Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Atlas
Global Global Atlas
control
and control
oncardiovascular
on cardiovascular
diseaseprevention
disease prevention on cardiovascular disease
prevention and
andcontrol
control prevention and control
disease prevention
and
Joint Publication
Published of theHealth
by the World World Organization
Health Organization
in collaboration with
theWorld
the WorldHeart
HeartFederation
Federationand
andthe
theWorld
WorldStroke
StrokeOrganization.
Organization
cardiovascular disease
Millions of premature
In the absence of
on cardiovascular
International efforts deaths due to
prevention strategies,
aimed at poverty cardiovascular disease
increasing numbers of
reduction will be can be prevented CVDs
CVDs
people will succumb
derailed if the rapidly by scaling up the
to heart attacks
growing global implementation of
and strokes due to
cardiovascular disease affordable, high impact
continuing exposure to
burden is ignored. interventions, which
risk factors.
already exist.
Published
Joint by the
Publication World
of the Health
World Organization
Health Organization
Atlas on
in collaboration withHeart
the World the World Heart Federation
Federation
Global Atlas
Organization.
and the World Stroke Organization
Global
ISBN
ISBN 978929244256419
978 15643783
20 Avenue Appia
CH-1211 Geneva 27
9 789242 564198
Switzerland
www.who.int/
CORRIGENDUM
Global Atlas on cardiovascular disease prevention and control. ISBN: 978 92 4
156437 3
The list of Figures on pages 127-129 should be amended as follows:
Figure 1. Normal heart with its blood supply (i). Ties van Brussel,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Anatomy_Heart_English_Tiesworks.jpg. Image
placed in the public domain.
Figure 2. Normal brain with its blood supply (i). Image licensed under the Creative
Commons Attribution ShareAlike 3.0 licence, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-
sa/3.0/.
Figure 59. Electrocardiogram ; atrial fibrillation compared with normal sinus rhythm.
Atrial fibrillation (top) and normal sinus rhythm (bottom). The purple arrow indicates a
P wave, which is lost in atrial fibrillation (i). J. Heuser. Image licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 3.0 licence,
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/.
Figure 60. Congenital heart disease; diagram of a healthy heart and one suffering from
tetralogy of Fallot. (i). Mariana Ruiz Villarreal
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetralogy_of_Fallot#/media/File:Tetralogy_of_Fallot.svg.
Image placed in the public domain.
Figure 61. Diagram of a heart with patent ductus arteriosus; an abnormality seen in
50% of children with congenital rubella syndrome (i).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Patent_ductus_arteriosus.jpg. Original source NIH
National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute.
Figure 62. Rheumatic heart disease at autopsy with characteristic findings (thickened
mitral valve, with its attachments (chordae tendineae), and hypertrophied left
ventricular wall (i).
Group A streptococci (i) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Public Health
Image Library (PHIL) http://phil.cdc.gov/phil/details.asp
Streptococcal pharyngitis with typical exudate on tonsils (i). James Heilman MD.
Image licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 3.0 licence,
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/.
Page 68
Photograph: Better housing can help to prevent Chagas disease through vector control
(i). http://en.wikipedia.org/
Global Atlas
on cardiovascular disease
prevention and control
This document was developed by the World Health Organization (Shanthi Mendis) in collaboration with the
World Heart Federation (Pekka Puska) and the World Stroke Organization (Bo Norrving)
Contributions were made by A. Alwan, T. Armstrong, D. Bettcher, T. Boerma, F. Branca, J. C.Y. Ho, C. Mathers,
R. Martinez, V. Poznyak, G. Roglic, L. Riley, E. d`Espaignet, G. Stevens, K.Taubert and G. Xuereb. Others who
provided assistance in various ways in the compilation of this document include A. Ayinla, X. Bi, F. Besson,
L. Bhatti, A. Enyioma, N. Christenson, F. Lubega, P. Nordet, M. Osekre-Amey and J. Tarel.
World Health Organization, World Heart Federation and World Stroke Organization 118
References 119
List of figures 127
References for figures 131
Annexes 133
Annex i – World Health Assembly resolution A64/61 134
Annex ii – Moscow Declaration 136
Annex iii – Regional Declarations on NCDs 139
Annex iv – Contact information 144
Annex V – Age-standardized death rates per 100,000
both sexes by cause and Member State, 2008 (1) 148
Index 153
Measurements
dl decilitre
g gram
kg kilogram
l litre
M/m metre
mg milligram
mmHg millimetre of mercury
mmol millimole
!
What are
■■ CVDs are the leading causes of death
and disability in the world.
■■ Although a large proportion of CVDs
is preventable they continue to rise
mainly because preventive measures
are inadequate.
■■ Out of the 17.3 million cardiovascular
deaths in 2008, heart attacks were
responsible for 7.3 million and strokes
were responsible for 6.2 million
cardiovascular deaths.
diseases (CVDs)?
Figure 1 Normal heart with its blood supply (i). Figure 2 Normal brain with its blood supply (i).
Reproduced with permission. Reproduced with permission.
Cardiovascular
Other NCDs diseases
33% 31%
Injuries
9% Communicable, maternal, perinatal
and nutritional conditions
27%
Figure 4 Distribution of CVD deaths due to heart Figure 5 Distribution of CVD deaths due to heart
attacks, strokes and other types of cardiovascular attacks, strokes and other types of cardiovascular
diseases, males (1). diseases, females (1).
Other cardiovascular diseases Rheumatic heart diseases Other cardiovascular diseases Rheumatic heart diseases
11% 1% 14% 1%
Hypertensive heart diseases Hypertensive
Inflammatory heart Inflammatory heart
6% heart diseases
diseases diseases 7%
2% 2%
Figure 7 World map showing the global distribution of CVD mortality rates in females (age standardized, per 100 000)
(1).
Figure 9 World map showing the global distribution of the burden of CVDs (DALYs) , in females (age standardized,
per 100 000) (1).
@
Death and disability
■■ CVD is the leading noncommunicable
disease ; nearly half of the 36 million
deaths due to noncommunicable
diseases (NCDs) are caused by CVDs.
■■ In 2008, nine million people died of
NCDs prematurely before the age
of 60; some eight million of these
premature deaths occurred in low-
and middle-income countries (LMICs).
■■ 10% of the global disease burden
Tobacco smoking, physical inactivity, unhealthy diets and decades, with rates, for example, for stroke and heart attack
the harmful use of alcohol are the main behavioural risk exceeding those in high-income countries (1, 6, 7).
factors of CVDs. These risk factors are shared by other major According to the Global Burden of Disease estimates (5),
NCDs such as cancer, diabetes and chronic respiratory dis- 68% of the 751 million years living with disability (YLD)
ease. Long-term exposure to behavioural risk factors results worldwide is attributable to NCDs, and 84% of this burden
in raised blood pressure (hypertension), raised blood sugar of NCD disability arises in LMICs. Heart disease is one of the
(diabetes), raised and abnormal blood lipids (dyslipidae- five leading contributors to YLD in elderly people in LMICs.
mia) and obesity. Major cardiovascular risk factors such as Stroke is also reported as a leading cause of disability in
hypertension and diabetes link CVD to renal disease. LMICs, second only to dementia. CVDs are responsible for
Of the 57 million global deaths in 2008, 36 million (63%) 151 377 million DALYs, of which 62 587 million are due to
were due to NCDs (Figure 10) and 17.3 million (30%) were coronary heart disease and 46 591 million to cerebrovascu-
due to CVDs. Nearly 80% of NCD deaths occur in LMICs and lar disease (2, 5).
is the most frequent cause of death in most countries, ex- The contribution of different CVDs to the global CVDs bur-
cept in Africa (1). In Africa, NCDs are rising rapidly and are den in males and females is shown in Figures 13 and 14, re-
projected to exceed communicable, maternal, perinatal spectively. Figures 15–18 show mortality rates of ischaemic
and nutritional diseases as the most common causes of heart disease (Figures 15 and 16) and stroke (Figures 17
death in another two decades. Over 80% of cardiovascular and 18) for males and females, respectively. Figures 19–22
and diabetes deaths occur in LMICs. show healthy years of life lost due to ischaemic heart dis-
While 29% of NCD deaths occurs among people below the ease (Figures 19 and 20) and stroke (Figures 21 and 22) for
age of 60 in LMICs, in high-income countries only 13% of males and females, respectively.
deaths occur below the age of 60 (1, 6) (Figure 11). Among
people below the age of 70, CVDs were responsible for the
largest proportion (39%) of NCD deaths (Figure 12). There
has been a doubling of CVD rates in LMICs during recent
Other NCDs
Respiratory Cardiovascular Other NCDs Cardiovascular 21%
diseases Cardiovascular Diabetes Diabetes
diseases 26% diseases
12% diseases melitus melitus
48% 35% 39%
3% 4%
Figure bo Distribution of global CVD burden (DALYs) due Figure bp Distribution of global CVD burden (DALYs)
to heart attacks, strokes and other types of CVDs in males due to heart attacks, strokes and other types of CVDs in
(5). females (5).
Cerebrovascular
disease Cerebrovascular
29% Ischaemic heart disease disease Ischaemic heart disease
45% 33% 37%
Figure br World map showing the global distribution of ischemic heart disease mortality rates in females
(age standardized, per 100 000) (1).
Figure bt World map showing the global distribution of cerebrovascular disease mortality rates in females (age
standardized, per 100 000) (1).
Figure cl World map showing the burden of ischemic heart disease (DALYs) in females (age standardized, per 100 000)
(5).
Figure cn World map showing the burden of cerebrovascular disease (DALYs) in females (age standardized,
per 100 000) (5).
#
The underlying
■■ Tobacco use, physical inactivity,
unhealthy diet, obesity, hypertension,
diabetes, and dyslipidaemia,
together with ageing and genetic
factors, promote atherosclerosis and
narrowing of the blood vessels.
■■ The process of atherosclerosis starts
in childhood and adolescence and
manifests as heart attacks and strokes
in later years.
pathology of heart
attacks and strokes
begins to bulge into the vessel lumen (Figures 23–26). When
the process continues, there is thinning of the fibrous cap
accompanied by fissuring of the endothelial surface of the
plaque, which may rupture. With the rupture of the plaque,
Atherosclerosis; the underlying basis lipid fragments and cellular debris are released into the
of heart attacks and strokes vessel lumen. These are exposed to thrombogenic agents
on the endothelial surface, resulting in the formation of a
One of the main underlying pathological processes that
thrombus. If the thrombus is large enough, and a coronary
leads to heart attacks (coronary heart disease) and strokes
blood vessel or a cerebral blood vessel is blocked, this results
(cerebrovascular disease) is known as atherosclerosis. The
in a heart attack or stroke (9, 10).
early changes of atherosclerosis develop in childhood and
adolescence due to the overall effect of a number of risk
factors (4–6). They include tobacco use, physical inactivity, Heart attack
unhealthy diet, harmful use of alcohol, hypertension, dia- When the blood flow to the heart is cut off, due to a throm-
betes, raised blood lipids, obesity, poverty, low educational bus on a ruptured atherosclerotic plaque, the decrease in
status, advancing age, male gender, genetic disposition the supply of oxygen and nutrients can damage the heart
and psychological factors. muscle, resulting in a heart attack. When the blood flow is
Atherosclerosis is an inflammatory process affecting me- decreased due to a blockage, it causes chest pain (angina)
dium- and large-sized blood vessels throughout the cardio- due to ischaemia.
vascular system (8–10). When the lining (endothelium) of
these blood vessels is exposed to raised levels of low-density Stroke
lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL cholesterol) and certain other The pathophysiology of ischaemic stroke is more diverse
substances, such as free radicals, the endothelium becomes and includes, besides thrombus formation in atheroscle-
permeable to lymphocytes and monocytes. These cells mi- rotic cerebral blood vessels (ischaemic stroke), small vessel
grate into the deep layers of the wall of the blood vessel. disease in the brain linked to vascular risk factors. Another
A series of reactions occur, attracting LDL cholesterol par- cause of stroke is haemorrhage (bleeding) due to a rupture
ticles to the site. These particles are engulfed by monocytes, of a blood vessel because of the presence of an aneurysm,
which are then transformed into macrophages (foam cells). for example, or due to damage from uncontrolled high
Smooth muscle cells migrate to the site from deeper layers blood pressure or atherosclerosis (haemorrhagic stroke). In
of the vessel wall (the media). Later, a fibrous cap consisting addition, strokes can also be caused by a travelling blood
of smooth muscle and collagen is formed. At the same time, clot. If a person has an irregular heartbeat, blood clots may
the macrophages involved in the original reaction begin to form in the heart and travel through the blood vessels to
die, resulting in the formation of a necrotic core covered by the brain. A clot carried to the cerebral circulation in this
the fibrous cap. These lesions (atheromatous plaques) en- way can be trapped in a cerebral blood vessel and block
large as cells and lipids accumulate in them and the plaque the blood flow to an area of the brain.
Adherence Adherence
Endothelial Leukocyte Endothelial Leukocyte Smooth- Foam-cell T-cell and and
permeability migration adhesion adhesion muscle formation activation aggregation entry of
migration of platelets leukocytes
Figure cq Fibrous cap formation and the necrotic core Figure cr The ruptured plaque (9). (From Ross I.
(9). (From Ross I. Reproduced with permission. © 1999 Reproduced with permission. © 1999 Massachusetts Medical
Massachusetts Medical Society.) Society.)
$
Evidence for
■■ CVDs are eminently preventable.
■■ Investment in prevention is the most
sustainable solution for the CVD
epidemic.
■■ Over the last two decades, CVD
mortality has declined in developed
countries due to a combination of
prevention and control measures.
prevention of heart
attacks
and strokes
Figures 27 and 28 show mortality rates of ischemic heart There has been a dramatic decline in coronary heart dis-
disease and cerebrovascular disease. Over the past two ease mortality in the United Kingdom from 1981 to 2000
decades, cardiovascular mortality rates have declined (14). Nearly 42% of this decrease has been attributed to
substantially in high-income countries (6, 11–13). There is treatment (including 11% to secondary prevention, 13%
clear evidence that population-wide primary prevention to heart failure treatment, 8% to initial treatment of acute
and individual health-care intervention strategies have myocardial infarction and 3% to hypertension treatment).
both contributed to these declining mortality trends. For About 58% of the decline has been attributed to popula-
example, during the 10-year period covered by the World tion-wide risk factor reductions (14).
Health Organization (WHO) Multinational Monitoring of The above data and similar experiences in Finland (15) and
Trends and Determinants of Cardiovascular Disease initia- other countries (16, 17) strongly support the view that pop-
tive (WHO MONICA Project), mortality from coronary heart ulation-wide primary prevention and individual health-
disease and stroke declined dramatically in many of the 38 care approaches go hand-in-hand to reduce the popula-
MONICA populations (13). tion burden of CVDs (6).
The decline in mortality has been attributed to reduced
incidence rates and/or improved survival after cardiovas-
cular events due to prevention and treatment interven-
tions. Across all populations with declining coronary heart
disease mortality, reduced cardiovascular risk contributed
to 75% and 66% of the change in men and women, respec-
tively; the remainder being attributed to providing health
care resulting in improved survival in the first four weeks
after the event. For stroke, about one third of the changes
in populations with declining mortality was attributed to
reduced incidence and 66% to improved survival.
Figure ct World map showing cerebrovascular disease mortality rates (age standardized, per 100,000) (1).
%
Reducing
■■ Cardiovascular risk factors such
as hypertension, diabetes and
hyperlipidaemia cluster together and
are major risk factors for strokes and
heart attacks.
■■ To prevent heart attacks and strokes,
the total cardiovascular risk needs to
be reduced by lowering all modifiable
risk factors.
■■ Prevention of heart attacks and
to prevent heart
attacks and strokes
A large percentage of CVDs (and other NCDs) is prevent- dence demonstrates that reducing total cardiovascular risk
able through the reduction of behavioural risk factors (to- results in the prevention of heart attacks and strokes (4).
bacco use, unhealthy diet, physical inactivity and harmful Pioneering work conducted by the Framingham Heart
use of alcohol) (3, 6). Study project in the United States (18, 19) and the Seven
Unhealthy behaviours lead to metabolic/physiologi- Countries study (20) in the 1960s and many other studies
cal changes: raised blood pressure (hypertension); over- since then, including the WHO MONICA Project (13) and
weight/obesity; raised blood sugar (diabetes); and raised the INTERHEART study (21), have provided further insights
blood lipids (dyslipidaemia). These intermediate risk factors into the risk factors and determinants of CVDs.
cause damage to coronary and cerebral blood vessels due If people at risk of developing myocardial infarctions and
to atherosclerosis, a process that develops over many years, strokes can be identified and measures taken to reduce
starting in childhood and manifesting as heart attacks and their cardiovascular risk, a vast majority of fatal and non-fa-
strokes in people of middle age. Since the underlying path- tal cardiovascular events can be prevented (4, 21, 22). WHO
ological process that causes heart attacks and strokes is ISH (International Society of Hypertension) risk prediction
similar, common approaches that address behavioural risk charts and other risk prediction tools can be used to assess
factors and metabolic risk factors are effective for preven- the risk of developing heart attacks and strokes (Figure 30).
tion of both conditions.
