Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
We call on Governments of the top ten economies of the world to enact laws, at least as strong
as the UK Modern Slavery Act 2015, with a budget and capability to ensure organisations are
held to account for modern slavery in their supply chains, and to empower independent oversight.
Government intervention
can have immediate impact
The men in this photo are raising their hands, having been asked “who
wants to go home?” by the Indonesian authorities who came to rescue
them in April 2015. The men, mostly from Myanmar, were used as slave
labour on Thai fishing boats, where they were beaten with sting-ray tails,
shocked with Taser-like devices at sea, forced to work almost non-stop
without clean water or proper food, paid little or nothing and prevented
from going home.
These men were saved by government intervention. We call on all
Governments to take action to identify and release victims of slavery,
and to hold those responsible to account.
Photo credit, AP Photo/Dita Alangkara
call to action
We call on Governments of the top ten economies of the world to
enact laws, at least as strong as the UK Modern Slavery Act 2015,
with a budget and capability to ensure organisations are held to
account for modern slavery in their supply chains, and to empower
independent oversight.
Cover image:
A Syrian family flees to In few other spheres is the need
Turkey when Islamic State for courageous and committed
attacked their home town
Kobane in September 2014.
leadership so critical. Personally,
Some 3,500 people, mainly I unashamedly use business to
women and children, were help end slavery and I ask every
being held in slavery in Iraq
by Islamic State in January chairman and chief executive to join
2016. This family fleeing is me. Organisations that don’t actively
highly vulnerable to modern look for forced labour within their
slavery and governments
who make the decisions we supply chains are standing on a
recommend will not only burning platform.
protect these people by their
own actions but provide These leaders, like all of us need
invaluable leadership to
the rest of the world.
support and empowerment to
Photo Credit, Ismail Ferdous
make major change. This is where
governments can play a leading role.
Copyright © 2016. Walk Free Foundation. All rights reserved.
Andrew Forrest
Printed in Australia/ United Kingdom/ India A Personal Message to Leaders
FOREWORD By Andrew Forrest
– A Personal Message to Leaders
Slavery is abhorrent, more rampant than at any time in history,
and entirely avoidable. Unlike major world epidemics such as
malaria and HIV/AIDS, slavery is a human condition of our own
making. While that in itself is a tragedy, it also means that we
have the power to end it. And end slavery we must; we cannot
allow future generations to fall prey to this hideous practice.
Improving the rights of 45.8 million human beings is both
wise and urgent for all leaders of countries and organisations.
Eradicating slavery makes sense, morally, politically, logically
and economically.
Slavery and its components, forced labour and trafficking, are
the ultimate economic negative multipliers. Nowhere is this more
apparent than the powerful economic forces unleashed by the
liberation of Chinese people, the greatest freeing from poverty
in human history. From President Deng to President Xi, the most
compelling evidence that freedom of people leads to immediate
economic growth is proved. Where slavery is allowed to exist for
the few pennies it might save, the host economy loses hundreds,
if not many thousands of times more in economic terms.
In few other spheres is the need for courageous and committed
leadership so critical. Personally, I unashamedly use business to
help end slavery and I ask every chairman and chief executive
to join me. Businesses that don’t actively look for forced labour
within their supply chains are standing on a burning platform.
These leaders, like all of us, need support and empowerment to
make major change. This is where governments can play a leading
role. We call on Governments of the top ten economies of the world
to enact laws, at least as strong as the UK Modern Slavery Act 2015,
with a budget and capability to ensure organisations are held to
account for modern slavery in their supply chains, and to empower
independent oversight.
As the slavery consciousness of the world increases, the types
of practices that I found in child “sanctuaries” in Nepal and
discovered in my own supply chains in the Middle East, will be
in the spotlight. I found slavery everywhere, simply because I
These chains were used to keep looked. Leaders who refuse to look into the realities of their own
Geronimo Sanchez Bravo inside supply chains are deluded and irresponsible.
a truck every night after he Slavery is an evil and corrupt practice. The sovereign leaders
worked picking tomatoes for his and corporations, who signal they have had enough of slavery
captors in the United States. He in their social systems and are prepared to move quickly to
escaped and testified against his eradicate slave masters and incarcerate those who continue to
captors, who were sentenced to practice after warnings, will send the best possible economic
12 years in prison. signals to the investment world. I can confidently state that there
is no shortage of capital in the world, but there is a dearth of
Photo credit, Jon Lowenstein/NOOR. responsible, attractive investment destinations.
45.8
ESTIMATED NUMBER OF PEOPLE IN MODERN SLAVERY GLOBALLY
MILLION
58%
The countries with the highest proportion
of their population in modern slavery are:
North Korea Syria
OF THOSE LIVING Uzbekistan South Sudan
IN SLAVERY ARE IN
Cambodia Somalia
COUNTRIES
5 India
Qatar
Libya
Central African
Pakistan Republic
INDIA Democratic Republic Mauritania
CHINA of the Congo Haiti
Sudan Dominican Republic
PAKISTAN
Iraq Myanmar
BANGLADESH Afghanistan Bangladesh
UZBEKISTAN Yemen
GOVERNMENTS TAKING ACTION
MOST ACTION MOST ACTION BY GDP*
++The Netherlands ++Philippines
++United States of America ++Georgia
++United Kingdom ++Brazil
++Sweden ++Jamaica
++Australia ++Croatia
++Portugal ++Montenegro
++Croatia ++Macedonia
++Spain ++Moldova
++Belgium ++Albania
++Norway ++Serbia
*GDP = Gross Domestic Product per capita in terms of Purchasing Power Parity
HIGHLIGHTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
COMMENTARY. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Measuring Modern Slavery - Work in Rapid Progress. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Jan Van Dijk
Connecting Slavery and Environmental Destruction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Kevin Bales
Distress Migration and Modern Slavery. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Fiona David
GLOBAL FINDINGS.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Prevalence. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Table 1 - Estimated proportion of population in modern slavery by counrty. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Table 2 - Absolute number of people in modern slavery by country. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Vulnerability.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
Table 3 - Measures of vulnerability to modern slavery by country . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34
Government Responses. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
Table 4 - Rank of countries by government response. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
REGIONAL ANALYSIS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
Asia Pacific. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50
Europe. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58
Russia and Eurasia. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66
Sub-Saharan Africa. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72
Middle East and Northern Africa. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80
The Americas. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88
SELECTED COUNTRY STUDIES.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96
Cambodia. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98
Dominican Republic. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104
India. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 108
Iraq. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118
Mauritania. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122
Mexico. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126
Poland. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130
Qatar.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134
Russia. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138
South Africa. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 142
Thailand. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146
United Kingdom. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152
APPENDICES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156
Appendix 1: Terminology.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158
Appendix 2: Summary of Methodology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 159
ENDNOTES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 176
Stone Scavengers of Jafflong, Bangladesh. At least 10,000 people, including over 2,500 women and 1,000 child labourers, are
engaged in stone and sand collection. Limited job opportunities push these individuals to migrate from other parts of Bangladesh.
They survive on less than 150 taka a day (about US$2).
Photo credit, GMB Akash
The Global Slavery Index is based on state of the art research In 2016, Cambodia has the third highest estimated prevalence
methodology that has been developed with the assistance of an of modern slavery. In Cambodia, extensive literature details the
independent Expert Working Group, comprised of world leading prevalence of commercial sexual exploitation and forced begging.
experts. The methodology has also been subjected to independent Our survey data highlight the existence of modern slavery in
external review. This estimate is based on data from nationally- manufacturing, farming, construction and domestic work.
representative, random sample surveys conducted in 25 countries. In 2016, we estimate 18.3 million people are in some form of
All surveys were conducted face-to-face in key local languages modern slavery in India. This estimate reflects extensive surveying
using a standardised instrument. Collectively, these surveys conducted in 2016 in 15 states. While many impressive efforts are
represent 44 percent of the global population. The results of these being taken by the Indian Government to address vulnerability,
surveys have been extrapolated to countries with an equivalent survey data suggest that domestic work, construction, farming,
risk profile. fishing, manual labour and the sex industry remain sectors of concern.
The 2016 estimate is an increase on the estimate provided in the The ten countries with the largest estimated absolute numbers
previous edition of the Index. As efforts to measure this hidden of people in modern slavery include some of the world’s most
crime are still relatively new, we are not asserting that modern populous countries: India, China, Pakistan, Bangladesh,
slavery has increased in the intervening period. Indeed, results Uzbekistan, North Korea, Russia, Nigeria, the Democratic
from our surveys reveal some national estimates have increased Republic of the Congo, and Indonesia. Several of these
while others have decreased. We believe that the overall larger countries provide the low cost labour that produces consumer
number reflects a significant increase in the quality and quantity goods for markets in Western Europe, Japan, North America and
of research on this issue. While the methodology will continually Australia. Some of these countries are taking important steps
improve, even at this early stage, survey data have greatly improved towards stamping out abuses in key industries. For example,
the accuracy of our measures. Indonesia’s work on rescuing and repatriating two thousand
trafficked fishermen is commendable.
TERMINOLOGY
Different countries use different terminology to describe modern forms of slavery, including the term
slavery itself, but also other concepts such as human trafficking, forced labour, debt bondage, forced
or servile marriage, and the sale and exploitation of children.
While definitions vary, in this report, modern slavery refers to situations of exploitation that a person
cannot refuse or leave because of threats, violence, coercion, abuse of power or deception, with
treatment akin to a farm animal. For example, their passport might be taken away if they are in a
foreign country, they may experience or be threatened with violence or their family might be threatened.
Refer to Appendix 1 for full terminology.
Modern slavery is a hidden crime that affects every country in the world. In 2015–2016, modern
slavery was found in many industries including the Thai fishing, Uzbek and Turkmenistan cotton, and
the Qatari construction industries. It was identified in the domestic households of diplomats, in Islamic
State (IS)[1] controlled areas, and in areas that have experienced natural disasters, such as Nepal, and
environmental destruction, such as the Democratic Republic of the Congo. It impacts on all of us,
from the food we consume and the goods we purchase. It is our responsibility to tackle this crime.
Nearly every country in the world has committed to eradicate modern slavery through their national
legislation and policies. Governments have a central role to play by enacting legislation, providing safety
nets to their populations, and pursuing criminals who participate in this heinous crime. Governments
need the support and engagement of civil society, the private sector and the community.
THE INDEX
The Global Slavery Index is a tool for citizens, non-government organisations (NGOs), businesses, and
governments to understand the size of the problem, existing responses, and contributing factors so that
they can advocate for and build sound policies that will eradicate modern slavery.
The Global Slavery Index has quantified data across three dimensions:
All supporting data tables and methodology are available to download from the Global Slavery
Index website: www.globalslaveryindex.org
Measuring the number of people in modern slavery is a difficult undertaking due to the hidden nature
of this crime and low levels of victim identification. Since 2014, we have conducted 25 surveys with
the Gallup[2] through their World Poll, interviewing over 28,000 respondents in 52 languages. This
year we also conducted state-level surveys in India. When these are included, we have interviewed
over 42,000 respondents in 53 different languages. The prevalence estimates in the Index are based on
data from these surveys, the results of which have been extrapolated to countries with an equivalent
risk profile.
The Global Slavery Index includes a model of 24 variables which affect vulnerability to enslavement.
These include:
• Civil and political protections
• Social, health and economic rights
• Personal security
• Refugees and conflict
These factors were identified by statistical testing as being relevant to prevalence of modern slavery.
The final component of the Index is a score of 161[3] government responses based on an assessment
of 98 indicators of good practice, taking into account factors such as whether each country has the
necessary laws in place, provides support to victims, and ensures application of labour standards
to vulnerable populations. Research for this aspect of the Index involved a partnership between the
Walk Free Foundation’s research team and DataMotivate, an organisation that provides training and
employment for survivors of modern slavery in the Philippines.
A summary of the methodology is Appendix 2, and a detailed methodology paper is available online.
Measuring Modern Slavery modern slavery might be too rare, and unevenly distributed
among the population, to be measurable through random
- Work in Rapid Progress sampling among national populations. Focussed sampling,
for example among vulnerable immigrant populations, might
JAN VAN DIJK be required. Also, successful interviewing of respondents
Tilburg University, The Netherlands, winner of the Stockholm about victimisation by sexual slavery may, just like other
Prize in Criminology 2012 sensitive crimes, need special interview techniques.
Interestingly, an alternative and complementary method to
International organisations such as the United Nations estimate the true numbers of victims of modern slavery is
Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and the International also identified in the Index. For the calculation of rates for
Labour Organization (ILO) over the past twenty years, Western countries, the report has made use of the results of
have made great strides in the measurement of modern the application of Multiple Systems Estimation (MSE) to
slavery across the world with their Global Reports on the multi-source data on victims identified by the British
Trafficking in Persons and Global Estimates of Forced authorities. According to this innovative study the real
Labour respectively. With the adoption by the United number of persons exploited in the United Kingdom is
Nations of eradicating human trafficking as a Sustainable four to five times higher than those formally identified.[4] A
Development Goal (SDG), this challenging work now UNODC-sponsored replication of this work on the dataset
needs to be geared up. As a performance measure, the of the Dutch National Rapporteur on Human Trafficking
UN member states have agreed on the “number of victims came up with an even higher ratio between identified and
of human trafficking per 100,000 population, by sex, real numbers in the Netherlands.[5]
age group and form of exploitation”. But how can this MSE, like standardised population surveys, holds great
possibly be done when the numbers of officially identified promise for better international crime statistics. This seems
victims tell us next to nothing about the real numbers, and especially to be the case with statistics on the complex crime
international research on the prevalence of crime remains of modern slavery. In many countries across the world,
fraught with political sensitivities? Might the adoption possible victims of modern slavery are identified through
of this ambitious performance measure prove to be just multi-agency National Referral Mechanisms comprising of
another 'pie in the sky'? police forces, immigration and labour inspectorates as well
Against this background, the fact that the Walk Free as NGOs. In many such countries, multi-source datasets are
Foundation now presents a Global Slavery Index—based available on the possible victims of modern slavery. While
on the results of standardised surveys on family-wide the possibility of victims being recorded by two or more
experiences with victimisation by modern slavery in 25 organisations was initially regarded as complicating their
countries—is an extraordinarily well-timed feat. Although accumulation to total counts, the double or triple counting
much work remains to be done, these 25 surveys conducted of the same victims on different lists now proves to be an
by Gallup Inc. show the global community the way forward asset by offering unique opportunities for estimating the true
with monitoring the SDG to end human trafficking. numbers through statistical modelling. If more countries
would apply the same estimation technique to their multi-
If the prevalence of crime is ever to be reliably measured agency databases on identified victims, a new source of
in a comparative fashion, standardised surveys among the international statistics on the prevalence of victimisation
population surely are the only viable approach. The track by human trafficking becomes available. Since the datasets
record of the International Crime Victims Survey, up till on identified victims in many countries predominantly refer
now carried out in about 90 countries once or more, and to victims of modern sexual slavery, MSE-based estimates
most recently in five countries in the Caribbean, bears provide a welcome complement to survey-based estimates
testimony to this. of modern slavery largely focusing on forced labour. MSE
The global community is well-advised to follow this has the potential to produce estimates of modern slavery by
best practice and start securing funds for carrying out sex, age and type of exploitation, just as suggested in the
standardised surveys not only on experiences with Monitoring Framework for the SDGs.
modern slavery, but with other types of violent crime The new Global Slavery Index, then, shows us two new,
including domestic violence against women and children. parallel tracks to collect reliable statistics on the numbers
Partnerships between International Organisations and of victims of modern slavery: the conduct of standardised
private foundations have proved to be instrumental in many surveys on experiences with victimisation by this crime, and
of the achievements under the UN’s previous development the execution of Multiple Systems Estimation using data
agenda. It is hoped that similar cooperation will drive the on identified victims. Just when this was more opportune
implementation of the new development agenda, including than ever before, a promising new generation of statistics on
by facilitating statistical monitoring of successes and modern slavery has been launched.
lapses with the use of innovative metrics.
As discussed in the Index, survey-based measures, although
holding great promise, have their own methodological
limitations. In the most-developed countries, victimisation by
Far from being an isolated incidence, her treatment reflects Beyond immediate realities, a strong focus on safe, well-
a deliberate strategy of war, as publications released by managed migration, whether in times of peace or conflict,
IS[8] provide that—"it is permissible to buy, sell, or give must become a cornerstone of integrated international and
as a gift female captives and slaves, for they are merely national responses to modern slavery. Responses must take
property, which can be disposed of…" into account the reality of the disproportionate effect of
conflict upon women and children—but should not ignore
The effects of the conflict are felt heavily in neighbouring the plight of men in these areas. Without this holistic
countries who typically bear most of the burden of response, we not only risk perpetuating enslavement—we
providing shelter. Walk Free and IOM research conducted risk compounding the horrors of war to those who most
in 2015 confirms that in Jordan and Lebanon, the massive need our shelter.
in-flux of refugees has had a trifold effect on the already
existing populations of migrant workers from Asia (see Time will show that our complicity in modern slavery will
Middle East North Africa regional study). First, there be measured by our response to its perpetrators. We should
is increased competition between refugees and existing all strive to be on the right side of history.
migrant workers for the lowest-paid, highest-risk jobs
in the informal sector, suggesting a rapid race to the
bottom. Second, there has been an increase in situations
of criminals taking advantage of vulnerability, through
forced begging, forced prostitution and forced marriage.
A Syrian family flees to Turkey when Islamic State attacked their home town Kobane in September 2014. Some 3,500 people,
mainly women and children, were being held in slavery in Iraq by Islamic State in January 2016.
Photo Credit, Ismail Ferdous
High Low
PREVALENCE
However, it is important that lack of data does not prevent North The situation in the Middle East, involving protracted, multiple
Korea from being held to account. conflicts and the expansion of the so-called Islamic State (IS),
has rapidly increased the numbers of internally-displaced people
As was the case in 2014, Uzbekistan has the second highest
and refugees. In these countries, due to conflict and displacement,
proportion of people in modern slavery, due to the high level of
our estimates are less reliable. At the same time, the dramatic
state-imposed forced labour. Although the Uzbek Government
increase in vulnerability of refugee populations is already being
has taken steps to address forced labour in the cotton industry
seen to generate enslavement.
with the introduction of a feedback mechanism and increased
monitoring, it continues to subject Uzbek citizens to forced
labour in the cotton harvest each year.
One facet of this is the open and
Cambodia entered the top ten in 2016. A national survey specific use of enslavement by
revealed that 1.6 percent of Cambodians are in some form of
modern slavery. While existing research details the prevalence of IS militants as part of their war
commercial sexual exploitation and forced begging in Cambodia, effort. A United Nations report in
the national survey confirmed the existence of modern slavery
in manufacturing, farming, construction and domestic work. January 2016 stated that some
The country with the fourth highest proportion of modern slavery
3,500 people, mainly women
is India. Reflecting data from 15 state-level surveys conducted and children, were being held in
in 2016, an estimated 18.3 million people are in some form of slavery in Iraq by Islamic State,
modern slavery in India. The national and state governments
are taking steps to address modern slavery by implementing and noted that other ethnic and
legislation through Anti Human Trafficking police Units, and religious minority communities
responding to vulnerability through the provision of safety nets
such as education, birth registration and labour inspections. were also being targeted.[10]
However, survey data suggests that domestic work, construction,
farming, fishing, other manual labour, and the sex industry The destruction of the rule of law that comes with war, as well as
remain sectors of concern. the ruin of infrastructure, schools, health care and whole cities in
this regional conflict, increasing levels of violence, and the very
Qatar remains in the top five in the third edition of the Index. With large numbers of refugees fleeing Iraq, Syria and neighbouring
an estimated 1.4 percent of people in modern slavery, its ranking countries, suggest that this region will see an increase in slavery
reflects the high number of migrant workers enslaved in the nation. in the future.
Although steps have been taken to improve legislative protections
for migrant workers, domestic workers are excluded and remain The lowest prevalence of modern slavery continues to be found
extremely vulnerable. With no new data available, and reports of in countries in Western Europe, the United States and Canada,
abuses continuing, this estimate remains conservative. The ten and Australia and New Zealand. Estimates for these countries
countries with the largest estimated absolute numbers of people have also increased with the introduction of a new statistical
in modern slavery include some of the world’s most populous technique[11],Multiple Systems Estimation (MSE), that allows
countries: India, China, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Uzbekistan, more precise measurement when random sample surveys are
North Korea, Russia, Nigeria, the Democratic Republic of the not effective. The United Kingdom (UK) and the Netherlands
Congo, and Indonesia. Collectively, these ten countries account were the first countries to use this technique.
for 68 percent of people living in modern slavery.
Uzbekistan is the world’s sixth largest producer of cotton. During the annual cotton harvest, citizens are subjected to state-
sanctioned forced labour. Monitoring by international organisations has meant the government has begun to take steps to
improve the situation, however, reports from the 2015 harvest estimate that over one million people were forced to work.
Photo credit, Simon Buxton/Anti-Slavery International
* Indicates nationally-representative Gallup survey data or data from multiple systems estimation was available for this country. For surveys, this includes
Brazil, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Nepal, Nigeria, Pakistan, Russia, Chile, Dominican Republic, Ghana, Guatemala, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Philippines,
Poland, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Tunisia, and Vietnam. For MSE, this included the Netherlands and United Kingdom.
Vulnerability to modern slavery is affected by a complex Statistical testing grouped 24 measures of vulnerability into four
interaction of factors related to the presence or absence of dimensions covering: 1) civil and political protections, 2) social
protection and respect for rights, physical safety and security, health and economic rights, 3) personal security, and 4) refugee
access to the necessities of life such as food, water and health populations and conflict. See Appendix 2 for further information
care, and patterns of migration, displacement and conflict. about our methodology, including data sources.
United Arab Emirates (UAE), Dubai. Migrant labourers working on extending the Dubai beach, close to the Burj Al
Arab Hotel (right). The employers keep their employees' passports when they arrive and pay their workers around
US$167 a month.
Photo credit, Xavier Cervera
*Note high presence of missing data for these countries. These results should be interpreted with caution. These countries have less than 50 percent of
data available on Dimensions 3 and 4.
High Low
AAA AA A BBB BB B CCC CC C D
This year, the UK has also joined the list of governments that Despite these positive steps, very few countries take active steps
are implementing measures to hold businesses to account. to learn from the experiences of survivors, either in relation to
Commercial organisations in the UK are now required to their experience of receiving victim support or as participants in
prepare a slavery and human trafficking statement each financial the criminal justice system. The United States offers an exception
year. Despite these positive steps, the number of governments to this rule and provides a model for survivor leadership.
engaging with businesses and investigating public procurement President Obama has formed an Advisory Council on Human
remains small with only four (the UK, Brazil, the USA, and to Trafficking made up entirely of survivors. There is also a national
a more limited extent, Australia) taking action. network of over 200 survivors who meet regularly to work on
strategic advocacy at the local and national levels.
More recently, in the USA, President Obama closed a loophole
in legislation which had previously made it impossible to enforce Those governments taking the least action to combat modern
laws against the importation of goods made with forced labour slavery are: North Korea, Iran, Eritrea, Equatorial Guinea, Hong
or by children.[16] Previously, if these goods met ‘consumptive Kong, Central African Republic, Papua New Guinea, Guinea, the
demand’, they could still be imported. As a result of these Democratic Republic of the Congo and South Sudan.
much-needed changes, in April 2016, US border agents seized Some of these countries are characterised by government
shipments they suspected were made with forced labour; the first complicity, as is the case in North Korea; low levels of political
time this has occurred since 2001.[17] will in countries like Iran; fewer resources, as with Papua New
It is not just governments at the top of the table that are taking Guinea; or high levels of conflict, as is the case in South Sudan
positive action to respond to modern slavery. As with the 2014 and Central African Republic. Hong Kong is one country in a
findings, when correlated against GDP(PPP), some countries group of wealthier countries that has taken relatively limited
stand out as taking relatively strong action when compared with action due to low level of recognition that modern slavery occurs.
those that have stronger economies.
AAA 90 to 100 The government has implemented an effective and comprehensive response to all forms of modern
slavery, with effective emergency and long-term reintegration victim support services, a strong
criminal justice framework, high levels of coordination and collaboration, measures to address
all forms of vulnerability, and strong government procurement policies and legislation to ensure
that slavery is not present in business supply chains. There is no evidence of criminalisation or
deportation of victims.
AA 80 to 89.9 The government has implemented a comprehensive response to most forms of modern slavery, with
strong victim support services, a robust criminal justice framework, demonstrated coordination and
collaboration, measures to address vulnerability, and government procurement guidelines and/or
supply chain policies or legislation to ensure that slavery is not present in business supply chains.
A 70 to 79.9 The government has implemented key components of a holistic response to some forms of modern
slavery, with strong victim support services, a strong criminal justice framework, demonstrated
coordination and collaboration, measures to address vulnerability, and may have taken action to
ensure that government procurement policies do not encourage slavery.
BBB 60 to 69.9 The government has implemented key components of a holistic response to modern slavery,
with victim support services, a strong criminal justice response, evidence of coordination and
collaboration, and protections in place for vulnerable populations. Governments may be beginning
to address slavery in supply chains of government procurement, or of businesses operating within
their territory. There may be evidence that some government policies and practices may criminalise
and/or cause victims to be deported.
BB 50 to 59.9 The government has introduced a response to modern slavery, which includes short-term victim
support services, a criminal justice framework that criminalises some forms of modern slavery, a
body to coordinate the response, and protection for those vulnerable to modern slavery. There may
be evidence that some government policies and practices may criminalise and/or cause victims to
be deported and/or facilitate slavery.
B 40 to 49.9 The government has introduced a response to modern slavery, with limited victim support services,
a criminal justice framework that criminalises some forms of modern slavery (or has recently
amended inadequate legislation and policies), a body or mechanisms that coordinate the response,
and has policies that provide some protection for those vulnerable to modern slavery. There is
evidence that some government policies and practices may criminalise and/or deport victims and/
or facilitate slavery. Services may be provided by International Organisations (IOs)/NGOs with
international funding, sometimes with government monetary or in-kind support.
CCC 30 to 39.9 The government has a limited response to modern slavery, with limited victim support services,
a criminal justice framework that criminalises some forms of modern slavery, and has policies
that provide some protection for those vulnerable to modern slavery. There may be evidence of a
national action plan and/or national coordination body. There may be evidence that some government
policies and practices may criminalise and/or deport victims and/or facilitate slavery. Services may
be largely provided by IOs/NGOs with international funding, with limited government funding
or in-kind support.
CC 20 to 29.9 The government has a limited response to modern slavery, with largely basic victim support services,
a limited criminal justice framework, limited coordination or collaboration mechanism, and few
protections for those vulnerable to modern slavery. There may be evidence that some government
policies and practices facilitate slavery. Services are largely provided by IOs/NGOs with limited
government funding or in-kind support.
C 10 to 19.9 The government response to modern slavery is inadequate, with limited and/or few victim support
services, a weak criminal justice framework, weak coordination or collaboration, while little is
being done to address vulnerability. There are government practices and policies that facilitate
slavery. Services, where available, are largely provided by IOs/NGOs with little government
funding or in-kind support.
D <0 to 9.9 The government has a wholly inadequate response to modern slavery, and/or there is evidence of
government-sanctioned modern slavery. However, countries in this category may be experiencing
high levels of poverty and internal conflict that may prevent or hinder a response to modern slavery.
Bosnia and
B 57.41 43.70 31.25 69.05 0.00 48.54
Herzegovina
CCC Trinidad and Tobago 31.11 44.63 31.25 66.67 0.00 39.69
Democratic Republic
C 7.78 11.67 31.25 26.19 0.00 15.01
of the Congo
Central African
C 14.81 17.22 12.50 7.14 0.00 11.02
Republic
C Hong Kong, SAR China 5.93 5.19 0.00 30.95 0.00 10.75
No Rank Afghanistan
No Rank Iraq
No Rank Libya
No Rank Somalia
No Rank Syria
No Rank Yemen
HONG KONG,
SAR CHINA
CHINA
TAIWAN
LAO PDR
INDIA VIETNAM
CAMBODIA
MYANMAR PHILIPPINES
THAILAND BRUNEI
INDONESIA
PAPUA
NEW GUINEA
TIMOR-LESTE
AUSTRALIA
NEW ZEALAND
30,435,300 66.4%
Average Government Response Rating Average Vulnerability Score
34.8/100 40.2/100
50 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Asia Pacific cont.
PREVALENCE
Estimated percent of Estimated number
Rank Country population in modern slavery in modern slavery Population
The Asia-Pacific is the most populous region of the world. It were also noted in countries with low levels of prevalence, such
spans Afghanistan in the west, to New Zealand in the south-east, as Australia.[8]
to Mongolia in the north. Two thirds of the estimated 45.8 million
people in modern slavery were identified in the Asia-Pacific. All
forms of modern slavery were identified including forced labour The high prevalence of modern
in brick kilns, agriculture and the garment sector,[1] child soldiers
in Afghanistan,[2] India[3] and Thailand,[4] forced begging, and
slavery in the region reflects the
commercial sexual exploitation. Men and women experienced reality that many countries in Asia
forced labour in manufacturing, agriculture, food production and provide low-skilled labour for the
construction. Women were also vulnerable to sexual exploitation,
forced marriage and domestic servitude. production stage of global supply
Large numbers of women and girls continued to migrate chains for various industries
internally and internationally for jobs as domestic workers. including food production,
While this offers an important economic opportunity, reports of
abuse, exploitation and servitude persist, particularly in wealthy
garments and technology.
countries within the region where there was high demand for
Within low-skilled and loosely-regulated industries, there is a
live-in help—Hong Kong, Japan, Malaysia, Singapore and
risk of modern slavery, such as human trafficking, forced labour
Taiwan. Inhumane treatment of domestic workers including
and debt bondage. In 2015–2016, there were cases of forced
starvation[5] and sexual abuse[6] was reported in 2015, as well as
labour within the Malaysian electronics industry,[9] exploitation
indicators of forced labour including extortionate recruitment
on Malaysian palm oil plantations,[10] and debt bondage in
fees, confinement to the place of employment, excessive unpaid
the apparel industries of Bangladesh[11] and Vietnam.[12] The
overtime, withholding of wages and confiscation of identity
reputational risk of slavery in supply chains compelled action
documents.[7] In 2016, cases of domestic worker exploitation
The International Organisation for Migration (IOM) is the in IOM’s web-based case management system (MiMOSA).
largest provider of services to victims of human trafficking This is the source of information presented below.
across the globe. In 2015, an estimated 7,000 victims
The graphics below present data from victims of trafficking
of trafficking were assisted by the Organisation in 117
registered in IOM’s case management system in 2015
countries of destination. The Organisation also collected
in Asia-Pacific.
in-depth information for 4,858 newly-identified victims of
trafficking from 65 countries of nationality, in 59 countries *The numbers in 'sector of exploitation' and 'types of exploitation' are
based on a breakdown of total cases for which data exists. Information
of destination/identification. This detailed data is recorded about type and sector of exploitation is not collected in every case.
30.7yrs
Approximately 50% of all victims were
ages between 25 and 35
Sex Breakdown
17.1% Female [281]
# #
2 Sold by
Non-Family
All countries within the Asia-Pacific exhibit some pre-conditions Unemployment and underemployment are chronic problems in the
to modern slavery. Some countries, such as Afghanistan and region which push men, women and children into risky migration
Pakistan have high levels of conflict, terrorism and displacement. practices and debt bondage. In 2015, the unemployment rate in
In other countries, such as Thailand and Myanmar, there is Afghanistan soared to 40 percent.[46] Myanmar also experienced
significant discrimination against minorities. Some countries a high youth unemployment rate of 9.5 percent,[47] which
in the region continue to exhibit weak rule of law, corruption assisted the Tatmadaw (Myanmar Armed Forces) to recruit and
and poverty, all of which increase individuals risk to modern use underage children in conflict. According to Child Soldiers
slavery. Though countries like Australia and New Zealand exhibit International, unaccompanied children searching for work were
high levels of development, stability and strong policies, some recruited at railway stations, bus terminals, markets and outside
minority groups, including regular and irregular migrants, remain temples, and deceptively offered roles as drivers.[48]
at risk of exploitation.
High levels of labour migration, some of which is regular but
can involve payment of illegal fees or other irregular aspects,
are reflected in patterns of exploitation. The Philippines has
As a result of economic growth, one of the largest migratory populations with their national
poverty rates across the region economy largely depending on Overseas Filipino Worker's
have fallen, notably in India (OFW) remittances.[49] The OFWs have been deemed the 'new
heroes' of the Philippines' economy.[50] However, some OFWs are
and China.[44] subjected to exploitation throughout the Asia-Pacific, Europe,
North America and the Middle East.[51] In November 2015, ten
Nonetheless, extreme poverty and unequal income distribution Filipina trafficking victims in Iraqi Kurdistan were rescued and
within countries, particularly between the rural and urban repatriated by the Philippine Embassy after being subjected to
populations, persist as serious social and economic challenges.[45] debt bondage.[52]
Natural disasters and the effects climatic conditions also exacerbate vulnerability,[57] increasing
the potential for internal displacement, migration and willingness
of climate change have increased to search for improved livelihood opportunities through informal
vulnerability to modern slavery. channels.[58] Throughout 2015–16, cyclones in Myanmar,[59]
flooding in India, and drought in Vietnam[60] have increased
Human traffickers preyed upon insecurity for thousands of people.
post-disaster populations[53] Systematic discrimination against some ethnic minorities and
who are vulnerable to accepting stateless populations across the region has resulted in patterns
promises of jobs and security. of high-risk migration. The Rohingya people, a Muslim ethnic
group living in Myanmar, continue to face systemic persecution
and denial of rights. In April 2015, the Myanmar Government
This was evidenced following Typhoon Haiyan where human
stripped Rohingya of their voting rights by rescinding their
traffickers were intercepted trafficking young women on false
temporary ID cards, the last official identification available to
job offers,[54] and seen again in 2015, after earthquakes in Nepal
them.[61] Many lost their homes, farms, and the ability to work,
displaced more than two million people.[55] Since then, Indian
creating a dire choice between residing in shanty towns on the
officials uncovered trafficking networks with an estimated
outskirts of Rakhine or paying smugglers to transport them
12,000 Nepalese children trafficked to India.[56] Evolving
abroad. In 2015, thousands were left stranded at sea.[62]
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Credit Survivors Criminal Coordination & Government &
rating Country supported justice accountability Addressing risk business Total score
C Hong Kong, SAR China 5.93 5.19 0.00 30.95 0.00 10.75
No Rank Afghanistan
In 2015, of the 25 countries within the Asia-Pacific, 24 have laws Official complicity and widespread corruption have also enabled
that criminalise some forms of modern slavery. North Korea forced labour and debt bondage to occur within the PNG
remains the only nation in Asia—and the world—that has not commercial mining and logging industry.[78] In Cambodia, corrupt
explicitly criminalised any form of modern slavery. Australia, officials have stalled progress in case investigations where the
New Zealand and the Philippines have the strongest responses to perpetrators are believed to have political, criminal or economic
modern slavery. These countries have reasonably strong victim ties to government officials.[79] In May 2015, the discovery of
support services, specialised law enforcement units, effective abandoned people smuggling camps on the Thai/Malaysia border
and measurable NAPs, and laws, policies and programmes that presented concerning evidence of official complicity in the trade
address cycles of vulnerability. and exploitation of Rohingya people. One of the mass grave
sites was located in an open field behind the police station in
Victim-centred assistance programmes which empower
Padang Besar, some 500 metres from the official border crossing
victims are essential to break the cycle of modern slavery. In
manned by officials from Thailand and Malaysia. Several arrests
the Philippines, the government has supported NGO victim
of allegedly complicit officials have been made, including the
recovery and reintegration programmes providing victims
arrest of army Lt. Gen. Manas Kongpan together with 52 local
with shelter, psychological, medical, legal and vocational
politicians, community leaders, businessmen, and gangsters for
support.[63] Innovative programmes, such as DataMotivate,
smuggling and trafficking.[80]
allows survivors to develop vocational skills in research and
data cleaning. In Australia, the Salvation Army offers unique In response to mounting international condemnation of domestic
support services for victims, including a survivor advocates worker exploitation, some governments in the Asia region have
programme for rehabilitated people to engage government, media sought to improve protections for this vulnerable cohort. The
and the general public on modern slavery.[64] However, the lack Philippines Government was the first in the region to sign the
of victim identification and victim support continues to hinder ILO Convention on Domestic Workers and remains the only
regional progress. For example, in Papua New Guinea (PNG), country in the region to have done so. With rising evidence of
the government has made no effort to identify, report or provide widespread exploitation of migrant domestic workers in Hong
victim support services to human trafficking victims.[65] Kong, it is significant that the government of Hong Kong has
made some effort to increase the frequency of employment
In March 2016, there was regional acknowledgement of the
agency inspections from 1,300 to 1,800 per year.[81] Some efforts
need to engage constructively with the private sector to combat
have also been made by Hong Kong and Singapore to prosecute
exploitative labour practices.[66]
agencies and employers—in January 2016, two employment
agencies in Hong Kong were convicted for collecting excessive
placement fees from foreign domestic workers. [82] In March
Australia and Indonesia co-chaired 2016, a Singaporean couple was convicted for starving their
the Sixth Ministerial Conference Filipina maid for more than 15 months.[83] The following month
of the Bali Process resulting in a a Singaporean couple went on trial for abusing their Indonesian
domestic helper, after subjecting her to physical, mental and
Ministerial Declaration pledging a verbal abuse.[84] Other governments have taken steps to address
comprehensive regional approach the exploitation of their nationals in the Middle East. Following
the execution of two Indonesian maids in Saudi Arabia, in April
to managing mixed migration 2015, Indonesia announced a domestic workers ban applying to
flows and ensuring humane several countries within the Middle East and Gulf.[85] While travel
bans are intended to be a protective measure, there is a risk this
labour practices within global will increase the potential for exploitation as Indonesians seek
supply chains.[67] unregistered work and travel through informal channels.[86] For
example, in March 2016, Indonesian National Police investigators
In March 2016, members of parliament from 13 Asia-Pacific uncovered a human trafficking syndicate that allegedly sent up to
nations, including Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Pakistan and Papua 600 Indonesian domestic workers abroad illegally flying them to
New Guinea, endorsed the Kathmandu Declaration[68] to end several of the banned Middle East and Gulf states.[87]
child marriage in South Asia.[69] While an important statement
Australia had the leading government response to modern slavery
of intention, significant policy and legislative steps remain
in the Asia Pacific in 2016. This past year saw the inclusion of
to be taken by countries with high prevalence of forced and
survivors of trafficking and slavery included in the meetings of
child marriage. India is yet to finalise the National Strategy
the government's National Roundtable on People Trafficking and
on Prevention of Child Marriage,[70] Bangladesh is currently
Slavery. Throughout the year, strategic outreach and awareness-
developing the National Plan to End Child Marriage,[71] Nepal
raising about the issue of forced marriage resulted in significant
is awaiting full government endorsement for the establishment
numbers of referrals to law enforcement and NGOs of young people
of the National Strategy to End Child Marriage,[72] and Pakistan
at-risk and people wanting to avoid or leave forced marriages.
has yet to raise the minimum age of marriage at the provincial
However, even its response has limitations. In 2015, critical gaps
level.[73] In 2015, the Bangladeshi Government considered
were identified in Australia's labour laws regarding domestic
reducing the minimum age of marriage for girls from 18 to 16
workers in private homes.[88]
years old[74] but refrained from doing so after strong opposition
from civil society and international groups.[75]
As in all regions of the world, corruption and official complicity
continue to undermine responses in parts of Asia.[76] For
example, in India, there are allegations that some corrupt law
enforcement officials have connections to human trafficking
rings, receiving bribes to ensure the protection of traffickers.[77]
NORWAY
ESTONIA
ICELAND
SWEDEN LATVIA
FINLAND LITHUANIA
CZECH
REPUBLIC SLOVAKIA HUNGARY
UNITED KINGDOM
DENMARK
IRELAND SERBIA
GERMANY
BELGIUM BULGARIA
LUXEMBOURG KOSOVO
FRANCE
TURKEY
SPAIN
PORTUGAL CYPRUS
BOSNIA &
SLOVENIA CROATIA HERZEGOVINA ALBANIA MONTENEGRO
GREECE
1,243,400 2.7%
Average Government Response Rating Average Vulnerability Score
54.2/100 27.1/100
58 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Europe cont.
PREVALENCE
Estimated percent of Estimated number
Rank Country population in modern slavery in modern slavery Population
Despite having the lowest regional prevalence of modern slavery sexual exploitation remain the most commonly reported forms
in the world, Europe remains a destination, and to a lesser of modern slavery in Europe;[4] nonetheless, instances of other
extent, a source region for the exploitation of men, women and forms of modern slavery, such as forced child marriage, have
children in forced labour and commercial sexual exploitation. been identified in Turkey.[5]
According to the most recent Eurostat findings, European Union
It is likely that the profile of identified victims may change in
(EU) citizens account for 65 percent of identified trafficked
time as a result of the massive influx of migrants and refugees
victims within Europe.[1] These individuals mostly originate
in 2015 and 2016. An IOM survey of migrants on the move
from Eastern Europe, including Romania, Bulgaria, Lithuania
throughout parts of Europe clearly indicates that people moving
and Slovakia.[2] Non-EU trafficked victims are predominantly
out of conflict zones and through Europe are both at high risk
from Nigeria, China and Brazil.[3] Forced labour and commercial
of exploitation, and are already being targeted (see page 62).
The International Organisation for Migration (IOM) is the in IOM’s web-based case management system (MiMOSA).
largest provider of services to victims of human trafficking This is the source of information presented below.
across the globe. In 2015, an estimated 7,000 victims
The graphics below present data from victims of trafficking
of trafficking were assisted by the Organisation in 117
registered in IOM’s case management system in 2015
countries of destination. The Organisation also collected
in Europe.
in-depth information for 4,858 newly-identified victims of
trafficking from 65 countries of nationality, in 59 countries *The numbers in 'sector of exploitation' and 'types of exploitation' are
based on a breakdown of total cases for which data exists. Information
of destination/identification. This detailed data is recorded about type and sector of exploitation is not collected in every case.
31.8yrs
Approximately 50% of all victims were
ages between 23 and 42
Sex Breakdown
42.5% Female [91]
# #
5 Sold by Family
6 Not Known
12 Friend Visit
2 Tourism
Many European countries rank high on indices of peace, For example, in Albania and Bosnia and Herzegovina, the
democracy, anti-corruption, human rights and access to social European Parliament has identified corruption and the judicial
services, all of which provide important protection from system as reform challenges towards accession talks within the
vulnerability to exploitation. This is not consistent across Europe, EU.[28] In Greece, the turbulent economic situation has increased
with some countries, notably Kosovo, Turkey, Albania, Bosnia vulnerability for populations seeking employment and livelihood
and Herzegovina, and Greece having a higher risk profile, opportunities. In Greece, unemployment reached 24.4 percent in
reflecting high political instability, low confidence in the judicial January 2016 with a youth unemployment rate of 51.9 percent.[29]
system and high levels of crime, corruption and discrimination.
In 2015–2016, the European migrant crisis has politically, Migrants and asylum seekers with limited resources are at high
economically and socially strained the EU with the arrival of risk of being exploited by brokers, recruiters and criminals along
more than one million migrants and refugees by land and sea.[30] the route. Unaccompanied minors and women are particularly
vulnerable to exploitation. According to UNHCR victim
In the first quarter of 2016, the IOM registered the arrival of
testimonies, asylum seekers and migrants who have run out
179,614 refugees and migrants with approximately 1,232 people
of money or have been robbed on the way are more likely to
missing or dead.[31]
engage in 'survival sex' in order to pay smugglers to continue
Irregular migration flows have stemmed from the Middle East their journey.[35] In addition, cases of exploited unaccompanied
and Sub-Saharan Africa. Many migrants and asylum seekers Pakistani boys have been reported, where naked photographs are
have made the dangerous journey to Europe by crossing the posted online with demands that their families send money.[36]
Aegean, Mediterranean or Alboran Seas using rubber dinghies
In 2015, approximately 70 percent of arrivals to Europe were men,
and wooden boats, or by land through Turkey and the Western
and so far in 2016, this has significantly shifted to approximately
Balkans.[32] According to UNHCR data, most of the arrivals are
60 percent of women and children.[37] This demographic shift
Syrian, Afghan, Pakistani, Eritrean and Somali nationals fleeing
poses significant challenges for European governments, with
internal conflict and political unrest.[33]
responsibility to provide protection for these vulnerable groups
Desperate to reach Europe, these asylum seekers and migrants through provision of gender appropriate services, livelihood
have turned to people smugglers to facilitate their passage.[34] opportunities for women, and education for children.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Western European countries typically have well-developed mechanisms, general anti-trafficking police training and all are
government responses to modern slavery. This reflects a currently implementing NAPs committed to combating modern
combination of resources but also political will that has resulted slavery, except Sweden. In the UK, the implementation of
in countries in the region agreeing to clear standard setting the also marks progress towards strengthening legislation in
and independent monitoring efforts. For example, the Council combating modern slavery.
of Europe’s Group of Experts on Action against Trafficking
Some of the countries in Europe are more affected by corruption
in Human Beings (GRETA) is a monitoring and reporting
and complicity than others. For example, law enforcement
mechanism that holds governments in the region accountable for
complicity, lenient judicial rulings and a lack of victim
their commitments under the Council of Europe Convention on
protection in Romania continue to contribute to the exploitation
Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. Within the region,
of vulnerable populations. In 2015, Lithuanian police launched
45 countries are signatories to the Convention indicating strong
an investigation into the director of a state-run orphanage,
regional cooperation and commitment towards combating crimes
allegedly operating a child sex-trafficking ring. In Bosnia and
of modern slavery.[38]
Herzegovina, local police have reportedly accepted bribes and
All countries in Europe criminalise modern slavery, either in sexual services in exchange for notifying brothel and nightclub
their criminal codes or in specific human trafficking legislation. owners in advance of police raids.
The Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Sweden, Portugal and
In October 2015, the UK enacted the landmark Modern Slavery
Croatia have the strongest responses to modern slavery in Europe.
Act 2015. This requires companies with an annual turnover of
Generally, these countries have high scores in measurements on
£36 million or more report on steps they have taken to safeguard
criminal justice, victim support and addressing vulnerability to
their global supply chains from modern slavery. [43] This will affect
break the cycle of modern slavery.
approximately 17,000 UK businesses which will impact global supply
These countries have government-funded victim support services, chains around the world.[44] This initiative has not yet been matched
affordable public health care and primary school education by developments in the legislation of other European countries.
systems, specialised anti-trafficking police units, reporting
BELARUS
RUSSIA
KAZAKHSTAN
KYRGYZSTAN
TAJIKSTAN
ARMENIA AZERBAIJAN
TURKMENISTAN UZBEKISTAN
2,809,700 6.1%
Average Government Response Rating Average Vulnerability Score
38.1/100 37.0/100
66 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Russia and Eurasia cont.
