19/10/2017 Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab?

Foreign Policy

ARGUMENT

Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab?

From the ashes of the countrys deadliest terrorist attack, lasting peace seems a long way off.
BY ALEX DE WAAL | OCTOBER 19, 2017, 2:11 PM

The scene of an exploded truck bomb in the Somali capital of Mogadishu on Oct. 14. (Mohamed Abdiwahab/AFP/Getty Images)

I
n the battle of wills for Somalias future, the terrorist group al-Shabab struck a cruel and potentially lasting blow on Oct. 14. Not only
did it kill more than 300 people in the largest terrorist attack in the countrys history; it shook the confidence of the Somali
government and its domestic and international backers that they can stay the course in rebuilding the war-torn East African nation.

By committing conspicuous atrocities such as this, al-Shababs leaders signal that they have burned all their bridges, that negotiation
with them is fruitless, and most importantly that they are still a potent threat. Al-Shabab has sustained its decadelong insurgency,
maintaining control over a significant, albeit diminished territory, because it focuses relentlessly on the essentials pounding the fragile
U.N.-backed government and the international forces that prop it up while positioning itself as a credible alternative by efficiently
administering the regions it controls. It has long been a better-run organization than its adversaries, including the corruption-plagued
central government. Licit traders and smugglers alike do business with al-Shabab, because where its writ extends, its licenses and
receipts are respected; there isnt the arbitrary extortion and corruption that characterized warlord rule from the 1990s to the middle
2000s and still impede business in government-controlled areas today.

It is even possible that this cancer of corruption made the Oct. 14 bombing possible: Questions are already being asked about how the
truck bomb was able to penetrate Mogadishus security cordon and whether al-Shabab had collaborators inside the government. That
kind of doubt in the integrity of Somali institutions is exactly what the terrorist group seeks to sow.

Ever since the 2012 London Conference that heralded the transition from years of discredited transitional governments to todays federal
government, the new Somali order has been underpinned by a collective effort by international donors to rebuild the country and its
institutions. Critics call it wishful thinking, disbelieving the idea that bickering Somali politicians and businessmen will work together

http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/10/19/can-somalia-ever-win-against-al-shabab-terrorism/?utm_content=bufferd47e3&utm_medium=social&utm_sour 1/5
19/10/2017 Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab? Foreign Policy

with a diverse group of regional powers, including Ethiopia, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and Qatar and that a 22,000-strong mission of
African Union troops can defeat al-Shabab on the battlefield. But Somalias many international backers are betting that they can outlast
the extremist insurgency and that over time people will come to embrace the new government they are helping to stand up.

And indeed there are signs that it is working if slowly and haltingly. Mogadishu is booming, resembling a giant construction site; the
famously dynamic business community is investing; diaspora Somalis are returning (at least to visit). Turkey has just opened a vast
military academy to help train the Somali army, a facility that early reports suggest may have been the actual target of Saturdays
bombing. (The driver reportedly panicked after being stopped by security forces and detonated his truck bomb in a central square where
by tragic coincidence a fuel tanker was parked, causing a fireball that hugely magnified the blast.) Saudi Arabia is contributing cash
directly to the national budget, and the United Arab Emirates is investing heavily in port infrastructure, although both countries have
recently butted heads with the Somali government over its refusal to take their side in the Gulf dispute with Qatar.

But Somalia remains stuck in a protracted cycle of insecurity, dependent on peacekeepers with the African Union Mission in Somalia
(AMISOM) who cannot remain forever. Ethiopian and Kenyan AMISOM troops began withdrawing from some areas in the last few
months allowing al-Shabab to reoccupy the strategic town of Bariire, close to Mogadishu and that drawdown is scheduled to
accelerate next year. The plan is to replace these troops with a new Somali national security architecture army, police, coast guard,
intelligence that is trained and equipped by AMISOM and its partners. But the Somali security services are far from ready, rendering
the AU and United Nations planning more of an exercise in political theater than practical planning. At the U.N. Security Council last
month, the Somali ambassador and several other international officials quietly spelled out why an AMISOM withdrawal would be a
recipe for disaster.

Still, the money has to come from somewhere. The European Union, which finances 80 percent of the AMISOM budget down from 90
percent two years ago is slowly cutting back on its funding. (A Barack Obama-era proposal to finance 75 percent of AU peace
operations from U.N. member states assessed contributions has died under the current administration.)

Equally important, while Somalis recognize that AU troops, mainly from Ethiopia and Kenya, are necessary to fight al-Shabab, their
presence is resented. The controlling role of historically antagonistic neighbors is an affront to Somali national pride, and Kenyan
investigative journalists have uncovered evidence of corruption and violations of humanitarian law by the Kenyan army in Somalia.
(There are no Ethiopian investigative journalists.)

The Mogadishu bombing makes any withdrawal planning moot. The Kenyans, Ethiopians, and the Somali army will now be under strong
pressure to ramp up their offensive actions, aiming especially at the areas recently reoccupied by al-Shabab.

