Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8

synopsis

The narrative leader


Build influence through “storytelling”

A n ancestral tradition, storytel-


ling has been from time imme-
morial the principal means by
which human beings have passed on
their knowledge and values. The great
nection between the various elements
that comprise them.

“Telling tales” often has a negative


connotation. Some stigmatize storytel-
religious books, such as the Bible, the ling as manipulative, that is, as a way of
Torah, the Koran, etc., used stories to persuading others through the imagi-
communicate values and a specific vi- nation, rather than reason or intellect.
sion of the world. The great ideas of the Thus, the story naturally has a limited
Greek philosophers – notably Socra- role in the rational universe of busi-
tes – have come down through the ages ness. Very few leaders dare attempt to
in all their nuances thanks to fabulous hold the attention of an audience long
storytellers such as Plato. Tales and enough to tell a story intended to serve
Didier Avril, série Storytelling legends communicate our convictions as lasting inspiration. Indeed, most ma-
and values, just as grandparents pass nagers prefer the reassuring structure of
Our sources down what they believe and hold dear a logical and factual “PowerPoint” pre-
This synopsis is based on the publications in the bedtime stories they tell to their sentation, which naturally leads people
presented below and on the back page. grandchildren. Nietzsche showed that to the desired conclusion.
a group defines its identity around its
chosen stories. Indeed, business orga- That being said, there is a growing rea-
Le storytelling en action
[Storytelling in Action]
nizations form their culture primarily lization that a purely rational approach
Olivier Clodong, Georges Chétochine, through anecdotes and events that are is not sufficient to influence people
Editions d’organisation, 2010,183 pages. told and retold by the people who work on a sustainable basis. Just as marke-
there. ting creates story lines to give meaning
Les sept règles du storytelling
and continuity to a brand, many lea-
[The Seven Rules of Storytelling]
John Sadowsky, Loïck Rock, There is nothing surprising about ders today would like to capitalize on
Pearson Village Mondial, 2009,163 pages. this. Storytelling is the means of the power of stories. What is currently
The Story Factor, Annette Simmons, communication most closely ali- known as “narrative communication”
Basic Books 2006,320 pages. gned with the way the human mind or “storytelling” is thus now returning
works, explain the experts. Indeed, to center stage.
we remember best the observations
to which we ascribe meaning. Stories
create meaning by bringing dry facts
to life and building a logical intercon-

In this synopsis… focus synopsIs focus


Rational arguments Keys to effective In what situations
and stories: two storytelling should you use stories?
complementary tools of
influence

The narrative leader  manageris ©2010 – 187b 1


focus

Rational arguments and stories:


two complementary tools of influence

The challenge
The world of business is basically rational. Educated to think logically and use sophisticated analytical techniques,
business leaders and managers naturally tend to prefer to convince their counterparts with rational explanations.
That’s why seminars and board meetings can hardly get by without at least one PowerPoint presentation. Yet, clearly
structured factual arguments are not the only way to sway an audience—far from it! Indeed, the ability to tell good
stories would be a valuable asset in the management toolkit of many a leader.

Distinct advantages and disadvantages


Logical arguments and stories work according to very different principles.

LOGICAL ARGUMENTS STORIES


Use reason to sway the listener Use emotion to sway the listener

•• The listener yields to logic and accepts the speaker’s •• The listener adheres to the message because he or she
)

point of view. is deeply convinced.


•• ••
Eventually, however, the listener reverts to his or her The message will not be conveyed effectively unless the
)

initial point of view as soon as he or she finds a good speaker owns the story and tells it authentically.
supporting argument.

Point to a single conclusion Let the listener draw his or her own conclusions

•• The speaker controls the message. •• The listener accepts the conclusion, because he or she
)

came up with it.


••
If any of the cited arguments are shaky or too
••
)

black-and-white, the listener may well challenge The same story is subject to different interpretations.
)

the entire conclusion.

Simplify the message to focus on the essential Describe different facets of a situation

•• The listener easily understands the speaker’s message. •• The listener observes that the speaker understands the
)
)

complexity of the situation.


•• Reality is often more complex and subtle than
)

••
argumentation tends to imply. The message is rarely The message is not explicit. The listener may draw
)

couched in sufficiently moderate terms to be absolutely conclusions that diverge from what the speaker hoped to
credible. communicate.

