Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ABSTRACT
ARTICLE INFO AIM: The aim was to investigate the effects of the
Article History: neurodevelopmental based goal directed therapy (GD-NDT) on
Received: Feb 25, 2015 the motor functions, daily living activities of children with CP.
Accepted: April 12, 2015 METHOD: 26 children with spastic CP, 14 males (53.8%) and 12
Published: April 28, 2015 females (46.2%) ,mean age 9.5 ± 3.2 years were included.
GMFCS levels were, I in 42.3%, II in 3.8% level, III in 15.4%, IV in
11.5% and V in 26.9%. GD-NDT was applied 3 times a week for 12
weeks.
RESULTS: Positive developments after therapy were identified
AUTHORS AFFILIATIONS in the gross motor functions of the children (p<0,01), in the self-
1
Hacettepe University, Faculty of Health Sciences, Department care, transfer, and locomotion subscales of the independence
of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation levels measured with WeeFIM (p<0.05), the "Physical Function",
2
Turgut Ozal University, S c h o o l of P h y s i c a l Therapy and "Role Limitations due to the Emotional/Behavioral Causes",
Rehabilitation "Pain", "Behavior", "Mental Health", "Self Care", "General
3
Hacettepe University, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Health", and "Family Activities," subscales of CHQ-PF50
Biostatistics (p<0.05). There was no c ha nge in muscle tone a n d
ankle dorsiflexion selective motor control after treatment
(p>0.05). The goals identified for the children before treatment
Correspondence: Mintaze Kerem Gunel, Hacettepe University,
were involved self-care 15.4%, physical activity 17.9%,
Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Physiotherapy and
locomotion and transfer 37.2%, social status and living
Rehabilitation, 06100, Samanpazarı, Ankara. Email:
activities 29.5%. 76.9% of the goals identified were reached;
mintaze@hacettepe.edu.tr
23.1% were not reached.
CONCLUSION: Improvements were found in gross motor
functions, independence in daily life and health related
quality of life of children with CP who were taken GD-NDT.
INTRODUCTION
Cerebral palsy (CP) is a developmental disorder characterized
by a group of movement and postural disorders that occur as
2
a result of a lesion in the cerebral motor centers and one of
the most common reason for childhood physical disability1.
3
Although the lesion is not progressive , the disorder
influences the child's life from an early stage and the effects on
the musculoskeletal system changes with the growing of the
child. Emerging problems may affect the child's daily living skills
and planning treatment program should support the motor
function development and goal facilitating the child's
4,5
participation in activities and adaptation to daily living .
Goal-directed therapy (GDT) aims to gradually increase
independence in daily living activities and improve functional
5
performance . This approach is based on the neuronal group
selection theory and dynamic systems theory that make up the
6,8
theoretical framework of motor control . GDT includes
Türker D et al., International Journal of Therapies and Rehabilitation Research 2015; 4 (4): 9-20
activities directed at the individualized goals, taking the child's alignment in the children. We identified the aim of our study as
learning potential into account. Phased grading of the child's investigating the effects of neurodevelopmental based goal-
designated enables developing an individualized plan for the directed treatment approach on motor functions of children
child to learn goal-directed activities and reach the goals and with CP and their daily living activities.
also makes it possible to individually evaluate treatment results. METHOD
GDT approach is a family-centered attitude which requires Participants:
4,6
the compliance of the child and the family . General treatment A total of 30 children with CP were included in the study. At the
approaches usually focus on normalizing the dysfunctional beginning of the study the parents of the children were
6,7
control of posture and movement in these children . informed about the research study and signed an informed
Neurodevelopmental treatment (NDT) consists of regulating consent form stating that they participated voluntarily. Our
neural-based motor responses in the central nervous system. study was approved by the Hacettepe University ethical
The NDT approach is continuing to develop and is now committee for non-interventional clinical trials. (Ethical
considered an approach instead of a method. It includes the Committee: GO 13/97). Inclusion criteria: a) CP diagnosis, b)
principles of providing CP children with a normal movement between 5 and 17 years of age; Exclusion criteria: a)
experience to minimize motor-sensory disturbances and Administration of Botulinum Toxin-A injection or surgery within
provide functional independence during activities. Other
the last 6 months. One of the children was undergone to
important principles it includes are emphasizing the child's
8 surgical procedure, 1 was administered Botulinum Toxin-A and 2
personal development and cognitive characteristics .
left the study so these children were excluded from the study.