PREVALENCE
Estimated percent of Estimated number
Rank Country population in modern slavery in modern slavery Population
Cases of state-sponsored forced labour have been documented World Bank beneficiary projects but did note that, "worrying
in several countries in the Eurasia region. According to some reports were received from other sources which have reported
reports, there are up to 20,000 North Korean workers in Russia, forced labour practices, and of harassment and threats to people
working in the construction industry, oil refineries, lumber, roads conducting their own monitoring."[11] The International Labour
and waterways.[1] While these positions are said to be highly Organization has developed a Decent Work Country Programme
sought after in North Korea (with some people reportedly paying with the government of Uzbekistan, being implemented from
bribes to get these roles), workers in these positions are tightly 2014–2016. This includes a survey of working conditions in the
controlled and are required to pay at least 90 percent of any cotton harvest, a review of national legislation and practice, and
wages to the North Korean state. In some cases, workers are capacity building for law enforcement and labour inspectors.[12]
not paid wages at all; instead, they are paid in kind through the
Reports suggest instances of forced labour and recruitment of
provision of daily meals.[2] Testimony from workers suggests that
children for armed conflict in the Ukraine. Citizens of occupied
citizens are not able to take these positions unless they have at
territories (such as Donetsk) have been detained for minor
least two children in North Korea,[3] indicating an implicit threat
public order offences and forced to participate in 'punishment
of retribution against family members.
brigades'.[13] These have involved war-related duties such as
filling sandbags and digging trenches in direct exposure to the
ongoing conflict.[14] Concerns have also been raised about the
The governments of both use of child soldiers in the region. Images released by Russian
Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan media have shown a 15-year-old squad leader posing in front
reportedly subject their citizens of a captured tank,[15] and Ukrainian media has documented the
wounding of a 17-year-old combatant.[16] The boy told media,
to forced labour during annual "it's not a person's age that matters here, but how prepared they
agricultural harvests. While it are to fight for their country".[17]
is impossible to verify with any Cases of forced labour have been identified within the large
populations of migrant workers existing with the region. In
precision the scale of these Kazakhstan, sectors implicated include the construction, [18]
practices, it is reported that in hospitality[19] and domestic sectors.[20] Other documented cases
Turkmenistan, tens of thousands involve the use of wage-related deception to keep migrants in
exploitative conditions,[21] where they were coerced through
were forced to work in the cotton the use of physical[22] and psychological abuse.[23] In Armenia,
sector.[4] forced labour cases have been identified in the agricultural,[24]
construction[25] and trade sectors.[26] A 2015 study of forced labour
Similarly in Uzbekistan, it is estimated that more than one in Armenia did not document evidence of explicit threats, but it
million[5] people worked in the cotton sector, and there are did document deception and the confiscation of documents.[27]
conflicting reports about the levels of forced labour. According In some countries within the region, the issue of forced marriage,
to NGO reports, regional production quotas are enforced by including through traditional practices of bride kidnapping, has
local authorities who achieve compliance through appeals to the reportedly made a resurgence. It is estimated that 11,800 women
national good but also through threats related to the termination of are subjected to bride kidnapping each year in Kyrgyzstan.[28]
employment,[6] heavy fines,[7] debt bondage,[8] asset confiscation[9] Nationals from countries in the Eurasia region fall within the top
and police intimidation.[10] This stands in contrast to findings by 10 group of countries of origin for victims of trafficking identified
the International Labour Organization which, in response to a by national authorities in the EU.[29] Russia is the fifth largest
request for monitoring by the World Bank of specific projects, country in this category and Ukraine is seventh.[30]
found no conclusive evidence of forced labour practices in
Given the ongoing conflict in Ukraine, forced migration With high levels of unskilled labour migration to the Russian
remains a significant trend. The Ukrainian civil conflict led Federation comes accompanying vulnerability to exploitation.[40]
to the displacement of at least one million people.[31] Most High population growth and limited job opportunities [41] in
were women and children fleeing from Crimea, Donetsk and former Soviet states such as Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan and the
other eastern regions.[32] Upon arrival in the West, they lacked Kyrgyz Republic[42] encouraged migrants to emigrate.[43] Such
employment prospects, financial resources and social services.[33] migrants are known to work in the shadow economy,[44] which is
Indeed, many health services were closed due to the war effort concerning yet unsurprising given tighter immigration restrictions
and no department has taken clear responsibility for protecting in the Russian Federation.[45] Approximately 40 percent of the
the displaced.[34] The men who stayed behind to defend their migrants lived in overcrowded, poorly maintained residences
property were also vulnerable to forced military service[35] and such as trailers and abandoned factories,[46] exacerbating pre-
forced labour to support the war efforts of pro-Russian rebels.[36] existing ethnic conflicts.[47]
There are also extensive labour migration movements both from There have been widespread reports of public and institutional
and within this region. Kazakhstan is a popular destination for xenophobia from within the Russian Federation.[48] These attitudes
labour migrants particularly from Uzbekistan, as it offers higher have manifested in the form of illegal (yet administratively
wages than neighbouring countries, visa-free entry and has a endorsed) 'volunteer squads' to track down illegal migrants,[49]
similar language.[37] anti-foreigner riots[50] and allegations of beatings orchestrated
by police and extremist members of the public.[51] Such abuses
were alleged to be met with impunity by the legal system,
It is reported that labour migrants owing to both a fear of reprisal[52] and an absence of effective
prosecution.[53]
experience routinely poor
living and working conditions in Despite their desire to create a better life for their families,
currency instability led to economic uncertainty in Central Asian
Kazakhstan, with an estimated 20 countries of origin. Remittances sent to families were typically
percent of workplaces having no transferred in small denominations of rubles.[54] Since the ruble
exchange rate was less stable than other currencies during the
amenities such as drinking water, reporting period,[55] the remittance system adversely affected
toilets or a place to eat. the economic outlook of some countries, such as the Kyrgyz
Republic and Tajikistan.[56]
Accommodation provided or found by employers or recruiters is
overcrowded, averaging 5.6 people per room but sometimes up
to 40 people per room.[38] Russia is the second largest destination
country for migrants in the world, hosting more than 11 million
migrants.[39] Many migrants continue onto Russia as it offers
higher wages than Kazakhstan.
The International Organisation for Migration (IOM) is the in IOM’s web-based case management system (MiMOSA).
largest provider of services to victims of human trafficking This is the source of information presented below.
across the globe. In 2015, an estimated 7,000 victims
The graphics below present data from victims of trafficking
of trafficking were assisted by the Organisation in 117
registered in IOM’s case management system in 2015 in
countries of destination. The Organisation also collected
Russia and Eurasia.
in-depth information for 4,858 newly-identified victims of
trafficking from 65 countries of nationality, in 59 countries *The numbers in 'sector of exploitation' and 'types of exploitation' are
based on a breakdown of total cases for which data exists. Information
of destination/identification. This detailed data is recorded about type and sector of exploitation is not collected in every case.
Victims Supported by IOM in Russia & Eurasia in 2015 Age of Victims at Time of Assistance
29.5yrs
Approximately 50% of all victims were
ages between 20 and 37
Sex Breakdown
56.1% Female [1,482]
# #
34 Not Applicable 14 Other
With the exception of Georgia and Moldova, responses to modern Legislative efforts to criminalise modern slavery in Eurasia are
slavery within this region are still in their infancy. Georgia and further behind than other regions. While nine of the 12 countries
Moldova were the only countries to score above 50 percent for had criminalised human trafficking, only four have laws that
a government response, with Georgia ranking number 18 in the criminalise forced labour and forced marriage, and three countries
world on its government responses to modern slavery (a BB have specifically criminalised slavery and the use of children
rating) and Moldova at number 36 (also a BB rating). in armed conflict. Russia was the only country in the region
to adequately criminalise child prostitution. Where laws exist,
punishments vary: for example, trafficking can be punished by a
One of the many innovations temporary disqualification from positions of authority in Georgia,
and child prostitution can be punished by community service in
in Moldova is its Centre for Kazakhstan.[64] While all countries except Russia and Belarus
Combating Trafficking in Persons, allowed victims to participate in the legal process, only Azerbaijan,
established in 2006 under the Georgia, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan
recognised in legislation that survivors of slavery are not criminals
Ministry of Interior. The Centre for crimes committed under the control of perpetrators.
has the status of a directorate, Only four countries in this region—Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia
which, by law, has the mission to and Moldova - had an NAP to coordinate efforts on modern
slavery issues and no country provided adequate funding for
investigate and prosecute human these plans. While all countries are part of a regional body which
trafficking crimes and other takes action on trafficking issues, once again, only four countries
related crimes.[57] signed bilateral agreements with countries of origin or destination.
It was, therefore, unsurprising to see evidence of modern slavery
Half of the countries in this region have conducted modern victims being deported in Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Russia,
slavery awareness-raising activities since 2010. These campaigns Ukraine and Uzbekistan. Official complicity in modern slavery
were only conducted systematically in two countries. In Georgia, cases was found in all countries except Georgia. For instance, in
awareness-raising media was broadcast between 2012 and Moldova, the head of a human rights organisation was arrested
2014.[58] In Armenia, an anti-trafficking hotline has regularly for subjecting children to forced begging.[65] Similarly, there are
been promoted since 2007.[59] All countries except Turkmenistan allegations that Kyrgyzstan's police have extorted and sexually-
operated some form of public reporting mechanism. All countries abused victims of child sex trafficking.[66] No investigations have
except Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan have carried out anti- occurred in relation to these incidents.[67]
trafficking training for front-line police officers. Though labour protection theoretically extends to all workers
Victim support services of some kind were available in each in 11 of the 12 countries, in reality, this was not the case for
country in the Eurasia region, with most governments contributing Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan.
financially to their running costs (the exceptions being Russia Indeed, state-sanctioned forced labour continued to exist in
and Turkmenistan). However, services typically concentrate on Belarus, Russia, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan.
women's needs only and half of the countries in this region do
not have services for men. Victim referral mechanisms existed
in only four countries and actual evidence of referral was only
found in Georgia. This scheme was set up by the government
of Georgia's Council on Trafficking in Human Beings[60] and
includes free translation services,[61] legal counsel[62] and access
to social programmes.[63]
Child carrying cotton in Dashoguz region, Turkmenistan, October 2015. Government-led forced labour of parents to
fulfill harvest quotas resulted in children picking cotton in at least one area, the Boldumasaz district of Dashoguz region.
Photo Credit, Ruslan Matiyev of Alternative Turkmenistan News (ATN)
CENTRAL AFRICAN
REPUBLIC
GAMBIA
ERITREA
GUINEA-BISSAU
NIGERIA
SOUTH ETHIOPIA
SUDAN
GUINEA UGANDA
KENYA
SIERRA TOGO BENIN RWANDA
LEONE DEMOCRATIC
REPUBLIC
OF THE CONGO
LIBERIA CÔTE GHANA EQUATORIAL BURUNDI
D'IVOIRE GUINEA TANZANIA
MALAWI
GABON
ANGOLA
ZAMBIA
REPUBLIC
OF THE CONGO MAURITIUS
NAMIBIA
BOTSWANA
MADAGASCAR
6,245,800 13.6%
Average Government Response Rating Average Vulnerability Score
28.2/100 47.3/100
72 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Sub Saharan Africa cont.
PREVALENCE
Estimated percent of Estimated number
Rank Country population in modern slavery in modern slavery Population
The International Organisation for Migration (IOM) is the in IOM’s web-based case management system (MiMOSA).
largest provider of services to victims of human trafficking This is the source of information presented below.
across the globe. In 2015, an estimated 7,000 victims
The graphics below present data from victims of trafficking
of trafficking were assisted by the Organisation in 117
registered in IOM’s case management system in 2015 in
countries of destination. The Organisation also collected
Sub-Saharan Africa.
in-depth information for 4,858 newly-identified victims of
trafficking from 65 countries of nationality, in 59 countries *The numbers in 'sector of exploitation' and 'types of exploitation' are
based on a breakdown of total cases for which data exists. Information
of destination/identification. This detailed data is recorded about type and sector of exploitation is not collected in every case.
23yrs
Approximately 50% of all victims were
ages between 17 and 27
Sex Breakdown
89.9% Female [79]
5 Sold by Family
# #
53 Labour Exploitation 16 Other 31 Offer of Employment or Labour
Migration Opportunities
Modern slavery in the Sub-Sahara was enabled by economic The critical migratory paths through and from Sub-Saharan Africa
conditions, violent conflict and territorial displacement, in are affected by violence and lawlessness; Migrants travelling
addition to widespread humanitarian and environmental crises.[47] to Saudi Arabia through Yemen were misinformed about the
extent of the conflict.[64] Internal conflict and terrorist attacks left
many stranded in the country[65] and vulnerable to exploitation.
The escalation of violence in Abduction and trafficking were also common along the Red
Sea coast leading there, especially in lawless regions of eastern
Nigeria following the Boko Haram Sudan[66] and along the Ethiopian/Eritrean border.[67] Trafficking
conflict[48] has had widespread from, through and to Somalia has also been widely reported.[68]
effects on Nigeria and across While some of these victims are destined for the Middle East
and Europe,[69] there are reports that children fleeing the Yemeni
the region, particularly in conflict have been transported to Kenya for the purpose of sexual
Cameroon where refugees exploitation.[70]
fleeing conflict have sparked While migrants had previously attempted to reach Europe
through Egypt and Israel, both countries have tightened border
a humanitarian crisis.[49] security.[71] Consequently, Mediterranean routes to Italy and the
Baltic states through Libya became more popular.[72] This region
As of February 2016, 2.5 million people were displaced as a
is still experiencing significant instability after the ousting of
result of the conflict and 20,000 people have been killed.[50]
Muammar Gaddafi in 2011.[73] Since the Islamic State occupied
Conflict is also prevalent in Chad and Cameroon, where Boko
the southern city of Sirte, it and the transitional government have
Haram is also active in creating violent conflicts, and in recruiting
been fighting for control over the country.[74]
young entrepreneurs through predatory loans.[51]
Displacement increases the risk of internal trafficking. In
Burundi, politically-motivated violence associated with President Within Libya, virtual lawlessness,
Pierre Nkurunziza's third term has led to the displacement of
at least 145,000 people.[52] The ongoing conflict in Somalia[53]
large populations of vulnerable
and Rwanda[54] similarly continued to create vulnerability migrant workers wanting to
through displacement. Due to the ongoing civil war in the CAR, travel on to Europe willing to
approximately one-quarter of the country's population have
been internally displaced and approximately 450,000 remain work to earn their passage, and
displaced.[55] Displaced children, in particular, are at risk of xenophobia towards Sub-Saharan
domestic servitude, forced labour in agricultural industries and
commercial sexual exploitation in the cities.[56] Continuing unrest
migrants[75] allowed trafficking
in the DRC has left 2.8 million people displaced[57] and at risk of networks to operate without fear
exploitation by armed groups in forced labour and compulsory of prosecution.
military service.[58] Homeless children in the state-controlled
capital of Kinshasa in the DRC were also at risk of domestic
A pervading culture of family-orientated collectivism, in which
servitude, forced begging and commercial sexual exploitation.[59]
gender roles are rigid and seniority is highly revered[76] persists
Slowed economic growth[60] and a failure to invest in domestic in many countries across the region. Interactions between these
employment[61] pushed citizens from central and western states values, geopolitical conditions and economic factors contribute
of Sub-Saharan Africa to seek work in Europe and the Middle to the relative stability of forced and child marriage. Renewed
East.[62] These factors created the perfect conditions for internal conflict and internal displacement created a need for physical
and transnational exploitation, as individuals migrating from and economic security—conditions frequently cited to justify
poverty-stricken rural areas to cities in search of employment child marriage.[77]
were left vulnerable to exploitative labour conditions [63] and
persons abandoning their home countries often took dangerous
migratory paths which also increased the risk of exploitation.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Government responses to modern slavery in Sub-Saharan Despite 33 of the 45 countries in Sub-Saharan Africa running
Africa were characterised by inadequate victim protection campaigns against known modern slavery risks since 2010, few
and a lack of coordination between government agencies and have raised awareness on methods to identify victims. The only
NGO bodies. Somalia,[78] the Democratic Republic of Congo,[79] country to make this an annual practice was Burundi, whose
Sudan[80] and Chad[81] faced severe political instability and Children and Ethics Brigade ran anti-trafficking awareness
internal violence, including losing control of areas within their programmes from at least 2011 to 2014.[83] While 28 countries
borders, consequently reducing their capacity to combat modern provided a mechanism to report modern slavery, less than
slavery. In Somalia, the government only controlled the capital half covered all demographics and even fewer had evidence
of Mogadishu and a small number of surrounding areas.[82] of translation services. Comprehensive reporting mechanisms
Consequently, reliable data on the steps taken by the government were only provided in South Africa and Lesotho.
to combat modern slavery was unavailable.
A talibe (boy studying in a Qur'anic school) begs on a bridge in Diamaguene, Senegal, May 18, 2015. Children are forced to beg
for an average of 8 hours a day, many of them spend their days almost without eating and end up sleeping on the streets due
to fatigue.
Photo Credit, Mario Cruz
TUNISIA
MOROCCO ISRAEL
IRAN
SAUDI ARABIA
QATAR
UNITED ARAB
EMIRATES
OMAN
YEMEN BAHRAIN
2,936,800 6.4%
Average Government Response Rating Average Vulnerability Score
32.7/100 45.0/100
80 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
MENA cont.
PREVALENCE
Estimated percent of Estimated number
Rank Country population in modern slavery in modern slavery Population
As violent conflict escalates and political, economic, social and surrounding IS-occupied territory where women can be bought
security spillovers destabilise many countries in the Middle East and sold at the market. There are reports of IS offering to sell
and North Africa (MENA), the profile of victims vulnerable to women back to their families for as much as US$40,000.[6]
modern slavery has shifted. Though MENA continues to act as
Forced marriage of children and women continues to be an issue.
a destination for men and women from Asia and Sub-Saharan
The phenomenon of 'temporary' or 'tourist' marriages whereby
Africa who are attracted to the region with promises of well-
men, often from the Gulf States, travel abroad and temporarily
paying jobs, increasingly Middle Easterners themselves faced
take a wife for the duration of their vacation has been identified
exploitation and slavery in 2016. Victims were identified as
in Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Morocco and India.[7] In some cases,
forced recruits in state and non-state armed groups, as victims of
child brides are forcibly married by their parents for economic
forced marriage and victims of commercial sexual exploitation.
gain. Children as young as 11 have been sold into temporary
Foreign and local citizens were subject to forced labour and debt
marriages in Egypt. These temporary religious marriages bind
bondage in service sectors such as domestic work, cleaning, and
the girl to her husband for an agreed time frame—often days or
as drivers and restaurant workers, as well as in construction,
weeks at a time, sometimes only hours—but do not afford the
agriculture and mechanics.
child or woman any legal rights. This leaves them vulnerable to
Children in Syria, Iraq, Palestine and Yemen were recruited, trained domestic servitude and prostitution and, in many cases, denies
and deployed in violent conflict. There were increasingly grave citizenship to any subsequent offspring.[8] In Morocco, the 2014
reports of children being used as suicide bombers, informants, census revealed more than 100,000 child brides,[9] some of whom
bomb makers and human shields. There are reports of families may have been married without free and informed consent.
selling disabled children to Islamic State (IS) in Iraq[1] and online Refugee children from Syria and Iraq have been forcibly married
videos showing very young children carrying out assassinations by desperate parents trying to ensure their economic security and
through beheading and shooting.[2] UNICEF estimates a five- protect them from the threat of sexual violence.[10]
fold increase in the recruitment of children in Yemen's civil war,
Migrant workers from Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa continue
meaning that a third of combatants are children.[3]
to flock to MENA for work. In 2015 there were reports that
There are verified reports of women and children being captured, Thai nationals were exploited on Israeli farms; [11] Filipina,
sold into slavery and held in barbarous conditions by IS. In Nepali, Bangladeshi, Sri Lankan, Indonesian, Ugandan, Kenyan,
2014, IS captured 3,000 women and children, mostly from the Ethiopian and Mauritanian women were abused in private
Kurdish-speaking Yazidi minority group—the largest single homes;[12] and Indian, Nepali, Pakistani and Bangladeshi men
capture of women this century. IS propaganda claimed that were exploited in the construction of resorts, museums, stadiums
the captured Yazidi women and girls were 'spoils of war' to be and infrastructure in UAE and Qatar.[13] Migrant workers are
divided among fighters.[4] Publications released by IS[5] provide subject to practices that may amount to forced labour including
an extreme interpretation of Shari'a describing the legality and extortionate recruitment fees, illegal confiscation of identity
illegalities of dealing with slaves—"it is permissible to buy, sell, documents, withholding and non-payment of salaries, hazardous
or give as a gift female captives and slaves, for they are merely working conditions, unhygienic living conditions, unlawful
property, which can be disposed of..." This alarming resurgence of overtime performed under the threat of deportation, and physical
slavery is evident in Raqqa, the self-proclaimed IS capital, and and sexual abuse.
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, & Refugees &
Country protections economic rights Personal security conflict Mean
In 2016, conflict in Syria, Iraq, Libya, Palestine and Yemen, has had a trifold effect on neighbouring host countries [20]:
coupled with terrorist attacks in Algeria, Lebanon, Tunisia, Israel (a) increased competition for low-paying jobs and employment
and Egypt, has created a catastrophic humanitarian situation. in the informal economy; (b) increased incidence of all forms
There is a strong statistical link between high levels of instability of modern slavery, such as child labour, forced begging and
within a country and an increase in that population's vulnerability forced early marriage; and (c) reduced capacity of State actors
to modern slavery.[17] In cases of armed conflict, there is often to respond to trafficking cases because already scarce resources
a corresponding weakening of the rule of law, providing fertile are outlaid on the emergency provision of services to refugees
ground for traffickers to profit with impunity.[18] The demand for instead of supporting migrant workers.[21]
the State to respond to other humanitarian emergencies, coupled
Though the number of refugees seeking international protection
with few specific human-trafficking services or organisations in
in Europe and further afield is increasing in 2016, Syria and Iraq's
these countries, means that protection of vulnerable migrants
neighbouring countries continue to host almost 90 percent of the
and support for victims of human trafficking in times of crisis
displaced population.[22] More than 142,000 Syrian children born
is limited.[19] In 2015, the IOM and Walk Free found that the
in exile are vulnerable to statelessness and more than 750,000
unprecedented displacement of Syrian and Iraqi populations
children are not in school[23]—worrying indicators of future risk
The International Organisation for Migration (IOM) is the in IOM’s web-based case management system (MiMOSA).
largest provider of services to victims of human trafficking This is the source of information presented below.
across the globe. In 2015, an estimated 7,000 victims
The graphics below present data from victims of trafficking
of trafficking were assisted by the Organisation in 117
registered in IOM’s case management system in 2015 in
countries of destination. The Organisation also collected
Middle East and Northern Africa (MENA).
in-depth information for 4,858 newly-identified victims of
trafficking from 65 countries of nationality, in 59 countries *The numbers in 'sector of exploitation' and 'types of exploitation' are
based on a breakdown of total cases for which data exists. Information
of destination/identification. This detailed data is recorded about type and sector of exploitation is not collected in every case.
29.8yrs
Approximately 50% of all victims were
ages between 25 and 35
Sex Breakdown
79.2% Female [210]
# #
21 K
idnapping
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Credit Survivors Criminal Coordination & Addressing Government & Total
rating Country supported justice accountability risk business score
In 2015, governments in MENA faced challenges responding Most countries had undertaken a basic human trafficking
to modern slavery but continued to take steps to increase public awareness campaign once in the past five years to educate the
awareness, build and enhance shelter services, and improve general public. This ranged from radio and television campaigns
national laws. In some countries, such as Lebanon and Jordan, in Lebanon and the UAE to awareness campaigns in Kuwait's
scores reflected the infancy of policies and laws, with further largest mall.[31] With the support of international organisations,
action required from a range of stakeholders to improve effective often the IOM, law enforcement officers and the judiciary were
national responses. Low scores in other countries, such as Oman trained on human trafficking, victim identification and national
and Saudi Arabia, reflected limited political will to recognise the legislation in most of the countries in the region.
existence of all forms of modern slavery.
Bekaa Valley, Lebanon, 2015. Houda (14 years old) pictured with
her teddy bear. She left Syria (Raqqa) four years ago and she
got married about one year ago. She lives in the Bekaa Valley
with her family while her husband works and lives in Beirut. Her
husband stays with her only on the weekend. Approximately 1.3
million refugees are officially registered in Lebanon. Marriages
in refugee camps often involve girls of 11 to 13 years, but can
include more extreme cases of girls as young as nine years old.
Photo credit, Laura Aggio Caldon
CANADA
UNITED STATES
DOMINICAN
CUBA JAMAICA HAITI REPUBLIC BARBADOS
MEXICO TRINIDAD
AND TOBAGO
GUATEMALA GUYANA
EL SALVADOR SURINAME
VENEZUELA
HONDURAS
COLOMBIA
PANAMA
PERU
BRAZIL
ECUADOR
BOLIVIA
PARAGUAY
2,168,600 4.7%
Average Government Response Rating Average Vulnerability Score
44.7/100 34.9/100
88 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
The Americas cont.
PREVALENCE
Estimated percent of Estimated number
Rank Country population in modern slavery in modern slavery Population
Modern slavery in the Americas affects men, women and 15–39 with low levels of education who had migrated internally
children, and has manifested as forced labour, commercial sexual to seek job opportunities.[11] Other reports from 2015 indicate
exploitation and, to a lesser degree, forced begging. Forced that approximately 500 Brazilian workers were transported to
labour primarily affects men and women in the agricultural, Angola, where they worked in circumstances akin to modern-
mining, construction and domestic industries, predominantly in day slavery.[12] In the Caribbean, limited job opportunities in
North and Central America and the Caribbean. Forced labour Haiti leads many nationals to illegally cross the border with
is a prevalent issue among indigenous groups in Peru, Bolivia the Dominican Republic, where they live, work and sometimes
and Colombia.[1] These incarnations of modern slavery are perish in the sugarcane field bateyes. Conditions reported
prevalent in labour-intensive, unskilled industries, including include indebtedness to recruiters and employers, physical
agriculture,[2] clothing manufacture,[3] construction and mining.[4] confinement in the work location, no rest days, lack of potable
Young men are particularly vulnerable to forced labour.[5] The water, deception about terms of work, withholding of wages and
inverse is true of commercial sexual exploitation, where women unlawful overtime performed under the threat of deportation.[13]
and children are more likely to report cases in South America.[6]
Through surveys conducted by Walk Free Foundation, the
Sexual exploitation is particularly prevalent among vulnerable
prevalence of modern slavery can be more precisely identified in
communities including lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender
several countries within the Americas including Brazil, Guatemala,
(LGBT) groups from Central and South America,[7] and children
Mexico, Chile, Dominican Republic and Bolivia. The survey results
in welfare systems in the United States.[8]
suggest that across these countries forced labour accounts for most
Concentrated in rural areas, exploitation occurs in the Cerrado instances of modern slavery, which is particularly prevalent in
region of Brazil and along the Amazon, [9] with reports of manual labour sectors such as construction, manufacturing and
forced labour in the mahogany, brick-making, and gold mining factory work, and domestic work.[14]
industries in the Amazonian regions of Peru and Ecuador.[10] In
2015, 936 workers were rescued from slave-like conditions in
Brazil alone. These individuals were mainly young males aged
The International Organisation for Migration (IOM) is the The graphics below present data from victims of trafficking
largest provider of services to victims of human trafficking registered in IOM’s case management system in 2015 in
across the globe. In 2015, an estimated 7,000 victims the Americas. The small number of cases reflects the
of trafficking were assisted by the Organisation in 117 differences in IOM programming and the use of MiMOSA
countries of destination. The Organisation also collected in this region and does not reflect the prevalence of
in-depth information for 4,858 newly-identified victims of exploitation and human trafficking.
trafficking from 65 countries of nationality, in 59 countries *The numbers in 'sector of exploitation' and 'types of exploitation' are
of destination/identification. This detailed data is recorded based on a breakdown of total cases for which data exists. Information
in IOM’s web-based case management system (MiMOSA). about type and sector of exploitation is not collected in every case.
This is the source of information presented below.
Victims Supported by IOM in The Americas in 2015 Age of Victims at Time of Assistance
17.5yrs
This average is greatly influenced by the age
of a victim who was only 1 at the time she/he
was registered by IOM
Sex Breakdown
25% Female [1]
# #
1 Labour Exploitation 1 Offer of Educational
Opportunities
The Americas are exceedingly diverse across their cultures, the cost is often a large debt and can involve payment through
languages and economies. Individuals within these nations are sexual slavery or forced labour.[38] Family members also act as
highly mobile, both inter- and intra-nationally[33]—which, in human traffickers,[39] in addition to criminal networks acting
addition to the prevalence of poverty and lack of employment as recruiters, and young male 'pimps'.[40] Large drug cartels
opportunities, provides fertile soil for labour trafficking and and criminal gangs operating in Central and South America
forced labour within national borders and across the region.[34] create hostile, violent conditions, increasing the risk of modern
slavery and human trafficking for vulnerable populations. States
Argentina, Chile, the United States, Uruguay and Canada had
are typically weak to respond to these instances of organised
the lowest vulnerability scores in the region however, this did
crime, thus allowing criminal syndicates to operate with relative
not exclude people within these countries falling victim to
immunity. High levels of corruption among police, governments
modern slavery. Some populations within these countries had
and judicial systems compound the power of gangs.[41] In Brazil,
a heightened vulnerability, such as the large irregular migrant
police retaliation to gang violence served to escalate the level of
worker population and employees on temporary work visas in
violence and increase the incidence of homicide.[42]
the United States.[35] Some notable areas where improvements
can be made to reduce the vulnerability to slavery include Latin America reports high rates of violence against women, with
increasing protection measures for the most vulnerable, El Salvador ranking as the top country for female homicides in the
particularly increasing transparency in temporary worker world.[43] Because of these crime rates, large numbers of women
visas and labour recruitment reforms, particularly prohibiting are seeking asylum in countries such as the United States.[44]
excessive recruitment fees.[36] However, asylum on the basis of gender violence remains a
controversial issue and many domestic crimes remain unreported
Poverty, drug rings, and corrupt judicial systems and border
by police and hospital staff.[45] In the United States, women,
control are major contributors to the trafficking industry in
children and transgender youth are particularly vulnerable to
the Americas.[37] People smugglers operating between Mexico
sexual exploitation.[46] There are also reports that lesbian, gay,
and the USA provide illegal passage to migrants; however,
bisexual and transgender individuals in Latin America and the
Caribbean are trafficked for the purposes of sexual exploitation of whom include refugees, crossing the US–Mexico border,[59]
to Western Europe.[47] and provided funding to Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador
to assist the reintegration of forcibly-returned migrants.[60]
According to a Gallup poll in 2012 and 2013, women in the
Americas were the least likely in the world to be treated with
respect and dignity, perhaps due to machismo cultural attitudes
and the pervasive violence in the region.[48] These factors, when
Systemic discrimination in the
combined with continued high demand for domestic workers in Americas towards indigenous
private homes, places these women at risk.[49] Discriminatory groups[61] increases their risk
cultural attitudes also place the lesbian, gay, bisexual or
transgender community at particular risk of human trafficking.[50] of exploitation.[62] In Mexico, the
Children, especially those in welfare systems or impoverished extreme poverty of and historic
and high crime areas, are vulnerable to forced labour and discrimination against the
sex trafficking.[51] Some children from the recent surge in
unaccompanied minors and undocumented families entering
Tarahumara indigenous group
the United States of America have been exploited by their state- make the community "easy
appointed guardians.[52] Children living in poverty, on the streets, prey for traffickers."[63] The dire
or in areas affected by extensive drug crime are also vulnerable,
as organised crime syndicates use vulnerable children to transport situation of approximately 3
and sell drugs.[53] Cultural attitudes regarding children at work are million indigenous girls exploited
also a contributing factor to labour exploitation of children; for
example, in Ecuador, it is suggested that attitudes surrounding in the domestic service and sex
child street beggars are positive in that these working children will industries led the lower house
alleviate the strain on poverty-stricken families, particularly in
indigenous communities.[54] Legal ambiguity between legitimate
of the Mexican Congress to label
child work and exploitation and/or trafficking continues to them as the most vulnerable
hamper efforts to protect children.[55] group in Mexico.[64]
The relative wealth and work opportunities in the United
States and Canada are attractive draws for vulnerable migrant Similarly, in Bolivia, the indigenous Guaraní community is
populations from their countries of origin. Unaccompanied exploited in the agricultural industry, where they work under
children are at particular risk of modern slavery and exploitation. conditions of forced labour.[65] The risk factors of poverty, lack
Transnational flows show a trend towards the United States and of education, sexual abuse, lack of social support, and physical
Canada;[56] however, migration flows also occur between South or mental health challenges are prevalent in Native American
American states.[57] In October–November 2015, 10,558 children populations in the United States, which heightens the risk of sex
crossed the border from Mexico to United States—an increase trafficking for young indigenous women and girls.[66] These issues
of more than 100 percent from the previous year's figure of are replicated in Colombia, where the civil war has displaced 6.5
5,129.[58] The legal situation of these children is fraught with million of the population, placing already vulnerable indigenous
uncertainty—legislators and government agencies in the United women and children at risk of forced prostitution, commercial sexual
States are currently confronting the issue of children travelling exploitation of children and forced begging.[67] In 2016, Canada will
alone in the hope of obtaining asylum. In 2015, the United launch an investigation into an estimated 4,000 murdered or missing
States Government provided millions in funding to assist the indigenous women.[68] Experts believe a percentage of these women
government of Mexico to crack down on these migrants, some may be victims of commercial sexual exploitation.[69]
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Within the Americas, the highest government response rankings Government responses were particularly poor in Cuba and
were held by the United States, Argentina, Canada and Brazil. Suriname. While Cuba's Government has successfully prosecuted
In 2015, the United States passed the Justice for Victims of sex traffickers,[74] it continues to deny the existence of forced
Trafficking Act, which expanded anti-trafficking training and labour as a problem within its borders and has not taken
the amount of compensation provided to victims.[70] The United any action to address this issue. [75] Indeed, there have been
States offered a model for survivor leadership. President Obama allegations that the government coerces medical practitioners
formed an Advisory Council on Human Trafficking made up to work in overseas medical institutions for its own financial
entirely of survivors. While having a markedly-different risk gain.[76] Suriname's record was similarly poor. The country has
profile and access to resources than the United States, it is notable no national plan of action to address trafficking, no legislation
that Haiti's efforts to combat trafficking improved markedly criminalising modern slavery outside of trafficking and has not
with the introduction of its Law on the Fight Against Trafficking conducted any awareness campaigns since 2010. While Brazil
in Persons. The new law criminalised all forms of human maintained a high ranking in the 2015 Index, it is important to
trafficking, established victim protection measures along with note that the country was forced to suspend its public register of
an anti-trafficking committee and enabled victims to receive companies fined for the use of forced labour by court order.[77]
compensation.[71] Additionally, Argentina adopted a new NAP to
combat trafficking and gender-based violence[72] and Paraguay
adopted new guidelines for the identification and screening of
trafficking victims.[73]
CCC Trinidad and Tobago 31.11 44.63 31.25 66.67 0.00 39.69
Overall government response trends in the region were mixed. Efforts to prevent governments from sourcing goods linked to
While all countries provided victim support services and 20 forced labour continued to be observed in this region, principally
of 27 countries had a toll-free reporting mechanism available by the United States and Brazil.
to all demographics, only six countries had formal guidelines
for identifying victims and only two had functioning referral
mechanisms. While the existence of toll free reporting mechanisms Despite the loss of its forced
are a good first step, efforts to build awareness of the mechanism,
and training and equipping those responding to complaints are
labour register, Brazil maintained
critical to improving response. Similar observations can be made policies against the use of
for criminal penalties and enforcement. While 22 countries in this forced labour in government and
region have criminalised human trafficking and allow victims of
the practice to receive compensation, only nine have criminalised corporate supply chains.[79]
forced labour.[78] This fact is particularly alarming given the
prevalence of forced labour in the Americas. Additionally, only The United States maintained similar policies[80] and the State of
eight countries have adequately criminalised child prostitution, California continued to require the production of annual reports
six have criminalised forced marriage and five have criminalised on the use of forced labour in government supply chains.[81]
the use of children in armed conflict. While 24 countries provided
anti-trafficking training to front-line police and 23 provided
anti-trafficking training to the judiciary, this was only delivered
systematically in two cases for the police and six cases for the
judiciary. Similarly, while 20 countries had an NAP to combat
some form of modern slavery, only four had an independent body
to monitor its implementation—Argentina, Brazil, Jamaica and
Uruguay. Furthermore, evidence of adequate funding for these
plans was only found in Brazil and Canada.
In plain sight: modern day slavery in the United States. Nilda came to the United
States when a friend of her employer in Guatemala City offered her a job working
as a domestic worker…Once in the United States she entered a hellish situation of
working about 16 hours a day for almost no pay. Her employers, who were Honduran,
sent her mother $100 per month, but withheld her passport and put her under strict
psychological control.
Photo credit, Jon Lowenstein/ NOOR
CAMBODIA
"I was forced to go to sea. I was hit with a knife by
my employer and his team while I was on the ship.
They slapped me. We never stopped working. They
said they will never pay me if I try to escape."
Walk Free survey respondent
256,800
41.51/100
PREVALENCE
Cambodia is a source and destination for exploitation of men, Out of the estimated 201,000 people in forced labour, the Walk
women and children in all forms of modern slavery, including Free survey found an estimated 60 percent of victims of forced
forced labour, debt bondage and forced marriage. The 2016 labour were in the manufacturing sector, some of whom may
Global Slavery Index estimates 256,800 people or 1.65 percent have been employed in the apparel sector.
of the total population live in conditions of modern slavery
In 2014, the Cambodian apparel industry exported US$5.7 billion
in Cambodia. This is based on a random-sample, nationally-
worth of goods, roughly one-third of Cambodia's GDP.[13] The
representative survey undertaken in 2015, that sought to identify
sector employs an estimated 600,000–700,000 garment workers,
instances of both forced marriage and forced labour within the
nearly 4 percent of Cambodia's population, and indirectly
general population (survey conducted in Khmer language).
supports many millions more family members.[14] The apparel
Forced marriage sector draws a large proportion of its workers from rural areas—
the 2015 Cambodia Apparel Workers Survey revealed 97 percent
Walk Free survey results suggest some 55,800 people are victims
of workers moved to Phnom Penh for their job.[15] Garment
of forced marriage in Cambodia (22 percent of the estimated
workers producing for international apparel brands experience
256,800 people in modern slavery in Cambodia).
high levels of serious labour rights abuses—conditions which
A literature review found no available research on forced sometimes amount to modern slavery. Workers continue to
marriage, highlighting the need for further investigation. Some experience forced and excessive overtime as a result of factory
limited figures are available on the prevalence of early marriages. practices and pressure from actors along the supply chain.[16]
In 2014, UNICEF reported 18 percent of Cambodian women Workers unable or unwilling to perform overtime are subject to
marry under the age of 18.[1] Article 5 of the Law on Marriage dismissal, wage reductions and punitive transfers from a monthly
and Family (1989) allows for the marriage of children upon wage to a piece-rate wage where income is dependent on the
the consent of their parents or guardians if the girl becomes number of garments individuals produce.[17] Poor wages, poor
pregnant.[2] While this may increase the risk of girls being health and safety conditions, excessive noise, poor air quality,
forced to marry, and girls being forced to marry if they fall unsanitary environments and employer abuse are common. In
pregnant through rape, there is insufficient data to suggest this some smaller factories that operate as subcontractors for export-
is widespread. NGOs report early marriage among teens aged oriented factories, workers are employed as casual workers or
14 to 17 is common in certain ethnic groups and geographical on short-term contracts that allow employers to easily dismiss
locations, particularly the north-east; however, these unions are employees and intimidate workers against speaking out about
commonly performed with the consent of the children.[3] abuse for fear their contract will not be reviewed.[18]
Trafficking for marriage Increasing demand for cheap domestic workers in private homes
in the Middle East, Malaysia and Singapore, coupled with the
The growing demand for foreign brides in China has created possibility of earning up to three times the salary than at that at
an emerging market for traffickers in the region. Cambodian home, is encouraging Cambodian women to travel abroad, often
women, eager to escape impoverished lives in rural villages, through informal channels, for employment as maids, nannies and
are entering brokered marriages to Chinese men in the hope of carers. In 2011, the government placed a moratorium on sending
a more lucrative life. In reality, many women find themselves maids to Malaysia amid reports of serious abuse; however,
deceived about their new living conditions, with many resettled workers continue to travel there through informal channels. In
in rural China[4] forced to work on farms or as domestic helpers, 2015, exploited Cambodian domestic workers continued to be
with some experiencing abuse at the hands of their husbands.[5] repatriated from Malaysia,[19] with many suffering serious mental
Other women are recruited for factory jobs and find themselves health issues upon return.[20] Government estimates suggest 8,000
forced into marriage.[6] Victims rescued in the past 18 months domestic workers remain employed in Malaysia.[21] Despite the
have mostly originated from Kampong Cham, Kampong Thom governments of Cambodia and Qatar signing a MoU in 2011
and Kandal provinces.[7] Cambodian women are also forced into to begin sending Cambodian workers to the Gulf state, in 2015
marriage to Korean and Taiwanese men,[8] some of whom are workers were still prevented from travelling to Qatar amid
subsequently forced into prostitution.[9] No research has been concerns of a 'high risk' of sexual abuse, low wages and harsh
conducted on the extent of this emerging trafficking trend though laws.[22] There is also demand for domestic workers within homes
in 2015 NGOs were routinely responding to the needs of victims. in Phnom Penh.[23] Walk Free survey data revealed that of an
estimated total of 201,000 people in forced labour, five percent
Forced labour
were exploited in the domestic service sector.
Cambodian men, often highly transient because of their need
to travel to secure employment, are subjected to forced labour
on fishing vessels in Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia. [10] In
2013, when significant media exposure and international pressure
brought this issue to global attention, ILO figures suggested 9
percent of Cambodian fishers were subject to forced labour,[11]
with Cambodians accounting for 40 percent of fishers across four
major Thai ports. To date, Cambodian victims of forced labour
on fishing vessels continue to be repatriated, including a group
of 59 trafficked fishermen who experienced slave-like conditions
on Thai vessels fishing in Indonesian waters in 2015.[12]
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, &
Country protections economic rights Personal security Refugees & conflict Mean
The mass genocide of an estimated 2.2–2.8 million people under which were forcibly evicted.[36] The loss of land and, therefore,
the Khmer Rouge regime of 1975–1979 dramatically shaped the livelihood, coupled with few employment opportunities in rural
current demographics of Cambodia. More than 50 percent of regions, is increasingly driving irregular and uninformed internal
the population are under 25,[32] placing immense strain on the and cross-border migration. The economic desperation of many
national economy to provide employment opportunities for the migrants, coupled with limited education or awareness of human
young burgeoning workforce.[33] trafficking, creates ideal conditions for recruitment agents and
labour brokers to trap people into situations of debt bondage or
Cambodia is a low-income country plagued by high levels of
offer lucrative jobs that frequently result in exploitation.
poverty; with more than 40 percent of the population living on less
than US$2 per day.[34] In 2014, almost 80 percent of the country's As tourism in Cambodia continues to boom—increasing from
population lived in rural areas and suffered comparably high rates only 700,000 visitors in 2003 to more than 4.5 million in
of poverty.[35] Cambodians living in rural areas are susceptible 2014[37]—the vulnerability of children to sex tourists and an
to land grabbing in the form of economic land concessions by increasing phenomenon of orphanage tourism increases the risk
large companies. Between 2003 and 2013, 2.2 million hectares of children being exploited at the hands of international visitors.
of land was seized affecting 420,000 Cambodians, 300,000 of Despite ongoing efforts to eliminate the child sex industry, men
from other Asian nations, the USA, Australia, South Africa and role in both facilitating and furthering the prevalence of human
Europe continue to engage in child sex tourism in Cambodia.[38] trafficking in the country.
Corruption in Cambodia continues to plague anti-trafficking Significant discrimination against girls and women persists,
efforts, particularly the prosecution of perpetrators and the with traditional gender roles championed in the school
acceptance of bribes by officials. Transparency International curriculum. Chbab Srey - a customary code of what respectable
found Cambodia to be the most corrupt country of the ten women say and do - continues to be taught to students.[43] The
ASEAN states.[39] Government officials continue to avoid code promotes ideas that women bring honour to and serve
investigation and prosecution for extensive human rights abuses their husband, maintain virginity before marriage and remain
including torture and assassinations.[40] In 2015, no government monogamous thereafter, to refrain from drawing attention to
employees complicit in trafficking were prosecuted, and Phnom themselves, to remain inside the home at night and to not leave
Penh's former anti-trafficking police chief convicted for human the home without permission. The observance of these rules has
trafficking in 2011 had his sentence overturned.[41] Protests significant implications for female victims of trafficking - ideas
by labour rights unions in early 2014 demanding a minimum of subservience to men and shame for their conduct often restrict
wage of US$177 per month were suppressed, and the leaders victims from coming forward to report abuse, and societal stigma
involved were prosecuted.[42] Such corruption can play a central for breaching cultural codes challenges successful reintegration
of victims.[44]
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
The Government of Cambodia is making progress in combating involvement of government agencies demonstrates that
trafficking. However this progress has been slow, and there are government is making a concerted effort to combat trafficking,
many challenges ahead. In 2014, the government released a it has also had the unintended consequence of creating undefined
five-year National Plan of Action (NPA) (2014–2018) devised boundaries of responsibility of the actors involved. This, in
by the National Committee for Counter Trafficking (NCCT)[45] turn, has resulted in discrepancies within services provided to
in collaboration with USAID and both international and national victims, with some areas being overly resourced while other
NGOs. This plan was designed to replace the 2011–2013 NPA, areas are completely lacking resources. Further, despite a
which was never successfully implemented.[46] The NCCT has concerted effort at the national level, implementation at the
stated that it has requested US$25,000 for funding from the local level is largely lacking support. Law enforcement task
Cambodia Government but hopes that the majority of funding forces lack the resources and training necessary to provide an
will be provided by the partnered NGOs and INGOs.[47] The effective response to trafficking. Similarly, although 2008 and
plan calls for increased government resources to combat 2009 saw the introduction of the Law on the Suppression of
trafficking, policy reform to aid the prosecution process and Human Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation and the renewed
greater involvement at the regional and local levels.[48] Although Penal Code, local practitioners lack the capacity to effectively
the plan holds promise for improving the country's stance on enforce them.[55]
trafficking in persons, it has yet to be implemented.[49]
Many victims in Cambodia do not receive adequate services.
The Cambodian Government has been a member of the The government is yet to develop a policy or practice that would
Coordinated Mekong Ministerial Initiative against Trafficking allow NGOs to take children into care, without risk of liability
(COMMIT), of which UNIAP is secretariat, since its foundation and court action. If guardians of children refuse to allow their
in 2004.[50] COMMIT is run by task forces that are the decisions child to attend a shelter, the children are often returned to their
makers for all policy and programming relating to trafficking homes where they may face a high risk of re-trafficking.
within their country.[51] At the fourth inter-ministerial meeting
Male victims, in particular, lack sufficient shelter and associated
of COMMIT early in 2015, Cambodia pledged to eradicate
services. Foreign victims located in Cambodia are usually
any situation that could cause a person to be exploited.[52]
repatriated to their home country and provided no legal
Over the past five years, the government has been developing
alternative regarding any hardship or risk they faced on return.
nationwide guidelines relating to the identification of victims
Similarly, Cambodian victims identified abroad lacked access
within vulnerable populations of society. These guidelines have
to government assistance particularly if located in countries
been tested in five provinces throughout the country but are yet
that lack Cambodian representation. These victims were largely
to be finalised.[53]
forced to rely on support from NGOs and INGOs.[56]
The victim response and support network in Cambodia relies
The Cambodian Government is obligated under international law
heavily on NGOs who provide services and use methods based
to ensure that the rights of workers are respected and redress
on their particular missions and capacities. This creates a
mechanisms are available. However, despite thousands of factory
patchwork of response mechanisms throughout the country with
inspections between 2010 and 2013, only ten fines were imposed
no comprehensive unified national institutional response. Due
on factories violating labour regulations.[57]
to the ever-changing nature of the NGO responses, victims may
be missing out on critical support due to a lack of awareness of In October 2015, prompted by years of ongoing violent protests
services available.[54] by garment workers and international pressure by rights groups,
the government raised the minimum wage for workers in the
Within the government, some ministries are involved in the
apparel industry to US$140 a month.[58]
human trafficking response, including the Ministry of Interior
(MOI), Labour and Vocational Training (MOLVT), Women's Though this goes some way to meeting worker demands,
Affairs (MOWA), NCCT and Social Affairs, Veteran and Youth greater inspections and increased punishments for perpetrating
Rehabilitation (MOSVY). Working with these ministries are employers must occur.
workforces, task forces and committees. Although the extensive
Government Business
• Increase specialist human trafficking support staff at • Conduct social audits on suppliers identified as high risk.
embassies where high numbers of Cambodian victims • Travel and tourism businesses to adopt child-safe tourism
have been identified, particularly in China, Thailand, policies.
Malaysia and Vietnam. Ensure that embassies/consulates
• Promote respect for workers' rights in the supply chain,
have sufficient budgets to provide immediate emergency
including both direct suppliers and subcontractor factories.
care, and establish shelter options for exploited
Cambodians to recuperate while their situation is resolved
(particularly pertinent for the Royal Cambodian Embassy
to Thailand, which is understaffed and unable to address
the needs of the volume of Cambodian's in need).
• Ensure embassy staff have sufficient training to provide
support to victims of modern slavery and to collaborate
with NGOs (both regional and local) to provide for the
voluntary return of victims.
• Sign a MoU between Cambodia and China to combat
trafficking for marriage in China. This MoU should define
trafficking to reduce the definitional discrepancy between
both countries when handling these cases.
• Regulate recruitment agencies and standardise information
provided to overseas job seekers.
• Increase training for police officers in the identification
of victims and handling of trafficking cases. Provide
specialised training in technologies designed to identify
and track foreign child sex offenders travelling to
Cambodia.
• Continue and upscale awareness campaigns to prevent
the sexual abuse of children, targeting school teachers,
parents, children and tourists.
• Improve the amount and quality of labour inspections,
particularly in the apparel industry, focusing on forced
overtime, non-payment of wages and working conditions.
• Monitor and issue public progress reports on enforcement
actions.
• Discipline or prosecute, where appropriate, law enforcement
personnel found complicit in cases of modern slavery.
• Conduct widespread awareness campaigns on the risks
of exploitative work abroad, particularly for men in the
fishing sector.
Phnom Penh, Cambodia 02/01/2014. Garment workers tried to help workers leave a factory during a strike but were prevented
by military forces from a nearby army base. Two women take shelter during a clash between protestors and police when a
garment workers' strike turned violent.
Photo credit, Luc Forsyth / Ruom
Phnom Penh 2014. In this image, Special Forces soldiers assault non-profit employees observing a violent stand-off between the
military and striking garment workers.
