Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
3, JULY 2008
Abstract—Materials with high thermal conductivity and thermal outstanding candidates for packaging applications. The four
expansion coefficient matching with that of GaAs are being used classes of materials are polymer matrix composites, metal
for packaging high-density microwave integrated circuits (MICs) matrix composites, and carbon–carbon composites. Tradition-
due to their ability of faster heat dissipation. Powder metallurgy ally, invar (Fe–Ni), kovar (Fe–Ni–Co), Cu–W, Cu–Mo, Cu,
(P/M) has emerged as a promising technique for the processing
of metal matrix composites (MMCs) in satellite applications such and Al have been used as packaging, substrate carrier plates,
as thermal management materials. Individual components in or heat sinks [1], [2]. Kovar has been used as a microwave
these composites must retain their metallurgical identity. The substrate carrier plate in order to provide mechanical support
present study investigates the processing of silvar (Fe–Ni–Co–Ag) to the alumina which has been used as a substrate. Although
alloys for thermal management materials. For these silvar alloys, the CTE of kovar nearly matches that of alumina, its thermal
composition was varied by varying the silver content from 15 to conductivity is poor. Cu–W and Cu–Mo have required CTE and
35 wt. %. The compacts were pressed at 400 and 600 MPa and thermal conductivity, but density and machining costs involved
sintered/infiltrated at 1100 C, 1150 C, and 1225 C. Quantitative
metallographic measurements were performed on all sample and
are high. Although Cu and Al have high thermal conductivity,
the results were discussed. It was observed that all samples were their CTE is much higher. Consequently, marginally thermal
sintered without any shape distortion. Microstructural evalua- stress compensating materials, such as alumina are needed. As
tion reveals that higher compaction pressure resulted in highly a result, the ability of Cu or Al to dissipate heat faster can no
contiguous structure. In spite of density differences between longer be realized due to the additional thermal resistance of
constituents, none of the alloys showed segregation. Coefficient alumina. The inability of traditional materials to dissipate the
of thermal expansion (CTE) values of the liquid phase sintered heat generated due to ever increasing power densities led to the
composites is near to the values obtained by rule of mixtures.
development of alternate packaging materials such as Al–SiC
Index Terms—Coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) and composites. The CTE of Al–SiC can be tailored anywhere
thermal conductivity, electronic packaging, metal matrix com- between 5–18 ppm/K while maintaining a thermal conductivity
posite (MMC), powder metallurgy (P/M), silvar. of 170–180 Wm K by changing the Al-to-SiC ratio on the
composite. However, Al–SiC composites are very difficult to
I. INTRODUCTION machine [3].
As described in the previous sections, thermal management
HE continuing increase in the electronic packaging
T density has resulted in a need for materials with high
thermal conductivities. In addition, to minimizing thermal
materials are generally processed through powder metallurgical
techniques, either by liquid phase sintering or infiltration.
W- and Mo-based materials are often made by P/M methods
stresses that can cause component or solder failure, packaging
including pressing and sintering followed by infiltration with
materials must have coefficients of thermal expansion (CTEs)
copper [4]. While these materials have the desirable range of
matching those of ceramic substrates (such as Al O , AlN),
and semiconductors (Si and GaAs). Further, low densities are thermal expansion and conductivity, their poor machinability
preferred in aerospace and avionic applications. The use and and platability have been a matter of concern. Elsewhere, ce-
potential for composites in electronic packaging is very broad. ramic-based materials were processed by using AlN as starting
By combining two or more constituents, it is possible to create material. Due to the significant amount of dissolved oxygen
materials with unique combinations of properties that cannot in the starting material, it forms a fine layer of Al O on the
be achieved in any another way. surface and resists densification [5]. Further work aimed at
In recent years, new composites have been developed that densification of AlN through liquid phase sintering by addition
provide unique combinations of properties that make them of small amounts of CaO Y O . This combines with Al O
from AlN and forms liquid phase at 1780 C resulting in
99% sintered density [6]. Cuvar is another suitable material
Manuscript received March 28, 2007; revised October 12, 2007. Published
July 7, 2008 (projected). This work was supported in part by the Department of processed by extrusion [7]. It is a composite of invar and
Space, Government of India, administered by the IIT-Kanpur Space Technology copper and stable in the range of 70 C to 400 C. However,
cell. This work was recommended for publication by Associate Editor I. Fidan exposure to higher temperatures has shown to cause diffusional
upon evaluation of the reviewers comments.