Are easy to remember in the short term Make a lasting impression

•• The human brain stores logical arguments to be able to •• Well-told stories create emotions that make them easier
)
)

retrieve them logically. to remember over time.


•• ••
Logical arguments are remembered in the short term; but Remembering every detail of a story is a challenge,
)
)

without an emotional link, they are not deeply engraved making subsequent re-telling difficult.
into the long-term memory.

2 manageris ©2010 – 187b The narrative leader


SYNOPSiS

Keys to effective
storytelling

T he idea of “telling a story” in


a professional context may
sometimes be quite intimi-
dating, and may seem best left up to
born orators like Martin Luther King,
Winston Churchill – one of the greatest
political storytellers in history – was
known to prepare his stories painsta-
kingly, weighing each word, every tiny
detail, every intonation, and to test
Make a lasting impression

To be effective, a story must become


legendary (even if the legend concerns
only the speaker’s immediate circle)
Winston Churchill, Charles de Gaulle, them out ad nauseam on his friends and and be told and retold by those who
Jack Welch or Barack Obama – all family. Thanks to these efforts, his sto- hear it. This is how people embrace a
legendary storytellers. Yet, each of us ries galvanized huge crowds and are still story and let it influence their behavior.
is capable of telling a story that cap- recounted more than 50 years later! At Apple, many stories about Steve
tivates a child, who will recall it with Telling effective stories thus takes Jobs’ beginnings continue to circulate
delight for days afterwards. We have all work and real effort to achieve three in the hallways. Everyone has heard
had experiences that could be valuable important objectives: how the first Apple computer was de-
to others. Similarly, good leaders must veloped in a garage by a handful of bri-
have a vision, values, a strategy and an Hold the attention ght young people who saw themselves
action plan to attain their objectives. In of the audience as “rebels” ready to fight to the death
short, we all possess the basic material against a world hostile to their ideas.
of which good stories are made. To be effective, a story must grab the
attention of the listener. This is a funda- Inspire trust
mental requirement in order for the lis-
Anyone can tell tener to project him or herself into the The line between influence and ma-
story and connect it with his or her own nipulation is always thin. To be persua-
a story that will sway situation. A story that became legend sive without triggering rejection, a story
an audience. in the Soviet Union is that of the miner must inspire trust in the speaker. Barack
Alekseï Stakhanov, who extracted four- Obama, for example, was a masterful
teen times the standard amount of coal storyteller during the 2008 presiden-
The mistake lies in believing that during a contest. This story was told on tial campaign. The many tales he told
the art of storytelling requires spon- and on with conviction and feeling by about his family – his mother’s illness
taneity. Quite to the contrary, the best factory managers. It was so compelling and his struggles with the health care
stories – those that seem most spon- that there was no need to specify that system, the African roots of his father,
taneous and natural – are often the every other miner was thereafter expec- etc. – were very powerful in earning the
most carefully prepared. For example, ted to go the extra mile like Stakhanov. public’s trust.

1 Prepare authentic stories


2 Anchor stories in reality
Five practices can help
3 Speak to the emotions
optimize a story’s power
4 Involve the audience
5 Rehearse continuously

The narrative leader  manageris ©2010 – 187b 3


1st key to success
Check-list Prepare authentic stories
To identify the stories that most No matter what story you tell, you is generally quite helpful here. The
resemble you, undertake an
reveal something about yourself when authors of Les sept règles du storytelling
introspective voyage:
you tell it. Because you chose that parti- [The Seven Rules of Storytelling],
• What have been the high points of
your life? When did you have the
cular story, it must be important to you recommend systematically asking
most energy? Why? What particularly somehow. The values or vision that it yourself three questions: Who are you?
motivated you? What guided you? conveys are your own. What do you represent? What mark do
• Conversely, what negative experiences To be credible, you must be perfectly you want to leave on your company and
made a lasting impression on you? at ease with the story and be able on the world in general? Thus, Michael
What did you learn from them? Did to tell it with passion. If you do not Dell regularly tells listeners how he
these experiences help shape your really believe in it, your chatted about “business
values? Did you act differently as a
nonverbal language – opportunities” with his
result? Your story must
attitude, gestures, tone sound right
parents at the dinner
• What encounters have been particularly
meaningful to you? What most struck
of voice – will almost and “resemble” you. table as a child. And
you about these individuals? How were always contradict the how, at the age of 12,
you moved or edified by what they did message of the story. he launched his first
well or poorly? Listeners are unlikely to miss such business experiment by developing
• Which stories have had a major impact discrepancies, and will doubt your a catalogue to give stamp collectors a
on you? To which of your values did sincerity. chance to make purchases without going
they refer? Would you be able to retell The first step in becoming a good through an auctioneer. Louder than any
them? storyteller is consequently to build factual explanation, this story conveys
Based on Les sept règles du storytelling
[The Seven Rules of Storytelling],
a repertory of stories in which you Dell’s conviction that disintermediation
John Sadowsky, Loïck Roche, believe and which transmit the values you is the wave of the future, and contributes
Pearson Village Mondial, 2009 hold dear. Some introspective research to his credibility as a business prodigy.

