Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
"Very interesting.
"The bloke doing the check couldn't believe it. They usually sell an expensive additive for people
with smoky diesels or if they're just over the MOT emission limit."
Ian
April 2002
Full schematic of the processor
How it works
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
7. 8. 9.
10. 11. 12.
Above: Methoxide Mixer showing air tool for mixing, cap for
adding caustic or manually feeding methanol. Top gate valve
for sucking in methanol from source via transparent sighting
tube.
Right: Bottom of Methoxide Mixer showing valve to control
feed to reactor and sighting tube, which is also used as
methanol pickup pipe.
To Keith Addison Ordinary iron and steel implements and containers will
keith@journeytoforever.org
eventually corrode because of the acid used in this process.
To Midori Hiraga
midori@journeytoforever.org However, you can still use the usual 55-gal (200-litre) drum.
Homepage The proportion of acid used in this process is very low --
http://journeytoforever.org/ you should be able to use an uncoated drum for a year or
more before the rust gets out of control. I use a
Handmade Projects polypropylene plastic reaction vessel. Any plastic that won't
Tamba
CAUTION
Japan deform at 100 deg C (212 deg F) or
a bit more is fine. Stainless steel is Sulphuric acid is a
also fine. Use an immersion heater DANGEROUS
Foolproof with plastic containers. With steel CHEMICAL. Take full
pictures containers you can use propane safety precautions,
Aleks made a couple of mini- heaters to heat the oil, then switch to wear safety goggles,
batches in glass jars for these an immersion heater before adding gloves and apron and
photographs -- one batch of the methanol. eye protection. Have
heavily used cooking oil and running water nearby.
fat, and one of pure fat. Don't inhale fumes!
First stage
4. End of acid stage (note
darker colour). 3. Measure the volume of oil/fats to be processed (preferably
in litres).
4. Heat the oil to 35 deg C (95 deg F) -- make sure that all
solid fats are melted.
10. Stir the unheated mixture for another hour, a total of two
hours, then stop mixing. Let the mixture sit for at least eight
7. First-stage glycerine. hours, overnight is better.
Methoxide
11. In the meantime prepare the the easy way
sodium methoxide: measure 0.12
litre of methanol for each litre of Mixing lye with
oil/fat (12% by volume) and weigh methanol creates an
3.1 grams (up to 3.5 grams if purity exothermic reaction,
is in doubt) of sodium lye (sodium generating heat. It's
hydroxide, NaOH) per litre of nasty stuff and it's not
oil/fat. Mix the lye into the methanol easy to mix -- and it
8. Second stage -- finished until the lye is completely dissolved. must be thoroughly
esters. mixed before you use
Sodium methoxide is a it, with all the lye
DANGEROUS CHEMICAL. Take dissolved. This is a
full safety precautions when safe and easy way to
working with methanol, lye and do it. The disadvantage
sodium methoxide, wear safety is that you have to do it
goggles, protective gloves and in advance, but that's
clothing, have running water nearby. easily arranged.
9. Second-stage glycerine. NOTE: This process uses only Take FULL SAFETY
about half the usual amount of lye as PRECAUTIONS when
there is less fat left to transesterify. working with
Use 99%+ pure sodium hydroxide methanol, lye and
lye. After opening the container, sodium methoxide!
close it again as quickly as possible
to prevent moisture getting in. Use a tough, thick,
Weigh the lye carefully -- using too container made of
much will complicate the washing HDPE (High-density
process later. Polyethylene -- usually
marked "HDPE" on the
12. After settling for eight hours, or bottom, with the
the next morning, pour half of the international code "2"),
prepared methoxide into the with a tight stopper
unheated mixture and mix for five and a screw-on lid.
minutes. This will neutralize the Measure out the
sulphuric acid and boost the base methanol into the
catalysis. If you've used solid fat, it container. Add the
probably solidified during settling -- required amount of lye
gently melt the mixture first. -- if you're doing large
quantities, add it bit by
Now you can continue with the bit rather than all at
normal procedure with the lye as the once, give the
second stage. container a swirl in
between (replace
stopper and lid first).
