Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Foster Care or Foster Careless? Abuse and Neglect Inside the System
Cassidy R. Shugrue
Abstract
This paper discusses the flaws and hardships involved inside the foster care system inducing
abuse and neglect. The author begins stating what foster care is and the goal of being in the
system along with its benefits. The author then discusses the legal timeline of entering the foster
welfare system and the actions that may involve a child being admitted into the system. Foster
care neglect cases are then presented and explained proving the improvement that must occur in
this system under the identified law. The author then states how civic organizations help these
children by providing grants and scholarships. The author concludes discussing how the system
Foster Care, or Foster Careless? Abuse and Neglect Inside the System
As many children around the nation are being placed in the Foster Care system, the goal
is to keep these children safe and out of harm's reach. Unfortunately, many children involved in
the foster care system are being abused and neglected from case workers, their foster parents or
previously from their biological parents. Factors inducing this abuse and neglect include “high
rates of family poverty, unemployment, homelessness, involvement in drugs and alcohol, HIV
and AIDS, unfair education, violence at home or among their peers, and racism” (Chipungu and
Bent-Goodley 74-93). These factors create large unique caseloads for caseworkers and then lead
to fewer visits and reviews of the foster parents treatment of the children as the social workers
are too caught up in each families unique situation. While in the foster care system the ultimate
goal is to reattach children with their families and keep them safe while also keeping in mind
their well being, but often these children are abused and neglected due to lack of care and
attention. The child welfare system is neglecting many children nationally of adequate care and
safety by placing them in dangerous homes. The foster care system is doing more harm than
care, abandoning children and their basic necessities vital for their growth physically, mentally,
A child can be placed in the foster care system for one of two reasons. The first reason,
and the most common reason, is that the child is being neglected or abused in their current home.
The second reason is that the parent has passed away, is experiencing stressors such as an illness,
substance abuse, poverty, is being incarcerated with no family able to take care of the child or it
was a voluntary decision made by the parent to enter their child into the system. The child will
then be placed in the foster care system with the ultimate goal to reconnect with his or her
biological family. While a child is in the system, the biological parents may be offered a series
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 4
of classes that provide them with guidance on the current situation they are in to help better not
“Ricky Powers is one of eleven thousand involved in the foster care system of North
Carolina alone” (Barnes, 2017). Ricky was brought into this system four years ago when both of
his parents passed away. He now lives in a foster care group home which houses more than 90
children of various ages. As Ricky is an older child in the foster care system, he is most likely to
age out rather than being adopted as there is not a very high demand for older children to be
adopted now a days. 1/12 foster care children will leave the system with nowhere to go
Legal Timeline
“The main goal of foster care is to make sure vulnerable children are kept safe and are
well, not being exposed to violence, illegal activity or other instances where parents have created
an unsafe environment for a child” (Chipungu and Bent-Goodley 74-93). When parents are
deemed unfit to provide adequate care for their child, have exposed a child to violence or an
unsafe environment, or are questioned whether or not they can provide care for their child, they
are reviewed by caseworkers, taken to family court to determine the future of the child at stake,
and then are placed in the foster care system in either a home or a group home.
When a parent is deemed unfit to provide a safe environment for their child, a complaint
will be made and taken to court by a child protective service worker for a judge to determine
whether or not the child is safe. When it is determined by a court of law that the current living
situation for a child is unsafe and the child is at risk for many different reasons, the juvenile court
judge of the case will then remove the child from his or her home and put them into the care of
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 5
child protective services. Once the situation has become serious enough to be brought to court
and the judge has made the decision to remove the child from their current home, this is called
temporary custody with the state having temporary custody of the child. Reasons a child can be
removed from a home are not all dangerous negative reasons such as exposure to drugs and
alcohol abuse from their parents. Other reasons could include serious family problems such as
parents being in the hospital with no place for the child to go. There are many reasons parents
can have their child taken away from them, but the court is only doing what is best for the child
in the long run. Social workers and parents typically work together to make sure their child
returns home, but a child cannot return home until the court determines that it is safe for the
return. Parents must communicate with social workers and their lawyers to ensure that
everything the court wants done before the child's return is checked off (When My Child Is
When a child is taken from the home of his or her parents, there are multiple places of
care the child could be placed in, the first one being family or kinship care. Kinship care is
believed to be the best care provided for a child as the they are not being placed in a total
strangers home; they will be placed in a family member's home other than their mother or father.
