Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
a urology focus
Elinor Clarke
T
undertaken. Implications for health professionals include: a
his article, the third in a four-part series on female mandatory requirement that all registered health professionals
genital mutilation (FGM), provides an overview of must record and report FGM (Serious Crime Act 2015) and
FGM and explores the urological complications the need to take care to avoid accusations of FGM during
that can be experienced by women and girls who surgical procedures such as episiotomies and suturing.
have undergone its various forms.The anatomical
proximity of the urethra to some locations on the vulva where Classification
cutting might occur, the risk of local trauma and the possible WHO (2008) classified FGM into types 1–4 (Table 1).The use of
psychological sequelae of FGM may have implications for a numerical classification such as this creates the impression that
urological outcomes. In this article, particular consideration will either type 1 or 4 is the most severe procedure or causes more
be given to the difficulties associated with the management of adverse health consequences than the other types. However,
urinary retention, infection and dysuria in women who have this is not the case as type 4 consists of pricking, piercing and
experienced FGM. stretching of the labia, which may be considered less severe
than the other forms of FGM. Type 3 is generally regarded as
What is FGM? the most severe as it involves narrowing the vaginal orifice and
FGM can be defined as all procedures that intentionally alter cutting and aligning the labia minora and/or labia majora (with
or cause injury to the female genitalia or genital organs for or without excision of the external portion of the clitoris) to
non-medical reasons (World Health Organization (WHO), create a seal or blind pocket. Figures 1 and 2 show the differences
2016a). This spectrum of practices involves partial or total between the unaltered (normal) female genitalia and type 3.
removal of the external genitalia or genital glands (greater and Furthermore, the WHO (2008) classification is challenging
lesser vestibular glands) and genital organs (external clitoris). to put into practice because a clinical examination is required
Removal of or damage to healthy genitalia may interfere with to identify the type of FGM, based on what has been removed.
normal body functions and can cause immediate, short-term The wide variation in unaltered anatomy (Brodie et al, 2016)
or lasting effects (Leye et al, 2006; Andersson et al, 2012;Terry makes identification of a specific type of FGM problematic.
and Harris, 2013; Muteshi et al, 2016; Saunby and Dean, 2016; The WHO (2008) classification of type 4 is open to wide
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
setting, the instruments used and the skill of the person distorts the stream of urine, causes constant wetting of the area,
performing the cutting. Damage to the urethra during FGM makes catheterisation difficult and leads to the inner squamous
can lead to fistula and urethral strictures (Reisel and Creighton, epithelial surface becoming irritated and infected (Verzin, 1975).
2015). Some types of FGM, such as type 3, are thought to It is also thought that micturition becomes increasingly difficult,
increase the incidence of UTI due to the formation of scar owing to the presence of scar tissue and progressive contraction.
tissue, which sometimes conceals the urethral meatus.Verzin Difficult or painful micturition is associated with infection.
(1975) found that bladder and urethral fistulae can result from Verzin (1975) observed that a tight scar may lead to the
a poorly performed repair following childbirth. formation of a calculus in apposition to the urinary meatus.
There are no data to support or refute a correlation between the A calculus is formed by the build up of urinary salts, which
types of FGM and specific urological complications.This is a serious prevent the passage of urine. There is an assumption that type
research gap that needs to be addressed. A key finding, however, 3 FGM, which occludes or damages the urinary meatus, is
is that the genitourinary sequelae of FGM can be reported years, associated with an increased risk of UTI.
sometimes decades, following the procedure (Berg et al, 2014). Iavazzo et al (2013) stated that FGM is commonly performed
on women and girls without anaesthesia and antibiotics, and
Pathophysiology of urinary tract in the absence of aseptic conditions. However, whether or not
complications this is the case depends on the specific circumstances: in some
Dysuria and voiding difficulties settings, anaesthesia is used and the procedure is carried out by
Difficulty with micturition during the first 24 hours following a medical professional.The risk of urinary tract complications
some forms of FGM appears to be common, but is increased is thought to increase if the FGM is undertaken in unclean
in women and girls who experience extensive cutting and circumstances or there is poor genital hygiene. For this reason,
the formation of a flat surface over the urinary meatus or the severity of health consequences may vary.
