Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 4

Proceedings of the 8th IEEE GCC Conference and Exhibition, Muscat, Oman, 1-4 February, 2015

Noninvasive Blood Glucose Level Measurement


Using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance
AHMED Y. LUAIBI, AHMED J. AL-GHUSAIN, ASIF RAHMAN, MOHAMMAD H. AL-SAYAH, HASAN A. AL-NASHASH
American University of Sharjah, Sharjah, UAE, hnashash@aus.edu

Abstract— Many investigations have been conducted in the Most of these techniques are described in a very
field of noninvasive blood-glucose concentration measurement comprehensive review article by Vashist [5]. Despite the
yet; none seem to meet the standards of comfort, accuracy and reported success of these methods under controlled conditions,
safety. This paper presents the preliminary outcomes of our none seem to meet the required standards of accuracy and
investigations into the potential of using nuclear magnetic safety when used in normal varying environmental conditions
resonance (NMR) principles for the noninvasive measurement of such as physical movement and temperature variations. In this
blood glucose level in humans. The initial phase of the research research work, we report our preliminary attempts in using
involved testing the feasibility of using NMR in measuring nuclear magnetic resonance principle for the noninvasive
glucose concentration in water. Then, the method was modified
measurement of blood glucose level in humans. The presented
to enable us to measure the glucose level concentration in
method and results are at the early stage of development. The
humans. Various signal processing methods were tested to find
the best algorithm that improves detection accuracy. Results
remaining sections of the paper are organized as follows: in
obtained from two human subjects are used to demonstrate the section II, the proposed methodology is introduced followed
feasibility and found to be promising with error varying between by results in section III. This is then followed in section IV by
3% and 14%. conclusions.

Keywords—noninvasive, glucose level, NMR, Diabetes II. METHODOLOGY


A. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR)
I. INTRODUCTION
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance takes place when a nucleus
The Glucose level in blood is a very important parameter in a magnetic field absorbs and emits electromagnetic
to measure, especially for people with diabetes. Currently, the radiation at a specific frequency, called the resonant
only way to measure a patient’s blood glucose level is by frequency. In fact, for the emission of electromagnetic energy
puncturing the skin and extracting a sample of blood for to take place, the frequency and the magnitude of the magnetic
analysis. This invasive method is painful and causes field are required to be at a certain proportion. This
discomfort for diabetic patients who need to check their blood phenomenon is called the Larmor precession which is
glucose levels several times a day. Also, diabetic patients’ expressed mathematically as . The gamma in this
blood does not clot easily which leads to high risk of infection. equation is known as the gyromagnetic ratio which is an
Furthermore, invasive methods require disposable test strips intrinsic and characteristic feature of the material. Each
that can be costly to the patient over very long periods of time. element has a specific gyromagnetic ratio at which resonance
In the last thirty years, there has been extensive research occurs, and this ratio is based on the nature of the material
efforts into creating a technique to measure blood glucose itself such as magnetic moment and electron spins [6]. This
levels without puncturing the skin, or noninvasively. physical principle of NMR is used in many applications, such
However, none of these attempts have created devices that are as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), magnetometers, and
safe and accurate. Therefore, there is a need for a new NMR spectroscopy. NMR Spectroscopy is a technique used to
approach to monitor blood glucose noninvasively. The nature study the nature of material in a sample. Due to the extremely
of this research is investigative; it will seek to explore the small size of molecules, researchers cannot directly view them
validity of using a new method to find a solution to the and therefore depend on more advanced techniques of
proposed problem. The current state of the art of minimally detecting material through their interaction with other forms of
invasive continuous glucose monitoring is based on the energy such as electromagnetic radiation. There are many
enzymatic catalysis principle [1]. This approach still requires a forms of spectroscopy, such as mass spectroscopy and infrared
thin needle to be inserted subcutaneously which also involves spectroscopy. NMR technique takes advantage of the fact that
puncturing the skin. In addition, there have been several different elements have unique gammas (or set of gammas)
noninvasive techniques which have been reported in the which can be employed to identify the nature of an unknown
literature. Solianis Monitoring has recently introduced a substance using a known frequency and magnetic field [6].
prototype for a genuine noninvasive monitor of glucose level This spectroscopic technique can therefore be carried out in
using dielectric and optical spectroscopy sensors [2]. Data several ways. In one method, a constant frequency and
collected from 150 channels are combined to estimate the magnetic field can be applied to check whether or not the
glucose level using some mathematical algorithm. Many other particle resonates at the corresponding gamma. In another
techniques have also been published including breath signal, method, one can sweep the magnetic field and keep the
electrical impedance, Ultrasound, NIR spectroscopy, frequency constant so that all the gammas that cause
photoacoustic spectroscopy, and thermal spectroscopy [3-5]. resonance can be detected. NMR spectroscopy has

