Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
There are two main theories about the origin of modern humans. These two theories are
Regional Continuity and the Replacement theory. The Regional Continuity theory, also known as
Continuity, our ancestors migrated from Africa over a million years ago and from there they
spread out all over the world. They adapted themselves to the regional environment,
intermingled with populations across a large area, and became the local populations across Asia
and Europe. This widespread migration from Africa to all over the world resulted in a steady
evolution of the new species simultaneously all over the world. According to multiregional
theory, after migrating from Africa the evolution process took in different parts of the world. M.
H. Wolpoff explained his theory of regional continuity as, pebbles thrown into a pond, causing a
ripple effect resulting in similar physical traits in populations across different regions. (Wolpoff,
Milford)
This theory stresses the importance of constant adaptations to regional populations and
resulting in diverse variations of the species. According to multiregional theory modern human
beings developed in different parts of the world from Homo sapiens who in turn had descended
from Homo erectus that had migrated from Africa and settled all over the world. The supporters
of multi-regional evolution compare the fossils of humans to show the differences in physical
features of human fossils found in one region to fossils found in another region. They also
compare the physical differences between populations during modern times to support their
theory. Milford Wolpoff believed that migration and the resulting exchange of genetic traits
between populations resulted in the evolution of a species in the same overall direction. This
kind of evolution grew at a steady pace because of the combination of cultural progress and
interbreeding or gene flow. This led to all species evolving at the same time. This process is also
Franz Weindenreich a German anthropologist also observed that human races have
evolved independently from Homo erectus to Homo sapiens while simultaneously there was a
gene flow between populations from different regions. He called his theory Polycentric
evolution. Weindenreich studied the fossils of Peking man which was unearthed in China. He
observed that the Peking man had many anatomical characteristics that were similar to modern
Asians.
The other theory is the Replacement theory. According to this theory modern humans
evolved not very long ago in Africa. They migrated to Europe and Asia and replaced all
populations in that area. (Stringer and Andrews 1988). The proponents of this theory believe that
after migrating from Africa, they spread to different parts of the world and became isolated.
They did not interbreed and evolved independently, into separate species. Supporters of this
theory believe that modern humans evolved from a single group of Homo sapiens. They came to
this conclusion based on genetic studies and fossil evidence. According to them modern humans
evolved from Homo sapiens as recently as 60,000 to 125,000 years ago. These isolated species
called Neanderthals had unique anatomical features like large, low cranial arch, double arched
brow ridge, large molars, severely worn incisors, shorter fore arms and legs. (Johanson, Donald)
Forster, showed that there has only been a single successful migration from Africa around 60,000
years ago. This data was compared with DNA patterns of early humans. The results showed that
both aboriginals and Melanesians shared the genetic features with the population that left Africa
50,000 years ago. Thus proving very little gene flow from the time of the original migration.
This study showed that all mitochondrial DNA came from one woman and she lived in Africa
around 200,000 years ago. She came to be known as “Mitochondrial Eve” or “African Eve”.
A study done by biologist Andrea Manica and her team from University of Cambridge,
compared male skulls from different parts of the world. They found that the cranial shape of the
skull was only found in skulls from Africa. Another research in 1579 done with female skulls
proved the same thing. These skulls shared the same features as the Neanderthals. No other
region outside of Africa shared the same characteristics, thus proving strongly in favor of Out-of-
Even though there is genetic and archeological evidence for both theories, I personally
believe in Out-of-Africa theory. There is evidence that supports the Replacement theory, such as
the DNA research showing the similarities between Neanderthals and modern humans. This is
the basis of my choice, because there is proof of similarities between the two. The DNA test
gives some kind of physical proof that modern humans originated from a common ancestor,
referred to as “Mitochondrial Eve”. There is sufficient evidence to show that she lived in Africa.
Also, the study done by Andrea Manica further reinforces the theory of Out-of-Africa evolution
theory.
Works Cited
Wolpoff, Milford H., and Rachel Caspari. Race and Human Evolution. New York: Simon &
Schuster, 1997. Print.