Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 10

Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664

DOI 10.1617/s11527-006-9093-0

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

On relationships between the mechanical properties of


recycled aggregate concrete: An overview
J.-Zh. Xiao · J.-B. Li · Ch. Zhang

Received: 23 May 2005 / Accepted: 18 November 2005



C RILEM 2006

Abstract In this paper, a detailed investigation is con- les relations entre ses qualités à la compression, à la
ducted to analyze the relationships between the me- tension, à la flexion, ou entre sa densité et le module
chanical properties of recycled aggregate concrete d’élasticité ont été plus particulièrement su set d’études
(RAC). Based on a large number of experimental re- et de remise en question. Il en résulte que les rela-
sults published worldwide in literature from 1985 to tions entre les propriétés mécaniques du BGR sont as-
2004, an experimental database is developed with re- sez différentes par rapport aux bétons normaux. De
gard to the main mechanical properties of RAC. In par- nouvelles équations améliorées sont avancée dans ce
ticular, the relations between the compressive strength, domaine a l’aide de la méthode des moindres carrés.
the density, the splitting tensile strength, the flexural
strength, and the elastic modulus are investigated and
discussed in detail. It is found that the interrelation- 1. Introduction
ships between the mechanical properties of RAC could
be quite different from those of normal concrete. Some Reuse of waste concrete as recycled aggregates in new
improved new equations are proposed for the predic- concretes is beneficial from the view point of environ-
tion of the relations between the mechanical properties mental protection and resources reservation. To the best
of RAC based on the statistical regression analysis with knowledge of the authors, the investigation on recy-
the least squares method. cled waste concrete was initiated by Glushge in Russia
1946 [1]. In the following years, a large amount of ex-
Résumé La recherche avancée présentée ici, anal- perimental works have been carried out worldwide to
yse les relations entre les propriétés mécaniques des investigate the recycling of waste concrete. Previous
Bétons à Granulat Recyclé (BGR). En s’appuyant sur la studies were mainly engaged in the processing of de-
bibliographie importante des résultats expérimentaux molished concrete, mix-proportion design, mechanical
publiés au niveau international de 1985 à 2004, une properties, durability aspects and improvements. Re-
base de données a été élaborée sur les propriétés cently, structural performances and economic aspects
mécaniques du BGR. Et, de façon plus approfondie, of using recycled aggregate concrete are also analyzed.
Some previous research results on the mechanical
behaviour of recycled aggregate concrete have been re-
J.-Zh. Xiao · J.-B. Li viewed by Hansen [2] and Li [3]. It was revealed that,
Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
in fact, none of the previous results indicated that the
Ch. Zhang recycled aggregate concrete is unsuitable for structural
University of Siegen, D-57068 Siegen, Germany applications. Recent investigations on the performance
656 Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664

