Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
25. Getting symbols and charge of fundamental They don’t appreciate that
ions wrong
26. Failing to omit spectator ions They don’t appreciate that they have to in NIE’s
27. MgCl2 is Mg2+ and Cl2-! Very common in my experience too.
28. Not knowing the formula of all elements Need to avoid K/P problems, need to know
diatomics etc. Standard states are useful to know.
Too many silly errors. (MJ) My students know the
HAIROGENS, which are the diatomic elements:
H = hydrogen, AIR = nitrogen and oxygen, OGENS
= the halogens
29. Applying oxidation and reduction as Failure to appreciate “source” and “sink”
independent processes
30. Charges on ions do not have to be written Especially when assigning oxidation numbers avoid
in a chemical equation or in an equilibrium the ambiguity of writing Mg2+Cl 2 - and confusing the
expression examiner. Eraser!
31. Failure to pay attention to stoichiometry x, 2x, 3x etc. often missed
when setting up ICE table for solubility
expressions
32. (2x)2 ≠ 2x2 Simple math misconception relevant in Ksp
situations
33. Be careful that proximity does not mean that Don’t try and find the moles of Fe with P V = n R T
the same calculation produces the correct even though it was appropriate with O 2
answer (2004, 2) calculate moles of Fe(s)
and O2(g), one use the ideal gas law the
other does not
Page 2 of 4
Additional Comments
1. The equilibrium constant for the reaction It is the square root of the second K. (AD) Common
SO 2 + ½ O 2 ⇄ SO 3 is half of, or the confusion between the treatment of combining ΔH
same as, the Keq for the reaction 2 SO 2 values and combining K values – also see
+ O 2 ⇄ 2 SO 3 reciprocal vs. negative, etc.
2. The quantity of a solid that is part of an Common error. Students memorize that solids are
equilibrium system is constant ignored when predicting equilibrium changes, so in
a reaction such as C(s) + CO 2 (g) ⇄ 2 CO(g),
when asked how the quantity of carbon would
change if the volume of the reaction vessel is
decreased, they will often say "remains the same."
Emphasize that although the solid does not drive
the equilibrium, it IS affected by the equilibrium
3. Beakers and Erlenmeyer flasks can be Volumetric flasks are used to accurately produce
used to accurately determine volume of a one given volume. Graduated cylinders are used to
liquid (came up on the 2009 exam) measure liquid volumes accurately. Students also
need to know how a pipette is used
4. Ethanol is more soluble in water than is We never accept the statement "like dissolves like"
carbon tetrachloride because “like as an explanation. The student must say that the
dissolves like” attractions between the alcohol and water
(dipoledipole or hydrogen bonds) are strong enough
to offset the attractions WITHIN the two
substances, while the attraction between the non-
dipole and water is too weak to cause the water
molecules to separate. Or something similar. (AD)
LOTS of ways to word this but clarity is the key
5. If the pressure on an equilibrium system is Although Le Chatelier spoke of pressure as a
increased by adding an unreactive (or stress, what is actually more valid is a change in
noble) gas, the reaction shifts as per Le volume. When we say "the pressure is increased"
Chatelier's Principle without specifying HOW it is increased, it is
assumed that we mean that the volume was
decreased! Adding a noble gas does not affect the
system. (AD) Inert gas NOT in the chemical
equation and not in the K expression
Energy is released when bonds are broken
6. (AD) The exact opposite is true
(came up a lot on the 2011 exam)
"m" is an acceptable abbreviation for
7. "moles" NO! ‘m’ is molality!
Additional Comments by Mike Jones, July 2010 & 2011 with some notes from me
1. Bonding misconceptions I have come to the conclusion that most people
assume that the default bond type is “ionic”. It
worries me that students will say that PCl 3 contains
a ‘P ion’ and three ‘Cl ions’, and the P has a charge
of +3 and chlorine a charge of -1. “Covalent” should
become the default bond type. In fact, I tell my
students that ALL bonds are covalent it’s just that
some are very polar. So rather than classify bonds
as either “ionic” or “covalent”, we talk about bonds
being covalent, and then specify the percent ionic
character of the (covalent) bond.
Page 3 of 4
2. Assumption that metal-nonmetal bonds are Again, we need to remind teachers and students
“ionic” and nonmetal-nonmetal bonds are that bonds lie along a continuum, and are not one
“covalent” or the other. In fact, we find that many
metalnonmetal compounds are more covalent than
they are ionic. Take the bonds in CuCl 2 . The
electronegativity difference is 1.26, which translates
to a bond with 33% ionic character (67% covalent).
There are many more metal-nonmetal bonds like
this. (AD) I introduce this as a “sliding scale”.
3. Incorrectly defining the “characteristics” of It is common to hear that “ionic” compounds have
compounds high melting points and “covalent” compounds have
low melting points. This is far too broad. What
determines melting point and boiling point are the
intermolecular attractions, not the internal bonding.
Compounds with high melting point have a network
arrangement of atoms. It doesn’t matter if the
network has bonding which is either predominately
ionic or covalent it’s the network that makes for the
high melting point, not the bonds. For instance
diamond and graphite have 100% covalent bonds
but very high melting points. Ditto for SiO 2 . The
same is true of MgO and NaCl. They are all
network solids. Compounds with low melting points
do not form networks of atoms, and therefore,
require less energy to separate the more weakly
attracted molecules held together by intermolecular
forces (van der Waals forces)
4. Confusing “oxidation number” and “ionic The oxidation number is the ionic charge an atom
charge” would have in a compound if in fact the atoms were
ions, which they aren’t. Herein lies the problem.
Students and teachers alike equate the oxidation
number with an ionic charge, even though no such
charge exists
Page 4 of 4