Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
T Analysis
Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats
Learning Community 19
Megan Alcox, Jon Ashbrook, Devin Berresford, Audrey Burris, Connor
Cavanagh, Avery Fehrenbach, Brian Frey, Susan Heath, Brian Hollis, Ishaan
Jotsinghani, Ryan Judge, Sydney Klein, Logan Nickell, Mark Rimkevicius, and
Hudson Whiting
TQL S.W.O.T. 2
Table of Contents
Introduction 2
Strengths
Weaknesses
Public Image 7
Limited Geographic Reach 8
Opportunities
Penalization 9
International Growth 10
Technological Improvements 12
Threats
Up-and-Coming Companies 13
Global Competition 15
Delays 16
Competitor Technology 19
Recommendations 21
Appendix 23
Bibliography 25
TQL S.W.O.T. 3
Introduction
Total Quality Logistics is a private, third-party firm that was founded in 1997 by Ken
Oakes in Cincinnati, Ohio. Since then, TQL has become the second-largest freight brokerage
firm in North America. With more than fifty-nine establishments in the United States, they
employ 4,200 people and are growing more and more every day (Figure A.2 and A.3).
TQLs strengths include their unique twenty-two week long training program that teaches
new employees the skills needed to be successful as a stockbroker in their company. TQL also
offers countless benefits to their employees including uncapped commission, special events
hosted by the company, a 24/7 gym, and many more. Their vast social media base is an efficient
way to stay connected with their customers and employees, and their outstanding and unique
Like any up-and-coming company, TQL does have weaknesses. Their company is not
very well-known in the public eye, they have a limited geographic reach because of not having
many establishments in the Western United States, their business practices could use major
improvements in efficiency, and drivers that receive bad reviews reflect negatively on TQL.
Opportunities that could improve TQL include a penalization system for late drivers,
international growth to greatly expand business, resource ownership to spread the company name
and lower costs, and technological improvements to compete with other stock brokerage firms as
There are multiple threats that could be potential concerns to TQL. Companies such as
Uber are beginning to enter the stock brokerage field, most competitors are global, weather
conditions can cause delays, and some competing companies are more technologically advanced.
Strengths
TQL S.W.O.T. 4
Total Quality Logistics strives to give all potential candidates the opportunities to grow
within the business. The company prides itself on their ability to hire from multiple backgrounds
and environments. They currently work with colleges and universities across the United States,
like the University of Cincinnati, to recruit top graduates for their programs. The company pulls
from different majors and minors but also allows those with pure work experience on board. In
the first five months, employees are trained under existing sales representatives to learn the
basics of the company. The new employees start with no clients and must work hard to develop a
base for themselves. This method allows TQL to separate themselves from other companies in
the field; the training they require is unique and shows new employees exactly what they are
getting into.
TQL starts off their employees with a flat salary of $35,000. However, this does not
include the employees ability to earn commission. Employees have no cap on what they can
earn and are expected to go above and beyond to increase their financial reward. Throughout the
training programs, employees maximize their hours and are encouraged to come in early or stay
late. Earning their own commission empowers new hires to continuously work harder. TQL also
offers job positions in numerous other fields. Finance, customer service, recruiting, and others
allow their staff to move within their company. Since the field of sales is ever-changing, TQLs
training program allows new hires to get an exact read on what they will be doing within the
company. This pushes them to develop their own connections and keep up with the demand of
Benefits
TQL has a long-standing commitment to providing their employees with more than the
TQL S.W.O.T. 5
average enterprise. With the flat salary and commission, they help their employees to enjoy
vacations, celebrate holidays, and keep themselves healthy. Many TQL employees enjoy paid
vacations as a reward for the extra effort they put in daily. The reward of time off motivates their
personnel to continue their standard of excellence. TQL often hosts holiday and charitable events
within the offices and around the towns where they are located. Along with this, the company
boasts a 24/7 gym and cafeteria to help their employees commit to a healthier lifestyle and a
quick way to refuel on the job. Total Quality Logistics offers many other benefits to their
employees including health and wellness, financial freedoms, and employee perks . Employees
of TQL receive medical and dental coverage as well as a discounted gym membership which
promotes beneficial habits. The company shows that they care about their employees financially
by offering a 401 K plan with employer match, short-term and long-term disability insurance,