The goal attainment scale (GAS) is used for determine goal-
The study was completed with 26 children with CP. A total of
directed treatment's effectiveness and it is a sensitive
26 spastic children with CP consisting of 14 males and 12
evaluation tool that demonstrates changes in the performance
9 females were included in the study. The mean age of the
of the goal that is important for the child and family and is
children included in the study was 9.5 ± 3.2 years. The GMFCS
widely used to individually evaluate the progress of
10 levels were I in 42.3%, II in 3.8% level, III in 15.4%, IV in
rehabilitation . This scale evaluates clinically significant
11.5% and V in 26.9%. The MACS levels were I in 23.1%, II in
qualitative changes and developments and individual goal
26.9%, III in 15.4%, IV in 15.4% and V in 19.2%.
achievement according to the age group. The sensitivity of GAS
for the activity and accuracy dimensions is higher than the Research Design:
commonly used standardized functional scales. While GAS Our study was a prospective interventional study aiming to
enables the measurement or achievement of movement reveal the effectiveness of the GD-NDT. The parents of the
development or functional objectives, it also associates these children who participated in the study were asked for
11 information on the socio-demographic and descriptive
goals with sociability and functionality . The international
classification of health, disability and functionality for characteristics of themselves and the children. The gross motor
children and young people (ICF- CY) is the structural basis for function levels of the children, the severity of CP, muscle tone,
physiotherapy and rehabilitation assessments and program ankle dorsiflexion, selective motor control function, the
12,13
planning . ICF-CY, provides a conceptual framework to topographic distribution of CP, hand functions, loss of function
define health information such as diagnosis and functionality and health related quality of life levels were evaluated.
and therefore defines the child's problems in association with
Three goals were identified for each child before the treatment
the function and anatomical features, activity limitations and
12,14,15 process. The GD-NDT program was applied to the children three
participation problems . It is very important for
times in a week for 12 weeks. The goals were selected based on
physiotherapists to adopt the ICF-CY model when in
the cooperation of the professional rehabilitation team and the
determining their assessment methods, both in terms of the
14 family including the child itself. We made sure the goals were
decision making process and to obtain meaningful results . In
specific, achievable and appropriate for the purpose. The
line with this framework, the goals chosen in GAS in compliance
outcome measurements were repeated before the therapy and
with the ICF basis are selected with the cooperation of the
rehabilitation team and the family including the child as they after 12 weeks of therapy.
will define the problems of the child and guide the treatment. Intervention:
The identified goals should be specific, measurable, achievable,
relevant and timed (SMART). The right goal increases the The daily environment, gross motor function level, and cognitive,
motivation of the child and family and supports the child's social and emotional status of the child were taken into
6 account for goal selection while considering the ICF. The
learning .
How the goal will be realized is also very important in NDT. activities the child had difficulty in performing, how often
therefore we wanted to see the effect of adding the ability to they were performed during the day and how they were
perform the selected goal-directed motor functions without performed were determined. In addition, we determined how
pathological movements and without disturbing the body much the activities the child had difficulty with were reflected.
in his/her daily life. The goals were selected based on
cooperation of the profesionel rehabilitation team and the family
Türker D et al., International Journal of Therapies and Rehabilitation Research 2015; 4 (4): 9-20
including the child. Accordingly, individual GDT was planned by due to Emotional/Behavioral Causes", "Self Esteem", "Mental
considering the learning potential of the child in line with the Health", "Behavior", "Emotional Impact on Parents", "Influence
selected goals. The obstacles the child encountered while of Time on Parents", "Family Activities", and "Family
working towards the goals were identified in the therapy Harmony"25.
