Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
This datasheet contains all the calculations and the design procedures for the three
models, in addition to the problems we encountered in both designing and constructing
these models. Solutions of those problems are also discussed in this paper.
1- Draw the model on excel, and allocate specific cells for variables such as “height, panel
width,..”
2- Solve the model manually (by hand) on external papers using joint or sectioning
method.
3- Inserting functions obtained from step no.2 into excel sheet to solve the truss.
Now that the truss can be solved at any changing variables in a blink of an eye, we move to
the next step which goes like this:-
1- Solving the truss at different heights for each member in a tabulated form.
2- Calculating the required area (A= Force/Allowable Stress) for each member in step no.1.
5- Now we have area and length, we can easily get the weight of each member by
multiplying the volume by the density, and therefore getting the weight of a single face
truss (weight should be doubled, in addition to other bracings)
6- Finding out the economic height that gives the minimum weight.
We have completed the design and construction of three models:
Initial Tests
Tensile test:
Results:
-37.04 Kg
2
h=9 cm
59.26 Kg
-50 Kg -12.96 Kg
20 Kg
1 36.8699 40 Kg 3 40 Kg 5
6 cm 6 cm
P=20 Kg P=20 Kg
30 Kg
Figure1 showing dimensions and loads applied on the truss before taking buckling in calculations.
Analysis in 2-D plane of all the members:
Volume (mm3)
h (cm)/Member M 1-2 M 1-3 M 3-5 M 2-3 M2-4 M 2-5 M 5-4
5 4160 2160 2160 400 3185 1040 2450
6 3287.02 1500 1500 480 2414.953 1073.313 2160
7 3403.649 1500 1500 560 2500.64 1111.396 2520
8 2595.997 1500 1500 640 2595.997 1153.776 2880
9 2700 960 960 720 1875 1200 2250
10 2811.69 960 960 800 1952.562 1249.64 2500
11 2930.188 960 960 880 2034.853 1302.306 2750
12 3054.701 960 960 960 2121.32 1357.645 3000
13 3184.525 960 960 1040 2211.476 1415.344 2080
14 3319.036 960 960 1120 2304.886 1475.127 2240
15 2401.172 960 960 1200 2401.172 1536.75 2400
16 2500 960 960 1280 2500 1600 2560
17 2601.082 960 960 1360 2601.082 1664.692 2720
18 2704.163 960 960 1440 2704.163 1730.665 2880
19 2809.026 960 960 1520 2809.026 1797.776 3040
20 2915.476 960 960 1600 2915.476 1865.905 3200
21 3023.347 960 960 1680 3023.347 1934.942 3360
22 3132.491 960 960 1760 3132.491 2004.794 3520
23 3242.78 960 960 1840 2075.379 2075.379 3680
24 3354.102 960 960 1920 2146.625 2146.625 3840
25 3466.356 960 960 2000 2218.468 2218.468 4000
Weight (g)
h (cm)/Member M 1-2 M 1-3 M 3-5 M 2-3 M2-4 M 2-5 M 5-4 Total Weight
5 0.762665 0.3959993 0.395999 0.073333 0.583916 0.190666 0.449166 5.25432378
6 0.602619 0.2749995 0.275 0.088 0.442741 0.196774 0.395999 4.156263966
7 0.624001 0.2749995 0.275 0.102666 0.45845 0.203755 0.461999 4.339742988
8 0.475932 0.2749995 0.275 0.117333 0.475932 0.211525 0.527999 4.189441473
9 0.494999 0.1759997 0.176 0.132 0.343749 0.22 0.412499 3.49799364
10 0.515476 0.1759997 0.176 0.146666 0.357969 0.2291 0.458333 3.660753836
11 0.5372 0.1759997 0.176 0.161333 0.373056 0.238756 0.504166 3.828853213
