Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 8
Pee ila ts SYSTEMS COMPARISON Deedee eon TO Rear To sear oars na erage ears oar rea isan Goes) Peete) paaanerens ek Saree eer “4st, 1000stals Troms. 6-8 months 10-12 mnths Design costs Sar precast assisted Same (precast assed, Sane. inital 88 8 585, lca |S 5 5 Maintenance oss 5 5 Financing costs Potential significant savings due to oreaty Potentially siificant savings duet greatly Typical. reduces schedule redvced schedule Timetorevenue Testo constucion schedule Tiesto constuction schedule. “Tes constuction schedule Impact to Least ste ingac. © Less ste impaa. © Greatest ste impact. neighborhood Approximately 95% offsite precast * Approximately 80% offsite precast All constuction workon ste andlor campus concrete, 5% st topping slabsipour cenit, 209% site topping slabs. Greatest number of onsite constuction stip ‘+ Mesian number of constuction workers crew required. + Fewest constuction wakes required on required on ste + Lay.coom area requied (ste stacking site ‘© Lapdovm areesteckping not ypically + Signcat ste construction waste + Laycdonn aeas/toctling not ypicaly required enecatd required ‘© Mineral tn constuction vaste 4 Minimal ono construction waste generated = generated. Timeto owners Fatest benecal occupaney possible Second eaiest beneficial ocapancy posible. Longest time to benfl occupancy. To sega aera Coro arin) Gta tl asa) Prearternty CaN ray rtiero er | eerie on ene ‘Matietaalably Depends on proximity to PCI ceed precast Depends on roy to PCl certified precast Contac realy lable desendiag on concrete producer lants Producton lead cancete producer pans Production eed posit an urban area tne of yay and times vay depending on construction actvy nes ary depending on construction acviy _consruten ac, Forming mera oud levels. leves. become scarce. aine pesonnel cud aso become scarce based on ait lee, Overllquaity, —* Precastconcetecomponertsprodued «Precast cDicee components podied ata * —Allcorponents areas at hejob ste, i MER) tng fish and ata Pere fait understingert PCL cred fai under stinger audited _sbjet to varying conditions wich could schedule audited qadelnes ad procedures. uses and procedures Fel toping's affect qualiy depending on the extent Minimize fe topping required) is Subject eying cendtons which could that the contractor protect the concrete ‘abjetto vying condtons which could act qualty copending onthe eertthat fromthe elements ding placement and affect quality, depenng on the exert thecontacorprotesthe conceteffom——_cuing, thatthe contacor protec the concete the elements curing placement and cufng, = Qualys completely dependent on fom te elements during pacement and» Fatry quality conto of beams clumns, genera contactor eld condtions, and ‘ng. sires and flooring elements tend to _naleble labor poo + Facory quality conrolof beams colunns produce a consistent, curable produc. + Onner must monitor all ste concrete ders, and faring elements tend to less ower stemontaringrequed per work or length of contact, Quality roduc a consistent, durable reduc the bln code of concrete dependent on general least owner ste monitoring equied per» Quality oftoping slabs (which reque contractor eld centons and avalable the bling code. less sled labor aon inal labo ook Quay of pour sips hich require site forming) is dependent on geneal_* Must provide tena exterior adding essed labor and onlin contrat; field condition, and avaiable system architec, precast concrete Ste forming) is dependent on gene labor pool metal panels ec) to cover structure if Certacto; field condition and avalable Class exert fish integrate wth aesthtics a conc, labo ool system. (Option range from form fish © Introduction of cout sips egies Clas exterior ish integrated wth gay concrete wich could veclve a ‘ring of ajacent sectors for 300 60 system (Options range am for rsh painters, toclor and sandblast to. day before placement, wich affects the 99 concrete which could rece a Integrate thi xc and stone) ‘overall schedule painted finish to color andsandlast 0» CIP concrete pour areas equal + Delays elated to posttersonng. Integrated thin brik and stone) approximately 80% less volume of CP + GP concete pou areas ual concrete _pproximately 95% ess volume of IP concrete | Gy oer eras fas) poe CConciete strength Typical precast concrete: 6000+ ps. Typical wie rato* 0.35-0.40 fer precast concrete Confinement of Bonde prestressed stands are more protec stand ed fom coreson, especialy in concrete with lower wion ratios Structural damage due to Corrosion or severing ofa prestessed