The bombing also highlights some of the dilemmas facing the Donald Trump administration, which has quietly ramped up the combat
operations of U.S. Special Forces in Somalia. The first is whether to embrace the multilateral approach of the leading international
players in Somalia the African Union and the European Union or continue to go it alone with its America First approach to foreign
policy. For reasons of pragmatism, the Pentagon and State Department will likely want to match the multilateralism of the EU and AU,
both of which have borne a significantly greater share of the human and financial costs of fighting al-Shabab. But that requires coughing
up the funds for a peacekeeping operation with a long time horizon and coordinating military strategy with African militaries, things the
Trump administration has seemed reluctant to do.

TRENDING

1 Republicans Have Stockholm Syndrome and Its Getting Worse 1387SHARES

2 The Resistible Rise of Xi Jinping 550SHARES

3 Some unhappy reasons for why we are on the verge of another war in Lebanon 246SHARES

4 Western Sanctions Are Shrinking Russias Population 521SHARES

5 Irans Not a Totally Fake Democracy, Study Says 257SHARES

6 Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab? 62SHARES

7 Armageddon by Accident 299SHARES

8 China Is Getting Better at Undermining Global Human Rights 237SHARES

The second dilemma is whether to prioritize political or military action. Bitter experience has shown that the metrics most readily usable
by military planners territory captured, body counts, high-value targets killed have no traction on the real progress of winning this
war. Military strikes are primarily a fireworks display to impress the spectators, rather than a strategy for victory. Al-Shabab can
continue to recruit, and each time a senior leader is killed, more radical lieutenants will take over.

This is a war that must be won politically as well as militarily. A common sentiment quietly muttered in Mogadishu is that the war will be
won when our Shabab are stronger than their Shabab. In other words, the Somali government must cultivate a credible Islamist
constituency of its own, winning over most of the political and financial backers of the Islamic Courts Union (ICU), the Islamist
movement that briefly took control of Mogadishu in 2006 and from which al-Shabab emerged. Many of the leading figures from the ICU

http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/10/19/can-somalia-ever-win-against-al-shabab-terrorism/?utm_content=bufferd47e3&utm_medium=social&utm_sour 2/5
19/10/2017 Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab? Foreign Policy

have already joined the political mainstream. Both President Mohamed Abdullahi Mohamed, known by the nickname Farmaajo, and his
predecessor, Hassan Sheikh Mohamud, made an effort to include them as part of a broad-based government. And just two months ago,
one senior al-Shabab commander, Mukhtar Robow, defected after protracted clandestine negotiations.

Its impossible to say for certain whether this combined military and political strategy is working and the worst possible time for a
clear-eyed assessment is in the immediate aftermath of an atrocity with massive civilian casualties but available evidence suggests that
it is slowly inching the country forward. The challenge for Farmaajo and his international backers after Saturdays horrific bombing is to
stay the course, even if the bloodshed makes it feel as if theyre slipping backward.

Alex de Waal is the executive director of the World Peace Foundation. His latest book is The Real Politics of the Horn of Africa: Money, War and the Business of Power.

SHOW
TAGS: AFRICA, ARGUMENT, SOMALIA COMMENTS

TRENDING NOW SPONSORED LINKS BY TABOOLA

End Your Nightly Snoring

Nightmare With This Simple
Solution
My Snoring Solution
Tiny Device Allows You To Track
Anything (it's Genius!)
TrackR Bravo
That's How You Find Super Cheap
Flights!
Save70.com
You Can Speak A New Language
In 15 Hours - All You Need Is This
App!
Babbel
BY TABOOLA

MORE FROM FOREIGN POLICY

This Is How Great-Power Wars Get
Started
The Palace Intrigue at the Heart of
the Qatar Crisis
When Europe Loved Islam
Will Qatars Diplomatic Exile Spark
the Next Great War?
Expelling the Taliban From Qatar Would Be a Grave Mistake
Theres No Space for Qatar to Save Face
BY TABOOLA

the latest
Irans Not a Totally Fake Democracy, Study Says
A new survey shows a country with a constrained but active body politic, contrary to plenty of D.C. conventional wisdom.
THE CABLE | RHYS DUBIN

Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab?

From the ashes of the countrys deadliest terrorist attack, lasting peace seems a long way off.
ARGUMENT | ALEX DE WAAL

Waiting for that official knock on the door: A military spouses thoughts
The "sacred trust" between military families and the commander in chief provides secure ground
BEST DEFENSE | THOMAS E. RICKS

voices

http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/10/19/can-somalia-ever-win-against-al-shabab-terrorism/?utm_content=bufferd47e3&utm_medium=social&utm_sour 3/5
19/10/2017 Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab? Foreign Policy

JAMES STAVRIDIS

Back to the Future in Afghanistan

SUZANNE NOSSEL

The Pro-Free Speech Way to Fight Fake News

DANIEL ALTMAN

If Anyone Can Bankrupt the United States, Trump Can

http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/10/19/can-somalia-ever-win-against-al-shabab-terrorism/?utm_content=bufferd47e3&utm_medium=social&utm_sour 4/5
19/10/2017 Can Somalia Ever Win Against al-Shabab? Foreign Policy

http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/10/19/can-somalia-ever-win-against-al-shabab-terrorism/?utm_content=bufferd47e3&utm_medium=social&utm_sour 5/5