Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274742773
CITATIONS READS
0 1,905
1 author:
Stanley Dubinsky
University of South Carolina
50 PUBLICATIONS 425 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Stanley Dubinsky on 24 September 2015.
Access provided by South Carolina University (24 Sep 2015 04:08 GMT)
872LANGUAGE, VOLUME 73, NUMBER 4 (1997)
1 1 am sincerely grateful to Sachiko Matsumoto for her willingness to participate in this project and for
providing me with her very insightful reactions to the text.
REVIEWS873
pitch accent. For a fuller treatment of any of these, however, a reader will want to refer to Vance
1987.
Ch. 4, 'Morphology' (125-59), is much more 'introductory' in its coverage than the previous
one. It is also shorter than I would have preferred and suffers organizationally, delaying the
definition of morpheme and a discussion of morpheme types (e.g. bound vs. free) until the middle
of the chapter. The syntax chapter (160-304), the longest, is the centerpiece of the book. It is
here that T is most at home, allowing her own research interests (e.g. unaccusativity) to set some
of the agenda. The chapter covers scrambling, hierarchical vs. flat structure, reflexives, passives,
causatives, unaccusativity, and light verbs. The dual purpose of the text also plays a role in fixing
its length, as it ranges from explaining the meaning of syntactic constituent (161-2) to arguing
for a syntactic account of the unergative-unaccusative distinction (270-6). One unfortunate aspect
of this chapter is that it focuses far too much on observations and analyses by Shigeru Miyagawa.
While T's presentation of these is quite informative and well written, they occupy far too promi-
nent a place in an introductory text. A naive reader of this book will come away with no sense
of the enormous early contributions to Japanese syntax of Kuno, Kuroda, and Shibatani and will
also have little sense of syntactic issues dealt with in work by Miyagawa' s equally important
contemporaries (e.g. Naoki Fukui and Mamoru Saito).2
The chapter on semantics (305-5 1) contains a very lucid introduction to aspectual (i.e. aktions-
art) properties of verbs and their application to Japanese. It also has a very user-friendly discussion
of the deictic uses of Japanese verbs of giving and receiving. In trying to be an introductory
textbook, this chapter stumbles at the beginning by vainly attempting to explain the difference
between entailment and presupposition in a single page (quite a waste, since T never returns to
the issue). The last chapter, 'Language variation' (352-81), is far too short to do justice to the
issues that it attempts to cover (historical linguistics, eleven pages; dialectal variation, eight
pages; gender differences, seven pages). It manages to provide a sense of the sort of issues that
language variation is concerned with but does little more.
As stated above, this book might have been a very useful introduction to linguistics for students
of Japanese, but to accomplish this, it would have to have presented basic linguistic concepts in
much more detail, rid itself of some of the more advanced discussion in the syntax chapter, and
provided more substance to the chapters on phonetics and language variation. This volume could
also have been an excellent text for a course in Japanese linguistics, whose prerequisite would
be a survey course in general linguistics. This would have involved expanding the chapters on
phonology, morphology, and syntax at the expense of the rest. Unfortunately, what Blackwell
has given us is a hybrid that is well suited for neither purpose.
REFERENCES
Dubinsky, Stanley. 1985. Japanese union constructions: A unified analysis of -sase and -rare. Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University dissertation.
Miyagawa, Shigeru. 1989. Structure and case marking m Japanese. Syntax and Semantics 22. San Diego:
Academic Press.
Vance, Timothy. 1987. An introduction to Japanese phonology. Albany: State University of New York
Press.
Linguistics Program
University of South Carolina
Columbia, SC 29208
[dubinsky @ sc .edu]
2 T's overemphasis on Miyagawa' s work goes so far as to attribute to him observations originally made
by others. One clear (to this author) instance is on p. 279 where Miyagawa (1989) is wrongly credited with
discovering that unaccusative verbal nouns disallow accusative case marking (the observation was originally
made in Dubinsky 1985).