program. The main problem of each child was determined and Success in realizing the goals identified for the children was
an attempt made to solve it in stages. For standardizing determined with the goal attainment scale. GAS focuses on
environment, all children’s interventions were undergone in a individualized progress and is therefore a reliable evaluation
same rehabilitation center with same team. method for the measurement of changes after the treatment in
Outcome Measurements: both clinical and research applications. Each goal in GAS is
The gross motor function measurement scale (GMFM) was scored as -2 for poor, -1 for no change, 0 for goal realized, +1
used to determine the level of gross motor function of for goal realized above expected, and +2 for goal realized way
26,27
children. GMFM is a measurement system developed to identify above expected .
the motor functions of children with CP. It includes consecutive
normal physiological development activities such as supine, Table I: A goal example for a child at GMFCS Level V.
prone, four-point position, sitting, over the knee, standing, GAS Score Improvement example for turning activity
16
walking and climbing stairs . +2 Can turn in bed from one side to the
The severity of CP was identified using the Gross Motor other independently in 12 weeks.
Function Classification System (GMFCS & ER). GMFCS & ER is a +1 Can turn in bed from one side to the
5-level system used to classify the motor involvement severity. other with minimal physical help of
Level I is ambulation in the community or at home without the parent in 12 weeks.
17,18
restriction while Level V is no independent mobility at all . 0 Can turn in bed from one side to the
The "Manual Abilities Classification System" (MACS) was used in other with moderate physical help of
the evaluation of children's manual abilities. MACS evaluates the parent in 12 weeks.
the movements both hands perform together in children with -1 Cannot turn in bed from one side to
CP between the ages of 4 and 18. MACS classifies manual the other without minimum physical
abilities with 5 levels. Level I is holding and using objects help of the parent in 12 weeks.
easily and successfully while objects cannot be held or used at -2 Cannot turn in bed from one side to
level V where there is severely limited ability to perform even the other without moderate physical
19-20
simple activities . help of the parent in 12 weeks.
The muscle tonus of the children was evaluated using the
Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS). The muscle tonus is graded
between “0” and “4” with this scale. "0" shows no increase in Table II: A goal example for a child at GMFCS Level I.
muscle tone while "4" shows that the affected part is rigid in GAS Improvement example for cycling activity goal
21
flexion and extension . Score
The selective motor control (SMC) scale was used to evaluate +2 Can cycle more than 50 meters independently by using
the ankle dorsiflexors. The SMC scale has good intra-observer reciprocal leg.
22
and re-tests reliabilities . +1 Can cycle 50 meters by using reciprocal leg.
The functional status of the children was determined with the 0 Can cycle 10 meters by using reciprocal leg.
Functional Independence Measure for Children (WeeFIM), a -1 Progresses by cycling with unilateral leg on bicycle.
pediatric functional independence scale. WeeFIM contains a
-2 Has difficulty balancing on bicycle, needs minimal
total of 18 items in 6 fields including self-care (6), sphincter
physical support
control (2), transfers (3), locomotion (2), communication (2),
and social status (3). While "7" shows level of full
Statistical Analysis:
independence, "1" indicates that the child is fully
23,24 The statistical analyses were performed on the SPSS for
dependent .
Windows Version 15.0 package program. The numerical
The parent form (CHQ-PF50) of the Child Health Questionnaire
variables were summarized as mean ± standard deviation or
(CHQ) consisting of 50 questions was used to determine the
median [min- max] values. The qualitative variables were
health-related quality of life of the children. CHQ-PF50 consists
shown as numbers and percentages. The difference between
of 12 subscales including "Physical Function", "Role
preliminary and final test results was evaluated with the
Limitations due to Physical Causes ", "Pain", "General Health",
Wilcoxon sign test. The relationship between the numerical
"Role Limitations
variables was assessed with
Türker D et al., International Journal of Therapies and Rehabilitation Research 2015; 4 (4): 9-20
Table IV: İndependence levels of the children measured with
RESULTS WeeFIM before and after treatment.