Cardiovascular risk distribution of the population can be
In terms of attributable deaths, the leading cardiovascular lowered through national health policies targeting the
risk factor globally is raised blood pressure (to which 13% whole population as well as those at high risk (Figure 31).
of global deaths is attributed), followed by tobacco use Population-wide strategies should address behavioural
(9%), raised blood glucose (6%), physical inactivity (6%) and risk factors. Simultaneously, those at high risk need to be
overweight and obesity (5%) (2) (Figure 29). identified and targeted through health systems using inte-
These behavioural and metabolic risk factors often coexist grated risk assessment and management approaches that
in the same person and act synergistically to increase the are cost effective (4, 6, 23). Figure 32 shows the distribution
individual’s total risk of developing acute vascular events of the population across different levels of cardiovascular
such as heart attacks and strokes. Strong scientific evi- risk in all WHO regions.
180
160
70
140
120
180
160
60
140
120
180
160
50
140
120
180
160
40
140
120
4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8
Cholesterol (mmol/l)
180
160
70
140
120
180
160
60
140
120
180
160
50
140
120
180
160
40
140
120
4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8
Cholesterol (mmol/l)
This chart can only be used for countries of the WHO Region of Africa, sub-region D, in settings where blood cholesterol
20 Global Atlas on (Algeria,
can be measured Cardiovascular Diseases
Angola, Benin, Prevention
Burkina and Control
Faso, Cameroon, Cape Verde, Chad, Comoros, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon,
Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Liberia, Madagascar, Mali, Mauritania, Mauritius, Niger, Nigeria, Sao Tome And
Principe, Senegal, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Togo).
Figure dm A combination of population wide and high risk strategies are required to shift the cardiovascular risk
distribution of populations to more optimal levels (23).
Population High-risk
strategy strategy
Optimal distribution
Present distribution
Percent of population
High risk
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Prevention of
Cardiovascular Disease
Pocket Guidelines for Assessment and
Management of Cardiovascular Risk
Predicting
Heart
Attack
and
Stroke risk
Geneva, 2007
60 60
96.05% 95.38%
50 50 83.33%
86.43%
40 73.26% 40
68.90%
57.98%
30 30
56.83%
20 20
10 10
0 0
<50 50–59 60–69 70+ <50 50–59 60–69 70+
Age Group (years) Age Group (years)
Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30% Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30%
40 35.27% 40
23.86%
32.09%
30 69.27% 30
50.09%
20 20
18.76%
10 19.27% 10 15.84%
3.15%
0 0
<50 50–59 60–69 70+ <50 50–59 60–69 70+
Age Group (years) Age Group (years)
Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30% Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30%
60 60 26.62%
98.63% 19.32%
99.01%
27.76%
50 35.33% 50
82.09% 84.43%
40 40
34.28%
30 30
28.35%
20 20 46.54%
30.20%
10 10 14.49%
5.44%
0 0
<50 50–59 60–69 70+ <50 50–59 60–69 70+
Age Group (years) Age Group (years)
Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30% Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30%
60 60 16.24%
92.57% 97.30%
18.10%
50 50
7.10%
40 40
69.69% 22.81% 79.51%
30 28.02% 30 24.24%
20 20 48.02%
14.20%
10 10 16.78%
13.59%
4.30%
0 0
<50 50–59 60–69 70+ <50 50–59 60–69 70+
Age Group (years) Age Group (years)
Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30% Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30%
30 30 40.66%
20 20
35.97%
29.80%
10 10
10.17%
6.64%
0 0
<50 50–59 60–69 70+ <50 50–59 60–69 70+
Age Group (years) Age Group (years)
Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30% Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30%
11. Western Pacific Region B (Males) 12. Western Pacific Region B (Females)
0.16% 0.10% 1.99%
100 0.40% 3.78% 100 0.16%
0.52% 2.51% 0.58% 2.29% 6.74%
15.06% 4.33% 15.28%
90 8.72% 21.63% 90 13.00%
40 84.99% 40
72.72%
30 30
48.11%
49.54%
20 20
24.15%
10 10
0 0
<50 50–59 60–69 70+ <50 50–59 60–69 70+
Age Group (years) Age Group (years)
Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30% Risk categories: ■ <10% ■ 10–19.9% ■ 20–29.9% ■ ≥30%
^
Tobacco: The totally
■■ Tobacco use is a principal contributor
to the development of heart attacks,
strokes, sudden death, heart failure,
aortic aneurysm and peripheral
vascular disease.
■■ Smoking cessation and avoidance
of second-hand smoke reduce the
cardiovascular risk and thereby help
to prevent CVDs.
There are currently about one billion smokers in the those who quit between 35 and 44 years of age had the
world. Manufactured cigarettes represent the major form same survival rates as those who had never smoked (27).
of smoked tobacco; other forms of tobacco consumed There is an inverse relationship between income level and
include “bidis” (a type of filter-less hand-rolled cigarette), prevalence of tobacco use and its related consequences.
cigars, hookahs and chewed tobacco (24, 25). Figure 33 In addition, tobacco consumption inflicts a greater harm
and 34 show the prevalence rates of current daily tobacco among disadvantaged groups due to tobacco-related ill-
smoking. The prevalence of daily tobacco smoking varied ness and the impact on household expenditure. There-
widely among the six WHO regions in 2009. fore, policies and interventions focusing on prevention of
The highest overall prevalence for smoking is estimated at tobacco use, promotion of smoke free environments and
nearly 31% in the WHO European Region, while the lowest smoking cessation should be important components of
is in the WHO African Region at 10% (26). national and international efforts to improve the health
Risks to health from tobacco use result not only from di- and well being of populations, especially the less affluent
rect consumption of tobacco, but also from exposure to (28).
second-hand smoke (24, 25). Nearly six million people die
from tobacco use and exposure to second hand smoke
each year, accounting for 6% of all female and 12% of all
male deaths in the world (1, 6). By 2030, tobacco-related
deaths are projected to increase to more than 8 million
deaths every year (2, 6).
Smoking is estimated to cause nearly 10% of CVD (2). There
is a large body of evidence from prospective cohort stud-
ies regarding the beneficial effect of smoking cessation on
coronary heart disease mortality (4). A 50-year follow-up of
British doctors demonstrated that, among ex-smokers, the
age of quitting has a major impact on survival prospects:
Figure dp World map showing the prevalence of current daily tobacco smoking in females. (age standardized adjusted
estimates) (6).
&
Physical inactivity:
■■ Regular physical activity reduces the
risk of heart attacks and strokes.
■■ Physical activity is a key determinant
of energy expenditure and thus
fundamental to energy balance and
weight control.
A preventable risk
factor of CVDs
Insufficient physical activity can be defined as less than 5 tion and vasomotor function in the blood vessels (33). In
times 30 minutes of moderate activity per week, or less addition, physical activity contributes to weight loss, gly-
than 3 times 20 minutes of vigorous activity per week, caemic control, improved blood pressure, lipid profile and
or equivalent. Insufficient physical activity is the fourth insulin sensitivity (34, 35). The beneficial effects of physical
leading risk factor for mortality. Approximately 3.2 million activity on cardiovascular risk may be mediated, at least in
deaths and 32.1 million DALYs – representing about 2.1% part, through these effects on intermediate risk factors.
of global DALYs – each year are attributable to insufficient The Global Status Report on NCD (6) showed that the prev-
physical activity (2). People who are insufficiently physically alence of insufficient physical activity was highest in the
active have a 20% to 30% increased risk of all-cause mortal- WHO Region of the Americas and the WHO Eastern Medi-
ity compared to those who engage in at least 30 minutes terranean Region. In all WHO regions, men are more active
of moderate intensity physical activity most days of the than women, with the biggest difference in prevalence
week. In 2008, 31.3% of adults aged 15 or older (28.2% men between males and females in the WHO Eastern Mediter-
and 34.4% women) were insufficiently physically active (6). ranean Region (Figures 35 and 36).
In adults, participation in 150 minutes of moderate physical The prevalence of insufficient physical activity is higher in
activity each week (or equivalent) is estimated to reduce high-income countries compared to low-income countries
the risk of ischaemic heart disease by approximately 30% due to increased automation of work and use of vehicles
and the risk of diabetes by 27% (4). for transport in high-income countries. High-income coun-
Many studies that have examined the association between tries have more than double the prevalence of insufficient
physical activity and CVDs (4, 6, 29–32) have reported re- physical activity compared to low-income countries for
duced risk of death from coronary heart disease and re- both men and women, with 41% of men and 48% of wom-
duced risk of overall CVDs, coronary heart disease and en being insufficiently physically active in high-income
stroke, in a dose–response fashion. Physical activity is a key countries compared to 18% of men and 21% of women in
determinant of energy expenditure and thus fundamen- low-income countries (6).
tal to energy balance and weight control. Physical activity
improves endothelial function, which enhances vasodilata-
* Less than 5 times 30 minutes of moderate activity per week or less than 3 times 20 minutes of vigorous activity per week, or equivalent.
Figure dr World map showing the prevalence of insufficient physical activity *, in females (age 15+, age standardized)
(6), (* less than 5 times 30 minutes of moderate activity per week or less than 3 times 20 minutes of vigorous activity per
week, or equivalent).
* Less than 5 times 30 minutes of moderate activity per week or less than 3 times 20 minutes of vigorous activity per week, or equivalent.
*
Harmful use of
■■ 14% of alcohol-attributable deaths
globally are due to CVD and diabetes
mellitus.
■■ There is a direct causal relationship
between levels and patterns of alcohol
consumption and risk of CVD.
■■ High levels of alcohol consumption
and heavy episodic (binge) drinking
are associated with increased risk of
CVD.
factor of CVDs
The harmful use of alcohol is a risk factor for multiple ad- drinking (defined as 60 or more grams of pure alcohol per
verse health and social outcomes, including hypertension, day) with the risk of CVD. Drinking at low levels without ep-
acute myocardial infarction, cardiomyopathy, cardiac ar- isodes of heavy drinking may be associated with a reduced
rhythmia, cirrhosis of the liver, pancreatitis, neuropathy, en- risk of multiple cardiovascular outcomes (overall mortality
cephalopathy, sexually transmitted diseases, unintended from CVDs, incidence of and mortality from coronary heart
pregnancy, fetal alcohol spectrum disorders, sudden infant disease and incidence of and mortality from stroke) in
death syndrome, violence, suicide and unintentional inju- some segments of the population (36–38). However, these
ries (e.g. motor vehicle crashes). In addition, people are af- effects tend to disappear if the patterns of drinking are
fected by other people's drinking, including that of their characterized by heavy episodic drinking (39, 40).
families, friends, co-workers and strangers. These harms Various mechanisms have been proposed for the protec-
range in magnitude from noise and fear to physical abuse, tive effect of light to moderate alcohol consumption, in-
sexual coercion and social isolation (2–6, 36). The adult per cluding the beneficial effects of alcohol on the HDL cho-
capita consumption of pure alcohol (litres) is shown in Fig- lesterol level, thrombolytic profile and platelet aggregation
ure 37. (39–42).
Hazardous and harmful drinking was responsible for 2.5 Overall alcohol consumption is associated with multiple
million (3.8%) deaths worldwide in 2004 (2,37,38). More health risks that, at the population level, clearly outweigh
than 50% of these deaths were due to CVDs, liver cirrho- potential benefits.
sis and cancer. An estimated 4.5% of the global burden of
disease – as measured in DALYs – is caused by the harmful
use of alcohol (2).
The relationship between alcohol consumption and coro-
nary heart disease and cerebrovascular diseases is complex.
It depends on both the level and the pattern of alcohol
consumption. There is a direct relationship between high-
er levels of alcohol consumption and the pattern of binge
(
Unhealthy diet:
■■ A modest reduction in salt intake
reduces blood pressure in individuals
with both normal and raised blood
pressure.
■■ Dietary salt increases blood pressure
in most people with hypertension and
in about one third with normotension.
■■ Dietary salt aggravates the age-
related rise in blood pressure.
■■ High dietary intakes of saturated fat,
There is a considerable body of evidence regarding the However, data from various countries indicate that most
nutritional background of atherosclerosis in general and populations are consuming much more salt than this (44).
coronary heart disease in particular. High dietary intakes of It is estimated that decreasing dietary salt intake from the
saturated fat, trans-fat cholesterol and salt, and low intake current global levels of 9–12 grams/day to the recom-
of fruits, vegetables and fish are linked to cardiovascular mended level of 5 grams/day would have a major impact
risk (2–6, 43). Obesity is a cardiovascular risk factor closely on blood pressure and CVD (45, 49).
linked to diet and physical inactivity. Obesity results, when A modest reduction in salt intake has a significant, and from
there is an imbalance between energy intake in the diet a population viewpoint, important effect on blood pressure
and energy expenditure. Regular physical activity can pre- in individuals with either normal or raised blood pressure
vent obesity by increasing the expended energy. Figures (50). There is also a correlation between the magnitude of
38 and 39 show the prevalence of obesity in adults and Fig- salt reduction and the magnitude of blood pressure reduc-
ure 40 shows the per capita intake of fruits and vegetables. tion within the daily intake range of 3–12 grams/day; the
Approximately 16 million (1.0%) DALYs and 1.7 million lower the salt intake, the lower the blood pressure (49, 50).
(2.8%) of deaths worldwide are attributable to low fruit and High consumption of saturated fats and trans-fatty acids
vegetable consumption (2). The amount of dietary salt con- is linked to heart disease; elimination of trans-fat and re-
sumed is an important determinant of blood pressure lev- placement of saturated with polyunsaturated vegetable
els and overall cardiovascular risk (43–45). Adequate con- oils lowers coronary heart disease risk (43).
sumption of fruit and vegetables reduces the risk of CVD
Energy from saturated fats usually accounts for one third of
(2, 46, 47). Frequent consumption of high-energy foods,
the energy from total fat, with the notable exception of the
such as processed foods that are high in fats and sugars,
WHO South-East Asia Region, where saturated fatty acids
promotes obesity compared to low-energy foods (48). A
account for over 40% of total fat intake. The availability of
healthy diet can contribute to a healthy body weight, a
total fat increases with income level, with the availability of
desirable lipid profile and a desirable blood pressure (44).
saturated fats around 8% in low- and lower-middle-income
WHO recommends a population salt intake of less than countries and 10% in upper-middle-income and in high-
5 grams/person/day to help the prevention of CVD (43). income countries (6, 43).
Figure du World map showing the prevalence of obesity * in females ( ages 20+, age standardized) (6).
(*BMI≥30 kg/m2)
BL
Obesity:
■■ Obesity is strongly related to major
cardiovascular risk factors such as
hypertension, type 2 diabetes and
dyslipidaemia.
■■ Imbalance between increased energy
intake (diet) and energy expenditure
(physical activity) is the major cause
of obesity.
■■ Obesity is a growing health problem
worldwide.
Worldwide, at least 2.8 million people die each year as a 21–23 kg/m2, while the goal for individuals should be to
result of being overweight or obese, and an estimated maintain a BMI in the range 18.5–24.9 kg/m2 (4).
35.8 million (2.3%) of global DALYs are caused by over- The prevalence of raised BMI increases with income level
weight or obesity (6). In 2008, 34% of adults over the age of of countries, up to upper-middle-income levels. The preva-
20 were overweight with a body mass index (BMI, a mea- lence of overweight in high-income and upper-middle-
sure of weight relative to height) greater than or equal to income countries was more than double that of low- and
25 kg/m2 (33.6% of men and 35% of women). In 2008, 9.8% lower-middle-income countries. For obesity, the difference
of men and 13.8% of women were obese (with a BMI great- more than triples from 7% obesity for both males and fe-
er than or equal to 30 kg/m2), compared to 4.8% for men males in lower-middle-income countries to 24% in upper-
and 7.9% for women in 1980 (6). middle-income countries (6). Rising income is associated
Obesity is a growing health problem in both developed with rising rates of overweight among infants and young
and developing countries (6). Figures 41 and 42 show the children. In high-income countries, such as the United
world distribution of the prevalence of overweight. Pro- Kingdom and the United States, lower socioeconomic sta-
spective epidemiological studies have shown a relation- tus is associated with a higher prevalence of obesity (55,
ship between overweight or obesity and cardiovascular 56). In contrast, in medium- and low-income countries a
morbidity, CVD mortality and total mortality. Obesity is positive relationship between socioeconomic status and
strongly related to major cardiovascular risk factors such as obesity in men, women and children has been observed.
raised blood pressure, glucose intolerance, type 2 diabetes
and dyslipidaemia (4, 6, 51–53).
