Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Namaste
Quarterly Newsletter
Peace Brigades International Nepal
In this edition of Namaste, PBI would like to emphasise the worrying situation of journalists in
Nepal. According to reports1 the murders of at least five journalists remain unsolved in the
country, four since 2006. The current environment of continuous threat is leading to self-
censorship among journalists. This is especially true after the murder in January of journalist
Uma Singh, who was killed in her own home. Despite the lack of verified information on the
motives behind the murder, the International Federation of Journalists’ investigation asserts
that there is little question that her work and reporting as a journalist was a major reason for
the killing. The International Media Mission states that attacks on and harassment of media
have a ‘chilling effect’2 on press freedom. Journalists and reporters are being forced into self-
censorship, depriving the general public of its right to information in a time of political transi-
tion.
Particularly worrisome is the situation of women journalists, who are increasingly withdrawing
from their profession as a result of the lack of security. One woman journalist and human
rights defender, accompanied by PBI, states that she is the only woman in her profession in the
district where she works. The current exodus of women from journalism as a profession will
make it harder for women to become journalists in the future.
The high level of impunity for past and ongoing abuses continues to be the norm, and this con-
tributes greatly to the current insecure situation in Nepal. After free and fair elections in 2008,
it is even more important that steps are taken to address the destructive culture of impunity in
Nepal.
1 Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), www.cpj.org, Federation of Nepali Journalists (FNJ) www.fnjnepal.org
2 International Media Mission, joint statement: http://www.i-m-s.dk/files/publications/Nepal%20Mission%20Statement%20_8%
20Feb%2009_%20Final%20ENG.pdf
2
The Situation of Journalists in Nepal
In Nepal’s struggle for democ- Workers Union (ANCPPWU) ily pressure. The majority of
racy, journalists and others who unit in Biratnagar staged a sit-in at women journalists are employed
work for press freedom face the main entrance of the regional in local radio stations, the media
threats that are severe and grow- office of Kantipur Publications. with the largest audience in Ne-
ing. Union members prevented distri- pal. Because of this, radio jour-
The Federation of Nepali Jour- bution of the national issues of nalists in general, and women
nalists (FNJ) recorded 342 press the newspaper. The union work- journalists in particular, face the
freedom violations in 2008 alone, ers demanded increases in salary highest threats.
highlighting an escalation in the as fixed by the government4. On In a press statement, the Inter-
number of physical attacks on 29 December the government national Media Mission (IMM) ex-
journalists and media houses. and the FNJ expressed commit- pressed concerns about the at-
Four journalists - Uma Singh, J.P. ment to press freedom and tacks on media outlets, about the
Joshi, Birendra Sah and Pushkar agreed to resolve the problems fact that those responsible are
Bahadur Shrestha - have been between the management and the not held accountable and about
killed since 20061. labor union within a week. On the vulnerable position of women
The Comprehensive Peace the same day, Maoist unionists journalists. The IMM stated that:
Agreement between the Govern- ended their siege5. “as of now, not one person has
ment of Nepal and Communist been convicted for a criminal act
Party of Nepal (Maoist) of 22 No- 342 Press Freedom Violations in 2008 against journalists and media out-
vember 2006 commits the parties Since 2006 four journalists have been
lets, and the IMM calls on the
to democratic values, competitive Prime Minister and Government
killed
multiparty governance, civil liber- to follow up their commitment to
ties, and human rights, including No one has been prosecuted to this day end impunity.”8
respect for full press freedom and PBI meets with FNJ regularly to
rule of law. On 1 March 2009, The attack on Himalmedia and exchange information on the
Maoist Chairman and Prime Min- the siege of the Kantipur office situation of journalists in Nepal.
ister Pushpa Kamal Dahal were condemned by several na- In January PBI Nepal volunteers
(Prachanda) reiterated the gov- tional and international organisa- accompanied a woman journalist9
ernment’s commitment, though tions. Jacqueline Park, Director after she received threats and had
remarked that the recent attacks of the International Federation of to be evacuated to Kathmandu.
on journalists and the flourishing Journalists (IFJ) Asia-Pacific stated: PBI continues to monitor her
culture of impunity were leftovers "This attack on Himalmedia is an security now that she is back in
from the 10 year conflict2. attack on press freedom and has her region. PBI supports journal-
One of the most serious attacks nothing to do with the defense of ists who defend human rights
on a media outlet took place on journalism or the public inter- through their work and will re-
21 December 2008. A group of est."6 spond to their requests for ac-
around 50 people led by Ramesh The brutal murder in January companiments in the future.
