Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SCM PROJECT
OUTSOURCING TREND IN INDIAN
INDUSTRIES
GROUP 6 SECTION A
8/15/2010
ROHIT RAJ| RANDHIR KUMAR | SMRITI RANI| DHEERAJ PRASANTH | HARA PRASAD
PRADHAN| ANU MONAL MINZ| RAJAT KUMAR
Table of Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The growth prospects of the logistics sector are closely linked to economic growth and foreign
trade. Third-party logistics (3PL) or logistics outsourcing is gaining importance as more and more
corporations across the world, unable to manage their complex supply chains, are outsourcing
logistics activities to the 3PL or logistics service providers. By outsourcing logistics activities,
corporations are able to not only concentrate on their core business operations, but also achieve
cost-efficiency and improve delivery performance and customer satisfaction. Now outsourcing is
seen as a strategic way to align the supply chain with the company direction and to become a
leading-edge practitioner. It is also recognized as a tactical way to better manage service and costs.
Global sourcing is now a competitive requirement of doing business. This perceived survival
imperative has created an extended supply chain, as to distance and time, which has a menu of
supplier and logistics demands. Directing the offshore supply chain, as to costs, performance,
inventory, visibility, collaboration, integration and agility is an imperative for corporate success
Supply chain outsourcing is catching up big in India. Though India lags behind its global developed
peers like USA and China in having logistics cost contributing high 13% of GDP. Indian companies
also lag in outsourcing their supply chain. Only 55% of Indian companies outsource their supply
chain in any form. But Indian supply chain outsourcing industry is experiencing good growth in
recent years. The number of participants in this industry had grown to be more than 600 by year
2009. The 3PL industry has been growing at cumulative average growth rate of 21.4% in the last 5
years. But still there are several challenges to Indian supply chain outsourcing industry.
Unorganized logistics players corner 85% of the Indian logistics market. These unorganized players
don’t pay taxes avoid regulations. Hence they can provide service at cheaper cost. And logistics is
an industry with high costs and wafer thin margins.
But outlook for the industry is very promising with imminent introduction of GST and Direct Tax
Code by 2011. Right now major problem of national level players is multiplicity of taxes on goods.
Situation is so bad that it is not economical to have a central warehouse because states charge sales
tax on goods where it is sold. So if a good produced is sent to store at one state and sent to different
state then it taxed two times, so upcoming tax reforms are expected to give major boost to logistics
industry of India.
Then in this project we have analysed supply chain outsourcing in automobile industry. Automobile
industry is one of the biggest sectors of Indian economy. India is 7th largest producer and consumer
of automobiles. And in the last concluded month indian automobile sales grew at the rate of 37%
even outstripping the 15% growth achieving by Chinese automobile economy. Spare parts logistics
is very critical for automobile industry. And we have analysed spare parts logistics industry. Then
we have looked at supply chain outsourcing done at various stages of supply chain of Bajaj the 2nd
largest 2 wheeler producer of the country
OBJECTIVES
Objectives of the project were
(1) Analysis of trend in supply chain outsourcing in India
(2) Determination of different providers of different 3pl services in India. And determination of
the services they provide
(3) Analysis of trend of supply chain outsourcing in automobile industry
(4) Analysis of spare parts logistics outsourcing industry
(5) Analysis of supply chain of Bajaj auto and the kind of outsourcing in its supply chain
INTRODUCTION
Outsourcing is having work or an activity done by people who are not employees of the company. It
is not new in logistics. Outsourcing existed before the topic earned a name and became business
chic.
What has evolved with outsourcing is the growth and amount of functions placed with outside firms
and has created new businesses with 4PLs and 3PLs. Initially, the outsourced functions often
represented non-core or non-vital activities or some other determinant where the company did not
want to invest its own resources--capital, people, technology and facilities. Now outsourcing is seen
as a strategic way to align the supply chain with the company direction and to become a leading-
edge practitioner. It is also recognized as a tactical way to better manage service and costs.
