Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
CHECKLIST
APPLICATION OF LRA
1
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
APPLICATION OF LRA
Law relevant to non-Muslim in Malaysia Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976
(LRA)
Gazetted: 1976
Enforcement: 1st March 1982 (throughout the whole Malaysia)
Provided for (inter alia):
i. Monogamous marriages
ii. Solemnization
iii. Registration of such marriages
iv. Matters incidental thereto
Application:
i. To the whole of Malaysia – English text is the authoritative text1
ii. S.3(1):
a. The Act shall apply to all persons in Malaysia & those who domiciled in
Malaysia but are the residents outside Malaysia
b. Although that person is domiciled in other country but he is subjected to
the act if he is a resident in Malaysia at the relevant point of time
c. Domicile in Malaysia isn’t the requirement for application of the Act
iii. S.3(2):
a. A person who is a citizen of Malaysia shall be deemed, until the contrary is
proven, to be domiciled in Malaysia
iv. S.3(3):
a. The act shall not apply to a Muslim or any person who is married under
Muslim law
b. No marriage of 1 of the parties which professes Islam shall be
solemnized/registered under LRA
c. Exception: Divorce cases between a Muslim & non-Muslim
d. Conclusion: the act is only applied to
o non-Muslims
o non-Muslim marriages
o divorce cases between non-Muslim & Muslim (S.51)
v. S.4:
a. LRA shall not apply to any native of Sabah/Sarawak/any aborigines of
Peninsular Malaysia their marriage is governed by native customary
law/aboriginal custom
UNLESS
o He elects to marry under the act
o He contracted his marriage under the Christian Marriage Ordinance
1
PU (B) 127/1976
2
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
3
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
Provisions of the statutes (eg. Christian Marriage Ordinance 1956 & Civil Marriage
Ordinance 1952)
Common law marriages
Customary marriages: Chinese, Hindu, natives of Sabah & Sarawak, aborigines
Muslim marriages
1. STATUTORY MARRIAGES
Peninsular: solemnized under
o Civil Marriage Ordinance 1952
o Christian Marriage Ordinance 1956
Re Loh Toh Met, Decd, Kong Lai Fong & Ors v Loh Peh Heng [1961]
Sarawak:
o Church and Civil Marriage Ordinance
o Didn’t apply to Muslims, Hindus, Dayaks & others who’re subjected to their
respective laws/customs
Sabah:
1. Christian Marriage Ordinance 1953
2. Marriage Ordinance 1959
o Lee Nyuk Wan @ Julia v Chin Oi Jin [1996]
o Kupok binte Limpongan v Kandilong binte Lantayan [1967]
4
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
o After ceremony: They lived together had a child who was registered as
Carolis’ child
o Jackson JC: The marriage was valid & lawful
“The law also will presume a contract of marriage from evidence of
cohabitation with the habit & repute of matrimony without any or with
imperfect formalities for its commencement.”
3. CUSTOMARY MARRIAGES
Sir Peter Benson Maxwell – Reg v Willans (1858)
“But where the law of the place is inapplicable to the parties by reason of peculiarities of
religious opinions and usages, then from a sort of moral necessity the validity of the
marriage depends upon whether it was performed according to the rites of their religion.”
I. CHINESE
The ingredient of a valid marriage was a marriage based on mutual consent
The requirements of ceremony, a contract and repute of marriage were only
evidentiary not essential for the validity of the marriage
Cases:
1. Dorothy Yee Yeng Nam v Lee Fah Kooi [1956]
2. Yeap Leong Huat v Yeap Leong Soon & Anor [1989]
3. The Six Widow Case (1908)
II. HINDU
The view in Reg v Willans regarding customary marriages is applicable to Hindus
as well
Cases:
1. Rex v Govidasamy [1933]
5
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
6
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
**Undang-undang Keluarga (Sivil) – Shamsuddin Suhor & Noor Aziah Awal (2007)
1. REQUIREMENTS
REQUIREMENTS
OF MARRIAGES
NOT IN
PROHIBITED
RELATIONSHIP – S.11
7
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
2. MONOGAMOUS MARRIAGE*
S.5 – Disability to contract marriages otherwise that under this Act
A man can’t have 2 wives at one time
If a man has already married a woman, he is prohibited from marrying another
woman & vice versa
o S.5(1): A person who (on the appointed date @ after 1st March of 1982)
is lawfully married under any law, religion, custom or usage to 1/more
spouses shall be incapable of contracting a valid marriage with any
other person whether the marriage is contracted within/outside
Malaysia
- If a man has 2 wives from 2 customary marriages prior to 1/3/82
those 2 marriages are valid He is incapable of marrying a 3rd
woman after that date
- S.6: Every marriage contracted in contravention of S.5 shall be void
- If a man lawfully married during the continuance of such marriage