When meeting with lawyers and case workers, this will be decided upon whether or not there is a
family member who could take care of the child. The next option is foster care. If the child
cannot be placed with a family member, then the child will be placed in a home with individuals
who are foster parents. The third option is a group home. Here the child will live with many
other children in one home with people who are trained to care for them. The next option is a
residential center. If the child needs more care than the average child does, such as a child with
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 6
disabilities, then they will be placed in a hospital or treatment center to suit them best. While the
child is away and not living with their parents and the court has temporary custody of the child,
the child's biological parent is still their legal parent or guardian unless stated otherwise by the
court or stated that parents are not allowed to visit the child, be told about the child's care, or help
make decisions for the child. Parents are still allowed to visit their child unless the court believes
it would harm them to see their parents (When My Child Is Unable to Remain in My Care: What
Once the child has been placed in their assigned foster care home, parents must follow
their case plan on what the court expects them to do to get the child back in their care and to
provide a safe environment for the child again. The main goal is to have the child away for the
shortest time possible but still being able to create a safe environment for the child (Chipungu &
Bent-Goodley, 2004).
Throughout this process, parents go to court for many different hearings. A shelter care
hearing will decide if the child is in danger and must be removed from their home. After this is
proven and decided upon that the home is dangerous, the court then decides which foster care
home the child will be sent to. Next is the adjudicatory hearing which is held no later than thirty
days after the first hearing. This is the chance for the parents to tell their viewpoint or side of the
story. From here the judge will determine if it is safe for the child to return home or not, and
decide if the child has been abused, neglected, or is dependent. If the child was found abused,
neglected or dependent, the parent will then go to a dispositional hearing. At this hearing, the
judge has the choice to “return the child home, keep the child in substitute care, give legal
custody to a person other than the parent, such as a relative, give permanent custody to the state,
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 7
Care: What Happens Next?, 2009). After this hearing, there will be a dispositional review where
the case will be examined at least every six months while the child is in foster care. These
reviews are used as check-ins to ensure the parents are following the case plan. Next, there will
be a permanency hearing if the child has been in temporary custody of the state for twelve out of
twenty two months. This hearing will determine the child's permanent plan of housing, whether
that be the child returning to home or whether the state will have permanent custody of the child;
so he or she can be adopted, give legal custody to someone other than the parent, or to give
permanent placement somewhere else such as a group home or residential center (When My
Throughout the legal timeline of dealing with foster care and the system, parents are
allowed to appeal any decision they do not agree with and have a rehearing after consulting with
their lawyers. Along with this, parents most likely always work side by side with the case
workers to ensure they get their child home as soon as possible to avoid moving the child from
home to home.
Case Workers
Foster care numbers have greatly heightened since the 1990’s, this is due to increased
numbers of births, growing numbers of parents becoming incarcerated, the opioid crisis and the
vulnerability of the child by being exposed to dangerous things such as violence or substance
abuse (J. DeGarmo, 2017). These factors get children involved in the foster care system and
then lead to large, complex caseloads for case workers dealing with the parents and the child.
Often families need more than just temporary housing for their child, the more needs the family
has, the more complex the case is. As each family has different needs, the child welfare system
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 8
has established relations with public and private businesses to ensure the family’s address and
get all the help they need to get their child back. As the caseworkers have many different cases
happening all at once, each case is different and requires many different needs that vary from
home to home. Due to low staffing numbers of case workers, this is often a very hard task to
keep up with, dealing with each necessary need of the parents and the families rights but also
making sure that the child is safe no matter where he or she may be at the moment. A major flaw
of the foster care system is in fact the low number of staff they employ. The system cannot keep
motivated staff, the workers then fall out leading to high staff turnover, and the current case
workers being to pile on more and more cases. The less cases a worker has, the more attention
and success their cases will get, then causing the parents to get their child back in their home
very quickly with less bumps in the road along the way. The process that is currently in place
with case workers is very long and complicated leaving the foster families, birth families and
case workers very confused and frustrated (Chipungu & Bent-Goodley, 2004).