There are following types of players in supply chain defined by their role in supply chain
outsourcing:
1PL: A First-party logistics provider (abbreviated 1PL) is a firm or an individual that needs
4PL: A Fourth-party logistics provider (abbreviated 4PL), lead logistics provider, or 4th Party
Logistics provider, is a consulting firm specialized in logistics, transportation, and supply chain
management. Typical fourth-party logistics providers are Theodore Wille Intertrade (TWI) , CPCS
(CPCS_transcom), Deloitte, WS Logistics, Procurus BMT Limited, Rollins andAccenture.
Accenture described the 4PL as an "integrator that assembles the resources, capabilities, and
technology of its own organization and other organizations to design, supply chain solutions"
3PL: A firm that provides multiple logistics services for use by customers. Preferably, these
services are integrated, or "bundled" together, by the provider. Among the services 3PLsprovide are
transportation, warehousing, cross-docking, inventory management, packaging, and freight
forwarding."
There are following four categories of 3PL providers
Standard 3PL provider: this is the most basic form of a 3PL provider. They would perform
activities such as, pick and pack, warehousing, and distribution (business) – the most basic
functions of logistics. For a majority of these firms, the 3PL function is not their main activity.
Service developer: this type of 3PL provider will offer their customers advanced value-added
services such as: tracking and tracing, cross-docking, specific packaging, or providing a unique
security system. A solid IT foundation and a focus on economies of scale and scope will enable this
type of 3PL provider to perform these types of tasks.
The customer adapter: this type of 3PL provider comes in at the request of the customer and
essentially takes over complete control of the company’s logistics activities. The 3PL provider
improves the logistics dramatically, but do not develop a new service. The customer base for this
type of 3PL provider is typically quite small.
The customer developer: this is the highest level that a 3PL provider can attain with respect to its
processes and activities. This occurs when the 3PL provider integrates itself with the customer and
takes over their entire logistics function. These providers will have few customers, but will perform
extensive and detailed tasks for them.
BENEFITS OF OUTSOURCING
Following are typical benefits of supply chain outsourcing;
• Improvement in customer satisfaction
• Improvement in logistics system performance
• Reduction in capital investment in facilities
• Reduction in capital investment in equipment
• Reduction in investment in information technology
• Impact on employee morale
• Reduction in manpower cost
• Improvement in specific logistics function parameters
• Improvement in inventory turnover rates
• Improvement in on-time delivery
• Increasing productivity
About 55.4 per cent respondents indicated that their organizations use third party logistics services,
while 44.6 per cent do not currently outsource logistics functions to third party logistics service
providers. Of those organizations currently outsourcing logistics services, 82.3 per cent indicated
that their firms employed the services of more than one logistics service provider. Furthermore, 28.6
per cent of these have been using the services of third party logistics service providers for over three
years. Another 18.8 per cent have been working with third party logistics service providers for 1-3
years. This indicates a relatively low amount of experience with third party logistics service
providers in India as a result of which the concept of outsourcing logistics functions to third party
logistics service providers is still in its nascent stage in India. This is in contrast to studies
conducted in developed countries like North America, Europe, Australia and Singapore.
Out of the total no of respondents, more than half the organizations have already outsourced
logistics activities such as outbound transportation (55.7 per cent), inbound transportation (52.2 per
cent) and custom clearing and forwarding (51.5 per cent). Other logistics activities that have been
outsourced by more than a fourth of the respondents are import and export management (34.5 per
cent), outbound warehousing (33.9 per cent), inbound warehousing (29.5 per cent), labelling and
packing (29 per cent), fleet management and consolidation (28.6 per cent), order picking (27 per
cent) and inventory management (23.5 per cent) indicating that these are the more important
services that are already being outsourced. The logistics functions that are least outsourced include
marketing sales promotion, assembly/installation, selected manufacturing and customer
service/support.
To determine why organizations decide to outsource certain logistics functions, respondents were
asked to indicate the importance of the same set of logistics functions on a five-point Likert scale,
with a score of 1 indicating “not important” and a score of 5 indicating “very important”. The
responses to importance rating and the extent of outsourcing of all logistics functions are presented
in following figure.
The test results clearly explain the variation in outsourcing percentage for logistics
activities by Indian organizations.
.