and life insurance. There are also opportunities for employee housing discounts as well as a
tuition assistance program to encourage employees to take more university classes. Their tuition
assistance program gives their staff an opportunity to return to school or continue into higher
TQL has a passion for helping the community and is willing to match any employee
donations to the eligible organizations. They match United Way donations as well. TQL sponsors
community events and participates in company-wide volunteering. They raised money to support
breast cancer and even created a Pinktober fundraising event where they donated a portion of all
Social Media
In todays digital world, one of the most effective ways for a company to stay connected
with their employees and customers is through the internet. Total Quality Logistics has an
TQL S.W.O.T. 6
outstanding social media base. The company has accounts on numerous sites including
Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Linkedin, and YouTube. TQL even has their own app that allows
Their Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram accounts all consist of daily posts about volunteer
work TQL does in both the United States and other places around the world, tips for truck
drivers, and other day-to-day happenings in the company. These accounts are all active on a daily
basis and especially benefit their truck drivers with posts about ways they can make better meal
choices to stay energized and alert behind the wheel. Other posts on TQLs main social media
accounts are directed towards potential employees by spreading their companys culture and
The TQL Linkedin account has 45,000 followers and is a very strong networking base
that shows their prominent leadership in service work. It also shares information on how to be
hired in order to start earning the countless benefits that the company has to offer. Another great
way to learn about the companys unique benefits is through their YouTube account. They work
to promote job applications, volunteer work, and their outstanding company culture through their
Youtube videos (Total Quality Logistics). In addition, TQL has an active blog that is updated
twice a month which helps in staying connected to its vast company and customer community
(Lifeattql). Another way that TQL is advancing technologically is through their app TQL Trax
that allows clients to track their truck loads in order to ensure an on-time delivery.
TQLs unique company culture embodies countless benefits for both their customers and
employees to enjoy as part of the team. Their work hard, play hard mentality is a great way to
motivate their employees to work as diligently as possible while also being able to build a solid
TQL S.W.O.T. 7
community foundation by participating in frequent fun events hosted at TQL. Being a family
oriented company also allows TQL employees to mix their personal lives with their work lives.
A normal day at TQL consists of playing cornhole or ping pong between calls, roller
blading down the hallways, and even fun challenges to earn bragging rights. This type of healthy
competition is a great way to motivate employees to work hard and create a balanced life, which
may seem very out of the ordinary to other large companies. Employees often describe the
atmosphere as never a dull moment. Multiple videos on YouTube prove that TQLs fun and
uplifting culture encourages everyone on the team to be the best they can be (Total Quality
Logistics).
In a similar aspect, the companys operations are somewhat out of the ordinary in
comparison to their competitors. TQL is able to book truck drivers and transport loads all over
the country without owning a single truck. In most cases depending on the cost of the load, this is
an important strength because all the company needs is office space and hard working employees
to operate the business. Another great advantage of the company is that operations are open
twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week, three hundred sixty-five days a year. This is only
possible because of their extremely hardworking employees who are willing to take calls from
Weaknesses
Public Image
Although TQL maintains a social presence on networks like Facebook, Twitter, and
LinkedIn, their overall name is not well known. Many companies excel in marketing campaigns
within commercials, billboards, or online advertising, but TQL has a limited reach. Their largest
TQL S.W.O.T. 8
commercial was for Super Bowl 50 when they partnered with Big Brothers Big Sisters as an
initiative within their TQL Cares program. This commercial could have been a great start to a
longer campaign but was never followed through. Many companies advertise with billboards as
well, and this should be an obvious move for TQL considering all of their shipments cross
highways. A customer delivering their own goods would see a billboard and know the next time
Another issue that comes with TQL not owning their own trucks is that their name is
never seen. When a company owns their trucks, they have another opportunity to market by
putting their logo and contact on said trucks. This would not be an issue if TQL were able to
fashion a different way of getting their name out. A remedy of this would be if affiliate truckers
put a bumper sticker or some sort of TQL logo on their truck for a bonus or reward.