12 0.560028 0.1759997 0.176 0.176 0.388908 0.248901 0.549999 4.001670499
13 0.583829 0.1759997 0.176 0.190666 0.405436 0.259479 0.381333 3.964152741
14 0.608489 0.1759997 0.176 0.205333 0.422562 0.270439 0.410666 4.128310546
15 0.440214 0.1759997 0.176 0.22 0.440214 0.281737 0.439999 3.908326992
16 0.458333 0.1759997 0.176 0.234666 0.458333 0.293333 0.469332 4.06265928
17 0.476864 0.1759997 0.176 0.249333 0.476864 0.305193 0.498666 4.21917256
18 0.495762 0.1759997 0.176 0.264 0.495762 0.317288 0.527999 4.377622267
19 0.514987 0.1759997 0.176 0.278666 0.514987 0.329592 0.557332 4.537795228
20 0.534503 0.1759997 0.176 0.293333 0.534503 0.342082 0.586666 4.699505506
21 0.554279 0.1759997 0.176 0.307999 0.554279 0.354739 0.615999 4.862590722
22 0.574289 0.1759997 0.176 0.322666 0.574289 0.367545 0.645332 5.026908836
23 0.594509 0.1759997 0.176 0.337333 0.380486 0.380486 0.674665 4.764289121
24 0.614918 0.1759997 0.176 0.351999 0.393547 0.393547 0.703999 4.916020306
25 0.635497 0.1759997 0.176 0.366666 0.406718 0.406718 0.733332 5.068531198
Weight vs Height
3
W
2
0
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Economic Height= 9 cm
Minimum Weight= 3.497994 g
Euler’s formula of buckling was used to determine the critical load at which buckling of a
compressed member begins.
This means that the bridge capacity should not exceed 10 kg to avoid buckling. In this
model we decided to decrease the height of the truss to 8 cm, hoping that buckling would
be less effective. Anyway, this led us to another sections and another economic height.
Economic Height= 5 cm
Minimum Weight= 2.141329 g
Members M 1-2 M 1-3 M 3-5 M 2-3 M2-4 M 2-5 M 5-4
Sections 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
Height could be less but it was taken 8 cm for the ease of construction, and the sections
remained the same. Lengths of members were taken from drafts (clear Length= Length
from C.L to C.L – 25 mm).
To hold this 10 kg load, floor beams should be sufficiently strong to endure the bending
moment applied by the load. 1.67 kg Sec 1-1 1.67 kg
Section 1-1:
f= M x Y / I
B.M.D
5 kg.cm
f2=1.171875 kgf/mm2
Conclusion: f1 < allowable compressive strength, f2 < allowable tensile strength. (SAFE)
Due to the small height, we had to test the model somehow to reassure ourselves that the
model complies with the calculations. So we brought water bottles (600ml= 600gm) and
started filling a plastic bag hanged on the floor beams. We crammed nearly 8 kilograms of
water bottles into the plastic bag and amazingly the truss didn’t show excessive
deformation or any signs of cracking. Unfortunately the bag couldn’t take more bottles
and we stopped the test. Sadly the model broke next day by accident so we didn’t achieve
the desired results.
MODEL 2: PRATT TRUSS
The next step was to design a new model that complies with the competition conditions,
so it seemed reasonable to choose the Pratt truss as the lengths of members don’t change
along the panels (and symmetric) which would save us time and effort. Diagonals were
inclined to form tangents with the B.M.D to avoid buckling from compression. Height of
the truss was taken 13 cm to allow entrance of the testing block.