Importance rating . 4.00. Logistics activities with “high” importance rating include customer
service/support, inventory management and rate negotiations. Less than 25 per cent organizations
have outsourced these activities to 3PL service providers primarily because of the criticality of the
information related to them and the strategic nature of these activities to impact business results.
Organizations using 3PL services for these activities have been working with 3PL service providers
over an extended period of time and rate the effectiveness of performance of top management of
3PL service providers as “high”.
.
Importance rating < 4.00 and . 3.25. Usage of 3PL services is exceptionally high for logistics
activities with a “moderate” importance rating between 4.00 and 3.25. Outbound transportation,
inbound transportation and customer clearing and forwarding are outsourced by maximum
percentage of respondents. Distribution (22.9 per cent), order fulfilment (20.4 per cent) and select
manufacturing (16.4 per cent) require organization-specific strategies from 3PL service providers
and hence score low on outsourcing percentage. Customized solutions at an operating level by 3PL
service providers could provide immense benefits for improving supply chain results for Indian
organizations in these three areas. Increased 3PL services for order picking, order warehousing,
labelling and packaging, import/export management, inbound warehousing, and fleet management
and consolidation depict the increased service offering by 3PL service providers and the growing
confidence in their services by Indian organizations.
.
Importance rating of < 3.25. Currently less than 25 per cent organizations use 3PL services for these
activities because of their “low” importance ratings. However, usage of 3PL services for reverse
logistics shows increasing trends.
Then organizations were asked on their reasons for outsourcing. We get the following results :
Following is the LPI( logistics performance indicator) scores of some select countries. India was
way behind in the rankings in the 30th place, way behind developed countries and China. But it was
best performing country in the countries in low income group.
The major reason for this is under penetration of organized sector in logistics sector in India.
Organized sector contributes to only 10-15% of logistics sector in India. And in the organized sector
only 6% is contributed by 3PL. While in developed countries like Japan 80% of companies
outsource their supply chain. In India only 55% of multinational outsource their supply chain. But
organized logistics is expected to grow at very rapid rate in the country with the imminent opening
of FDI in retail sector.
The Automobile industry in India is the seventh largest in the world with an annual production of
over 2.6 million units in 2009. In 2009, India emerged as Asia's fourth largest exporter of
automobiles, behind Japan, South Korea and Thailand. By 2050, the country is expected to top the
world in car volumes with approximately 611 million vehicles on the nation's roads.
Following economic liberalization in India in 1991, the Indian automotive industry has
demonstrated sustained growth as a result of increased competitiveness and relaxed restrictions.
Several Indian automobile manufacturers such as Tata Motors, Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra and
Mahindra, expanded their domestic and international operations. India's robust economic growth led
to the further expansion of its domestic automobile market which attracted significant India-specific
investment by multinational automobile manufacturers. In February 2009, monthly sales of
passenger cars in India exceeded 100,000 units.
The biggest share of Service parts logistics comes from Automotive Sector. Following are the main
players in the service parts logistics market in India:
(1)TVS logistics
(2) Reliance logistics
(3) DHL
(4) CEVA
BAJAJ AUTO
Bajaj Auto was founded in 1945.It is India's second largest two wheeler manufacturer and the
world's 4th largest two and three-wheeler manufacturer. It is based in Pune. with plants in Akurdi
and Chakan (Pune), Waluj and Pantnagar in Uttaranchal Currently It holds a market share of 22%
over all two wheeler industry and a phenomenon 71% share in 125- 250 cc category. It has a joint
venture with Kawasaki and 31.72 % stake in Australian based company KTM
With operations spanning to such vast geographies, managing a supply chain globally becomes
more and more complex. In countries where Bajaj perceives a strong market potential, they
establish a tie up with one major industrial establishment eager to invest in the project. This
investment may include setting up strategic manufacturing or assembly units, apart from a well-
established nation-wide network for marketing, distribution and after sales services. These investors
who form alliances with Bajaj Auto are termed as “Business Partners”.
