Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
We Georgia voters urge you not to pass voting system bill SB403 in haste as the session comes
to a close. SB403 fails to mandate verifiable auditable elections using hand-marked paper
ballots counted by scanners and manually audited—the most secure and accurate balloting
method. Instead, we ask that you support HR1699 for a Voting System Study Committee to
permit state officials to better assess voting system security requirements.
We look to you as our representatives to protect our voting rights, including the right to have our
votes counted as cast and secured against malicious interference.
We seek your commitment to oppose SB403 because it contains undemocratic principles and
reckless security practices:
• SB403 permits vulnerable voting machines that use barcodes to record and tabulate
the official ballot. Current law does not permit insecure barcode balloting. The law
should not be changed to permit high-risk technology. Computer scientists agree that
barcodes have no business tabulating Georgia’s elections, likening ballot barcodes
to the ability to attach a keyboard to the tabulation scanner.
• Barcode ballots cannot be audited or manually recounted as claimed.
• Federal (EAC) system certification is not required in SB403.
• Deadlines for election certifications preclude meaningful post-election audits.
• SB403 mandates a schedule of rapid implementation that is recklessly unrealistic,
building in a likely security failure in the 2020 elections.
• Basic ballot security and chain-of-custody controls are absent.
• SB403 mandates centralizing all election programming in the Secretary of State’s
office without proper checks and balances. Single point of failure risk is high.
• SB403 mandates a single source supplier for the system, counter to good business,
cybersecurity, and financial principles.
• SB403 permits cities, including Atlanta, to continue to run municipal elections on the
un-auditable paperless touchscreen ballots.
• Unverifiable barcode balloting systems can cost more than three times the cost of
hand- marked paper ballots counted by optical scanning equipment.
Events of the last several weeks have occurred at the federal level that should also be factored
into any voting system legislation. We ask you to avoid enacting new voting system statutes
until the following considerations can be taken into account, preferably through the proposed
Study Committee:
• Approximately $10.6 million in new federal funding can be granted to Georgia for
enhancing voting system security if requirements are met.
• New voting system standards will be determined by the federal Election Assistance
Commission on April 20, 2018.
• On March 20, 2018, the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee issued basic
recommendations for voting system security. SB403 violates those standards.
Leading election integrity organizations have publicly stated their opposition to SB403 for its
failure to mandate secure, auditable, and verified elections. Such organizations include Verified
Voting, Common Cause Georgia, Georgians for Verified Voting, and National Election Defense
Coalition. There is no known citizen support for SB403.
SB403 as constructed degrades election security while promoting the interest of certain vendors
to legally permit the purchase of their new insecure vulnerable technology. Voters, not vendors,
should be the beneficiaries of all new election legislation.
In summary, the Georgia voters want hand-marked paper ballots counted by tabulating
scanners and manually audited in statistically valid audits. Please avoid degrading the election
statutes through SB403 to permit vulnerable new technology to be acquired. We also insist that
any new voting system legislation include basic security requirements, mandatory post-election
audits, and transparent processes permitting full public oversight of its elections.
Respectfully submitted,