2 4 6 8 10
h= 13 cm
61.7 Deg
1 7cm 7cm 7cm 7cm 7cm
3 5 7 9 11
R= 21kg
member m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7
Axial Force (kg) -23.8509 11.30769 0 -22.6154 23.850868 11.30769 -21 -33.9231 23.85087
member m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
Axial Force (kg) 22.61538 -21 -45.23077 23.85087 33.923077 -7 -41.4615 7.950289 45.23077 0
Axial Forces
height / cm m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
5 -36.1298 29.4 0 -58.8 36.12977 29.4 -21 -88.2 36.12977 58.8 -21 -117.6 36.12977 88.2 -7 -107.8 12.04326 117.6 0
6 -32.2684 24.5 0 -49 32.26841 24.5 -21 -73.5 32.26841 49 -21 -98 32.26841 73.5 -7 -89.8333 10.75614 98 0
7 -29.6985 21 0 -42 29.69848 21 -21 -63 29.69848 42 -21 -84 29.69848 63 -7 -77 9.899495 84 0
8 -27.9041 18.375 0 -36.75 27.90413 18.375 -21 -55.125 27.90413 36.75 -21 -73.5 27.90413 55.125 -7 -67.375 9.301378 73.5 0
9 -26.6041 16.33333 0 -32.66667 26.60409 16.333333 -21 -49 26.60409 32.66667 -21 -65.3333 26.60409 49 -7 -59.8889 8.868031 65.33333 0
10 -25.6338 14.7 0 -29.4 25.63377 14.7 -21 -44.1 25.63377 29.4 -21 -58.8 25.63377 44.1 -7 -53.9 8.544589 58.8 0
11 -24.8915 13.36364 0 -26.72727 24.8915 13.363636 -21 -40.0909 24.8915 26.72727 -21 -53.4545 24.8915 40.09091 -7 -49 8.297167 53.45455 0
12 -24.3118 12.25 0 -24.5 24.31178 12.25 -21 -36.75 24.31178 24.5 -21 -49 24.31178 36.75 -7 -44.9167 8.103926 49 0
13 -23.8509 11.30769 0 -22.61538 23.85087 11.307692 -21 -33.9231 23.85087 22.61538 -21 -45.2308 23.85087 33.92308 -7 -41.4615 7.950289 45.23077 0
14 -23.4787 10.5 0 -21 23.47871 10.5 -21 -31.5 23.47871 21 -21 -42 23.47871 31.5 -7 -38.5 7.826238 42 0
15 -23.1741 9.8 0 -19.6 23.17412 9.8 -21 -29.4 23.17412 19.6 -21 -39.2 23.17412 29.4 -7 -35.9333 7.724708 39.2 0
16 -22.9218 9.1875 0 -18.375 22.92183 9.1875 -21 -27.5625 22.92183 18.375 -21 -36.75 22.92183 27.5625 -7 -33.6875 7.640609 36.75 0
17 -22.7106 8.647059 0 -17.29412 22.71061 8.6470588 -21 -25.9412 22.71061 17.29412 -21 -34.5882 22.71061 25.94118 -7 -31.7059 7.570202 34.58824 0
18 -22.5321 8.166667 0 -16.33333 22.53208 8.1666667 -21 -24.5 22.53208 16.33333 -21 -32.6667 22.53208 24.5 -7 -29.9444 7.510692 32.66667 0
19 -22.3799 7.736842 0 -15.47368 22.37987 7.7368421 -21 -23.2105 22.37987 15.47368 -21 -30.9474 22.37987 23.21053 -7 -28.3684 7.459958 30.94737 0
20 -22.2491 7.35 0 -14.7 22.2491 7.35 -21 -22.05 22.2491 14.7 -21 -29.4 22.2491 22.05 -7 -26.95 7.416367 29.4 0
21 -22.1359 7 0 -14 22.13594 7 -21 -21 22.13594 14 -21 -28 22.13594 21 -7 -25.6667 7.378648 28 0
22 -22.0374 6.681818 0 -13.36364 22.03739 6.6818182 -21 -20.0455 22.03739 13.36364 -21 -26.7273 22.03739 20.04545 -7 -24.5 7.345798 26.72727 0
23 -21.9511 6.391304 0 -12.78261 21.95105 6.3913043 -21 -19.1739 21.95105 12.78261 -21 -25.5652 21.95105 19.17391 -7 -23.4348 7.317018 25.56522 0
24 -21.875 6.125 0 -12.25 21.875 6.125 -21 -18.375 21.875 12.25 -21 -24.5 21.875 18.375 -7 -22.4583 7.291667 24.5 0
25 -21.8077 5.88 0 -11.76 21.80767 5.88 -21 -17.64 21.80767 11.76 -21 -23.52 21.80767 17.64 -7 -21.56 7.269223 23.52 0
26 -21.7478 5.653846 0 -11.30769 21.74778 5.6538462 -21 -16.9615 21.74778 11.30769 -21 -22.6154 21.74778 16.96154 -7 -20.7308 7.24926 22.61538 0
27 -21.6943 5.444444 0 -10.88889 21.69428 5.4444444 -21 -16.3333 21.69428 10.88889 -21 -21.7778 21.69428 16.33333 -7 -19.963 7.231428 21.77778 0
28 -21.6463 5.25 0 -10.5 21.6463 5.25 -21 -15.75 21.6463 10.5 -21 -21 21.6463 15.75 -7 -19.25 7.215435 21 0
