Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 113

Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor Panel Design - Table Content

Fundamental Theories
Power Factor
Harmonics

Design inputs
Design Inputs Based on Existing PF Installation
Designing PF Panel with Limited Information

Power Factor Correction System Design


Components Selection
Application Example
Setting the regulator

Post Installation Check on PFC System

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


POWER FACTOR
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - What is Power Factor?

Ratio of Real Power [W] over Apparent


Power [VA]

Dimensionless

Range between -1 to 1

Measures the efficiency of real power


transferred

Near modulus 1 is considered good

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Consequences of Low Power Factor

Due to linear load


High transmission losses
Inefficiency of power transfer
Lower source capacity

Due to non-linear load


Harmonics
Resonance
Damaging of power factor capacitor
Damaging of neutral line

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - What causes Low Power Factor?

Non-linear load

High reactive component load

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - How to Improve Power Factor?

Power factor correction capacitor (for inductive load)

Active filter

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Utility Penalty from Low Power Factor

TNB classifies user as:


Domestic
Commercial
Industrial

Power factor penalty details:


Single phase not applicable
Domestic not applicable
132kV and above 0.90
Below 132kV 0.85
Aggregated monthly

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Utility Penalty from Low Power Factor

Malaysias Utility TNB

1.5% surcharge of the current bill for every 0.01 less than 0.85 power factor.

3% surcharge of the current bill for every 0.01 less than 0.75 power factor.

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Utility Penalty from Low Power Factor

The following is an excerpt from the TNB Tariff Book.

For all Tariffs, except Tariffs A and G, the consumer should strive to obtain the highest
Power Factor possible in the operation of any of his electrical installations.

If the Average Power Factor in any month is found to be:

Below 0.85 and up to 0.75 lagging, a supplementary charge of one and one-half
per cent (1%) of the bill for that month for each one-hundredth part (0.01)
below 0.85 and up to 0.75 lagging Power Factor will be added to the bill for that
month, and

Below 0.75 lagging, in addition to the charge payable under subparagraph (A)
above, a supplementary charge of three per cent (3%) of the bill for that month
for each one-hundredth (0.01) part below 0.75 lagging Power Factor will be
added to the bill for that month.

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Utility Penalty from Low Power Factor

Example: A Consumer has a Power Factor at 0.60 and his consumption is


RM4,800.00

(a) 0.85 - 0.75 = 1% x 10 units lagging = 15%

(b) 0.75 - 0.60 = 3% x 15 unit lagging = 45%


Total extra levied = 60%

Therefore, his penalty charge would be


60% of RM 4,800.00 which is RM 2,880.00

The total payable will hence be RM 7,680.00

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Estimation of total kVAR requirement

Required information:
Utility bill
Total reactive load
Transformer size
Power meter reading

Required total kVAR can be calculated from:

Q = P x (Tan 1 Tan 2)

Q = Total required reactive power [VAR]


P = Full load active power [W]
1 = Measured displacement power factor angle
2 = Target displacement power factor angle (For 0.85, 2 is 31.79o)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor - Displacement Power Factor (DPF) vs. Power Factor (PF)

Power Factor
Power factor is the ratio of total
active power [W] over total
apparent power [VA]

PF = P / |Vrms| x |I rms|

The calculation of power factor


takes into account the harmonics
component

Utility meter measure power factor

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor DPF vs. PF

Displacement Power Factor


Displacement power factor is the ratio of total
fundamental active power [W] over total
fundamental apparent power [VA] which does
not take into account of harmonics

Displacement power factor is caused by linear


load which causes phase shift between voltage
and current

Displacement power factor are usually


represented by cos phi

Power factor regulator typically measures


displacement power factor and only corrects
displacement power factor
www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Power Factor DPF vs. PF (Calculation Example)

Power factor is typically less than or equals to displacement power factor

PF DPF

RMS 50Hz 150Hz 350Hz


V 10o 0.220o 0.0510o
I 130o 0.280o 0.15-20o

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Displacement Power Factor vs. Power Factor (Calculation Example)