Panta, the president of the Maoist 2009 of Uma Singh7, a 26-year-old
-affiliated All Nepal Hotel and woman journalist from Janakpur,
Restaurant Workers’ Union raised many questions about the
(ANHRWU), entered the meet- security situation of journalists, 1. IMM, 8 Feb 2009, Joint Statement: Interna-
tional Press Freedom and Freedom of Expression
ing hall of Himalmedia’s Hattiban especially women, in Nepal. An Mission: Rapid Response Assessment Mission to
office vandalizing the premises FNJ fact-finding mission found Nepal
and injuring at least 12 senior that journalists in western dis- 2. Kantipur report, 6 Feb 2009, PM Dahal asks
journalists and other senior-level tricts have been working under not to doubt govt commitment on free press
3. Himalayan Times, 21 Dec 2008, Himalmedia
employees. The union had threat- "psychological terror" due to
staff, editors beaten up
ened Himalmedia for allegedly threats issued by various armed 4. Kantipur report, 23 Dec 2008, Maoist union
writing against workers in its lat- groups and cadres of Unified stages sit-in at Biratnagar Kantipur office
est issue. Earlier, they had CPN (Maoist). Women journalists 5. Kantipur report, 29 Dec 2008, Kantipur
torched the copies of the news in particular feel insecure and siege ends
6. Kantipur report, 23 Dec 2009, Intl media
magazine and vandalized the dis- hopeless after the murder of Uma bodies deplore Maoist attack on Himalmedia;
tribution office3. Singh. According to IFJ and FNJ urge nonpartisan investigation,
On 23 December, the Maoist- sources, many women are leaving 7. Kantipur Report, 2 Feb 2009, FNJ: Women
affiliated All Nepal Communica- the profession both due to per- journalists face psychological terror
tions, Printing and Publications sonal fear and in response to fam- 8. IMM, 8 Feb 2009, Joint Statement
9. See the interview with KD in this edition of
Namaste, p 5 3
Street protests
in Kathmandu
Road in Ilam,
eastern Nepal 4
Interview with Kokila:
Woman, Journalist, Human Rights Defender
petrators. The police are unable I think it is worse than during the
to take action and to provide se- conflict. The culture of impunity
curity for us. It is said that jour- is spreading. There have been
nalists are the fourth organ of the threats, intimidations, attacks,
state but the state is not acting abductions and killings to journal-
responsibly towards our security ists but no one has been held ac-
and protection. countable, no action has been
Working as a Human Rights De- taken against perpetrators. The
Kokila is a young journalist and re- fender (HRD) is even tougher state is turning a blind eye.
porter for Ilam-based Kanchenjunga than being a journalist. There are
FM radio station and a district cen- many cases of domestic violence How do you see the future
tral committee member of the Na- against women in the east and for journalists?
tional Alliance for Women Human whenever we’ve reported on If the trend and culture of impu-
Rights Defenders in Ilam in eastern them and raised our voice, it has nity prevails then there will be no
Nepal. On 17 January 2009 she gone unheard, and at times we security for HRDs and journalists.
published an article about Limbuwan received threats from the perpe- The general public will be de-
groups1 levying illegal road taxes on trators themselves. As HRDs we prived of their basic human rights,
the highway in the eastern region. are not safe and are unable to and right to information.