Children deemed to be involved in the foster care system by a court of law have been in
some way abused or neglected by their parents. When entering the foster care system, the goal is
to provide a safe environment for these children to make them less vulnerable, but what happens
when foster care parents abuse and neglect these children just as badly if not worse than the
In 2015, four million reported cases of child maltreatment were documented involving
more than seven million children with approximately 683,000 children being victims of
maltreatment by foster parents. Of these victims, seventy five percent suffered from neglect,
seventeen suffered from physical abuse and eight percent suffered from sexual assault ("Child
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 9
Abuse and Neglect," n.d.). All children, particularly young children, are extremely vulnerable.
More than three fourths of these children suffering from maltreatment were younger than three
years old. One thousand six hundred and seventy children in 2015 died from abuse and neglect,
of these children, and forty nine percent were under the age of one year old. Although it may be
easy to assume that these deaths were the result of physical abuse then later leading to their
death, almost three fourths of these deaths were the result of the child being neglected or with it
being in a pair with another form of maltreatment ("Child Abuse and Neglect," n.d.).
Six innocent, helpless children in Florida who had previously been taken from their
biological mother for being an alcoholic were left in the cruel hands of Jacqueline and Frank
Lynch, of whom were collecting $150,000 a year for being foster parents. These children were
then placed in this home and left unchecked by all Florida case workers and foster care system
for nearly two years violating the mandatory monthly visits a case worker must make. They left
these children unseen for two years allowing anything to happen to them and being completely
When placing the children in the hands of these strangers, the state completely ignored
Lynch’s background, even though multiple bells went off indicating how dangerous this home
was and should not have housed any children in it. Lynch previously had one of their children
taken by the state for allegations of physical and sexual abuse going on in their home and their
other two children living with them were under protective supervision of the state. “At one
point, Lynch fled the state's jurisdiction in order to avoid the department. There had been a
statewide alert put out, and yet, when she came back, they licensed her and her husband as foster
While placed in the care of Lynch, these children were expected to be kept safe, but
instead they got the exact opposite. "I used to think in my mind, 'I wish I was dead so I didn't
have to be in this stupid place,'" one of the six children recalled (Ross, n.d.). All six of the
children lived, or to more accurately represent their living situation there, were locked inside of a
tiny room in the house together. Every night the children slept on the floor, constantly waking
up shivering because it was so cold. It doesn't stop there though. Cockroaches crawled out from
the old dirty floors and vents scaring the younger kids every night. For each meal, the children
all kneeled down and ate out of one single bowl, sometimes they were not fed and were forced to
eat their own vomit. They were given no access to the bathroom once they were locked in the
room and if they had to go they either held it until the morning or were forced to do so in their
tiny room. Everyday after school this was their world, no furniture, no place to do homework
and no toys for the young children to play with. “After the state received reports from school
about possible abuse, the caseworkers continued to file reports with "nothing but high praise" for
the Lynches, saying they were "excellent foster parents" who provided "a secure, loving home."”
(Ross, n.d.). Not only were the living conditions extremely poor, Lynch would also abuse the
children by hitting them with their hands or with belts saying their reason for doing so was
because the children were “retarded.” There were also other punishments the children faced other
than being physically abused, once Lynch made Toby, one of the children, eat a whole jar of red
hot peppers which then caused him to have blisters all over his mouth in the following days.
