Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
J.R. BAKER
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene,
London, England
R. MULLER
International Institute of Parasitology,
St Albans, England
and
D. ROLLINSON
The Natural History Museum,
London, England
VOLUME 35
ACADEMIC PRESS
Harcourt Brace & Company, Publishers
London San Diego New York Boston
Sydney Tokyo Toronto
ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED
24/28 Oval Road
LONDON NWI 7DX
Copyright 0 1995, by
ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
ISBN 0-12-031735-4
V
vi CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 35
George A Conder.
Upjohn Laboratories. The Upjohn Company. Kalamazoo. Michigan. USA
and
.
William C Campbell
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
2. TheDrugs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
3. New Methods of Drug Delivery . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
4. Macrocyclic Lactones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
4.1. Mechanism of Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
4.2. lvermectin .............................. 7
4.3. Abamectin .............................. 14
4.4. Moxidectin .............................. 15
4.5. Milbemycin B-41D .......................... 19
4.6. Milbemycin oxime .......................... 19
4.7. Doramectin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
5. Prospective Drugs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
5.1. Paraherquamide ........................... 22
5.2. PF1022A ............................... 25
5.3. Dioxapyrrolomycin .......................... 25
5.4. Clonostachydiol ............................ 26
. ....................
6 Resistance to Antinematodal Drugs 26
6.1. Is resistance an issue? ...
..................... 26
....................
6.2. Extent of resistance worldwide 29
.
6.3. Causes of treatment failure . . . . . . . .............. 38
6.4. Continuing spread of resistance . . . . .
. .............. 42
6.5. Factors contributing-to resistance . . . .
. .............. 43
6.6. Mechanisms of resistance ......... .............. 45
6.7. Monitoringheportingof resistance . ... .............. 49
6.8. Strategies to limit resistance development .............. 54
6.9. Epilogue ................ ............... 57
Acknowledgements .............................. 57
Note added in proof .............. ............... 57
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58
+ 1. INTRODUCTION
give short shrift to older drugs and to new drug candidates that have not
reached the marketplace. We would emphasize, however, that whereas
some of the old standbys have been dropped from regular use others still
play important roles in the control of nematodiases.
2. THE DRUGS
Anthelmintic use may vary to some extent in various parts of the world, but
it :rests largely on a common set of chemical compounds. It may be
instructive, therefore, to list the compounds currently approved by the
United States Government for use against nematode parasites in various
animal species:
In beef cattle: albendazole, coumaphos, fenbendazole, haloxon, ivermectin,
levamisole, morantel tartrate, oxfendazole, phenothiazine, thiabendazole.
In non-lactating dairy cattle: albendazole, fenbendazole, haloxon,
ivermectin, levamisole, oxfendazole, phenothiazine, thiabendazole.
In lactating dairy cattle: coumaphos, morantel tartrate, thiabendazole.
In sheep: ivermectin, levamisole, phenothiazine, thiabendazole.
In goats: phenothiazine, thiabendazole.
In swine: dichlorvos, fenbendazole, hygromycin B, ivermectin, levamisole,
piperazine, pyrantel tartrate, thiabendazole.
In horses: butonate, cambendazole, dichlorvos, febantel, fenbendazole,
ivermectin, levamisole, mebendazole, oxfendazole, oxibendazole, pheno-
thiazine, piperazine, pyrantel pamoate, pyrantel tartrate, thiabendazole,
tioxidazole, trichlorfon.
In dogs: arsenamide sodium, butamisole hydrochloride, dichlorvos,
diethylcarbamazine citrate, disophenol sodium, diathiazanine iodide, feban-
tel, fenbendazole, glycobiarsol, ivermectin, mebendazole, milbemycin
oxime, oxibendazole, piperazine, pyrantel pamoate, styrylpyridinium
chloride, thenium closylate, ticarbodine, toluene.
In cats: dichlorvos, diethylcarbamazine citrate, disophenol sodium,
febantel, piperazine, toluene.
A few of these compounds (haloxon, butonate, cambendazole, butami-
sole) are not currently marketed, but remain approved (Courtney and
Sundlof, 1991).
Compounds approved by other regulatory agencies are likely to be the
same as those listed above or of the same chemical class. Anthelmintics vary
widely in efficacy, safety, and cost; selection of a compound for a particular
use is usually governed by such factors. Decisions on the strategy of
treatment (frequency and timing) will also depend on the epidemiological
4 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
An aspect of the older drugs that warrants brief consideration here is the
development of new delivery technology. As livestock production becomes
more intensified, labor-saving methods are eagerly sought. Devices have
been developed to provide sustained chemoprophylaxis or periodic
chemotherapy without the need for repeated and costly handling of animals.
The incorporation of anthelmintics into salt “licks”, molasses
“blocks”, and the like, is an old technique for getting livestock to ingest
drug over a prolonged period. Studies are being done on the application of
fenbendazole (one of the newer benzimidazoles) in this way (Miller et al.,
1992).
Morantel has been incorporated into two sustained-release devices for
cattle. The first was a ruminal bolus designed to provide delivery of drug
for 60-90 days. The second, more recent, device is a flexible plastic sheet
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 5
4. MACROCYCLIC LACTONES
Although the mechanism of action for the macrocyclic lactones is not fully
understood, it appears these compounds exert their effect by irreversibly
opening chloride channels in muscle membranes (Martin and Pennington,
1989). Contrary to early reports (reviewed by Turner and Schaeffer, 1989)
suggesting these chloride channels were associated with y-aminobutyric
acid (GABA) receptors, more recent evidence (reviewed by Geary et al.,
1992b) seems to indicate that there is no GABA association. Arena el al.
(1991, 1992) have proposed that the anthelmintic activity of the macro-
cyclic lactones is mediated by an interaction with a glutamate-gated
chloride channel; this conclusion is based on electrophysiological examina-
tion of membrane currents recorded from Xenopus laevis oocytes injected
with Caenorhabditis elegans RNA. It is unclear where receptors relevant
for anthelmintic activity for the macrocyclic lactones are located. Geary et
al. (1993) speculate that altered pharynx function (e.g. nutrient ingestion,
excretion, or regulation of turgor pressure) may be the actual site of
anthelmintic action as opposed to somatic musculature function, since
ivermectin inhibits pharyngeal pumping more potently than motility in
6 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
V V
0 I I I I I 1 1
4.2. Ivermectin
R R A B X
J J
cn CH
x) Yw
n
" Oral formulation. Injectable formulation. Treatment aids in control. Including hypobiotic larvae.
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 11
Table 3 Parasites of swine for which the use of ivermectin’ has been approved.
Gastrointestinal nematodes Other nematodes Lice Mites
Ascaris suum (adult & 4 ) Metastrongylus spp. Haemotopinus Sarcoptes
(adult) suis scabiei
Hyostrongylus rubidus
(adult & L4)
Oesophagostomum spp.
(adult & 4 )
x
Strong loides ransomi
(adult)
’ Injectable formulation.
Colostral transmission to piglets can be prevented by treatment of sow 7-14 days
before farrowing.
Table 4 Parasites of horses for which the use of ivermectina has been approved.
Gastrointestinal nematodes Other nematodes Bots
Strongylus vulgaris (adult & immature) Dictyocaulus arnfreldi Gastrophilus spp.
(adult & immature) (oral & gastric
stages)
Strongylus edentatus (adult & immature) Onchocerca sp.
(microfilaria)
Strongylus equinus (adult)
Triodontophorus spp. (adult)
Cyuthostomum spp. (adult & immature)
Cylicocyclus spp. (adult & immature)
Cylicostephanus spp. (adult & immature)
Cylicodontophorus spp.
(adult & immature)
Gyafocephalus sp. (adult & immature)
Oxyuris equi (adult & immature)
Parascaris equorum (adult)
Trichostrongylus axei (adult)
Habronema muscae (adult)
Strongyloides westeri (adult)
a Oral formulation.
4.3. Abamectin
the C22-23 position, whereas that linkage has been reduced by selective
hydrogenation in the case of ivermectin. The only approved commercial
formulation of abamectin is AVOMEC Injection for Cattle (Merck & Co.,
Inc.). It is similar to the corresponding ivermectin product and is not
further discussed here.
4.4. Moxidectin
Table 6 Parasites of sheep for which the use of moxidectin"has been approved.
Gastrointestinal parasites Pulmonary worms External parasites
Haemonchus contortus Dictyocaulus jilaria Psorergates ovis
Ostertagia circumcincta
(including inhibited larvae)
Ostertagia trifurcata
Trichostrongylusaxei
Trichostrongyluscolubriformis
Trichostrongylusvitrinus
Nematodirus battus
Nematodirus spathiger
Nematodirus filicollis
Cooperia curticei
Cooperia oncophora
Cooperia pectinata
Cooperia punctata
Oesophagostomum columbianum
Oesophagostomum venulosum
Chabertia ovina
Trichuris ovis
Strongyloides papillosus
4.7. Doramectin
*
Doramectin is a new macrocyclic lactone (Figure 2). It was discovered
as a result of studies in which a mutant strain of Streptomyces avermi-
tilis was used to produce avermectins with C-25 substituents different
from those found in avermectins produced by conventional strains of the
bacterium. After screening for antinematodal activity in vitro (Dutton et
al., 1991), selected compounds were evaluated in laboratory animals and
in cattle (Goudie et al., 1993). The compound chosen for development
was 25-cyclohexyl-5-0-demethyl-25-de( 1 -methylpropyl) avermectin A],,
or doramectin. It has been given the trade name DECTOMAX, and
commercialization by Pfizer Inc. is imminent.
Studies on formulation and pharmacokinetics of doramectin led to the
development of formulations for parenteral use in cattle (Wicks et al.,
1993). As with other members of this class, the plasma profile can be
modified by formulating the drug in vehicles that yield different rates of
absorption from subcutaneous tissue. Sesame oil was found to be a good
vehicle, especially when ethyl oleate was added (10%) to enhance persis-
tence of efficacy. Such oil-based formulations were well tolerated by cattle
and gave clinically significant plasma levels for 12 days or more after
injection.
Cattle. Data collected in 28 trials conducted in North America and
Europe showed that doramectin, given subcutaneously at 200 pg kg-I,
was highly effective against a broad spectrum of gastrointestinal nema-
todes and lungwoms (Jones et al., 1993). Both natural and experimental
infections were used in this series of trials. Doramectin was >99%
effective against Ostertagia ostertagi (including inhibited larvae), Oster-
tagia lyrata, Haemonchus placei, Trichostrongylus axei, T. colubriformis,
Cooperia oncophora (including inhibited larvae), Cooperia pectinata,
Cooperia punctata, Cooperia spatula ta, Cooperia surnabada, Bunostomum
phlebotomum, Strongyloides papillosus, Oesophagostomum radiatum, and
Dictyocaulus viviparus. The drug was 93-97% effective against Tricho-
strongylus longispicularis, Nematodirus spathiger and Trichuris spp. It was
approximately 75% effective against adult and immature Nematodirus
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 21
and the prolonged plasma profile obtained with the formulation used. In
comparison, a conventional dose of ivermectin protects against the Old
World screwworm, but not against the New (Benz et al., 1989).
Doramectin was highly active against the tick Boophilus microplus in
two laboratory studies using experimentally infected calves (Gonzales et
al., 1993). In one study, a single injection (200 pg kg-’) was given to calves
which had been exposed repeatedly to infection and which carried ticks of
various degrees of maturity. As expected, there was no “knock-down
effect”; that is, there was no elimination of engorged ticks, because such
ticks would not have ingested drug. However, as the other ticks ingested
blood over the ensuing days, they were affected by the blood-borne drug.
Only a few ticks succeeded in engorging in the days immediately following
treatment, and these ticks exhibited a progressive reduction in egg produc-
tion and egg hatchability. By eight days after treatment, the engorgement
and detachment of ticks had completely stopped (except for one infertile
tick that detached on day 11). In the other study, the single injection of
drug was given before the multiple exposures to B . microplus. The infec-
tive larvae were applied to calves at intervals over a period of 17 days after
treatment. Saline-treated control calves showed that the ticks first reached
the engorged and detachment stage on day 23 after treatment (the first
detached ticks presumably being those applied immediately after treat-
ment). In the drug-treated calves, however, no detachments were recorded
until day 38. Even then, and in the three days remaining until the end of
trial, ticks detached in very small numbers and with greatly reduced
fecundity and egg hatchability. Thus the drug had persisted in host blood
for at least 17 days in amounts sufficient to interfere with the development
of B. microplus.
5. PROSPECTIVE DRUGS
5.1. Paraherquamide
Dosages of 0.5 mg kg-' or higher were at least 98% effective against adult
H. contortus, Ostertagia circumcincta", T. axei, T. colubriformis and
Cooperia curticei, and against inhibited fourth-stage larvae of Cooperia
sp. Such dosages were of uncertain efficacy against inhibited fourth-stage
larvae of 0. circumcincCa and were not significantly active against adult
Oesophagostomum columbianum. It was estimated that the EDg5 for 0.
columbianum would be greater than 4 mg kg-'. In these trials, the strain of
H. contortus was resistant to ivermectin and the T. colubriformis was
resistant both to ivermectin and benzimidazoles.
5.2. PF1022A
5.3. Dioxapyrrolomycin
contortus in the jird. The active component of the crude preparation was
identified as dioxapyrrolomycin, which was shown to clear >90% of H.
contortus from jirds when administered orally at 0.33 mg per animal, while
having only slight activity against T. colubriformis in the model (-40%
clearance at 0.33-1.0 mg per jird). In sheep, dioxapyrrolomycin given
orally at doses 23.125 mg kg-' cleared > 99% of H. contortus, whereas
>92% clearance was observed at 1.56 mg kg-'. Studies done in the jird
(Conder et ul., 1992) using ivermectinbenzimidazole-or levamisole/ben-
zimidazole-resistant strains of H. contortus demonstrated that dioxapyrro-
lomycin has approximately equal efficacy against the resistant and
susceptible strains, and so is not cross-resistant with the three major
classes of broad-spectrum anthelmintics (benzimidazoles, levamisole/
morantel/pyrantel, and macrocyclic lactones). However, an in vitro
migration assay showed dioxapyrrolomycin is -6 times less active
against closantel-resistant H. contortus than ,against susceptible worms.
Based on these studies dioxapyrrolomycin appears to be a narrow-spectrum
anthelmintic with a closantel-like mode of action. The LD50of dioxa-
pyrrolomycin in mice is 13 mg kg-I (Carter et al., 1987). No toxic signs
were observed at doses up to 12.5 mg kg-' (highest dose examined) in
sheep in the studies reported by Conder et al. (1992).
5.4. Clonostachydiol
tion upon initial or prior exposure). Resistance should not be confused with
tolerance. In the context of veterinary parasitology, the term tolerance is
conventionally restricted to the innate unresponsiveness of a parasite
population to a drug; that is, to the insusceptibility of a population,
independent of prior exposure to that drug or others of its class. These
usages are consonant with those of Coles (1986b), Prichard et al. (1980)
and Shoop (1993). In general, discussion will be limited to the three classes
of modem broad-spectrum anthelmintics, i.e. benzimidazoles, levamisole/
morantel/pyrantel, and macrocyclic lactones.
Experience in the antibacterial/antiviral (Cohen, 1992; Gibbons, 1992,
Neu, 1992), insecticidal (Georghiou, 1986; Roush, 1990), and protozoal
(Chapman, 1990; Femex et al., 1990) arenas has clearly demonstrated
resistance is the rule rather than the exception. Therefore, it should come
as no surprise that resistance of nematodes to anthelmintics is a growing
problem, particularly in certain geographic areas and some host species.
Resistance may be expected to develop more slowly in nematodes than in
bacteria, viruses, insects, or protozoa. This is due to longer generation times,
a more limited range of mobility (essentially that of their host), selection
generally limited to parasitic stages, and the high efficacy and non-persistent
nature of most anthelmintics (in the case of persistence, the macrocyclic
lactones and the salicylanilides are exceptions). Nevertheless, anthelmintic
resistance is and will continue to be a problem. Waller (1990) points out
“. . . most of the important nematode genera of domestic livestock have
shown that they possess the genetic capacity to develop resistance”.
To exemplify that resistance to antinematodal drugs is indeed something
with which we should be concerned, the following six points should be
considered.
at a high level in the high rainfall regions of the East African (Kenya,
Tanzania, Zimbabwe) and South American (Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay)
countries”.
3. The problem of resistance is growing in both the number of properties
having resistance and the level of resistance observed. This is supported
by surveys conducted in earlier years compared to similar surveys done
more recently in New Zealand (West et al., 1989; McKenna et al.,
1990), South Africa (Van Wyk et al., 1987, 1990), England (Taylor,
1990a; Coles et al., 1991), Australia (Edwards et al., 1986; Waller e f al.,
1988; Love et al., 1992), and the Netherlands (Borgsteede, 1990;
Borgsteede et al., 1991).
4. Whereas in earlier surveys and clinical reports resistance was limited to
a single parasite and anthelmintic class, there are now instances of
multigeneric resistance (examples include Barton et al., 1985; Martin
et al, 1985; Edwards et al., 1986; Anderson et al., 1988a; Hughes, 1988;
Waller et al., 1988, 1990a; McKenna, 1989; West et al., 1989; Watson
and Hosking, 1990; Duwel, 1991; Hong et al., 1992; Varady et al.,
1993) and/or multidrug (class) resistance (examples include Sangster et
al., 1979; Green et al., 1981; Hall et al., 1981a; Kettle.et al., 1983;
Barton et al., 1985; Dash, 1986a; Edwards et al., 1986; Anderson et al.,
1988a, b; Drudge et al., 1988; Van Wyk and Malan, 1988; Waller et al.,
1988, 1990a; Van Wyk et al., 1989a, b; Badger and McKenna, 1990;
McKenna et al., 1990; Watson and Hosking, 1990; Maingi, 1991a;
Reinecke et al., 1991; Jackson et al., 1992a, b; Love et al., 1992;
Pomroy et al., 1992; Uppal et al., 1992; Varady et al., 1993).
5. Resistance is becoming evident in hosts, such as swine (Roepstorff et al.,
1987; Bj@m et al., 1989, 1990; Waller et al., 1990b) and cattle
(Anderson, 1977; Anderson and Lord, 1979; Boersema, 1983a; Eagleson
and Bowie, 1986; Geerts et al., 1987; Jackson et al., 1987; Pinheiro
and Echevarria, 1990; Hosking and Watson, 1991; McKenna, 1991;
Williams, 1991; Williams et al., 1991; Eagleson et al., 1992; Watson,
1993), where it was not previously recognized.
6. Unfortunately, resistance is generally not recognized until it becomes a
problem, due to our inability easily to assess subclinical resistance in the
field and to our general unwillingness to accept anything less than
clinical failure as an indication of resistance. Once resistance results
in clinical failure it is probably too late to do anything to reverse this
situation. Although there are a few examples of resistant strains
reverting to susceptibility following discontinued use of anthelmintics
of the class that elicited resistance, the overwhelming evidence suggests
that reversion is unlikely (for example Herlich et al., 1981; Hall et al.,
1982; Le Jambre et al., 1982; Herd et al., 1984; Dash, 1986b;
Boorgsteede and Duyn, 1989; Taylor and Hunt, 1989; Lyons et al.,
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 29
1990; Jackson, 1993), and even when it occurs, the increased suscept-
ibility is not sufficient to be of value in the field or there is rapid
reselection for resistance (Simpkin and Coles, 1978; Kelly and Hall,
1979; Martin el al., 1988a; Waller et al., 1988).
An interesting observation was made by Ian Barger (CSIRO Laboratory,
Armidale, NSW, Australia) at a meeting of European (France, Ireland,
Spain and UK) scientists where they were examining with colleagues
from Australia what had been learned from the Australian experience
with resistance which could be used to prevent similar problems in
Europe. His suggestion was that the problem had probably already deve-
loped too far in Europe to learn from the mistakes of the Australian sheep
industry (Anonymous, 1992). The same may be said for much of the rest
of the world. Clearly, based on the above, resistance is an issue. It will
not go away and it will continue to worsen without significant and timely
intervention.
Although an attempt has been made to detail by country and host those
species of nematodes which have been reported to be resistant to one or
more of the three classes of modem broad-spectrum anthelmintics, there
are undoubtedly reports which have been missed, particularly where the
literature relating this information is hard to access. Reports of resistance
where the resistant nematode species (or genera) are not identified will not
be detailed herein, except in the case of the horse where only rarely are
identifications made. In addition, it is often difficult to assess whether
resistance was indeed present based on the information provided, hence
our inclusion or omission of particular reports of resistance may not agree
entirely with others’ interpretations of the data.
required but are generally not used in goats (McKenna and Watson, 1987;
Coles et al., 1989a; Scott et al., 1989; Sangster et al., 1991a; Hennessy et
al., 1993). In short, treating goats as though they were sheep and com-
mingling these species can contribute to anthelmintic resistance. Both hosts
are considered together here, because of the role this intimate relationship
between sheep and goats has had on resistance development.
Table 7 shows those parasite species by geographic distribution which
have been identified as being resistant to antinematodal drugs from the
three modem broad-spectrum classes in sheep and/or goats. Haemonchus
contortus, Ostertagia spp. and Trichostrongylus spp. are resistant to the
benzimidazoles throughout much of the world but show a more spotty
distribution of resistance to levamisole/morantel/pyrantel and the macro-
cyclic lactones. Resistant parasites in other genera (Nematodirus, Cooperia,
Oesophagostomum, Chabertia and Strongyloides) show more limited
distributions, which may reflect innate differences in ability to generate
viable resistant populations for these organisms or may be an artifact of
inadequate recognition due to the relatively lower pathogenicity and hence
notice of these species compared to more problematic species. It also is
evident that the narrow-spectrum salicylanilides, used almost exclusively
to control strains of H. contortus resistant to the broad-spectrum anthel-
mintics, are rapidly generating resistance in South Africa (Van Wyk and
Gerber, 1980; Van Wyk et al., 1982, 1987) and Australia (Rolfe et al.,
1990).
6.2.2. Cattle
In contrast to the situation in sheep and goats, resistance has been slow to
develop in cattle. Barger (1993) suggests that bovine dung-pats may
provide a relatively larger refugia of susceptible infective larvae, and
hence, reduce the proportion of the population exposed to anthelmintic
selection. Alternatively, less frequent use of anthelmintics in this host may
minimize selection pressure. It has been suggested (Eagleson and Bowie,
1986; Waller, 1993) that selection for resistance in some parasites of cattle
occurs in other species, such as goats, which can harbor species of
nematodes common to both hosts. As noted in Table 8, few reports of
resistance are available, but in many cases the parasite identified as being
resistant is 0. ostertagi. Since, with a single exception, all of the reports of
resistance to date are for levamisole/morantel or benzimidazoles, both of
which provide less than optimal protection against inhibited larval stages, it
is possible that resistance has developed in response to what amounts to
subtherapeutic dosing of inhibited larvae. Populations of Haemonchus spp.,
T. axei and C . oncophora resistant to the benzimidazoles have also been
identified sporadically, Boersema ( 1983a) reported a strain of Dictyocaulus
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 35
Ostertagia
ostertagi Australia 23 2 -
Belgium - 4 -
New Zealand 5 - -
United States - 6.7 -
Trichostrongylus
axei Australia 8-9 - -
New Zealand 10' - -
Cooperia
oncophora New Zealand 5,ll - 12'
Dictyocaulus
viviparus Belgium - 13 -
' References: (1) Pinheiro and Echevarria, 1990, (2) Anderson, 1977, (3) Anderson
~ ~~
and Lord, 1979, (4) Geerts et al., 1987, ( 5 ) Hosking and Watson, 1991, (6) Williams,
1991, (7) Williams et al., 1991, (8) Eagleson and Bowie, 1986, (9) Eagleson et al.,
1992, (10) McKenna, 1991, (11) Jackson et al., 1987, (12) Watson, 1993, (13)
Boersema, 1983a.
-, NO known reports.
' Genus but not species identified.
6.2.3. Horses
Small strongyles are recognized throughout the world as being resistant
to the benzimidazoles (Table 9). To date, 13 species (Cyathostornurn
catinatum, Cyathostornum coronaturn, Cyathostomum labiaturn, Cyathos-
tornurn labratum, Cylicocyclus brevicapsulatus, Cylicocyclus insigne,
Cylicocyclus leptostomus, Cylicocyclus nassatus, Cylicostephanus cali-
catus, Cylicostephanus goldi, Cylicostephanus longibursatus, Cylico-
stephanus minutus, and Cylicostephanus poculatus) have been identified
with benzimidazole resistance. In addition, resistance to pyrantel is
believed to be present for small strongyles in the United States (Herd,
1992). Benzimidazole resistance appears to be present in the United States
Table 9 Nematodes of horses with reported resistance to broad-spectrum anthelmintics.
Anthelmintic class'
Nematode country Benzimidazoles Levamisole/morantel/pyrantel Macrocyclic lactones
Cyathostomwn catinatum Germany 1
United States 2,3,4,5,6,7
Cyathostomum coronatum Belgium 8
Germany 1
Netherlands 9,lO
United States 2,3,4,5,6,7,11
Cyathostomwn labiatum Belgium 8
Netherlands 10
United States 2
Cyathostomum labratum Belgium 8
Netherlands 9,lO
Cylicocyclus brevicapsulatus United States 11
Cylicocyclus insigne United States 2,ll
Cylicocyclus leptostomus United States 5,ll
Cylicocyclus nassatus Belgium 8
Germany 1
Netherlands 9,lO
United States 2,3,4,5,6,7,11
Cylicostephanus calicatus Belgium 8
Germany 1
Netherlands 9,lO
United States 54
Cylicostephanus goldi Belgium 8
Germany 1
United States 2,4,5,6,7,11
Cylicostephanus longibursatus Belgium
Germany
Netherlands
United States
Cylicostephanus minutus Germany
Netherlands
United States
Cylicostephanus poculatus Germany 1
Unspecified small strongyles" Australia 12,13
Austria 14
Brazil 15,16,17
Canada 18,19
Denmark 20
New Zealand 21
Norway 22,23
South Africa 24,25
Sweden 26
United Kingdom 27,28,29,30,3 1,32,33,34
Strongylus edentatus United States 35
aReferences: (1) Burger and Bauer, 1987, (2) Drudge et al., 1977, (3) Drudge et al., 1983, (4) Drudge et al., 1984, ( 5 ) Wescott et al.,
1985, (6) Chapman et al., 1991, (7) Drudge et al., 1991, (8) Geerts et al., 1988, (9) Eysker et al., 1988, (10) Eysker et al., 1989, (11)
Wescott et al., 1982, (12) Barger and Lisle, 1979, (13) Kelly et al., 1981b, (14) Lippert and Prosl, 1988, as reported by Borgsteede,
1990, (15) Vieira-Bressan et al., 1988, (16) Campos Pereira et al., 1989, (17) Campos Pereira et al., 1991, (18) Slocombe and Cote,
1977, (19) Slocombe et al., 1989, (20) Bj0m et al., 1991c, (21) Hope and Kemp, 1980, (22) Helle, 1986, (23) Waller et al., 1990b, (24)
Van Wyk, 1987, (25) Van Wyk and Van Wijk, 1992, (26) Nilsson et al., 1989, (27) Round et al., 1974, (28) Herd, 1986c, (29) Ryan et
al., 1987, (30) Britt and Clarkson, 1988, (31) Love et al., 1989, (32) Lumsden et al., 1989, (33) King et al., 1990, (34) Fisher et al.,
1992a, (35) Uhlinger and Johnstone, 1984.
-, No known reports. ' Includes only those countries where the resistant species have not been identified in at least one report.
38 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
6.2.4. Swine
In Europe, A. suum resistant to benzimidazoles and Oesophagostomum
quadrispinulatum and 0. dentatum resistant to pyrantel citrate have been
reported (Table 10). It is interesting to note that in the case of Oesophago-
stomum spp. modem management practices have virtually eliminated the
parasite refugia, resulting in infection coming almost uniformly from
offspring of resistant worms surviving treatment (Roepstorff et al., 1987).
6.7), without exception they are poorly predictive and/or not conducive
to use in the field.
The second factor is more insidious as it is primarily philosophical in
nature. It is readily acknowledged that the time to combat resistance is
before it becomes entrenched. Theoretically, in early stages of resistance
development, while individual organisms are heterozygous for resistance
and potentially less fit than wild-type, susceptible organisms, it may be
possible to introduce strategies which allow for reversion to susceptibility
(Martin et al., 1988a; Maingi et al., 1990; Prichard, 1990a). Later in the
development of resistance, individuals become homozygous for the resis-
tant trait and as some evidence suggests, more fit (Kelly et al., 1978; Hall et
al., 1981b; Maingi et al., 1990), after which time reversion to susceptibility
is less likely (Maingi et al., 1990). Although some studies do not support
the fitness aspects of this hypothesis (MacLean et al., 1987; Waller et al.,
1989; Scott and Armour, 1991; Echevarria et al., 1993a), it is difficult to
interpret these data since in no case was the parent susceptible strain
compared to the resistant strain or the genetics of the populations known
with regard to resistance. To date, studies examining reversion to sus-
ceptibility have been overwhelmingly unsuccessful (Borgsteede and
Duyn, 1989; Martin, 1990; Jackson, 1993). Yet, almost without fail we
continue to look for resistance in the field by evaluating compounds at
recommended use level, a level which is characteristically well onto the
plateau of the dose-response curve and a level which could mask early,
subtle changes in resistant status. Instead, we should be studying the
response of parasites in the field at the shoulder of the dose-response
curve where small changes in resistance can be readily detected (Conder
et al., 1993; Shoop, 1993; Shoop et al., 1993b). This point is illustrated in
Figure 4, which is based on information from Conder et al. (1993). The
figure demonstrates moxidectin side-resistance for ivermectin in a jird
model, if a dose on the shoulder of the dose-response curve (i.e. 1.25 pg
per jird) is considered, but side-resistance would not be detected if a dose
on the plateau (i.e. 5 pg per jird) is used. Since the recommended use
level dose of moxidectin in ruminants is well onto the plateau of the
dose-response curve, side-resistance would not be detected at this dose as
was the case in studies reported by Craig et al. (1992), Oosthuizen and
Erasmus (1993), Pankavich et al. (1992), Pomroy et al. (1992), and Watson
et al. (1993) or would have been only marginally evident (Pomroy and
Whelan, 1993). It should be clear that two distinct issues are being confused
as one; by testing at use level in the field we are asking whether the drug in
question continues to have therapeutic efficacy regardless of resistance
status, not whether resistance to that drug is in place. Hence, resistance is
constantly being underestimated and strategies to limit or control resistance
are not implemented in a timely, potentially effective manner.
42 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
100-
m
.-E
.-
E
E
-
r 60-
u)
a
L
0
c
C
0
0 00-
i
r
0
0
40-
2
a
0
Ti
a
p 20-
c
c
a
e
2
0 ' I I I 1 I I
later did resistance develop to other parasites in cattle (Geerts et al., 1987;
Williams, 1991; Williams et al., 1991), swine (Bjarn et al., 1989, 1990;
Roepstorff et al., 1987), and other hosts (Isaza et al., 1987; Malan et al.,
1988). In the case of the benzimidazoles, resistance has been identified in
nematodes from at least eight genera (Haemonchus, Ostertagia, Tricho-
strongylus, Nematodirus, Cooperia, Oesophagostomum, Chabertia, and
Strongyloides) in sheep and goats, four genera (Cyathostomum, Cylico-
cyclus, Cylicocostephanus and Strongylus) in horses, four genera
(Haemonchus, Ostertagia, Trichostrongylus and Cooperia) in cattle, one
genus (Ascaris) in swine, and still more in other host species. In addition,
there are now cases of single nematode species at a particular site being
resistant to all available classes of modern broad-spectrum anthelmintics
(McKenna et al., 1990; Watson and Hosking, 1990; Pomroy et al., 1992;
Varady et al., 1993) or nematodes of up to six genera being resistant to a
single drug on one property (McKenna, 1989).
Geographically, the spread of resistance is extending into areas such as
Europe and North America which were previously thought to be relatively
immune to problems of resistance, due to the combination of climate and
husbandry practices. The number of reports of anthelmintic resistance in
nematodes continues to grow dramatically, and there are indications that
we are only beginning to see the extent of resistance. For example, in a
survey of sheep and goats in the United States (Miller and Craig, 1988), it
was found that for each of the three classes of modem broad-spectrum
antinematodal drugs 25-53% of the sheep flocks examined harbored
nematode populations which were resistant, and nematodes in 57-75% of
goat flocks were resistant to benzimidazoles or levamisole. Although no
ivennectin resistance was present in goat flocks at that time, it has since
been identified in goats in the study area (Craig and Miller, 1990). Besides
expansion of resistance into geographic areas previously not recognized for
resistance, it is evident that resistance continues to expand on the local level.
A final proof of the expansion of resistance is the growing number of
clinical reports relating to resistance. Perhaps the most dramatic evidence
of this was reported by Van Wyk et al. (1988a, b) where resistance in some
regions of South Africa has got so completely out of hand that livestock
producers whose families have farmed for generations are getting out of
business due to the failure of all available anthelmintics to control
nematode disease in their animals.
Martin et al., 1982, 1984) clearly demonstrate that frequent dosing selects
for resistance more strongly than less frequent dosing regimes. In addition,
anecdotal evidence for-the role of frequent dosing in the generation of
resistant nematodes is that resistance has appeared most rapidly and has
been most pronounced in regions of South Africa, Australia and South
America where climatic conditions permit almost continuous exposure to
reinfection and acquisition of heavy nematode burdens, and where, as a
result, frequent dosing has been the cornerstone of control efforts. Even in
temperate climates frequent dosing is the rule as shown by a survey of
sheep farmers in the United States (Reinemeyer et al., 1992) where nearly
60%of ewes and rams and approximately,20% of lambs were dosed four or
more times a year. Frequent dosing is particularly troublesome when
dosing intervals are shorter than the prepatent period, since only resistant
worms are allowed to reach patency and contribute to the subsequent gene
pool; continued use of this practice for goats in New Zealand has resulted
in a high incidence of benzimidazole resistance and emergence of multiple
resistance (Jackson, 1993).
Underdosing is another major contributor in selecting for resistance.
Doses high enough to kill individuals heterozygous for resistance render
this trait in effect recessive, whereas subtherapeutic doses make it effec-
tively dominant (Roush and McKenzie, 1987). By using subtherapeutic
doses, marginally resistant heterozygous individuals are allowed to survive
and contribute resistant genes to subsequent populations. The example
cited earlier (Besier and Hopkins, 1988), where 86% of the farmers asked
to guess the weight of sheep (common practice in the field) would have
underdosed, demonstrates how frequently underdosing can occur. In
addition, animals are often further underdosed by using lower than
recommended doses to save money. Another potential contributor to under-
dosing is where a single host harbors different types of parasites (i.e.
.nematodes and arthropods) with different susceptibilities to a drug and
the drug is used at the dose sufficient for the more sensitive organism(s)
on a spot basis. A good example of this is the use of ivermectin to control
Hypoderma spp., since ivermectin is active against this parasite at doses
well below those recommended for nematodes. Inadequate attention to
calibration or condition of dosing equipment can also result in delivery
of less than the desired dose. The extreme case of underdosing is where an
animal is inadvertently not dosed.
It is generally believed that alternation of drug classes between but not
within parasite generations or on an annual basis can prevent or slow
development of resistance (Prichard et al., 1980). However, in practice,
farmers tend to use a single drug until it no longer works. As an illustration
of this point, Reinemeyer et al. (1992) surveyed sheep farmers in the
United States and found this to be the case, since approximately one out
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 45
of two herds were being dosed with a single anthelmintic until it failed.
Unfortunately, when farmers do alternate, they often tend to do so within a
season rather than on a yearly basis (> 50% of respondents in the above
survey) and/or to use drugs within the same class. In the former case,
multiple resistance may be generated, whereas in the latter, selection for
resistance will continue unchecked, since all compounds within a class
utilize the same mode of action.
Management practices can contribute in a variety of ways to the genera-
tion of resistance. Clearly, relying exclusively on drugs to control nema-
tode infections is a poor management practice that can and often does lead
to resistance. Introducing new animals that may harbor populations of
resistant parasites onto a farm without appropriate quarantine, disease
monitoring, and treatment can rapidly result in resistance problems.
Anthelmintic dosing schemes which ignore the particular characteristics
of development and transmission of the parasites in question, particularly
the availability of susceptible free-living stages in the environment which
can contribute to subsequent infection, may result in enhancing resistance.
An example of this latter point for H. contortus is where sheep in temperate
climates are dosed during the periparturient period. Since the parasite’s
free-living stages are susceptible to cold, they are greatly reduced on
pasture at this time, leaving the major source of subsequent infection to
be the progeny of those worms which are resistant and survive treatment
(Taylor, 1990a; Sykes et al., 1992). Dosing animals and moving them to
“clean” or minimally contaminated pasture has long been advocated;
however, this practice could contribute to resistance development
because, as in the above example, those worms which are resistant and
survive treatment would be the major contributors to subsequent infection
(Le Jambre, 1978; Taylor and Hunt, 1989; Smith, 1990). Commingling
host species such as sheep and goats as noted above can lead to cross-
transmission of resistant parasites from one host (goats) where resistance is
more readily generated to another (sheep) in which resistance may be less
likely to occur. In addition, ignoring the pharmacokinetic differences
between species as in the case of sheep and goats can result in underdosing
(Coles et al., 1989a; Sangster et al., 1991a) and generation of resistance for
goats treated at doses recommended for sheep. Likewise, pharmacokinetic
differences between breeds of the same species or even within a breed
under diverse management schemes can affect dose requirements and can
contribute to resistance.
are the target parasite/rodent models which have utility for all the modem
broad-spectrum antinematodal drugs. The only models of this type used
to date to assess resistance of suspect field strains compared to strains
known to be susceptible to the drugs in question or to assess crosshide
resistance between drugs are jirds infected with T. colubriformis (Ostlind
et al., 1990) or H . contortus (Conder et al., 1991, 1993; Duwel, 1991) or
guinea pigs infected with T. colubriformis (Kelly et al., 1981a) or H .
contortus (Rolfe, 1990). Clearly, although in vivo rodent models are
available for all classes of modem anthelmintics, they have not been
developed for the majority of parasites of interest, they are expensive
artd labor intensive relative to in vitro assays, they are limited to the
laboratory, and they require the use of animals. Nevertheless, they
provide some unique advantages over both egg reduction and in vitro
assays which have not been fully exploited to date. Whereas egg reduc-
tion tests do not fully assess the survival of worms following anthelmintic
treatment and even spot examination of animals for actual worm survival
in target hosts by necropsy techniques is prohibitively expensive, parallel
studies in rodent models can fully assess worm survival. Not only is it
possible to determine worm survival following treatment in rodent mod-
els, but this can be done in a systematic and cost-effective manner which
first identifies the shoulder of the dose-response curve (the most sensitive
point to detect a change in susceptibility) for a susceptible strain and
subsequently compares the response for the suspect strain. Hence, resis-
tance and not efficacy is being measured. The utility of this approach has
been demonstrated in rodents (Conder et al., 1993) and substantiated by
target host studies (Shoop et al., 1993b). In addition, the resistance
factors for resistant strains relative to susceptible strains for these in
vivo models more closely parallel the situation in the field than do the
in vitro assays.
