You are on page 1of 8

(http://www.hmhco.

com)
Sign In (/account/Sign-In-Register?ReturnUrl=%2fstudy-guides%2fprinciples-of-
management%2fleadership-and-management%2fsituational-approaches-to-leadership)
 | 
Sign Up (/account/Sign-In-Register?ReturnUrl=%2fstudy-guides%2fprinciples-of-
management%2fleadership-and-management%2fsituational-approaches-to-leadership#signup)

(/)

Search CliffsNotes

Literature Notes (/literature)Test Prep (/test-prep)Study Guides (/study-guides)Student Life (/student-life)

 

Situational Approaches to Leadership


Home (/) » Study Guides (/Study-Guides)
» Principles Of Management (/Study-Guides/Principles-Of-Management)
» Situational Approaches To Leadership (/Study-Guides/Principles-Of-Management/Leadership-And-
Management/Situational-Approaches-To-Leadership)

Situational Approaches to Leadership

The Nature of Management


rs (/study-guides/principles-of-management/the- 
ent/functions-of-managers)  All

ment The Evolution


Management
Theory of Management Thought
(/study-guides/principles-of-
Myths (/study-guides/principles-of-
Subjec

olution-of-management-thought/behavioral-
ture-of-management/dispelling-common-
) Back to Top
Managerial Environments
ments (/study-guides/principles-of- 
of
erial-environments/adapting-to-environments)
ganizations
Management
(/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
olution-of-management-thought/quantitative-
ture-of-management/management-and-
ence DecisionMaking
nt) Decison Making(/study-guides/principles-of-
and Problem Solving 
n-making-and-problem-solving/conditions-that-
agerial Environments (/study-guides/principles-of-
of Management (/study-guides/principles-of-
aking)
erial-environments/introduction-to-managerial-
ans Organizational Planning
(/study-guides/principles-of-
olution-of-management-thought/contingency- 
zational-planning/detailing-types-of-plans)
nt)
aking Styles (/study-guides/principles-of-
n-making-and-problem-solving/personal-
ment (/study-guides/principles-of-
Creating
ongPlanning Organizational Structure
(/study-guides/principles-of-
nagement (/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of- 
s)
erial-environments/the-external-environment)
g-organizational-structure/concepts-of-
zational-planning/identifying-barriers-to-planning)
olution-of-management-thought/quality-
nt)
hmentQuantitative
(/study-guides/principles-of-
Tools (/study-guides/principles-of-
Organizational Design and Structure
/study-guides/principles-of-
tudy-guides/principles-of- 
erial-environments/the-internal-environment)
n-making-and-problem-solving/decision-making-
zational-planning/defining-planning)
zational-design-and-structure/bureaucracy-
zation (/study-guides/principles-of-
Future
ols)
g-organizational-structure/the-informal-
zational
antages Managing
ofChange
Planning Change
(/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of- 
g Process (/study-guides/principles-of-
ganizational
ng-change/challenges-of-organizational-
Design (/study-guides/principles-of-
zational-planning/recognizing-the-advantages-of-
n-making-and-problem-solving/the-
zational-design-and-structure/factors-affecting-
to Organizing (/study-guides/principles-of-
ess)
ws
n) andStaffing
Regulations and Human Resource Management
(/study-guides/principles-
g-organizational-structure/going-from-planning- 
fing-and-human-resource-management/hr-
ve for Change
Goals (/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
Organizational
nd-regulations)
ng-change/diagnosing-the-need-for-change)
Design (/study-guides/principles-of-
zational-planning/using-plans-to-achieve-goals)
ms Understanding
(/study-guides/principles-of- Teams
zational-design-and-structure/five-approaches-to-
rocess (/study-guides/principles-of- 
n)tanding-teams/effectiveness-of-teams)
Resource
nge (/study-guides/principles-of-
Needs (/study-guides/principles-of-
g-organizational-structure/the-organizational-
g-and-human-resource-
ng-change/steps-in-planned-change)
gnBehavior Motivating
y-guides/principles-of- and Rewarding Employees
(/study-guides/principles-of-
mining-human-resource-needs)
Defined (/study-guides/principles-of- 
izational
ting-and-rewarding-employees/motivation-
tanding-teams/team-building)
Changes (/study-guides/principles-of-
zational-design-and-structure/organizational-
rson
ng-change/opposition-to-organizational-
for the Job (/study-guides/principles-of-
aders Leadership
lopment and Management
(/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
g-and-human-resource-management/selecting- 
ophies
ship-and-management/challenges-facing-leaders)
tanding-teams/stages-of-team-development)
the-job) and Motivation (/study-
management/motivating-and-rewarding-
onal Change (/study-guides/principles-of-
flict
ning Communication
/study-guides/principles-of-
Process(/study-guides/principles-of- and Interpersonal Skills
(/study-guides/principles-of-
ment-philosophies-and-motivation)
ng-change/causes-of-organizational-change)
Programs (/study-guides/principles-of- 
unication-and-interpersonal-skills/the-
ship-and-management/leadership-defined)
tanding-teams/managing-team-conflict)
g-and-human-resource-
sess)
(/study-guides/principles-of-
tion-and-training-programs)
onales Control:
toControl
Leadership The
study-guides/principles-of-
Systems Linking Function
(/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-
ting-and-rewarding-employees/motivation- 
trol-the-linking-function/effective-
ship-and-management/situational-approaches-to-
tanding-teams/teamwork-defined)
ication
Performance (/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
unication-and-interpersonal-skills/methods-of-
ol-systems)
o TQMProductivity
dy-guides/principles-of- and Total Quality Management
(/study-guides/principles-of-
(/study-guides/principles-of- 
rol
tanding-teams/types-of-teams)
tivity-and-total-quality-management/major-
Techniques (/study-guides/principles-of-
ting-and-rewarding-employees/defining-
unication
-the-linking-function/organizational-control-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
vironment Management in a Global Environment
(/study-guides/principles-of-
unication-and-interpersonal- 
ement-in-a-global-environment/the-international-
of TQM
communication) (/study-guides/principles-of-
Individual Needs (/study-guides/principles-of-
rol
tivity-and-total-quality-management/the-
Objectives (/study-guides/principles-of-
munication
qm)-the-linking-function/organizational-control-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
Situational Approaches to Leadership
rnational Manager (/study-guides/principles-of-
unication-and-interpersonal-
ement-in-a-global-environment/functions-of-the-
ISO 9000 Certification (/study-
communication)
Control
er)
management/productivity-and-total-quality-
Process (/study-guides/principles-of-
cations
lass-quality-iso-9000-certification)
-the-linking-function/the-organizational-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
for GlobalTheManagerstheme in(/study-guides/principles-of-
early approaches to understanding leadership was the desire to identify traits or behaviors
ality that effective leaders had in common. A common set of characteristics proved to be elusive, however.
ement-in-a-global-environment/personal-
(/study-guides/principles-of-
nal
tivity-and-total-quality-
-managers)
Controls (/study-guides/principles-of-
Researchers were continually frustrated by the lack of consistent support for their findings and
tivity-and-quality)
orporation conclusions. As a result, research began to focus on what style of leadership was most effective in a
(/study-guides/principles-of-
ement
ement-in-a-global-environment/the-
(TQM) (/study-guides/principles-of-
particular situation. Contingency or situational theories examine the fit between the leader and the
ation)
situation and provide guidelines for managers to achieve this effective fit.
The theorists in this section believe that managers choose leadership styles based on leadership
situations. Managers adjust their decision‐making, orientation, and motivational approaches based
upon a unique combination of factors in their situations: characteristics of employees, types of work,
organizational structures, personal preferences, and upper‐level management's influences.
Back to Top