“The most effective leaders start by looking in a mirror”.


Noel Tichy, The Leadership Engine

2nd key to success


Anchor stories in reality
Remember
To make a lasting impression, a story
A story is effective if listeners or rea- A story like this is much more powerful
must be simple, but contain enough ders can put themselves in the shoes of than an abstract presentation of the
details for listeners to feel they are the protagonists to experience the situa- facts! Indeed, the power of this story is
actually experiencing it: tion by proxy, that is, feel their emotions, illustrated by the response of an Obama
• Personalize your stories. Give a and then draw their own conclusions supporter, who, when asked why she
name to the main character; describe from this experience. had come to support the presidential
his or her notable physical features To achieve this, a story must be candidate, simply said: “I am here
and personality. Give listeners the personalized around strong characters because of Ashley.”
impression they know the person!
who are given distinctive shape and For this type of projection to take place,
• Take the time to “set the stage.”
Listeners must be able to visualize the
form and named by name. To convey his however, the story must include many
scene. Give them details, e.g.: Where ideas on reforming the sensory and visual
did the story take place? What was the American health care The story must details. For example,
weather like? What were you doing system, Barack Obama be sufficiently precise the story of Ashley
there? often told the story of and detailed could be accompanied
• Call upon all of the senses. Listeners Ashley, a 9-year-old girl to seem real. by a photograph of the
must be immersed in your story. whose mother, ill with little girl’s determined
Describe colors, sights, sounds, smells, cancer, had been laid off and was forced face, or a precise description of the
sensations, etc.
to declare personal bankruptcy. Ashley meeting: “When I met Ashley, she looked
• But keep it simple. Avoid drowning
had succeeded in convincing her mother tiny and frail in her red dress, but you could
your story in too much detail. Find the
right balance between making the story
that her favorite dish was a sandwich of see her fierce determination in her eyes and
precise enough to make an impression, mustard and pickles, the two cheapest mouth.” With such details, listener will
and keeping it moving quickly enough ingredients she could find. So, she ate be able to sense and visualize the scene
to avoid boring listeners. mustard sandwiches for an entire year. clearly and thus remember it better.

4 manageris ©2010 – 187b The narrative leader


3rd key to success
Speak to the emotions Example

Stories speak to the heart more than ges,” he says. “An incident puts things out Introduction of a speech calling for a
road replacement:
do factual arguments. Indeed, this is of balance and demands a reaction.”
"I came here by the cliff road this
the key to an effective story, because The way a story is told is just as fun- morning. I had my four-year-old daughter,
emotions make a much more lasting damental. To speak to the heart, you Sarah, with me. I belted her tightly into
impression than ratio- must reveal your own her seat; I knew that road is dangerous.
nal explanations. A story that speaks emotions, weaknesses, I was driving very carefully, when a car
Stories tend to move to the emotions fears, and be willing to came from the other direction. Instantly,
people, for example, makes a lasting share them with your the thousands of people killed on that
when they contain fan- impression. audience. You must also road every year flashed into my mind. I
tastic, epic, surprising, tell your story with thought about all those people who had
died at that exact spot – not to mention
combative or challenging elements – passion, by modulating your tone,
those who had merely been injured! As
all emotionally charged. In his article, volume and pace of speech. Try to use
you can see, Sarah and I survived the trip.
Storytelling that Moves People, scenario short, simple sentences like when you This time, the other driver wasn’t drunk.
writer Robert McKee recommends de- are thinking to yourself. Don’t tell the This time, the other driver was attentive.
signing a story like a film scenario: “A story chronologically, but insert your But I wonder if, one day, maybe we’ll just
story expresses how and why a life chan- thoughts and feelings. be another statistic on that road."
Adapted from The Power of Storytelling, IESE
Insight, April/June2005.