of beams [4–6], columns [7], beam-column joints [8], 2. Scope of the investigations
and slabs [9] made from recycled aggregate concrete
all gave positive results, which further supports and Based on a large number of experimental works pub-
encourages the possibilities of applying recycled ag- lished in literature, over 1200 test results were collected
gregate concrete in civil engineering structures. to get a wide spread database. Our aim was to take
The interrelationships of the main mechanical prop- as many types of recycled aggregates as possible into
erties of recycled aggregate concrete are important is- account, and simultaneously to establish as simple as
sues for the design, construction and analysis of struc- possible relationships between the various mechani-
tures when this kind of materials is applied. In the case cal properties. The most important mechanical param-
of normal concretes, the relationships between their eters and the corresponding test conditions collected
mechanical properties have been well established and are briefly described and given in Table 1. Due to the
described in detail within various design codes, stan- large variety of the aggregate combinations, regional
dards and handbooks. However, some previous studies differences, different production methods and storage
[10–13] have indicated that such existing relationships conditions, as well as other influencing factors such as
for normal concrete may not be valid for recycled ag- different curing/test methods and used standards, the
gregate concrete. Therefore, a reliable establishment test results had to be selected from an engineering point
of the relationships between the various physical and of view in order to get a reasonably good fitting equa-
mechanical properties of recycled aggregate concrete tion for concrete with all kinds of recycled concrete
is desirable and has to be performed. With this aim aggregates. The selection was completed according to
in mind, this paper provides an attempt in this direc- the rules illustrated in Table 2. After that, only 528 test
tion. Previous experimental results including our own results from Refs. [6, 12, 14–38] were kept for further
results for recycled aggregate concrete published in lit- consideration.
erature are collected and compared carefully. Based on Even for the left 528 test results, a strict statistical
these results, a database is developed and some novel evaluation of all the test results was hardly possible
equations for describing the relations between the main due to the following reasons: (1) most of the informa-
mechanical properties of recycled aggregate concrete tion about the test results and the test conditions were
are derived by using a statistical regression analysis. somewhat incomplete, (2) the number of the test speci-
It should be remarked here that a considerably large mens was often too small or the conditions were gained
amount of experimental works have been done in past on different mixtures, and (3) the objectives of the test
years, and it is beyond the scope of this investigation to programs were quite different and they were not the
collect and discuss all of the published results. The re- same as in this investigation. Despite these difficulties,
sults presented in this paper are neither exhaustive nor it is still useful to keep the database as general as pos-
complete. Some recent and even very important results sible, and it is also practicable to do some statistical
may still be missing in our discussion. analysis from the developed database. In this paper,

Table 1 Properties of collected test results

Parameters Value range and test conditions

Compressive strength 10–65 MPa


at 28 day (cylinder/cube)
Cure condition Air/standard/water
Density 1800–2450 kg/m3
Water/cement ratio 0.2–1.2
Cement content 90–550 kg/m3
Type of cement used CEM I 32.5R/CEM II 42.5NA OPC 32.5R/OPC 42.5R CEM I A 52.5/CEM III B 42.5
Fly ash content 0–97 kg/m3
Recycled aggregates content 10–100%
Recycled aggregates used Crushed concrete/crushed brick
Percentage of masonry rubble 0–80%
Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664 657

Table 2 Conditions for selecting the test results for the database

Parameters Value range and test conditions

28 Day compressive strength (cube) 15–55 MPa


Cure condition Standard/water
Density 2200–2450 kg/m3
Age 28 days or more
Water/cement ratio 0.3–1.2
Cement content 90–550 kg/m3
Type of cement used CEM I 32.5R/ CEM I 42.5NA OPC 32.5R/OPC 42.5R CEM I A 52.5/CEM IIIB 42.5
Fine aggregate Natural sand
Fly ash content 0
Recycled aggregates content 10–100%
Source of recycled aggregates Demolished concrete/laboratory-cast concrete/airport pavement/rejected structural
precast element
Percentage of masonry rubble 0–5%

the least squares method was applied to derive the new density. Within the data investigated, Fig. 1 shows the
equations for the relationships between the mechanical values of the cube compressive strength obtained by
properties of recycled aggregate concrete. various investigators as a function of the mass density.
It can be assumed here that there exists approximately
3. Relationships between the mechanical a linear relationship between the compressive strength
properties and the mass density. A statistical regression analysis
is undertaken to establish the empirical relationship be-
3.1. Relationship between the compressive tween the compressive strength and the mass density,
strength and the mass density where a linear regression model is used. The result is
given by
Generally speaking, the compressive strength of the
normal concrete increases with a rising of the mass f cu = aρ + b, (1)

