Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
MOLLANEDA
vs. LEONIDA C. UMACOB
G.R. No. 140128
June 6, 2001
SANDOVAL-GUTIERREZ, J.:
FACTS:
Sometime Sept 7, 1994, Leonida Umacob, a public school, teacher went to the
office of Mr. Rolando P. Suase to follow up her request for transfer to a
different district. Therein, Arnold Mollaneda, school Division Superintendent,
after entertaining her request hugged her, embraced her, kissed her nose and
lip in a torrid manner, and mashed her breast. Mollaneda did these acts for
several times then warned Umacob not to tell the incident to anybody.
Umacob reported the incident to the police station and filed a complaint for
acts of lasciviousness before the Municipal Trial Court. She also filed an
administrative complaint as well with the Civil Service Commission - Regional
Office XI, Davao City (CSC-RO XI). She furnished the Department of Education,
Culture and Sports - Regional Office XI, Davao City (DECS-RO XI) a copy of her
affidavit-complaint.
ISSUE:
HELD:
1) No. With regard to the DECS and CSC, DECS was just furnished a copy of
the complaint - it was not filed before the DECS. The resolution of DECS was
just a recommendatory resolution. With regard to the filing of the case both in
the CSC and the court, the case filed before the CSC is an administrative case
while that before the court is a criminal case, thus it does not constitute forum
shopping.
2) No. The witnesses' testimonies were offered not to prove its truth, but
merely to prove that Umacob told the witnesses what transpired in the office.
What was given more credence was the testimony of Umacob which was
straight and replete with details consistent with human nature.