Once it's all added,
replace the stopper and
Second stage the lid, and swirl the
mixture about for a
few seconds. Then let
it stand. Do that a few
Washing
Why bother?
Site Search
Use Advanced Frequently Asked Question: "Do you really need to
search for multiple words and 'wash' biodiesel? I've been running a 50/50 biodiesel/petro
phrases diesel mix for a few months so far and my Dodge Cummins
Please support runs great on it."
Journey to
Forever Answer: "Yes, we do. Detergents in gasoline or petroleum
diesel? Maybe. Sodium or potassium soaps in biodiesel? Not.
A can of HEET (methanol) in the tank every once in awhile to
resolve a water issue? Maybe. A dose of methanol to hoses
En espaol and seals with every inch on the odometer? Not. And certainly
Biocombustibles, biodiesel there isn't any benefit to leaving caramelizing glycerin floating
freely in a fuel and headed for an injector. I think it best be left
Biofuels to the petro-chemical distilleries to leave varnishes, paraffins
Biofuel mailing list - and the like in their fuel and serve it up as champagne to the
subscribe unsuspecting. As for 'no problems 'til now?' You might take
Biofuels Library note that nothing is ever broken until it breaks." -- Todd
Biofuels supplies and Swearingen, Appal Energy, at the Biofuel mailing list.
suppliers
Read what the Fuel Injection Equipment (FIE)
Biodiesel Manufacturers (Delphi, Stanadyne, Denso, Bosch) have to
say about the contaminants left in unwashed biodiesel:
Make your own
Summary -- html
biodiesel
Full document -- Acrobat file, 104kb
Mike Pelly's recipe
Two-stage biodiesel See: Determining the Influence of Contaminants on
process Biodiesel Properties, Jon H. Van Gerpen et al., Iowa State
FOOLPROOF University, July 31, 1996 -- 12,000-word report on
biodiesel process contaminants and their effects. Acrobat file, 2.1Mb
Biodiesel processors
Biodiesel in Hong Quality biodiesel must be washed.
Kong
Nitrogen Oxide Frequently Asked Question: "I don't wash my biodiesel,
emissions but I filter it through an automotive oil filter, then through a 3
Glycerine micron oil filter, this is after allowing the biodiesel to settle in
Biodiesel resources a 55 gal barrel for a couple days. Is this adequate?"
on the Web
Answer: No. Settling and filtering will not remove the soap,
Do diesels have a
catalyst, glycerin or excess methanol contaminants.
future?
Vegetable oil yields
Frequently Asked Question: "Methanol is good fuel, why
and characteristics
wash out the excess methanol, what a waste!"
Washing
Biodiesel and your
vehicle Answer: Methanol is good fuel in specially prepared race car
Food or fuel? engines, which are not diesels. Excess methanol in unwashed
Straight vegetable oil biodiesel is not good fuel and does harm, corroding the fuel
as diesel fuel injection system. Recover the methanol for re-use or wash it
out of the fuel.
Heaters, burners,
stoves
- Which way is best?
Ethanol
Frequently Asked Question: "I was wondering if anyone
Ethanol resources on
could tell me which way might be best for washing large
the Web
batches of biodiesel? I was wondering if bubble washing or
Is ethanol energy- top-mist washing would be better." -- Biofuel mailing list, July
efficient? 2004
--
Wood gas -- Answer: Perhaps neither.
producer gas
Home First you have to know what an emulsion is and why it
What people are saying matters. Briefly (more below), oil and water don't mix, and
about us well-made biodiesel should separate quickly and cleanly from
About Handmade the wash water when it settles. But if the biodiesel isn't made
Projects properly there'll be more soap in it than there should be, along
Sitemap (text only) with half-processed oil molecules, monoglycerides and
diglycerides (MGs and DGs), which are emulsifiers.