Overweight and obesity cause adverse metabolic effects
on blood pressure, cholesterol, triglycerides and insu-
lin resistance. Risks of coronary heart disease, ischaemic
stroke and type 2 diabetes mellitus increase steadily with
an increasing BMI (54). To achieve optimal health, the me-
dian BMI for adult populations should be in the range of
*BMI ≥ 25 kg/m2
Figure en World map showing the prevalence of overweight * in females (ages 20+, age standardized) (6),
(*BMI ≥ 25 kg/m2).
*BMI ≥ 25 kg/m2
BM
Raised blood pressure
■■ Raised blood pressure is a major
risk factor for strokes and heart
attacks as well as heart failure, renal
impairment, peripheral vascular
disease and blindness.
■■ There is a continuous relationship
between blood pressure and
cardiovascular risk (risk of developing
heart attacks and strokes).
■■ Early detection of hypertension and
CVDs
Worldwide, raised blood pressure is estimated to cause females combined. The lowest prevalence of raised blood
7.5 million deaths, about 12.8% of the total of all annual pressure was in the WHO Region of the Americas, with 35%
deaths (2, 6). This accounts for 57 million DALYS or 3.7% for both males and females. Across the income groups of
of total DALYS. Raised blood pressure is a major risk fac- countries, the prevalence of raised blood pressure was con-
tor for coronary heart disease and cerebrovascular disease sistently high, with low-, lower-middle- and upper-middle-
(4). Blood pressure levels have been shown to be positively income countries all having rates of around 40% for males
and progressively related to the risk of stroke and coronary and females. The prevalence in high-income countries was
heart disease. In some age groups, the risk of CVD doubles lower, at 35% for both genders (6).
for each incremental increase of 20/10 mmHg of blood Policies to reduce salt consumption can shift the popula-
pressure, starting as low as 115/75 mmHg. In addition to tion distribution of blood pressure so that there is a reduc-
coronary heart disease and cerebrovascular disease, un- tion in cardiovascular risk (4). The stroke and heart attack
controlled blood pressure causes heart failure, renal impair- risk of people with high cardiovascular risk and/or raised
ment, peripheral vascular disease and damage to retinal blood pressure can be reduced through non-pharmaco-
blood vessels and visual impairment (1–6, 57). logical (e.g. low salt diet, physical activity) and pharmaco-
Figures 43 and 44 show the distribution of prevalence logical measures. These measures are very important for
of raised blood pressure in the world in adult males and people with diabetes as they are particularly vulnerable to
females, respectively. Globally, the overall prevalence heart attacks and strokes. Primary care access to cardiovas-
of raised blood pressure in adults aged 25 and over was cular risk assessment and essential medicines for reduc-
around 40% in 2008. The number of people with uncon- ing cardiovascular risk can improve health outcomes of
trolled hypertension has risen from 600 million in 1980 to people with hypertension (6).
nearly one billion in 2008 (6). Undetected and uncontrolled
hypertension that increases the cardiovascular risk is a ma-
jor contributor to stroke worldwide (6).
The prevalence of raised blood pressure was highest in
the WHO African Region, where it was 46% for males and
Figure ep World map showing the prevalence of raised blood pressure * in females (ages 25+, age standardized) (6),
(* SBP≥ 140 and /or DBP ≥90).
BN
Raised blood sugar
■■ The risk of cardiovascular events is
two to threefold higher in people
with diabetes and the risk is
disproportionately higher in women.
■■ Impaired glucose tolerance and
impaired fasting glycaemia increase
the risk for future development of
diabetes and CVD.
■■ Early detection and treatment of
diabetes, including reduction of
CVDs
Diabetes is a major risk factor of CVD. Diabetes is defined have a poorer prognosis after cardiovascular events com-
as having a fasting plasma glucose value ≥ 7.0 mmol/l pared to people without diabetes.
(126 mg/dl). Impaired glucose tolerance and impaired fast- Cardiovascular risk increases with raised glucose values
ing glycaemia are risk categories for future development of (61, 62). Furthermore, abnormal glucose regulation tends
diabetes and CVD (4). to occur together with other known cardiovascular risk fac-
In 2008, diabetes was responsible for 1.3 million deaths tors such as central obesity, elevated blood pressure, low
globally. The magnitude of diabetes and other abnormali- HDL cholesterol and a high triglyceride level (63–66).
ties of glucose tolerance would be considerably higher Lack of early detection and care for diabetes results in se-
than the above estimate if the categories of “impaired fast- vere complications, including heart attacks, strokes, renal
ing” and “impaired glucose tolerance” were included. In failure, amputations and blindness. Primary care access to
2008, the global prevalence of diabetes was estimated to measurement of blood glucose and cardiovascular risk as-
be 10% (6). sessment as well as essential medicines including insulin
The estimated prevalence of diabetes is relatively con- can improve health outcomes of people with diabetes (6).
sistent across the income groupings of countries. Low-
income countries showed the lowest prevalence (8% for
both males and females), and the upper-middle-income
countries showed the highest prevalence (10% for both
males and females). The prevalence of raised blood glu-
cose worldwide is shown in Figures 45 and 46).
CVD accounts for about 60% of all mortality in people with
diabetes. The risk of cardiovascular events is from two to
three times higher in people with type 1 or type 2 diabetes
and the risk is disproportionately higher in women (58–60).
In some age groups, people with diabetes have a twofold
increase in the risk of stroke (4). Patients with diabetes also
Figure er World map showing the prevalence of raised blood glucose * in females (ages 25+, age standardized) (6),
(*≥ 7 mmol/l or on medication for raised blood glucose).
BO
Raised blood
■■ Hypercholesterolaemia is a major
cardiovascular risk factor.
■■ There is continuous association
between total cholesterol and
cardiovascular risk.
■■ Lowering cholesterol in people with
moderate-high cardiovascular risk
prevents heart attacks and strokes.
cholesterol:
A major risk factor of CVDs
The lipoprotein profile includes: (i) low density lipoprotein in 40-year old men has been reported to result in a 50% re-
cholesterol (LDL), also called “bad” cholesterol); (ii) high duction in heart disease within five years; the same serum
density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL), also called “good” cholesterol reduction for 70-year old men can result in an
cholesterol); and (iii) triglycerides. Excess calories in the average 20% reduction in heart disease occurrence within
body are converted into triglycerides and stored in fat cells five years (6).
throughout the body. In 2008, the global prevalence of raised total cholesterol
LDL cholesterol is deposited in the walls of arteries and among adults was 39% (37% for males and 40% for fe-
causes atherosclerosis. In general, lower LDL cholesterol males). The prevalence of raised cholesterol in males and
numbers are better for vascular health. HDL cholesterol females in different parts of the world is shown in Figures
protects against vascular disease by removing the “bad” 47 and 48, respectively. Globally, mean total cholesterol
cholesterol out of the walls of arteries. Total blood choles- changed little between 1980 and 2008, falling by less than
terol is a measure of LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol and 0.1 mmol/l per decade in males and females. The preva-
other lipid components. High triglycerides increase the risk lence of elevated total cholesterol was highest in the WHO
of atherosclerotic CVD. European Region (54% for both genders), followed by the
Raised blood cholesterol increases the risk of heart disease WHO Region of the Americas (48% for both genders). The
and stroke (4). Globally, one third of ischaemic heart dis- WHO African Region and the WHO South-East Asia Region
ease is attributable to high cholesterol (2, 5). Overall, raised showed the lowest percentages (23% and 30%, respec-
cholesterol is estimated to cause 2.6 million deaths (4.5% tively) (6).
of total) and 29.7 million DALYS, or 2% of total DALYS glob- The prevalence of raised total cholesterol noticeably in-
ally (2). In 2008, the prevalence of raised total cholesterol creases according to the income level of the country (6).
among adults – defined as total cholesterol ≥ 6.2 mmol/l In low-income countries, around 25% of adults have raised
(240 mg/dl) – was 9.7% (8.5% for males and 10.7% for fe- total cholesterol, while in high-income countries, over 50%
males) (6). of adults have raised total cholesterol (6, 67).
Lowering raised serum cholesterol reduces the risk of heart
disease. For example, a 10% reduction in serum cholesterol
Figure et World map showing the prevalence of raised blood cholesterol * in females (ages 25+, age standardized) (6),
(*≥ 5 mmol/l or on medication for raised blood cholesterol).
BP
Social determinants
■■ Choices that people make regarding
behaviour (tobacco use, use of
alcohol, physical activity or diet) are
shaped by the “opportunities” that
society offers to them.
■■ Poverty, lack of education and
unplanned urbanization have a
negative impact on cardiovascular
health.
■■ Unfair distribution of power, money
Social determinants such as the distribution of income or uities as well as the implementation of a social determi-
the level of education indirectly influence cardiovascular nants approach across public health programmes.
health as well as health in general. These determinants Poverty, low rates of literacy (Figure 49), environmental
shape a set of socioeconomic positions within hierarchies degradation, poor housing and unplanned urbanization
of power, prestige and access to resources. Several struc- have a negative impact on health (68, 69, 71, 72). For exam-
tural mechanisms are responsible for creating the differen- ple, children from lower socioeconomic strata have a high
tial social positions of individuals, including governance, prevalence of rheumatic heart disease and people living in
education systems, labour market structures and the pres- poor housing develop Chagas cardiomyopathy. The poor,
ence or absence of redistributive welfare policies. Social have limited opportunities for healthy choices and have a
stratification shapes individual health status as well as CVD high prevalence of smoking (Figure 50).
outcomes by impacting behavioural and metabolic cardio-
To mount an effective response to address social determi-
vascular risk factors, psychosocial status, living conditions
nants that impact health, governance and systems need to
and the health system (68).
be put in place that deliver a wide range of intersectoral ac-
In 2005, WHO convened the Commission on Social De- tions. Promoting participation and leadership of commu-
terminants of Health to provide advice on how to reduce nities and civil society groups in decision-making are key
health inequities. The final report of the Commission (69) aspects of the governance necessary for action on social
made three overarching recommendations: (i) to improve determinants. Such an inclusive and responsible approach
daily living conditions; (ii) to tackle the unequal distribution would contribute to the implementation of coherent poli-
of power, money and resources; and (iii) to monitor health cies that increase opportunities for people and create a
inequities. WHO Member States discussed the report and fairer society and healthier populations.
passed a resolution urging action on social determinants at
the 2009 World Health Assembly (WHA) (70). The resolution
called for a “Health in All Policies” approach and a renewed
commitment to intersectoral action to reduce health ineq-
Figure fl Smoking prevalence by income quintiles, People in poorest households in poorer countries smoke the most
(11, 24, 25).
45
40
35
30
Percentage
25
20 Lowest household
income quintiles
15
10
5
Highest household
0 income quintiles
Low-income Lower-middle- Upper-middle- High-income
countries income countries income countries countries
BQ
Risk factors take
■■ Improving the nutrition of girls and
women could prevent CVD in future
generations.
■■ Implementation of policies to
promote healthy lifestyles in children
and youth is essential for prevention
of CVD.
■■ Undernutrition in fetal life and
infancy increases an individual’s
vulnerability to CVD.
Low birth weight is associated with an increased risk of 51 and 52). Children also have no control over exposure to
adult diabetes and CVD. There is increasing evidence that passive cigarette smoke.
exposure to undernutrition in early life increases an indi- When exposed to risk factors, changes of atherosclerosis
vidual’s vulnerability to these disorders by “programming” within blood vessels have been shown to begin in the first
permanent metabolic changes (73–75). The fetus depends decade of life as fatty streaks and plaques (7). These lesions
on the mother for its nutrition and adapts to inadequate have been shown to regress through modification of be-
nutrition by prioritization of brain growth at the expense of havioural risk factors.
other tissues such as the abdominal organs and by altered
Many WHA resolutions address the protection of children
secretion and sensitivity to the fetal growth hormones,
and youth from health risks (3, 78–81):
insulin and upregulation of the hypothalamo-pituitary-
■■ WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control
adrenal “stress” axis. The fetus sacrifices tissues that require
(FCTC); resolution WHA56.1;
high-quality building blocks, such as muscle or bone, and
instead lays down less demanding tissue, such as fat. These ■■ Global Strategy to Reduce the Harmful Use of Alcohol,
changes can become “programmed” because they occur resolution WHA63.13;
during critical periods of early development and can lead ■■ Global Strategy on Diet, Physical Activity and Health,
to adult CVD, or render the individual more susceptible to resolution WHA57.17;
the effects of environmental and behavioural risk factors. ■■ recommendations on the marketing of foods and non-
Behavioural risk factors such as tobacco use and dietary alcoholic beverages to children; endorsed in resolution
habits are learned in childhood and continue into adult- WHA63.14;
hood. In many countries, metabolic risk factors such as ■■ 2008–2013 Action Plan for the Global Strategy for Pre-
obesity and diabetes are starting to appear at early ages vention and Control of Noncommunicable Diseases
(76, 77). In 2008, global estimates for overweight among (WHO Global NCD Action Plan); resolution WHA61.14.
infants and young children indicated that there were However, development and implementation of policies
40 million (or 6%) preschool children with a weight-for- and strategies at the country level to protect the health
height above more than two standard deviations of the and well-being of pregnant women, children and youth
WHO child growth standards median (6). Children spend remain inadequate. Undernutrition in fetal life and infancy
a substantial portion of their time watching television, increases an individual’s vulnerability to CVD. Healthy be-
which can contribute to obesity through displacement of haviours such as physical activity are learned in childhood
physical activity and increased calorie consumption while and continue into adulthood.
watching or caused by the effects of advertising (Figures
28
26 USA
24
Prevalence (%) of overweight in children
22
20 Australia
UK
18
Greece
Germany
16 Sweden France
14 Finland
Denmark
12 Netherlands
10
0 50 100 150 200
Figure fn Percentage of television advertisements on sweets, fatty food and healthy food in selected countries (iv-ix).
Australia
UK
Brazil
Spain
Malaysia
China
Sweden
South Africa
Greece
Italy
Mexico
Canada
Bulgaria
USA
Germany
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Type of food advertisements on television (%)
BR
Heart attacks and strokes in
■■ Risk factors of CVDs are similar for
men and women.
■■ Every year 8.6 million women die from
CVDs.
■■ CVD affects as many women as men.
women
There are many misconceptions about CVDs in women. in the clinical presentation of CVD in women leading to
In reality, CVDs affect as many men as women. However, inadequate diagnostic and treatment interventions (82).
women loose less years of life due to CVDs as the disease Better self-awareness in women regarding identification of
develops about 7-10 years later in women compared to their cardiovascular risk factors and symptoms can improve
men (4, 6) (Figure 53). Risk factors of CVDs are similar for early detection. There is evidence that CVD is underdetect-
men and women. Every year, 3.3 million women die of ed in women and that there are delays in referral, hospital-
heart attacks and 3.2 million die of strokes globally. ization, diagnosis and invasive treatment compared to men
Gender norms and roles influence these risk factors as wom- (83–86). Women with CVD living in developing countries
en, in some contexts, do not have access to and control over experience specific challenges in accessing cost-effective
resources that can diminish their exposure to the risk factors. prevention, early detection and treatment due to gender
For example, women’s multiple roles in the household and inequality, family responsibilities and the costs of seeking
workplace community may diminish their ability to engage care. These factors are made worse by health systems that
in meaningful physical activity. Social expectations relating fail to respond to specific needs of women.
to mobility and norms about permitted clothing influence Women, although responsible for household food pro-
the ability of girls and women to participate in sports and curement and preparation in most societies, may not have
developing a lifelong habit that values physical activity. access to the requisite information about healthy food.
In the developing world, tobacco use rates for adult fe- Women are responsible for rearing children, including how
males remain relatively low, but could rise quickly among time is used and development of health promoting hab-
teenage females (25). Aggressive campaigns by the tobac- its. Such habits are often not passed along if women are
co industry, which targeted women and girls increasingly not specifically targeted as both beneficiaries and signifi-
over the years, have contributed to such increases and are cant gatekeepers for health promotion to other members
of great public health concern. of their families. Their potential role as “change agents” of
families and communities with respect to healthy behav-
The risk of heart disease and stroke in women are often un-
iours is often underutilized.
derestimated because of the mistaken notion that females
are protected from CVDs. There may be certain differences
450
400
350
CVD death rate (per 1000 000)
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Low-income Lower-middle-income Upper-middle-income High-income
BS
Other determinants
■■ Ageing, globalization and
urbanization drive the cardiovascular
epidemic that is shaped by the rise of
behavioural risk factors.
