3UPPLY#HAIN$ESIGN0AST0RESENTAND&UTURE

+YLE$#ATTANI
+ELLEY3CHOOLOF"USINESS)NDIANA5NIVERSITY"LOOMINGTON).KCATTANI INDIANAEDU

6INCENT!-ABERT#ORRESPONDINGAUTHOR
+ELLEY3CHOOLOF"USINESS)NDIANA5NIVERSITY"LOOMINGTON).MABERT INDIANAEDU

!"342!#4
/PERATIONSMANAGERSINTHEPASTTHREEDECADESHAVEWITNESSEDAPERIODOFRAPIDCHANGEWITHADVANCES
INTECHNOLOGYMARKETGLOBALIZATIONANDINTERNATIONALTRADEAGREEMENTS7ITHANINCREASINGNUMBER
OFDOMESTICANDINTERNATIONALCOMPETITORSSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNHASBECOMEACRITICALSUCCESSFACTOR
FORORGANIZATIONSTOREMAINCOMPETITIVE'IVENTHEDYNAMICSOFTODAYSGLOBALBUSINESSENVIRONMENT
ITISUSEFULTOPROVIDEAPERSPECTIVE4HISARTICLESHARESSOMEINSIGHTSGAINEDFROMOURINVESTIGATION
OFRECENTCONTRIBUTIONSTOSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNINTHECONTEXTOFALONGHISTORYOFSUPPLYCHAINDESIGN
EFFORTS7EDElNESUPPLYCHAINMANAGEMENTBROADLYANDCONSIDERTHATWHILESUPPLYCHAINDESIGN
HASBEENCRITICALLYIMPORTANTFORMILLENNIAITHASEVOLVEDOVERTIME4HESUPPLYCHAINDESIGNDECI
SIONDOESNOTOCCURFREQUENTLYFORANORGANIZATIONBUTITSIMPACTISLONG TERM4HEAVAILABILITYOF
NEWTECHNOLOGYAFFECTINGMANUFACTURINGANDTRANSPORTATIONPLUSCHANGESTOINFORMATIONSYSTEMS
HAVEINCREASEDTHEPACEANDmOWOFMATERIALSANDDATA7HILETHEINTENSITYOFCHANGEHASINCREASED
INRECENTTIMESSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNISSUESTHEMSELVESHAVEEXISTEDSINCEANTIQUITY)NTHISPAPERWE
PROVIDEAHISTORICALPERSPECTIVEBYHIGHLIGHTINGSOMEPASTDEVELOPMENTSDISCUSSINGPRESENTIDEASAND
CONCEPTSANDSUGGESTINGFUTURESUPPLYCHAINDESIGNDIRECTIONS
+EYWORDSSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNSUPPLYCHAINMANAGEMENTVALUECHAINDESIGNLOGISTICS

).42/$5#4)/. THE NETWORK OF FACILITIES AND TASKS THAT COMPRISE

3UPPLYCHAINMANAGEMENTISACRITICALFUNCTIONFOR THE SUPPLY CHAINS NUMEROUS STAGES 4HE ABILITY
TWENTY lRSTCENTURYENTERPRISESCOMPETINGINTHE TO MONITOR AND CONTROL SUPPLY CHAIN mOWS HAS
GLOBALECONOMY-ANAGINGTHEmOWOFMATERIALS INCREASED DRAMATICALLY WITH WIDESPREAD INVEST
INFORMATION EQUIPMENT PERSONNEL AND MONEY MENTS IN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SUCH AS ENTER
FROM MULTIPLE SUPPLY SOURCES TO GEOGRAPHICALLY PRISERESOURCESPLANNING%20 SYSTEMS!CADEMIC
DISPERSEDCUSTOMERSANDPARTNERSISAMAJORCHAL RESEARCHINTHEAREAHASINCREASEDDURINGTHELAST
LENGEFORTODAYSMANAGERS TWODECADESTOADDRESSISSUESRANGINGFROMTRADI
4HECOMMERCIALAIRCRAFTINDUSTRYOFFERSAGOOD TIONALTOPICSSUCHASINVENTORYMANAGEMENTAND
EXAMPLEOFCHANGINGREQUIREMENTS)NTHEPASTA SUPPLIERDEVELOPMENTTOEMERGINGAREASSUCHASE
lRMWOULDDESIGNAPRODUCTITSELFANDMANUFAC COMMERCESUPPLYCHAINDISRUPTIONSANDSUSTAIN
TUREMOSTOFTHESUBASSEMBLIESANDCOMPONENTS ABLEENTERPRISES4HISGROWINGBODYOFKNOWLEDGE
PLUS PROVIDE AFTERMARKET SUPPORT 4ODAY lRMS HASPRIMARILYFOCUSEDONPROVIDINGBETTERGUIDE
SUCHAS"OEINGAND!IRBUSOUTSOURCEASIGNIlCANT LINES FOR EFFECTIVE IMPLEMENTATION AND EXECUTION
PORTION OF PRODUCT DESIGN TO KEY PARTNERS AND OFPOLICIESANDPROCEDURESTOCONTROLMATERIALAND
MANUFACTURING AND AFTERMARKET SUPPORT TAKES INFORMATIONmOWINCLUDINGTHEUSEOF*UST IN 4IME
PLACEINDIFFERENTPARTSOFTHEWORLD!SIMILARPAT *)4 SYSTEMSANDVENDOR MANAGEDINVENTORIES
TERNISPRESENTINOTHERINDUSTRIESSUCHASAPPLI 7HILE SIGNIlCANT WRITINGS FOCUS ON mOWS IN
ANCEMANUFACTURINGANDTRANSPORTATION THESUPPLYCHAINTHISARTICLECONCENTRATESONSUP
4OASSISTMANAGERSINTHISMORECOMPLEXWORLD PLYCHAINDESIGN4OPROVIDEACLEARSETTINGWElRST
MANYBUSINESSLEADERSHAVEADOPTEDVARIOUSSUP DElNEWHATASUPPLYCHAINISEXAMINEHOWWRITERS
PLYCHAINMANAGEMENTPRINCIPLESANDPROCEDURES DESCRIBE SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT AND PRESENT
TO ASSIST IN DESIGNING PLANNING AND CONTROLLING OURVISIONOFSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNCOMPONENTS3EC