Projects Emulsifiers are used to make stable mixtures of oil and water,
Community development such as mayonnaise. Soap also does that. If there's too much
Why we're doing this
of this stuff in your biodiesel, some of the biodiesel or all of it
Rural development won't separate from the wash water, or at least not quickly,
Fixing what's broken
City farms and in some cases maybe not for weeks. You have an emulsion
Edible cities problem.
Organic gardening
Everyone can grow their In fact it's a quality test -- if it doesn't separate, you need to
own food work on improving your processing. Properly made biodiesel
Composting with good completion of the reaction will not emulsify.
The Wheel of Life
Small farms You can "fix" an emulsion, or prevent it forming (see below),
The way forward
and emerge successfully... but with poor-grade fuel. The
Small farms library emulsifiers are fuel contaminants, they can't be washed out,
Classics on organic
growing, soil and health (full and the upper limits for them in the national standards
text online) specifications are low. Above those limits they'll cause injector
Biofuels coking and damage your engine, especially with prolonged
Fuel for the future use.
Solar box cookers
Sun power saves lives and Gentle and super-gentle washing techniques like bubble-
trees
washing and top-mist washing simply mask the problem that
Trees, soil and water
Healthcare for mountains the fuel may not have been made properly in the first place.
Seeds of the world
No seeds, no food
Appropriate technology
What works and fits
Todd Swearingen of Appal Energy replied:
Project vehicles
The workhorses
"Mist- and bubble-washing have become
Internet 'institutionalized' amongst home-brewers primarily due
Why it really matters to the frequency of incomplete reactions that lead to
Internet interaction washing problems. They are both methods of treating
Finding your way incomplete reactions with little kid's gloves in the
hopes that any resulting emulsion won't be 'too bad' or
Schools projects 'too noticeable.'
Introduction
Biofuels "No wash method should be used on any batch unless
Solar box cookers it is known for certain that the reaction has completed.
Backpack stove (See Quality testing.) Unfortunately, many people fail
PicoTurbine to guarantee this for themselves, opting to just 'go
Low-tech radio ahead and wash it gently.'"
What to do with a
cardboard carton Quite so. See below, Stir washing.
Sisters of silk
Silkworms in a shoebox There is a lot of confusion about this. Here's a different reply
School gardens to the same message, from a champion of super-gentle
School composting washing methods:
Trees and forests
The Beach House fish "Either mistwash or bubblewash works fine for big
pond batches, but the same rules apply as for small batches
HOMeR -- more water is needed for misting and less
Eco-footprint emulsification happens, much less water is needed for
School and youth bubblewashing but more chance that emulsification
programs on the Web can take place.
Education resources
on the Web "I actually use both now -- mist for a few gallons and
then I bubblewash with good use of water recycling
Contact us during bubblewashing. In my 350 gallon wash tank,
my small aquarium air pump gives fine results, but not
To Keith Addison all of the air pumps might be able to handle such large
keith@journeytoforever.org batches. It looks like a tiny amount of bubbles are
To Midori Hiraga rising but it works really well -- less emulsification
midori@journeytoforever.org than the same air pump agitating up a smaller batch."
Homepage
http://journeytoforever.org/
-- Maria "Girl Mark" Alovert, July 2004
Handmade Projects But what sort of fuel will emulsify at all in a 350-gallon tank
Tamba with only a small aquarium air pump to "agitate" it? Well-
Japan made fuel can take rough washing with a paint-stirrer without
The two-stage adaptation of
Mike Pellys biodiesel recipe
By Aleks Kac
Note: Many biofuellers are using this method and report high-quality results. Aleks has
since evolved the process -- see the FOOLPROOF biodiesel method
The two-stage processes are advanced methods, not for novices -- learn the basics
thoroughly first. The single-stage base method is the place to start. Start here.
