Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
PII: S0024-3205(17)30621-5
DOI: doi:10.1016/j.lfs.2017.11.044
Reference: LFS 15456
To appear in: Life Sciences
Received date: 1 August 2017
Revised date: 12 November 2017
Accepted date: 26 November 2017
Please cite this article as: Abdel K. Raffoul-Orozco, Ana E. Ávila-González, Christian M.
Rodríguez-Razón, Teresa A. García-Cobian, Edsaul E. Pérez-Guerrero, Trinidad García-
Iglesias, Edy D. Rubio Arellano , Combination effect naringin and pravastatin in lipid
profile and glucose in obese rats. The address for the corresponding author was captured
as affiliation for all authors. Please check if appropriate. Lfs(2017), doi:10.1016/
j.lfs.2017.11.044
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As
a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The
manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before
it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may
be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the
journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Arellano*d
PT
a
Institute of Experimental and Clinical Therapeutics, Department of Physiology, Health
RI
Sciences University Center, University of Guadalajara, Sierra Mojada st. 950. P.C. 44340
b
Guadalajara, Jal, Mex 01 33 1058 5200. Laboratory immunology. Department of
SC
Physiology, Health Sciences University Center, University of Guadalajara, Sierra Mojada st.
NU
950 Guadalajara, Jal, Mexico 01 33 1058 5200, c Doctorate of pharmacology. De partment of
Physiology, Health Sciences University Center, University of Guadalajara, Sierra Mojada st.
MA
d
950. P.C. 44340 Guadalajara, Jal, Mexico 01 33 1058 5200, Laboratory Pharmaceutical
center. University of Guadalajara, Marcelino García Barragan Blvd. 1421 P.C. 44430.
E
*Corresponding Author:
CE
Edy David Rubio-Arellano PhD MD. Laboratory Pharmaceutical Research and Development.
Guadalajara, Marcelino García Barragan Blvd. 1421 P.C. 44430 Guadalajara, Jal. Mexico 01
33 13785900
1
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
ABSTRACT
Aims: The purpose of this study was to compare the effect of naringin 100 mg/kg in
combination with pravastatin 10 mg/kg by gavage for 6 weeks compared with monotherapy
over lipid profiles, glucose levels and weight in murine model of obesity.
Main methods: The study design was planned with 5 groups of 6 male Wistar Albina rats:
Group 1: control with balanced food and vehicle (C-); Group 2: control with Obesity and
PT
vehicle (C+); Group 3: Obesity + naringin (N); Group 4: Obesity + pravastatin (P); Group 5:
RI
Obesity + pravastatin + naringin (NP). Obesity was developed with a food model.
SC
Key findings: The naringin groups showed a decrease in weight gain and low glucose values
compared to the control group (weight NP:311.4 vs C+:348.6; glucose NP: 173.12 vs
NU
C+:235.56) (p <0.05); the group with naringin+pravastatin combination showed the total
cholesterol (TC), LDL and triglycerides (TGs) to normal levels (TC NP:51.6 vs C+:83.4;
MA
LDL NP:9.32 vs C+:32.32; TGs NP:39.4 vs C+:89.4) (p <0.05); but was not statistically
Significance: The combination of naringin and pravastatin did not appear to be better than
PT
monotherapy on lipids, but its use could generate euglycemic and antiobesogenic effects, in
2
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
INTRODUCTION
Obesity is one of the most prevalent diseases, a growing public health problem in Mexico as
in the world [1,2]. Obesity is related to other metabolic diseases such as dyslipidemia and
type 2 diabetes, among others [3-5]. Although there are drugs for treating each of these
diseases, the use of nutraceuticals or phytodrugs have yielded good results [6-8], and their
PT
RI
Naringin (chemically 4',5,7-rhamnoglucoside trihydroxyflavanone-7) is a citru-flavanone
SC
glycoside extracted from citrus fruits, although found in greater proportion in the pericarp of
citrus paradisi also used in herbal medicine with good results in murine models and in
NU
clinical trials [10], according to studies, it inhibits the 3-hydroxy-3methylglutaryl CoA
action, achieving effect on serum lipids similar to statins, besides in DM2 and anti-obesogenic
effects [11,12], according to experts, its use should not replace statins therapy [9]. Naringin is
D
a product used in the food industry, which is an easy and inexpensive extract to obtain,
E
PT
adhering the therapy for dyslipidemia could be beneficial in lowering treatment costs, also as
an alternative treatment for patients who have not achieved lipid goals, or patients with
CE
intolerance to statins as suggested in the Position Paper from an International Lipid Expert
Panel and in the review study of Robert S. Rosenson et al, in the Journal of the American
AC
Statins are inhibitors of HMG-CoA, first choice therapy for dyslipidemia [14,15], pravastatin,
one of the safest even in patients with multiple treatments, being metabolized in the kidney
which does not require hepatic metabolism by the CYP450 family, that has less activity as an
antagonist [13,16].