It is obvious that we need to develop better means to identify resistance
in the field. It is equally obvious that the absence of a good “cow-side”
assay for resistance should not be an excuse for inadequately monitoring
resistance development. We need to use the tools at-hand more wisely.
Clearly, it is not acceptable to examine drugs in the field at use level as a
measure of incipient resistance; using this approach, resistance will only be
recognized when it is beyond the point where anything can be done to
control it. Since the only assays currently available which are capable of
identifying resistance early in the developmental process are those in the
laboratory, it is imperative that surveillance programs utilizing these assays
be implemented. The program initiated in England by Coles (1990b) and
the “Wormtest” campaign in Australia are reasonable examples of such a
surveillance program.
54 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
Since currently available assays are impractical for field use and/or are
unable to detect early resistance in the field, and it is difficult or impossible
to render populations with high degrees of resistance susceptible again, it
makes sense to strive to prevent resistance from developing rather than
managing resistance once it is in place (Roush, 1990). With this in mind, a
number of strategies have been suggested to limit the development of
resistance. It should be recognized that any strategy must fit the particular
characteristics (parasite and host biology, environment, epidemiology, etc.)
of the target population, and hence, strategies will vary considerably
. between or even within regions.
Perhaps the most widely advocated practice to prevent resistance deve-
lopment is to limit the number of anthelmintic treatments. By reducing
exposure to drug, selection pressure can be minimized. To do this, how-
ever, it is imperative that the parasites present and the epidemiology of
helminth disease locally be known, so dosing schedules can be strategically
timed and integrated with other management practices to prevent disease,
limit parasite proliferation, and optimize production. History has taught
us that, in fact, only rarely are anthelmintics used strategically. Educa-
tion programs need to stress that although alternative nematode control
strategies relying less heavily on anthelmintics may be more costly than
reliance solely on drugs, once resistance develops there are fewer options
to control these parasites and greater costs due to reduced efficiency or
profits (Roush, 1990). A corollary of limited, strategic use of anthelmintics
is to use only a single class of anthelmintics annually or within a parasite
generation, so multiple (class) resistance is not generated, and to rotate
anthelmintic classes on a yearly basis to limit passage of resistance genes
(resistant to the previous class but susceptible to the alternate class of
ahthelmintic) early in the selection process while organisms are hetero-
zygous for the trait allowing for a reversion to susceptibility. In addition,
periodic assessment of resistance status should be a standard part of any
nematode control strategy utilizing anthelmintics. Use of any anthelmintic
should be discontinued if resistance to it is detected and subsequent
treatments should use a drug with a different mode of action.
A critical aspect of limiting resistance development, regardless of dosing
scheme, is the need to assure that an effective dose of a highly efficacious
drug be delivered, so that heterozygous resistant individuals are effectively
removed along with susceptible worms, i.e. animals are not underdosed.
Toward this end, animal weights should be accurately determined, not
guessed, and group dosing should be based on the heaviest animal. In
addition, label directions should be followed explicitly with regard to
dose, route, target parasites, target hosts, and expiration date.
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 55
6.9. Epilogue
Never has the arsenal of antinematodal drugs been more formidable than
today. The three classes of modem broad-spectrum anthelmintics provide
an unprecedented spectrum of activity (including not only nematodes but
also flatworms and ectoparasites), a wide range of delivery options, and the
opportunity to develop and use a variety of treatment strategies. Although
alternatives to chemotherapeutic control of nematodes are being explored
and showing promise, it is unlikely that any of these approaches will be
broadly available in the near future. This combined with the fact that
anthelmintic resistance is a reality dictates prudent use of anthelmintics,
implementation of integrated control strategies, and early recognition of
and appropriate response to resistance development.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
sheep from Greece which were imported from France and the United
Kingdom (Himonas and Papadopoulos, 1994) has been reported.
REFERENCES
Andersen, F.L. and Christofferson, P.V. (1973). Efficacy of haloxon and thiaben-
dazole against gastrointestinal nematodes in sheep and goats in the Edwards
Plateau area of Texas. American Journal of Veterinary Research 34,1395-1398.
Anderson, N. ( 1977). The efficiency of levamisole, thiabendazole and fenbenda-
zole against naturally acquired infections of Ostertagia ostertagi in cattle.
* Research in Veterinary Science 23, 298-302.
Anderson, N. and Lord, V. (1979). Anthelmintic efficiency of oxfendazole, fenben-
dazole and levamisole against naturally acquired infections of Ostertagia
ostertagi and Trichostrongylus axei in cattle. Australian Veterinary Journal
55, 158-162.
Anderson, N., Martin, P.J. and Jarrett, R.G. (1988a). Mixtures of anthelmintics: a
strategy against resistance. Australian Veterinary Journal 65, 62-64.
Anderson, N., Martin, P.J., Jarrett, R.G., Brown, T.H. and Miller, D.W. (1988b).
Sequential development of resistance to thiabendazole and levamisole in
nematodes of sheep. International Journal for Parasitology 18, 243-249.
Andrews, S.J., Ferrari, M.M., Pow, J.D.E. and Lancaster, M.B. (1993). Nematode
egg output and plasma concentration of ivermectin after its administration to red
deer (Cervus elaphus elaphus). Veterinary Record 132, 161-163.
Anonymous, A.A. (1984). Advances in malaria chemotherapy. World Health
Organization Technical Report Series No. 7 11.
Anonymous, A.A. (1986). Directorate of Veterinary Services, South Africa:
Laboratory Services Monthly Reports: January, p. 4.
Anonymous, A.A. (1989). Report of the Working Party for the Animal Health
Committee of the Standing Committee on Agriculture. SCA Technical Report
Series No. 28, Anthelmintic Resistance, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial
Research Organization, Australia.
Anonymous, A.A. ( 1992). Anthelmintic resistance: Learning from the Australian
experience. Veterinary Record 130, 362-363.
Arena, J.P., Liu, K.K., Paress, P.S. and Cully, D.F. (1991). Avermectin-sensitive
chloride currents induced by Caenorhabditis elegans RNA in Xenopus oocytes.
Uolecular Pharmacology 40,368-374.
Arena, J.P., Liu, K.K., Paress, P.S., Schaeffer, J.M. and Cully, D.F. (1992).
Expression of a glutamate-activated chloride current in Xenopus oocytes injected
with Caenorhabditis elegans RNA: evidence for modulation by avermectin.
Molecular Brain Research 15, 339-348.
Badger, S.B. and McKenna, P.B. (19%). Resistance to ivermectin in a field strain
of Ostertagia spp. in goats. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 38, 72-74.
Baker, R. and Swain, C.J. (1989). Ivermectin - a drug for all seasons. Chemistry
in Britain 25, 692-696.
Baker, N.F., Miller, J.E., Madigan, J.E., Fulton, R. and Seward, R.L. (1984).
Anthelmintic action of ivermectin, oxibendazole and pyrantel pamoate against
thiabendazole-resistant small strongyles of horses. Equine Practice 6, 8, 10-12,
1 4 1 5 , 17-19.
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 59
Calcott, P.H. and Fatig, R.O., 111. (1984). Inhibition of chitin metabolism by
avermectin in susceptible organisms. Journal of Antibiotics 37, 253-259.
Campbell, W.C. (1986). The chemotherapy of parasitic infections. Journal of
Parasitology 72, 45-6 1.
Campbell, W.C. (1989) “Ivermectin and Abamectin.” Springer-Verlag, New York.
Campbell, W.C. (1990). Benzimidazoles: veterinary uses. Parasitology Today 6,
13Ck133.
Campbell, W.C. and Benz, G.W. (1984). Ivermectin: a review of efficacy and
safety. Journal of Veterinary Pharmacology and Therapeutics 7, 1-16.
Campbell, W.C., Fisher, M.H., Stapley, E.O., Albers-Schonberg, G. and Jacob,
T.A. (1983). Ivermectin: a potent new antiparasitic agent. Science 221,823-828.
Campos Pereira, M., Campos, R., Foz R.P.P., Lima, S.B. and Vieira-Bressan,
M.C.R. (1989). Estudo comparativo da eficiCncia de ivermectina, de fenbenda-
zole, de mebendazole e de mebendazole associado a0 citrato de piperazina, no
’ controle de ciatostomineos de equinos da raga Mangalarga Paulista. Revista
Faculdade de Medicina Veterinaria Zootecnia Universidade de Sao Paulo 26,
53-60.
Campos Pereira, M., Kohek, I., Jr, Campos, R., Lima, S.B. and Foz, R.P.P. (1991).
A field evaluation of anthelmintics for control of cyathostomes of horses in
Brazil. Veterinary Parasitology 38, 121-129.
Carmichael, I., Visser, R., Schneider, D. and Soll, M. (1987). Haemonchus
contortus resistance to ivermectin. Journal of the South African Veterinary
Association 58, 93.
Carter, G.T. (1989). New anthelmintic and growth promoting agents from actino-
mycetes. In “Novel Microbial Products for Medicine and Agriculture” (A.L.
Demain, G.A. Somkuti, J.C. Hunter-Cevera and H.W. Rossmore, eds), pp.
229-237. Elsevier, Cambridge.
Carter, G.T., Nietsche, J.A., Goodman, J.J., Torrey, M.J., Dunne, T.S., Borders,
D.B. and Testa, R.T. (1987). LL-F42248a, a novel chlorinated pyrrole antibiotic.
Journal of Antibiotics 40, 233-236.
Cawthome, R.J.G. and Cheong, F.H. (1984). Prevalence of anthelmintic resistant
nematodes in sheep in south-east England. Veterinary Record 114, 562-564.
Cawthome, R.J.G. and Whitehead, J.D. (1983). Isolation of benzimidazole resistant
strains of Ostertagia circumcincta from British sheep. Veterinary Record 112,
274-277.
Chalmers, K. (1985). Detection of benzimidazole resistant Nematodirus spathiger.
New Zealand Veterinary Journal 33, 53.
Chapman, H.D. (1990). Drug resistance in coccidia of the fowl. In “Resistance of
Parasites to Antiparasitic Drugs” (J.C. Boray, P.J. Martin and R.T. Roush, eds),
pp. 33-41. MSD Agvet, Rahway.
Chapman, M.R., Klei, T.R. and French, D.D. (1991). Identification of thiabendazole-
resistant cyathostome species in Louisiana. Veterinary Parasitology 39,293-299.
Charles, T.P., Pompeu, J. and Miranda, D.B. (1989). Efficacy of three broad-
spectrum anthelmintics against gastrointestinal nematode infections of goats.
Veterinary Parasitology 34, 7 1-75.
Cohen, M.L. (1992). Epidemiology of drug resistance: implications for a post-
antimicrobial era. Science 257, 1050-1055.
Coles, G.C. (1986a). Anthelmintics for small ruminants. Veterinary Clinics of
North America: Food Animal Practice 2 , 4 1 1 4 2 1 .
Coles, G.C. (1986b). Anthelmintic resistance to sheep. Veterinary Clinics of North
America: Food Animal Practice 2,423-432.
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 63
Coles, G.C. (1988). Strategies for control of anthelmintic-resistant nematodes of
ruminants. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 192,
330-334.
Coles, G.C. (1990a). Recent advances in laboratory models for evaluation of
helminth chemotherapy. British Veterinary Journal 146, 113-1 19.
Coles, G.C. ( 1990b). How widespread are benzimidazole-resistant nematodes of
sheep? Veterinary Record 126, 629.
Coles, G.C. and Simpkin, K.G. (1977). Resistance of nematode eggs to the ovicidal
activity of benzimidazoles. Research in Veterinary Science 22, 386-387.
Coles, G.C., Tritschler, J.P., 11, Giordano, D.J., Laste, N.J. and Schmidt, A.L. (1988).
Larval development test for detection of anthelmintic resistant nematodes.
Research in Veterinary Science 45, 50-53.
Cbles, G.C., Giordano, D.J. and Tritschler, J.P., 11. (1989a). Efficacy of levamisole
against immature and mature nematodes in goats with induced infections.
American Journal of Veterinary Research 50, 1074-1075.
Coles, G.C., Folz, S.D. and Tritschler, J.P., 11. (1989b). Motility response of
levamjsole/benzimidazole-resistantHaemonchus contortus larvae. Veterinary
Parasitology 31, 253-257.
Coles, G.C., Hong, C. and Hunt, K.R. (1991). Benzimidazole resistant nematodes
in sheep in southern England. Veterinary Record 128, 44.
Coles, G.C., Bauer, C., Borgsteede, F.H.M., Geerts, S., Klei, T.R., Taylor, M.A.
and Waller, P.J. (1992). World Association for the Advancement of Veterinary
Parasitology (W.A.A.V.P.) methods for the detection of anthelmintic resistance
in nematodes of veterinary importance. Veterinary Parasitology 44,35-44.
Colglazier, M.L., Kates, K.C. and Enzie, F.D. (1969). Anthelmintic activity of
tetramisole, thiabendazole, and purified fine particle phenothiazine against
experimental infections of Haemonchus contortus and Trichostrongylus species
in sheep. Proceedings of the Helminthological Society of Washington 36,68-74.
Colglazier, M.L., Kates, K.C. and Enzie, F.D. (1970). Comparative response of
two ovine isolates of Haemonchus contortus to thiabendazole. Journal of
Parasitology 56, 768-772.
Conder, G.A., Johnson, S.S., Guimond, P.M., Geary, T.G., Lee, B.L., Winterrowd,
C.A., Lee, B.H. and DiRoma, P.J. (1991). Utility of a Haemonchus contortusljird
(Meriones unguiculatus) model for studying resistance to levamisole. Journal of
Parasitology 77, 83-86.
Conder, G.A., Zielinski, R.J., Johnson, S.S., Kuo, M.-S.T., Cox, D.L., Marshall,
V.P., Haber, C.L., DiRoma, P.J., Nelson, S.J., Conklin, R.D., Lee, B.L., Geary,
T.G., Rothwell, J.T. and Sangster, N.C. (1992). Anthelmintic activity of
dioxapyrrolomycin. Journal of Antibiotics 45, 977-983.
Conder, G.A., Thompson, D.P. and Johnson, S.S. (1993). Demonstration of co-
resistance of Haemonchus contortus to ivermectin and moxidectin. Veterinary
Record 132, 65 1-652.
Conway, D.P. (1964). Variance in the effectiveness of thiabendazole against
Haemonchus contortus in sheep. American Journal of Veterinary Research 25,
844-845.
Cook, G.C. (1990). Use of benzimidazole chemotherapy in human helminthiasis:
indications and efficacy. Parasitology Today 6, 133-136.
Courtney, C.H. and Sundlof, S.F. (1991). “Veterinary Antiparasitic Drugs”.
Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville.
Craig, T.M. (1986). Epidemiology and control of gastrointestinal nematodes and
64 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
Drudge, J.H., Lyons, E.T., Swerczek, T.W. and Tolliver, S.C. (1983). Cambenda-
zole for strongyle control in a pony band: selection of a drug-resistant population
of small strongyles and teratologic implications. American Journal of Veterinary
Research 44, 110-1 14.
Drudge, J.H., Tolliver, S.C. and Lyons, E.T. (1984). Benzimidazole resistance of
equine strongyles: critical tests of several classes of compounds against popula-
tion B strongyles from 1977 to 1981. American Journal of Veterinary Research
45, 804-809.
Drudge, J.H., Lyons, E.T., Tolliver, S.C., Lowry, S.R. and Fallon, E.H. (1988).
Piperazine resistance in population-B equine strongyles: a study of selection in
thoroughbreds in Kentucky from 1966 through 1983. American Journal of
Veterinary Research 49, 986-994.
Dydge, J.H., Lyons, E.T., Tolliver, S.C. and Fallon, E.H. (1990). Phenothiazine
in the origin of benzimidazole resistance in population-B equine stronglyes.
Veterinary Parasitology 35, 117-130.
Drudge, J.H., Lyons, E.T. and Tolliver, S.C. (1991). Resistance of population-B
equine strongyles to thiabendazole, oxfendazole, and phenothiazine (1981 to
1987). 'American Journal of Veterinary Research 52, 1308-1312.
Duncan, J.L. and Love, S. (1991). Preliminary observations on an alternative stra-
tegy for the control of horse strongyles. Equine Veterinary Journal 23,226-228.
Dutton, C.J., Gibson, S.P., Goudie, A.C., Holdom, K.S., Pacey, M.S., Ruddock,
J.C., Bu'Luck, J.D. and Richards, M.K. (1991). Novel avermectins produced by
mutational biosynthesis. Journal of Antibiotics 44, 357-365.
Diiwel, D. (1991). How reliable are in vitro tests in diagnosis of benzimidazole
resistance in sheep? Revue de MCdecine VitCrinaire 142, 623-63 1.
Duwel, D., Schmid, K. and Bechmann, G. (1987). Benzimidazole-resistant
Haemonchus contortus in sheep in the Federal Republic of Germany. Berliner
und Miinchener Tierarztliche Wochenschrift 99, 120-123.
Eagleson, J.S. and Bowie, J.Y. ( 1986). Oxfendazole resistance in Trichostrongylus
axei in cattle in Australia. Veterinary Record 119, 604.
Eagleson, J.S., Bowie, J.Y. and Dawkins, H.J.S. (1992). Benzimidazole resistance
in Trichostrongylus axei in Australia. Veterinary Record 131, 317-318.
Echevania, F.A.M. and Trindade, G.N.P. (1989). Anthelmintic resistance by
Haemonchus contortus to ivermectin in Brazil: a preliminary report. Veterinary
Record 124, 147-148.
Echevama, F.A.M., Armour, J. and Duncan, J.L. (1991). Efficacy of some anthel-
mintics on an ivermectin-resistant strain of Haemonchus contortus in sheep.
Veterinary Parasitology 39, 279-284.
Echevama, F.A.M., Gennari, S.M. and Tait, A. (1992). Isoenzyme analysis of
Haemonchus contortus resistant or susceptible to ivermectin. Veterinary
Parasitology 44, 87-95.
Echevarria, F.A.M., Armour, J., Borba, M.F. and Duncan, J.L. (1993a). Survival
and development of ivermectin-resistant or susceptible strains of Haemonchus
contortus under field and laboratory conditions. Research in Veterinary Science
54, 133-139.
Echevama, F.A.M., Gettinby, G. and Hazelwood, S. (1993b). Model predictions
for anthelmintic resistance amongst Haemonchus contortus populations in
southern Brazil. Veterinary Parasitology 47, 3 15-325.
Eddi, C., Bianchin, I., Honer, M.R., Muniz, R.A., Caracostantogolo, J. and Do
Nascimento, Y.A. (1993). Efficacy of doramectin against field nematode
infections of cattle in Latin America. Veterinary Parasitology 49, 39-44.
66 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
Edwards, J.R., Wroth, R., de Chaneet, G.C., Besier, R.B., Karlsson, J., Morcombe,
P.W., Dalton-Morgan, G. and Roberts, D. (1986). Survey of anthelmintic resis-
tance in Western Australian sheep flocks. I. Prevalence. Australian Veterinary
Journal 63, 135-138.
Eysker, M. and Boersema, J.H. (1992). The efficacy of moxidectin against Dictyo-
caulus viviparus in cattle. Veterinary Quarterly 14, 79-80.
Eysker, M., Jansen, J., Boersema, J.H. and Lewing-Van Der Wiel, P.J. (1983a).
Development of benzimidazole resistance in a Haemonchus contortus strain in
The Netherlands following fenbendazole treatment of ewes at parturition.
Research in Veterinary Science 34, 46-49.
Eysker, M., Jansen, J. and Wemmenhove, R. (1983b). Alternative grazing of horses
and sheep as control for gastrointestinal helminthiasis in horses. Veterinary
Parasitology 13, 273-280.
Eysker, M., Jansen, J. and Mirck, M.H. (1986). Control of strongylosis in horses
by alternate grazing of horses and sheep and some other aspects of the
epidemiology of strongylidae infections. Veterinary Parasitology 19, 103-1 15.
Eysker, M., Boersema, J.H., Kooyman, F.N.J. and Berghen, P. (1988). Possible
resistance of small strongyles from female ponies in The Netherlands against
albendazole. American Journal of Veterinary Research 49, 995-999.
Eysker, M., Boersema, J.H. and Kooyman, F.N.J. (1989). Emergence from
inhibited development of cyathostome larvae in ponies following failure to
remove them by repeated treatments with benzimidazole compounds. Veterinary
Parasitology 34, 87-93.
Femex, M., Mittelholzer, M.-L., Reber, R., Stiirchler, D. and Bispham, K. (1990).
A drug combination to overcome and prevent development of drug resistance in
malaria- parasites. In “Resistance of Parasites to Antiparasitic Drugs’’ (J.C.
Boray, P.J. Martin and R.T. Roush, eds), pp. 17-24. MSD Agvet, Rahway.
Fisher, M.H. (1986). Chemistry of antinematodal agents. In “Chemotherapy of
Parasitic Diseases” (W.C. Campbell and R.S. Rew, eds), pp. 239-266. Plenum
Press, New York.
Fisher, M.A., Jacobs, D.E., Grimshaw, W.T.R. and Gibbons, L.M. (1992a). Pre-
valence of benzimidazole-resistancein equine cyathostome populations in south
east England. Veterinary Record 130, 3 15-3 18.
Fisher, M.A., Jacobs, D.E. and Jones, P.A. (1992b). Field evaluation of an
. albendazole intraruminal capsule against benzimidazole-resistant Haemonchus
contortus. Veterinary Record 130, 35 1-352.
Folz, S.D., Pax, R.A., Thomas, E.M., Bennett, J.L., Lee, B.L. and Conder, G.A.
( 1987). Motility response of benzimidazole-resistant Haemonchus contortus
, larvae to several anthelmintics. Proceedings of the Helminthological Society
of Washington 54, 249-253.
Geary, T.G., Nulf, S.C., Favreau, M.A., Tang, L., Prichard, R.K., Hatzenbuhler,
N.T., Shea, M.H., Alexander, S.J. and Klein, R.D. (1992a). Three P-tubulin
cDNAs from the parasitic nematode Haemonchus contortus. Molecular and
Biochemical Parasitology 50, 295-306.
Geary, T.G., Klein, R.D., Vanover, L., Bowman, J.W. and Thompson, D.P.
(1992b). The nervous systems of helminths as targets for drugs. Journal of
Parasitology 78, 215-230.
Geary, T.G., Sims, S.S., Thomas, E.M., Vanover, L., Davis, J.P., Winterrowd,
C.A., Klein, R.D., Ho, N.F.H. and Thompson, D.P. (1993). Haemonchus
contortus: Ivermectin-induced paralysis of the pharynx. Experimental
Parasitology 77, 88-96.
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 67
Geerts, S., Brandt, J., Kumar, V. and Biesemans, L. (1987). Suspected resistance of
Ostertagia ostertagi in cattle to levamisole. Veterinary Parasitology 23, 77-82.
Geerts, S., Guffens, G., Brandt, J., Kumar, V. and Eysker, M. (1988). Benzimidazole
resistance of small strongyles in horses in Belgium. Vlaams Diergeneeskundig
Tijdschrijl57, 20-26.
Geerts, S., Brandt, J., Borgsteede, F.H.M. and Van Loon, H. (1989). Reliability and
reproducibility of the larval paralysis test as an in vitro method for the detection
of anthelmintic resistance of nematodes against levamisole and morantel tartrate.
Veterinary Parasitology 30, 223-232.
Geerts, S., Bertels, G., Balis, B., Brandt, J. and Kumar, V. (1990). Benzimida-
zole resistance in nematodes on a dairy goat farm in Belgium. Vlaams
Diergeneeskundig Tijdschrift 59, 90-92.
Georghiou, G.P. (1986). The magnitude of the resistance problem. In “Pesticide
Resistance: Strategies and Tactics for Management” (National Academy of
Sciences, ed.), pp. 14-43. National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
Gettinby, G. (1989). Computational veterinary parasitology with an application to
chemical resistance. Veterinary Parasitology 32, 57-72.
Gettinby, G., Soutar, A., Armour, J. and Evans, P. (1989). Anthelmintic resistance
and the control of ovine ostertagiasis: a drug action model for genetic selection.
International Journal for Parasitology 19, 369-376.
Gettinby, G., Hazelwood, S. and Armour, J. (1990). Computer models applied to
drug resistance in parasites. In “Resistance of Parasites to Antiparasitic Drugs”
(J.C. Boray, P.J. Martin and R.T. Roush, eds), pp. 213-219. MSD Agvet,
Rahway.
Gevrey, J., Robin, B., Guerrero, C., Hugonnet, L. and Taranchon, P. (1984).
EfficacitC de l’ivermectine sur 2 souches de strongyles digestifs d’origine
ovine. Comparison avec le thiabendazole et le fenbendazole. Science Vkterinaire
Mtdkcine Comparke 86, 145-151.
Gibbons, A. (1992). Exploring new strategies to fight drug-resistant microbes.
Science 257, 1036-1038.
Gibson, T.E. (1975). “Veterinary Anthelmintic Medication”, Third Edition.
Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, Slough.
Giles, C.J., Urquhart, K.A. and Longstaffe, J.A. (1985). Larval cyathostomiasis
(immature trichonema-induced enteropathy): a report of 15 clinical cases.
Equine Veterinary Journal 17, 169-201.
Gill, J.H., Redwin, J.M., Van Wyk, J.A. and Lacey, E. (1991). Detection of
resistance to ivermectin in Haemonchus contortus. International Journal for
Parasitology 21, 77 1-776.
Gillham, R.J. and Obendorf, D.L. (1985). Therapeutic failure of levamisole in d a q
goats. Australian Veterinary Journal 62, 426-427.
Giordano, D.J., Tritschler, J.P., I1 and Coles, G.C. (1988). Selection of ivermectin-
resistant Trichostrongylus colubriformis in lambs. Veterinary Parasitology 30,
139-148.
Goa, K.L., McTavish, D. and Clissold, S.P. (1991). Ivermectin: a review of
its antifilarial activity, pharmacokinetic properties and clinical efficacy in
onchocerciasis. Drugs 42, 640-658.
Gonzales, J.C., Muniz, R.A., Farias, A., Goncalves, LC.B. and Rew, R.S. (1993).
Therapeutic and persistent efficacy of doramectin against Boophilus microplus in
cattle. Veterinary Parasitology 49, 107-1 19.
Gordnier, P.M., Brezner, J. and Tanenbaum, S.W. (1987). Chitin metabolism: not a
68 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
Hennessy, D.R., Sangster, N.C., Steel, J.W. and Collins, G.H. (1993). Comparative
pharmacokinetic behaviour of albendazole in sheep and goats. International
Journal for Parasitology 23, 321-325.
Herd, R.P. (1986a). Parasite control in horses: seasonal use of equine anthel-
mintics. Modern Veterinary Practice 67, 895-898.
Herd, R.P. (1986b). Pasture hygiene: a nonchemical approach to equine endo-
parasite control. Modern Veterinary Practice 67, 36-38.
Herd, R.P. (1986~).Epidemiology and control of equine strongylosis at Newmarket.
Equine Veterinary Journal 18, 447452.
Herd, R.P. (1986d). Epidemiology and control of nematodes and cestodes in small
ruminants: Northern United States. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Food
Animal Practice 2, 355-362.
Herd, R.P. (1992). Choosing the optimal equine anthelmintic. Veterinary Medicine
87, 231-232, 234, 236-239.
Herd, R.P., Streitel, R.H., McClure, K.E. and Parker, C.F. (1984). Control of
hypobiotic and benzimidazole-resistant nematodes of sheep. Journal of the
Amepican Veterinary Medical Association 184, 726-730.
Herlich, H., Rew, R.S. and Colglazier, M.L. (1981). Inheritance of cambendazole
resistance in Haemonchus contortus. American Journal of Veterinary Research
42, 1342-1344.
Himonas, C. and Papadopoulos, E. (1994). Anthelmintic resistance in imported
sheep. Veterinary Record 134, 456.
Hong, C., Hunt, K.R., Harris, T.J., Coles, G.C., Grimshaw, W.T.R. and McMullin,
P.F. (1992). A survey of benzimidazole resistant nematodes in sheep in three
counties of southern England. Veterinary Record 131, 5-7.
Hope, J.J. and Kemp, G.K. (1980). Apparent Trichonema resistance to fenbendazole.
New Zealand Veterinary Journal 28, 80-81.
Horton, R.J. (1990). Benzimidazoles in a wormy world. Parasitology Today 6,
106.
Hosking, B.C. and Watson, T.G. (1991). Benzimidazole-resistant nematodes in
cattle. Journal of the New Zealand Institute of Agricultural Science 26, 53.
Hotson, I.K., Campbell, N.J. and Smeal, M.G. (1970). Anthelmintic resistance in
Trichostrongylus colubriformis. Australian Veterinary Journal 46, 356-360.
Hubert, J. and Kerboeuf, D. (1992). A microlarval development assay for the
detection of anthelmintic resistance in sheep nematodes. Veterinary Record
130.44246.
Hubert, J., Kerboeuf, D., Nicolas, J.A., Dubost, G. and Gayaud, C. (1991).
Resistance of small ruminant nematodes to benzimidazole derivative com-
pounds in Limousin (France). Recueil de Mkdecine VktCrinaire 167, 135-140.
Hughes, P.L. (1988). Further field comment on anthelmintic resistance in sheep
nematodes. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 36, 157-158.
Hunt, K.R. and Taylor, M.A. (1989). Use of the egg hatch assay on sheep faecal
samples for the detection of benzimidazole resistant nematodes. Veterinary
Record 125, 153-154.
Hunt, K.R., Hong, C., Coles, G.C., Simpson, V.R. and Neal, C. (1992).
Benzimidazole-resistant Cooperia curticei from Comwall, England. Veterinary
Record 130, 164.
Hunt, K.R., Hong, C., Coles, G.C. and Jones, T.O. (1994). Benzimidazole-resistant
Trichostrongylus colubriformis from goats in central England. Veterinary
Record 134, 4 2 0 4 2 1.
Isaza, R., Courtney, C.H., and Neal, F.C. (1987). Benzimidazole-resistant
70 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
Scott, E.W., Bairden, K., Holmes, P.H. and McKellar, Q.A. (1989). Benzimidazole
resistance in nematodes of goats. Veterinary Record 124, 492.
Scott, E.W., McKellar, Q.A., Armour, J., Coop, R.L., Jackson, F. and Mitchell,
G.B.B. (1990). Incidence of anthelmintic resistance in Scotland, UK. In
“Resistance of Parasites to Antiparasitic Drugs” (J.C. Boray, P.J. Martin and
R.T. Roush, eds), pp. 99-101. MSD Agvet, Rahway.
Scott, E.W., Duncan, J.L., McKellar, Q.A., Coop, R.L., Jackson, F. and Mitchell,
G.B.B. (1991a). Benzimidazole resistance in sheep nematodes. Veterinary
Record 128,618-619.
Scott, J.G., Roush, R.T. and Liu, N. (1991b). Selection of high-level abamectin
resistance from field-collected house flies, Musca domestica. Experientia 47,
288-291.
Sheir-Neiss, G., Lai, M.H. and Moms, N.R. (1978). Identification of a gene for
P-tubulin in Aspergillus nidulans. Cell 15, 639-647.
Shelton, M. (1968). An evaluation of some newer anthelmintics. Journal of Animal
Science 27, 1136.
Shoop, W.L. (1993). Ivermectin resistance. Parasitology Today 9, 154-159.
Shoop, W.L., Egerton, J.R., Eary, C.H. and Suhayda, D. (1990). Anthelmintic
activity of paraherquamide in sheep. Journal of Parasitology 76, 349-35 1.
Shoop, W.L., Eary,C.H., Michael, B.F., Haines, H.W. and Seward, R.L. (1991).
Anthelmintic activity of paraherquamide in dogs. Veterinary Parasitology 40,
339-341.
Shoop, W.L., Haines, H.W., Eary, C.H. and Michael, B.F (1992a). Acute toxicity
of paraherquamide and its potential as an anthelmintic. American Journal of
Veterinary Research 53, 2032-2034.
Shoop, W.L., Michael, B.F., Haines, H.W. and Eary,C.H. (1992b). Anthelmintic
activity of paraherquamide in calves. Veterinary Parasitology 43, 259-263.
Shoop, W.L., Egerton, J.R., Seward, R.L., Eary, C.H., Haines, H.W. and Michael,
B.F. (1993a). Anthelmintic activity of milbemycin oxime against adult and
immature Uncinaria stenocephala in dogs. Australian Veterinary Journal 70,
187-1 88.
Shoop, W.L., Haines, H.W., Michael, B.F. and Eary, C.H. (1993b). Mutual
resistance between avermectins and milbemycins: oral activity of ivermectin
and moxidectin against ivermectin-resistant and susceptible nematodes.
Veterinary Record 133, 4 4 5 4 7 .
Simpkin, K.G. and Coles, G.C. (1978). Instability of benzimidazole resistance in
nematode eggs. Research in Veterinary Science 25, 249-250.
Slocombe, J.O.D. and Cote, J.F. (1977). Small strongyles of horses with cross
resistance to benzimidazole anthelmintics and susceptibility to unrelated
compounds. Canadian Veterinary Journal 18, 212-2 17.
Slocombe, J.O.D., Cote, J.F. and McMillan, I. (1989). Effectiveness of oxibenda-
zole against benzimidazole-resistant strongyles in horses. Canadian veterinary
Journal 30, 663-665.
Smeal, M.G., Gough, P.A., Jackson, A.R. and Hotson, I.K. (1968) The occurrence
of strains of Haemonchus contortus resistant to thiabendazole. Australian
Veterinary Journal 44, 108-109.
Smith, G. (1990). A mathematical model for the evolution of anthelmintic
resistance in a direct life cycle nematode parasite. International Journal of
Parasitology 20, 9 13-92 1.
Smith-Buijs, C.M.C. and Borgsteede, F.H.M. (1986). Effect of cool storage of
faecal samples containing Haemonchus contortus eggs on the results of an in
80 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
Van Wyk, J.A., Van Schalkwyk, P.C., Gerger, H.M., Visser, E.L., Alves, R.M.R.
and Van Schalkwyk, L. (1989b). South African field strains of Haemonchus
contortus resistant to the levamisole/morantel groups of anthelmintics.
Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research 56, 257-262.
Van Wyk, J.A., Bath, G.F., Gerber, H.M. and Alves, R.M.R. (1990). A field strain
of Trichostrongylus colubriformis resistant to levamisole and morantel in South
Africa. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research 57, 1 19-122.
Varady, M., Praslicka, J., Corba, J. and Vesely, L. (1993). Multiple anthelmintic
resistance of nematodes in imported goats. Veterinary Record 132, 387-388.
Vercruysse, J., Domy, P. and Meurrens, K. (1989). Benzimidazole resistance of
nematodes in sheep in Belgium. Veterinary Record 125, 602-603.
Vercruysse, J., Domy, P., Hong, C., Harris, T.J., Hammet, N.C., Smith, D.G.
and Weatherley, A.J. (1993). Efficacy of doramectin in the prevention of
gastrointestinai nematode infections in-grazing cattle. Veterinaj Parasitology
49. 51-59.
Vieira, L.S., Berne, M.E.A., Cavalcante, A.C.R. and Costa, C.A.F. (1992).
Haemonchus contortus resistance to ivermectin and netobimin in Brazilian
sheep. Veterinary Parasitology 45, 111-1 16.
Vieira-Bressan, M.C.R., Campos Pereira, M., Cordova, C.C., Suma, R.P. and
Queiroz, A. (1988). Estudo comparativo da eficzicia de ivermectina, de oxiben-
dazole e de febantel no controle de estrongilideos de equinos de raga purosangue
ingles e puro-sangue airabe. Hora Veterinaria 46, 29-33.
Vizard, A.L. and Wallace, R.J. (1987). A simplified faecal egg count reduction test.
Australian Veterinary Journal 64, 109-1 11.
Vlassoff, A. and Kettle, P.R. (1980). Benzimidazole resistance in Haemonchus
contortus. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 28, 23-24.
Wagland, B.M., Jones, W.O., Hribar, L., Bendixsen, T. and Emery, D.L. (1992). A
new simplified assay for larval migration inhibition. International Journal for
Parasitology 22, 1183-1 185.
Waller, P.J. (1990). Resistance in nematode parasites of livestock to the benzimi-
dazole anthelmintics. Parasitology Today 6, 127-1 29.
Waller, P.J. ( 1993). Control strategies to prevent resistance. Veterinary Parasitology
46, 133-142.
Waller, P.J., Dobson, R.J., Donald, A.D., Griffiths, D.A. and Smith, E.F. (1985).
Selection studies on anthelmintic resistant and susceptible populations of
Trichostrongylus colubriformis of sheep. International Journal for Parasitology
15, 669-676.
Waller, P.J., Dobson, R.J., Obendorf, D.L. and Gillham, R.J. (1986). Resistance
of Trichostrongylus colubriformis to levamisole and morantel: differences in
relation to selection history. Veterinary Parasitology 21, 255-263.
Waller, P.J., Dobson, R.J. and Axelsen, A. (1988). Anthelmintic resistance in the
field: changes in resistance status of parasitic populations in response to anthel-
mintic treatment. Australian Veterinary Journal 65, 376-379.
Waller, P.J., Donald, A.D., Dobson, R.J., Lacey, E., Hennessy, D.R., Allerton, G.R.
and Prichard, R.K. (1989). Changes in anthelmintic resistance status of
Haemonchus contortus and Trichostrongylus colubriformis exposed to different
anthelmintic selection pressures in grazing sheep. International Journal for
Parasitology 19, 99-1 10.
Waller, P.J., Dobson, R.J. and Haughey, K.G. (1990a). The effect of combinations
of anthelmintics on parasite populations in sheep. Australian Veterinary Journal
67, 138-140.
CHEMOTHERAPY OF NEMATODE INFECTIONS OF VETERINARY IMPORTANCE 83
Waller, P.J., Nansen, P. and Bjorn, H. (1990b). Anthelmintic resistance and its
impact on the intensive animal production industries of Scandinavia. In
“Resistance of Parasites to Antiparasitic Drugs’’ (J.C. Boray, P.J. Martin and
R.T. Roush, eds), pp. 123-127. MSD Agvet, Rahway.
Watson, T. (1993). Resistance lasts for ever. The New Zealand Farmer April,
38-39.
Watson, T.G. and Hosking, B.C. (1990). Evidence for multiple anthelmintic
resistance in two nematode parasite genera on a Saanen goat dairy. New
Zealand Veterinary Journal 38, 50-53.