E. R. Tagore was with the International Advanced Research Center for
interaction between the phases. As higher density is not desired
Powder Metallurgy and New Materials, Hyderabad 500005, India. He is now for avionic applications, several researchers processed a new
with the School of Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering, Oregon State type material Al–SiC [8]. Generally, these composites were
University, Corvallis, OR 97331 USA. processed by infiltration of liquid metal into ceramic preform
A. Upadhyaya is with the Department of Materials and Metallurgical
Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology—Kanpur, Kanpur 208016, India [9]. Capillary-induced infiltration has distinct advantages over
(e-mail: anishu@iitk.ac.in). other methods in that it does not require expensive tooling
A. V. Pathak is with the Space Application Center, Indian Space Research and equipment. The first such kind of infiltration of Al–Mg
Organization, Ahmedabad 380015, India.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
alloys were made by Aghajanian et al. [10]. They showed that
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. a variety of ceramics, including Al O , SiC, AlN, and TiB ,
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TEPM.2008.926287 could be infiltrated in the range of 750 C to 900 C. Rao et al.
1521-334X/$25.00 © 2008 IEEE
TAGORE et al.: PROCESSING OF SILVAR FOR MIC PACKAGING APPLICATIONS 261
Fig. 6. Effect of compaction pressure and Ag content on the (a) green and sin-
tered density and (b) densification parameter of comilled kovar–Ag alloys.
shrinkage observed after sintering of these alloys at 1150 C. Fig. 8. Elemental mapping of kovar25Ag alloy. The alloy was prepared by
This could be attributed to communition of particle size during comixing and subsequently pressed at 600 MPa and sintered at 1150 C.
milling and more homogeneous Ag distribution, both of which
enhance sintereability. Ag coating on kovar makes the system
0 dihedral angle unless otherwise the kovar and Ag system is
assumed to be high dihedral angle. A similar kind of behavior
was observed in a W–Cu system.
B. Microstructures
Fig. 7 shows the optical microstructures of silvar alloys sin-
tered at various temperatures. It is evident that all microstruc-
tures are liquid phase sintered. It can also be seen that despite in- Fig. 9. Optical microstructures showing the effect of rolling on the microstruc-
creasing the sintering temperature, no change in the microstruc- ture of silvar alloys containing 25% silver. The alloy was rolled to 50% reduction
tures is discerned. This is because of negligible intersolubility and annealed at 700 C.
between the phases. In all micrographs, continuous network of
kovar is interspersed in the silver matrix. Kovar–35Ag alloys Fig. 8 show the elemental distribution maps determined using
show higher porosity as compared to lower Ag content. How- EDAX. As the kovar powder is in pre-alloyed condition, Fe, Ni,
ever, in all the cases, the pores are completely isolated from the and Co appears distributed homogeneously in kovar grains. The
silver phase, which is due to the formation of highly contiguous presence of sliver is seen only in liquid phase.
kovar network well before the liquid formation. The presumed As described earlier, sintered silvar alloys were rolled and
reason for high contiguity is the high dihedral angle between annealed to achieve full density. Fig. 9 shows the optical mi-
kovar and silver systems. crostructures of kovar25Ag in sintered, rolled, and annealed
Energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) analysis was carried condition. It is clearly visible that kovar grains were elongated.
out on the sintered microstructure, grain (dark spot), and liquid Furthermore, due to the rolling, the pores got closed, and it
(colored phase) to determine the elemental distribution in each also induces some residual stresses. After complete annealing,
phase. The composition of grain is the same as that of as-re- stresses will relieve and grains regains their shape. However, in
ceived kovar powder, whereas the liquid phase composition cor- the present study, the annealing temperature was insufficient to
responds to pure silver. cause recrystallizing.
264 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ELECTRONICS PACKAGING MANUFACTURING, VOL. 31, NO. 3, JULY 2008
Fig. 10. SEM micrograph of comilled kovar20Ag pressed at 400 MPa and sin-
tered at 1150 C.
Fig. 12. Variation of bulk hardness for various silvar alloys consolidated by
(a) pressing and sintering (600 MPa; 1150 C); rolling (50% reduction) and
subsequent annealing (700 C); 1 h) and (b) milling and infiltration.
Fig. 13. SEM microstructures of kovar30Ag (a) as sintered and (b) cold rolled
to 98% reduction.
