Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
com
Briefing Paper
1 In addition to BRE Global’s BREEAM International schemes, BREEAM also supports a number of National Scheme Operators (NSOs) across the world. The NSOs affiliated to BREEAM and their local schemes are listed on the BREEAM website http://www.breeam.
com. These local schemes must be used for international assessments where appropriate, in these instances contact your local NSO for further information. Where a building falls outside of the scope of these local schemes, the pan country BRE Global BREEAM
International schemes can be used.
Table A - level of overlap used in the Appendices
Formal certification under one scheme can be used as evidence of full compliance with
Equivalent the other. The awarded feature or credit can be used as verification that the requirement
has been satisfied.
The outcomes and methodologies are aligned but there are material differences between
the requirements of the schemes. For instance the required performance levels may
Aligned be different. In this case it may be possible to carry out a single analysis and use this
as evidence in both schemes although this will need to be separately submitted to the
relevant assessor.
Appendix A only - Formal certification under BREEAM can be used as evidence of partial
p Partially equivalent compliance with WELL features. This indicates that further requirements will need to be
met before the feature can be deemed to be fully met.
Appendices A and B – The issue is not covered by BREEAM and so will require full
− Not addressed
assessment under WELL.
Appendix A only – The WELL feature is covered by EU or UK directive/regulation and
EU/UK directive/regulation
may not need to be assessed for projects in these countries.
UKR UK regulation Appendix A only – The WELL feature is covered by regulations in the UK.
EUR EU regulation Appendix A only – The WELL feature is covered by directives or regulations across the EU.
Appendix B only – WELL evidence can be used to demonstrate full or partial compliance
BREEAM compliant WELL evidence
with the BREEAM requirements but formal review will be required by the Assessor.
AIR
Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality -
Hea 02 Indoor air quality –
Standards for volatile Volatile organic compound Volatile organic compound Volatile organic compound HEA 18 Volatile organic
Post-construction indoor air
substances (VOC) emission levels (post (VOC) emission levels (post (VOC) emission levels (post compounds
quality measurement
construction) construction) construction)
HEA 14 Internal
environment: CO2
Hea 02 Indoor air Hea 02 Indoor air Hea 02 Indoor air Hea 02 Indoor air Monitoring
Air quality
01 Standards for quality - Indoor air quality quality - Indoor air quality quality - Indoor air quality quality - Indoor air quality HEA 15 Internal
standards
particulate matter (IAQ) plan; Ventilation; (IAQ) plan; Ventilation; (IAQ) plan; Ventilation; (IAQ) plan; Ventilation; environment: CO
and inorganic gases Adaptability - Potential for Adaptability - Potential for Adaptability - Potential for Adaptability - Potential for Monitoring
natural ventilation natural ventilation natural ventilation natural ventilation HEA 16 Internal
environment: NOx
monitoring
Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality -
Filter accommodation −
Ventilation Ventilation Ventilation Ventilation
Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality -
Particle filtration −
Ventilation Ventilation Ventilation Ventilation
05 Air filtration
MAN 04 Operation and
Air filtration maintenance manuals
maintenance − − − −
MAN 05 Maintenance
procedures
Cleaning plan for
09 Cleaning protocol HEA 21 Deep cleaning − − − −
occupied spaces
Pesticide LE 05 External landscaping/
10 Pesticide use − − − −
management maintenance
Asbestos and lead Hea 02 Indoor air quality - Hea 02 Indoor air quality -
EUR EUR EUR p p p p p
restriction Prerequisite Prerequisite
HEA 14 Internal
environment: CO2
Monitoring
HEA 15 Internal
Indoor air monitoring − − − −
environment: CO Monitoring
Air quality HEA 16 Internal
18 monitoring and environment: NOx
feedback monitoring
Air data record
keeping and − − − − −
response
Environmental
Measures Display − − − − −
Hea 02 Indoor air quality Hea 02 Indoor air quality Hea 02 Indoor air quality Hea 02 Indoor air quality HEA 03 Thermal control
Full control - Potential for natural - Potential for natural - Potential for natural - Potential for natural
ventilation ventilation ventilation ventilation HEA 04 Ventilation controls
Operable
19 Outdoor air
windows − − − − −
measurement