■■ Unregulated globalization and
unplanned urbanization increase the
risk of exposure to cardiovascular
risk factors and are detrimental to
cardiovascular health.
of CVDs: Ageing,
globalization and urbanization
Mortality due to CVD has declined in high-income coun- national economic performance and household income.
tries during the last three decades, while the cardiovascular National income is particularly important for prevention
epidemic continues to increase in other countries to the and control of CVD because of its impact on public sector
extent that the majority of the disease burden from CVD resources available for health care.
is found in LMICs. This situation primarily results from tre- Rapid, unplanned urbanization also promotes unhealthy
mendous global shifts in demographics with the ageing of behaviours i) by limiting healthy food choices ii) by not
populations (Figure 54) and accompanied by urbanization providing environments conducive to physical activity iii)
(Figure 55) and the globalization of unhealthy behaviours, by causing exposure to air pollutants (including tobacco
producing an explosive increase in the population preva- smoke) and the harmful use of alcohol (90). Many govern-
lence of cardiovascular risk factors and subsequent disease ments and municipalities are unable to keep pace with
(1, 2, 6). rapidly expanding needs for infrastructure and services
Age is a powerful cardiovascular risk factor. The rapidly and overlook the fact that urban planning is needed to
growing burden of CVD in LMICs is accelerated by popula- support health behaviours. As a consequence, people are
tion ageing. According to United Nations (UN) projections, exposed to risks and denied healthy choices in terms of
in 2025 there will be 1.2 billion elderly people worldwide, diet and physical activity.
with 71% of them likely to be in developing countries (87).
CVD is also driven by the negative effects of unregulated
globalization and unplanned urbanization (88, 89). For ex-
ample, irresponsible marketing supported by multination-
al food cooperations is targeting children and adolescents
to promote consumption of “junk” food with high levels
of energy, fat and salt. Similarly, well-funded advertising
campaigns of tobacco companies are targeting women to
promote tobacco smoking. Financial and economic glo-
balization also has an influence on trade, national income,
Age category
Age category
-0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20% -0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20%
Proportion of total males (%) and females (%) Proportion of total males (%) and females (%)
Age category
-0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 -0,0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20% -0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 -0,0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20%
Proportion of total males (%) and females (%) Proportion of total males (%) and females (%)
Age category
45–49 5.5% 5.5% 45–49 6.2% 6.3%
40–44 6.4% 6.4% 40–44 6.5% 6.5%
35–39 7.1% 7.1% 35–39 7.2% 7.1%
30–34 7.5% 7.4% 30–34 8.1% 7.8%
25–29 8.3% 8.1% 25–29 9.0% 8.7%
20–24 9.3% 8.9% 20–24 9.4% 8.9%
15–19 10.2% 9.6% 15–19 8.8% 8.2%
10–14 10.5% 9.8% 10–14 8.4% 7.8%
5–9 9.8% 9.1% 5–9 8.5% 7.8%
0–4 9.5% 8.7% 0–4 8.6% 9.9%
-0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 -0,0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20% -0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 -0,0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20%
Proportion of total males (%) and females (%) Proportion of total males (%) and females (%)
Age category
-0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 -0,0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20% -0,20%
20 -0,15
15% -0,10
10% -0,5%05 -0,0,0%00 0,5%05 0,10
10% 0,15
15% 0,20
20%
Proportion of total males (%) and females (%) Proportion of total males (%) and females (%)
100% Nauru
Kuwait
Belgium
Malta
Australia Argentina
90% Lebanon New Zealand
Denmark Brazil United Kingdom
Proportion of population living in urban areas (%)
Gabon Sweden
Netherlands Canada USA Luxembourg Saudi Arabia
80% Libyan Arab Jamahiriya United Arab Emirates
Dominica France Mexico Norway Spain
Russian Federation Germany Colombia Marshall Islands Cyprus Malaysia Cook Islands
Czech Bulgaria
70% Estonia Ukraine Republic
Hungary Austria Iran (Islamic Republic of)
Italy
Turkey
Dominican Republic
Lithuania Latvia Tunisia Ecuador Iraq Japan
Philippines
Sao Tome and Principe Finland Algeria Congo South Africa
60% Greece Poland Paraguay Ireland
Croatia Botswana Portugal
Mongolia Cape Verde Gambia Kazakhstan Cameroon
Slovakia Seychelles Romania
Georgia Jamaica Serbia
Indonesia Côte d'Ivoire
50% Guatemala
Ghana Bosnia and Herzegovina
Slovenia
Kiribati
Benin Sierra Leone Senegal China Mauritius Mauritania
40% Maldives Barbados
Mozambique Zambia Zimbabwe Pakistan Namibia
Guinea Thailand Bhutan
Myanmar Mali Madagascar Saint Kitts and Nevis
30% Democratic Republic
Bangladesh Viet Nam India Lao People's Chad
of the Congo
Comoros Democratic Tonga Swaziland
Cambodia Burkina Republic Samoa
Faso Eritrea Micronesia (Federated States of)
20% Kenya Solomon Islands
Malawi Nepal Ethiopia Sri Lanka
Niger
Papua New Guinea
10%
0%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
BT
Inequities and CVDs
■■ CVD affect the poor as well as the rich.
■■ Inequities of power, money and
resources impact the health status
and the development of CVD.
■■ Disadvantaged populations are more
exposed to cardiovascular risk due to
lack of power and knowledge.
■■ Unfair policy choices are the root
causes of health inequities.
Socioeconomic stratification has been consistently associ- There are differences in exposure to health risks and health
ated with differences in prevalence of cardiovascular risk outcomes between different population groups that are
factors, CVD incidence and mortality across multiple popu- avoidable, unfair and remediable (99–107). Unfair policy
lations (91–96). CVD and its risk factors were originally more choices are often the root causes of these differences. Even
common in upper socioeconomic groups in the devel- in countries where the conditions for universal health cov-
oped world, but this pattern has reversed over the last 50 erage are broadly achieved, inequities persist between dif-
years. Those in low socioeconomic positions have a poorer ferent socioeconomic, ethnic and geographic groups.
risk factor profile, including greater levels of hypertension Figure 56 shows the Gini index of national income distri-
and diabetes and a trend towards higher rates of smoking bution around the world. The Gini index is a measure of
compared to those of higher socioeconomic positions (6, the inequality of a distribution (0 = equality and 100 = in-
97). The inverse association between socioeconomic status equality). Figure 57 shows the CVD mortality by World Bank
and CVD is strongest for incidence and mortality of stroke, income groups and the higher Gini index (higher income
with low socioeconomic groups showing lower survival inequality)in low income countries compared to high in-
and higher stroke incidence in many populations in devel- come countries. Figure 58 shows the association between
oped countries (93, 95, 96). stroke mortality rates and national income.
From the moment of conception, during intrauterine life Several complementary approaches in health and other
and over the course of a lifetime, the cumulative risk of cor- sectors are required to address inequities. First, policy and
onary heart disease and cerebrovascular disease develops structural interventions must address root social causes such
by way of a complex interplay of genetics, in utero environ- as poverty, illiteracy, unemployment and deprived neigh-
ment, biological risk factors and social determinants. Disad- bourhoods. Second, protecting the cardiovascular health
vantaged populations are more exposed to risks (tobacco of lower socioeconomic groups through population-based
use, use of alcohol, physical activity or diet). The extent of prevention strategies needs to be a priority. Third, health sys-
exposure is shaped by the “opportunities” that society offers tem delivery of primary and secondary prevention interven-
to individuals (97). In addition to unhealthy behaviours, dis- tions must pay special attention to disadvantaged groups.
advantaged groups have limited access to social support, And fourth, resources need to be earmarked for improving
lack of perception of control and greater job stress, lower the health of disadvantaged groups who may lack political
health-seeking behaviours, less access to medical care and power for making the case for sufficient funding.
greater comorbidity (98).
GINI index*
0–34
35–40
41–47
48–74
Data not available © WHO 2011. All rights reserved.
Figure fs Gini index and CVD mortality by World Bank Income group in men and women, (age standardized,
per 100 000) (1, iii).
450 50.00
400 45.00
40.00
350
CVD death rate (per 100 000)
35.00
300
30.00 GINI index
250
25.00
200
20.00
150
15.00
100 10.00
50 5.00
0 0.00
Low-income Lower-middle-income Upper-middle-income High-income
300
Cerebrovascular disease death rate (per 100 000)
250
200
150
y = -0.0012x + 109.14
R2 = 0.27233
100
50
0
100 10 100 20 100 30 100 40 100 50 100 60 100 70 100 80 100 90 100
Figure ft 2. Association between the burden of cerebrovascular disease and national income (130).
2 500
Cerebrovascular disease burden (DALYs, per 100 000)
2 000
1 500
y = -0,0012x + 994.98
R2 = 0.2473
1 000
500
0
100 10 100 20 100 30 100 40 100 50 100 60 100 70 100 80 100 90 100
Other CVDs
Key messages
BU
Cardiac arrhythmia
■■ The percentage of strokes attributable
to atrial fibrillation increases with
age, and in the elderly it accounts for
about one fifth of all strokes.
■■ Coronary artery disease is a cause of
cardiac arrhythmia.
■■ Sudden death due to a cardiac
arrhythmia may be the first sign of
coronary artery disease.
Each heartbeat originates as an electrical impulse in the of stroke attributable to atrial fibrillation increases from
right atrium of the heart in the area called the sino atrial 1.5% for ages 50–59 to 23.5% for ages 80–89 (108, 109). If
node. The impulse initially causes both of the atria to con- electrocardiography facilities are available, atrial fibrillation
tract, then activates the atrioventricular node and the elec- can be diagnosed by opportunistic and targeted screening
trical impulse spreads through both ventricles via the bun- in primary care. Once atrial fibrillation is diagnosed, drugs
dle of His and the Purkinje fibres causing a synchronized are given to control the heart rate and anticoagulants are
contraction of the ventricles of the heart. given to prevent stroke (110).
Abnormal electrical activity in the heart is known as car- Heart attacks may present as ventricular arrhythmias. Sud-
diac arrhythmia; the heartbeat may be too fast or too slow, den cardiac death due to such arrhythmias is an important
and may be regular or irregular. It may originate from the cause of cardiovascular mortality. Electrical defibrillation
region of the atria or ventricles. Sometimes cardiac ar- is required to restore coordinated activity of the heart in
rhythmia is life threatening and causes medical emergen- these cases and even short delays in defibrillation signifi-
cies, sometimes it may not cause symptoms or it may give cantly deteriorate outcome. To enable early out-of-hospital
rise to palpitations. Atrial fibrillation is one of the common defibrillation, automated external defibrillators are increas-
tachyarrhythmias arising from the atria (Figure 59). It is ingly made available for public use in highly frequented
characterized by predominantly uncoordinated atrial acti- places in developed countries (111, 112).
vation with consequent deterioration of mechanical func- However, public access defibrillation programmes are ex-
tion of the heart (108). pensive and the marginal improvements in survival do not
The prevalence of atrial fibrillation increases with advanc- justify spending the limited financial resources for wide-
ing age to a prevalence of about 9% for ages 80–89 (108). scale deployment of automated external defibrillation in
Other risk factors of atrial fibrillation include hypertension, resource-constrained settings. In such settings, more funds
diabetes, thyroid overactivity and cardiac valve abnormali- need to be diverted to strengthening programmes for pre-
ties. Atrial fibrillation is commonly associated with, and vention of CVD in order to reduce the need for defibrilla-
complicated by, stroke and congestive heart failure. Atrial tion programmes (112–114).
fibrillation increases the risk of stroke fivefold. The incidence
CL
Congenital heart
■■ A significant proportion of congenital
heart disease can be prevented
by public health measures such as
rubella vaccination, promotion of
universal use of salt fortified with
iodine and promotion of staple food
fortified with folic acid.
■■ Policies to optimize women’s diet
before and throughout pregnancy are
critical for prevention of congenital
Congenital heart disease is a defect in the structure and the heart causes mixing of blood from the right and left
function of the heart due to abnormal heart development sides of the heart. Non-cyanotic congenital heart diseases
before birth. With an incidence ranging from 19 to 75 per include ventricular septal defect, atrial septal defect, patent
1000 live births, congenital heart disease is an important ductus arteriosus, aortic stenosis, pulmonary stenosis, coarc-
cause of childhood morbidity and mortality worldwide tation of the aorta and atrioventricular canal (endocardial
(115). Congenital heart disease is the leading cause of birth cushion defect).
defects. When infectious diseases are excluded, congenital Symptoms depend on the specific defect. While cyanotic
heart disease accounts for more deaths in the first year of congenital heart disease such as Fallots tetrology (Fig-
life than any other condition (1, 116). ure 60) features are present at birth, some other defects
Birth defects can be caused by single gene defects, chro- may not be immediately obvious. Defects such as coarcta-
mosomal disorders, multifactorial inheritance, environ- tion of the aorta may not cause problems for many years.
mental teratogens and micronutrient deficiencies (115, People with small ventricular septal defects may have no
116). Maternal infectious diseases such as syphilis and ru- symptoms and can have a normal lifespan. Many congeni-
bella are also significant causes of birth defects in LMICs. tal heart defects are amenable to cost-effective surgery
Diabetes mellitus and iodine and folic acid deficiency in that can be life saving and improve long-term prognosis.
the mother as well as exposure to medicines and recre- A portfolio of prevention approaches are available for pre-
ational drugs, including alcohol and tobacco, certain envi- vention of congenital heart disease and other birth defects
ronmental chemicals and high doses of radiation, are other (117). Most birth defects of environmental origin can be
factors that cause birth defects (116). prevented by public health approaches, including preven-
The majority of congenital heart diseases presents as an tion of sexually transmitted infections, legislation controlling
isolated defect and is not associated with other diseases. management of toxic chemicals (e.g. certain agricultural
They can also be a part of various genetic and chromosom- chemicals), vaccination against rubella and fortification of
al syndromes such as Down syndrome, Turner syndrome, basic foods with micronutrients (iodine and folic acid). Poli-
Marfan syndrome, trisomy 13 and Noonan syndrome. cies to optimize women’s diet before and throughout preg-
Congenital heart disease can be cyanotic (Figure 60) or non- nancy are critical for prevention of birth defects, including
cyanotic (Figure 61) depending on whether the defect in congenital heart and nervous system defects (117, 118).
Overriding aorta
Pulmonic stenosis
Right ventricular
hypertrophy
Figure gm Diagram of a heart with patent ductus arteriosus (PDA); an abnormality seen in 50% of children with
congenital rubella syndrome (i). Reproduced with
Heart cross permission.
section with patent ductus arteriosus
PDA
Aorta
Pulmonary artery
Left pulmonary veins
High pulmonary veins
Left atrium
CM
Rheumatic heart
■■ At least 15.6 million people are
estimated to be currently affected by
rheumatic heart disease.
■■ Rheumatic heart disease
disproportionately impacts children
and young adults living in low-income
countries.
■■ Poverty alleviation and better living
conditions are key for prevention of
rheumatic heart disease.
poor
prophylaxis.
Rheumatic fever is a common cause of acquired heart dis- The global burden of disease caused by rheumatic fever
ease in children and adolescents living in poor socioeco- and rheumatic heart disease currently falls disproportion-
nomic conditions. Acute rheumatic fever follows untreated ately on children and young adults living in low-income
or inadequately treated group A streptococcal infection of countries and is responsible for about 233 000 deaths
the tonsillopharynx and manifests after a latent period of annually (Figures 63–66). At least 15.6 million people are
about three weeks. Acute rheumatic fever primarily affects estimated to be currently affected by rheumatic heart dis-
the heart, joints and central nervous system. The major ease with a significant number of them requiring repeated
importance of acute rheumatic fever is its ability to cause hospitalization and often unaffordable heart surgery in the
fibrosis of heart valves (Figure 62), leading to crippling hae- next 5 to 20 years (120–122).
modynamics of valvular heart disease, heart failure and Primary prevention is achieved by treatment of acute throat
death. Surgery is often required to repair or replace heart infections caused by group A streptococcus. This effect
valves in patients with severely damaged valves, the cost may be achieved at relatively low cost if a single intramus-
of which is very high and a drain on the limited health re- cular penicillin injection is administered (123). Secondary
sources of poor countries. prevention is used following an attack of acute rheumatic
Rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease continue to fever to prevent the progression to cardiac disease and
exert a significant burden on the health of low socioeco- has to be continued for many years. Secondary prevention
nomic populations in LMICs despite the near disappear- programmes are currently thought to be more cost effec-
ance of the disease in the developed world over the past tive for prevention of rheumatic heart disease than primary
century (119). The decline of rheumatic fever in developed prevention and may be the only feasible option for LMICs
countries is believed to be the result of improved living (119) in addition to poverty alleviation efforts.
conditions and availability of antibiotics for treatment of
group A streptococcal infection. Overcrowding, poor hous-
ing conditions, undernutrition and lack of access to health
care play a role in the persistence of this disease in devel-
oping countries.
