Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

Clinical EEG and Neuroscience

http://eeg.sagepub.com/

Utility of the Electroencephalogram in Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder


J. Gordon Millichap, John J. Millichap and Cynthia V. Stack
Clin EEG Neurosci 2011 42: 180
DOI: 10.1177/155005941104200307

The online version of this article can be found at:


http://eeg.sagepub.com/content/42/3/180

Published by:

http://www.sagepublications.com

On behalf of:

EEG and Clinical Neuroscience Society

Additional services and information for Clinical EEG and Neuroscience can be found at:

Email Alerts: http://eeg.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts

Subscriptions: http://eeg.sagepub.com/subscriptions

Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav

Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav

>> Version of Record - Jul 1, 2011

What is This?

Downloaded from eeg.sagepub.com at UMKC University Libraries on May 25, 2014


CLINICAL EEG and NEUROSCIENCE ©2011 VOL. 42 NO. 3

Utility of the Electroencephalogram in


Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
J. Gordon Millichap, John J. Millichap and Cynthia V. Stack

Key Words bation raise concern about the safety of methylphenidate in children
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder with a tendency to seizures. The clinical utility of the EEG in ADHD has
Electroencephalogram been controversial, viewed as limited by some investigators and of
Pediatrics value by others, and needs reappraisal.7,8
In this review, the literature regarding the EEG in the management of
ABSTRACT children with ADHD is analyzed; the value of the EEG in determination
An electroencephalogram (EEG) has not been routinely utilized in of safety of stimulant versus nonstimulant medication in ADHD is dis-
the evaluation of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder cussed; and the evidence in favor and against antiepileptic drug (AED)
(ADHD). The utility of the EEG in ADHD is unclear. A recent study in treatment in patients at risk of cognitive impairment is summarized.
our laboratory using sleep and sleep deprivation routinely found one in Learning disability is a frequent comorbid problem in children with ADHD,
four non-epileptic children evaluated for attention deficit disorder has and brief cognitive deficits (transient cognitive impairment) occur in those
epileptiform discharges in the EEG, more than half focal. The majority patients with subclinical EEG abnormalities.9 Treatment with AEDs may
of abnormalities (97.5%) occur in sleep and sleep-deprived records control EEG epileptiform discharges and benefit cognition in children
compared to 7% in prior wake only records. A review of eight publica- with ADHD, a finding that may prompt the reappraisal of the principle of
tions showed that laboratories using awake only as routine EEG treating clinical seizures but not the EEG.10
recordings report a relatively low prevalence of epileptiform dis- PREVALENCE OF EEG EPILEPTIFORM
charges, whereas the higher prevalence of epileptiform discharges is ABNORMALITIES IN ADHD
seen in those with more prolonged sleep recordings. We have deter- Children with ADHD have a higher rate of EEG epileptiform
mined that sleep deprivation and sleep are essential to rule out an abnormalities than the 3.5% reported in healthy controls.11 In our review
abnormal EEG in attention deficit disorder. of 8 studies of nonepileptic children with ADHD, the prevalence of
In patients with attention deficit disorder complicated by epilepsy, epileptiform EEGs varied from 6% to as high as 53%, and an average
stimulant therapy is generally safe, provided seizures are controlled by of 23.4%.2 The wide range of abnormal records may be attributed to
antiepileptic medication. Patients with epilepsy or subclinical electro- several factors, including length of recording, sleep, method of
graphic abnormalities not treated with anticonvulsants are at increased recording (paper or digital), and differences in interpretation. EEGs with
risk of seizures when stimulant therapy is introduced, especially the highest incidence of abnormalities were prolonged and sleep
extended-release methylphenidate. Apart from an increase in risk of deprived. In one study of routine, awake EEGs, epileptiform
seizures and need for caution in use of stimulants, studies show that abnormalities were present in 6.1% of 347 patients. Epileptiform
epileptiform discharges in the electroencephalogram are linked to a generalized discharges occurred only in response to activation
better response of attention deficit to methylphenidate and a higher procedures, hyperventilation (n=2 patients) and photic stimulation
cognitive performance. Transient cognitive impairment related to sub- (n=4); sleep was not obtained and sleep deprivation was not
clinical electrographic abnormalities responds to antiepileptic requested.7 In our laboratory, 26.1% of non-epileptic ADHD patients had
medication. An EEG is important in selected cases of attention deficit epileptiform EEGs, and more than half had focal discharges, chiefly
disorder and is useful in choice of medication, especially in children central, frontal and temporal.2 Figures 1 and 2 are brief samples of the
with lack of awareness and transient cognitive impairment. kind of focal and generalized epileptiform discharges encountered in
INTRODUCTION EEGs of our patients with ADHD. The majority of abnormalities (94.5%)
According to the American Academy of Pediatrics Clinical Practice occurred in sleep deprived records and 97.5% were sleep records; only
Guidelines proposed in 2001,1 an EEG is not routinely indicated in the 7% of abnormalities, all generalized, were elicited with hyperventilation
management of children with ADHD. However, a recent study in our and 10 % with photic stimulation. Of a total of 57 wake-only EEGs, 4
laboratory employing the sleep deprived EEG finds 1 in 4 children with (7.0%) were abnormal, a similar percentage to that reported in a study
ADHD has an epileptiform abnormality.2 The Physicians Desk that employed wake EEG as a routine.7
Reference3 warns that central nervous stimulants, generally used to
treat ADHD, should be avoided or used with caution in patients with an
From the Division of Neurology (J.G. Millichap, J.J. Millichap, C.V. Stack), Epilepsy Center
abnormal EEG. One in 5 children with epilepsy has ADHD,4 and (J.J. Millichap) and Neurodiagnostic Electroencephalography Laboratory (C.V. Stack),
children with ADHD have an increased risk of epilepsy.5 A significant Children’s Memorial Hospital, Northwestern University Medical School, Chicago, Illinois.
increase in the incidence of seizures is reported during treatment with Address correspondence to J. Gordon Millichap, MD, Division of Neurology, Children’s
Memorial Hospital, 2300 Children’s Plaza, Box 51, Chicago, IL 60614.
methylphenidate in children with ADHD and centro-temporal (rolandic) Email: gmillichap@childrensmemorial.org
spikes in the EEG.6 These warnings and reports of seizure exacer- Received: November 26, 2010; accepted: January 18, 2011.

