dorweiler come from a
company that recently entered the Chinese market. Having a local
presence and developing strong relationships have helped all three
Table 2
Highlighted Canadian Companies
Clearwater Seafoods Hatch IJW Dorweiler
Started in China 1994 1999 2015
Differentiator Recognized globally for Offers unique, proprietary Provides content for
superior quality, food engineering technologies hockey programs
safety, and diversity of (such as those for
Provides cross-border
premium wild-caught, metallurgical processing
financial services for
eco-certified seafood and environmental
SMEs, particularly
protection)
technology companies,
in China
China strategy Local presence/ Local presence/ Local presence/
sales offices offices office
Importers Acquisitions Joint venture
and distributors
New sales channels Joint ventures Partnerships
Other key Canada, U.S., Europe, Canada, Asia/Pacific, Canada, U.S.,
markets Asia, Argentina U.S., South America, Singapore, Europe
Europe, Middle
East, Africa
Introduction
Canada has benefited from Chinas seemingly insatiable demand for
natural resources over the past decade. The value of exports to China
grew at a double-digit pace, lifting it to second place among Canadas
export markets. Although Chinas economic growth is slowing and the
economy is moving from an export- and investment-led model to a more
services- and consumption-based one, the country continues to be one
of the fastest-growing economies in the world and represented over 17
per cent of the worlds economy in 2015.3 With its growing middle class,
China may offer tremendous new opportunities for Canadian companies.
Canada and China have also launched exploratory talks on a free trade
agreement that could eventually open more doors to business in China
The research shows that the most promising sectors in China for
Canadian companies are in the sweet spot where all of these
factors co-exist:
The most promising sectors are found where demand and openness,
capacity, and competitiveness intersect. (See Exhibit 1.)
Exhibit 1
Success Factors: The Intersection of Demand and Openness,
Capacity, and Competitiveness
Demand and
openness
1
Success
Capacity Competitiveness
Research Findings
However, economic growth has been slowing over the last few years.
The stimulus generated a large oversupply of housing, which led to
slower growth in building investment. Slower investment growth is in line
with Chinas goal to move away from an investment-led growth model
toward a consumption- and services-based one. The latest five-year
plan6 (201620), released in March 2016, reinforced the commitment to
this shift. The Chinese government said it would focus on supporting
innovation, reducing excess capacity, and developing industries that
meet changing consumer demand.
Specifically, the researchers found that Chinese demand for the following
goods and services is likely to rise, and that China isor is expected to
becomerelatively open to foreign businesses in these sectors:
commodities:
agricultural commodities (such as cereals, vegetables, and
live animals)
some non-agricultural commodities (such as mineral fuels, oils, and
distillation products, and precious stones and precious metals)
consumer goods:
Canada has global processed foods (such as meat, fish, seafood, vegetables, fruits, nuts,
strengths in many and food products)
of the sectors non-food consumer goods (such as apparel, footwear, headgear, toys,
that align with and pharmaceutical products)
increasing Chinese manufactured goods, such as pulp and aircraft, and some
demand. automotive products
works of art, collectors pieces, and antiques
services sectors:
scientific research, technical services, and geologic prospecting
computer services
financial services
travel services
personal, cultural, and recreational services
e-commerce.
Table 3
Benchmarking Capacity, by Industry
High capacity Moderate capacity Low capacity Minimal capacity
Architectural, engineering, and Finance and insurance services Pharmaceutical and medicine Leather and allied product
related services manufacturing manufacturing
Management services Other chemical manufacturing Aerospace product and parts Wood product manufacturing
manufacturing
Mining (except oil and gas) Transportation and government Beverage and tobacco product Textile mills
services manufacturing
Petroleum and coal product Computer and information services Printing and related support Textile product mills
manufacturing activities
Crop production Basic chemical manufacturing Plastics and rubber products Motor vehicle manufacturing
manufacturing
Animal production Travel services Other transportation Paper manufacturing
manufacturing
(continued ...)
Table 3 (contd)
Benchmarking Capacity, by Industry
High capacity Moderate capacity Low capacity Minimal capacity
Other commercial services Non-metallic mineral product Furniture and related product Computer and electronic product
manufacturing manufacturing manufacturing
Fishing, hunting, and trapping Machinery manufacturing Motor vehicle parts manufacturing
Primary metal manufacturing Clothing manufacturing
Artificial and synthetic fibres and
filaments manufacturing
Fabricated metal product
manufacturing
Miscellaneous manufacturing
Food manufacturing
Electrical equipment, appliance,
and component manufacturing
Table 4
Canadian Industries Best- and Least-Prepared to Capitalize
on Growing Demand
Best prepared Need to increase capacity
Scientific research and development services Wood product manufacturing
Mining Aerospace product and parts manufacturing
Crop production Vehicles and parts manufacturing
Animal production
Fishing, hunting, and trapping
Finance and insurance services
Computer and information services
Food manufacturing
Other commercial services
These methods differ from those Hatch uses to grow business in other
international markets. In some markets, we dont need a permanent
presence and can just establish on a project basis, but in China, it is
essential to have a local presence, explains Lombard. The emphasis on
partnerships in China is stronger and brings greater benefits in terms of
more referrals and opportunities. Its still necessary to create a concrete
initiative, but the connections are the important catalyst for that.