Watson, T.G.and Manley, T.R. (1985). Pharmacokinetics of oxfendazole in red
deer (Cervus elaphus). Research in Veterinary Science 38, 231-233.
Watson, T.G., Hosking, B.C. and Mckee, P.F. (1993). Stability of ivermectin
resistance in a field strain of Ostertagia spp. Proceedings of the New Zealand
Society of Animal Production 53, 1-3.
Weatherley, A.J., Hong, C., Harris, T.J., Smith, D.G. and Hammet, N.C. (1993).
Persistent efficacy of doramectin against experimental nematode infections in
calves. Veterinary Parasitology 49, 45-50.
Webb, R.F. and Ottaway, S.J. (1986). The prevalence of anthelmintic resistance in
sheep nematodes on the central tablelands of New South Wales. Australian
Veterinary Journal 63, 13-16.
Webb, R.F., McCully, C.H., Clarke, F.L., Greentree, P. and Honey, P. (1979). The
incidence of thiabendazole resistance in field populations of Haemonchus
contortus on the Northern Tablelands of New South Wales. Australian Veter-
inary Journal 55,422426.
Webb, J.D., Burg, J.G. and Knapp, F.W. (1991). Moxidectin evaluation against
Solenopotes capillatus (Anoplura: Linognathidae), Bovicola bovis (Mallophaga:
Trichodectidae), and Musca autumnalis (Diptera: Muscidae) on cattle. Journal of
Economic Entomology 84, 1266-1269.
Wescott, R.B. (1986a). Epidemiology and control of nematodes and cestodes in
small ruminants: Western United States. Veterinary Clinics of North America:
Food Animal Practice 2, 363-366.
Wescott, R.B. (1986b). Anthelmintics and drug resistance. Veterinary Clinics of
North America: Equine Practice 2, 367-380.
Wescott, R.B., Jen, L.W., Hellier, L.E., Stenslie, J.L. and Torbeck, R.L. (1982).
Efficacy of combinations of piperazine and fenbendazole against benzimidazole-
resistant small strongyles in horses. Veterinary MedicinelSmall Animal Clinician
77, 247-249.
Wescott, R.B., Jen, L.W., Hellier, L.E., Schaefer, D.C. and Traub, J.L. (1985).
Treating for benzimidazole-resistant small strongyles (cyathostomes). Veterinary
Medicine 80, 60-64.
West, D.M., Pomroy, W.E., Probert, A.D. and Charleston, W.A.G. (1989). Multi-
generic resistance to benzimidazole anthelmintics in four sheep flocks. New
Zealand Veterinary Journal 37, 76-78.
Whitlock, H.V., Kelly, J.D., Porter, C.J., Griffin, D.L. and Martin, I.C.A. (1980). In
vitro field screening for anthelmintic resistance in strongyles of sheep and
horses. Veterinary Parasitology 7, 2 15-232.
Wicks, S.R., Kaye, B., Weatherley, A.J., Lewis, D., Davison, E., Gibson, S.P. and
Smith, D.G. (1993). Effect of formulation on the pharmacokinetics and efficacy
of doramectin. Veterinary Parasitology 49, 17-26.
Williams, J.C. (1991). Efficacy of albendazole, levamisole and fenbendazole
84 GEORGE A. CONDER AND WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
K. MacKenzie
H.H. Williams
B. Williams
A.H. McVicar
R. Siddall
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86
2. Parasites and Pollution ......................... 87
2.1. Hydrocarbon pollution ....................... 87
2.2. Heavy metals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92
2.3. Thermal pollution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94
2.4. Other forms of pollution ...................... 98
3. Effects of Natural Environmental Factors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105
4. Helminth Life Cycles, Transmission Processes and Water Quality ... . 109
5. Guidelines and Procedures for Selecting Hosts and Parasites ..... . 126
5.1. Guidelines ............................. 126
5.2. Procedures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129
References ............................... 129
1. INTRODUCTION
Many of the papers claiming that pollution influences the numbers and
distribution of marine parasites deal with three specific categories of
pollution - hydrocarbon, heavy metal and thermal. We therefore consider
these categories separately below.
The toxic effects on marine fish of crude oil and its fractions have been
studied since the early 1970s (Blanton and Robinson, 1973; Anderson et al.,
1974a, b, 1977; Gardner, 1975; Di Michele and Taylor, 1978; McCain et al.,
1978; Payne et al., 1978; Dey et al., 1983; Kiceniuk and Khan, 1983, 1987;
Khan, 1987a, b) and histopathological effects have been studied since the
late 1970s (Hawkes, 1977; Hodgins et al., 1977; Solangi and Overstreet,
1982; Haensly et al., 1982; Khan and Kiceniuk, 1984; Grizzle, 1986).
The effects of oil and its components on fish parasites have been
88 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
oiled sediment which had been weathered for a year, and 6.84 in control
fish. Haensly et al. (1982), in their investigations of parasites of plaice after
the Amoco Cadiz oil spill, found that at their last three collection times,
stomach parasites (Protozoa and encysted helminths) were significantly
less frequent at oiled sites than at reference sites.
Khan and Kiceniuk (1983) found that exposure to water-soluble frac-
tions of oil reduced the prevalence and intensity of infection of the
acanthocephalan Echinorhynchus gadi in cod. Prevalence was 100% and
intensity 4.9 worms/fish in controls compared with 7 1 % and 2.0 worms/fish
in cod treated with water-soluble fractions of Hibernian oil for 81 days.
Venezuelan oil appeared to have a weaker effect on parasitism since
differences in prevalence and intensity of infection in exposed and control
fish were significant only after 140 days exposure. Similarly, exposure to
oil reduced the prevalence and intensity of infection of the digenean
Steringophorusfurciger in the gut of winter flounder.
Khan and Kiceniuk (1983) suggested reasons for a reduction in gut
parasites in fish exposed to oil: there could be direct toxicity to the
parasites, or the effects may be indirect. Indirect effects include modifica-
tions of the gut environment so that it becomes inhospitable to the para-
sites, owing to a change in the fish’s physiology and a change in the
composition of bile, which can happen in cod exposed to oil and hydro-
carbons (Dey et al., 1983). If this is so, cod may be an ideal fish for future
work since it has a distinctive tapeworm Abothrium gadi, and it is well
known that tapeworms have requirements for host-specific bile salts
(Williams and Halvorsen, 1971). Although the life cycle of A. gadi has
not been elucidated, it may be a useful model for investigating changes in
water quality.
Some caution is necessary in setting up and interpreting the results of
laboratory experiments with fish carrying gut parasites. Williams (1966)
and Moller (1976) found that starved fish lost their gut parasites. Moller
found that the rate of ejection was particularly high for parasites not
attached to or only loosely attached to the gut wall, or relying on the host’s
gut contents for nutrition. For example, 84.2% of the acanthocephalan
Echinorhynchus gadi was lost from cod over 46 days, and 91.8%, 100%
and 100% of the nematode Hysterothylacium (= Contracaecum) aduncum
(feeders on gut contents), were lost from eelpout Zoarces viviparus, sculpin
Myoxocephalus scorpius and flounder Platichthys jlesus, respectively, over
76 days. The lowest rates of ejection were 38.2% loss of the mucosa-
feeding nematode Cucullanus heterochrous, 13.9% loss of the digenean
Podocotyle atomon and 6.5% loss of the cestode Bothriocephalus scorpii.
Since cestodes and acanthocephalans have no gut and rely for nutrition on
the active transport of amino acids, fatty acids and monosaccharides
through their body surfaces, it is perhaps to be expected that they would
92 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
be lost quickly from starving fish. Williams (1966) found that rays Raja
clavata starved for a week were devoid of infection by the cestodes
Echeneibothrium and Echinobothrium.
In contrast to the above results, Khan and Kiceniuk (1983) recorded the
same prevalence (94%) of the digenean Steringophorus furciger in control
flounder kept unfed for 34 days in aquaria as in freshly captured flounder
necropsied immediately, and the prevalence of the acanthocephalan
Echinorhynchus g a d was 100% in two sets of control fish compared
with 94% in freshly captured cod.
Poland between 1972 and 1974. It was found that the thermally polluted
Lake Goslawskie had two fewer parasite species than Lake Goplo (with 27
species) and the array of parasites present differed: 19 species were common
to both lakes, but eight species occurring in Lake Goplo were absent from
Lake Goslawskie, and six species in that lake were absent from Lake Goplo.
in the thermally polluted lake fewer fish were infected with Myxosporea, the
monogeneans Ductylogyrus fulcatus and D . wunderi, the digenean Sphuero-
stoma brumue and the cestode Curyophyllueus laticeps. In Lake Goslawskie
the parasitic copepod Ergusilus sieboldi matured earlier and had a longer
reproductive period. Changes in the maturation and recruitment of Curyo-
phyllueus luticeps to new fish hosts produced different patterns in the
dynamics of infrapopulation densities in this parasite, as shown by the
change in prevalence and intensity of infection in Lake Goslawskie.
Pojmhska and Dzika (1987) in a report on data collected at Lake
Goslawskie between 1983 and 1984, found that there had been a number
of changes in the ten years since 1974. The parasite community in the lake
had been reduced by two species and five species had disappeared, with
three new species establishing. Four species decreased in frequency and six
others increased, thus changing the dominance structure of the parasite
community. The number of Ergusilus sieboldi had decreased; although the
higher temperatures allowed a longer reproductive period, it is likely that
the poor tolerance by the free-living stages of the higher temperatures
caused an overall decrease to a very low population density. Since most
Ductylogyrus species specific to bream increased it appears that they could
tolerate the higher temperatures.
Some of the trends suggested by the 1972-74 study were confirmed for
parasites with complex life cycles. They were: the earlier peak in density of
some parasite infrapopulations in fish (Curyophyllueus luticeps and the
digenean Tylodelphys cluvutu); earlier maturation of some species (C.
luticeps); prolongation of reproductive period and time of invasion by
young stages (C. luticeps and the digenean Sphuerostoma muius); and
loss of seasonal occurrence in fish (the digeneans Diplostomum sp. and
Ichthyocotylurus sp.) Pojmhska et al. (1980) regarded changes in the
benthos and littoral invertebrates, which act as intermediate hosts to the
parasites, as the main reason for the difference in the parasite communities
between the thermally polluted lakes and Lake Goplo. In 1983-84
Pojmhska and Dzika (1987) found that devastation of the habitats of
invertebrate intermediate hosts and of the nesting and feeding grounds of
the bird final hosts was much more important than thermal pollution in
influencing the parasite fauna. The authors commented that parasitological
studies have limitations in evaluating disturbance to ecosystems from
thermal pollution, but nevetherless the data indicated some stabilization
in Lake Goslawskie. For example, the appearance of Acunthocephalus
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 97
digeneans were found in snails in the control area, compared with seven
species in the heated area.
Sankurathri and Holmes (1976) described an interesting interaction
between the commensal oligochaete Chaetogaster limnaei limnaei, living
on the head, foot and in the mantle cavity of P. gyrina, and the larval
digeneans parasitizing this snail. C.1. limnaei actively ingested a number
of cercariae (Echinoparyphium recurvatum, Echinostoma revolutum,
Notocotylus urbanensis, Trichobilharzia cameroni, Apatemon gracilis,
Zchthyocotylurus erraticus and Cotylurus sp.). In experiments using iso-
lated snails and miracidia of E. recurvatum, the number of miracidia
successfully penetrating and developing was inversely proportional to the
number of oligochaetes present. This was also true for cercarial penetration
and development. If snails were grouped together, the protective effect of
the oligochaetes was enhanced. Even if miracidia or cercariae were not
eaten, the oligochaetes obstructed them: dead cercariae were observed in
dishes containing snails with commensal oligochaetes, but not in control
dishes. Wright ( 1956) recorded a similar phenomenon: Turritella snails
from Millport, Scotland, carried on their opercula colonies of the hydroid
Leuckartiara which, together with their free-swimming medusae, fed on
large numbers of cercariae shed by the snails.
C.1. limnaei was sensitive to higher temperatures: in the heated area of
the lake with water temperatures of 24°C or over the oligochaetes were
present on 36.5% of the snails with a mean intensity of 3.6. Conversely, in
the control area, they occurred on 92.7% of snails, with a mean intensity of
10.1 oligochaetes. The lower mean intensity in the thermally polluted area
would favour parasite transmission to snails.
Thulin (1984) suggested that thermal pollution may have been a factor in
changing the distribution and infection intensity of the digenean eye fluke
Diplostomum sp., a freshwater parasite found in coastal waters of the Baltic
Sea. At one site, near the nuclear plant at Oskarshamn, 90% of cod
examined carried these eye flukes, and a quarter of the fish had very
high infection intensities of 50-200 flukes, causing greying or whitening
Qf the lens. Invasion of a marine host (cod) by a freshwater parasite, and
thermal pollution, were factors regarded as perhaps contributing to high
infection levels.
Table 1 Continued
Type of pollution Parasites/hosts and observations Reference and locality
Low level of The myxosporean Myxobolus exiguus Papema and
dissolved oxygen, on gills of mullet Mugil cephalus Overstreet (1981)
possibly caused and M . auratus. Fish kill associated Crimea (marine)
by pollutants with heavy infection
“Municipal Gill trichodinids on gills of several Dabrowska (1974)
pollution” fish species. Increased infection and Poland (rivers)
gill damage in fish from polluted
stations
from the limed river. The difference was particularly marked in those
parasite groups, notably digeneans, with complex life cycles, this being
in large part attributable to the adverse effects of acidification on the
invertebrate intermediate hosts. Differential susceptibility of the parasites
or their intermediate hosts to acidification appeared to be major factors in
structuring the parasite communities. The authors concluded that the
assemblage of metazoan parasites of fish may be useful as environmental
indicators and may also provide information on the dynamics of altered
food webs.
Valtonen and Taskinen (1988) suggested that the increased prevalence of
metacercariae of the digenean Rhipidocotyle campanula in fish from
eutrophic lakes in Finland might be attributable to lowered resistance in
the fish. Snieszko (1974) and Sindermann (1979) reviewed examples of
disease outbreaks associated with pollutants as environmental stressors. In
the light of studies by O’Neill (1981), Zeeman and Brindley (1981),
Kiceniuk et al. (1982), Sakanari et al. (1984), Wojani and Alfred (1984),
Fries (1986), Khan (1987a) and Mohan and Sommerville (1988) it seems
that increased parasitism could reflect increased susceptibility in fish hosts,
since fish exposed to pollutants showed suppressed antibody synthesis,
damage to lymphoid tissue, changes in numbers of leucocytes, reduced
phagocytosis and damage to the mucus layer protecting skin and gills.
Andrews et al. (1966) found that bluegills Lepomis macrochirus exposed
once to concentrations of the insecticide heptachlor at 0.0125-0.500 ppm
became heavily infected with trematode metacercariae which encysted in
the liver, kidneys and heart, whereas unexposed control fish did not.
Some experimental work appears to lend support to the idea that pollu-
tants increase susceptibility of fish to parasites. In experiments with carp
Cyprinus carpio, Vladimirov and Flerov (1975) exposed fish to 1.5 mg
polychloropinene 1-’ water (0.0015 ppm) for 48 h. Only half the fish
survived this exposure. Surviving fish were challenged with parasitic
invasion by I . multijiliis 1, 7, 15, 30 and 60 days after the time of their
102 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
Table 2 Continued
Type of pollution Parasitehost and observations Reference and locality
Paper and pulp Numbers of helminth parasite species Anikieva (1982)
plant effluent present in 1 1 fish species reduced in Lake in Karelia,
more heavily polluted zones of lake: Russia
41 species in clean zone versus 20
species in most polluted zone.
Monogeneans most affected: 10 species
in clean zone, 1 (Diplozoon paradoxum)
in most-polluted zone. Most differences
were recorded for fish which shoal in
circumscribed areas, e.g. perch Perca
fluviatilis and roach Rutilus rutilus
Urbdindustrial Reduced diversity of species and Bum (1980)
pollution parasite numbers in winter flounder Raritan Bay (polluted
Pseudopleuronectes americanus in area)
heavily polluted area (five parasites Block Island Sound,
missing: E . gadi, Ascarophis sp., (clean area)
Podocotyle atomon, Cryptocotyle E Coast USA
lingua and a digenean of family
Opecoelidae); this area had reduced
benthic fauna so reduction in
intermediate hosts a likely cause (but
direct pollution effects not ruled out)
Urbdindustrial 50% decrease in parasite species of Sulgostowska (1988)
pollution flounder Platichthys flesus since 1930s Gdansk Bay, Poland
from 14 to 7 species. Some species compared 1980s data
lost: cestodes Caryophyllaeus laticeps, with that of
Proteocephalus sp.; acanthocephalans Janiszewska (1939)
Neoechinorhynchus rutili,
Echinorhynchus salmonis and
Corynosoma semerme; digenean
Brachyphallus crenatus. Remaining spp.
tended to increase: cestode
Bothriocephalus scorpii, digenean
metacercariae of Diplostomum sp.,
acanthocephalans E. gadi (2.5% of fish
infected in 1930s, 13.0%infected
1982-83), Pomphorhynchus laevis
(8.5% of fish infected in 1930s, 31.4%
1982-83); nematodes, Thynnascaris
adunca, Cucullanus minutus (latter, from
50% prevalence to 80%, 1982-83).
Changes in parasite community
attributed to loss of certain intermediate
and even final hosts
104 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
In the foregoing review of marine parasites and pollution our main aim was
to update Khan and Thulin (1991). However, much of the work published
106 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
that it is not clear how, and to what extent, the factors referred to in
Table 5 individually and in various combinations, affect the numbers and
distribution of parasites under natural conditions. This problem highlights
the complexity of parasite ecology, which can be defined as the total
relationship of a species to its biotic and abiotic environments.
It follows that the relationship between pollution and marine parasite
ecology is also very complex. The problem is exacerbated by the need (1)
to define the kind of pollution that is involved, and (2) to know the form of
parasite life cycle under investigation - what stages are most susceptible
and what host species are involved.
In some instances a parasite may be directly susceptible to the toxic
effects of pollutants, in which case pollution may reduce infection pre-
valence and intensity. On the other hand, if the host is more susceptible
than the parasite to the pollutant, its resistance to infection may be lowered,
leading tb higher prevalence and intensity. Being parasitized may itself
increase the host’s susceptibility to pollution. Fish mortality due to the
combined effects of pollution and parasitic infection has been demon-
strated experimentally (Perevozchenko and Davydov, 1974; Boyce and
Yamada, 1977; Pascoe and Cram, 1977; Pascoe and Woodworth, 1980).
Further complications arise when the life cycle of the parasite is indirect,
since pollution can affect intermediate or alternative hosts.
It is now accepted that a large number of biotic and abiotic factors affect
the prevalence and abundance of parasites and that temperature is among
the most important of these. Esch (1982) divided abiotic factors into two
groups: those which are determined and predictable in character and those
which are not. In nature, temperature is a determinate predictable character,
e.g. according to season, but through the influence of humans in artificially
heating water with thermal effluent from coal-fired and nuclear electricity
power stations, it is often unpredictable. Most indeterminate factors are
artificial and include fire, flood, artificially elevated temperature, radical
temperature change on a short-term basis and nutrient enrichment of water.
This area of research is an important but little understood aspect of
parasites and pollution because it is well known that water temperature
plays a crucial role in the development and activity of free-living and
ectoparasitic stages of fish helminths. Most of the evidence to support this
statement is based on freshwater fish helminths such as Gyrodactylus,
Dactylogyrus, Caryophyllaeus, Proteocephalus, Bunodera, Allocreadium
and Eustrongylides. The monogenean Dactylogyrus solidus on the gills
of carp Cyprinus carpio is sluggish and easily removable at low tempera-
tures (Bauer, 1962). Since temperature will vary according to the season of
the year at various latitudes and longitudes, it is not surprising that much
has been written on the seasonality and zoogeography of parasitic worms
with many references to water temperature as an all-important factor in
108 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
About 200 fish helminth life cycles have been elucidated, and we there-
fore have a good knowledge of the basic transmission patterns for each
of the main taxonomic groups, namely Monogenea, Gyrocotylidea,
Amphilinidea, Caryophyllidea, Cestoda, Aspidogastrea, Digenea,
Nematoda and Acanthocephala. A transmission route is the pathway
through which a parasite progresses from one developmental stage to
the next and from one host to another. Most helminths have a range of
possible host species at certain life cycle stages, resulting in a number
of possible transmission routes. Associated with each transmission route
is a transmission window - the period during which transmission of the
parasite from one host to another can take place. The length of the
window depends on the concurrence of infective stages of the parasite
with hosts that are suceptible to infection. In some transmission routes
these windows are open virtually throughout the entire life span of the
host so that infection can take place at almost any time. In others the
windows are very narrow and transmission is limited to brief seasonal
periods. These narrow transmission windows represent weak links in
parasite life cycles at which routes through some host species may be
easily disrupted by changes in environmental conditions.
The Monogenea and some Gyrocotylidea have delicate free-living
ciliated larval stages in their direct form of life cycle, which involves
one host only (Tables 6 and 7). The larvae are also known to be short-
lived (up to 30 h) and therefore transmission from one host to another must
take place during a very brief period in the life cycle. Some nematodes (e.g.
some cucullanids) also have a life cycle involving only one host, but the
110 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
surface of sole,
and then Fish host - the common sole,
Solca solca
lamellae of fish I
1
attach; to host
paragraph, in that the development time for the egg may be longer, they
may or may not include free-living larval stages, and intermediate hosts
(invertebrates and fish) are often implicated (Tables 8, 9 and 13). The
number of possible transmission routes is therefore greater. The free-living
112 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
oncomiracidium
(no host chemical
stimulus required for
tenuis (= dollfusi) survive for 35 days at 11”C, 58 days at 15°C and 19 days
-at 19°C (Sakanari and Moser, 1985a). This longevity opens the opportunity
for several transmission routes to be utilized.
The life cycles of digeneans are even more complicated, involving from
one to four developmental stages in different host species plus a number of
alternative host species for some of these stages, giving rise to a large
number of possible transmission routes (Table 11). A digenean is usually
highly specific to its primary host (usually a mollusc), infecting only a
single species, or a group of closely related species, but may have a wide
range of alternative intermediate or definitive host species. Alternative host
species in helminth life cycles may be arranged along a continuum from
those to which the parasite is best adapted and which provide it with the
highest probability of successful transmission, to “dead-ends’’ or “eco-
logical &ks”, through which no further development is possible (Holmes,
1979).
An example of a cestode species with alternative hosts giving widely
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 115
plerocercoid
ingestcd with
second
intermediate
. host by elasmobranchs of
elasmobranch gnvid pmglottid
'
definitive host.
the genus R a j a (body acgment
and develops to containing eggs)
adult detaches and is
I
shed with host
~rocercoid innested
L i b copcpodiy
fish second pcrculurn (lid) -
intermediate host
'on time = 3-6
Coracidium - f m - \1 to rele.sc
t-'
coracidium
+;EJK 3
coracidium swimming luvd stage.
survival lime = m u . 9-11
drys n 16-ZO°C (McCuCay
Procercoid unpubl). d u least 14 days
in copepod first procercoid 10-16°C. (Bates 1987)
intermediate
host. eg.
Acarrfa.
PscudocaIanus.
Poracalanw ,
Tcmora.
Adult cestode
plero
inges
sccond
intermediate Definitive host -
host by the spur dog,
elasmobrancb gravid proglottid
definitive host. Squalus acanthias (body segment
and develops to containing eggs)
adult &tubes and 1s
sbcd w ~ t bhost
proglottid brcaks
up in water LO
proccrcoid ingested
with copcpod by
fish second
intermediate host
cestodes in these hosts will ever complete their life cycles because the
definitive host, the angel-shark Squatina squatina, is a bottom-living
ambush predator which is unlikely ever to prey on pelagic fish (MacKenzie
et af., 1984). Transmission routes through demersal fish hosts such as the
sea-breams (Sparidae) are likely to be more successful.
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 117
Table 9 Life cycles in the Eucestoda (strobilate tapeworms). Trypanorhyncha: in
some species eggs hatch to release ciliated coracidia. Most vulnerable stage: free-
swimming coracidium.
Species Key observations References
Grillotia erinaceus Coracidium infected copepods and Ruszkowski (1934)
(Figure 4) developed to procercoid in experiments
Lacistorhynchus Hatching and survival of coracidium dependent Sakanari and Moser
tenuis (= Lacisto- on temperature and salinity (eggs hatched after (1985a);
rhynchus dolljhJa 11 days in 50% sea water at 15OC). Mudry and Dailey
Coracidium infected copepods and developed (1971);
to a procercoid in experiments; the Moser (1981);
plerocercoid stage is found in > 60 teleost Young (1954)
species. In lab, plerocercoids from the
shinerperch Cymatogaster aggregata infected
leopard shark Triakis semifasciata. The
copepod Tigriopus californicus, mosquito fish
Gambusia aflnis and T. semifasciata were
suitable first and second intermediate and
definitive hosts
Parachristianella No free-swimming coracidium. Develops in Mudry and Dailey
monomegacantha copepod to form an immature plerocercus (1971)
probably directly infective to elasmobranchs
Gilquinia squali No free-swimming coracidium. Probably MacKenzie (1975)
(Figure 5 ) develops in benthic copepods. Plerocercoids
in humours of eye of whiting Merlangius
merlangus. Adult worms in spurdog Squalus
acanthias
Pseudophyllidea Life cycles of fresh water species best known
Eubothrium Marine form's preferred host is Salmo solar. Kennedy (1978a, b);
crassum Eggs are sensitive to salinity changes: Kuperman (1978)
need 5-20 ppt
Bothrioce halus Adults in turbot Psetta maxima; plerocercoids Davey and Peachey
gregariusf in the teleost Gobius minutus (= second (1968);
intermediate host); first intermediate host may Robert et al. (1990)
be a crustacean. Plerocercoids in first
intermediate host appear to be infective to
young turbot
Diphyllidea Adults parasitize elasmobranchs; intermediate hosts include molluscs,
gammarids and crabs. Adult worms may be the most vulnerable
Echinobothrium Metacestodes in Carcinus maenas. Adults in Dollfus (1964)
afine Raja clavata
Lecanicephalidea Very little useful information available on life cycles, but marine
and Tetraphyllidea species are very abundant
a Sakanari and Moser (1985a, b) called their material L. tenuis, but collected from
the Pacific coast of the USA, which means that it is really L. dollfusi, according to
Beveridge and Sakanari (1987).
Bothriocephalus scorpii was recognized as a species complex: Renaud et al.
(1983) and Renaud and Gabrion (1984) distinguished four species: B. scorpii, B.
gregarius, B. barbatus and B . funiculus.
118 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
I
pre-adult
ingesrcd by the
Fish host -
the thornback Lays eggs
Af 4
Cercaria - free-
swimming, fork-
tailed larval stage via exhalent siphon of
mollusc. Several
hundred emitted per
day
metacercaria
ingested with
second
intermediate
-
Main definitive host - five
bearded rockling, Ciliutu
-
I
inhabits body cavity
of rockling, and
stomach of eel and
conger eel
I
I
host copepod and n u s f c f u . (also reported from eel
develops to adult Anguilla angurlla and conger eel retained in
Conger conger) worm in body cavity of
rockling. Eggs are
released when rockling
dies or is eaten, and
\broken down. 1
Metacercaria - devel
in copepod second
intermediate host eg.
Tigrropsrs brevrcornis Miracidium -
possibly occurs, but
the gut wall and encyst in the visceral cavity. All infection of herring
Clupea harengus takes place in their first summer of life, when they feed
on planktonic organisms of approximately the same size as these cercariae.
The fastest growing juvenile herring apparently progress to feeding on
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 121
Table 11 Life cycles in the Digenea. The life cycles involve active penetration
of the mollusc first intermediate host by free-living miracidia and penetration of the
second intermediate host by free-living cercariae. These free-living stages are the
most vulnerable. Free-swimming miracidia are present in rhe life cycles of digen-
eans in the following families: Allocreadiidae, Bucephalidae, Derogenidae, Didy-
mozoidae, Gorgoderidae, Lecithasteridae, Lepocreadiidae and Opecoelidae. Free-
swimming cercariae are present in the life cycles of digeneans in the families
Hemiuridae, Fellodistomidae (Angel, 1971; K0ie, 1979a, 1980), Derogenidae
( K ~ i e ,1979b), Acanthostomidae (Maillard, 1976), Azygiidae (Stunkard, 1956)
and Bivesiculidae (Coil et al., 1965; Pearson, 1968). In the last two families,
cercariae are eaten by fish.
Species Key observations References
Proctoeces maculata This species may be ideal in view of the Freeman and
(syn. subtenuis) range of its life cycle strategies, which Llewellyn (1958)
(Fellodistomidae) include three or more generations of
sporocysts which produce cercariae in Bray and Gibson
spring-summer when water temperature (1980);
is high and labrid fish present, but only Bray (1983)
sporocysts in autumn when temperatures
fall and fish move offshore. In estuaries Aitken-Ander
of southeast England, sexually mature and Levin
adults are found in the lamellibranch (1985);
Scrobicularia plana Turner (1986)
Opechona Free-swimming miracidia penetrate Kdie (1975);
bacillaris Nassarius pygmaeus (first intermediate Bray and Gibson
(Lepocreadiidae host) and rediae produce cercariae which ( 1990)
emerge and penetrate ctenophores,
chaetognaths and medusae, but do not
encyst. Adult worms are found in the
teleost fish Cyclopterus lumpus and
Scomber scombrus
Derogenes varicus First intermediate hosts are molluscs of K d e (1979b)
- (Derogenidae) the genus Natica
Stephanostomum First intermediate host is the gastropod Koie (1978)
caducum Natica alderi. Rediae produce cercariae
(Acanthocolpidae) which emerge to encyst in gobies
(Pomatoschistus pictus, P. microps and
Chaparrudo flavescens), usually just
under epithelium of mouth. The final host
is the cod Gadus morhua
Podocotyle reflexa Free-living miracidia penetrate the KBie (1981);
(Opecoelidae) prosobranch Buccinum undatum; sporo- Gibson and Bray
cysts produce cotylocercous xiphidio- (1982)
cercariae which penetrate amphipods,
decapods and mysids as second inter-
mediate hosts. Adult worms are found in
the teleosts Gadus morhuu, Pholis
gunnellus, Rhinonemus cimbrius,
Cyclopterus lumpus and Zoarces viviparus
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 123
Table 11 Continued
~~ ~ ~
Bum ( 1 980) noted that the two dominant trematode species in winter
flounder in Jamaica Bay, New York, fluctuated greatly over a relatively
short period (10 weeks) in the summer, and regarded this as an example of
temperature-dependent parasite seasonality. The trematode Lepocreadium
124 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
Table 12 Life cycles in the Nematoda. Most require an intermediate host, but this
is not obligatory for some, e.g. the cucullanids. Some cucullanid eggs hatch to
release second-stage larvae. Other cucullanid and anisakid eggs are released non-
embryonated. The rhabdochonids and cystidicolids release partly or fully embryo-
nated eggs. Camallanids and philometrids are viviparous, releasing first-stage
larvae which behave so as to attract intermediate hosts. Survival of eggs, first- and
second-stage larvae, and rate of egg development are temperature dependent.
Species Key observations References
Cucullanus truttae First moult occurs in egg; egg hatches in Moravec, (1976,
7-8 days at 22-24°C. In some 1979, 1980)
populations, lampreys Lampetra planeri
are main, obligatory intermediate hosts.
Salmonids are definitive hosts
C. minutus First moult may occur in egg; egg hatches Gibson (1972)
in seven days at 19°C. Intermediate host
may be involved, but no firm evidence
yet; adults in flounder, Platichthys Jesus
C. heterochrous Egg hatches in seven days at 19°C; first Gibson (1972)
moult occurs in water; direct infection of
definitive host (flounder Platichthys Jesus)
by second-stage larvae, is likely
Pseudanisakis Adults found in elasmobranchs, e.g. Raja Uspenskaya
rotundata radiata; intermediate hosts are decapods (1960)
(Lithodes sp.); paratenic hosts are gadid
and pleuronectid fish
Ascarophis morhua Eggs are released fully embryonated, are Uspenskaya
ingested by crustaceans Carcinus maenas (1960);
and Pagurus sp. as intermediate hosts Poinar and
and hatch to moult twice. Final hosts are Thomas (1976)
cod Gadus morhua and haddock
Melanogrammus aeglejnus
Phiionem Gravid female expelled with roe at Uhazy (1977a, b)
oncorhynchi spawning, bursts in water to release first-
stage larvae which are ingested by cyclo- Platzer and
poid copepods (Cyclops bicuspidatus, Adams (1967)
C.b. thomasi). At 10°C L1 survive 25
days in sea water. Infective copepods are KO and Adams
eaten by fish definitive hosts ( 1969)
Oncorhynchus nerka and other salmonids.
Development times of larvae in definitive KO and Adams
and intermediate hosts given by authors (1969);
listed opposite. Maturation of host and Bashirullah
parasite synchronized so that both are ( 1973)
gravid at spawning grounds, perhaps host
hormones mediate parasite reproduction
Proleptus obtusus Crabs (Carcinus maenas, Eupagurus Lloyd (1928)
bernhardus) are intermediate hosts, and
elasmobranchs are final hosts
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 125
Table 12 Continued
Species Key observations References
Echinocephalus Adults parasitic in spiral valve of KO (1975);
SPP. elasmobranchs: E. sinensis in Aetabatus KO et al. (1975b);
jagellurn; E. uncinatus in Trygon, Millemann
Myliobatis, Balistes and other fish; E. (1963);
pseudouncinatus in Heterodontus Andrews et al.
francisa, Myliobatis californicus; E. (1988);
overstreeti in Heterodontus Anderson (1988);
portusjacksoni; larvae found in molluscan Pearse and Timm
intermediate hosts: bivalves (oysters and (1971)
abalone) and possibly sea urchins for E.
pseudouncinatus; bivalves (Crassostrea
gigas) for E. sinensis; Chlamys bifrons,
Pecten albus for E. overstreeti with oysters
as possible paratenic hosts; the gastropod
Hemrfuscus pugilinus for E. uncinatus;
Haliotis corrugata and possibly sea urchins
for E. pseudouncinatus
the variability would be the first step towards understanding the significance
of such variation in applied studies.
Most of the examples given above involve host species which are
probably not essential for the survival of populations of these particular
parasites, but which may make some contribution to the parasite’s total
reproductive output. Plaice are considered less important than some other
species of flatfish in the life cycle of S. baccatum, herring less important
than sprats Sprattus sprattus in those of C. doricha and C . pythionike, and
mackerel less important than demersal fish in that of G. smuris-gora.
Because they tend to be particularly vulnerable to changes in environ-
mental conditions, narrow transmission windows associated with less
important hosts could provide a highly sensitive advance warning system
for aquatic pollution. A significant change in environmental conditions
may result in greatly reduced transmission or even in complete failure.
For instance, Siddall et al. (1993) found that miraoidia of digeneans using
Buccinum undutum as an intermediate host were susceptible to toxic effects
of trace metals, and they considered this to be the major factor in reducing
parasite prevalence along a pollution gradient. Conversely, the effects of
environmental stress on hosts might result in increased transmission
(Paperna, 1975; Skinner, 1982; Overstreet, 1988). A significant deviation
either way from a normal rate of transmission may be a warning of adverse
environmental conditions. Monitoring of parasite prevalence could be used
to assess long-term, chronic effects of pollution in coastal and estuarine
waters, to detect and characterize pollution incidents and to determine the
dispersal patterns of known contaminants, e.g. trace metals around dump
sites (Siddall et al., 1993). A parasite-based index of pollution may
ultimately be most valuable as part of a combined monitoring approach,
including the analysis of sediment contamination, infaunal community
composition and laboratory bioassays. An approach to the use of these
trailsmission processes in pollution monitoring is proposed below.
5.1. Guidelines
1. The marine biology and parasitology of the study area should have been
well researched over a period of at least 25 years.
2. Attention should be focused on host species known to be non-migratory
or to have small migratory movements and on juvenile fish for which
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 127
parts of the study area serve as nursery grounds. Some species of the
genus Raja are good examples in British waters (Steven, 1947). It is
advisable to avoid migratory fish or invertebrates which are known to
travel long distances unless the study area is known to cover their full
migratory range.
3. Parasites which have been well studied with regard to their ecology and
life cycles are preferable as sentinels. They should also be easily seen if
present, easily collected and identified and adult stages should be
capable of surviving in cooled filtered sea water until they have pro-
duced large numbers of eggs for storage and experimentation. Ideally an
, abundance of eggs should be available for storage in sea water at the
5.2. Procedures
-6. CONCLUSIONS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Aho, J.M., Gibbons, J.W. and Esch, G.W. (1976). Relationship between thermal
loading and parasitism in mosquitofish. In ‘!Thermal Ecology 11” (G.W. Esch
and R. W. McFarlane, eds), pp. 213-218. Technical Information Center, Energy
Research and Development Agency (CONF - 750425).
Aitken-Ander, P. and Levin, N.L. (1985). Occurrence of adult and developmental
stages of Proctoeces maculatus (Trematoda: Digenea) in the gastropod Crepidula
convexa. Transactions of the American Microscopical Society 104,250-260.
Anderson, J.W., Dixit, D.B., Ward, G.S. and Foster, R.S. (1977). Effects of
petroleum hydrocarbons on the rate of heart beat and hatching success of
estuarine fish embryos. In “Physiological Responses of Marine Biota to
Pollutants” (F.J. Vemberg, A. Calabrese, F.P. Thurberg and W.B. Vemberg,
eds), pp. 241-258. Academic Press, New York.
Anderson, J.W., Neff, J.M., Cox, B.A., Tatem, H.E. and Hightower, G.M. (1974a).
Characteristics of dispersions and water-soluble extracts of crude and refined oils
and their toxicity to estuarine crustaceans and fish. Marine Biology 27, 75-88.
Anderson, J.W., Neff, J.M., Cox, B.A., Tatem, H.E. and Hightower, G.M. (1974b).
The effects of oil on estuarine animals: toxicity, uptake and depuration, respira-
tion. In “Pollution of Marine Organisms” (F.J. Vemberg and W.B. Vemberg,
eds), pp. 288-310. Academic Press, New York.
Anderson, R.C. ( 1988). Nematode transmission patterns. Journal of Parasitology
74, 30-45.
Andrews, A.K., van Valin, C.C. and Stebbings, B. (1966). Some effects of
heptachlor on bluegills, Lepomis macrochirus. Transactions of the American
Fisheries Society 95, 297-303.
Andrews, R.H., Beveridge, I., Adams, M. and Baverstock, P.R. (1988). Identifica-
tion of life cycle stages of the nematode Echinocephalus overstreeti by allozyme
electrophoresis. Journal of Helminthology 62, 153-157.
Angel, L.M. (1971). Burnellus gen. nov. (Digenea: Fellodistomidae), the life
history of the type species, B. trichofurcatus (Johnston and Angel, 1940), and
130 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
northeast Atlantic: review of the genera Opechona Looss, 1907 and Prodisto-
mum Linton, 1910. Systematic Parasitology 15, 159-202.