978-4799-8422-0/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
Proceedings of the 8th IEEE GCC Conference and Exhibition, Muscat, Oman, 1-4 February, 2015
traditionally been used to study the structure and dynamics of Where OB(t) is the convolution of all other components in the
molecules. However, there have been some cases where the blood. Using the convolution theorem, we can also express the
technology has been used to study the concentration of output signal in frequency domain as:
molecules. In one case, researchers used magnetic resonance
(3)
imaging units to detect the concentrations of iron in patients
suffering from iron-loading disorders such as
hemochromatosis and sickle cell disease [7]. This
measurement of iron concentration was done noninvasively.
This demonstrates the feasibility of using this technology for
not only measuring concentrations, but also for noninvasive Fig. 1: NMR System with Blood Sample Model
measurement. In another case, researchers used NMR Assuming that we have the spectrum of a calibration sample
spectroscopy to measure the brain glucose concentrations [8] of pure glucose solution with a known concentration, then we
and diabetes studies [9]. Therefore, it can be seen that the can use equation (3) to compute the spectrum OB f . This
technology seems to fit as an ideal solution to the problem of spectrum will then be used in equation (3) to compute the
noninvasive blood glucose measurement.
glucose spectrum for an unknown glucose concentration in a
While it can be argued that the cost of NMR devices is blood sample:
very high, it should be noted that there have been many
breakthroughs in the field of magnetic technology that signal a (4)
decline in the price of future NMR devices. For instance, the
main reason that high resolution NMR devices are expensive Fig. 2 shows a typical NMR blood spectrum with glucose
is that the devices use superconducting magnets which require concentration of 100mg/dL. Notice that the y-axis is in
very low temperatures. Therefore, many NMR devices use relative magnetic field intensity, and the frequency x-axis is in
liquid nitrogen to cool the devices and keep them temperatures Hz. The NMR system plots from left to right and therefore to
between 63 and 77 Kelvin. Permanent magnets have not been preserve the same spectrum, the axis was plotted in reverse in
used because they do not provide enough magnetic field MATLAB (Hence it appears to be ‘negative’, but this is just
intensity and also because they do not provide magnetic fields for plotting purposes).
that are homogenous. However, there have been
breakthroughs in permanent magnet technology that have not
4
x 10 Spectrum of Blood and Glucose (concentration 100 mg/dL)
6.5
only reduce the size of the magnet, but have also increased the 6
field intensity while still managing to maintain homogeneity
of the field. For example, a palm-size NMR, which uses 5.5
Relative Magnetic Field Intensity

permanent magnets, has been introduced recently and it is able 5

to provide a homogenous field intensity of 0.7 Tesla [10, 11]. 4.5

This is remarkable as NMR devices have traditionally been 4


very large. Also, by using permanent magnets, the cost of 3.5
NMR devices can be drastically reduced. Therefore, there is a
lot of potential for the development of a low cost NMR
3

devices in near future. 2.5

2
B. NMR Spectroscopy Systems
1.5
The NMR spectroscopy system that was primarily used in -1800 -1600 -1400 -1200 -1000 -800
Frequency (-Hz)
-600 -400 -200 0

this research was the Bruker Ultrashield NMR Avance 400.