One of the important things the firm has learned is that Chinese clients
place greater value on products than on services. We had to change
the way professional services are presented because the market
for professional services is less mature in China than in some other
countries, says Lombard. In Canada, we might help a client design
something new based on a range of possibilities; in China, the emphasis
needs to be changed to one that shows we are bringing a technology to
bear that addresses the clients needs but is not otherwise available.
marketplace was the partners trip to the Asian Financial Forum in Hong
Kong in 2012. The degree of business connections was unparalleled,
says Dorweiler.
Passionate about hockey and convinced that Beijing would clinch the
hosting of the 2022 Winter Olympics, Dorweiler had already been
networking to sell his vision for growing the sport in China. Through his
Chinese contacts, he was introduced to CTC Groupanother company
with roots in Canada, but in the refrigeration and rink infrastructure
business. They forged a joint venture called Canadome, with CTC
building rinks for the China initiative andtogether with IJWD
developing Chinas hockey content at the grassroots level through
schools and youth programs, including CanadaChina tournaments
and an exchange program. It was a stroke of luck that this match with
CTC was made, since it has a turnkey solution and a strong pipeline
in Asia with the Canada brand, emphasizes Dorweiler, who brought in
Woodens company to help in fundraising and round out the team.
The decision to open an office in Hong Kong reflects the need to have
a local presence in order to do their kind of business effectively. The
success ratio in getting an initial meeting with potential clients in North
America is 50 per cent; in Hong Kong and mainland China, its 95 per
cent. Asian business people are willing to listen and explore how to work
Business people together, notes Dorweiler.
in China want to
learn more about Developing relationships with venture capitalists and other firms is
you and trust another method for growing business. Its quite different to do business in
you before doing China, says Dorweiler. You rarely get rapid decisions in China and Asia.
business with you. Business people in China want to learn more about you and trust you
before doing business with you, so its important to develop relationships
first. Weve had great success because weve been back and forth
sufficiently in the last five years to cultivate these relationships, which
leads to people making introductions for us and giving referrals. Even
though it is just a start-up, IJWD has already been honoured with the Hong
KongCanada Business Association 2016 Business Leader Award and
named the Hong Kong Forum Success Story of the Year for 2016.
Least-Prepared Sectors
Unlike these sectors that are well-prepared to meet rising Chinese
demand, other sectors lack some capacity to meet future demand.
According to the Conference Board analysis, manufacturing industries
such as wood products manufacturing, vehicles and parts manufacturing,
and aerospace industrieswill need to invest in capacity expansion
(plant, machinery, and/or labour) and boost competitiveness to benefit
from the expected increase in demand from China. In the case of
Canadian wood products, for example, firms had to use all their physical
capital in recent years to meet rising demand from the U.S. They will
need to make additional investments to take advantage of Chinese
demand, since they do not have much spare capacity to increase
production in the short term.
Faced with rising competition from Mexico, which benefits from a cost
advantage, the vehicles and parts manufacturing industry has been
struggling to remain competitive. Companies will need to find the right
product mix to secure a market niche in China.
Clearwater Seafoods
It has a laser focus on premium quality and food safety. Its highly valued brand
has kept it strong and growing despite the competition. Its local sales reps
focus on technical education of distributors and chefs, teaching them about
proper product handling and preparation. Also, it hires executive chefs to work
with other chefs to position Clearwater products for local cuisine. Another
distinguishing feature is an innovation group that develops new products.
Hatch
It brings over six decades of international business and technical experience in
the mining, energy, and infrastructure sectors, in more than 150 countries. Rather
than focusing on low cost and repetition of previous solutions, like many other
engineering firms do, it emphasizes innovative solutions and improved technology.
Its biggest differentiators are its unique proprietary technologiesfor example,
technologies for metallurgical processing and environmental protection.
IJWD
It is unique in providing a hockey content development service that leverages
Canadas brand in the sport. It also provides transactional and strategic advisory
services that do not compete with those of large institutions; cross-border
exposure to tech start-ups in Hong Kong and China; and discounted professional
services to build long-term relationships with the start-up companies as they grow.