Brown, A.F. and Pascoe, D. (1989). Parasitism and host sensitivity to cadmium: an
acanthocephalan infection of the freshwater amphipod Gammaruspulex. Journal
of Applied Ecology 26, 473487.
Brown, B.E. (1977). Effects of mine drainage on the River Hayle, Comwall. A.
Factors affecting concentrations of copper, zinc and iron in water, sediments and
dominant invertebrate fauna. Hydrobiologia 52, 22 1-223.
Bryan, G.W. and Hummerstone, L.G. (1973). Brown seaweed as an indicator of
heavy metals in estuaries in south-west England. Journal of the Marine
Biological Association of the United Kingdom 53, 705-720.
Bum, P.R. (1980). Pollution effects on fish parasites. Coastal Ocean Pollution
Assessment News 1, 3 4 .
Buron, I. and Golvan, Y.J. (1986). Les HBtes des Acanthoctphales I. Les H6tes
intermediares. Annales de Parasitologie Humaine et Comparke 61, 58 1-592.
Bychowsky, B.E. (1961). “Monogenetic Trematodes. Their Systematics and
Phylogepy.” English Translation by P.C. Oustinoff (W.J. Hargis, Jr, ed.).
American Institute of Biological Sciences, Washington, DC,627 pp.
Chubb, J.C. (1977). Seasonal occurrence of helminths in freshwater fishes. Part I.
Monogenea. Advances in Parasitology 15, 133-199.
Chubb, J.C. (1979). Seasonal occurrence of helminths in freshwater fishes. Part II.
Trematoda. Advances in Parasitology 17, 141-3 13.
Chubb, J.C. (1980). Seasonal occurrence of helminths in freshwater fishes. Part 111.
Larval Cestoda and Nematoda. Advances in Parasitology 18, 1-120.
Chubb, J.C. (1982). Seasonal occurrence of helminths in freshwater fishes. Part IV.
Cestoda, Nematoda, Acanthocephala. Advances in Parasitology 20, 1-292.
Coil, W.H., Reid, W.A. and Kuntz, R.E. (1965). Paucivitellosusfragilis gen. et sp.
nov. (Bivesiculidae: Digenea), a parasite of Chelon troscheli from Formosa.
Transactions of the American Microscopical Society 84, 365-368.
Cole, H.A. (1979). The assessment of sub-lethal effects of pollutants in the sea.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London ( B ) 286, 399424.
Colin, J.A., Williams, H.H. and Halvorsen, 0. (1986). One or three gyrocotylideans
(Platyhelminthes) in Chimaera monstrosa (Holocephali)? Journal of Parasitology
72, 10-21.
Cone, D.K., Marcogliese, D.J. and Watt, W.D. (1993). Metazoan parasite commu-
nities of yellow eels (Anguilla rostrata) in acidic and limed rivers of Nova
Scotia. Canadian Journal of Zoology 71, 177-184.
Dabrowska, H. (1974). An attempt to evaluate the state of health of fish from the
Lyna and Walsza Rivers in connection to their pollution. Przeglad Zoologicny
18, 390-395.
Das, M.C. and Shrivastava, A.K. (1984). Fish mortality in Naini Tal Lake (India)
due to pollution and parasitism. Hydrobiological Journal 20, 60-64.
Davey, J.T. and Peachey, J.E, (1968). Bothriocephalus scorpii (Cestoda: Pseudo-
phyllidea) in turbot and brill from British coastal waters. Journal of the Marine
Biological Association of the United Kingdom 48, 335-340.
Dey, A.C., Kiceniuk, J.W., Williams, U.P., Khan, R.A. and Payne, J.F. (1983).
Long term exposure of marine fish to crude petroleum. 1. Studies on liver lipids
and fatty acids in cod (Gadus morhua) and winter flounder (Pseudopleuronectes
americanus). Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 75, 93-101.
DiMichele, L. and Taylor, M.H. (1978). Histopathological and physiological
132 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
Khan, R.A. and Kiceniuk, J. (1983). Effects of crude oil on the gastrointestinal
parasites of two species of marine fish. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 19,
253-258.
Khan, R.A. and Kiceniuk, J. (1984). Histopathological effects of crude oil on
Atlantic cod following chronic exposure. Canadian Journal of Zoology 62,
2038-2043.
Khan, R.A. and Kiceniuk, J.W. (1988). Effect of petroleum aromatic hydro-
carbons on monogeneids parasitizing Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua L. Bulletin
of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 41,94-1 00.
Khan, R.A. and Thulin, J. (1991). Influence of pollution on parasites of aquatic
animals. Advances in Parasitology 30, 20 1-238.
Kiceniuk, J. and Khan, R.A. (1983). Toxicology of chronic crude oil exposure:
sublethal effects on aquatic organisms. In “Aquatic Toxicology” (J.O. Nraigu,
ed.), pp. 425-536. John Wiley, New York.
Kiceniuk, J.W. and Khan, R.A. (1987). Effect of petroleum hydrocarbons on
Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua, following chronic exposure. Canadian Journal of
Zoology 65, 490-494.
Kiceniuk, J.W., Khan, R.A., Dawe, M. and Williams, U. (1982). Examination of
interaction of trypanosome infection and crude oil exposure on hematology of
the longhorn sculpin (Myoxocephalus octodecemspinosus). Bulletin of
Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 28, 435-438.
KO, R.C. (1975). Echinocephalus sinensis n. sp. (Nematoda: Gnathostomatidae)
from the ray (Aetobatus jlagellum) in Hong Kong, Southern China. Canadian
Journal of Zoology 53, 490-500.
KO, R.C. and Adams, J.R. (1969). The development of Philonema oncorhynchi
(Nematoda: Philometridae) in Cyclops bicuspidatus in relation to temperature.
Canadian Journal of Zoology 47, 307-3 12.
KO, R.C., Morton, B. and Wong, P.S. (1975a). Preliminary studies on Echino-
cephalus sinensis (Nematoda: Spinuoidea), an unusual parasite from the oyster
Crassostrea gigas Thunberg, 1793 (Mollusca: Bivalvia) in Hong Kong. In
“Symposium Papers of the Pacific Science Association Special Symposium on
Marine Sciences” (B. Morton, ed.), pp. 66-70. PSA. Hong Kong.
KO, R.C., Morton, B. and Wong, P.S. (1975b). Prevalence and histopathology
of Echinocephalus sinensis (Nematoda: Gnathostomatidae) in natural and
experimental hosts. Canadian Journal of Zoology 53,550-559.
K@ie, M. (1975). On the morphology and life history of Opechona bacillaris
(Molin, 1859) Looss, 1907 (Trematoda, Lepocreadiidae). Ophelia 13,63-86.
Kflie, M. (1976). On the morphology and life history of Zoogonoides viviparus
(Olsson, 1868) Odhner, 1902 (Trematoda, Zoogonidae). Ophelia 15, 1-14.
Klie, M. (1978). On the morphology and life history of Stephanostomum
caducum (Looss, 1901) Manter, 1934 (Trematoda, Acanthocolpidae). Ophelia
17, 121-133.
Kgiie, M. (1979a). On the morphology and life history of Monascus (= Haplocladus)
jliformis (Rudolphi, 1819) Looss, 1907 and Steringophorus firciger (Olsson,
1868) Odhner, 1905 (Trematoda, Fellodistomidae). Ophelia 18, 113-1 32.
Kflie, M. (1979b). On the morphology and life history of Derogenes varicus
(Muller, 1784) Looss, 1901 (Trematoda, Hemiuridae). Zeitschrifi fur Parasiten-
kunde 59,67-78.
Kgiie, M. (1980). On the morphology and life history of Steringotrema pagelli
(van Beneden, 1871) Odhner, 1911 and Fellodistomum fellis (Olsson, 1868)
136 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
McVicar, A.H. (1986). The use of fish pathology in programmes to monitor marine
contaminants. In “Report of the ICES Workshop in the Use of Pathology in
Studies of the Effects of Contaminants” (J. Thulin, ed.), pp. 58-64. International
Council for the Exploration of the Sea CM 1986/E: 40, Ref. F.
Millemann, R.E. (1963). Studies on the taxonomy and life history of echino-
cephalid worms (Nematoda: Spiruroidea) with a complete description of
Echinocephalus pseudouncinatus Millemann, 1951. Journal of Parasitology
49,754-764.
Mohan, C.V. and Sommerville, C. (1988). Effect of cadmium on susceptibility and
immune response of common carp to the protozoan Ichthyophthirius multijiliis
(Abstract). Programme and Abstracts of the Vrh European Multicolloquium of
Parasitology, 107.
Moller, H. (1976). Reduction of the intestinal fauna of marine fishes in captivity.
Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 56,
781-785.
Moller, H. (1978a), The effects of salinity and temperature on the development and
survival of fish parasites. Journal of Fish Biology 12, 31 1-324.
Moller, H. (1978b). Ecological effects of cooling water of a power plant at
Kiel Fjord. Berichte der Deutschen Wissenschaflichen Kommission fur
Meeresforschung 26, 117-1 30.
Moller, H. (1981). Fish diseases in German and Danish coastal waters in
summer 1980. Berichte der Deutschen Wissenschaftlichen Kommission fur
Meeresforschung 29, 1-16.
Moller, H. (1984). Dynamics of fish diseases in the lower Elbe River. Helgolander
Meeresuntersuchungen 37, 3 8 9 4 13.
Moller, H. (1985). A critical review of the role of pollution as a cause of fish
diseases. In “Fish and Shellfish Pathology” (A.E. Ellis, ed.), pp. 169-182.
Academic Press, London.
Moller, H. (1987a). Pollution and parasitism in the aquatic environment. Inter-
national Journal for Parasitology 17, 353-362.
Moller, H. (1987b). The marine ecologist - scientist or advocate of nature?
Marine Pollution Bulletin 18,267-270.
Moravec, F. (1976). Occurrence of the encysted larvae of Cucullanus truttae
(Fabricius, 1794) in the brook lamprey, Lampetra planeri (Bl.). Scripta
Facultatis Scientiarum Naturalium Universitas Purkynianae Brunensis Biologia
I, 6, 17-20.
Moravec, F. (1979). Observations on the development of Cucullanus (Truttaedac-
nitis) truttae (Fabricius, 1794) (Nematoda: Cucullanidae). Folia Parasitologica
26, 295-307.
Moravec, F. (1980). Biology of Cucullanus truttae (Nematoda) in a trout stream.
Folia Parasitologica 27, 2 17-226.
Moser, M. (1981). Parasitological survey of San Francisco Bay - Delta area.
Striped bass and other select species. Report to California State Water Resources
Control Board, Standard Agreement 9-100-400-0, 114 pp.
Mudry, D.R. and Dailey, M.D. (1971). Postembryonic development of certain
tetraphyllidean and trypanorhynchan cestodes with a possible alternative
life cycle for the order Trypanorhyncha. Canadian Journal of Zoology 49,
1249-1 253.
Munkittrick, K.R. and Dixon, D.G. (1988). Growth, fecundity, and energy stores of
white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) from lakes containing elevated levels of
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER OUALITY 139
copper and zinc. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 45,
1355-1 365.
Nagasawa, K., Imai, Y. and Ishida, K. (1988). Long-term changes in the
population size and geographical distribution of Pennella sp. (Copepoda) on
the saury, Cololabis saira, in the western North Pacific Ocean and adjacent
seas. In “Biology of Copepods” (G.A. Boxshall and H.K. Schminke, eds), pp.
57 1-578. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Belgium.
Noisy, D. and Maillard, C. (1980). Microhabitat branchial preferentiel de Micro-
cotyle chrysophrii van Beneden et Hesse, 1863 (Monogenea, Microcotylidae),
parasite de la Daurade (Sparus aurata L., 1758). Annales de Parasitologie
Humaine et Comparte 55, 3340.
Odhner, T. (1910). Stichocotyle nephropis J.T. Cunningham, ein aberranter
Trematode der Digenefamilie Aspidogastridae. Kungliga Svenska Vetenskapsa-
kademiens Handlingar 45, 1-16.
Oliver, G. (1976). New observations on the biology and ecology of some
Diplectanidae (Monogenea, Monopisthocotylea). Trudy Biologo-Pochvennogo
Instituta (Issledovaniya monogenticheskikh sosal’shchikov), Novaya Seriya 34,
104-109 (In Russian).
Oliver, G. (1978). Description de deux cas d’ovoviviparite chez les Diplectanidae
Bychowsky, 1957 (Monogenea, Monopisthocotylea). Zeitschrift fur Para-
sitenkunde 57, 247-250.
Oliver, G. (1982). Quelques aspects de la sp6cificitC parasitaire chez les
Diplectanidae Bychowsky, 1957 (Monogenea, Monopisthocotylea). Mtmoires
du Muskum nationale dhistoire naturelle, Serie A, Zoologie 123,295-301.
Oliver, G. (1984). Microcotyle chrysophrii van Beneden et Hesse, 1863 (Mono-
genea, Polyopisthocotylea, Microcotylidae) parasite de Sparus aurata Linnaeus,
1758 (Teleostei, Sparidae) dans les etangs littoraux du Languedoc-Rousillon
(France). Bulletin de la Socittt zoologique de France 109,113-1 18.
Olson, R.E. and Pratt, I. (1971). The life cycle and larval development of Echino-
rhynchus lageniformis Ekbaum, 1938 (Acanthocephala: Echinorhynchidae).
Journal of Parasitology 57, 143-149.
O’Neill, J.G. (1981). The humoral immune response of Salmo trutta L. and
Cyprinus carpio L. exposed to heavy metals: Journal of Fish Biology 19,
297-306.
Osmanov, S.O. and Yusopov, 0. (1985). Influence of the increasing salinity of the
Aral Sea on the fish parasite fauna. Parazitologicheskii Sbornik 33, 1 4 4 3 (In
Russian).
Overstreet, RM. (1988). Aquatic pollution problems; southeastern US coasts:
histopathological indicators. Aquatic Toxicology 11, 2 13-239.
Overstreet, R.M. (1993). Parasitic diseases of fishes and their relationship with
toxicants and other environmental factors. In “Pathobiology of Marine and
Estuarine Organisms” (J.A. Couch and J.W. Fournie, eds.), pp. 111-156. CRC
Press Inc., Boca Raton, Florida.
Overstreet, R.M. and Howse, H.D. (1977). Some parasites and diseases of estuarine
fishes in polluted habitats of Mississippi. Annals of the New York Academy of
Sciences 298,427462.
Palombi, A. (1942). I1 ciclo biologic0 di Ptychogonimus megastoma (Rud.),
Osservazioni sulla morfoligica e fisiologia delle forme larvali e considerazioni
filogenetiche. Rivista Parassitologia 6, 1 17-172.
Paperna, I. (1975). Parasites and diseases of the grey mullet (Mugilidae) with
special reference to the seas of the near East. Aquaculture 5, 65-80.
140 K. MACKENZIE ET AL
Paperna, I. and Overstreet, R.M. (1981). Parasites and diseases of mullets (Mugi-
lidae). In “Aquaculture of Grey Mullets” (O.H. Oren, ed.), pp. 41 1-493. Inter-
national Biological Programme 26, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
UK.
Parker, T. (199 1). Pollution indicator species (Editorial). Marine Pollution Bulletin
22, 101.
Pascoe, D. and Cram, P. (1977). The effect of parasitism on the toxicity of
cadmium to the three-spined stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus L. Journal of
Fish Biology 10,467472.
Pascoe, D. and Woodworth, I. (1980). The effects of joint stress on sticklebacks.
Zeitschrift fur Parasitenkunde 62, 159-163.
Payne, J.F., Kiceniuk, J.W., Squires, W.R. and Fletcher, G.L. (1978). Pathological
changes in a marine fish after a 6-month exposure to petroleum. Journal of the
Fisheries Research Board of Canada 35, 665-667.
Pearse, J.S. and Timm, R.W. (1971). Juvenile nematodes (Echinocephaluspseudo-
uncinatus) in the gonads of sea urchins (Centrostephanus coronatus) and their
effect on host gametogenesis. Biological Bulletin. Marine Biological Laboratory,
Woods Hole, Mass, 140, 95-103.
Pearson, J.C. (1968). Observations on the morphology and life-cycle of Paucivi-
tellosus fragilis Coil, Reid and Kuntz, 1965 (Trematoda: Bivesiculidae).
Parasitology 58, 769-788.
Perevozchenko, 1.1. and Davydov, O.N. (1974). DDT and its metabolites in some
cestodes in fishes. Gidrobiologicheskii Zhurnal 10, 86-90 (In Russian).
Pilcher, M.W., Whitfield, P.J. and Riley, J.D. (1989). Seasonal and regional
infestation characteristics of three ectoparasites of whiting. Merlangius
merlangus L.. in the North Sea. Journal of Fish Biology 35.97-1 10.
Platzer, E.G. and Adams, J.R. (1967). The life history of a dranunculoid, Philo-
nema oncorhynchi, in Oncorhynchus nerka. Canadian Journal of Zoology 45,
3143.
Poinar, G.O. Jr and Thomas, G.M. (1976). Occurrence of Ascarophis (Nematoda:
Spiruridea) in Callianassa californiensis Dana and other decapod crustaceans.
Proceedings of the Helminthological Society of Washington 43, 28-33.
Pojmhska, T. (1984a). An analysis of seasonality of incidence and maturation of
some fish parasites with regard to thermal factor. I. General methods. Ergasilus
. sieboldi Nordmann, 1832. Acta Parasitologica Polonica 29, 217-228.
Pojmhska, T. (1984b). An analysis of seasonality of incidence and maturation of
some fish parasites with regard to thermal factor. 11. Caryophyllaeus laticeps
(Pallas, 1781). Acta Parasitologica Polonica 29, 229-239.
P.ojmhska, T. (1984~).An analysis of seasonality of incidence and maturation of
some fish parasites with regard to thermal factor. 111. Bunodera luciopercae
(MUller, 1776). Acta Parasitologica Polonica 29, 3 13-321.
Pojminska, T. (1985a). An analysis of seasonality of incidence and maturation of
some fish parasites with regard to thermal factor. IV. Bucephalus polymorphus
Baer, 1927. Acta Parasitologica Polonica 30, 25-34.
Pojminska, T. (1985b). An analysis of seasonality of incidence and maturation of
some fish parasites with regard to thermal factor. V. Digeneans of the genus
Sphaerostoma Rudolphi, 1809. General conclusion. Acta Parasitologica
Polonica 30, 35-46.
Pojminska, T. and Dzika, E. (1987). Parasites of bream (Abramis brama L.) from
the Lake Goslawskie (Poland) affected by long-term thermal pollution. Acta
Parasitologica Polonica 32, 139-1 6 1.
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 141
Sankurathri, C.S. and Holmes, J.C. (1976). Effects of thermal effluents on parasites
and commensals of Physa gyrina Say (Mollusca: Gastropoda) and their interac-
tions at Lake Wabamun, Alberta. Canadian Journal of Zoology 54, 1742-1753.
Schell, S.H. (1973). Rugogaster hydrolagi gen. et sp. n. (Trematoda: Aspido-
bothrea: Rugogastridae fam. n.) from the ratfish, Hydrolagus colliei (Lay and
Bennett, 1839). Journal of Parasitology 59, 803-805.
Schleip, W., Herter, K. and Autrum, H. (1937). Hirudineen. Teil 2. VI. Die
Okologie der Hirudineen. Bronns Klassen u. Ord. Tierreichs Leipzig 1937
Bd.4 Abt.3 Buch 4 Teil 2, 321-496.
Siddall, R., Pike, A.W. and McVicar, A.H. (1993). Parasites of Buccinum undatum
(Mollusca: Prosobranchia) as biological indicators of sewage-sludge dispersal.
Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 73,
931-948.
Simmons, G.E. (1974). Gyrocotyle: a century-old enigma. In “Symbiosis in the
Sea” (W.B. Vemberg, ed.), pp. 195-218. University of South Carolina Press,
USA.
Sindermann, C.J. (1979). Pollution-associated diseases and abnormalities of fish
and shellfish: a review. Fishery Bulletin 76, 717-749.
Skinner, R.H. (1982). The interrelation of water quality, gill parasites and gill
pathology of some fishes from South Biscayne Bay, Florida. Fishery Bulletin 80,
269-280.
Smith, J.W. (1969). The distribution of one monogenean and two copepod parasites
of whiting, Merlangius merlangus (L.) caught in British waters. Nytt Magasinfor
Zoologi 17, 58-63.
Snieszko, S.F. (1974). The effects of environmental stress on outbreaks of
infectious diseases of fishes. Journal of Fish Biology 6, 197-208.
Solangi, M.A. and Overstreet, R.M. (1982). Histopathological changes in two
estuarine fishes, Menidia beryllina (Cope) and Trinectes maculatus (Bloch and
Schneider), exposed to crude oil and its water-soluble fractions. Journal of Fish
Diseases 5 , 13-35.
Stark, G.T.C. (1965). Diplocotyle (Eucestoda), a parasite of Gammarus zaddachi in
the estuary of the Yorkshire Esk, Britain. Parasitology 55, 415-420.
Steven, G.A. (1947). The British Raiidae. Science Progress 138, 220-236.
Strazhnik, L.V. and Davydov, O.N. (1975). The effects of high temperature on the
. biological activities of some fish cestodes. Parazitologiya 9 , 3 7 4 6 (In Russian).
Stunkard, H.W. (1956). The morphology and life-history of the digenetic trema-
tode, Azygia selago Land, 19 10. Biological Bulletin. Marine Biological
Laboratory, Woods Hole, Mass, 111, 248-268.
Sulgostowska, T. (1988). Changes in the parasite fauna of the flounder Platichthys
Jesus dependent on the degree of pollution of the south-westem Baltic Sea.
Wiadomasci Parazytologiczne 34, 59 1-594.
Sunila, I. (1987). Histopathology of mussels (Mytilus edulis L.) from the
Tvarminne area, the Gulf of Finland (Baltic Sea). Annales Zoologica Fennici
24, 55-69.
Symonds, J.D. (1972). Infestation of Nephrops norvegicus (L.) by Stichocotyle
nephropis Cunningham in British waters. Journal of Natural History 6,423426.
Thoney, D.A. and Burreson, E.M. (1987). Morphology and development of the
adult and cotylocidium of Multicalyx cristata (Aspidocotylea), a gall bladder
parasite of elasmobranchs. Proceedings of the Helminthological Society of
Washington 54, 96-104.
Thulin, J. (1984). The impact of some environmental changes on the parasite
PARASITES AS INDICATORS OF WATER QUALITY 143
'
. R.C.A. Thompson. A.J. Lymbery2and C.C. Constantine'
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146
1.1. Status of hydatid disease ...................... 146
1.2. Variation in Echinococcusand control of hydatid disease . . . .
.. 146
1.3. Taxonomic considerations ..................... 147
.
2 Species Concepts and their Application ................. 150
2.1. Definition of a species ....................... 150
.........
2.2. An evolutionary species concept for Echinococcus 151
.
3 Identification of OTUs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152
3.1. Echinococcus granulosus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153
3.2. Echinococcus multilocularis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158
. ...............
3.3. Echinococcus vogeli and E oligarthrus 159
.
4 Phylogeny of OTUs ........................... 159
. ...................
5 Delimitation of Evolutionary Species 162
5.1. Species 1 (Echinococcussp.) .................... 162
.................
5.2. Species 2 (Echinococcusortleppin 164
.................
5.3. Species 3 (Echinococcusequinusn 165
...............
5.4 Species 4 (Echinococcusmultilocularis) 165
. ......
5.5 Species 5 and 6 (Echinococcus vogeli and E oligarthrus) 166
................
5.6. Species 7 (Echinococcusgranulosus) 166
6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 167
Acknowledgements ........................... 168
References ............................... 168
1. INTRODUCTION
E . granulosus Sheep strain GSH Sheep, cattle, pigs, camels, Dog, fox, dingo, Australian mainland, Europe, USA,
goats, macropods, humans jackal, hyena New Zealand, Africa, China, Middle
East, South America, Russia
E. granulosus Tasmanian sheep GTA Sheep, cattle? humans Dog (fox) Tasmania
Strain
E. granulosus Buffalo strain(?) GBU Buffalo (cattle?) (humans?) Dog (fox?) Asia
E. granulosus Horse strain GHO Horses and other equines Dog Europe, Middle East, South Africa
(New Zealand? USA?)
E. granulosus Cattle strain GCT Cattle, humans Dog Europe, South Africa, India, Sri
Lanka, Russia
E. granulosus Camel strain GCM Camels, goats, cattle? Dog Middle East, Africa
humans?
E. granulosus Pig strain GPI Pigs, humans? Dog Europe, Russia, South America
E. granulosus Cervid strain' ? Cervids, humans Wolf, dog North America, Eurasia
E. granulosus Lion strain' ? Zebra, wildebeest, warthog, Lion Africa
bushpig, buffalo, various
antelope, giraffe?
hippopotamus? (humans?)
E. rnultilocularis European strain' MEU Rodents, humans Fox, dog, cat Europe, China(?)
E. multilocularis Alaskan strain' ? Rodents, humans Fox, dog, cat Alaska
E. rnultilocularis North American h4NO Rodents, humans Fox, dog, cat North America
Strain'(?)
E. rnultilocularis Hokkaido strain'(?) ? Rodents, pig, horse, Fox, dog, cat Japan
humans
E . vogeli None reported VOG Rodents, humans Bush Dog South America
E. oligarthrus None reported OLI Rodents, humans Felids South America
(new genetic variants can replace old variants within the species
through gene flow) or demographic exchangeability (new genetic
variants can replace old variants within the species through genetic
drift and natural selection). This definition recognizes the importance
of interbreeding, but it becomes just one of a class of mechanisms
responsible for maintaining cohesion and the evolutionary integrity of
a lineage.
Determining species status is a two-step procedure; organisms must first
be grouped into taxa and then these taxa ranked into their appropriate
category (Donoghue, 1985). We will take the two parts of the evolutionary
species concept described above as our grouping and ranking criteria for
Echinococcus. The operational steps for delimiting species within the
genus are then as follows:
1 . Identify basal taxa (operational taxonomic units [OTUs]; Sneath and
Sokal, 1973). Ideally these will be geographically localized populations,
but sampling limitations will often necessitate the use of more inclusive
sublineages.
2. Reconstruct the phylogeny of OTUs. This will provide a hierarchy of
monophyletic groups suitable for ranking into their appropriate category.
3. Rank as evolutionary species those most inclusive groups having the
potential for genetic or demographic exchangeability:
(a) OTUs which are sympatric and yet maintain genetic distinctness
clearly do not possess exchangeability and should be considered
separate species;
(b) The exchangeability of allopatric OTUs must be inferred from
information on their genetic and ecological similarity. The appro-
priateness of these criteria for inferring exchangeability is discussed
by Lymbery (1994). They do not provide an infallible guide. Each
case must be considered separately and a decision on species status
made according to all the information available at that time. It is
inevitable that this procedure will produce errors, but the delimita-
tion of evolutionary species should be considered an hypothesis to
be tested by further data.
3. IDENTIFICATION OF OTUs
We will take as our basal taxa, not populations, but those groups of
organisms which have already been defined as different species, sub-
species or strains of Echinococcus (Table 1). The reasons justifying their
classification and categorization have previously been discussed in detail
VARIATION IN ECHINOCOCCUS: TOWARDS A TAXONOMIC REVISION OF THE GENUS 153
Bowles et al. (1992a) and Bowles and McManus (1993b, c) found these
species to be quite distinct genetically from each other and from all other
species and strains of Echinococcus examined. Only two isolates of E.
vogeli and one isolate of E. oligarthrus were sequenced, however, and we
are aware of no other studies which have examined genetic, morphological
or biological variation within these species.
4. PHYLOGENY OF OTUs
There has been little previous work on the phylogeny of species and strains
of Echinococcus. Lymbery ( 1992) analysed published morphological data
for a number of strains of E . granulosus and E . multilocularis, but the
accuracy (sensu Hillis and Bull, 1993) of the resultant phylogeny was
severely constrained by the availability and quality of morphological
characters.
The DNA sequence data published by Bowles et al. (1992a) and Bowles
and McManus (1993~)provide much more reliable characters with which
to reconstruct the phylogeny of OTUs of Echinococcus. Available for
analysis are the published sequences of a 366 bp fragment of the mito-
chondrial COI gene and a 47 1 bp fragment of the NDl gene, determined for
all four currently described species of Echinococcus, seven strains of E .
granulosus and two strains of E . multilocularis (Table 1). Published
sequence data are not available for the putative cervid and lion strains of
E . granulosus.
The data were analysed by maximum parsimony, using the branch and
bound algorithm of PAUP 3.1.1 (Swofford, 1993). All nucleotide positions
160 R.C.A. THOMPSON ET AL
were considered and base changes weighted equally for analysis. Fasciola
hepatica and Ascaris s u m (sequence data obtained from GenBank and
aligned with the Echinocmcus sequences with the aid of the program
MacVectorTM(International Biotechnologies Inc.)) were used as outgroups
to provide the rooted trees shown in Figure 1.
Separate analysis of the COI and ND1 data sets produced quite different
minimum-length trees (cf Figure l a and lb), with little consensus in
higher-level structure (Figure lc). Analysis of the combined datasets
produced two minimum-length trees and a consensus of these two (Figure
Id) showed an almost identical topology to the ND1 tree. There has
recently been much dispute about the relative merits of consensus and
Combined approaches to obtaining an overall estimate of phylogeny from
two or more data sets (Miyamoto, 1985; Barrett et al., 1991; Bull et al.,
1993; de Queiroz, 1993). We have assumed that the COI and NDl
sequences, both being from the non-recombining mitochondrial genome,
cannot be regarded as providing independent characters and that a com-
bined approach should provide a more accurate estimate of phylogeny than
separate analysis of either sequence (de Queiroz, 1993).
We believe, therefore, that the tree shown in Figure Id is the best
estimate of phylogenetic relationships between OTUs of Echinococcus
available from currently published data. However, it should be regarded
as no more than a testable hypothesis of the true phylogeny. For many of
the OTUs, only a small number of isolates from a limited geographic range
have been sampled. More importantly, the data sets which have been
analysed are incomplete in that they do not include OTUs of uncertain
status, such as the cervid and lion strains of E. granulosus; inclusion of
these OTUs may alter the phylogeny. Fasciola hepatica and Ascaris suum
were used as outgroups in the analysis because they were the most closely
related helminths for which published DNA sequence data were available.
Effective character polarization requires more closely related outgroups,
preferably in the same family as Echinococcus (Maddison et al., 1984).
Finally, the phylogenetic analysis was based on sequences from only two
genes, both in the mitochondria1 genome. To increase the probability that
such gene trees accurately reflect the true evolutionary pathway of the
OTUs involved, requires sequences from a number of genes that have
evolved independently (Pamilo and Nei, 1988). Additional sequence data
are therefore needed from the nuclear genome of Echinococcus OTUs,
preferably from one of the more rapidly evolving regions of ribosomal
DNA (Hillis and Dixon, 1991). Bowles and McManus (1993a) state that
they are sequencing the internal transcribed spacer 1 region of the ribo-
somal DNA repeat unit, and this may provide data for a more definitive
phylogenetic analysis.
The uncertainty of our current understanding of phylogenetic relation-
VARIATION IN ECHINOCOCCUS: TOWARDS A TAXONOMIC REVISION OF THE GENUS 161
GSH GSH
GTA GBU
GBU GTA
GHO GHO
VOG Gcr
MNO GCM
MEU GPI
OLI MNO
Gcr MEU
GCM VOG
GPI OLI
GSH GSH
GBU GBU
(ETA GTA
GHO GHO
Gcr Gcr
GCM GCM
GPI GPI
MNO MNO
MEU MEU
VOG VOG
OLI OLI
Figure 1 Phylogenetic trees identified using the branch and bound algorithm of
PAUP 3.1.1 (Swofford, 1993) on sequence data from regions of the mitochondria1
COI and ND1 genes (Bowles et al., 1992a; Bowles and McManus, 1993~).
Fasciola hepatica and Ascaris suum were used as outgroups for all trees. Numbers
at nodes represent percentage occurrence of clades in lo00 bootstrap replications
of the data. (a) Single minimum-length tree from analysis of 366 bp fragment of the
COI gene. Length of tree = 316 steps, consistency index = 0.84. (b) Single
minimum-length tree from analysis of 471 bp fragment of the ND1 gene. Length
of tree = 527 steps, consistency index = 0.784. (c) Strict consensus (Sokal and
Rohlf, 1981) between the trees in (a) and (b). (d) Strict consensus of two minimum-
length trees from analysis of combined COI and NDl data. Length of trees = 853
steps, consistency index = 0.80. OTU codes as in Table 1.
162 R.C.A. THOMPSON ET AL
ships within the genus Echinococcus is reflected in the poor support from
bootstrap analyses (Felsenstein, 1985) for much of the higher-level struc-
ture shown in Figure Id. Clearly, clades that appear in only 18%, 19% or
even 48%-54% of bootstrap samples should be viewed with suspicion.
Nevertheless, we believe that there is enough well-supported structure at
lower levels in the tree to warrant the ranking of some clades as evolu-
tionary species. The groupings shown in Figure Id which were consistently
supported by parsimony analysis of bootstrap samples were also robust to
phylogenetic distance analyses (results not shown).
The pig and camel strains of E. grunulosus (GPI and GCM in Figure 1)
were invariably monophyletic in parsimony analyses of mtDNA sequence
Table 2 Putative evolutionary species in the genus Echinococcus.
~~ ~
Species 1 E. sp.? Dog Pigs, humans? Europe, Russia, South E. granulosus pig strain Pig strain?
America
Species 2 E. ortleppi Dog Cattle, buffalo, Europe, Africa, India, E. granulosus ortleppi,
humans Sri Lanka. Russia E. granulosus cattle
Strain
Species 3 E. equinus Dog Horses and other Europe, Middle East, E. granulosus equinus,
equines South Africa (New E. granulosus horse
Zealand? USA?) strain
Species 4 E. multilocularis Fox, dog, Rodents, pigs, Europe, North America, E. sibiricensis European strain,
cat horses, humans Canada, Japan, China North American
strain, Alaskan
strain? Hokkaido
Strain?
Species 5 E. vogeli Bush dog Rodents, humans South America
Species 6 E. oligarthrus Felines Rodents, humans South America E. pampeanus, E. cruzi
Species 7 E. granulosus Dog, fox, Sheep, cattle, Australia, Europe, E. patagonicus, E . Common sheep
dingo, pigs, goats, USA, New Zealand, cepanazoi, E. g. strain, Tasmanian
jackal, buffalo, camels, Africa, China, Middle granulosus, E. g. sheep strain,
hyena macropods, East, Asia, South newzealandensis Buffalo strain?
humans America, Russia
data. There is no evidence that these OTUs occur in sympatry and their
potential for exchangeability must be inferred from genetic, morphological
and ecological data. Morphological studies have suggested affinities
between the taxa (Eckert et al., 1993), but genetic data are equivocal.
Sequence analysis of mitochondrial COI and ND1 genes suggests very
close genetic similarity (0.003, 0.006 base substitutions per nucleotide,
respectively, as estimated by the method of Jukes and Cantor (1969)
from the data of Bowles et al. (1992a) and Bowles and McManus
(1993c)), as do some RFLP analyses of rDNA (McManus and Rishi,
1989; Bowles and McManus, 1993b). Eckert et al. (1993), however, found
much greater genetic differences from RFLP analyses of rDNA and an
uncharacterized fragment of genomic DNA (0.06, 0.01 base substitutions
per nucleotide respectively, as estimated by the method of Nei and Li
(1979)). The camel isolates used in these studies were from different
geographic areas, however, and, as discussed previously (Section 3.1.6),
epidemiological evidence suggests the possible occurrence of different
OTUs in cycles involving camels. We believe further data are required
before a decision can be reached on the taxonomic status of the form of
Echinococcus found in camels.
At this point, we consider the OTU currently known as the pig strain of
E. granulosus to be a valid evolutionary species (Table 2). As far as we are
aware, this taxon has not been previously named, although the descriptions
given by Vogel (1957) and Verster (1965) for E. granulosus of pig origin
could be used as the type.
These OTUs (VOG and OLI in Figure 1) form a reasonably well supported
monophyletic group. They maintain major genetic, morphological and
.ecological differences in sympatry and therefore must be regarded as
separate evolutionary species (Table 2). Neither species consistently
groups with other OTUs in phylogenetic analyses and they are both quite
distinct genetically from all other species (for E. ,vogeli 0.060.184, for
E. oligarthrus 0.093-0.184 base substitutions per nucleotide in mitochon-
drial genes, calculated from the data of Bowles et al. (1992a) and Bowles
and McManus (1993~)).
6. CONCLUSIONS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
REFERENCES
Abraham, J., Pillai, K.M. and Iyer, R.P. (1980). Fertility rate in hydatid cysts in
domestic animals. Kerala Journal of Veterinary Science 11, 155-158.
Ballek, D. (199 1). Zum Vorkommen von Echinococcus multilocularis und anderen
Zestoden und Nematoden beim Rotfuchs (Vulpes vulpes L.) in den Regierungs-
bezirken Amsberg, Detmold and Kassel. Inaugural Dissertation, Tierarztliche
Hochschule Hannover, Hannover, Germany.
Barrett, M., Donoghue, M.J. and Sober, E. (1991). Against consensus. Systematic
Zoology 40, 486-493.
Bartel, M.H., Seesee, F.M. and Worley, D.E. (1992). Comparison of Montana and
Alaska isolates of Echinococcus multilocularis in Gerbils with observations on
the cyst growth, hook characteristics and host response. Journal of Parasitology
78, 528-529.
Batsch, A.J.G.C. (1786). Naturgeschichte der Bandwurmgattung Uberhaupt und
i b e r Arten insbesondere, nach den neuen Beobachtungen in einem systema-
tischen Auszuge. Halle.
Bowles, J. and McManus, D.P. (1991). Molecular characterisation of Echinococcus.
Archivos De La Hidatidosis 30, 55-63.
Bowles, J. and McManus, D.P. (1993a). Molecular variation in Echinococcus. Acta
Tropica 53, 291-305.
Bowles, J. and McManus, D.P. (1993b). Rapid discrimination of Echinococcus
species and strains using a polymerase chain reaction-based RFLP method.
Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 57, 23 1-240.
Bowles, J. and McManus, D.P. (1993~).NADH dehydrogenase 1 gene sequences
compared for species and strains of the genus Echinococcus. International
Journal for Parasitology 23,969-972.
Bowles, J., Blair, D. and McManus, D.P. (1992a). Genetic variants within the
VARIATION IN ECHINOCOCCUS: TOWARDS A TAXONOMIC REVISION OF THE GENUS 169
Said, I.M., Abdel-Hafez, S.K. and Al-Yaman, F.M. (1988). Morphological varia-
tion of Echinococcus granulosus protoscoleces from hydatid cysts of human and
various domestic animals in Jordan. International Journal for Parasitology 18,
11 11-1 114.