The following sections describe the three most well‐known situational theories.
Fiedler's contingency theory

Fred E. Fiedler's contingency theory


centers on the belief that there is no
best way for managers to lead.
Different situations create different
leadership style requirements for
managers. The style that works in one
environment may not work in another.

Fiedler looked at three elements that


dictate a leader's situational control.
These elements are:

Task structure. Is the job highly structured, fairly unstructured, or somewhere in between? The
spelling out in detail (favorable) of what is required of subordinates affects task structure.

Leader/member relations. This element applies to the amount of loyalty, dependability, and support
that a leader receives from his or her employees. In a favorable relationship, a manager has a highly
formed task structure and is able to reward and/or punish employees without any problems. In an
unfavorable relationship, the task structure is usually poorly formed, and the leader possesses limited
authority.

Positioning power. Positioning power measures the amount of power or authority a manager
perceives the organization has given him or her for the purpose of directing, rewarding, and punishing
subordinates. Positioning powers of managers depends on the taking away (favorable) or increasing
(unfavorable) of the decision‐making power of employees.

Fiedler then rated managers as to whether they were relationship oriented or task oriented. Task‐
oriented managers tended to do better in situations with good leader/member relationships, structured
tasks, and either weak or strong position power. They also did well when the tasks were unstructured
but position power was strong, as well as when the leader/member relations were moderate to poor and
the tasks were unstructured. Relationship‐oriented managers, on the other hand, do better in all other
situations.

The task‐motivated style leader experiences pride and satisfaction in task accomplishment for his or her
organization, while the relationship‐motivated style leader seeks to build interpersonal relations and
extend extra help for team development in his or her organization.

Back to Top
Judging whether a leadership style is good or bad can be difficult. Each manager has his or her own
preferences for leadership. Task‐motivated leaders are at their best when their teams perform
successfully—such as achieving new sales records or outperforming major competitors. Relationship‐
oriented leaders are at their best when greater customer satisfaction is gained and positive company
images are established.