\
 / /  N 6 / ,    . /   0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL

 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

ONDWHILEONEMAYASSUMESUPPLYCHAINDESIGNIS LEVELANDRECYCLING4HEACTIVITIESTOINCLUDEFORAN

ARECENTCONCERNWECONSIDERAHISTORICALPERSPEC ORGANIZATIONWILLBEDETERMINEDBYTHESCOPEOFTHE
TIVETHATLOOKSATHOWSOMEEARLYINDIVIDUALSAND BUSINESSENTERPRISE4HEVERYBREADTHOFTHESUPPLY
ORGANIZATIONS FOCUSED ON THIS CRITICAL AREA4HIRD CHAINMAKESTHEMANAGEMENTTASKCHALLENGING
WEINSPECTCURRENTWRITINGSTODETERMINECONTRIBU "OWERSOX #LOSS AND #OOPER  P 
TIONSDURINGTHELASTCOUPLEOFDECADES&OURTHWE STATETHATh3UPPLYCHAINMANAGEMENTCONSISTSOF
PRESENTACASESTUDYTHATHIGHLIGHTSHOWONElRMS lRMS COLLABORATING TO LEVERAGE STRATEGIC POSITION
USEOFTHE)NTERNETFORRETAILSALESINmUENCESSUPPLY ANDTOIMPROVEOPERATINGEFlCIENCY&OREACHlRM
CHAINDESIGN&INALLYWEDISCUSSFUTUREDIRECTIONS INVOLVEDTHESUPPLYCHAINRELATIONSHIPREmECTSA
FORSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNTHATWEBELIEVEAREOPPOR STRATEGIC CHOICE 4HE SUPPLY CHAIN STRATEGY IS A
TUNITIESTHATINTERESTEDINVESTIGATORSCANPURSUE CHANNEL ARRANGEMENT BASED ON ACKNOWLEDGED
DEPENDENCY AND COLLABORATION 3UPPLY CHAIN
3500,9#(!).-!.!'%-%.4$%&).%$ OPERATIONSREQUIREMANAGERIALPROCESSESTHATSPAN
!USEFULSTARTTOOURDISCUSSIONISLOOKINGATHOW FUNCTIONALAREASWITHININDIVIDUALlRMSANDLINK
CURRENTWRITERSDElNEhSUPPLYCHAINvVERSUShSUP TRADING PARTNERS AND CUSTOMERS ACROSS ORGANIZA
PLY CHAIN MANAGEMENTv4HIS IS HELPFUL BECAUSE TIONALBOUNDARIESv
THE MEANING AND RESPONSIBLE AREAS OF INCLUSION 4HE PREVIOUS DESCRIPTION SUGGESTS A STRATEGIC
OFTEN VARY FROM ONE INDIVIDUAL TO ANOTHER &OR VIEW OF SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT WHICH CAN
EXAMPLE3PRAGUE RECENTLYINDICATEDTHAT BE CONTRASTED WITH THIS SOMEWHAT MORE TACTICAL
SUPPLYCHAINMANAGEMENTISEQUIVALENTTOPHYSI APPROACH PUT FORWARD BY 3IMCHI ,EVI +AMIN
CAL DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT 0$-  WHICH IS SKYAND3IMCHI ,EVIP h3UPPLYCHAIN
PRIMARILY CONCERNED WITH OUTBOUND LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT IS A SET OF APPROACHES UTILIZED TO
ACTIVITIES/URFOCUSISBROADER#ONSIDERTHEFOL EFlCIENTLY INTEGRATE SUPPLIERS MANUFACTURERS
LOWINGTWODElNITIONSOFTHESUPPLYCHAIN WAREHOUSES AND STORES SO THAT MERCHANDISE IS
„ h!SUPPLYCHAINCONSISTSOFALLPARTIESINVOLVED PRODUCEDANDDISTRIBUTEDATTHERIGHTQUANTITIES
DIRECTLYORINDIRECTLYINFULlLLINGACUSTOMERRE TO THE RIGHT LOCATION AND AT THE RIGHT TIME IN
QUEST 4HE SUPPLY CHAIN INCLUDES NOT ONLY THE ORDERTOMINIMIZESYSTEM WIDECOSTSWHILESATISFY
MANUFACTURER AND SUPPLIERS BUT ALSO TRANSPORT INGSERVICELEVELREQUIREMENTSv
ERS WAREHOUSES RETAILERS AND EVEN CUSTOMERS 4HE DIFFERENT VIEWS TO DElNE SUPPLY CHAIN
THEMSELVES7ITHIN EACH ORGANIZATION SUCH AS A AND SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT INmUENCE HOW
MANUFACTURERTHESUPPLYCHAININCLUDESALLFUNC ONEMIGHTVIEWTHESUPPLYCHAINDESIGNDECISION
TIONSINVOLVEDINRECEIVINGANDlLLINGACUSTOMER 4HIS IN TURN CAN DETERMINE THE DESIGN PARAM
REQUEST4HESEFUNCTIONSINCLUDEBUTARENOTLIM ETERSOFTHESUPPLYCHAIN
ITED TO NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT MARKETING 7HAT ARE THE DESIGN PARAMETERS OF A SUPPLY
OPERATIONS DISTRIBUTION lNANCE AND CUSTOMER CHAIN7ElNDITHELPFULTOLOOKTOEARLIERWRIT
SERVICEv#HOPRAAND-EINDL  ERSFORGUIDANCE!SNOTEDBY'EORGE3ANTAYANA
„ h3UPPLYCHAINISTHENETWORKOFFACILITIESAND ;P=h4HOSEWHOCANNOTREMEMBERTHE
ACTIVITIESTHATPERFORMSTHEFUNCTIONSOFPRODUCT PASTARECONDEMNEDTOREPEATITv 4HEQUESTIONS
DEVELOPMENTPROCUREMENTOFMATERIALFROMVEN *OHN$UNCANPUTFORTHNEARLYYEARSAGO
DORSTHEMOVEMENTOFMATERIALSBETWEENFACILITIES P;NUMBERINGADDED= DEMONSTRATETHATWHILE
THE MANUFACTURING OF PRODUCTS THE DISTRIBUTION THE EMPHASIS AND FOCUS OF SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN
OFlNISHEDGOODSTOCUSTOMERSANDAFTER MARKET ISSUESEVOLVETHEQUESTIONSREMAINRELEVANTTODAY
SUPPORTFORSUSTAINMENTv-ABERTAND6ENKATARA  4O WHAT EXTENT SHALL THE ENTERPRISE BE THE
MANAN  SPECIALIZED
4HESETWODElNITIONSINDICATETHATTHESUPPLY  4O WHAT EXTENT SHALL THE BUSINESS BE INTE
CHAIN CAN ENCOMPASS NUMEROUS FACILITIES AND A GRATEDANDCONCENTRATED
BROADARRAYOFACTIVITIESFROMPRODUCTDESIGNAND  7HERESHALLTHEPLANTBELOCATED
UPSTREAMSOURCINGTOPRODUCTDELIVERYATTHERETAIL  (OWSHALLAPLANTTOBEBUILT

0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL \ 6 / ,    . /   N  //
 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

 7HAT FORM OF POWER SHALL BE EMPLOYED TO 4HESE EIGHT COMPONENTS ARE HIGHLY INTERRE
RUNTHEPLANT LATED MAKING DESIGN DECISIONS CHALLENGING &OR
 7HATSHALLBETHEBASISOFITSINTERNALORGANI EXAMPLE (EWLETT 0ACKARD (0 PRODUCES PRINT
ZATION ERS THAT ARE DISTRIBUTED WORLDWIDE USING A POST
 (OWSHALLTHELABORFORCEBEHANDLED PONEMENT PROCESS4HIS REQUIRES A TIERED SUPPLY
 (OWSHALLTHERAWMATERIALSBETREATED CHAIN IN WHICH VENDORS SUPPLY COMPONENTS TO
 (OWSHALLWEDETERMINETHEEFlCIENCYOFOUR (0 MANUFACTURING PLANTS AND DISTRIBUTION CEN
EQUIPMENT TERS THAT CONlGURE PRODUCTS4HE MANUFACTURED
 (OW SHALL THE GOODS BE DISTRIBUTED TO THE GENERIC PRINTER ENGINES UNITS ARE SHIPPED VIA
CONSUMER INTERMODALBULKCONTAINERS AS7)0TODISTRIBU
4HESHIFTINFOCUSFORSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNOVER TIONCENTERSFORlNALCONlGURATIONLABELSPOWER
THE PAST DECADES HAS BEEN TOWARD SUPPLIER AND SUPPLYSOFTWAREANDDOCUMENTATIONPROVIDEDBY
SOURCING MANAGEMENT AND PRODUCT AND PROCESS VENDORS BASED UPON DEMAND "ESIDES SHIPPING
CONlGURATIONS)NPARTICULARQUESTIONS PRODUCTSTOCUSTOMERS(0PROVIDESPRODUCTSUP
ANDREMAINTHEFOCUSOFSUPPLYCHAINDESIGN PORTTHROUGHCALLCENTERSANDPRODUCTTAKE BACK
ALTHOUGHQUESTIONSANDHAVEEVOLVEDTOTAKE FORWARRANTYANDRECYCLING4HEREFOREATWO WAY
AMOREGLOBALANDSTRATEGICFOCUS4HEREMAINING mOWOFMATERIALANDINFORMATIONOCCURSACROSSALL
QUESTIONSCONTINUETOBERELEVANTALTHOUGHPER STAGESOFTHESUPPLYCHAIN4HISmOWISTYPICALIN
HAPSWITHAMORETACTICALFOCUS7HILE$UNCANS TODAYS WORLD ECONOMY AS NUMEROUS TASKS AND
 QUESTIONS ASSIST IN DElNING AN ENTERPRISES PROCESSESAREPRESENTATALLSTAGESWITHINTHESUP
MISSION AND SCOPE THEY ALSO HELP IDENTIFY THE PLYCHAIN,EE"ILLINGTONAND#ARTER 
FOLLOWINGMAJORINTERRELATEDSUPPLYCHAINDESIGN %XHIBITGIVESANOVERVIEWOFATYPICALMOD
COMPONENTSCOMPANIESNEEDTOADDRESS ERN SUPPLY CHAIN AND A SAMPLE OF THE OPERATING
„ PRODUCTANDPROCESSCONlGURATIONˆPRODUCTBILL COMPONENTS IT INCLUDES !S ONE QUICKLY SEES A
OF MATERIAL "/- STRUCTURE PACKAGING HAN MODERNSUPPLYCHAINISCOMPOSEDOFPOTENTIALLY
DLINGENVIRONMENTALREQUIREMENTSASSEMBLYAND THOUSANDSOFCOMPONENTSWHICHINCLUDEMATERI
TEST SEQUENCES PERSONNEL SKILLSEQUIPMENT CAPA ALS THAT mOW IN AND OUT OF FACILITIES EQUIPMENT
BILITIESQUESTIONSAND THATMAKEANDMOVEPRODUCTSSYSTEMSTHATMONI
„ SUPPLIERSˆSINGLE VERSUS MULTIPLE SOURCES NUM TOR AND EXCHANGE DATA mOW AND PERSONNEL WHO
BER OF TIERS ALLIANCES VERSUS BIDDING REQUEST FOR PROCESSTRANSACTIONSANDPLANACTIONS'ENERALLY
QUOTE;2&1=ORREVERSEAUCTION QUESTIONAND NO ONE ENTERPRISE PERFORMS ALL THE SUPPLY CHAIN
„ FACILITIESˆROLE MANUFACTURING DISTRIBUTION TASKSBUTANUMBEROFTRADINGPARTNERSTHATARE
WAREHOUSINGORSERVICECENTER CAPACITYPROCESS BOTH UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAM WORK TOGETHER
ESEMPLOYEDLOCATIONQUESTION 5SINGBOTHMANUALANDAUTOMATEDPROCESSESTHEY
„ INVENTORYˆSEASONAL AND CYCLE INVENTORY LEVELS MANAGETHEmOWFROMSOURCETOUSETOTAKE BACK
RAW VERSUS WORK IN PROCESS 7)0 VERSUS lNISHED
GOODSINVENTORY&') STATUSLOCATIONQUESTION 3/-%()34/2)#!,/"3%26!4)/.3
„ TRANSPORTATIONˆMODE OPTIONS INFRASTRUCTURE 7HILE SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN COMPONENTS SUCH AS
REQUIREMENTSQUESTIONSAND SUPPLIERSOURCINGANDPRODUCTIONPROCEDURESARE
„ MANAGEMENT SYSTEMSˆPERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES MAJOR TOPICS IN TODAYS MANAGEMENT LITERATURE
MEASUREMENT METRICS OPERATING POLICIES AND THEY HAVE CONCERNED ORGANIZATIONS SINCE ANCIENT
PROCEDURESCHANNELINCENTIVESANDCOORDINATION TIMES#ONSIDERAFEWEXAMPLESFROMHISTORY
QUESTION „ SUPPLY SOURCEˆ4HE PYRAMIDS OF %GYPT USE
„ PERSONNELSYSTEMSˆKNOWLEDGEBASESKILLSETS FULLYILLUSTRATESUPPLYCHAINDESIGNISSUESINEARLY
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS QUESTIONS TIMES3UPPLIERSOFQUARRIEDLIMESTONEHADTOBE
AND IDENTIlED AND ARRANGED WITHIN REASONABLE DIS
„ INFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYˆDATAELEMENTSCAPTURE TANCE FROM 'IZA 0LATEAU THE CONSTRUCTION SITE
SYSTEMSANALYSISANDREPORTINGSYSTEMSNEW  "ECAUSEBUILDINGMATERIALSWERELARGEANDHEAVY