Sum of all harmonics order of active power


P = (1)(1)cos 30o+ (0.2)(0.2)cos 60o+ (0.05)(0.15)cos 30o = 0.892

(Vrms)2 = 12 + 0.22 + 0.052 = 1.0425, Vrms = 1.021

(Irms)2 = 12 + 0.22 + 0.152 = 1.0625, Irms = 1.031

Apparent Power, S = (Vrms)(Irms) = 1.052

Power Factor, PF = P / S = 0.892 / 1.052 = 0.848

Displacement Power Factor, DPF = cos(fundamental) = cos 30o


= 0.866 (lag)

PF (0.848) < DPF (0.866)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


HARMONICS
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

What is Harmonics

IEEE 519 definition:

A sinusoidal component of a periodic wave or quantity having a frequency


that is an integral multiple of the fundamental frequency.

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - How Harmonics are generated

Arc discharge

Saturated magnetic devices

Rotating devices

Static power converters

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - How Harmonics are generated

Static Power Converters are the largest none linear load that are used in the
industry

It includes circuitries with rectifiers such as:

UPS
Inverter systems
Adjustable speed drives
Switch mode power supply (SMPS)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - How Rectifying Circuits Generates Harmonics


Currents are drawn only when Vs > Vcap

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Number of Pulse and Harmonics Order

h = kq 1
k = any integer
q = pulse number of converter

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - THD Definition

IEEE definition The denominator is the fundamental value

CSA definition The denominator is the total rms value

IEEE Definition CSA Definition

Note: CSA Definition will yield a smaller THD value

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Parallel Resonance

Typically load mixture of linear and non-linear load

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Parallel Resonance

Power factor compensation (capacitor) interacts with the non-linear load

When the system resonant frequencies corresponds to one of the harmonics


frequencies being produced by non-linear load (natural frequency),
harmonic resonance can occur

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Consequences of Parallel Resonance

Harmonics current will see a low


impedance at the resonance circuit

This causes a high resonance current

During parallel resonance, a high


magnitude current will flow from
harmonic source to power factor
capacitor and transformer circuit

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Consequences of Parallel Resonance

Effects on power factor capacitor


This high current flows through the power factor capacitor and heats up
the capacitor above its rating which reduces its lifespan
Higher temperature also causes faster degradation of insulation within
the capacitor

Effects on power quality


Parallel resonance will cause voltage distortion thus affecting power
quality

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Regulatory Requirements for Harmonics

IEEE Std 519-1992

IEEE Recommended Practices and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electric Power System

IEC 61000-3-6

Part 3: Limits. Section 6: Assessment of Emission Limits for Distorting Loads in MV and HV
Power Systems

IEC 61000-3-2

Part 3-2: Limits - Limits for harmonic current emissions (equipment input current 16 A per
phase)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - IEC 61000-2-2 Typical Harmonics Level at Low Voltage System

Long term compatible THDV level is 8%

Short term compatible THDV level is 11%

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Triplen Harmonics

The triplen harmonics will flow through the neutral conductor

There is a possibility where the neutral current will be 300% of the phase
current due to the triplen harmonics

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Regulatory Requirements for Harmonics

America adopts IEEE Std. 519-1992 standard


Europe adopts IEC 61000-3-6 standard
These standards apply in industrial electrical system

User can utilize solution such as 6-pulse inverter to cancel off harmonics

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Regulatory Requirements for Harmonics

For domestic appliances, Europe adopts IEC 61000-3-2 standard


The electrical system designer virtually does not have to bother about
harmonics issue as the solution is already pre-designed into the equipment

Expensive equipment

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Overcoming Parallel Resonance

Creating a trap filter using a reactor in series with the power factor
correction capacitor

12

10

Amp
6

Filter Attenuation
4

0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Order

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Overcoming Parallel Resonance

Utility Linear Load

150Hz

50Hz

150Hz
100Hz 200Hz

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Overcoming Parallel Resonance Linear Load