3
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
There are several studies with naringin and pravastatin, however, only in one report it
evaluates co-administration, it concluded the safe administration in patients [17]. Until now,
there are no studies evaluating the combination of metabolic diseases, given that the
individual characteristics may result with a decrease of lipid concentration greater than
monotherapy; if results are positive in addition to synergic effect, studies could be carried out
PT
with this combination in patients to evaluate it as an additional tool for the treatment of
RI
dyslipidemia with pleiotropic effects added to statins, especially for patients with obesity or
SC
untreated patients with hyperglycemia.
NU
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of combining pravastatin and naringin in
serum concentrations for lipids and glucose in the obesity murine model.
MA
Animals. Thirty male Wistar rats, 5 weeks of age, weighing 100 ± 20 grams, were evaluated;
E
PT
the rats were housed in groups per cage and were kept in well-ventilated animal rooms in a
temperature of 25-27 ° C in a light / dark cycle of 12 hours. Rats had free access to a modified
CE
Ethical consideration. The animals were handled with the institutional guidelines of the local
Ethics Committee and the Mexican Official Standards (NOM-062-ZOO-1999) the projects
approval number DF/CB068/13, and international guidelines on the Use and Handling of
4
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Induction of Obesity, Diet-model. Obesity was induced in rats by feeding a hyper caloric
nutritional model (diet-model obesity DMO), which was taken as the food base, “Purine,
Rodent Chow®”, immersed for 10 minutes in lard, which was previously melted at 90 ° C,
then left at room temperature for easy manipulation, enough sucrose (10% dry weight) to
cover the food completely, a homogeneous mixture was added. Food was offered on free-
demand the model was reached after 8 weeks, which reached a higher total body weight to a
PT
normal body weight (>50% total body weight) [19]; in rats with a balanced diet (Rodent
RI
Chow®) the animal reached an average weight (200±20 g) which was used as a negative
SC
control. Nutritional data is shown in Table 1.
NU
TABLE 1. Nutritional information. Comparison of calories and percentages between balanced food
Treatment. The animals were randomly divided into five groups. Treatment was administered
by gavage. Vehicle: saline solution, naringin (100 mg / kg/ d) and / or pravastatin (10 mg / kg/
Group 1: Control with balanced food and vehicle, ie normo weight (C-) (note: group used
only to define the presence of the disease in the murine model); Group 2: control with DMO
5
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
and vehicle, ie control obese group (C+) Group 3: DMO + naringin (N); Group 4:
After completing a 6-week intervention, the rats fasted for 12 to 16 hours. The animals
were sacrificed under anesthesia, the blood sample was taken by cardiac puncture
PT
rpm (600 x g approx.) for 10 min, the supernatant (serum) was collected individually and
RI
stored at -20°C until analysis.
SC
Intervention. Naringin was acquired from "SAINA Xi'an Biological Technology Co., Ltd."
NU
China, with high degree of purity, concentration of 98%. Quantified by HPLC. Naringin was
Pravastatin used was Novina® 30 tablets of 10 mg. Novag Laboratories (Novag Infancia, S.A.
de C.V.). Pravastatin was pulverized and administered in sufficient amounts per rat in 1 ml
D
saline solution.
E
(TGs), high density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, glucose, ALT, AST and creatinine for
CE
samples were removed at a temperature of -20° C then used at room temperature; the
AC
calculation of the results were done with an automated software ERBA 1100
spectrophotometer.
