Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Building arguments
Every paragraph starts with a claim / idea, followed by supporting evidence, concluding sentence
tying it all together.
Intro / claim:
Support:
Concluding statement:
Arguments build a foundation from which both the writer and reader can build knowledge.
(Badenhorst, p. 113).
Therefore .
So
Hence
Thus
Consequently, .
This argument proves that
This statement justifies the / my belief that
I conclude that
[This] implies that
[This] allows us to assume / conclude that
It follows that
Subsequently,
[This] establishes the idea that
[This] demonstrates that
Heres what happens when arguments and evidence are not thought through carefully:
1. Generalisations: sweeping claims with little or no evidence. All women are oppressed.
Check your generalisations; identify, unpack and provide evidence.
2. Stereotyping: making assumptions about people, places, things because everyone knows
without providing evidence. This often happens at the beginning of an argument. Rural
areas are slow. Unpack, contextualise and provide evidence.
3. Either-or: limiting an argument to two alternatives, when in fact there may be more. Us and
Them .. Children misbehave in the class because they get no attention at home or are
struggling with the work. Polarising and dualisms oversimplify the situation. Explore the
range of complexity, introduce the notion of degrees, and explain how / why you limited
your discussion.
4. Faulty logic or reasoning: logic is about one event happening after another because the first
causes or leads to the second. Faulty logic occurs when the conclusion doesnt follow the
logic of the argument and evidence. Children from single parent households struggle to
make friendships at school or learners who constantly misbehave in class experience
reading difficulties.
5. Assuming a truth: arguments are flawed when assumptions are taken for granted. Science
is about truth and therefore my conclusions are truthful. Unpack your assumptions.
Parents who are not involved in their childs homework often have not been through school
themselves and do not value education.
TASK:
Be Critical:
Adapted from: Badenhorst, C. (2013). Dissertation writing. A research journey. Pretoria: Van
Schaik Publishers