Exhibit 2
Key Resources for Building a Global Competitive Advantage
Global
competitive
advantage
International Innovation
networks capabilities
Table 5
Key Success Factors for Market Penetration in China
1. Skilled Executives Has a global vision, operating in all Has an export-driven mindset, Has over 50 years of
(knowledgeable, global growth- continents except Antarctica continuously seeking new growth professional experience in
minded leaders, willing to take risks) Has executives who have lived opportunities in different markets serving international clients.
around the world and worked in Has a CEO and management
all markets team very steeped in international Wants to grow its Hong Kong
Is willing to take risks and focus on business, who travel extensively office as a gateway to Asia and
the long term Takes prudent risks Australia and India
Has executives who travel
overseas monthly
2. Foreign Market Knowledge (ability Has a long-established global Has had a strong interest since Focused exclusively on Hong
to prioritize the foreign markets to focus, with 65 offices around the 1990s in diversifying and Kong and mainland China
pursue, and to adapt products and the world expanding into different markets at inception
approach to local market needs)
Develops deep local knowledge where there is demand for Is targeting Singapore and
by hiring local managers, wild, sustainably sourced, and then, potentially, Japan, India,
supported by culturally savvy premium seafood products and Australia
foreign managers Ranks Asia-Pacific as its largest Offers cross-border play
Changed the way it presents its and most important region for SMEs in China and Asia
professional services in China Uses reps to educate and unfamiliar with financing
to focus on technology solutions influence the market in China, resources overseas
not to sell directly
3. Innovation Has a defined R&D expenditure Developed from sea to plate Uses Canadian hockey
Capabilities target that is a percentage of process to ensure lobsters expertise and talent to help
(develop unique products or sales, which is unusual for an shipped overseas reach popularize the sport in China
processing methods for product or
engineering firm destination at peak of perfection Developed a start-up program
service differentiation)
Develops and offers unique Is a global leader in sustainable to perform financial modelling
proprietary technologies seafood excellence and valuation services at a
Carries out ongoing innovative Has an innovation group that discount for smaller technology
and developmental project develops products; marketing firms in China and Asia
work that helps clients staff also focus on new
face challenges product development
4. International Establishes joint ventures with Taps into services of Canadian Uses Canadian and Chinese
Networks Chinese firms for large projects consulates abroad government resources and
(identify new opportunities, secure contacts, including consulates,
Draws on global resources, Seeks assistance from Canada
financing, tackle regulations, and build
contacts, and expertise of 9,000 China Business Council on trade commissioners,
a reputation)
employees with experience in regulatory matters and Hong Kong Trade
more than 150 countries Development Council
Collaborates with partners
and leverages relationship
with Hong Kong-Canada
Business Association
The company also monitors growth trends and new sales channels
to understand how they relate to its business and how to leverage
1. Demand:
Opportunity for Clearwater: As the middle class and disposable
income have grown in China, seafood consumption per capita has
increased from 35 kilograms per person five years ago to 41 kilograms
per person now.
Strategies
Geographic expansion: Clearwater is focused on bringing products into
Tier 2 cities.
E-commerce and retail channels: The company has a new focus on retail
and e-commerce channels as efficient ways of extending its business. It
recently started a partnership with Tmall, a major e-commerce platform,
so people can buy live lobster.
Supply expansion: Thats one of the reasons Clearwater acquired a
Scottish company, Macduff Shellfish, in late 2015. It has about 7,000
tonnes of product to sell beyond Europe, particularly to China.
Expanded product offering: Clearwater is introducing a wider breadth of
products, such as brown crab from Macduff.
Smart investment: Clearwater invests heavily in people and in vessels
to support products that end up in the AsiaPacific region, especially
China, and have put resources behind the clam business.
Future: With Chinas expanding middle class fuelling discretionary
spending and an affluent consumer segment, Clearwater will continue
to capitalize on the growing demand for premium seafood in this
marketplace well into the future, says Morency.
2. Demands
High-quality seafood.
Environmental improvement, as the nature of Chinese investment
changes from building heavy industry and public infrastructure to
focusing on environmental improvement and promotion of a more
services-oriented consumer economy.
Outbound Chinese investment, as investors increasingly look to diversify
in other markets.
Strategies
Project teams: As a project-focused organization, Hatch rapidly creates
strong project teams around an existing core team for each assignment.
For example, the firm grew its Shenyang office from 100 to 200 people
in a few months. It had to hire, train, and integrate these people to
deliver on a specific project related to the QSLIC magnesium smelter
dehydration plant in Qinghai.
Proprietary technologies: Hatch develops new technologies, such as
clean technologies for environmental remediation.
R&D initiatives: Hatch has a target R&D expenditure.