Jacqueline and Frank Lynch were not the only abusers though. The Lynch’s teenage son would
tape the children to large plastic crates and would then dump them into the swimming pool so
they were unable to breathe. While this was going on, the other children were forced to watch
helplessly. This same teenage son was also convicted of sex crimes against a minor, but yet the
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 11
Lynch’s still stayed in the good graces of Florida's system as they were allowed to remain as
foster care parents and were later approved for adoption of all six of these children allowing
them to continue racking in thousands of dollars. Thankfully after five years of these children
being under Lynch’s care, someone called a child abuse hotline and the police were able to
After being in the Lynch’s care for more than five years being abused and neglected, the
police finally responded. When doing so, the police found emotionally battered, extremely
malnourished children. Susanna, who was four years old at the time of her adoption, weighed
only nineteen pounds in a size 2T dress which completely swallowed her up. Once the police
realized the danger these children were in and the inhumane things that they had been living
through, the law did very little to the Lynch’s (Ross, n.d.).
When on trial for abuse and neglect against these six innocent children, Lynch was told
by prosecutors to plead guilty as a no contest plea. She was then convicted of just one
misdemeanor count of child neglect, she faced one year of probation and was ordered to pay
court fees of only one hundred forty dollars. "These children were tortured. These children were
neglected. These children were abused," says Howard Talenfeld, a family-rights attorney. "What
happened to these children was inhumane." (Ross, n.d.). Lynch now runs a restaurant in
Alabama, and when asked about the case of these six children, they say they have no comment
about the children that were once in their care (Ross, n.d.).
Not only was Lynch at fault in this case, the state of Florida was as well. Recently, there
was an out of court settlement for the state of Florida to pay five million dollars into a trust fund
for these children. They also paid over one million dollars in attorney fees. As for the
employees handling this case, not a single one of them have been fired or disciplined, and at least
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 12
three of them are still handling foster children even after they put these six in harm for so long
(Ross, n.d.).
The six children have now been adopted by a very loving family. "When I was in foster
care," says Toby, "I wanted a family that I can have fun with. And I got that family that I
wanted." (Ross, n.d.). Kathy and Rod Rodriguez adopted all six of these children and said that
they have shown incredible strength to overcome what happened in the past. These children are
in a much better, more safe place now thanks to their new parents (Ross, n.d.).
This case is one of many where the state foster care system and parents have been able to
abuse and neglect children with no punishments made towards them after. Lynch was charged
with only one misdemeanor count of child neglect, only faced one year of probation and was
ordered to pay court fees after hurting and torturing these children. The case workers who were
handling this case at the time did not receive any punishment and were not dismissed after
allowing this to occur for so long and failing to check on these children.
Often times caseworkers desperately put children in homes with the hope of preventing
them from sleeping with the child in the child welfare office. When a child cannot be placed, the
case worker is required to stay with the child in the office in a sleeping bag or on a cot. After a
period of time, the case worker may give up and put the child in a group home or shelter which is
basically a modern day orphanage where they will live until they age out of the system (Teo,
2015). This is exactly what these children were neglected of when being placed and evaluated
while in the system. The case workers gave up on these children and desperately put them in a
home to get them off their hands without reviewing the parents background or checking in on the
children after reports of abuse were made. This is not the only case where a child has been
abused and neglected by not only their foster parents, but their case workers as well.
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 13
A six year old girl was sent by an adoption agency to live with foster parents who had
very lengthy criminal records. Bethanna, the foster care agency, looked past these records and
desperately put a helpless six year old girl into great harm. Sixteen years later she finally
gathered the courage to come forth and tell a jury of what happened to her in the hands of the
Scotts under the supervision of Bethanna. Walter Scott, who was at the time under investigation
for accusations of child rape from other children in the foster home and was charged with
welfare fraud convictions, was named a foster parent of this six year old placed in his home.
Shortly after living there, this innocent child was repeatedly molested and raped by Walter Scott
and was severely beaten by Deborah Scott for four years. Reports from caseworkers show that
upon visiting this child at the home they believed that she was being abused and was in danger
but Bethanna did nothing and continued to keep this child in the criminals home. Upon arrival to
court multiple years later, after many more children had gone through this home of an on record
rapist, Bethanna stated that they had no idea that this child was in danger to harm or sexual
abuse, even though case workers reported the child was in harm, Bethanna continued to say they
were unaware of this situation because the six year old girl never told anyone, nor did any
supervisor, child advocate, or doctor have suspicions of physical or sexual abuse despite the case
workers report of the child being in danger. What happened to this child was systematic failure.