180
Downloaded from eeg.sagepub.com at UMKC University Libraries on May 25, 2014
CLINICAL EEG and NEUROSCIENCE ©2011 VOL. 42 NO. 3

Figure 1.
Representative EEG with focal epileptiform discharges recorded from a non-epileptic 13-year-old boy with ADHD. There are focal spike and slow wave discharges
on either frontal central or central parietal area. Horizontal dipoles were present over each hemisphere. (longitudinal bipolar montage, sensitivity 10 µV/mm, vertical
lines = 1 second.)

A review of 8 published reports of the prevalence of epileptiform combination with AED treatment may be safe in the majority of children
abnormalities reported in nonepileptic children with ADHD2 shows that with ADHD and epilepsy, the substitution of an extended-release
those with a relatively low prevalence were awake only or not stated, preparation (OROS-MPH) in increasing doses has been associated with
whereas the highest prevalence occurred in those with prolonged sleep an increased daily risk of seizures.17 The physician in choosing a medica-
recordings. One earlier study employing sleep deprivation12 reported tion for a child with ADHD must weigh the risks and benefits of stimulant,
epileptiform EEG discharges in 30.1% of 176 patients, a relatively high nonstimulant, immediate-release or extended-release preparations. The
prevalence similar to that documented in our laboratory.2 EEG can be of help in arriving at an informed decision.
RISK OF SEIZURES WITH STIMULANT MEDICATION VALUE OF EEG IN SELECTION OF MEDICATION FOR ADHD
The safety of methylphenidate in the treatment of ADHD in children In patients presenting with ADHD, an EEG is not part of the routine
with epilepsy or EEG abnormalities has been studied only in patients workup. In some circumstances, however, the EEG can be of value in
receiving AEDs in combination with methylphenidate.4 None of 25 the selection of medication.2 Patients with episodic altered awareness or
children who were seizure free had attacks during methylphenidate daydreaming, frequent memory lapses, or family history of epilepsy
treatment, whereas 3 of 5 children with seizures had an increase in should be considered for EEG. Activation procedures, especially sleep
attacks. Other investigators report the combined treatment safe and deprivation, should be employed to ensure exclusion of EEG seizure dis-
effective in 57 children with ADHD and active seizures and in 62 with charges and clinical seizure susceptibility.2 When electrographic sei-
ADHD and EEG abnormalities only.13 Caution is advised in using com- zures are uncovered, the non-stimulant, atomoxetine may be considered
binations of certain AEDs or antidepressants with methylphenidate; 2 as a safer alternative to stimulants and a first choice treatment for ADHD.
children with ADHD and epilepsy developed severe dyskinesia and brux- If stimulant medication is preferred, the immediate-release preparation is
ism when methylphenidate was added to the maintenance valproic acid probably safe in small to moderate doses, and not likely to trigger
therapy.14 Buproprion lowers the seizure threshold and, if used in combi- seizures.2 Larger doses and extended-release stimulant preparations
nation with methylphenidate, tonic-clonic seizures can be induced.15 should be avoided or used with caution, since seizures are reported,
Improvements in teacher rating scales of attention and behavior even in patients treated with AEDs in combination with stimulant.17
without recurrence of seizures are reported in 10 children with ADHD SUBCLINICAL ELECTROGRAPHIC SEIZURES
and epilepsy treated with AEDs and methylphenidate.16 The EEG AND TRANSIENT COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT
showed no significant changes of epileptiform features or background A longitudinal follow-up clinical, neuropsychological, and EEG
activity in patients who continued psychostimulant therapy, and no alter- study of the effectiveness of AEDs in treatment of ADHD and epilep-