Fig. 1 Relationship
between the compressive
strength and the mass
density of RAC
658 Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664

where a and b are the regression coefficients, fcu is In the ACI Code [40] and Chinese Code GB 50010-
the compressive strength in MPa, and ρ is the mass 2002, the relationships between the splitting tensile
density in kg/m3 of the recycled concrete. With a strength and the compressive strength (both in MPa)
correlation coefficient R = 0.92, the constants a and for normal concrete are expressed as
b are obtained as a = 0.069 and b = −116.1. Thus,
the relation between the compressive strength and the ACI : f sp = 0.49 f cu
0.50
, (3)
mass density of recycled concrete can be established
as GB : f sp = 0.19 f cu
0.75
. (4)

f cu = 0.069ρ − 116.1. (2) It should be noted here that in Equation (3), a con-
version factor of 0.76 from the cylinder to the cube
Equation (2) is drawn in Fig. 1, which shows that it can compressive strength has been undertaken according
describe the test results quite well. to Ref. [41].
By using Equations (3, 4), the relationship between
3.2. Relationship between the splitting tensile fsp and fcu for the recycled aggregate concrete is plotted
strength and the compressive strength in Fig. 2. From Fig. 2, it can be seen that Equations (3,
4) results in a significant overestimation of the splitting
The splitting tensile strength test is often used to ob- tensile strength of the recycled aggregate concrete. To
tain the tensile strength of concrete, rather than by a improve Equations (3, 4), a regression analysis of the
direct tensile strength test because the former is eas- test results was performed by using the following re-
ier to perform. In practical applications, however, the gression equation
tensile strength of concrete is often estimated from the
compressive strength. The splitting tensile strength of f sp = c f cu
d
, (5)
the recycled aggregate concrete obtained by previous
investigators as a function of the compressive strength where c and d are the regression coefficients to be deter-
is summarized and shown in Fig. 2. Although the re- mined. By using a correlation coefficient R = 0.87, the
sults show a considerable scatter, the tendency that the regression analysis yields c = 0.24 and d = 0.65. Hence,
splitting tensile strength increases with increasing com- the following equation is proposed for the relation be-
pressive strength can still be recognized. tween the splitting tensile strength and the compressive

Fig. 2 Relationship
between the splitting tensile
strength and the
compressive strength of
RAC
Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664 659

Fig. 3 Relationship
between the flexural
strength and the
compressive strength of
RAC

strength of the recycled aggregate concrete It should be noted here that in Equations (7, 8), a conver-
sion from the cylinder to the cube compressive strength
f sp = 0.24 f cu
0.65
. (6) has been undertaken. According to Ref. [41], the cylin-
der compressive strength is taken as 0.76 times of the
cube compressive strength.
Comparisons between the test results and that predicted
It can be seen from Fig. 3 that the ACI equation
by Equation (6) are illustrated in Fig. 2. It can be seen
leads to an underestimation, while the CEB equation
that the proposed Equation (6) can provide a better
yields an overestimation of the flexural strength of the
agreement with the experimental results than Equations
recycled aggregate concrete.
(3, 4) do.
Based on the collected test results and by using the
following regression equation
3.3. Relationship between the flexural strength
and the compressive strength 
ff = e f cu , (9)
The flexural strength of concrete is another mechani-
cal quantity which is often used to calculate the tensile
a statistical regression analysis was performed. With
strength of concrete. The test results for the flexural
a correlation coefficient R = 0.91, the regression
strength of the recycled aggregate concrete obtained
coefficient e was determined as e = 0.75. There-
by various investigators are given in Fig. 3 versus the
fore, the following equation is suggested for describ-
compressive strength. Although unavoidable discrep-
ing the relation between the flexural strength and
ancies exist amongst the results, there exists a tendency
the compressive strength of the recycled aggregate
that the flexural strength increases with increasing the
concrete
compressive strength.
In the CEB Code [39] and the ACI Code [40], the 
empirical relationships between the flexural strength f f = 0.75 f cu . (10)
and the compressive strength (both in MPa) for normal
concrete are given by the following equations
Compared with Equations (7) and (8), Equation (10)
 provides a much better description of the relation
CEB : f f = 0.81 f cu , (7) between the flexural strength and the compressive

ACI : f f = 0.54 f cu . (8) strength of the recycled aggregate concrete.
660 Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664

