MATERIAL COMPARISON SUMMARY

BETWEEN A283 Gr. C & JIS SS400

Document No.
2L1704-PTS-300-PI-SPC-002

Contract No.:
2L1704

PTS MODIFICATION PROJECT

0 11-Jan-2018 Issued for Approval ABU/YYS AS/HRT US/TM

Rev. Date Description By Chk. App.
 Doc. No. : 2L1704-PTS-300-PI-SPC-002

PTS MODIFICATION PROJECT Discipline : Piping

Doc. Type : Material Comparison

Rev. Date : 11-Jan-2018

MATERIAL COMPARISON SUMMARY
BETWEEN A283 Gr. C & JIS SS400 Revision : 0

TABULATION OF REVISED PAGES

SHEET REVISIONS SHEET REVISIONS

A B 0 1 2 3 4 5 A B 0 1 2 3 4 5
1 51
2 52
3 53
4 54
5 55
6 56
7 57
8 58
9 59
10 60
11 61
12 62
13 63
14 64
15 65
16 66
17 67
18 68
19 69
20 70
21 71
22 72
23 73
24 74
25 75
26 76
27 77
28 78
29 79
30 80
31 81
32 82
33 83
34 84
35 85
36 86
37 87
38 88
39 89
40 90
41 ATTACHMENTAPPENDIX
42 1 A
43 2 B
44 3 C
45 4 D
46 5 E
47 6 F
48 7 G
49 8 H
50 I

Page 2 of 2
 Prep: ABU/YYT
Rev/Appv: US/TM
Date: 11-Jan-18
MATERIAL COMPARISON SUMMARY
BETWEEN A283 Gr. C & JIS SS400
Thickness 8.00mm (22 and above) Thickness 6.00mm (22 and above)
Original Spec Proposed Spec
No. Variables Technical Evaluation
ASTM A283 Grade C JIS G3101 Grade SS400
1 Design Temperature (deg C) 350 350
2 Design Pressure (kg/cm2g) 0.5 0.5
3 Carbon 0.24 -

4 Silicon 0.4 -
Chemical Composition
The element max (%)

5 Mangan 0.9 -

6 Phosphorus 0.035 0.05

Technically Accepted
7 Sulphur 0.04 0.05

8 Molybdenum - -

9 Chrome - -

10 Nickel - -

11 Tensile Strenght, ksi (Mpa) 55-75 (380-515) 58-74 (400-510)

Mechanical
properties

12 Yield Strenght, ksi (Mpa) 30 (205) 36 (245)

13 Elongation in 2 in, min % 25 21

Comparison Basic Allowable Stresses
14 in Tension for Metals based on Table A- See-Attach 1
1 ASME B31.3

References
1. ASTM A283 Standard Specification for Low and Intermediate Tensile Strength Carbon Steel Plates
2. JIS G 3101 Rolled Steels for General Structure
3. ASME B31.3 Process Piping_2014

1 of 2
ASME B31.3-2008
Table A-1 Basic Allowable Stresses in Tension for Metals1 (Cont’d) Attachment-1
Basic Allowable Stress S, ksi (1), at Metal Temperature, °F (7)

NO. MATERIAL KETERANGAN STATUS Yield 37.78°C 93.33°C 148.89°C 204.44°C 260.00°C 315.56°C 343.33°C 371.11°C 398.89°C 426.67°C MAT. GROUP
DATA (ksi) <100°F 200°F 300°F 400°F 500°F 600°F 650°F 700°F 750°F 800°F

1. ASTM A283 Grade C OK 30 16.9 16.1 15.3 14.6 13.8 13.0 12.6 12.2 11.1
2. JIS G3101 Grade SS400 Using A36 data OK 36 17.8 16.9 16.9 16.9 16.9 16.9 16.9 16.9
3.
4.

2 of 2