After the story was broadcast on carry out our work freely.
local radio, Kokila received a number Working as a woman is very dis- What is your experience of
of threatening calls on her mobile couraging. In rural Nepali society PBI?
phone and landline. The caller we are not taken seriously. This is I am very happy and thankful to
claimed that Kokila’s reporting had why we have a very small number PBI for its work. It accompanied
tarnished the image of the Limbu- of women journalists. In Ilam, I me to the region where I work at
wan movement for autonomy, and am the only woman actively a time when I was very upset and
he threatened to kidnap her. Due to working as a journalist. When- scared. Since then I have not ex-
an increased feeling of insecurity ever we have to work late with a perienced further problems with
following the brutal murder of the male colleague, people perceive that particular group. Probably
journalist Uma Singh2 earlier in Janu- this negatively and spread mali- the presence of PBI created a
ary, Kokila fled Ilam. PBI was then cious rumours. Psychologically good environment. It helped me a
requested to accompany her back to this is challenging. In spite of this lot for my safety and security.
Ilam and to socialize international I think we should stand up as an In all districts of the eastern re-
presence and attention with the local example, and show that women gion, journalists are facing difficult
authorities. Here is what Kokila has are equal to men. times when carrying out their
to say about the general situation of daily work. The situation of
journalists and Human Rights De- What motivates you? HRDs is not very different. I think
fenders in Nepal and her own ex- From a young age I worried about PBI should visit these areas fre-
periences as a woman working in issues faced by women in this pa- quently, meet local journalists and
these areas. triarchal society, where women HRDs and continuously assess
are confined to the kitchen. I the situation in the region.
PBI: What challenges are you used to think: ‘How can we
facing as a woman, a journal- change and improve the fate of
ist, and a Human Rights De- women so that they are liber-
fender? ated?’ I then started working in
Kokila: Journalists have to report order to change the mindset of
the truth and facts. Our reporting 1.Limbuwan groups: political groups op-
society towards women and to erating in the eastern region of Nepal
may disappoint some groups or bring out grievances of rural demanding Limbuwan, a federal autono-
individuals, which makes us more women. mous province east of river Arun.
vulnerable to threat and intimida-
tion. These days, journalists are What is your opinion on the 2. CNN.com, Jan 12, Nepalese Journalist
working on the edge of a knife: situation of journalists follow-
Hacked to Death
we report about crimes but no ing the peace agreement?
one takes action against the per-
5
Interview with Dharmendra Jha, Director of FNJ
The Federation of Nepalese Journal- rial published or broadcast from You mentioned armed
ists (FNJ)1 is a nationwide umbrella any media source. This is where groups. Can you tell us
organisation representing print and the threats come from, and more?
nowadays their number is very Why they emerged, what their
visual media in Nepal. FNJ has
high. goals are, what exactly they want
branch offices and associate organi- Women are now a target, - we don’t know. We think that
sations across the country. With not before. Why this change? politics is slightly shifting into
the deteriorating situation of free- If we compare print and radio, we criminalisation and this is shifting
dom of expression and press free- find many more women journal- into a trend towards conflict.
dom, as well as increasing attacks ists in the latter. Radio is a very We think that many recognized
popular media, especially in the political parties provide security
on the media, FNJ is active in voicing countryside. This also has an in- to such groups, either as a party
its concerns and denouncing the fluence on the high
growing culture of impunity. Dhar- number of women
mendra Jha was elected president of employed here.
FNJ in 2008. PBI interviewed him to They are a target
for those who feel
find out more about the current
strongly against
situation for journalists in Nepal. women working in
radio. If women see
PBI: How has the situation of journalism as a dan-
journalists been since the gerous profession,
elections in April 2008? they are likely to
Dharmendra Jha: The situation prevent their kids
and condition of journalists is de- from becoming
teriorating day by day. All over journalists. Many Peaceful journalist protests, Kathmandu
Nepal, journalists are receiving women journalists (photo courtesy of FNJ)
threats and media houses are be- now are leaving or
ing vandalized. The degree of thinking about leaving their pro- or individually. They are going to
impunity is very high. We are not fession. If they leave the profes- protect or are already protecting
aware that anyone has been taken sion now, it may be much harder those groups. That is why impu-
into custody for these cases. for women in the next generation nity is increasing.