Fig. 11. Optical microstructures of (a) top and (b) regions of kovar25Ag C. Material Characterization
pressed at 400 MPa (left) and kovar15Ag pressed at 600 MPa (right). 1) Bulk Hardness: Fig. 12(a) shows the hardness variation
of liquid phase sintered, cold worked and heat-treated silvar al-
Fig. 10 shows the SEM micrograph of the comilled and loys. It is clear from the figure that rolling up to 50% reduc-
sintered kovar-20%Ag alloy. It is found that milling not only tion in thickness resulted in increasing hardness. Usually, cold
resulted in densification enhancement but also significant (five rolling results in work hardening of the material, and it also
times) reduction in kovar grain size. As the milled powder induces stresses that contribute to hardness enhancement. An-
particle size was finer, the number of interparticle contacts in- nealing at 700 C results in lowering of hardness, but it is still
creases. In addition to this, the dihedral angle is also high. This higher as compared to the sintered alloy. Furthermore, 700 C
leads to the highly contiguous and connective network of kovar. does not result in recrystallization of grains. This observed phe-
The extent of connectivity and contiguity is such that silver nomenon could be because of insufficient annealing tempera-
phase is completely isolated from one another. This would af- ture. Increasing the silver content resulted in lowering of bulk
fect the conductivity of the alloy which relies on the continuity hardness which is due to the soft nature of silver.
of the conducting phase. Elemental mapping of the above alloy Fig. 12(b) shows the effect of milling and infiltration on
was carried out to verify whether any alloying occurred during bulk hardness of silvar alloys. This is clear from the figure
milling. It is clearly observed that the elemental distribution is that hardness of the milled and infiltrated alloys is higher than
similar to the liquid phase sintered alloys. Milling does not lead their liquid phase sintered counterparts. Due to the higher
to any compositional change in the phases. sintered density, infiltrated alloys exhibit higher hardness as
Fig. 11 represents the optical microstructures of the top and compared to the sintered alloys. In the case of infiltrated alloys,
bottom surfaces of silvar alloys processed through the infiltra- due to the less silver content, compacts pressed at 600 MPa
tion technique. In both (400 and 600 MPa) the cases, the mi- (kovar15Ag) showed marginally higher hardness than those
crostructures look self similar. This attributes to the perfect in- pressed at 400 MPa (kovar25Ag). In spite of higher sinter
filtration. To reinforce the above statement, segregation studies density, hardness of infiltrated alloys is inferior to comilled
were carried throughout the axial cross-section. Except a few alloys which have finer grain size.
areas, which would have formed in the earlier stage of com- 2) Machinablility: Machinability is the important property
paction, there was no such kind of segregation. The microstruc- required for electronic packaging materials. Fig. 13 shows the
tures were homogeneous all over the cross section. microstructures of silvar alloy. Fig. 13(a) and (b) represents the
TAGORE et al.: PROCESSING OF SILVAR FOR MIC PACKAGING APPLICATIONS 265
TABLE II [5] J. H. Harris, “Sintered aluminum nitride for high-power electronic ap-
CTE AND THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY OF DIFFERENT SILVAR ALLOYS plications,” J. Mater., vol. 50, no. 6, pp. 56–60, 1998.
[6] K. Komeya, H. Inoue, and A. Tsuage, “Effect of various additives on
sintering of aluminum nitride,” J. Ceramic Soc. Japan, vol. 89, no. 6,
pp. 330–336, 1981.
[7] S. Jha, “CUVAR-a new controlled expansion, high conductivity mate-
rial for electronic thermal management,” in Proc. Electron. Compon.
Technol. Conf., Las Vegas, NV, 1995, pp. 542–547.
[8] J. Coleto, J. Maudes, J. Goni, J. Marcos, J. Calvin, and F. Costas,
“Novel electronic packages made of highly loaded sic particle alu-
minium based composites for space applications,” in Mater. Sci.
Forum, 2003, pp. 426–432.
[9] M. A. Occhionero, R. W. Adams, K. P. Fennessy, and R. A. Hay,
“Cost-effective manufacturing of aluminum silicon carbide AlSiC elec-
tronic packages,” in Proc. Int. Symp. Adv. Packag. Mater.: Process.,
Properties, Interfaces, Braselton, GA, 1999, pp. 118–124.
