Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SONNY S. LUKBAN,
Accused,
x-----------------------------------------x
TRANSCRIPT
of the stenographic notes
taken during the hearing of the above entitled case,
before, HON. JONATHAN VINCENT CASTILLO,Presiding Judge, RTC,
Branch 16, Naval, Biliran August, 2015 at
10:45 o’clock in the morning
ASSISTED BY:
COURT:
COURT INTERPRETER:
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
COURT:
COURT INTERPRETER:
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 3
COURT:
Purpose?
ATTY. PABIO:
COURT:
Your Lukban.
ATTY. PABIO:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
A Yes, Sir.
A We are friends.
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 4
ATTY. PABIO:
A No, Sir.
A None, Sir.
A I was in Barpels.
A No, Sir.
A Gee Renomeron.
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 5
ATTY. PABIO:
A Gary.
A When she opened the door she was fixing her hair.
A With Gary.
Q Can you please tell us, how long did that fist fight
lasted?
ATTY. PABIO:
Q During that fight you said it only lasted for two (2)
minutes, what eventually happened please tell us?
A When our fist fight was almost done Garry fell to the
door of the comfort room and then when he was on
the gesture to stand up, he got a gun.
A Yes, Sir.
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
Sustained.
ATTY. PABIO:
A It was in him.
Q You said that the hand gun hit Garry Montejo, what
was your reaction thereafter?
ATTY. PABIO:
A Yes, Sir.
A Hospital drive.
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 9
ATTY. PABIO:
A To surrender.
A Yes, Sir.
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
ATTY. BORJA:
With all due respect, Your Honor, the document which the
accused just identified, a copy thereof rather was pre-marked
during the pre-trial as our Exh. “5”and it appears on page 151 of
the court’s record.
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
With all due respect, Your Honor I think the comment of the
good counsel for the private prosecution is proper during the
formal offer, Your Honor.
COURT:
ATTY. PABIO:
ATTY. BORJA:
That is why Your Honor, the Police Officer who issued that
document should identify the particular document and not this
accused that is why we are raising.
ATTY. PABIO:
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 11
ATTY. PABIO:
A Palo.
A Selda.
A I was in Ormoc.
Q Did you come to know what was the result of the Paraffin
Test conducted on you?
A Negative.
COURT:
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 12
ATTY. PABIO:
A Preliminary Investigation.
COURT:
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
COURT:
ATTY. BORJA:
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 13
COURT
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
A Yes, Sir.
A That is my signature.
ATTY. BORJA:
Sustained.
ATTY. PABIO:
A With Gary.
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
ATTY. PABIO:
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 15
COURT:
ATTY. PABIO:
COURT:
Cross?
ATTY. BORJA:
CROSS EXAMINATION
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
Q In fact, you said you know him for about ten (10)
years prior to the incident or more than ten (10)
years?
A Yes, Sir.
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 16
ATTY. BORJA:
A I tried.
Q In what way?
A I followed him.
Q Where?
Q But instead you said you just went home because you
did not find Johnoutside the hospital?
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
A I was afraid.
A No, Sir.
ATTY. PABIO:
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
Objection, overruled.
LUKBAN:
ATTY. BORJA:
A Sitio Laka.
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 18
ATTY. BORJA:
A No, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
Q So, how did you know that he was hit Mr. Lukban.
COURT:
LUKBAN:
COURT:
LUKBAN:
ATTY. BORJA:
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 19
LUKBAN:
A Yes, Sir.
ATTY. BORJA:
Q So, he was never lying down during the time that you
were grappling?
A Yes, Sir.
COURT:
LUKBAN:
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
A I was the one who made this statement and they were
the ones who prepared the document.
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
Any re-direct?
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 20
ATTY. CERRA: RE-DIRECT EXAMINATION
Q You were made to admit, Mr. Lukban that you did not
immediately surrender to the police and it took you
about 8 hours before you surrendered to the police
station. Now, what was the reason why it took you 8
hours more or less before you surrendered to the
police station?
A George Reyes.
ATTY. PABIO:
COURT:
Re-cross?
ATTY. BORJA:
COURT:
Proceed.
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
A Yes, Sir.
TSN
N-2818/FOR: MURDER
DLB/August 5, 2015
Page 21
ATTY. BORJA:
ATTY. PABIO:
COURT: ORDER
SO ORDERED.
CERTIFICATION
DOREEN L. BORJA
Court Stenographer III