Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
10.1177/0898010105282511
Prater, of Holistic
/ Called
Nursing
to Nursing
Purpose: This study uncovers reasons students report for wanting to become nurses, to quantify those who feel that
they are called to nursing, and to learn what “being called” means to them. Method: A descriptive, cross-sectional sur-
vey was conducted with all students enrolled in nursing courses at one program in a private, faith-based university.
Findings: Most students decided to go to nursing school while in high school or college and chose nursing because they
had a desire to help others. The most common personal characteristics they identified that will be helpful in nursing
were being caring or compassionate. Almost two thirds of the students indicated they were “called” by God to become
nurses. Conclusion and Implications: Findings can help nursing educators and leaders determine how to better recruit
and retain individuals into the nursing profession and how to support and encourage caring and compassionate qualities
in all nurses.
several times that she became a nurse in answer to a study, and one small survey was located that described
divine call (Gaydos, 2001; Widerquist, 1992). the notion of nursing as a vocation. Bloom, O’Reilly,
Beginning in the second half of the 20th century, and Parlette (1979) examined professionalism among
nursing education moved from hospitals to colleges public health nurses, focusing on the nurses’ intent to
and universities, and values and beliefs shifted. Empha- organize into labor unions. Among the findings, the
sis moved away from serving humanity as nurses were researchers reported that older nurses were more
taught to view their role as a psychodynamic care pro- likely to view nursing as a calling than young nurses
vider rather than a nurturer. They learned to view the were. They compared the sense of calling to “Nightin-
nurse-patient relationship objectively and use a prob- galeism” (p. 45), which was described as the belief that
lem-solving process to provide nursing care. As nurs- one should be dutiful and deferential, contrasting it
ing education evolved, nursing moved away from the with “professionalism.”
conceptualization of vocation and calling and toward Raatikainen (1997) conducted a study examining
the conceptualization of profession. characteristics of proficient nurses. Among the vari-
ables she considered was the concept of calling. She
The Concept of Calling and Nursing Practice performed an analysis to see how a calling influences
professionalism and found that nurses who experi-
Despite the move to enhance professionalism, dur-
enced a calling worked at a high professional level. In
ing the past two decades, nursing scholars have reem-
addition, she determined that nurses who experienced
phasized that the essence or nature of nursing involves
a calling had better knowledge about patients’ needs
caring for and about others. This theme of caring about
than nurses who did not experience a calling and con-
others ties nursing to its past and the idea of calling
cluded that a calling is a strong resource that fosters
(Hawkins, 1999). Although little has been described in
proficiency among nurses.
the literature, when compared with other nurses,
Siccardi (1995) performed a “minisurvey” on nurs-
called nurses place greater emphasis on showing con-
ing as a vocation. She questioned several nurses from
cern and providing comfort, assisting the patient and
South America on their views of nursing and vocation.
family to find meaning in an illness, facilitating
The nurses in this survey defined vocation as a “natu-
expression of feelings, responding to spiritual distress,
ral gift in people that have a tendency to service or
and promoting actions aimed at seeking forgiveness
ministry” and “being called by God to ministry” (p. 9).
(Widerquist & Davidhizar, 1994).
The nurses overwhelmingly believed that nursing is a
Nurses who are called typically have deep personal,
vocation, and most reported that they became nurses to
religious beliefs or embrace humanitarian values.
help those who suffer and to serve.
They are aware of the meaning and importance of sup-
porting the spiritual needs of patients (i.e., through
prayer or reading scripture; Lane, 1987). Jeffries (1998)
Purpose of the Study
described several characteristics of a calling as it Because of the critical shortage of nurses that exist
relates to nurses. She stated that each calling is unique in many areas, it is important to encourage and nurture
and creates a passion for the work, and the calling those who view nursing as a calling and to learn how
requires special talents and expresses itself in enthusi- best to support them in their studies and practice. The
asm and energy for work. Jeffries also noted that following questions were addressed by the current
sometimes a calling is quite clear and may be inter- study:
preted as an order from God; however, other times a
calling may be subtle, manifested by a series of steps • What reasons do nursing students give for choosing to
that leads the individual to pursue nursing. pursue nursing as a career?
• What percentage of nursing students feel they were
Research Studies That Examine “called” to become nurses?
• What does being “called” mean to those students?
Nursing as a Calling
• Do students who believe they are called differ from
No research studies specifically addressing the con- students not called in such areas as self-reported per-
cept of nursing as a calling were identified in the litera- sonality traits, future practice preferences, and demo-
ture; however, two references were found that men- graphic characteristics (e.g., age, race and/or ethnic-
tioned the concept within the realm of another, larger ity, gender)?
Instrument Findings
The questionnaire was developed by the research-
ers following an in-depth review of the literature A total of 205 questionnaires were distributed (not
related to the concept of called to nursing. The ques- all students were present on the day the surveys were
tionnaire consisted of a group of open-ended questions administered), and 131 were returned completed for a
designed to gather information on motivations, response rate of 63.9%. As a group, the students at the
beliefs, and feelings students have about why they school of nursing were young, female, White, and
chose nursing and related issues. The original form unmarried. Indeed, an overwhelming majority of the
was circulated to five nursing school faculty for evalu- participating students (85%) were aged 20 to 24 years,
ation of readability and content validity. Their sugges- 12% were aged 25 to 40 years, and 3% stated that they
tions and feedback were incorporated into the question- were older than age 40 years. Most of the students
naire, which was then given to five graduate students for indicated that they were White (83.2%). Other race
additional comments related to content validity. Minor and/or ethnic groups and percentages were Black
modifications were made, and the final survey form (8.4%), Hispanic (4.6%), and Asian (3.1%); 1 student
comprised six open-ended questions and several did not answer.
demographic questions (i.e. age range, race and/or
ethnic group, gender) to be used for comparisons. Analysis of Responses
to Individual Questions
Procedure Analyses and exemplars for each survey question
The University’s Institutional Review Board are described here.
approved the study and questionnaire. A cover letter
explained the purpose of the project and ensured Question 1: “When did you decide you wanted to be a
respondents that participation was voluntary and nurse?”
answers would be confidential.