29 -21.6031 5.068966 0 -10.13793 21.60311 5.0689655 -21 -15.2069 21.60311 10.13793 -21 -20.2759 21.60311 15.2069 -7 -18.5862 7.201037 20.27586 0
30 -21.5641 4.9 0 -9.8 21.56409 4.9 -21 -14.7 21.56409 9.8 -21 -19.6 21.56409 14.7 -7 -17.9667 7.18803 19.6 0
Area Required (mm2)
height / cm m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
5 23.0288 11.36837 0 37.478618 13.97063 11.36837 13.38522 56.21793 13.97063 22.73674 13.38522059 74.95724 13.97063 34.10511 4.46174 68.7108 4.656877 45.47348 0
6 20.56761 9.473642 0 31.232181 12.47752 9.4736418 13.38522 46.84827 12.47752 18.94728 13.38522059 62.46436 12.47752 28.42093 4.46174 57.259 4.159174 37.89457 0
7 18.92956 8.120264 0 26.770441 11.48379 8.1202644 13.38522 40.15566 11.48379 16.24053 13.38522059 53.54088 11.48379 24.36079 4.46174 49.07914 3.827929 32.48106 0
8 17.78586 7.105231 0 23.424136 10.78995 7.1052314 13.38522 35.1362 10.78995 14.21046 13.38522059 46.84827 10.78995 21.31569 4.46174 42.94425 3.59665 28.42093 0
9 16.95722 6.315761 0 20.821454 10.28725 6.3157612 13.38522 31.23218 10.28725 12.63152 13.38522059 41.64291 10.28725 18.94728 4.46174 38.17267 3.429084 25.26304 0
10 16.33874 5.684185 0 18.739309 9.912046 5.6841851 13.38522 28.10896 9.912046 11.36837 13.38522059 37.47862 9.912046 17.05256 4.46174 34.3554 3.304015 22.73674 0
11 15.86563 5.167441 0 17.035735 9.625027 5.167441 13.38522 25.5536 9.625027 10.33488 13.38522059 34.07147 9.625027 15.50232 4.46174 31.23218 3.208342 20.66976 0
12 15.49612 4.736821 0 15.616091 9.40086 4.7368209 13.38522 23.42414 9.40086 9.473642 13.38522059 31.23218 9.40086 14.21046 4.46174 28.6295 3.13362 18.94728 0
13 15.20234 4.37245 0 14.414853 9.222636 4.3724501 13.38522 21.62228 9.222636 8.7449 13.38522059 28.82971 9.222636 13.11735 4.46174 26.42723 3.074212 17.4898 0
14 14.96513 4.060132 0 13.385221 9.078732 4.0601322 13.38522 20.07783 9.078732 8.120264 13.38522059 26.77044 9.078732 12.1804 4.46174 24.53957 3.026244 16.24053 0
15 14.77099 3.789457 0 12.492873 8.960953 3.7894567 13.38522 18.73931 8.960953 7.578913 13.38522059 24.98575 8.960953 11.36837 4.46174 22.9036 2.986984 15.15783 0
16 14.61018 3.552616 0 11.712068 8.863395 3.5526157 13.38522 17.5681 8.863395 7.105231 13.38522059 23.42414 8.863395 10.65785 4.46174 21.47212 2.954465 14.21046 0
17 14.47555 3.343638 0 11.023123 8.78172 3.3436383 13.38522 16.53468 8.78172 6.687277 13.38522059 22.04625 8.78172 10.03091 4.46174 20.20906 2.92724 13.37455 0
18 14.36175 3.157881 0 10.410727 8.712686 3.1578806 13.38522 15.61609 8.712686 6.315761 13.38522059 20.82145 8.712686 9.473642 4.46174 19.08633 2.904229 12.63152 0
19 14.26474 2.991676 0 9.8627941 8.653833 2.9916764 13.38522 14.79419 8.653833 5.983353 13.38522059 19.72559 8.653833 8.975029 4.46174 18.08179 2.884611 11.96671 0
20 14.18139 2.842093 0 9.3696544 8.603266 2.8420925 13.38522 14.05448 8.603266 5.684185 13.38522059 18.73931 8.603266 8.526278 4.46174 17.1777 2.867755 11.36837 0
21 14.10926 2.706755 0 8.9234804 8.55951 2.7067548 13.38522 13.38522 8.55951 5.41351 13.38522059 17.84696 8.55951 8.120264 4.46174 16.35971 2.85317 10.82702 0
22 14.04645 2.58372 0 8.5178676 8.521403 2.5837205 13.38522 12.7768 8.521403 5.167441 13.38522059 17.03574 8.521403 7.751161 4.46174 15.61609 2.840468 10.33488 0
23 13.99141 2.471385 0 8.1475256 8.488017 2.4713848 13.38522 12.22129 8.488017 4.94277 13.38522059 16.29505 8.488017 7.414154 4.46174 14.93713 2.829339 9.885539 0
