Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 33

Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New

DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,


Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

REPORT
ON
EXISTING FOUR (4) STOREY RCC OFFICE BUILDING LOCATED AT PLOT# 430, G-
7, NAKHALPARA, TEJGAON, DHAKA. BANGLADESH.

NAME OF THE CLIENT:


ENERGYPAC POWER GENERATION LTD.

Date of submission: 05-05-2018 Name & Address of the Submitting Engineer:


Engr. Abdul Quddus
B.Sc. Engg(Civil, BUET),
DMINB/CE-0231
MIEB-21384
DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT SOLUTION
Road-#23, H-#337, Ground Floor
Mohakhali New DOHS
Dhaka-1206

1
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Table of content

Sl No Description
ABSTRACT
1.0 Introduction
2.0 Basic Information of the Building
3.0 Limitations
4.0 Methodology
5.0 Structural Design Concept and criteria
5.1 Codes and Standards
5.2 Structural Framing System
5.3 Material Data
5.4 Definitions of loads.
5.5 Load applied on structure
5.6 Design Method
5.7 Method of Analysis
5.8 Engineering software used for design
5.9 Pictorial evidence of core cutting
6.0 Input Data
6.1 Static Load Cases
6.2 Load Combinations
7.0 Structural Feasibility check.
7.1 Foundation adequacy check
7.2 Column adequacy check
7.3 Slab Adequacy check
7.4 Beam Adequacy check
8.0 Working sequences & safety measures during retrofitting
9.0 Conclusion & Recommendation
Signature Of the Engineer
Attachments

2
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

ABSTRACT

This report includes the structural assessment of a FOUR (4) storey Office building of ENERYGPAC
POWER GENERATION LTD located at plot# 430, G-7, Nakhalpara, Tejgaon, Dhaka, Bangladesh. This
building has structural construction with RCC frame structure.

Assessment has been done considering Bangladesh National Building Code (BNBC-2006) load
combinations & 63 live load in working space.

A detailed calculation and analysis has been described in the rest of the report.

3
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

1.0 INTRODUCTION

No credible structural document was available. For this reason information was obtained from
site and as built drawing prepared. Ferro scanner (Hilti PS 200) was used to identify the
reinforcement inside concrete. Concrete core tests were performed to estimate the concrete
strength. Soil test was done by ENERYGPAC POWER GENERATION LTD. to know about the
sub surface condition of the site. The site was visited by engineers to inspect present condition
of the structure and to gather required information.

Assessment is done based on the structural drawing prepared from the information obtained
from site. Information gained from visual inspection was used in conjunction with analytical
evaluation to conclude decisions.

2.0 BASIC INFORMATION OF THE BUILDINGS

The building has been four storied building with beam-column RCC frame. The vertical gravity

load & lateral load of the building is carried by RCC columns to foundations. The foundation of

the building is isolated type. The depth of footing is mentioned around 15 ft below the EGL. The

lateral load arising from wind & earth quake is taken by framing action of beam-column system.

The beams and columns have sufficient capacity to carry the lateral loads arising from wind &

earth quake.

3.0 LIMITATIONS
To produce the design report of this project we have some limitations. It was unable to collect all

the data from every sections of every member. We have collect data from some specific locations

of specific members.

4
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

4.0 METHODOLOGY
The as-built architectural and structural drawings of the building have been prepared &
rechecked by DDS. The consultants have visited the building site several times and collected
necessary practical information regarding the architectural as well as structural designs in order
to verify the as-built drawings. Soil sample has been collected by “ENERGYPAC POWER
GENERATION LTD.” The structural integrity, safety and serviceability have been evaluated on
the basis of the tested material properties, as-built drawings, existing load plan and by conducting
analytical investigation on the basis of 3D finite element analysis. The different load cases and
load combinations considered in the analysis those are specified in the BNBC standard, 2006.

5.0 STRUCTURAL DESIGN CONCEPT & CRITERIA


The structural element has been designed and considering the following criteria.

5.1 Codes and Standards

5.1.1 Bangladesh National Building Code (BNBC)-2006


5.1.2 American Concrete Institute (ACI 318-99)
5.1.3 American Society for Testing Materials (ASTM)

5.2 Structural Framing System

On the basis of existing structural detailing Intermediate Moment Resisting Frame (IMRF)
has been adopted.