Although TQL has numerous awards and accomplishments within the industry, their
reviews on Yelp and Better Business Bureau are close to zero. They have amounted eleven
reviews on Yelp and only have a one star (Nikolai). Along with this, BBB rated them an A
company but the public reviews are 94% negative (Total Quality Logistics, LLC). This issue
could be a reason why so many do not know of them. These issues could easily be fixed if the
company acknowledges the complaints they are getting and makes moves to settle them.
The companys growth reached new heights this year and continues to expand from their
start in 1997. In just six years they doubled in monetary size and continue to make improvements
(Figure A.1). However the size of their reach is limited, their only international office is in
Canada and serves the southern points by the US. They would be able to reach more areas if the
amount of offices increased. Currently they hold 59 offices nationwide but most are concentrated
TQL S.W.O.T. 9
in the Midwest, most of their expansion would be beneficial if they moved into the south and
west along with expanding nationally (Figure A.2). Along with this, other markets are growing
rapidly and make it difficult for TQL to keep up with fiercer competition.
Along with fewer offices, the company utilizes one form of transportation, trucking.
Opening their market into planes, ships, or trains would allow for the company to reach more
while remaining third-party. They could continue to utilize other companies as they have with
Since this move would lead to added costs it is the most difficult of their weaknesses to
overcome. Many companies who utilize the ability to go global are able to skyrocket their
revenue with the added markets. Those who fail are often the ones who are unable to adapt to
Opportunities
Penalization
When analyzing the opportunities that TQL faces, penalizing drivers who fail to show up
for a shipment that they promised to transport, are significantly late on a shipment, or simply
abandon a shipment could benefit the company in many ways. Currently, TQL flags unreliable
drivers in their system; so in the future they are aware of the fact that the driver has committed a
wrongdoing. This means that drivers who have done the company wrong, may still be able to
TQL S.W.O.T. 10
continue transporting shipments for TQL. However, if the company took a more drastic step by
financially penalizing drivers who caused issues, they would establish a more reliable trucker
base and be compensated for the inconvenience they have been caused. In turn, this would prove
to customers that TQL will be more likely to deliver the first time. Walmart instituted this policy
by fining drivers 3% for early or late shipments and have seen tremendous reaction (Pandolph).
If every unreliable driver was fined $500, it would guarantee that the amounts of
incidences would decline significantly. Drivers who know they have the potential to cause an
inconvenience to TQL would not want to inquire about a shipment knowing that they would have
to pay $500 out of pocket for a potential wrongdoing. The financial punishment would assure
truckers would take extra precaution to do a good job. This allows TQL to attract drivers who are
reliable and serious about their job. Customers would also feel more at ease with their shipments.
TQL S.W.O.T. 11
International Growth
There is no doubt that TQL has been extremely successful in its domestic
intermediations, however that is just the tip of the iceberg. If TQL decided to first expand its
business into Canada and Mexico and then eventually worldwide, the company would promote
diversity, have the chance to network with businesses all over the world, and increase revenue.
The benefit of a global expansion with a company like TQL is that the interactions between TQL,
its drivers, and it's customers are done over the phone and computer which enables the company
While opening offices worldwide is an option as well, technology enables TQL to be able
to conduct business around the world without the need to physically be there. Due to the fact that
there is no trucks/ property owned by TQL that would need to be shipped overseas for global
expansion to take place, international growth could be relatively inexpensive for the company.
While expansion in general would increase revenue, expanding to different countries allows TQL
to pay drivers in nations with a low cost of living significantly less than they would be paid if
they were doing shipments in the United States. While there are some shipments that go into
Canada and Mexico, making these shipments apart of the daily regime, while expanding all over
the world, would ensure TQLs place as a successful intermediary in an ever changing and
competing marketplace.
Another benefit of international offices is the ability to expand the TQL culture and hire
better. Most professionals in other companies would prefer to be hired by someone from their
own country and who grew up speaking the same language as them. Starting a company with an
American worker, then hiring natives to the country, TQL could assure their unique business
practices and programs would remain unchanged. Global expansion can be down completely
TQL S.W.O.T. 12
online without physical locations however beginning the construction of global offices could
Technological Improvements
With a society that is ever advancing technologically, there is no doubt that an industry
will need to keep up with the demands of consumers by using the most updated, state of the art
through a freight truck, TQL has the opportunity to utilize drones, planes, submarines, and even
trains to get the job done. TQL can maximize the benefits of all types of technology from new
(drones) to old (trains), in order to transport a shipment in the manner seen most effective for that
particular order. While TQL would not be the first company to ponder the idea of drones, theyd
definitely be the first in their industry to put this into effect. When implemented, using strong,
durable drones for shipments could be efficient and cost effective by cutting out the human
advancing society. As said before, while trucks may be most efficient for some orders, it may not
be as effective for others. By maximizing every type of transportation from trucks, trains, boats,
submarines, planes, and possibly drones in the near future, business will extremely thrive.