3.4. Relationship between the elastic modulus Zilch and Roos [42]:
and the compressive strength  2
ρ
E c = 9100 × ( f cu + 8)1/3 × (15)
The elastic modulus of concrete reflects the linear elas- 2400
tic stress-strain relation which is very important in both
Mellmann [43]:
the static and the dynamic analysis of reinforced con-
crete structures. In the past, different equations have
E c = 378 f cu + 8242 (16)
been suggested by various investigators for describing
the relationship between the elastic modulus and the It should be noted here that in Equation (13) a con-
compressive strength (both in MPa) of recycled aggre- version factor of 0.79 from the cylinder to the cube
gate concrete, and some of them are given in Equations compressive strength of recycled aggregate concrete
(11–16). has been made according to Ref. [21]. In Equations
Ravindrarajah and Tam [12]: (13, 14), the mass density of the recycled aggregate
concrete can be calculated by using Equation (2).
E c = 7770 f cu
0.33
(11) Equations (11–16) are displayed in Fig. 4 for the
elastic modulus versus the compressive strength of re-
Dhir et al. [14]: cycled aggregate concrete. It can be seen that there
exists a remarkably high diversity in the results. The
reason for the discrepancies is quite simple: the refer-
E c = 370 f cu + 13100 (12) enced author/authors has/have proposed his/their equa-
tion, just to best fit his/their own experimental results.
Kakizaki et al. [20]: However, some of the reported results ware obtained
only from a limited number of test specimens or lim-
 1.5  ited types of recycled aggregates, while some other
ρ f cu
E c = 1.9 × 10 ×5
× (13) suggested equations are hardly in accordance with the
2300 2000
experimental findings.
The collected test results of elastic modulus of recy-
Dillmann [25]: cled aggregate concrete by different investigators are
summarized and their variation with the compressive
E c = 634.43 f cu + 3057.6 (14) strength is shown in Fig. 5.

Fig. 4 Different equations


proposed for the elastic
modulus of RAC
Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664 661

Fig. 5 Relationship between the elastic modulus and the compressive strength of RAC

In the ACI code [40] and Chinese Code GB50010– where g and h are the regression coefficients to be de-
2002, the following equations are adopted to estimate termined. With a correlation coefficient R = 0.91, the
the elastic modulus of normal concrete, respectively. regression coefficients are obtained as g = 2.8 and
h = 40.1. Thus, the following relation is suggested
ACI : E c = 4127 f cu
0.50
(17) to estimate the relation between the elastic modulus
and the compressive strength of the recycled aggregate
105 concrete
GB : E c = (18)
2.2 + 34.7
f cu

105
Similar to Equation [3], a conversion factor of 0.76 Ec = . (20)
from the cylinder to the cube compressive strength is 2.8 + 40.1
f cu
used. Results obtained by using Equations (17, 18) are
also presented in Fig. 5 and compared with the exper-
A comparison of the results predicted by Equation (20)
imental results. It can be seen in Fig. 5 that Equation
with the experimental ones and that provided by Equa-
(17) provides an underestimation of the elastic mod-
tion (16) shows that Equation (20) gives a satisfactorily
ulus when the compressive strength is relatively low,
adequate estimation of the relation between the elastic
whereas Equation (18) leads to an overestimation of
modulus and the compressive strength of recycled ag-
the elastic modulus.
gregate concrete.
In this investigation, an alternative regression anal-
In addition, Equation (20) is also compared with
ysis was performed based on the collected test results
Equations (11–16) and it is found that the predicted
using the following regression equation
results by Equation (11) are very close to that by Equa-
tion (20), which is also drawn in Fig. 5 for compar-
105 isons. Therefore, both Equation (11) and Equation (20)
Ec = , (19)
g + fhcu can be used to describe the relation between the elastic
662 Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664