5
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

5.3 Material Data


Equivalent compressive strength of concrete core:

Core test report presented below

6
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Equivalent compressive strength of concrete


Ref: ACI-562 & 214.4R

Equivalent in place concrete strength


= compressive strength of concrete core* correction factor (1.06)for damage due to drilling*Correction
factor (1.03) for 75 mm dimeter core*l/d factor

Compressive
Equivalent in Variation
strength of Length
Sample place Modification
concrete L/d ratio diameter
Number Compressive Factors (Kc)
core factor
strength (Psi) table
(Psi)

1 2390 1.93 0.994 2594.28 n Kc


2 2390 1.93 0.994 2594.28 2 2.4
3 2510 1.90 0.992 2718.18 3 1.47
4 3630 1.93 0.994 3940.26 4 1.28
5 5 1.2
6 6 1.15
7 7 1.125
8 8 1.1
n 4 10 1.08
Average f'c 2961.74643 12 1.06
Sigma 654.9511132 16 1.05
V 0.221136795 20 1.03

Kc 1.28

Equivalent concrete strength (fceq) 2165 Psi

Yield strength of steel, fy =40 Ksi.

7
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

5.4 Definitions of Load

Dead Load:

Dead load is the vertical load due to the self-weight of the permanent structural and non-structural
component of a building, e.g Foundation, column, beam, walls, ceilings, permanent partitions
and fixed service equipment.

Unit weight of materials and the calculation of design dead loads are according to section-2.2,
Chapter-2, part-6, BNBC-Page6-22

Live Load:

Live load is the load superimposed by the use or occupancy of the building not including the
environmental loads such as wind load, rain load, and earthquake load. Dead load. (Ref. BNBC,
Part-6, Chapter-2, Sec-2.3.2)

But it should be not less than the minimum floor live load. (Ref. BNBC, Part-6, Chapter-2, Sec-
2.3.3)

5.5 Load applied on structure.

Proposed Live Load plan attached with the report.

Wind Load:
The calculation of wind load confirms the sub-clause 2.4, Chapter 2, Part-6 of BNBC. The
following equation has been used to calculate sustained wind pressure of the structure.

Pz=CgCpCcCiCzVb2 [BNBC, 2.4.6.2,2.4.6.3 Page-6-33,6-34]


Wind load was applied in two orthogonal directions X and Y.
The following parameters are considered

1. Design wind speed =210 km/hr


2. Exposure Type =A
3. Importance factor, I = 1.0

8
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Earth quake Load:

As per specifications of BNBC, Part-6, Chapter-2, section-2.5.51, Equivalent Static Force


Method can be applied to calculate the earth quake force of this structure.
Design Base Shear, V=ZICW/R (Ref. Sec2.5.6.1, Chapter-2, Part-6, BNBC)

Where,
1.0 Seismic Zone coefficient factor, Z=0.15 for Zone-02
(Ref.Table6.2.22 Sec2.5.6.1, Chap.-2, Part-6, BNBC)
2.0 Importance factor, I = 1.0
(Ref. Table 6.2.23 Sec2.5.6.1,Chap.-2,Part-6, BNBC)
3.0 Numerical Co-efficient, C=0.029
4.0 Response Modification factor, R=8
(Ref. Table 6.2.24 Sec2.5.6.2, Chap.-2,Part-6, BNBC)

Considering the structural detailing of existing drawing Intermediate Moment Resisting Frame
(IMRF) has been adopted for this structure. (Ref. BNBC, Part-6, Sec1.3.2)
Earth quake load was applied in two orthogonal directions X & Y.

5.6 Design Method

Reinforcement concrete structure has been designed with Ultimate Strength Design (USD)
method has been adopted.