\
 / /  N 6 / ,    . /   0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL

 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

%8()")4 %XAMPLESOF3UPPLY#HAIN$ESIGN#OMPONENTS

IALS -ATERIAL)NFORMATION&INANCIAL&LOWS #ON

- ATER SUM
ER
2AW
)NBOUND -ANUFACTURING /UTBOUND 2ETAIL!FTER
3OURCING
,OGISTICS ,OGISTICS -ARKET3ERVICE

z ENDOR
6 z AREHOUSE
7 z 0 RODUCT z $#LOCATIONS z ETAILnNUMBER
2
NUMBER NUMBER FORECASTS LOCATION
LOCATION LOCATIONSIZE z #FUNCTIONS
$ )NTERNET
CAPACITY FUNCTIONETC z 0ROCESSCHOICES ANDSIZE
ALLOCATIONETC z UMBERAND
.
z 4 RANSPORTATION z #APACITYLEVELS z )N HOUSEVERSUS LOCATIONOF
z 0 RODUCTDESIGN MODE N -ACHINE CONTRACTCARRIER SERVICECALL
SUPPORT N 7ORKFORCE
z )NVENTORYSAFETY CENTERS
z )N HOUSEVERSUS
4 OOLINGDESIGN CONTRACTCARRIER STOCKLEVELS & UNCTIONAND
z z 0 ROCESS z
ANDSUPPLY TECHNOLOGIES z !3!2SYSTEMS SIZE
z )NVENTORYSAFETY
OFROBOTICS
z POTMARKET
3 STOCKLEVELS 0 ACKAGE z PARES
3
#!- z
PURCHASEOF ENGINEERING INVENTORYLEVEL
PARTNERSHIP z !3!2SYSTEMS ANDLOCATIONS
z LLIANCESJOINT
!
z AREHOUSE
7 VENTURES z $))NTERNET
%
z ELIVERY
$ LINKS z ERVICEFLEET
3
SCHEDULES MANAGEMENT SIZEAND
z ATERIAL
-
SYSTEM HIPPING
3 EQUIPMENT
PLANNING z
z UPPLIER
3 SCHEDULES
DEVELOPMENT z EHICLE
6 $ATAMINING
z %20SYSTEMS z
DISPATCHING z 0 RODUCT
z 0/TRACKING z !3NOTICES CONFIGURATION z ORKFORCESKILLS
7
z ARCODING
" LEVELS
z $))NTERNET
% 2&)$ z )NVENTORYLEVELS
LINKS z ARRANTY
7
z UALITY
1 PROCESS
ASSURANCE
z ISPOSAL
$
z 0 RODUCT PROCESS
DEVELOPMENT
z 0/3LINKS

!DAPTEDFROM-ABERT6INCENT!AND-!6ENKATARAMANANh3PECIAL2ESEARCH&OCUSON3UPPLY#HAIN,INKAGES#HALLENGESFOR

$ESIGNAND-ANAGEMENTINTHEST#ENTURYv$ECISION3CIENCES6OLNO

ANDTRANSPORTATIONTECHNOLOGYWASLIMITEDSUP BRANCHDEVOTEDTOLOGISTICSBUTSUPPLYINGTROOPS

PLYCHAINDESIGNREQUIREDTHEBUILDINGSITEBENEAR INTHElELDOFTENSTARTEDFROM)TALYOR'AULUSING
TOLIMESTONESUPPLYSOURCESˆINSOMECASESNEXT BOTH WATER 2OMAN .AVY AND ROAD TRANSPORTA
TOTHEPYRAMIDS,EHNER  TION 7HILE 2OMAN ARMIES IN ENEMY TERRITORY
„ INFRASTRUCTUREˆ!NOTHERHISTORICALEXAMPLEFO WOULD OFTEN SUPPLEMENT OR REPLACE SUPPLIED RA
CUSESONTHE2OMAN%MPIREANDREPRESENTSSOME TIONS WITH FORAGING OR PURCHASING FOOD LOCALLY
BLOCK AND TACKLECOMPONENTSOFSUPPLYCHAINDE THISWASOFTENINSUFlCIENTFORTHEIRNEEDSASINGLE
SIGN THE %MPIRES SYSTEM OF BUILDING AN EXTEN LEGIONREQUIREDTONSOFFOODPERMONTHAN
SIVEWELL MAINTAINEDROADNETWORK4HESEROADS AMOUNT IMPOSSIBLE TO SOURCE LOCALLY (EATHER
INCLUDED ESTABLISHED MILEAGE MARKERS MEASURED P 3HIPSANDCARTSWEREMAJORCONVEY
BYANODOMETER4HISALLOWEDFORACCURATECALCU ANCEMODESTOMOVESUPPLIESBUTTHEROADINFRA
LATIONOFTHETIMENECESSARYTOTRAVELACERTAINDIS STRUCTUREITSELFWASAKEYCOMPONENTOFTHESUPPLY
TANCEFACILITATINGMULTIPLESUPPORTPLANS3UPPLY CHAINDESIGN
CHAINMANAGEMENTFORTHE2OMANSASFORMANY „ PRODUCT SECURITYˆ4HE .ABATAEANS OF 0ETRA
CIVILIZATIONSWASDRIVENINLARGEPARTBYMILITARY PRESENT DAY SOUTHWESTERN *ORDAN  WERE IMPOR
CONCERNS4HE2OMANMILITARYHADNOSPECIALIZED TANTCOMMERCIALTRADERSINTHE-IDDLE%ASTDUR

0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL \ 6 / ,    . /   N  //
 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

ING THE 2OMAN %MPIRE )T WAS COMMON IN THAT MANUFACTURINGPERFORMANCEDATAUSINGINDEXCARDS
PERIODFORPRODUCTSINTRANSITTOBETAMPEREDWITH (EPROPOSEDACOSTCOLLECTIONSYSTEMTHATFOCUSED
OR ACCESSED )N RESPONSE THE .ABATAEANS DEVEL
ON TRANSACTIONS AND CREATED A CARD SYSTEM AS THE
OPED SECURITY APPROACHES ALLOWING THE LONG
DIS
BASICDATAELEMENTFORSTORINGONEPIECEOFINFOR

TANCETRANSPORTOFVALUABLECARGOES&OREXAMPLE MATION2EID "EFORETHENALLINFORMATION
THECONTAINERDEVELOPEDNEARTHEENDOFTHElRST WASKEPTINALEDGERORLOGTHATLISTEDITEMSSEQUEN

CENTURYWASTHEPIRIFORMUNGUENTARIUM)TWASA TIALLY4HECARDSYSTEMWASAUNITRECORDAPPROACH
PEAR
SHAPEDBOTTLEWITHALONGNECKUSINGACLAY FORINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYCONCERNEDWITHSTOR

STOPPER4HIS POTTERY CONTAINER WAS CONSTRUCTED ING DATA THAT ENABLED REARRANGING AND EASY SORT

TOMAXIMIZEPRODUCTINTEGRITYANDSECURITY4HE ING OF TRANSACTIONS TO MONITOR PERFORMANCE OVER
CLAY WAS SOURCED FROM A VERY LOW
POROSITY lELD TIME4HIS MEANT THAT MANAGEMENT COULD BETTER
NEAR 0ETRA WHERE IT WAS LEVIGATED TO FURTHER RE
EVALUATESHOPPERFORMANCEWITHINASUPPLYCHAINS
DUCE POROSITY AND THEN THE UNGUENTARIA WERE PRODUCTIONFACILITY7HILE-ETCALFESCONCERNWAS
SLIPPEDANDlREDINACONTROLLEDWAYATUPTO— THE&RANKFORT!RSENALSOPERATIONSTHECONCEPTOF
&UNUSUALLYHIGHHEATINTHATERA TOFURTHERRE
UNITRECORDDATAISTHEBASISOFALL%20PROCESSING
DUCEPOROSITYANDACHIEVEAQUARTZ
LIKEHARDNESS ANDDATAANALYSISTODAY
4HELOWPOROSITYANDOPAQUEBODYREDUCEDEVAP
„ INTEGRATEDMANUFACTURINGˆ)NTHETWENTIETHCEN

ORATION AND MAINTAINED THE INTEGRITY AND SCENT TURY(ENRY&ORDWORKEDTOWARDAFULLYINTEGRATED
OF THE CONTENTS4O ACCESS ITS CONTENTS A PERSON
HAD TO BREAK THE BOTTLE WHEN REMOVING ITS CLAY
STOPPER4HISPRECLUDEDADULTERATIONENROUTEAND
RESULTED IN A hONE
USEv FEATURE OF THE CONTAINERS
SUPPLY CHAIN &OR EXAMPLE THE COMPANY OWNED
FORESTSTHATPROVIDEDLUMBERFORWHEELSPOKESAND
IRONMINESIN-INNESOTAFORTHEPRODUCTIONOFEN
GINEBLOCKS"UILDINGONHISSUCCESSINEFlCIENTLY
(ULLP  MASSPRODUCINGAFFORDABLEAUTOMOBILESALTHOUGH
„ STANDARDIZEDCOMPONENTSˆ4HE6ENICE!RSENAL CUSTOMERCHOICEWASLIMITEDTOhANYCOLOURSO
PROVIDES ANOTHER CASE IN POINT $URING THE TH LONGASITISBLACKv;&ORDAND#ROWTHERP
AND TH CENTURIES THE ARSENAL EMPLOYED UP TO = &ORDDESIGNEDHISMASSIVE2IVER2OUGEPLANT
WORKERSANDWASONEOFTHELARGESTINDUSTRI
TOFULLYINTEGRATETHESUPPLYCHAINFROMRAWMATERI

ALWORKSINTHE7ESTERNWORLD4HETASKASSIGNED ALSTOlNALPRODUCT4HESUPPLYCHAININCLUDEDORE
TOTHEARSENALWASTOPRODUCEMORETHANNAVAL PROCESSINGRAILROADSANDEVENANELECTRICITYPLANT
WARSHIPSQUICKLYTORESPONDTOA4URKTHREATINTHE TOPROVIDEPOWER&ORD 
-EDITERRANEAN-ASSPRODUCTIONPROCEDURESMAY
HAVEPREDATEDTHEOPERATIONSATTHE6ENICE!RSE
2%#%.4$%6%,/0-%.43
NALBUTHEREISTHElRSTDOCUMENTEDAPPROACHED 7HILE SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN COMPONENTS HAVE
TO CONTROL THE mOW OF MATERIAL ACROSS A SERIES OF CONCERNEDENTERPRISESFORCENTURIESANUMBEROF
OPERATIONS ,ANE   !DDITIONALLY "ALDISSERA ADVANCEDTHINKERSANDWRITERSHAVETAKENAMORE
$RACHIO AN ARSENAL MASTER TECHNICIAN SPECIlED STRATEGIC PERSPECTIVE TODAY 4HE SUPPLY CHAINS
INTHEUSEOFhCOMMONTIMBERvTOOVERCOME GOAL IS TO SUPPORT THE MARKET STRATEGY AND ITS
THEINDIVIDUALCHARACTEROFTHECOMPONENTDESIGN DESIGN MUST ALIGN ACCORDINGLY 7HAT ARE THOSE
ANDCONSTRUCTIONPROCESSESREmECTINGADESIREFOR GOALS&ISHER PROPOSESTHATSUPPLYCHAINS
STANDARDIZEDCOMPONENTS:AN2OSSAND:AM
BE VIEWED ALONG A CONTINUUM FROM EFlCIENT TO
BON (EREONESEESTHEINTERRELATIONSHIPOF RESPONSIVETOMEETCUSTOMERSPRIORITIES+NOWING
THE FACILITYS PRODUCTION PROCESS RAPID ASSEMBLY THE TARGET DETERMINES THE NATURE OF THE DESIGN
OFNAVYSHIPSANDTHEPRODUCTCONlGURATIONMA
COMPONENTS SUCH AS SUPPLIER REQUIREMENTS AND
TERIAL COMPONENT STANDARDIZATION REQUIREMENTS INVENTORYTARGETSASINDICATEDIN%XHIBIT
INmUENCINGSUPPLYCHAINPERFORMANCE /RGANIZATIONS HAVE PURSUED OTHER OBJECTIVES
„ INVENTORYCONTROLˆ)NATTHE&RANKFORT!R
LIKE LEAN 7INCEL  AND INTEGRATED SUPPLY
SENALIN0HILADELPHIA#APT(ENRY-ETCALFEOUT
CHAINS4HE LEAN PERSPECTIVE FOLLOWS MANY CON