Photo Credit, Luc Forsyth
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
"They talked to us as if they were selling a product.
All the traffickers see is the money. We were told
the girls would do anything we wanted, however
we wanted... [They] never in their wildest dreams
thought they were going to get arrested. We want
to break this cycle of impunity."
Interview conducted by Reuters with an agent who ran
a sting operation against a child prostitution ring,
4 January 2015.[1]
104,800
38.13/100
BB 10,528,000 $13,262
104 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Dominican Republic cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 104,800 people or 1.00 Children in the Dominican Republic are also at risk of exploitation
percent of the total population live in conditions of modern slavery in domestic service, street vending (shining shoes and washing
in the Dominican Republic. This is based on a random-sample, car windows), begging, construction and the movement of illicit
nationally-representative survey undertaken in 2015, that sought to narcotics.[14] There is evidence of children being trafficked from
identify instances of both forced marriage and forced labour within rural to urban locations within the country, as well as Haitian
the general population (surveys conducted in Spanish language). children being trafficked across the border.[15]
Despite the Dominican Republic's high rates of economic restricted from sitting national exams to obtain a diploma.[24] This
growth, more than 40 percent of the multi-ethnic, multicultural limits opportunities for children to pursue higher education and
population lives in poverty.[17] Unemployment is rife, with access formal sector employment and may increase their risk
many workers resorting to unstable informal work where they of accepting exploitative work as adults. As a result, women
face precarious working conditions. Women, in particular, are accept offers of low or semi-skilled work as waitresses, dancers
vulnerable to informal employment where they commonly or models, which in practice can manifest as commercial sexual
earn incomes below minimum wage.[18] Dominicans frequently exploitation at the hand of a trafficker.[25]
seek opportunities to travel abroad for employment—the latest
Discrimination against certain ethnic groups in Dominican
survey by the Americas Barometer found 28.9 percent of citizens
society results in a significant disparity in employment, and
intended to live or work in a third country within the next three
access to basic public services.[26] Haitians provide a cheap
years.[19] Only Jamaicans and Haitians had a higher intention
source of labour for construction, agriculture and domestic work.
to leave their country.[20] The desire to seek better employment
Undocumented or stateless Haitians and Dominicans of Haitian
opportunities abroad drives labour brokers to exploit jobseekers,
descent are most vulnerable to modern slavery. The most recent
often resulting in irregular migration and sometimes in situations
government figures from 2012 suggest that more than 458,000
of debt bondage and forced labour.[21]
Haitians live in the Dominican Republic, while NGOs estimated
Uneven access to obtaining birth certificates and identification in 2015 that as many as one million Haitians live in the country,
documents denies many children admission to primary and many of whom are stateless and vulnerable to deportation.[27] In
secondary schools.[22] This contradicts the General Education 2013, the Dominican Constitutional Tribunal stripped citizenship
Act which provides for education as "a permanent and inalienable from children born to people 'in transit', the vast majority of
human right...without any discrimination on the grounds of race, whom were undocumented Haitian immigrants.[28] The porous
sex, belief, economic and social status or any other basis". [23] border between Haiti and the Dominican Republic continues to
NGOs report that the misapplication of this right means some provide an escape to those in search of economic opportunities
children are pushed into work while others attend school but are and ensures traffickers can transport people without detection.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
The Dominican Republic have enacted legislation criminalising these government departments tasked with combating trafficking
all forms of human trafficking[29] and in 2013 reformed the have been provided specialised training and equipment to aid in
Criminal Code to include slavery and increase penalties for the investigation and prosecution of human trafficking cases.[32]
commercial sexual exploitation of children.[30] The Criminal This has included capacity building activities such as training in
Code includes penalties for illegal travel, child labour and Creole, the language spoken in neighbouring Haiti and by many
commercial sexual exploitation.[31] To meet the legal mandate, victims of modern slavery, and the administration of a certificate
two inter-institutional groups were formed: the Inter-Agency course in Human Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation undertaken
Committee Protection of Migrant Women (CIPROM) (Decree by 40 prosecutors.[33] The combination of improved public
No. 97-99 of 1999) and the Inter-agency Commission on policy and intensive training of law enforcement bodies has
Combating Trafficking in Persons and Smuggling of Migrants increased investigations, prosecutions and convictions. Between
(CITIM) (Decree No.575-07 of 2007). The latter drafted and January 2014 and March 2015, 18 cases were prosecuted against
promoted the implementation of the First National Plan against traffickers and 20 cases have been prosecuted for CSE.[34]
trafficking 2009–2014. Combating trafficking in persons has
been added to the National Human Rights Plan.
In 2013, the Attorney General's Office shared letter No. 00788,
Despite these initial
instructing all members of the Public Prosecution Service improvements, NGOs report a
to take immediate and forceful action against "pimping and vital need for increased inspection
human trafficking". Since this time, to enhance investigation
and prosecution, the National Police, Migration Directorate, in all sectors where children are
Attorney General's Office and the three largest Prosecutors' known to be exploited.
Offices (Santo Domingo, Distrito Nacional and Santiago)
have created specialised units to combat human trafficking. In Language training must be rolled out more broadly, as labour
particular, the role of the Specialized Prosecutor against the inspections continue to be hampered by translation issues between
Smuggling of Migrants and Trafficking in Persons has created Spanish-speaking inspectors responsible for interviewing Creole-
a comprehensive policy to combat trafficking in persons and speaking workers with limited or no Spanish-language abilities.[35]
migrant smuggling. The Prosecutors Office has created standard There are also serious concerns about official complicity in
operating procedures with the support of the Specialized trafficking cases, with police reportedly failing to identify minor
Prosecutor Office against TiP (Políticas para la Persecución Penal victims of CSE, physically or sexually-abusing minors, and in
de los Fenómenos Criminales: Tráfico Ilícito de Migrantes y Trata one case, a police officer is to be tried for his participation in a
de Personas). With the support of international organisations, sex trafficking ring that involved child victims.[36]
There are ongoing efforts to combat sex tourism where many that many survivors of slavery, particularly minors, are often
victims are sexually exploited at the hand of traffickers. Tourists quickly returned to their family without sufficient screening and
with sex convictions have been denied entry to the country by often left to seek support on their own.
immigration officials.[37] The Specialized Corps for Tourist Safety
To address the unregistered status of many people in the
(CESTUR) work in partnership with UNICEF to build capacity
country, the 2014 Naturalization Law was passed to recognise
and train members of the tourism industry.[38] Hotels have
the nationality of those already registered as Dominicans,
signed codes of conduct and frequently display signs saying:
and to establish a registration process for those entitled to
"It is prohibited to take minors into hotel rooms" and "Trafficking
citizenship but who lacked official documentation.[46] The Plan
and sexual exploitation are crimes punishable by law."[39] While
Nacional de Regularización de Extranjeros, (National Plan for the
UNICEF reports that CESTUR is working to prevent child sex
Regularization of Foreigners) was established by Presidential
abuse in tourist areas, rescuing minors and arresting and bringing
Decree No. 327-13 and began accepting applications from June
to justice child sex offenders, local NGOs have not seen evidence
2014 to May 2015.[47] Following the expiration of the registration
of this.[40]
period in June 2015, thousands of people have crossed the border
In 2015, the Inter-Agency Commission Against Trafficking in into Haiti, either spontaneously out of fear of arrest or have
Persons (CITIM), in collaboration with the IOM, developed a been forcibly returned by Dominican authorities. [48] In June
protocol to detect, refer and assist child and adolescent victims 2015, there were reports people were deported on the basis of
of trafficking. However, some reports indicate that CITIM did appearance with little or no verification of their identity and
not convene all relevant agencies during the reporting period and nationality.[49] In January 2016, international organisations
that its efforts were otherwise limited.[41] In 2015, the IOM also reported that Dominican migration authorities have established
assisted the government in the creation of a second protocol— stronger procedures including case-by-case handling, verification
to identify, assist and reintegrate survivors of trafficking in of migration status and dignified shelter, all of which were being
persons.[42] Local organisations largely welcomed the protocols monitored by the UN country team.[50]
but reported concerns about the limited efforts being made to
Deportations are creating a complex migrant situation, whereby
implement the protocols.[43]
stateless people are returning to Anse-Pitre in South-East Haiti
Victim assistance continues to be largely provided by international where prolonged drought is resulting in food insecurity and
and local organisations. In late 2015, the government remodelled malnutrition. As of September 2015, four informal settlements
a house that it intends to open as a shelter for human trafficking have sprung up in Haiti to house up to 3,000 people.[51] Lack of
survivors immediately after their rescue. The funding for the basic services and health care means many men cross the border
remodelling was secured from a private donor. NGOs report back into the Dominican Republic each day seeking low-paid
that the shelter is scheduled to open in 2016.[44] This is a positive work. Without identification documents proving they are either
development considering no government agency currently Haitian or Dominican, this stateless group will remain extremely
provides case management, therapy, job training or other vulnerable to exploitation.
economic empowerment opportunities.[45] One NGO reported
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government
• Investigate cases of children being solicited for sex in tourist
areas, prosecute offenders and refer victims to shelters.
• Follow up on the regularisation of all migrants, and ensure
that nationality is granted to those who are entitled, that
consular services (especially Haitian) are available to
assure access to birth registration and ID documents.
• Assure access to Dominican Nationality to those who
would become stateless unless otherwise granted.
• Ensure that all children and adults can obtain identity
documents to reduce their vulnerability to forced labour.
• Continue to train police and labour inspectors in Creole to
ensure exploited workers are identified.
• Ensure the National Police and Public Ministry commit
to increasing the capacity of law enforcement officials to
investigate human trafficking.
• Investigate and record the rates of forced and child marriage.
• Commit to developing specialised services for victims,
particularly child victims, through CONANI (Child
Welfare Agency).
INDIA
“No one can imagine such a painful life. There is
much torture on me and I am punished even at my
minor mistakes like a child. My family is always
living under threats. There is also physical violence
against me and my family members.”
Survey respondent, India State Survey, 2016.
18,354,700
51.35/100
B 1,311,051,000 5,701
108 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
India cont.
PREVALENCE
India is undergoing a remarkable 'triple transition', in which to evict us from our homeland, shown their anger if I denied
economic growth is both driving and is being affected by rapid to perform any task. Sometimes the consequence extended
social and political change.[1] Economic growth has rapidly to my family and they used physical torture in several time."
transformed the country over the past 20 years, including the (Survey respondent, 2016).
creation of a burgeoning middle-class.[2] In 1993, some 45
Bonded labour is not only illegal, research confirms that it has
percent of the population were living in poverty; by 2011 that had
serious negative health impacts for those affected, who typically
been reduced to 21 percent.[3] In addition to economic growth,
work in unsanitary and dangerous working conditions with no
ambitious programmes of legal and social reform are being
access to health care.[6]
undertaken right across the board, from regulation of labour
relations to systems of social insurance for the most vulnerable. Domestic service
Even with such remarkable change, given India has a population Examples of forced labour of domestic workers were described
of more than 1.3 billion people, there are still at least 270 million by survey respondents. While not all domestic workers are
people living on less than US$1.90 per day. While laws, systems abused, domestic workers are a particularly vulnerable group
and attitudes regarding key 'fault lines' such as the caste system, as work takes place in private homes and largely out of the reach
gender and feudalism are rapidly changing, social change of of regulation. Official figures in India suggest that there are more
this depth and scale necessarily takes time.[4] In this context, it than 4.2 million men, women and children working as cooks,
is perhaps unsurprising that existing research suggests that all cleaners, drivers, gardeners and caregivers across the country.[7]
forms of modern slavery continue to exist in India, including These estimates are from 2004[8] and experts suggest that there
intergenerational bonded labour, forced child labour, commercial may be many more workers unaccounted for in these statistics.[9]
sexual exploitation, forced begging, forced recruitment into non-
state armed groups and forced marriage. Domestic workers in some states are excluded from labour laws
and can experience excessive overtime, withholding of wages
Quantification of modern slavery in any country is difficult, but or receive insufficient remuneration. It is reported that girls as
is doubly so in a country as large and complex as India. Whereas young as ten continue to be hired in private homes.[10] Domestic
in other countries, a national survey was used to estimate workers can be subject to threats of and actual physical violence
prevalence, in India, we chose to proceed with surveys at the and in, some cases, sexual abuse.
State level. In 2016, random-sample surveys were conducted
by Gallup in 15 States.[5] Collectively these surveys account for "You are well aware that if a young lady works as a domestic
nearly 80 percent of the Indian population. servant she is always a soft target of being easily molested.
So with me. I have not paid a single amount and in the
The survey data suggest that there are more than 18 million name of debt I was made a victim of the sexual violence."
people or 1.4 percent of the total population, who are living in (Survey respondent, 2016)
conditions of modern slavery in India. Industries implicated in
the survey data include domestic work, the construction and sex Forced begging
industries, agriculture, fishing, manufacturing, manual labour, Street begging by adults and children is a prominent feature of
and forced begging. many Indian cities. Though many beggars do so out of economic
desperation, survey data confirms that criminals also force people
Bonded labour to beg:
While bonded labour has been outlawed for decades, survey data "Though I am begging I am not paid a single amount. I have
and pre-existing research confirms that this practice still persists. to deposit all to them. I am deprived of food and good sleep.
Narratives available from 2016 survey respondents identify that I am not paid my wages only working as a bonded labor."
some respondents perceived their situation to be one of bonded (Survey respondent, 2016)
labour, some of which is inter-generational:
"I was forced to do begging and still begging with the
"Sir, it is the sin of my father that I have to repay the debts unless others….I cant say anything to you because I am in constant
I shall have to beg. I have a threat against my family. I am fear. I am threatened by my employer not to open my
prone to physical violence everyday." (Survey respondent, 2016) mouth to anybody otherwise I will be punished severely."
(Survey respondent, 2016)
"This is an old disease in the village that if you are not able
to pay off your debts you will have to work as a bonded Commercial sexual exploitation
labor in the field of a powerful person. My husband was
employed far from the village so that he can not run away." Existing research and the 2016 survey data confirm the existence
(Survey respondent, 2016) of forced prostitution. As one survey respondent said:
"My wife is kept in the locked room and sexually harassed and
In other cases, it appeared that bonded labour reflected debt being forced to work as a prostitute. She is physically punished
lending practices and continuation of a feudal mindset: whenever she refuse to have sex. My family is under death
"There are many people in the village who were working with me threat. We are also threatened of legal action against us."
as a bonded labor. I was physically and sexually assaulted when (Survey respondent, 2016)
I was working in the field. I had also threat on my life and on Another reported:
my family. I was also threatened that I had to leave the village." "I was forced to work in the flesh trade… Can you imagine that
(Survey respondent, 2016) I kept in a locked room for the whole day when I refused to
"It's very common in this village that we have to work for repay work under pressure? It is because they had always threatened
the amount, our family borrowed. I was one of them. My motto me and my family for physical violence and tortured."
was just repay the amount as soon as I could. They threatened (Survey respondent, 2016).
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, & Refugees &
Country protections economic rights Personal security conflict Mean
There are more than 270 million people living below the poverty required to clean out dry latrines. When they seek to leave or
line in India.[20] Homelessness, including of children, remains refuse to do this work, they face violence and abuse.[25]
a major concern. For example, a census of children living on
Women and girls face significant discrimination and high rates
the street in Mumbai in 2013 found a total of more than 37,000
of sexual violence across India, and this is particularly true for
children, primarily concentrated in commercial areas with a
women and girls from the Scheduled Castes and Tribes.[26] While
bustling informal economy. Seventy percent were boys and thirty
Prime Minister Narendra Modi referred to a string of rapes as
percent were girls, and 18 percent were in the 10–12 year old
a national ‘shame’, and there has been a raft of legislative and
age bracket.[21]
criminal justice reforms signalling some progress, women are
The informal nature of much of India’s labour economy also still at very high risk of sexual assault and domestic violence.
impacts on vulnerability. According to government statistics,
While factors such as dowry payments and a desire to avoid
some 75 percent of rural workers and 69 percent of urban workers
sexual violence are commonly given as reasons for early and
are in the informal economy.[22]These workers face risks associated
child marriage, recent research suggests that these are symptoms
with a highly unregulated and unmonitored work environment,
of deeper risk factors. Vulnerability to early and child marriage
particularly in the country’s many brick kilns. The country’s
has been attributed to a complex matrix of underlying risk
steady population growth and the corresponding demand
factors, reflecting the interplay of patriarchy, class, caste, religion
for improvement of infrastructure and increased dwellings
and sexuality, that all impact on decision making.[27] Overlaid
have enabled the ʻblood bricks’ produced in these industries
with this are the economics of marriage, dominant concepts of
to continue.[23]
sexuality, widely-accepted gender norms including concepts of
Vulnerability to slavery in India has some common elements, masculinity, educational and institutional gaps, the centrality of
with poverty and the lack of capacity to absorb shocks, and marriage in Indian society, and the desire for parents to exercise
deep structural inequalities reflecting gender, caste and tribe all control over their children as they become young adults.[28]
being highly relevant.[24] However, vulnerability is also distinct
Across India, but particularly in some southern states, Indian
state by state. For example, in Bihar, agricultural shocks, high
migrant workers actively seek jobs in construction and care
prevalence within the population of members of the Scheduled
industries, primarily in the Gulf, Europe and North America. There
Castes, combined with borders to Nepal, result in forced labour
are reported to be 14 million Indian men and women working
connected to migration for work both within and from India.
overseas, primarily in the Gulf, many of whom will have sought
Also, Bihar is one of the states affected by the Naxalite conflict.
work through their networks rather than formal channels.[29]
According to the UN Security Council, Naxalites in Bihar,
Official migration processes are complex and often tainted by
Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand and Odisha states recruited boys and
corruption, which further encourages irregular migration. These
girls between six and 12 years of age into specific children’s
channels leave migrants with little recourse against practices such
units. Uttar Pradesh which has the highest proportion of castes
as unilateral contracts, dangerous working and living conditions,
and tribes of all Indian states, the issues are quite different.
limited movement and access to communications, withholding of
For example, so-called ʻmanual scavenging’ is reported to be
passports and wages, and physical and sexual abuse.[30]
still widely practised, in which members of a certain caste are
Given the scale and complexity of the issue in India, it is makes interpretation of results difficult. There is also no current
significant that the government of India has taken many steps legislation covering the use of children in armed conflict.[34]
designed to address vulnerability on a broad scale. Recent
Responsibility for the national government’s response is divided
amendments to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
between three ministries: Ministry of Labour, Ministry of Home
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act makes it an offence to, among other
Affairs, and Ministry of Women and Child Development. While
things, compel a member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled
each agency has different mandates and areas to cover, the
Tribe to do begar or other forms of forced or bonded labour;
absence of strong, continuing coordination across these agencies
dispose or carry human or animal carcasses, or dig graves; or
had led to a fragmented and complex response to modern slavery.
do manual scavenging. The 2016 amendments also make it an
offence to promote dedicating a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Implementation of anti-trafficking laws in the Penal Code is the
Tribe woman to a deity, idol, object of worship, temple, or other responsibility of the Ministry of Home Affairs, which provides
religious institution as a devadasi or any other similar practice.[31] information about cross-government efforts on its anti-trafficking
portal. The portal includes criminal justice statistics, details of
The government has also drafted a ‘National Policy for Domestic
anti-trafficking police units, information on government and
Workers’, which is currently awaiting Union Cabinet approval.
law enforcement training, and information on anti-trafficking
If enacted, the Policy would safeguard a minimum salary of Rs
legislation and reporting mechanisms, including the ChildLine
9,000 (approximately $135 USD) per month for skilled full-
hotline.[35] Criminal justice statistics, both on human trafficking
time domestic workers, paid leave and maternity leave, social
and bonded labour crimes, are published by the National Crime
security, and the right to collectively bargain. It also includes
Records Bureau.[36]
calls for provisions against sexual harassment and bonded labour
for domestic workers.[32] The fact that domestic workers were Laws prohibiting bonded labour have been on the statute books
identified in forced labour in the 2016 Walk Free Foundation state for decades.[37] The response to bonded labour is coordinated by
surveys underscores the urgency of policy change on this issue. the Ministry of Labour while the district and sub-divisional level
vigilance committees provide advice to the courts on bonded labour
In June 2015, the Ministry of Women and Child Development
issues.[38] The National Human Rights Commission monitors the
launched ‘Khoya Paya’, a Lost and Found website, which
government response, regularly reviews existing government
operates in addition to the Ministry of Home Affairs’ ‘Track
policies and practices from a human rights perspective,[39] and
Child’ site. ‘Track Child’ provides a forum for police to exchange
provides training to district Magistrates, Deputy Commissioners
information on missing children, while the new site extends to
and other government officials.[40] Statistics suggest that many
the public, allowing registration of missing children by their
states are yet to implement the Supreme Court order which
families in coordination with police efforts.[33]
required district vigilance committees to undertake surveys to
In terms of more specific responses to modern slavery, India has identify and release those in bonded labour, as many still submit
criminalised most forms of modern slavery, including trafficking, an official report of zero cases.[41] The state of Karnataka has
slavery, forced labour, child prostitution and forced marriage, made progress on the Order, as reflected in the numbers of cases
as part of its penal code or under specific legislation. However, of bonded labourer identified in official crime statistics. Outside
there is no distinction drawn under the existing trafficking this, there are concerns about the effectiveness of the response
legislation between human trafficking and sex work which to bonded labour in India.[42]
In July 2015, the AHTU of Telangana state The AHTU raid found women and girls
police removed 39 women and girls who living in unhygienic conditions in cramped
had been trapped working in squalid rooms. Of the 39 victims, a number were
conditions in a brothel in Chandrapur, HIV positive and some were pregnant.
The Indian National Government has undertaken an ambitious protection for Indian citizens migrating overseas. Indian police
programme to establish specialist anti-trafficking police units have cooperated with regional counterparts on transnational
throughout the country. These are mandated to facilitate human trafficking investigations. In 2014, Indian and Bangladeshi
interagency coordination for the rescue of children and post- police undertook a joint investigation to identify two Bangladeshi
rescue care efforts, to monitor interventions and provide girls sold into commercial sexual exploitation in India. Both girls
feedback, and to collect and analyse data related to trafficking were found and successfully repatriated; the offenders are being
to be shared with state governments and the media as appropriate. prosecuted under new anti-trafficking provisions.[50] In March
The government continued to expand the number of units across 2016, India and Bahrain agreed to increase bilateral cooperation
the country, reaching 225 units by December 2014, with the aim to on human trafficking issues, especially women and children in
establish 330 anti-human trafficking units.[43] While these efforts the Gulf.[51] [52] This agreement provides protection for victims,
are commendable, it is also clear that some units are working including repatriation, and provides for close cooperation and
well and others are not. It is reported that one issue relates to information exchange between police and other concerned
budget, but there are also numerous systemic issues that result authorities.[53] In April 2016, media reports suggested India will
in investigations stopping at state boundaries. Reflecting these sign a similar agreement on anti-human trafficking collaboration
concerns, a recent National Legal Services Authority submission with the United Arab Emirates shortly.[54]
to the Supreme Court called for a central investigations bureau
In December 2015, in response to public interest litigation
to be established to investigate cross-border crimes.[44]
initiated by an NGO, the Supreme Court of India took note
Both the judiciary and law enforcement have received training; of evidence of the deficiencies of the existing victim support
more than 20,000 police personnel have been trained on victim network.[55] The Supreme Court of India disposed of the litigation
identification, implementation of the new legal framework, when the Ministry of Women and Child Development stated
and victim-centred investigations. The government victim that it was taking steps to establish the ʻOrganised Crime
compensation scheme also extends to victims of human Investigative Agencyʼ (OCIA) and had established a committee
trafficking; however, the amount and efficiency of dispersal is to prepare new ʻcomprehensive anti-trafficking legislationʼ
largely dependent on the state administration and is not available to ensure, among other things, that victims are not treated
country-wide.[45] In a recent landmark case, four traffickers were as criminals and provided with adequate shelter homes. The
prosecuted following a three-day trial for kidnapping a 14-year- Supreme Court also highlighted the need for stronger victim
old Haryana girl and forcing her into domestic servitude and protection legislation and protocols and provision of adequate
sexual exploitation; they were sentenced to between seven shelters.[56] This is critical as recent research suggests that rescue
and ten years in jail, with half of the fine paid to the victim efforts involving children are not always operating in the best
as restitution.[46] interests of victims, and are not resulting in appropriate criminal
action against employers or traffickers, leaving children at risk
The Indian Government funds victim support services, however,
of retaliation and re-trafficking.[57]
efforts need to be directed at improving these both in terms of
approach and quality of care. The Ujjawala project is one of the Early indications are that many steps have resulted from this
primary support systems in India for children and young women Supreme Court order. An inter-ministerial committee has been
at risk, but this does not necessarily equate to specialist services formed, legislation has been drafted and certain outcomes
for victims of trafficking. Most shelters have limited facilities appear close to completion. For example, efforts to develop
and resources to provide holistic support. [47] Government a comprehensive standard operating procedure on rescue,
shelters are required to register; however, services vary as there rehabilitation and prevention of trafficking of women and
are no standards attached to registration, and no inspections or children for sexual exploitation was being finalised at the time
follow-up. Furthermore, under existing laws, survivors under of print.[58] It is not yet clear how this will impact on the existing
the age of 21 can and are subject to extended periods of court laws and infrastructure, such as the anti-human trafficking units,
ordered custody in protective homes, effectively resulting in already established. Part of the challenge will be to ensure that
their detention.[48] Specific government trafficking shelters are gains already made are not lost in efforts to create a new system,
currently available only for women and girls.[49] while the new system does not add another layer of complexity
to an already overcrowded system.
India continued to take steps toward collaborating across the
region to respond to transnational trafficking crimes and provide
Government Business
• W
ith many of the necessary laws in place and under • P
artner with civil society organisations to provide safe
development, the focus must be on implementation and work and vocational training to survivors of modern
tracking improvements in implementation. For example, slavery, under the Company Act 2013 corporate social
given the high levels of internal migration, there is a clear responsibility requirements.
need to ensure State police are encouraged and enabled to • E
xport-oriented industries such as textiles, agriculture and
continue investigations across borders. This needs to be carpet weaving should work through their industry bodies
in addition to any central investigations bureau which will and with appropriate third parties to create industry-wide
likely focus on only the most complex cases. supply chains that are free of modern slavery.
• R
atify and implement the Convention on the Worst Forms • D
omestic industries, such as construction, manufacturing
of Child Labour. and brick kilns, should work with state governments and
• Ratify and implement the Domestic Workers Convention. local organisations to find innovative ways of eliminating
• P
roactively require all states to follow up on the Supreme the need for child and bonded labour in their businesses.
Court Judgment of October 15, 2012, to identify and
release those in bonded labour, and report on progress.
Require States who report zero cases of bonded labour
to show what steps have been taken to actually find and
assist bonded labourers.
• U
pdate regulations and processes for the implementation of
the Bonded Labour Act, and report on its implementation.
• F
ocus on practical ways to regulate and monitor practices
of placement agencies.
• I mplement a new National Action Plan that targets the
full spectrum of modern slavery, while recognising the
differences between highly organised crime (which is
likely to be cross-border) and more localised practices of
bonded labour.
• E
nsure that victims are not criminalised or detained both
by law enforcement and in the shelter system. Victims
must be protected (including protecting their identities)
throughout the duration of their court cases. Repeal laws
which permit detention of victims.
• I ncrease the proportion of female police officers in
enforcement.
• C
reate and monitor implementation of standard operating
procedures for shelter homes to support quality and rights
based post-rescue rehabilitation of survivors.
• P
revent the recruitment of children into armed opposition
groups and provide targeted rehabilitative services to
rescued children.
STATE STUDY 1 – P
roblem description and state government
responses in Uttar Pradesh
199,812,341 [59]
US$161.1 Billion [60]
As the most populous state in India, Uttar Pradesh (UP) is a centre of agriculture, industry and tourism.
Though poverty across the state is declining, UPʼs poverty rate remains higher than the national
average.[61] A combination of population growth and persistent migration flows from neighbouring
states, predominantly Bihar, Madhya Pradesh and West Bengal, have increased the available workforce
despite limited employment opportunities. This, coupled with the highest prevalence of Scheduled
Castes in India (the official term for Hindu, Sikh and Buddhist Dalits)[62] and prevailing discrimination
against women,[63] heightens people’s vulnerability to modern slavery in UP.
UP is a source, transit and destination state for modern slavery. UP’s 619 km stretch of open borders
with Nepal,[64] proximity to Bangladesh and New Delhi, and home to tourist destinations of Varanasi and
Agra, facilitate the flow of vulnerable people and impede the ability of law enforcement to detect human
traffickers. Following the 2015 earthquake in Nepal, migrants from earthquake affected areas poured
into UP,[65] some of whom were vulnerable to accepting exploitative jobs in the informal economy.
Children in UP are at particular risk of forced labour and commercial sexual exploitation. A 2015 study
found a 13 percent rise in child labour in UP despite the fact that child labour is gradually declining
across India.[66] Nationally, one in five child labourers in India is exploited in UP,[67] with almost 900,000
children aged 5–14 years in the workforce in 2011.[68] Many children are engaged in the worst forms of
child labour—forced begging in Varanasi and Agra, and forced labour in embroidery, carpet weaving,
leather work, sports ball stitching and bangle making.[69] Despite the efforts of some international
brands to sever contracts with factories manufacturing with child labour, the illegal work of many
children in UP goes undetected as they work from home for meagre piece-rate wages.
UP’s 40 million people belonging to Scheduled Castes[70] are particularly vulnerable to caste-based slavery
such as manual scavenging. Despite legislation prohibiting manual scavenging,[71] the act of removing
faeces from non-flush systems and septic tanks by hand for little or no pay remains common.[72]
Persisting hierarchical attitudes ensure manual scavengers remain entrapped in this lifestyle, subject
to violence, stigma, debt bondage and discrimination.
UP has the highest proportion of child marriages in India, with more than 2.8 million children married
in the 10–19 years category.[73] Children and young women are vulnerable to short-term contract
marriages with tourists who temporarily marry for the duration of their visit to UP.[74]
Uttar Pradesh does not have state-level legislation specifically targeting slavery; however, some
elements of trafficking are criminalised under the Goonda Act and the Gangster Act of UP, which
recently received Presidential assent.[75] The legally-mandated Uttar Pradesh Victim Compensation
Scheme 2014 provides for financial compensation to victims of trafficking who have suffered loss or
injury,[76] though no data exists on how many victims accessed this fund.
Under the national anti-trafficking initiative, 35 anti-human trafficking units were functional in UP
and will receive technical support from UNICEF during 2016–2017.[77] Considerable efforts were made
at the state level to combat modern slavery including the training of 2,076 stakeholders, rescue
missions across a range of districts and the approval of a State Task Force in 2015.[78] Operation Smile,
a 2014 initiative of the Ghaziabad Police which rescues children from child labour, and tracks missing
and trafficked children,[79] continued operations in 2016.[80] Following the earthquake in Nepal, the
government of UP installed CCTV cameras on border crossings to monitor human trafficking though
it is unclear whether any victims were identified in this way.[81]
STATE STUDY 2 – P
roblem description and state government
responses in Bihar
104,099,452 [82]
US$66.4 Billion [83]
In Bihar, a combination of chronic poverty, distress migration, open borders, caste, ethnicity and
gender drive the prevalence of modern slavery. According to the National Sample Survey Office’s most
recent report, 34 percent of Bihar’s population are below the poverty line, with 56 percent of children
under five years of age underweight.[84]
Despite a wealth of fertile land and natural resources, ongoing flooding and drought have reduced
agricultural output and hindered the state’s growth. With reduced livelihood opportunities, distress
migration is common. The 2011 Census showed that net migration out of Bihar stood at 1.7 million
people,[85] making it the second-highest state in India for out-migration. Other reports have suggested
as many as 4.42 million people migrate out of Bihar every year.[86] The use of migration as a survival
strategy across all age groups in Bihar, often under extremely vulnerable circumstances, exacerbates
vulnerability to slavery.[87]
Ongoing crimes against Scheduled Castes, 25 percent higher than the national average (3.5 per 100,000
population, compared with 2.8 per 100,000 nationally),[88] coupled with more desperate economic status
and severe social exclusion, increase vulnerability to exploitation. Although many new government
initiatives are starting to have a positive effect on discrimination against marginalised groups, more
than 56 percent of women in Bihar aged between 15 and 49 report that they are subject to physical
and sexual violence.[89]
Bihar’s proximity to Bangladesh and its 800 km stretch of open borders with Nepal, facilitate the ease
with which traffickers cross internationally without identification. Major transport hubs in these border
areas have become hotspots for trafficking, as well as sites of commercial sexual exploitation. Bihar
acts as a transit and destination for girls and women trafficked from Nepal, Bangladesh, West Bengal
and northeastern states. An estimated 40 red light areas exist in Bihar, many of which are home to
intergenerational sex workers from the Natt tribal group.[90]
Children in and from Bihar are subject to forced labour, forced marriage, forced begging and forced
recruitment into non-state Armed Opposition Groups (AOGs). Persistent civil unrest between the
Naxalite-Maoist insurgency and the government has resulted in Bihari children as young as six recruited
into service and taught to handle weapons as part of their training. Throughout 2015–2016, local
newspapers continued to report on the rescue of Bihari children trapped in forced labour in a variety
of sectors, including jacket-manufacturing,[91] bangle making,[92] textiles,[93] food manufacturing[94] and
waste recycling.[95]
Efforts to combat slavery and the corresponding attempts to address the corruption of local services
is still at an early stage. Bihar does not have state-specific laws addressing slavery, although they are
considering drafting legislation for anti-trafficking protection. Under the national initiative, Bihar
State Police created anti-human trafficking units (AHTUs) and this has led to the identification and
rescue of victims in 14 of 38 districts.[96] Data collection and reporting remains an issue, especially in
the management of missing persons by police despite previously receiving training in tracing and
rehabilitating missing children. The Astiva Action Plan for Preventing and Combating Trafficking
2008—that coordinates state, district and Panchayat (village) task forces in order to “care and protect
trafficking victims at all stages of rehabilitation and also ensure strong prosecution of cases”[97] commenced
strongly, but efforts since appear to have diminished. The 2015 ‘Operation Mahavir’, to trace and
free child victims of trafficking, saw police in 38 districts of Bihar monitoring places like brick kilns,
roadside hotels, markets, bus stands and railway stations.[98] However, at the time of writing, no data
was available on the number of cases identified in this operation. Many of the gaps in government
implementation of anti-slavery policies and legislation are a legacy of Bihar’s decades of misrule.
They reflect deep-seated, long-term challenges that will require continued and determined efforts.
STATE STUDY 3 – P
roblem description and state government
responses in Maharashtra
112,374,333 [99]
US$264.80 Billion [100]
Maharashtra is one of the wealthiest states in India and is considered the trade and commercial hub
of the country. According to the 2011 Census, 45 percent of Maharashtra’s population is urban.[101]
The wealth disparity between rich and poor is particularly evident in Mumbai with 54 percent of the
capital cityʼs population residing in slums. Mumbai is home to 22 million people[102] and is notorious
for being the commercial sex capital of India.[103]
Human trafficking and commercial sexual exploitation is witnessed throughout Maharashtra. Rural
Maharashtra continues to be a major source of trafficking victims. Due to poverty and a lack of livelihood
prospects, men, women and children from rural tribes are pushed to search for opportunities in urban
cities, increasing their vulnerability to modern slavery. Commonly, women and girls are trafficked
and exploited by independent recruitment agencies largely unregulated by state authorities.[104]
Many human traffickers also pose as matchmakers arranging false marriages within India where,
instead of marriage, the women are sold and subjected to forced prostitution and forced labour
within the domestic service.[105]
The government of Maharashtra has made efforts to implement legal mechanisms to protect vulnerable
populations from modern slavery. Maharashtra is the first state in the country to have prepared a state
action plan for the elimination of child labour.[113] It is also one of the first states to adopt various acts
specific to issues of mathadis (manual labourers who load and unload trucks),[114] migrant labourers
and domestic workers.[115] In accordance with the Maharashtra Domestic Workers Welfare Act (2008),
the Maharashtra Domestic Workers Welfare Board has registered many domestic workers within the
state so that they are privy to the benefits outlined in the Act.[116][117]
In 2008, Maharashtra established AHTUs and various rescue operations have been conducted since
then. By 2012, the AHTUs had rescued 2,683 victims across 478 operations, arrested 1,558 traffickers
and registered 372 cases.[118] AHTUs have repatriated 26 Bangladeshi women rescued from Pune,
Mumbai and Thane.[119] The Crime Branch’s Social Service Branch (SSB), which investigates trafficking
crimes in Mumbai, have reported increasing success in identifying and rescuing victims from 159
women and nine minors (2013) to 308 women and 23 minors (2014).[120] Despite these successes,
inter-departmental coordination remains a serious challenge to human trafficking law enforcement,
particularly between the local police, AHTUs and SSB.[121]
In 2014, the government of West Bengal and Maharashtra signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU)
to ensure the identification and repatriation of women and children who are victims of trafficking.[122]
The MoU established a standard operating procedure to ensure the verification of identities and
family tracing of rescued human trafficking victims.[123] In addition to this, it was reported in June
2015 that the governments of Jharkhand, Delhi, West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra will sign
an MoU to closely collaborate and jointly combat modern slavery.[124] These efforts contribute to the
collaboration of states to combat modern slavery through the exchange and sharing of information
and the unification of inter-state modern slavery data.
IRAQ
"The Islamic State didn't come to kill the women
and girls, but to use us as spoils of war, as objects
to be sold with little or to be gifted for free. Their
cruelty was not merely opportunistic. The IS
soldiers came with a pre-established policy
to commit such crimes."
Excerpt from a statement by Nadia Murad Basee Taha,
Trafficking Survivor, to the UN Security Council on 18
December 2015. On 15 August 2014, Nadia was captured
by Islamic State militants in Iraq; she was raped and
tortured for three months until she successfully escaped.
403,800
63.83/100
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 403,800 people or resulted in their use as suicide bombers, informants, bomb
1.13 percent of the total population live in conditions of modern makers and human shields. There are also reports of families
slavery in Iraq. Though Walk Free did not conduct a survey selling disabled children to IS.[14]
in Iraq, respondents in other survey countries—Bangladesh,
Cambodia and Nepal reported a family member exploited in Iraq.
Online video footage released
Forced labour
by IS shows children, some as
The current armed conflict and the subsequent humanitarian
crisis in Iraq continue to significantly impact the security of young as ten, undergoing military
civilians and migrant workers in the country. Before the outbreak training at camps, carrying out
of violence, Iraq was gaining popularity as a destination for
migrant workers, particularly from Bangladesh, Indonesia, assassinations and completing
Nepal, the Philippines, Sri Lanka, India and Thailand.[1] Migrant suicide bombing missions, as
workers, either knowingly or unknowingly, came to Iraq to
meet manpower demands in growing sectors such as health,
well as graphic images of a child
construction, domestic work and hospitality. There are also shooting dead two alleged Russian
reports of Asian migrants forced into prostitution.[2] To attract spies and another showing a child
more local and foreign investors, Iraq passed an investment law
in 2006, which ensured the right of companies to employ foreign carrying out a suicide bombing.[15]
workers and for non-Iraqi workers to remit their salaries.[3]
PMF elements also recruit children, though it is unclear to what
Before the violence escalated, migrant workers in Iraq extent children join alongside relatives and caregivers versus
were already vulnerable to forced labour and debt bondage those forcibly recruited. There are reliable testimonies of children
commensurate with regional trends. However, the current crisis confirming that they were tricked into believing they were joining
has magnified these issues and introduced new risks and threats. the police but instead were taken to PMF training camps.[16] There
In mid-2014, hundreds of South Asian migrant workers in Iraq are unconfirmed reports the PMF abducts children. However, it
were caught in the crossfire between the Iraqi military and is unclear whether they are being abducted for ransom, leverage,
Islamic State (IS). Those wanting to leave the country faced a recruitment or other purposes.[17]
difficult situation as employers retained worker passports. There
are reports of Indian migrant workers striking because they Forced marriage
wanted to return home but could not access their passports.[4] Despite legislation preventing girls under 18 from marrying,
During an intense period of conflict in Tikrit, north of Baghdad, widespread evidence of forced and temporary marriage persists.
IS militants briefly captured Bangladeshi workers[5] while 41 Forced marriages are often used as a tool to strengthen familial
Indian construction workers were detained indefinitely in Najaf, ties within tribes and tribal allegiances.[18] Fasliyya, the practice
south of Baghdad[6] and 46 Indian nurses were left stranded in a of marrying off a woman from one tribe to settle a feud with
hospital.[7] Reports of IS holding migrant workers in situations of another, continues with girls being traded as compensation for
debt bondage in Iraq have emerged since their rise to prominence crimes.[19] This practice reportedly increased throughout 2015–
in 2014, as well as their use for forced labour, sexual exploitation 2016 in the southern provinces of Iraq, namely Missan, Basrah,
and as human shields in conflict.[8] Thi-Qar, Muthanna, and Babeil, where the role of government
is increasingly being overtaken by local tribes. [20] In Iraqi
Sexual slavery
Kurdistan, the tradition of jin be jin (a woman for a woman)
There are verified reports of women and children being captured, persists whereby brides are exchanged between tribes to avoid
sold into slavery and held in barbarous conditions by IS. In 2014, payments of dowries.[21]
IS captured 3,000 women and children, mostly from the Kurdish-
speaking Yazidi minority group—the largest single capture of Dowry payments received by fathers of child brides continues
women this century. IS propaganda claimed that the captured to provide an economic incentive to marry daughters early. New
Yazidi women and girls were 'spoils of war' to be divided among research from November 2015 found economic incentives played
fighters.[9] Publications released by IS[10] provide an extreme a role in 51.4 percent of forced marriages, out of a representative
interpretation of Shari'a describing the legality and illegalities sample of 1,249 cases.[22] Parental fear of inter-ethnic marriage has
of dealing with slaves - "it is permissible to buy, sell, or give as a also been noted as a cause for forced marriage. The socio-tribal
gift female captives and slaves, for they are merely property, which tradition of marrying daughters to relatives continues in 2016.[23]
can be disposed of..." This alarming resurgence of slavery is According to research published in November 2015, 80.2 percent
evident in Raqqa, the self-proclaimed IS capital, and surrounding of forced marriages in Iraq would end a girl's education.[24] This
IS-occupied territory where women can be bought and sold at lack of education is particularly concerning when coupled with
the market.There are reports of IS offering to sell women back the reality of many girls being abandoned by their husbands or
to their families for as much as US$40,000.[11] widowed. Without education, and unable to financially depend on
their husband, girls find it incredibly difficult to access another
Forced recruitment of children into militia groups
source of income. This is compounded by a lack of legal rights,
There are grave concerns for Iraqi children being used in armed as many marriages are conducted outside of the court system by
combat by IS, emerging militias and within existing, expanding a cleric. Another 2015 study which investigated 4,265 marriage
and government groups such as the Popular Mobilization Forces cases in Iraq across the governorates of Baghdad, Basrah, Thi-
(PMF)[12] which operate under the control of the Prime Minister's Qar, Muthanna, Missan, Babil, Al Anbar, Diyala and Nineveh
Office (PMO).[13] The forced recruitment of children by IS has found more than one-third were conducted outside of the court
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, &
Country protections economic rights Personal security Refugees & conflict Mean
The brutal rise of the self-proclaimed Islamic State[32] in 2014–15 the merging of the Ministry for Women's Affairs and the Ministry
has seen almost 3.2 million Iraqis flee their homes[33] with a for Human Rights with other Ministries in August 2015.[48] The
further 8.2 million requiring immediate humanitarian support birth registration system remains weak, particularly in rural and
as at June 2015.[34] As many as two million war widows and remote areas. Children in Iraq, already vulnerable to recruitment
more than one million orphans have been left destitute across into the armed forces and militia groups, are even more exposed
the country[35] with internally-displaced persons (IDPs) residing to risk when unable to prove their age.[49] Sixty-seven separate
in roughly 3,550 locations.[36] Chronic lack of funding, resulting attacks on schools in 2014,[50] including targeted murders of
in emergency food distribution delays and health care cuts, has teachers, has left many children without access to education.
left millions unable to meet their basic daily needs.[37]
Deeply entrenched religious and ethnic divisions continue to
There is a strong link between high levels of instability within expose some sectors of the community to modern slavery.
a country and increases in that population's vulnerability to
modern slavery.[38] In cases of armed conflict, there is often a
corresponding weakening of the rule of law, providing fertile Yazidis, Assyrians, Christians and
ground for traffickers to profit with impunity.[39] The demand for
the State to respond to other humanitarian emergencies, coupled
other minorities are particularly
with few human-trafficking specific services or organisations vulnerable to exploitation at the
in these countries, means protection of vulnerable migrants, hands of IS.
IDPs and ethnic minorities, and support for victims of human
trafficking in times of crisis is limited.[40] In Iraq, a combination Fleeing IDPs of particular ethnicities and religious sects have been
of protracted displacement, dwindling financial resources, prevented from entering certain governorates, exposing them to
limited employment opportunities and loss of assets, coupled danger and heightening their risk of seeking help from opportunistic
with missing identification documentation,[41] is creating fertile traffickers. In April 2015, thousands of Sunni-Muslims fleeing IS
ground for modern slavery. in Anbar were prevented from entering Shia Baghdad, stranding
The rapid onset of violence in some provinces meant many them in no man's land without shelter or food.[51]
fled without an opportunity to secure vital proof of identity Forced marriage and early marriage are prohibited by the Iraqi
documentation[42] which is essential to access medical care, Personal Status Code. [52] However, in February 2014, the draft
education, food rations, employment and government social- Jaafari Personal Status Law was approved by the Council of
welfare schemes. The situation is particularly precarious for Ministers. This law permits the marriage of girls as young as nine,
women without a male companion, as ID cards often bear the forbids wives to leave the house without permission and waives
name of the male head of the household, without whom she the husband's responsibility to pay financial support (nafaqah)
is unable to access services and assistance.[43] These women, when a wife is either a minor or a senior and hence unable to
particularly girls and those refugees who originally fled Iraq sexually satisfy him. To date, the draft law remains dormant, but
into Syria now subsequently returning to Iraq, are easy targets it remains of significant concern, particularly as it would apply
for exploitation.[44] Some women are resorting to survival sex only to Shiite Muslims thereby dividing the now unified judicial
while others are vulnerable to trafficking for commercial sexual courts into religious courts headed by clerics. Many clerics in Iraq
exploitation or forced marriages with men who abduct them. continue to perform underage marriages because they believe the
This, in turn, increases their risk of falling victim of honour minimum legal age for marriage contradicts Islamic principles.
crimes.[45] Some girls sold into commercial sexual exploitation There are some encouraging practices emerging—in Dohuk,
(CSE) are imprisoned for their protection from reprisals for the Islamic Religious Committee cooperates with the Personal
dishonouring their family.[46] Impunity for perpetrators of child Status Court to ensure that couples have legally registered their
sexual offences exists if they subsequently enter a valid marriage marriage before conducting a religious marriage.[53]
with the child victim.[47]
Many government institutions are riddled with corruption while
others have merged due to financial constraints—as evidenced by
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
At present, the Government of Iraq has fragmented control of trafficking. Recognising that the recovery needs of trafficking
over some areas of the country, faces sectarian and ethnic victims require specialised support, a government shelter has
divisions, and is largely reliant on international aid to deliver been built to accommodate 100–150 female victims, but it has
essential services to large swathes of its displaced population. not yet begun accepting victims. It is uncertain when the shelter
The information that follows on government responses should will open—it currently lacks sufficient funds to operate, has
be understood in that context, recognising this response, in inadequate safety protections[58] and requires Ministry of Justice
reality, does not reach all portions of the population outside of approval to open.[59] Specialised staff within MOLSA can provide
government-controlled areas. psycho-social and medical care to victims, but it is unclear if
any victims are given this support.[60]
Despite the protracted conflict, in the past ten years the Iraqi
Government has passed some key pieces of legislation with Workers abandoned by their employer in Iraq have little to no
the aim of strengthening the country's counter-trafficking protection or humanitarian services to turn to. There are no
framework. In 2005, Article 37 of the new constitution outlined NGOs specialising in anti-human trafficking, and there are strict
that, alongside prohibitions against torture, "forced labor, slavery, government restrictions on an NGO's capacity to provide long-
slave trade, trafficking in women or children, and sex trade shall term assistance such as accommodation or vocational training.[61]
be prohibited".[54] Law No.28 on Trafficking in Persons covers Workers without passports or permits (many employers allow
prosecution of perpetrators (sentences of a maximum jail term of permits to expire and fail to renew them) have no clear access
life imprisonment and fines of up to 25 million dinars), protection to help. NGOs are unable to assist victims who have been
of victims and prevention. The law protects victims by providing designated for deportation by law enforcement. Many victims
medical care, witness protection and financial assistance. The of trafficking are imprisoned for infractions such as overstaying
Act largely adopts the UN definition of trafficking in persons,[55] visas, illegal border crossing, missing identity documents, forged
however, there are omissions such as the facilitating of child entry visa and forged residency documents.[62]
prostitution is not considered an act of trafficking.