Acquisitions and joint ventures/partnerships: Hatch uses these methods
to gain access to complementary expertise.
Future: We absolutely see increasing demand for Hatchs services in the
next few years and have the capacity to deliver through our 9,000-person
organization, particularly in supporting outbound investment,
says Lombard.
3. Demands:
Recreation services for the growing middle class.
Increasing Chinese outbound investment.
Strategies
Legal: IJWD is formalizing incorporation with CTC on the
hockey initiative.
Financing: The firm is creating a fund to finance Canadome ice rinks
and related hockey content projects through capital markets in Canada,
targeting institutions to participate, and setting up a parallel fund in Hong
Kong through investment bankers and its regional network. It has also
hired a capital markets expert in Canada to help.
Hiring: IJWD wants to bring on board Mandarin-speaking business
development support staff to successfully reach into mainland China and
help build its brand in Asia.
Future: Seeing the huge advantage of Hong Kong as a gateway to Asia,
IJWD wants to grow its office there in terms of clients, revenues, and
employees. It has already relocated its office in Hong Kong to be closer
to the financial hub. We expect our Asian operations in five years will be
five times the size of our Canadian business.
All three of our profiled companies hire locally to facilitate outreach to non-
English-speaking people.Their executives also understand the importance
of being culturally savvy to succeed there.They all emphasize the need to
be attuned to and respectful of cultural differences (for example, you wont
get a quick yes or no, so patience is required) and to take time to build
relationships first.This is an area where Canadians possess a greater
advantage by having more of that sensitivity than other international
competitors, says Lombard. It will be extremely rewarding financially and
personally if you put effort into this, adds Dorweiler.
Clearwater sets itself apart from its many competitors by focusing on the
quality its become known for and for which people are willing to pay a
premium.Its differentiators include an industry designation guaranteeing
sustainability, a special band on lobsters to ensure authenticity, frozen-
at-sea products, technical education on proper seafood handling and
preparation, and an innovation group for new product development.
bring is help for their clients who want to expand overseas, find a partner,
Its a very different or get a valuation if they want to sell.
market, society,
culture, and legal Intellectual property (IP) protection: Safeguarding IP is a common
system than in concern for companies doing business in China, especially those
The key is to make sure you have relationships in place that are strong,
capable, and built on trust, and that can be leveraged over the long term.
Never underestimate the value of these relationships.
I was really struck with the welcoming and receptive nature of the
business climate. The people we meet withincluding senior managers,
and partners of VC, private equity, and legal firmsare serious about
doing business and spend quality time with us.
Conclusion
China has long represented great potential for Canadian exporters,
particularly those in the commodities sector. However, as Chinese
economic growth decreases from its previous heights and China shifts
from an investment to a consumption modeldriven by its burgeoning
middle classthe countrys demands for goods and services are
gradually changing. Although commodities are still expected to account
for a large share of Chinese imports, other goodsespecially agricultural
and high-quality food productswill likely represent an increasing share
of the mix. More opportunities in services sectors are also projected
to emerge as Chinas structural transition progresses, if China opens
its services sectors to foreign direct investment. The rebalancing of
the Chinese economy presents many potential new opportunities for
Canadian companies.
APPENDIX A
Bibliography
Audet, Kristelle, and Michael Shaw. Selling to the World: Learning From
the International Experience of 20 Successful Canadian Companies.
Ottawa: The Conference Board of Canada, 2015.
Prasad, Eswar. The Path to Sustainable Growth in China. April 22, 2015.
www.brookings.edu/testimonies/the-path-to-sustainable-growth-in-china/
(accessed October 17, 2016).
e-Library.
Do you want to have access to expert thinking on the issues that really
matter to you and your organization?
Our e-Library contains hundreds of Conference Board research studies in the areas of
Organizational Performance, Economic Trends and Forecasts, and Public Policy.
www.e-library.ca
About The Conference Board of Canada
We are:
To cite this briefing: Baka, Susan. Shifting Chinese Demand: New Opportunities for Canadian Companies.
Ottawa: The Conference Board of Canada, 2017.
An accessible version of this document for the visually impaired is available upon request.
Accessibility Officer, The Conference Board of Canada
Tel.: 613-526-3280 or 1-866-711-2262 E-mail: accessibility@conferenceboard.ca
The Conference Board of Canada and the torch logo are registered trademarks of The Conference Board, Inc. Forecasts
and research often involve numerous assumptions and data sources, and are subject to inherent risks and uncertainties.
This information is not intended as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice. The findings and conclusions of
this report do not necessarily reflect the views of the external reviewers, advisors, or investors. Any errors or omissions in
fact or interpretation remain the sole responsibility of the Conference Board of Canada.