Figure gq Proportion of global CVD burden (DALYs) due Figure gr Proportion of global CVD burden (DALYs) due
to rheumatic heart disease in males, 2008 (5). to rheumatic heart disease in females, 2008 (5).
CN
Chagas disease
■■ Chagas disease is a neglected disease
of the poor that has a high potential
for elimination through alleviation of
poverty and improvement of living
conditions.
■■ An estimated 10 million people
are infected with Chagas disease
worldwide.
(American trypanosomiasis):
A neglected disease of the
poor
Chagas disease is a chronic, systemic, parasitic infection An estimated 10 million people are infected worldwide,
caused by the protozoan Trypanosoma cruzi. It is mainly mostly in Latin America where Chagas disease is endemic
transmitted by the infected faeces of triatomine bugs (also (Figure 68). More than 25 million people are at risk of the
known as “kissing bugs”), which live in the cracks in the disease. It is estimated that in 2008 Chagas disease killed
walls of poorly constructed homes in rural or suburban more than 10 000 people (124). In the past several decades,
areas. The illness can also be transmitted by blood trans- it has been increasingly detected in Canada, the United
fusions or organ transplants from infected donors or from States and European and Western Pacific countries mainly
an infected mother to her newborn during pregnancy or due to migration of infected people from endemic coun-
childbirth (124–128). tries (127).
Chagas disease has two phases: the initial acute phase of Key components of prevention and control initiative of
infection lasts from four to eight weeks; and the chronic Chagas Disease include vector control, prevention of trans-
phase persists for the lifespan of the host. The acute phase mission from non-vectorial mechanisms, improved hous-
may be asymptomatic; when symptoms occur, they in- ing, health education, epidemiological surveillance, sero-
clude: malaise; fever; hepatomegaly; splenomegaly; logical screening and drug treatment. Such initiatives have
lymphadenopathy; subcutaneous oedema (localized or achieved a substantial decrease in the burden of Chagas
generalized); signs of portal of entry of Trypanosoma cruzi disease. However, to maintain the achieved results and fur-
through a skin lesion (chagoma); or purplish swelling of the ther decrease the burden, surveillance and control activi-
lids of one eye (Romaña sign) (Figure 67). During the chron- ties, including vector control, serological screening, super-
ic phase, up to 30% of patients suffer from cardiac disorders vised treatment and new antiparasitic drugs, are needed
and up to 10% suffer from digestive problems (typically en- at international, regional and national levels in the future
largement of the oesophagus or colon) and neurological (127–129).
involvement. Chagas disease can lead to sudden death or
heart failure caused by progressive destruction of the heart
muscle (124–126).
CO
Prevention and
■■ The decline in cardiovascular
mortality seen in many developed
countries over the last two decades
has been attributed to reduced
incidence rates and/or improved
survival after cardiovascular events
due to a combination of prevention
and treatment interventions.
■■ To reverse CVD trends, a significant
increase in the investment in
700
Ischamic heart disease death rate (per 100 000)
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Years
Figure . Trends in CVD mortality rates in the United Figure . Trends in CVD mortality rates in Finland
Kingdom (15, xi). (14, xi).
hlm hln
3000 500
Men Men
Mortality rate from ischaemic heart disease (per 100 000)
Women Women
2500
Ischaemic heart disease deaths (per 100 000)
400
2000
300
1500
200
1000
100
500
0 0
1968 1973 1978 1983 1988 1993 1998 2003 2008 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Years Years
CP
Prevention and
■■ For prevention and control of CVD a
combination of population-wide and
individual health-care strategies is
required.
■■ The total-risk approach for controlling
cardiovascular risk factors is more
cost effective than a single-risk factor
approach.
control of CVDs:
The need for integrated and
complimentary strategies
In all populations, it is essential that individual health care are initiated depends on the availability of resources and
targeting people at raised cardiovascular risk and people the impact of specific interventions. The cost effectiveness
with disease is complemented by population-wide public of pharmacological treatment for high blood pressure and
health strategies (Figure 31) (4, 6). Although cardiovascu- blood cholesterol depends on the total cardiovascular risk
lar events are less likely to occur in people with low lev- of the individual before treatment (4, 137–141); long-term
els of risk, no level of risk can be considered “safe”. Without drug treatment is justified only in high-risk individuals
population-wide public health prevention efforts, cardio- with a low risk–benefit ratio. If resources allow, the target
vascular events will continue to occur in people with low population can be expanded to include those with mod-
and moderate levels of risk, and who are the majority in erate levels of risk; however, lowering the threshold for
any population. Furthermore, public health approaches treatment will increase not only the benefits, but also the
can effectively slow down the development of atheroscle- costs and potential harm. Everyone with low levels of risk
rosis (and also reduce the incidence of some cancers and will benefit from population-based public health strategies
chronic respiratory diseases) in young people, thereby re- and, if resources allow, individual counselling to motivate
ducing the likelihood of future epidemics of cardiovascular behavioural change.
events such as were seen in the period 1960–1990 in most State-funded health systems have the difficult task of set-
high-income countries. Population-wide strategies would ting a risk threshold for treatment that balances the health-
also support lifestyle modification in those at high risk. care resources in the public sector, the wishes of clinicians
The extent to which one strategy is emphasized over the and the expectations of the public. These decisions are par-
other depends on achievable effectiveness, cost effective- ticularly challenging when public expenditure for health is
ness and resource considerations. Prevention and control inadequate (Figures 71 and 72). As the threshold for inter-
of strokes and heart attacks require integrated strategies vention is lowered, the number of individuals eligible to
because they share common risk factors and a common benefit increases, but so do the costs and the number of
pathogenesis (atherosclerosis) (134–136). adverse events caused by drug treatments (2, 4, 6).
The appropriate threshold of an individual’s total risk at
which intensive lifestyle interventions and drug treatment
Figure hn World map showing health expenditure as a percentage of the gross domestic product (11, iii).
CQ
Prevention and control of CVDs:
■■ Determinants of CVD lie outside the
health sector in many other domains.
■■ Prevention and control of CVD require
a coherent policy response and
intersectoral collaboration.
Determinants of cardiovascular risk factors (tobacco use, why health is a shared goal across society and identify how
unhealthy diet and physical inactivity) lie outside the health other sectors can benefit from action to protect health, in
sector in many other domains, including finance, educa- terms of their own priorities. The health sector also has an
tion, transport, agriculture, food, trade, environment and important role in working with other sectors to reduce dif-
urban planning (4, 142, 143). Prevention and control of CVD ferences in exposure and vulnerability to cardiovascular
require a coherent policy response across all these sectors. risk factors.
Ministries of health have the challenging task of providing Despite new insights into the impact on health of poor
leadership to navigate stakeholders in these multiple sec- housing, built-up environment, lack of education and un-
tors who have differing interests by setting shared respon- employment, systems in all countries remain inadequate
sibilities for improvements in health that are linked to other to coherently implement whole-of-government strategies
development priorities. working between different sectors to address these issues
Health in All Policies highlights the important links be- (68, 69, 144). As no single sector on its own can mount an
tween health and broader economic and social goals in effective response, new systems and governance are re-
modern societies. It is a political choice and highly context quired to deliver a range of actions for protection of car-
specific. It requires strategies to support the required gov- diovascular health. The lack of development of the nec-
ernance and implementation of integrated policies. Health essary governance and systems to implement coherent
in All Policies needs to be viewed as a shared goal across policies across government has been a significant obstacle
different government departments, and be used as an in- to progress. The response needs to consider the impact of
novative approach to intersectoral action. intersectoral policies on health as well as the benefits of
While implementation of policies across different sectors is improvements in health for the goals of other sectors.
essential to improve cardiovascular health, the health sec-
tor remains vital for progress. It has an important role in
the governance required for intersectoral action, although
it should not expect to lead all activities in other sectors.
Instead, the health sector needs to construct a dialogue on
75
Key messages
CR
Prevention and
■■ Healthy public policies are essential
for prevention and control of CVD.
■■ A national NCD policy enables
governments to take coherent and
sustained macrolevel action on
intersectoral and health system
issues that are key for prevention and
control of all NCDs, including CVD.
■■ Multiple stakeholders need to
be engaged in monitoring and
CS
Policies and
■■ Tobacco control interventions are best
buys.
■■ Implementing specific tobacco
demand reduction measures is
possible in a short time.
■■ Accelerating progress in tobacco
control requires leadership of national
authorities, political commitment,
efficient governance mechanisms and
investment.
strategies for
tobacco control
To counter the global threat of the growing tobacco epi- Many countries have successfully implemented the follow-
demic, WHO Member States have negotiated the WHO ing articles of the WHO FCTC:
Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), which ■■ Article 6: Increasing tobacco taxes and prices (Figure
has been ratified by over 170 countries representing about 74);
90% of the world's population (145–147). The reports from ■■ Article 8: Creating completely smoke-free environ-
Parties indicate massive progress worldwide, with strong ments in indoor workplaces, public places and trans-
achievements by Parties and the Conference of Parties. portation;
Countries can take advantage of the significant progress ■■ Articles 11 and 12: Warning the population about the
in implementing the WHO FCTC and remarkable global dangers of tobacco;
momentum for tobacco control created by the treaty to
■■ Article 13: Banning tobacco advertising, promotion and
further advance its implementation.
sponsorship;
Preliminary new evidence indicates that total expenditure ■■ Article 5.2: Creating strong national tobacco control
for implementation of tobacco control demand reduction programmes as a mechanism to exert governmental
strategies would range from US$ 0.10 to US$ 0.23/person/ leadership in tobacco control;
year in low-income and lower-middle-income countries,
■■ Article 5.3: Protecting public health policies from com-
and from US$ 0.11 to US$ 0.72/person/year in upper-mid-
mercial and other vested interests of the tobacco in-
dle-income countries. An important portion of this expen-
dustry.
diture is attributed to educational media campaigns, while
other measures come at a lower cost (e.g. increasing taxes, More recently, the tobacco industry has been shifting its
complete smoke-free indoor environments, health warn- focus to LMICs, with a particular emphasis on marketing
ings, banning tobacco advertising, promotion and spon- to the young and to women in these countries. This has
sorship) (6, 145, 148, 149). resulted in an increase in tobacco use among the young
(Figure 75) and in women. The size and reach of the to-
Experiences in several countries show that implementing
bacco industry activities alone can, if left unchecked, undo
the demand reduction measures of the WHO FCTC can be
much of the health gains achieved by many LMICs in the
accomplished in a short time and at very reasonable cost.
last 20 or so years.
Scaling up the implementation of the WHO FCTC is feasi-
ble and would bring immense health, social and economic
benefits (25, 78, 150–157).
Figure hq Prevalence of current tobacco use among youth (13-15 year old boys and girls) by World Bank income group
and exposure to tobacco smoke(indoor and outdoor) (11).
30% 65%
25% 55%
45%
and tobacco products (%)
20%
35%
15%
25%
10%
15%
5% 5%
0% -5%
Low-income Lower-middle-income Upper-middle-income High-income
CT
Policies and
■■ Reduction of saturated and trans-
fatty acids, reduction of salt from
industrially processed food, reduction
of marketing of food and non-
alcoholic beverages to children and
improvement of availability of fruits
and vegetables are interventions that
can have a high impact in preventing
CVDs.
strategies to
■■ Accelerating progress in reducing
diet-related NCDs/CVDs requires the
leadership of national authorities,
In response to global nutrition challenges, the 63rd World There is evidence to suggest that multipronged interven-
Health Assembly requested WHO to develop a compre- tion strategies have the potential to achieve greater health
hensive implementation plan on maternal, young child gains than individual interventions, and often with greater
and infant nutrition that would boost the implementation cost effectiveness. Additionally, a combination of national
of food and nutrition policies and programmes worldwide and local-level actions in different sectors is beneficial to
(158). In addition, to counteract the extensive advertising the implementation of food and nutrition policies. They in-
and other forms of food marketing to children, the 63rd clude maternity protection at work, improvement of family
World Health Assembly endorsed a set of recommenda- and community practices, improving skills in health work-
tions on the marketing of foods and non-alcoholic bever- ers, communication and information strategies, product
ages to children (81). The document calls for national and labelling to help consumers make the right food choices
international action to reduce the impact on children of and improving school food in combination with educa-
marketing of foods high in saturated fats, trans-fatty acids, tional activities and interventions in workplace settings (3,
free sugars or salt. 25, 80, 151–163).
The maximum benefit of a life-course approach to improv- Figure 79 shows the salt consumption per capita and salt
ing nutrition would be achieved from interventions target- consumption surplus in selected countries. WHO has set
ing early stages of life as well as actions towards older chil- a global target for maximum intake of salt for adults at 5
dren and adolescents (80, 159–163). There is evidence that grams/day (i.e. 2000 mg/day of sodium) or lower if speci-
poor nutrition during pregnancy and early life increases fied by national targets (43, 49, 50, 159). High-income coun-
the predisposition to NCDs later in life (72–74). Television tries are taking steps to reduce population salt intake by
advertising is associated with increased consumption of reducing salt in processed food (45). In rural areas in LMICs,
snacks and drinks high in sugar, consumption of nutrient- where most of the salt consumed comes from salt added
poor foods and increased caloric intake. Figures 76 and 77 during cooking or from sauces and additives, a public edu-
show trans-fatty acids as a percentage of total fat in fast cation campaign is needed to encourage people to use
foods sold in selected countries. Improvement of infant less salt. In urban areas in LMICs, there is increasing con-
and young child feeding and the reduction in marketing sumption of processed and prepared food. In these areas,
of foods and non-alcoholic beverages high in salt, fats and a combination of measures, including a food industry re-
sugar to children are cost-effective actions to reduce CVDs sponse to reduce the amount of salt added to food, food
and other NCDs. Figure 78 shows countries that have taken labelling and consumer education, will be required to re-
regulatory action to reduce trans-fats. duce the population intake of sodium.
Figure hs Proportion of trans fatty acids as a percentage of total fat (fried chicken and chips) sold in selected countries,
in a different multinational food chain outlet shown in Figure 76 (xii, xiii).
50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
* Spain: average Malaga and Barcelona; UK: average Glasgow, Aberdeen,
Proportion
Proportion London;acids
ofoftrans-fatty
trans-fatty Germany: average Hamburg
acidsasasaapercentage
percentage totaland
ofoftotal fatWiesbaden; US: average NYC and
fat
Boston; South Africa: average Johanesberg and Durban.
-15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20
Average salt consumption per capita (gr/day) and salt surplus based on WHO recommendation
WHO recommendation: 5 gr/person/day
CU
Policies and
■■ An enabling environment facilitates
regular physical activity.
■■ Physical activity is influenced by
policies and practices in many sectors,
including transport, sport, education,
environment, urban design and the
media.
■■ It is critical to engage all stakeholders
as part of the solution for physical
inactivity.
strategies to
facilitate physical activity
Physical activity can play a significant role in the preven- likely to have sedentary occupations, to use motorized
tion and control of CVD and in addressing overweight and means of transportation and be less likely to engage in
obesity (Figures 80–82). There are many gaps and chal- physical activity during their leisure and recreation time.
lenges encountered in improving physical activity levels, The WHO Global NCD Action Plan (2008) urges Member
and intersectoral action is required to address them. Areas States to promote physical activity through the implemen-
for action on physical activity promotion include: (i) school- tation of school-based interventions and the provision of
based programmes; (ii) transport policies that prioritize physical environments that support safe active commut-
walking and cycling; (iii) urban design; (iv) primary health ing, safe transport and the creation of space for recreation-
care; (v) public awareness and mass media; (vi) communi- al activity (3).
ty-wide programmes; and (vii) sports system/programmes.
All the evidence on changing physical activity habits
An effective approach requires the implementation of mul-
shows that creating an enabling environment, providing
tiple concurrent strategies, therefore, the participation of
appropriate information and ensuring wide accessibility
the sectors and leaders corresponding to each of these ar-
are critical to influencing behaviour change, regardless of
eas of action is critical. In many countries, the first step has
the setting.
been to engage these key sectors to raise their awareness
about how their policies and actions are affecting health.
Adequate levels of physical activity, including moderate
intensity physical activity such as everyday walking and
cycling as a means of transportation, can best be achieved
through an enabling environment. Thus, increasing physi-
cal activity is a societal and not just an individual undertak-
ing. As such, it demands a population-based, multisectoral,
multidisciplinary and culturally relevant approach (163,164).
