Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Debatesdebates transcript
NO YES
Thomas S. Szasz, M.D. Richard S. Shottenfeld, M.D.
Professor Psychiatry Emeritus Assoc. Prof. of Psychiatry
SUNY Health Science Yale University School of Med.
Syracuse, N.Y. New Haven, Conn.
Page 1 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Okay. I think almost anything can cause
addiction in the sense that it can form a habit which is hard to get
rid of, depending on how volitionally strong people are. Drugs can
cause addiction; so can my girlfriend. If I am deprived of her I
will be restless and suffer from insomnia, loss of appetite, all kinds
of things that being deprived of an addictive substance--because
it's not the substance that is addictive, it's you who wishes to
continue a habit that you have formed. Is my time up?
Page 2 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
Page 3 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
Page 4 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
provide treatment for what are not diseases but are politically
defined as diseases. It's difficult for me to discuss this subject
without reminding people of the audience that masturbation, self
abuse, was for 200 years the leading psychiatric disease before it
was replaced by drug abuse. So these are not diseases. Now if this
person wants to stop using drugs, he should use the same economic
means to get treatment that he used to get the drugs, namely, he
should pay for it. If he wants it, he will pay for it. A characteristic
of so-called drug treatment today is that the people who get it
don't pay for it. They only pay for the drugs, not for the treatment.
DR. SZASZ: Yes, indeed. First of all, the first appropriate thing I
think government's duty is to leave adults alone. If your concern
is children, then the government should say if you want to smoke
or take heroin or anything else as an adult, as a competent adult,
then stay out of my life. After that, I would say that it would worry
Jefferson, not to mention Aristotle, the idea that it is the
government's job to protect children from taking toxic substances.
For thousands of years, and even today, when it comes to
household cleansers and toilet cleansers, which are all very toxic,
it is parents who have to protect the children. The government
does not assume--you don't hear either from Mr. Dole or Mr.
Clinton talk about protecting you from Clorox. But Clorox is
much more dangerous for children than marijuana.
Page 5 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. GELLER: Oh, that over the long haul, drug addiction causes
a great many more--
DR. SZASZ: That's not true. It's only if society defines it that
way.
Page 6 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. GELLER: Oh, you should tell that to the people who are
dying from the results of their nicotine and alcohol addiction and
to the people whose children have been killed--
DR. SZASZ: Not able to? Or not willing to? How can you tell the
difference?
TIMEKEEPER: It's difficult for me to stop this, but you may sit.
Dr. Schottenfeld, you can stand and your team can now question
Dr. Schottenfeld.
DR. SZASZ: What percentage pay you directly from their own
pockets?
Page 7 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
also work very much in the public treatment system that is very
much supported by public treatment dollars. And the people who
come--
DR. SZASZ: Let me only say that this sounds to me--and I don't
know if it sounds to you--very, very eerily similar to forcible
religious conversion. But I would like Professor Alexander to
continue.
Page 8 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. SCHOTTENFELD: Well, it's not clear that they know all
the things that I know at any level. As Dr. Geller has already said,
most of the people who become addicted to drugs start out using
drugs as children, adolescents. I don't think they are fully informed at
that point. I don't think they can imagine what life
will be like if they become addicted. I think they get swayed very
early on by what a friend, what a peer is doing, and make choices
that can be terrible for them.
Page 9 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
questioned.
MR. ALEXANDER: I think you are. Let me tell you why I think
you are. People create all sorts of problems, such as not making
themselves employable, which the government ultimately has to
solve in one way or another, and drugs are no different from that.
Lots of people can use drugs without becoming a government
liability, and as a general matter I reject the notion that because
any habit may ultimately make a person indigent or in need of
government help gives government a right for that reason to
intervene.
Page 10 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
Page 11 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: I would like to try to define first of all
what we mean by treatment. If we mean by treatment an
educational effort to call attention to the damage that drugs
produce--
MR. ALEXANDER: Well, then I am all for it.
DR. GELLER: No, no, no--
DR. GELLER: I would like to ask you: Have you read the
treatment outcome data? Are you aware that there is considerable
scientific evidence that treatment in fact is effective for a certain
percentage of the people treated? Not all of them--
Page 12 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
Page 13 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Yes, I do, a). And b) Let me point out I
am opposed to involuntary treatment of anything, including for
that matter cancer or whatever else.
DR. SZASZ: But look, if I may say something, this discussion and
your comments certainly are premised on ignoring the fact that the
American government, instead of persecuting foreign enemies,
which used to be the duty of governments for thousands of years,
is now persecuting its own citizens in the name of drug abuse and
drug treatment. After all, the jails are full of people, for instance--
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Well, I haven't gone into that because
that wasn't the question I was being asked.
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Forgive me, when you say prosecuting its
own citizens, the government always prosecutes people who break
its laws. If it has made a law, which you may oppose--
DR. SZASZ: But you are opposed to it. But you are opposed to it.
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: No, no, forgive me. I have not talked
about that. I am against involuntary treatment, but I am not
necessarily against punishment for people who break the law. I
Page 14 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
may want to change the law or not; that's a different matter. But
meanwhile I don't regard it as persecution if a person is
prosecuted and punished for breaking a law with which you may
disagree or I may disagree. It's still a law.
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: I didn't say these laws were just or that
any laws were just..
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: And you know, I haven't discussed it.
Forgive me, I have merely objected to Tom's insistence that--
MR. ALEXANDER: But was it not persecution in Germany?
Page 15 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. GELLER: I --
Page 16 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
genetic changes that occur, the expression at the level of the gene,
of proteins that occur from drug abuse, and I was wondering how
you--
Page 17 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. SZASZ: Well then how do you explain the fact that when a
person like this is treated in the old-fashioned, brutal way, and
simply put in prison for two months, cold turkey, then he comes
out and starts taking the drug again. Now he's free of the drug
effect.
