Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness of splint therapy on the electromyographic activity of
masticator'/muscles (anterior temporalis and masseter) before and after the application of a muscle relaxation splint. Electromyog-
raphy recordings from the masseter and anterior temporalis muscles were analyzed quantitatively during maximal biting in the
intercuspal position both before and after treatment without a splint. Fourteen patients whose chief complaint was masticatory
muscle pain were selected for the study. After the initial evaluations muscle relaxation splints were applied, and the patients were
instructed to use the splints for 6 weeks. Surface electromyographic recordings were taken from each patient before the beginning
of clinical therapy and after 6 weeks of wearing the splints. The data obtained were analyzed through paired sample t tests and
Wilcoxon's signed rank tests. The results of the study were as follows: (1) the electromyographic activity of the two muscles during
maximal biting was not markedly changed after the muscle relaxation splint was used; and (2) the changes observed in elec-
tromyographic activity of the involved and noninvolved sides were insignificant as well. (Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral
Radiol Endod 1998;85:674-9)
674
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Canay et al. 675
Volume 85, Number 6
Grinding + + + +
Pain at rest + + + + + +
Pain with function + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Trigger Point +
Limitation at opening + + +
Interferences in intercuspal positions + + +
Retruded contact position + + + + + +
= Intercuspal position
Deviation + + + + + + + + +
Table II. Electromyographic activity of masseter and anterior temporal muscles before and after splint therapy
(gV/sec)
Before splint After splint
Muscle f2 SD X SD t p
Right masseter 283.86 167.61 262.71 130.34 0.53 0.604
Left masseter 249.79 99.95 249.71 96.16 0.00 0.997
Right temporal 358.86 134.55 372.57 126.25 0.72 0.483
Left temporal 305.57 103.44 347.93 127.79 1.33 0.205
dentition, and none was currently undergoing treatment trigger points. An interincisal opening of less than 45 mm
for any medical problem. Patients were selected on the was recorded as limitation at opening. Retruded contact
basis of the following criteria: position (RCP) and maximum intercuspal position (IP)
1. Spontaneous facial pain at rest and increased pain were identified, and if the occlusion was stable in the
with function. RCR it was recorded as RCP = IP. Contacts that signifi-
2. Restriction in mandibular opening; changes in cantly altered the intercuspal position were recorded as
movement, as evidenced by mandibular deviation; occlusal interference in intercuspal position. According
and changes in normal range of lateral movements. to the data obtained, the main problem was determined to
3. Moderate to severe tenderness to bimanual palpa- be muscle disorder (Table I).
tion at the preauricular region of the elevator
muscles. When two or more painful spots were
Occlusal splint
present, this factor was recorded as positive.
For each patient a full-coverage maxillary muscle
4. Muscle weakness and fatigue, especially in the
relaxation splint was made of clear, self-curing acrylic
morning.
resin. The base of the occlusal splint was shaped on a
5. Lack of joint sounds.
model, and the occlusal surface was prepared from a
6. Onset of symptoms between 8 to 16 weeks before
layer of autopolymerizing acrylic resin. Before the resin
admission into the study.
Each patient underwent a thorough clinical examina- set, a bilateral manual mandibular manipulation tech-
tion and was questioned to determine the anamnestic and nique was used to achieve RCR Canine disclusion of
clinical dysfunction index. The type of parafunctional the posterior teeth during eccentric and protrusive
activity was recorded as either clenching or grinding. movements was also provided. The height of the
Intermittent application of masticatory force in a static occlusal splint was approximately 1 mm more than the
occlusal relationship was recorded as clenching. Fric- freeway space, and it was controlled by speech. The
tional excursive movements of opposing teeth were patient was instructed to wear the appliance all day
recorded as grinding. Pain was classified as at rest or long--both at night and during the day---except during
during function (or both). Hypersensitive areas in eating. The first EMG recordings were made just before
muscles that elicit pain during palpation were recorded as the MRS was adjusted, and the final EMG recordings
676 Canay et al. ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY
June 1998
Statistical analysis
The differences in the EMG activity of the muscles
before and after MRS therapy were tested by means of
paired sample t tests. Because of a lack of homogeneity
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram shows placement of electrodes on
temporal and masseter muscles. of variance, the data were analyzed by means of
Wilcoxon signed rank tests for comparison of the
involved and noninvolved sides.
l a n e Ilk Myoelectrical value of masseter muscle on involved and noninvolved sides (gV sec)
n Before treatment X After treatment J( z p
Involvedside 9 287.77 265.77 0.4146 0.6784
Noninvolvedside 9 252.33 258.11 0.5331 0.5940
Bilateralinvolvement
Left masseter 5 255.2 240.0 0.1348 0.8927
Right masseter 5 266.8 251.8 0.6742 0.5002
lable IV. Myoelectrical value of anterior temporal muscle on involved and noninvolved sides (gV sec)
n Before treatment X After treatment X z p
Involvedside 9 334.44 288.11 0.7701 0.4413
Noninvolvedside 9 316.44 344.44 0.6516 0.5147
Bilateralinvolvement
Left temporal 5 309.2 356.2 0.1348 0.8927
Right temporal 5 379.6 416.6 0.6742 0.5002
According to the Wilcoxon signed rank test, p was 0.441 measurements with no splint, primarily to avoid causing
for the involved side and 0.515 for the noninvolved side. muscle fatigue through the exercise of two measure-
The patients' complaints before and after MRS therapy ments in the same session, and secondarily to prevent
are compared in Table V. The main clinical symptoms such fatigue from affecting our results.