5.7 Method of Analysis


Computer 3 Dimensional (3D) Model Analysis by ETABS 9.7.4

5.8 Engineering software used for design:

PCA Column, ACECOMS Gear-2003, ETABS 9.7.4

9
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

6.0 INPUT DATA:

6.1 Static Load Case

Load Case Type


DEAD DEAD
LIVE LIVE
WINDX WIND
WINDY WIND
EQX QUAKE
EQY QUAKE

6.2 Load Combinations:

Combo Type Case Factor CaseType SortID


WSD ADD DEAD 1 Static 15
WSD LIVE 1 Static 16
DCON1 ADD DEAD 1.4 Static 19
DCON2 ADD DEAD 1.4 Static 20
DCON2 LIVE 1.7 Static 21
DCON3 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 22
DCON3 LIVE 1.275 Static 23
DCON3 WINDX 1.275 Static 24
DCON4 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 25
DCON4 LIVE 1.275 Static 26
DCON4 WINDX -1.275 Static 27
DCON5 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 28
DCON5 LIVE 1.275 Static 29
DCON5 WINDY 1.275 Static 30
DCON6 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 31
DCON6 LIVE 1.275 Static 32
DCON6 WINDY -1.275 Static 33
DCON7 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 34
DCON7 WINDX 1.275 Static 35
DCON8 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 36
DCON8 WINDX -1.275 Static 37
DCON9 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 38
DCON9 WINDY 1.275 Static 39
DCON10 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 40
DCON10 WINDY -1.275 Static 41
DCON11 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 42
DCON11 WINDX 1.3 Static 43
DCON12 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 44

10
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

DCON12 WINDX -1.3 Static 45


DCON13 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 46
DCON13 WINDY 1.3 Static 47
DCON14 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 48
DCON14 WINDY -1.3 Static 49
DCON15 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 50
DCON15 LIVE 1.275 Static 51
DCON15 EQX 1.4025 Static 52
DCON16 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 53
DCON16 LIVE 1.275 Static 54
DCON16 EQX -1.4025 Static 55
DCON17 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 56
DCON17 LIVE 1.275 Static 57
DCON17 EQY 1.4025 Static 58
DCON18 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 59
DCON18 LIVE 1.275 Static 60
DCON18 EQY -1.4025 Static 61
DCON19 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 62
DCON19 EQX 1.4025 Static 63
DCON20 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 64
DCON20 EQX -1.4025 Static 65
DCON21 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 66
DCON21 EQY 1.4025 Static 67
DCON22 ADD DEAD 1.05 Static 68
DCON22 EQY -1.4025 Static 69
DCON23 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 70
DCON23 EQX 1.43 Static 71
DCON24 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 72
DCON24 EQX -1.43 Static 73
DCON25 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 74
DCON25 EQY 1.43 Static 75
DCON26 ADD DEAD 0.9 Static 76
DCON26 EQY -1.43 Static 77

11
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

7.0 Structural Feasibility check


7.2 Column Adequacy check
Firstly column has been checked following table is prepared considering 63 psf live load in working
space & load combinations as per BNBC.
FOR LONG PART OF BUILDING:
Before Retrofitting (WITHOUT SHED LOAD):
Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99
Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
TOP C1 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.747
3F C1 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.051
2F C1 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.695
GF C1 C1B-14X14 DCON6 0.891
TOP C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.372
3F C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.459
2F C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.985
1F C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.427
GF C2 C1B-14X14 DCON6 0.683
TOP C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.299
3F C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.47
2F C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.081
GF C3 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.025
TOP C4 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.263
3F C4 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.488
2F C4 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.115
GF C4 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.051
TOP C5 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.205
3F C5 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.484
2F C5 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.136
GF C5 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.084
TOP C6 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.253
3F C6 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.508
2F C6 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.176
GF C6 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.064
TOP C7 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.278
3F C7 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.526
2F C7 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.216
GF C7 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.077
TOP C8 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.326
3F C8 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.553
2F C8 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.264
GF C8 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.098