In June 2015, Iraq's Prime Minister Al-Abadi urged the UN to
There is almost no proactive identification of victims in Iraq and consider IS's recruitment and use of children as crimes against
low levels of understanding of what constitutes a trafficking- humanity.[63] However, this disregarded the government's own
in-persons crime among law enforcement personnel.[56] The use of children in the PMF militias that he formally commands.[64]
Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs (MOLSA) is responsible There are no comprehensive policies or strategies addressing child
for the inspection of workplaces according to the Labour Law. recruitment and use in armed conflict.[65] Furthermore, legislation
Despite this, no MOLSA staff has been trained on labour criminalising the enlistment of children into armed forces, non-
inspections.[57] A large number of vulnerable migrant workers state armed groups, and their use as active participants in hostilities,
working across the country means even training a few staff could only applies to offences committed from 17 July 1968 to 1 May
not possibly account for all of the workplaces that need review. 2003, therefore not to those committed subsequently.[66] The draft
Migrant workers are extremely vulnerable to exploitation as the National Guard Law presented to the Council of Representatives in
conditions at workplaces are determined solely by employers March 2015 includes exceptions related to the age of recruitment,
and remain unregulated. which would allow children associated with pro-government
militias to join the National Guard.[67] In December 2015, the
Very limited support is available to victims in Iraq, and of
UN Security Council announced their abhorrence of all acts of
those services that exist, they assist a range of people including
trafficking in human beings by IS, stating that certain acts might
orphans, the elderly, victims of domestic violence and victims
be considered crimes against humanity.[68]
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government
• Islamic scholars qualified to interpret Shari'a law must • O
pen the dedicated shelter for trafficking victims to
speak out against the practices of IS, particularly the provide essential accommodation, support and services.
enslavement and sale of women and girls. • A
llow NGOs to play a role in the provision of essential
• Rescue and rehabilitate children forcibly recruited into IS, assistance for victims of modern slavery; encourage the
PMF and other armed groups. creation of a specialised NGO with trained staff.
• Ensure all marriages are registered, punish clerics found • C
onduct widespread awareness campaigns, with the
to be conducting forced marriages and engage fathers in support of international organisations, on modern slavery
education on the minimum legal age of marriage. and victim identification.
• Coordinate and monitor the cross-border movement of
Iraqi girls, screening for cases of muta'a marriages.
• Train members of the Ministry of Interior (police officers,
staff at the Residency Department labour inspectors)
and members of the High Judicial Council (judges,
prosecutors, lawyers) on counter trafficking and build
their abilities on the identification and protection of
victims, including assistance delivery and recovery needs,
to be the focal points for counter-trafficking efforts.
7
Prevalence Index Rank
MAURITANIA
Former slave, Noura Mint Mourada. Noura escaped
from the house of her owner with the help of the
activist group Initiative for the Resurgence of
Abolitionism in Mauritania, a group that fights
for the end of slavery in Mauritania.
Mauritania, Nr. Boutilimit
43,000
46.77/100
CC 4,068,000 $3,912
122 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Mauritania cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 43,000 people or 1.06 the domestic sector typically herd animals (camels, cows, goats)
percent of the total population live in conditions of modern and or are forced to work in the fields.[11]
traditional slavery in Mauritania. This is based on a random-
There is an increasing demand for Mauritanian domestic
sample, nationally-representative survey undertaken in 2015,
workers in the Middle East. In September 2015, Mauritanian
that sought to identify instances of both forced marriage and
trade unions reported 900 Mauritanian women were trafficked
forced labour within the general population (surveys conducted
to work in Saudi Arabia.[12] These women believed they had
in French, Hassanya, Poulaar, Wolof and Soninke languages).
accepted roles as nurses, teachers and childminders, but instead
Mauritania continues to host a high proportion of people living were expected to perform domestic work in private homes.
in slavery in the world. Slavery is entrenched in Mauritanian These women experienced physical confinement in the home,
society. Slave status is inherited generation to generation and passport confiscation, and some reported physical and sexual
is deeply rooted in social castes and the wider social system. harassment.[13] As traditional migrant labour sending countries,
Those owned by masters often have no freedom to own land, such as the Philippines and Indonesia, implement stricter bans
cannot claim dowries from their marriages nor inherit property on the recruitment of their nationals for domestic work in the
or possessions from their families.[1] Middle East, the hiring of Mauritanian women to fill the void
is likely to continue.
Forced marriage
Forced begging
Religion and slavery are closely interrelated in Mauritania
Walk Free survey data reveals and religion has reportedly been called upon by masters as
an estimated 23,000 victims of justification for ownership over another person.[14] There have
forced marriage in Mauritania (or been cases of Talibes, boys who attend Koranic school, being
forced into begging on the streets.[15] Forced begging is practised
53 percent).[2] primarily by Black Mauritanians.[16] Boys from low-income
families in the Halpulaar community were most vulnerable to
UNFP estimates as many as 35 percent of marriages in the forced begging.[17]
country are forced or early.[3] The dangerous and damaging
practice of leblouh or gavage, the force-feeding of child brides
to make them gain weight before marriage, continues across the Walk Free Foundation 2015 survey data
country.[4] It is predominantly practised by Arab Moors seeking % male % female
the highest dowry for their daughter.[5] Number % victims victims
Maslaha marriages (kinship marriages) remain common between Forced labour 20.000 47 71 29
cousins with many girls being married early in a stated effort
to prevent them from rape and sexual violence.[6] The desire to Forced
23,000 53 28 72
marriage
prevent pregnancies out-of-wedlock has similarly been noted as
a driving factor fuelling the prevalence of forced marriages.[7] Modern
43,000 100 48 52
slavery total
The practice of siriya or 'temporary' marriages continues between
Mauritanian girls and wealthy Middle Eastern men.[8] Some
reports suggest young daughters are frequently married off to Forced labour by sector of exploitation %
Saudi Arabian men as prepubescent brides who are later rejected
once they reach puberty or become pregnant.[9] Mauritanian Domestic work 42
women and girls are also at risk of being forced into prostitution Construction 43
by their 'husbands' in the Middle East. Manufacturing 4
Men, women and children in Mauritania continue to be as many as 80 percent of children in Haratine communities in
vulnerable to a range of risk factors associated with entering Nouakchott were not in school.[26] Lack of education increases
into and remaining in situations of modern slavery. Mauritanian the vulnerability of children to the worst forms of child labour
society is deeply divided by ethnicity, descent, castes and class[18] and forced marriage, as a lack of future economic or employment
which continue to influence the vulnerability of some groups to options leads many parents to marry their daughters early.
hereditary or chattel slavery—whereby slave status is inherited
Some children continue to lack birth registration certificates
generation to generation.
which deny them access to essential health and education
The Black Moors (also known as Haratines) were historically services, limits an individual's ability to assert property rights,
enslaved by the Arab Moors, the minority rulers.Today, due to and reduces legal work options—this makes individuals highly
their entrenched marginalised status, many remain under the vulnerable to accepting jobs in the informal market where they
direct or indirect control of their traditional masters.[19] The are denied appropriate protection. Some Mauritanian refugee
psychological nature of slavery means it is not uncommon children who fled to neighbouring Mali remain stateless although
for masters and slaves to form bonds[20] which can hinder this situation is improving following the 2015 decision of
efforts to shift the traditional cultural mindset that slavery is the Malian Government to extend birth certificates to 7,807
acceptable. Many Black Moors remain caught in an isolating Mauritanian children.[27]
system perpetuated by a lack of education and knowledge of life
The opposing flow of Malian refugees into Mauritania following
outside of servitude.[21] Some AfroMauritanians, including the
the 2012 conflict has seen the creation of the M'bera refugee
Peuhl, Soninke, Wolof and Bambara, continue to be vulnerable
camp. New refugees continued to arrive throughout 2015.[28] The
to modern slavery as a result of their discriminatory status.
traditional caste hierarchy persists in the camp affecting equitable
The systematic exclusion of Black Moors and AfroMauritanians aid distribution.Bella children, already vulnerable to exploitation
from political and economic life results in a corresponding and forced labour as domestic workers in the homes of Arabs and
economic disparity between groups.[22] An estimated 42 percent Tuaregs in Mali, are particularly vulnerable to food shortages and
of Mauritanian's are living in poverty,[23] many of whom reside ill-treatment in the camp.[29] UNHCR continues to advocate for
in rural communities reliant on the precarious agriculture and the adoption of national asylum law and provision of civil status
pastoralist sectors for their livelihood. Mauritania is subject documentation for refugees,[30] many of whom are vulnerable
to harsh climatic conditions—including frequent droughts and to human trafficking. The government does not provide legal
floods—which result in persistent severe food crises.[24] The lack alternatives to the removal of foreign victims of modern slavery
of alternative livelihood opportunities provides little incentive to countries where they may face hardship or retribution.[31]
for enslaved workers to seek work outside of their master's home
Mauritanians and other Sub-Saharan African migrants continue
or farm.
to be vulnerable to human trafficking as they travel within the
Despite a constitutional guarantee of free compulsory primary country and onto North Africa. The vast, poorly-patrolled borders
education, many children do not attend school.[25] In 2014, the UN increase the accessibility of transit through the country and the
Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Racism reported ability of traffickers to exploit victims with impunity.[32]
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Slavery in Mauritania was abolished in 1981, criminalised in In March 2013, the President of Mauritania established the
2007 and designated as a crime against humanity under the National Agency to Fight against the Vestiges of Slavery,
constitutional reform in 2012.[33] In August 2015, a new anti- Integration, and Fight against Poverty (known as Tadamouns)
slavery law was enacted that increased the maximum prison which outlined a National Plan of Action.[39] In March 2014, the
sentence for the crime of slavery from 10 to 20 years.[34] All plan was formally adopted by the government of Mauritania
forms of trafficking, except hereditary slavery, are prohibited by in cooperation with the OHCHR Field Office in Nouakchott
the 2003 Law Against Trafficking in Persons, which prescribes and a special Tribunal to prosecute crimes of slavery was
penalties of five to 10 years' imprisonment for violations.[35] established.[40] The Tribunal has not prosecuted any cases of
Despite these legislative advancements, a 'deliberate and slavery and field sources suggest there is no evidence that such
systematic failure' of both the government and local organisations a Tribunal exists.[41] In December 2015, the government ordered
to enforce laws allows exploitation of citizens to continue.[36] In the creation of special courts to try slavery cases—further details
2011, the first and only slave owner was convicted in Mauritania, on the timeframe for their creation were not found.[42] The UN
receiving an inadequate sentence of 6 month's imprisonment.[37] Special Rapporteur on Trafficking has expressed concerns that
Despite this unprecedented conviction, the government has not Tadamoun was not independent of the government.[43] To date,
pursued investigations, prosecutions or convictions for slavery it is unclear what effect the activities undertaken by the body
crimes since.[38] has had on victims.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government Business
• Educate parents on the dangerous health impacts of • Import and export trading with any Mauritanian business
leblouh or gavage, and prosecute those found forcing their should be considered high risk until there is evidence
daughters to participate. that the government are actively making progress in the
• Create bi-lateral agreements with labour-receiving Roadmap to End Slavery (particularly China, Mauritania's
countries in the Middle East to ensure decent working largest trading partner, importing more than 50 percent of
conditions are met for Mauritanian domestic workers. goods from the country).[54]
• Fully implement the recommendations made by the ILO • Draft a clause to include in contracts with major cattle and
Committee on the Application of Standards. goat exporters, prohibiting the purchasing of livestock that
has been sourced from farmers using forced labour in their
• Conduct a nationwide awareness campaign on the
herding practices.
illegality of slavery and forms of modern slavery that
persist in Mauritania today.[53]
• Increase support for victims by establishing a victim-
support mechanism with emergency shelter and
assistance, legal assistance and reintegration programmes
for both adults and children.
• Increase support to civil society organisations and NGOs
who are working to combat slavery and to implement new
slavery policies.
MEXICO
"They took him to another state to work in a building
site. And they keep him working day and night. He
wanted to return home, but they say to him that if
he wanted to go home before the construction was
finished, he would have to do it with his own money
and he wouldn't receive payment for his work. He
accidentally spilled some material so they took
money out of his salary. He had no money to travel
home and had to stay until he was paid."
Walk Free survey respondent
376,800
47.02/100
BB 127,017,000 $17,108
126 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Mexico cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 376,800 people or in maize harvesting, tomato fields,[15] tomato processing plants[16]
0.30 percent of the total population live in conditions of modern and other plantations such as chilli pepper, cucumber and
slavery in Mexico. This is based on a random-sample, nationally- eggplant,[17] in 18 states.[18] News media reported that 49 victims,
representative survey undertaken in 2015, that sought to identify including children, were found working in a cucumber field under
instances of both forced marriage and forced labour within the modern slavery conditions in the Mexican region of Colima.[19]
general population (survey conducted in Spanish language). This added to the 452 persons found working in conditions
of servitude from February to March 2015.[20] In July 2015,
Victims of modern slavery in Mexico are primarily Mexicans
exploited agricultural workers from San Quintin Valley staged
themselves or citizens of Central and South American
mass protests against their abusive treatment and conditions.[21]
countries.[1] There have been some isolated cases of victims
from Eastern European countries, Asia and Africa.[2] By some Mexican seasonal farm workers are also found in conditions of
estimates, 70 percent of modern slavery cases in Mexico are forced labour in the USA, where they are subject to poor living
related to organised crime groups.[3] The various cartels[4] commit and working conditions that may amount to forced labour—
kidnappings for forced prostitution and forced labour across all particularly, excessive working hours, withholding and non-
age groups, often with the complicity of local, state and federal payment of salaries, confinement to plantations, refusal of
authorities.[5] Groups with increased vulnerability include women medical care, and physical and sexual abuse.[22] Under a loophole
and children, indigenous people, the disabled, migrants and in US labour laws, children as young as 12 can work in agriculture
LGBTQ-identified persons.[6] with no minimum wage requirements or cap on working hours.[23]
Mexican workers in the USA also fulfil low-paid and low-skilled
Anecdotal evidence from escapees indicates that Mexico's
roles in food processing, construction, janitorial/cleaning jobs,
desaparecidos (the disappeared) crisis, where tens of thousands
child/elderly care and manufacturing.[24] A recent study found the
of men, women and children have vanished since 2006, involves
highest rate of reported trafficking violations and abusive labour
camps in which forced prostitution, labour and criminal acts are
practices occur in the construction industry, with janitorial and
sanctioned by the cartels.[7]
cleaning businesses the next worst.[25]
Commercial sexual exploitation Forced labour is prevalent in the mining sector, with the coal
The commercial sexual exploitation of Mexican women and and silver industries accounting for the poor labour conditions
children both within Mexico and in the USA persists. The of men, women and children in Mexico.[26] There are also reports
city of Tenancingo, Tlaxcala is dubiously dubbed the sex of modern slavery in the garment sector; in February 2015, a
trafficking capital of the world, with often poor, uneducated further 129 workers (121 women and eight men, including two
and indigenous girls duped into 'love relationships' with local adolescents under the age of 18) were rescued from forced labour
men who essentially trap them into forced prostitution.[8] Some conditions in a garment factory in Zapopan, Jalisco State.[27]
of these women and children are relocated to the infamous kerb-
crawling district of La Merced, Mexico City where street and
brothel-based prostitution is rife.[9] Walk Free Foundation 2015 survey data
Others are trafficked across the border into the USA, some % male % female
Number % victims victims
serving clients in New York, others being transported around
the country to service migrant farm workers in what is known Forced labour 376,800 100 95 5
as 'city to farm sex pipelines'.[10] Traffickers from Tenancingo
rank on the USA Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Forced
0 0 0 0
marriage
list of most-wanted human traffickers. In 2015, ICE announced
it had caught the 12th member of a Tenancingo trafficking ring, Modern
376,800 100 95 5
the outcome of a lengthy operation that rescued 25 Mexican slavery total
commercial sex trafficking victims in New York City.[11]
NGOs in El Paso reveal the commercial sexual exploitation
of Mexican girls continues on a daily basis in their city and
Forced labour by sector of exploitation %
across the USA, with highways in New Mexico and Texas rapidly
transporting girls across the country within hours of their arrival Domestic work 0
across the border.[12] Construction 69
The commercial sexual exploitation of children to service tourists Manufacturing 0
continues, particularly in the areas of Acapulco, Cancun and
Other manufacturing 20
Puerto Vallarta.[13] Studies of Mexican children forced to enter
sex work found they experienced a higher prevalence of sexual Farming 5
violence and substance use risk, with associated health impacts.[14] Sex Industry 0
Despite verified evidence of CSE cases in Mexico, the Walk Drug production 0
Free survey did not identify any victims in this sector. This is a Retail sector 5
limitation of the survey highlighting difficulties accessing victims
of CSE, rather than a reflection of no cases of CSE occurring. Other 0
DK 0
Forced labour
Refused 0
Low, semi- and unskilled, domestic and foreign labourers are at
Total 100
risk of forced labour within the agricultural sector, particularly
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, &
Country protections economic rights Personal security Refugees & conflict Mean
Endemic internal violence resulting from cartel activity, a high the mestizo ethnic group are highly vulnerable to coercion into
risk of kidnapping[34] and the weak rule of law all contribute to the commercial sex industry—mestizo women are favoured for
a high risk of modern slavery in Mexico. Cartel violence across their fair skin while traffickers can purchase indigenous women
North and Central America has displaced many men, women and at the lowest price.[37]
children resulting in large-scale migration attempts to the United
Persisting government corruption and involvement at local, state
States. Migrants that reach the border of Mexico and the USA
and federal levels allows organised crime groups to operate freely
remain vulnerable to coyotes and polleros or border 'guides' who
in the country.[38] Some public officials are known to accept bribes
may elect to sell them into slavery or hold them in debt bondage
from traffickers, extort bribes and sexual services from adults
once they have entered the United States.[35]
and children in the commercial sex sector and irregular migrants,
Limited formal employment opportunities for Mexican men in and threaten victims with prosecution if they do not file official
some smaller towns is reportedly driving them to become pimps complaints against their traffickers.[39] Some cartel members
and traffickers. In turn, they are deceptively recruiting women have infiltrated institutions obligated to uphold the rule of law,
and children into the commercial sex industry. Women from leaving victims unwilling and often unable to come forward
poor southern states, particularly Chiapas, Oaxaca and Guerrero to authorities to report abuse without fear of re-victimisation.
are highly vulnerable to recruitment into the sex industry in Ongoing, horrific, unpunished human rights violations in Mexico
Northern Mexico and abroad, as limited livelihood opportunities perpetuate the climate of impunity for perpetrators.
exist in their villages.[36] Young indigenous girls and those from
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Despite initial hopes that Mexico's National Programme for the compensation for victims and support services, with many
Prevention, Punishment and Eradication of Crimes on Trafficking services provided through private financing.[42]
in Persons and the Protection and Assistance to Victims 2014–
Throughout 2015, criminal charges have been laid against
2018 would reduce trafficking, at the time of writing, no funds
traffickers, particularly for cases of sexual exploitation. In
were allocated to execute the plan. National activists report that
October 2015, six traffickers were charged for the exploitation of
the human trafficking response is fragmented with some states,
27 people in Mexico City.[43] This follows success in sentencing
such as Coahuila, actively policing and prosecuting cases, and
the first person for child labour exploitation in 2014. Four people
others implementing localised anti-trafficking committees.[40]
were sentenced to four years and six months in prison for forcing
However, NGOs report that only half of Mexico's states are
ten children aged between seven and 17 years to work and beg in
performing prevention and prosecution, leaving significant gaps
the town of Texcoco.[44] In January 2016, after a lengthy police
in victim protection.
operation in Cancun, 16 trafficking victims were rescued, seven
Mexico has taken steps to combat modern slavery crimes at of whom were minors, and six people were arrested. NGOs
a transnational level by signing agreements with some key reported this was indicative of better police awareness of and
countries including Guatemala, Peru and the USA to streamline attention to trafficking crimes, particularly victims of commercial
and strengthen coordination. Particularly important is the Merida sexual exploitation.[45]
Initiative between the USA and Mexico, still operational from
These are positive steps by the Mexican Government, which has
2008, focusing on combating transnational organised crime
previously displayed consistently low levels of convictions in
including trafficking.[41] Gaps in Mexico's provision of victim
cases of modern slavery.[46] Mexico's efforts to build the capacity
shelters and ad hoc referral processes have resulted in victim
of the legal profession through wide-ranging training programmes
identification and support as Mexico's weakest response area.
are contributing to a stronger criminal justice response. However,
NGOs reported a desperate need for government supported
these developments must be closely monitored considering the a National Conduct Code for the Protection of Children in
complicity of Mexican officials in human rights abuses and the Travel and Tourism Sector, which identifies hotels and
corruption in modern slavery cases.[47] accommodation establishments as free from human trafficking.[48]
Although NGOs suggest that many hotels continue to turn a blind
There is slow momentum to combat the sexual abuse of Mexican
eye to blatant cases of child sexual abuse.[49]
children in Puerto Vallarta—the Ministry of Tourism signed
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government Business
• Investigate and prosecute government officials at all levels • Businesses operating in the tourist sector should adopt the
complicit in modern slavery cases in Mexico. National Code of Conduct for the Protection of Children
• Increase investigations and prosecutions of drug cartels and Adolescents in Sector Travel and Tourism.
for crimes relating to modern slavery including forced • Members of the National Association of Hotels and
labour and forced prostitution. Motels (Asociación de Hoteles y Moteles) should continue
• Strengthen victim identification processes at border to train employers on victim identification.
crossings into the US, and at airports, bus and train • Sectors particularly vulnerable to child labour, including
stations, particularly around the human trafficking of agriculture and construction, should join efforts to
children and young adults. implement industry-wide standards on policies and
• Create a national coordination mechanism to streamline the practices to address the use of forced child labour.
implementation of each state's counter-trafficking legislation. • Businesses employing Mexican citizens abroad should
• Promote legal and regulated migration as the safest verify policies on the recruitment of migrant workers,
means of emigration to increase the number of Mexicans ensuring all employers are employed via legal and
emigrating via formal channels. regular channels.
• Develop a comprehensive strategy to raise awareness among
labour migrants on their rights in destination countries.
• Strengthen workers' organisations and unions to empower
workers through the delivery of information about human
rights and labour rights.
POLAND
"We left Poland with a few belongings and 10 Zloty
[£8] that I borrowed from a friend, I was worried,
but happy that I would be working again....The
room was cold and dirty. Black mould was on the
walls, wallpaper was dropping off and the house
was damp. My heart stopped. I paid my debt [for
travel to the UK] after a month, but if I left I knew
they would find me and kill me, so I had to stay....
I was their property and there was no escape.
I lived every day in fear."
A Polish migrant describes their experiences of forced
labour while living in the UK[1]
181,100
26.66/100
BB 38,025,000 $24,744
130 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Poland cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 181,100 people or Commercial sexual exploitation
0.48 percent of the total population live in conditions of modern Forced prostitution and commercial sexual exploitation affect
slavery in Poland. This is based on a random-sample, nationally- women and girls trafficked in and out of Poland. Of 50 trafficking
representative survey undertaken in 2015, that sought to identify victims identified by Polish police in 2014, the majority were
instances of both forced marriage and forced labour within the women. These women, including one minor, were trafficked for
general population (survey conducted in Polish language). prostitution or pornography.[18] Most of the victims originated
from the Ukraine.[19] The Polish Border Guards have also identified
Forced labour
Bulgarian Roma people as victims, who are typically involved in
Forced labour affects migrant populations within Poland and 'roadside prostitution'. An investigation by the Maritime Border
Polish citizens migrating overseas. Walk Free Foundation survey Guard identified two citizens of Bulgaria and one citizen of
data suggests construction (45 percent), domestic labour (31 Poland as victims of human trafficking for prostitution.[20] A study
percent), other manual labour (eight percent), and manufacturing of prosecutions for the crime of commercial sexual exploitation
(six percent) were sectors of concern Within Poland, migrant of children found that 14 children were trafficked within Poland
labourers from nearby Eastern European countries, such as and one child trafficked to Germany between September 2011
Ukraine, Bulgaria and Romania,[2] and parts of South East Asia, and February 2012.[21]
are vulnerable to exploitation in the construction, agriculture,
retail and domestic sectors.[3] Despite existing literature giving evidence of CSE cases in
Poland, the Walk Free survey did not identify any victims in
While previously victims of exploitation were predominately this sector. The survey result may not indicate an absence of
from the former Soviet Union, there has been a shift in recent cases but possibly a lack of willingness to self-identify or report
years to an increase in the number of identified victims from this issue. We will continue to work with experts to identify the
Asia,[4] including Vietnam, the Philippines, China and Korea.[5] most robust ways to ensure the issue of sexual exploitation is
In 2014, the Border Guard identified 31 victims of forced labour, fully accounted for in our survey results in future.
19 of whom originated from the Philippines. When cases of
domestic servitude are included, this figure increases to 34
forced labour victims, of which 21 were from the Philippines.[6] Walk Free Foundation 2015 survey data
A study released by the European Alliance for Human Rights in
North Korea implicated Polish firms in the use of North Korean % male % female
forced labour. As many as 800 North Koreans are believed to be Number % victims victims
working in the country, primarily in shipyards and orchards.[7] Forced labour 181,100 100 56 44
Even those migrants who legally enter the country may become
subject to forced labour. In 2010, 58 Thai migrant workers who Forced
0 0 0 0
entered the country with work permits, for example, were made marriage
to work excessive hours, received limited food and were not Modern
paid full wages.[8] 181,100 100 56 44
slavery total
Polish nationals made up the fifth largest group of European Union
(EU)-registered trafficking victims experiencing exploitation
within the EU between 2010 and 2012.[9] Most of these individuals
Forced labour by sector of exploitation %
were identified in the UK (405), Poland (263) and the Netherlands
(187).[10] In 2012, 54 individuals were identified as victims of Domestic work 31
labour exploitation;[11] victims are recruited online, attracted by
Construction 45
the promise of employment and the provision of accommodation
and transport.[12] Polish victims in the UK are most likely to be Manufacturing 6
victims of labour exploitation and have been forced to work in Other manufacturing 8
agriculture, construction, factories and car washes.[13] Polish men
Farming 0
and women have also experienced modern slavery in the UK, the
Netherlands, Germany and France.[14] Sex Industry 0
Drug production 0
Forced begging
Retail sector 0
Regionally-organised crime syndicates are implicated in forced
begging rings. Roma mothers from poor communities in Moldova Other 0
and the Ukraine are offered jobs in the sales or care sectors DK 0
in Poland but have their passports confiscated upon arrival.[15]
Refused 10
Along with their children, they are forced to beg on the streets
and report their daily intake back to the trafficker. Children as Total 100
young as three and five have been identified in cases of Ukrainian
nationals trafficked to Poland for forced begging.[16]
In 2014, the police identified only one case of forced begging.
However the Border Guard found three suspected cases; in every
instance, the victims were Romanian citizens.[17]
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, &
Country protections economic rights Personal security Refugees & conflict Mean
High levels of unemployment in Poland, significant rates of Significant emigration of Polish citizens, a growing economy,[31]
emigration to Western Europe, the low socioeconomic status and historical links with South East Asian Communist countries[32]
of citizens in neighbouring countries and regional instability has led to an influx of economic migrants from South East Asia.
contribute to the vulnerability of nationals and migrants to Migrants from Asia, in particular, face difficulties integrating
modern slavery both within Poland and in Western Europe. into Polish society.[33] While Poland is considered a relatively
peaceful country, discrimination towards migrant workers
Economic factors remain the chief motivator for Polish
and minorities[34] can lead to isolation[35] and an increase in
emigration.[24] Official unemployment figures have hovered
vulnerability to exploitation. According to a 2013 study from the
around 10 percent since the end of 2012, although this has
Centre of Research on Prejudice at the University of Warsaw, up
recently decreased to approximately 7 percent at the close of
to 69 percent of Poles do not want 'non-whites' living in Poland,
2015.[25] Youth unemployment, however, has remained relatively
believing that they deprive Poles of employment and have a
high at nearly 21 percent in 2015.[26] The outflow of labour from
detrimental effect on the economy.[36] Coupled with a limited
Poland has stabilised,[27] but there are still around two million
understanding of the Polish language, migrants are vulnerable
Polish people living abroad as of 2015, with 640,000 Polish
to exploitation and have difficulties accessing support once
residing in the United Kingdom (UK) alone.[28]
exploitation has occurred.
Polish migrants tend to be from rural areas and the main
Ongoing conflict and the economic crisis in the Ukraine has led
breadwinners of their families[29] and, as such, there is pressure
to increasing numbers of refugees[37] and economic migrants
to find work, often at the expense of basic labour conditions.
leaving the Ukraine to neighbouring countries, including
Poland.[38] Ukrainians make up the largest group of registered
foreign workers in Poland, with an increase in the issuance of
Research conducted in the declarations of intent and work permits in recent years. In the
UK shows that migrants from first half or 2015, more than 20,000 permits were issued, twice
Eastern European Accession that for the same period in 2012.[39] [40] Limited and contradicting
data exists on the overall number of registered and unregistered
countries, including Poland, suffer migrants.[41] [42] However, there are estimates of between 300,000
from discrimination, insecure and 500,000 Ukrainians working in Poland.[43] Those who are
undocumented are vulnerable to exploitation and forced labour.[44]
conditions, substandard pay, There have been cases, for example, where economic migrants
racial stereotyping and skill have become vulnerable to traffickers en route to and in Poland,
and in neighbouring Russia, Germany, Belarus and Israel.[45]
degradation.[30]
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
The Government of Poland has been largely reactive in implementation of NAP activities in 2014,[51] which reflects a
responding to modern slavery in recent years[46] while it is unclear gradual increase in State funding over recent years for programs
what steps the new government (elected in October 2015) will to combat human trafficking. However, legislation related to
take to tackle this crime. The National Action Plan 2013–2015 third-country nationals has been criticised for its complexity
(NAP) outlines provisions to address the most critical areas of and ambiguity[52] while a lack of standardised data collection
response. Implementation of the NAP has been largely successful. techniques prevents comparability of case data between different
The government succeeded in amending the legislation relating agencies. Some measures were also delayed due to a lack of
to third-country nationals,[47] expanding victim identification financing or other difficulties.[53] The current NAP expired in
processes,[48] setting standards for the provision of assistance to December 2015; NAPs are typically issued every three years.[54]
victims,[49] and training employees of crisis centres, NGOs and However, there is no indication when the new government will
consular staff on identification and assistance mechanisms.[50] approve a new NAP or what the budget will be.[55]
The government set aside the equivalent of US$363,000 for the
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government Business
• Enact a new National Action Plan, with a corresponding • Ensure that employees are not paying recruitment fees to
budget. receive a job.
• Develop and implement a campaign to shift community and • Ensure that employees are only recruited from registered
business perception around forced and exploitative labour. employment agencies.[72]
• Develop policies that require businesses to conduct audits • Businesses should familiarise themselves with
and inspections to identify forced labour throughout their international labour standards, which are also enshrined in
supply chains. Polish Law, and introduce these standards into their Code
• Continue investigations of organised crime gangs in of Conduct[73] and supplier contracts.
relation to human trafficking and forced begging.
• Conduct targeted and relevant raising-awareness
campaigns among migrant populations to raise awareness
of their rights. In particular, promote their entitlement
to a three-month reflection period to decide whether to
participate in the criminal process.
• Extend existing trafficking training for front-line law
enforcement to include a systematic and comprehensive
program on forced labour.
• Ensure trafficking training for prosecutors and judges is
adequately financed and delivered in a systematic fashion.
• Develop and implement a standardised approach for
collecting data on modern slavery.
QATAR
"Qatar must change its ways in relation to the
people it welcomes to the country. I am speaking as
a player but it must be even worse for the workers
over there. I have had the chance to see how it
works. If Qatar does not change its ways, I have the
courage to say that in 2022 we will have the World
Cup of Shame and the World Cup of Slavery, for not
respecting human rights, and I am brave enough
to say it."
Abdeslam Ouaddou, Professional Footballer
30,300
31.71/100
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 30,300 people or 1.36 nations.[3] Workers from nations without embassies in Qatar have
percent of the total population live in conditions of modern slavery few alternate options to flee to in cases of exploitation.
in Qatar.
Domestic workers are excluded from protections contained
Forced labour within the Labour Law pursuant to Art 3(4) of the Labour Law
No.14 of 2004 . Draft legislation specifically relating to domestic
Forced labour in the construction sector is one of the dominant
workers is currently under consideration.[4] Qatar has not ratified
forms of modern slavery in Qatar, reflecting the demand for
nor does it comply with ILO Convention No.189, the Domestic
cheap labour to build extensive infrastructure for the 2022 FIFA
Workers Convention . Domestic workers continue to report
World Cup and National Vision 2030. The ongoing construction
cases of serious maltreatment and abuse including physical,
of football stadiums, and the huge infrastructure projects required
psychological and sexual violence. Rather than being able to
to access and service these locations, continues to see massive
access help, domestic workers risk imprisonment for 'illicit
influxes of migrant labour who are vulnerable to abuse.
relations' if they report such abuse to authorities. Among female
The vast majority of construction workers are low, semi and foreign nationals, domestic workers are particularly prone to
unskilled. They are almost exclusively male (99.4 percent in being detained and deported for violating the Sponsorship Law.
2012[1]) and are predominately from South and South East
Asian nations—India, Nepal, the Philippines, Sri Lanka and
Bangladesh. These men are vulnerable to exploitation at all In March 2013, of the 378 women
stages of the recruitment process—from the initial stage where held in detention, 90–95 percent
they often incur large debts to pay recruitment agents' fees to
reliance on their sponsor for residency and legal status, and had been employed as domestic
discrimination from laws that criminalise workers for leaving workers.[5]
exploitative situations ('absconding').
The incidence of migrant construction workers taking out loans Information on the exploitation of migrant fishermen on Qatari
to pay recruitment fees in their respective home countries creates boats is an emerging but under-researched area. Anecdotal
situations of debt bondage in Qatar. The average recruitment evidence suggests Qatari shipowners are hiring migrant labourers,
charges are as follows: India: US$1,300, Nepal: US$1,400, the predominately men from India, Sri Lanka, Pakistan and the
Philippines: US$1,130, Sri Lanka: US$900 and Bangladesh: Philippines,[6] to work on small to medium-sized vessels often
US$925.[2] Interest on these loans is being charged at rates of for months at a time.[7] Migrant fishermen are known to experience
between 30 and 60 percent p.a. This directly conflicts with the practices that may amount to forced labour such as limited and
laws of Islamic Finance under which Qatar financial institutions delayed payment of wages (for example, some men receive no
have been able to attract ever larger investor contributions wage and instead receive a percentage of that day's catch), forced
from parties seeking to ensure that their money is managed in overtime, poor living conditions and abandonment at sea.[8]
accordance with the strict requirements of the Islamic faith.
Commercial sexual exploitation
Workers who incur debt through their recruitment, many of Data on adult commercial sexual exploitation is scarce due to the
whom are deceived about their true salary and face employers significant social stigma of discussing sex and widespread denial
who are indifferent to their predicament, face substantial pressure of the existence of prostitution in Qatar. Both prostitution and
to continue their employment to service their debt. Between the sex outside of marriage are illegal in Qatar. Anecdotal evidence
recruitment fees, the interest rates and the fact that their wages, suggests some women travelling for employment in the domestic
even when paid in full, are often substantially lower than the level service sector or retail and service industries may be subjected
misrepresented to them when accepting the job, many workers to involuntary prostitution at the hands of traffickers or labour
are completely unable to escape the cycle of debt. brokers. It is also believed women who 'abscond' from formal
Despite substantial international pressure to reform the treatment employment and those without No Objection Certificates (a legal
of migrant construction workers, reports continue to find document issued by a Sponsor to certify he has no objections
workers facing conditions that may amount to those of slavery. to his employee changing Sponsor/moving to another job) may
These include work performed under the threat of penalty or have few options but to turn to operators of the sex trade.
deportation, deprivation of food, inadequate accommodation
with limited or no privacy, physical confinement in the work Forced and early marriage
location/labour camp severely restricting freedom of movement, There is limited information available on forced and early
misrepresentation and substitution of types and terms of work, marriage in Qatar. According to a 2010 government review in
confiscation of identity documents, non-payment, withholding Qatar, 9.3 percent of marriages of Qatari women occur in the
and/or deductions from pay, and unsafe working conditions in 15–19-year-old age category; while 16.6 percent of marriages
extremely high temperatures. of non-Qatari women in Qatar occur in the 15–19-year-old age
category.[9] The circumstances surrounding these early marriages
Domestic workers in Qatar are almost exclusively female, aside are unknown.
from gardeners, drivers, cooks and guards/watchmen who are
almost exclusively male. Traditionally, the majority of female
domestic workers come from the Philippines, Indonesia, Sri
Lanka, India and Nepal. Efforts by sending countries (particularly
the Philippines) to address the low wages paid to domestic
workers is resulting in a growing trend of hiring cheaper maids
from Uganda, Kenya, Ethiopia and other Sub-Saharan African
The population of Qatar has grown at an unprecedented rate; The kafala system, and limited local knowledge of the rights of
between 2004 and 2014, the population has almost tripled.[10] foreign workers creates a starkly unequal platform for victims to
In 2015, 88 percent[11] of Qatar's population of 2,347,000 assert their rights. Worker vulnerability is compounded by their
people[12] were non-Qatari, making Qatar the country with the limited access to mechanisms for legal redress. Generally, workers
largest population proportion of foreigners in the world. [13] filing a court case need to stay in the country for the duration of
This foreign population is predominantly made up of young, the hearing which can take up to one year to be heard. During this
semi- or low-skilled workers who meet the demand for cheap in- time, the worker will likely have no job—which exacerbates debts
house domestic help, as labourers for the booming construction and the inability to provide for dependents—no accommodation
industry and as low-paid workers in roles notoriously rejected and no accepted legal status as the employer is unlikely to agree
by locals. Qatari citizens represent no more than 12 percent of to transfer their sponsorship if they are being sued.
the population; Qatari males constitute only 4.7 percent of the
Women occupy an inferior status in Qatari society which affects
total male workforce and only one percent of the private sector.[14]
a female victim's ability to access justice once exploited.
Qatari leaders continue to hold strong and widespread fears
of migrants gaining power via collective bargaining, asserting
their labour rights, and eventually challenging the balance of
power and control within their borders. Demonstrations, trade
For example, in Qatar, women's
unions and associations dealing with public affairs continue to testimony is worth half of men's,
be banned in Qatar.[15]
so police frequently discount
Terminology on this issue continues to be a cause for concern and women's statements when
heated debate in Qatar. The word 'slavery' is deemed incorrect
when discussing the exploitation of workers in Qatar and can refuted by male employers; and
create great offence to Qatari nationals. In 2007, Qatar's own judges routinely sentence women
National Human Rights Committee (NHRC) published a report
which referred to the existence of modern-day 'slavery practices'
for immorality and adultery
in industries at that time. The backlash from the Qatari public stemming from associated sexual
and business sectors almost caused the government to close the
NHRC completely. It has taken considerable time and effort
abuse claims.
by the NHRC to re-establish a trusted position and distance
Being a woman not only increases vulnerability to being
itself from the terminology/word 'slavery'. Human trafficking
exploited but perpetuates victimisation once trapped.[20]
is acknowledged but largely misunderstood, and forced labour
is equated with poor employment practices rather than human Statelessness is a key risk factor for vulnerability to trafficking,
rights violations. forced labour and forced marriage. The NHRC of Qatar maintains
concerns that Qatari women married to non-Qatari men are
Prevailing attitudes about migrant workers suggest persistent and
subject to discrimination as their children cannot obtain Qatari
deep-seated racism. Media stereotyping of migrant workers as
citizenship, as per article 34 of the Nationality Act for 2005. The
inferior, potential rapists (male workers)[16] and thieves (domestic
Bidoon (also referred to as Bidun), a stateless minority in the
workers)[17] drives discrimination and fear. All-male labour camp
Gulf region, number approximately 1,200–1,500 in Qatar.[21]
accommodation sites for construction workers are located away
Bidoon are only allowed to apply for citizenship after living in
from Qatari residential areas as there is a belief that workers are
the country for 25 consecutive years according to the Nationality
culturally insensitive, with others fearing 'foreign bachelors'
Act for 2005. As only 50 citizenship applicants are accepted
may sexually violate Qatari women and children.[18] In 2015,
each year, most Bidoon remain unable to acquire citizenship.
Doha's Central Municipal Council called on the government to
Furthermore, the government does not register the birth of Bidoon
more strictly enforce a five-year-old ban on blue-collar workers
children.[22] These issues of statelessness must be addressed to
living in neighbourhoods populated by Qatari families.[19] These
reduce vulnerability to modern slavery.
attitudes drive division and inequality.
Despite some reforms to the kafala system in 2015 (not yet in
practice, discussed below), the sponsorship system increases
the dependency of migrant workers on sponsors rendering
them vulnerable to various forms of exploitation and abuse.
The system is also open to abuse, particularly with the creation
of what is termed the 'Loose Market'—a black market trading in
visas for migrant workers which do not correspond to the work
being undertaken by individuals. The process enables Qatari
individuals and businesses to profit from the system's failings
and allows workers to fraudulently enter the country. These
workers are then open to exploitation on the black market due
to their precarious legal status.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
In October 2015, the Emir of Qatar issued Law Number 21 of committed to devising "regulations, including standards and
2015 on the regulation of the entry and exit of expatriates and conditions, to better manage the recruitment and employment of
their residency, thereby amending some aspects of the kafala domestic helpers". Urgent legislative and practical support is
system (expected to enter into force at the end of 2016). The new needed for this highly vulnerable cohort.
law addresses the issue of employees obtaining their sponsor's
Another legislative reform was signed in February 2015, in which
permission to change jobs or travel abroad, instead requiring the
the Emir signed into law a requirement that companies pay their
Ministry of Interior to approve these movements. The Ministry
employees through direct bank transfers to be implemented on
must still obtain the employer's consent for employee movement,
November 2, 2015. It is expected this will make it easier to
but workers will have a right to appeal if permission is denied.
settle disputes about non-payment of wages. Firms that flout the
The new law allows migrant workers to change employers after rules risk penalties of up to one month in prison and a maximum
their contracts expire or after five years of working for one QR6,000 fine.[26]
employer. As the suggested maximum duration of contracts is
In June 2014, at the 26th session of the United Nations Human
five years, and the law will not come into force until the end
Rights Council special dialogue, Qatar announced that it
of 2016, it may be 2022 (the year of the World Cup) before
has adopted the Arab Initiative to Build National Capacities
an employee can change jobs without permission from their
to Combat Human Trafficking in the Arab Countries. The
employer.[23] Some safeguards have been enacted, such as the
Government of Qatar has committed to covering all costs of the
ability of the Ministries of Interior and Labour to transfer work
Arab Initiative, to the amount of US$6 million. This Initiative is
visas in cases of "abuse or for the public good", however, it is
being implemented in partnership with the QFPSR, the United
unclear how accessible these safeguards will be to workers in
Nations Office on Drugs and Crime and the Arab League. The
practice.[24] The new law addresses the black market visa selling
government is making some efforts to engage with international
practice—Article 38 says employers will receive a jail term
trade unions and human rights groups to better understand
of no more than three years and/or a fine up to QR500,000.
and plan long-term interventions against trafficking, but their
Likewise, employers who hire workers without authorisation
response to these issues still lack coordination. As a first step,
may be fined QR12,000.
the government will need to address the pervading perception of
Some international groups have criticised these reforms saying poor labour practices as separate from forced labour.
they "add a new layer of repression for migrant workers and
Positive developments, such as the requirement that companies
leave the kafala modern slavery system intact". [25] These reforms
set up bank accounts for workers and pay wages electronically,
continue to exclude migrant domestic workers, who remain
as well as bans on midday outdoor work, need to be reinforced
insufficiently protected in law and overwhelmingly exposed to
with collective action from employers, police and the judiciary.
abuse. Widespread reluctance to extend the rights of domestic
The increase in routine and surprise raids of manpower agencies,
workers persist, despite reports Qatar has worked on a draft law
including the cancellation of 15 agencies licenses from 2014–
for domestic workers and despite the statement in the National
2015, is an encouraging sign.
Development Strategy wherein the government ostensibly
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government Business
• Create an independent reform commission—labour rights, • Must ensure employers are trained in the new wage
freedom of association, the right to bargain collectively. payment system, and penalise employers for non-
• Amend Article 3 of the Labour Law to ensure domestic compliance with this requirement.
workers, drivers, cooks and gardeners have their labour • Must comply with restrictions on midday work and alert
rights legally protected. authorities about businesses breaching this requirement.
• Establish a minimum wage for domestic workers. • International businesses operating in Qatar must update
• Monitor the non-payment of wages and prosecute offenders the Code of Conduct and contractual provisions to include
to effectively dissuade illegal practices by employers. specific clauses on passport retention and the recruitment
of employees for suppliers and sub-suppliers operating in
• Retract provisions in legislation about absconding and
Qatar.
ensure that victims are not criminalised for fleeing
exploitative situations. • Investigate the recruitment practices of suppliers and sub-
suppliers and work with suppliers to compensate staff that
• Ensure law enforcement actors and the judiciary are
has paid excessive recruitment fees.
adequately trained and sensitised on forced labour practices.
• Ensure suppliers are paying staff to the contracted amount
• Enforce existing laws that facilitate migrant workers'
or national minimum wage, including premiums for
access to redress mechanisms and actively promote these
overtime work.
mechanisms among highly vulnerable populations.
• Work with suppliers to develop corrective action plans
• Provide new individual sponsors with information and/
and recourse for workers found exploited in supply chains.
or training on their legal obligations to safeguard the
wellbeing of migrant workers.
• Amend provisions in the Penal Code about 'illicit
relations' to ensure victims of CSE are not criminalised.
1
GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016 | 137
photo credit, Denis Sinyakov
6
Prevalence Index Rank
RUSSIA
"Ayauly and Bibihul were among 12 migrants from
Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, including three children,
who were held captive for 10 years in a supermarket
after being promised employment in Russia. In
Russia, they were beaten and forced to work without
pay by the couple who owned the supermarket.
Their passports were confiscated by their traffickers
who said they needed the documents to officially
register them as workers with authorities. The
passports were never returned…The couple used
threats of violence, beatings, and sexual violence
to demand subservience."
United States Department of State's Trafficking in Persons
Report 2013.