were muscle pain and restricted interincisal opening. Of Lund and Laminate 3° recorded maximum biting
the 14 patients experiencing pain before splint therapy, forces and electromyograms of the masseter and
12 reported no pain after therapy; 2 patients still had temporal muscles during maximum voluntary isometric
muscle pain, especially in the masseter region. In eight contraction in the region of the premolar teeth on one
patients interincisal opening had increased; in three side of the jaw with and without local anesthesia. EMG
patients there was no change; and the other three patients potentials were reduced after local anesthesia. They
showed decreased interincisal opening after therapy. The concluded that cortical neurons controlling the excita-
paired sample t test did not demonstrate any significant tion of the closing muscles of the jaw would receive
difference (t = 0.696; p = 0.499). positive feedback from receptors in the periodontal
Before MRS therapy, 8 of the 14 patients in the study had
membrane. Blockage of these receptors would reduce
a deflection; after MRS therapy 5 patients were the same, but
the biting forces and the integrated EMG potentials
the remaining 3 patients had normal openings of the pathway.
during maximum voluntary isometric contraction.
Furthermore, some recent studies have reported that the
DISCUSSION
palatal base causes changes in tongue position and in the
During the last decade several theories have been
discharge of mucosal palatal receptors.31-33These inputs
proposed concerning the causes of dysfunction of the
may play a role in the postural control mechanisms.
TMJ. Most authors agree that the etiology is multifacto-
rial and that muscle hyperactivity is one of the main In our study we bore in mind the fact that forces
factors. To understand the underlying neurologic process conveyed onto the periodontal membrane were different
of muscle hyperactivity, EMG has been widely used. depending on the presence or absence of a splint in the
A considerable number of reports on clinical observa- mouth. As the person's biting force would formulate
tions of the therapeutic effects of splints are available in different muscular activities from a tooth-to-tooth
the literature. However, little has been done to quantita- contact, palatal receptors would be effective on splints;
tively determine whether splint therapy changes therefore EMG recordings were made without splint.
muscular activity and contributes to muscular relaxation. In the present study the EMG readings in the masseter
Available studies do not appear to demonstrate directly on the affected side declined in comparison with
the muscular activity changes during maximal biting pretreatment readings. These readings were the same
force. Many studies have reported the EMG activities of for both the unilaterally affected and the bilaterally
the muscles with and without occlusal splints. 4,27-29 affected patients (Table III). The posttreatment EMG
There exist many previous studies that measured activity readings were lower than the pretreatment read-
EMG activity with splint. In our work we conducted ings in the temporal muscle in the unilaterally affected
678 Canay et al. ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY
June 1998
patients. However, a rise was observed in bilaterally vertical dimension caused by the splint during therapy
affected patients (Table IV). varied between 1 and 2 mm with respect to the natural
Because temporal muscle is fan-shaped, its fibers pull occlusal vertical dimension.
in different directions. Blanksma and Van Eijden34 have Some studies showed that occlusal splints with canine
reported that alteration in activity relative to bite force guidance reduce radically the contractile activities
was generally the smallest in the anterior region of the recorded from the masseter and anterior temporalis
muscle. In our study the EMG muscular activities were muscles during teeth grinding and mastication. 38-4°
measured in the anterior region of the temporal muscle; Williamson and Lundquist 41 had also concluded that
for this reason, no proportionate change in EMG activity only when posterior disclusion is obtained by an appro-
was observed in the temporalis muscle after treatment. priate anterior guidance can the electromyographic
When the mean EMG muscular activities on the right activity of the elevating muscles be reduced.
and left sides were compared, the EMG activities on the Hersek et al.42 observed in their study the effect of ante-
right side were found to be higher. However, this differ- rior repositioning splint therapy on the masticatory
ence was statistically insignificant. This is true for both muscle activity of patients, particularly those with disk
the temporal and the masseter muscles with regard to displacement with reduction problems, and concluded
both pretreatment and posttreatment (Table III). that splint therapy did not cause any significant modifica-
The comparison of the differences between the right tion of the EMG activity. Our study follows the same line.
and left sides for both pretreatment and posttreatment The purpose of this study was to investigate the effec-
and for both the masseter and temporal muscles was tiveness of splint therapy in patients with muscle pain.
made with a Student t test; the results displayed Many studies have failed to adequately define their
insignificance for both the right and left sides (right, t = patient populations, incorporating both patients with
0.12 andp = 0.904; left, t = 1.03 andp = 0.155). extracapsular and patients with intracapsular problems.
With the occlusal splint inserted, it is reasonable In contrast, we selected a patient population with
because of the new occlusal scheme to expect a change muscle problems and then evaluated our results on the
in the neuromuscular problem stemming from peri- basis of objective criteria. It is known that the splint
odontal receptors. On the other hand, the TMJ receptor causes changes in muscular activity while it is in the
could also be involved, on account of the rotation of the mouth; our objective was to investigate whether there
condyle on variation of the vertical dimension caused would be a permanent change in the muscular activity
by the occlusal splint insertion. as a result of treatment. It was found that in comparison
Previous studies have reported the clinical importance with the pretreatment findings, the appliance did not
of the vertical height of the occlusal splints33,35-37; cause any significant modification of EMG activity in
furthermore, the thickness of an appliance may be crit- the aforementioned muscles after splint therapy. As a
ical for its effectiveness. In our study the increase in the result of our experiment, even though a significant
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Canay et al. 679
Volume 85, Number 6