12
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
TOP C9 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.469
3F C9 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.722
2F C9 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.46
GF C9 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.548
TOP C10 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.232
3F C10 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.82
2F C10 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.725
GF C10 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.014
TOP C11 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.978
3F C11 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.672
2F C11 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.549
GF C11 C1B-14X14 DCON2 2.183
TOP C12 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.989
3F C12 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.689
2F C12 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.61
GF C12 C1B-14X14 DCON2 2.036
TOP C13 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.997
3F C13 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.726
2F C13 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.678
GF C13 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.913
TOP C14 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.968
3F C14 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.746
2F C14 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.739
GF C14 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.834
TOP C15 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.97
3F C15 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.774
2F C15 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.799
GF C15 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.885
TOP C16 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.972
3F C16 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.803
2F C16 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.851
GF C16 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.991
TOP C17 C1-12X12 DCON10 1.108
3F C17 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.844
2F C17 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.848
TOP C18 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.836
3F C18 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.268
2F C18 C1-12X12 DCON6 3.095
GF C18 C1B-14X14 DCON2 11.871
TOP C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.017

13
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
3F C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.25
2F C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.972
1F C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 5.267
GF C20 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.772
TOP C21 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.823
3F C21 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.021
2F C21 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.651
GF C21 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.492
TOP C22 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.634
3F C22 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.801
2F C22 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.472
1F C22 C1-12X12 DCON2 8.105
GF C22 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.865
TOP C23 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.584
3F C23 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.774
2F C23 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.419
1F C23 C1-12X12 DCON2 36.345
GF C23 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.862
TOP C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.554
3F C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.764
2F C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.384
1F C24 C1-12X12 DCON2 37.478
GF C24 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.855
TOP C25 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.599
3F C25 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.766
2F C25 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.347
GF C25 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.854
TOP C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.616
3F C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.76
2F C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.317
GF C26 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.852
TOP C27 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.617
3F C27 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.763
2F C27 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.28
GF C27 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.847
TOP C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.468
3F C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.703
2F C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.325
1F C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.905
GF C28 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.704

14
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Before retrofitting (with shed load):

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
TOP C1 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.773
3F C1 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.051
2F C1 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.694
GF C1 C1B-14X14 DCON6 0.901
TOP C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.358
3F C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.453
2F C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.977
1F C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.486
GF C2 C1B-14X14 DCON6 0.688
TOP C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.283
3F C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.466
2F C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.077
GF C3 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.032
TOP C4 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.258
3F C4 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.483
2F C4 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.112
GF C4 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.068
TOP C5 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.195
3F C5 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.479
2F C5 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.132
GF C5 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.102
TOP C6 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.233
3F C6 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.503
2F C6 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.172
GF C6 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.072
TOP C7 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.258
3F C7 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.521
2F C7 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.211
GF C7 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.083
TOP C8 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.308
3F C8 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.549
2F C8 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.261
GF C8 C1B-14X14 DCON6 1.106
TOP C9 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.468
3F C9 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.722
2F C9 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.46
GF C9 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.63
TOP C10 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.227

15
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
3F C10 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.822
2F C10 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.727
GF C10 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.01
TOP C11 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.977
3F C11 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.675
2F C11 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.551
GF C11 C1B-14X14 DCON2 2.167
TOP C12 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.972
3F C12 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.687
2F C12 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.607
GF C12 C1B-14X14 DCON2 2.072
TOP C13 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.982
3F C13 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.725
2F C13 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.675
GF C13 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.926
TOP C14 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.969
3F C14 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.75
2F C14 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.742
GF C14 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.809
TOP C15 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.971
3F C15 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.778
2F C15 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.802
GF C15 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.852
TOP C16 C1-12X12 DCON14 0.974
3F C16 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.8
2F C16 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.854
GF C16 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.97
TOP C17 C1-12X12 DCON10 1.117
3F C17 C1-12X12 DCON14 1.834
2F C17 C1-12X12 DCON14 2.839
TOP C18 C1-12X12 DCON6 1.856
3F C18 C1-12X12 DCON6 2.261
2F C18 C1-12X12 DCON6 3.092
GF C18 C1B-14X14 DCON2 24.367
TOP C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.038
3F C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.249
2F C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.971
1F C20 C1-12X12 DCON5 5.678
GF C20 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.782
TOP C21 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.831