The system did not do its job by desperately placing her in a home just to get her off the hands of
the case workers then putting her in more danger and not checking up on her when harm was
Governing Laws
As previously stated, the goal of foster care is to "provide a temporary, safe haven for
children whose parents are unable to care for them" ("Standards of Excellence for Child Welfare
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 14
Services," n.d.). Unfortunately, statistics prove that foster care children suffer abuse ten times
more often than children in the general population (Mushlin, 1988). When these children are
being exposed to more violence and are being abused or neglected and finally gather the courage
to speak up, who can we put at fault to fix this system and make up to the child for all they have
been through?
42 U.S.C. section 1983 states that abused foster care children may sue under this code,
but only may be entitled to sue the agencies that have wronged them by putting and keeping
them in a dangerous homes. “The Constitution, as the supreme law of the land, trumps all state
statutes and case law that might give full or partial sovereign immunity to government agencies
or employees...” (Kubitschek, n.d.). As known in tort law, defendants are only left liable for the
injuries they cause themselves. Foster care agencies and case workers typically do not abuse
these children directly, it comes from a third party such as their foster parents. Foster parents are
not state actors and therefore will not be held liable under federal law, but can still be brought to
court for abuse, rape or neglect. Foster care agencies, however, will be held liable for the abuse
that was inflicted from these parents upon the child in their home and if deemed so by the court
One example is the case of K.H., a child born in Chicago in 1981. Foster care left K.H.
abused and emotionally disturbed by her fifth birthday. Her foster parents beat and
neglected her, while a neighbor of one foster parent sexually abused her. The Illinois
Department of Children and Family Services failed to stop the abuse after discovering it.
In K.H. Through Murphy v. Morgan,' K.H. sued the Department, its director, and the two
social workers involved, alleging gross negligence in failing to protect her. The Seventh
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 15
Circuit upheld the lower court's rejection of the defendant's qualified immunity defense."
while K.H. may recover from the defendant state employees in their individual capacity,
the Seventh Circuit stated, in dicta, that foster parents are not "state actors" and therefore
Being a child involved in the foster care system is a very emotional, tough journey to deal with.
These children have been failed by their parents, taken out of their homes and then tossed into
this system being exposed to much greater harm than it does good. After aging out of the
system, one out of four former foster care children will end up in prison two years after aging out
and having nowhere to go, more than a fifth of these children will be homeless after aging out,
only half of foster care children will have a high school degree by the age of 18, and of those
who have a high school degree, only three percent will continue on to obtain a college degree
(Barnes, 2017).
To deal with these hard times presented while in the foster care system, children are
offered many programs from beneficial civic organizations. These children are given
opportunities to apply for grants and scholarships for being a child in the system. These
scholarships and grants help children to pursue their educational and vocational goals, help to
purchase necessities for independent living, such as bedding and dishes for a first apartment, and
give chances to become successful adults. Civic organizations have also created mini-grants for
these children. Since money is tight in the system, children may not be able to attend prom or
class trips, mini grants are given to children that help to grant some wishes they have which can
help find their talent and boosts their self esteem. Grants are also given to children who show
exceptional talent for a skill and wish to further their dream of doing this particular talent.
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 16
Scholarship camps are also given to these children allowing them to participate in a summer
camp boosting their self esteem and social interaction skills. These civic and faith based
organizations have other programs that give children backpacks full of things to comfort them
like a teddy bear or blanket, they send christmas presents annually to every foster care child and
always make sure the child has a present on his or her birthday. Organizations take away some
of the hard feelings of being in the system, help the child not miss their family as much as they
do, give foster kids the opportunity to live happier lives, and teach them to be self-sufficient
Conclusion
As stated by Dr. John DeGarmo 2017, a foster care expert at the Foster Care Institute:
Civic and faith based organizations can become more involved in helping the children
and the families. More focus must also be made on helping the families in need before
the child is placed into care, and try to keep families together, if possible.