“What touches the heart is engraved in the memory.”


4th key to success Voltaire, Philosophical Dictionary

Involve the audience


To be profoundly influenced by Kroc happened to pass by a McDonald’s Remember
a story, listeners must make it their restaurant whose parking lot was piled
own. To do this, they must somehow with garbage. Empty milk cartons, “hap- To help listeners assimilate your story,
feel as if they personally experienced py meal” boxes, and paper napkins were get them involved:
what they are hearing. The more you strewn about the ground. Kroc stop- • Use inclusive language. Tell the story
are able to tell a story ped immediately, went as if you assume that listeners share
interactively, the more A story works even in, and asked to see the your perspective.
the audience will assi- better when listeners manager of the restau- • Avoid closing listeners into a story that
milate it. participate, thus making rant. He simply said, is tied up too neatly. In particular, let
By the same token, it their own. “We have a lot of work to them draw their own conclusions.
• Invite listeners to react. Giving listeners
you must let listeners do; we don’t want trash
a chance to participate in your story
draw their own conclusions, barring on our sites.” Everyone went to work to helps them assimilate it.
which they are likely to feel manipula- clean the place up, including Kroc him- • Respect their time. The best stories
ted. In the Journal of Management De- self! The fact that the story stops here are short. Because listeners pay active
velopment, Sandra Morgan tells a story makes it all the more effective, because attention to the entire story, they can
about Ray Kroc, then president of Mc- listeners can continue to think about it remember it fully and retell it in turn,
Donald’s. While driving to Chicago, and draw their own conclusions. thus making it their own.

Invite listeners to react


Even if the answer is obvious, answering a question gets listeners involved in
Don’t hesitate to ask rhetorical questions
the story. E.g.: Do you think he accepted that? What would you have done?

If you leave silences in your story, listeners will tend to fill them and thus
Take pauses
participate.

If listeners exclaim, laugh, sigh, applaud, hold their breath, listen to their
Don’t interrupt demonstrations of emotions
reactions, and wait until they are ready before continuing.

Make an aside referring to the audience’s reaction and adapt your story if
Accept losing some control over your story
necessary.

The narrative leader  manageris ©2010 – 187b 5


5th key to success
Rehearse continuously
Check-list
Great storytellers like Winston ling] recommend keeping a written
To prepare a story, you must start by Churchill and Jack Welch rehearse journal to jot down new ideas for sto-
defining a framework or basic pattern their stories again and again, and work ries to test on your friends and family
which can be expanded upon more or
very hard on refining them in order to before developing them more fully.
less depending on the situation:
• Describe the environment.
maximize their impact. In the Harvard Putting spoken language into writing
– Where does the story take place? Business Review article The Four Truths will also force you to be more precise
At what time of year? of the Storyteller, an investment banker in your choice of words, sensory de-
– Who are the protagonists? What is recounts, “When we help a company with tails, articulations, and planned pauses.
most remarkable about them? an IPO, we see the chairman and his team This type of script is not designed to
What role do you play? tell their story 10, 20, so- fix the story in stone,
• Clarify the structure of the story. metimes 30 times! And but rather to clarify the
The most natural
– What is the initial situation? you know what? Each basic pattern, so that
narrators are those who
– What is the most striking event likely
time is generally better best prepare the narrator can more
to trigger emotions?
than the last.” their stories. easily move away from
– How does the story end?
• Think about pacing.
So, when you tell a it, depending on the
– What aspects should be expanded story, observe the reactions of those audience’s reaction, and hence be more
upon? who hear it, and integrate this feed- natural in telling it.
– What could you eliminate altogether back to improve it. Every time you tell In the same way, rehearsing your
or cover more rapidly? a story, you relive it, and are likely to story in different ways – in front of a
– What are the important transitions? think of new ideas for improving it the mirror, into a tape recorder, or with an
• What message would you like your next time you tell it. The process of re- observer who is asked to provide feed-
audience to take away from the story?
hearsing and developing your abilities back – will help you acquire a natural
as a storyteller is thus a continuous and style. Intensive practice will make your
iterative process. story more impactful by helping you
The authors of Les sept règles du sto- tell it without having to think about it
rytelling [The Seven Rules of Storytel- consciously.