Non-linear
Utility load
Non-linear
load

50Hz
150Hz

150Hz

150Hz
100Hz 200Hz

200Hz

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Harmonics - Overcoming Parallel Resonance Linear Load

Non-linear
Utility load
Non-linear
load

50Hz

189Hz
150Hz

189Hz

200Hz

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


DESIGN INPUT
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Design Input

Data required

Design input based on existing installation

New Design

Output

Type of panel

Type of compensation

Capacitor voltage

To use detuned reactor?


www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui
DESIGN INPUT BASED ON
MEASURING EXISTING
INSTALLATION
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Design Input Based on Measuring Existing Installation

Data required
Effective kVAR requirement

Resonance

Individual Harmonics Component

THD-I

THD-V

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Site Measurement Equipment for Existing Installation

Equipment required

Power Quality Analyzer

Hioki PW3198
Yokogawa CW120

Clamp on power meter

Yokogawa CW10

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Checking Effective kVAR Requirement

Check on TNB meter if PF > 0.85 and still have available capacitor banks yet
to turned on?

OR

Turn on all capacitor banks manually and check if the TNB meter displays
leading/capacitive power factor?

If the existing PF panel has sufficient effective kVAR for displacement


power factor compensation, dont have to add additional capacitor
banks

If not, . Continue

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Measuring the Required Effective kVAR (Existing PF Panel Insufficient kVAR)

1. Turn on all capacitor banks

2. Turn on all available loads with full loading

3. Measure the displacement power factor (Cos ) / read from power


meter (maximum instantaneous reactive power)

4. Determine the target displacement power factor required (Cos t)

5. Calculate or by reading on the table the total effective kVAR required

Required VAR = P (tan tan t)

6. Sub divide the kVAR to 15 25 % of the total capacitor bank kVAR for a
good average power factor compensation
www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Checking for Resonance

1. Turn off all capacitor banks

2. Turn on all the loads (especially those that produce harmonics)

3. Turn on 1 by 1 capacitor banks and record the THD-I and THD-V value

4. Check if THD-I and THD-V increases with the turning on of capacitor


banks

5. If it increases, means resonance occurred in the system and should


consider using detuned reactor

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Measuring Harmonics (For Detuned Reactor Sizing)

1. Turn off all capacitor banks

2. Turn on all the loads (especially those that produce harmonics)

3. Measure the individual current and voltage harmonic order and


maximum amplitude (Measure without capacitor connected). You can
measure the harmonics current on the secondary side.

4. Calculate the %THDI and %THDV

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Important Site Measurement Data - Power Factor Sizing Guide

Are there any significant


Use standard
harmonics in the system?
N capacitor would
be sufficient
THDI > 10%
or
THDV > 3%?
Use p=14%
Y Y
Is I3 > 0.2 . I5? type reactor
I3 significant

N
Is THDV > 7%? Use p=7%
type reactor
N

N Use p=5.67%
Is THDV > 10%?
type reactor
Y

Customize
type reactor
Y

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


DESIGNING PF PANEL WITH
LIMITED INFORMATION
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Designing PF Panel with Limited Information

Does your factory needs power factor panel?

Does your utility company penalize you for low power factor?

Does your source (generator) requires displacement power factor


compensation for better power efficiency (Issue with voltage drop)?

If your answer is yes for either one of the questions above, your factory
requires a power factor panel for power factor compensation.

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Designing PF Panel with Limited Information

What type of Power Factor Compensation do you need?

If you have a few big Fixed Compensation, PF


inductive loads with minor Capacitor connected
variation in power directly to the load
consumption

If you have fast changing Thyristor type switching of


load PF Capacitor

If you have only inverter Active Filter


type load

If you have many small Automatic Compensation


inductive loads with
significant variation in
power consumption

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Designing PF Panel with Limited Information

How much effective kVAR do you need?

What is your minimum power factor requirement imposed by the utility company
without penalty?

What is your monthly calculated cos phi (also known as displacement power factor),
or X/R ratio and total active power at your point of common coupling (PCC)?