Saimot, A.G., Meulemans, A., Hay, J.M., Mohler, J., Manuel, C. and Coulaud, J.P.
(1981). Etude pharmacocinetique du flubendazole au cours de l’hydatidose
humaine a E . granulosus., Resultats preliminaies. Nouvelle Presse Medicale
10, 3121-3124.
Sanyal, P.K. and Sinha, P.K. (1983). A note on the prevalence of hydatidosis in
cattle and buffalo in West Bengal. Haryana Veterinarian 22, 47-50.
Schantz, P.M. (1982). Echinococcosis. In “CRC Handbook Series in Zoonoses”
(J. Steele, ed.), Section C, 1, pp. 231-277. CRC Press, Boca Raton.
Schantz, P.M. (199 1). Parasitic zoonoses in perspective. International Journal for
Parasitology 21, 161-170.
Schantz, P.M., Van den Bossche, H. and Eckert, J. (1982). Chemotherapy for larval
echinococcosis in animals and humans: report of a workshop. Zeitschrgt fur
Parasitenkunde 67, 5-26.
Shabovskaya, E.A., Bulgakov, V.A., Ponomareva, V.E., Dariko, O.P., Voloshchuk,
S.D. and Kikot, V.11. (1989). Hydatidosis in the Ukranian SSR. Meditsinskaya
Parazitologiya i Parazitarnye Bolezni 6, 49-5 1 (In Russian).
Siles-Lucas, M., Cuesta-Bandera, C. and Cesar-Benito, M. (1993). Random ampli-
fied polymorphic DNA technique for speciation studies of Echinococcus
granulosus. Parasitology Research 79, 343-345.
Singh, B.P., Srivastava, V.K. and Sharma Deorani, V.P. (1988). Pig hydatidosis in
Uttar Pradesh. Veterinary Record 123, 299-300.
Skvortsova, F.K. and Artemenko, Yu.G. (1987). Morphological characteristics of
Echinococcus granulosus strains in southern Ukraine. Byulleten’ Vsesoyuznogo
Instituta Gel’mintologii im K.I. Skryabina 47, 69-72 (In Russian).
Smyth, J.D. (1990). Parasitological serendipity: from Schistocephalus to Echino-
coccus. International Journal for Parasitology 20, 4 11-423.
Smyth, J.D. and Smyth, M.M. (1969). Self insemination in Echinococcus
granulosus in vivo. Journal of Helminthology 43, 383-388.
Sneath, P.H.A. and Sokal, R.R. (1973). “Numerical Taxonomy”. W.H. Freeman,
San Francisco.
- Sokal, R.R. and Rohlf, F.J. (198 1). Taxonomic congruence in the Leptopodomorpha
re-examined. Systematic Zoology 30, 309-325.
Storandt, S.T. and Kazacos, K.R. (1993). Echinococcus multilocularis identified in
Indiana, Ohio, and east-central Illinois. Journal of Parasitology 79, 301-305.
I Swofford, D.L. (1993). “PAUP: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsmony Version
3.1 ”. Illinois Natural History Survey, Champaign, Illinois.
Templeton, A.R. (1989). The meaning of species and speciation: a genetic
perspective. In “Speciation and its Consequences” (D. Otte and J.A. Endler,
eds), pp. 3-27. Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachusetts.
Thompson, R.C.A. (1988). Intraspecific variation and epidemiology. In:
“Parasitology in Focus”. (H. Mehlhorn, ed.), pp. 3 9 1 4 1 1, Springer, Berlin.
Thompson, R.C.A. (1991). Echinococcus and Giardia: variation on a theme.
International Journal for Parasitology 21, 29 1-297.
Thompson, R.C.A. (1992). Echinococcosis/Hydatidosisin Australia. In “Zoonoses.
Proceedings 194. Post Graduate Committee in Veterinary Science”, pp. 77-87.
University of Sydney.
Thompson, R.C.A. (1994). Biology and systematics of Echinococcus. In
VARIATION IN ECHINOCOCCUS: TOWARDS A TAXONOMIC REVISION OF THE GENUS 175
Marijke De Jong-Brink
.
1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 178
1.1. Problems to be solved by schistosomes in their hosts ........ 178
1.2. Interference with the host's regulatory systems . . . . . . . . . . . 180
1.3. Parasitic components/products as candidates for interference with
regulatory mechanisms in the host ................. 182
1.4. Advantages of the model Trichobilhania ocellata-Lymnaea stagnalis
for studying the effects of schistosomes on the regulatory systems
of their hosts ............................ 190
.
2 The Effects of Trichobilhania ocellata on its Snail Host Lymnaea stagnalis
with Reference to Other Schistosome-Snail Partnerships ........ 190
2.1. Effects on internal defence ..................... 190
2.2. Effects on reproduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 201
2.3. Effects on metabolism and growth ................. 202
. .
3 How T ocellata Affects Reproduction and Growth of its Snail Host ... 204
3.1. Peripheral effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 204
3.2. Central effects ........................... 212
3.3. Schistosomin: origin and induction of its release by a parasite-derived
factor ................................ 214
. .....................
4 Parasites: long-term stressors? 219
...................
4.1. The stressconcept in mammals 219
. . ................
4.2. T ocellata: a stressor for L stagnalis? 222
4.3. Schistosomes: stressors for their vertebrate hosts? . . . . . . . . . 227
4.4. Non-schistosome parasite-host combinations . . . . . . . . . . . . 228
.
5 Summary and Conclusions ....................... 234
Acknowledgements ........................... 237
References ............................... 238
1. INTRODUCTION
The complex life cycle of trematodes comprises at least two hosts, i.e., one
or more intermediate hosts and a definitive host. The parasitic worms that
cause schistosomiasis (bilharzia) in man belong to these trematodes (genus
Schistosoma). Asexual multiplication occurs in the intermediate hosts
(freshwater snails), whereas the parasites reach sexual maturity in the
definitive hosts (man or other mammal$). Eggs laid by the adult female
pass through the wall of the intestine or the bladder and are voided with the
faeces or urine of the host. If the eggs find themselves in water they hatch
and produce a ciliated larva (miracidium), which, for its further develop-
ment, must meet a compatible snail. After penetrating through the skin of
the mantle or the head-foot of the snail, the miracidium transforms near the
site of penetration into a primary (mother) sporocyst in which secondary or
daughter sporocysts develop. The daughter sporocysts leave the mother
sporocyst and migrate to the hind part of the snail, the digestive gland/
ovotestis area, where they grow and give rise to the final larval stage, the
cercariae, the production of which may continue for the rest of the life of
the snail. Upon an appropriate stimulus, e.g., a light stimulus, the cercariae
leave the snail. They have a brief swimming life and must soon enter a
suitable definitive host. After penetration through the skin of the defini-
tive host, the development of the cercariae into adult worms takes 2-3
months. The adults live in blood vessels, the sexes are separate and the
female is carried by the male. The fertilized eggs of the parasite leave the
host. As soon as the miracidium has reached a suitable snail the cycle can
. continue.
The major problems which schistosomes have to overcome during their
life cycle are the following: (1) they have to find their hosts (with which
they are compatible) and to penetrate their skin and tissue (for reviews see
’ Haas and Voigt, 1988; Haas, 1992), (2) they have to adapt to environmental
stress induced by changes of physicochemical factors as light, osmolarity,
pH, Pco2,Poz, and glucose concentration, (3) they have to evade immune
attacks in their hosts and (4) they have to obtain energy and space within
their hosts enabling them to grow and reproduce prior to transmission.
Especially the latter two points are relevant for the stages in the vertebrate
as well as in the invertebrate host and in this review we will focus on these
two points with the aim of unravelling the strategies they employ inside
their hosts in order to survive, to continue their development and to
reproduce.
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 179
are studied in connection with each other. This might explain why studies
available on this topic with respect to parasitic infections are rather limited
and fragmentary.
has been demonstrated for somatostatin (cf., Payan et al., 1984; Eglezos et
al., 1993).
(ii) Enzymes. Schistosomes secrete a variety of proteolytic enzymes,
proteases, in the different stages of their life cycle. The presence of large
glands or glandular cells where these enzymes are produced, for example,
the escape and acetabular glands in cercariae, and the occurrence of
surface-associated proteases indicate an obvious role in parasite-host
interactions. They function not only in invasion of host tissue, in transfor-
mation and in nutrition but also in immunoevasion (e.g., by degrading host
immunoglobulins) (for review see McKerrow and Doenhoff, 1988). As
mother sporocysts in vitro continue to: secrete a low level of active
. cysteine proteinase Yoshino et al. (1993) suppose that these proteinases
may also play a role in the establishment/maintenanceof infections within
the snail host. It seems also a powerful mechanism to interfere with
regulatory systems if parasitic enzymes would be able to detach receptors
from cells of the host (cf., De Carvalho et al., 1993). Their antigenic nature
has made them candidates for serodiagnosis and immunoprophylaxis.
The same applies to detoxifying or anti-oxidant enzymes, which are
produced and secreted by schistosomes as a response to immunological
stress caused by oxygen radicals, nitric oxide and other toxic molecules
released by cells of the host’s immune systedinternal defence system (for
review see Adema et al., 1991a; Brophy and Pritchard, 1992). These
molecules can attack parasite proteins, nucleic acids and membrane
lipids. In the absence of detoxifying enzymes this may result in parasite
killing (cf., Liew and Cox, 1991). An anti-oxidant substance has been
detected in E/S products of S. mansoni sporocysts (Connors et al., 1991).
For schistosomula and adult worms glutathione transferases (GSTs), gluta-
thione peroxidase (GPx) and superoxide dismutases (SODs) have been
reported to play an important role in defence. Because these cytosolic
enzymes are secreted and - transitionally - bound to the surface they
are important candidate vaccine antigens. Much attention has been paid to
their molecular cloning and sequencing (GSTs, Balloul et al., 1987;
Mitchell, 1989; Nare et al., 1991, 1992; Trottein et al., 1992; G h ,
Williams et al., 1991; SODs, Hong et al., 1992, 1993). For S. mansoni, it
has been demonstrated that the activity of these membrane-associated
enzymes increases significantly with the maturation of the worms. This
increase in activity was found to be positively correlated with the resistance
to oxidants (Callahan et al., 1988; Nare et al., 1990). The fact that inter-
species variation exists, as has been shown for the 28 kDa GSTs (Trottein
et al., 1992), might indicate that they play a role in the compatibility
between parasite and host.
Surprisingly, many of the circulating schistosome antigens that have
been identified are cytosolic metabolic enzymes including at least two
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 185
does not have transmembrane domains. It also seems unlikely that they are
linked to the surface by a phosphatidylinositol-glycan linkage because they
do not possess hydrophobic C-terminal sequences (Srivastava and Maki,
1991).
It is unclear how cells recognize environmental changes and the HSP
gene expression is activated (Welch ef al., 1991). For cercariae of S.
mansoni it has been demonstrated that environmental stimuli can only
activate HSP 70 gene expression after the tails have been removed
(Neumann ef af., 1993). It has been speculated that the tails produce
inhibiting signals that diffuse to the bodies and suppress their HSP 70
genes. These data seem to complete those obtained by Tielens ef al.
. (1993) who found that neither heat shock nor in vifro transformation
(loss of tails) had any effect on the pattern of protein synthesis - and
hence of HSPs - in sporocysts and/or cercariae of S. mansoni. Apparently,
both heat shock and transformation are necessary for induction of HSP 70
in the cercariae. This conclusion, however, contradicts data obtained by
other authors showing that only a heat shock is sufficient to induce HSP 70
gene expression (Yuckenberg et af., 1987; Blanton and Licate, 1992). The
expression of a HSP 60 homologue in all stages of S. mansoni has been
demonstrated (Tielens et al., 1993). Expression of HSP genes is probably
linked to the expression of other genes involved in parasite differentiation
and development (Polla, 1991).
HSPs, mainly HSP 70, are among the dominant antigens recognized by
the immune system - humoral, cellular, or both - in a large spectrum of
parasites (Kaufmann, 1990a, b; Young ef af., 1990; Estes and Teale, 1991;
Winfield and Jarjour, 1991). The fact that HSPs interact with mammalian
T cells can be ascribed to their structural and functional features which
assures that they are efficiently processed and presented at the macrophage
surface resulting in an interaction with T cells (Shinnick, 1991).
Proteins of the HSP 90 family of some parasites, among them S.
mansoni, have also been reported to be antigenic (Shinnick, 1991). The
members of this family play an important role in the prevention of steroid
receptor binding to DNA and of the phosphorylation of tyrosine kinase in
the absence of the proper stimulus. They keep the receptors inactive until
the signal for activation is received (Lindquist and Craig, 1988). This
seems very important in the refractory period after a stress stimulus.
Comparison between HSPs from different organisms has revealed that
they have been highly conserved during evolution. For several pathogens
the immune response to the HSPs is directed predominantly towards spe-
cific, non-conserved epitopes (Shinnick, 1991) and these non-conserved
epitopes might serve as an “immunological smoke screen” to divert the
host’s immune response from the conserved epitopes, which may be the
regions required for functional activity. The slightly different explanation
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 187
for example, the antigenic HSPs, which are synthesized upon eicosanoid
stimulation (Amici and Santoro, 1991).
0.60 -
0.55 .
+ + + + + +
m m m m m m
0.1:
11
?
MSM 0-33 h r ~
\
sc'9
33-72 h r ~
n l
72-96 hrs
same amounts (Ndiiez et al., 1994b). The suggestion that the parasites
produce two main fractions which together gave a resultant effect on
haemocyte activity was confirmed by testing the combined E/S fractions
of the three time groups of parasite cultures in the BCA. The combined
E/S fractions from 0-33 h cultures gave a resultant effect of increasing
the killing activity of haemocytes, whereas the combined fractions from
33-72 h cultures lowered the killing activity. The E/S fractions from
72-96 h cultures had no significant effect on haemocyte activity. So, the
results obtained in vitro seem to reflect the in vivo situation.
::; 40kD
r c N r n r t N r n
9+ $ +
m E l a l a E H l a
T
$ 4 4
MARIJKE DE JONG-BRINK
MSM MSM+P
Figure 5 Effect of E/S factors produced during in vitro transformation of
Trichobilharzia ocellata miracidia (0-33 h), on the bacterial killing activity of
haemocytes from non-infected juvenile Lymnaea stagnalis. MTT reduction by
surviving bacteria following incubation with haemocytes (H)which had been
pre-incubated with the fractions 1-3 obtained from MSM in which T. ocellata
had been cultured (MSM + P) or the corresponding fractions obtained from MSM
alone. MTT reduction is expressed as mean absorbance/well 2SE (n = 12; each
well contains haemocytes from one individual snail). Incubation of bacteria (B)
only serves as control. (Ndiiez et al., 1994b.)
used in this study, is too low for the BCA). Incubation of haemocytes and
bacteria with the activating factor, isolated from the medium in which T.
ocellata had been cultured, resulted in the haemocytes from both snail
species having an increased activity compared to that of the corresponding
haemocytes incubated in the absence of any factor. The suppressing factor
also had a modulating effect on haemocytes from L. stagnalis. However,
this effect was not observed with haemocytes from P. corneus (Figure 6).
The supposition that this direct suppressive factor of ca 40 kDa is impor-
tant with respect to compatibility between parasite and host is, furthermore,
supported by data obtained in viva In these experiments haemocytes taken
from juvenile L. stagnalis, which had been exposed to or injected with
miracidia of either T, ocellata or S . mansoni were tested for their capacity
to attack bacteria. The activity of haemocytes taken from snails 1.5 h after
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELfClTED IN THEIR HOSTS 197
0.65
T
0.60
I
0.55
0.50
0.45 7-
3 m
+ 3 m+
m m s p sp m s p
+ + r + + +
L stagllalic P. eomcus
Figure 6 Effect of EIS factors, produced during in vitro transformation of
Trichobilharzia ocellata miracidia, on the bacterial killing activity of haemocytes
from non-infected adult Lymnaea stagnalis or Planorbaris corneus. MTT reduction
by surviving bacteria, at the two concentrations for each of the snail species,
following incubation with haemocytes from L. stagnalis or P. corneus which had
been pre-incubated in the absence or presence of either activating factor (A) or
suppressing factor (S). MTT reduction is expressed as mean absorbancelwell ?SE
(n = 12; each well contains haemocytes from one individual snail). Note: data of
haemocytes with bacteria (H+ B) for each of the snail species are used as controls.
(Ndiiez and De Jong-Brink, 1994.)
being exposed to or injected with either of the two species was significantly
higher than that of cells from the corresponding sham-treated snails.
Haemocytes from snails that had been exposed to or injected with S.
mansoni 24, 48 or 72 h earlier also had higher clearing capacities than
those from the sham-treated snails. This, however, was not the case with
haemocytes from snails exposed to T. ocelluru as these were all suppressed
and hence had lower killing activities at these time points (Figure 7).
In summary, the activating parasitic factor is recognized by haemocytes
of both the compatible and non-compatible host, the parasite-derived
suppressive factor, on the other hand, is not recognized by haemocytes of
non-compatible hosts. This might explain why parasites in an incompatible
combination are encapsulated and eliminated.
These findings corroborate the results obtained with E/S products of 1
day primary cultures of S. munsoni (Yoshino and Lodes, 1988). These E/S
products affect polypeptide synthesis by haemocytes of B. glubrutu.
198 MARIJKE DE JONG-BRINK
0 Control
T. o c e W
0.65 Exposure 0.65 Injection S. mansoni
T
0.55 0.55
...
0.45 I 1 I I 0.45
P
e
v!
+ B + H(Nn + B + H(NI)
Figure.7 Effect of Trichobilharzia ocellata or Schistosoma mansoni infections
on the bacterial killing activity of haemocytes from juvenile Lymnaea sfagnalis.
MTT reduction by surviving bacteria following incubation with haemocytes taken
from snails at 1.5, 24, 48 or 96 h post-infection (PI) after either exposure to or
injection with T. ocellata, S. mansoni or S S S (controls). MTT reduction is
expressed as mean absorbance/well 2 S E (n = 12; each well contains haemocytes
from one individual snail). Note: data of bacteria with haemocytes from snails
sham exposed or sham injected are used as controls. (Nliiiez and De Jong-Brink,
1994.)
01
2 4 6 8 10
Time post -exposure (h)
-
observations have been described for the combination S. mansoni-B.
glubrutu (e.g., Meier and Meier-Brook, 1981). The observation by Cooper
et al. (1992) that a moderate to high percentage of B. glubrutu, infected as
neonates, was eventually capable of simultaneously producing both eggs
and cercariae is difficult to explain.
In specimens infected at a sub-adult stage, on the other hand, a signifi-
cant increase in fecundity was observed in the first weeks after infection.
401
35
30
25
20
I5
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
a higher basal metabolic rate than non-infected snails but they reduce their
locomotory activity to compensate and maintain a constant rate of energy
conversion (Becker, 1980). For L. stagnalis it has been shown that food
consumption does not differ in parasitized animals compared to controls,
whereas the assimilation remains initially constant and declines slightly
from the time the daughter sporocysts contain differentiated cercariae and
the snails are shedding (Bayomy et al., 1989). In shedding snails there is a
severe glycogen depletion in the head-foot and mantle region (Joosse,
1988), i.e., from the parts where glycogen-storing vesicular connective
tissue cells are numerous (Sminia, 1972). Although at an earlier stage of
parasitosis, when the daughter sporocysts commence to grow and the
cercariae start to develop, the glucose content in the haemolymph of
infected snails was found to be decreased compared to that of controls,
glycogen depletion was not accompanied or caused by a (second) change in
haemolymph glucose concentration (cf. Becker, 1980). Apparently an, as
yet unknown, control mechanism in the process of glycogen depletion is
involved. In L. stagnalis infected with T . ocellata the haemolymph
protein concentration, mainly haemocyanin, and that of total free amino
204 MARLIKE DE JONG-BRINK
acids (mainly polar amino acids) are lower than in non-infected controls
(Bayomy et al., 1989).
Investigations by Thompson et ul. (1992) have shown that the effects of
nutrient utilization by developing S. mansoni on the snail host may depend
on the snail's diet. The reduction of free phosphatides in the digestive
gland of B. glabrata that coincided with pateicy of' the infection with S.
mnsoni, could not be observed when the snails were maintained on high
fat diets containing egg yolk.
MDB
LDB
LL
WLNN
Figure 12 Schematic drawing of the right cerebral ganglion of the central
nervous system of L. stagnalis showing the neurosecretory caudodorsal cells
(CDC), the lobus anterior (LA) with the alanine-proline-glycine-tryptophan
(APGW) neurons, the medio- and latero-neurosecretory light green cells (mLGC,
lLGC), the lateral lobe (LL) with the canopy cell (C), which also belongs to the
LGC, and the endocrine medio- and latero-dorsal bodies (MDB, LDB). CC,
cerebral commissure, the neurohaemal area of the CDC; LN, lip nerve, the
neurohaemal area of the LGC.
jl1
% Ca-pos mitochondria
+ 0 -can
+can
20
d
e e
0 0
0
3 6 9 12
weeks pe.
I
PRIMARY STRUCTUREOFSCHISTWOMIN
*-
% response
loo 1
80 -
60-
40-
20 -
0 - 1 I I 1
serum 0.0 2.5 5 .O 7.5
protein
pmol schistosomin
Figure 15 Inhibition by schistosomin of the ovulation-inducing activity of
synthetic CDCH in Lymnaea stugnalis. Increasing doses of purified schistosomin
(0-3.5 pmol) were injected simultaneously with 2 pmol of synthetic CDCH.After
30 min the animals were dissected and checked for ovulation and formation of an
egg mass. Haemolymph (serum) protein as well as the buffer from the final
purification step of schistosomin (0 pmol schistosomin) were used as controls.
(Hordijk er al., 1991a.)
210 MARUKE DE JONG-BRINK
Comptetive
anragonism
NOn-
competetive
anragonism
PhySlOlOgICd
Pntapmsm
AC, did not activate the AC-CAMPsystem in DBs. So, if schistosomin has
an effect on DBs, it is not mediated by the AC-CAMPsystem.
The observation that schistosomin exerts both central and peripheral
effects on female reproduction-regulating neuroendocrine mechanisms
justifies the conclusion that it is responsible for the inhibition of egg laying
in L. stagnalis infected with T. ocellata. As schistosomin also has been
demonstrated to enhance AC activity in neurons producing the peptide
alanine-proline-glycine-tryptophan(APGW n e w m in the anterior lobes
of the cerebral ganglia; Figure 12), which are involved in the innervation of
the male copulatory system (Croll et al., 1991), it may alsoplay a role in
the inhibitory effects of parasitosis on male reproductive activity in this
. hermaphrodite snail.
However, the inhibition of the development of the reproductive tract in
juvenile snails, which is already obvious at an early stage of infection,
cannot be ascribed to schistosomin as it was absent from haemolymph of
snails in this stage of infection. Therefore, another mechanism must be
responsible for this effect of parasitosis. The same is true for the increase in
fecundity that was observed in the first week after infection in snails
exposed when sub-adult.
The evidence that schistosomin clearly affects the LGCs suggests that it
is also involved in the effects on growth and metabolism in parasitized
snails. This corresponds to the observation that the start of enhanced body
growth and glycogen depletion in infected snails coincides with the
appearance of schistosomin in the haemolymph. Up until now no assays
are available to investigate whether schistosomin also interferes with the
effects of LGC products on their target tissues.
Figure 19 Electron micrographs of a telo-glial cell showing a cell body (cb) and
an elongation (insert) accompanying an axon (a) in the penial complex of L.
srugnulis. The secretory granules (s) show immuno-gold labelling with anti-
schistosomin. n, nucleus.
216 MARIJKE DE JONG-BRINK
daughter sporocysts (see also Figure lo), the stimulation of its production
and release is probably caused by a humoral factor derived from cercariae.
An in vitro bioassay was developed to study the origin and nature of this
parasitic factor. In this bioassay freshly dissected CNS of L. stagnalis were
incubated in media containing acetic acid or methanolic extracts of cer-
cariae and of other developmental stages of the parasite (miracidia and in
vitro cultured mother sporocysts) in order to see whether these extracts
induce the release of schistosomin from CNS in vitro (Schallig et al.,
1992b). HPLC-purified release products of the incubated CNS with chro-
matographic properties of schistosomin were tested for bioactivity in the
CaF1-bioassay. As mentioned, in this assay the stimulating effect of CaFl
on secretory cells of the albumen gland is inhibited in the presence of
schistosomin. Release of schistosomin was only found to be induced with a
methanolic extract of cercariae whereas an acetic acid extract had no
effect. Both acetic acid and methanolic extracts of miracidia and mother
sporocysts did not induce schistosomin release (Figure 21). As only the
methanolic extract of cercariae contains a factor inducing schistosomin
release in vitro, it is likely that the parasite factor has a more or less
such as reproduction and growth and that it exerts its effect at two
levels: the productionhelease of hormones and their effect upon target
cells. However, schistosomin shows no sequence homology with any of
the vertebrate types of cytokines identified so far. It has been demonstrated
that a factor acting similarly to schistosomin occurs in haemolymph of
other schistosome-snail combinations, e.g., S. mansoni-B. glabrata (De
Jong-Brink et al., 1991). As haemolymph from L. stugnalis infected with T .
ocellatu did not affect the CaFl response in albumen gland cells of B .
glubratu and similarly the response to CaFl in L. stagnalis was not
inhibited by haemolymph from B . glabrata infected with S . mansoni, it
seems interesting to study the degree of sequence homology between the
factors in haemolymph of different species of parasitized snails.
100
90
80
70
60
30
20
10
0
A B C D E F
Figure 22 Means and standard deviations of the percentages of Ca-positive
mitochondria in albumen glands of L. stagnalis incubated in the following
media: A, Ringer (R); B, R with the neuropeptide calfluxin (R + CaFl); C, R +
CaFl + schistosomin; D, haemolymph from snails starved for 12 days + CaFl; E,
haemolymph from snails starved for 12 days + CaFl; E, haemolymph from snails
kept for 12 days at 4°C + CaFl; F, haemolymph from snails kept for 45 days in
dirtied water + CaFl. Each mean is based on counts in five glands, 100 mito-
chondria per gland. Groups not sharing a common letter differ significantly. (De
Jong-Brink et al., 1992.)
them from the wall of the jar and placing the jar with the snail on a slowly
moving shaker for 2 min in order to prevent the snail from adhering again
to the wall. All the disturbed groups of snails showed a significant increase
of the time (ca 30-40 min) between the CWS and the moment of ovulation
egg-mass deposition compared to the non-disturbed controls, irrespective of
their being disturbed before or after the CWS. This indicates that this delay
of egg-mass deposition is induced independently of the CWS, that, is
activation of CDC activity.
The question of whether this delay was caused by the release of schis-
tosomin into the haemolymph of disturbed snails was investigated using
three bioassays, (1) the CaFl bioassay, (2) a dotting immuno assay (DIA)
using a polyclonal antiserum against schistosomin and (3) an assay in
which the excitability of isolated LGCs (mean number of action potentials
per 10 s) was quantified (De Jong-Brink et al., 1994). As mentioned,
schistosomin causes an increase of LGC excitability. Haemolymph of
disturbed snails with delayed ovulation or oviposition, showed similar
effects as purified schistosomin, whereas this was not the case with
haemolymph from non-disturbed controls. As the release of schistosomin
was also obvious in snails, which had been disturbed while staying in
dirtied water, the question remains whether such a disturbance might
also induce schistosomin release in snails which had been kept under
224 MARUKE DE JONG-BRINK
75 C C
11 I
b
1
0
a
1
ap
0 A - - - -
B C D E
Figure 23 Percentages (means and standard deviations) of Ca2+ (Ca-)positive
mitochondria in albumen glands of non-infected L. srugnalis incubated in Ringer
(A), in Ringer with calfluxin (CaF1, B) or with CaFl in haemolymph from snails
30 min after an ovulation-inducing clean water stimulus (CWS) (C), 30 min after
CWS, 20 min after disturbance (D), 90 min after C W S (E),90 min after CWS,
30 min after disturbance (F).Groups not sharing a common letter on top of the bars
differ significantly. (De Jong-Brink er al., 1994.)
1
T
R R+ NC NC DW DW
CaFl +D +D
260 -
230 -
-
i t +
200
170 -
140 -
110 -
80 - I I I I I I I
Although the 2 kDa and 40 kDa factors in this early stage of infection
have appeared to be peptides/proteins, a role of other E/S products, such as
excretory products and/or diffusible molecules, cannot be excluded. How-
ever, the fact that the effects caused by in vitro released products seem to
reflect the in vivo situation does not favour other possibilities. No indica-
Cytokine-likefactor(s)
schistosomin Neuropeptides
Target tissues
/organs
i L
Physiological
processes
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
manuscript and for critical reading and commenting on it, to all people in
our laboratory who have contributed to the research on parasite-snail
interactions especially Marion Bergamin-Sassen, Robert Hoek and Wessel
Lageweg and to Thea Laan for patience and care in typing the manuscript.
REFERENCES
J.C. Andries and A. Dhainaut, eds), pp. 163-172. Elsevier Science B.V.
(Biomedical Division), Amsterdam.
De Jong-Brink, M., Bergamin-Sassen, M.J.M., Kuyt, J.R.M. and Tewari-Kanhai,
A.L. (1986b). Enzyme cytochemical evidence for the activation of adenylate
cyclase in the follicle cells of vitellogenic oocytes by the dorsal body hormone
in the snail Lymnaea stagnalis. General and Comparative Endocrinology 63,
212-219.
De Jong-Brink, M., Elsaadany, M.M. and Boer, H.H. (1988a). Trichobilhurzia
ocellata: interference with the endocrine control of female reproduction of its
host Lymnaea stagnalis. Experimental Parasitology 65, 91-100.
De Jong-Brink, M., Elsaadany, M. and Boer, H.H. (1988b). Schistosomin, an
antagonist of calfluxin. Experimental Parasitology 65, 109-1 18.
De Jong-Brink, M., Schallig, H.F.H., Chatlet, M. and ‘Zonneveld, C. (1989).
. Endocrine interactions between digenetic trematode parasites and their
intermediate hosts, freshwater snails with emphasis on the possible role of
ecdysteroids. Invertebrate Reproduction and Development 15, 202-209.
De Jong-Brink, M., Elsaadany, M. and Solis Soto, .M. (1991). The occurrence of
schistosomin, an antagonist of female gonadotropic hormones, is a general
phenomenon in haemolymph of schistosome-infected freshwater snails.
Parasitology 103, 371-378.
De Jong-Brink, M., Hordijk, P.L., Vergeest, D.P.E.J., Schallig, H.D.F.H., Kits,
K.S.and Ter Maat, A. (1992).The anti-gonadotropic newpeptide schistosomin
interferes with peripheral and central neuroendocrine mechanisms involved in
the regulation of reproduction and growth in the schistosome-infected snail
Lymnaea stagnalis. In “The Peptidergic Neuron. Rogress in Brain Research”
(J. Joosse, R.M. Buijs and F.J.H. Tilders, eds), Vol. 92,pp. 385-396. Elsevier
Science (Biomedical Division), Amsterdam.
De Jong-Brink, M., Bergamin-Sassen, M.J.M., Broers-Vendrig, T., Glasmeier, A.
and Kits, K.S. (1994). A stress response that delays ovulation egg laying in the
snail Lymnaea stagnalis. Submitted.
Diklcehm, R., Tijnagel, J.M.G.H., Mulder, E.C. and Van der Knaap, W.P.W.
(1987).Haemocytes of the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis generate reactive forms
of oxygen. Journal of Invertebrate Pathology 49,321-331.
. Dunn,T.S. and Yoshino,T.P. (1988).Schistosoma munsoni: origin and expression
of a tegumental surface antigen on the miracidium and primary sporocysts.
Experimental Parasitology 67, 167-18 1.
Dushay, M.S. and Beckage, N.E. (1993). Dose-dependent separation of Cotesia
’ congregata-associated polydnavirus effects of Manduca sexta larval develop-
ment and immunity.Journal of Insect Physiology 12, 1029-1040.
Duvaux-Miret, 0..Stefano, G.B., Smith, E.M., Dissous, C. and Capron, A. (1992).
Immunosuppression in the definitive and intermediate hosts of the human parasite
Schisrosoma mansoni by release of immunoreactive peptides. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the USA 89,778-78 1.
Duvaux-Miret, 0.. Leung, M.K., Capron, A. and Stefano, G.B. (1993).Schistosoma
mansoni: an enkephalonergic system that may participate in internal and
host-ite signalling. Experimental Parasitology 76, 76-84.
Eglezos, A.; Andrews, P.V. and Helme, R.D. (1993).In vivo inhibition of the rat
primary antibody response to antigenic stimulation by somatostatin. Immunology
and Cell Biology 71, 125-129.
Elsasser, T.H., Rumsey, T.S., Hammond, A.C.and Fayer, R. (1988).Influence of
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 243
Kaufmann, S.H.E. (1990a). Heat shock proteins and the immune response.
Immunology Today 11, 129-136.
Kaufmann, S.H.E. (1990b). Heat-shock proteins: a missing link in the host-parasite
relationship? Medical Microbiology and Immunology 179, 6 1 4 6 .
Kavaliers, M. and Colwell, D.D. (1992). Parasitism, opioid systems and host
behaviour. Advances in Neuroimmumlogy 2, 287-295.
Kavaliers, M. and Podesta, R.B. (1988). Opioid involvement in parasite-induced
behavioural modifications: evidence from hamsters infected with Schistosoma
mansoni. Canadian Journal of Zoology 66, 2653-2657.
Kavaliers, M., Podesta, R.B., Hirst, M. and Young, B. (1984). Evidence for the
activation of the endogenous opiate system in hamsters infected with human
blood flukes. Life Sciences 35, 2365-2373.
Kavelaars, A., Ballieux, R.E. and Heynen, C.I. (1989). The role of I11 in the
corticotropin release factor and arginine-induced vasopressin-induced secretion
of immunoreactive beta-endorphin by human peripheral blood mononuclear
cells. Journal of Immunology 342,2338-2342.
Kehoe, J.S. (1975). Electrogenic effects of neutral ,amino acids on neurons of
Aplysia californica. Cold Spring Harbor Symposium, The Synaps 40, 145-155.
Kitano, H., Wago, H. and Arakawa, T. (1990). Possible role of teratocytes of the
gregarious parasitoid, Cotesis ( = Apanteles) glomerata in the suppression of
phenoloxidase activity in the larval host, Pieris rapae crucivora. Archives of
Insect Biochemistry and Physiology 13, 177-1 85.
Kits, K.S. (1980). States of excitability in ovulation hormone producing neuro-
endocrine cells of Lymnaea stagnalis (Gastropoda) in their relation to the
egg-laying cycle. Journal of Neurobiology 11, 397410.
K(lhler, P. and Voigt, W.P. (1988). Nutrition and metabolism. In “Parasitology in
Focus. Facts and Trends” (H. Mehlhorn, ed.), pp. 412453. Springer-Verlag,
Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, London, Paris, Tokyo.
Koolman, J. (1990). The occurrence of ecdysteroids in vertebrates infected with
helminths. Progress in Clinical and Biological Research 342, 704-709.
Kuchler, K. (1993). Unusual routes of protein secretion: the easy way out. Trends
in Cell Biology 3, 421426.
Langley, J.G. and Dunne, D.W. (1992). Temporal variation in the carbohydrate and
peptide surface epitopes in antibody-dependent, eosinophil-mediated killing of
-Schistosoma mansoni schistosomula. Parasite Immunology 14, 185-200.
Lawrence, P.O. (1990). Serosal cells of Biosreres longicaudarus (Hymenoptera:
Braconidae): ultrastructure and release of polypeptides. Archives of Insect
Biochemical Physiology 13, 199-216.
Lawrence, P.O. and Lanzrein, B. (1993). Hormonal interactions between insect
endoparasites and their host insects. In “Parasites and Pathogens of Insects”
(N.E. Beckage, S.N. Thompson and B.A. Frederici, eds), Vol. 1: Parasites, pp.
59-86. Academic Press, New York.
k h a n , R.M., Toni, R., Clark, B.D., Cannon, J.G., Shaw, A.R., Dinarelo, C.A.
and Reichlin, S. (1990). Immunoreactive interleukin-1f3 localization in the rat
forebrain. Brain Research 514, 135-140.
Lie, K.J. (1982). Survival of Schistosoma mansoni and other trematode larvae in
the snail Bbmphalaria glabrara. A discussion of the interference theory.
Tropical and Geographicat Medicine 34, 111-122.
Lie, K.J., Jeong, K.H. and Heyneman, D. (1987). Molluscan host reactions to
helminthic infection. In “Immunology, Immunopathology, and Immunopro-
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 247
phylaxis” (E.J.L. Soulsby, ed.), Vol. IV, pp. 211-270. CRC Press, Boca
Raton, Florida.
Liew, F.Y. and Cox, F.E.G. (1991). Nonspecific defence mechanisms: the role of
nitric oxide. In Immunoparasitology Today (Immunology Today 12, Parasitology
Today 7), A17-A21. Elsevier Trends Journals, Cambridge.
Lightowlers, M.W. and Rickard, M.D. (1988). Excretory-secretory products of
helminth parasites: effect on host immune responses. Parasitology 96, 123-166.
Lindquist, S. and Craig, E.A. (1988). The heatshock proteins. Annual Reviews of
Genetics 22, 631-677.
Lingelbach, K.R. (1993). Plasmodium falciparum: a molecular view of protein
transport from the parasite into the host erythrocyte. Experimental Parasitology
76, 318-327.
Lodes, M.J. and Yoshino, T.P. (1990). The effect of schistosome excretory-
secretory products on Biomphalaria glabrata haemocyte motility. Journal of
Invertebrate Pathology 56, 75-85.
Lodes, M.J., Connors, V.A. and Yoshino, T.P. (1991). Isolation and functional
characterization of snail hemocyte-modulating polypeptide from primary sporo-
cysts of Schistosoma mansoni. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 49,
1-10.
Loker, E.S. and Bayne, C.J. (1982). In vitro encounters between Schistosoma
mansoni sporocysts and hemolymph components of susceptible and resistant
strains of Biomphalaria glabrata. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 31,999-1005.
Loker, E.S. and Bayne, C.J. (1986). Immunity to trematode larvae in the snail
Biomphalaria. Symposia Zoological Society of London 56, 199-220.
Loker, E.S., Bayne, C.J. and Yui, M.A. (1986). Echinostoma paraensei: hemocytes
of Biomphalaria glabrata as targets of echinostome mediated interference with
snail host resistance to Schistosoma mansoni. Experimental Parasitology 62,
149-154.
Loker, E.S., Cimino, D.F. and Hertel, L.A. (1992). Excretory-secretory products of
Echinostoma paraensei sporocysts mediate interference with Biomphalaria
glabrata hemocyte functions. Journal of Parasitology 73, 1090-1098.