16
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
3F C21 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.018
2F C21 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.65
GF C21 C1B-14X14 DCON2 1.567
TOP C22 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.619
3F C22 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.792
2F C22 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.464
1F C22 C1-12X12 DCON2 13.734
GF C22 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.871
TOP C23 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.566
3F C23 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.765
2F C23 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.411
GF C23 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.866
TOP C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.535
3F C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.755
2F C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.375
GF C24 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.86
TOP C25 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.583
3F C25 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.76
2F C25 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.34
GF C25 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.86
TOP C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.603
3F C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.754
2F C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.31
GF C26 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.857
TOP C27 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.603
3F C27 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.753
2F C27 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.271
GF C27 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.853
TOP C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.455
3F C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 1.694
2F C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.316
1F C28 C1-12X12 DCON5 2.977
GF C28 C1B-14X14 DCON5 0.709

It is observed that with or without presence of shed on top of the floor, Almost columns go to overstress
as per the combination of BNBC.

17
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

SHORT PART OF BUILDING:

Before Retrofitting:

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
TOP C1 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.634
3F C1 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.74
2F C1 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.899
1F C1 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.429
GF C1 C2B-14X14 DCON6 0.381
TOP C3 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.671
3F C3 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.788
2F C3 C2-12X12 DCON6 1.023
1F C3 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.751
GF C3 C2B-14X14 DCON2 0.696
TOP C4 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.739
3F C4 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.845
2F C4 C2-12X12 DCON6 1.039
1F C4 C2-12X12 DCON15 0.705
GF C4 C2B-14X14 DCON2 0.619
TOP C5 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.453
3F C5 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.578
2F C5 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.768
1F C5 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.96
GF C5 C2B-14X14 DCON6 0.397
TOP C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.501
3F C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.668
2F C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.905
1F C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 1.149
GF C6 C2B-14X14 DCON2 0.618
TOP C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.521
3F C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.697
2F C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.939
1F C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 1.187
GF C7 C2B-14X14 DCON2 0.69
TOP C10 C3-10X10 DCON2 0.18
3F C10 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.264
2F C10 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.414
1F C10 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.671
GF C10 C3B-12X12 DCON5 0.337
TOP C13 C3-10X10 DCON2 0.327
3F C13 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.4

18
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
2F C13 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.52
1F C13 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.723
GF C13 C3B-12X12 DCON5 0.388
TOP C14 C4-12X10 DCON16 0.127
3F C14 C4-12X10 DCON16 0.214
2F C14 C4-12X10 DCON16 0.324
GF C14 C4B-14X12 DCON2 0.376
TOP C15 C4-12X10 DCON2 0.32
3F C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.408
2F C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.544
1F C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.742
GF C15 C4B-14X12 DCON5 0.41
TOP C16 C4-12X10 DCON15 0.144
3F C16 C4-12X10 DCON15 0.215
2F C16 C4-12X10 DCON15 0.332
GF C16 C4B-14X12 DCON2 0.541
TOP C24 C3-10X10 DCON16 0.07
3F C24 C3-10X10 DCON15 0.168
2F C24 C3-10X10 DCON16 0.166
GF C24 C3B-12X12 DCON2 0.315
TOP C25 C3-10X10 DCON2 0.187
3F C25 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.265
2F C25 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.423
1F C25 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.657
GF C25 C3B-12X12 DCON5 0.339
TOP C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.568
3F C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.681
2F C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.826
1F C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.381
GF C26 C2B-14X14 DCON6 0.333
TOP C27 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.413
3F C27 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.541
2F C27 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.738
1F C27 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.934
GF C27 C2B-14X14 DCON6 0.404

Some columns show overstressed for applied loads.

19
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

After Retrofitting:

For long part of building without shed load:

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
TOP C1 RC1STEEL DCON2 0.972
3F C1 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.821
2F C1 RC1 DCON2 0.391
1F C1 RC1 DCON2 0.249
GF C1 RC1B DCON2 0.235
TOP C2 C1-12X12 DCON6 0.93
3F C2 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.71
2F C2 RC1 DCON6 0.223
1F C2 RC1 DCON2 0.147
GF C2 RC1B DCON16 0.146
TOP C3 C1-12X12 DCON6 0.782
3F C3 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.668
2F C3 RC1 DCON16 0.295
1F C3 RC1 DCON2 0.274
GF C3 RC1B DCON2 0.259
TOP C4 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.779
3F C4 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.657
2F C4 RC1 DCON6 0.263
1F C4 RC1 DCON2 0.295
GF C4 RC1B DCON2 0.277
TOP C5 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.713
3F C5 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.672
2F C5 RC1 DCON2 0.267
1F C5 RC1 DCON2 0.308
GF C5 RC1B DCON2 0.288
TOP C6 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.75
3F C6 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.662
2F C6 RC1 DCON2 0.257
1F C6 RC1 DCON2 0.293
GF C6 RC1B DCON2 0.275
TOP C7 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.733
3F C7 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.667
2F C7 RC1 DCON2 0.259
1F C7 RC1 DCON2 0.294
GF C7 RC1B DCON2 0.276
TOP C8 RC1STEEL DCON2 0.593
3F C8 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.655

20
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
2F C8 RC1 DCON2 0.257
1F C8 RC1 DCON2 0.291
GF C8 RC1B DCON2 0.273
TOP C9 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.953
3F C9 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.74
2F C9 RC1 DCON2 0.327
1F C9 RC1 DCON2 0.353
GF C9 RC1B DCON2 0.328
TOP C10 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.804
3F C10 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.752
2F C10 RC1 DCON5 0.28
1F C10 RC1 DCON13 0.3
GF C10 RC1B DCON13 0.641
TOP C11 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.511
3F C11 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.826
2F C11 RC1 DCON2 0.29
1F C11 RC1 DCON2 0.389
GF C11 RC1B DCON2 0.361
TOP C12 C1-12X12 DCON6 0.41
3F C12 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.789
2F C12 RC1 DCON2 0.295
1F C12 RC1 DCON2 0.399
GF C12 RC1B DCON2 0.371
TOP C13 C1-12X12 DCON6 0.386
3F C13 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.767
2F C13 RC1 DCON2 0.288
1F C13 RC1 DCON2 0.392
GF C13 RC1B DCON2 0.365
TOP C14 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.391
3F C14 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.753
2F C14 RC1 DCON2 0.28
1F C14 RC1 DCON2 0.385
GF C14 RC1B DCON2 0.358
TOP C15 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.39
3F C15 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.752
2F C15 RC1 DCON2 0.279
1F C15 RC1 DCON2 0.383
GF C15 RC1B DCON2 0.357
TOP C16 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.373
3F C16 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.746

21
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
2F C16 RC1 DCON2 0.273
1F C16 RC1 DCON2 0.377
GF C16 RC1B DCON2 0.352
TOP C17 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.602
3F C17 RC1STEEL DCON16 0.861
2F C17 RC1 DCON2 0.356
1F C17 RC1 DCON2 0.494
GF C17 RC1B DCON2 0.455
TOP C18 RC1STEEL DCON2 1.051
3F C18 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.928
2F C18 RC1 DCON2 0.394
1F C18 RC1 DCON6 0.244
GF C18 RC1B DCON13 0.407
TOP C20 RC1STEEL DCON2 0.615
3F C20 C1-12X12 DCON15 0.75
2F C20 RC1 DCON6 0.303
1F C20 RC1 DCON14 0.286
GF C20 RC1B DCON14 0.548
TOP C21 RC1STEEL DCON2 0.971
3F C21 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.833
2F C21 RC1 DCON2 0.371
1F C21 RC1 DCON2 0.327
GF C21 RC1B DCON2 0.306
TOP C22 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.89
3F C22 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.721
2F C22 RC1 DCON15 0.248
1F C22 RC1 DCON2 0.235
GF C22 RC1B DCON2 0.225
TOP C23 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.892
3F C23 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.714
2F C23 RC1 DCON15 0.251
1F C23 RC1 DCON2 0.241
GF C23 RC1B DCON2 0.229
TOP C24 C1-12X12 DCON5 0.899
3F C24 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.711
2F C24 RC1 DCON15 0.25
1F C24 RC1 DCON2 0.242
GF C24 RC1B DCON2 0.23
TOP C25 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.954
3F C25 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.715