What is your calculated total reactive power (kVAR) per month at your PCC?

Does your utility company calculate power factor penalty by averaging or demand
method?

If all of the above is not available, size power factor panel 30% or up to 40%
of transformers kVA rating for kVAR compensation

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Designing PF Panel with Limited Information

440V AC Dry Type Capacitor Less Durable

440V AC Oil Type Capacitor

525V AC Dry Type Capacitor

525V AC Oil Type Capacitor

525V AC Dry Type Capacitor with 7% Detuned Reactor

525V AC Oil Type Capacitor with 7% Detuned Reactor More Durable

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


POWER FACTOR
CORRECTION (PFC) SYSTEM
AND COMPONENTS
SELECTION
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Four Types of Power Factor


Solutions
Fixed capacitor compensation

Automated compensation

Fast changing load compensation

Pure none linear load compensation (Active filters)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Important Parameters of Power


Factor Capacitor
Rated Voltage

Rated Frequency

Power kVAR

Temperature

Indoor or outdoor

Dry or Oil type

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Oil Type vs. Dry Type Capacitor

Item Oil Type Dry Type

Safety (fire Capacitor Oil will not catch fire, but it N/A
hazard) have a flash point at 230oC

Losses of the It is same, because it used metalized PP film with low loss factor
capacitor

Reliability It is same, because it used of high quality materials ensure reliability


and longevity

Other
Need more space for installation More convenience, no
- Installation need more space

- Leakage After using for long time oil may leak and No liquid impregnate
dirty.

- Price High Economical

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Relationship Between kVAR and


System Voltage
kVAR2 = kVAR1 x (U2/U1)2

U1Rated Voltage 1
U2Rated Voltage 2
kVAR1 Rated Reactive Power at U1
kVAR2 Rated Reactive Power at U2

Example :
What is the effective reactive power of a capacitor rated at 75kVAR, 525V AC
used at system voltage 400V AC?

kVAR400 = kVAR525 x (400/525)2


= 43.54 kVAR

X kVAR Capacitor at 525V AC using at 400V AC will yield a smaller kVAR then
X

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Relationship Between kVAR and


System Voltage
The kVAR of 525V AC rated power factor capacitor is about 62% at 415V AC

50kVAR @ 525V AC = 50 x 0.62


= 31kVAR @ 415V AC

The kVAR of 440V AC rated power factor capacitor is about 89% at 415V AC

25kVAR @ 440V AC = 25 x 0.89


= 22kVAR @ 415V AC

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Important Parameters of Reactor

%p Detuning factor

Rated Frequency

Capacitor power kVAR

Capacitor rated voltage

System voltage

Linearity

Core type

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Detuning/Filtering Factor %p

%p = XL / XC

XL : Impedance of the reactor


XC : Impedance of the capacitor

Determines the filtering characteristic

6% 233 Hz
7% 189 Hz
14% 134 Hz 6

5.67% 210 Hz 5

Freq = System Freq / Sqrt(%p)


Attenuation
3

0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Frequency

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Selection of Reactor Depends On


Capacitor
Capacitor voltage increases by an induced voltage of a factor of 1 p

On top of that, the capacitor will have an additional voltage increase due to
harmonics current flowing in the detuning circuit

Example
System voltage 400V AC, using p = 7% reactor, what is the voltage increase due
to the induced voltage of the reactor?

Voltage across the capacitor will increase to

Uc = 400 / (1 - 0.07)
= 430V AC

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Selection of Reactor Depends On


Capacitor
The effective kVAR will also increases by an factor of 1 p

The bigger the %p, the bigger the increase

Example
System voltage 380V AC, using p = 7% reactor matching with 50kVAR 525V AC
power factor capacitor, what is the effective kVAR?