strand Islocalied to an india precast concrete rem oor manber Bonded prestessing svand inthe loner half stand location ofthe couble-te stems, beams an aby or roof labs ony Joint sealant At precastto-precast ints and pour stip tooled jis. pansion joint 300-350" spacing Horizontal surface Noctypcaly required, due tthe high quality sealer of concrete, Surface membrane Same, when equed. Exterior finish Precast concrete architectural shes maybe integrated ina precast concrete elements at ‘minimal ost, Achtectural Recommend integration inthe exterior facing Finishes precast concrete elements to maximize value to peje. Spaniel eights Typical 4:0" wo 7-0 TOTAL PRECAST CONCRETE: Gey Typical precast concrete: 6000+ ps. Concrete used for taping 4000 035-4140 for precast concrete, Bonded pesuesed strands are moce protec ed fom corcson, especially in concete with lower wlem rates Stucural damage due to carosion severing ofa prestressed sand Islocalzed to an indidal precast coete mane: Bonded presessing strand inthe lone: alt of the double estos, beams, and lay or Corer Pesaro “pia: 4000-5000 ps 040-048, Unborded post tensioning estes potenti for future coosion when wate ges into the sheathing Los of unbonded sands ether ‘om corrosion o: severing ofthe stands) can make lage aeas of the garage strutaly ‘efit Untonded post tensioning ands in slab areas to contal temperature and shrinkage roof dbs only. ‘aac asin brtom of beans for oad canyng capac topping slab tooled joints aligned with At enstuction ints precast to precast joins, 300'-350' spacing. 300 $+ spacing, Requied on CP concrete surfacesby AC|-362. Required on CP conzee surfaces byACl-362 same “ypically secondary system deseo = (quireé—often architecture precast concrete, FS coating, meal panel screening stems, ox painted spandrels are used. "Must be ost appli by separate wade ad ing cst, ne, and another one subco- tector that would impact it play: 40" 16-0" same, Precast concrete architectural fishes may be integrated into precast concrete elements at minimal cost, Recommend integration inthe exterior fang precast conaete elements to masimize aise to projec. pial: 4-0" 10 7-0" * Lover ates mati (wos gest none onat'soral sth a bi Ps Poe ei He neh ice econ sce CRITERIA, TOTAL PRECAST CONCRETE: rarer CCAST-IN-PLACE (CIP) CONCRETE PRE-TOPPED foes POST-TENSIONED caer ereeeisrcoe Interior apoeciance 26° deen double-ee stems at on center. 26" deep double-tee stems at on cente: 30° deep beans at 18-36! on center, | [tov columns Fever columns typically 3688! on cetet__ Fever columns, play 36°48" on cent, More columns, tical 2-36 on ent we éligs Facirystel forms impart few fany seams at Factory steel forms inpartfew ary seamsat _* os: fomsinpart weed granoraiher cel lg, regular seams at eling, i + More ssceptbe to concrete pate i i leakage. equates, bug-hols et Hors Indvdl tes (1016 wide) withave a roared in the itd with itor tooled Same as flopped plant-conroledtroom fis fukdesth joints with appropriate saint. \ Jot wth appropriate sean, Floorunifomiy Regular consoljpints at 10-16’ oncenter Regula tole cnteljcinis at 1016! on Fewer oor ints shnkage and enperatire ‘based on tee width) ver te shrakage and center (ased ante wit) sinkage and cracks expect. ‘temperature catkins. temperature cracking pica contained at contol joints and therefore rt exzesed to Natualight Fewer erteroc columns; openings in tewal Fewer exterior clus; opeing in itewall Sight beter natal ghtng a exterior due andinteror shea walls allow interior tobe and interior shear wal allow inter to be to shorter spare eight, but there are typ open toatl ight open to natural ight. cally more columns Inti ighting sina. Secu Most open interior avalable Mast open interior avallabe, Mor obstuced views theresa tht column spacing. Vibration More percept More perceptible Less perceptible. Vertiation Same, same Same. Lighting Sane, same Same, considerations Pubing pipes Same. same same Hetical condi Same Same same, CRITERIA Obstructions side Flea toot heights Fire rating Dainae systems Bectcal tens Plumbing systems Elevator systems Waytndng ystems Venton systems ADA requirements Ssuace detwioaton soints ea reerars rsnany (rte Requies fener clumns thus increasing ‘open space, vst, and ease of navigation through die lanes, wel a allowing for maimurn ety in parking space layout Same or sight more oo o-oo height r- ‘ged. Typcl double tee ste cent is 28° + 3 flange; end of bayedoe depth of structure beams 36" sane sane Same, Sane, Sar, Sane, Same. Same. ery rare bottom deteration of load

Вам также может понравиться