Serum low density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol was estimated using the equation by
6
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Statistical Analysis. Was performed using the Kruskal-Wallis test to compare results between
groups. Post hoc testing was used, the U of Mann-Whitney test. In addition to the comparison
of changes in body weight using the Wilcoxon test for intergroup testing before and after the
The results were analyzed using SPSS version 21. Data are expressed as mean ± SD.
PT
Diet-model obesity. A comparison of the results between the group of normal weight “control
RI
(-)”, and obese rats untreated, “control (+)” was performed, this is to show model results and
SC
define the presence of the disease being treated. Table 2 shows significant statistical and
clinical differences between the main parameters, getting rats weighing more than 50% of
NU
their weight than the normal weight rats (p = 0.008) in groups before the beginning and the
end of the intervention, plus the presence of hyperglycemia comparing observed the values
MA
obtained in the normal weight rats against the values in obese rats, finally altered lipid values
7
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
serum lipids in rats are shown. Weight expressed in grams, the rest of the values expressed
in mg/dl
mean ± SD mean ± SD
PT
Final Weight 223 ± 23.9 348.60 ± 37.7 0.01**
RI
Glucose 99.5 ± 11.5 235.6 ± 77.9 0.01**
SC
Total Cholesterol 53.54 ± 2.8 83.4 ± 12.3 0.01**
Biosafety in diet-model obesity. To assess the biosafety of the disease model, renal creatinine
(AST) for liver biosafety; there were no clinical differences or statistics, p > 0.05, dates are
shown in table 2.
RESULTS
Effect of naringin and/or pravastatin in Body Weight (BW) of obese Rats. The data of the
weight at the beginning and at the end of the intervention are shown in Table 3. There were
8
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
between “” of each intervention group and control (+) was performed, the results are shown
compared to the control (+) and obese rats treated with pravastatin.
TABLE 3. Basal and final weight of obese rats. The mean and SD obtained from the total
PT
body weight in grams.
RI
Group Average basal weight Average final weight p=
SC
Control (+) 306.4±6.2 348.6±12 0.01*
* refers to p≤0.01 compared between basal vs. final weight, add* refers to p≤0.01 compared
9
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
shows the effect of naringin and/or pravastatin on glucose concentrations. The concentrations
obtained by the diet-model are displayed in the control (+) group, we can observe that the
naringin group obtained the best results (p <0.05), although the other 2 treatment groups
PT
RI
SC
NU
MA
E D
PT
CE
Effects of naringin and/or pravastatin on triglycerides (TGs) total cholesterol (TC), High
AC
Density Lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL) and low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL) of
obese Rats. The data on the effects of naringin and/or pravastatin on TGs, TC, HDL and LDL
in obese rats are represented in Figure 3. In the comparative analysis of TGs in groups, a
statistically significant difference p = 0.003 was found, post hoc tests were performed, we
found a significant difference in all treatment groups vs. control (+), resulting p = 0.009 (*), in
addition, we found that the naringin group also has a significant difference compared to the
10
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
pravastatin group (**). The results of total cholesterol show a statistical significance of p =
0.02, performing post hoc tests, finding that the groups tested showed a difference against the
In the analysis of missing lipids, ie, HDL and LDL cholesterols, there were no statistically
significant differences, although in the comparison group tested against the control group (+)
it could be observed with clinically significant differences in LDL, which is shown in the
PT
figure 3.
RI
SC
NU
MA
E D
PT
CE
AC
Biosafety treatments. Figure 4 shows the biosafety of the various treatments used in addition
to being contrasted with the control (+). In the pravastatin group shows ALT elevated which
is statistically significant, not clinically. The naringin group pravastatin did not show the
elevation of ALT that produced in pravastatin as monotherapy, the combination not only
11
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
SC
NU
MA
DISCUSSION
A high-calorie food, high level consumption of sucrose model for this research was used
E D
[19,23] according to the results we found its feasible use and reproduction to establish a
PT
model with diseases linked to obesity, hyperlipidemia with elevated levels of TGs, total
cholesterol, LDL and hyperglycemia, although showing different glucose levels, high values
CE
were presented in all experiment rats, which helped us evaluate interventions to measure a
AC
hypoglycemic or euglycemic effect. Compared to other models used, this study was
inexpensive and did not require chemical additives, making it a safer model, but may present
variation in respect to models enriched with lipids as cholesterol directly added or toxic
agents, such as alloxan and estreptosotozin models [21,22,24]; although they generate
excellent results to simulate a DM2 there may be side effects and not show obesity.