[10] M. K. Aghajanian, M. A. Rocazella, J. T. Burke, and S. D. Keck, “The
fabrication of metal matrix composites by pressureless infiltration tech-
nique,” J. Mater. Sci., vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 447–454, 1991.
kovar30Ag alloy in as-sintered and 98% cold rolled conditions, [11] G. Manchang, K. S. Bong, K. Hyeong, L. J. Mu, and L. C. Yong, “,”
respectively. Even after severe rolling, the slivar alloy shows no Korea Patent No. KR 2003005439, 2003.
evidence of crack or any defect, which confirms good ductility. [12] J. C. Calder, D. R. Harrgan, and W. C. Riley, in Proc. Int. Conf.
This can attribute to the good machinability. The final compo- Multichip Modules and High Density Packag., Denver, CO, 1998, pp.
160–164.
nent was machined without any difficulty. [13] R. M. German, Powder Metallurgy and Particulate Materials Pro-
3) CTE Measurement: The CTEs of these alloys were mea- cessing, 3rd ed. Princeton, NJ: Metal Powder Industries Federation,
sured using a vertical pushrod dilatometer. Table II summarizes 2005.
the CTE values obtained by experiments and rule of mixtures. It [14] S. Nagarjuna, “Thermal conductivity of Cu-4.5 Ti alloy,” Bull. Mater.
Sci., vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 69–71, 2004.
is evident from the table that CTE values of experimental results
are near to the values obtained by rule of mixtures. Elsewhere,
Rao et al. [3] proved that rule of mixtures is reliable for CTE of
Al-SiC composites. The observed variation is due to the pres- Eluri Ravindranadh Tagore received the B.Tech.
degree from the National Institute of Technology,
ence of porosity in the sintered material. Tiruchirappalli, India, and the M.Tech. degree from
4) Thermal Conductivity: Thermal conductivity of the silvar the Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur. He is
alloys were not measured experimentally. However, using elec- currently pursuing the Ph.D. degree from Oregon
trical resistivity measurements, thermal conductivity was mea- State University, Corvallis.
His areas of interest are powder metallurgy, corro-
sured from Wiedemann Franz’s law [14]. The results obtained sion, and microfluidic devices.
are summarized in Table II. This table also contains the conduc-
tivity values predicted using rule of mixtures. Note that there
is significant deviation between the experimental and model
values. The observed deviation in the results could be due to
the presence of pores in the sintered parts which possibly con-
Anish Upadhyaya received the M.S. and Ph.D. de-
tributed to errors in measuring the resistance of these alloys. grees from The Pennsylvania State University, State
College.
V. CONCLUSION He is currently an Associate Professor in the De-
For the first time, silvar alloys were consolidated through partment of Materials and Metallurgical Engineering
at the Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur. His
P/M by premixing the kovar (Fe–Ni–Co) and Ag powder via area of specialization is in powder metallurgical
liquid phase sintering, infiltration, and liquid phase sintering of processing of ferrous, nonferrous, and refractory
comilled powders. The CTE values of these alloys were close to alloys with special emphasis on sintering.
the values predicted by rule of mixtures. In addition to the above,
none of the alloys resulted in macro-segregation of phases.
REFERENCES
Anand V. Pathak received the B.Eng. and M.Eng.
[1] C. Zweben, “High performance thermal management materials,” Elec- degrees in mechanical engineering from Gujarat Uni-
tron Cooling, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 36–42, 1999. versity, Gujarat, India, and the Indian Institute of Sci-
[2] A. V. Pathak, K. J. Patel, B. S. Rao, and V. Jayaram, “The need and ence, Bangalore, respectively.
approach for the development of metal matrix composites for hybrid He is currently a Project Manager with the Space
microcircuits for space use,” in Proc. 3rd Int. Conf. Adv. Composites Applications Center, Indian Space Research Organ-
(ADCOMP), Bangalore, India, 2000, pp. 250–256. ization (ISRO), Ahmedabad, India, and is working
[3] B. S. Rao, C. Hemamber, A. V. Pathak, K. J. Patel, J. Rodel, and V. on INSAT and GSAT spacecraft payloads. He is re-
Jayaram, “Al–SiC carriers for microwave integrated circuits by a new sponsible for design, development, and fabrication of
technique of pressureless infiltration,” IEEE Trans. Electron. Packag. communication payloads. In the past, he had deliv-
Manuf., vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 58–63, Jan. 2006. ered various payloads for the Indian National Satel-
[4] P. H. Dawson, “A range of tungsten–copper electronic substrate heat- lite System (INSAT). Currently, he is interested in the development of new ma-
sink materials,” GEC Rev., vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 168–170, 1986. terials for MMIC technology.