Table 3 Difference between proposed relations and of huge test data is often not sufficient and further study
equations suggested by ACI is still needed in the future to investigate the relation-
This paper ACI Code ships between the mechanical properties of recycled
aggregate concrete.
f sp = 0.65
0.24 f cu f sp = 0.49 f cu
0.50
√ √
f f = 0.75 f cu f f = 0.54 f cu
5
E c = 2.810
+ 40.1
or E c = 7770 f cu
0.33
E c = 4127 f cu0.50
Acknowledgements The comments from the two anonymous
f cu
reviewers are greatly appreciated. Jianzhuang Xiao would like
to express his sincere appreciate to the Alexander von Hum-
boldt Foundation in Germany, which granted him to work for
modulus and the compressive strength of recycled ag-
more than one year in Germany. Special thanks are extended to
gregate concrete. Prof. Dr.-Ing. H. Falkner who provided Jianzhuang Xiao very
convenient work facilities during his visiting the Institute of
Building Materials, Structural Concrete and Fire Protection of
TU Braunschweig.
4. Summary

Based on our collected experimental results published


worldwide in literature, a database for the mechanical References
properties of recycled aggregate concrete is developed.
Our investigation shows that the commonly used equa- 1. Gluzhge PJ (1946) The work of scientific research institute.
tions for relating the mechanical properties of normal Gidrotekhnicheskoye Stroitel’stvo 4:27–28. (only available
in Russian)
concrete cannot be directly applied to the recycled ag- 2. Hansen TC (1992) Recycling of demolished concrete and
gregate concrete. A statistical regression analysis of masonry (E & FN SPON, London)
the collected experimental results is performed to de- 3. Li JB (2004) Study on mechanical behaviour of recycled
rive improved equations for describing the relations aggregate concrete (Master thesis, Tongji University)
4. Sogo M, Sogabe T, Maruyma I, Sato R, Kawai K
between the mechanical properties of recycled aggre- (2004) Shear behaviour of reinforced recycled concrete
gate concrete. In particular, approximate equations for beams. Proceedings of the International RILEM Confer-
the following relationships are presented: ence on the Use of Recycled Materials in Buildings and
Structures, Barcelona, Spain, 8–11 November, pp 610–
1. The relationship between the compressive strength 618
5. Maruyma I, Sogo M, Sogabe T, Sato R, Kawai K (2004)
and the mass density of recycled aggregate concrete.
‘Flexural properties of reinforced recycled concrete beams.
2. The relationship between the tensile strength and Proceedings of the International RILEM Conference on the
the compressive strength of recycled aggregate con- Use of Recycled Materials in Buildings and Structures,
crete. Barcelona, Spain, 8–11 November, 525–535
6. Dolara E, Di Niro G, Cairns R (1998) Recycled aggregate
3. The relationship between the flexural strength and
concrete prestressed beams. Proceedings of Conference on
the compressive strength of recycled aggregate con- Sustainable Construction: Use of Recycled Concrete Ag-
crete. gregate, University of Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November,
4. The relationship between the elastic modulus and 255–262
7. Konno K, Sato Y, Kakuta Y, Ohira M (1997) Property of
the compressive strength of recycled aggregate
recycled aggregate column encased by steel tube subjected
concrete. to axial compression. Transactions of the Japan Concrete
Institute 19:231–238
The presented approximate relations that are sum- 8. Corinaldesi V (2003) Recycled aggregate concrete under
marized and compared with ACI equations for nor- cyclic loading. Proceedings of the International Symposium
mal concrete in Table 3, may be used for reference on Role of Concrete in Sustainable Development, University
of Dundee, Scotland, 3–4 September, 509–518
and comparison purposes in the structural design and 9. Cyllok M (2002) Concrete with recycled aggregate: laps and
applications of recycled aggregate concrete in civil cracks, Proceedings of the 4th International PhD Symposium
engineering. in Civil Engineering, Munch, Germany, 19–21 September,
It should be emphasized that the conditions of re- 72–73
10. Konrad Z, Frank R (2001) Design of concrete structures
cycled aggregate and the mix proportion adopted are made from recycled aggregate – a globe recommendation
very complicated, especially in in-situ concrete produc- following the DIN 1045-1. Proceeding to the fib-Symposium
tion. Therefore, a single statistical regression analysis Concrete and Environment, Berlin, 3–5 October
Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664 663