12
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
The doses of naringin and pravastatin for the present study were taken from studies conducted
in murine models that showed desired effects, besides showing the peaks of absorption and
The results indicated that administration of naringin generates a decrease in weight gain in
the diet model used, this is reflected in the 2 groups with naringin, although it is more
significant in the monotherapy group, these results although lower than expected, are
PT
supported by previous studies, such as published by Alam Ashraful M. and cols [11], which
RI
explained how naringin has an effect on obesity by increasing the expression of PPAR,
SC
carnitine palmitoyltransferase 1 (CPT-1), and uncoupling protein 2 (UCP-2) expression in the
liver, which could reduce adiposity in rats. Also naringin promotes gene expression and
NU
regulation of adipocytes, thereby decreasing deposition in fatty tissues [10].
Naringin significantly lowers blood glucose levels, these results are found in similar studies
MA
in rats [27-29], but contrasted in a study from Reshef N et al. [30] performed in hypertensive
patients, where there were no significant changes in glucose levels, although it is possible that
D
the results were not significant because treatment was not given completely, as naringin is
E
time-dependent [31], and naringin has shown good results in studies no longer than 5 weeks
PT
of treatment. In the study by Alam Ashraful M. et al [11] similar to the mechanism of action
CE
of naringin, which explains that naringin improves insulin signaling, for higher glucose
Following the results of this study, we observed a similar reduction in the group naringin
combination with pravastatin, which lead us to ask, if positive results are minimal in the
conduct a study of bioavailability and dose of the combination suggested in this study to
answer the questions above, since studies have concluded that pravastatin generates adverse
13
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Control obese rats showed significantly elevated serum levels of TGs, TC and LDL, but not
HDL cholesterol levels compared to the other treatment groups. The results are comparable
to those reported in a previous study [33], which supports and enables us to compare the final
results and define the effects found in the study, we can also find other studies presenting
more elevated lipid levels, for example the models induced with estreptozotocin, such as the
study by J Crespo and cols. [34], where the model shows that there are not only affects at a
PT
pancreatic level but generates higher levels of cholesterol that would help find the best
RI
treatment effects, so that new studies could be made with the combination proposed in this
SC
research but with a murine model with higher cholesterol levels.
In this study the administration of naringin or pravastatin and the combination on obese rats
NU
reduced TGs, CT and LDL compared with the control obese rats. The naringin monotherapy
group showed the better results in TGs but not in LDL and CT, the combination had the best
MA
statistical result in CT, although clinically not significant. Clinically, there were no
differences in lipids between treatment groups naringin and pravastatin and their combination,
D
it is likely that these results are presented to be given the maximum possible effect, since the
E
results of the 3 groups are similar to the levels of lipids they were in the control rats without
PT
disease. An important point to note is that the pravastatin group was not superior to naringin
CE
in any of the points studied, including the lipid profile. This study could not determine
similar study with a combination proposal but with higher level lipids, such as in those found
in studies in rats with invasive disease models, lipids added, to show real advantages over
monotherapy.
As for biosafety, this study shows how the combination of naringin and pravastatin is
clinically safe in the model of obese rats, these results were expected, first by the decision to
14
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
hepatic levels, pravastatin is the only statin that does not need the metabolism of family
CYP450, and naringin is credited its main antagonism to the liver by this family [35], besides
this, since there are no reports of adverse events by naringin [10], and pravastatin is usually a
safe treatment; although in the present study we found a "plus", because the use of naringin
could reduce the adverse effects in the liver by pravastatin, in the group of obese rats with
PT
are not observed in the group where naringin was added, so the question arisen, naringin is a
RI
liver protector against pravastatin? Does there exist a change in bioavailability? Could
SC
naringin reduce the remaining adverse effects of pravastatin? And other statins? The results of
this study opens up opportunities for new and more comprehensive studies, there is a need for
NU
more studies with this combination to show the positive effects that it could exert, if it works,
it could be an interesting tool for treating dyslipidemia by reducing adverse effects and
MA
Interest conflict. The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest
E
PT
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Thanks to the animal house, the University of Guadalajara for allowing the study, care and the
CE
FUNDING
This work was supported by the Doctorate of Pharmacology, Physiology Department, and
University of Guadalajara.