Freight could be transported overseas which would expand business globally. This would also
allow TQL to potentially become the largest stock brokerage firm rather than the second largest
in America.
TQL S.W.O.T. 14
Threats
Up-and-Coming Companies
In May of 2017, Uber announced its entrance into the transportation industry focusing on
truckload brokerage. Uber Freights product manager, Eric Berdinis, posted in a blog a
description of this new side of Uber. He stated that Uber Freight is an app used to match trucking
companies with loads that must be picked up (Madrigal). This, in turn, relieves stress from
truckers in having to find a load to pick up. Berdinis stated that Ubers new app allows for
truckers to search for a load and decide if they wish to pick it up. If truckers book the load a
confirmation is sent within seconds to avoid anxiety for truckers. Additionally, Uber Freight is
committed to paying truckers within a few days, fee-free, for every load. Uber is attempting to
take a different angle in which it focuses on small fleets, making up 90 percent of registered
motor carries in the nation. In the future, Uber wishes to increase its freight type to flatbeds,
Ubers new venture into the truckload brokerage parallels Total Quality Logistics almost
to a tee. Given the popularity of Uber, it could highlight an impending threat to TQL and its
ability to maintain and further expand its company. Additionally, while TQL has several different
payment plans for truckers, a 28 day term where fees do not apply or next day with fees; Uber
pays within a few days without fees. The benefits in switching to Uber could severely decline
TQLs client base. With truckers wanting to be paid quickly and without fees, TQL would need
to upgrade their payment plan and find a way to take out fees. Ubers widely-known brand
allows it to be supported in new ventures even with TQL being longer established.
Amazon, the worlds largest internet retailer, has grown to a monopolistic size. They are
TQL S.W.O.T. 15
seeking to create their own shipping company with the intent of cutting out the middleman. This
would allow them to gain more control over packages with the possibility of even shipping to
other retailers. This would give them nearly entire control over the market. Not only are large
shipping companies such as UPS and FedEx threatened by the possible emergence of Amazons
transportation of goods to other companies. Amazon is the worlds largest retailer and has a
healthy sum of revenue, although starting a transportation company is considered difficult with
an already large group of consumers Amazon may be able to pull it off and cut out their
competition. With over 55% of online shopping searches starting on Amazon a large majority of
online purchases is through them. TQL does not just transport packages to consumers but they
are also known to supply retailers in the food industry. Amazon has recently bought the grossing
organic supermarket, Whole Foods. The relationship of Amazon and Whole Foods gives a taste
of what more Amazon could do in the grocery industry. Since this is a large focus of TQLs
Global Competition
While TQL primarily focuses its business within America, there are multiple companies
that engage in global business. The ability to expand results in higher revenues and a broader
TQL S.W.O.T. 16
consumer base. An example being XPO Logistics, a publicly owned corporation, reported
revenue of $14.6 billion with $211 million in free cash flow in 2016 alone. While operating in 32
countries with over 91,000 employees, this company overtakes TQL by a landslide (Our). It
allows for XPO to expand its business ventures to different cultures and countries thus providing
a larger platform to grow. TQL is limited to the areas in which it can conduct business and has a
Another major company is C.H. Robinson. C.H. Robinson is the largest freight brokerage
firm in the industry working as a global company with revenues in the billions. In 2016 C.H.
Robinson reported a total revenue of $13.1 billion, over six times TQLs. Additionally, C.H.