ations in AED levels. Whereas immediate-release methylphenidate in tiform discharges showed a temporal relation between subclinical focal

181
Downloaded from eeg.sagepub.com at UMKC University Libraries on May 25, 2014
CLINICAL EEG and NEUROSCIENCE ©2011 VOL. 42 NO. 3

Figure 2.
Representative EEG with generalized epileptiform discharges recorded from a non-epileptic 9-year-old boy with ADHD. There is a brief burst of generalized spike
and slow wave discharges noted during wake without concurrent clinically apparent seizure activity. (longitudinal bipolar montage, sensitivity 20 µV/mm, vertical
lines = 1 second.)

epileptiform discharges and cognitive dysfunction.10 The effect of AEDs titative EEG spectral analysis demonstrated normalization of the EEG,
on cognitive impairments should be monitored in addition to seizure behavior, and cognitive function. Boys with ADHD showed improve-
control and reduction in EEG discharges. Transient cognitive impair- ments in tasks involving reading, coding, and visual-motor perception
ments involving verbal, visuospatial, and memory function in children that correlated with regional changes in the EEG.22
with benign childhood epilepsy with centro-temporal spikes are directly COGNITIVE EFFECTS OF ANTIEPILEPTIC DRUGS
related to paroxysmal EEG activity.18 Cognitive impairment in children Adverse cognitive effects of AEDs23,24 are the chief deterrents to their
with ADHD and subclinical spikes in the EEG, described as the under- usage in non-epileptic children with ADHD complicated by learning
recognized epilepsy spectrum, is improved following treatment with the disability. However, a multicenter study of the effects of withdrawal of
AED levetiracetam.19 AEDs,25 using neuropsychological tests to assess psychomotor function
Transient cognitive impairment is reported during generalized and cognitive processing, found significant improvements on only one
spike-wave bursts for more than 3 sec, and also with focal EEG test, psychomotor speed. The impact of AED treatment on higher-order
discharges.9 Left-sided focal spiking is more likely to be associated cognitive function may be limited and less significant than generally
with errors on verbal tasks, whereas right-sided discharges are determined. Impairments persist after drug withdrawal, indicating that the
accompanied by impairment in nonverbal function. These researchers cognitive impairment attributed to AEDs may be explained partly by the
concluded that transient cognitive impairment related to subclinical effects of persisting seizures, especially absence seizures. A decade
interictal EEG discharges contribute to learning disabilities in children later, these investigators concluded that transient cognitive impairment
with epilepsy. Suppression of discharges by AED therapy may improve attributed to interictal epileptiform discharges may sometimes be caused
psychological function. Some investigators hypothesize that interictal by short non-convulsive partial seizures or post-ictal effects. Existing
spikes, particularly if frequent and widespread, can impair cognitive epidemiological data show that the prevalence of cognitive impairment
abilities by interfering with waking learning and memory and memory during epileptiform EEG discharges is low; only 2.2% of patients referred
consolidation during sleep.20 The association between interictal to a special epilepsy center had episodes of cognitive impairment that
epileptiform discharges and transient cognitive impairment and reports correlated with the EEG discharges.26
of improved cognition following AED treatment require further Epileptiform EEG discharges in children with epilepsy and psycho-
investigation and confirmation by controlled study.19,21 social-educational problems, and assessed by 24-hour periods of am-
In contrast to the potential negative effects of methylphenidate in bulatory monitoring, were reduced by AED therapy when compared to
patients with ADHD and an abnormal EEG, one study using quan- placebo.27 Psychosocial function improved in 8 out of 10 children, and