1,048,500
43.45/100
CC 143,335,000 $25,636
138 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Russia cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 1,048,500 people or Netherlands, Norway, Cyprus, Malta), the Middle East (UAE,
0.73 percent of the total population live in conditions of modern Turkey, Bahrain, Israel, Egypt, Lebanon) and the Far East (China,
slavery in Russia. This is based on a random-sample, nationally- South Korea, Kazakhstan).[11] Foreign women from across the
representative survey undertaken in 2014, that sought to identify globe—Uzbekistan, Ukraine, Belarus, Moldova, Tajikistan,
instances of both forced marriage and forced labour within the Vietnam and various countries in Africa—have been identified
general population (surveys conducted in Russian language). as CSE victims in the Russian sex industry.[12]
Continuing economic decline coupled with ongoing regional the diaspora) to get work permits and registration which often
instability and cross-border migration flows has created new operate outside of formal channels. Once operating outside of
pockets of vulnerability among both Russian citizens and regulated channels, irregular migrants and their families face
migrants. Among Russian citizens, increased unemployment, few opportunities for recourse. Children of irregular migrants
poverty, demands for cheap labour in unregulated markets and thus lack the documentation needed to access education and
a lack of social safety nets creates opportunities for labour social services, exacerbating their likelihood of participation in
exploitation. This is especially true for those residing outside the informal labour force.
the major regional centres with limited employment prospects
Refugees crossing into Russia are often met by a deficient
who are forced to travel for employment.
processing system, leaving asylum seekers without robust
protection systems. The complex asylum process has seen
refugees in recent months continuously crossing borders with
Russia is the second largest little confirmation from the government on if/how asylum
migrant receiving country in the claims will be processed. This lack of assurance and protection
world,[23] with approximately mechanisms places refugees in Russia at risk. As of January
2016, up to 5,500 mainly Syrian refugees who crossed the border
seven million or more said to have from Russia to Norway on bike began being transported back
irregular employment or living to Russia.[29]
status.[24] Negative or indifferent societal attitudes toward immigration
do little to bolster support or promote government action on
Irregular migrants who are willing to engage in high-risk social the issue. Indeed, corrupt law enforcement officials enable
behaviour, including illegal migration and informal work, are trafficking networks to operate, both in situations of forced
susceptible to human trafficking and forced labour into and labour and commercial sexual exploitation.
within Russia. In 2015, economic contraction in Russia slashed migrant job
In some cases, these are not active decisions by migrant opportunities while depreciation of the ruble has reduced the real
groups, but rather attributed to a lack of general education on incomes of migrant workers.[30] This has had serious impacts on
safe migration and deceptive recruitment. Persistent conflict both migrant workers within Russia and their dependent families
in neighbouring Ukraine has entrenched a fertile passage for abroad - remittances to Ukraine declined by 27 percent, to
human traffickers from both countries to flourish. As the second Uzbekistan by 16 percent, Armenia by 11 percent and Tajikistan
poorest country in Europe by GDP,[25] Ukrainian citizens are by 8 percent.[31] Job-poor Tajikistan is the most remittance-
desperately seeking employment, often compromising the need dependent country in the world—the latest figures from 2013
for employment contracts. Although Russia, as an employment reveal 49 percent of their GDP constituted remittances. In 2015,
destination country for Ukrainians, has declined since the 25 percent of Tajik migrant workers in Russia were expected
conflict,[26] it was still within the top five destination choices to return home despite having no job prospects,[32] creating
for Ukrainians in 2015.[27] Some 41 percent of Ukrainian's abroad increasingly dire options. The defection of Tajik special-forces
remained engaged in unofficial work in 2015 compared to 28 commander Colonel Gumurod Khalimov to IS in 2015 resulted
percent in 2011.[28] in him calling on Tajik migrant labourers in Russia to follow
him.[33] IS are known to be offering significant sums of cash to
This reflects patterns among other migrant groups who are willing desperate, unemployed workers in Russia. It remains to be seen
to accept jobs without knowing exactly what work and conditions whether the drop in remittances and economic recession will
they are committing to. Migrant workers in Russia often rely affect the prevalence of modern slavery; this will be essential
on underground networks and intermediaries (generally within to monitor over 2016.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
The Russian Government continues to make few efforts to concerns that this new law will further increase the vulnerability
address the exploitation of their own and foreign citizens. On 1 of workers in already precarious situations by facilitating their
January 2015, a new migration law was implemented requiring dependence on informal verbal agreements with traffickers and
foreign workers from countries outside the Eurasian economic illegal brokers to secure visas and jobs in the informal market.
union to pass Russian language and history tests, acquire
In June 2015, a new law on 'undesirable foreign organisations'
expensive permits and pay steep monthly fees.[34] Furthermore,
came into force, authorising the extrajudicial banning of foreign
Tajik citizens who could previously travel in Russia using
or international groups which allegedly undermine Russia's
national identity cards will now have to produce an international
security, defence, or constitutional order. [38] This follows
passport[35] and many face a re-entry ban.[36] For those Tajik
enactment of the 2012 Law on Foreign Agents which demanded
workers already in the country, this change of law gives workers
that many Russian civil society organisations register as 'foreign
neither the right to remain nor the right to leave.[37] There are
agents' if they engaged in political activities and accepted foreign and increasing their vulnerability to slave-like practices.[44]
funds. Amendments to the law in June 2014, which gave the Outsourcing now has strict provisions, including limitations on
Justice Ministry power to brand groups as 'foreign agents' without the duration people may be employed as out-staffers, equal pay
their consent, made the operation of many NGOs in Russia even to permanent workers in the same position and compensation
more complicated and precarious.[39] These developments have for hazardous work.
made the operation of NGOs combating modern slavery and
working with victims difficult. No NGO in Russia is currently
devoted purely to anti-slavery efforts and no NGO working In 2015, a shelter for victims of
with victims of forced marriage exists. Government-funded care
remains unavailable to victims of trafficking.[40]
modern slavery was not identified
nor was a national coordinator on
Russia continues to lack a dedicated human trafficking law;
however, modifications to the Russian Criminal Code, namely trafficking in human beings. The
Articles 127.1 and 127.2, prohibit human trafficking and the use government has failed to develop
of slave labour. Articles 240 and 241 address the inducement to
and organisation of prostitution, and are often used to prosecute a national referral mechanism that
offences.[41] A pending human trafficking law has yet to be passed. would allow formerly-enslaved
There were several legislative developments in 2015. In July 2015, persons to receive adequate
new amendments to the Administrative Code and the Federal Law medical, social, judicial and other
on the Legal Status of Foreign Citizens in the Russian Federation
entered into force.[42] These amendments now allow authorities types of assistance after being
to deport migrant workers if they work in a profession that is discovered by law enforcement.
not indicated in their patent (work visa) and fine the employers
for hiring such workers. Employees' visas will not be tied to The Federal Law on Government Protection of Victims, Witnesses
their Russian employer and workers will be able to change the and other Participants of Criminal Proceedings provides for the
profession listed in their patent in some cases.[43] A draft article protection of "victims, witnesses and other participants in criminal
10.13 for the new Administrative Code expected to be adopted court proceedings", but the protection is only offered on a case-
in 2016 requires the government to shut down the activity of a by-case basis, and the programme suffers from a lack of funding.
legal entity if it created conditions for trafficking in minors and There do not seem to be protocols in place to ensure that victims
child pornography. Elena Mizulina, a Senator, also planned an of trafficking are not prosecuted for crimes committed as a result
amendment to the Criminal Code, article 127.1 Trafficking in of being trafficked. Migrant victims are not offered reflection
Human Beings, prohibiting commercial surrogate motherhood. periods or residence permits, however, if a victim cooperates with
A new amendment to the Labor Code, Tax Code and Federal Law law enforcement, he/she may be granted temporary residence,
on Employment limiting out-staffing (employment agency work) security and legal aid, but these agreements are informal and
came into force on 1 January 2016. Out-staffing is work that decisions are made on a case-by-case basis. Therefore, aside
an employee fulfils at his/her employer's instruction, but for an from established deportation procedures for migrants who have
individual or legal entity, not his/her boss. Employment agencies been found in violation of immigration law,[45] Russia continues
were able to 'rent out' an employee to any enterprise, leaving to rely on international organisations to safely repatriate victims
them with fewer labour rights, creating loopholes for trafficking to their country of origin or social reintegration in Russia.[46]
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government • P
ublically report statistics on the number of identified
• Draft and approve a comprehensive law on human victims, prosecutions and court outcomes related to
trafficking, using international definitions. modern slavery.
• Train law enforcement personnel on human trafficking, • E
nsure that forced labour and human trafficking are
with a particular focus on attitudinal change. prevented in the construction of FIFA sites in Russia and
during the games themselves.
• Criminalise the possession of child pornography.
• Sign and ratify the Council of Europe Convention on Business
Action against Trafficking in Human Beings, and other • Develop a National Action Plan on Business and Human
international treaties and conventions. Rights.
• Establish a national referral mechanism for identification • Ensure that migrant workers have legal documentation to
of human trafficking victims. work in Russia.
• Provide the financial and human resources to strengthen • Ensure that migrant workers have full access to their
the capacity for the Labour Inspectorate to conduct identity documents, safe accommodation and receive
rigorous onsite inspections. a fair and full payment. In cases of non-compliance,
• Allocate funding for the creation of shelters and other companies must work with suppliers to compensate
outreach centres that can assist in identifying and referring workers, including payment of overtime allowance.
victims and providing them with direct services.
SOUTH AFRICA
"There is, however, no sector and no region that is
not affected. We have seen fishermen from the Far
East arrive in Cape Town after years at sea without
breaks or remuneration. We have seen girls come
in to work as waitresses but end up in prostitution,
and little boys as young as seven years being
trafficked from West Africa to South Africa, having
been told that they will become famous soccer
players here."
Richard Ots, Chief of Mission for IOM South Africa,
9 October 2015.[1]
248,700
45.87/100
B 54,954,000 $13,046
142 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
South Africa cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 248,700 people or Walk Free survey results revealed an estimated 11 percent of
0.45 percent of the total population live in conditions of modern victims are exploited in construction, five percent in farming, and
slavery in South Africa. This is based on a random-sample, eight percent in drug production. This reflects existing research
nationally-representative survey undertaken in 2015, that sought which notes that foreign and domestic modern slavery victims
to identify instances of both forced marriage and forced labour have been exploited in agriculture,[14] mining,[15] construction,
within the general population (survey conducted in Afrikaans, street work and hospitality industries.[16]
English, Sotho, Zulu, Xhosa languages).
Child labour
Commercial sexual exploitation Though the Basic Conditions of Employment Act sets the minimum
Forty-three percent of victims in modern slavery in South Africa age for employment at 15 years,[17] young children labouring in
identified in the 2015 Walk Free survey were/are subjected to the agricultural and domestic service sectors persists, as well as
commercial sexual exploitation. Though the purchasing of sex in food services, street vending and forced begging.[18] Children
is criminalised,[2] the sex industry thrives on the street and in in South Africa are trafficked from rural to urban areas, including
brothels and private residences. South African women, women to Bloemfontein, Cape Town, Durban and Johannesburg.[19]
from neighbouring states and Thai, Chinese, Russian and
Brazilian women have been identified as victims of commercial
sexual exploitation in South Africa.[3] South African women Walk Free Foundation 2015 survey data
have also been trafficked abroad, predominantly to Europe. [4]
Throughout 2015, the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation % male % female
Number % victims victims
(DPCI), known as the Hawks, continued to identify Nigerian
sex trafficking syndicates operating between the North West, Forced labour 238,000 96 46 54
Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal provinces.[5]
Forced
Forced marriage 10,600 4 0 100
marriage
Walk Free survey results reveal an estimated 10,600 women
Modern
are victims of forced marriage. Although UNICEF data from slavery total
248,700 100 44 56
2015 reveals that South Africa has one of the lowest rates of
child marriage in Sub-Saharan Africa,[6] the persistence of some
traditional practices have been noted by academics as fuelling
early and forced marriages. Ukuthwala, meaning 'to carry' in Forced labour by sector of exploitation %
isiXhosa and isiZulu, is a customary practice used to bypass
extensive and lengthy marriage rituals.[7] It often involves the Domestic work 4
kidnapping and rape of a girl or young woman by a man or Construction 11
group of men with the intention of compelling the girl or young
Manufacturing 0
woman's family to endorse marriage negotiations.[8] Traditionally,
ukuthwala was an accepted path to marriage, however, it did not Other manufacturing 6
involve rape or consensual sex until the marriage negotiations Farming 5
concluded. Today, girls as young as 12 are abducted and raped,
Sex industry 43
often by significantly older men, and routinely exposed to HIV/
AIDS transmission. One study on HIV/AIDS-positive young Drug production 8
girls aged 12–19 found 56 percent were forcibly married through Retail sector 4
ukuthwala.[9] The financial burden of daughters, coupled with
the continuing tradition of grooms providing a lobola payment Other 19
(dowry), reportedly incentivises some parents to force their DK 0
daughters into early marriage. The continued existence of Refused 0
ukuthwala, coupled with Walk Free estimates of more than
10,000 victims of forced marriage, necessitates further studies Total 100
of marriage practices in South Africa.
Forced labour
The Walk Free Foundation survey suggests that more than
200,000 workers are subject to forced labour in South Africa.
Both women and children are employed as domestic workers
in South Africa. The legacy of apartheid, leaving many African
and coloured women without education, has created a labour
pool of unskilled workers who are funnelled into low-paying
domestic work.[10] Economic necessity is the key driver of
women accepting work in the domestic service sector.[11] On 1
December 2015, new minimum wage rates came into effect for
domestic workers,[12] however, critics have slammed the rise for
not ensuring a living wage.[13] Domestic workers in South Africa
have reported withholding of wages and unpaid overtime, and
physical, sexual and psychological abuse.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
On 9 August 2015, President Zuma officially proclaimed entry concerning the protection of and services to foreign victims have
into force of the Prevention and Combating of Trafficking in not yet become operational.[48]
Persons Act (7/2013).[44] This Act rectifies significant previous
The enactment of this legislation will arguably provide clearer
gaps in legislation that largely prevented prosecutors bringing
data on the prevalence of modern slavery, particularly efforts
forward cases of trafficking for forced labour,[45] provides for
to prosecute and punishment perpetrators. Until August 2015,
the payment of compensation to victims[46] and requires internet
cases of trafficking have been brought under other acts, such as
service providers to take all reasonable steps to prevent and
the Sexual Offences Amendment Act or the Children's Amendment
report trafficking.[47] Chapter 3 of the Act attaches positive duties
Act, where traffickers were charged for trafficking in persons, but
on the State to provide support to foreign victims including a rest
were often also charged with kidnapping and rape.[49] This creates
and recovery period and accompanying visitor's visa. Though
what one expert has dubbed "an elusive statistical nightmare" for
it is important to note that, at the time of writing, the sections
understanding the extent of modern slavery in South Africa,[50]
a situation exacerbated by the continuing lack of an official travelling with only one parent or unaccompanied, an affidavit
government database on modern slavery. Under section 42 of providing consent must also be carried. While admirable in its
the new Act, Ministries responsible for combating trafficking attempts to address the ongoing exploitation of children, experts
are required to submit annual reports on the implementation have questioned whether such onerous requirements will curb
of the Act.[51] trafficking considering the frequently illegal and clandestine
border movements that traffickers use and the inability of
As of January 2016, no cases had been tried under the new
immigration guards to verify the authenticity of birth certificates
trafficking act. However, some recent prominent cases indicate
at borders.[57] However, one expert noted that in the week
the government are making concerted efforts to prosecute
preceding the implementation of the regulations, immigration
offenders of modern slavery.
authorities discovered three incidences of children travelling
abroad in suspicious circumstances. One of these cases involved
authorities preventing the travel of a 7-year-old girl to Pakistan to
In 2015, the government visit her father - authorities subsequently established the girl had
welcomed the Western Cape High no father in Pakistan and was a victim of child sexual abuse.[58]
Court's rejection of an appeal International and local organisations working with victims
by Mvumeleni Jezile (aged 33) continued to express concerns of victims being criminalised for
illegal conduct, such as prostitution, instead of being identified
who was sentenced to 22 years as victims of trafficking.[59] Studies have also highlighted the
imprisonment after forcibly unwillingness of women to turn to the police for support because
of stigmatisation and fear that police would inform others in the
marrying a 14-year-old girl.[52] community about the victim's involvement in the sex industry.[60]
There are also concerns that victims and authorities alike are
This high-profile ukuthwala case was used as evidence by unable to correctly identify victims despite ongoing awareness
the Minister in the Presidency responsible for Women, Susan programs and training being conducted throughout 2015.[61] Local
Shabangu, that the government is continuing endeavours to groups are concerned that there is no formal strategy to address the
ensure the rights of women, emphasising that cultural practices abuse, both physical and sexual, of sex workers by authorities.[62]
must not violate rights and reminding perpetrators that time
will not erase crimes committed.[53] This followed the well- During 2015, key government and civil society stakeholders met
documented 2014 conviction of 62-year-old businessman to improve the coordination and integration of services to better
Nyambi Mabuza who was handed down eight life sentences support victims of trafficking.[63] The multi-sectoral national task
for the trafficking of Mozambican girls, between the ages of team, comprised of the Departments of Justice and Constitutional
11 and 17 for sexual exploitation. [54] Despite these positive Development, Home Affairs and Social Development, as well as
developments, to date, none of the international syndicates the National Prosecuting Authority, South African Police Service,
facilitating the commercial sexual exploitation of women have civil society representatives and international organisations,
been successfully prosecuted.[55] are tasked with implementing the National Action Plan to Fight
Human Trafficking in South Africa. The Child Protection and
Also in 2015, in an effort to curb illegal movement of children International Social Services directorates in the Department of
across borders, the government enacted new immigration Social Development continue to implement a strategy for the
regulations requiring all minors under the age of 18 years to prevention of child trafficking. The Child Protection Directorate
produce, in addition to their passport, an Unabridged Birth also ensures the safe return of South African child victims and
Certificate (showing the particulars of both parents) when unaccompanied South African minors to their families and legal
exiting and entering South African ports of entry.[56] For children guardians in South Africa.[64]
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government
• Implement a wide-scale awareness campaign to educate • C
onsult with NGOs and victims to ensure policies and
South Africans about the new Prevention and Combating services match the needs of victims.
of Trafficking in Persons Act. • R
eview and increase the minimum wage rate for domestic
• Establish a national database on modern slavery cases workers to ensure a living wage.
and convictions. • I nvestigate, prosecute and imprison members of known
• Initiate a comprehensive counter-corruption strategy. criminal syndicates sexually exploiting and trafficking
• Conduct targeted educational programs in schools and people for commercial gain, especially young women
rural communities about the dangers of ukuthwala and and children.
the physical and psychological damage caused by early
marriage.
20
Prevalence Index Rank
THAILAND
"Every morning at 2 a.m., they heard a kick on the
door and a threat: Get up or get beaten. For the
next 16 hours, No. 31 and his wife stood in the
factory that owned them with their aching hands
in ice water."
Excerpt from an interview conducted by the Associated
Press with victims of forced labour in Thailand in
December, 2015.[1]
425,500
47.54/100
B 67,959,000 $15,735
146 | GLOBAL SLAVERY INDEX 2016
Thailand cont.
PREVALENCE
The 2016 Global Slavery Index estimates 425,500 people or documents, all of which render the victims' ability to escape
0.63 percent of the total population live in conditions of modern from their exploitation much more difficult, or impossible.[15]
slavery in Thailand.
Commercial sexual exploitation
Forced labour Thailand's sex industry is reported to be a site for the commercial
Human trafficking for forced labour in the Thai fishing industry sexual exploitation of children, both boys and girls. The profile
(on both the seafaring and processing sides) enslaves men, of CSE victims is difficult to define—older teenage girls (15–
children and women from the Greater Mekong Subregion 17) and young women are commonly found in entertainment
(GMS).[2] In the US$7 billion industry,[3] seafaring labourers, hotspots, bars and hotels. On the streets, the age of victims
often young men and boys, endure brutal treatment that includes tends to be younger (under 17) with many children performing
severe and frequent physical abuse and threats thereof, excessive survival sex and a higher prevalence of young boys available to
and inhumane working hours, sleep and food deprivation, forced service the demands of male tourists.[16] They experience greater
use of methamphetamines, and long trips at sea confined to the transmission rates of sexually-transmitted infections (including
vessel.[4] Thailand's fishing industry is reliant on trans-shipments HIV/AIDS) often as a result of being forced to provide sexual
at sea to reduce expenditure on fuel and sustain constant fishing[5] services to clients without condom use.[17]
meaning that some long-haul trawlers and the fishermen remain
Victims from Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar and Vietnam have been
at sea for years at a time. Traumatised victims have reported
identified in Thailand while some victims from Bangladesh,
witnessing the vessels' captains excessively and violently abusing
Pakistan, Vietnam, North Korea and China transit through
and murdering other workers, and captains abandoning overboard
Thailand on route to Indonesia, the United States, Western
workers at sea.[6] Due to overfishing in the Gulf of Thailand and
Europe, Singapore and Russia.[18] Of the 595 victims of human
Andaman Sea, fishing vessels are forced to operate far from shore,
trafficking identified by the government in 2014, 222 were
sometimes travelling along the coastlines of Indonesia and other
victims of commercial sexual exploitation, most of whom were
neighbouring countries. Both jurisdictionally and practically,
girls from Laos and Thailand.[19] However, these statistics refer
this makes monitoring costly and difficult. This situation is
only to those victims formally identified by the government.
exacerbated by poor registration and licencing of fishing vessels
in which many operate under layers of false documentation.[7] Child soldiers
Exploitation in seafood pre-processing facilities is also evident, Armed violence, attacks against civilians and conflict between
with reports of men, women and children from Myanmar, local armed groups and the government continues to plague
Cambodia and Laos working excessive hours in oppressive and the southern border of Thailand.[20] Children are recruited into
abusive conditions. non-state armed groups where they are trained to be lookouts,
informers and/or combatants.[21] Little comprehensive research
Skilled Thai migrants move toward stronger economies, such
exists on the scale of involvement of children in armed groups
as those in the United States, Europe, Israel, East Asia and
in Thailand. However, a 2015 Child Soldiers International study
Australia. Official numbers from the Ministry of Labour's
found children as young as 14 participated in hostilities. [22]
Office for Thai Workers Going Overseas recorded 143,101 Thai
Children allegedly associated with armed groups continue to
citizens moving abroad for work in 2012;[8] however, others
face administrative detention[23] contrary to their need for shelter
also migrate via irregular channels.[9] The vast majority (around
and rehabilitation.
84 percent) of overseas Thai workers are men, working in the
construction, agricultural and manufacturing industries.[10]
Thai migrant workers supply the majority of labour for Israel's
agriculture. In 2015, serious labour abuses against the workforce
were uncovered including excessive work hours (sometimes up
to 17 hours/day), low wages, inadequate and unsanitary living
conditions and exposure to harmful pesticides with unsatisfactory
safety equipment.[11]
Women overseas-workers tend to find employment in private
households or the entertainment or service sectors such as
restaurants.[12] According to World Bank data, approximately
US$5.69 billion in personal remittances made up around 1.47
percent of Thailand's US$387 billion Gross Domestic Product
in 2013.[13] Thai migrants often must pay significant fees for the
migration and recruitment processes (sometimes up to a year's
wages) and they are vulnerable to exploitation by recruiters and/or
employers; in places where it is available, assistance for exploited
workers can be difficult to access in unfamiliar settings.[14]
Domestic workers are predominantly females from rural Thailand
(including ethnic minorities), Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar,
some of whom are the children of migrants working formally and
informally in Thailand. Victims often report that their employers
physically and sexually abuse them, confine them within the
home, withhold their pay and withhold their identification
Throughout 2014–2015, Rohingya refugees undertook dangerous and often fatal sea and land journeys across the
Bay of Bengal, the Andaman Sea and the Myanmar/Thai border in pursuit of a better life. Many of these cases were
situations of people smuggling, where a sum was paid in exchange for transportation. However, for some refugees,
their smugglers intended to exploit them upon arrival or deliver them to someone who would. Some Rohingya are held
at camps where they are held for ransom—those unable to pay are often physically abused, sold into forced labour,
often in the fishing sector (men), or forced to marry to secure their release (women).
In May 2015, Thai authorities discovered abandoned people smuggling camps on the Thai/Malaysia border with the
remains of Rohingya people who had died through starvation, disease and violence at the hands of smugglers and
traffickers. There is concerning evidence of official complicity in the trade and exploitation of Rohingya—one of the
mass grave sites was located in an open field behind the police station in Padang Besar, some 500 metres from the
official border crossing manned by officials from Thailand and Malaysia. Several arrests of officials have been made
for alleged smuggling and trafficking, including the arrest of Army Lt. Gen. Manas Kongpan together with local
politicians, community leaders, businessmen and gangsters.[25]
Thailand has been reluctant to provide assistance to Rohingya refugees, including preventing boats carrying Rohingya
from landing in Thailand.[26] Throughout 2015, Thailand attended international meetings to address this issue and
reported they would not "push back migrants stranded in Thai waters".[27] In March 2016, 92 alleged human traffickers
and smugglers went on trial for their involvement in the discovered Rohingya death camps. [28]
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, &
Country protections economic rights Personal security Refugees & conflict Mean
Over the past decade, significant structural differences in labouring under the threat of deportation. Extortion of money
population demographics and economic development between is common—employers demand money for work permits and
Thailand and neighbouring countries have transformed the police officers fine workers who are caught outside their district.
available workforce.[29] As an increasingly well-educated Thai Workers are also unable to send their children to school.[36]
population shun poorly-paid work in unglamorous sectors— The Social Security Fund, which provides social protection to
predominantly in fishing, construction, agriculture, domestic migrant workers and their families, does not extend to workers
services and small manufacturing businesses[30]—migrant workers in the informal sector or on fishing boats.[37] For those trapped
play a critical role in filling these labour shortages.[31] Workers, in situations of modern slavery, the risk of fines, arrest and
particularly from neighbouring Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar, deportation, coupled with language barriers, prevents victims
who often use irregular channels of migration into Thailand, are coming forward.
particularly vulnerable to exploitation. Employment brokers on
The risk of arrest and deportation is also high for refugees and
both sides of the border—even through the legal immigration
asylum seekers in Thailand, many of whom are vulnerable to
process—can knowingly or unwittingly place migrants in the
trafficking and forced labour. Thailand is not a party to the 1951
hands of exploitative employers.[32]
Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol, meaning many
Migrant workers in Thailand may migrate through MoU asylum seekers are treated by Thai authorities as illegal migrants.
procedures (signed in 2002/2003 with Cambodia, Laos and As at June 2015, 625,256 people were registered with UNHCR,
Myanmar), the national verification process (NV) or at One Stop which includes 110,372 refugees, 8,166 asylum seekers and
Service Centres (OSSCs) established in 2014.[33] Despite these 506,197 stateless people.[38]
efforts to provide options for regular migration and regularisation,
Thailand has one of the largest stateless populations of any
in 2015, the International Labour Organisation maintained
country. There are as many as 450,000 Hill Tribe ethnic people in
concerns for an unknown but presumably a considerable number
Northern Thailand that remain without citizenship despite being
of workers with irregular status.[34] Many migrant workers are
born in the country, being legally eligible for Thai citizenship
not provided with a visa, but a stay of deportation, allowing
and waiting for their applications to be approved for several
them to work for one employer in one district for a year at a time
years. Hill Tribe people face some hurdles in their application
before expulsion from the country.[35] This system heightens the
for citizenship: navigating a complex bureaucracy in a language
vulnerability to exploitation by creating a compliant workforce
they do not speak, living in remote areas with limited access to
the required administrative offices and/or relying on misinformed These groups can experience high poverty, pressure to support
government officials that have little political incentive to approve their family, face xenophobic and discriminatory attitudes from
the applications. Even if Hill Tribe people know their legal rights Thais, lack community support and have limited or no access
and recognise the importance, it can take up to 10 years for their to health care or schooling, which has further implications for
citizenship applications to be approved.[39] future employment and livelihood opportunities.[41]
The lack of citizenship rights for Hill Tribe minorities makes Police complicity in human trafficking crimes continued to be
them particularly vulnerable to abuse and exploitation. They are reported in 2015. Thailand's most senior police investigator
much more likely to migrate for economic reasons, including into human trafficking fled to Australia to seek political asylum,
paying a middleman. They also lack the legal documentation fearing for his life after he uncovered complicity of influential
to take out formal loans, increasing the likelihood of taking figures in the Thai Government, military and police.[42] NGOs
informal loans for financial emergencies, making them more reported official corruption is a significant barrier to justice for
vulnerable to debt bondage. Furthermore, and because of their victims, including preventing victims from testifying in cases
undocumented status, Hill Tribe minorities are also much less due to their mistrust of police.[43] The presence of police in
likely to call the police if they believe they have been subjected commercial sexual establishments, as either clients or complicit
to criminal exploitation, allowing perpetrators to abuse or in accepting bribes, fuelled a perception of police corruption.
exploit ethnic minorities with little fear of actually being held This is similarly noted in the fishing industry where the business
accountable for their crimes, so there continues to be a culture interests of some public officials conflict with formal duties.
of impunity when it comes to trafficking in persons.[40]
As Thai nationals seek higher-paid employment opportunities
Migrant, Hill Tribe, refugee, stateless, and street working abroad, some are falling victim to forced labour and CSE abroad.
children are particularly vulnerable to CSE and forced begging. Victims have been identified globally.
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
Examining the Thai response to combating modern slavery must creation of the Command Centre for Combating Illegal Fishing
be considered in light of the new government led by the National in May 2015 to address IUU fishing.[50] Since the Centre was
Council for Peace and Order (NCPO) who took control of the established, the Deputy National Police Chief reported the
government in a coup d'état in May 2014. On 31 March 2015, investigation of 36 cases, arrests of 102 suspects, and rescue
nationwide enforcement of the Martial Law Act of 1914 was of 130 presumed trafficking victims.[51] The first major reform
replaced with section 44 of the interim Constitution, providing of fishing legislation in over 50 years—the Royal Ordinance on
unlimited administrative, legislative and judiciary powers to Fisheries B.E. 2558 2015—came into force on 15 November
Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha in his capacity as the NCPO 2015 with the objective of eliminating illegal fishing and
chairman without any oversight or accountability.[44] The interim promoting sustainable fishing. The law is being implemented
constitution also absolves anyone carrying out actions on behalf by 28 port-in-port-out (PiPo) Centres and officers from the
of the NCPO of all legal liability.[45] In September 2015, a Department of Fisheries, Ministry of Labour, Marine Department
247-person commission rejected a draft constitution prepared and Mobile Team Units. To promote understanding of these
by the Constitution Drafting Committee, extending military rule major legal changes, a 'fishermen's' legal handbook has been
under the interim document until 2017.[46] These developments published.[52] Though these legal reforms were long overdue,
point to a worrying trend of the government being principally the lack of consultation with workers' organisations and industry
concerned with consolidating its power though experts suggest associations was a missed opportunity, with some concerns the
they will combat trafficking to the extent it assists the country's suspension of unlicensed vessels will force Thai boat owners into
economic interests.[47] other illegal activities.[53] For the migrant fishermen themselves,
despite the creation of the One Stop Service Centre for the
registration of migrant workers,[54] organisations reported in
Throughout 2015, the Thai 2015 that the hoped-for large-scale registration and regularisation
had not occurred. Almost all workers in the Thai fishing sector
Government faced unprecedented remain unregistered.[55]
pressure to tackle forced labour
Thailand took new steps to combat the CSE of children,
in the fishing sector. In April 2015, particularly their abuse for pornography. In May 2015, the
the European Commission put National Legislative Assembly of Thailand voted unanimously
to amend The Criminal Code of Thailand to criminalise child
Thailand on formal notice for not pornography.[56] This brings Thailand's legislation in line with the
taking sufficient measures to Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on
the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography.[57]
combat illegal, unreported and The Bill prescribes punishment of up to five years' imprisonment
unregulated fishing (IUU)[48] under for mere possession of child pornography, up to seven years for
threat of a trade ban which could distribution, and up to 10 years for production and trade. The
government also made efforts to prosecute some perpetrators
see Thailand lose up to US$1.4m a of CSE of children—in June 2015, following extensive
year in seafood exports.[49] investigations, Pra Chai, a Buddhist monk and leader of a
trafficking ring, was sentenced to 124 years in prison for his
The government have reportedly accelerated their efforts to involvement in the human trafficking and sexual exploitation of
combat exploitation and avoid trade sanctions, including the teenage boys. This was the sixth conviction of a Buddhist monk
for involvement in a trafficking ring since 2014.[58]
Also in 2015, the government approved a change in the Thai While Thailand's Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act is a comprehensive
Nationality Act to allow citizenship applications to be approved at piece of legislation, implementation and enforcement were
the district and provincial levels, a move which will significantly skewed toward certain sectors in 2015. Despite the rhetoric
increase the efficiency and speed at which these are processed. of the National Policy Strategies and Measures to Prevent and
Before this change, the law required that all citizenship Suppress Trafficking in Persons (2011–2016), the government's
applications be submitted and approved at the district, provincial efforts remain disconnected to the reality of exploitation on the
and national levels by several committees and subcommittees. ground. The majority of the RTG's efforts focus on addressing
One international organisation reported 426 of their clients had the sexual exploitation of women and children, with limited focus
their pending citizenship applications approved shortly after the on exploitation of workers in the construction and agricultural
government enacted this change.[59] This is a positive first step sectors, particularly in southern Thailand, and in the domestic
in addressing the vulnerabilities of a significantly large sector service sector.
of the Thai population.
The Ministry of Social Development and Human Security
In addition to the significant legislative improvements over the (MSDHS) is responsible for the provision of assistance and
past year, in August 2015 Thailand established a new court in protection to victims of trafficking and throughout 2015
the special division of the Criminal Court devoted solely to continued to operate shelters and provide rehabilitative support.
trying human trafficking cases.[60] A second special court was Despite this, these services lack specialisation; some victims are
created to hear cases related to corruption and misbehaviour by prevented from leaving, and victims are unable to work. Many of
government officials.[61] The challenge for the Thai Government the support services provided to child victims of trafficking for
is now effectively implementing these legislative changes and sexual purposes come from INGOs and NGOs in the country.[62]
using the courts.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government Business
• Improve victim identification and protection. • Businesses importing Thai seafood products conduct
• Make far more effective use of the 2003 MoU with in-depth supply chain mapping exercise, including
Myanmar on Migrant Workers for the safe migration subcontractors multiple tiers deep, to identify product origin.
of migrants from Myanmar, and grant these workers • Conduct social audits on suppliers identified as high risk,
employment-based visas that allow the workers to change ensuring interviews with migrant workers are conducted
employers without losing legal status and having to obtain in a safe environment, and that workers voices are sought
their first employer's permission. in feedback processes.
• Record and report all cases of modern slavery in a • Work with suppliers to develop corrective action plans
single national database, including details on the arrest, and recourse for workers found exploited in supply chains.
prosecution and conviction of offenders, disaggregated by This may include systems to pay back workers held in
age, sex and type of exploitation.[63] debt bondage and compensating underpaid workers.
• Investigate and prosecute modern slavery cases
particularly those involving labour exploitation and/or
complicity of law enforcement officials, justice officials,
monks, and teachers.
• Reform labour laws to allow migrant workers the right to
create or join an existing union.
• Create supply chain transparency laws to ensure the
labour practices are aligned with international standards.
• Criminalise the recruitment and use of children in state
or non-state armed forces
• Ratify the 1951 Refugee Convention and work with
UNHCR to deliver services to asylum seekers
UNITED KINGDOM
"Salah, an orphan, was 12 when she was brought to the UK on a 'holiday' from West Africa. Within days
of arriving, she was forced into domestic slavery. Given only leftovers to eat, Salah quietly cried herself
to sleep on the floor every night. If she made a noise, she was kicked and beaten. In the daytime, her
captors invited men to the house to rape her for money. When she finally managed to escape, Salah
was forced to sleep on the streets for months before she finally found a safe place to stay. Neither the
people that trafficked Salah to the UK nor the family that abused her for years were punished for what
they did. Salah is supported via ECPAT UK's London-based peer support group for trafficked girls.
She is still traumatised by her experience but is determined to rebuild her life."
ECPAT UK
11,700
26.79/100
PREVALENCE
The UK is a destination for men and women from Central and cleaning, nannies and taxi drivers. These cases are incredibly
Eastern Europe, Asia, Africa and the Middle East often seeking diverse, impacting men, women and children.
better livelihood opportunities. In 2014, research was carried out
Significant numbers of domestic workers are brought to the UK
in the context of the UK Government's Modern Slavery Strategy
each year, including an unknown number who travel into and
to estimate the scale of enslaved people living in the UK. The
out of the UK with the families they are working for in other
Home Office estimated as many as 10,000–13,000 potential
countries.[9] In 2014, 16,753 individuals entered the UK on the
victims of modern slavery in the UK, an estimate reflected in
Overseas Domestic Worker visa.[10]
the 2016 Global Slavery Index.[1]
In the UK, migrant domestic workers are tied to their employer
Cases of modern slavery have been uncovered in diverse sectors
by the immigration rules, increasing their vulnerability to
and locations—from Vietnamese children locked into Manchester
exploitative practices by dissuading workers to come forward
flats to grow cannabis to Albanian women and girls sexually
and risk deportation. Kalayaan, a UK-based NGO for migrant
exploited in the London sex industry, and to the hundreds of
domestic workers, found that, in a 2015 study of their domestic
men working low or semi-skilled jobs trapped in situations of
worker clients, the treatment of migrant workers differed
debt bondage.[2] The National Crime Agency estimates 3,309
between those on tied and untied visas—68 percent of those
potential victims of human trafficking came into contact with
on tied visas experienced restrictions on freedom of movement
the State or an NGO in 2014.[3] The latest government statistics
compared with 38 percent who were not tied, 70 percent worked
derived from the UK National Referral Mechanism in 2014
excessive hours compared with 49 percent who were not tied, 38
reveal 2,340 potential victims of trafficking from 96 countries
percent were not paid compared with 14 percent who were not
of origin, of whom 61 percent were female and 29 percent were
tied,[11] and 66 percent of workers had their passports withheld
children.[4] Of those identified through the NRM, the majority
compared with 54 percent who were not tied. Although all
were adults classified as victims of sexual exploitation followed
figures demonstrate high levels of exploitative treatment from
by adults exploited in the domestic service sector and other
employers,the consistently higher rates of abuse experienced
types of labour exploitation.[5] The largest proportion of victims
by those on tied visas indicate an urgent need to review the
was from Albania, followed by Nigeria, Vietnam, Romania and
current system.
Slovakia. The 6th highest group of victims by country of origin
were UK nationals.[6] These statistics do not reflect the unknown Forced marriage
number of victims who refuse to enter the NRM or are unable
to escape their situation of exploitation. Concerns have been The most recent data from the Forced Marriage Unit (FMU), a
consistently raised about the numbers of trafficked children joint Foreign and Commonwealth Office and Home Office Unit,
going missing from local authority care and being re-trafficked.[7] revealed 1,267 individuals were provided advice or support
on forced marriage in 2014.[12] Of this cohort, 79 percent were
Forced labour female, more than 10 percent involved victims with disabilities
and 11 percent involved victims under the age of 16.[13] In
As noted in the government's 2015 review of modern slavery,
23 percent of the cases handled by the FMU, there were no
labour exploitation amounting to modern slavery has been found
overseas elements. Of the 77 percent of cases with an overseas
across multiple sectors, including, but not limited to, factories,
element, 88 different countries were identified, with the largest
agricultural and construction sections, car washes, nail bars,
proportion involving Pakistan (38.3 percent), India (7.8 percent)
restaurants and bars, the tarmac and paving industry, and the
and Bangladesh (7.1 percent). Considering that some victims are
maritime sector.[8] Some victims have been identified in the scrap
supported by specialist independent NGO services or by local
metal and recycling industry, chicken catching, selling DVDs,
police,[14] it is likely there is an even larger total figure.
VULNERABILITY
Civil & political Social, health, &
Country protections economic rights Personal security Refugees & conflict Mean
Domestic trafficking remains a serious threat in the UK, The restrictions imposed by the Overseas Domestic Worker
particularly the grooming of teenage girls for commercial sexual visa in April 2012 are reportedly linked to vulnerability. This
exploitation.[15] Despite this, the majority of modern slavery tied visa, valid for six months, is not renewable and prevents
victims identified in the UK are men, women and children domestic workers changing their employer, regardless of their
from abroad.[16] The past two decades has brought a significant circumstances. In effect, it means domestic workers cannot
number of migrants and job seekers, vulnerable to accepting legally remain in the UK if they leave their employers—easily
low-paid, low-skilled work, which may be exploited at the allowing employers to use the threat of the involvement of the
hand of traffickers, gangmasters or opportunistic employers. immigration authorities to coerce workers. Although not in
Despite an increased and widespread awareness of the existence and of itself responsible for modern slavery, this dependency
of modern slavery, too few potential victims or perpetrators of on the employer reduces the willingness of domestic workers
modern slavery are identified.[17] Once within the UK, the diverse to challenge any mistreatment or report abuse to the police.
sectors victims are found in, including those on geographically- This is because it will likely result in the termination of their
remote farms or behind closed doors in private homes, make it employment and removal to their home country (unless the
exceedingly difficult to identify and provide outreach. conditions they experienced amount to a situation of trafficking
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE
In December 2015, the UK Government launched a new is a positive development, there is a clear discrepancy between
enhanced helpline, replacing the existing number, which will the amount of cases being identified and the few that progress
become operational in 2016. Victims will be able to call or text to conviction. Also, NGOs report that the issuing of a Forced
for help—the texting function has been included for those fearful Marriage Protection Order (FMPO) does not always restrict
of being overheard.[34] NGO Polaris won the Home Office tender families acquiring new passports or travelling abroad.[37] The
to run the service.[35] FMU has continued to operate a hotline to provide advice and
support to victims. They have also continued to deliver outreach
Forced marriage was criminalised under the Anti-Social
and training to professionals and potential victims throughout
Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014 . In June 2015, a 34-year-
the year, as well as the 2015 'right to choose' film campaign.[38]
old man was the first person convicted of a forced marriage
Such awareness raising must be backed by shelter services for
offence under this new legislation, after making a 25-year-old
victims to flee to, which NGOs report are currently lacking.
woman marry him under duress.[36] Though this first conviction
RECOMMENDATIONS
Government
• Implement the recommendations made in the independent • I ncrease funding for quality-assessed victim-support
review of the Overseas Domestic Workers (ODW) visa shelters and services.
and immediately revoke the tied visa. • U
ndertake a robust and comprehensive evaluation of the
• Sign and ratify ILO Convention 189 on Decent Work for NRM pilots ensuring inclusion of victim feedback.
Domestic Workers. • R
estructure and reform the NRM to improve identification
• Enact a statutory system of independent child trafficking decision-making, and improve access to services and
advocates or guardians for all separated and trafficked outcomes for victims of modern slavery.
children. • C
losely monitor the impact of the supply chain
• Ensure provision of specialist foster care for trafficked requirements of the Modern Slavery Act, to ensure they
children and training of frontline workers. deliver results not just reporting.
• Improve data collection on victims and perpetrators
of modern slavery in the UK and encourage European
countries to follow the UKs led by estimating prevalence
within their borders so progress can be tracked over time.
Human trafficking
Human trafficking is defined in the UN Trafficking in Persons Protocol as involving three steps.
1. Recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons;
2. By means of threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of
power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent
of a person having control over another person;
3. With the intent of exploiting that person through: prostitution of others, sexual exploitation, forced labour, slavery
(or similar practices), servitude, and removal of organs.
The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of a child for the purpose of exploitation shall be considered
'trafficking in persons' even if this does not involve threat, use of force, or coercion.
Forced labour
Forced labour is defined in the International Labour Organisation (ILO) Convention on Forced Labour 1930 as "all work
or service which is exacted from any person under the menace of any penalty and for which the said person has not offered
himself voluntarily." This excludes compulsory military service, normal civil obligations, penalties imposed by a court
action taken in an emergency, and minor communal services.
Debt bondage
Debt bondage is a status or condition, where one person has pledged their labour or service (or that of someone under their
control), in circumstances where the fair value of that labour or service is not reasonably applied to reducing the debt or
length of debt, or the length and nature of the service is not limited or defined.
INTRODUCTION
The Global Slavery Index reflects a complex set of measures on the estimated number of people in modern slavery, the
factors that make individuals vulnerable, and also the steps governments are taking to respond to it.
The Index includes a model of vulnerability, which draws on 24 variables that impact on risk, such as the capacity to
borrow emergency funds, trust in the judiciary, levels of internal displacement, and discrimination. These variables are
grouped into four dimensions: civil and political protections; social, health and economic rights; personal security; and
conflict and refugees (see Part A: Assessing vulnerability).
Central to the Index is the estimated prevalence of modern slavery in 167 countries. The estimates are based on the
vulnerability model, together with survey data from face-to-face interviews conducted with over 42,000 individual
respondents in 53 languages, across 25 countries. Limited adjustments are made in specific cases where the existing data
are unable to account for country-specific considerations (see Part B: Estimating prevalence).
The rating of government responses is based on an assessment of 98 indicators of good practice for each country, taking
into account factors such as whether a country has the necessary laws in place, provides support programmes for victims
and works with business to regulate supply chains. The indicators are directed at measuring whether key outcomes have
been achieved, such as the identification of victims, and reduction in risk factors that enable slavery to occur (see Part C:
Government responses).
The vulnerability model used in the 2014 Index was the starting point for the development of the 2016 model. Tests
undertaken in 2015 suggested that the vulnerability model, together with existing survey data, provides a robust foundation
for estimating prevalence[1]. Nonetheless, to ensure continual improvement, the 2014 model was subjected to extensive
external expert review by the Index Expert Working Group, individual experts, and an independent review. This review
process has heavily informed the methodological approaches, choices of source data and normalisation processes used in
the 2016 model.
Normalisation
To identify the variables that would be used in the 2016 model, we compiled an initial long list of variables to subject to
statistical testing. The data for each of these variables were normalised to a linear scale from 1 to 100. A normalisation
procedure was employed based upon the following formula:
y=1+(x–A)*(100–1)/(B–A)
Where a variable represented resilience to modern slavery instead of vulnerability, or the scale used by the data source gave
a higher score for a lower risk, the data were inverted. For example, a higher confidence in judiciary score would suggest
lower risk, therefore it made sense to invert this score. A description of the inverted variables and justification can be found
in the longer methodology paper available on the website.
For variables where the data were not normally distributed (i.e., Refugees, Displaced, and GDP(PPP)), these data were
logarithmically transformed before any normalisation was undertaken.
Factor analysis
Principal Factor Analysis was selected as the optimal method for identifying which variables empirically group together into
distinct major factors. On the basis of this analysis, the following dimensions were identified, and confirmed for cluster analysis.
DIMENSION 2
DIMENSION 1 Social, Health & DIMENSION 3 DIMENSION 4
Civil & Political Protections Economic Rights Personal Security Refugee Populations & Conflict
Confidence in judicial system Financial inclusion: Financial inclusion: availability of Impact of terrorism
borrowed any money emergency funds
Weapons access Cell phone subscriptions Women’s physical security Refugees resident
Variables within each dimension were averaged to provide a dimension vulnerability score. The dimension scores were
then averaged for an overall vulnerability score for each country.
Where data were missing, an imputed value was determined by applying the overall vulnerability average to the dimensions
where data were missing. For example, there were three countries in Dimension 4 that did not have any dimension-level
data points: Brunei, Cape Verde and Suriname. The overall vulnerability mean for each country (for Dimensions 1, 2 and
3) was applied to these missing data points as the Dimension 4 data point replacements. For a more detailed discussion on
missing data, please see the longer methodology paper, available for download on our website.
Each of the national prevalence estimates in the Global Slavery Index reflects one of three methodologies:
• D
irect estimation following a nationally representative random sample survey, or state surveys in the case of India
(25 countries);
• Multiple systems estimation (two countries); or
• E
xtrapolation based on mathematical modelling of risk, to which relevant survey data has been applied
(139 countries).
Direct estimation through surveys
In 2014, Walk Free Foundation partnered with Gallup Inc. to conduct surveys in seven countries—Brazil, Ethiopia,
Indonesia, Nepal, Nigeria, Russia and Pakistan. A further 18 surveys were conducted in late 2014 and early 2015 for
inclusion in the 2016 Global Slavery Index: Bangladesh, Bolivia, Cambodia, Chile, Dominican Republic, Ghana,
Guatemala, Hungary, India, Mauritania, Mexico, Myanmar, Philippines, Poland, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Tunisia
and Vietnam[29].
Methodology
The survey instrument developed in 2014 for the first round of surveying was again included in the Gallup World Poll in
late 2014 and early 2015. The original instrument, developed through cognitive testing in five countries, was subjected to
minor refinements following feedback from the survey teams.
Walk Free Foundation adds a module to the World Poll in selected countries. Overall, the World Poll survey data
are representative of 98 percent of the world’s adult population. Face-to-face or telephone surveys are conducted
across households in more than 160 countries and in over 140 languages. A detailed description of the World Poll
methodology is available online, however some of the key aspects of the methodology include:
• The target population is the entire civilian, non-institutionalised population, aged 15 and older.
• W
ith the exception of areas which are scarcely populated or present a threat to the safety of interviewers,
samples are probability based and nationally representative.
• The questionnaire is translated into the major languages of each country.
• In-depth training is conducted with field staff and a standardised training manual is provided.
• Q
uality control procedures ensure that the correct samples are selected and the correct person is randomly
selected in each household.
Table 2: Sample size, survey languages, and exclusions across WFF survey countries
Afan Oromo,
Six of the nine zones of the Somali region
Ethiopia 9 1,004 Amharic, 3.4
(Degehabur, Warder, Korahe, Fik, Gode, Afder)
Tigrigna
Bahasa
Indonesia 7 1,000 No exclusions
Indonesian
English, Hausa,
Three states of the North East region
Nigeria 3 1,000 Igbo, Pidgin, 4.5
(Adamawa, Borno and Yobe)
Yoruba
Dominican
20 1,000 Spanish No exclusions
Republic
English, Hausa,
Ghana 11 1,000 Ewe, Twi, No exclusions
Dagbani
Cambodia 50 1,000 Khmer 2.9–3 Koh Kong, Oddar Meanchey, and Stueng Treng
Hindi, Tamil,
Kannada,
Andaman & Nicobar islands, Arunachal
Telugu, Marathi,
Pradesh, Dadra & Nagar Haveli, Daman & Diu,
India 56 3,000 Gujarati, Bengali, 9.2
Lakshadweep, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram,
Malayalam,
Nagaland, Pondicherry, Sikkim, Tripura
Odia, Punjabi,
Assamese
French,
Hassanya,
Mauritania 37 1,000 No exclusions
Poulaar, Wolof,
Soninke
Filipino, Iluko,
Hiligaynon,
Cebuano,
Philippines 14 1,000 No exclusions
Bicol, Waray,
Maguindanaon,
Maranao
Afrikaans,
South Africa 18 1,000 English, Sotho, No exclusions
Zulu, Xhosa
Sri Lanka 3 1,062 Sinhala, Tamil 2.4 Mullativu and Batticaloa districts
The Walk Free Foundation survey questions were based on a network sampling frame, to partly address the limitations
of a census framework when the target population is largely hidden. That is, it was decided to use 'family' rather than
'household' as the reference group, in order to increase the likelihood of identifying victims in a random sample survey.
We used an explicit definition of 'family' that includes parents, spouse/partner, siblings, and children, and obtained counts
for each of these types of kinship.