In urban settings, the changing environment is reducing
opportunities for physical activity. City dwellers are also
Lithuania 8% 4%
Romania 10% 4%
Russian Federation 12% 4%
Slovakia 11% 4%
Estonia 11% 5%
Ukraine 12% 5%
Turkey 14% 5% Men
Latvia 8% 6% Women
Poland 12% 6%
Bulgaria 18% 6%
Switzerland 14% 7%
TFYR Macedonia 19% 7%
England 13% 8%
France 14% 8%
Isreal 17% 8%
Norway 16% 8%
Denmark 13% 9%
Luxembourg 16% 9%
Sweden 15% 9%
Countries
Lithuania 9% 5%
Ukraine 9% 5%
Latvia 12% 5%
Switzerland 12% 5%
Slovakia 11% 6%
Russian Federation 11% 7%
Denmark 9% 7% Men
France 12% 8% Women
Turkey 13% 7%
Austria 14% 7%
Estonia 14% 7%
Bulgaria 18% 7%
Poland 14% 8%
Germany 14% 8%
Romania 15% 8%
Netherlands 8% 8%
Norway 10% 9%
Sweden 13% 9%
TFYR Macedonia 17% 10%
Countries
Lithuania 8% 4%
Romania 10% 4%
Russian Federation 12% 4%
Slovakia 11% 4%
Estonia 11% 5%
Ukraine 12% 5%
Turkey 14% 5% Men
Poland 12% 6% Women
Latvia 8% 6%
Bulgaria 18% 6%
TFYR Macedonia 19% 7%
Switzerland 14% 7%
France 14% 8%
England 13% 8%
Norway 16% 8%
Israel 17% 8%
Czech Republic 14% 9%
Luxembourg 16% 9%
Sweden 15% 9%
Countries
Austria 19% 9%
Denmark 13% 9%
Ireland 15% 10%
*Belgium 13% 10%
Croatia 19% 10%
Netherlands 10% 10%
Slovenia 20% 10%
Italy 23% 10%
Greece 25% 11%
Germany 16% 11%
Hungary 17% 11%
Spain 19% 11%
Scotland 14% 12%
Finland 19% 12%
Iceland 22% 12%
Portugal 22% 13%
Canada 25% 14%
Wales 21% 18%
Greenland 21% 23%
USA 33% 26%
Malta 32% 28%
alcohol
The Global Strategy to Reduce the Harmful Use of Alco- ■■ legal-based comprehensive restrictions on bans on ad-
hol, endorsed by the World Health Assembly in May 2010 vertising and promotion of alcoholic beverages;
and the WHA resolutions WHA61.4, WHA63.13 (79) and ■■ treatment of alcohol use disorders and brief interven-
WHA58.26 (165) as well as the regional and subregional tions for hazardous and harmful drinking.
strategies and action plans provide the necessary policy The challenge to the implementation of these effective
and implementation frameworks for reducing the harmful strategies is to ensure mobilization of political will and the
use of alcohol. The reduction of alcohol-related harm en- necessary resources for sustainable multisectoral action to
tails a range of effective measures implemented at all lev- guarantee the necessary resources and establish appropri-
els, including population-based measures and adequate ate monitoring and evaluation mechanisms.
health services responses such as early identification of
The French alcohol and tobacco policy law – La Loi Évin
people at risk and subsequent interventions (166–169). Fig-
(formally Loi n°91–32 du 10 janvier 1991 relative à la lutte
ures 83 and 84 show the prevalence of alcohol consump-
contre le tabagisme etl'alcoolisme) – provides examples of
tion of students (13–15 years) from selected countries.
restrictions on alcohol advertising and marketing (170).
Special attention needs to be paid for preventing alcohol
This policy bans the advertising of all alcoholic beverages
consumption in children.
containing over 1.2% alcohol by volume on television or
The following strategies and interventions have the high- in cinemas, and prohibits sponsorship of sports or cultural
est level of effectiveness to prevent the harmful use of al- events by alcohol companies. La Loi Évin also prohibits the
cohol: targeting of young people and controls the content of
■■ increasing excise taxes on alcoholic beverages; alcohol advertisements. Messages and images must refer
■■ regulating physical availability of alcoholic beverages, only to the characteristics of the products and a health
including minimum legal purchase age, restrictions on warning must be included in each advertisement. In 2008,
outlet density and time and place of sales, public health this legislation was extended to apply to alcohol advertis-
oriented licensing systems and governmental monop- ing on the Internet and in newspaper and magazine edi-
olies of retail sales; torials. Alcohol advertising is only permitted in the press
■■ drink-driving countermeasures such as lowered blood for adults, on billboards, on radio channels (under certain
alcohol concentration limits and “zero tolerance” for conditions) and at some special events or places. There are
young drivers, random breath testing and sobriety significant monetary sanctions for infringements of the
check points; law, which have ensured its implementation.
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
interventions for
interventions are not available or
accessible to people who need them.
■■ Unless the resource availability and
prevention and limitations in health systems improve
dramatically, a commitment to
4000 3000
3500
Males 2500 Males
Females
3000 Females
Cerebrovascular deaths (’000)
2000 1500
1500
1000
1000
500
500
0 0
Low-income Lower-middle- Upper-middle- High-income AFRO AMRO EMRO EURO WPRO SEARO
income income
Figure is Total deaths due to ischemic heart disease by Figure it Total deaths due to ischemic heart disease by
World Bank Income groups, 2008 (1). WHO regions, 2008 (1).
4000 2500
3500
Males
2000
Ischaemic heart disease deaths (’000)
Females Males
3000 Both Sexes Females
Both Sexes
2500 1500
2000
1500 1000
1000
500
500
0 0
Low-income Lower-middle- Upper-middle- High-income AFRO AMRO EMRO EURO WPRO SEARO
income income
DN
Role of primary
■■ A balanced investment between
primary care and other levels of care
is vital for prevention and control of
CVD.
■■ Prevention and control of CVD cannot
be addressed without strengthening
primary care.
■■ Prioritizing, financing and
strengthening the health systems to
deliver a realistic set of high-impact
control of CVDs
If rising trends of CVDs are to be halted and reversed, cur- ulation-wide screening is not affordable for LMICs, targeted
rent approaches to addressing them need to be reformed. screening of people in different settings (e.g. adults over
At present, the main focus of health care for CVD in many a certain age screened at primary care facilities, worksites
LMICS is tertiary care based. Tertiary care, including stroke and community settings) is an approach used for early de-
units, coronary care units and rehabilitation units, play an tection and diagnosis. Addressing cardiovascular risk has
important role in improving outcomes of people who suf- been demonstrated to be more efficient when a total-risk
fer CVD events. However, balancing investment in primary, approach is used (178, 184, 185).
secondary and tertiary care is vital for sustainability of CVD The primary health care approach places equity as a cen-
programmes. tral value across all health system functions: governance,
Currently, a large proportion of people with high cardio- health information, workforce, service delivery, providing
vascular risk remains undiagnosed and often even those essential medicines and technologies (186, 187). Universal
diagnosed have insufficient access to treatment. When health coverage is receiving increasing priority as part of
diagnosis is made, it is frequently at a late stage of the dis- the agendas of health systems strengthening. The health
ease, when people become symptomatic and are admit- sector could address health inequities related to CVD by
ted to hospitals with acute myocardial infarction or stroke taking steps towards universal health coverage, starting
and when costly high-technology interventions are re- with the implementation of a set of high-impact essential
quired for treatment. Examples of such costly health-care CVD interventions (6, 173). Strengthening primary health
interventions include coronary artery bypass surgery and care also requires ensuring performance, quality and effec-
other types of vascular surgery for unstable angina and tiveness of service delivery. Equitable health system financ-
cerebrovascular disease (6, 106, 171). ing and the location of health-care services as well as the
Early detection is key to improving outcomes of CVDs. Af- motivation and training of the health workforce (Figures
fordable tools (e.g. clinical measurements, laboratory in- 89 and 90) are crucial to positively impact health inequi-
vestigations, cardiovascular risk assessment charts, afford- ties (188, 189). The shortfall of physicians in many parts of
able blood pressure measurement devices) are available the world call for engaging non-physician health workers
for early detection of people with disease and those at in service delivery for NCD/CVD, particularly in primary care
high risk (4, 6, 183). Since CVDs are asymptomatic in early (Figures 89 and 90). A participatory approach by communi-
stages, such tools need to be proactively utilized to detect ties in service delivery is also important for reducing health
those at risk of developing heart attacks or strokes. As pop- inequities.
Figure jl World map showing the density of health workforce (nonphysicians) (per 100 000 population) (11).
DO
Best buys for
■■ A pragmatic approach to address
CVDs in resource-constrained settings
is to implement and scale up very
cost-effective, feasible and high-
impact interventions (best buys).
■■ Best buys can be implemented even
in low-income countries if there is
a modest increase in investment in
health.
cardiovascular
disease (CVD) prevention and control
The CVD epidemic is progressing relentlessly in LMICs. As Implementing population-wide interventions for tobacco
shown in the world maps (Figures 91 and 92), there is a control, control of the harmful use of alcohol, reduction of
large disease burden worldwide attributable to heart at- salt content in processed foods and substitution of partially
tacks and strokes. Policy-makers and investors often ask hydrogenated trans-fat with polyunsaturated fats have the
whether CVD can be tackled and, if so, where the focus potential to prevent millions of deaths per year. In addition,
of attention should be. There is clear evidence that pre- promoting physical activity through the media (in combi-
vention interventions work and that improved access to nation with a healthy diet) has been estimated to be a low-
health care can reduce the burden of morbidity, disability cost and highly feasible option.
and premature mortality. However, in making a decision, The above population-wide preventive strategies can be
policy-makers also want to know what evidence there is to combined with more targeted approaches to improve
show that interventions will represent a cost-effective use health gains. Individual interventions that are best buys in-
of resources in the settings in which they are to be imple- clude (4, 6, 160, 171, 173): (i) providing aspirin to people with
mented and that scaling up these interventions is appro- an acute heart attack – this saves the lives of one in five of
priate, affordable and feasible. those with a heart attack; (ii) providing a simple multidrug
Cost effectiveness summarizes the efficiency with which treatment to people following a heart attack or stroke (or
an intervention produces health outcomes. Feasibility of transient ischaemic attack or angina) in order to prevent
an intervention depends on: (i) reach (the capacity of the recurrent ischaemic events – this results in a reduction in
health system to deliver an intervention to the targeted recurrent heart attacks and strokes of up to 75% – and also
population); (ii) technical complexity; (iii) capital intensity decrease mortality; (iii) reducing the cardiovascular risk
(the amount of capital required for an intervention); and (controlling blood pressure, blood cholesterol and blood
(iv) cultural acceptability. sugar; tobacco use) in people, including those with diabe-
A set of interventions exists for the prevention and control tes, who are at high risk of heart attacks and strokes; and
of CVD that has a significant public health impact and is (iv) controlling glucose levels in people with diabetes – this
highly cost effective, inexpensive and feasible to imple- investment reduces cardiovascular complications, blind-
ment; these interventions can be considered as “best buys” ness and kidney failure in people with diabetes. Financing
for investors (Table 1). A range of other interventions that tools are available to assist countries to cost resources re-
constitute “good buys” can also be identified (6, 160, 173). quired for implementing the best buys (160).
CVD and diabetes ■■ Provide counselling and multidrug therapy (including blood sugar control
for diabetes mellitus) for people with medium-high risk of developing heart
attacks and strokes (including those who have established CVD)
■■ Treat heart attacks (myocardial infarction) with aspirin
Package of Essential
Noncommunicable (PEN) Disease
Interventions for
Primary Health Care
in Low-Resource Settings
Heart
disease
& stroke
CanCer
CHroniC
diabetes respiratory
disease
To ensure equity, delivery of essential NCD Health systems research related to primary
interventions in primary care need to be health care is one of the NCD/CVD research
strengthened. priorities.
Figure jn World map showing burden of cerebrovascular disease (DALYs) (age standardized, per 100 000) (5).
DP
Bridging the
■■ Research is essential to bridge
the “knowledge translation” and
“implementation” gaps in prevention
and control of NCDs.
■■ In the long run, investment in
implementation research and impact
evaluation can save resources.
■■ The WHO Prioritized Research Agenda
for Prevention and Control of Major
Noncommunicable Diseases (WHO
control of CVDs
Cost-effective interventions that have the potential to of NCDs and the human resource and financial capacity to
halve the NCD burden over the next two decades and lead respond to these demands. Therefore, global and national
to large health and economic benefits are available. Imple- NCD research agendas require prioritization with the aim
mentation and dissemination of these interventions have of focusing on key research issues that are likely to have
resulted in the decline of, for example, CVD in many de- the greatest potential to impact prevention and control of
veloped countries (13, 14). Research is essential in order to NCDs.
understand and to demonstrate how these interventions To address this need, the WHO NCD Research Agenda was
can be implemented effectively in LMICs, despite resource developed from 2008 to 2010 and identified 20 top priority
constraints and other competing health priorities. research areas that are likely to have a high impact on na-
Particularly in resource-constrained settings, available re- tional NCD policies and programmes, with a special focus
sources need to be invested in NCD programmes and in- on LMICs (190). The WHO NCD Research Agenda provides
terventions that have a sound scientific basis so that there guidance to Member States in understanding and identify-
is a good return on investment. Although we already know ing the key public health research needs related to NCDs
“what has worked” in developed countries, “how” these (186).
interventions can be applied in resource-constrained set- Figures 93 and 94 show the annual research and devel-
tings needs to be researched. At the country level, there- opment expenditure as a proportion of gross domestic
fore, implementation research focused on high-impact and product (GDP) and national health expenditure, respec-
affordable interventions (best buys) needs to be strength- tively. Adequate resources for research are crucial – both
ened to generate the required insight. financial and technical – through strengthened national,
Implementation research seeks to understand how to ef- regional and international cooperation and collaboration
fectively deliver efficacious interventions in a specific con- (191). The WHO NCD Research Agenda provides a basis for
text, thus filling this gap between knowledge and practice. improved cooperation among research funders and other
LMICs stand to benefit enormously from promoting and key partners to align aid with NCD research priorities. This
supporting this type of research so that resources are not would help to strengthen the research capacity of LMICs
wasted on programmes that are not appropriate to the and enable them to develop national NCD research plans
context. that articulate clear research priorities focused on national
At present, there is a major mismatch between country de- public health needs.
mands for conducting research on prevention and control
Sweden
0,8
Denmark
0,6 USA
United Kingdom
Belgium Singapore
Canada
0,4 France Austria Japan
Finland
Hungary Germany
Spain Ireland
Turkey Italy Netherlands
0,2 Norway
Panama Cuba South Africa Czech Republic Republic of Korea
Argentina Poland
Portugal
Trinidad & Greece Slovakia
Brazil
China Slovenia
Luxembourg
Tobago Mexico Russia
0,0
0,0 0,5 1,0 1,5 2,0 2,5 3,0 3,5 4,0
Proportion of GDP spent on research and development (%)
Figure jp Annual research and development expenditure as a proportion of national health expenditure for 2005
(comparable country estimates) (xxxiii).
12
Iceland
Proportion of research and development expenditure
spent on health research and development (%)
10
Sweden
8
Denmark
United Kingdom
6
Finland Belgium
Canada
Japan
4 Austria France USA Turkey
Israel Germany Hungary
Republic of Korea Czech Republic Ireland Spain
Norway Netherlands Italy
2
Brazil Slovakia Poland South Africa Cuba Venezuela Panama
China Mexico Romania
Russia India Luxembourg Greece Portugal Argentina
Slovenia Trinidad & Tobago
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Proportion of National health expenditure spent on research and development (%)
DQ
Monitoring CVDs
■■ Monitoring major cardiovascular risk
factors and CVD death rates is a key
component of CVD prevention and
control.
■■ Monitoring and evaluation are tools
for improving the accountability of
different stakeholders.
Monitoring CVDs and their risk factors provides the foun- NCD surveillance varies considerably among countries. For
dation for advocacy, policy development and programme countries with little existing NCD surveillance activity, the
implementation. Collection of mortality and risk factor data development of the system should be an incrementally
helps to assess the magnitude, track the trends of CVDs evolving process. In low-resource settings with limited ca-
and their risks over time, and evaluate the effectiveness pacity, a viable and sustainable system needs to be simple
and impact of interventions. Figure 95 shows countries and, at a minimum, gather data periodically on cardiovas-
with surveillance data for risk factors. Lack of reliable data cular risk factors.
on cardiovascular mortality, risk factors and their determi- Quality risk factor surveillance is possible even in the least
nants is a major obstacle to the progress of efforts aimed at resourced countries. Such surveillance remains the prior-
addressing the cardiovascular epidemic. High-quality data ity within a more comprehensive NCD surveillance frame-
can only be generated by adequate investment in civil reg- work, as it predicts the future of the NCD burden and gives
istration and in surveillance systems (6, 192). impetus for action.