LINEDANAPPROACHFORRECORDINGANDTRANSMITTING CEPTSDEVELOPEDBY4OYOTA#ORPORATIONOVERTHE

\
 / /  N 6 / ,    . /   0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL

 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

%8()")4 #OMPARISONOF%FFICIENTAND2ESPONSIVE3UPPLY#HAINS

%FFICIENT 2ESPONSIVE

0RIMARYGOAL 3UPPLYPREDICTABLEDEMANDEFFICIENTLY 2ESPONDQUICKLYTOSALESOPPORTUNITIES

ATLOWESTPOSSIBLECOST MINIMIZESTOCKOUTSAVOIDMARKDOWNSON
OBSOLETEINVENTORIES

-ANUFACTURING %FFICIENCYHIGHUTILIZATIONOFCAPACITY -AINTAINBUFFERCAPACITYFORPROVIDE

IMPERATIVES VOLUMEANDPRODUCTVARIETYFLEXIBLITY

)NVENTORYSTRATEGY !CHIEVEHIGHTURNOVERBYMINIMIZING $EPLOYBUFFERSTOCKSFOCOMPONENTSAND

STOCKTHROUGHOUTCHAIN MODULESAWAITINGFINALCONFIGUATION

,EADTIMES 3HORTENIFITDOESNTINCREASECOST )NVESTAGGRESSIVELYTOREDUCELEADTIME

3UPPLIERSELECTIONCRITERIA #OSTQUALITY 3PEEDFLEXIBILITYQUALITY

!DAPTEDFROM&ISHER-ARSHALLh7HATISTHERIGHTSUPPLYCHAINFORYOURPRODUCTv(ARVARD"USINESS2EVIEW-ARCH !PRIL  

PAST  YEARS FOR MANUFACTURING TO PULL MATE !MERICANPRODUCTSUPPLYCHAINWHICHCOMPRISED
RIALTHROUGHTHESYSTEMANDLOOKFORCONTINUOUS THE5NITED3TATES#ANADAAND-EXICO4HElRM
IMPROVEMENTPROCESSESTOENHANCEPERFORMANCE NEEDEDTOCONSOLIDATEPLANTSTOREDUCEMANUFAC
3IMILARLY INTEGRATED SUPPLY CHAINS ARE NOT NEW TURING EXPENSE AND WORKING CAPITAL TO IMPROVE
!SMENTIONEDABOVETHE&ORD-OTOR#OMPANYS SPEEDTOMARKETANDTOAVOIDCAPITALINVESTMENT
MATERIAL mOW DURING THE S AND S IS A FEWER PRODUCTION LINE CONVERSIONS BECAUSE OF
CLASSICILLUSTRATION4ODAYOILlRMSSUCHAS%XXON NEWREFORMULATION 4HESTUDYREEXAMINED0'S
AND3HELLAREINTEGRATEDFROMOILlELDTORETAILGAS PRODUCT SOURCING AND DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM FOR ITS
STATIONENABLINGSIGNIlCANTCOORDINATIONCONTROL .ORTH !MERICAN OPERATIONS 4HE METHODOLOGY
INACOMMODITYINDUSTRY DEVELOPED TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM MERGED 0'S
4HESE STRATEGIC SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN GOALS DATAPROCESSPROCESSINGWITHOPTIMIZATIONMODELS
INmUENCE MORE TACTICAL DECISIONS THAT ORGANIZA AND A GEOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION SYSTEM WHICH
TIONSULTIMATELYMUSTDETERMINE)TISATTHISLEVEL PROVIDED AN IMPROVED SUPPLY CHAIN CONlGURA
THATANUMBEROFCONTRIBUTIONSHAVEBEENMADE TION#AMM#HORMAN$ILL%VANS3WEENYAND
TO DESIGN ISSUES 4WO CASE STUDIES PUBLISHED IN 7EGRYN 
THE S ILLUSTRATE THE INTEREST IN DESIGN AND !STHESETWOCASESTUDIESILLUSTRATETHESUPPLY
APPROACHES TAKEN AT THESE lRMS 4HE lRST CON CHAIN DESIGN DECISION HAS CONCERNED ENTERPRISES
CERNS $IGITAL %QUIPMENT #ORPORATION WHICH FORMANYYEARS4HEPRIMARYTOOLSUSEDTOASSISTIN
EVALUATED ITS GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN ALTERNATIVES THEDESIGNPROCESSEMPLOYEDENTERPRISEDATABASES
AND DETERMINED WORLDWIDE MANUFACTURING AND MATHEMATICAL PROGRAMMING MODELS SIMULATIONS
DISTRIBUTION STRATEGY 5SING A LARGE MIXED INTE ANDGEOGRAPHICALINFORMATIONSYSTEMS)NFACTTHE
GER LINEAR PROGRAM THE APPROACH RECOMMENDED LAST DECADE HAS SEEN MANY SUPPLY CHAIN REDESIGN
A PRODUCTION DISTRIBUTION AND VENDOR NETWORK INITIATIVESASCONSULTINGlRMSLIKE!CCENTUREAND
FORTHElRM4HEGOALWASTOMEETMANYREQUIRE IENGAGEWITHCLIENTSTORECONlGURETHEIRCHAINS
MENTSSUCHASESTIMATEDDEMANDRESTRICTIONSON SUPPLYPRODUCTIONANDDISTRIBUTIONCOMPONENTS
LOCALCONTENTOFFSETTRADEANDJOINTCAPACITYFOR 7HILEPRACTICINGMANAGERSHAVELOOKEDATTHE
MULTIPLE PRODUCTS WHILE MINIMIZING lXED AND SUPPLYCHAINDESIGNDECISIONTHEACADEMICCOM
VARIABLECOSTSSUCHASVARIABLEPRODUCTIONCHARGES MUNITYHASALSOINVESTIGATEDTHISAREA)NDE
INVENTORYCHARGESDISTRIBUTIONEXPENSESVIAMUL +OKAND'RAVESEDITEDABOOKFOCUSINGONSUPPLY
TIPLE MODES TAXES DUTIES AND DUTY DRAWBACK CHAIN DESIGN COORDINATION AND OPERATION )T IS
!RNTZEN"ROWN(ARRISONAND4RAFTON  USEFULTONOTEWHATTHEVARIOUSAUTHORSDISCUSSED
4HE SECOND EXAMPLE FOCUSES ON 0ROCTER  IN THE BOOKS SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN SECTION 4HE
'AMBLES 0'S RE EXAMINATION OF ITS .ORTH CHAPTERS INCLUDED MODELS FOR DETERMINING THE

0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL \ 6 / ,    . /   N  //
 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

NUMBER OF WAREHOUSES WAREHOUSE LOCATIONS PRECONlGUREDSTANDARD BAGSARESOLD!NIMPOR

WAREHOUSESIZINGPRODUCTSHIPPINGORIGINTODES
TANT ASPECT OF 4IMBUKS SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN
TINATION ANDLOCATIONOFINVENTORIESRAWMATE
FOR DELIVERING MASS
CUSTOMIZED PRODUCTS IS THE
RIAL7)0ANDlNISHGOODS INTHESUPPLYCHAIN COMPANYSmEXIBLE3AN&RANCISCOFACTORYSABILITY
ASWELLASISSUESOFPRODUCTVOLUMEANDMIXmEX
TOPRODUCEANINDIVIDUALBAGOFANYCONlGURATION
IBILITYANDEMPLOYINGAPOSTPONEMENTAPPROACH AND DELIVER IT WITHIN DAYS TO ANY 53 LOCATION
THATISINmUENCEDBYCOMPONENTSTANDARDIZATION #ATTANI$AHANAND3CHMIDT 
ANDCOMMONALITY!NOTHEREDITEDBOOKBY3IM
!TTHETIMEOFTHISSTUDYBY#ATTANI$AHAN
CHI
,EVI7U AND 3HEN  INCLUDES A SIMI
AND 3CHMIDT  4IMBUK WAS USING A 3AN
LAR MODELING APPROACH TO LOCATION PLANT SIZING &RANCISCO FACTORY TO lLL DEMAND FOR BOTH THE
PRODUCT ASSIGNMENT VOLUME AND SO ON FACTORS MASS
CUSTOMIZED BAGS SOLD ONLINE AND THE STAN

THE AUTHORS SUGGEST SHOULD BE A lRMS PRIMARY DARDMAKE
TOSTOCK-43 BAGSSOLDINITSTRADI

DESIGNCONSIDERATIONS TIONAL RETAIL CHANNEL 7HILE EMPLOYING A hCLICKS
7HILETHISSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNREVIEWISCUR
AND BRICKSv RETAIL STRATEGY FOR MEETING DEMAND
SORYINSCOPEWEHOPEITPROVIDESTHEREADERABET
MANAGEMENT CONSIDERED REDESIGNING THE lRMS
TERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEENORMITYOFTHEDESIGN SUPPLY CHAIN TO ADD AN OFFSHORE FACTORY TO PRO

DECISION 7HILE HUNDREDS OF ARTICLES HAVE BEEN DUCESOMEORALLOFTHESTANDARDBAGS7HILETHE
WRITTEN IN THE LAST DECADE ON VARIOUS TOPICS LIKE OFF
SHORECAPACITYWOULDPRODUCEATALOWERUNIT
BUSINESS
TO
BUSINESS"" CONTRACTSVENDORALLI
COSTTHANTHECURRENTFACILITYITWOULDNOTBEABLE
ANCES REVERSE AUCTIONS VENDOR MANAGED INVEN
TOlLLDEMANDFORTHEMASS
CUSTOMIZEDMAKE
TO

TORY6-) ANDTHIRD
PARTYLOGISTICS0, FEW ORDER-4/ BAGSSOLDONLINEINATIMELYMAN

WRITERSHAVEEXTENDEDTHERESULTSOFTHEIRSTUDIES
TO DEMONSTRATE HOW THE SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN IS
AFFECTED%XISTINGWORKISMOSTLYMYOPICINVIEW
4IMBUKS MANAGEMENT TEAM WONDERED WHAT
ING THE NATURE OF THE PROBLEM BEING ADDRESSED
NER!SARESULTTHE3AN&RANCISCOFACTORYWOULD
CONTINUETOPRODUCETOMEETTHIS-4/DEMAND
EFFECT A SHIFT TO OFFSHORE PRODUCTION OF STANDARD
/NE NEEDS TO SEE HOW THESE INDIVIDUAL DESIGN BAGSWOULDHAVEONOVERALLCOSTSINCLUDINGTHOSE
DECISION COMPONENTS CASCADE AND INTERACT WITH ATTHEmEXIBLEDOMESTICFACTORYWHERETHECUSTOM
OTHERPARTSOFTHESUPPLYCHAIN BAGSWOULDCONTINUETOBEPRODUCED
)NTHENEXTSECTIONWEILLUSTRATEHOWONElRM -ANAGERS READILY CALCULATED THE DIRECT UNIT
USESTHE)NTERNETASPARTOFITSRETAILREACHTOTHE COST SAVINGS THE OFFSHORE STRATEGY OFFERED FROM
CUSTOMERANDITSIMPACTONTHEENTERPRISESOVERALL THEUSEOFEFlCIENTPRODUCTIONREDUCEDUNITCOST
SUPPLYCHAINDESIGN4HISISFOLLOWEDBYADISCUS
TIMES UNITS PRODUCED  )N CONTRAST USING ONLY
SIONFOCUSINGONANUMBEROFDESIGNAREASNEEDING THE DOMESTIC FACTORY TO PRODUCE BOTH STANDARD
FURTHERINVESTIGATIONINTHETWENTY
lRSTCENTURY AND MASS
CUSTOMIZED PRODUCTS RESULTED IN LOWER
AMORTIZEDlXEDCOSTPERUNITBYMAKINGBETTERUSE
7(%2%).4(%7/2,$)34)-"5+ OFCAPACITYANDTHUSYIELDSCOUNTER
BENElTSTHAT
4IMBUKA3AN&RANCISCO
BASEDMANUFACTUREROF ARELESSAPPARENT4IMBUKSMANAGERSSUSPECTED
BICYCLEMESSENGERBAGSHASAN)NTERNETSITEWHERE OPENING AN OFFSHORE FACILITY COULD SAVE MONEY
CUSTOMERS CONlGURE AND ORDER MASS
CUSTOMIZED UNLESS THE PERCENTAGE OF TOTAL ORDERS FOR CUSTOM
BAGSSHIPPEDDIRECTLYFROMTHEMANUFACTURER 4HE PRODUCTSWASSUFlCIENTLYHIGHTHATISABOVESOME
)NTERNET CHANNEL TAKES ADVANTAGE OF 4IMBUKS THRESHOLD  ALTHOUGH MANAGEMENT DID NOT HAVE
mEXIBLE MANUFACTURING CAPABILITIES AND COMPLE
A GOOD INTUITION FOR WHAT LEVEL WOULD BE hSUFl