182
Downloaded from eeg.sagepub.com at UMKC University Libraries on May 25, 2014
CLINICAL EEG and NEUROSCIENCE ©2011 VOL. 42 NO. 3

no cognitive deterioration attributable to the medication was detected. opinion based on a prevalence of 6.1% of patients with epileptiform
The investigators conclude that subclinical EEG discharges that impair discharges, and 15% having developed clinical seizures, concludes
psychosocial function can be suppressed by AED treatment. that the risk of seizures is small, and the clinical utility of the EEG
In a study of the effects of valproic acid in 6 children with EEG dis- limited.7 However, the significance of this study is also limited by the
charges and transient cognitive impairment, suppression of epileptiform use of only a routine awake EEG. A sleep-deprived, sleep EEG would
discharges improved cognitive performance in only 2. Short epileptiform be expected to show a significantly higher prevalence of epileptiform
subclinical discharges of 10 seconds or less in children with or without records and higher risk of seizures.2
epilepsy will impair reaction time, short term verbal and nonverbal CONCLUSIONS
memory, and school performance in reading, writing, and arithmetic. Fifty The prevalence of epileptiform discharges in the EEG of non-
percent of children with subclinical epileptiform discharges show tran- epileptic children with ADHD is at least 6-fold greater than in a healthy
sient cognitive impairment; those with predominantly left-sided dis- population without ADHD. Patients with episodic altered awareness,
charges are poor readers while those with right-sided discharges are frequent daydreaming or memory lapses should be considered for
poor in performance of visual spatial tasks. The phenomenon of transient EEG. If a tendency to seizures is suspected in a child with ADHD, a
cognitive impairment should be considered when evaluating results of sleep EEG with sleep deprivation is recommended. Guidelines for the
psychological tests and suspected AED-induced cognitive effects.28 EEG in ADHD should be modified to specify the indications and
SIGNIFICANCE OF EPILEPTIFORM AND preferred method of recording. The limited diagnostic value of routine
BACKGROUND ABNORMALITIES IN EEG OF ADHD awake EEG only in children with this disorder requires emphasis.
Apart from a potential increase in risk of seizures and need for The EEG may be of value in selection of medication for the treatment
caution in use of stimulants and some everyday activities such as swim- of ADHD, and the prediction of response and outcome.2 In addition to the
ming and sleep habits, epileptiform discharges and EEG background choice of stimulant (immediate- or extended-release) or non-stimulant
abnormalities influence outcome of ADHD, response to therapy, and treatment, EEG findings may lead to a trial of an AED in the absence of
cognition. A report of EEG abnormalities in children with minimal brain clinical seizures. Transient cognitive impairment complicating ADHD and
dysfunction, a former term for ADHD, suggests that EEG and/or neuro- correlated with electrographic seizure activity is sometimes an indication
logical abnormalities (“soft” or “subtle” signs) may predict a better for AED. A more frequent use of AEDs in selected patients with ADHD
response to methylphenidate than that in patients with normal EEG and requires proof of efficacy by controlled studies and the exclusion of ad-
no neurological soft signs.29 Also, both epileptiform discharges and EEG verse cognitive effects. The phenomenon of transient cognitive impair-
background abnormalities are linked to higher measures on cognitive ment may be important in the evaluation of AEDs and significance of
performance tests in hyperactive children,30 findings determined to be cognitive effects.
consistent with a neurobiological and maturational basis for ADHD. This review and analysis of the utility of the EEG in the management
A quantitative EEG study in ADHD that analyzed the relative power of ADHD was prompted by our recent report of the importance of sleep
in delta, theta, alpha, and beta bands found 3 distinct clusters with deprivation and ineffectiveness of a routine wake EEG in prediction of
differences in slow and fast activity in frontal, central, and posterior seizure susceptibility in these patients.2 In view of the frequency of
regions. The EEG frequency clusters correlated with clinical subtypes, epileptiform abnormalities demonstated in our study and that of others12
a finding suggestive of a heterogeneous disorder with different under- using sleep deprivation, trials of AEDs in ADHD children with epileptiform
lying electrophysiological abnormalities.31 In a further quantitative EEG discharges and transient cognitive impairment or memory lapses should
study of 100 patients with attention deficit disorder, background activ- receive further study. “Treat the patient’s seizures and not the EEG,” that
ities (frontal alpha or theta excess, or inter-hemispheric incoherence) often repeated doctrine or sometimes, admonition, may require modifi-
are correlated with response to stimulant or anticonvulsant treatment cation to include AED treatment of the epileptiform discharge.
and with clinical outcome.32 DISCLOSURE AND CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The risk of seizures correlating with an epileptiform EEG varies J. G. Millichap, J. J. Millichap and C. V. Stack have no conflicts of
with individual patients and their inherent susceptibility. One report and interest in relation to this article.