11. Rasheeduzzafar, Khan A (1984) Recycled concrete-a source 27. Corinaldesi V, Moriconi G (2001) Role of chemical and min-
of new aggregate. Cement, Concrete, and Aggregates eral admixtures on performance and economics of recycled
(ASTM) 6(1):17–27. aggregate concrete. Proceedings of the 7th CANMET/ACI
12. Ravindrarajah RS, Tam CT (1985) Properties of concrete International Conference on Fly Ash, Silica Fume, Slag and
made with crushed concrete as coarse aggregate. Magazine Natural Pozzolans in Concrete, Chennai (Madras), India,
of Concrete Research, 37(130):29–38 22–27 July, 869–884
13. Tavakoli M, Soroushian P (1996) Strength of recycled ag- 28. Teranishi K, Dosho Y, Narikawa M, Kikuchi M (1998) Ap-
gregate concrete made using field-demolished concrete as plication of recycled aggregate concrete for structural con-
aggregate. ACI Materials Journal, 93(2): 182–190 crete. Proceedings of International Conference on Sustain-
14. Dhir RK, Limbachiya MC, Leelawat T (1999) Suitability able Construction: Use of Recycled Concrete Aggregate,
of recycled aggregate for use in BS 5328 designated mixes. University of Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November, 143–156
Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 134:257– 29. Yanagi K, Kasai Y (1998) Experimental study on the appli-
274 cation of recycled aggregate concrete to cast-in-place con-
15. Mandal S, Gupta A (2002) Strength and durability of re- crete pile. Proceedings of International Symposium on Sus-
cycled aggregate concrete. IABSE Symposium Melbourne, tainable Construction: Use of Recycled Concrete Aggregate,
Melbourne, Australia, 11–12 September University of Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November, 359–370
16. Limbachiya MC, Leelawat T, Dhir RK (1998) RCA concrete: 30. De Pauw P, Vyncke J (1998) Shrinkage and creep of concrete
a study of properties in the fresh state, strength development with recycled materials as coarse aggregate. Proceedings of
and durability, Proceedings of International Symposium on International Symposium Conference on Sustainable Con-
Sustainable Construction: Use of Recycled Concrete Ag- struction: Use of Recycled Concrete Aggregate, University
gregate, University of Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November, of Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November, 214–225
227–237 31. Di Niro G, Dolara E, Cairns R (1998) Properties of hardened
17. Salem RM (1996) Strength and durability characteristics of recycled aggregate concrete for structural purposes. Proceed-
recycled aggregate concrete (PhD Dissertation, University ings of International Symposium on Sustainable Construc-
of Tennessee, Knoxville) tion: Use of Recycled Concrete Aggregate, University of
18. Ikeda T, Yamane S (1988) Strengths of concrete contain- Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November, 177–187
ing recycled aggregate. Proceedings of the 2nd International 32. Kawai T, Watanabe M, Nagataki S (1988) Replaced aggre-
RILEM Symposium on Demolition and Reuse of Concrete gate concrete made from demolished concrete aggregates.
and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11 November, 585–594 Proceedings of the 2nd International RILEM Symposium
19. Kawamura M, Tori K (1988) Reuse of recycled concrete on Demolition and Reuse of Concrete and Masonry, Tokyo,
aggregate for pavement. Proceedings of the 2nd International Japan, 7–11 November, 680–689
RILEM Symposium on Demolition and Reuse of Concrete 33. Tadayoshi F (1988) Strength and drying shrinkage of con-
and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11 November, 726–735 crete using concrete crushed aggregate. Proceedings of
20. Kakizaki M, Harada M, Soshiroda T, Kubota S, Ikeda T, the 2nd International RILEM Symposium on Demolition