This NMR system works by varying the frequency while Fig. 2: A Typical NMR Blood Spectrum
keeping the magnetic field constant. This produces a spectrum
that displays the frequency response of the material under The system was first tested by observing how much blood it
study. Therefore all the ratios that cause resonance can be would take to mask the glucose spectrum. Therefore, to know
determined from the peaks of the spectrum. The maximum the approximate ratio of blood to mix with glucose solution, a
frequency of the device is 400 MHz with magnetic field of preliminary test was conducted to see the extent of the
9.39 Tesla. glucose and other element in blood resonate at distortion caused by the blood signal. The test samples were:
similar frequency ranges. The system can be modeled as a • pure glucose solution (450μL)
cascaded system where the output signal in the time domain is • glucose solution (449μL) with 1μL of blood
the convolution of the input impulse and the different • glucose solution (440μL) with 10μL of blood
resonance signals emitted by each constituent in the sample as • glucose solution (400μL) with 50μL of blood
depicted in Fig. 1. This can be modeled as follow: According to the experimental protocol approved by the
(1) university IRB committee, the participating subject must first
sign the consent form. All blood samples were taken at the
In the case of a sample which contains a mixture of blood university health clinic with the help of trained professionals
cells, hemoglobin, glucose, the output signal is: while observing the regulations. The blood had a glucose level
(2) of approximately 94 mg/dL when it was taken. The NMR

978-4799-8422-0/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
Proceedings of the 8th IEEE GCC Conference and Exhibition, Muscat, Oman, 1-4 February, 2015
spectra were then obtained as shown (zoomed in on the elements to calculate the ratio. The ratio for all samples was
glucose region) in Fig. 3. Results show that the blood was not calculated using the same procedure described in Fig. 4.
severely masking the glucose signal even when 50μL of blood
was added to 400μL pure glucose solution. This test was
beneficial because it showed the scope of how much blood
should be added for the other tests. It also shed some light on
the behavior of NMR signals when the volume of blood was
altered.
100 mg/dL Glucose Solution with Added Blood

Control
20000 1uL added blood
10uL added blood
50uL added blood
Relative Magnetic Field Intensity

15000

10000

5000

-1500 -1450 -1400 -1350 -1300 -1250


Frequency (-Hz)

Fig. 3: Results of First Set of Samples

C. System Calibration
The NMR introduces some fluctuations and random error
to every sample, therefore simply taking the amplitude does not
represent the concentration. One possible solution is to
compare the ratio of spectrum area occupied by the glucose to
that of blood, i.e:
A C
(5) Fig. 4: The Algorithm Block Diagram
A C

Simpson's rule was used to calculate the area. The glucose It was observed that the ratios were increasing as expected
concentration in the human subject's blood was naturally with glucose concentration since the other elements are
increased by asking the subject to take honey. For calibration relatively constant in comparison to glucose. These calculated
purposes, the glucose concentration of the subject was ratios are plotted in the calibration curve depicted in Fig. 5. As
measured using the standard glucose meter available at the can be seen, the linearity coefficient of determination, R2 is
clinic. The glucose concentration of this young university 0.96. This calibration curve will then be used to calculate the
student subject was measured at different times after taking unknown concentration of a glucose sample.
honey and found to be 120mg/dL, 100mg/dL, 95mg/dL and
92mg/dL. The blood samples were processed in the NMR
machine along with one pure reference glucose sample that had Test 1 Calibration Curve
a concentration of 100 mg/dL. Then, the following procedure 500
obtained values

was implemented using Matlab. The glucose-only sample was 400 y = 6.38x - 312.44
set as a reference, followed by scaling accomplished by
300 R² = 0.96
multiplying the glucose 100 mg/dL reference with the ratio of
the sample under test to the first sample. This way the error of 200
the NMR will also apply to the reference which eventually 100
made our calibration curve time and subject independent.
Then the areas of the glucose and blood sample spectra are 0
calculated. This is followed by dividing the reference glucose 0 50 100 150
spectrum by that of the sample under test. The result is the
spectrum that represents the concentration of other elements in glucose concentration (mg/dL)
blood. The area of spectrum of other elements is measured. Fig. 5: Calibration Curve
Finally the area of glucose will be divided by that of the other

978-4799-8422-0/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
Proceedings of the 8th IEEE GCC Conference and Exhibition, Muscat, Oman, 1-4 February, 2015
This algorithm was then applied on a sample taken from the areas within the same sample; hence, the glucose spectrum
same subject with 92mg/dL. The calculated concentration was area was compared with the other elements spectrum area and
found to be 89.12mg/dL with 3.13% error. This result was the ratio of the areas equal the ratio of concentration.
encouraging which prompted us to conduct more tests on According to the initial test it was seen that the other elements
another subject. have relatively constant concentration in comparison to
glucose which changes much more rapidly. Finally, each set of
III. RESULTS samples had a different calibration curve but this problem was
The algorithm described above was further tested on fixed by scaling the reference glucose spectrum which made
another human subject. Calibration was conducted using all the sets fit on one global calibration curve that is subject
samples with concentrations 85, 108, 123, 137, and 163 mg/dL and time independent. There are still some errors which are
as measured using the glucose meter available in the mainly due to random experimental errors such as uncertainty
university clinic. Fig. 6 shows the calibration curve for this of ±5 and small alterations in the intervals that were used to
new subject. compute the areas. More tests need to be carried out in order
to improve calibration curve and the results.