REFERENCES
1. American Academy of Pediatrics Clinical Practice Guidelines. Pediatrics 5. Hamoda HM, Guild DJ, Gumlak S, Travers BH, Gonzales-Heidrich J.
2001; 108(4): 1033-1044. Association between attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and epilepsy in
2. Millichap JJ, Stack CV, Millichap JG. Frequency of epileptiform discharges pediatric populations. Expert Rev Neurother 2009; 9(12): 1747-1754.
in the sleep-deprived electroencephalogram in children evaluated for 6. Hemmer SA, Pasternak JF, Zecker SG, Trommer BL. Stimulant therapy and
attention-deficit disorders. J Child Neurol 2010. Epub: jcn.sagpub.com/ seizure risk in children with ADHD. Pediatr Neurol 2001; 24(2): 99-102.
content/early/2010/08/17/0883073810371228. 7. Richer LP, Shevell MI, Rosenblatt BR. Epileptiform abnormalities in chil-
3. Physicians’ Desk Reference. 55th ed. Montvale, NJ: Thomson PDR; 2001. dren with attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder. Pediatr Neurol 2002;
4. Gross-Tsur V, Manor G, van der Meere J, et al. Epilepsy and attention 26(2): 125-129.
deficit hyperactivity disorder: is methylphenidate safe and effective? J 8. Tan M, Appleton R. Attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder, methyl-
Pediatr 1997; 130(4): 670-674. phenidate, and epilepsy. Arch Dis Child. 2005; 90(1): 57-59.

183
Downloaded from eeg.sagepub.com at UMKC University Libraries on May 25, 2014
CLINICAL EEG and NEUROSCIENCE ©2011 VOL. 42 NO. 3