MENTSTHElRMSTRADITIONALRETAILCHANNELWHERE CIENTv!NSWERINGTHISQUESTION#ATTANI$AHAN


4HEINTERESTEDREADERCANLINKTOTHECOMPANYWEBSITEATWWWTIMBUKCOM

!T4IMBUKSTANDARDANDCUSTOMPRODUCTSAREASSOCIATEDWITHRETAILSTORESAND)NTERNETSALESRESPECTIVELY)NREALITYTHEDISTRIBUTIONCHANNELAND
PRODUCTTYPENEEDNOTBELINKEDnTHECOMPANYCOULDALSOSELLSTANDARDBAGSDIRECTLYTOCUSTOMERSANDCUSTOMIZEDBAGSTHROUGHRETAILERS4HEANALYSIS
WOULDBESIMILAR

\
 / /  N 6 / ,    . /   0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL

 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

AND 3CHMIDT  DETERMINED THE THRESHOLD CONSUMERCONlDENCETRANSPORTATIONROADBLOCKS

TOBEAPPROXIMATELYONE HALF4HATISIFDEMAND SUCH AS THE  7EST #OAST PORT CLOSURES THAT
FORMASS CUSTOMIZEDPRODUCTSCOMPRISEDROUGHLY BROUGHTTHOUSANDSOF53BUSINESSESTOASTAND
ONE HALFORMORE OFTOTALDEMANDTHENITWOULD STILL CUSTOMER BANKRUPTCIES SUCH AS THE RECENT
NOT BE FRUITFUL TO OPEN THE OFFSHORE PLANT 3UR #IRCUIT #ITY CLOSURE THAT DRAMATICALLY AFFECTED
PRISINGLYMANAGERSFOUNDTHETHRESHOLDROBUSTTO MANY CONSUMER ELECTRONICS MANUFACTURERS TER
THECOSTOFEFlCIENTCAPACITY%VENIFITWASMUCH RORISTATTACKSANDPOLITICALUNRESTWHICHCANAFFECT
CHEAPERPERUNITTOOPENANDUSEANEFlCIENTFACIL SUPPLYDISTRIBUTIONANDTRANSPORTATIONFACILITIES
ITYTOPRODUCESTANDARDPRODUCTSWHENDEMAND ANDDRAMATICCHANGESINCURRENCYEXCHANGERATES
FORMASS CUSTOMIZEDUNITSISABOVETHETHRESHOLD INmUENCINGTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENPROlTANDLOSS
OVERALLCOSTSARELOWERIFTHEEFlCIENTFACILITYISNOT !DDRESSINGSOMEOFTHESEPOTENTIALPROBLEMSISA
OPENED)NSHORTAlRMTHATISPRIMARILYAMASS MAJOR CHALLENGE FOR TODAYS MANAGER INVOLVING
CUSTOMIZERMAYSAVEMONEYBYCENTRALIZINGPRO RISK ASSESSMENT AND THE EVALUATION OF TRADE OFFS
DUCTION OF STANDARD -43 PRODUCTS IN THE SAME FORSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNALTERNATIVES
FACILITYINWHICHITPRODUCES-4/ITEMS „ DESIGN FOR SUSTAINABILITYˆ"USINESSES FACE IN
4HE4IMBUKEXAMPLEILLUSTRATESSOMEISSUESOF CREASING PRESSURE TO PAY MORE ATTENTION TO EN
SUPPLYCHAINDESIGNDECISIONS&IRSTTRADEOFFSEXIST VIRONMENTAL AND RESOURCE CONSEQUENCES OF THE
INPRODUCTANDPROCESSCONlGURATIONSFACILITYLOCA PRODUCTSANDSERVICESTHEYOFFERANDTHEPROCESSES
TIONSANDCAPACITYDECISIONSANDCHANNELMANAGE THEY DEPLOY #OMMUNITIES DEMAND HIGHER STAN
MENT3ECONDTHEDESIGNDECISIONCANBEDYNAMIC DARDSOFAIRWATERANDSOILQUALITY%UROPEANAND
REQUIRING ROUTINE MONITORING OF THE OPERATING *APANESE LEGISLATION ON PRODUCT TAKE BACK AND
ENVIRONMENT&OR4IMBUKASHIFTINTHEPROPOR WASTEEXPORTSALSOCREATECHALLENGESANDPOSSIBLE
TIONOF-4/VERSUS-43DEMANDWOULDSIGNALA OPPORTUNITIESFORMANUFACTURERS3USTAINABLEEN
CHANGEINTHEOPTIMAL SOURCINGORIGIN TERPRISESMEETPRESENTNEEDSWITHOUTCOMPROMIS
7E NEXT EXPLORE OTHER DIRECTIONS FOR SUPPLY INGTHEABILITYOFFUTUREGENERATIONSTOMEETTHEIR
CHAINDESIGNINTHETWENTY lRSTCENTURY OWNNEEDS!SBUSINESSESADDRESSRELEVANTDOMES
TIC AND INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION
&5452%$)2%#4)/.3 THEYWILLNEEDTODESIGNTHEIRPRODUCTSANDSUPPLY
!S MENTIONED ABOVE AN ENTERPRISE MUST REVIEW CHAINSCONSIDERINGSUSTAINABILITYISSUES
ITS SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN CONlGURATION ROUTINELY „ DESIGN FOR MASS CUSTOMIZATIONˆ4HERE SEEMS
BECAUSEOFCHANGESINBUSINESSCONDITIONSTECH TO BE HEIGHTENED INTEREST IN MASS CUSTOMIZED
NOLOGYLAWSBUSINESSAGREEMENTSANDSOONTHAT PRODUCTSPOSSIBLYDUETOTHESUCCESSOFCOMPA
INmUENCEMANYCOMPONENTSILLUSTRATEDIN&IGURE NIESSUCHAS$ELLASWELLASTOTHESPREADOFTHE
.EXTWEPRESENTSEVERALIMPORTANTDESIGNAREAS )NTERNET4HE)NTERNETFOSTERSCUSTOMIZATIONBE
IN NEED OF ATTENTION BY THE OPERATIONS MANAGE CAUSEITENABLESRAPIDTWO WAYCOMMUNICATION
MENTCOMMUNITYINTHECOMINGDECADES7HILE BETWEENAlRMANDITSCUSTOMERS4HISFACILITATES
RESEARCHERSHAVEBEGUNTOADDRESSSOMEOFTHESE PRODUCT CONlGURATION AND PRICING AND MEDIA
AREASWEEXPECTTHEAREASTOPROVIDEFERTILElELDS RICHCONCEPTUALIZATIONOFPRODUCTALTERNATIVESBY
FORFUTUREINVESTIGATION CUSTOMERSTHEREBYATTRACTINGCUSTOMERSWHOCAN
„ DESIGNFORDISRUPTIONSˆ!SCOMPANIESGETMATE ATTAINABETTERPRODUCTlTORWHOSIMPLYPREFERTO
RIALSFROMSOURCESFARTHERAWAYANDASCUSTOMERS CONlGURETHEIROWNPRODUCTSDESPITEHAVINGTO
INCREASINGLYSPREADAROUNDTHEGLOBETHELOGISTICS WAITFORDELIVERYORPAYAHIGHERPRICE4HECHAL
CHAINSGROWMORECOMPLEXITISEASYTOSEEHOWA LENGEOFMASSCUSTOMIZATIONISTOTAILORAPRODUCT
SUPPLYCHAINDISRUPTIONQUICKLYCANDEVELOPINTO ORPROCESSTOEACHCUSTOMERSWISHESWHILEDELIV
A BUSINESS NIGHTMARE %XAMPLES INCLUDE NATURAL ERING AND ADMINISTERING THE PRODUCT AS THOUGH
DISASTERS WHICH HAVE THE ABILITY TO PHYSICALLY IT WERE A STANDARD ITEM 3AMPSON AND &ROEHLE
DEVASTATE ANY PART OF THE SUPPLY AND DISTRIBU  PROPOSETHATSERVICEPROCESSESDIFFERFROM
TIONNETWORKPRODUCTRECALLSWHICHCANDESTROY MANUFACTURING PROCESSES IN THAT THE CUSTOMER