labial fusion (Agugua and Egwuatu, 1982). Vella et al (2015) Following some types of FGM, urine may become stagnant,
suggested that voiding difficulties are experienced when the which may lead to chronic ascending bacteria. Berg et al
person initially tries to avoid pain by not voiding. Other studies (2014) identified 10 studies (n=28 940) that reported long-
have also reported fear of voiding (Verzin, 1975). Reasons for term genitourinary infections.These comparative studies were
this include dysuria due to the raw edges. undertaken between 1969 and 2005, and focused on women
In addition, the immediate aftermath of the cutting, some from countries with a high prevalence of type 3 FGM. The
girls in some communities have their legs tied together to stop early studies may not be relevant today.
bleeding, which can increase the likelihood of the formation
of scar tissue. In these circumstances, urination is not only Management of urological complications
physically difficult, but also is exacerbated by the fear of pain Assessment and identification of type of FGM
and the stress associated with voiding. Women and girls who have experienced FGM require a
culturally sensitive and non-judgemental approach. For health
Acute urinary retention educators who are unsure of how to initiate discussions, a useful
A tight circumcision or a completely obliterated orifice can starting point is to consider general bathroom experiences,
cause urinary retention (El Dareer, 1983b). Urinary retention is such as the number of visits and length of time spent in there.
common due to pain, swelling and inflammation (Little, 2003). Conversations could progress to identification of bladder issues,
Urinary retention experienced in the first 3 days following such as discomfort, pain, length of time to void and appearance
FGM has been attributed to postoperative pain, irritation of of urine.Women may complain of straining or a slowed urinary
the raw areas by urine and obstruction of the external urethral stream (Little, 2003).These questions should be asked in order
meatus by skin flaps or blood clots (Vella et al, 2015). to establish healthy behaviours and experiences. It is important
Acute urinary retention can be relieved at home by hot water, to bear in mind that women who have undergone FGM often
as medical care is not always sought (Shandall, 1967; Verzin, lack knowledge of unaltered anatomy and the function of female
1975). Bladder catheterisation is the preferred method of medical genital organs (Saunby and Dean, 2016).
management, but this may not be possible if the urethral meatus The size and appearance of unaltered female genitalia
has been obstructed, occluded or traumatised (Vella et al, 2015). varies widely throughout each woman’s lifetime. Brodie et al
Urethral injuries and acute urinary retention following some (2016) noted that paediatric female genitalia have not been
forms of FGM have been reported (Berg et al, 2014). Localised well described. The relationship between the clitorial hood
swelling resulting from cutting the genital area, as well as the and the urethral orifice and labia major, and the length and
restrictive movement and isolation following an act of FGM, depth of the labia minora, are poorly referenced. Brodie et al
can cause difficulty in voiding the bladder. If the urethral meatus (2016) suggested that the clitorial hood and the labia minora
is injured, it may develop a meatal obstruction and urinary are anatomically distinct structures in unaltered female genitalia.
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
strictures (Little, 2003). This small study (which observed 58 girls aged 0–16 years)
provides a reference for health professionals.
Urinary tract infections Genital examination is an intimate procedure that should
The possible mechanism for recurrent UTI is the ‘bridge of not be routinely undertaken. However, all girls with urological
skin’, or the closure and hiding of the urinary meatus, which symptoms should undergo a genital examination, although the
in these studies for preventing and treating urological physical changes that will occur to the appearance of the genitals,
complications, specifically UTIs and urinary retention in girls and the impact on urination and the importance of perineal hygiene.
women living with type 3 FGM.The WHO recommendation The data collection (mandatory recording to NHS data) at
number 3 (2016b) states that there is no direct evidence to the point of care (known as the enhanced data set) provides
recommend deinfibulation. information on the number of girls and women in England
Foundation for Women’s Health, Research and Development (FORWARD), com/zrouzck (accessed 29 September 2016)
London Vella M, Argo A, Costanzo A et al (2015) Female genital mutilations: genito-
El Dareer AA (1983a) Epidemiology of female circumcision in the Sudan. Trop urinary complications and ethical-legal aspects. Urologia 82(3): 151–9
Doc 13(1): 41–5 Verzin JA (1975) Sequale of female circumcision. Trop Doc 5: 163–9
El Dareer AA (1983b) Complications of female circumcision in the Sudan. Trop Vloeberghs E, van der Kwaak A, Knipscheer J, van den Muijsenbergh M (2012)
Doc 13(3): 131–3 Coping and chronic psychosocial consequences of female genital mutilation
Elmusharaf S, Elhadi N, Almroth L (2006) Reliability of self reported form of in The Netherlands. Ethn Health 17(6): 677–95