24 13.94294 2.36841 0 7.8080453 8.458609 2.3684105 13.38522 11.71207 8.458609 4.736821 13.38522059 15.61609 8.458609 7.105231 4.46174 14.31475 2.819536 9.473642 0
25 13.90002 2.273674 0 7.4957235 8.432573 2.273674 13.38522 11.24359 8.432573 4.547348 13.38522059 14.99145 8.432573 6.821022 4.46174 13.74216 2.810858 9.094696 0
26 13.86185 2.186225 0 7.2074265 8.409416 2.186225 13.38522 10.81114 8.409416 4.37245 13.38522059 14.41485 8.409416 6.558675 4.46174 13.21362 2.803139 8.7449 0
27 13.82775 2.105254 0 6.9404848 8.38873 2.1052537 13.38522 10.41073 8.38873 4.210507 13.38522059 13.88097 8.38873 6.315761 4.46174 12.72422 2.796243 8.421015 0
28 13.79717 2.030066 0 6.6926103 8.370177 2.0300661 13.38522 10.03892 8.370177 4.060132 13.38522059 13.38522 8.370177 6.090198 4.46174 12.26979 2.790059 8.120264 0
29 13.76964 1.960064 0 6.4618306 8.353475 1.9600638 13.38522 9.692746 8.353475 3.920128 13.38522059 12.92366 8.353475 5.880191 4.46174 11.84669 2.784492 7.840255 0
30 13.74477 1.894728 0 6.2464363 8.338387 1.8947284 13.38522 9.369654 8.338387 3.789457 13.38522059 12.49287 8.338387 5.684185 4.46174 11.4518 2.779462 7.578913 0
Section needed (mm2)
height / cm m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
5 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 8x 8 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 9x 9 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 9x 9 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4
6 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 8x 8 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 8x 8 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4
7 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 8x 8 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 8x 8 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4
8 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4
9 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4
10 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 7x 7 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4
11 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4
12 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4
13 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4
14 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4
15 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
16 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
17 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
18 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
19 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
20 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
21 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
22 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
23 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
24 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
25 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
26 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
27 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
28 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
29 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
30 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4
Actual Area (mm2)
height / cm m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
5 25 16 16 49 16 16 16 64 16 25 16 81 16 36 16 81 16 49 16
6 25 16 16 36 16 16 16 49 16 25 16 64 16 36 16 64 16 49 16
7 25 16 16 36 16 16 16 49 16 25 16 64 16 25 16 64 16 36 16
8 25 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 49 16 25 16 49 16 36 16