Lolait, S.J., Clements, J.A., Marck-Wick, A.J., Chang, C., McNally, M., Smith,
A.J. and Funder, J.W. (1986). Proopiomelanocortin messenger ribonucleic acid
and post-translational processing of beta-endorphin in spleen macrophages.
Journal of Clinical Investigation 77, 1776-1779.
Maizels, R.M., Bundy, D.A.P., Selkirk, M.E., Smith, D.F. and Anderson, R.M.
(1993). Immunological modulation and evasion by helminth parasites in human
populations. Nature 365, 797-805.
Maresca, B. and Caratu, L. (1992). The biology of the heat shock response in
parasites. Parasitology Today 8, 260-266.
McClelland, G. and Bourns, T.K.R. (1969). Effects of Trichobilharzia ocellata
on growth, reproduction and survival of Lymnaea stagnalis. Experimental
Parasitology 24, 137- 146.
McKerrow, J.H. and Doenhoff, M.J. (1988). Schistosome proteases. Parasitology
Today 4, 334-340.
McLaren, D.J. (1980). Schistosoma mansoni: the parasite surface in relation to host
immunity. In “Tropical Medicine Research Studies” (K.H. Brown, ed.),
Research Studies Press, Chichester.
Meier, M. and Meier-Brook, C. (1981). Schistosoma mansoni: effect on growth,
248 MARlJKE DE JONG-BRINK
Neumann, S., Ziv, E., Lantner, F. and Schlechter, I. (1993). Regulation of HSP70
gene expression during the life cycle of the parasitic helminth Schistosoma
mansoni. European Journal of Biochemistry 212, 589-596.
Nevhutalic, P.A., Salafsky, B., Haas, W. and Conway, T. (1993). Schistosoma
mansoni and Trichobilharzia ocellata: comparison of secreted cercarial
eicosanoids. Journal of Parasitology 79, 130-1 33.
Newport, G., Culpepper, J. and Agabian, N. (1988). Parasite heat-shock proteins.
Parasitology Today 4, 306-3 12.
Nicaise, G. (1973). The gliointerstitial system of molluscs. In “International
Review of Cytology” (G.H. Bourne, J.F. Danielli and K.W. Jeon, eds), Vol.
34, pp. 251-332. Academic Press, New York, San Francisco, London.
Nilsson, L.A., Lange, S. and Lonnroth, I. (1992). Induction of anti-secretory factor
in mice by the nonintestinal parasite Schistosoma mansoni. Journal of Para-
sitology 78, 1055-1058.
Nird6, P., Torpier, G., Capron, A., Delaage, M. and De Reggi, M.L. (1984).
Ecdysteroids in schistosomes and host-parasite relationships. In “Biosynthesis,
Metabolism and Mode of Action of Invertebrate Hormones” (J.A. Hoffmann and
M. Porchet, eds). Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Nisticb, G. (1993). Communications among central nervous system, neuro-
endocrine and immune systems: interleukin-2. Progress in Neurobiology 40,
463475.
Noda, S. and Loker, E.S. (1989). Phagocytotic activity of hemocytes of M-line
Biomphalaria glabrata snails: effect of exposure to the trematode Echinostoma
paraensei. Journal of Parasitology 75, 26 1-269.
Nozaki, T. and Dvorak, J.A. (1993). Intraspecific diversity in the response of
Trypanosomacruzi to environmental stress. Journal of Parasitology 79.45 1454.
Ndiiez, P.E. and De Jong-Brink, M. (1994). The suppressive excretory-secretory
product of Trichobilharzia ocellata: a possible factor for determining com-
patibility in parasite-host interactions. Journal of Parasitol. Research.
Submitted.
Nliiiez, P.E., Adema, C.M. and De Jong-Brink, M. (1994a). Modulation of the
killing activity of haemocytes of Lymnaea stagnalis by the trematode parasite
Trichobilharzia ocellata. Parasitology 109, 299-3 10.
Nliiiez, P.E.,Li, K.W. and De Jong-Brink, M. (1994b). Excretory-secretory pro-
ducts of Trichobilharzia ocellata and their modulating effects on the internal
defence system of Lymnaea stagnalis. Submitted.
Oehlmann, J. and Bettin, C. (1992). TBT-induced imposex and the role of steroids
in marine snails. In “Abstracts 11 International Malacological Congress”
(F. Giusti and G. Manganelli, eds). University of Siena, Siena.
Ottaviani, E., Petraglia, F., Montagnani, G., Cossarizza, A., Monti, D. and
Franceschi, C. ( 1990). Presence of ACTH- and P-endorphin-immunoreactive
molecules in the freshwater snail Planorbarius corneus (L.) (Gastropoda,
Pulmonata). Regulatory Peptides 27, 1-9.
Ottaviani, E., Caselgrandi, E., Petraglia, F. and Franceschi, C. (1992). Stress
response in the freshwater snail Planorbarius corneus (L.) (Gastropoda, Pulmo-
nata): interaction between CRF, ACTH, and biogenic amines. General and
Comparative Endocrinology 87, 354-360.
Ottaviani, E., Caselgrandi, E., Franchini, A. and Franceschi, C. (1993a). CRF
provokes the release of norepinephrine by hemocytes of Viviparis ater (Gastro-
poda, Prosobranchia): further evidence in favour of the evolutionary hypothesis
250 MARIJKE DE JONG-BRINK
Segura, J.J., Guerrero, J.M., Goberna, R. and Calvo, J.R. (1992). Somatostatin
inhibition of VIP- and isoproterenol-stimulated cyclic-AMP production in rat
peritoneal macrophages. Neuropeptides 23, 2 9 4 3 .
Shiff, C.J. and Dossaji, S.F. (1991). Ecdysteroids as regulators of host and parasite
interactions: a study of interrelationships between Schistosoma mansoni and the
host snail Biomphalaria glabrata. Tropical Medical Parasitology 42, 11-1 6.
Shinnick, T.M. (1991). Heat shock proteins as antigens of bacterial and parasitic
pathogens. In “Current Topics in Microbiology and Immunology” (S.H.E.
Kaufmann, ed.), Vol. 167: Heat shock proteins and immune responses, pp.
145-160. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Shoemaker, G.B., Ramachandran, H., Landa, A., dos Reis, M.G. and Stein, L.D.
(1992). Alternative splicing of the Schistosoma mansoni gene encoding a
homologue of epidermal growth factor receptor. Molecular and Biochemical
Parasitology 53, 17-32.
’Shoemaker, C.B., Reynolds, S.R., Wei, G., Tielens, A.G.M. and Ham, D.A. (1994).
Schistosoma mansoni hexokinase: cDNA cloning and immunogenecity studies.
Experimental Parasitology. In press.
Simpson, A.J.G. and Smithers, S.R. (1985). Schistosomes: surface, egg and circu-
lating antigens. Current topics in Microbiology and Immunology 120, 205-223.
Sluiters, J.F. (1981). Development of Trichobilharzia ocellata in Lymnaea stag-
nalis and the effects of infection on the reproductive system of the host. Zeitung
fur Parasitenkunde 64, 303-3 19.
Sluiters, J.F., Brussard-Wust, C.M. and Meuleman, E.A. (1980). The relationship
between miracidial dose, production of cercariae, and reproductive activity of
the host in the combination Trichobilharzia ocellata and Lymnaea stagnalis.
Zeitschrqt fur Parasitenkunde 63, 13-26.
Sminia, T.S. (1972). Structure and function of blood and connective tissue cells of
the freshwater pulmonate Lymnaea stagnalis studied by electron microscopy and
enzyme histochemistry. Zeitung fur Zellforschung 130,497-526.
Sminia, T.S.and Van der Knaap, W.P.W. (1981). The internal defence system of
the freshwater snail Lymnaea stagnalis. Developmental and Comparative
Immunology 5, 87-97.
Sminia, T.S.and Van der Knaap, W.P.W. (1986). Immunorecognition in inverte-
brates with special reference to molluscs. In “Immunity in Invertebrates”
(M. Brehelin, ed.), pp. 112-124. Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg.
Sminia, T.S., Borghart-Reinders, E. and Van der Linde, A.W. (1974). Encapsula-
tion of foreign material experimentally introduced into the freshwater snail
Lymnaea stagnalis. Cell and Tissue Research 153, 307-326.
Smjt, A.B., Vreugdenhil, E., Ebberink, R.H.M., Geraerts, W.P.M., Klootwijk, J. and
Joosse, J. (1988). Growth controlling molluscan neurons contain the precursor of
molluscan insulin-related peptide. Nature 331, 535-538.
Smith, E.M. (1989). Neuropeptide gene expression in lymphoid tissue. In
“Endogenous Sleep Factors” (S. Inoue and J.M. Krueger, eds), Bouma, Text,
Wassenaar.
Smith, E.M. and Johnson, E.W. (1991). Neuropeptides and neuropeptide receptors
in the immune system. In “Studies in Neuroscience. Comparative Aspects of
Neuropeptide Function” (E. Florey and G.B. Stefano, eds), pp. 3 13-316.
Manchester University Press, Manchester.
Soderhall, K. and A s p h , A. (1993). Prophenol oxidase activity system and its
role in cellular communication. In “Insect Immunity” (J.P.N. Pathak, ed.), pp.
113-130. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, Boston, London.
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 253
Insects” (N.E. Beckage, S.N. Thompson and B.A. Frederici, eds), Vol. 1:
Parasites, pp. 167-187. Academic Press, New York.
Strand, M.R. and Dover, B.A. (1991). Development disruption of Pseudoplusia
includens and Heliothis virescens larvae by the calyx fluid and venom of
Microplitis demolitor. Archives of Insect Biochemistry and Physiology 18,
131-1 45.
Sun, S.C., Lindstrom, I., Boman, H.G., Faye, I. and Schmidt, D. (1990). Hemolin:
an insect-immune protein belonging to the immunoglobin superfamily. Science
250, 1729-1732.
Tanaka, T. and Vinson, S.B. (1991). Depression of prothoracic gland activity of
Heliothis virescence by venom and calyx fluids from the parasitoid, Cardiochiles
nigriceps. Journal of Insect Physiology 37, 139-144.
Tanaka, T. and Wago, H. (1990). Ultrastryctural and functional maturation of
teratocytes of Apanteles kariya. Archives of Insect Biochemistry and Physiology
* 13, 197-197.
Ter Maat, A. Lodder, J.C. and Wilbrink, M. (1983). Induction of egg-laying in
the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis by environmental stimulation of the release
of ovulation hormone from the caudo-dorsal cells. International Journal of
Invertebrate Reproduction 6, 239-247.
Teunissen, Y. (1994). Molecular-biological studies of growth and reproduction in
the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis. Thesis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.
Thompson, S.N. ( 1990). Physiological alterations during parasitism and their
effects on host behaviour. In “Parasitism and Host Behaviour” (C.J. Barnard
and J.M. Behnke, eds), pp. 64-94. Taylor and Francis, London.
Thompson, S.N., Mejia-Scales, V. and Borchardt, D.B. (1992). Physiological
studies of snail-schistosome interactions and potential for improvement of in
vitro culture of schistosomes. In Vitro Cellular and Developmental Biology 27A,
497-5 14.
Thorndyke, M.C. (1990). Neurohormonal peptides in parasitic worms: a new
frontier in host-parasite pathophysiology. In “Progress in Comparative Endo-
crinology” (A. Epple, C.G. Scanes and M.H. Stetston, eds). Wiley-Liss, New
York.
Thorndyke, M.C. and Whitfield, P.J. ( 1987). Vasoactive intestinal polypeptide-
like immunoreactive tegumental cells in the digenean helminth Echinostoma
liei: possible role in host-parasite interaction. General and Comparative
Endocrinology 68, 202-207.
Thornhill, J.A., Jones, J.T. and Kusel, J.R. (1986). Increased oviposition and
growth in immature Biomphalaria glabrata after exposure to Schistosoma
, mansoni. Parasitology 93, 443-450.
Tielens, A.G.M., Van den Heuvel, J.M. and Van Eden, W. (1993). Schistosoma
mansoni: an HSP60 homologue is constitutely expressed. Experimental
Parasitology 77, 495-497.
Tracey, K.J. and Cerami, A. (1992). Tumor necrosis factor in the malnutrition
(cachexia) of infection and cancer. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 47, 2-7.
Trottein, F., Godin, C., Pierce, R.J., Sellin, B., Taylor, M.G., Gorillot, I., Silva,
M.S., Lecocq, J.P. and Capron, A. (1992). Inter-species variation of schistosome
28-kDa glutathione S-transferases. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 54,
63-72.
Van der Knaap, W.P.W. and Loker, E.S. (1990). Immune mechanisms in trematode-
snail interactions. Parasitology Today 6, 175-1 82.
HOW SCHISTOSOMES PROFIT FROM STRESS RESPONSES ELICITED IN THEIR HOSTS 255
Van der Knaap, W.P.W., Sminia, T., Kroese, F.G.M. and Dikkeboom, R. (1981).
Elimination of bacteria from the circulation of the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis.
Developmental and Comparative Immunology 5, 2 1-32.
Van der Knaap, W.P.W., Sminia, T., Schutte, R. and Boemgter-Barendsen, L.H.
(1983). Cytophilic receptors for foreigness and some factors which influence
phagocytosis by invertebrate leucocytes: in vitro phagocytosis by amoebocytes
of the snail Lymnaea stagnalis. Immunology 48, 377-383.
Van der Knaap, W.P.W., Boots, A.M.H., Meuleman, E.A. and Sminia, T. (1985).
Search for shared antigens in the schistosome-snail combination Trichobilharzia
ocellata-Lymnaea stagnalis. Zeitschrift fur Parasitenkunde 71, 2 19-226.
Van der Knaap, W.P.W., Meuleman, E.A. and Sminia, T. (1987). Alterations in the
internal defence system of the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis induced by infec-
tion with the schistosome Trichobilharzia ocellata. Parasitology Research 73,
57-65.
Vankelcom, H., Carmeliet, P., Van Damme, J., Billiau, A. and Denef, C. (1989).
Production of interleukin-6 by folliculo-stellate cells of the anterior pituitary
gland in a histotypic cell aggregate culture system. Neuroendocrinology 59,
102-106.
Vinson, S.B. (1993). Interactions between the insect endocrine system and the
immune system. In “Insect Immunity” (J.P.N. Pathak, ed.), Vol. 48, pp. 103-1 11.
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Boston, London.
Vreugdenhil, E., Jackson, J. F., Bouwmeester, T., Smit, A.B., Van Minnen, J., Van
Heerikhuizen, H., Klootwijk, J. and Joosse, J. (1988). Isolation, characterization
and evolutionary aspects of a cDNA clone encoding multiple neuropeptides
involved in the stereotyped egg-laying behavior of the freshwater snail
Lymnaea stagnalis. Journal of Neuroscience 8, 4 1 8 4 4191.
Wakelin, D. (1984). “Immunity to Parasites. How Animals Control Parasite
Infections.” Edward Arnold (Publishers) Ltd., London.
Wakelin, D. (1988). Genetic control of immunity to helminth infections. In
“Parasitology in Focus. Facts and Trends” (H. Mehlhorn, ed.), pp. 651-670.
Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg.
Wani, M., Yagi, S. and Tanaka, T. (1990). Synergistic effect of venom, calyx and
teratocytes of Apanteles kariyai on the inhibition of larval pupal ecdysis of
the host, Pseudaletia separata. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 57,
10 1-104.
Weigent, D.A., Cam, D.J.J. and Blalock, J.E. (1990). Bidirectional communication
between the neuroendocrine and immuno systems. Annals of the New York
Academy of Sciences 659, 17-27.
Welch, W.J. (1993). How cells respond to stress. Scientific American 268(5),
3441.
Welch, W.J., Kang, H.S., Beckmann, R.P. and Mizzen, L.A. (1991). “Response
of Mammalian Cells to Metabolic Stress; Changes in Cell Physiology and
Structure/Function of Stress Proteins.” Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg.
Wijdenes, J., Van Elk, R. and Joosse, J. (1983). Effects of two gonadotropic
hormones on polysaccharide synthesis in the albumen gland of Lymnaea stag-
nalis, studied with the organ culture technique. General and Comparative
Endocrinology 51, 263-27 1.
Williams, C.L. and Gilbertson, D.E. (1983). Altered feeding behaviour of Schisto-
soma mansoni-infected Biomphalaria glabrata. Journal of Parasitology 69,
671-676.
Williams, D.L., Pierce, R.J., Cookson, E. and Capron, A. (1991). Molecular
256 MARIJKE DE JONG-BRINK
Martin Hall
Richard Wa II
.
1 Introduction ............................... 258
1.1. What is myiasis? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 258
......................
1.2. Classification of myiases 259
.
2 Principal Myiasis Species and Their Life Cycles ............. 262
2.1. Oestridae .............................. 262
2.2. Calliphoridae and Sarcophagidae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 266
. ..............
3 Evolution of Myiasis as a Life History Strategy 269
3.1. Oestridae .............................. 269
..................
3.2. Calliphoridae and Sarcophagidae 271
.
4 Current Status of Species: Their Distribution. Economic Importance and
............
Current Research on Their Behaviour and Ecology 273
4.1. Oestridae .............................. 273
4.2. Calliphoridae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 279
4.3. Sarcophagidae ........................... 286
.
5 Physiology of Myiasis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 287
5.1. Predisposing conditions for myiasis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 287
5.2. Pathology and immunology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 289
6. New and Improved Control Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 293
6.1 Insecticides ............................. 293
....................
6.2. Mechanical means of control 298
..........................
6.3. Biological control 299
.......................
6.4. Sterile insect technique 299
6.5. Genetic control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 301
1. INTRODUCTION
The different forms of myiasis have been classified in two ways. First, in
anatomical terms, based on the part of the host’s body that is infested
(Bishopp, in Patton, 1922) and second, in parasitological terms, according
to the types of host-parasite relationship (Patton, 1922). The first classifi-
cation can provide a convenient short cut to identification of the fly species
concerned for practical diagnosis (Table 2), but the second gives a better
understanding of the biology of the fly as a guide to treatment or prevention
as well as providing information on the evolution of the habit.
Adopting the parasitological classification, we will consider three main
groups of myiasis-producing species: obligatory parasites, which must
Table 1 Matrix categorizing the associations between fly larvae and animals
with respect to the state of the animal host (living or dead) and the nature of the
association (detrimental or beneficial).
Detrimental Beneficial
Living hosts Myiasis (see this review) Maggot therapy (e.g. Sherman
and Pechter, 1988)
Dead hosts Food spoilage (e.g. Esser, Nutrient recycling and forensic
1991) (e.g. Smith, 1986)
260 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
develop on live hosts and facultative parasites, which can develop on both
living and dead organic matter and can be divided into two groups, the
primary species which are able to initiate myiasis and the secondary
species which occur after obligate or primary species have initiated it
(Zumpt, 1965).
A fourth grouping, the accidental myiases or pseudomyiases (Zumpt,
1965), occur when fly eggs or larvae are inadvertently swallowed. In a
cgntrolled experiment, nausea, vomiting, intestinal cramps and diarrhoea
were observed in volunteers who swallowed live larvae of Musca domes-
tics, Calliphora or Sarcophaga in gelatine capsules (Kenney, 1945).
Naturally acquired accidental intestinal infestations can show similar
symptoms or be benign (Nagakura et al., 1991).
Miscellaneous myiases are often reported, particularly in humans, that
are essentially accidental but do not involve the intestinal tract. They occur
when the wrong host is invaded or eggs are laid in atypical sites for the
species. Examples are facultative species involved in human urinary tract
myiases, when eggs are deposited at the entrance to the urethra, hatch into
larvae and develop at the end of the urethra (Musca, Gupta et al., 1982) or
inside the urethra or bladder, being passed in the urine (Megaselia, Singh
and Ranah, 1989; Piophilu, Saleh and El Sibae, 1993). Another internal
region of the human body that can be unusually infested is the respiratory
tract, with relatively mild (Megaselia, Carpenter and Chastain, 1992) or
MVlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 261
here, except where they involve species important in their true host, for
example, Oestrus causing ophthalmomyiasis and Gasterophilus causing so-
called creeping myiasis in the dermal layers of humans. Chodosh and
Clarridge (1992) review ophthalmomyiasis of humans.
The three major families of myiasis-producing flies are the Oestridae, as
recognized by Wood (1987) (four subfamilies, Oestrinae, Gasterophilinae,
Hypodermatinae and Cuterebrinae), the Calliphoridae (blowflies) and the
Sarcophagidae (fleshflies) and this review will concentrate on them. They
all belong to the superfamily Oestroidae (Calyptrate) (McAlpine, 1989).
Their involvement in myiasis is tabulated from an entomological perspec-
tive, but taking account of the degree of parasitism and anatomical loca-
tion, in Table 3. Works containing detailed taxonomic identification keys to
'myiasis species are James (1947), Zumpt (1963, Guimariies et al. (1983),
Spradbery (1991) and Hall and Smith (1993).
The Oestridae (ca 151 species in 28 genera; Wood, 1987) are all obligate
parasites and all of the nutritional requirements for adulthood are taken
from their hosts during the larval stage. Adults have atrophied mouthparts
and do not feed, although Cephenemyia and Cuterebra may imbibe fluids
(Wood, 1987).
In contrast to the Oestridae, the Calliphoridae (ca 1000+ species in 150
genera; Shewell, 1987a) and Sarcophagidae (ca 2000+ species in 400
genera; Shewell, 1987b) include both obligate and facultative parasites
and all feed both as larvae and as adults. At least 80 species in these two
families have been recorded as agents of myiasis (Zumpt, 1965). However,
only a relatively small number of species, three obligate screwworms
(Cochliomyia hominivorax, Chrysomya bezziana and Wohlfahrtia magni-
&a) and two species of primary facultative blowflies (Lucilia sericata and
Luqilia cuprina) are of major clinical and economic importance worldwide.
They will, therefore, be the focus of future discussion.
2.1. Oestridae
2.1.1, Oestrinae
The genus Oestrus includes 0. ovis, the sheep nasal bot fly, whose larvae
develop in the head sinuses and nasal passages of sheep and goats in all
sheep-farming areas of the world. Females can produce up to 500 larvae
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 263
which are deposited directly into the hosts’ nostrils (Kettle, 1990). Adult
fly activity can cause panic, sheep burying their heads in other sheep or
running about snorting in an effort to dislodge larvae. Oestrus ovis larvae
are well adapted to their location in the nasal passages of sheep and goats,
with a variation in spinulation between instars that accords with the
requirements of the instar for anchoring within the respiratory tract
(Guitton and Dorchies, 1993). Effects of infestation can be insignificant
or severe (especially in lambs), with purulent discharge from nostrils,
repeated sneezing and shaking of head and breathing difficulties. Rarely,
larvae may enter the brain causing a condition known as “false gid”
(ataxia, circling and head pressing). Development takes 25-35 days in
summer but is extended through the winter when first instars may last up
to 9 months, giving a total development time of 10-11 months.
Larvae of the Old World genus Rhinoestrus, infest the nasal sinuses of
their hosts and are, generally, very host specific: R . purpureus attacks
horses and donkeys. The genus Gedoelstia generally parasitizes ante-
lopes, but can cause a’serious myiasis of sheep in the western parts of
southern Africa (Zumpt, 1965).
Cephalopina titillator, the camel nasal bot fly, is the only species in its
genus and the larvae develop in the nasal cavities of camels wherever
camels naturally occur, even in areas of introduction such as Australia
(Spratt, 1984). High levels of infestation may occur in camel herds, up to
91% in the rainy season in Nigeria (Desbordes and Ajogi, 1993), and the
presence of larvae in their nostrils may cause considerable irritation,
difficulty in breathing and, exceptionally, death following complications
due to secondary infections (Higgins, 1985).
Important throat bot flies of reindeer are Cephenemyia trompe (reindeer
throat bot fly) and C. auribarbis (red deer throat bot fly).
Oestrus ovis and Rhinoestrus purpureus can cause ophthalrnomyiasis in
humans. Other Oestrinae reported to cause human ophthalmomyiasis
include Pharyngomia picta, the deer throat bot fly (Sauter and Huber, 1988).
2.1.2. Gasterophilinae
Originally restricted to the Palaearctic and Afrotropical regions, species of
Gasterophilus (bot flies) now have a worldwide distribution. Their larvae
develop in the digestive tract of equids. Eight species of Gasterophifus are
generally recognized and all but one of those with known biology lay their
eggs directly on the host, attaching them to the hairs in particular body
regions such as cheek, chin, lip, leg and mane (Cogley, 1991). The numbers
of eggs produced depends on the species, ranging from about 160 for G .
haemorrhoidalis to over 2000 for G . pecorum (Kettle, 1990). A combina-
tion of morphological specialization of the eggshell (attachment organ) and
264 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
2.1.3. Hypodermatinae
Hypoderma are the heel flies, warble flies or cattle grubs whose larvae
develop in subcutaneous “warbles” which spoil the hosts’ hides and cause
serious losses to the cattle industry of the Holarctic region (Scholl, 1993).
The important species are H . bovis and H . lineatum. Mating takes place off
the host at aggregation points where females are intercepted in flight.
Females are reproductively well adapted to their short, non-feeding life
style, because they emerge from the puparium with all their eggs fully
developed, and the capacity to mate immediately and oviposit on host
cattle (Scholl and Weintraub, 1988). Eggs are laid on the host’s hairs,
either singly ( H . bovis) or in batches of up to 15 ( H . lineatum) on the
lower region of the legs and lower body. The persistence of the females in
laying 300-800 eggs can cause a dramatic escape response, “gadding”, by
the hosts. The most obvious economic effects are due to the creation of
holes in hides once the larvae have reached the back after their migration
from sites of oviposition via the spinal column ( H . bovis) or oesophagus
( H . lineatum). Losses due to decreased weight gain and milk production
may be more significant in economic terms (Steelman, 1976; Tarry, 1986).
In a similar manner to the cattle pests, Hypoderma diana parasitizes deer
aqd H . tarandi (= Oedemagena tarandi, Wood, 1987) parasitizes reindeer.
A related warble fly is the goat warble of the Mediterranean Basin,
Przhevalskiana silenus. Rarely, the larvae of Strobiloestrus species, para-
sites of antelopes in the family Bovidae (e.g. klipspringers, mountain
reedbuck, steenbok), cause a furuncular myiasis of cattle (Horak and
Boomker, 1981) and sheep (Brain et al., 1983).
2.1.4. Cuterebrinae
The most important Cuterebrid is Dermatobia hominis (tbrsalo, beme,
human bot fly), a Central and South American species whose larvae create
boil-like swellings where they enter the skin (Lane et al., 1987). In
economic terms it is most important as a pest of cattle, but it also para-
sitizes man, dogs and a variety of other domestic and wild animals and
birds. The hides of infested cattle can be made worthless. Dermatobia
hominis do not feed as adults and live for only a short time (ca. 6 days).
A noteworthy adaptation to this appears to be the early degeneration of
less-developed cytoblasts in the ovaries of pupae, cytoblasts that would not
have time to complete their oogenesis in the adult (Secco et al., 1992).
Dermatobia have a fascinating method of infecting their hosts. Whereas
other Cuterebridae lay eggs on substrate near or within the entrance to host
nests (Beamer et al., 1943; Catts, 1967; Capelle, 1970) or on grass near
trails used by hosts (Beamer, 1950), D . hominis lay their eggs onto host-
visiting, carrier (phoretic) insects. The eggs incubate on the carrier and
then, when the carrier next visits a host, first instar larvae hatch in response
to the sudden temperature rise near the host’s body, leaving the egg through
a well-developed, plate-like operculum at the anterior end (Mourier and
Banegas, 1970). The larvae invade the host’s subcutaneous tissues where
they remain for 35-42 days. Although eggs are ready to hatch after 4 days
at 30”C, larvae may emerge from the same batch over a considerable period
(e.g. from 5-20 days at 28°C; Mourier and Banegas, 1970), which might
help to improve dispersion of larvae.
In the laboratory, females held in conditions of constant dark laid only
266 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
The calliphorid and sarcophagid agents of myiasis have broadly similar life
cycles except for Auchmeromyia and Cordylobia. The latter two genera are
discussed separately at the end of this more general discussion about the
remaining genera.
For most genera, eggs or first instar larvae are laid on or in the host. The
larvae pass through three instars while feeding on the host tissues, before
entering a wandering stage in which they migrate away from the strike
focus and, after a period of dispersal, pupate, prior to adult emergence.
The New World screwworm fly, Cochliomyia hominivorax, is an obligate
ectoparasite and will infest almost all warm-blooded livestock, wildlife and
humans; it is unable to breed in carrion (James, 1947). Females are auto-
genous, mate during early vitellogenesis and oviposit approximately every
three days (Guillot et al., 1977). They lay batches of up to 500 eggs, with a
mean of 200 per batch, at the edges of open wounds or in body orifices
(Thomas and Mangan, 1989). Within 24 h of hatching, the maggots start to
feed, burrowing into the living tissue. The behavioural, ecological and
physiological characteristics of the different phases (adolescent, sexual
and reproductive) in adult screwworm life, are reviewed by Thomas
(1993a). The extensive wound which results from larval feeding may
rapidly lead to the death of the struck animal.
The Old World screwworm fly Chrysomya bezziana is similar in many
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 267
2.2.1. Auchmeromyia
Bloodsucking larvae of the African species Auchmeromyia senegalensis
the Congo floor maggot, are atypical myiasis species as they do not live on
or in the host, but are obligate, haematophagous ectoparasites and suck the
blood of sleeping humans (Noireau, 1992) and burrow-dwelling animals
(sanguinivorous myiasis). In this respect their behaviour is more like that
of an adult, bloodsucking insect rather than a myiasis species, to the extent
that they have been shown experimentally to be capable of transmitting
trypanosomes (Geigy and Kauffmann, 1977). Somewhat similar behaviour
is shown by blood-feeding blowfly larvae of the genus Protocalliphora.
These are obligate parasites of nestling birds (Sabrosky et al., 1989;
Bennett and Whitworth, 1991) but, in general, their effects are not serious
(Whitworth and Bennett, 1992; Johnson and Albrecht, 1993).
2.2.2. Cordylobia
Cordylobia includes C . anthropophaga, the “tumbu” fly of Africa, which
causes a boil-like (furuncular) type of myiasis like that of D . hominis in the
Americas. Its biology has been investigated most extensively by Blacklock
and Thompson (1923), who concluded that wild rats were the most impor-
tant natural reservoir of infection in Sierra Leone. However, humans and
dogs are the most important hosts in economic terms. Eggs are not
deposited directly onto a host, rather onto dry, shaded ground, especially
if contaminated by urine and faeces. They may also be laid on drying
laundry. Larvae hatch in 1-3 days and remain just under the soil surface
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 269
until activated by host body heat. They then emerge, burrow into the host
and grow for 8-15 days in a furuncle, usually with only one larva per
abscess. Cordylobia rodhaini only rarely infests man (Kremer ef al., 1970).
This section will concentrate on the evolution of the myiasis habit itself
rather than the evolution of the groups involved in myiasis, although the
two are interlinked. The phylogeny of the three principal myiasis families,
Oestridae, Calliphoridae and Sarcophagidae, has been considered in detail
by McAlpine (1989) and Pape (1992).
The family and subfamily groups can be characterized with respect to their
feeding habits (Schaefer, 1979). Most Calliphoridae and Sarcophagidae are
catholic in the range of hosts they exploit and their selection of hosts is
frequently a reflection of host availability. Thus, in much of the Americas,
Cochliomyia hominivorax is principally a pest of cattle but in Libya it was
mainly found on sheep, the most numerous local hosts (FAO, 1992). In
contrast, most Oestridae show a high degree of host specificity. The
specialization of some Oestridae on endangered hosts could, of course,
lead to their extinction, for example, Gyrostigma on rhinoceroses (Cogley,
1990).
Zumpt (1965) postulated two roots for the evolution of myiasis: (1) the
sanguinivorous root, with the specialized oestrid behaviours derived from
less-specialized calliphorids that had ectoparasitic bloodsucking larvae,
like the present day Auchmeromyia (on mammals) and Protocalliphora
(on birds), and, (2) the saprophagous root, with an evolutionary trend from
carrion breeders to obligate wound myiasis species, as outlined below.
James (1969) noted that the transition to parasitism, especially faculta-
tive, involved a broad adaptability or lack of specialization of a group in a
state of biological flux, of relatively youthful and vigorous stock.
3.1. Oestridae
4.1. Oestridae
4.1.1. Oestrinae
Adult Oestrus ovis seriously annoy sheep as they deposit larvae, leading to
a loss of grazing time and condition of the sheep. Horak and Snijders
(1974) demonstrated a poorer weight gain of 0. ovis infested lambs
compared to those freed of the parasite by rafoxanide treatment, whereas
Ilchmann et al. (1986) reported losses in production ranging from 1.1 to
4.6 kg of meat, 200 to 500 g of wool and up to 10% of milk. Recent studies
have shown infestation levels in sheep of 6 5 2 % (Zimbabwe; Pandey,
1989), up to 69% (India; Jagannath et al., 1989b), up to 100% (Morocco;
Pandey and Ouhelli, 1984: South Africa; Louw, 1989: Brazil; Ribeiro et
274 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
al., 1990) and with a seasonal variation of 44-88% (France; Yilma and
Dorchies, 1991 - who discuss other recent epidemiological studies).
Yilma and Dorchies (1991) observed a maximum of three fly generations
per year in southwest France, with adults peaking in numbers in three
periods, March-April, June-July and September-October. They suggest
that treating sheep during these three periods would considerably reduce
the incidence of disease locally. In Britain the general prevalence of 0. ovis
infestation is e l % , but it can be much higher in local “hot-spots”, with
most infestations in the south of England and Wales (P. Bates, personal
communication), from where human ophthalmomyiasis has been reported
(Stevens et al., 1991).
Cases of human ophthalmomyiasis due to the larvae of 0. ovis are
frequently published, in particular from the Middle East and Mediterranean
Basin (Cameron et al., 1991; Mariotti and Vacheret, 1992; Amr et al.,
1993; Hira et al., 1993). Most cases of ophthalmomyiasis due to 0. ovis
resolve rapidly as the larvae are unable to develop beyond the first instar.
Infrequently, nasal myiasis due to 0. ovis is reported in humans (Quesada
et al., 1990).
In the Caspian region of the former USSR, Rastegayev ( 1 984) reported a
prevalence of infection of horses with Rhinoestrus of 96.7-loo%, the
major species being R . latifrons and R . purpureus. Between 45 and 899
Rhinoestrus larvae were found in the head cavities of infested horses, with
a mean of 154. Rastegayev (1984) made detailed records of the biology,
life cycle and behaviour of these species, including the observation that
female Rhinoestrus can insert larvae into the nostrils of horses not only
while in flight, but also when landed on the ground or on other objects near
the host. Thus, females can raise themselves on their tarsi and launch
several batches of larvae into the current of air inhaled by the horse.
Zayed et al. (1993) recorded the prevalence of R . purpureus in donkeys
in Egypt and showed that larvae were present from January to October with
two peaks of 100% monthly infestation, in March and July-August. No
’
infestations were found in the winter, November-December, and it was
concluded that there were two generations of the fly per year. The mean
monthly larval burden was greatest in June (58 per donkey). All first instar
and the majority (94%)of second instar R. purpureus were located in the
ethmoid bone of donkeys, whereas third instars were mostly (42%)found
in the sphenopalative communication, prior to their maturation and migra-
tion to the exterior via the common and nasal meatus and the nostrils
(Zayed and Hilali, 1993).
4.1.2. Gasterophilinae
The high value of many horses, the recurrent expense of treatments and
possible self-injury by horses under “attack” from ovipositing females
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 275
4.1.3. Hypodermatinae
The gadding behaviour of cattle irritated by ovipositing Hypoderma is
thought to be a potential cause of injury, spontaneous abortion and reduced
milk production, but these losses have not been assessed (Scholl, 1993).
Likewise, the effects of Hypoderma on weight gain are open to interpreta-
tion and Scholl (1993) points out that many questions regarding effects of
infection remain to be answered, including the threshold levels of infesta-
tion for economic loss. However, the effect of Hypoderma on hides is well
established.
A programme of Hypoderma eradication in Britain was launched in
1978, at which time annual losses in the UK due to Hypoderma were
estimated to be approximately E l 3 million (Tarry, 1986). The programme
was based on a combination of the voluntary use of pour-on organo-
phosphorus treatments, with compulsory treatment of cattle showing Hypo-
derma larvae in the spring, plus appropriate movement restrictions. The
programme was very successful and resulted in a decrease in the original
infestation levels from about 40% to less than 1% in four years. From 1982
it became compulsory to treat a whole herd in which Hypoderma was found
(Tarry,1986) and the programme was so effective that, recently, it has only
been possible to detect infestations by serological analysis of hosts
(Sinclair et al., 1990; Tarry et al., 1992) and even these revealed zero
276 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
herd member was negatively correlated with the distance between calving
and summer grazing grounds. The calving grounds are where the greatest
larval shedding occurs. Folstad et al. (1991) hypothesize that the annual
migration between these two grounds is a behaviour that confers a reduc-
tion in Hypoderma levels, and that, in addition to predator avoidance and
enhanced access to good food, such parasite avoidance behaviour may have
played an important role in forming migration patterns among herbivore
populations.
Hypodermosis in man most frequently features skin allergies accompa-
nied by blood eosinophil differential counts varying from subnormal to
6 0 8 above the normal (Boulard and Petithory, 1977). The severity of
infection varies with the site of the larvae, from a “creeping myiasis”
caused by subdermal migrations (Uttamchandani et al., 1989), to ophthal-
momyiasis interna resulting in visual loss (Edwards et al., 1984), to rare
intracerebral myiasis (Kalelioglu et al., 1989). Since 1982 (Syrdalen et al.,
1982), H . tarandi has been increasingly reported as a cause of more or less
severe ophthalmomyiasis in humans, infestations even leading to blindness
(Kearney et al., 1991). Surgical techniques for removal of larvae in cases
of human ophthalmomyiasis are discussed by Syrdalen et al. (1982) and
Rapoza et al. (1986).
Larvae of Przhevalskiana burrow into the skin of goats in the same
manner as the larvae of Hypoderma in cattle (Puccini et al., 1987).
Infested animals lose condition and the perforation of the hide causes
considerable losses to its value. A good correlation has been found
between the loss of weight of young goats and the numbers of larvae of
P. silenus harboured by them (Liakos, 1986). The most recent studies of P.
silenus have been made in southern Italy, by Tassi et al. (1989) who also
review the literature on this species. They recorded infection rates ranging
from 30 to 81% of goats in a herd, each with up to a mean of 5.3 warbles:
there was a greater prevalence of infection among younger animals which
showed a higher mean intensity of infection.