Questions asked
In addition to demographic questions, the questions asked were:
1. Have you or has anyone in your immediate family ever been forced to work by an employer?
2. Have you or has anyone in your immediate family ever been forced to work by an employer to repay a debt with
that employer?
3. Have you or has anyone in your immediate family ever been offered one kind of work, but then were forced to do
something else and not allowed to leave?
4. Have you or has anyone in your immediate family ever been forced to marry?
An additional filter question was added in Mauritania to ensure capture of traditional forms of slavery:
5. Have you or has anyone in your immediate family ever been forced to work for a master
as a slave?
Where a respondent answered yes to any of these filter questions on behalf of themselves or an immediate family member,
they were then asked a series of follow up questions to capture more information about the experience, including when and
where the experience occurred. A copy of the survey instrument can be found at globalslaveryindex.org
Counting rules
A positive response for forced labor or forced marriage was recorded when a respondent's series of answers met the
following counting rules:
1. Respondents answered ‘yes’ to any of the forced labour questions or to the forced marriage question AND
2. Reported that the forced labour or forced marriage was either in relation to their own experience, or on behalf of a
spouse, child, parent or sibling AND
3. Had been coerced (forced labour) or did not consent (forced marriage) AND
4. Experienced forced labour or forced marriage in the five years preceding the survey.
Note: Mauritania calculated as ‘ever’ for forced labour and last five years for forced marriage.
Note: In India, the results from state surveys are used not the national survey results.
Total 8 14,000
There was an unusually high level of refusals during the India state surveys, where respondents were willing to answer
the first filter questions about forced labour and forced marriage, but refused to answer subsequent questions that sought
further information.
Table 5: Refusal rate to subsequent questions about forced labour/marriage, 2016 survey
This high refusal rate was not experienced in the national survey for India, or in other national surveys.
Consultation with the survey team and experts in India strongly suggested that the high refusal rate reflects the sensitivity
of the issues being discussed, fear of consequences of providing further information, and the lack of privacy in interview
situations. This sensitivity was also reflected in the detention by local officials of some of the team in the survey process. In
addition the survey team observed that with such a large sample size, the team was spending several days in each location.
They observed that information about the survey questions was rapidly percolating through the community in the areas
being surveyed, with the result that some people may have been pre-warned not to share information.
These observations were confirmed by subsequent analysis of the characteristics of refusers, and non-refusers, and also
analysis of refusal rates in relation to time spent in each site. Refusers were more likely to be rural, poor and live very close
to their family than non-refusers. Refusal rates increased the longer a field team spent in a location. Based on the convergent
evidence, we can expect that the ratio of filtered to confirmed cases would be lower for refusers than for respondents.
To account for the high level of refusals, a statistical method was developed to reasonably but conservatively estimate the
result that would have been achieved, had more respondents completed the survey questions. This involved calculating the
ratio of 'identified' cases (respondents who passed the filter question and then went on to identify which member of their
family the victim was) to 'confirmed' cases (cases which met the full criteria set out above), and then applying this ratio to
the number of respondents who 'passed' the first filter question (see Table 5 above). This assumed that those who were not
willing to report further information would yield a similar proportion of 'positive' cases had they continued with the questions.
Table 6: Distribution of data from random sample surveys across the groups
Number of countries
Cluster Survey data in the cluster in the cluster
2 No survey data 4
4 Mauritania, Ghana 16
5 Cambodia 12
8 No survey data 13
9 Bolivia, Vietnam 17
11 United Kingdom 17
12 Hungary 11
Reflecting the limitations of any data driven process, a final set of adjustments was made in limited cases to better account
for state-sanctioned forced labour, conflict and geopolitical concerns. A final, downward adjustment for Small Island
Developing States was applied to ensure the extent of the problem was not over-estimated in these countries (see table 7).
Central African Republic, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Somalia, Afghanistan, Sudan, Syria,
Conflict
South Sudan, Iraq, Pakistan, Yemen, Libya
China, Israel, Haiti, Timor-Leste, Eritrea, Swaziland, Malawi, Zambia, Lesotho, Madagascar, Sierra Leone,
Geopolitical
Namibia, Kenya, Iceland, Finland, Portugal, Italy
Barbados, Cape Verde, Cuba, Guinea-Bissau, Guyana, Jamaica, Mauritius, Papua New Guinea, Suriname,
Small Island Developing States
Trinidad and Tobago
A detailed explanation of the computations for countries within each cluster is available on the Global Slavery Index website.
The government plays a critical role in developing and implementing the laws, policies and programmes that are needed to
prevent and respond to modern slavery. To complement prevalence estimates, for the second year running, the Index also
includes an assessment of government responses to modern slavery.
As in 2014, governments are assessed against their efforts towards meeting the following five milestones:
1. Survivors of slavery are identified, supported to exit and remain out of slavery;
2. Criminal justice mechanisms function effectively to prevent modern slavery;
3. Coordination occurs at the national and regional level, while governments are held accountable for their response;
4. Risk factors, such as attitudes, social systems and institutions, that enable modern slavery are addressed; and
5. Businesses and governments stop sourcing goods and services that use modern slavery.
Process
Government responses were examined in 161 countries in 2016.[41] Building on work conducted in 2014, the process for
assessing government processes incorporates three stages: conceptual framework development, data collection and analysis.
Underpinning the five milestones are 98 indicators to determine how well a government is responding to modern slavery
(see Table 7: Conceptual Framework), grouped into 28 activities. The 133 indicators used to assess governments in 2014
were reviewed post launch to identify gaps in our conceptual framework, such as the collection of data on labour inspectors,
and data gaps, such as missing information on standard operating procedures for police units. As a result of this review, and
data gaps post data collection for certain indicators, the number of indicators was reduced to 98 core indicators.
These revised indicators include ‘positive indicators’ which cover actions the government is taking to achieve each
milestone. This year, these indicators were supplemented by standardised ‘negative indicators’, which attempt to measure
the implementation of a particular activity. For example, if shelters exist for modern slavery victims, the negative indicator
‘victims are detained and unable to leave the shelter’ would capture whether victims are detained and experience secondary
victimisation despite the existence of these shelters. The negative indicators also cover broader factors which, if conducted
by governments, would increase the risk of modern slavery. These included state-sanctioned forced labour, high levels of
government complicity, criminalisation of victims, deportation of potential victims, and policies which tie migrant workers
to their employers.
Publicly available information was collected through desk-based research for each of these indicators. Governments and
NGOs were also given the opportunity to provide information to inform this process. In April 2014, a survey was sent
to all governments included in the Global Slavery Index requesting information about their response to modern slavery.
Information submitted via these surveys was also included for 38 countries. In October 2015, this was supplemented by a
survey which was sent to NGO partners to obtain an update on government responses in the last 18 months; 32 surveys were
received and written submissions from a further seven NGOs. Finally, in-country experts were consulted where possible
to verify the information and help address any gaps.
Ratings
Each indicator was scored on a 0 to 1 scale. On this scale, 0 meant no information was identified or available, or information
explicitly demonstrated that the government did not meet any indicators; 1 meant that the indicator had been met. For
negative indicators, these were scored on a 0 to –1 scale. On this scale, 0 meant no information was identified or available,
or information explicitly demonstrated that the government did not meet any indicators; –1 meant that the indicator had
been met.
As with last year, we grouped these indicators into activities, as the below conceptual framework describes. Each activity
was weighted evenly to 100 points. Negative indicators, where these tested the implementation of certain activities (marked
as ‘negative implementation’ in bold in the conceptual framework), were incorporated into the individual activities with
the following formula:
= (positive indicators + negative indicators)/ total number of positive indicators * 3.57143[42]
All negative indicators were treated in this way, apart from government corruption and complicity (Milestone 4, indicator
1.4.3) and state sanctioned forced labour (Milestone 4, indicator 1.8.1). These are marked with a bold ‘NEGATIVE’ in the
below table. Due to the importance of these indicators, these were not weighted and were subtracted from the final score.
As each government was rated at the activity level, the simplest way to fairly compare governments was to aggregate these
scores.[43] These scores were then converted to credit ratings, based on ten different categories, and adjusted so that any
countries at the top of the table that either scored a negative on arrest or deportation of victims (Milestone 2, indicator 1.4.5
and Milestone 3, indicator 3.2.4) were unable to achieve above a BBB rating.
Limitations
Collecting data across 98 indicators for 161 countries is a complex undertaking. Access to data for all indicators is limited
in certain countries where information is not publicly available, or not available in languages spoken by the research team.
Information that is publicly available might also distort reality on the ground—it may appear that no services are provided
by governments, but an active civil society ensures that victims are fully supported. As with all policy analyses, it is difficult
to move beyond the existence of policies to assess their active implementation—laws may exist, but be poorly understood
and implemented by local law enforcement, for example. While the inclusion of ‘negative implementation’ indicators this
year goes some way to addressing the issues of measuring implementation, there will still be gaps in our assessment which
gives credit where no action is taking place in reality, or does not give credit where policies do not exist, but there is an
active civil society filling gaps in a government response.
urvivors of modern slavery are supported to exit slavery and are empowered
MILESTONE 1: S
to break the cycle of vulnerability
Increase in 1.1 1.1.1 Information is distributed to the public about how to identify and report cases of
reported cases of The public knows modern slavery
modern slavery what modern 1.1.2 This information is distributed systematically and at regular intervals (as distinct
slavery is and how from one-off, isolated)
to report it
1.1.3 There has been an increase in number of members of the public reporting cases of
modern slavery
2.2 2.2.1 Training on basic legal frameworks and victim identification has been carried out
Police know what for front line ‘general duties’ police
modern slavery is
and how to report it NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
2.2.4 There is evidence that police officers have not identified victims of modern slavery
in the last 12 months
2.3 2.3.1 Training on how to identify victims of modern slavery is provided to front line
Government and regulatory bodies likely to be ‘first responders’
non- government 2.3.2 Training on how to identify victims of modern slavery is provided to workers
bodies know what likely to be ‘first responders’
modern slavery is
and how to report it 2.3.3 Training for first responders is delivered systematically and at regular intervals (as
distinct from one-off, isolated)
Victim- 3.1 3.1.1 Victim support services are available for suspected victims of modern slavery
determined Basic victim (men, women and children where relevant) regardless of ethno-cultural or
services are determined support socioeconomic background
available for all is available for all
victims of modern identified victims NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
slavery 3.1.2 Suspected victims have a choice about whether or not to remain in a shelter
3.1.3 Government contributes to the operational costs of the victim support services
3.1.4 Physical and mental health services are provided to victims of modern slavery
NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
3.1.5 Victim support services are not available for all victims of modern slavery
NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
3.1.7 No victims have accessed the services or shelters since 1st June 2014
3.3 3.3.1 Training has been carried out for all staff providing assistance services
Victim determined 3.3.2 Services have been evaluated
services are
high quality and 3.3.3 Evaluations of services have been provided to cooperative framework or
responsive coordination body
Agencies work 4.1 4.1.1 The government has clear guidelines for identifying and screening victims.
together in the Government 4.1.2 The guidelines make provision for a category of 'presumed victims', who can be
interests of victims coordinates the provided with services until a formal determination is made.
identification of
victims 4.1.3 The guidelines clearly set out which organisations have the authority to identify
victims of modern slavery
MILESTONE 2: E
ffective criminal justice responses are in place in every jurisdiction
Victims are able 1.4 1.4.1 National laws allow victims to participate in the legal system, regardless of their
to access justice Victims are able to role as a witness
participate in court 1.4.2 Law recognises that victims should not be treated as criminals for conduct that
to receive justice occurred while under control of criminals
(arrest of trafficker/
compensation/ 1.4.3 Visas to stay in the country are not dependent on victim participation in the court
redress) process
NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
1.4.5 There is evidence that victims of modern slavery have been treated as criminals for
conduct that occurred while under control of criminals
2.1 2.1.1 There are free legal services available for victims of modern slavery
Victims are 2.1.3 Evidence of witness and victim protection mechanisms are in place to ensure that
supported to access neither witnesses nor victims are intimidated, nor interfered with inside the court
justice
2.1.4 Evidence of witness and victim protection mechanisms are in place to ensure that
neither witnesses nor victims are intimidated, nor interfered with outside the court
2.1.5 The legal framework supports restitution or compensation for victims of modern
slavery
2.1.6 Child friendly services are provided during the criminal justice process, from
engagement with police through to court process
MILESTONE 3: Governments coordinate and are held accountable for their actions
Responses to 1.1 1.1.1 National coordination body exists involving both government and NGOs
modern slavery Mechanisms exist 1.2.1 National Action Plan exists with clear indicators and allocation of responsibilities
are coordinated to coordinate the
response 1.3.2 Government routinely uses the National Action Plan as a framework for reporting
its actions
1.3.5 Activities in the national action plan are fully funded
2.1 2.1.1 Independent entity to monitor the implementation and effectiveness of National
Independent Action Plan exists
mechanisms exist
to monitor the
response
3.2 3.2.1 The government cooperates with the government of the home country to facilitate
Cross border return of victims
collaboration NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
exists for victim
protection 3.2.4 Foreign victims are not identified AND/ OR are detained and deported
3.2.6 Bilateral agreements exist between countries on labour migration
MILESTONE 4: L
aws, policies and programmes address attitudes, social systems and
institutions that create vulnerability and enable slavery
1.2 1.2.1 Awareness campaigns target specific known risks of modern slavery
Government
interventions are
tailored to risk
1.6 1.6.3 Private recruitment fees are paid by the employer, not the employee
Safety nets exist for 1.6.5 Labour laws extend to everyone, including migrant workers, domestic workers and
migrant workers those in the fishing and construction sectors
NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
1.6.7 Patterns of abuse of labour migrants are widespread and unchecked
NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
1.6.9 There are laws or policies that prevent or make it difficult for workers to leave
abusive employers without punishment
1.7 1.7.1 Government provides training for its consular staff on modern slavery
Governments 1.7.2 Government provides identification documents and support travel arrangements for
provide support for citizen return
citizens overseas
NEGATIVE IMPLEMENTATION
1.7.5 Diplomatic staff are not investigated or prosecuted for alleged complicity or abuse
in modern slavery cases
MILESTONE 5: G
overnments stop sourcing goods and services linked to modern slavery
Government 1.1 1.1.2 Public procurement policies and systems exist to minimise the risk of governments
sources goods and Government purchasing products tainted by forced labour
services which are regulates its supply 1.1.3 Annual reports on forced labour in government supply chains are produced and
slavery free chains against publically available
forced labour
Businesses source 1.2 1.2.1 Laws or policies require businesses to report on their actions to implement risk
goods and services Governments minimisation policies
which are slavery regulate businesses 1.2.2 Laws or policies require businesses to have transparent, risk-minimisation
free against use of strategies in place that will identify and respond to a case of modern slavery in
forced labour their supply chains
1.2.3 Governments implement a responsible investment reporting requirement for
investment funds and banks head-quartered in their country to ensure that
investment does not support modern slavery
1.2.4 Laws are in place that make it a criminal offence for Company Directors or
companies who fail to prevent modern slavery being utilised in their business’ first
tier supply chain
Note: Numbering reflects numbering in the government response database available at www.globalslaveryindex.org.
Slavery, Maid in Taiwan', Taipei Times, February 17, 2015, accessed Diplomat, November 24, 2014, accessed 11/04/2016:http://thedip-
20/04/2016:http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/feat/archiv lomat.com/2014/11/the-women-who-escape-from-north-korea/
es/2015/02/17/2003611746 Ana Anand, 'India's Bride Trafficking Fuelled by Skewed
25
8
Personal communication. Sex Ratios', The Guardian, December 17, 2014, accessed
06/04/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/global-develop-
9
'Insight – As Obama heads to Malaysia, human trafficking
ment/2014/dec/17/india-bride-trafficking-foeticide
stance questioned', Reuters, November 19, 2015, accessed
04/04/2016:http://news.trust.org//item/20151119173424-e8s2a/?- Document submitted by Terre des Hommes for the Day of General
26
workers-tell-of-abuses-on-malaysian-plantations-1437933321 tion', Philippines Official Gazette, February 18, 2014, last modified
18/02/2014,http://www.gov.ph/2014/02/18/dswd-fight-child-sexu-
'Bangladesh: 2 Years After Rana Plaza, Workers Denied Rights',
11
al-abuse-and-commercial-sexual-exploitation/
Human Rights Watch, April 22, 2015, accessed 05/04/2016:https://
www.hrw.org/news/2015/04/22/bangladesh-2-years-after-rana- United Nations Human Rights Council, Report of the Commission
28
accessed 21/04/2016:https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/
Declan Croucher, 'Solutions: How Patagonia is Addressing Forced
13
world_report_download/wr2016_web.pdf
Labour in its Supply Chain', Verite, accessed 12/05/2016:http://
www.verite.org/vision/june2015/solutions 'North Korea putting thousands into forced labour abroad, UN
30
publications/WCMS_BK_PB_67_EN/lang--en/index. see also Ian currency', Market Watch, May 19, 2015, accessed 12/04/2016:http://
Urbina, 'Sea Slaves: The Human Misery That Feeds Pets and Live- www.marketwatch.com/story/north-korea-turning-to-hu-
stock', New York Times, July 27, 2015, accessed 13/05/2016:htm, man-trafficking-for-foreign-currency-2015-05-18
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/27/world/outlaw-ocean-thai- 'North Korea putting thousands into forced labour abroad, UN
33
land-fishing-sea-slaves-pets.html,; see also 'Seafood from Slaves: says', The Guardian, October 29, 2015, accessed 20/04/2016:http://
An AP Investigation Helps Free Slaves in the 21st Century', Associ- www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/29/north-korea-workers-
ated Press, last accessed April 5, 2016, http://www.ap.org/explore/ forced-labour-abroad-un-report
seafood-from-slaves/
Esther Htusan and Margie Mason, 'More than 2,000 enslaved
34
in Indonesia since Benjina 'Slave Fisheries' Exposed', Inter- cret to Saving the World, (Speigel and Grau/Random House, 2016).
national Organisation for Migration, March 8, 2015, accessed As above.
58
14/04/2016:https://weblog.iom.int/over-500-new-human-traffick-
ing-victims-identified-indonesia-benjina-%E2%80%98slave-fish- "Myanmar floods: Food security and livelihoods still at risk,
59
39
Paul Dillon, 'Over 500 New Human Trafficking Victims Identified Plan of Action DREF operation no MDRVN013", Reliefweb,
in Indonesia since Benjina 'Slave Fisheries' Exposed', Inter- accessed April 12, 2016,http://reliefweb.int/report/viet-nam/
national Organisation for Migration, March 8, 2015, accessed viet-nam-drought-and-saltwater-intrusion-emergency-plan-ac-
14/04/2016:https://weblog.iom.int/over-500-new-human-traffick- tion-dref-operation-no
ing-victims-identified-indonesia-benjina-%E2%80%98slave-fish- Silvia di Gaetano, 'How to Solve Southeast Asia's Refugee Crisis',
61
national Organisation for Migration, March 8, 2015, accessed Myanmar, Shunned by Malaysia, are Spotted Adrift in Andaman
14/04/2016:https://weblog.iom.int/over-500-new-human-traffick- Sea', The New York Times, May 14, 2015, accessed 11/04/2015: ; see
ing-victims-identified-indonesia-benjina-%E2%80%98slave-fish- also BBC News, 'Why are so many Rohingya migrants stranded at
eries%E2%80%99-exposed sea?', BBC News, May 18, 2015, accessed 15/04/2016:http://www.
nytimes.com/2015/05/15/world/asia/burmese-rohingya-bangla-
42
Personal communication. deshi-migrants-andaman-sea.html?_r=0, http://www.bbc.com/
43
As above. news/world-asia-32740637
44
United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
63
the Pacific, Economic and Social Survey of Asia and the Pacific 2015, in Persons Report: Philippines Country Narrative, (United States
(United Nations, 2015), p. 131, accessed 04/04/2016:http://www. Department of State, 2015), p. 281, accessed 11/04/2016:http://
unescap.org/sites/default/files/Economic%20and%20Social%20 www.state.gov/documents/organization/243561.pdf
Survey%20of%20Asia%20and%20the%20Pacific%202015.pdf "Freedom Partnership to End Modern Slavery", The Salvation
64
45
As above. Army, last accessed April 28, 2016,http://endslavery.salvos.org.au/
46
"Afghanistan Unemployment Rate", Trading Economics, last ac- about/
cessed April 13, 2016,http://www.tradingeconomics.com/afghani- Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Traf-
65
and use of children by the Myanmar army, (Child Soldiers Interna- to the Challenges of Modern Slavery', The Australian Outlook,
tional, 2015), p. 11, accessed 12/04/2016:http://www.child-sol- March 25, 2016, accessed 04/04/2016:http://www.internationalaf-
diers.org/research_report_reader.php?id=804 fairs.org.au/australian_outlook/the-bali-process-responding-to-
the-challenges-of-modern-slavery/
49
R.W Dellinger, 'Human trafficking account: the Philippines:
Escaping twice from domestic servitude', Angelus News, March "Sixth Regional Ministerial Conference, Bali, Indonesia, 23 March
67
17, 2016, accessed 04/04/2016:http://www.angelusnews.com/ 2016", The Bali Process, accessed April 20, 2016,http://www.balip-
news/local/human-trafficking-account-the-philippines-escap- rocess.net/ministerial-conferences-and-senior-officials-meetings
ing-twice-from-domestic-servitude-10342/#.VwIAGKR97IU "SAARC: Kathmandu Declaration 2014 (full text)", Online Khabar,
68
50
Sarah L. Bhatia, 'Overseas Filipino Workers become economic he- last accessed 28/04/2016: ; see also: Heather Hamilton, 'South
roes', Stanford Asia Pacific Research Centre, April 15, 2013, accessed Asian governments commit to end child marriage', Girls Not
15/04/2013:http://aparc.fsi.stanford.edu/news/overseas_filipi- Brides, November 22, 2014, accessed 28/04/2016:http://www.on-
no_workers_become_economic_heroes_20130415 linekhabar.com/2014/11/211832, http://www.reproductiverights.
org/sites/crr.civicactions.net/files/documents/SA%20End%20
51
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking Child%20Marriage%20Brochure_20Nov14(final)-2%20(1).pdf
in Persons Report: Philippines Country Narrative, (United States
Department of State, 2015), p. 279, accessed 03/04/2016:http:// Asian Forum of Parliamenterians on Population and Development
69
55
'Nepal Earthquake: More than 160 trafficked Nepali's rescued 'Bangladesh: Girls Damaged by Child Marriage', Human Rights
74
by India in aftermath of quake', ABC News, February 15, 2016, Watch, June 9, 2015, accessed 21/04/2016:https://www.hrw.org/
accessed 12/04/2016:http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-02-15/ne- news/2015/06/09/bangladesh-girls-damaged-child-marriage
pal-earthquakes-cause-spike-in-human-trafficking/7168398
56
Jason Burke, 'Indian gangs found trafficking women from
earthquake-hit Nepal', The Guardian, July 31, 2015, accessed
01/04/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/law/2015/jul/30/indi-
an-gangs-trafficking-women-nepal-earthquake
ernment of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, accessed Andrea Bruce, 'Romania’s Disappearing Girls', Al Jazeera America,
9
whose weight dropped from 49kg to 29kg', The Straits Times, Trafficking in Persons to Europe for sexual exploitation, (Unit-
10
March 23, 2016, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.straitstimes.com/ ed Nations Office on Drugs and Crime), p. 3, accessed
singapore/courts-crime/singaporean-couple-convicted-of-starv- 21/04/2016:https://www.unodc.org/documents/publications/
ing-maid-whose-weight-dropped-from-49kg TiP_Europe_EN_LORES.pdf
'Abused maid in Singapore says she was punished in bizarre ways',
84 A. Oluwabiyi, 'Legal Response to Women Trafficking in Nige-
11
The Star Online, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.thestar.com.my/ ria', Frontiers of Legal Research 3, no.1 (March 2015): 2, doi:
news/regional/2016/04/07/abused-maid-in-singapore-says-she- 10.3968/6078.
was-punished-in-bizarre-ways/ National Referral Mechanism Statistics – End of Year Summary 2015,
12
in Indonesia', The Jakarta Globe, March 19, 2016, accessed p. 23, accessed 21/04/2016:https://ec.europa.eu/anti-trafficking/
11/04/2016:http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/news/po- sites/antitrafficking/files/eurostat_report_on_trafficking_in_hu-
lice-bust-major-human-trafficking-syndicate-indonesia/ man_beings_-_2015_edition.pdf
Improving Protections for Migrant Domestic Workers in Australia,
88
National Crime Agency, National Referral Mechanism Statistics
16
(Walk Free Foundation and the Salvation Army, 2015), p. 2, – End of Year Summary 2015, (National Crime Agency 2016),
accessed 15/04/2016:http://endslavery.salvos.org.au/wp-content/ p. 4, accessed 28/03/2016:http://www.nationalcrimeagency.
uploads/2015/02/Improving-Protections-for-Domestic-Work- gov.uk/publications/676-national-referral-mechanism-statis-
ers-in-Australia.pdf tics-end-of-year-summary-2015/file
Felicity Lawrence, 'Lithuanian gangmasters jailed in modern slav-
17
ery and trafficking case', The Guardian, January 23, 2016, accessed
29/03/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/jan/22/
lithuanian-gangmasters-jailed-in-modern-slavery-and-traffick-
ing-case
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, Severe Labour
18
Bank, last modified 18/03/2015:http://www.worldbank.org/en/ Report concerning the implementation of the Council of Europe
news/feature/2015/03/18/improving-living-conditions-for-mar- Convention on action against Trafficking in Human Beings by Sweden,
ginalized-roma (Council of Europe, 2014), p. 13, accessed 12/04/2016:http://
20
Kate D’Arcy and Isabelle Brodie, 'Roma Children and Young www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/trafficking/docs/Reports/GRE-
People in Bulgaria: Patterns of Risk and Effective Protection in TA_2014_11_FGR_SWE_en.pdf
Relation to Child Sexual Exploitation', Social Inclusion 3, no.4 (July Andrea Bruce, 'Romania’s Disappearing Girls', Al Jazeera America,
40
Kenan Malik, 'The Failure of Multiculturalism', Foreign Affairs, Rights Resource Centre, accessed March 16, 2016,http://busi-
March/April 2015, accessed 13/04/2016:https://www.foreignaffairs. ness-humanrights.org/en/uk-modern-slavery-act-comes-into-ef-
com/articles/western-europe/failure-multiculturalism fect
24
As above. Amelia Gentleman, 'UK firms must show proof they have no
44
25
Emma Psaila, Vanessa Leigh, Marilena Verbari, Sara Fiorenti- links to slave labour under new rules', The Guardian, October 29,
ni et al., Forced Marriage from a gender perspective, (European 2015,http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/28/uk-compa-
Parliament, 2016), pp. 60–68, accessed 13/04/2016:http://www. nies-proof-no-links-slave-labour-supply-chain
europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2016/556926/IPOL_ 'Opstelten: Task Force Strengthens and Broadens Approach to
45
Russia and Eurasia Ana Maria Buller, Hanni Stoklosa and Cathy Zimmerman, Labour
18
As above, p. 25.
3
in Persons Report: Kazakhstan Country Narrative, (United States
Alternative Turkmenistan News, Spotlight on Turkmenistan: Wide-
4 Department of State, 2015), accessed 11/04/2016:http://www.state.
spread State-Orchestrated Forced Labour in Turkmenistan’s 2014 Cot- gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/countries/2015/243465.htm
ton Harvest, (Cotton Campaign, 2015), accessed 07/04/2016:http:// As above.
20
www.cottoncampaign.org/uploads/3/9/4/7/39474145/stateforced-
Ana Maria Buller, Hanni Stoklosa and Cathy Zimmerman, Labour
21
laborinturkmenistan2014_report_atn.pdf
Exploitation, Trafficking and Migrant Health: Multi-Country Findings
Uzbek-German Forum for Human Rights, The Coverup: White-
5
on the Health Risks and Consequences of Migrant and Trafficked
washing Uzbekistan’s White Gold, (Cotton Campaign, 2015), p. 5, Workers, (International Labor Organisation, 2015), p. 107, ac-
accessed 11/04/2016:http://harvestreport2015.uzbekgermanforum. cessed 11/04/2016:https://publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/
org/pdf/harvestreport-2015.pdf labour_exploitation_trafficking_en.pdf
Alternative Turkmenistan News, Spotlight on Turkmenistan:
6
As above.
22
uzbekgermanforum.org/pdf/harvestreport-2015.pdf, ; see also Uz- Labor and Labor Trafficking in Armenia: Pilot Study, (Organization
bek-German Forum for Human Rights, Silk Loop for Uzbek Farm- for Security and Co-Operation in Europe, 2015), p. 21, accessed
ers, (Cotton Campaign, 2015), p. 6, accessed 11/04/2016:http:// 11/04/2015:http://www.osce.org/yerevan/212571?download=true
www.cottoncampaign.org/uploads/3/9/4/7/39474145/silk-loop-
As above.
26
for-uzbek-farmers.pdf
As above.
27
As above.
7
for Human Rights, Silk Loop for Uzbek Farmers, (Cotton Cam- p. 36, accessed 19/04/2016:https://ec.europa.eu/anti-trafficking/
paign, 2015), p. 9, pp. 14–15, accessed 11/04/2016: http://www. sites/antitrafficking/files/eurostat_report_on_trafficking_in_hu-
cottoncampaign.org/uploads/3/9/4/7/39474145/silk-loop-for-uz- man_beings_-_2015_edition.pdf
bek-farmers.pdf As above.
30
As above, p.4.
9
'Ukraine: Situation report No.28 as of 20 February 2015', Relief-
31
accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.cottoncampaign.org/up- Displacement on the Rise in Ukraine - Briefing Paper, (Internal Dis-
loads/3/9/4/7/39474145/stateforcedlaborinturkmenistan2014_re- placement Monitoring Centre, 2014), accessed: 17/03/2016:http://
port_atn.pdf, ; see also Uzbek-German Forum for Human Rights, www.internal-displacement.org/europe-the-caucasus-and-central-
The Coverup: Whitewashing Uzbekistan’s White Gold, (Cotton Cam- asia/ukraine/2014/time-to-act-internal-displacement-on-the-rise-
paign, 2015), p. 17, accessed 11/04/2016:http://harvestreport2015. in-ukraine
uzbekgermanforum.org/pdf/harvestreport-2015.pdf, ; see also
As above.
33
Uzbek-German Forum for Human Rights, Silk Loop for Uzbek
Farmers, (Cotton Campaign, 2015), p. 9, accessed 11/04/2016 As above.
34
http://www.cottoncampaign.org/uploads/3/9/4/7/39474145/silk- As above.
35
loop-for-uzbek-farmers.pdf
'Ukraine: Rebels Subject Civilians to Forced Labor', Human Rights
36
As above.
17
As above, pp. 11-12.
42
As above, p.9.
43
As above, p. 44.
44
47
As above. News, November 18, 2014, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.iol.co.
za/news/africa/swaziland-is-a-trafficking-hub---report-1782123
48
Anti-Discrimination Centre, From Tajikistan to Russia: Vulner-
ability and Abuse of Migrant Workers and their Families, (Inter- 'Swaziland: Swazi Govt Misleads On Child Labour', All Africa,
2
national Federation for Human Rights, 2014), p. 11, accessed January 20, 2015, accessed 21/04/2016:http://allafrica.com/sto-
17/03/2016:https://www.fidh.org/IMG/pdf/russie641uk2014hd.pdf ries/201501201394.html
49
As above, pp. 17-22. Human Rights Council, Report of the Commission of Inquiry on
3
54
Eurasian Development Bank, Labour Migration, Remittances and United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, UNHCR Eligibil-
5
Human Development in Central Asia, (United Nations Development ity Guidelines for Assessing the International Protection Needs of
Programme, 2015), p. 25, accessed 11/02/2016:http://www.eurasia. Asylum Seekers from Eritrea, (United Nations High Commissioner
undp.org/content/dam/rbec/docs/CA%20M&R%20HD%20 for Refugees, 2011), pp. 14–16, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.
paper%20frozen%20ENG%20Layout.pdf refworld.org/docid/4dafe0ec2.html
55
As above, p. 26. UK Border Agency, Operational Guidance Note: Eritrea, (Home
6
comply with Committee of the Parties Recommendation CP(2012)5 for government-allied fighters,' The Guardian, September 28,
on the implementation of the Council of Europe Convention on Action 2015, accessed 21/04/16: ; see also Tristan McConnell, 'The rape
against Trafficking in Human Beings, (Council of Europe, 2014), camps of South Sudan,' AFP Correspondent, October 7, 2015,
accessed 11/04/2016:https://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/global-devel-
trafficking/Docs/CommitteeParties/Reply_REC/CP_2014_20_RR_ opment/2015/sep/28/south-sudan-women-girls-raped-as-wages-
GEO_en.pdf for-government-allied-fighters, http://blogs.afp.com/correspon-
61
As above. dent/?post/the-rape-camps-of-south-sudan
62
As above. Hannah McNeish, 'Reliving the rape camps of South Sudan's civil
10
As above.
16
2015, accessed 29/03/2016:http://janelabous.com/2015/03/docu- Central and West Africa, (United Nations Children's Fund, 2015),
mentary-togos-trafficked-cinderellas-tell-tales-of-modern-slav- pp. 14–28, accessed 03/02/2016:http://www.unicef.org/wcaro/
ery/ english/Child_Mariage_Adolescent_Pregnancy_and_Family_For-
'Benin/Togo: protecting migrating children, Tdh brings the
18 mation_in_WCA.pdf
media on board', Terre des Hommes, October 21, 2015, accessed As above.
45
Agence-France Presse, 'Burundi's child sex slaves: 'I feel like I have
23 Moki Edwin Kindzeka, 'Refugees Fleeing Boko Haram Spark
49
been used and tossed away'', The Guardian, February 20, 2014, Humanitarian Crisis in Cameroon', Voice of America, December
accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/global-develop- 17, 2015, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.voanews.com/content/
ment/2014/feb/20/burundi-child-sex-slaves-prostitution humanitarian-crisis-as-boko-haram-refugees-stream-into-camer-
oon/3106733.html
'Senegal: Decade of Abuse in Quranic Schools', Human Rights
24
Watch, April 20, 2015, accessed 07/04/2016:https://www.hrw.org/ 'Boko Haram: children among villagers burned to death in
50
As above.
29 Burundi 9 July", United Nations Office of the High Commissioner
for Human Rights, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.ohchr.org/EN/
As above.
30
NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=16221&LangID=E
Ludovica Iaccino, 'DRC child soldiers: Children grow up 'more
31
Connor Gaffey, 'Watch: The Rise of Al-Shabaab in Somalia', News-
53
comfortable with weapons than with books'', International Business week, March 30, 2016, accessed 11/04/2016:http://www.newsweek.
Times, October 30, 2016, accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.ibtimes. com/watch-rise-al-shabab-somalia-442173
co.uk/drc-child-soldiers-children-grow-more-comfortable-weap-
ons-books-video-1526518 Emma Graham-Harrison, 'The World Looks Away as Blood
54
As above.
39
Headwinds, (International Monetary Fund, 2015), p. ix, accessed
As above.
40 09/02/2016:https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/reo/2015/afr/
eng/pdf/sreo0415.pdf
As above.
41
As above,p. 35.
61
violence, (Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre, 2015), p. "Regional Mixed Migration 3rd Quarter Trend Analysis 2015",
62
22, accessed 04/02/2016:http://www.internal-displacement.org/ Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16: ; see also
publications/2015/global-overview-2015-people-internally-dis- "Regional Mixed Migration 2nd Quarter Trend Analysis 2015",
placed-by-conflict-and-violence/ Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16:http://
www.regionalmms.org/index897d.html?id=55&tx_ttnews[tt_
"Child Marriage Around the World: Central African Republic",
43
news]=373&cHash=899eab72869f066e34cfa9ff5174ac7d, http://
Girls not Brides, accessed 03/02/16:http://www.girlsnotbrides.org/ www.regionalmms.org/index42f9.html?id=55&tx_ttnews%5Btt_
child-marriage/central-african-republic/ news%5D=345&cHash=be8f0df5525e2408606820daf1bac8b1
tional Labor Organisation, 2015), p. 54, accessed 09/02/2016: ; see dracunculiasis', World Health Organisation, January 24, 2014, ac-
also United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, An Introduction cessed 21/04/2016:http://www.who.int/dracunculiasis/political_in-
to Human Trafficking: Vulnerability, Impact and Action – Background stability_in_South_Sudan/en/
Paper, (United Nations, 2008), p. 88, accessed 09/02/2016:http:// 'Chad: At War With Boko Haram', Al Jazeera, May 20, 2015, ac-
81
www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/---dcomm/-- cessed 21/04/2016: ; see also Charlotte Bonzonnet, 'Chad struggles
-publ/documents/publication/wcms_337069.pdf, https://www. to cope with refugees from conflict in Central African Republic',
unodc.org/documents/human-trafficking/An_Introduction_to_ Al Jazeera, March 11, 2014, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.
Human_Trafficking_-_Background_Paper.pdf aljazeera.com/programmes/peopleandpower/2015/05/chad-war-
64
'UNHCR warns against perilous Horn of Africa sea crossings as boko-haram-150520165103249.html, http://www.theguardian.
92,000 reach Yemen in 2015, 36 already drowned this year', United com/world/2014/mar/11/central-african-republic-chad-border
Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, January 19, 2016 accessed Annual Report: Somalia: 2015/2016, (Amnesty International, 2016),
82
04/02/2016:http://www.unhcr.org/569e2a846.html accessed 21/04/2016:https://www.amnesty.org/en/countries/africa/
65
'IOM Evacuates Ethiopian Trafficking Victims from Yemen', Relief- somalia/report-somalia/
Web, July 21, 2015, last accessed February 4, 2016,http://reliefweb. Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
83
int/report/ethiopia/iom-evacuates-ethiopian-trafficking-vic- in Persons Report: Burundi Country Narrative, (United States De-
tims-yemen partment of State, 2013), accessed 07/04/2016: ; see also Office to
66
"I Wanted to Lie Down and Die": Trafficking and Torture of Eritreans Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking in Persons
in Sudan and Egypt, (Human Rights Watch, 2014), accessed Report: Burundi Country Narrative, (United States Department
04/02/2016:https://www.hrw.org/report/2014/02/11/i-wanted-lie- of State, 2015), accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/docu-
down-and-die/trafficking-and-torture-eritreans-sudan-and-egypt ments/organization/210738.pdf, http://www.state.gov/documents/
67
"Regional Mixed Migration 3rd Quarter Trend Analysis 2015", organization/243558.pdf
Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16: ; see also Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Traffick-
84
"Regional Mixed Migration 2nd Quarter Trend Analysis 2015", ing in Persons Report: Malawi Country Narrative, (United States
Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16:http:// Department of State, 2015), accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.state.
www.regionalmms.org/index897d.html?id=55&tx_ttnews[tt_ gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf
news]=373&cHash=899eab72869f066e34cfa9ff5174ac7d, http:// Government of Rwanda, 'Public Law No Special of 27 of May
85
www.regionalmms.org/index42f9.html?id=55&tx_ttnews%5Btt_ 2009, Law Regulating Labour in Rwanda, 2009', May 27, 2009,
news%5D=345&cHash=be8f0df5525e2408606820daf1bac8b1 accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.ilo.org/dyn/natlex/docs/SERI-
68
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking AL/81725/89012/F-1047050984/RWA-81725.pdf
in Persons Report: Special Case: Somalia, (United States Depart- Benin, Cape Verde, Djibouti, Eritrea, Gabon, Gambia, Lesotho,
86
ment of State, 2015), accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/j/ Malawi, Namibia, Senegal, South Africa, Sudan, Zimbabwe.
tip/rls/tiprpt/countries/2015/243530.htm
Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
87
69
As above. in Persons Report: Benin Country Narrative, (United States Depart-
70
As above. ment of State, 2015), accessed 07/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/
71
"Regional Mixed Migration 1st Quarter Trend Analysis 2015", documents/organization/243558.pdf
Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16: ; see also Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Traffick-
88
"Regional Mixed Migration 3rd Quarter Trend Analysis 2015", ing in Persons Report: Tanzania Country Narrative, (United States
Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16: ; see also Department of State, 2015), accessed 07/04/2016;http://www.state.
"Regional Mixed Migration 2nd Quarter Trend Analysis 2015", gov/documents/organization/243562.pdf
Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16:http://
www.regionalmms.org/index7f47.html?id=55&tx_ttnews[tt_ The Middle East And North Africa
news]=342&cHash=403cac4577afca2ae439c5cc773ae7cd, http://
www.regionalmms.org/index897d.html?id=55&tx_ttnews[tt_ Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights, Conven-
1
news]=373&cHash=899eab72869f066e34cfa9ff5174ac7d, : http:// tion on the Rights of the Child, Committee on the Rights of the
www.regionalmms.org/index42f9.html?id=55&tx_ttnews%5Btt_ Child, 'Concluding observations on the report submitted by Iraq
news%5D=345&cHash=be8f0df5525e2408606820daf1bac8b1 under article 8, paragraph 1, of the Optional Protocol to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of
72
"Regional Mixed Migration 1st Quarter Trend Analysis 2015", children in armed conflict', (United Nations, 2015), p. 5, accessed
Regional Mixed Migration Secretariat, accessed 03/02/16:http:// 12/01/2016:https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/
www.regionalmms.org/index7f47.html?id=55&tx_ttnews[tt_ G15/043/49/PDF/G1504349.pdf ?OpenElement
news]=342&cHash=403cac4577afca2ae439c5cc773ae7cd
Lizzie Dearden, 'Isis Kidnaps up to 500 Children in Iraq to use
2
73
Joe Lee Anderson, 'ISIS Rises in Libya', The New Yorker, August 4, as Suicide Bombers and Child Soldiers,' The Independent, June 1,
2015, accessed 04/02/2016:http://www.newyorker.com/news/news- 2015, accessed 22/07/2015:http://www.independent.co.uk/news/
desk/isis-rises-in-libya world/middle-east/isis-kidnaps-up-to-500-children-in-iraq-to-
74
As above. use-as-suicide-bombers-and-child-soldiers-10288989.html
75
Libya is Full of Cruelty: Stories of Abduction, Violence and Sexual 'Yemen Children Bearing the Brunt of Brutal Conflict', UNICEF,
3
Abuse from Migrants and Refugees, (Amnesty International, 2015), April 10, 2016, accessed 14/04/2016:http://www.unicef.org/media/
p. 11, accessed 04/02/2016:http://www.amnesty.org.uk/sites/de- media_90828.html
fault/files/libya_is_full_of_cruelty.pdf 'Iraq: ISIS Escapees Describe Systematic Rape, Yezidi Survivors
4
76
Child Marriage, Adolescent Pregnancy and Family Formation in in Need of Urgent Care,' Human Rights Watch, April 14, 2015,
Central and West Africa, (United Nations Children's Fund, 2015), accessed 22/07/2015:http://www.hrw.org/news/2015/04/14/
pp. 14–28, accessed 03/02/2016:http://www.unicef.org/wcaro/ iraq-isis-escapees-describe-systematic-rape
english/Child_Mariage_Adolescent_Pregnancy_and_Family_For- 'Islamic State (ISIS) Releases Pamphlet on Female Slaves,' MEMRI's
5
79
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Traf- Al Arabiya, April 18, 2015, accessed 14/04/2016:http://english.
ficking in Persons Report: The Democratic Republic of Congo alarabiya.net/en/perspective/features/2015/04/18/Saudi-Arabia-
Country Narrative, (United States Department of State, 2015), grappling-with-the-surge-in-temporary-marriage.html
accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/coun- Sarah El Masry, 'Under-reported and underage: Early marriage in
8
World News, 14 October 2015,http://www.moroccoworldnews. Husn, The Other Migrant Crisis: Protecting Migrant Workers Against
com/2015/10/170369/over-100000-underage-girls-are-married-in- Exploitation in the Middle East and North Africa, (IOM and the Walk
morocco/ Free Foundation, December 2015), accessed 14/04/2016:https://
Too Young to Wed: The Growing Problem of Child Marriage Among
10 publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_migrant_crisis.pdf
Syrian Girls in Jordan, (Save the Children, 2014), accessed As above.
29
Middle East and North Africa, (IOM and the Walk Free Founda- Arab Republic of Egypt, The People's Assembly,' Law No. (64)
34
tion, December 2015), accessed 14/04/2016: ; see also 'Kenyan of 2010 regarding Combating Human Trafficking'. Available
Domestic Workers 'abused in Saudi Arabia'', BBC, September 1, fromwww.protectionproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/
2015, accessed 14/04/2016: ; see also 'The Aftershocks: Migrant Egypt_TIP-Laws-20082010.pdf
Workers Vulnerable to Exploitation in Post-Earthquake Nepal', 'New draft law to combat human trafficking brings hope in Mo-
35
London School of Economics and Political Science, October 22, rocco,' UN Women, September 9, 2015, accessed 12/04/2016,www.
2015, accessed 13/03/2016:http://www.middleeasteye.net/news/ unwomen.org/en/news/stories/2015/9/new-draft-law-to-combat-
hundreds-mauritanian-women-subject-slave-conditions-sau- human-trafficking-brings-hope-in-morocco
di-arabia-121500465, http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/
MDE22/004/2014/en/7b7121b8-37c1-4e49-b1a1-2d8a005450a3/ Samantha McCormack, Jacqueline Joudo Larsen, Hana Abul
36
mde220042014en.pdf, https://publications.iom.int/system/ Husn, The Other Migrant Crisis: Protecting Migrant Workers Against
files/pdf/other_migrant_crisis.pdf, http://www.bbc.com/ Exploitation in the Middle East and North Africa, (IOM and the Walk
news/world-africa-34121412,, http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/human- Free Foundation, December 2015), accessed 14/04/2016:https://
rights/2015/10/22/the-aftershocks-migrant-workers-vulnera- publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_migrant_crisis.pdf
ble-to-exploitation-in-post-earthquake-nepal-2/ 'Kuwait: New Law a Breakthrough for Domestic Workers,' Human
37
Free Foundation, December 2015), accessed 14/04/2016:https:// into kafala changes (updated),' Doha News, October 27, 2015,
publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_migrant_crisis.pdf accessed 20/04/2016:http://dohanews.co/qatars-emir-approves-
As above.
15 kafala-reforms-changes-more-than-one-year-away/
Personal communication.
16 Robert Booth, 'UN Gives Qatar a Year to End Forced Labour of
40
Free Foundation, December 2015), accessed 14/04/2016:https:// Husn, The Other Migrant Crisis: Protecting Migrant Workers Against
publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_migrant_crisis.pdf Exploitation in the Middle East and North Africa, (IOM and the Walk
Europe; Syrian Asylum Applications from Apr 2011 to Jan 2016,
22 Free Foundation, December 2015), accessed 14/04/2016:https://
Syrian Regional Refugee Response, Inter-Agency Information Sharing publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_migrant_crisis.pdf
Portal, UNHCR, accessed 13/04/2016.
3RP Regional Progress Report June 2015, 3RP Regional Refugee &
23
accessed 14/04/2016:https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2015/
country-chapters/saudi-arabia
haitian-workers-in-dr.htm, http://www.dol.gov/ilab/reports/pd-
Fernando Murillo, Migration and Urbanization Paths: Reshap-
33
f/20130926DR.pdf
ing the Human Geography of Latin America and the Caribbean,
14
Walk Free Foundation and Gallup, 2015 surveys. (International Organization for Migration, 2014), p. 5, accessed
15
Colleen Owens et al., Understanding the Organization, Operation, 21/04/2016:https://www.iom.int/sites/default/files/our_work/ICP/
and Victimization Process of Labor Trafficking in the United States, MPR/WMR-2015-Background-Paper-FMurillo.pdf
(Urban Institute, 2014), p.xi, accessed 21/04/2016: ; see also Clare Ribando Seelke, Trafficking in Persons in Latin America
34
"Home Page", Polaris, last accessed April 21, 2016,http://www. and the Caribbean, (Congressional Research Service, 2015), p. 4,
urban.org/research/publication/understanding-organization-op- accessed 12/04/2016:https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL33200.pdf
eration-and-victimization-process-labor-trafficking-united-states,
Sheldon Zhang, Sex Trafficking in a Border Community: A Field
35
http://polarisproject.org/
Study of Sex Trafficking in Tijuana, Mexico, (San Diego State Univ-
16
Organised Crime and Illegally Mined Gold In Latin America, (Global eristy, 2011), accessed 21/04/2016:https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/
Alliance Against Transnational Organised Crime, 2016), pp. nij/grants/234472.pdf
28–29, accessed 13/05/2016: ; see also Risk Analysis of Indicators of
Personal communication.