Window operation
measurement − − − − −
Appliance and heater
combustion ban − − − − −
Combustion Low emission
24 Pol 02 NOx emissions Pol 02 NOx emissions Pol 02 NOx emissions Pol 02 NOx emissions POL 06 NOx emissions
minimization combustion sources
Engine exhaust
reduction − − − − −
WATER
Sediment EUR EUR EUR EUR EUR
Fundamental
30
water quality
Micro-organisms EUR EUR EUR EUR EUR
Inorganic
31 Dissolved metals EUR EUR EUR EUR EUR
contaminants
Organic
32 Organic Pollutants EUR EUR EUR EUR EUR
Contaminants
Herbicides and
EUR EUR EUR EUR EUR
Agricultural pesticides
33
contaminants
Fertilizers EUR EUR EUR EUR EUR
Organic chemical
removal − − − − −
Sediment filter − − − − −
Microbial elimination − − − − −
36 Water treatment
Water quality
maintenance − − − − −
LIGHT
Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort
- Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external
Visual acuity for focus HEA 08 Illuminance levels
lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and
Visual lighting control control control control
53
design
Brightness
Management − − − − −
Strategies
Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort
- Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external
Lamp Shielding HEA 08 Illuminance levels
lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and
Electric light glare control control control control
55
control Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort
- Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external
Glare minimization HEA 08 Illuminance levels
lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and
control control control control
View window Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort -
HEA 02 Glare control
shading Glare control Glare control Glare control Glare control
56 Solar glare control
Daylight Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort -
HEA 02 Glare control
management Glare control Glare control Glare control Glare control
Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort
Low-glare Working and
- Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external
57 workstation learning area surface HEA 08 Illuminance levels
lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and
design reflectivity
control control control control
Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort
- Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external
58 Color quality Color rendering index HEA 08 Illuminance levels
lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and
control control control control
Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort Hea 01 Visual comfort
Working and
- Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external - Internal and external
59 Surface design learning area surface HEA 08 Illuminance levels
lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and lighting levels, zoning and
reflectivity
control control control control
WELL Building Standard BREEAM Credit(s) WELL - BREEAM Overlap
Automated sunlight Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort –
Automated HEA 02 Glare control
control Glare control Glare control Glare control Glare control
60 shading and
dimming controls Responsive light
control − − − − −
Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort –
Lease Depth HEA 28 View out
View out View out View out View out
61 Right to Light
Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort –
Window access HEA 28 View out
View out View out View out View out
Healthy sunlight Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort -
62 Daylight modeling HEA 01 Glazing
exposure Daylighting Daylighting Daylighting Daylighting
Window sizes for
Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort - Hea 01 Visual comfort – Hea 01 Visual comfort –
working and learning HEA 01 Glazing
Daylighting; View out Daylighting; View out View out View out
spaces
Window
Daylighting
63 transmittance in
fenestration − − − − −
working and learning
areas
Uniform color
transmittance − − − − −
FITNESS
Activity incentive Activity incentive HEA 26A Health and
65 − − − −
programs programs Wellbeing
Professional fitness HEA 26A Health and
program Wellbeing − − − −
Structured fitness
66
opportunities HEA 26A Health and
Fitness education − − − −
Wellbeing
Pedestrian Amenities − − − − −
Exterior active Pedestrian promotion
67 − − − − −
design
Neighborhood Tra 02 Proximity to Tra 02 Proximity to Tra 02 Proximity to Tra 02 Proximity to TRA 03 Proximity to
connectivity amenities amenities amenities amenities amenities
Tra 01 Sustainable transport