Bajaj Auto offers a number of services to its business partners. They include:
• Training in sales, service and spare parts management based on the Bajaj distribution system
• Active support for setting up manufacturing facilities overseas including transfer of
technical know-how
• Assistance in setting up an assembly plant for assembly of vehicles from complete knocked
down (CKD) kits
• Selecting of machinery and equipment and training of technical personnel, all in a phased
manner as required by the regulations in the recipient country
SPARE PARTS
Automobiles need periodic replacement of parts. Not surprisingly therefore, spare parts comprise a
profitable business for major automobile manufacturers. The objectives of the spare parts business
of Bajaj Auto are to perform an effective role in supporting new vehicle sales, maintain ‘vehicle
goodwill’ across different geographies, makes and consumer groups, and contribute to the bottom-
line.
Challenge: To make the company’s spare parts available in not just the authorised service centres
but also the private garages and spare part shops that dot the country. This is a high volume, credit
intensive business that requires mastery over the supply of heterogeneous products.
Solution: In 2004-05, Bajaj Auto created a separate channel exclusively for distribution of spare
parts. Today, the channel has 73 distributors, who cater directly to over 15,000 retail shops across
the country. This channel now accounts for sales of over 70% of total spare parts of Bajaj Auto Ltd.
Other 30% is distributed via the distribution channel of the bike itself.
SAP IMPLEMENTATION
Bajaj Auto ltd. is India’s largest manufacturer of two- and three-wheeler vehicles. Spare parts
distribution, critical to the servicing of the vehicles, is handled through a network of 400 dealers
and
15 distributors. Spare parts are distributed from four warehouses that are strategically located across
the country. The process that bajaj Auto was using to manage the supply of spare parts across the
distribution network was inefficient, did not produce accurate results, and was unsuitable for the
increasing complexities of distribution. to keep track of its safety stock, amounting to over 14,000
different items, the company was using a cumbersome manual process that was neither timely nor
accurate. And lack of visibility of order status resulted in inventory problems at sales outlets
because needed items didn’t always get priority during packing and shipping. This combination of
problems affected service level in the marketplace, leading to customer dissatisfaction. At the same
time, high inventory levels at the warehouses meant increased amounts of non moving stock, which
had an impact on the dealers’ working capital.
So Bajaj Auto implemented “Go Live” of their External Portal Initiative for their sales and
service employees, dealers and suppliers. SAP’s mySAP Enterprise Portal was implemented
simultaneously with the current SAP R/3 ERP implementation. Business information is available to
the company’s external community in real time. This assists in improved decision-making, whether
it is to meet customer requirements or to maintain efficiency in supply chain management. The
company’s field sales teams get full visibility on all dealer activities while the dealers get real-time
access to relevant information on operational activities. The dealers and sales employees get
information relevant to their respective region and territory by aggregation from the underlying SAP
R/3 ERP database. Bajaj has linked 380 out of its 483 dealers through this system. Also connected
are 165 out of a total of 200 suppliers. The dealer portal, in addition to operating information,
provides access to unstructured information like news items, new product releases, new product
introduction, dealer discussion groups and internal marketplace. The supplier gets up-to-date
information on purchase orders and contracts, material schedules, and payment details. Bajaj Auto,
in turn, gets invoicing information from suppliers for its automated material receipt system. This
helps in streamlining the supply chain, optimising inventories and reducing non-value-adding
activities at both ends.
In order to cater to a widespread network of dealers, distribution is a challenge for Bajaj Auto. Here
the concept of “business partners” comes in. Bajaj has tried leveraging the existing distribution
network of the “business partner” in the country where the partner is present. Bajaj Auto has also
set up assembling units in few of the continental hubs. These continental hubs act as goods
receivers from the manufacturing units of Bajaj in India. The logistics for this is outsourced to third
party vendors like Maersk Sealand, P&O Nedloyd and APL.
There is an exisisting generic channel which is used for segmentation of this category of two-
wheelers and three wheelers.