To guarantee possible inclusion of all students, The responses were coded based on whether the stu-
instructors teaching in each of the four semesters of dent reported becoming interested in nursing as a
the nursing program agreed to allow class time for data young child or early adolescent (before high school),
collection. In agreement with each course instructor, during high school or college, or as an adult. Based on
during one of the final class periods for the course, the these categories, 17.5% stated that they were younger
researchers distributed survey forms and consent letters (grade school or middle school), and 9.2% indicated
and explained the study. Those students who were will- that they were adults or that nursing was a second
ing to participate were allowed 20 minutes at the end career. Thus, almost three fourths (73.3%) were in
of the class period to complete the survey. The students high school or college when they decided to pursue
were instructed not to include any form of identifica- nursing as a career.
tion on the questionnaire and to place completed forms The most common response to when the students
in a covered box at the rear of the room as they exited. decided on nursing was during their freshman or soph-
omore year in college. A number of the students indi-
what the call is, (b) how the call is felt or perceived, 72% for Black students, 75% for Asian students, and
and (c) the purpose of the calling. In the first group 100% of Hispanic students (6 of 6 students); however,
(what a call is), many students used words like “plan,” this was not statistically significant (p = .258, df = 3).
“purpose,” “direction,” “passion,” “ministry,” and
“reason.” Other terms were “a life mission,” “feeling a
Discussion
sense that you are needed,” and “following God’s will.”
In the second grouping (how the call was per- Although after many years of teaching in a faith-
ceived), several statements were similar to these: based school of nursing, we understood that many of
“doors were opened” or “barriers were removed.” our students perceived a calling to the nursing profes-
Also, “God led me down this path,” and “God facili- sion; we were nonetheless surprised with the findings.
tated money, grants and other help received.” Another Based on the responses, a very significant majority of
fairly common theme related to the process of being our students felt that they were led by God or that their
called was “given strength.” For example one student being in nursing was within a divine plan. The stu-
wrote “He gave me strength to go on,” and another said dents’ descriptions of their perception of calling were
“God gives me strength to take care of others.” very closely tied to what was discovered in the litera-
In describing the purpose of the calling, 11 students ture. For example, the call to nursing gave them pur-
specifically wrote they were called to care or serve oth- pose, direction, and reason for their choice, which is
ers. A similar response was to “minister to those in consistent with Chrisopherson’s (1994) definition of
need.” Some students specifically cited use of the call- calling. Furthermore, as Jeffries (1998) observed in
ing to reach others for God. Examples included “car- discussing a sometimes stepwise path that leads to rec-
ing for the ill . . . to teach the Gospel,” “to be a witness ognition of a calling, the called students frequently
to others,” and “to demonstrate God’s love in the described coming to nursing as a process of “closing”
world.” A few students were very specific, as one said and/or “opening doors” in which they moved from one
“to help other people with cancer,” and another “feeling idea or direction to another while in high school or
the need to serve others in under-developed countries.” college.
Some students were specific in describing the Another important, although not particularly sur-
meaning of calling. Examples included “Being called prising, finding was that almost one half of the stu-
means responding to God’s desire to work through dents indicated that the primary reason they wanted to
me,” “It means knowing that becoming a nurse is one become a nurse was to help and/or care for people.
of God’s purposes for my life,” and “This is what God Because 75% of students described themselves as
intends for me to do.” One eloquent student wrote “I wanting to be nurses because they were caring, com-
feel that everybody has a ‘calling’ . . . it depends on passionate, and empathetic, it is clear the underlying
whether you are listening. God made me for such a motivators for being a nurse are more likely to be inter-
time as this.” nal rather than external. Aptitude tests and other for-
mats have been used to assist young people in search-
Analysis of the Theme of Calling and ing for a career that will fit their personality. Those
Relationships With Other Variables who possess a strong desire to help and serve should be
Several interesting findings were discovered when encouraged and sponsored by nursing faculty when-
comparing those who described themselves as ever possible. Other, perhaps less altruistic reasons
“called” and those who did not. For example, females (e.g., did not want the time commitment of medical
were more likely to report being called (66.4%) than school or job security) should be recognized, and
males (54.5%); however, chi-square analysis showed recruitment activities can include attention to those
that the difference was not statistically significant (p = individuals who have lost jobs or who are at risk for
.430, df = 1). Age did not appear to be a factor as the losing jobs.
groups were very similar, although it was difficult to Several other findings hold significant implications
compare as very few were in the older age groups. for those involved in recruitment of individuals into
Findings related to race were interesting, as being the nursing profession. For example, almost three
called was more common among students from racial fourths of the respondents were in high school or col-
and/or ethnic minority groups. Indeed, while 60% of lege when they decided on going to nursing school.
White students reported being called, percentages were Previous experience with the health care system,