contracted another union with any other woman such woman
would only be his mistress
o S.7: It’s an offence for any person who was lawfully married to purport
any other marriage in contravention of S.5 this is also an offence
within the meaning of S.494 PC
Cases:- PP v Rajappan [1986]
- This is a case decided before the 1986 amendment of LRA come into force (the
amendment was made in regard to this case)
- A Malaysian man, who was already married when he went abroad, had
married another woman
- Court held: The courts in Malaysia didn’t have the jurisdiction to try him for
the offence of bigamy because the 2nd marriage took place in another country
8
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
3. AGE*
S.10 – Age of the parties
Male : 18 yo
Female : 18
: 16 yo – the solemnization of such marriage will be authorised by a license
granted by the Chief Minister under S.21(1)
Chief Minister:-
o Malaysian Embassy, High Commission, Consulate: Malaysian
Ambassador, High Commissioner, Consul
o Federal Territory: Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department
o State: Chief Minister/Menteri Besar
A marriage of minors will be held void as stated in S.69(b)
2
S.9(1) of the Adoption Act 1952
9
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
5. CONSENT*
S.12 – Requirements of consent by a parent
Consent must be obtained from parent
PARENT
o S.12(1): If the girl and boy are less than 21 yo the necessary consent
to the marriage must be obtained
- The consent must be in writing
- Consent can be obtained from:-
Father or mother
Father or mother (for cases of illegitimate child/death of parent)
Adopted father or mother (for adopted child)
A person standing in loco parentis3 (if the child has no parents &
was under the guardianship of the said person)
o S.12(2): Allowed the court, on application, to give consent for any
person for marriage
- This consent shall have the same effect as if it had been given by
the person whose consent was required by S.12(1)
- The situation where the court may do so are:-
The consent of any person to a proposed marriage is being
withheld unreasonably
All those persons who could give consent under S.12(1) are dead
It’s impracticable to obtain such consent
o S.12(5): Marriage of a minor who has previously married
- If a person I below 21 yo and is a widow/widower or a divorcee
he/she isn’t a minor
- The consent to the marriage of a minor shall not be necessary if the
minor has been previously married
- Case: Re CHS [1997]
This case was decided before the amendment of S.124
Facts of the case: The mother of a minor had asked the court to
dispense with her husband’s consent and that she be allowed to
give the necessary consent to her daughter’s marriage. The
daughter had undergone a customary marriage with one LEW
and wished to marry in accordance with the LRA. She was also 6
months’ pregnant at the time of the application
Court held: Augustine Paul CJ – The mother could consent only
if the child’s father is dead and not on any other grounds If
3
Loco parentis – A person who stands vis-à-vis the child as the child’s parents OR the child’s guardian
4
S.3(3), 12(1), 51, 51A, 76, 95 were amended in October 2017
10
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
5
S.37(a)
11
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
2. PROHIBITIONS OF MARRIAGE
The prohibitions of marriage can be found under S.69
Any marriage that has been prohibited, if contracted, will be rendered void
The prohibitions are:-
SECTIONS DESCRIPTIONS
69(a) Polygamous marriage
69(b) Marriage of a minor (Male: < 18, Female: < 16 < 18)
69(c) Prohibited degrees of r/ship
69(d) Parties aren’t respectively male & female
1. S.14: Notice of marriage – Parties sign & give notice to the Registrar
2. S.16: Declaration to accompany notice – Notice given under S.14 must be
accompanied by a written declaration
3. S.15: Publication of notice – Registrar will publish the notice by posting a
copy & to make it visible to the public
4. S.17: Issue of certificate of marriage – The Registrar will issue a certificate of
marriage after the expiration of 3 moths from the date of the publication of
the notice
5. S.18: Marriage to take place within 6 months – Marriage must be held
within 6 months after the date of the publication of the notice If the
marriage doesn’t take place: the notice & all proceedings consequent
thereon shall be void & a fresh notice shall be given before the parties can
lawfully marry
6. S.19: CAVEAT – The caveat may be entered by interested persons who are
aware of the intended marriage and who may have objections thereto
7. S.22: Solemnization of marriages – Every marriage under LRA shall be
solemnized at:-
a. The Registrar’s office (S.22)
b. Malaysian Embassies etc. & abroad (S.26)
c. Abroad & not being a marriage registered under S.26 (S.31)
12
INSYIRAH MOHAMAD NOH UKM LAW SCHOOL 2018
13