Test 2 Calibration Curve


600 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
obtained values

Our team would like to thank everyone who contributed and


400 helped with this research work. Special thanks to the Lab
200 instructors and Health Center at the American University of
Sharjah for allowing the team to oversee the experiments
0 during their own time.
0 50 100 150 200
glucose concentration (mg/dL) REFERENCES
[1] S. Updike, G. Hicks, “The enzyme electrode”, Nature, Vol. 214, pp.
Fig. 6: Calibration Curve of subject 2 986–988, 1967.
[2] A. Caduff, M. Talary, P. Zakharov, “Cutaneous blood perfusion, as a
perturbing factor for noninvasive glucose monitoring”, Diabetes Technol
The glucose concentration was tested on this subject 7 days Ther, Vol. 12, pp. 1–9, 2010.
later. The glucose concentration of the new sample is [3] G. Dongmin, D. Zhang, L. Zhanga, L. Guangming “Non-invasive blood
71mg/dL as measured by the glucose meter and was found to glucose monitoring for diabetics by means of breath signal analysis”,
be 62mg/dL as measured using our proposed NMR method Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical, Volume 173, pp. 106–113, October
2012.
with 14.1% error. The linearity and sensitivity were lower in
[4] A. Tura, A. Maran, G. Pacini, “Non-invasive glucose monitoring:
comparison to the previous test. This is mainly because of assessment of technologies and devices according to quantitative
human and experimental errors. The glucose concentration of criteria”, Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice, Vol. 77, pp.16–40,
the blood could change in the time between taking the 2007.
measurement and obtaining the blood samples and the [5] S. Vashist, “Non-invasive glucose monitoring technology in diabetes
invasive glucose meter had ±5 level of uncertainty. The curve management: A review”, Analytica Chimica Acta, Vol. 750, pp. 16–27,
2012.
obtained from this procedure was close to the previous
[6] J. Hornak, “The Basics of NMR”, Rochester, NY: Center for Imaging
procedure if the errors were neglected. Hence the calibration Science, Rochester Institute of Technology, 1999.
curve could be universal because this was done on a different [7] T. Pierre, P. Clark, A. Fleming, " Noninvasive measurement and
subject. Using these algorithms the concentration of the added imaging of liver iron concentrations using proton magnetic resonance",
sample was calculated but with an error; given that this sample TRANSFUSION MEDICINE, July 15, 2004.
was taken from the same subject a week later. Again the error [8] R. Gruetter, E. Novotnyf,, S. Boulwareo, " Direct measurement of brain
glucose concentrations in humans by 13C NMR spectroscopy," , Vol.
is due to random and instrumental errors. 89 , pp. 1109-1112, February 1992.
[9] [9] A. Taxitiemuer, Y. Yimamu, P. Mohemaiti, " Serum Metabonomic
Study of 2 Uyghur Probable MODY Families Based on 1H NMR,"
IV. CONCLUSIONS Journal of Diabetes and Metabolism, April 15, 2011.
The proposed NMR method shows to be a promising :http://www.omicsonline.org/2155-6156/2155-6156-2-122.php.
technique for measuring glucose in the blood. The other [10] [10] P. Patel, "Palm-Size NMR" Technology Review MIT, June 10,
2010. :http://www.technologyreview.com/biomedicine/25527/.
elements in blood do not mask the whole spectrum and,
because NMR represent blood as a cascaded system of [11] [X. Zhang, V. Mahesh, R. Hubbard, " Design, construction and NMR
testing of a 1 tesla Halbach Permanent Magnet for Magnetic
different elements; glucose can be filtered by dividing the Resonance," , 2005.
output with the other elements. The NMR introduces a random
error for every test but this can be cancelled by comparing the

978-4799-8422-0/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE

Вам также может понравиться