Introduction
For some time now a growing group of people have been trying
and succeeding to make diesel fuel out of used cooking oil
(waste vegetable oil, WVO) by themselves. There are many
magnificent articles on this subject on the Internet that can teach
you how to get started.
Since no one at our Biofuel discussion group complained about this "missed" glycerine, I
thought I must have gone wrong in my calculations and just poured the soup into my "brand
new" used Jeep. I started the engine and went for a ride. Engine and pump didn't choke on the
stuff, I happily noticed "The Smell" and started cooking some more.
But over time I noticed a slight nailing sound from the engine on fresher mornings and started to
research. After a while I stumbled over Camillo Holecek's mail -- you know, the guy with the
continuous process -- and this man gave me some good advice.
Theory
Well, if you remember your chemistry class, in many chemical reactions we know of a thing
called equilibrium (some reactions go in one direction only). Let's look at a reaction like this:
As you noticed, the reaction direction is reversible, and of this type is also the transesterification
reaction we like and do so much. When reactants and products reach equilibrium, the reaction
stops. We don't like that, because it means that the WVO isn't converting anymore. Now our
biodiesel is a mixture of WVO and FAME (fatty acid methyl ester). You can't tell these two
apart, because FAME is a good solvent and thus the unreacted WVO is dissolved. We all know
that you shouldn't run a regular diesel engine on unheated WVO, so we have to do something.
The adaptation
There are two remedies for that. Let's imagine that C and D represent our products: FAME and
glycerine (A and B stand for WVO and methanol). To push the reaction towards C and D --
meaning, we want to convert all the WVO to FAME -- we can do the following:
1. add more methanol -- this will push the reaction to the right, or
2. retract the undesired product (glycerine) -- right direction again.
Adding methanol doesn't do much, unless you really exaggerate, meaning, you must add more
than twice the amount needed to get a slight result. This will make the price of your homemade
fuel go sky-high. But, retracting glycerine is another story, as it helps to pull out one third more.
This means that more WVO gets transesterificated. Pulling out glycerine during the reaction is
hard because you need a liquid-liquid separator (centrifuge) to do that, and this equipment is very
expensive. I almost abandoned this idea, when Camillo offered a fine and simple solution: do it
in two stages!
The process
Let's sum up Mike's process quickly:
titrate
heat up the WVO
prepare the methoxide
mix WVO and methoxide
settle and retract glycerine
wash and dry.
The two-stage process differs in only two things: no titration and a second mix of methoxide and
WVO. First things first: why no titration? Well, any analytic chemist will tell you that if you
don't work with fresh chemicals and in at least three parallels, you won't get accurate results. So I
figured out an empiric quantity of lye (NaOH), which for all my batches was more than good:
around 6.25 g of NaOH per litre of waste oil. For the second stage you don't need any new
equipment, just some more time. OK, here is how it's done:
CAUTION:
Wear proper chemical-proof gloves, apron, and eye protection and do not inhale any vapors.
Methanol can cause blindness and death, and you don't even have to drink it, it's absorbed
through the skin. Sodium hydroxide can cause severe burns and death. Together these two
chemicals form sodium methoxide. This is an extremely caustic chemical. These are dangerous
chemicals -- treat them as such! Always have a hose running when working with them. The
workspace must be thoroughly ventilated. No children or pets allowed. See Safety for further
information.
First stage
2. Prepare your methoxide this way: mix 25% (by volume of WVO) of pure methanol and
(6.25g/litre of WVO) of sodium lye (NaOH)
4. Add 3/4 of the prepared methoxide (save the rest in a sealed container out of reach of children
and flames, sparks... or prepare a fresh batch for the next stage -- do two calculations: first
determine the amount of needed chemicals, then split it in 3/4 and 1/4).
7. Separate the glycerine from the FAME -- you'll notice that at this point the glycerine is
unusually thin.