9. Binnie CD, Channon S, Marston D. Learning disabilities in epilep- 21. So EL. Interictal epileptiform discharges in persons without a history of
sy:neuropsychological aspects. Epilepsia 1990; 31 (suppl 4): S2-S8. seizures: what do they mean? J Clin Neurophysiol 2010; 27(4): 229-238.
10. Laporte N, Sebire G, Gillerot Y, Guerrini R, Ghariani S. Pediatr Neurol 22. Swartwood MO, Swartwood JN, Lubar JF, et al. Methylphenidate effects
2002; 27(4): 307-311. on EEG, behavior, and performance in boys with ADHD. Pediatr Neurol
1998; 18(3): 244-250.
11. Kaufmann R, Goldberg-Stern H, Shuper A. Attention-deficit disorders and
epilepsy in childhood: incidence, causative relations and treatment possi- 23. Nordli DR Jr. The management of epilepsy in children: cognitive and
bilities. J Child Neurol 2009; 24(6): 727-733. behavioral side effects. Rev Neurol Dis 2004; 1 (suppl 1): S4-9.
12. Hughes JR, DeLeo AJ, Melyn MA. The electroencephalogram in attention 24. Loring DW, Meador KJ. Cognitive side effects of antiepileptic drugs in
deficit-hyperactivity disorder: emphasis on epileptiform discharges. children. Neurology 2004; 62(6): 872-877.
Epilepsy Behav 2000; 1(4): 271-277. 25. Aldenkamp AP, Alpherts WC, Blennow G, et al. Withdrawal of antiepileptic
13. Gucuyener K, Erdemoglu AK, Senol S, Serdaroglu A. Soysal S, Kockar AI. medications in children – effects on cognitive function: the multicenter
Use of methylphenidate for attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder in Holmfrid study. Neurology 1993; 43(1): 41-50.
patients with epilepsy or electroencephalographic abnormalities. J Child 26. Aldenkamp AP, Arends J. Effects of epileptiform EEG discharges on
Neurol 2003; 18(2): 109-112. cognitive function: is the concept of “transient cognitive impairment” still
valid? Epilepsy Behav 2004; 5 (suppl 1): S25-34.
14. Gara L, Roberts W. Adverse response to methylphenidate in combination
with valproic acid. J Child Adolesc Psychopharmacol 2000; 10(1): 39-43. 27. Marston D, Besag F, Binnie CD, Fowler M. Effects of transitory cognitive
impairment on psychosocial functioning of children with epilepsy: a
15. Ickowicz A. Buproprion-methylphenidate combination and grand mal
therapeutic trial. Dev Med Child Neurol 1993; 35(7): 574-581.
seizures. Can J Psychiatry 2002; 47(8): 790-791.
28. Kasteleijn-Noist Trenite DG. Transient cognitive impairment during
16. Feldman H, Crumrine P, Handen BL, Alvin R, Teodori J. Methylphenidate subclinical epileptiform electroencephalographic discharges. Semin
in children with seizures and attention-deficit disorder. Am J Dis Child Pediatr Neurol 1995; 2(4): 246-253.
1989; 143(9): 1081-1086.
29. Satterfield JH, Lesser LI, Saul RE, Cantwell DP. EEG aspects in the
17. Gonzalez-Heydrich J, Whitney J, Waber D, et al. Adaptive phase I study of diagnosis and treatment of minimal brain dysfunction. Ann NY Acad Sci
OROS methylphenidate in attention deficit hyperactivity disorder with 1973; 205: 274-282.
epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav 2010; 18(3): 229-237.
30. Satterfield JH, Cantwell DP, Saul RE, Yusin A. Intelligence, academic
18. Deonna T, Zesiger P, Davidoff V, et al. Benign partial epilepsy of childhood: achievement, and EEG abnormalities in hyperactive children. Am J
a longitudinal neuropsychological and EEG study of cognitive function. Psychiatry 1974; 131: 391-395.
Dev Med Child Neurol 2000; 42(9): 595-603.
31. Clarke AR, Barry RJ, McCarthy R, Selikowitz M. EEG-defined subtypes of
19. Mintz M, Legoff D, Scornaienchi J, et al. The underrecognized epilepsy children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Clin Neurophysiol
spectrum: the effects of levetiracetam on neuropsychological functioning in 2001; 112(11): 2098-2105.
relation to subclinical spike production. J Child Neurol 2009; 24(7): 807-815. 32. Suffin SC, Emory WH. Neurometric subgroups in attentional and affective
20. Holmes GL, Lenck-Santini PP. Role of interictal epileptiform abnormalities disorders and their association with pharmacotherapeutic outcome. Clin
in cognitive impairment. Epilepsy Behav 2006; 8(3): 504-515. EEG Neurosci 1995; 25(2): 76-83.

184
Downloaded from eeg.sagepub.com at UMKC University Libraries on May 25, 2014

Вам также может понравиться