Anyone can think that if they beat to become journalists. Our goal is that if anywhere in
or kill a journalist, there will be Have you noticed regional the world, not just Nepal, any
no consequences. After the elec- differences as far as threats group is fighting for its rights, we
tion, we were hoping for im- and journalists’ situation? should support them. But you
provements but we only received In the mid-Terai, especially Parsa have to proceed in the correct
promises, and nothing has been to Sunsari district and also in the way; you have to seriously con-
implemented. Freedom of ex- mid-plain, main-Terai, the danger vince people of you and your
pression and press freedom are in is high. Many armed groups, iden- rights. If you use any kind of
danger. tified and un-identified, recog- weapon to help convince, then
You mentioned threats. Has nized and un-recognized, prevail we will not tolerate it. In Nepal,
the type and level of threats here. The condition between if armed groups have any cause,
changed over time? journalists working in the Terai or any basic right they want to
Now many women journalists are and those outside differs; in Kath- defend, we ask them to please
targeted. We believe that as mandu we are almost safe. But in come and talk, talk to the govern-
journalists, criticism is part of our the Terai not a single journalist ment and society, and we will be
job. Many people are not happy can say that he or she is safe. supportive. But if you want to
to hear or listen to criticisms, and Likewise, in the eastern region, create a state of fear, or use any
especially after the election put various groups are active and kind of weapon, if you want to kill
them in power, they are not will- threatening journalists, who do journalists, then we cannot and
ing to tolerate critical news mate- not feel safe. will not tolerate it. {cont. next
page}
1 www.fnjnepal.org
6
Interview with Dharmendra Jha, Director of FNJ continued
So you link this to the ment, is there anything misinformation.
current uprising of ethnic you would do for journal- Some journalists in
groups, such as Tharu, ists especially, to change Banke commented that
Limbuwan.. this culture? they would like FNJ to
Yes, they have a right to We need to provide profes- act when journalists get
raise their voice, and we sup- sional skills and moral sup- threats not later, when
port any right-based move- port to local journalists journalists are killed.
ment. But if people are working in the field. Now Would you like to com-
threatened in the name of that the CA is writing the ment? “When we
such movement, if impunity new constitution we have to We are working for journal- demand our
increases, then we can’t ac- ensure that press freedom ists and you know that every government to
cept it. But to act peacefully, and freedom of expression event we organise, we try to ensure press
that is your right. are included. We should be do well. FNJ is an umbrella
freedom rights,
There seems to be an the bridge between the peo- organisation, with more than
understanding that you ple and CA members. 8000 journalists, so some- when we call to
can only reach your What do you think of the times we fail to serve all of end impunity, it
rights by taking up arms, quality of information them is not only on
as the Maoists did. today? What do you see as the behalf of
It is happening, it is a prob- In general if we analyse role of internationals at journalists, we
lem and it is not a good cul- Nepalese media, it is reliable present in Nepal?
do this for all
ture, not the right way to and accurate. In journalism They can play a vital role.
demand rights. Maoists used we say that you have infor- This is a universal issue. It is the people of
this theory and after seeing mation, misinformation and the duty of the world com- Nepal.”
this, many groups are trying distortion. If you are not able munity to secure these Dharmendra
to imitate them. I think this to give the right information, rights everywhere, not just Jha, FNJ
is not a good solution and you don’t have to write and Nepal.
we need to change our mind misinform or distort. The When we demand our gov-
set. If we are responsible problem we face is self- ernment to ensure press
towards society, we should censorship, especially in the freedom rights, when we call
deliver our ideas to society Terai. Journalists in that to end impunity, it is not
peacefully. But if we use any area are not going to misin- only on behalf of journalists,
kind of violence while doing form you. It is correct that we do this for all the people
this, then we violate other they are not able to give ap- of Nepal.
people’s rights. propriate information, but
If you were in govern- they are not going to give
8
Krystal (PBI Nepal)
left, and Katherine
(PBI USA)
9
www.pbi-nepal.org
PBI Nepal Project
P.O. Box 8975, Phone: +977 1221 1200
E.P.C. 1865 Fax: +977 1553 7473
Sanepa, Lalitpur, Email: info@pbi-nepal.org
Kathmandu, Nepal www.pbi-nepal.org
10