GENERIC CHANNEL
Figure 18: Generic distribution channel of Bajaj Auto
The physical flow of goods takes place from the factory to either the depot or to the carrying
and forwarding agent, depending upon the geographic distance and the location of the Depot. The
transport & logistics for this is outsourced to third party vendors which are under Transport
Corporation of India (TCI). Depending upon the demand these goods have, they flow from Depot or
the C&F agent to the dealer and their network. In case of high profile dealers, the dealer can
himself take the physical delivery of goods directly from the manufacturing plant. The dealer, at
the last juncture, caters ASC, RSO, Sub Dealer & its own branch
MANUFACTURING PLANT
Bajaj Auto’s vehicle manufacturing capacity currently stands at 3.96 million units — comprising
3.6 million two-wheelers and 360,000 three-wheelers. The newest plant at Pantnagar (Uttarakhand)
has a capacity to produce 900,000 two-wheelers.
Figure 19: Plant capacity at Bajaj Auto plant
The company’s first plant at Akurdi which was a vehicle assembly unit was shut down in
September 2007. The reason for doing so was the higher cost of manufacturing, which placed this
location at a disadvantageous position compared to the other facilities.
This function of distribution is not owned by the company in any form. This is outsourced in toto to
the third party vendors. The third party here is Transport Corporation of India (TCI) and a few other
private vendors. The fleet to be transported is custom-designed for Bajaj Auto by the vendor.
Key Facts
TCI looks after the packaging of the bike from the manufacturing unit to its delivery upto the
warehouse of the dealer or to the depot, as required. In the above example, one truck or a single
factory load can carry either 43 premium bikes or 53 general bikes. Depending upon the product
mix ordered by the dealer, the truck is loaded. It can then either go to the dealer’s warehouse
directly or to the depot, as depicted in the generic channel. From the depot, these bikes are loaded in
smaller fleet and distributed to the respective dealer. In this case, the fleet size is 28 premium bikes
or 35 general bikes. This load is termed as Depot Load.
CONCLUSION
Logistics is one the most important and integral part of any organisations strategy and function.
When the logistical process is carried out accurately then not only the company reduces the
production cost but also improves the efficiency and customer satisfaction. Overall logistics
management is very important for today’s highly competitive and cut- throat corporate world.
Third-party logistics or 3PL is growing around the world as more and more corporations prefer
to outsource their logistics operations to the 3PL or logistics service providers. The 3PL market
in India is still in its infancy and is highly fragmented. However, there is a high potential for
growth of the market, which was evident from the survey of the Indian logistics service
providers. The respondents held the poor infrastructure and the lack of awareness and trust
among the Indian firms responsible for the low growth of 3PL in India so far. However, more
and more Indian firms are becoming aware of the benefits of 3PL and outsourcing a part or
whole of their logistics-related activities to the service providers. With respect to developing the
infrastructure, the Indian Government has already taken some initiatives, which may be
facilitated by allowing private investments in this sector. The Government should identify
investments in infrastructure that will lead to the growth of 3PL, as one of the thrust areas as this
would not only contribute to the GDP, but also generate employment. The policies and
procedures also have to be simplified to speed up the process of service delivery
Nevertheless outlook for supply chain outsourcing is still very rosy in India. Govt. is doing the
reforms. Logistics sector has 100% FDI allowed so several foreign companies are entering India.
Just 3-4 months ago Hitachi entered into logistics industry of India by acquiring an Indian firm.
REFERENCES
(1) www.wikipedia.com
(2) www.ibef.org
(3) 3PL practices: an Indian perspective B. S. Sahay and Ramneesh Mohan
(4) Indian Auto Supply Chain at the cross-roads Karthik Balakrishnan, Ananth Iyer, Sridhar
Seshadri, Anshul Sheopuri
(5) Strategies for Enhancing Competitiveness of Indian Auto Component Industries Dr.
Kamala TN Prof. Doreswamy AG
(6) A Survey of the Third-Party Logistics (3PL) Service Providers in India by Subrata Mitra,
IIM Calcutta Working paper series
(7) Bajaj Auto, annual report 2009-10, annual report 2008-9
(8) www.scribd.com/doc/28073759/Analysis-of-Indian-Logistics-Sector
(9) Bajaj auto Simplifying Spare parts planning and distribution from http:\\download.sap.com
(10) http://www.frost.com/prod/servlet/market-insight-top.pag?docid=74102578