9 25 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 49 16 25 16 49 16 36 16
10 25 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 49 16 25 16 36 16 25 16
11 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 36 16 25 16
12 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 36 16 25 16
13 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 36 16 25 16
14 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 36 16 16 16 25 16 25 16
15 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
17 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
18 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
19 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
20 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
21 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 25 16 16 16
22 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
23 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 25 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
24 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
25 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
26 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
27 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
28 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
29 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
30 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16
length (mm2)
height / cm m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
5 86.02325 70 50 70 86.02325 70 50 70 86.02325 70 50 70 73.48469 70 50 70 86.02325 70 50
6 92.19544 70 60 70 92.19544 70 60 70 92.19544 70 60 70 74.16198 70 60 70 92.19544 70 60
7 98.99495 70 70 70 98.99495 70 70 70 98.99495 70 70 70 74.83315 70 70 70 98.99495 70 70
8 106.3015 70 80 70 106.3015 70 80 70 106.3015 70 80 70 75.49834 70 80 70 106.3015 70 80
9 114.0175 70 90 70 114.0175 70 90 70 114.0175 70 90 70 76.15773 70 90 70 114.0175 70 90
10 122.0656 70 100 70 122.0656 70 100 70 122.0656 70 100 70 76.81146 70 100 70 122.0656 70 100
11 130.384 70 110 70 130.384 70 110 70 130.384 70 110 70 77.45967 70 110 70 130.384 70 110
12 138.9244 70 120 70 138.9244 70 120 70 138.9244 70 120 70 78.1025 70 120 70 138.9244 70 120
13 147.6482 70 130 70 147.6482 70 130 70 147.6482 70 130 70 78.74008 70 130 70 147.6482 70 130
14 156.5248 70 140 70 156.5248 70 140 70 156.5248 70 140 70 79.37254 70 140 70 156.5248 70 140
15 165.5295 70 150 70 165.5295 70 150 70 165.5295 70 150 70 80 70 150 70 165.5295 70 150
16 174.6425 70 160 70 174.6425 70 160 70 174.6425 70 160 70 80.62258 70 160 70 174.6425 70 160
17 183.8478 70 170 70 183.8478 70 170 70 183.8478 70 170 70 81.24038 70 170 70 183.8478 70 170
18 193.1321 70 180 70 193.1321 70 180 70 193.1321 70 180 70 81.85353 70 180 70 193.1321 70 180
19 202.4846 70 190 70 202.4846 70 190 70 202.4846 70 190 70 82.46211 70 190 70 202.4846 70 190
20 211.8962 70 200 70 211.8962 70 200 70 211.8962 70 200 70 83.06624 70 200 70 211.8962 70 200
21 221.3594 70 210 70 221.3594 70 210 70 221.3594 70 210 70 83.666 70 210 70 221.3594 70 210
22 230.8679 70 220 70 230.8679 70 220 70 230.8679 70 220 70 84.2615 70 220 70 230.8679 70 220
23 240.4163 70 230 70 240.4163 70 230 70 240.4163 70 230 70 84.85281 70 230 70 240.4163 70 230
24 250 70 240 70 250 70 240 70 250 70 240 70 85.44004 70 240 70 250 70 240
25 259.6151 70 250 70 259.6151 70 250 70 259.6151 70 250 70 86.02325 70 250 70 259.6151 70 250
26 269.2582 70 260 70 269.2582 70 260 70 269.2582 70 260 70 86.60254 70 260 70 269.2582 70 260