The foster care system is not perfect and has many careless flaws. Often times case workers are
lazy and throw the child into the foster care system before trying to work with the family. If
change occurs it needs to be here by obtaining motivated staff who actually want the best for
these families. Reunification is possible, case workers must work with the mindset that “parents
who have children taken away are not forever unable to provide for those children” (Dupere,
2016). Change of the system is possible, more extensive background checks on potential
parents, motivated staff, and more action within is required to ensure these vulnerable children
are no longer exposed to harm or taken advantage of. As of now the system produces hardly any
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 17
good, with a change of motivation we will see a more protective, safe system and a more
References
Barnes, G. (2017, September 25). State foster care numbers surge. Retrieved from
http://www.thetimesnews.com/news/20170925/state-foster-care-numbers-surge
Chang, H. H. (2015, January 29). Attorney: Rape of Girl Was a Systemic Failure.
https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/local/Attorney-Rape-of-Foster-Girl-Caused-by-
Systematic-Failure-290007381.html
http://www.childrensrights.org/newsroom/fact-sheets/child-abuse-and-neglect/
https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubpdfs/majorfedlegis.pdf+
Contemporary Foster Care. The Future of Children, 14(1), 74-93. Retrieved October 2,
Dannunzio, P. (2017, November 22). $11M Verdict Awarded in Child Abuse Lawsuit.
Retrieved from
https://www.law.com/thelegalintelligencer/sites/thelegalintelligencer/2017/11/22/11m-
verdict-awarded-in-child-abuse-lawsuit/
Dell'Antonia, K. (2015, May 22). When Parents Can't Care for Their Children. Retrieved
from https://parenting.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/05/22/when-parents-cant-care-for-their-
children/
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 19
Dupere, K. (2016, June 04). 6 problems with the foster care system -- and what you can
problems/#HFD5zrCloqqW
FAFS. (n.d.). Foster Children Programs | Programs for Foster Children | NJ Foster
https://www.fafsonline.org/foster-children-programs/
Federal judge's advisers cost Texas $1.5 million, offered unworkable foster care fixes,
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/texas-politics/2017/12/20/ken-paxton-says-proposal-
ofjudges-advisers-overhaul-texas-foster-care-unworkable-not-plan
sheets/foster-care/
https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubs/factsheets/foster/
The Kansas City Star Editorial Board. (n.d.). Children in foster care in Kansas and
http://www.kansascity.com/opinion/editorials/article190632424.html
https://www.americanbar.org/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/human_rights_
vol32_2005/winter2005/hr_winter05_fostercare.html
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 20
Lopez, R. J. (n.d.). Child Maltreatment 2015 (Rep.). Retrieved December 14, 2017, from
http://www.childrensrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/cm2015.pdf
care-neglect-abuse-and-mistreatment-cases.html
foster-care-month-as-an-opportunity-to-raise-awareness-about-the-challenges-of-
children-in-the-foster-care-system-and-encouragin
services/social-services/Pages/Foster-Care-Program.aspx
Ross, B. (May 24). Six Kids Neglected by Florida Foster Care. Retrieved from
http://abcnews.go.com/2020/story?id=123897&page=1
Simon, S. (2017, December 23). The Foster Care System Is Flooded With Children Of
foster-care-system-is-flooded-with-children-of-the-opioid-epidemic
Standards of Excellence for Child Welfare Services. (n.d.). Retrieved December 22,
excellence-for-child-welfare-services/
Teo, D. (2015, April 15). The 10 Most Surprising Things About Foster Care. Retrieved
surprising-things-about-foster-care_b_7058474.html
FOSTER CARE OR FOSTER CARELESS 21
United States, Advisory Committee on Children, Families & the Courts. (2009, October).
http://www.guernseycountycs.org/About_Us/PDF_Files/whathappensnextaguide.pdf
https://www.adoptuskids.org/adoption-and-foster-care/how-to-adopt-and-foster/state-
information/virginia
https://openscholarship.wustl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1925&context=law_lawrev
iew