Robinson employees 13,159 employees which is roughly three times the amount of employees
that TQL has. Since C.H. Robinson is a publicly owned company it allows for more transactions
to occur, thus allowing them to expand globally. C.H. Robinson has offices in North America,
South America, Europe, and Asia. In current business, companies are almost required to move
internationally (About). Shipping in Greece, Japan, and China have skyrocketed and have
Delays
While the transportation industry runs practically 24/7/365, there are some circumstances
in which deliveries cannot be delivered on time due to weather conditions. If a truck cannot
deliver and is standing idle it is a waste of money. Blizzards can make roads dangerous and
TQL S.W.O.T. 17
inoperable to drive on, heavy rains carry a danger of hydroplaning, while strong winds have the
potential of tipping trucks. Since the majority of TQLs revenue comes from the trucking aspect,
this places a constant threat to its operations. If trucks cannot move goods, then TQL is not
Another weather condition that proves to be a certain threat is rising sea levels.
population in coastal areas and the inevitable change in climate will result in worsening flooding
and storm surges. The worrisome aspect for the transportation industry is that approximately
60,000 miles of coastal highways experience flooding due to storms and wave action. If these
highways were located in a remote area it would not impose negative consequences; however,
coastal areas are a hub for economic prosperity. In addition, inland areas are also expected to
experience the force of climate change through an increase of precipitation. While precipitation
does not seem like it could cause the transportation industry to halt to a stop it has in the past. In
1993, a massive flood spanning 500 miles along the Mississippi and Missouri River caused land
transportation to stop for six weeks. While this flood affected the transportation industry in 1993,
if this flood occurred again it would affect the transportation industry more today given that a
higher percentage of products are transported by ground. This would affect the whole
greater risk to delays in delivery. The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) reported that
TQL S.W.O.T. 18
American roadways were almost failing with a score of a D. In addition, ASCE reported that
one in nine bridges in America was structurally inadequate. While 3.5 million truckers drive 279
billion miles on deteriorating roads and bridges, it is more than expected that delays will occur
Thirty-two million trucks transport goods everyday from sun up to sundown, but often times are
stuck idle in traffic jams. In 2016, the trucking industry experienced a loss of $50 billion due to
...wasted time and fuel Several of Americas lawmakers state that due to Americas
roadways, American businesses pay $27 billion a year in extra freight transportation costs,
While TQL may not have control over this aspect of the trucking industry it is definitely a
cost that will hurt not only them but every freight brokerage firm. Deteriorating infrastructure
will cause a rise in cost for truckers and thus displace this cost onto businesses that wish to have
their goods transported. This could potentially decrease sales for TQL. In addition, TQL could
face losses if trucks find themselves in traffic jams more often causing TQL to compensate for
Competitor Technology
While it may seem far fetched and not feasible, robots could potentially overtake the
trucking industry within the next decade, replacing 1.7 million American truckers. Given that
highways are the easiest way to navigate without human intervention and are used for most long-
According to the Los Angeles Times, one major competitor for TQL are robot trucks themselves.
With all the advancing technology in these self driving cars, it could potentially threaten
business for TQL (Kitreoffe). There would not be a need for a middle man anymore, and since
TQL is a middle man, there would not be a need for TQL. In the article, Robots Could Replace
1.7 Million American Truckers in the Next Decade, written by Natalie Kitroeff, it stated that
Trucking will likely be the first type of driving to be fully automated meaning theres no one
at the wheel, (Kitreoffe). This is a serious issue that will jeopardize not only TQL but the entire
logistics industry within a few years. Also, given the rapid rate of technological advancements
If TQL is not able to somehow incorporate these robot trucks into their business as they
arrive on the market, it will most likely do damage. It is also possible that things would be worse
off than that. As mentioned before, it is not out of the question that it could cause the company to
If advancing technologies such as robot trucks are coming out soon, who is to say that
there arent other competitor technologies that could do damage to logistics companies that are
TQL S.W.O.T. 20
being made now. That is one of TQLs biggest threats. The fact that advancing technology is so
Recommendations
The group deliberated on the possibilities TQL has to remedy some of their negatives and
came up with four solutions. The majority of the companys issues come from a lack of adaptive
behavior. Looking at competitors shows what needs to be improved and where the market and
competition are going in the future. Most of the companies we looked at, such as Walmart and
Amazon, are multi-billion dollar companies revolutionizing the industries they represent.