4.1.4. Cuterebrinae
Dermatobia hominis occurs from Mexico (24-26”N) south throughout all
countries of central and south America, except Chile (Roncalli and Usher,
1988; Uribe et al., 1989), to northern Argentina (30-32”s). The annual
costs of D. hominis infestation (meat, milk and hide production losses)
were estimated to be some US$200 million annually in 1976 (Steelman,
1976): more recent estimations are needed. In Costa Rica up to 42% of
cattle are infested by D . hominis and up to 62% of water buffaloes (Sancho
et al., 1989). Thomas (1988) recorded a mean monthly infestation rate of
278 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
mens for over 50 years (Cogley and Cogley, 1989); the eggs are also
strongly adhered to each other. The adhesive(s) can be broken down by
enzymatic activity (papain and bromelain). The combination of egg-to-egg
and egg-to-carrier attachment increases the likelihood of the eggs remaining
attached and increases the overall rigidity of the egg mass. Cogley and
Cogley (1989) concluded that a number of structural and location features
enhance the ability of larvae to infest a host, e.g. the ventral placement of
eggs such that the hatching end is nearest the host’s skin, the offsetting of
egg tiers which enables larvae to escape without obstruction from overlying
eggs, and egg curvature that helps to give all eggs a nearly equal contact
with the host.
In addition to its major importance as a veterinary pest, D . hominis is a
common pest of humans. Rarely it can cause fatalities, as when larvae
penetrate the fibrous portion of the bregmatic fontanel of infants (Rossi and
Zucoloro, 1972). As air travel increases, cases of human infestation with
D. hominis are recorded more frequently outside its natural range. Recent
reports in the literature have included cases not only in the New World (e.g.
USA: McIntyre, 1989; Lowry, 1992) but also in the Old World, in Belgium
(Deroo et al., 1990), England (Hay, 1990), France (Nderagakura et al.,
1989), Italy (Polidori et al., 1992), Poland (Wegner et al., 1986, 1992),
Japan (Maeda et al., 1990) and Saudi Arabia (Qadri and Al-Ahdal, 1988). In
addition to passive migration in humans, larvae of both D. hominis
(Bourdeau et al., 1988; Roosje et al., 1992) and Cordylobia anthropophaga
(Fox et af., 1992) have also been imported to Europe with dogs.
In contrast to Dermatobia, Cuterebra species have a virtually negligible
economic impact as they naturally parasitize rodents and lagomorphs
(Catts, 1982). However, they can parasitize humans in North America, as
reported in detail by Baird et al. (1989). Alouattamyia baeri is a cuterebrid
parasite of howler monkeys (Catts, 1982), but can cause a pulmonary
myiasis of man (Fraiha er al., 1984).
4.2. Calliphoridae
4.2.1. Cochliomyia
The distribution of New World screwworm fly, Cochliomyia hominivorax,
extends from the southern states of the USA through Central America and
the Caribbean Islands to northern Chile, Argentina and Uruguay. In North
America the fly used to spread north and west each summer into more
temperate zones from its overwintering areas near the USAhlexican
border. The fly was of greatest significance as a pest of livestock, neces-
sitating the continued costs of vigilance, treatment and control. In the
280 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
epidemic year of 1935 in Texas there were approximately 230 000 cases in
livestock and 55 in humans (Dove, 1935). Up to 1958, the annual cost of C.
hominivorax control in the United States was estimated to be US$140
million. Large-scale screwworm fly control, by sterile insect technique
(SIT), was initiated in the south eastern states of the United States of
America in 1957-59. Subsequent control operations spread the area of
sterile male release and in 1966 effective control of C. hominivorax in
the US was declared. Several outbreaks since then, most notably in 1968
and 1972, occurred but control was quickly reimposed and no cases of
infestation have been recorded since 1982. The eradication programme has
subsequently been directed against the fly in Mexico, Puerto Rico, Vieques
* and the Virgin Islands (Graham, 1985; Krafsur et al., 1987). SIT has been
advocated for use on other islands in the Caribbean region where it can be a
serious pest of livestock (Rawlins and Mansingh, 1987) and humans
(Rawlins, 1988).
In 1988, C. hominivorax were discovered in an area 10 km south of
Tripoli in Libya (Gabaj et al., 1989). This was the first known established
population of this species outside the Americas. The fly quickly spread to
infest about 25 000 km2. In 1989 there were about 150 cases of myiasis by
C. hominivorax, but in 1990 a total of 12 068 confirmed cases of screw-
worm fly myiasis were recorded and, at its peak, almost 3000 cases were
seen in the single month of September 1990, mainly in sheep. Humans
were also affected (El-Azazy, 1990; Reichard et al., 1992). It was esti-
mated that if unchecked the infestation could cost the Libyan livestock
industry about US$30 million per year and the North African region
approximately US$280 million per year (Lindquist et al., 1992). This led
to the implementation of a major international control programme to
eradicate the fly from this area (see section 6.4.2).
. Cochliomyia macellaria is a ubiquitous carrion breeder in the Americas,
but can act as a secondary invader of strikes, and is known as the
secondary screwworm fly. It can cause myiasis in humans, usually in
immobile or debilitated persons (Smith and Clevenger, 1986). A rare case
of Cochliomyia minima myiasis has been reported in a dog in Puerto Rico
(Lebn and Fox, 1980).
4.2.2. Chrysomya
The Old World screwworm fly Chrysomya bezziana screwworm is an
obligate parasite which occurs throughout much of Africa, India, the
Arabian peninsula, southeast Asia and the Indonesian and Philippine
islands to New Guinea (Norris and Murray, 1964; Spradbery and Kirk,
1992). The precise status of C. bezziana as a clinical and economic pest is
uncertain, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, and few studies have been
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 28 1
4.2.3. Lucilia
Twenty seven species have been described within the genus Lucilia, found
worldwide, although they are originally and predominantly Palaearctic and
Ethiopian in distribution (Aubertin, 1933). However, only two, Lucilia
sericata and Lucilia cuprina, are of major clinical and economic signifi-
cance as primary agents of cutaneous myiasis, particularly affecting sheep,
although they may also strike a range of other wild and domestic animals
and humans.
Cases of blowfly strike of sheep have been recorded from many parts of
nothern Europe where the primary species responsible is L. sericata. Sheep
strike by L. sericata has been recorded in the Netherlands (Baudet and
Nieschultz, 1938) and in Scandinavia (Rigndahl, 1942). In the summer of
1981 in north and west Germany, myiasis by L. sericata resulted in sheep
mortality rates of up to 10% (Liebisch et al., 1983). Lucilia sericata was
shown to be the most important primary agent of sheep myiasis in Scotland
(Ratcliffe, 1935; Haddow and Muirhead Thompson, 1937), Wales (Davies,
1934) and the Ukraine (Mashkei, 1990).
In a comprehensive national survey of sheep blowfly strike in Britain,
MacLeod (1943) found that L. sericata was by far the most important
primary myiasis fly; only in the western highlands of Scotland was it
found in less than 90% of all strikes. However, the Lucilia caesar group
(L. caesar and L. illustris), Protophormia terraenovae, and the bluebottles
Calliphora vicina and C . vomitoria were also found in small numbers,
though rarely in pure cultures, suggesting that they generally act only as
secondary agents of myiasis. In a more recent, though considerably less
detailed, study than that of MacLeod, samples of larvae were collected
'from strikes at spring shearing in England and Wales. The same general
pattern of species in myiases was confirmed, with 81% of strikes composed
of L. sericata alone, 13% of mixed cultures of L. sericata and L. caesar and
6% of L. caesar alone. No other species were found (Wall et al., 1992a).
Larvae of L. sericata in pure cultures have been collected from strikes on
domestic rabbits, dogs, cats and wild hedgehogs and birds which had been
brought into veterinary surgeries in the UK (Wall, unpublished data).
However, the extent to which existing injury predisposed these animals
was unknown. A pure culture of L. illustris has recently been recovered
from myiasis of a fox cub (Vulpes vulpes) in south west England (Wall,
unpublished data).
MYIASIS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 283
4.2.5. Calliphora
There are a great many species in this widely distributed genus, particularly
in the Holarctic and Australasian regions. Species of Calliphora are
primarily carrion feeders (e.g. Davies, 1990) but a number can act as
secondary or tertiary agents of myiasis (Zumpt, 1965). The two most
important species in the northern hemisphere are Calliphora vicina and
Calliphora vomitoria. Attempts to induce sheep strike by C . vicina proved
286 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
4.2.6. Cordylobia
As with Dermatobia, human movements carry infestations of Cordylobia
anthropophaga outside the endemic areas with increasing frequency, for
example, in Belgium (Hausdorfer-Scheiff et al., 1993), France (Gall et al.,
1987), Italy (Pampiglione et al., 1993), the UK (Chopra et al., 1985), Japan
(Kagei et al., 1989) and the USA (Ockenhouse et al., 1990). Of interest in
this regard is the acquisition of Cordylobia myiasis in northern Europe by
two brothers who had never been to Africa (Baily and Moody, 1985): the
explanation for this infestation was that their father, who had made several
recent trips to Africa, might have brought back eggs of the tumbu fly with
his baggage. More difficult to explain is the case of a British woman who
had also never been to Africa, but had acquired an infection with tumbu fly
in Spain (Laurence and Herman, 1973). It appears that C . anthropophaga
may not be restricted to sub-Saharan Africa as is usually stated (Zumpt,
1965): seven cases were recently reported originating in the Asir region
of southwestern Saudi Arabia (Omar and Abdalla, 1992).
A rare case of human myiasis due to C. rodhaini was reported from Italy,
in a patient returned from Ethiopia. The case was particularly severe
involving some 150 larvae (Pampiglione e f al., 1991).
4.3. Sarcophagidae
The most important genus acting as agents of myiasis in this family are
Wohlfahrtia, the key species being W. magnijica. It is considered to be the
most important myiasis-causing species of camels (Higgins, 1985), but is
even more important as a pest of sheep. Levels of infestation appear to be
higher in sheep in Eastern European countries (e.g. Bulgaria, 23-41%,
MYIASIS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 287
5. PHYSIOLOGY OF MYIASIS
5.1.1. Oestridae
Maia and Guimaries (1985) reported an association between abscesses on
cattle and infestation by Dermatobia hominis which can be explained by
the observations of Koone and Banegas (1959) that such abscesses
(including ongoing Dermatobia infestations) are attractive to important
egg vectors such as Sarcopromusca arcuata. Lesions of D . hominis on
cattle are not attractive to adult Cochliomyia hominivorax and therefore do
not usually become secondarily infested by screwworms (Thomas, 1987).
However, myiasis due to C. hominivorax was observed in some sheep after
removal of Dermatobia larvae (Amarante et al., 1992). In Sao Paulo State,
Brazil, sheep were affected by D. hominis after shearing, particularly in the
scrotum of rams (Amarante et al., 1992).
Within a single breed of cattle there may be considerable differences in
the rate of infestation of individuals by Dermatobia hominis (e.g. Maia
and Guimaries, 1985) and there is evidence for differences in breed
susceptibility. Steers of Bos indicus had significantly fewer naturally
acquired nodules of D. hominis than did steers of Bos taurus (14.6 versus
21.5 nodules, respectively; Moraes et al., 1986). Similarly, Oliveira and
Alencar (1992) showed that crosses of Holstein-Fresian and Guzera breeds
were increasingly susceptible to Dermatobia infestation as the proportion
288 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
sheep within flocks (Raadsma, 1987; Raadsma et al., 1989). There is,
therefore, the potential for selection for resistance to reduce the incidence
of this condition. In practice it is likely that indirect selection criteria, such
as for resistance to fleece rot, would be employed rather than direct
selection for resistance to body strike (Raadsma, 1991).
The risk of myiasis by L. sericata in England and Wales has been shown
to increase with increasing flock size and stocking density and to decrease
with increasing farm altitude and latitude (French et al., 1994a). In
Australia, flystrike was shown to be positively related to increases in the
density and activity of gravid L. cuprina, rainfall, cloud cover and the rate of
pasture growth (Wardhaugh and Morton, 1990). The analysis suggested that
rainfall determined overall levels of strike, whereas pasture conditions and
cloud cover determined the type of strike, with crutch strike replacing body
strike under dry conditions and when fly densities were low (Wardhaugh
and Morton, 1990).
Calving seemed to predispose camels to myiasis by Wohlfahrtia magni-
frca, gravid female flies being attracted to lochial fluids and damaged
tissues (Hadani et al., 1989).
5.2.1. Oestridae
The parasitic rhinitis caused by the larvae of Oestrus ovis is characterized
by a sticky and mucoid nasal discharge, at times haemorrhagic (Roncalli,
1984b). Histopathological changes in the nasal tissues of sheep and goats
due to infestation by 0. ovis were recorded by Jagannath et al. (1989a):
they were characterized by catarrh, infiltration of inflammatory cells and
squamous metaplasia, with conversion of secretory epithelium to stratified
squamous type. Yilma and Dorchies (1993) reported a significant reduction
in the population of 0. ovis artificially placed into sheep nostrils, which
they suggested was due to host immune reactions. Previously, Rogers and
Knapp (1973) had demonstrated levels of mortality of the immature stages
of 0. ovis ranging from 9699%. There is a danger in ovine oestrosis of
secondary infections leading to lung abscesses (Dorchies et al., 1993).
Harvey (1986) presents a comparative study of 30 cases of human
ophthalmomyiasis due to Oestrus ovis. The common symptom of all was
an acute conjunctivitis, 63% also showed lid oedema and 43% a superficial
punctate keratopathy,produced by movement of the larva across the cornea.
However, in rare cases the larva may invade the interior of the eye,
producing extensive retinal destruction and preretinal fibrosis (Rakusin,
1970).
290 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
infestations with D . hominis. They showed that the larvae of this species
elicit a humoral response from the host. The first instar larvae produced the
greatest host reaction and allowed the earliest detection of infestation by
ELISA. However, the initial immune response against antigens produced
by second and third instar larvae was depressed during the course of an
infestation, but started to increase as soon as the larvae left their host. This
suggests that immunosuppression may be a phenomenon of Dermatobia
infestation. Weisbroth et al. (1973) demonstrated that the antigens
provoking the immune response in rabbits naturally infected with Cuterebra
buccata resided in the alimentary tract and haemolymph fractions of
dissected larvae and that sensitization of the host occurred as a consequence
of exogenous larval secretions injected during feeding.
Dermatobia infestations also produce a cell-mediated immune response
(Lello and Peraqoli, 1993). Since immunization of rabbits with a crude
antigen of D . hominis led to higher levels of cellular response and antigen-
specific antibody production, vaccination against first instar larvae may be
a future means of biological control of this myiasis.
retractor and protractor muscles of the head contract and relax alternately,
while the mouth hooks are held in an adducted position. The semiliquid
material is then sucked through the oral aperture into the atrium (Barnard,
1977).
Sheep struck by L. cuprina display a rapid increase in temperature and
respiratory rate accompanied by loss of weight and appetite (Broadmeadow
et al., 1984). The animals become anaemic and suffer severe toxaemia,
with both kidney and heart tissues affected. A massive cellular infiltration
occurs in the skin of sheep within 48 h of primary or secondary infections
with L. cuprina, with a complex of cellular immune responses (Bowles et
al., 1992). The feeding activity of the larvae may cause extensive tissue
damage, which, in combination with the larval proteases produced (Bowles
‘et al., 1988), results in the development of inflamed, abraded or under-
mined areas of skin. This may result in considerable distress to the struck
animal, a loss of fertility (Heath et al., 1987) and, if untreated, rapidly leads
to death from chronic ammonia toxicity (Broadmeadow et al., 1984;
Guerrini, 1988).
Myiasis from a range of species has been shown to produce an immuno-
logical response in the host. Sheep struck by L . cuprina produce specific
antibodies in the serous exudate produced at the skin in response to the
feeding activity of larvae (O’Meara et al., 1991): sheep bred for resistance
to blowfly strike produce greater exudate protein release during infection
(O’Meara et al., 1992). Repeated exposure to four or five infestations of
these larvae at two-week intervals produces at least partial resistance to
reinfection (O’Donnell et al., 1981), but it is short-lived and requires
frequent larval exposure (Sandemann et al., 1992). Antibodies to whole
third instar larvae have been shown to be present in previously struck sheep
and significant mortality of larvae is observed in a challenged sheep, while
growth retardation is seen when larvae are cultured in vitro in the presence
of serum from previously infested sheep (Eisemann et al., 1990).
Larvae of Cordylobia anthropophaga rarely cause the severe pathology
in humans seen in infestations with Dermatobia hominis. They remain in
the skin or subcutaneous tissues and do not migrate into deeper tissues. The
skin surrounding the furuncles can become erythematous, oedematous and
tender to touch. An inflammatory infiltrate, consisting of lymphocytes,
histiocytes, neutrophils and eosinophils, extends throughout the tissues
around and below the larva (Ockenhouse er al., 1990). The larvae secrete
bacteriostatic fluid which can prevent secondary infections (Hausdorfer-
Scheiff et al., 1993). Blacklock and Thompson (1923) reported an acquired
immunity of dogs, guinea pigs, monkeys and humans to infestations by C.
anthropophaga and postulated at that early time that it might be possible to
immunize cattle against myiasis species, in particular Dermatobia and
Hypoderma.
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 293
There are basically three levels at which control of myiasis species can be
considered:
1. Suppression or eradication of fly population (e.g. eradication of
Cochliomyia hominivorax and Hypoderma species);
2. Avoidance of infestation where adult control is not possible (e.g. by fly
screening, dressing of wounds, prophylactic treatments);
3. Treatment because of failure of both above levels (removal of larvae
. manually or by insecticides, application of antibiotics).
The location of the parasites for much of their developmental stages on
the host means that control techniques can be very precisely targeted
against at least the larval stage. The precision of targeting and the propor-
tion of the population that can be reached depends on the host specificity of
the parasite (i.e. whether there are wild animal, reservoir hosts which
cannot be easily treated), and its degree of dependence on the host (i.e.
whether or not it is a facultative species that can also develop on carrion).
6.1. Insecticides
6.1.1. Oestridae
An aerosol technique using trichlorphon has been developed against
Oestrus ovis (Ilchmann and Splistester, 1982) and has been used for
large-scale treatment of sheep in Mongolia (Ilchmann et al., 1986). How-
ever, most treatments for 0. ovis are based on systemics, applied by
injection or oral dosing. Thus, Rafoxanide administered orally at a dose
rate of 7.5 and 10 mg kg-' gave 94100% and 100% effective cure,
respectively, of 0. ovis in sheep (Horak et al., 1971; Roncalli et al.,
1971). Injected at a rate of 3 mg kg-', it gave 94100% reduction in
larvae (Arm er al., 1982; Schindler et al., 1986). Following a preliminary
epidemiological survey that demonstrated three generations of 0. ovis per
year in south-west France, a control regimen of two treatments of Closantel
(10 mg kg-') at eight-week intervals was tested by Dorchies et al. (1992)
and found to be very effective in improving sheep condition and protecting
against late infections. Previously, Closantel had been shown to be effec-
tive in both cure and prevention of 0. ovis infection: 98% of larvae were
eliminated in treated animals and there was a 75% reduction in incidence in
treated animals compared to controls after eight weeks (Dorchies et al.,
1989).
294 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
hominis in calves that were experimentally infested with first instar larvae
(Moya-Borja et al., 1993a). Thus, 48 h after treatment with a subcutaneous
injection of Doramectin _at a dose rate of 200 pg kg-', the number of
Dermatobia nodules was significantly reduced compared both to pre-
treatment levels and to controls treated with saline: there was 100% reduc-
tion in nodules after 6 days. At the same dose rate, Doramectin gave at least
35 days protection from infection by first instar larvae. This ability to
protect cattle from infestation gives chemicals such as Doramectin a
marked advantage over those that are only effective in treating existing
infections since, in economic terms, it is more important to prevent hide
damage than treat animals with an infection that has already damaged the
hide (Moya-Borja et al., 1993a). Dermatobia hominis is a seasonal pest,
* especially in the southern parts of its range, populations appearing in the
rainy season and disappearing in the cool, dry seasons. Strategic treatment
of cattle with Doramectin at regular intervals could provide protection from
Dermatobia throughout the season of fly activity.
available for flea control (Zakson et af., 1992), may also prove an impor-
tant future direction for myiasis control. Insect growth regulators are
particularly suited for use in strategic pest control and integrated pest
management but, since they do not act immediately and often do not kill
the pest at the stage where damage occurs, a better understanding of the
ecology and population dynamics of the pest is required for their effective
use.
6.4.1. Oestridae
The major problem with application of SIT to oestrid flies is the extreme
difficulty of rearing the species. Beesley (1967) cultured first instar larvae
of Hypoderrna in vitro: a few moulted to second instar but did not develop
further. Techniques were described more recently for enhanced survival of
H. lineaturn in artificial media (Chamberlain and Scholl, 1991), but these
300 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
6.4.2. Calliphoridae
The use of SIT against the screwworm fly Cochliomyia hominivorax in
North and Central America, supported by insecticidal treatments of live-
stock, restrictions on movement of infected animals and an intensive
idormation campaign, has been documented in detail (Graham, 1985;
Krafsur et al., 1987). The New World screwworm is ideally suited to
mass rearing techniques, nowadays achieved using a gelled diet (Taylor,
1992). Mass production is aided by selection for laboratory traits of
increased fecundity and shortened development time, but these must be
balanced against selection for undesirable traits that reduce effectiveness of
the strain on release (Thomas, 1993b).
The inadvertent introduction of C. hominivorax screwworm flies in
North Africa in 1988 led to the implementation of an international pro-
gramme to eradicate the fly using SIT, co-ordinated by the Food and
Agriculture asanisation of the United Nations (Lindquist et al., 1992).
Cochliomyia hominivorax were reared at the screwworm production facil-
ity of the Mexican-American Commission for Eradication of Screw-worm
in Tuxtla Gutidrrez, Mexico. They were sterilized by exposure to gamma
MWASIS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 30 1
October 1985 to less than one female per hectare in May 1986, when
releases were terminated (Foster and Smith, 1991). The population
remained at below four females per hectare for the following 10 months
(Foster, 1989; R. Mahon, personal communication).
However, although the Hinders Island trial showed that it is possible to
reduce an isolated Lucilia population by this method, further trials in the
much larger Furneaux Island group, encountered significant problems.
Difficulties were experienced in rearing the 15 million modified flies
required per week to swamp the wild population and problems arose
from recombination within males carrying the translocation under large-
ssale rearing conditions. As a result of these considerations, together with
the expense of maintaining large-scale rearing facilities, removal of L.
cuprina from large areas of the Australian mainland using this technique
has not so far been attempted.
6.6. Vaccines
Much work has been carried out to characterize bovine immune responses
to Hypoderma infestations, reviewed by Baron and Weintraub (1987),
Baron and Colwell (1991b) and Scholl (1993). This work is based on the
observation that, generally, fewer larvae appear in the back of older cattle
than in calves or yearlings, implying that some immunity develops with
age. The principal antigens appear to be Hypoderma digestive enzymes and
four proteinase fractions have been identified: hypodermin A, hypodermin
B and hypodennin C (collagenase) and P2. Recent work by Baron and
Colwell (1991a) involved a comparison of calves immunized with a
purified combination of hypodermins A, B and C, and monophosphoryl
lipid A (MPL, a potent immune system stimulant), calves treated with MPL
alone and untreated control calves. All calves were given a subcutaneous
injection of 100 first instar larvae of H. lineatum one week after a two-week
immunization schedule. The maximum number of grubs appearing in the
back of the antigen+MPL group was significantly lower than that of the
other two groups, but the mean number of viable larvae (after death of
grubs in the back) was not different between the two treated groups,
although both were significantly lower than in the control group. MPL
enhanced antigen specific lymphocyte responsiveness in immunized calves
by completion of the immunization schedule. It also enhanced lymphocyte
responsiveness to antigen stimulation in calves receiving only MPL by four
weeks post-infection. Baron and Colwell (1991a) concluded that stimula-
tion of a strong antigen-specific cellular immune response prior to infesta-
tion could significantly reduce the survival of H. lineatum, but the role of
antibodies in that response remains to be determined. There is no apparent
304 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
foregut and midgut epithelial cells may be protected from antibodies by,
respectively, a cuticle layer and the peritrophic membrane.
(Cork, 1994). Such work might lead to new odour baits simulating wound
odours that attract a greater proportion of gravid females than swormlure.
Carrion-baited traps (Vogt and Havenstein, 1974; Williams, 1977) and
sticky traps (Wardhaugh et al., 1984) have been used for monitoring
populations of Lucilia cuprina and coloured, sticky targets for L. sericata
(Wall et al., 1992b, 1993a). Catches made by baited traps and targets are
however, subject to a considerable range of biases as a result of weather,
sex and stage in the reproductive cycle at which flies are more or less
attracted. All of these need to be considered in the interpretation of catch
data (Vogt et al., 1983, 1985b; Vogt and Morton, 1991; Spradbery and
Vogt, 1993; Wall, 1993).
that has dttracted increasing recent attention. However, most of the work
has beeg conducted on calliphorids and sarcophagids. This could usefully
be extended to further work on the behaviour of Oestridae, as shown by the
detailed studies of reindeer bot flies, Cephenemyia trompe, at reindeer and
reindeer-like traps (Anderson, 1975, 1989; Anderson and Nilssen, 1990).
It is clear that avermectins have had a dramatic impact on control of
myiasis species, oestrids in particular. However, the use of avermectins for
prophylactic control of myiasis will necessitate the maintenance of high
blood concentrations over long periods, administered by multiple treat-
ments or by rumenal bolus. Avermectins eliminated in cattle dung have
been shown to have a significant impact on non-target dung fauna, parti-
cularly beetle larvae, since a high proportion of the administered dose is
eliminated in the faeces where it may remain toxic (Strong, 1992). Con-
sequently such prophylaxis is likely to be environmentally undesirable,
although the debate is ongoing (Herd et al., 1993).
The recent introduction of Cochliomyia hominivorax into Libya, followed
by its costly eradication (US$75 million: Cunningham et al., 1992),
indicates the real need for more detailed information on the behaviour,
ecology and life cycles of myiasis species. Such information is important
not only for control programmes in the endemic areas but can provide
predictions on species performance in areas into which they might be
introduced as exotic pests. At its time of introduction to Libya, C . hornini-
vorax was not a notifiable pest and there were no international regulations
regarding the transport of infected livestock. It is now included on Disease
List B of the Office International des Epizooties (FAO, 1992). However,
myiasis due to Chrysomya bezziana is not included on the list despite the
facts that it has the potential to be as serious a pest as C. hominivorax
(Spradbery, 1994) and has previously been redistributed through countries
of the Persian Gulf with livestock (Rajapaksa and Spradbery, 1989). It is
worth noting that accidental transfer of screwworms in infested hosts is a
risk not just with animal vectors but with humans too (Mehr et al., 1991).
The current threat of reintroduction of Hypoderma to the UK is a further
example of the dangers of passage of myiasis species with infested live-
stock (Tarry, 1994). However, it should be remembered that such move-
ments of myiasis species are not a new phenomenon: Hypoderma,
Gasterophilus, Oestrus and Lucilia have all had their ranges greatly
extended by human activities.
There is considerable scope for further study of the interactions between
agents of myiasis and other parasites of domestic livestock, regarding
immunosuppression and the possibility of myiasis making animals more
susceptible to other diseases. Similarly, there is scope for further integra-
tion of monitoring and control programmes for myiasis species with those
for other diseases, for example, the monitoring for hypodermosis in the UK
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 31 1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are very grateful to all those who answered numerous requests for
reprints and other information on myiasis and to the staff of the Ento-
mology Library, Natural History Museum, for their great help in tracing
references. We are also grateful to Keith Wardhaugh, David Tarry and Paul
Ready for their comments on an earlier draft of the manuscript.
REFERENCES
Barrett, M. and Trevella, W. (1989). The immune response of the sheep popliteal
lymph node to a purified phenoloxidase from larval cuticle of the sheep
ectoparasite, Lucilia cuprina. Journal of Parasitology 75, 70-75.
Barton Browne, L., Van Gerwen, A.C.M. and Williams, K.L. (1979). Oocyte
resorption during ovarian development in the blowfly Lucilia cuprina. Journal
of Insect Physiology 25, 147-153.
Baruch, E., Godel, V., Lazar M., Gold, D. and Lengy, J. (1982). Severe external
ophthalmomyiasis due to larvae of Wohlfahrtia sp. Israel Journal of Medical
Sciences 18, 8 15-8 16.
Baudet, E.A.R.F. and Nieschultz, 0. (1938). Uber Fliegenlarveninfektion (Lucilia
seriata) bei Schafen im Wieringermeerpolder (Zuiderseegebiet). Zeitschrift f i r
Angewandte Entomologie 20, 324-325.
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 313
Broadmeadow, M., Gibson, J.E., Dimmock, C.K., Thomas, R.J. and O’Sullivan,
B.M. (1984). The pathogenesis of flystrike in sheep. Wool Technology and Sheep
Breeding 32, 28-32. -
Broce, A.B., Goodenough, J.L. and Coppedge, J.R. (1977). A wind oriented trap
for screwworm flies. Journal of Economic Entomology 70, 413-416.
Cameron, J.A., Shoukrey, N.A. and Al-Garni, A.A. (1991). Conjunctival
ophthalmomyiasis caused by the sheep nasal botfly (Oestrus ovis). American
Journal of Ophthalmology 112, 331-334.
Capelle, K.J. (1970). Studies on the life history and development of Cuterebra
polita (Diptera: Cuterebridae) in four species of rodents. Journal of Medical
Entomology 7 , 320-327.
Carpenter, T.L. and Chastain, D.O. ( 1992). Facultative myiasis by Megaselia sp.
(Diptera: Phoridae) in Texas: a case report. Journal of Medical Entomology 29,
56 1-563.
Catts, E.P. (1967). Biology of a Californian rodent bot fly Cuterebra latifrons
Coquillett (Diptera: Cuterebridae). Journal of Medical Entomology 4, 87-101.
Catts, E.P. (1982). Biology of New World bot flies: Cuterebridae. Annual Review
of Entomology 27, 318-338.
Chabaudie, N. and Boulard, C. (1992a). Effect of hypodermin A, an enzyme
secreted by Hypoderma lineatum (Insect Oestridae), on the bovine immune
system. Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology 31, 167-177.
Chabaudie, N. and Boulard, C. (1992b). Immunomodulation of the bovine defence
system by the larval secretions of Hypoderma bovis and H . lineatum. In
“Improvements in Control Methods for Warble-fly in Cattle and Goats”
(A. Gasca, S. Hernandez, J. Martinez, and K. Pithan, eds), pp. 115-131.
Commission of the European Communities EUR 1435 1, Brussels.
Chabaudie, N. and Boulard, C. (1993). In vitro and ex vivo responses of bovine
lymphocytes to hypodermin C, an enzyme secreted by Hypoderma lineatum
(Insect Oestridae). Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology 36, 153-162.
Chabaudie, N., Villejoubert, V. and Boulard, C. (1991). The response of cattle
vaccinated with hypodermin A to a natural infestation of Hypoderma bovis and
Hypoderma lineatum. International Journal for Parasitology 21, 859-862.
Chamberlain, W.F. and Scholl, P.J. (1991). New procedures to enhance survival of
third-instar Hypoderma lineatum (Villers) (Diptera: Oestridae) in artificial
media. Journal of Medical Entomology 28, 266-269.
Chodosh, J. and Clarridge, J. (1992). Ophthalmomyiasis: a review with special
reference to Cochliomyia hominivorax. Clinical Infectious Diseases 14,
444449.
Chopra, A., Probert, A.J. and Beer, W.E. (1985). Myiasis due to tumbu fly. Lancet
i, 1165.
Cogley, T.P. (1990). Morphology of the eggs of the rhinoceros bot flies Gyrostigma
conjugans and G . pavesii (Diptera: Gasterophilidae). International Journal of
Insect Morphology and Embryology 19, 323-326.
Cogley, T.P. (1991). Key to the eggs of the equid stomach bot flies Gasterophilus
Leach I8 17 (Diptera: Gasterophilidae) utilizing scanning electron microscopy.
Systematic Entomology 16, 125-1 33.
Cogley, T.P. and Anderson, J.R. (1983). Ultrastructure and function of the attach-
ment organ of Gasterophilus eggs (Diptera: Gasterophilidae). International
Journal of Insect Morphology and Embryology 12, 13-23.
Cogley, T.P. and Cogley, M.C. (1989). Morphology of the eggs of the human bot
fly, Dermatobia hominis (L. Jr.) (Diptera: Cuterebridae) and their adherence to
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 315
Hall, R.D. and Townsend, L.H. (1977). The insects of Virginia No. 11. Research
Division Bulletin 123, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.
Hall, R.D., Anderson, P.C. and Clark, D.P. (1986). A case of human myiasis caused
by Phormia regina (Diptera: Calliphoridae) in Missouri, USA. Journal of
Medical Entomology 23, 578-579.
Hammack, L. and Holt, G.G. (1983). Responses of gravid screwworm flies,
Cochliomyia hominivorax, to whole wounds, wound fluid and a standard blood
attractant in olfactometer tests. Journal of Chemical Ecology 9, 9 13-922.
Hammack, L., Bromel, M., Duh, F.M. and Gassner, G. (1987). Reproductive
factors affecting responses of the screwworm fly, Cochliomyia hominivorax
(Diptera: Calliphoridae), to an attractant of bacterial origin. Annals of the
Entomological Society of America 80, 775-780.
Haralampidis, S.T. ( 1987). ELISA in the seroepidemiology of parasitoses of sheep
and goats. Deltion tes Ellenikes Kteniatrikes Etaireias 38, 215-223.
' Harvey, J.T. (1986). Sheep botfly: ophthalmomyiasis externa. Canadian Journal of
Ophthalmology 21, 92-95.
Hasegawa, S., Miwata, H., Masuda, S., Naruse, H. and Ozaki, T. (1992). An
infantile case of intestinal myiasis. Acta Paediatrica Japonica 34, 87-89.
Haufe, W.O. and Nelson, W.A. (1957). Human furuncular myiasis caused by the
flesh fly Wohlfahrtia opaca (Coq.) (Sarcophagidae: Diptera). Canadian Entomol-
ogist 89, 325-327.
Hausdorfer-Scheiff, S., Bourland, A. and Pirard, Ch. ( 1993). Histopathological
aspects of myiasis. Dermatology 186, 298-300.
Hay, J. (1990). Dermatobia hominis myiasis in Leicester. Entomologist 109,
125-1 26.
Heath, A.C.G. and Bishop, D.M. (1986). Flystrike in sheep. Annual Report, 1985/86,
Wallaceville Animal Research Centre, Agricultural Research Division, 1 11-1 12.
Heath, A.C.G., Bishop, D.M. and Tenquist, J.D. (1987). The effects of artificially-
induced fly-strike on food intake and liveweight gain in sheep. New Zealand
Veterinary Journal 35, 50-52.
Hendrickx, M.O., Anderson, L., Boulard, C., Smith, D.G. and Weatherley, A.J.
(1993). Efficacy of doramectin against warble fly larvae (Hypoderma bovis).
Veterinary Parasitology 49, 75-84.
Herd, R., Strong, L. and Wardhaugh, K. (eds) (1993). Environmental impact of
avermectin usage in livestock. Veterinary Parasitology (Special Issue) 43, 344
PP.
Higgins, A.J. (1985). The camel in health and disease. 4. Common ectoparasites of
the camel and their control. British Veterinary Journal 141, 197-216.
Hjra, P.R., Hajj, B., AI-Ali, F. and Hall, M.J.R. (1993). Ophthalmomyiasis in
Kuwait: first report of infections due to larvae of Oestrus ovis before and after
the Gulf Conflict. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 96, 241-244.
Hope, F.W. (1840). On insects and their larvae occasionally found in the human
body. Transactions of the Royal Entomological Society of London 2, 256-271.
Horak, I.G. (1987). Arthropod parasites of some wild animals in South Africa and
Namibia. Journal of the South African Veterinary Association 58, 207-21 1.
Horak, I.G. and Boomker, J. (1981). Strobiloestrus sp. larvae in cattle. Journal of
the South African Veterinary Association 52, 21 1-212.
Horak, I.G. and Snijders, A.J. (1974). The effect of Oestrus ovis infestation on
Merino lambs. Veterinary Record 94, 12-16.
Horak, I.G., Louw, J.P. and Raymond, S.M. (1971). Trials with rafoxanide. 3.
Efficacy of rafoxanide against the larvae of the sheep nasal bot fly Oestrus
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 321
ovis, LinnB, 1761. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medicine Association
42,337-339.
Humphrey, J.D., Spradbery, J.P. and Tozer, R.S. (1980). Chrysomya bezziana:
pathology of old world screw-worm fly infestations in cattle. Experimental
Parasitology 49, 38 1-397.
Hussein, M.F., Elamin, F.M., El-Taib, N.T. and Basmaeil, S.M. (1982). The
pathology of nasopharyngeal myiasis in Saudi Arabian camels (Camelus drome-
-&mius).Veterinary Parasitology 9, 253-260.
Ilchmann, G. and Splistester, H. (1982). Aerosolbedhandlung bei der oestrose der
Schafe. Tagungsbericht 197, 8 1-85.
Ilchmann, G., Betke, P., Grafe, D. and Gossing, S. (1986). Untersuchungen zur
oestrose und ihre bekiimpfung in der Mongolischen Volksrepublik. Monatshefte
f i r Veterinarmedizin 41, 128-132.
Ilchmann, G., Montag, Th., Brose, E. and Nisafi, A. (1989). Zum Proteinmuster
von Gasterophilus intestinalis - larven (Diptera: Gasterophilidae), Psoroptes
cuniculi und Chorioptes bovis (Acarida: Psoroptidae). Angewandte Parasitologie
30, 1 1 1-1 15.
Isimbekov, Zh.M. and Zhanuzakov, N.Zh. (1983). Wohlfahrtiasis of sheep in
Kazakhstan and prophylactic measures against it. In “Parazitozy sel’skokho-
zyaistvennykh zhivotnykh Kazakhstana i mery ikh preduprezhdeniya” (N.Zh.
Zhanuzakov, ed.), pp. 52-62. Kazakhskii Nauchno-Issledovatel’skii Veterinarnyi
Institut, Alma-Ata.
Jackson, H.C. (1989). Ivermectin as a systemic insecticide. Parasitology Today 5,
146-156.
Jagannath, M.S., Cozab, N. and Vijayasarathi, S.K. (1989a). Histopathological
changes in the nasal passages of sheep and goats infested with Oestrus ovis
(Diptera: Oestridae). Indian Journal of Animal Sciences 59, 87-9 1.
Jagannath, M.S., Cozab, N., Abdul Rahman, S. and Honnappa, T.G. (1989b).
Incidence of Oestrus ovis in sheep and goats. Indian Journal of Animal Sciences
59, 1216-1219.
Jagannath, M.S., Cozab, N., Abdul Rahman, S. and Honnappa, T.G. (1989~).
Serodiagnosis of Oestrus ovis infestation in sheep and goats. Indian Journal of
Animal Sciences 59, 1220-1 224.