Effective kVAR will be increased to

Qc = 50kVAR x (380/525)2 / (1 - 0.07)


= 28.2 kVAR

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Current per phase calculation for capacitor bank


Current per phase = 2
3

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Cable, Isolator, Contactor and Protection Devices Selection

Contactor Size = 2 times current per phase of capacitor bank


Fuse size = 1.6 1.8 times rated current per step
Cable size = 1.8 times rated current per phase of capacitor bank
Main CB Size = 125% of sum of rated current of all steps
CB Size per step = 1.3 times of rated current per step

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Cable Selection Table for Capacitor

Wire Size mm2 Up till [Amp]


4 12.5
6 19.7
10 28.9
16 43.3
25 57.7
35 72.2
50 98.4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Contactor Selection Table for


Capacitor
Typically use AC-6b type contactors for capacitor switching

With the installation of reactor, possible to use AC-6 type contactor as the
reactor would limit the inrush current

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

PFC System and Components Selection - Discharge Resistor

The power factor capacitor requirements in accordance to IEC 60831


is when disconnected from system voltage, the capacitor must discharge
to a voltage less then 75V AC within 3 minutes
t
R
Vi 2
Ct ln
V
f

Vi : Initial capacitor voltage (typically system voltage)


Vf : Capacitor safety voltage, 75V AC
t : Discharge time, 180s (3 min)
Ct : Capacitance
R : Discharge resistance

Note: Usually included in the power factor capacitor


www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated


step size

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

The regulator needs to know what capacitor it controls at each step in


order for it to compensate effectively

We need to set C/K value and rated step size (or let the regulator auto-
detect) for the regulator to know
Load

PF Panel

PFR
? kVAR ? kVAR ? kVAR ? kVAR

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

Setting the C/K value tells the regulator what the smallest capacitor size
is in the PF panel

Setting the rated step size tells the regulator what other capacitor sizes
are in the PF panel
Load

PF Panel

PFR
5 kVAR 10 kVAR 15 kVAR 25 kVAR

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

C/K is actually VAR divided by CT Ratio and line voltage

Rated step size is the multiple of the smallest step size

C/K = Effective kVAR

CT Ratio x Line Voltage

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : Settings Example

C/K = 5000/415/sqrt(3)/75x5 = 0.46


Rated Step Size : {S2:2; S3:3; S4:5; S5:0; S6:0}
415V
Load
75/5
PF Panel

PFR60
5 kVAR 10 kVAR 15 kVAR 25 kVAR
415V 415V 415V 415V

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

Note:
Need to use effective kVAR, e.g. 100kVAR 525V used at 415V, effective kVAR is 62kVAR

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

C/K determines whether or not to switch in or off the capacitor bank

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

Demand = 7kVAR
Smallest step size = 5kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 15kVAR 25kVAR

Demand = 7kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

Turning on 5kVAR does not overcompensate


Turn ON 5kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 15kVAR 25kVAR

Demand = 2kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Setting the regulator : C/K and rated step size

Demand is now 2kVAR after turning on Step 1


Regulator will stop switching because demand (2kVAR) is less than
smallest step size (5kVAR)

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 15kVAR 25kVAR

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


FREQUENTLY ASKED
QUESTION (FAQ) AND
EXPERIENCES
WHAT IS THE LOWEST CURRENT
THAT MIKROS PFR CAN
DETECT?
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Minimum Current

Old Version PFR


Lowest current detection capability: 0.15A

New Version PFR


Lowest current detection capability : 0.05A

PFRLCD
Lowest current detection capability : 0.01A

The latest improvement of Mikros power factor regulator series expands the
dynamic range of current detection to better detect low load condition

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Minimum Current

100A ON Big
Load
1000/5
0.5A PF Panel

ON Small
PFR
5 kVAR
Load
2.5 kVAR 10 kVAR 10 kVAR

PFR able Step 1 Step 3 Step 4


Step 2
to detect DPF

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Minimum Current

20A OFF Big


Load
1000/5
0.1A PF Panel

ON Small
PFR
2.5 kVAR 5 kVAR 10 kVAR 10 kVAR Load

Old PFR not Step 1 Step 3 Step 4


Step 2
able to detect DPF

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


WHICH SWITCHING MODE IS
BETTER?
AUTOMATIC VS. ROTATIONAL
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Load Demand = 17kVAR