The first solution has to do with the customer reviews that TQL has received on Better
Business Bureau and Yelp. The easiest way to deal with them is to acknowledge the complaints
and train to fix them. Since reviews cannot be proved and are completely based on a customers
opinion and mood, sometimes changes will not reflect in the posts. An incentive program for
customers and truckers to review positively their experience would greatly help. Something as
simple as no fee on a shipment or some money off would give reason to truckers to score the
Customers opinions also need to be taken care of. Many of the complaints for TQL stem
form a lack or overage of communication. They range from being called too much to not being
able to get ahold of their broker. Another remedy we have worked to find is an app specifically
for the communication between customer, trucker, and broker. Similar to apps like Kik and
GroupMe, this app could alleviate the need to be on constant call and would be much quicker
and more efficient. The app would allow for another form of hands-free communication between
trucker and broker but would also allow for only concise information to be released between the
two. All messages would be saved so both the client and TQL could review it when needed.
Another way TQL could use technology and apps to their advantage would be to pair
with an existing GPS service like Google Maps or Waze. Both these navigation softwares give
TQL S.W.O.T. 22
important updates to their users. Both are able to show the quickest route, where to go to avoid
tolls, and give instant traffic updates. A partnership would give TQL the chance to advertise and
connect their truckers through one interface. Even without a partnership, TQL has the ability to
develop their own similar programming and combine it with their other existing apps.
A pro and con of TQL is they do not own their own resources. This helps them in saving
costs but removes a method of exposing their brand more. A remedy would be to open up hubs in
major cities where drivers for TQL could stop and where shipments can be warehoused. Starting
small and eventually building to more and more would allow TQL to control the amount of costs
going into the development of them. These stations would allow TQL to have more direct control
in their shipments while still being able to remain third party and not put the expense into
Finally, our team has read articles on Wal-Marts utilization of penalization for their late
and early truckers and believes this could benefit all shipping companies. Along with penalizing,
a system of rewarding truck drivers for excellent service would entice them to continue
performing well at TQL. Penalization systems have been proven effective but could be improved
with an added benefit for drivers. Since many clients would respond better to a reward for safely
Overall, TQL is in a large, ever-changing market and industry. This brings the ability to
grow and really improve their current practices but also poses many threats with their
competitors ranging from small business to multi-billion dollar companies. Their current
practices have gotten them far but with slight arrangement could propel them higher.
Appendix
Figure A.1
TQL S.W.O.T. 23
Figure A.2
Figure A.3
TQL S.W.O.T. 24
Figure A.4
TQL S.W.O.T. 25
Bibliography
About Our Company. C.H. Robinson, C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc., 2017,
www.chrobinson.com/en-US/About-Us/CHRobinson/.
Boyle, Matthew. Wal-Mart Will Punish Its Suppliers for Delivering Early. Bloomberg.com,
arriving-early-wal-mart-puts-its-suppliers-on-notice.
Burch, Kevin. Faltering infrastructure hurts trucking and all of America. TheHill, 15 May
2017, thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/transportation/332916-faltering-infrastructure-
hurts-trucking-and-all-of-america.
Explore Job Opportunities at TQL. TQL - Search Jobs,
careers.tql.com/ShowJob/Id/288933/Sales-Representative/.
Jaillet, James. New Walmart policy dings truckers, shippers for late loads and early ones.
shippers-for-late-loads-and-early-ones/.
Kitroeffe, Natalie. Robots could replace 1.7 million American truckers in the next decade. Los
labor-20160924/.
Madrigal, Alexis C. How Uber Is Building Uber for Trucking. The Atlantic, Atlantic Media
building-uber-for-trucking/536157/.
www.economist.com/news/economic-and-financial-indicators/21674507-merchant-fleets.
TQL S.W.O.T. 26
N., Nikolai, et al. Total Quality Logistics - Eastgate - Cincinnati, OH. Yelp, 26 Oct. 2017,
www.yelp.com/biz/total-quality-logistics-cincinnati.
company.
Pandolph, Stephanie. Walmart will start fining its suppliers for early and late deliveries.
fining-suppliers-early-late-deliveries-2017-7.
Total Quality Logistics, LLC. BBB Business Profile | Total Quality Logistics, LLC Reviews
quality-logistics-llc-in-cincinnati-oh-3005210/reviews-and-complaints?section=reviews.