Bicycle storage and Tra 03 Cyclist facilities - Tra 03 Cyclist facilities - Tra 03a Alternative modes accessibility – Alternative
TRA 01 Cyclist facilities p p p p p
support Cycle storage Cycle storage of transport – Option 5 transport measures
Active (Measure B)
69 transportation
support Tra 01 Sustainable transport
Post commute and Tra 03 Cyclist facilities – Tra 03 Cyclist facilities – Tra 03a Alternative modes accessibility – Alternative
TRA 01 Cyclist facilities
workout facilities Cyclist facilities Cyclist facilities of transport – Option 5 transport measures
(Measure C)
COMFORT
Hea 06 Accessibility –
Accessibility and
72 Accessible design UKR UKR Inclusive and accessible HEA 10 Inclusive design −
usability
design
Hea 05 Acoustic Hea 05 Acoustic Hea 05 Acoustic Hea 05 Acoustic
Exterior noise HEA 20 Acoustic
74 Sound pressure level performance - Internal performance - Internal performance - Internal performance - Internal
intrusion conditions
indoor ambient noise levels indoor ambient noise levels indoor ambient noise levels indoor ambient noise levels
WELL Building Standard BREEAM Credit(s) WELL - BREEAM Overlap
MIND
Occupant survey Man 05 Aftercare - Post Man 05 Aftercare - Post Man 05 Aftercare - Post Man 05 Aftercare - Post HEA 23 Occupant
content occupancy evaluation occupancy evaluation occupancy evaluation occupancy evaluation satisfaction
Post-Occupancy
86
Survey Man 05 Aftercare - Post Man 05 Aftercare - Post Man 05 Aftercare - Post Man 05 Aftercare - Post HEA 24 Occupant
Information reporting
occupancy evaluation occupancy evaluation occupancy evaluation occupancy evaluation satisfaction: feedback
LE 02 Ecological value LE 02 Ecological value
of site and protection of of site and protection of LE 02 Ecological value LE 02 Ecological value
ecological features ecological features of site and protection of of site and protection of
LE 03 Minimising impact LE 03 Minimising impact ecological features ecological features LE 01 Planted area
Outdoor biophilia on existing site ecology on existing site ecology LE 04 Enhancing site LE 04 Enhancing site LE 02 Ecological features of
LE 04 Enhancing site LE 04 Enhancing site ecology ecology planted area
Biophilia II - ecology ecology LE 05 Long term impact on LE 05 Long term impact on
100
quantitative LE 05 Long term impact on LE 05 Long term impact on biodiversity biodiversity
biodiversity biodiversity
HEA 26A Health and
Indoor biophilia − − − −
Wellbeing
Water feature − − − − −
Appendix B – BREEAM New Construction and Refurbishment and Fit-Out alignment with WELL features
Man 04 Commissioning and Commissioning building services 03 Ventilation effectiveness – System balancing
handover Testing and inspecting building 14 Air infiltration management – Air leakage
fabric testing
Handover
Aftercare support
Seasonal commissioning
Man 05 Aftercare 86 Post-occupancy survey - Occupant survey
content
Post occupancy evaluation
86 Post-occupancy survey - Information
reporting
HEALTH & WELLBEING
56 Solar glare control – View window
shading
Glare control 56 Solar glare control – Daylight management
60 Automated shading and dimming controls
- Automated sunlight control
62 Daylight modelling – Healthy sunlight
exposure
Daylighting
63 Daylighting fenestration – Window sizes
for working and learning spaces
61 Right to light – Lease depth
61 Right to light – Window access
View out
Hea 01 Visual comfort 63 Daylighting fenestration – Window sizes
for working and learning spaces
53 Visual lighting design – Visual acuity for
focus
55 Electric lighting glare control – Lamp
shielding
55 Electric lighting glare control – Glare
Internal and external lighting levels, minimization
zoning and control
57 Low-glare workstation design – Glare
avoidance
58 Color quality – Color rendering index
59 Surface design – Working and learning
area surface reflectivity
11 Fundamental material safety - Asbestos
Prerequisite (asbestos)
and lead restriction
07 Construction pollution management –
Duct protection
07 Construction pollution management –
Filter replacement
Indoor air quality (IAQ) plan 07 Construction pollution management –
Moisture absorption management
07 Construction pollution management –
Dust containment and removal
13 Air flush – Air flush
02 Smoking ban - Indoor smoking ban − −
03 Ventilation effectiveness - Ventilation design
03 Ventilation effectiveness - Demand control
ventilation
Ventilation
05 Air filtration – Filter accommodation
Hea 02 Indoor air quality 05 Air filtration – Particle filtration
15 Increased ventilation – Increased outdoor
air supply
04 VOC reduction - Interior paints and coatings
04 VOC reduction - Interior adhesives and