Smallest step size = 5kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 17kVAR
Cap ON = 0kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Step 1 turn ON
Net Demand = 12kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 12kVAR
Cap ON = 5kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Step 2 turn ON
Net Demand = 7kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 7kVAR
Cap ON = 10kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Step 3 turn ON
Net demand = 2kVAR
Regulator will stop switching in more capacitor banks because
net demand (2kVAR) < smallest step size (5kVAR) of the PF panel

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 2kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Load demand reduces from 17kVAR to 9kVAR


Regulator will prepare to switch off Step 1 as the absolute value of the
net demand (6kVAR) > smallest step size (5kVAR) of the PF panel

PF Panel Capacitive!

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 9kVAR
Net Demand = - 6kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Step 1 turn OFF


Net Demand = -1kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 9kVAR
Net Demand = - 1kVAR
Cap ON = 10kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Load demand increases back to 17kVAR


Regulator will prepare to turn on Step 4 because the absolute value of the
net demand (7kVAR) > smallest step size (5kVAR) of the PF panel

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 7kVAR
Cap ON = 10kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Step 4 turn ON
Net Demand = 2kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 2kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Load demand reduces back to 9kVAR from 17kVAR


Regulator will prepare to switch off step 2 because the absolute value of
the net demand is now bigger than the smallest step size of the PF panel

PF Panel Capacitive!

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 9kVAR
Net Demand = - 6kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: FIFO Mode

Step 2 turn OFF


Net Demand = - 1kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR 5kVAR


Load Demand = 9kVAR
Net Demand = - 1kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Load Demand = 17kVAR


Smallest step size = 5kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 17kVAR
Cap ON = 0kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Step 2 turn ON
Net Demand = 7kVAR

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 7kVAR
Cap ON = 10kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Step 1 turn ON
Net Demand = 2kVAR
Regulator will stop switching in more capacitor banks because the
net demand (2kVAR) < smallest step size of the PF panel

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 17kVAR
Net Demand = 2kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Load demand reduces from 17kVAR to 4kVAR


Regulator will prepare to switch off Step 2 because the absolute value of
the net demand < smallest step size of PF panel

PF Panel Capacitive!

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 4kVAR
Net Demand = -11kVAR
Cap ON = 15kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Step 2 turn OFF


Net Demand = -1kVAR
Regulator will stop switching in more capacitor banks because the
net demand < smallest step size of the PF panel

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 4kVAR
Net Demand = -1kVAR
Cap ON = 5kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Load demand increases from 4kVAR to 26kVAR


Regulator will prepare to turn on Step 3 because the absolute value of the
net demand < smallest step size of PF panel

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 26kVAR
Net Demand = 21kVAR
Cap ON = 5kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Example: Automatic Mode

Step 3 turn ON
Net Demand = 1kVAR
Regulator will stop switching in more capacitor banks because the
net demand < smallest step size of the PF panel

PF Panel

5kVAR 10kVAR 20kVAR 40kVAR


Load Demand = 26kVAR
Net Demand = 1kVAR
Cap ON = 25kVAR
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

FIFO vs. Automatic Switching Mode Comparison

FIFO typically have the same step size per step e.g. 25kVAR for all 12 steps

Advantage of using same step size is common stock for capacitor,


contactor, breaker, fuse

Simplicity, equal wear and tear of capacitor banks

Disadvantage of using same step size is target power factor might not be
achieved (i.e. oscillation issue, longer time, need a lot of steps)

Automatic mode : Fast, more precise, balancing algorithm within the


same step size

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


WHAT DETERMINES THE
SWITCHING TIME OF THE
REGULATOR?
Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Mikro PFR has a slow response in switching in capacitor bank?

Determination of switching in capacitor banks of regulators in the market:


Time delay method
Sensitivity method (Mikro)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Condition to turn on/off capacitor banks is when demand vs. smallest


step size of power factor panel.