27 278.9265 70 270 70 278.9265 70 270 70 278.9265 70 270 70 87.17798 70 270 70 278.9265 70 270
28 288.6174 70 280 70 288.6174 70 280 70 288.6174 70 280 70 87.74964 70 280 70 288.6174 70 280
29 298.3287 70 290 70 298.3287 70 290 70 298.3287 70 290 70 88.31761 70 290 70 298.3287 70 290
30 308.0584 70 300 70 308.0584 70 300 70 308.0584 70 300 70 88.88194 70 300 70 308.0584 70 300
Weight (g)
height / cm m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10 Total Weight
5 0.394272525 0.205333 0.146666 0.6288322 0.252334 0.205333 0.146666 0.821332 0.252334 0.320833 0.1466664 1.039498 0.215555 0.461999 0.146666 1.039498 0.252334 0.628832 0.146666 14.75663909
6 0.422561686 0.205333 0.176 0.4619992 0.270439 0.205333 0.176 0.628832 0.270439 0.320833 0.17599968 0.821332 0.217541 0.461999 0.176 0.821332 0.270439 0.628832 0.176 13.59849032
7 0.453726026 0.205333 0.205333 0.4619992 0.290385 0.205333 0.205333 0.628832 0.290385 0.320833 0.20533296 0.821332 0.21951 0.320833 0.205333 0.821332 0.290385 0.461999 0.205333 13.43242819
8 0.487214131 0.205333 0.234666 0.3208328 0.311817 0.205333 0.234666 0.461999 0.311817 0.205333 0.23466624 0.628832 0.221461 0.320833 0.234666 0.628832 0.311817 0.461999 0.234666 12.27890366
9 0.522579453 0.205333 0.264 0.3208328 0.334451 0.205333 0.264 0.461999 0.334451 0.205333 0.26399952 0.628832 0.223396 0.320833 0.264 0.628832 0.334451 0.461999 0.264 12.75330506
10 0.559466115 0.205333 0.293333 0.3208328 0.358058 0.205333 0.293333 0.461999 0.358058 0.205333 0.2933328 0.628832 0.225313 0.320833 0.293333 0.461999 0.358058 0.320833 0.293333 12.62055899
11 0.382459179 0.205333 0.322666 0.3208328 0.382459 0.205333 0.322666 0.461999 0.382459 0.205333 0.32266608 0.461999 0.227215 0.205333 0.322666 0.461999 0.382459 0.320833 0.322666 12.11608701
12 0.407510949 0.205333 0.351999 0.205333 0.407511 0.205333 0.351999 0.320833 0.407511 0.205333 0.35199936 0.461999 0.2291 0.205333 0.351999 0.461999 0.407511 0.320833 0.351999 12.07093956
13 0.433100689 0.205333 0.381333 0.205333 0.433101 0.205333 0.381333 0.320833 0.433101 0.205333 0.38133264 0.461999 0.23097 0.205333 0.381333 0.461999 0.433101 0.320833 0.381333 12.54339747
14 0.459138457 0.205333 0.410666 0.205333 0.459138 0.205333 0.410666 0.320833 0.459138 0.205333 0.41066592 0.461999 0.232826 0.205333 0.410666 0.320833 0.459138 0.320833 0.410666 12.73707674
15 0.485552181 0.205333 0.439999 0.205333 0.485552 0.205333 0.439999 0.320833 0.485552 0.205333 0.4399992 0.320833 0.234666 0.205333 0.439999 0.320833 0.485552 0.205333 0.439999 12.70273475
16 0.512283712 0.205333 0.469332 0.205333 0.512284 0.205333 0.469332 0.320833 0.512284 0.205333 0.46933248 0.320833 0.236492 0.205333 0.469332 0.320833 0.512284 0.205333 0.469332 13.18423896
17 0.539285791 0.205333 0.498666 0.205333 0.539286 0.205333 0.498666 0.320833 0.539286 0.205333 0.49866576 0.320833 0.238305 0.205333 0.498666 0.320833 0.539286 0.205333 0.498666 13.66787958
18 0.566519735 0.205333 0.527999 0.205333 0.56652 0.205333 0.527999 0.205333 0.56652 0.205333 0.52799904 0.320833 0.240103 0.205333 0.527999 0.320833 0.56652 0.205333 0.527999 13.92234817
19 0.593953651 0.205333 0.557332 0.205333 0.593954 0.205333 0.557332 0.205333 0.593954 0.205333 0.55733232 0.320833 0.241888 0.205333 0.557332 0.320833 0.593954 0.205333 0.557332 14.40938937
20 0.621561059 0.205333 0.586666 0.205333 0.621561 0.205333 0.586666 0.205333 0.621561 0.205333 0.5866656 0.320833 0.243661 0.205333 0.586666 0.320833 0.621561 0.205333 0.586666 14.89779236