Hersey-Blanchard's situational model

The Hersey‐Blanchard Model of Situational Leadership, shown in Figure , is based on the amount of
direction (task behavior) and amount of socioemotional support (relationship behavior) a leader must
provide given the situation and the level of maturity of the followers.

Task behavior is the extent to which the leader engages in spelling out the duties and responsibilities to
an individual or group. This behavior includes telling people what to do, how to do it, when to do it, and
where to do it. In task behavior, the leader engages in one‐way communication. Relationship behavior,
on the other hand, is the extent to which the leader engages in two‐way or multiway communications.
This behavior includes listening to, facilitating, and supporting employees. And maturity is the
willingness and ability of a person to take responsibility for directing his own behavior. Employees tend
to have varying degrees of maturity, depending on the specific tasks, functions, or objectives that they
attempt to accomplish. Back to Top
To determine the appropriate leadership style to use in a given situation, a leader must first determine
the maturity levels of his or her followers in relationship to the specific task. As employee maturity
levels increase, a leader should begin to reduce task behavior and increase relationship behavior until
his or her followers reach moderate maturity levels. As the employees move into above‐average
maturity levels, the leader should decrease not only task behavior but also relationship behavior.

Once maturity levels are identified, a manager can determine the appropriate leadership style: telling,
selling, participating, or delegating.

Telling. This style reflects high task/low relationship behavior (S1). The leader provides clear
instructions and specific direction. Telling style is best matched with a low follower readiness level.

Selling. This style reflects high task/high relationship behavior (S2). The leader encourages two‐way
communication and helps build confidence and motivation on the part of the employee, although the
leader still has responsibility and controls decision making. Selling style is best matched with a
moderate follower readiness level.

Participating. This style reflects high relationship/low task behavior (S3). With this style, the leader
and followers share decision making and no longer need or expect the relationship to be directive.
Participating style is best matched with a moderate follower readiness level.

Delegating. This style reflects low relationship/low task behavior (S4). Delegating style is appropriate
for leaders whose followers are ready to accomplish a particular task and are both competent and
motivated to take full responsibility. This style is best matched with a high follower readiness level.

House's path-goal theory

The path‐goal theory, developed by Robert House, is based on the expectancy theory of motivation. A
manager's job is to coach or guide workers to choose the best paths for reaching their goals. Based on
the goal‐setting theory, leaders engage in different types of leadership behaviors depending on the
nature and demands of a particular situation.

A leader's behavior is acceptable to subordinates when viewed as a source of satisfaction. He or she is


motivational when need satisfaction is contingent on performance; this leader facilitates, coaches, and
rewards effective performance. Path‐goal theory identifies several leadership styles:

Achievement‐oriented. The leader sets challenging goals for followers, expects them to perform at
their highest levels, and shows confidence in their abilities to meet these expectations. This style
Back is
to Top
appropriate when followers lack job challenges.
Directive. The leader lets followers know what is expected of them and tells them how to perform
their tasks. This style is appropriate when followers hold ambiguous jobs.

Participative. The leader consults with followers and asks them for suggestions before making a
decision. This style is appropriate when followers are using improper procedures or are making poor
decisions.

Supportive. The leader is friendly and approachable. He or she shows concern for the followers'
psychological well‐being. This style is appropriate when followers lack confidence.

Path‐goal theory assumes that leaders are flexible and that they can change their styles as situations
require. This theory proposes two contingency variables that moderate the leader behavior‐outcome
relationship:

Environment characteristics are outside the control of followers, task structure, authority system,
and work group. Environmental factors determine the type of leader behavior required if follower
outcomes are to be maximized.

Follower characteristics are the focus of control, experience, and perceived ability. Personal
characteristics of subordinates determine how the environment and leader behavior are interpreted.

Effective leaders clarify the path to help their followers achieve their goals, and make their journeys
easier by reducing roadblocks and pitfalls. Research demonstrates that employee performance and
satisfaction are positively influenced when leaders compensate for shortcomings in either their
employees or the work settings.

Back to Top
CliffsNotes study guides are written by real teachers and professors, so no matter what
you're studying, CliffsNotes can ease your homework headaches and help you score high
on exams.

Back to Top
About CliffsNotes (/discover-about) Advertise with Us (/discover-advertise) Contact Us (/discover-contact)

Follow us: (https://twitter.com/cliffs_notes) (https://www.facebook.com/CliffsNotes)

(https://www.youtube.com/user/cliffsnotes/videos) (https://instagram.com/cliffsnotesofficial/)

© 2016 Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. All rights reserved.

Terms & Conditions (http://www.hmhco.com/common/terms-conditions)

Privacy Policy (http://www.hmhco.com/common/privacy-policy) Disclaimer (/disclaimer) Sitemap (/sitemap)

A18ACD436D5A3997E3DA2573E3FD792A

Back to Top