15
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
REFERENCES
PT
3) Wacher-Rodarte N. Epidemiología del síndrome metabólico. Gac Méd Méx
RI
2009;145(5),384
SC
4) Carrillo R, Sanchez MJ, Elizondo S. Sindrome metabolico. Rev Fac Med UNAM
2006;49(03):98-104
NU
5) Han TS, Lean MEJ. A clinical perspective of obesity, metabolic syndrome and
10.1177/2048004016633371
Vázquez-Cabral BD, González-Laredo RF. Plants with potential use on obesity and its
E
7) Patti AM, Toth PP, Giglio RV, Banach M, Noto M, Nikolic D, Montalto G, Rizzo M.
CE
9) Cicero AFG, Colletti A, Bajraktari G, Descamps O, Djuric DM, Ezhov M, et al. Lipid
16
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
10) Bharti S, Rani N, Krishnamurthy B, Arya DS. Preclínical Evidence for the
11) Alam MA, Subhan N, Mahbubur M, Uddin S, Reza HM, Sarker SD. Effect of Citrus
12) Mahmoud AM. Hematological alterations in diabetic rats - Role of adipocytokines and
PT
effect of citrus flavonoids. EXCLI J 2013;12: 647–657.
RI
13) Rosenson RS, Baker S, Banach M, Borow KM, Braun LT, Bruckert E, et al.
SC
Optimizing Cholesterol Treatment in Patients With Muscle Complaints. J Am Coll
15) ATP III, Third Report of the National Cholesterol Education Program (NCEP) Expert
(Adult Treatment Panel III) Final Report National Cholesterol Education Program
E
National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute National Institutes of Health. NIH 2002;
PT
16) Fryhofer SA. Switching From Simvastatin 80 mg: How to Shop for
18) NIH. United States Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service,
National Institutes of Health. Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals; NIH
17
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Pharmacopuncture 2017;20(2):201-206
20) Friedewald WT, Levy RI, Fredrickson DS. Estimation of the concentration of low-
PT
ultracentrifuge. Clin. Chem 1972;18:499–502.
RI
21) Erejuwa OO, Nwobodo NN, Akpan JL, Okorie UA, Ezeonu CT, Ezeokpo BC, et al.
SC
Nigerian Honey Ameliorates Hyperglycemia and Dyslipidemia in Alloxan-Induced
24) Fasanmade AA, Alabi OT. Differential effect of honey on selected variables in lloxan-
dysfunction and obesity in high carbohydrate, high fat diet-fed rats. Nutrients 2013;5:
637-50
18
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
10.1038/aps.2014.24
27) Annadurai T, Muralidharan AR, Joseph T, Hsu MJ, Thomas PA, Geraldine P.
2012;68:307–318
PT
28) Annadurai T, Thomas PA, Geraldine P. Ameliorative effect of naringenin on
RI
hyperglycemia-mediated inflammation in hepatic and pancreatic tissues of Wistar rats
SC
with streptozotocin- nicotinamide-induced experimental diabetes mellitus. Free Radic
Res 2013;47:793–803
NU
29) Tsai S-J, Huang C-S, Mong M-C, Kam W-Y, Huang H-Y, Yin M-C. Anti-
Chem 2012;60:514–521
2005;18(10):1360-3
PT
2006;9(4):582–586
32) Lorza-Gil E, Salerno AG, Wanschel AC, Vettorazzi JF, Ferreira MS, Rentz T, et al.
Chronic use of pravastatin reduces insulin exocytosis and increases β-cell death in
10.1016/j.tox.2015.12.007.
19
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
33) Bailey DG, Arnold JM, Strong HA, Munoz C, Spence JD. Effect of grapefruit juice
94.
34) Crespo MJ, Quidgley J. Simvastatin, atorvastatin, and pravastatin equally improve the
10.4239/wjd.v6.i10.1168
PT
35) Koitabashi Y, Kumai T, Matsumoto N, Watanabe M, Sekine S, Yanagida Y, et al.
RI
Orange juice increased the bioavailability of pravastatin, 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl
SC
CoA reductase inhibitor, in rats and healthy human subjects. Life Sci
2006;78(24):2852-2859
NU
MA
E D
PT
CE
AC
20