Volatile organic compound (VOC) sealants
emission levels (products) /
04 VOC reduction - Flooring
Emissions from building products
04 VOC reduction - Insulation
04 VOC reduction - Furniture and furnishings − −
Volatile organic compound (VOC)
emission levels (post construction) / 01 Air quality standards - Standards for volatile
Post-construction indoor air quality substances
measurement
03 Ventilation effectiveness - Demand control
Adaptability - Potential for natural ventilation
ventilation
19 Operable windows - Full control
BREEAM – WELL Overlap
BREEAM Assessment Issue BREEAM Credit(s) WELL Feature Name and Part UK NC UK RFO
INC 2016 IRFO 2015
2014 2014
76 Thermal comfort - Ventilated thermal
environment
Thermal modelling
76 Thermal comfort - Natural thermal
adaptation
Hea 04 Thermal comfort
Adaptability - for a projected climate
change scenario
Thermal zoning and controls
81 Sound barriers - Wall construction
Sound insulation
specification
74 Exterior noise intrusion - Sound pressure
level
Hea 05 Acoustic performance 75 Internally generated noise - Acoustic
Internal indoor ambient noise levels
planning
75 Internally generated noise - Mechanical
equipment sound levels
Reverberation 78 Reverberation time - Reverberation time
Safe access
Hea 06 Accessibility 72 Accessible design - Accessibility and
Inclusive and accessible design
usability
Building services water systems:
Minimising risk of contamination
36 Water treatment – Legionella control
Hea 09 Water quality
Building occupants: Provision of 37 Drinking water promotion - Drinking water
fresh drinking water access
WATER
12 Moisture management - Interior liquid
Leak detection system
water management
Wat 03 Water leak detection
12 Moisture management - Interior liquid
Flow control devices
water management
TRANSPORT
Accessibility Index
LE 02 Ecological value of site and Ecological value of site 100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
protection of ecological features Protection of ecological features 100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
LE 03 Minimising impact on existing Change in ecological value 1 100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
site ecology Change in ecological value 2 100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
Ecologist’s report and
recommendations
100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
LE 04 Enhancing site ecology
Increase in ecological value 100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
LE 05 Long term impact on
biodiversity
Long term impact on biodiversity 100 Biophilia II quantitative - Outdoor Biophilia
POLLUTION
24 Combustion minimization - Low emission
Pol 02 NOx emissions NOx emissions
combustion sources
Appendix C - BREEAM In-Use alignment with WELL features
BREEAM –
BREEAM In-Use Assessment Issue/Credit(s) WELL Feature Name and Part WELL Overlap
BIU 2015
MANAGEMENT
MAN 04 Operation and maintenance manuals 04 Air filtration – Air filtration maintenance
HEA 01 Glazing 63 Daylighting fenestration - Window sizes for working and learning spaces
56 Solar glare control - View window shading
HEA 02 Glare control 56 Solar glare control - Daylight management
60 Automated shading and dimming controls - Automated sunlight control
HEA 03 Thermal control 19 Operable windows - Full control
HEA 15 Internal environment: CO Monitoring 01 Air quality standards - Standards for particulate matter and inorganic gases
HEA 16 Internal environment: NOx monitoring 18 Air quality monitoring and feedback - Indoor air monitoring
01 Air quality standards - Standards for volatile substances
04 VOC reduction - Interior paints and coatings
HEA 18 Volatile organic compounds
04 VOC reduction – Interior adhesives and sealants
04 VOC reduction – Flooring
04 VOC reduction – Insulation
04 VOC reduction - Furniture and furnishings
HEA 19 Control of chemicals 17 Direct source ventilation – Pollution isolation and exhaust
74 Exterior noise intrusion - Sound pressure level
HEA 20 Acoustic conditions
75 Internally generated noise - Acoustic planning
75 Internally generated noise - Mechanical equipment sound levels
76 Reverberation time – Reverberation time
HEA 21 Deep cleaning 09 Cleaning protocol - Cleaning plan for occupied spaces
ENE 04 Pressure/ air leakage test 14 Air infiltration management - Air leakage testing
BREEAM –
BREEAM In-Use Assessment Issue/Credit(s) WELL Feature Name and Part WELL Overlap
BIU 2015
TRANSPORT
WATER
WAT 07 Leak detection system 12 Moisture management - Interior liquid water management
POLLUTION
BRE Global
Bucknalls Lane
Watford
United Kingdom
WD25 9XX
T +44 (0)333 321 8811
E breeam@bre.co.uk
www.breeam.com