DR. GELLER: Oh, he's free, but his brain has changed. I mean,
I think that we all understand that--
DR. GELLER: Well, no, but they are not the same kind of
changes. I mean, obviously some changes will--
DR. SZASZ: They are much more clearly demonstrable than the
changes you claim.
DR. GELLER: Oh, but the kind of changes you get from boxing
are going to possibly cause dementia or difficulty in cognitive
Page 18 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
function, but they are not going to cause addiction, because they are not in
the same area of the brain.
DR. SZASZ: Well--
DR. GELLER: Oh, I think that one of the very interesting areas
of research is why some people appear to be more vulnerable to
drugs than others. And certainly we have a lot of research that
suggests--I think the data is convincing--that this is on a genetic
basis, not a simple gene, but a complex mode of inheritance which
makes some people more vulnerable to the effects of certain
substances.
Page 19 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. SZASZ: Yes, we give the message that you can't help
yourself.
DR. SZASZ: But you are not speaking of the issue of temptation.
The way the government can influence the system is by letting
people be exposed to temptation and suffering the consequences as
early as possible. It's to do with raising a child and training him
how not to wet the bed, how not to eat all night.
Page 20 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
TIMEKEEPER: It was almost like that, but don't sit down yet.
DR. SZASZ: Well, I don't know if you have read and whether
you trust a book like Malcolm X's Autobiography of Malcolm X,
which describes how he was unable to get off drugs with all the
treatment systems, but got off it when he decided to get off it.
And that he said that getting off cigarettes was much harder than
getting off cocaine or heroin. I trust that kind of an account much
more than the professionally prejudiced accounts, all of which
profit economically from this enormous government-funded
industry called drug treatment.
Page 21 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
in that there are many ways that people can come off drugs, and
Malcolm X demonstrates one of them. [bell] People can come
off in other ways too. Medical treatment is very effective as a
way of helping--
DR. SZASZ: Then would you have any objection to-- [bell]
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: It's a wholly different matter whether the
government is legitimate, whether its laws are legitimate, whether
you want to obey them, whether you think morally it's better not
to obey them-- That's not what I was discussing. I was discussing--
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Right. And let me point out--I want to
quarrel just a little bit more semantically, because I don't think we
are all that-- intellectually at least--divided. I do totally agree that
Page 22 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
people can, if they want to, control themselves. And that when
they say "I can't," they generally mean, "I am unwilling to,"
despite the fact that you call to their attention that they should, et
cetera, et cetera. But I think you go a little too far. You see,
people's volition, what they want, can be influenced by other
people. Not compelled--I am totally opposed to that; it doesn't
work. But you can influence them. You can, for instance, try to
change the atmosphere of the young in such a way that--
MR. ALEXANDER: Forgive me. I see where you are going, and
we probably agree on a good part of it. Let me get to something
on which we disagree. Since we both agree that taking drugs is a
volitional matter and we both agree that it is illegitimate for
government normally to change choices legitimately made, why
are you for criminalizing the use of drugs?
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: The major effect has been to--
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Yes, I totally agree with you. More
attractive to get into the business, but the price is higher. And the
price being higher, less of it will be consumed. And if a
government's intention is to reduce the consumption, this is one
way of achieving it.
Page 23 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
really explain that the matter isn't volitional, it makes sense for
the government to fill half of its prisons and jails with people
who are there because the government is trying to dissuade
a few from taking drugs, that sounds fairly nonsensical.
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: Now if you like drugs so much that you
are willing to take the risk to go to prison for them, et cetera, then--
DR. VAN DEN HAAG: I am not sure that I follow you fully, but
let me point out that there are good reasons why the taking of
drugs is socially undesirable. Not to the point necessarily of
saying that the people who do it can't help it or anything like that.
I think they can help it, but I think the government has a right to
discourage this. I think the majority of the American people
would like it to be discouraged because they are aware of the fact
that people who do take drugs become in many ways socially
undesirable. [bell]
Page 24 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. GELLER: Yes, I want to say the objection that you are
having to "vulnerability," would you consider that some people are
not vulnerable to diabetes, to arthritis--
Page 25 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
TIMEKEEPER: Dr. Schaler, you can now turn that around into
a question, if you like.
DR. GELLER: You are very different from myself. And I think
we differ on many aspects. You look different. You have a beard;
I don't have a beard. We differ also, I think, in our response to
drugs, and you may be much less vulnerable to the effect of
addictive drugs than I am. And I am not talking about the 87
percent of people, if that's indeed the correct number, who can
give up drugs without problem. I am talking about actually the 10-15 percent
of people who experience enormous difficulty in spite
of their desire to do so--patients who come to me saying, "Please
help me. I want to give up drugs, but I can't." And I think that
their pleas are genuine and their addiction is a part of their
particular physiological makeup.
Page 26 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
DR. SCHALER: I think they are liars. They are not telling the
truth.
DR. GELLER: That is not true that it has not been upheld by the
research. It depends what research you look at. There is
considerable research done by Mark Schochet, Henri Begleiter,
looking at differences in people who later become addicted or who
are sons and daughters of alcoholics.
Page 27 of 28 pages
Do Drugs Cause Addiction?
Debatesdebates transcript
human brain has not changed, and many of the chemicals that we
are now talking about have been around for a long time. How
come we are having this discussion today in 1996? And my
answer is because this has become convenient for both right-wing,
left-wing, and middle-wing governments in the Western world. As
they have run out of scapegoats, the foreign enemies, they are all
now running against drugs, and this is a convenient scapegoat and
therefore your whole discussion about brains and chemistry is
really beside the point. [bell]
Page 28 of 28 pages