James, M.T. (1947). The flies that cause myiasis in man. United States Department
of Agriculture Miscellaneous Publication No. 631, 175 pp.
James, M.T. (1969). A study in the origin of parasitism. Bulletin of the Entomo-
logical Society of America 15, 25 1-253.
Johnson, L.S. and Albrecht, D.J. (1993). Effects of haematophagous ectoparasites
on nestling house wrens, Troglodytes aedon: who pays the cost of parasitism.
Oikos 66,255-262.
Johnston, L.A.Y., Eisemann, C.H., Donaldson, R.A., Pearson, R.D. and Vuocolo,
T. (1992). Retarded growth of Lucilia cuprina larvae on sheep and their sera
following production of an immune response. International Journal for
Parasitology 22, 187-193.
Jones, C.M., Oehler, D.D., Snow, J.W. and Grabbe, R.R. (1976). A chemical
attractant for screwworm flies. Journal of Economic Entomology 69, 389-391.
Jordan, P.A., Botkin, D.B. and Wolfe, M.L. (1971). Biomass dynamics in a moose
population. Ecology 52, 147-152.
Kagei, N., Murata, I. and Kurahashi, H. (1989). An imported case of myiasis
caused by a larva of Cordylobia anthropophaga from Africa. Japanese Journal
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 17, 347-350.
322 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
Kalelioglu, M., Aktiirk, G., Aktiirk, F., Komsuoglu, S.S., Kuzeyli, K., Tigin, Y.,
Karaer, Z. and Bingol, R. (1989). Intracerebral myiasis from Hypoderma bovis
larva in a child. Journal of Neurosurgery 71, 929-931.
Kal’vish, T.K. ( 1990). Morphophysiological features of the entomopathogenic
fungus Tolypocladium niveum (0. Rostr.) Bissett (Deuteromycotina:
Moniliales) new to the flora of the USSR. Mikologiya i Fitopatologiya 24,
210-215.
Karter, A.J., Folstad, I. and Anderson, J.R. (1992). Abiotic factors influencing
embryonic development, egg hatching, and larval orientation in the reindeer
warble fly, Hypoderma tarandi. Medical and Veterinary Entomology 6,355-362.
Kearney, M.S., Nilssen, A.C., Lyslo, A., Syrdalen, P. and Dannevig, L. (1991).
Ophthalmomyiasis caused by the reindeer warble fly larva. Journal of Clinical
Pathology 44, 276-284.
Keech, J.P. (1981). Dermatobia hominis - in kelize. Journal of the Royal Army
Medical Corps. 127, 131-133.
Kenney, M. (1945). Experimental intestinal myiasis in man. Proceedings of the
Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine 60, 235-237.
Kettle, D.S. ( 1990). “Medical and Veterinary Entomology”. Reprinted by CAB
International, Wallingford, 658 pp.
Kim, K.C. and McPheron, B.A. (eds) (1993). “Evolution of Insect Pests: Patterns
of Variation.” John Wiley, New York, 479 pp.
Kirby, W. and Spence, W. (1815). “An Introduction to Entomology”. London,
Volume 1, edition 3, 5 19 pp.
Knipling, E.F. (1955). Possibilities of insect control or eradication through the use
of sexually sterile males. Journal of Economic Entomology 48, 459462.
Komari, K., Hara, K., Smith, K.G.V., Oda, T. and Karamine, D. (1978). A case of
lung myiasis caused by larvae of Megaselia spiracularis Schmitz (Diptera:
Phoridae). Transactions of the Royal Sociery of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
72,467-470.
Koone, H.D. and Banegas, A.D. (1959). Biology and control of Dermatobia hominis
(L. Jr.) in Honduras. Journal of Kansas Entomological Society 32, 100-108.
Krafsur, E.S., Whitten, C.J. and Novy, J.E. (1987). Screwworm eradication in north
and central America. Parasitology Today 3, 131-137.
Kremer, M., Lenys, J., Basset, M., Rombourg, H. and Molet, B. (1970). Deux cas
de myiase a Cordylobia rodhaini contractke au Cameroun et diagnostiqute en
Alsace. Bulletin de la Sociktk de Pathologie Exotique 63, 592-596.
Kunz, S.E., Scholl, P.J., Colwell, D.D. and Weintraub, J. (1990). Use of sterile
insect releases in an IPM program for control of Hypoderma lineatum and H .
bovis (Diptera: Oestridae): a pilot test. Journal of Medical Entomology 27, 523-
529.
Lancaster, J.L. and Meisch, M.V. (1986). “Arthropods in Livestock and Poultry
Production”. Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 402 pp.
Lane, R.P., Lovell, C.R., Griffiths, W.A.D. and Sonnex, T.S. (1987). Human
cutaneous myiasis - a review and report of three cases due to Dermatobia
hominis. Clinical and Experimental Dermatology 12, 4 0 4 5 .
Laurence, B.R. and Herman, F.G. (1973). Tumbu fly (Cordylobia)infection outside
Africa. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine 67, 888.
Lehrer, A.Z. and Verstraeten, C. ( 1991). Expansion parasitologique et gtographi-
que de Wohlfahrtia magnijica (Schiner) (Diptera Sarcophagidae) en Roumanie.
Bulletin des Recherches Agronomiques de Gembloux 26, 563-567.
Lehrer, A.Z., Lehrer, M. and Verstraeten, C. (1988). Les myiases caustes aux
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 323
moutons de Roumanie par Wohlfahrtia magnifica (Schiner) (Diptera
Sarcophagidae). Annales de Me‘decine Ve‘te‘rinaire132, 4 7 5 4 8 1.
Leiper, J.W.G. (1951). A new approach to phenothiazine therapy in sheep. Veter-
inary Record 63, 885-889.
Lello, E. de and Boulard, C. (1990). Rabbit antibody responses to experimental
infestation with Dermatobia hominis. Medical and Veterinary Entomology 4,
303-309.
Lello, E. and Peraqoli, M.T.S. (1993). Cell-mediated and humoral immune
responses in immunized and/or Dermatobia hominis infested rabbits. Veterinary
Parasitology 47, 129-138.
Lello, E. de, Greg6ri0, E.A.P. and Toledo, L.A. (1985). Desenvolvimento das
Gonadas de Dermatobia hominis (Diptera: Cuterebridae). Memorias do Instituto
Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro 80, 159-170.
Le6n. D. de and.Fox, I. (1980). Canine minima myiasis in Puerto Rico - a case
report. Journal of Agriculture of the University of Puerto Rico 64, 126-128.
Liakos, B.D. (1986). Effects of hypodermatosis on the body weight of young goats.
Bulletin of the Hellenic Veterinary Medical Society 37, 8-1 2.
Liebisch, A., Froehner, H. and Elger, D. (1983). Myiasis in sheep caused by Lucilia
sericata - an approaching problem? Tierarztliche Umschau 38, 747.
Li b o n g , P.T., Lui, H. and Buck, H.W. (1992). Cutaneous myiasis: a simple and
effective technique for extraction of Dermatobia hominis larvae. International
Journal of Dermatology 31, 657-659.
Lindquist, D.A., Abusowa, M. and Hall, M.J.R. (1992). The New World screw-
worm fly in Libya: a review of its introduction and eradication. Medical and
Veterinary Entomology 6 , 2-8.
Lonsdale, B., Tarry, D.W., Bowen, F.L. and Stansfield, D.G. (1990). Cyromazine
pour-on for the prevention of cutaneous myiasis of sheep. Veterinary Record
126,207-210.
Losson, B., Lonneux, J.F. and Pithan, K. (eds) (1993). “Improvements in the
Control Methods for Warble-fly in Cattle and Goats”. Commission of the
European Communities COST 81 1, Brussels, 127 pp.
Louw, J.P. (1989). Overberg research projects. V1. The biology and control of
Oestrus ovis in sheep in the winter rainfall areas of the Southern Cape.
Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research 56, 239-244.
Lowry, M.A. (1992). Dermatobia hominis infestation: a case report. Military
Medicine 157, 683-684.
Lukin, L.G. (1989). Human cutaneous myiasis in Brisbane: a prospective study.
Medical Journal of Australia 150, 237-240.
Lysyk, T.J.,Colwell, D.D. and Baron, R.W. (1991). A model for estimating
abundance of cattle grub (Diptera: Oestridae) from the proportion of uninfested
cattle as determined by serology. Medical and Veterinary Entomology 5,
253-25 8.
Mackerras, I.M. and Fuller, M.E. (1937). A survey of the Australian sheep
blowflies. Journal of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research
(Australia) 10, 261-270.
Mackerras, I.M., Fuller, M.E., Austen, K.M.and Lefroy, E.H.B. (1936). Sheep
blowfly investigations: the effect of trapping on the incidence of strike in sheep.
Journal of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (Australia) 9,
153-162.
Mackley, J.W. and Brown, H.E. (1984). Swormlure-4: A new formulation of the
Swormlure-2 mixture as an attractant for adult screwworms Cochliomyia
324 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
the sexual behaviour and longevity of Dermatobia hominis (L. Jr.). Revista
Brasileira de Biologia 41, 237-241.
Moya-Borja, G.E. and Borkovec, A. (1981). Sexual sterility of Dermatobia homi-
nis (Linnaeus Jr.) induced by chemosterilants. Revista Brasileira de Biologia 41,
5 1-56.
Moya-Borja, G.E., Muniz, R.A., Sanavria, A., Goncalves, L.C.B. and Rew, R.S.
(1993a). Therapeutic and persistent efficacy of doramectin against Dermatobia
hominis in cattle. Veterinary Parasitology 49, 85-93.
Moya-Borja, G.E., Oliveira, R.A., Muniz, R.A. and Goncalves, L.C.B. (1993b).
Prophylactic and persistent efficacy of doramectin against Cochliomyia
hominivorax in cattle. Veterinary Parasitology 49, 95-1 05.
Nagakura, K., Kawauichi-Kato, Y.,Tachibana, H.,Kaneda, Y.,Shinonaga, S. and
,Kano,R. (1991). Three cases of intestinal myiasis in Japan. Journal of Infectious
’Diseases 163, 1170-1 171.
Nderagakura, F., Smail, A., Chardonnier, J. and Devauchelle, B. (1989). Les
myiases: localisations faciales. A propos d’une observation d’infestation A
Dermatobia hominis. Revue Stomatologie et Chirurgie Maxillo-Faciale 90,7-16.
Nedelchev, N.K. (1988). Distribution and causes of myiasis among farm animals.
Veterinarna Sbirka 86, 33-35. (In Bulgarian).
Noireau, F. ( 1992). Infestation by Auchmeromyia senegalensis as a consequence
of the adoption of non-nomadic life by Pygmies in the Congo Republic.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 86, 329.
Noms, K.R. (1990). Evidence for the multiple exotic origin of Australian
populations of the sheep blowfly Lucilia cuprina (Weidemann) (Diptera:
Calliphoridae). Australian Journal of Zoology 38, 635648.
Noms, K.R. and Murray, M.D. (1964). Notes on the screw-worm fly, Chrysomya
bezziana (Diptera: Calliphoridae), as a pest of cattle in New Guinea. Technical
Paper of the Division of Entomology, CSIRO Australia, No. 6.
Nunzi, E., Rongioletti, F. and Rebora, A. (1984). Dermatobia hominis infestation.
Postgraduate Medical Journal 60, 162-1 63.
Nunzi, E., Rongioletti, F. and Rebora, A. (1986). Removal of Dermatobia hominis
larvae. Archives of Dermatology 122, 140.
Nuorteva, P. (1987). Empty puparia of Phormia terraenovae R.D. (Diptera:
Calliphoridae) as forensic indicators. Annals Entomologica Fennica 53, 53-56.
O’Brien, D.J. and Fahey, G. (1991). Control of fly strike in sheep by means of a
pour-on formulation of cyromazine. Veterinary Record 129, 35 1-353.
Ockenhouse, C.F., Samlaska, C.P., Benson, P.M., Roberts, L.W., Eliasson, A.,
Malane, S. and Menich, M.D. (1990). Cutaneous myiasis caused by the African
tumbu fly (Cordylobia anthropophaga). Archives of Dermatology 126, 199-202.
O’Donnell, I.J., Green, P.E., Connell, J.A. and Hopkins, P.S. (1981). Immunization
of sheep with larval antigens of Lucilia cuprina. Australian Journal of Biological
Science 34,411417.
Oliveira, G.P. de (1991a). Dingmica parasitlria de bernes em bovinos 1. IncidEncia
em relaGao ao declibito. Pesquisa Agropecuhria Brasileira 26, 4 6 7 4 7 1.
Oliveira, G.P. de (1991b). Ecologia de Dermatobia hominis L. Jr. 1781 (Diptera:
Cuterebridae) na R e g l o de Sgo Carlos, Estado de SHo Paulo, Brasil, Turrialba
41, 367-375.
Oliveira, G.P. de (1991~).Dingmica parasitibia de Dermatobia hominis L. Jr.
1781, em bovinos. 11. Densidade, relaqgo entre regices corp6reas e efeito da
“vassoura” caudal. Turrialba 41, 359-366.
Oliveira, G.P. de (1991d). Epidemiologia de Dermatobia hominis (L. Jr. 1781)
326 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
Payne, J.A. and Cosgrove, G.E. (1966). Tissue changes following Cuterebra
infestation in rodents. American Midland Naturalist 75, 205-2 13.
Podmogil’naya, A.P. (1983). Wohlfahrtia myiasis in sheep in the southern Urals
and its control. In “Veterinamaya Entomologiya i Akarologiya” (Nepoklonov,
A.A. ed.), pp. 177-182. Series Nauchnye Trudy Vaskhnil, Moscow.
Pokidov, 1.1. and Goncharov, A.P. (1971). Problems of the control of wohlfahrtiosis
in shekp. Veterinariya, Moscow 7 , 25-31.
Polidon“, G.A., Principato, M., Amenduni, M. and Bussani, F. (1992). Miasi
cutanea da Dermatobia hominis: aspetti zoonosici ed interesse zootecnico della
parassitosi. PRAXIS Veterinaria 13, 26-28.
Portchinsky, I.A. (1916). Wohlfahrtia magnifica, Schin., and allied Russian
species. The biology of this fly and its importance to man and domestic
animals. Memoirs of the Bureau Entomology Scientific Committee Central
Board of Lartd Administration and Agriculture Petrograd 11, 1-108 (In
Russian).
Puccini, V., Tassi, P. and Anu, E. (1983). Efficacia dell’ ivermectina iniettabile
contx’o le larvea di Oestrus ovis (L. 1761) in ovini infettati naturalmente. Atti
della Societa Italiana della Scienze Veterinarie 37, 732-734.
Puccini, V., Tassi, P., Spinto, S. and Gaggiano, G. (1987). Infection by the warble
fly Przhevalskiana silenus Brauer in Italian goats - an update. In “Warble Fly
Control in Europe. IV” (Puccini, V. and Tassi, P. eds) pp. 25-42. Symposium in
the Programme of Coordination of Research on Hypodermosis, Bari, April 9-1 1.
Qadri, S.M.H., Al-Ahdal, M.N. (1988). Cutaneous myiasis due to Dermatobia
hominis: report of a case. Annals of Saudi Medicine 8, 286-287.
Quesada, P., Navarrete, M.L. and Maeso, J. (1990). Nasal myiasis due to Oestrus
ovis larvae. European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 247, 13 1-132.
Raadsma, H.W. (1987). Flystrike control: an overview of management and
breeding options. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding 35, 174-185.
Raadsma, H.W. (1991). Fleece rot and body strike in Merino sheep. V. Heritability
of liability to body strike in weaner sheep under flywave conditions. Australian
Journal of Agricultural Research 42, 279-293.
Raadsma, H.W., Gilmour, A.R. and Paxton, W.J. (1989). Fleece rot and body strike
in Merino sheep. I1 Phenotypic and genetic variation in liability to fleece rot
following experimental induction. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research
40,207-220.
Rajapaksa, N. and Spradbery, J.P. (1989). Occurrence of the Old World screw-
worm fly Chrysomya bezziana on livestock vessels and commercial aircraft.
Australian Veterinary Journal 66, 94-96.
Rakusin, W. (1970). Ocular myiasis intema caused by the sheep nasal bot fly
(Oestrus ovis L.). South African Medical Journal 44, 1155-1 157.
Rapoza, P.A., Michels, R.G., Semeraro, R.J. and Green, W.R. (1986). Vitrectomy
for excision of intraocular larva (Hypoderma species). Retina 6, 99-104.
Rastegayev, Yu.M. (1984). Ecological characteristics of the warble and bot flies
attacking horses (Diptera: Oestridae, Gasterophilidae) in the desert zone of the
Caspian region. Entomologicheskoye Obozreniye 63, 455-459.
Rastegayev, Yu.M. (1988). Efficacy of ivermectin against Rhinoestrus and
Gasterophilus in horses. Izvestiya Akademii Nauk Turkmenskoi SSR, Seriya
Biologicheskikh Nauk 6, 67-69.
Ratcliffe, F.N. (1935). Observations on the sheep botfly (Lucilia sericata Meig.) in
Scotland. Annals of Applied Biology 22, 742-753.
328 MARTIN HALL AND RICHARD WALL
Tenquist, J.D. and Wright, D.F. (1976). The distribution, prevalence and economic
importance of blowfly strike in sheep. New Zealand Journal of Experimental
Agriculture 4, 291-295.
Thomas, D.B. Jr. (1987). Incidence of screwworm (Diptera: Calliphoridae) and
Torsalo (Diptera: Cuterebridae) myiasis on the Yucatan Peninsula of Mexico.
Journal of Medical Entomology 24: 498-502.
Thomas, D.B. (1988). The pattern of Dermatobia (Diptera: Cuterebridae) myiasis
in cattle in Tropical Mexico. Joltrnal of Medical Entomology 25, 131-135.
Thomas, D.B. (1993a). Behavioural aspects of screwworm ecology. Journal of the
Kansas Entomological Society 66, 13-30.
Thomas, D.B. (1993b). Fecundity and oviposition in laboratory colonies of the
screwworm fly (Diptera: Calliphoridae). Journal of Economic Entomology 86,
1464-1472.
’
Thomas, D.B. and Mangan, R.L. (1989). Oviposition and wound visiting behaviour
of the screwworm fly, Cochliomyia hominivorax (Diptera: Calliphoridae).
Annals of the Entomological Society of America 82, 526-534.
Thomas, D.B. and Pruett, J.H. (1989). Antibodies to antigens of Cochliomyia
hominivorax (Coquerel) (Diptera: Calliphoridae) in the sera of infested sheep.
A serological technique for the detection of screwworm myiasis. Journal of
Entomological Science 25, 143-149.
Thomas, D.B. and Pruett, J.H. (1992). Kinetic development and decline of anti-
screwworm (Diptera: Calliphoridae) antibodies in serum of infested sheep.
Journal of Medical Entomology 29, 870-873.
Tillyard, R.J. and Seddon, H.R. (1933). The sheep blowfly problem in Australia.
Report No. 1 of the Joint Blowfly Committee. Council for Scientific and
Industrial Research, Australia Pamphlet, No. 37.
Torr, S.J. and Hall, M.J.R. (1992). Odour-baited targets to control New World
screwworm (Cochliomyia hominivorax (Coquerel): Diptera: Calliphoridae): a
preliminary study. Bulletin of Entomological Research 82, 4 1 7 4 2 3 .
Townend, C. (1987). Sheep strike and mulesing. Parasitology Today 3, 68-69.
Townsend, C.H.T. (1935). “Manual of Myiology. Part 11: Muscoid Classification
and Habits.” Charles Townsend and Filhos, Silo Paulo, Brazil, 296 pp.
Uttamchandani, R.B., Trigo, L.M., Poppiti, R.J., Rozen, S. and Ratzan, K.R.
( 1989). Eosinophilic pleural effusion in cutaneous myiasis. Southern Medical
Journal 82, 1288-1 29 1.
Uribe, L.F., McMullin, P.F., Cramer, L.G. and Amaral, N.K. (1989). Topically
applied ivermectin: efficacy against Torsalo (Diptera: Cuterebridae). Journal of
Economic Entomology 82, 847-849.
‘Vinogradova, E.B. (1986). Geographical variation and ecological control of
diapause in flies. In “The Evolution of the Insect Life Cycle” (F. Taylor and
K. Karban, eds), pp. 3 5 4 7 , Springer, New York.
Vogt, W.G. and Havenstein, D.E. (1974). A standardized bait trap for blowfly
studies. Journal of the Australian Entomological Society 13, 249-253.
Vogt, W.G. and Morton, R. (1991). Estimation of population size and survival of
sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina, in the field from serial recoveries of marked flies
affected by weather dispersal and age-dependent trappability. Researches on
Population Ecology 33, 141-163.
Vogt, W.G., Woodburn, T.L., Morton, R. and Ellem, B.A. (1983). The analysis
and standardisation of trap catches of Lucilia cuprina (Weidemann) (Diptera:
Calliphoridae). Bulletin of Entomological Research 73, 609-617.
Vogt, W.G., Woodburn, T.L. and van Gerwen, A.C.M. (1985a). The influence of
MYlASlS OF HUMANS AND DOMESTIC ANIMALS 333
Marek Kaliszewski
FranGoise Athias-Binche
Evert E. Lindquist
1. Introduction .
....... .... ....... ...
.. ....... 336
2. Phoresy, a Pre-adaptation for Parasitism and Parasitoidism? ....... 337
3. Physogastry, a Pre-adaptation for Parasitoidism? . . . ......... 341
* This paper was initiated by the first and second authors. This collaboration was suddenly
interrupted by the tragic death of Dr Marek Kaliszewski in an automobile accident in
October 1992. Thereafter, the third author kindly agreed to augment and complete the
manuscript. The world of acarology lost in M. Kaliszewski one of its most dynamic and
innovative young scientists. This paper is dedicated to his memory.
1. INTRODUCTION
development, and it feeds during only one stage of its development (i.e., as
a larva but not as an adult, or vice versa) (Lindquist, 1983).
HETEROSTIGMATA
DOUCHOCYBOIDEA
TARSONEMINA TROCEOUETRIDIOIDEA
by other authors, e.g. Mahunka (1970), Lindquist (1973, 1986) and Krantz
(1978), and this requires some explanation here. Krantz’s (1978) manual
largely followed Mahunka’s (1970) classification of the Tarsonemina in
having three superfamilies: Pyemotoidea with four families, Dolichocybi-
dae, Caraboacaridae, Pyemotidae, and Acarophenacidae; Pygmephoroidea
with three families, Scutacaridae, Pygmephoridae (including Trocho-
metridiinae and Siteroptinae as subfamilies), and Microdispidae; and
Tarsonemoidea with two families (Tarsonemidae and Podapolipidae).
Lindquist ( 1986) recognized that Trochometridiidae and Dolichocybidae
had to be accommodated in separate superfamilies to account for their
more ancestral, sequential relationships as out-groups to the other super-
families. More recently, the senior author’s continuing cladistic studies
indicated additional classificatory changes, including recognition of
Scutacaroidea (with families Scutacaridae and Microdispidae) as a sister
superfamily separate from Pygmephoroidea (with Pygmephoridae and
Siteroptidae as separate families) and transfer of Caraboacaridae from
Pyemotoidea to Trochometridioidea, hich also includes Athyreacaridae
‘$I
as described by Lindquist et al. (1990 , This classification is summarized
by the dendrogram in Figure 1. The phylogenetic rationale for most of its
branching sequences, based on apomorphies, is presented by Lindquist
(1976, 1986); however, the basis for the sister branches Scutacaroidea
and Pygmephoroidea has yet to be presented, and that for the branch
Trochometridioidea needs further refinement.
PARASITISM AND PARASlTOlDlSM IN TARSONEMINA 343
Little is known about the ways of life of species of the one family in this
group, which is recognized as the earliest derivative, or most “primitive”,
among the described families of Tarsonemina (Lindquist, 1986). Never-
theless, these mites are highly specialized morphologically, and also
manifest several specialized biological attributes (Figures 3-6). They
appear to be associated with subsocial and social insects, particularly
beetles and ants, on which they are phoretic as adult females. Rack
(1967) documented that adult females of Dofichocybe hippocastani Rack
are fungivorou’s,undergo extensive hysterosomal phy sogastry during feed-
ing, and give rise to adult male and female progeny. Physogastric females
produced from 30 to 200 progeny each, with the sex ratio strongly biased
towards females; 70% to 96% of progeny were females. Most progeny
included three to nine males. Mating occurred either inside the dying
maternal body sphere or immediately after birth. Birth appeared to be a
mass emergence of several to many females and males together through
ruptures of the maternal body sphere, rather than sequentially through a
birth canal. Multiple matings of new adult females with the same or
different males were observed. Multiple matings with different males
may reflect the lesser degree of sexual dimorphism in Dolichocybidae,
with concomitant lack of special leg modification in the males for selec-
tive precopulatory transport of females, in contrast to those found to some
extent in all other superfamilies of Tarsonemina. When Rack (1973)
described Dolichomotes crossi Rack, she noted that one female was gravid
and strongly physogastric, containing about 47 progeny. Feeding habits
were not confirmed but the sample of mites was collected under bark of
walnut trees (Jugfans),where fungal growth probably occurred. Similarly,
Dofichocybe keiferi Krantz was collected from dying limbs of maple trees
(Acer),where there was some fungal growth and some of the female mites
were noted as “swollen” (Krantz, 1957). The phenomenon of adult female
dimorphism has been determined for one member of this family, in the
genus Formicomotes, by Magowski (1988). The biological aspects of
fungivory, extensive opisthosomal physogastry, high fecundity (105-355
progeny per female), and strongly female-biased sex ratio (c. 98% female)
of Formicomotes heteromorphus Magowski, as reported by Kantaratanakul
e f al. (1989), are similar to those mentioned above for B.hippocastani. In
general, dolichocybid mites do not appear to be parasites of their hosts.
However, their adult females, basically fungivorous, physogastric, and
phoretic, may in some cases have undergone adaptations in the direction
of facultative parasitoidism, as discussed next for Trochometridium.
344 MAREK KALISZEWSKI ET AL
mum
above, fungivory with physogastry has been documented for adult females
in the Dolichocybidae, the earliest derived family of Tarsonemina which is
known.
\ 9
I
'7'
I
T
14 15
17
and are frequently encountered in insect cultures and stored foods. The
ubiquitous and euryxenous Pyemotes tritici (Lagr&ze-Fossat and
MontagnC) is a significant mortality factor for stored product insects
(Tawfik et al., 1981). It has been used (under the name P . helfsi) in
biological control of insects such as the pink bollworm, Pectinophora
gossypiellu (Saunders), in Egypt (Tawfik and Awadallah, 1971), and it
has even been introduced for biological control of the imported fire ant,
Solenopsis invicta Buren, in the United States with inconsistent success
(Bruce and LeCato, 1980; Thorvilson and Phillips, 1987). All attacked prey
die immediately, paralysed by neuromuscular toxins, and the mite attacks
all instars of the host. Thus, this form should be considered as a micro-
predator, the mite being much smaller than its prey. This species manifests
one of the highest reproductive rates known for any animal (Bruce and
Wrensch, 1990), with such attributes as a short life cycle (4-7 days), no
intermediate host, numerous progeny (average 254, maximum number
observed 355), all development of progeny occurring within the mother’s
engorged body, and all offspring born as sexually mature adults. Females
represent 95-99% of the population, and they mate immediately after birth
and seek a host. Populations are easily cultured in the laboratory, and the
species is routinely commercialized (Moser et al., 1987a, b). The bites of
females in the P . ventricosus group, e.g. P . helfsi (Oudemans) (syn. P .
zwoelferi Krczal) and P . tritici, are so toxic that they cause a pruriginous
dermatitis, called “grain itch”, of granary workers (Krczal, 1959; Moser,
1975; Le Fichoux et al., 1980). Another member of the P . ventricosus
group, Pyemotes barbara Moser, Smiley & Otvos, is a parasitoid of the
Douglas-fir cone moth, Barbara colfuxiana (Kearfott). Its females feed
naturally on the pupa of this host, but they readily attacked immature
instars of other forest insects offered in the laboratory, and were suggested
as candidates for the biological control of other cone and seed insects
(Moser et al., 1987a, b).
The kind of ovoviviparous development occurring in species of Pye-
motes results in only adult females and males being directly exposed to
external environmental factors. Further, the sex ratio is highly biased;
males usually represent only 1-20% of the progeny, which still suffices
for nearly all the emerging females to be fertilized. These traits are
advantageous in that adults are the only “units of selection”, the maternal
genome is exposed in haploid condition in her sons, and the female diploid
genome is optimized both in number of individuals, and dispersants
(Maynard Smith, 1989; Bruce and Wrensch, 1990; Kaliszewski and
Wrensch, 1993). During the birth of adult progeny from the maternal
body, male(s) issue first, which facilitates their mating with the females
immediately, or shortly after, they are born. In some species, the male
assists and accelerates the birth process of his sisters, but apparently no
352 MAREK KALISZEWSKI ET AL
moderately high number of progeny per female requires more than the
minimal one son to ensure the mating of nearly all daughters, much as in
Pyemotidae rather than Acarophenacidae. The fertilized, unfed, young
females then seek a carrier. To synchronize with the host’s life cycle,
this unfed, pre-phoretic and phoretic stage of the mites may last from 2 to
4 weeks during the active season under temperate conditions, or up to 8
months in fall and over winter (Lindquist and Bedard, 1961; Balazy and
Kielczewski, 1965; Lindquist, 1969~).
Adult females of the genus Tursonemellu have been recorded as disper-
sants on adult chalcidoid wasps and undetermined beetles (Lindquist,
1986). Based on their spectacularly long cheliceral stylets, Lindquist
(1986) suggested that these mites may be parasitoids on the immature
instars of their host. However, there are unpublished data which indicate
a remarkable symbiosis between some of these mites, their agaonid wasp
carriers, and host fig fruit. The pollinating agaonid wasp females carry the
mites through the ostiole into the fig fruit, where the mites initiate gall
formation by some of the fig ovules on which they feed in dense
aggregations (personal correspondence between S. G. Compton and E.
E. Lindquist, 1986-1 989; Compton, 1993).
There are few documented examples of predation among tarsonemid
mites. Species of Acaronemus prey on eggs of tetranychid and tenuipalpid
mites on the foliage of evergreen trees (Smiley and Landwehr, 1976;
Lindquist and Smiley, 1978). Evidence that some members of Dendrop-
tus, the sister-genus of Acaronemus, may prey on gall-producing eriophyid
mites, or on eggs of arboreal tydeid mites, was reviewed by Lindquist
(1986). These are relatively highly derivative genera, and there appears to
be no evidence for their representing an intermediate step between
fungivory and parasitoidism or parasitism in the family.
All instars of Tursonemus (Chuetotarsonemus) dispur Beer live as
symbionts beneath the elytra of the passalid beetle, Popilius disjunctus
(Illiger) (Beer, 1954; Lindquist, 1986). As their cheliceral stylets are not
enlarged, these mites are perhaps paraphagic, though parasitism should not
be dismissed.
The adult female of Pseuducurupis indoupis (Lindquist) was described
as a phoront on Apis cerunu Fabricius (= A. indicu Fabricius) in India
(Lindquist, 1968, 1986), and we have a similar record of it from Thailand.
Its body shape is similar to that of females of the parasitic tarsonemid
genus Acurupis, and it secludes itself in the same areas on the bee as does
Acurupis externus Morgenthaler (Figure 17), i.e., the cervix and posterior
head near the posterior tentorial pits. In contrast to species of Acurupis, the
presence of only the adult female on the bee, and the short cheliceral stylets
and small pharynx of Pseuducurupis, do not indicate parasitism. Further,
this is a relatively highly derived genus, which could not represent an
356 MAREK KALISZEWSKI ET AL
As with many other mite lineages which have evolved towards parasit-
ism (Parasitengona (mostly the Hydracarina) in Actinedida, Psoroptides in
Acaridida, Dermanyssoidea in Gamasida), one notes a tendency to lose the
phoretic means of dispersal as all mites remain in all stages on the host
(Athias-Binche, 1991; Athias-Binche and Morand, 1993). This evolution-
ary trend is also encountered in Tarsonemoidea: Acarapis and the Corei-
tarsonemini in the family Tarsonemidae, and all taxa in the sister family
Podapolipidae as parasites infest a new host directly from another host
(Lindquist, 1986). Movement between hosts is primarily by adult female
mites in Acarapis (and probably in Coreitarsonemini), but there is a trend
for this behavior to shift from the adult female to the larval female in
Podapolipidae.
Mites of the family Podapolipidae are exclusively internal or external
parasites of insects. Podapolipids occur under elytra and on vaginal mem-
branes of beetles, in the trachea and air sacs of orthopterans, and externally
on grasshoppers and cockroaches. Most podapolipid genera exhibit reduc-
tion of the legs and other morphological structures. However, although
the adult females show the greatest trend towards leg reduction and
becoming a reproductive sac, the larvae consistently retain three pairs
of well-developed legs, evidently indicating the need for some movement
for transfer between hosts. This phenomenon is evidently connected with
the completely parasitic way of life throughout the entire family (Regenfuss,
1968; Lindquist, 1986).
However, members of the earliest derived genus known, Chrysomelobia,
which are subelytral parasites of leaf beetles in Europe and North America,
retain four pairs of legs in the adult male and female. Most species of
Podapolipus, Podapolipoides, Peripolipus, Panesthipolipus and Bakerpo-
lipus are external parasites of Orthoptera (Husband, 1984). Species of
Rhynchopolipus occur on weevils (Husband, 1984). Species of Locusta-
carus occur in respiratory systems of locusts and bees, apparently piercing
tracheal walls to feed (Wehrle and Welch, 1925; Husband and Sinha,
1970). Members of the genera Tarsopolipus, Eutarsopolipus, Tetrapoli-
pus, Coccipolipus, Dorsipes, Chrysomelobia, Dilopolipus, Stenopolipus,
Archipolipus, Regenopolipus, Stigmarcarus, and some species of Podapo-
lipus feed externally on a variety of beetles (Regenfuss, 1968; Feldman-
Musham and Havivi, 1972; Baker and Eickwort, 1975; Husband, 1984).
Some species of Ovacarus are also parasites of beetles, but appear to be
restricted to the vaginal membranes and oviduct sacs of their carabid hosts
(Stannard and Vaishampayan, 1971; Husband, 1984).
358 MAREK KALISZEWSKI ET AL
5. DISCUSSION
The Tarsonemina manifest various attributes that have acted in the course
of evolution in favor of a diversity of symbiotic ways of life. Their small
size no doubt has facilitated general or loose symbioses, especially
phoresy. Abbreviated post-embryonic development, arrhenotoky, and the
variety of feeding habits have contributed to the success of dispersal and
colonization of an appropriate host or habitat. Physogastry, which appears
frequent in the group, also has permitted an optimal production of even-
aged dispersants or infective stages. In fact, it seems that true, free-living,
edaphic forms, which would occupy the original ecological niche of mites,
are infrequent in the group. In many cases, the pygmephorids and tarso-
nemids sampled in soil by classic extraction techniques such as the
Berlese-Tullgren funnel may preferentially inhabit ground nests of
various organisms. Most of the Tarsonemina are associated with other
animals or are fungivores or plant feeders, and many of them are found
in above-ground layers.
The Tarsonemina, then, comprises a typically non-conservative lineage
of mites which has colonized largely non-edaphic trophic niches in the
course of its evolution and diversification. Not surprisingly, various of the
aforementioned characteristics, especially phoretic dispersal, may even-
tually lead repeatedly towards parasitic and parasitoid ways of life. Such
patterns are encountered in other groups of mites, such as the Derma-
nyssoidea (Radovsky, 1994), Hydracarina (Parasitengona) (Mitchell, 1967;
Wiggins et al., 1980), and Psoroptides (Houck and O’Connor, 1991).
However, the Tarsonemina constitutes the outstanding example among
the Acari of a lineage showing independently repeated, complete loss of
a true, free-living way of life in adaptation to parasitism and, uniquely,
parasitoidism.
Parasitoidism has evolved in earlier as well as more recently derived taxa
among the superfamilies, and even within the families, of Tarsonemina.
For example, it arose in the lineage ancestral to the entire superfamily
Pyemotoidea, yet it has arisen in just one known genus, Zponemus, in the
most recent derivative subfamily of Tarsonemidae. That evolution to
parasitoidism is, phylogenetically, a more recent phenomenon in Tarso-
nemidae than in Pyemotoidea is supported also by life history attributes.
Although physogastric, adult female Zponemus still retain the primitive
characteristics of ovipositing their eggs outside the maternal body, and
of the eggs hatching into active larvae. There may not have been sufficient
evolutionary time, yet, for retention of the eggs and reduction of the larvae
to a regressed stage within the physogastric mother, as in the Pyemotoidea.
Parasitism, in contrast with parasitoidism, appears to have evolved in
PARASITISM AND PARASlTOlDlSM IN TARSONEMINA 359
1. When all stages of a taxon are encountered on one host individual, the
taxon may be a parasite, or a commensalistic or mutualistic associate,
but it is not a parasitoid. When only the adult female of a taxon is found
on an adult host, the taxon may be a parasitoid, or a commensalistic or
mutualistic associate, or simply a phoretic, but it is not a parasite.
2. Adult female parasites are expected to undergo some engorgement
while feeding and fecund, but to generate and produce one or few
eggs at a time, sequentially over an extended time span (one to several
weeks). Adult female parasitoids are expected to undergo extended
physogastry while feeding and fecund, so as to generate and produce
a large number of even-aged progeny over a short time span (1-3 days).
3. The larva is expected to remain an active, feeding instar in parasitic
taxa, but to become inactive and non-feeding in parasitoid taxa. (In
Tarsonemidae, the nearly immobile larvae, with vestigial legs I1 and 111,
in the parasitic genus Acurupis, and the fully developed larvae, capable
of movement, in the parasitoid genus Zponemus, may appear to contra-
dict this; however, the former remain fully active as feeding parasites,
whereas the latter remain clustered together and do not feed.)
4. The sex ratio is not expected to be highly skewed (i.e., > 80%) in favor
'of females in parasitic taxa, but it is predicted to be so in parasitoid
forms.
5 . Among parasitoid and other taxa capable of extensive physogastry, the
360 MAAEK KALISZEWSKI ET AL
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Figures 2-1 7 have been modified and entirely redrawn from several authors
by M. J. Bodiou, draftswoman, CNRS.
REFERENCES
Dactylosomatidae, 30, 1
Distribution, Relationships and Identification of Enzymic Variants within the
Subgenus Trypanozoon, 29, 1
Dracunculus and Dracunculiasis, 9, 73
Dynamics of Parasitic Equilibrium in Cotton Rat Filariasis, 4, 255
Onchocerciasis, 8, 173
Ontogeny of Cestodes and its Bearing on their Phylogeny and Systematics, 11,481
Oxygen-derived Free Radicals in the Pathogenesis of Parasitic Disease, 25, I