36
Forced Labour and Human Trafficking in Illegal Gold Mining in Peru
(Verité, 2013), last accessed 13/05/2016 ; see also International Clare Ribando Seelke, Trafficking in Persons in Latin America
37
Labour Organization, 'Etude transfrontalière sur le travail des and the Caribbean, (Congressional Research Service, 2015), p.4,
enfants dans l’orpaillage.' As cited in A Poisonous Mix: Child Labor, accessed 12/04/2016:https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL33200.pdf
Mercury, and Artisanal Gold Mining in Mali, (Human Rights Watch, Jasmine Garsd, 'In Central America, Human Smugglers
38
and the Caribbean, (Congressional Research Service, 2015), p.4, in Persons Report: United States Country Narrative, (United States
accessed 12/04/2016: ; see also Fact Sheet: Children on the move Department of State, 2015), accessed 03/04/2016:http://www.state.
in Peru, (Terre des Hommes Suisse, 2012), accessed 13/04/2016: gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/2015/index.htm
; see also Risk Analysis of Indicators of Forced Labor and Human Kate Swanson, 'Begging as a path to progress: Indigenous women
54
Trafficking in Illegal Gold Mining in Peru, (Verité, 2014), accessed and children and the struggle for Ecuador's urban spaces'. (Ath-
21/04/2016:https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL33200.pdf, http:// ens, GA: University of Georgia Press, 2010). As cited in Puck,
destination-unknown.org/wp-content/uploads/DU-fact-sheets- G., 'The 'street children' of Latin America,' The Psychologist 28,
South-America-Peru.pdf, http://www.Verité.org/sites/default/files/ (2015), pp. 20–23:https://thepsychologist.bps.org.uk/volume-28/
images/Indicators%20of%20Forced%20Labor%20in%20Gold%20 january-2015/street-children-latin-america
Mining%20in%20Peru_0.pdf
Personal communication.
55
Bradley Myles, 'The town where boys are 'groomed to become
40
pimps'', CNN, December 2, 2015, accessed 21/04/2016: ; see also Smuggling of migrants from the Northern Triangle to the United
56
Nina Lakhani, 'Tenancingo: the small town at the dark heart of States, (United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2012),
Mexico’s sex-slave trade', The Guardian, April 5, 2015, accessed accessed 21/04/2016:https://www.unodc.org/documents/toc/
21/04/2016:http://edition.cnn.com/2015/12/01/opinions/sex-traf- Reports/TOCTASouthAmerica/English/TOCTA_CACaribb_mi-
ficking-tenancingo-polaris/index.html, http://www.theguardian. grantsmuggling_to_US.pdf
com/world/2015/apr/05/tenancingo-mexico-sex-slave-trade-amer- Chen Jiang, 'Forced Prostitution and Modern Slavery: Brazil’s
57
ica', Latin Post, February 15, 2016, accessed 21/04/2016: ; see also October 10, 2015, accessed 21/04/2016: ; see also Sonia Nazario,
Melissa Fleming, 'The other refugee crisis – women on the run 'Outsourcing a Refugee Crisis: U.S. Paid Mexico Millions to Target
from Central America', The Guardian, January 16, 2016, accessed Central Americans Fleeing Violence' Democracy Now, October 13,
21/04/2016:http://www.latinpost.com/articles/115102/20160215/ 2015, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/11/
highest-female-murder-stats-world-logged-latin-america.htm, opinion/sunday/the-refugees-at-our-door.html?_r=0, http://www.
http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-profession- democracynow.org/2015/10/13/outsourcing_a_refugee_crisis_us_
als-network/2016/jan/16/the-other-refugee-crisis-women-on-the- paid
run-from-central-america As above.
60
flee Central America and Mexico', United Nations High Commis- Human Rights Watch, August 8 2015, accessed 21/04/2016: ; see
sioner for Refugees, 28 October, 2015, accessed 21/04/16:http:// also Americas: indigenous people’s long struggle to defend their
www.unhcr.org/5630c2046.html rights in the Americas, (Amnesty International, 2014), accessed
Pamela Constable, ''He forced me many times. I ran away, but he
45 21/04/2016:https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2014/08/
always found me again'', The Washington Post, January 31, 2016, rights-trampled-indigenous-peoples-across-americas/, https://
accessed 21/04/2016:https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/ www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/4000/amr010022014en.
social-issues/he-forced-me-many-times-i-ran-away-but-he-al- pdf
ways-found-me-again/2016/01/31/78209ce2-bafa-11e5-99f3- Americas: indigenous people’s long struggle to defend their rights
62
Individuals', Int Law News, 42, 4 (2014):http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih. Annie Kelly, 'The Faces of Modern Day Slavery', The Guardian,
65
gov/pmc/articles/PMC4204396/ April 13, 2013, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/
Cynthia English and Johanna Godoy, 'Respect and Dignity for
48
global-development/gallery/2013/apr/03/faces-modern-day-slav-
Women Lacking in Latin America', October 14, 2014, accessed ery-in-pictures
21/04/2014:http://www.gallup.com/poll/178427/respect-digni- Victoria Sweet, 'Trafficking in Native Communities', Indian
66
ty-women-lacking-latin-america.aspx Country, May 24, 2015, accessed 21/04/2016:http://indiancountry-
Clare Ribando Seelke, Trafficking in Persons in Latin America and
49
todaymedianetwork.com/2015/05/24/trafficking-native-communi-
the Caribbean, (Congressional Research Service, 2015), p. 4, ac- ties-160475
cessed 12/04/2016:https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL33200.pdf 'Campaigners: Colombia's Displaced 'Highly Vulnerable' to
67
71
Government of Haiti, Public Law No CL/2014–103, 'La Loi Sur Argentina, Barbados, Brazil, Costa Rica, Haiti, Mexico, Nicaragua,
78
la Lutte Contre la Traite de Personnes', June 2, 2014, accessed Panama, United States.http://www.theguardian.com/global-de-
12/04/2016:http://www.healthpolicyproject.com/pubs/740_Hai- velopment/2016/mar/02/brazil-loss-dirty-list-sparks-fears-work-
tiAntiTraffickingLawFINAL.pdf er-exploitation-olympic-games-international-labour-organisation
72
Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
79
in Persons Report: Argentina Country Narrative, (United States in Persons Report: Brazil Country Narrative, (United States Depart-
Department of State, 2015), accessed 12/04/2016:http://www.state. ment of State, 2015), accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/
gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/countries/2015/243384.htm documents/organization/243558.pdf
73
Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Traf-
80
in Persons Report: Paraguay Country Narrative, (United States ficking in Persons Report: United States of America Country
Department of State, 2015), accessed 12/04/2016:http://www.state. Narrative, (United States Department of State, 2015), ac-
gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/countries/2015/243512.htm cessed 21/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/coun-
74
Office to Combat and Monitor Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking tries/2015/243559.htm
in Persons Report: Cuba Country Narrative, (United States Depart- State of California, Bill No 657, 'Transparency in Supply Chains
81
ment of State, 2015), accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.state.gov/ Act', September 30, 2010, accessed 21/04/2016:http://www.leginfo.
documents/organization/243558.pdf ca.gov/pub/09-10/bill/sen/sb_0651-0700/sb_657_bill_20100930_
75
As above. chaptered.pdf
76
As above.
77
Bruce Douglas, 'Brazil: Loss of dirty list sparks fears of worker
exploitation as Olympics near', The Guardian, March 2, 2016,
accessed 12/04/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/global-develop-
ment/2016/mar/02/brazil-loss-dirty-list-sparks-fears-worker-ex-
ploitation-olympic-games-international-labour-organisation
ic Region, (Plan International Australia, July 2014), accessed Qatar', The Phnom Penh Post, September 19, 2015, accessed
07/10/15:https://www.plan.org.au/~/media/plan/documents/ 11/10/15:http://www.phnompenhpost.com/national/abuse-fears-
resources/plan_child_marriage_report_july_2014.pdf ?la=en holding-workers-pact-qatar
Personal communication.
3 Kristi Eaton, 'Maid in Cambodia’ Highlights Skills, Better Wages,'
23
Personal communication.
7
in Cambodia is Far from Over,' Washington Post, May 21, 2015,
Strategic Information Response Network, Mekong Region: Country
8 accessed 09/10/15:https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/
Datasheets: Human Trafficking, (United Nations Inter-Agency Proj- the-fight-against-child-sex-trafficking-in-cambodia-is-far-from-
ect on Human Trafficking, 2010), accessed 10/10/15:http://www. over/2015/05/21/743c8e44-ff19-11e4-805c-c3f407e5a9e9_story.
no-trafficking.org/reports_docs/siren/uniap_2010ht_datasheets. html
pdf Glenn Miles and Heather Blanch, What About Boys? An Initial
26
Working Conditions in Thailand’s Fishing Sector, (ILO Tripartite Chaiyot Yongcharoenchai, 'Young Lives for Sale', Bangkok Post,
28
Action to Protect the Rights of Migrant Workers within and from June 29, 2014, accessed 07/10/15:http://www.bangkokpost.com/
the Greater Mekong Subregion, 2013), accessed 07/05/16:http:// print/417880/
www.ilo.org/dyn/migpractice/docs/184/Fishing.pdf "Residential Care in Cambodia", UNICEF, 2011, accessed
29
uploads/2015/07/SR32-BFC-Final-after-PAC_Eng.pdf
"The World Factbook: Cambodia", Central Intelligence Agency,
32
dle/10986/22699 07/10/15:http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.RUR.TOTL.ZS/
countries/1W-KH?display=graph
Better Factories Cambodia, Better Factories Cambodia: Garment
16
Industry 32nd Compliance Synthesis Report (International Labour "Children’s Rights Monitoring Office", LICADHO, accessed
36
44
Survivor Experiences and Perceptions of Stigma: Reintegrating Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Traffick-
8
into the Community, Working paper: The Butterfuly Longitudinal ing in Persons Report: Dominican Republic Country Narrative,
research Project, (Chab Dai, 2015), accessed 12/12/15:http:// (United States Department of State, 2015), p. 144, accessed
static1.squarespace.com/static/55a81f9be4b01a30079bb- 10/03/2016:http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/243559.
9d3/t/568a1452d8af102bf3eb4d00/1451889758745/Butterfly+Stig- pdf
ma+2015
Personal communication.
9
45
The National Committee for Counter Trafficking,"National Plan of
Personal communication.
10
Action of the National Committee for Counter Trafficking 2014-2018,
(Kingdom of Cambodia, 2014), accessed 05/03/16:http://ncct.gov. United Nations Population Fund Trafficking in Women, Girls and
11
47
As above. Personal communication.
13
48
Charles Rollet, 'Progress Seen On Trafficking', Phnom Penh Post, Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Traffick-
14
August 20, 2015, accessed 03/02/16:http://www.phnompenhpost. ing in Persons Report: Dominican Republic Country Narrative,
com/national/progress-seen-trafficking (United States Department of State, 2015), p. 144, accessed
10/03/2016:http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/243559.
49
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
pdf
In Persons Report: Cambodia Country Narrative,, (United States
Department of State, 2015), accessed 03/02/16:http://www.state. Bureau of International Labor Affairs, Findings on the Worst Forms
15
08/10/15:http://features.hrw.org/features/HRW_2015_reports/
Bureau of International Labor Affairs, Findings on the Worst Forms
22
Cambodia_Garment_Workers/index.html
of Child Labor Report: Dominican Republic, (United States Depart-
58
'Cambodia raises minimum wage for garment workers', BBC News, ment of State, 2014), accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.dol.gov/
accessed 08/10/15:http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-34474397 ilab/reports/child-labor/dom_republic.htm
Government of the Dominican Republic, 'Law no 66-97', article 4,
23
of Child Labor Report: Dominican Republic, (United States Depart- with Drought, Poverty and Lack of Opportunities', Interna-
ment of State, 2014), accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.dol.gov/ tional Organisation for Migration, September 18, 2015, accessed
ilab/reports/child-labor/dom_republic.htm 10/03/2016:https://www.iom.int/news/haitian-migrants-return-
'Busting Sex Tourists in Dominican Republic', Reuters, April
25 ing-dominican-republic-faced-drought-poverty-and-lack-oppor-
1, 2015, accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.newsweek.com/bust- tunities
ing-sex-tourists-dominican-republic-318735 Celso Perez, 'The Dominican Republic’s Tortured Relationship
49
public Expels 'Migrants'', Reuters, September 19, 2015, accessed 'Haitian Migrants Returning from the Dominican Republic Faced
51
al_Report_2014.pdf Trust and American Jewish World Service, last accessed April 6,
2016,https://ajws.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/EarlyChild-
Anastasia Moloney, 'Dominican Republic Busts Child Sex
39
MarriageinIndia_Landscape
Parties to Combat Trafficking', Reuters, April 1, 2015, ac-
cessed 10/03/2016:http://mobile.reuters.com/article/idUSKB- 'The Marriage Bazaar: How Female Foeticide has Made Bride
13
ment of State, 2014), accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.dol.gov/ Guardian, December 17, 2014, accessed 06/04/2016:http://
ilab/reports/child-labor/dom_republic.htm www.theguardian.com/global-development/2014/dec/17/in-
Personal communication.
42 dia-bride-trafficking-foeticide
Personal communication.
43 'Bare branches, redundant males', The Economist, accessed
15
Personal communication.
44 05/04/2016:http://www.economist.com/news/asia/21648715-dis-
torted-sex-ratios-birth-generation-ago-are-changing-mar-
Personal communication.
45
riage-and-damaging-societies-asias
We Are Dominican: Arbitrary Deprivation of Nationality in the
46
India Report to the Committee on the Rights of the Child in advance of
16
Dominican Republic, (Human Rights Watch, 2015), accessed India's initial report on the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the
10/03/2016:https://www.hrw.org/report/2015/07/01/we-are-do- Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict,
minican/arbitrary-deprivation-nationality-dominican-republic (Child Soldiers International, 2013), p.2, accessed 05/04/2016
As above.
47
As above.
17
the Security Council (A/69/926–S/2015/409), (Office of the Special October 21, 2015,http://ncrb.nic.in/StatPublications/CII/CII2014/
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children and Armed Statistics%202014.pdf
Conflict, 2015), accessed 05/04/2016:https://childrenandarmed- Government of India, "Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act
37
conflict.un.org/countries/india/ 1976", accessed 16/09/2014:http://www.childlineindia.org.in/
19
Sanjay Pandey, 'Forcing Children to Fight in India's Restive East', CP-CRDownloads/Bonded%20Labour%20System%20(Aboli-
Al Jazeera, March 22, 2015, accessed 05/04/2016:http://www. tion)%20Act%201976%20and%20Rules.pdf
aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2015/03/forcing-children-fight-in- Silvia Palomba, Sr. Namrata Joseph Cfmss, Modern Slavery in
38
dia-restive-northeast-150315075033994.html India: cases of bonded labour, (Franciscans International, 2012),
20
Table 162: Number and Percentage of Population Below Poverty p. 13, accessed 16/09/2014:http://franciscansinternational.org/
Line, Reserve Bank of India,https://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/Publi- fileadmin/docs/Contemporary_Forms_of_Slavery/Modern_Slav-
cationsView.aspx?id=16603 ery_in_India___Bonded_Labour_Cases_FINAL_17_Sept_2012.
21
Action Aid and Tata Instiute of Social Studies, Making Street pdf
Children Matter A census study in Mumbai City, (Action Aid and "Abolition of Bonded Labour", National Human Rights Commis-
39
Tata Instiute of Social Studies, 2013), accessed 05/04/2016:http:// sion, last accessed September 16, 2014,http://nhrc.nic.in/hrissues.
actionaid.org/sites/files/actionaid/mumbai_street_children_v3.pdf htm#no1
22
National Statistical Survey Organisation, Informal Sector and As above.
40
Conditions of Employment in India, (Government of India 2014), See Statistics 2014,National Crime Records Bureau, p. 60, Table
41
accessed 05/04/2016:http://mospi.nic.in/Mospi_New/upload/ 1.13,http://ncrb.nic.in/StatPublications/CII/CII2014/Statistics%20
nss_report_557_26aug14.pdf 2014.pdf
23
Anuradha Nagaraj, 'India's booming cities built from "blood Silvia Palomba, Sr. Namrata Joseph Cfmss, Modern Slavery in
42
bricks" of bonded labourers', Thomson Reuters Foundation, India: cases of bonded labour, (Franciscans International, 2012),
March 11, 2016, accessed 03/04/2016:http://news.trust.org/ p. 13, accessed 16/09/2014:http://franciscansinternational.org/
item/20160311000331-s5a8y/?source=dpagetopic fileadmin/docs/Contemporary_Forms_of_Slavery/Modern_Slav-
24
On the caste system see for example, Gabriel Domínguez, “Mod- ery_in_India___Bonded_Labour_Cases_FINAL_17_Sept_2012.
ern Slavery Widespread in India”, Deutche Welle,http://www. pdf
dw.com/en/modern-day-slavery-widespread-in-india/a-17180433 "About Us", Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, last
43
25
'Cleaning Human Waste: "Manual Scavenging," Caste, and modified January 27, 2014,http://stophumantrafficking-mha.nic.
Discrimination in India', Human Rights Watch, August 25, 2014, in/forms/Mainlinks.aspx?lid=7
accessed 20/04/2016:https://www.hrw.org/report/2014/08/25/ See for example, Himadri Ghosh, 'West Bengal: The Epicentre
44
cleaning-human-waste/manual-scavenging-caste-and-discrimina- of India's Boom in Sexual Slavery', Scroll.in April 25, 2016, last
tion-india accessed 08/04/2016 ; see also Report of the National Legal Services
26
See for example, the report of Justice Verna, in the aftermath of a Authority Submitted to the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the Writ
gang rape in Delhi that galvanised public opinion and led to re- Petition (C) No. 56/2004 titled Prajwala v. Union of India and Others,
forms of laws: Justice Verna, Justice Seth, G Subramanium, Report page 17. This also reflects personal communications.http://scroll.
of the Committee on Amendments to Criminal Law, (Committee on in/article/807092/west-bengal-the-epicentre-of-indias-boom-in-
Amendments to Criminal Law, 2013), accessed 13/05/2016:http:// sexual-slavery
www.prsindia.org/uploads/media/Justice%20verma%20commit- Victim compensation available for victims of human trafficking
45
tee/js%20verma%20committe%20report.pdf in some states – see Government of India, Response to 6 Monthly
27
"Early and Child Marriage: A Landscape Analysis", Nirantar Update on Response to Modern Slavery - Case Study, (Walk Free
Trust and American Jewish World Service, last accessed April 6, Foundation, 2014), accessed 14/07/2014:http://www.globalslave-
2016,https://ajws.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/EarlyChild- ryindex.org/country/india/
MarriageinIndia_LandscapeAnalysis_SUMMARY.pdf Alex Woods, 'Justice Triumphs! Four Traffickers Convicted in In-
46
28
As above. dia', HuffPost Impact, March 11, 2016, accessed 05/04/2016:http://
29
"Statistics on Labour Migration within the Asia Pacific", Red Cross, www.huffingtonpost.com/free-the-slaves/justice-triumphs-four-
last accessed April 5, 2016,http://www.ifrc.org/Global/Documents/ tra_b_9400846.html
Asia-pacific/201505/Map_Infographic.pdf United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Current Status of
47
30
See for example, Verité, Indian Workers in Domestic Textile Victim Service Providers and Criminal Justice Actors in India on
Production and Middle East-Based Manufacturing, Infrastructure, Anti-Human Trafficking, (United Nations, 2013), p. 36, accessed
and Construction, (Verité, 2010), accessed 06/04/2016: ; see also 14/07/2014:http://www.unodc.org/documents/southasia//reports/
Amnesty International, Exploited Dreams: Dispatches from Indian Human_Trafficking-10-05-13.pdf
migrant workers in Saudi Arabia, (Amnesty International, 2014), See The Suppression of Immoral Traffic in Womenand Girls Act 1956,
48
31
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atroci- Victim Service Providers and Criminal Justice Actors in India on
ties) Act, 1989 (as amended in 2016). Anti-Human Trafficking, (United Nations, 2013), p. 36, accessed
32
'Govt readies domestic workers policy, proposes Rs 9,000 14/07/2014:http://www.unodc.org/documents/southasia//reports/
minimum pay with benefits', F.India, August 17, 2015, accessed Human_Trafficking-10-05-13.pdf
05/04/2016:http://www.firstpost.com/india/govt-readies-do- Government of India, Response to 6 Monthly Update on Response
50
35
Government of India, Response to 6 Monthly Update on Response man trafficking, help victims', Thomson Reuters Foundation,
to Modern Slavery - Case Study, (Walk Free Foundation, 2014), March 10, 2016, accessed 04/04/2016,http://news.trust.org/
accessed 14/07/2014:http://www.globalslaveryindex. org/country/ item/20160310160022-ngwy5/
india/
tween India and Bahrain on Cooperation for Prevention of Human sex tourism', The Telegraph, April 14, 2013, accessed
Trafficking especially trafficking in Women and Children',Ministry 03/04/2016:http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/in-
of Home Affairs, March 10, 2016, accessed 05/04/2016,http://up- dia/9993453/Teenager-exposes-Indias-one-month-wives-sex-tour-
home.gov.in/writereaddata/Portal/Images/MoU.pdf ism.html
"India Says Will Sign Accord with UAE to Stop Human
54
Kamal Saksena, 'Combating Human Trafficking in Uttar Pradesh',
75
Trafficking", The Economic Times, April 13, 2016, accessed Indian Police Service, accessed 04/04/2016:http://uphome.gov.in/
14/04/2016,http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/poli- writereaddata/Portal/Images/AHTI.pdf
tics-and-nation/india-says-will-sign-accord-with-uae-to-stop-hu- "The Uttar Pradesh Victim Compensation Scheme", Government of
76
man-trafficking/articleshow/51812864.cms?from=mdr India, last accessed April 4, 2016,http://uphome.gov.in/writereadd-
In the Supreme Court of India Civil Original Jurisdiction Writ
55
ata/Portal/Images/victim.PDF
Petition (C) No. 56 of 2004 Prajwala… Petitioners vs Union of Kamal Saksena, 'Combating Human Trafficking in Uttar Pradesh',
77
India and Ors… Respondents, Judgement, Justice Anil R Dave, Indian Police Service, accessed 04/04/2016:http://uphome.gov.in/
December 9, 2015). writereaddata/Portal/Images/AHTI.pdf
Bhanupriya Rao, 'Women in the Police Force- Numbers and
56
"Initiatives in Uttar Pradesh: Anti Human Trafficking", October 7,
78
Beyond', Factly, August 19, 2015,https://factly.in/women-in-the- 2015, last accessed April 3, 2016,http://stophumantrafficking-mha.
police-force-numbers-beyond/ nic.in/writereaddata/Uttar%20Pradesh.pptx
Elizabeth Donger and Jacqueline Bhabha, Is this Protection?
57
"Operation Smile: Cracking the puzzle of missing children", India
79
Analyzing India's Approach to the Rescue and Reintegration of Today, November 17, 2014, accessed 03/03/2016:http://indiatoday.
Children Trafficked for Labour Exploitation, (FXB Center for Health intoday.in/story/operation-smile-missing-children-ghaziabad-po-
and Human Rights at Harvard University, 2016), p. 12, accessed lice/1/401187.html
05/04/2016:https://cdn2.sph.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/
sites/5/2016/03/Is-this-Protection-Final.pdf Kamal Saksena, 'Combating Human Trafficking in Uttar Pradesh',
80
and Christian Dalits are not included in these figures. India Brand Equity Foundation, last accessed 06/04/2016:http://
"India: Official Dalit Population Exceeds 200 Million", In-
63 www.ibef.org/states/bihar-presentation
ternational Dalit Solidarity Network, May 29, 2013, accessed Ginny Baumann, Rohit Dwivedi and Paras Jha, Modern Slavery
84
03/04/2016:http://idsn.org/india-official-dalit-population-ex- Landscape in the State of Bihar, India, (The Global Fund to End
ceeds-200-million/ Slavery, 2014), p. 28.
"Initiatives in Uttar Pradesh: Anti Human Trafficking", October 7,
64
"Census of India 2011", Census 2011, last accessed April 3,
85
June 11, 2015, accessed 02/04/2016:http://www.thehindu.com/ Landscape in the State of Bihar, India, (The Global Fund to End
news/national/cry-releases-report-on-child-labourers-in-india/ Slavery, 2014), p. 28.
article7305797.ece "Crimes against Persons Belonging to SCs/STc," National Crime
88
As above.
67
Records Bureau, 2011.
"Census 2011", Ministry of Labour and Employment, last accessed
68
Rajiv Gandhi Institute for Contemporary Studies, A report on crime
89
April 2, 2016,http://labour.gov.in/upload/uploadfiles/files/Divi- against women in Bihar, (Rajiv Gandhi Institute for Contemporary
sions/childlabour/Census-2001%262011.pdf Studies, 2011), accessed April 3, 2016,http://www.rgics.org/test/
'Indian Town Where Glass-Making is a Household Craft', Al
69 wp-content/uploads/2013/11/Crime-Against-Women-In-Bihar.pdf
Jazeera, February 13, 2015, accessed 02/04/2016:http://www. Ginny Baumann, Rohit Dwivedi and Paras Jha, Modern Slavery
90
aljazeera.com/indepth/inpictures/2015/02/indian-town-glass- Landscape in the State of Bihar, India, (The Global Fund to End
making-household-craft-150209200924438.html Slavery, 2014), p. 37.
'India: Official Dalit population exceeds 200 million', International
70
'14 Minors Rescued from Jacket Factory', The Times of India,
91
Dalit Solidarity Network, May 29, 2013, accessed 02/04/2016:http:// September 9, 2015, accessed 04/04/2016,http://timesofindia.india-
idsn.org/india-official-dalit-population-exceeds-200-million/ times.com/city/ludhiana/14-minors-rescued-from-jacket-factory/
The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and Their
71 articleshow/48879345.cms
Rehabilitation Act, 2013 '16 children rescued from bangle-making unit in Jaipur', Hindustan
92
than factory', Business Standard, January 5, 2016, accessed blind eye'", The Indian Express, March 17, 2014, last accessed
05/04/2016:http://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/ 05/04/2016:http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/mathadi-
child-labourers-from-bihar-up-rescued-from-rajasthan-facto- unions-run-amok-as-police-turn-a-blind-eye/
ry-116010500366_1.html Walk Free Foundation, Modern Slavery in Maharashtra: Under-
115
95
'Bengaluru: 8 Bihari Minors Rescued from Bonded Labor', India standing the problem and existing responses 2014 (draft), (Walk Free
Today, February 2, 2016, accessed 05/04/2016:http://indiatoday. Foundation, 2015), p. 3, accessed 05/04/2016
intoday.in/story/bengaluru-8-bihari-minors-rescued-from-bond- As above.
116
ed-labor/1/585338.html
Surendra P Gangan, 'Now, Maharashtra domestic workers to get
117
96
Ginny Baumann, Rohit Dwivedi and Paras Jha, Modern Slavery benefits of minimum wages act', Hindustan Times, August 29, 2013,
Landscape in the State of Bihar, India, (The Global Fund to End accessed 05/04/2016:http://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai/
Slavery, 2014). now-maharashtra-domestic-workers-to-get-benefits-of-mini-
97
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Current Status of Vic- mum-wages-act/story-W69wX4CrZVqMpuZBTEdN7H.html
tim Service Providers and Criminal Justice Actors in India on Anti Hu- "Exceptional Work done by Anti Human Trafficking Units",
118
man Trafficking, United Nations, 2013), accessed 04/04/2016:http:// Anti Human Trafficking Unit Maharashtra, last accessed
www.unodc.org/documents/southasia/reports/Human_Traffick- 05/04/2016:http://www.icds-wcd.nic.in/trafficking/CAC%20pdf/
ing-10-05-13.pdf Presentation%20by%20Maharastra%20Police%20AHTU.pdf
98
"Bihar launches operation against child trafficking", Yahoo, As above.
119
January 1, 2015, accessed 04/04/2016:https://in.news.yahoo.com/
bihar-launches-operation-against-child-trafficking-152404085. Rohit Alok, 'No headway by Mumbai police in human traf-
120
html ficking cases', The Indian Express, January 31, 2016, accessed
05/04/2016:http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/no-
99
"Maharashtra Population Census", Census 2011, last accessed headway-by-mumbai-police-in-human-trafficking-cases/
April 4, 2016,http://www.census2011.co.in/census/state/maharash-
tra.html As above.
121
100
"Industrial Development and Economic Growth in Uttar Pradesh", Shiv Sahay Singh, 'West Bengal, Maharashtra ink pact on
122
India Brand Equity Foundation, last accessed 06/04/2016:http:// victims of human trafficking', The Hindu, June 3, 2014, accessed
www.ibef.org/states/bihar-presentation 05/04/2016:http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/
west-bengal-maharashtra-ink-pact-on-victims-of-trafficking/arti-
101
"Maharashtra Population Census data 2011", Census 2011, last cle6075890.ece
accessed 05/04/2016:http://www.census2011.co.in/census/state/
maharashtra.html As above.
123
102
"Population of Mumbai", India Online Pages, last accessed April 5, Saurav Roy, 'Five states to jointly fight human trafficking',
124
slowly learn they have rights', Thomson Reuters Foundation, Jihad and Terrorism Threat Monitor, December 4, 2014, accessed
March 22, 2016, accessed 05/04/2016:http://news.trust.org/ 25/07/15:http://www.memrijttm.org/islamic-state-isis-releases-
item/20160322010257-wtcxt/ pamphlet-on-female-slaves.html
113
Walk Free Foundation, Modern Slavery in Maharashtra: Under- Personal communication.
11
standing the problem and existing responses 2014 (draft), (Walk Free
Foundation, 2015), p. 4, accessed 05/04/2016
other in Iraq Conflict', Human Rights Watch, October 30, 2015, on the Rights of the Child, Committee on the Rights of the Child: Con-
accessed 12/01/16: ; see also, Office of the High Commissioner cluding observations on the report submitted by Iraq under article 8,
on Human Rights, Convention on the Rights of the Child, Committee paragraph 1, of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights
on the Rights of the Child: Concluding observations on the report of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict, (United
submitted by Iraq under article 8, paragraph 1, of the Option- Nations, 2015), p. 5, accessed 12/01/16:https://documents-dds-ny.
al Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G15/043/49/PDF/G1504349.pd-
involvement of children in armed conflict, (United Nations, 2015) f ?OpenElement
p. 4, accessed 12/01/16:http://www.hrw.org/news/2015/10/30/ Personal communication.
29
no-childs-play-kids-fighting-one-another-iraq-conflict, https://
documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G15/043/49/PDF/ Josh Halliday, 'Female Jihadis Publish Guide to Life Under Islamic
30
of Ministers' Decision in April 2015 instructed ministries and Walk Free have chosen to use the term IS (Islamic State) recog-
32
state institutions that the PMC should be considered a formal in- nising the group are known by different terms, including, but not
stitution under the Prime Minister's Office (PMO). PMF are often limited to, Daesh, ISIL (Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant), ISIS
referred to as pro-government militias, despite their formalisation. (Islamic State in Iraq and Syria), and ISWK (Islamic State Wilayat
International Organizations have questioned the control PMO has Khorasan, also ISIL-K).
over the PMF. There are also many groups fighting under the PMF "Displacement Tracking Matrix, Round XXVIII", International
33
label. Organization for Migration, 2015, accessed 21/02/16:
Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights, Convention
14
Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, 2015 Iraq
34
on the Rights of the Child, Committee on the Rights of the Child: Con- Humanitarian Response Plan Overview: Iraq on the Brink, (United
cluding observations on the report submitted by Iraq under article 8, Nations, 2015), p. 2, accessed 21/02/16:https://docs.unocha.org/
paragraph 1, of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights sites/dms/Iraq/iraq_hrp_overview.pdf
of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict, (United
Nations, 2015), p. 5, accessed 12/01/16:https://documents-dds-ny. Rania Abouzeid, 'Out of Sight', The New Yorker, October 5,
35
as Suicide Bombers and Child Soldiers', The Independent, 1 June, umentation for the Displaced in Iraq', Humanitarian Practice
2015, accessed 22/07/15:http://www.independent.co.uk/news/ Network, 2015, accessed 21/02/16:http://odihpn.org/magazine/
world/middle-east/isis-kidnaps-up-to-500-children-in-iraq-to- identity-crisis-documentation-for-the-displaced-in-iraq
use-as-suicide-bombers-and-child-soldiers-10288989.html Special Feature: The Crisis in Iraq Number 65, (Humanitarian
37
Personal communication.
16 Exchange, Humanitarian Practice Network), p. 5, November 2015.
Personal communication.
17 2014 Global Slavery Index, (Walk Free Foundation, 2014), p. 27, ac-
38
cessed 21/02/2016:http://www.globalslaveryindex.org/download/
Personal communication.
18
Laura Lungarotti, Sarah Craggs, Agnes Tillinac, 'Trafficking in
39
Omar Jaffal, "Underage Marriage of Iraqi Girls Rises", Al-Monitor,
19
Persons in Times of Crises – A Neglected Protection Concern: The
2012, accessed 22/07/15:http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/ar/cul- Case of Iraq', Humanitarian Policy Group of the Overseas Develop-
ture/2012/12/the-underage-marriage-crisis-in-iraq.html# ment Institute, October 2015, available at:http://odihpn.org/maga-
Personal communication.
20
zine/human-trafficking-in-crises-a-neglected-protection-concern/
Miriam Puttick, The Lost Women of Iraq: Family-based violence
21
As above.
40
during armed conflict, (Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights and Julia St. Thomas King and Dennis Ardis, 'Identity Crisis? Doc-
41
Minority Rights Group International, 2015) p. 25, accessed umentation for the Displaced in Iraq', Humanitarian Practice
22/07/15:http://minorityrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/ Network, October 2015, accessed 21/02/16:http://odihpn.org/mag-
MRG-report-A4_OCTOBER-2015_WEB.pdf azine/identity-crisis-documentation-for-the-displaced-in-iraq/
As above, p. 21.
22
As above.
42
Personal communication.
23
As above.
43
pdf Iraqi Penal Code (1969) Act No. 111, Article 398, accessed
47
paragraph 1, of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights, Convention
49
of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict, (United on the Rights of the Child, Committee on the Rights of the Child: Con-
Nations, 2015), p. 3, accessed 12/01/16:https://documents-dds-ny. cluding observations on the report submitted by Iraq under article 8,
un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G15/043/49/PDF/G1504349.pd- paragraph 1, of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights
f ?OpenElement of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict, (United
Minority Rights Group International, Istifhal thahirat zawaj
27
Nations, 2015), p. 3, accessed 12/01/16:https://documents-dds-ny.
al-qasirat fi al-'iraq', 30 August 2013, as cited in Miriam Puttick, un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G15/043/49/PDF/G1504349.pd-
The Lost Women of Iraq: Family-based violence during armed conflict, f ?OpenElement
(Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights and Minority Rights Group "Iraq", Office of the Special Representative of the Security-General
50
International, 2015), p. 24,http://minorityrights.org/wp-content/ for Children and Armed Conflict, last accessed June 21, 2015,https://
uploads/2015/11/MRG-report-A4_OCTOBER-2015_WEB.pdf childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/countries/iraq/
will be able to access the shelter. in Persons Report: Mauritania Country Narrative, (United States
60
Samantha McCormack, Jacqueline Joudo Larsen, and Hana Department of State, 2015), p. 241, accessed 2/10/15:, see also,
Abul Husn, The Other Migrant Crisis: Protecting Migrant Workers Equality Now, Protecting the Girl Child: Using the Law to End Child,
against Exploitation in the Middle East, (International Organisa- Early and Forced Marriages and Other Human Rights Violations,
tion for Migration and Walk Free Foundation, 2015), accessed (Equality Now, 2014), p. 43, accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.state.
17/02/16:https://publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_mi- gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf, http://www.equalitynow.
grant_crisis.pdf org/sites/default/files/Protecting_the_Girl_Child.pdf
61
Personal communication. As above.
9
62
Samantha McCormack, Jacqueline Joudo Larsen, and Hana Anti-Slavery International, Thematic report on slavery in Mauritania
10
Abul Husn, The Other Migrant Crisis: Protecting Migrant Workers for the UN Human Rights Committee, 107th session, 11–28 March
against Exploitation in the Middle East, (International Organisa- 2013. Adoption of the List of Issues on the initial report of Maurita-
tion for Migration and Walk Free Foundation, 2015), accessed nia, Anti-Slavery International, (United Nations Office of the High
17/02/16:https://publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/other_mi- Commissioner for Human Rights, 2013), accessed 10/03/2016
grant_crisis.pdf As above.
11
63
'PM Al-Abadi Calls for Considering Child Recruitment as a Crime 'Mauritanian Women Kept as Slaves in Saudi Arabia', International
12
against Humanity', Prime Minister's Office, June 15, 2015, accessed Trade Union Confederation, September 24, 2015, aacessed 10/03/16:
27/07/15:http://pmo.iq/pme/press2015en/15-6-20152en.htm
Jeroen Beirnaert, 'Stop the Trafficking of Mauritanian Women
13
64
Christoph Wilcke, 'No Child's Play: Kids Fighting One Another to Saudi Arabia', Equal Times, September 22, 2015, accessed
in Iraq Conflict', Human Rights Watch, October 30, 2015, accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.equaltimes.org/stop-the-trafficking-of#.
12/01/16:http://www.hrw.org/news/2015/10/30/no-childs-play- Vgt3Jsuqqko
kids-fighting-one-another-iraq-conflict
Human Rights Council, Report of the Special Rapporteur on
14
65
Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights, Convention Contemporary Forms of Slavery, Including its Causes and Conse-
on the Rights of the Child, Committee on the Rights of the Child: Con- quences, (United Nations General Assembly, 2010), accessed
cluding observations on the report submitted by Iraq under article 8, 10/09/14:http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/slavery/rappor-
paragraph 1, of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights teur/docs/A.HRC.15.20.Add.2_en.pdf
of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict, (United
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
15
Nations, 2015), p. 2, accessed 12/01/16:https://documents-dds-ny.
in Persons Report: Mauritania Country Narrative, (United States
un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G15/043/49/PDF/G1504349.pd-
Department of State, 2014), p. 268, accessed 22/07/14:http://www.
f ?OpenElement
state.gov/documents/organization/226847.pdf
66
Iraqi High Tribunal Act No. 10 (2005) article 13, accessed
Personal communication.
16
27/07/15:http://gjpi.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/iraqstatu-
teengtrans.pdf Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
17
Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism, istrative, Police and Justice Systems, (Anti-Slavery International,
racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, (United 2013), p. 4, accessed 22/09/14 via personal communication
Nations General Assembly, 2013), p. 4, accessed 10/03/2016:http:// 'Mauritania creates new courts to try slavery cases,' Daily Mail
42
www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Racism/A-HRC-26-49.pdf Australia, December 12, 2015, accessed 01/04/2016:http://www.
"Poverty and Equity Data", The World Bank, accessed
23
dailymail.co.uk/wires/afp/article-3356335/Mauritania-cre-
10/03/2016:http://povertydata.worldbank.org/poverty/region/SSA ates-new-courts-try-slavery-cases.html
'IOM Combats Food Insecurity in Mauritania', Internation-
24
Human Rights Council, Report of the Special Rapporteur on
43
al Organisation for Migration, September 22, 2015, accessed Contemporary Forms of Slavery, Including its Causes and Conse-
10/03/2016:https://www.iom.int/news/iom-combats-food-insecu- quences, (United Nations General Assembly, 2010), accessed
rity-mauritania 10/09/14:http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/slavery/rappor-
Bureau of Labor Affairs, Findings on the Worst Forms of Child Labor
25 teur/docs/A.HRC.15.20.Add.2_en.pdf
Report (United States Department of Labor, 2014), p. 2, accessed 'Mauritania becomes the second African country to commit to
44
racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, (United Jazeera, June 19, 2014, accessed 05/09/14:http://m.aljazeera.com/
Nations General Assembly, 2013), p. 4, accessed 10/03/2016:http:// story/201461874846807471
www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Racism/A-HRC-26-49.pdf 'Biram Dah Abeid Still Imprisoned: Latest Developments', Unrep-
46
HCR, accessed 02/10/15:http://www.unhcr.org/pages/49e486026. Human Rights Council, Report of the Special Rapporteur on
50
html Contemporary Forms of Slavery, Including its Causes and Con-
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
31
sequences (United Nations General Assembly, 2010), accessed
in Persons Report: Mauritania Country Narrative, (United States 10/09/14:http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/slavery/rappor-
Department of State, 2015), p. 242, accessed 2/10/15:http://www. teur/docs/A.HRC.15.20.Add.2_en.pdf
state.gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf John D Sutter, 'Slavery's Last Stronghold', The CNN Freedom Proj-
51
in Persons Report: Mauritania Country Narrative, (United States Mexico, (United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2014),
Department of State, 2015), p. 242, accessed 2/10/15:http://www. accessed 02/04/16:https://www.unodc.org/documents/mexicoand-
state.gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf centralamerica/Diagnostico_trata_de_personas.pdf
istrative, Police and Justice Systems, (Anti-Slavery International, ing in Persons Report: Mexico Country Narrative, (United States
2013), p. 4, accessed 22/09/14 via personal communication Department of State, 2015), p. 244, accessed 02/02/16:http://www.
state.gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf
John D. Sutter, 'Slavery's Last Stronghold', The CNN Freedom Proj-
37
ect, March 17, 2012:http://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2012/03/ Ioan Grillo, 'The Mexican Drug Cartels’ Other Business: Sex Traf-
3
state.gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf Templar, Barrio Azteca, BLO, Tijuana, Juarez, Sinaloa, Gulf, and
EPR.
Creating a National Agency for the Fight Against the Legacy of
39
Slavery, (National Commission for Human Rights in Mauritania, Mexico’s Disappeared: The Enduring Cost of a Crisis Ignored,
5
March 21, 2013), accessed 05/09/14:http://www.cndh.mr/content/ (Human Rights Watch, 2013), pp. 20–30, accessed 03/02/16:http://
view/180/1/ www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/reports/mexico0213_ForUp-
load_0_0_0.pdf
'UN Expert Urges Mauritania to Take More Vigorous Efforts to
40
Eliminate Slavery', United Nations News Centre, February 27, 2014, Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Traffick-
6
accessed: 05/09/14:http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?News- ing in Persons Report: Mexico Country Narrative, (United States
ID=47243#.VAltsfmSzUw Department of State, 2015), pp. 243-244, accessed 02/02/16:http://
www.state.gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf
Labor Camps', Insight Crime, July 15, 2013: and Mexico’s at Garment Factory', ABC News, February 6, 2015, accessed
Disappeared: The Enduring Cost of a Crisis Ignored (Human 06/02/16:http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-02-06/mexico-res-
Rights Watch, 2013), pp. 20–30, acessed 03/02/16:http://www. cues-129-workers-from-factory/6075492
insightcrime.org/news-briefs/criminal-groups-enslaving-mexi- Personal communication.
28
cans-in-forced-labor-camps, http://www.hrw.org/sites/default/
files/reports/mexico0213_ForUpload_0_0_0.pdf Katy Watson, 'Maids in Mexico: Defending the Rights of Domestic
29
http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2013/06/30/actuali- Ring', The Huffington Post, February 29, 2012: ; See also: 'Women
dad/1372556638_992102.html Held in Mexico-to-Ireland’ Adoption Racket', MSNBC, July 17,
9
Anel Hortensia and Gomes San Luis, 'Prostitution of Young Girls 2012, accessed 01/04/16:http://www.huffingtonpost.com/erin-sie-
and Adolescents: an Approach to Their Social Representation gal/mexico-adoption-child-trafficking_b_1311404.html, http://
Among Traders o' ʻLa Merced'', Peninsula 9, no.2, (August 2014), www.nbcnews.com/id/46020446/ns/world_news-americas/t/wom-
accessed 04/03/16:http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?pid=S1870 en-held-mexico-to-ireland-adoption-racket/#.U_NnCvmSyAV
-57662014000200006&script=sci_arttext Carolin Schurr and Laura Perler, ''Trafficked’ into a Better
32
10
Christina Sterbenz, 'City-to-Farm Sex Pipelines Expose a Disturb- Future? Why Mexico Needs to Regulate its Surrogacy Industry
ing Trend in America', Business Insider, February 7, 2015, accessed (and Not Ban It)', Open Democracy, December 17, 2015, accessed
04/02/16:http://www.businessinsider.com.au/city-to-farm-sex- 03/03/16:https://www.opendemocracy.net/beyondslavery/car-
pipeline-2015-2 olin-schurr-laura-perler/trafficked-into-better-future-why-mexi-
co-needs-to-regulate
11
Judith Matloff, 'Brothel State in Mexico is Conduit for Human
Trafficking in New York', Al Jazeera America, June 1, 2015, ac- 'Tabasco lawmakers end foreign surrogacy', Mexico News Daily,
33
16
'Mexico Rescues 275 Workers From ‘Slavery’ At Tomato Plant Mexico, (United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2014),
in Toliman', Agence France Presse, June 13, 2013, accessed accessed 02/04/16:https://www.unodc.org/documents/mexicoand-
04/02/16:http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/12/mexi- centralamerica/Diagnostico_trata_de_personas.pdf
co-workers-slavery-toliman_n_3427120.html?ir=Australia Arun Kumar Acharya, 'Sexual Exploitation and Trafficking of
37
17
Richard Marosi, 'Hardship on Mexico’s Farms, a Bounty for Women and Girls in Mexico: An Analysis on Impact of Violence
U.S. Tables', Los Angeles Times, December 7, 2014, accessed on Health Status', Journal of Intercultural Studies 35 no.1 (March
04/02/16:http://graphics.latimes.com/product-of-mexico-camps/ 2014), p. 189, accessed 02/03/16:http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/
18
Namely, Sinaloa, Sonora, Baja California, Baja California Sur, pdf/10.1080/07256868.2014.885414
Chihuahua, Guanajuato, Zacatecas, Jalisco, Nayarit, Colima, San 'Mexico’s Disappeared: The Enduring Cost of a Crisis Ignored',
38
Luis Potosí, Querétaro, Veracruz, Morelos, Hidalgo, Michoacán, (Human Rights Watch, 2013), pp. 20–30, accessed 06/02/16:http://
Mexico State and Chiapas www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/reports/mexico0213_ForUp-
19
'More Farm Labourers Working as Slaves, Mexico News Daily, load_0_0_0.pdf
March 24, 2015, accessed 04/02/16:http://mexiconewsdaily.com/ Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons ,Traffick-
39
22
'Human Trafficking and Farmworkers', Freedom Network USA, Cooperation: The Merida Initiative and Beyond, (Congressional
March 2013; See also: "Who are guestworkers?", National Guest- Research Service, 2016), p. 1, accessed 05/03/16:http://fas.org/sgp/
worker Alliance, 2013:http://freedomnetworkusa.org/wp-content/ crs/row/R41349.pdf
uploads/2012/05/Farmworkers-FINAL-1.pdf, http://www.guest- Personal communication.
42
23
Stephen Stock and David Paredes, 'Child Labor: Young Hands Quadratin Veracruz, October 25, 2015, accessed 05/03/16:https://
Picking Our Food', NBC Bay Area Investigative Unit, August 31, veracruz.quadratin.com.mx/Rescata-PGJDF-a-27-victimas-de-tra-
2012, accessed 06/02/16:http://www.nbcbayarea.com/investiga- ta-en-colonia-Cuauhtemoc/
tions/series/children-in-the-field/Children-in-the-Field-Picking- Heriberto Santos, 'Condenan a Cuatro Personas por Ex-
44
Our-Food-164796976.html plotación Laboral en Edome', El Milenio, June 15, 2014 accessed
24
Sheldon Zhang, Looking for a Hidden Population: Trafficking of 04/02/16:http://www.milenio.com/estados/explotacion_lab-
Migrant Laborers in San Diego County, (San Diego State University, oral-condenan_a_cuatro_personas_en_Edomex-trata_de_perso-
2012), p. 11, accessed 05/02/16:https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/ nas_0_317968408.html
nij/grants/240223.pdf Personal communication.
45
25
As above, p. 12. Programa Nacional para Prevenir, Sancionar y Erradicar los Delitos
46
26
'Mexico – Country Mining Guide', (KPMG International, 2013), en Materia de Trata de Personas y Para la Protección y Asistencia
p. 17, accessed 06/02/16:http://www.kpmg.com/Ca/en/industry/ a las Víctimas de Estos Delitos 2014–2018, (Mexico Secretary of
Mining/Documents/Mexico.pdf the Interior, 2014), p. 28, accessed 16/02/16:http://sn.dif.gob.mx/
wp-content/uploads/2014/05/PROGRAMANacionalPrevenirSan-
cionarErradicarDelitosTrataPersonas2014-2018.pdf
(Human Rights Watch, 2013), p. 3, accessed 04/02/16: ; see also lem in Poland and in the World, (Nobody's Children Foundation,
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking 2012), accessed 22/01/2016,
in Persons Report: Mexico Country Narrative (United States Depart- Ministry of the Interior, Implementation of the National Action Plan,
22
ment of State, 2015), p. 271, accessed 04/02/16:http://www.hrw. (Ministry of the Interior, 2014) cited in Zbigniew Lasocik et al.,
org/sites/default/files/reports/mexico0213_ForUpload_0_0_0.pdf, ; see also Country Strategy Report: Modern Slavery Landscape in
http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/243560.pdf Poland 2014, (Walk Free, 2014), p.16, accessed 24/01/2016.