21 0.649319832 0.205333 0.615999 0.205333 0.64932 0.205333 0.615999 0.205333 0.64932 0.205333 0.61599888 0.320833 0.24542 0.205333 0.615999 0.320833 0.64932 0.205333 0.615999 15.38738067
22 0.677211356 0.205333 0.645332 0.205333 0.677211 0.205333 0.645332 0.205333 0.677211 0.205333 0.64533216 0.320833 0.247167 0.205333 0.645332 0.205333 0.677211 0.205333 0.645332 15.64700637
23 0.705219881 0.205333 0.674665 0.205333 0.70522 0.205333 0.674665 0.205333 0.70522 0.205333 0.67466544 0.320833 0.248901 0.205333 0.674665 0.205333 0.70522 0.205333 0.674665 16.13854314
24 0.733332 0.205333 0.703999 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.703999 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.70399872 0.205333 0.250624 0.205333 0.703999 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.703999 16.39988507
25 0.761536241 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.761536 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.761536 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.252334 0.205333 0.733332 0.205333 0.761536 0.205333 0.733332 16.89294004
26 0.789822736 0.205333 0.762665 0.205333 0.789823 0.205333 0.762665 0.205333 0.789823 0.205333 0.76266528 0.205333 0.254034 0.205333 0.762665 0.205333 0.789823 0.205333 0.762665 17.38663
27 0.818182952 0.205333 0.791999 0.205333 0.818183 0.205333 0.791999 0.205333 0.818183 0.205333 0.79199856 0.205333 0.255722 0.205333 0.791999 0.205333 0.818183 0.205333 0.791999 17.88088715
28 0.846609483 0.205333 0.821332 0.205333 0.846609 0.205333 0.821332 0.205333 0.846609 0.205333 0.82133184 0.205333 0.257398 0.205333 0.821332 0.205333 0.846609 0.205333 0.821332 18.37565267
29 0.875095864 0.205333 0.850665 0.205333 0.875096 0.205333 0.850665 0.205333 0.875096 0.205333 0.85066512 0.205333 0.259065 0.205333 0.850665 0.205333 0.875096 0.205333 0.850665 18.8708753
30 0.903636436 0.205333 0.879998 0.205333 0.903636 0.205333 0.879998 0.205333 0.903636 0.205333 0.8799984 0.205333 0.26072 0.205333 0.879998 0.205333 0.903636 0.205333 0.879998 19.36651016
Min Weight 12.07093956 g
Economic Height 12 cm
m1-2 m1-3 m2-3 m2-4 m2-5 m3-5 m4-5 m4-6 m4-7 m5-7 m6-7 m6-8 m6-9 m7-9 m8-9 m8-10 m8-11 m9-11 m11-10
4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4
Member m1-2
Critical Load (kg) 15.12367
Member 4-5 was not modified and left as it is 4 x 4 which means that it can only carry an
axial compression of (1.074 kg) before buckling occurs. However the test was carried out
on the Pratt truss, and the truss failed at 16 kg, which means that member 4-5 was
carrying nearly (4 kg) compression. In other words, buckling didn’t affect the member. So
what caused the failure?
Failure Analysis:
Picture A
MODEL 3: ARCH TRUSS
The arch truss was challenging on the architectural aspect, but the design procedures
remain the same. Height of the truss was taken 30 cm to allow entrance of testing block
from the shortest panel.
8
6 θ4=12.094757 -34.3kg
-38.28kg
4 θ3=32.73523
-39.327kg 14.375kg
9.2kg
2 θ2=46.974934 4.5164kg
14.807kg h=30cm
-5.75kg h=28.125cm
h=22.5cm
-41.46kg 6.91064kg
0kg h=13.125cm
Actual Height 30 cm
Weight 16.6 gm
Member M1-2 M1-3 M 3-5 M 3-2 M 2-4 M 2-5 M 5-7 M 5-4 M 4-6 M 4-7 M 7-9 M 7-6 M 6-8 M 6-9 M 8-9
Sections 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 6x 6 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4 4x 4 5x 5 4x 4 4x 4
Element Price
4x4 8.5 L.E/m'
5x5 11 L.E/m'
6x6 12 L.E/m'
Plate 1m x 10cm 300LE/m2