The socio-demographic characteristics, MACS and GMFCS levels
and topographic distribution of the children who participated in Based After
our study are shown in Table III. WeeFIM Subscale GDT GDT
†
scores X ±SD X ±SD P Value
Table III: Socio-demographic characteristics Self-care 18.4 ± 19.9 ± .000
Table III: Socio-demographic characteristics N= 26 15.4 14.4
Age, X ± SD, year 9.5 ± 3.2 Sphincter control 8.3 ± 2.0 8.3 ± 2.0 1.000
Gender, n (%) Transfers 9.8 ± 8.1 10.71 ± .004
Male 14 (53.8) 7.9
Female 12 (46.2) Locomotion 7.03 ± 8.46 ± .001
CP Type: 5.7 5.0
Diplegia: 5 (19.2) Communication 10.61 ± 10.61 ± 1.000
Quadriplegia: 13 (50) 4.9 4.9
Hemiplegia 8 (30.8) Social status 14.6 ± 14.6 ± 1.000
GMFCS 7.5 7.5
Level I 11 (42.3) Total motor score 43.3 ± 46.8 ± .000
Level II 1 (3.8) 32.8 31.2
Level III 4 (15.4) Total cognitive score 25.2 ± 25.2 ± 1.000
Level IV 3 (11.5) 12.2 12.2
Level V 7 (26,9) Total WeeFIM score 65.8 ± 72.5 ± .000
MACS 43.9 40.9
Level I † : Wilcoxon sign test.
6 (23.1)
Level II 7 (26.9)
Statistically significant increases were obtained in the "Physical
Level III 4 (15.4)
Function", "Role Limitations due to the Emotional/Behavioral
Level IV 4 (15.4)
Causes", "Pain", "Behavior", "Mental Health", "Self Esteem",
Level V 5 (19.2)
"General Health", "Family Activities," subscales of the CHQ-
Statistically significant increases were found in the gross motor PF50 questionnaire filled by the parents compared to pre-
functions of the children after treatment (p= .00). No change was treatment (p<0.05). However, no statistically significant
seen in muscle tone and ankle dorsiflexion selective motor differences were found in the "Role Limitations due to the
control post-treatment evaluation (p>0.05). We also found no Physical Causes ", "Family Harmony”, "Emotional Impact on
change in the disability severity of the children after the Parents", and "Influence of Time on Parents" subscales
treatment (p>0.05). (p>0.05). (Table VI)
The goals identified involved self-care in 15.4%, physical activity
in 17.9%, locomotion and transfer in 37.2%, and social state and DISCUSSION:
life activities in 29.5%. We were able to achieve 76.9% (60/78) We found an increase in gross motor functions and certain
of the goals we had identified before GDT use. 23.1% (18/78) fields of health-related quality of life in this study where we
were not realized. There was a significant difference between investigated the effects of GD-NDT on motor functions and
pre-treatment and post-treatment GAS scores of the children daily living activities in children with CP.
(p<0.05). This study combines the goal directed therapy with the NDT.
The importance of GDT is well explained in the literature but
Table V presents the data regarding the independence levels of there is not any study with goal directed therapy based on
the children measured with WeeFIM before and after NDT principles. Additionally, relationship between goal directed
treatment. Although there was no statistically significant therapy and quality of life is also important for the literature.
difference in the sphincter control, communication and social CP ha s b e e n d e s c r i b e d in recent y e a r s as
state subscales before and after treatment (p> 0.05), there was mov em e nt a n d posture disorders creating activity
a statistically significant increase in the self-care, transfer and restrictions. ICF-CY is currently the structural basis in
locomotion subscales (p<0.05). This increase was also reflected physiotherapy and rehabilitation evaluations and program
planning. Using the ICF- CY model as the basis is important to
in the total WeeFIM score (p<0.05). 12,13,14,15
obtain meaningful results when planning therapy . The
most important outcome of GDT determined jointly by the
rehabilitation team and the family and child according to the
principle of motor learning is
Türker D et al., International Journal of Therapies and Rehabilitation Research 2015; 4 (4): 9-20
Türker D et al., International Journal of Therapies and Rehabilitation Research 2015; 4 (3): 9-14
Pre-treatment Post-treatment
†
Child Health Questionnaire Subscales X ±SD X ±SD P Value
Physical function 31.6 ± 33.4 35 ± 35.7 0.018
Role Limitations due to the Emotional/Behavioral Causes 63.2 ± 29.9 66.6 ± 31.8 0.020
Role Limitations due to Physical Causes 58.9 ± 34.0 60.2 ± 33.0 0.317