22
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
2F C25 RC1 DCON15 0.251
1F C25 RC1 DCON2 0.244
GF C25 RC1B DCON2 0.233
TOP C26 C1-12X12 DCON5 0.972
3F C26 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.711
2F C26 RC1 DCON16 0.252
1F C26 RC1 DCON2 0.246
GF C26 RC1B DCON2 0.234
TOP C27 C1-12X12 DCON2 0.931
3F C27 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.759
2F C27 RC1 DCON16 0.274
1F C27 RC1 DCON2 0.237
GF C27 RC1B DCON2 0.225
TOP C28 C1-12X12 DCON6 0.521
3F C28 C1-12X12 DCON16 0.673
2F C28 RC1 DCON6 0.305
1F C28 RC1 DCON14 0.382
GF C28 RC1B DCON14 0.744

For Short part of building:

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
TOP C1 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.573
3F C1 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.655
2F C1 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.892
1F C1 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.398
GF C1 RC2B DCON6 0.139
TOP C3 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.6
3F C3 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.705
2F C3 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.996
1F C3 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.719
GF C3 RC2B DCON2 0.24
TOP C4 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.654
3F C4 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.734
2F C4 C2-12X12 DCON6 1
1F C4 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.667
GF C4 RC2B DCON2 0.219
TOP C5 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.433

23
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
3F C5 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.57
2F C5 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.627
1F C5 RC2 DCON15 0.23
GF C5 RC2B DCON6 0.184
TOP C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.471
3F C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.666
2F C6 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.794
1F C6 RC2 DCON2 0.364
GF C6 RC2B DCON2 0.289
TOP C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.491
3F C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.699
2F C7 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.821
1F C7 RC2 DCON2 0.396
GF C7 RC2B DCON2 0.311
TOP C10 C3-10X10 DCON2 0.142
3F C10 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.232
2F C10 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.402
1F C10 C3-10X10 DCON13 0.522
GF C10 C3B-12X12 DCON5 0.287
TOP C13 C3-10X10 DCON2 0.243
3F C13 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.326
2F C13 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.436
1F C13 C3-10X10 DCON13 0.511
GF C13 C3B-12X12 DCON5 0.289
TOP C14 C4-12X10 DCON16 0.11
3F C14 C4-12X10 DCON16 0.209
2F C14 C4-12X10 DCON16 0.263
1F C14 RC4 DCON14 0.303
GF C14 RC4B DCON5 0.103
TOP C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.239
3F C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.336
2F C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.478
1F C15 C4-12X10 DCON5 0.54
GF C15 C4B-14X12 DCON5 0.313
TOP C16 C4-12X10 DCON15 0.129
3F C16 C4-12X10 DCON15 0.207
2F C16 C4-12X10 DCON15 0.264
1F C16 RC4 DCON14 0.35
GF C16 RC4B DCON5 0.111
TOP C24 C3-10X10 DCON16 0.067

24
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Concrete Design 1 - Column Summary Data - ACI 318-99


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
3F C24 C3-10X10 DCON15 0.15
2F C24 C3-10X10 DCON15 0.157
1F C24 RC3 DCON14 0.272
GF C24 RC3B DCON5 0.081
TOP C25 C3-10X10 DCON2 0.146
3F C25 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.225
2F C25 C3-10X10 DCON5 0.388
1F C25 C3-10X10 DCON13 0.505
GF C25 C3B-12X12 DCON9 0.286
TOP C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.496
3F C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.586
2F C26 C2-12X12 DCON6 0.804
1F C26 C2-12X12 DCON15 0.332
GF C26 RC2B DCON6 0.12
TOP C27 C2-12X12 DCON2 0.384
3F C27 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.527
2F C27 C2-12X12 DCON5 0.607
1F C27 RC2 DCON2 0.23
GF C27 RC2B DCON2 0.187

Detail retrofitting drawing has been provided in attachments.