0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL \ 6 / ,    . /   N  //
 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

PROVIDES SIGNIlCANT INPUTS INTO THE PRODUCTION DITIONALCHANNEL!SDISCUSSEDBY#ATTANI'ILLAND

PROCESS 5NDER THIS DElNITION MASS CUSTOMIZA (EESE AND 3WAMINATHAN   DIFFERENTPRIC
TIONLIESATTHEINTERSECTIONOFSERVICESANDMANU INGSTRATEGIESMIGHTBEOPTIMALDEPENDINGONTHE
FACTURING AS PRODUCTION CANNOT BEGIN UNTIL THE RELATIVE CHARACTERISTICS SUCH AS CONVENIENCE OF
CUSTOMERSPECIlESHISORHERPREFERENCES0RODUC EACHCHANNEL-ANYMANUFACTURERSTENDTOPRICE
TION OF MASS CUSTOMIZED PRODUCTS THUS ENTAILS IDENTICALLYACROSSTHETWOCHANNELSBUTAS)NTERNET
SPECIAL CHALLENGES BUT ALSO AS4IMBUK SHOWS CHANNELSBECOMEMORECONVENIENTTHEREMAYBE
PROVIDESOTHEROPPORTUNITIESTOCREATIVELYDESIGN TREMENDOUSINCENTIVEFORMANUFACTURERSTODESIGN
SUPPLYCHAINSTOCAPITALIZEONTHEUNIQUEINTERAC THESUPPLYCHAINWITHDIRECTCHANNELSONLYELIMI
TIONBETWEENTHESUPPLYCHAINANDTHECUSTOMER NATINGTHEUSEOFTHETRADITIONALCHANNEL#ATTANI
&UTURE RESEARCH ON MASS CUSTOMIZATION MIGHT AND3OUZA SHOWTHATASUPPLYCHAINTHAT
PROVIDE MORE INSIGHTS ON HOW TO USE MASS CUS USESADIRECTMARKETMAYBEABLETOUSEINVENTORY
TOMIZATIONASACOMPETITIVESTRATEGY RATIONINGANDSHIPMENTmEXIBILITYTOOPTIMIZETHE
„ DESIGNOFHEALTHCARESUPPLYCHAINSˆ7ITHHEALTH SUPPLYCHAINGIVENTHATSOMECUSTOMERSAREWILL
CARE EXPENDITURES NOW EXCEEDING  PERCENT OF INGTOWAITFORTHEIRORDERS4HEPOSSIBLESUPPLY
53 GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT '$0 AND RISING CHAINDESIGNSANDPOLICIESGIVENTHEPOSSIBILITYOF
FASTERTHANTHEECONOMYHEALTHCAREHASBECOME )NTERNETCHANNELSPROVIDEAmOODOFOPPORTUNI
AFOCALPOINTOFCONCERNINTHE5NITED3TATESAND TIESFORRESEARCHERS4HE)NTERNETWILLCHANGETHE
ELSEWHERE )NCREASINGLY COMPLEX PATIENT NEEDS OPTIMALDESIGNOFSUPPLYCHAINSANDWORKFORCES
AND DECREASING REIMBURSEMENTS FROM GOVERN )T ENABLES MANY JOBS TO BE COMPLETED REMOTELY
MENTANDPRIVATEINSURERSMAKEITCHALLENGINGFOR TELECOMMUTING ANDALSOFACILITATESINFORMATION
HEALTHCAREORGANIZATIONSTOPROVIDEEXCELLENTCARE mOWINSUPPLYCHAINSTOPROVIDEBETTERVISIBILITY
COST EFFECTIVELYANDSAFELY4HEINCREASEINGOVERN ANDCONNECTIVITYBETWEENPLAYERS-ANYRESEARCH
MENTREIMBURSEMENTSCONCURRENTWITHINCREASING OPPORTUNITIESTOEXPLOREOPPORTUNITIESARISEFROM
NUMBERSOFUNINSUREDORUNDERINSUREDCITIZENSIS THESEISSUES
PROMPTING THE GOVERNMENT TO CALL FOR DRAMATIC „ DESIGN OF PACKAGINGˆ!N AREA ALMOST VOID OF
IMPROVEMENTSINBOTHTHEQUALITYANDEFlCIENCY INVESTIGATIONISTHEISSUEOFPRODUCTPACKAGINGDE
OF HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATIONS4HE SERVICE SUPPLY SIGNWHICHSERVESMANYFUNCTIONS7HENDEALING
CHAINDESIGNSINTHEHEALTHCAREINDUSTRYHAVETHE WITHTHEULTIMATECONSUMERAESTHETICAPPEALAND
SPECIALCHALLENGEOFDIFFERENTOPTIMIZATIONCRITERIA PRODUCT PROTECTION ARE PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONS
COMPAREDTOTRADITIONALSUPPLYCHAINS#OSTSARE 4HEREFORECOMPANIESCONSIDEROPTIONSLIKEBUBBLE
IMPORTANTˆINDEED ONE PRIMARY DRIVER OF THESE SHRINK WRAP AND CORRUGATED lBER BOXES /N THE
INITIATIVESˆBUTREDUCTIONSINCOSTNEEDTOOCCUR OTHERHANDWHENSHIPPINGCOMPONENTSBETWEEN
WITHOUTCOMPROMISETOTHEPATIENTOUTCOME2E TRADING PARTNERS CHOOSING BETWEEN DISPOSABLE
DUCEDCOSTSMUSTBEACCOMPANIEDWITHIMPROVED BOXESWITHDUNNAGEANDRETURNABLETROLLEYSPALLETS
OR AT LEAST CONSTANT PATIENT RECOVERY RATES 7E BECOMESANIMPORTANTFOCUSFORCOSTANDSUSTAIN
ANTICIPATE THAT INVESTIGATIONS BY THE OPERATIONS MENT 7HATEVER TYPE OF PACKAGING AN ENTERPRISE
MANAGEMENTCOMMUNITYPRACTITIONERSANDACA ULTIMATELYSELECTSITINmUENCESCOMPONENTSOFTHE
DEMICIANS CAN PROVIDE SIGNIlCANT INSIGHTS INTO SUPPLY CHAIN SUCH AS TYPE OF MATERIAL HANDLING
BETTERDESIGNSOFHEALTHCARESUPPLYCHAINS EQUIPMENTEMPLOYEDFORKLIFTSCONVEYORSROLLERS
„ DESIGNOFTHEDOWNSTREAMSUPPLYCHAINBRICKAND PERSONNEL AND SO ON AND SHIPPING MODES EM
MORTARVERSUS)NTERNETRETAILINGVERSUSBOTHˆ7ITH PLOYED4HEREFORERESEARCHERSNEEDTOINVESTIGATE
THEADVENTOFTHE)NTERNETASAVIABLEDOWNSTREAM TRADE OFFS THAT WILL TAKE PLACE BETWEEN PRODUCT
CHANNEL SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN CAN NOW CONSIDER PACKAGINGANDOTHERSUPPLYCHAINELEMENTS
THE OPPORTUNITIES AND IMPACT OF USING A DIRECT „ DESIGN FOR ROBUSTNESS PRICE mUCTUATIONSˆ&OR
)NTERNETCHANNELINCONJUNCTIONWITHORINLIEU THE PAST THREE DECADES 53 MANUFACTURERS HAVE
OF ATRADITIONALBRICKANDMORTARCHANNEL3OME STEADILY MOVED PRODUCTION FACILITIES OFFSHORE OR
MANUFACTURERSCHOOSETOUSEBOTHADIRECTANDTRA SOURCEDFROMOVERSEASVENDORSTOKEEPLABORCOSTS

\
 / /  N 6 / ,    . /   0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL

 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

LOW$URINGTHISTIMEOILPRICESWERELOWENABLING 4HIS ARTICLE ATTEMPTED TO PROVIDE A USEFUL

TRANSPORTATIONEXPENSESTOBEAMINORPARTOFTHE PERSPECTIVE ON PAST PRESENT AND FUTURE SUPPLY
OVERALLPRODUCTCOST"UTTHINGSHAVECHANGEDTHE CHAIN DESIGN DECISIONS THAT FACE ORGANIZATIONS
PRICEOFOILDRAMATICALLYINCREASEDFROMTO 7E HOPE WE PRESENTED SOME INSIGHTS THAT WILL
"ECAUSEOFTHISlRMSSTARTEDCHANGINGTHEIR
STRATEGIES )NCREASING TRANSPORTATION COSTS FORCED
lRMS EITHER TO MINIMIZE THE LENGTH OF JOURNEY
lRSTCENTURY
FROMSUPPLYSOURCESTOTHERETAILERORTOSHIPIN
LARGERQUANTITIESTOTAKEADVANTAGEOFECONOMIES
ASSIST OPERATIONS MANAGERS AND RESEARCHERS TO
EFFECTIVELYDESIGNINTEGRATEDSUPPLYCHAINSINTHE
TWENTY
2%&%2%.#%3
OFSCALE4HISFORCEDLARGERWAREHOUSESTOBEBUILT !RNTZEN"#''"ROWN40(ARRISONAND,,
WHICHENABLEDLARGERSTOCKSTOBEHELD2ESPOND
4RAFTON'LOBALSUPPLYCHAINMANAGEMENTATDIGI