Second stage
13. Separate the glycerine from the FAME -- now the glycerine is a gelatinous mass. On top of
the glycerine layer you'll find a thick layer of settled waxes (cream colored), which you shouldn't
process further. Remember, this is one of the things that might clog your fuel injectors.
14. Wash and dry with your favorite method. I use the Idaho bubble wash method.
Here is what you'll need: a large plastic vessel (twice the volume of your reaction vessel), a
cheap aquarium air pump (with enough air flow), a large aquarium air stone and some rubber
hose to connect the pump with the stone. I use a pH meter for my measurements, but you can use
pH paper (scaled 1/2 pH unit) or a digital pH indicator (around US$15). The pH indicator is the
cheapest instrument if you plan to make more than 20 batches.
pH explained
pH has no real unit, as it's formula is "pH= log (conc. (H+)ions)". So this is a number that is
not affected by volume, as chemists needed a way of telling how much H- or H+ ions there are in
an unknown volume of a liquid.
The pH of your second-stage FAME will be well over 7 (surplus lye), which is a sort of zero on
the pH scale. The scale ranges from 0 to 14, acidic is 0 through 7, from 7 up it shows alkalinity, 7
itself is neutral.
So, if you have, say, 10 litres of a liquid with a pH value of 9 (2 units above 7) and mix it with 10
litres of a liquid with a pH value of 5 (2 units under 7), the result will be a liquid with a pH value
of more or less 7, meaning neutral. This trick we'll use to wash our FAME.
The Wash
So, if your FAMEs pH is 8.7, the water should have a pH of 5.3. All well so far? Now pour your
second-stage FAME into the vessel, throw in the aquarium stone and fire up the air pump. Soon
youll notice a string of bubbles rising up through the FAME carrying minute amounts of water
right to the surface. When this water falls down again, it washes the soaps and surplus methanol
out of the FAME and the vinegar neutralizes the remaining lye.
Let it bubble for 6 hours minimum. Turn the pump off and let the mixture sit for 12 hours. The
water will fall to the bottom, turning completely white and the fuel you made will look much
lighter in color now. Take the FAME out of the vessel, taking care not to get any water with it.
You can achieve that either with a translucent hose, or you can epoxy a valve to your vessels
wall near the bottom. Now slowly heat the washed FAME to 100 deg C (212 deg F) and hold the
temperature until you see no more steam bubbles rising. The pH of your homemade fuel will be
7 +/- 0.25, which is good enough. Cool it down, filter the fuel, pour it in your cars tank and
drive away.
See Washing
Conclusion
I tested biodiesel made by this method thoroughly in my Jeep Cherokee 2.1 litre turbodiesel. It
behaves better than "classic" biodiesel, and even better than petrodiesel (the engine is grunting
happily). Now that winter is on the doorstep, I will upgrade the fuel filter with a small heater, and
that should eliminate other nasty little surprises.
As Im finishing this article it got cold and its drizzling outside. I poured myself a finger of fine
Scotch whiskey and Im sipping it slowly. My cat is purring on my lap and I think very much of
next spring, looking forward to some traveling. Hopefully we can all meet someday, possibly
near a field of blooming sunflowers.
Aleks Kac
Ljubljana
Slovenija
Mike Pelly
Camillo Holecek
Steve Spence
Keith Addison
and Joshua Tickell
Feedback
COMMENT
In one of Aleks Kac's first messages to the Biofuel mailing list he said he was making micro-
batches of biodiesel, and the stuff he made from virgin oil was fine, "but with used fryer oil the
ester smells like kitten vomit ... it has a real nasty smell, like when you open a compost heap.
Any advice?" (It worked okay though.) It didn't take Aleks long to move from novice status to
become one of the leading lights in the biofuels movement: it was only five months after this
first message that he uploaded his two-stage biodiesel processing method to the Web. Good
going Aleks -- keep up the great work!
-- Keith Addison
Mike Pelly
Steve Spence
http://www.green-trust.org/
Joshua Tickell:
VeggieVan
http://www.veggievan.org/