About one third of the countries in the world still do not There is also a need for measurable process and output
have vital registration systems that capture the total num- indicators to permit accurate monitoring and evaluation
ber of deaths. Accurate reporting of the cause of death on of actions taken and their impact. The indicators cited in
the death certificate is a challenge. Although total all-cause Table 2 are examples of measurements that can be used
mortality may be reported reasonably well, significant ac- for monitoring and reporting on the national status of the
curacy problems exist for cause-specific certification and prevention and control of CVD.
coding in a large number of countries. In these countries,
national initiatives to strengthen vital registration systems
and cause-specific mortality are a key priority.
Sustainable NCD surveillance systems need to be formal-
ized as a key component of the national public health in-
frastructure and become part of a country's health infor-
mation system. They should be seen as more than a data
collection exercise and mechanisms must be set in place
for the analysis and dissemination of collected data to
inform policy-making. Clearly, the capacity to undertake
1. Mortality ■■ All cause mortality by age, sex and region (urban and rural or by other administrative area,
as available)
■■ CVDs (ischaemic heart disease, cerebrovascular disease) mortality (urban and rural or by
other administrative area, as available)
3. Control of tobacco, diet and ■■ Comprehensive tobacco controls (e.g. tobacco product tax increases, health warning labels,
the harmful use of alcohol smoke-free legislation and advertising bans on all forms of direct and indirect tobacco ad-
vertising )
■■ Healthy diet policy measures (e.g. food-based dietary guidelines, salt reduction, fiscal poli-
cies, consumer information/labelling and marketing restrictions)
■■ Comprehensive alcohol control (e.g.tax increases, advertising bans and restricted access)
4. Prevention of heart attacks ■■ Percentage of adult population with a 10-year cardiovascular risk (fatal and non-fatal cardio-
and strokes through a vascular events), above 20%, managed through combination therapy (multiple drug treat-
primary care approach ment and counselling), including people with diabetes mellitus and established CVD
Figure jq World map showing countries with surveillance data for risk factors (6).
DR
Social mobilization
■■ Civil society institutions are uniquely
placed to mobilize political awareness
and support for addressing CVD.
■■ Civil society institutions can play a
key role in advocating for a higher
priority given to CVDs/NCDs in health
and development strategies and
programmes.
■■ Civil society institutions are
significant providers of prevention
Civil society institutions, in particular NGOs, academia and In many countries, civil society institutions also play a sig-
professional associations, have a major role to play in the nificant role in delivering prevention and treatment ser-
prevention and control of NCDs at both country and global vices for CVD. Partnerships between NGOs and academia
levels (193). Within countries, these groups help to shape can bring together the expertise and resources needed to
the policy response and also support or deliver prevention build both workforce capacity and the skills of individuals,
and treatment programmes. In addition, these institutions families and communities. A further role that civil society
provide important support to WHO technical and norma- institutions are best placed to undertake is the indepen-
tive functions and for the implementation of regional- and dent monitoring and evaluation of progress in delivering
country-level initiatives. on commitments, and in achieving outcomes, by both
Civil society institutions have a number of roles that they governments and the private sector.
are uniquely placed to fulfil. They have a high degree of Recently, a number of civil society institutions, in particular
“legitimacy” that comes from their separation from gov- NGOs, have come together to coordinate more effectively
ernment and the commercial interests of the marketplace, their contribution to global NCD prevention and control.
combined with grassroots networks of committed citizens. A significant milestone was the establishment of the NCD
Thus, advocacy is central to their role and they are well Alliance, a formal association of four international federa-
placed to raise political awareness and mobilize the society tions of NGOs representing the four main NCDs outlined in
for wide support for NCD/CVD prevention and control. This the WHO Global NCD Action Plan – CVD, diabetes, cancer
is of particular importance in addressing the common risk and chronic respiratory disease – as a mutual platform for
factors of tobacco use, unhealthy diet, physical inactivity collaboration and joint advocacy. The value of these “col-
and the harmful use of alcohol where complex commer- lective” civil society organizations is considerable (194).
cial, trade, political and social factors are at play. In particu-
lar, civil society institutions act as a political counterbalance
to strong commercial and private sector interests in the for-
mation and implementation of NCD/CVD prevention and
control policies at the national level.
105
Key messages
DS
Prevention and
■■ The priority accorded to NCD/CVDs
in development work at global and
national levels needs to be raised.
■■ Prevention of CVDs needs to be
a priority of official development
assistance in high-burden LMICs.
Total commitments
(US$ billions)
$6.19 $10 $9.65 $11.92 $15.53 $17.02 $19.42 $21.70
100%
15% (1.5) 11% (2.43)
17% (2.7)
90%
Proportion of ODA/OOF commitments (%)
20%
37% (7.94)
30% (4.73)
10% 25% (2.54)
0%
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Years
HIV/AIDS Health General
Tuberculosis, malaria and infectious diseases Basic health (excluding infectious disease and nutrition)
Reproductive health and nutrition
DT
Generating resources
■■ There are different approaches to
raise additional resources for health
and reduce financial risks and barriers
to accessing essential health-care
interventions to address CVD.
■■ An innovative financing mechanism
based on a global solidarity tobacco
levy is feasible to promote sustainable
health financing.
■■ A solidarity tobacco levy has the dual
4,00%
Bangladesh India
4 940 585 37 358 760
Percentage increase in poverty (poverty line $1.08)
3,50%
3,00%
China
2,50% 32 431 209
Nepal
515 933
2,00%
1,50%
Vietnam Total of
848 870 78 158 299
1,00% people are
Philippines pushed below
445 680 Indonesia
the poverty line
0,50% Thailand 1 440 395
in 11 countries.
100 201 Sri Lanka
10 562 Kyrgyzstan
Malaysia 10 562 5 989
0,00%
30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Out of pocket payments as a proportion of total health expenditure (%)
Figure jt Out of pocket payments as a proportion of total health expenditure by average percentage of households
selling assets or borrowing money to finance health (99, xxvi, 11).
70%
Burkina Faso
65%
Percentage increase in poverty (poverty line $1.08)
50%
55%
50%
45%
Mauritania
40%
Zimbabwe
35%
Chad
Kenya Congo Senegal
30%
Ethiopia Ghana Mali Côte d’Ivoire
Namibia Malawi Swaziland
25%
Zambia
20%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Out of pocket payments as a proportion of total health expenditure (%)
DU
CVD prevention and
■■ International efforts in poverty
reduction will be derailed if the global
challenge of CVD is not addressed.
■■ If no action is taken, increasing
numbers of people will slip into high-
risk categories or develop CVD due to
continuing exposure to risk factors.
■■ Millions of deaths due to CVD
can be prevented by scaling up
implementation of high-impact
longer?
controls; promotion of healthier diets
and physical activity; reducing the
harmful use of alcohol; improving
people's access to essential health
care.
Equatorial Guinea
Oman
Saudi Arabia
Slovakia
Estonia
Hungary
Trinidad and Tobago
Low-income countries
Croatia
Poland High-income countries
Czech Republic
Afghanistan
Kuwait
Kyrgyzstan
United Arab Emirates
Somalia
Bahrain
Tajikistan
Brunei Darussalam
Malawi
Bahamas
Guinea-Bissau
Greece
Zambia
San Marino
Guinea
Barbados
Mozambique
Cyprus
Ethiopia
Germany
Central African Republic
Malta
Chad
Slovenia
Democratic Republic of the Congo
Finland
Uganda
United States of America
Burundi
Austria
Lao People's Democratic Republic
Luxembourg
Benin
Sweden
Burkina Faso
Portugal
Bangladesh
Qatar
Liberia
Ireland
United Republic of Tanzania
Denmark
Comoros
United Kingdom
Sierra Leone
New Zealand
Mauritania
Singapore
Ghana
Belgium
Rwanda
Norway
Gambia
Italy
Togo
Iceland
Cambodia
Republic of Korea
Myanmar
Switzerland
Haiti
Netherlands
Mali
Andorra
Eritrea
Canada
Madagascar
Australia
Niger
Spain
Nepal
Monaco
Solomon Islands
France
Kenya
Israel
Zimbabwe
Japan
Democratic People's Republic of Korea
Figure Ten leading causes of burden of disease, world, 2004 and 2030 (5).
2004 As % As % 2030
Disease or injury of total Rank Rank of total Disease or injury
DALYs DALYs
Lower respiratory infections 6.2 1 1 6.2 Unipolar depressive disorders
Diarrheal diseases 4.8 2 2 5.5 Ischaemic heart disease
Unipolar depressive disorder 4.3 3 3 4.9 Road traffic accidents
Ischaemic heart disease 4.1 4 4 4.3 Cerebrovascular disease
HIV/AIDS 3.8 5 5 3.8 COPD
Cerebrovascular disease 3.1 6 6 3.2 Lower respiratory infections
Prematurity and low birth weight 2.9 7 7 2.9 Hearing loss, adult onset
Birth asphyxia and birth trauma 2.7 8 8 2.7 Refractive errors
Road traffic accidents 2.7 9 9 2.5 HIV/AIDS
Neonatal infections and other 2.7 10 10 2.3 Diabetes mellitus
EL
CVD Prevention
■■ The WHO Global NCD Action Plan
endorsed by the WHA for prevention
and control of NCDs, in 2008, provides
a clear vision and road map to address
the cardiovascular epidemic.
■■ A public health framework that
incorporates the objectives of the
Global NCD Action Plan is essential for
prevention and control of CVD at the
national level.
tobacco use
sea s e s
la r di
s cu
va chro
nic
io
rd
re
sp
ca
ira
to
ry
d
isea
ses
l use of alcohol
physical inactivity
fu
harm
dia
b
es
et
rs
e
nc
ca
unhealthy diets
86. Zhang Y. Cardiovascular diseases in American women. Nu- 98. James PD et al. Avoidable mortality by neighbourhood
trition, Metabolism, and Cardiovascular Diseases, 2010, July, income in Canada: 25 years after the establishment of uni-
20(6):386–393. Epub 2 June 2010. versal health insurance. Journal of Epidemiology and Com-
munity Health, 2007, 61(4):287–296.
87. Population Division of the Department of Economic and
Social Affairs of the United Nations Secretariat (UNDESA). 99. World Health Organization. World Health Report 2010:
World Population Prospects: The 2006 Revision and World Ur- Health systems financing: The path to universal coverage. Ge-
banization Prospects: The 2007 Revision. New York, United neva, WHO, 2010.
Nations, 26 February 2008 (http://esa.un.org/unup). 100. Xu K. Household catastrophic health expenditure: A multi-
country analysis. Lancet, 2003, 362:111–117.
88. Mathenge W, Foster A, Kuper H. Urbanization, ethnicity
and cardiovascular risk in a population in transition in Na- 101. Xu K et al. Protecting households from catastrophic health
kuru, Kenya: A population-based survey. BMC Public Health, spending. Health Affairs, 2007, 26(4):972–983.
2010, September, 22(10):569. 102. Knaul FC, Frenk J. Health insurance in Mexico: Achieving
89. Vorster HH. The emergence of cardiovascular disease dur- universal coverage through structural reform. Health Af-
ing urbanisation of Africans. Public Health Nutrition, 2002, fairs, 2005, 24:1467–1476.
5(1A):239–243. 103. Mahal A, Karan A, Engelgau M. The economic implications
of non-communicable disease for India. HNP Discussion Pa-
90. WHO Centre for Health Development. Our cities, our health,
per. Washington DC, World Bank, 2010.
our future. Report to the WHO Commission on Social De-
terminants of Health from the Knowledge Network on 104. Kruk ME, Goldmann E, Galea S. Borrowing and selling to
Urban Settings. Kobe, Japan, World Health Organization, pay for health care in low- and middle-income countries.
2008. Health Affairs, 2009, 28:1056–1066.
137. Jackson R et al. Treatment with drugs to lower blood pres- 150. World Health Organization. WHO technical manual on to-
sure and blood cholesterol based on an individual's abso- bacco tax administration. Geneva, WHO, 2010.
lute cardiovascular risk. Lancet, 2005, 365(9457):434–441. 151. World Health Organization. Protection from exposure to sec-
138. British Heart Foundation. Updated guidelines on CVD risk as- ond-hand tobacco smoke: Policy recommendations. Geneva,
sessment. Factfile 08/2004 (http://www.bhf.org.uk/profes- WHO, 2007.
sionals/index.asp?secID=15&secondlevel=471&thirdlevel 152. International Tobacco Control Project. International Tobac-
=970&artID=5446). co Control Policy Evaluation Project: Key findings. Waterloo,
139. Assmann G, Cullen P, Schulte H. Simple scoring scheme for Ontario, ITC, 2010.
calculating the risk of acute coronary events based on the 153. Hoek J et al. Lessons from New Zealand’s introduction of
10-year follow-up of the prospective cardiovascular Mun- pictorial health warnings on tobacco packaging. Bulletin of
ster (PROCAM) study. Circulation, 2002, 105(3):310–315. the World Health Organization, 2010, 88:861–866.
140. Conroy RM et al. SCORE Project Group. Estimation of ten- 154. National Bureau of Economic Research. Tobacco adver-
year risk of fatal cardiovascular disease in Europe: The tising: Economic theory and international evidence. Cam-
SCORE Project. European Heart Journal, 2003, 24(11):987– bridge, MA, NBER, 1999.
1003.
155. World Health Organization. WHO report on the global to-
141. Mendis S et al. World Health Organization (WHO) and In- bacco epidemic: Implementing smoke-free environments.
ternational Society of Hypertension (ISH) risk prediction Geneva, WHO, 2009.
charts: Assessment of cardiovascular risk for prevention
156. International Tobacco Evidence Network. Economics of
and control of cardiovascular disease in low- and middle-
tobacco control international evidence for tobacco control
income countries. Journal of Hypertension, 2007, August,
network. University of Illinois at Chicago, ITEN, 2002.
25(8):1578–1582.
157. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Best practices
142. Puska P, Ståhl T. Health in All Policies – the Finnish initiative: for comprehensive tobacco control programs. Atlanta, CDC,
Background, principles, and current issues. Annual Review 2007.
of Public Health, 2010, 21 April, 31:315–328. Review.
158. Resolution WHA63.23. Maternal, young child and infant nu-
143. Mendis S, Fuster V. National policies and strategies for non- trition: Implementation plan. Geneva, World Health Organi-
communicable diseases. Nature Reviews Cardiology, 2009, zation, May 2010.
November, 6(11):723–727. Review.
159. Reducing salt intake in populations. Report of a WHO forum
144. World Bank. Public policy and the challenge of chronic non- and technical meeting, Paris, 5–7 October 2006. Geneva,
communicable diseases. Executive summary. Washington, WHO, 2007.
DC, WB, 2007 (http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTPH/
160. World Health Organization. Estimation of resource needs
Resources/ PublicPolicyandNCDsWorldBank2007FullRe-
and costs for scaling-up a core noncommunicable disease
port.pdf ).
intervention package in low and middle income countries,
145. World Health Organization. Guidelines for implementation Geneva, WHO 2011.
of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. Ge-
161. World Health Organization. Interventions on diet and physi-
neva, WHO, 2011.
cal activity: What works: Summary report. Geneva, WHO,
146. World Health Organization. History of the WHO Framework 2009.
Convention on Tobacco Control. Geneva, WHO, 2009.
162. Ramachandran A et al. The Indian Diabetes Prevention
147. Ranson MK et al. Global and regional estimates of the ef- Programme shows that lifestyle modification and metfor-
fectiveness and cost-effectiveness of price increases and min prevent type 2 diabetes in Asian Indian subjects with
other tobacco control policies. Nicotine & Tobacco Re- impaired glucose tolerance (IDPP). Diabetologia, 2006,
search, 2002, 4:311–319. 49:289–297.
173. World Health Organization. Package of essential noncom- 186. Mendis S, Alwan A, eds. A prioritized research agenda for
municable disease interventions for primary health care in prevention and control of noncommunicable diseases. Ge-
low-resource settings. Geneva, WHO, 2010. neva, World Health Organization, 2011.
187. World Health Organization. World Health Report 2008: Pri-
174. Lim SS et al. Prevention of cardiovascular disease in high-
mary health care – now more than ever. Geneva, WHO, 2008.
risk individuals in low-income and middle-income coun-
tries: Health effects and costs. Lancet, 2007, 370:2054– 188. Evans DB, Etienne C. Health systems financing and the
2062. path to universal coverage. Bulletin of the World Health Or-
ganization, 2010, 88:402.
175. Yusuf S. Two decades of progress in preventing vascular
disease. Lancet, 2002, 360:2–3. 189. WHO Framework for Action. Everybody’s business: Strength-
ening health systems to improve health outcomes. Geneva,
176. Abegunde DO et al. Can non-physician health-care work- World Health Organization, 2007.
ers assess and manage cardiovascular risk in primary care?