INGTOTHESECHANGESSOMElRMSAREMOVINGFAC
TALEQUIPMENTCORPORATION)NTERFACES 

TORIESCLOSERTOTHEMARKETS&OREXAMPLE3HARP "OWERSOX$$#LOSSAND-"#OOPER3UPPLY
#ORPORATION MOVED PART OF ITS mAT
SCREEN 46 CHAIN LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT ND ED "OSTON -C'RAW
(ILL
MANUFACTURING TO -EXICO FROM !SIA TO REDUCE )RWIN
TRANSPORTATIONANDINVENTORYCOSTS3IMCHI
,EVI #AMM*$4%#HORMAN&!$ILL*2%VANS$
.ELSON -ULANI AND 7RIGHT   7HILE THIS *3WEENY!.$'77EGRYN"LENDING/2-3
SEEMEDLIKEAGOODMOVEINOILPRICESFELL JUDGMENT AND ')3 RESTRUCTURING 0'S SUPPLY CHAIN
)NTERFACES 

DRAMATICALLYINAND4HESEPRICESHIFTS
NOW SIGNAL AGAIN A POSSIBLE NEED TO MODIFY THE #ATTANI+%$AHAN'3CHMIDT,OWERCOSTMAY
NOTLOWERTOTALCOSTUSINGhSPACKLINGvTOSMOOTHMASS
CUS

SUPPLYCHAIN)FENERGYCOSTmUCTUATIONSOVERTIME
TOMIZEDPRODUCTION&ORTHCOMINGIN0RODUCTIONAND/PERA

REmECTAGROWINGTRENDFOROTHERMAJOREXPENSE
TIONS-ANAGEMENT
ITEMVARIABILITYITISIMPORTANTTHATSUPPLYCHAIN
#ATTANI+'&ERRER7'ILLANDAND*3WAMINATHAN
RESEARCHERSINVESTIGATEWAYSOFMODIFYINGTHESUP

 "OILING FROGS PRICING STRATEGIES FOR A MANUFACTURER
PLY CHAIN TO RESPOND TO RAPID CHANGES IN LABOR ADDINGANINTERNETCHANNEL0RODUCTIONAND/PERATIONS-AN

FUELANDTECHNOLOGYCOSTS AGEMENT 

#ATTANI+'3OUZA)NVENTORYRATIONINGANDSHIP

#/.#,53)/. MENTmEXIBILITYALTERNATIVESFORDIRECTMARKETlRMS0RODUC

3UPPLY CHAIN DESIGN DECISIONS HAVE BEEN AROUND TIONAND/PERATIONS-ANAGEMENT 

FORMILLENNIA&ROMANCIENT%GYPTAND2OMETO
#HOPRA 3 AND 0 -EINDL  3UPPLY #HAIN -ANAGE

THE !RABIAN 0ENINSULA SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN HAS MENT 3TRATEGY 0LANNING  /PERATION 5PPER 3ADDLE 2IVER
BEENACRITICALSUCCESSFACTORTOSOCIETALVENTURES .*0EARSON0RENTICE(ALL
2ECENTLY PROGRESS IN INFORMATION SYSTEMS AND $UNCAN * #  4HE PRINCIPLES OF INDUSTRIAL MANAGE

OTHER TECHNOLOGIES SUCH AS THE )NTERNET HAVE MENT.EW9ORK$!PPLETONAND#O
PROVIDEDOPPORTUNITIESFOREVENMOREALTERNATIVES
&ISHER -  7HAT IS THE RIGHT SUPPLY CHAIN FOR YOUR
TOOPTIMIZESUPPLYCHAINDESIGNS/THERADVANCES PRODUCT(ARVARD"USINESS2EVIEW-ARCH
!PRIL 

ANDCHANGESWILLOCCURFROMBOTHGOVERNMENTAND
PRIVATEINITIATIVESINDICATINGTHATAlRMNEEDSTO &ORD ( AND 3 #ROWTHER  -Y ,IFE AND 7ORK
'ARDEN#ITY.9$OUBLEDAY0AGE#O
RE
EVALUATEDITSSUPPLYCHAINDESIGNCONlGURATION
ROUTINELY BECAUSE OF BUSINESS AND ENVIRONMENT &ORD (  4ODAY AND 4OMORROW 'ARDEN #ITY .9
DYNAMICS!NIMPORTANTEXAMPLEINTHENEWSWAS $OUBLEDAY0AGE#O
THERESTRUCTURINGOF'ENERAL-OTORSINWHICH (EATHER04HE&ALLOFTHE2OMAN%MPIRE.EW9ORK
THE53GOVERNMENTREQUIRED4HERESIGNEDSUP
-AC-ILLAN#O
PLYCHAININVOLVEDALMOSTEVERYASPECTOFTHElRM (ULL"&RANKINCENSEMYRRHANDSPICESTHEOLD

FROM CHANGING SOURCING REQUIREMENTS AND PROD
ESTGLOBALSUPPLYCHAIN*OURNALOF-ACROMARKETING 
UCTOFFERINGSTOCLOSINGNUMEROUSMANUFACTURING 

PLANTS AND REDUCING THE NUMBER OF DEALERSHIPS ,ANE&6ENETIAN3HIPSAND3HIPBUILDERSOFTHE2ENAIS

4IMEWILLDETERMINEIFTHISEFFORTWILLSUCCEED SANCE"ALTIMORE4HE*OHNS(OPKINS0RESS

0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL \ 6 / ,    . /   N  //
 3500,9#(!).$%3)'.0!3402%3%.4!.$&5452%

,EE(,#"ILLINGTONAND"#ARTER(EWLETT

0ACKARDGAINSCONTROLOFINVENTORYANDSERVICETHROUGHDE
SIGNFORLOCALIZATION)NTERFACES  
,EHNER-3OMEOBSERVATIONSONTHELAYOUTOFTHE
KHUFUANDKHAFREPYRAMIDS*OURNALOFTHE!MERICAN2ESEARCH
#ENTERIN%GYPT 
-ABERT6!AND-!6ENKATARAMANAN3PECIAL
RESEARCHFOCUSONSUPPLYCHAINLINKAGESCHALLENGESFORDESIGN
ANDMANAGEMENTINTHESTCENTURY$ECISION3CIENCES 
n
2EID74HEDEVELOPMENTOF(ENRY-ETCALFESCARD
SYSTEM OF SHOP RETURNS AT FRANKFORD ARSENAL  
*OURNALOF-ANAGEMENT  
3AMPSON3%AND#-&ROEHLE&OUNDATIONSAND
IMPLICATIONSOFAPROPOSEDUNIlEDSERVICESTHEORY0RODUCTION
AND/PERATIONS-ANAGEMENT  
3IMCHI ,EVI $ 0 +AMINSKY AND % 3IMCHI ,EVI 
$ESIGNINGAND-ANAGINGTHE3UPPLY#HAIN#ONCEPTS3TRATE
GIESAND#ASE3TUDIES"OSTON-C'RAW(ILL)RWIN
3IMCHI ,EVI$3$7UAND:*3HEN(ANDBOOK
OF1UANTITATIVE3UPPLY#HAIN!NALYSIS-ODELINGINTHE% "USI
NESS%RA"OSTON+LUWER!CADEMIC0UBLISHERS
3IMCHI ,EVI$$.ELSON.-ULANIAND*7RIGHT
h#RUDE#ALCULATIONSv4HE7ALL3TREET*OURNAL3EP
TEMBERP2
3PRAGUE , '  %VOLUTION OF THE lELD OF OPERATIONS
MANAGEMENT *OURNAL OF /PERATIONS -ANAGEMENT  n

3ANTAYANA'4HE,IFEOF2EASONVOL.EW9ORK
#HARLES3CRIBNERS3ONS
7INCEL *  ,EAN 3UPPLY #HAIN -ANAGEMENT .EW
9ORK0RODUCTIVITY0RESS
:AN,&2OSSAND3:AMBON4HEhDISCOURSEON
MANAGEMENTvACCOUNTINGANDMANAGERIALPRACTICESAT6ENICES
STATESHIPYARDn"OLOGNA-ULINO

\
 / /  N 6 / ,    . /   0RODUCTIONAND)NVENTORY-ANAGEMENT*OURNAL

Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.