Kasai Y (1988) Strength and elastic modulus of recycled and Reuse of Concrete and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11
aggregate concrete. Proceedings of the 2nd International November, 672–679
RILEM Symposium on Demolition and Reuse of Concrete 34. Nihibayashi S, Yamura K (1988) Mechanical properties and
and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11 November, 565–574 durability of concrete from recycled coarse aggregate pre-
21. Roos F (2002) A contribution for the calculation of concrete pared by crushing concrete. Proceedings of the 2nd Interna-
with recycled aggregate according to DIN 1045-1 (PhD the- tional RILEM Symposium on Demolition and Reuse of Con-
sis, Munich University, 2002). (only available in German) crete and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11 November, 652–659
22. Hansen TC, Boegh E (1985) Elasticity and drying shrinkage 35. Yamato T, Emoto Y, Soeda M, Sakamoto Y. (1988) Some
of recycled aggregate concrete. ACI Journal 82(5):648–652 properties of recycled aggregate concrete. Proceedings of
23. Bairagi NK, Ravande K, Pareek VK (1993) Behaviour the 2nd International RILEM Symposium on Demolition
of concrete with different proportions of natural and re- and Reuse of Concrete and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11
cycled aggregates. Resource, Conservation and Recycling November, 643–651
9(3):109–126 36. Mulheron M, O’Mahony M (1988) The durability of recy-
24. Gómez-Soberón JMV (2002) Creep of concrete with sub- cled aggregate and recycled aggregate concrete, Proceedings
stitution of normal aggregate by recycled concrete aggre- of the 2nd International RILEM Symposium on Demolition
gate. Proceedings of the 5th ACI International Conference and Reuse of Concrete and Masonry, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11
on Innovation in Design with Emphasis on Seismic, Wind, November, 633–642
and Environmental Loading; Quality Control and Innova- 37. Poon CS, Shui ZH, Lam L, Fok H, Kou SC (2002) Strength
tions in Materials/Hot-Weather Concreting Cancun, Mexico, of concretes prepared with natural and recycled aggregates
December, 461–474 at different moisture conditions. Proceedings of the Inter-
25. Dillmann R (1998) Concrete with recycled concrete aggre- national Conference on Advances in Building Technology,
gate. Proceedings of International Symposium on Sustain- Hong Kong, China, 4–6 December, 1407–1414
able Construction: Use of Recycled Concrete Aggregate, 38. Xiao J-Zh, Li J.B, Zhang Ch (2005) Mechanical properties of
University of Dundee, Scotland, 11–12 November, 239–253 recycled aggregate concrete under uniaxial loading. Cement
26. Bretschneider A, Rühl M (1998) The influence of recycled and Concrete Research, 35(6):1187–1194
aggregate concrete on the compressive strength and the elas- 39. CEB-FIP (1990) Mode code for concrete structures design
tic modulus of concrete. Darmstadt Concrete, 13:131–141 (Paris)
664 Materials and Structures (2006) 39:655–664

40. ACI Committee 318 (2002) Building Code Require- 42. Zilch K, Roos F (2001) An equation to estimate the modu-
ments for Structural Concrete (ACI318-02) and Com- lus of elasticity of concrete with recycled aggregates. Civil
mentary (ACI318R-02) (American Concrete Institute, Engineers, 76(4):187–191. (only available in German)
Detroit) 43. Mellmann G (1999) Processed concrete rubble for the reuse
41. Guo Zh -H, Shi X-D (2003) Theory and analysis of rein- as aggregate, Proceeding of the International Seminar on Ex-
forced concrete (Tsinghua Press, Beijing). (only available in ploiting Waste in Concrete, University of Dundee, Scotland,
Chinese) 7 September, 171–178

Вам также может понравиться