25
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

7.3 Slab adequacy check


For long part of building:

CAPACITY CALCULATION OF TWO WAY SLAB

Panel Size
Short Span (A) 14.083 feet
Long Span(B) 15.68 feet
m 0.90
Beta 1.113399
Thick ness 6 inch
Thickness req 3.9684 inch
So Thickness OK

Material Data
fy 40000 psi
f'c 2165 psi

Load Data
Floor Finish 25 Psf
Other Dead 0 Psf
Total Dead 100 Psf Coefficients (Case 9)
Liveload 63 Psf Posative Negative
Factored Load 247.1 Psf Cadl 0.024 Ca 0.068
Call 0.036 Cb 0.025
Cbdl 0.017
Cbll 0.022

As req (Sq
Moments(Kip ft) d (Inch) Inch/feet) As Provided Feasibility
+MaDL 0.476 (Sq Inch/ feet)
+MaLL 0.450
+Ma(Total) 1.431 4.75 As+(short) 0.092 As+(short) 0.33 Ok
+MbDL 0.418
+MbLL 0.341
+Mb(Total) 1.164 4.25 As+(Long) 0.084 As+(Long) 0.264 Ok
-Ma 3.333 4.75 As-(short) 0.220 As-(short) 0.66 Ok
-Mb 1.519 4.25 As-(Long) 0.110 As-(Long) 0.528 Ok

So two way slab is adequate to carry the proposed load.

26
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

For short part of building:

CAPACITY CALCULATION OF TWO WAY SLAB

Panel Size
Short Span (A) 15.68 feet
Long Span(B) 16.5 feet
m 0.95
Beta 1.052296
Thick ness 7 inch
Thickness req 4.290667 inch
So Thickness OK

Material Data
fy 40000 psi
f'c 2165 psi

Load Data
Floor Finish 30 Psf
Other Dead 0 Psf
Total Dead 117.5 Psf Coefficients (Case 4)
Liveload 63 Psf Posative Negative
Factored Load 271.6 Psf Cadl 0.03 Ca 0.055
Call 0.035 Cb 0.045
Cbdl 0.024
Cbll 0.029

As req (Sq
Moments(Kip ft) d (Inch) Inch/feet) As Provided Feasibility
+MaDL 0.867 (Sq Inch/ feet)
+MaLL 0.542
+Ma(Total) 2.135 5.75 As+(short) 0.113 As+(short) 0.33 Ok
+MbDL 0.768
+MbLL 0.497
+Mb(Total) 1.920 5.25 As+(Long) 0.112 As+(Long) 0.264 Ok
-Ma 3.673 5.75 As-(short) 0.198 As-(short) 0.66 Ok
-Mb 3.327 5.25 As-(Long) 0.197 As-(Long) 0.528 Ok

So two way slab is adequate to carry the proposed load.

27
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

7.4 Beam adequacy check:

For long part of building:

Fig: Grade beam reinforcement

It is observed that as per as-built building, without assigning shear wall and retrofitting work of
columns, grade beam shows overstressed.

Fig: Typical floor beam reinforcement

It is found that the rebar area as per as- built condition, required area of rebar is greater than the provided
one.

28
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Long part of building after using Shear wall & Retrofitted column:

Fig: Grade beam reinforcement

It is observed that after using shear walls & retrofitting works of column, grade beam shows
sufficient in presence reinforcement provision.

Fig: Typical beam reinforcement

It is observed that the provided reinforcement is insufficient for carrying current load.

29
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Short part of building:

Fig: Grade beam reinforcement

Some beam show overstressed.

After retrofitting:

Fig: Grade beam reinforcement


After retrofitting the grade beam as 10”X19” instead of 10” X 15” of marked portion; grade beam is
adequate.

A Detail retrofitting drawing has been provided in attachments.

30
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

9.0 CONCLUSION & RECOMMENDATION:


a) Most of the columns for the building show overstressed. Retrofitting works should be
carried out as per given drawings.
b) Slabs are adequate for present load and thickness.
c) Most of the beams show inadequacy for the provided reinforcement.
d) As foundation has not been excavated, so it is not possible to check footing adequacy.

Thanking You

Md. Abdul Quddus


B.Sc Engg. (Civil, BUET)
MIEB-21384, DMINB/CE-0231
CEO & Structural Designer
DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT SOLUTION

Attachment-1:
1. Core test report
Attachment-2:
1. As-Built drawing (Architectural)
2. As-Built drawing (Structural)
3. Retrofitting Drawing

31
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

CORE TEST REPORT

32
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

33

Вам также может понравиться