'IOM Works with Puerto Vallarta, Mexico to Combat Child Traf-
48
Unit Against Trafficking in Human Beings Trafficking in Human
23
ficking', International Organisation for Migration, October 24, 2014, Beings, (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), pp.6–7, accessed
accessed 09/02/16:https://www.iom.int/news/iom-works-puer- 25/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/other-docu-
to-vallarta-mexico-combat-child-trafficking;nmm ments/6826,Trafficking-Human-Beings-2014-report.html
Personal communication.
49
W. A. Kusek and N. Wise, 'Artistic Perceptions of Poles in
24
Human Trafficking Crisis', The Guardian, February 4, 2016 20.9% in 2015. Youth unemployment rate is the number of
26
As above.
10
Successful European Union Citizens and Disadvantaged Labour
As above.
11 Migrants?', Work, Employment and Society, 25, 540 (2011) cited in
Gabriella Albertia, Jane Holgatea and Maite Tapiab, 'Organising
The cost of accommodation and transport is then deducted from
12
Migrants as Workers or as Migrant Workers? Intersectionality,
their wages upon arrival, see Unit Against Trafficking in Human Trade Unions and Precarious Work,' The International Journal of
Beings, Trafficking in Human Beings, (Ministry of the Interior, Human Resource Management, 24, 22: 4133 (2013).
2015), p. 10, accessed 25/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/
hle/database/other-documents/6826,Trafficking-Human-Be- Marcin Piatkowski, 'How Poland Became Europe's Growth
31
Human Beings, (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), p. 6, accessed indicated that five out of 100 foreigners faced unequal in Warsaw
25/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/other-docu- but that figure was up to four times that in other cities. Joanna
ments/6826,Trafficking-Human-Beings-2014-report.html Fomina, 'Ukrainians in Poland: In Pursuit of a Better Life?', New
As above.
18 Eastern Europe, July 15, 2015, accessed 22/01/2016:http://newea-
sterneurope.eu/articles-and-commentary/1815-ukrainians-in-po-
As above.
19
land-in-pursuit-of-a-better-life
As above.
20
International Migrants: A Relational Human Resource Manage- of the 'National Action Plan Against Trafficking in Human Beings
ment Perspective', The International Journal of Human Resource for 2013–2015' for 2014, (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), p.39,
Management, 24, 22, 4125 (2013). accessed 27/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/
36
Adam Leszczyński, 'Poles Don't Want Immigrants. They Don't national-action-plan/6366,The-National-Action-Plan-against-
Understand Them, Don't Like Them', The Guardian, July 2, 2015, Trafficking-in-Human-Beings-for-2013-2015.html
accessed 22/01/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/ Zbigniew Lasocik et al., "Country Strategy Report: Modern Slav-
54
37
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 2016
'Country Notes: Recent Changes in Migration Movements and Group of Experts on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings,
56
Policies', in International Migration Outlook 2015, (OECD Publish- Report Concerning the Implementation of the Council of Europe
ing, 2015), 236,http://www.keepeek.com/Digital-Asset-Manage- Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings by Po-
ment/oecd/social-issues-migration-health/international-migra- land", (Council of Europe, 2013), p. 38, accessed 10/03/14:http://
tion-outlook-2015_migr_outlook-2015-en www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/trafficking/Docs/Reports/GRE-
38
Matthew Luxmoore, "In Poland, a Challenge to Integrate ‘Invisible' TA_2013_6_FGR_POL_with_comments_en.pdf
Ukrainian Refugees", Aljazeera America, August 23, 2015, ac- Interview with Human Trafficking Studies Centre, February 4th,
57
cessed 21/01/16:http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2015/8/23/ 2016
poland-integrates-invisible-refugees-east-ukraine.html
Government of Poland, Progress Report, (Walk Free Foundation,
58
39
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 2014), accessed 01/09/14:http://www.globalslaveryindex.org/
'Country Notes: Recent Changes in Migration Movements and country/poland/
Policies', in International Migration Outlook 2015, (OECD Publish-
ing, 2015), 236,http://www.keepeek.com/Digital-Asset-Manage- The penal code was amended with the addition of "at work or in
59
41
Interview with Human Trafficking Studies Centre, February 4th, Human Beings," (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), p. 5, accessed
2016 25/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/other-docu-
ments/6826,Trafficking-Human-Beings-2014-report.html
42
Joanna Fomina, 'Ukrainians in Poland: In Pursuit of a Better Life?',
New Eastern Europe, July 15, 2015, accessed 05/02/2016:http:// Zbigniew Lasocik, Emilia Rekosz-Cebula, Łukasz Wieczorek, "Hu-
62
Knowledge, Cooperation and Exchange of Information in Estonia, erence for charging defendants with crimes such as deprivation
Finland and Poland, eds. Anniina Jokinen, Natalia Ollus and Kau- of liberty or falsifying documents rather than human traffick-
ko Aromaa (Warsaw: Heuni, 2011), 172, accessed 06/03/14:http:// ing. Reasons for this include the complexity of trafficking cases
www.heuni.fi/material/attachments/heuni/reports/6KmRLQd2d/ and the reduced chance of a success. Zbigniew Lasocik, Emilia
HEUNI_report_68_netti.pdf Rekosz-Cebula, Łukasz Wieczorek, Human Trafficking for Forced
Labour in Poland: Effective Prevention and Diagnostics of Mech-
44
International Labour Organisation, Project Brief: Elimination of anisms, (Council of the Baltic Sea States, 2014), p.47, accessed
Human Trafficking from Moldova and Ukraine through Labour Market 22/01/2016:http://www.cbss.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/
Based Measures, (International Labour Organisation, 2008), 1. raport_polish_english_ONLINE.pdf
45
Maxim Tucker, 'Sex, Lies and Psychological Scars: Inside Ukraine's A representative of the labour inspectorate reported that only five
64
Human Trafficking Crisis', The Guardian, February 4, 2016, cases of suspected forced labour had been referred to the public
accessed 05/02/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/global-devel- prosecutor's office in recent years. Zbigniew Lasocik, Emilia
opment/2016/feb/04/sex-lies-psychological-scars-ukraine-hu- Rekosz-Cebula, Łukasz Wieczorek, Human Trafficking for Forced
man-trafficking-crisis Labour in Poland: Effective Prevention and Diagnostics of Mech-
46
Field sources. anisms, (Council of the Baltic Sea States, 2014), p. 46, accessed
47
Ministry of the Interior and KCIK, Report on the Implementation 22/01/2016:http://www.cbss.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/
of the 'National Action Plan Against Trafficking in Human Beings raport_polish_english_ONLINE.pdf
for 2013–2015' for 2014, (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), p. 14, As part of the NAP (2013-2015) the government of Poland in-
65
accessed 27/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/ creased its efforts to train officials in the identification of victims
national-action-plan/6366,The-National-Action-Plan-against- and human trafficking in general. However it is unclear if this
Trafficking-in-Human-Beings-for-2013-2015.html included adequate information on forced labour. Ministry of the
48
As above. Interior and KCIK, Report on the Implementation of the 'National
Action Plan Against Trafficking in Human Beings for 2013–2015'
49
As above. for 2014, (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), pp. 23–26, accessed
50
Ministry of the Interior and KCIK, Report on the Implementation 27/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/national-
of the 'National Action Plan Against Trafficking in Human Beings for action-plan/6366,The-National-Action-Plan-against-Trafficking-
2013–2015' for 2014, (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), p. 26-29, in-Human-Beings-for-2013-2015.html
accessed 27/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/ Zbigniew Lasocik & Łukasz Wieczorek, "Trafficking for Forced
66
national-action-plan/6366,The-National-Action-Plan-against- Labour in Poland: Research Report," (Human Trafficking Studies
Trafficking-in-Human-Beings-for-2013-2015.html Centre, Warsaw University, 2010), 68–72.
51
National Consulting and Intervention Centre for the Victims of Ministry of the Interior and KCIK, "Report on the implementation
67
Trafficking, National Action Plan Against Trafficking in Human Be- of the 'National Action Plan Against Trafficking in Human Beings
ings 2013–2015, (KCIK, 2013), pp. 6–7, accessed 11/03/2014,http:// for 2013–2015' for 2014," (Ministry of the Interior, 2015), 28–29,
www.kcik.pl/en/doc/POLAND_NAP_2013-2015__EN_.pdf. accessed 27/01/2016:http://www.handelludzmi.eu/hle/database/
52
Zbigniew Lasocik et al., Country Strategy Report: Modern Slavery national-action-plan/6366,The-National-Action-Plan-against-
Landscape in Poland 2014, (Walk Free, 2014), 54. Trafficking-in-Human-Beings-for-2013-2015.html
Government of Poland, Law No. 99. "Promotion of Employment
68
in Persons Report: Poland Country Narrative, (United States Depart- Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer, October, 2015, accessed
ment of State, 2015), p. 282, accessed 21/01/2016:http://www.state. 10/02/16:http://mideastsoccer.blogspot.dk/2015/10/new-qatari-
gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/2015/ labour-law-too-little-too.html
Interview with Human Trafficking Studies Centre, February 4th,
70
"Global Slavery Index: Qatar Country Study", Walk Free Founda-
20
zapobieganie, (Council of the Baltic Sea States, 2014), pp. 45–47. Watch, 2014), accessed 27/07/15:https://www.hrw.org/world-re-
Polish law requires all employment agencies to be registered.
72 port/2013/country-chapters/qatar
Government of Poland, 'Law No. 99, "Promotion of Employment As above.
22
and Labour Market Institutions ['ustawy z dnia 20 kwietnia 2004 r. Personal communication.
23
o promocji zatrudnienia i instytucjach rynku pracy']"', Journal of
Laws, 20/04/2004, Article 121/1. "Qatar: Renaming Kafala is not Ending Kafala", Migrant Rights, 9
24
Slavery Landscape in Poland 2014,, (Walk Free, 2014), p. 59. Confederation, 28 October, 2015, accessed 21/02/16:http://www.
ituc-csi.org/qatar-s-labour-law-reforms-a-sham
Qatar Peter Kovessy, Riham Sheble and Heba Fahmy 'Qatar's Emir signs
26
dation, July 2014) p. 43, accessed 12/02/16:http://www.qscience. taev and Caress Schenk, Country Strategy Report: Modern Slavery
com/userimages/ContentEditor/1404811243939/Migrant_Labour_ Landscape in Russia, (draft), (Walk Free Foundation, 2014).
Recruitment_to_Qatar_Web_Final.pdf Rebecca Surtees, Trafficked at Sea. The Exploitation of Ukrainian
2
Personal communication.
3 Seafarers and Fishers, (International Organisation for Migration,
2013), pp. 15–18, accessed 28/02/14:http://lastradainternational.
See also Decree No.8 of 2005 which covers some minimum protec-
4
org/doc-center/2981/trafficked-at-sea-the-exploitation-of-
tions for workers and requirements for employers. ukrainian-seafarers-and-fishers-2012
Amnesty International, My sleep is my break: Exploitation of
5
Maxim Tucker, 'Sex, Lies and Psychological Scars: Inside Ukraine’s
3
Migrant Domestic Workers in Qatar, (Amnesty International, 2014), Human Trafficking Crisis', The Guardian, February 4, 2016,
p. 9, accessed 25/06/14:http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/ accessed 07/02/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/global-devel-
MDE22/004/2014/en/7b7121b8-37c1-4e49-b1a1-2d8a005450a3/ opment/2016/feb/04/sex-lies-psychological-scars-ukraine-hu-
mde220042014en.pdf man-trafficking-crisis
Personal communication.
6
Elena Platonova, 'In the New Year Without Turks', Gazeta, Jan-
4
istry of Development Planning and Statistics, last accessed February "Where We’re From", International Organisation for Migration,
7
21, 2016,http://www.qsa.gov.qa/eng/publication/pdf-file/Social/ accessed 9/08/14:http://www.iom.int/cms/en/sites/iom/home/
AnalyticalSummaryMarriage_Divorce_En.pdf about-migration/world-migration.html
Qatar's Fourth National Human Development Report: Realising Qatar
10
Country Profiles - Europe and Central Asia, (United Nations Office
8
National Vision 2013, (Ministry of Development Planning and on Drugs and Crime, 2012), p. 99, accessed 08/09/14:http://www.
Statistics, 2015), p. 40, accessed 10/07/15:http://www.gsdp.gov.qa/ unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/glotip/Country_Pro-
portal/page/portal/gsdp_en/knowledge_center/Tab2/NHDR4%20 files_Europe_Central_Asia.pdf
Complete%20Report%20English%20LowResolution%20
28May2015.pdf Sharon Shpurer, 'Biggest Trafficker of Women in Israeli
9
proceeds of child prostitution. See: Government of the Rus- in Persons Report 2015: Russia Country Narrative, (United States
sian Federation, Public Law No 63 of 1996, 'Criminal Code of Department of State, 2015), accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.state.
the Russian Federation', February 29, 2012, Art242.1, accessed gov/documents/organization/243561.pdf
10/03/2016:https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_ As above.
41
LAW_10699/23ac064057d5bca235050872f65b23a1a1db092a/
'Putin Allowed to Expel From Russia Are Not Working in
42
17
Bureau of International Labor Affairs, Findings on the Worst Forms the Specialty of Migrants', Rosbalt, July 1, 2015, accessed
of Child Labor: Russia, (United States Department of Labor, 2014), 10/03/2016:http://m.rosbalt.ru/main/2015/07/01/1414422.html
accessed 05/01/2016:http://www.dol.gov/ilab/reports/child-labor/
findings/2014TDA/russia.pdf As above.
43
18
Elena Maltseva, Lauren McCarthy, Maria Mokhova, Dmitry Pole- Catherine Chevalier, 'What is Contingent Labor and Why It Was
44
taev and Caress Schenk, Country Strategy Report: Modern Slavery Banned?', AIF.RU, accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.aif.ru/dont-
Landscape in Russia, (draft), (Walk Free Foundation, 2014) knows/eternal/1163702
19
Vitalu Shevchenko, 'Ukraine Conflict: Child Soldiers Join the Russia’s deportation procedure can be reviewed here (in Russian):
45
Fight', BBC News, November 26, 2016, accessed 10/03/2016:http:// Postanovlenie RF ot 30.12.2013 No. 1306 "Ob Utverzhdenii Pravil
www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30134421 Soderzhaniia (Prebyvaniia) v Spetsialnykh Uchrezhdeniiakh
Federalnoi Migratsionnoi Sluzhby Inostrannyh Grazhdan" [Decree
20
Bureau of International Labor Affairs, Findings on the Worst Forms of the Russian Federation No. 1306 passed on 30 December 2013
of Child Labor: Russia, (United States Department of Labor, 2014), 'On Approval of the Rules of (stay) in Institutions of the Federal
accessed 05/01/2016:http://www.dol.gov/ilab/reports/child-labor/ Migration Service of Foreign Citizens']http://www.consultant.ru/
findings/2014TDA/russia.pdf document/cons_doc_LAW_157232/?frame=1
21
Elena Maltseva, Lauren McCarthy, Maria Mokhova, Dmitry Pole- Personal communication.
46
taev and Caress Schenk, Country Strategy Report: Modern Slavery
Landscape in Russia, (draft), (Walk Free Foundation, 2014)
South Africa
22
As above. 1
'Modern Day Slavery South Africa', International Organization for
23
Personal communication Migration, October 9, 2015, accessed 12/02/16:http://southafrica.
24
Steven Eke, 'Russia: new rules hit foreign workers', BBC World iom.int/modern-day-slavery-south-africa/
Service, accessed 06/02/16:http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/ 2
Government of South Africa, 'Criminal Law (Sexual Offenses and
specials/119_wag_climate/page9.shtml Related Matters) Amendment Act 32 of 2007', accessed 10/02/16: ;
25
"GDP per capita", The World Bank, accessed 07/02/2016:http://data. note: the purchasing of sex was criminalised long before this Act –
worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD in the Sexual Offences Act 23 of 1857 (of which many sections are
26
GFK Ukraine, Human Trafficking Survey: Ukraine, (International now replaced/repealed by the 2007 Act)https://www.issafrica.org/
Labour Organisation, 2015), accessed 07/02/2016 crimehub/uploads/sexual_offences_act32_2007_eng.pdf
27
It is necessary to differentiate between West and Eastern Ukraine.
3
Chandre Gould, 'Sex Trafficking and Prostitution in South
Eastern Ukraine, being predominantly Russian speaking, saw Africa', The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and
many flee to Russia during the conflict and considered 'refugees' Social Science 653 no.1 (May 2014), accessed 09/02/16: doi:
although they were not necessarily given such official status. 10.1177/0002716214521557, see also; Office to Monitor and Com-
bat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking in Persons Report: South Af-
28
GFK Ukraine, Human Trafficking Survey: Ukraine, (International rica Country Narrative, (United States Department of State, 2014),
Labour Organization, 2015), accessed 07/02/2016:http://www. pp. 308–309, accessed 11/02/16:http://www.state.gov/documents/
iom.org.ua/sites/default/files/pres_gfk_iom2015_ukraine_eng_ organization/243561.pdf
fin_3_2.pdf 4
Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, Trafficking
29
'Norway Sends Syrian Refugees Back to Russia', EuroNews, in Persons Report: South Africa Country Narrative, (United States
January 20, 2016, accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.euronews. Department of State, 2014), p. 309, accessed 11/02/16:http://www.
com/2016/01/20/norway-sends-syrian-refugees-back-to-russia/ state.gov/documents/organization/243561.pdf
30
'Remittances Growth to Slow Sharply in 2015, as Europe and 5
Lenyaro Sello, 'Combating Human Trafficking: Working the law',
Russia Stay Weak; Pick Up Expected Next Year', The World Bank, eNews Channel Africa, July 28, 2015, accessed 09/02/16:http://www.
April 13, 2015, accessed 10/03/2015:http://www.worldbank.org/ enca.com/south-africa/combating-human-trafficking-working-law
en/news/press-release/2015/04/13/remittances-growth-to-slow-
sharply-in-2015-as-europe-and-russia-stay-weak-pick-up-expect-
6
"A Profile of Child Marriage in Africa", UNICEF, accessed
ed-next-year 10/02/16:http://data.unicef.org/corecode/uploads/document6/up-
loaded_pdfs/corecode/UNICEF-Child-Marriage-Brochure-High-
31
As above. Single_246.pdf
32
David Trilling, 'Tajikistan: Remittances to Plunge 40% – 7
Marcel van der Watt, 'Human trafficking in South Africa: an
World Bank', Central Asia Today, May 26, 2015, accessed elusive statistical nightmare', eNews Channel Africa, July 17, 2015,
10/03/2016:http://www.eurasianet.org/node/73591 accessed 10/02/16:http://www.enca.com/life/human-traffick-
33
Karoun Demirjian, 'New Russian Migration Law Boosts Islamic ing-south-africa-elusive-statistical-nightmare
State Recruitment in Tajikistan', The Guardian, July 14, 2015, 8
"Ukuthwala", Justice and Constitutional Development Republic of
accessed 10/03/2016:http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/ South Africa, accessed 10/02/16:http://www.justice.gov.za/bro-
jul/14/russian-migration-law-tajikistan-islamic-state-recruits chure/ukuthwala/ukuthwala.html#sthash.ZIxgFjNf.dpuf
34
As above. 9
Evaluation of Stepping Stones: A Gender Transformative HIV Preven-
35
Kommersant, 'Russia Toughens Migration Policy for CIS Citizens', tion Intervention' (Medical Research Centre, Gender and Health
Russia Beyond the Headlines, June 24, 2014, available at:http://rbth. Research Unit, 2011)http://www.justice.gov.za/brochure/ukuthwa-
com/news/2014/06/24/russia_toughens_migration_policy_for_ la/ukuthwala.html#sthash.ZIxgFjNf.dpuf
cis_citizens_37673.html Luso Mnthali, 'South Africa's Domestic Workers Gains a Mini-
10
36
Personal communication. mum Wage', Equal Times, August 4, 2015, accessed 12/02/16:http://
37
Matthew Luxmoore, 'Ruble Ripple: New Russian Laws Make www.equaltimes.org/south-africa-s-domestic-workers#.Vrg-
Life Difficult for Migrant Workers', Al Jazeera, February 27, Bfl97IV
2015, accessed 10/03/2016:http://america.aljazeera.com/arti- Mariam Seedat-Khan, Gunasekharan Dharmaraja and Sinethemba
11
South African Department of Labour Online, December 2015, November 27, 2010, accessed 07/02/16:http://www.abc.net.au/
accessed 12/02/16:http://www.labour.gov.za/DOL/downloads/leg- news/2010-11-27/third-of-south-african-men-admit-to-rape-
islation/sectoral-determinations/basic-conditions-of-employment/ study/2353188
domesticwages_dec2015.pdf David Smith, 'South African Girl’s Gang-Rape and Murder Trig-
36
dirty slavery secret in 2014', News24, November 10, 2014, accessed Ignores ‘Corrective’ Attacks', The Guardian, March 13, 2009, ac-
11/02/16:http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Dont-look- cessed 06/02/16:http://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/mar/12/
away-SAs-dirty-slavery-secret-in-2014-20141110 eudy-simelane-corrective-rape-south-africa
Ray Mwareya, 'South Africa’s 'Gold Slaves'', Equal Times, Decem-
15
David Smith, 'South African Girl’s Gang-Rape and Murder Trig-
38
ber 2, 2014, accessed 11/02/16:http://www.equaltimes.org/south- gers Political Outrage', The Guardian, February 8, 2013, accessed
africa-s-gold-slaves?lang=en#.VpNscBV97IU 06/02/16:http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/feb/07/south-
'Modern Day Slavery South Africa', International Organisation for
16 africa-girl-gang-rape-murder
Migration, October 9, 2015, accessed 12/02/16:http://southafrica. 'South Africa: Justice Served for Disebo Gift Makau', Gender Links,
39
As abovee.
19 Africa? The Data is Flawed', Africa Check, November 13, 2014, ac-
cessed 06/02/16:https://africacheck.org/reports/is-a-child-raped-
'Modern Day Slavery South Africa', International Organisation for
20
every-three-minutes-in-south-africa-the-statistic-is-flawed/
Migration, October 9, 2015, accessed 12/02/16:http://southafrica.
iom.int/modern-day-slavery-south-africa/ 'Public Trust in Government Dwindles', Corruption Watch, Febru-
42
(Institute for Security Studies and Africa Check, 2014), accessed Beatri Kruger, 'Celebrating the New Law to Combat Human Traf-
45
15/03/16: ; see also, Crime Situation in South Africa, (South ficking in South Africa', Gateway News, August 20, 2015, accessed
African Police Service, 29 September 2015)https://africacheck. 11/02/16:http://gatewaynews.co.za/celebrating-the-new-law-to-
org/factsheets/factsheet-south-africas-official-crime-statis- combat-human-trafficking-in-south-africa/
tics-for-201314/, http://www.saps.gov.za/resource_centre/publica- Government of South Africa, 'Prevention and Combating of Traf-
46
Year High', The Wall Street Journal, May 26, 2015, accessed Personal communication.
48
ter 3: 2015 (Statistics South Africa, 2015), page iv, accessed Government of South Africa, 'Prevention and Combating of Traf-
51
07/02/16:http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0211/P02113rd- ficking in Persons Act (2013)', article 39, accessed 11/02/16:http://
Quarter2015.pdf www.gov.za/sites/www.gov.za/files/36715_gon544.pdf
Ray White, 'SA’s Economy on brink of recession, says World Bank',
28
Note: ukuthwala in toto was not declared unconstitutional (per-
52
Eyewitness News, February, 2016, accessed 08/02/16:http://ewn. sonal communication).
co.za/2016/02/02/World-Bank-SA-economy-on-brink-of-recession
"Parliament on Court’s Rulings Following Ukuthwala Case in
53
Brent Swails and Jason Hanna, 'South Africa deploys troops to
29
Hewit", South African Government, accessed 10/02/16: see also:
help stem immigrant attacks', CNN News, April 22, 2015, accessed Jezile v S and Others (A 127/2014) [2015] ZAWCHC 31 (23 March
08/02/16:http://edition.cnn.com/2015/04/21/africa/south-afri- 2015):http://www.gov.za/speeches/government-welcomes-rulings-
ca-xenophobia-attacks/ courts-ukuthwala-case-and-hewitt-26-mar-2015-0000, http://
'Cape Town protests against attacks on immigrants', Eurone-
30
saflii.org/za/cases/ZAWCHC/2015/31.html
ws, April 23, 2015, accessed 07/02/16:http://www.euronews. 'Eight Life Sentences for Human Trafficking', JBay News, accessed
54
com/2015/04/23/cape-town-protests-against-attacks-on-immi- 21/03/16:http://www.jbaynews.com/eight-life-sentences-to-a-busi-
grants/ nessman-accused-of-human-trafficking/
David Smith, 'Calls for inequality to be tackled in South Africa
31
Marcel van der Watt, 'Human Trafficking in South Africa: An
55
as violent crime rises', The Guardian, October 1, 2015, accessed Elusive Statistical Nightmare', eNews Channel Africa, July 17, 2015,
06/02/16:http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/01/ accessed 10/02/16:http://www.enca.com/life/human-traffick-
south-africa-violent-crime-murders-increase-inequality ing-south-africa-elusive-statistical-nightmare
As above.
32
"New Immigration Regulations", Department of Home Affairs
56
Intimate Femicide in South Africa 10 years later!,(South African Out of SA (and What is an Unabridged Birth Certificate)", Africa
Medical Research Council, 2012), accessed 07/02/16:http://www. Check, accessed 10/02/16:https://africacheck.org/factsheets/fact-
mrc.ac.za/policybriefs/everyeighthours.pdf sheet-how-to-travel-with-children-into-and-out-of-south-africa-
and-what-is-an-unabridged-birth-certificate/
59
'Modern Day Slavery South Africa', International Organisation for Repatriation of Trafficking Victims and Other Exploited Women and
Migration October 9, 2015, accessed 12/02/16:http://southafrica. Girl Workers - A Study of 124 Cases, (International Organization for
iom.int/modern-day-slavery-south-africa/ Migration, 2004), p. 21, 16/03/16:http://bit.ly/1R5DSeG
60
Chandre Gould, 'Sex Trafficking and Prostitution in South Situational Analysis of the Commercial Sexual Exploitation of
16
Africa', The ANNALS of the American Academy of Politi- Children in Thailand, (ECPAT International, 2015), p. 39, accessed
cal and Social Science, 653 no.1 (May 2014): 09/02/16, doi: 09/02/16
10.1177/0002716214521557. Rebecca Surtees, After Trafficking: Experiences and Challenges in the
17
61
Personal communication. (Re)Integration of Trafficked Persons in the Greater Mekong Sub-re-
gion, (United Nations Inter-Agency Project on Human Trafficking
62
Personal communication. /NEXUS Institute, 2013), p. 134, accessed 09/02/16:http://un-act.
63
"South Africa Tackles Human Trafficking", South Africa Info, last org/publication/view/trafficking-experiences-challenges-reinte-
modified February 24, 2015, accessed 10/02/16:http://www.south- gration-trafficked-persons-greater-mekong-sub-region/
africa.info/services/rights/trafficking-240215.htm#.VrhfXPl97IV Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, 2015 Traf-
18
64
As above. ficking in Persons Report: Thailand Country Narrative, (United States
Department of State, 2015), accessed 09/02/16:http://www.state.
Thailand gov/documents/organization/243562.pdf
1
Bureau of International Labour Affairs, Findings on the Worst 'Thailand’s Trafficking in Persons Report 2014: Country Report, (Min-
19
Forms of Child Labour Report: Thailand, (United States Department istry of Foreign Affairs, 2014), p. 40, accessed 06/02/16:http://
of Labour, 2014), accessed 06/02/16:http://www.dol.gov/ilab/re- www.mfa.go.th/main/en/media-center/14/54368-Thailand's-Traf-
ports/child-labor/thailand.htm ficking-in-Persons-2014-Countr.html
2
Elaine Pearson, Sureeporn Punpuing et al., "The Mekong Chal- United Nations General Assembly Security Council, 'Report
20
lenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The Realities of of the Secretary-General on Children and Armed Conflict
Young Migrant Workers in Thailand (Volume One)," (Interna- (A/69/926-S/2015/409)', (United Nations, 2015), accessed
tional Labour Organization, 2006), 10,http://www.ilo.org/asia/ 14/02/16:http://www.un.org/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol-
whatwedo/publications/WCMS_BK_PB_67_EN/lang--en/index. =A/69/926&Lang=E&Area=UNDOC
htm "Thailand", Office of the Special Representative of the Secre-
21
3
Dean Irvine, 'Slaves at Sea: Report into Thai Fishing Industry tary-General for Children and Armed Conflict, June 2015, accessed
Finds Abuse of Migrant Workers', CNN, March 6, 2014, accessed 06/02/16:https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/countries/thai-
04/02/16:http://edition.cnn.com/2014/03/06/world/asia/thai- land/
land-fishing-modern-slavery-report/index.html Southern Thailand: Ongoing recruitment and use of children by armed
22
4
Caught at Sea: Forced Labour and Trafficking in Fisheries, (In- groups, (Child Soldiers International, January 2015), accessed
ternational Labour Organization, Special Action Programme 14/02/16:http://www.child-soldiers.org/research_report_reader.
to Combat Forced Labour, 2013), p. 15, pp. 19–20, accessed php?id=799
04/02/16:http://www.ilo.org/global/topics/forced-labour/publica- "Thailand", Office of the Special Representative of the Secre-
23
tions/WCMS_214472/lang--en/index.htm tary-General for Children and Armed Conflict, June 2015, accessed
5
Thailand’s Seafood Slaves: Human Trafficking, Slavery and Murder 06/02/16:https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/countries/thai-
in Kantang’s Fishing Industry, (Environmental Justice Foundation, land/
2015), accessed 15/03/16:http://ejfoundation.org/sites/default/ Silvia di Gaetano, 'How to Solve Southeast Asia’s Refugee Crisis',
24
newal, labelled ʻre-entry'. Number of Thai Workers Deployed, by The Diplomat, October 23, 2015, accessed 14/01/16:http://thediplo-
Destination, (Ministry of Labour, Office for Thai Workers Going mat.com/2015/10/thailand-must-end-its-own-rohingya-atrocity/
Overseas, 2012,) accessed through personal communication. 'Malaysia, Indonesia, but not Thailand, Agree to Take in
27
9
Suttiporn Bunmak, 'Migrant Networks in Thailand and Malay- Rohingya Migrants', The Japan Times, May 21, 2015, accessed
sia: Irregular Nayu Workers in Tom Yam Restaurants in Kuala 16/03/16:http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2015/05/21/asia-pa-
Lumper', (Doctor of Philosophy Thesis, University of Wollongong, cific/social-issues-asia-pacific/malaysia-indonesia-will-take-boat-
2010), accessed 30/07/14:http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent. people-u-s-will-help-thailand-balks/#.VtQEU_l97IV
cgi?article=4317&context=theses Simon Lewis, '4 Things to Know About Thailand’s Trial of 92
28
10
Jerrold W. Huguet, and Aphichat Chamratrithirong, eds., Thailand Alleged Human Traffickers', Time, March 18, 2016, accessed
Migration Report 2011 - Migration for development in Thailand: 16/03/16:http://time.com/4263868/thailand-trial-92-human-traf-
Overview and tools for Policymakers, (International Labour Organi- ficking/
zation, 2011), p. 14 & p. 39, accessed 06/02/16:http://publications. International Labour Organisation , 'Employment Practices and
29
12
Jerrold W. Huguet, and Aphichat Chamratrithirong, eds., Thailand Jerrold W. Huguet, ed., 'Thailand Migration Report 2014', (United
31
Migration Report 2011 – Migration for Development in Thailand: Nations Thematic Working Group on Migration in Thailand,
Overview and Tools for Policymakers, (International Organization 2014), accessed 15/03/16:http://th.iom.int/images/report/
for Migration, 2011), p. 39, accessed 14/01/16:http://publications. TMR_2014.pdf
iom.int/system/files/pdf/tmr_2011.pdf Transnational Organised Crime in East Asia and the Pacific, (Unit-
32
13
"Personal Remittances, Received (Current US$) – Thailand 2013", ed Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2013), p. 8, accessed
World Bank, accessed 30/07/14:http://data.worldbank.org/indica- 14/08/14:http://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/
tor/BX.TRF.PWKR.CD.DT/countries/TH?display=default Studies/TOCTA_EAP_web.pdf
14
Jerrold W. Huguet, and Aphichat Chamratrithirong, eds., Thailand
Migration Report 2011 – Migration for Development in Thailand:
Overview and Tools for Policymakers, (International Labour Orga-
nization, 2011), pp.39–48, accessed 10/01/16:http://publications.
iom.int/system/files/pdf/tmr_2011.pdf
tion Between Thailand and Neighbouring Countries, (ILO Tripartite Thai fishing Industry Trafficks, Imprisons and Enslaves', The
Action to Protect the Rights of Migrant Workers within and from Guardian, July 20, 2015, accessed 07/02/16:http://www.theguard-
the Greater Mekong Subregion, 2015), accessed 16/03/16:http:// ian.com/global-development/2015/jul/20/thai-fishing-indus-
www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---asia/---ro-bangkok/docu- try-implicated-enslavement-deaths-rohingya
ments/publication/wcms_356542.pdf Jerrold W. Huguet, ed., Thailand Migration Report 2014, (United
54
As above.
34
Nations Thematic Working Group on Migration in Thailand,
Personal communication; please note migrant workers in the
35 2014), accessed 09/02/16:http://th.iom.int/images/report/
seafood sector can change employers and districts, as noted in: TMR_2014.pdf
Trafficking in Persons Report 2015: The Royal Thai Government’s Personal communication.
55
Response, (The Royal Thai Government, 2015), p. 48, accessed 'UNODC Assists Thailand to Criminalise Possession of Child Sex
56
12/03/2016: Abuse Material', United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime South-
Personal communication.
36
east Asia and the Pacific, May 18, 2015, accessed 07/01/16:https://
Jerrold W. Huguet, ed., Thailand Migration Report 2014, (United
37 www.unodc.org/southeastasiaandpacific/en/2015/05/child-
Nations Thematic Working Group on Migration in Thailand, hood-sex-abuse-material/story.html
2014), accessed 16/02/16:http://th.iom.int/images/report/ Situational Analysis of the Commercial Sexual Exploitation of
57
Personal communication.
39 Behind Bars', International Justice Mission, June 2, 2015, accessed
06/01/16:https://www.ijm.org/articles/trafficking-ring-run-thai-
Personal communication.
40
monk-crumbles-leader-behind-bars
"Situational Analysis of the Commercial Sexual Exploitation
41
Personal communication.
59
of Children in Thailand', (ECPAT International, 2015), p. 21,
accessed 04/01/16: 'Human Trafficking Court Opens, More Traffickers Arrested',
60
Human Rights Watch, July 24, 2014, accessed 04/02/16: ; 'Thai United Kingdom
Junta to replace martial law but retain key powers', Al Jazeera Kevin Bales, Olivia Hesketh and Bernard Silverman, 'Modern
1
America, March 31, 2015, accessed 07/01/16:https://www.hrw.org/ Slavery in the UK: How Many Victims?', Significance, 12, 3, p. 25
news/2014/07/24/thailand-interim-constitution-provides-sweep- (2015).
ing-powers, http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2015/3/31/
prayuth-to-replace-martial-law-but-retain-powers.html Lindsay Fortado, 'FT Seasonal Appeal: trapped and trafficked in
2
14/01/16:http://www.ictsd.org/bridges-news/biores/news/eu-
warns-thailand-on-illegal-fishing As above.
6
Emanuel Stoakes, Chris Kelly & Annie Kelly, 'Revealed: How the
49 Personal communication; see also The APPG for Runaway and
7
Thai Fishing Industry Trafficks, Imprisons and Enslaves', The Missing Children and Adults and the APPG for Looked After
Guardian, July 20, 2015, accessed 15/02/16:http://www.theguard- Children and Care Leavers, Report from the Joint Inquiry into
ian.com/global-development/2015/jul/20/thai-fishing-indus- Children Who Go Missing From Care, (The APPG for Runaway
try-implicated-enslavement-deaths-rohingya and Missing Children and Adults and the APPG for Looked After
Children and Care Leavers, 2012), accessed 10/02/16:https://www.
'Press releases: Thailand’s Progress in Combating IUU Fishing',
50
gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Kingdom of Thailand, January file/175563/Report_-_children_who_go_missing_from_care.pdf
14, 2016, accessed 10/02/16:http://www.mfa.go.th/main/en/
media-center/14/63733-Thailand%E2%80%99s-Progress-in-Com- Inter-Departmental Ministerial Group, "2015 Report of the
8
bating-IUU-Fishing.html United Kingdom and the introduction of the tied Overseas Domestic
Worker visa (Kalayaan, 2015), p. 1, accessed 17/07/15:http://www.
kalayaan.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Kalayaan-3-year-
briefing.pdf
As above.
11
12
"Statistics January to December 2014," Forced Married Unit, ac- In 2015, Walk Free, in conjunction with ECPAT ran a campaign
28
Inquiry into Child Sexual Exploitation in Gangs and Groups, man Trafficking, (Home Office, November 2014), accessed
2013), accessed 16/07/15:https://www.childrenscommissioner.gov. 15/07/15:https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/up-
uk/sites/default/files/publications/If_only_someone_had_listened. loads/attachment_data/file/467434/Review_of_the_National_Re-
pdf ferral_Mechanism_for_victims_of_human_trafficking.pdf
16
Inter-Departmental Ministerial Group, "2015 Report of the Personal communication.
31
(Department of Justice, 2015), 21, accessed 10/02/16:https://www. Human Trafficking and Exploitation (Scotland) Bill, (Human Traf-
33
gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/ ficking Foundation, October 2015) ,accessed 12/02/16:http://www.
file/469968/IDMG_Report_Final.pdf humantraffickingfoundation.org/blog/2015/10/human-traffick-
17
As above. ing-and-exploitation-scotland-bill
18
"Big step in the right direction but deficiencies leave us – and Graeme Demianyk, 'Government Launches Helpline To Tackle
34
victims of modern slavery – wholly unsatisfied", Anti-Slavery Modern Slavery Which Home Secretary Theresa May Calls An
International, accessed 14/12/2015:http://www.antislavery.org/ 'Affront To Humanity', Huffington Post UK, December 9, 2015,
english/press_and_news/news_and_press_releases_2009/analy- accessed 12/02/16:http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/12/09/
sis_of_modern_slavery_act.aspx theresa-may-modern-slavery-helpline_n_8760642.html
19
Ms C Reyes and Ms T Suryadi v Mr J Al-Malki and Mrs Al-Malki Personal communication.
35
and Others [2015] EWCA Civ 32 Press Association, 'Businessman is the First Person Jailed Under
36
20
Benkharbouche/Janah v Sudan Embassy/Libya [2015] EWCA Civ Forced Marriage Laws,' The Guardian, 11 June, 2015, accessed
33 27/07/15:http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jun/10/34-
21
Jorge Bustamante, Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Human year-old-man-first-person-to-be-convicted-under-forced-mar-
Rights of Migrants, (United Nations General Assembly, March riage-laws
2010), p. 15, accessed 22/07/2016:http://www2.ohchr.org/english/ Shaheen Hashmat, 'Forced Marriage in Britain: It Nearly
37
(Home Office and UK Visas and Immigration, 2015) accessed Foreign and Commonwealth Office and Home Office, last modified
17/07/15:https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/over- March 8, 2016,https://www.gov.uk/guidance/forced-marriage
seas-domestic-workers-visa-independent-review
24
As above.
25
Inter-Departmental Ministerial Group, 2015 Report of the Inter-De-
partmental Ministerial Group on Modern Slavery, (Department of
Justice, 2015), p.9, accessed 10/02/16:https://www.gov.uk/gov-
ernment/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/469968/
IDMG_Report_Final.pdf
26
"Historic Law To End Modern Slavery Passed", Home Office, 26
March, 2015, accessed 12/07/15:https://www.gov.uk/government/
news/historic-law-to-end-modern-slavery-passed
27
As above.
'Modern Slavery: A global reckoning', Significance (Royal Statistical place for gay or lesbian people to live. Taken from "Gallup Analyt-
Society October 2015. Available for download from:http://onlineli- ics", Gallup Analytics, accessed 24/03/2016:http://www.gallup.com/
brary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1740-9713.2015.00854.x/pdf products/170987/gallup-analytics.aspx
The theoretical concept of human security builds on the United
2
"Table 3: Inequality-adjusted Human Development Index", United
21
Nations Development Programme's 1994 Report on Human Se- Nations Development Program, accessed 24/03/2016:http://hdr.
curity that identifies the seven major areas of security as political undp.org/en/composite/IHDI
security, community security, personal security, environmental Percentage of respondents who stated their region is not a good
22
security, food security, economic security, and health security. place for people with intellectual disabilities to live. Taken from
VIF references the Variance Inflation Factor, which assesses the
3
"Gallup Analytics", Gallup Analytics, accessed 24/03/2016:http://
severity of multicollinearity by estimating the inflation of regres- www.gallup.com/products/170987/gallup-analytics.aspx
sion coefficients as compared to when the predictor variables are Percentage of respondents who stated their region is not a good
23
not linearly related. While VIF scores between 1 and 5 indicate place for immigrants to live. Taken from "Gallup Analytics",
moderate correlation, we established our threshold at any variable Gallup Analytics, accessed 24/03/2016:http://www.gallup.com/
over a VIF score of 10, which indicates very high correlation. products/170987/gallup-analytics.aspx
In statistics, tolerance is used as an indicator of multicollinearity
4
Percentage of respondents who stated their region is not a good
24
and is estimated by subtracting the R-squared value from 1, where place for racial and ethnic minorities to live. Taken from "Gallup
the R-squared value is calculated by regressing the independent Analytics", Gallup Analytics, accessed 24/03/2016:http://www.
variable of interest onto the remaining independent variables. gallup.com/products/170987/gallup-analytics.aspx
Researchers generally desire higher levels of tolerance, because
when the tolerance levels are too low, or below 0.1, the results The total number of refugees (including refugee-like situations)
25
from multiple regression analysis can be affected. by country/territory of asylum/residence. Taken from "Population
Statistics," United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, accessed
From series 'Borrowed any money, past year (% aged 15+)' in
5
24/03/2016:http://popstats.unhcr.org/PSQ_TMS.aspx
"Global Findex (Global Financial Inclusion Database)", The World
Bank, accessed: 24/03/2016:http://databank.worldbank.org/data/ Total number of displaced persons from "Population Statis-
26
(% aged 15+)' in "Global Findex (Global Financial Inclusion 'POLITY2' variable in "The Polity Project", Center for Systemic
27
Global Findex (Global Financial Inclusion Database)", The World A survey was also conducted in Thailand in Thai language but the
29
Bank, accessed: 24/03/2016:http://databank.worldbank.org/data/ results are not being used for estimation purposes in this Global
reports.aspx?source=1228 Slavery Index. Research confirms that migrant workers from
"Mobile cellular subscriptions (per 100 people)", The World Bank,
8 Cambodia and Myanmar are subject to high levels of exploitation
accessed 24/03/2016:http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/IT.CEL. (see Simon Baker, Human Trafficking Trends in Asia: Migration
SETS.P2 Experiences of Cambodia Workers deported from Thailand in 2009,
2010 and 2012, (UNDP & UN ACT, 2015) and UNIAP Trafficking
World Social Protection Report 2014/15, (International Labour Or-
9
Estimates, Estimating Labor Trafficking: A Study of Burmese Migrant
ganization, 2015), pp. 186-194, accessed 24/03/2016:http://www. Workers in Samut Sakhon, (UNDP, 2011), Given the known lim-
ilo.org/global/research/global-reports/world-social-security-re- itations of the Thai survey, we also undertook surveys in source
port/2014/WCMS_245201/lang--en/index.htm countries, Vietnam, Cambodia and Myanmar, partly to test out
"Food Security", Food and Agriculture Organization of the United
10
whether this would give us a sufficient sample of returned migrant
Nations, accessed 24/03/2016:http://faostat3.fao.org/down- workers to estimate prevalence in Thailand. However, on further
load/D/*/E consideration this method of estimation was rejected. We have
"Incidence of tuberculosis (per 100,000 people)", The World Bank,
11 therefore used our extrapolation methodology for Thailand for
accessed 24/03/2016:http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.TBS. this year. Consultations prior to the launch of the Index confirmed
INCD/countries this was the best approach. We continue to seek alternative ap-
proaches for estimating prevalence in Thailand.http://un-act.org/
Percentage of respondents who stated 'yes' in response to whether
12
publication/view/human-trafficking-trends-asia-migration-expe-
or not they had confidence in the judicial system and courts. riences-cambodian-workers-deported-thailand-2009-2010-2012/
Taken from: "Gallup Analytics", Gallup Analytics, accessed http://www.no-trafficking.org/reports_docs/estimates/uniap_esti-
24/03/2016:http://www.gallup.com/products/170987/gallup-ana- mating_labor_trafficking_report.pdf
lytics.aspx
Initially this was 14 States but Andrha Pradesh state was split into
30
'Improved water source (% of TOTAL population with access)' in
13
two in June 2014, with creation of the new state Telangana. As
"Data & estimates", WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme the survey was already on foot in Andrha Pradesh, a decision was
for Water Supply and Sanitation, accessed 24/03/2016:http://www. made to split the sample of 1000 across both States.
wssinfo.org/data-estimates/tables/
See also the work of the Human Rights Data Analysis
31
Indicator 'Political Instability' in "Global Peace Index 2015: Global
14
Group.https://hrdag.org/2013/03/11/mse-the-basics/
Rankings", Vision of Humanity, accessed 24/03/2015:http://www.
visionofhumanity.org/#page/indexes/global-peace-index/2015 Kevin Bales, Olivia Hesketh, Bernard Silverman, 'Modern Slavery
32
Global Rankings", Vision of Humanity, accessed 24/03/2015:http:// Kevin Bales, Olivia Hesketh, Bernard Silverman, 'Modern Slavery
34
Rankings", Vision of Humanity, accessed 24/03/2015:http://www. Multiple Systems Estimation for estimating the number of victims
visionofhumanity.org/#page/indexes/global-peace-index/2015 of human trafficking across the world', Paper presented at the UN
Crime Commission, Vienna, May 2016.
"Data", WomanSTATS Project, accessed 24/03/2016:http://www.
18
womanstats.org/data.html
Indicator 'Weapons access' in "Global Peace Index 2015: Global
19
36
Small Island Developing States (SIDS), United Nations, There Ronald Clarke and Ross Homel, 'A Revised Classification of
39
were three diversions from this general rule: (1) a similar ad- Situational Crime Prevention Techniques', in Crime Prevention
justment was made for Madagascar as it has a socio-economic at a Crossroads, ed. Cincinnati, OH and Andersen, (1997), p. 17
environment similar to SIDS. (2) While the UN lists Singapore -27.; Paul Ekblom & Nick Tilley, 'Going equipped: criminology,
as a SIDS, it is markedly different to other nations in this list situational crime prevention and the resourceful offender', British
due largely to stronger economic conditions, which is a strong Journal of Criminology, 40, 3: (Summer 2000): 376; Klaus Von
pull factor. (3) No adjustment was made for Haiti. Although it is Lampe, 'The application of the framework of Situational Crime
recognised as a SIDS, there was high confidence in the existing Prevention to 'organized crime'', Criminology and Criminal Justice,
data point for Haiti which was based on random sample survey 11 (2011): pp. 145-163.
data.http://www.un.org/en/events/islands2014/smallislands.shtml Kevin Bales, Ending Slavery: How we Free Today's Slaves, (Universi-
40
37
In simple terms, K-means is a statistical method which groups ty of California Press, 2007); Anne Gallagher & Paul Holmes,
similar items into clusters, ensuring that items not in the same 'Developing an Effective Criminal Justice Response to Human
cluster are as different as possible. This is achieved by allocating Trafficking: Lessons from the Frontline', International Criminal
an item to the cluster with the nearest centroid, or the mean of Justice Review, 18, 3, (September 2008), pp. 318-348; Office to
the cluster. The cluster's mean is then recalculated and the process Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, The 3Ps: Prevention,
of allocating items to clusters begins again until no items change Protection, Prosecution, (Democracy and Global Affairs, 2011),
groups, or those changes do not make a substantial difference in accessed 17/09/14:http://www.state.gov/documents/organiza-
the definition of clusters. tion/167334.pdf
38
Jacqueline Joudo Larsen, Monti Narayan Datta, and Kevin Bales, Due to the ongoing conflict and extreme disruption to govern-
41
'Modern Slavery: A global reckoning', Significance (Royal Statistical ment function, we have not included ratings for Afghanistan, Iraq,
Society October 2015. Available for download from:http://onlineli- Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen.
brary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1740-9713.2015.00854.x/pdf Calculated to equal a total of 100 points (so 100/28)
42
WWW.GLOBALSLAVERYINDEX.ORG
WWW.GLOBALSLAVERYINDEX.ORG