Four areas of preparation

Get in touch with your emotions Listen to your audience

Start by focusing on what you are feeling when you tell the story. Ensure that your story is meaningful to others beside yourself.
What do you want to communicate? What words and details are Test your story on a neutral audience. Depending on the
particularly meaningful to you? reactions you receive, you can refine your story by articulating
your scenario differently, choosing different words, describing
the characters and context in a different way, etc.

Prepare a pattern or framework Practice modulating your story

For a story to “work,” you must define a few invariables, that is, Imagine that you have to tell the story in an elevator, at a
the backbone that ensures that everyone who hears it will hear dinner, to a perfect stranger, to a subordinate, etc. If you do
the same story, regardless of its form. this exercise regularly, you will be able to tell your story in any
context.

6 manageris ©2010 – 187b The narrative leader


focus

In what situations
should you use stories?

The challenge
Telling a story is often much more effective than using a logical argument to influence others. More than the facts,
what people often take away from a speech are the anecdotes selected to illustrate the message, akin to Martin
Luther King’s legendary “dream,” or the story of the unwittingly boiled frog told by Al Gore in his documentary
"An Inconvenient Truth.” At the same time, stories must be used in the right circumstances to avoid losing your
audience.

Some situations where stories are more effective than rational arguments
Storytelling is particularly helpful in achieving three main objectives.

Establish your credibility • Always be ready with a story that shows what kind of person you are.
For people to listen to you, you must e.g.: Rather than saying “I have a very human side,” you can recount a difficult
inspire trust. choice you had to make as a manager, and how you dealt with the human
However, trust is normally built over aspect.
time, as people observe that you act Jack Welch used to tell in minute detail how his mother taught him to
according to your word. persevere in early childhood.
A story can help accelerate
this process by serving as a
“concentrated experience.” • Learn to illustrate your intentions with stories.
e.g.: Rather than saying "I want to succeed," which can be interpreted in many
ways, telling the story of someone successful whom you admire will help
listeners understand your intentions and assimilate them more easily.

Convey the implicit • Use stories to transmit know-how.


Some ideas are too complex or e.g.: The UPS parcel delivery service abounds with stories of employees who
abstract to be simply explained went out of their way to deliver packages on time in the most complex
factually. situations. These stories show what types of initiatives are possible and
Storytelling is very helpful in such expected of delivery staff to keep the customer promise.
situations because a story doesn’t
even try to cover the subject
completely, which would be • Present your vision in the form of a story.
impossible, but simply and strikingly e.g.: A World Bank executive placed priority on access to information by telling
illustrates a particular dimension the story of a social worker in a small Zambian village who had discovered
of it. It is then up to the listener to how to prevent and treat malaria on the web. "That’s what we would like for
deduce the rest of the message! everyone!" he concluded.

Defuse conflict • Express your messages less abruptly with a story.


When you want to influence e.g.: Rather than demanding more collaboration from your subordinates,
someone, encountering a certain encourage them to make changes by telling a story like that of NASA, where
degree of resistance is normal. organizational silos were the root cause of the Challenger disaster.
A story presents the various facets
of a situation. As such, it helps
demonstrate that you understand • Move away from a confrontational mindset with a story.
the listener’s viewpoint and thus e.g.: When conflicts become heated, logical arguments are often unhelpful
lower his or her resistance. as people generally take sides and often refuse to budge. Telling a story is a
nonaggressive way to put the situation into perspective and present the bigger
picture.