190. Wood D et al. Research priorities: Prevention and control of
Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2007, 85:432–440.
cardiovascular diseases, with a focus on low- and middle-
177. Mendis S et al. Cardiovascular risk management and its income countries. Paper 1. In: Mendis S, Alwan A, eds. A
impact on hypertension control in primary care in low- prioritized research agenda for prevention and control of
resource settings: A cluster-randomized trial. Bulletin of the noncommunicable diseases. Geneva, World Health Organi-
World Health Organization, 2010, June, 88(6):412–419. zation, 2011.
193. Collie-Akers V et al. Evaluating mobilization strategies with 206. United Nations resolution 2010/8. ECOSOC resolution on
neighborhood and faith organizations to reduce risk for tobacco use and maternal and child health. Adopted by the
health disparities. Health Promotion Practice, 2009 April, UN Economic and Social Council, 22 July 2010. New York,
10(Suppl. 2):118S–127S. United Nations.
194. The NCD Alliance web site (http://www.ncdalliance.org/ 207. Statement on Commonwealth Action to Combat Noncom-
unspg). municable Diseases, 27–29 November 2009 (http://www.
uicc.org/sites/clonesource.agenceinovae.com/files/pri-
195. Engelgau MM et al. Capitalizing on the demographic tran-
vate/statementoncommonwealthactiontocombatnon-
sition: Tackling noncommunicable diseases in South Asia.
communicablediseases.pdf ).
Washington, DC, World Bank, 2011.
208. The progress in implementation of the WHO Global NCD
196. United Nations resolution 65/1. Keeping the promise: United
Action Plan in 2008–2009 reported to the 126th Executive
to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. Adopted by
Board, 18–23 January 2010. Geneva, World Health Organi-
the General Assembly, 19 October 2010. New York, United
zation.
Nations.
209. The progress in implementation of the WHO Global NCD
197. McCoy D, Chand S, Sridhar D. Global health funding: How
Action Plan in 2008–2009 reported to the 63rd World
much, where it comes from and where it goes. Health Pol-
Health Assembly, 17–21 May 2010. Geneva, World Health
icy Plan, 2009, November, 24(6):407–417.
Organization.
198. Taskforce on Innovative International Financing for Health 210. United Nations resolution 64/265. Prevention and control
Systems. Constraints to scaling up and costs: Working group of noncommunicable diseases. Adopted by the General As-
1 report. Geneva, International Health Partnership, 2009 sembly, 10 May 2010. New York, United Nations.
(http://www.internationalhealthpartnership.net//CMS_
211. United Nations resolution 65/238. Scope, modalities, format
files/documents/working_group_1_-_report_EN.pdf ).
and organization of the high-level meeting of the General
199. Taskforce on Innovative International Financing for Health Assembly on the prevention and control of NCDs. Adopted
Systems. Raising and channelling funds: Working group by the General Assembly, 13 December 2010. New York,
2 report. Geneva, International Health Partnership, 2009 United Nations.
(http://www.internationalhealthpartnership.net//CMS_
212. United Nations resolution 65/95. Global health and foreign
files/documents/working_group_2_-_report_EN.pdf ).
policy. Adopted by the General Assembly, 10 February
200. Taskforce on Innovative International Financing for Health 2011. New York, United Nations.
Systems. More money for health, and more health for the
213. Resolution WHA64/21. Prevention and control of noncom-
money: Final report. Geneva, International Health Partner-
municable diseases: WHO’s role in the preparation, imple-
ship, 2009 (http://www.internationalhealthpartnership.
mentation and follow-up to the high-level meeting of the
net//CMS_files/documents/taskforce_report_EN.pdf ).
United Nations General Assembly on the prevention and con-
201. Schmidt R. The currency transaction tax: Rate and revenue trol of noncommunicable diseases, September 2011. Geneva,
estimates. Ottawa, North-South Institute, 2007 (www.nsi- WHO, 2011.
ins.ca).
202. Thai Health Promotion Foundation web site (http://
en.thaihealth.or.th/).
203. Nam EW et al. Sustainable funding of health initiatives in
Wonju Republic of Korea via a tobacco consumption tax.
Health Promotion International, 2011, 14 March.
204. Bhutta ZA et al. Countdown to 2015 decade report (2000–
2010): Taking stock of maternal, newborn, and child sur-
vival. Lancet, 2010, 5 June, 375(9730):2032–2044. Review.
Erratum in: Lancet, 2010, 4 September, 376(9743):772.
Figure 3. Distribution of major causes of death including CVDs Figure 20. World map showing the burden of ischemic heart
(1). disease (DALYs) in females (age standardized, per 100 000)
(5).
Figure 4. Distribution of CVD deaths due to heart attacks, strokes
Figure 21. World map showing the burden of cerebrovascular
and other types of cardiovascular diseases, males (1).
disease (DALYs) in males (age standardized, per 100 000) (5).
Figure 5. Distribution of CVD deaths due to heart attacks, strokes
Figure 22. World map showing the burden of cerebrovascular
and other types of cardiovascular diseases, females (1).
disease (DALYs) in females (age standardized, per 100 000)
Figure 6. World map showing the global distribution of CVD (5).
mortality rates in males (age standardized , per 100 000) (1).
Figure 23. Endothelial dysfunction: Leukocyte adhesion and
Figure 7. World map showing the global distribution of CVD migration into the deep layer of the intima (9) From Ross1
mortality rates in females (age standardized, per 100 000) (1). and reprinted with permission. © 1999 Massachusetts
Figure 8. World map showing the global distribution of the Medical Society.
burden of CVDs (DALYs), in males (age standardized, per Figure 24. Fatty streak formation revealing platelet aggregation
100 000) (1). on the endothelial surface, foam-cell formation and smooth
Figure 9. World map showing the global distribution of the muscle migration (9). From Ross1 and reprinted with
burden of CVDs (DALYs) , in females (age standardized , per permission. © 1999 Massachusetts Medical Society.
100 000) (1). Figure 25. Fibrous cap formation and the necrotic core (9) From
Figure 10. Distribution of global NCD by cause of death, both Ross1 and reprinted with permission. © 1999 Massachusetts
sexes (1). Medical Society.
Figure 11. Distribution of global NCD by cause of death for less Figure 26. The ruptured plaque (9). From Ross1 and reprinted
than 60 year old persons, both sexes (1). with permission. © 1999 Massachusetts Medical Society.
Figure 12. Distribution of global NCD by cause of death for less Figure 27. World map showing ischaemic heart disease mortality
than 70 year old persons, both sexes (1). rates (age standardized, per 100 000) (1).
Figure 13. Distribution of global CVD burden (DALYs) due to Figure 28. World map showing cerebrovascular disease mortality
heart attacks, strokes and other types of CVDs in males (5). rates (age standardized, per 100 000) (1).
Figure 14. Distribution of global CVD burden (DALYs) due to Figure 29. Ranking of 10 selected risk factors of cause of death
heart attacks, strokes and other types of CVDs in females (5). (2).
Figure 15. World map showing the global distribution of Figure 30. WHO ISH risk prediction chart e.g. AFR D (4).
ischemic heart disease mortality rates in males (age Figure 31. A combination of population wide and high risk
standardized, per 100 000) (1). strategies are required to shift the cardiovascular risk
Figure 16. World map showing the global distribution of distribution of populations to more optimal levels (23).
ischemic heart disease mortality rates in females (age Figure 32. Distribution of cardiovascular risk categories in
standardized, per 100 000) (1). selected WHO subregions (4).
Figure 17. World map showing the global distribution of Figure 33. World map showing the prevalence of current daily
cerebrovascular disease mortality rates in males (age tobacco smoking in males (age standardized adjusted
standardized, per 100 000) (1). estimates, 2008) (6).
Figure 18. World map showing the global distribution of Figure 34. World map showing the prevalence of current daily
cerebrovascular disease mortality rates in females (age tobacco smoking in females. (age standardized adjusted
standardized, per 100 000) (1). estimates, 2008) (6).
Figure 71. World map showing the per capita expenditure on Figure 90. World map showing the density of health workforce
health in 193 countries (11). (nonphysicians) (per 1000 population) (11).
Figure 72. World map showing health expenditure as a Figure 91. World map showing burden of ischemic heart disease
percentage of the gross domestic product (11, iii). (DALYs) (age standardized, per 100 000) (5).
Figure 73. World map showing WHO member states reporting Figure 92. World map showing burden of cerebrovascular
the presence of a NCD policy (6). disease (DALYs) (age standardized, per 100 000) (5).
Figure 74. World map showing countries that tax tobacco Figure 93. Annual research and development expenditure as a
products (tax as a percentage of the price of the most sold proportion of GDP for 2005 (comparable country estimates)
brand of cigarettes) (11). (xxxiii).
Figure 75. Prevalence of current tobacco use among youth (13- Figure 94. Annual research and development expenditure
15 year old boys and girls) by World Bank income group and as a proportion of national health expenditure for 2005
exposure to tobacco smoke (indoor and outdoor) (11). (comparable country estimates) (xxxiii).
Figure 76. Proportion of trans fatty acids as a percentage of total Figure 95. World map showing countries with surveillance data
fat (fried chicken and chips) sold in selected countries, in a for risk factors (6).
certain multinational food chain outlet (xii, xiii). Figure 96. Proportions of donor commitments (Official
Figure 77. Proportion of trans fatty acids as a percentage of total Development Assistance and Other commitments) by health
fat (fried chicken and chips) sold in selected countries, in a sector disciplines 2002 to 2009 (US $, billions) (xxxiv).
different multinational food chain outlet shown in Figure 76 Figure 97. Change in poverty (USD 1.08 per day) head count
(xii, xiii). ratio by out of pocket payments in 11 countries in Asia (99,
Figure 78. World map showing countries that have taken xxv, 11).
regulatory action against transfat xiii-xxvii). Figure 98. Out of pocket payments as a proportion of total health
Figure 79. Salt consumption per capita and salt consumption expenditure by average percentage of households selling
surplus in selected countries (xxvii-xxx). assets or borrowing money to finance health (99, xxvi, 11).
Figure 80. Proportion of children (11 years old) who are reported Figure 99. Mortality rates of CVDs in high income and low
to be overweight or obese in selected European countries, income countries (age standardized ).
USA and Canada (xxxi). Figure 100. Mortality rates of CVDs in high income and low
Figure 81. Proportion of children (13 years old) who are reported income countries .
to be overweight or obese in selected European countries, Figure 101. Graph showing the projected mortality trends from
USA and Canada (xxxi). 2008 to 2030 for NCDs, CVDs and communicable diseases
Figure 82. Proportion of children (15 years old) who are reported (2).
to be overweight or obese in selected European countries, Figure 102. Ten leading causes of burden of disease, world, 2004
USA and Canada (xxxi). and 2030 (5).
Figure 83. Proportion of students (13-15 years) who consumed
alcohol in the last 30 days from selected low and middle
income countries (41, xxxii).
Figure 84. Proportion of students (15-16 years) who consumed
alcohol in the last 30 days from 34 European countries and
USA (41, xxxii).
xi) British Heart Foundation Statistics Database. Statistics on xxiv) Agence nationale de sécurité sanitaire de l’alimentation,
mortality from coronary heart disease statistics 2010 (http:// de l’environnement et du travail. The populations intake of
www.bhf.org.uk/heart-health/statistics/mortality.aspx, ac- trans fatty acids. Paris, Maisons-Alfort, ANSES, 2009.
cessed 16 June 2011). xxv) Consumer Affairs Agency, Food Labelling Division. Regula-
xii) Steen S et al. A trans world journey. Atherosclerosis Supple- tory trends of nutrition labelling and trans fatty acid labelling.
ments, 2006, 7(2):47– 52. Tokyo, Government of Japan, 2010.
xiii) Steen S, Dyerberg J, Astrup A. Consumer protection xxvi) National Council for Nutrition. Strategy plan for 2005–2009,
through a legislative ban on industrially produced trans including proposed courses of action, under the auspices of
fatty acids in food in Denmark. Scandinavian Journal of the Norwegian Directorate for Health and Social Affairs: A
Food and Nutrition, 2006, 50(4):155–160. Healthy Diet for good health. Oslo, 2005.
atherosclerosis 3, 14, 15
atrial, fibrillation 58, 59 deaths from
cardiovascular disease (CVD) 110
coronary heart disease 110
behavioural see also risk factors 46, 47
inflammatory heart disease 62- 65
beta-blockers 92 rheumatic heart disease 62-65
best buya 96, 97
declarations 136-143
birth weight 46
defects see also abnormality and malformation 60
bleeding, see also haemorrhage 14
diabetes mellitus 40, 41, 97
blood clotting see also clotting 3 prevalence 40, 41
blood lipids 8, 42, 43 type 1 40
abnormal see also dyslipidaemia 8 type 2 40
blood pressure 8,38, 39, 92 diet see also food 32, 80-83, 96
blood sugar level 40, 41 dietary salt see also salt intake 32-34, 83
blood vessels see also arteries 3, 14, 15
disability-adjusted life year (DALY) 3
body mass index (BMI) 36, 37
dyslipidaemia see also abnormal blood lipids 42, 43
calorie 34
economic costs see also costs 54-56, 108, 110
cardiac defibrillation 58
electrocardiogram (ECG) 58, 59
cardiovascular disease (CVD) 2-7, 8-13, 48, 15
death from 3, 8-13
disability-adjusted life year (DALY) 3, 8-13 fever see also rheumatic fever 62-65
prevention of 70, 72, 74, 76, 94, 96-108 food 32-35
risk factors 3, 18-25 fast 81
surgery 62 fruit and vegetables 35, 82
stenosis 60 processed 34
causative see also risk factors 18 future 113
cerebrovascular disease see also stroke 3, 8, 14
Chagas disease 66, 67, 68 gender differences see also women 3, 48
haemorrhage see also bleeding 14 physical activity see also activity and inactivity 28, 84-87, 97
HDL cholesterol see also cholesterol, HDL 42, 43 policies 74, 76, 78, 80, 84, 88
healthcare health- in- all 74, 75
primary 94, 95 polyunsaturated fat 97
health warnings 75, 99 poverty 44, 54, 106, 107
heart
attack 3, 14, 48, 49
research 97, 100, 101
congenital disease 60, 61
resources 108, 109
inflammatory disease 62
muscle 63 resolutions
valves 62 World Health Assembly 134, 135
see also cardiac and coronary and hypertensive heart disease rheumatic heart disease 3, 62
38 rheumatic fever 62
hypercholesterolaemia 42, 43 risk factors 18, 46
hypertension 18, 38 behavioural 3
see also blood pressure, high genetic 3
hypertensive heart disease 38, 39 metabolic 3
cardiovascular 20, 21
high-risk 21
implementation 100, 101
prediction 20
inequities 54
inflammation 14
salt intake see also dietary salt 32, 97
ischaemia 14
saturated fats 32, 34
smoking see also tobacco use 26
LDL cholesterol see also cholesterol, LDL 14 socioeconomic status 44
lipids 42, 43, 80 development 106, 107
social determinants 44, 45
literacy rates 45 social mobilization 104, 105
liver cirrhosis 30 statins 92
low birth weight 46 strategy
global 114, 115
metabolic see also risk factors 18 streptococcal infection 62, 63
mortality 56 stress 3
myocardial infarction see also heart attack 70, 07 stroke 14, 18
surveillance 102
noncommunicable disease (NCD) 76, 80
control
and control
oncardiovascular
on cardiovascular
diseaseprevention
disease prevention on cardiovascular disease
prevention and
andcontrol
control prevention and control
disease prevention
and
Joint Publication
Published of theHealth
by the World World Organization
Health Organization
in collaboration with
theWorld
the WorldHeart
HeartFederation
Federationand
andthe
theWorld
WorldStroke
StrokeOrganization.
Organization
cardiovascular disease
Millions of premature
In the absence of
on cardiovascular
International efforts deaths due to
prevention strategies,
aimed at poverty cardiovascular disease
increasing numbers of
reduction will be can be prevented CVDs
CVDs
people will succumb
derailed if the rapidly by scaling up the
to heart attacks
growing global implementation of
and strokes due to
cardiovascular disease affordable, high impact
continuing exposure to
burden is ignored. interventions, which
risk factors.
already exist.
Published
Joint by the
Publication World
of the Health
World Organization
Health Organization
Atlas on
in collaboration withHeart
the World the World Heart Federation
Federation
Global Atlas
Organization.
and the World Stroke Organization
Global
ISBN 978
ISBN 978929244256419
15643783
20 Avenue Appia
CH-1211 Geneva 27
9 789242 564198
Switzerland
www.who.int/