Example 1:
Smallest step: 10kVAR
Required kVAR: 20kVAR
Demand vs. C/K*
DPF < Target PF Turn on capacitor

*Smallest Step Size


Example 2:
Smallest step: 10 kVAR
Demand: -30 kVAR If Demand < smallest step size,
DPF > Target PF Turn off capacitor capacitor banks stop switching

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

As the load fluctuates, regulator cannot immediately turn on/off


capacitor when the threshold has been crossed (oscillation issue)

Oscillation Issue

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Most regulator will have hysteresis threshold and time delay to avoid
oscillation (i.e. switching on and off capacitor frequently)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

At some cases, it is inevitable that the load fluctuates.

Time delay / sensitivity method is used to control the switching of the


capacitor banks to accommodate this load fluctuation condition

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Switching time is inversely proportional to capacitors lifespan (i.e. more


switching, reducing the lifespan of capacitor banks)

If the load fluctuates frequently, faster switching time will be better to


avoid power factor penalty

No. of Capacitor
Switching Lifespan

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Case 1:
If your systems worst case of load fluctuation causes you to incur power
factor penalty, increase the response time of switching (i.e. reducing the
sensitivity time setting) to track the load fluctuation so that your system
will not incur power factor penalty

This is because the priority of avoiding power factor penalty is higher


than capacitor banks lifespan

Priority of Power Factor Penalty Decrease sensitivity OR time delay


> Capacitor Bank Lifespan setting

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Condition
Penalty threshold : 0.85
Fluctuation demand > Smallest step size
Fluctuation power factor : 0.95 -> 0.98 (Does not incur penalty)
Fluctuation time = 10s (Oscillate from 0.95)

Solution
Priority to prevent capacitor from switching in and out frequently
Setting of sensitivity/time delay > fluctuation time (10s)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Case 2:
If your systems load fluctuation does not cause you to incur power factor
penalty, decrease the response time of switching (i.e. increasing the
sensitivity or time delaysetting) to avoid reducing the lifespan of capacitor
banks

This is because the priority of capacitor banks lifespan is more important


as the load profile is stable (i.e. no power factor penalty incurred)

Priority of Capacitor Bank Lifespan Increase sensitivity OR


> Power Factor Penalty time delay setting

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Condition
Penalty threshold : 0.85
Fluctuation demand > Smallest step size
Fluctuation power factor : 0.80 -> 0.98 (Incur penalty)
Fluctuation time = 10s (Oscillate from 0.95)

Solution
Priority to avoid penalty in the expense of frequent switching of capacitor
Setting of sensitivity/time delay = Fluctuation time (10s)

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

Time delay switching method


If the absolute value of kVAR demand >> smallest step size of the PF
panel, the response time to switch in/out capacitor banks will be at a
fixed amount of time (depending on the setting of the time delay)
regardless on whether the demand requirement is big or small

Mikros sensitivity switching method


If the absolute value of kVAR demand >> smallest step size of the PF
panel, response time to switch in/out capacitor banks will be fast

As the kVAR demand drops close to the smallest step size of the PF panel,
response time to switch in/out capacitor banks will be slow

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Switching Reaction Time

If Mikro PFRs sensitivity time setting is set to be the same as regulators


using time delay methods setting, at a big demand requirement, Mikros
PFR will have a faster response time

At a small demand requirement on the other hand, Mikros PFR will have
a same response time as regulators using time delay method (if time
delay setting is set to be same as Mikros sensitivity time setting)

10s 10s

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui


Mikro Electrical Distribution Solution 2014

Contact Us

Mr. Tay Siang Hui


MSc. Eng, MBA, P.Eng, MIEM
Email : taysh@itmikro.com
Website: www.itmikro.com

Mikro MSC Bhd.


No. 1, Jalan TP 7/7,
Sime UEP Industrial Park,
40400, Shah Alam, Selangor
Malaysia.

Tel : +6 03 5192 7155


Fax : + 6 03 5192 7166
Hp : +6 16 216 4801

www.itmikro.com Copyright Mikro Sdn Bhd Tay Siang Hui

Вам также может понравиться