The narrative leader  manageris ©2010 – 187b 7


Find out more

Our selection
For the best ideas on this topic, we recommend the following publications:
Further readings
Le storytelling en action [Storytelling in Action]
Olivier Clodong, Georges Chétochine, Editions d’organisation, 2010. To explore this topic further:

In this book, Olivier Clodong and Georges Chétochine dissect the mechanisms that
• Use your influence effectively
make storytelling such an effective tool of influence. Based on numerous examples (Manageris synopsis 124a)
taken from the world of politics (Barack Obama, George Bush, Abdoulaye Wade Obtain a better grasp of the mechanisms of
in Senegal, Marc Ravalomanana in Madagascar), brand marketing (Chanel, World power and influence in the organization.
of Warcraft, Twilight), business (Danone, 3M, IBM, HSBC), and great humanitarian
• The underpinnings of manipulation
causes (animal rights, microcredit, etc), the authors identify how we can influence
(Manageris synopsis 128b)
others with well-told stories.
Study the mechanics of manipulation to
The first two parts, which expand upon a long series of highly detailed real-life situations, serve to
manage its impact more effectively.
prove the immeasurable effectiveness of storytelling, while explaining the phenomena at work.
The authors continue in part three by offering a relatively unstructured toolkit from which leaders • The keys to persuasion
can draw at will to improve their storytelling skills.
(Manageris synopsis 171b)
Adapt your strategy of persuasion to the
This is a book to be read more for its extremely lively and well told examples than for its explicit
decision-making style of your counterpart.
conclusions.
• Leadership beyond words
(Manageris synopsis 176b)
Les sept règles du storytelling Reinforce your powers of persuasion with
[The Seven Rules of Storytelling] nonverbal language.
John Sadowsky, Loïck Rock, ED.Pearson Village Mondial, 2009.
An excellent how-to manual, based on the leadership coaching experience of the
authors, this book starts from the conviction that anyone, and particularly any leader,
can and should develop his or her storytelling skills. The argument is well put in the
first part, and “sold” with stories (Dell, Apple) which will surely inspire you and make
you want to read the rest. This is followed by seven golden rules, each of which has
its own dedicated chapter, to turn you into a good storyteller even if you aren’t a
natural at it. Some important points to keep in mind: Start with some introspection
to identify stories that “resemble” you and inspire trust in you; learn to “let go” to allow listeners
to make your stories their own and draw their own conclusions; personalize your stories and provide
sufficient details to anchor them in reality. And last but not least, keep it simple!
Once you have read this book, all you’ve got to do is to dare give up your structured PowerPoint
presentations and start telling stories!

The Story Factor


Annette Simmons, Basic Books 2006, 320 pages.
This short book is different from traditional management literature. The author tries
to show how stories are much more persuasive than rational arguments, and applies
this principle to the letter. So, don’t expect to find any structured demonstrations or
lists of recommendations: Annette Simmons tells stories to convey her point of view.
It is then up to us to decide whether or not we should apply her ideas!
MANAGERIS
This is a book that is both enjoyable to read and interesting in terms of its fresh
28, rue des Petites Écuries
perspective on the work leaders and managers need to do to build influence.
75010 Paris - FRANCE
Tel.: +33 (0)1 53 24 39 39
Fax: +33 (0)1 53 24 39 30
E-mail: info@manageris.com
And also… www.manageris.com

We also relied on the following publications:


One-year subscription
to Manageris synopses
• The Power of Storytelling, Brian Leggett, IESE Insight, April / June 2005.
Share information and knowledge through storytelling.
Web subscription 850 €
• Telling Tales, Stephen Denning, Harvard Business Review, May 2004. (22 synopses) + V.A.T
Which stories should you tell and how should you tell them to influence the behavior of your
Full archive subscription 1 850 €
listeners?
(over 200 synopses) + V.A.T
• Real Leaders Don’t Do PowerPoint: How to Sell Yourself and Your Ideas, Christopher Witt,
Dale Fetherling, Crown Business, 2009.
A humorous look at the public speaking skills of leaders. One synopsis
• Storytelling That Moves People, A Conversation with Screenwriting Coach Robert McKee,
Subscribers 33 € HT + V.A.T
Bronwyn Fryer, Harvard Business Review, June 2006.
How to turn a story into a genuine tool of influence? Non subscribers 66 € HT + V.A.T
• The Four Truths of the Storyteller, Peter Guber, Harvard Review Business, Dec. 2007. For copyright permissions and group rates,
Four pillars that support the authenticity of a story. contact us.

8 manageris ©2010 – 187b The narrative leader

Вам также может понравиться