Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 7

Med. J. Cairo Univ., Vol. 82, No.

2, December: 123-129, 2014


www.medicaljournalofcairouniversity.net

Value of Endotracheal Aspirate Cultures Versus Blood Cultures in


Predicting Sepsis in Ventilated Preterm and Full-Term Neonates
LAILA H. MOHAMED, M.D.*; OLA A. EL-SISY, M.D.**; NERMIN R. MOHAMED, M.D.*;
NAGY A. EL-HUSSIENY, M.D.*** and DALIA B. MOHAMED, M.D.*
The Departments of Pediatrics*,*** & Clinical Pathology**, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University*,** and
Ahmed Maher Teaching Hospital***

Abstract whom the clinical presentation can be subtle and


nonspecific. The incidence of neonatal sepsis is 1-
Sepsis is a common complication in the NICU. The
incidence of neonatal sepsis is 1-5/1000 livebirth and its 5 per 1,000 live births, and its mortality rate is
mortality rate is 5-20%. Mechanical ventilation plays an 5%-20%. Disseminated intravascular coagulation
important role because artificial airways bypass the body’s and thrombocytopenia are well-known complica-
defense against inhaled pathogens and offer new routes for tions of sepsis. Hospital-acquired infections (noso-
non airborne pathogens. comial infections) are the most common compli-
The goal of our work is to clarify the valuable comparison cations encountered in the neonatal intensive care
of endotracheal aspirate cultures versus blood cultures in unit [1] .
order to predict sepsis in ventilated preterm and full term
neonates. Sixty (60) full term ( >!37 wks) & preterm ( !937 wks) Nosocomial infections are infections that are
neonates with respiratory distress and mechanically ventilated a result of treatment in a hospital or a healthcare
in NICU with clinical evidence of sepsis were selected for
service unit. Infections are considered nosocomial
our study. Our selected cases were subjected to clinical
evaluation and to the Hematological Scoring System of Sepsis. if they first appear 48 hours or more after hospital
The golden pearl in our study is the blood culture for any admission or within 30 days after discharge [2] .
neonatal infant suggested clinically and by laboratory criteria
to be neonatal sepsis. Healthcare-associated infections are of impor-
tant wide-ranging concern in the medical field.
We found that Endotracheal Aspirate (ETA) culture is not
considered a gold standard as sensitivity and specificity in
They can be localized or systemic, can involve
predicting sepsis in ventilated newborns is low in comparison any system of the body, be associated with medical
to blood culture results, the rate of culture positivity increased devices or blood product transfusions. There are
as the birth weight decreased, gestation week got smaller and 3 major sites of healthcare-associated infections
the duration of intubation prolonged. (i.e., bloodstream infection, pneumonia, and urinary
Because of longer duration of mechanical ventilation, tract infection ) with ventilator associated pneumo-
longer stay in the NICU, increased use of antibiotics, higher nia (VAP) being the most common form of venti-
costs for healthcare, and most importantly, increased mortality, lator associated infections (VAI) [3] .
the prevention of VAP is the main priority. In spite of the
great advances in the pathogenesis of VAP, intensivists still The mortality rate associated with VAP ranges
struggle with the prevention strategy. from 24-50% and can escalate up to 76% based on
Key Words: NICU (Neonatal Intensive Care Unit ) – Hema- specific settings and host-pathogen relationship.
tological scoring system of sepsis – VAP (Venti-
lator Associated Pneumonia) – Blood culture. The development of VAP is also associated
with greater hospital mortality rates and longer
Introduction lengths of stay in Intensive Care Unit (ICU) and
hospitals. Microorganisms responsible for VAP
SEPSIS is a common complication in the Neonatal
may differ according to the population of patients
Intensive Care Unit (NICU). It is the most common
in the ICU, the duration of hospital and ICU stays,
of the smallest and most premature infants, in
and the specific diagnostic method(s) used [4] .

Correspondence to: Dr. Nagy A. El-Hussieny, The Department Neonatal septicemia is a potentially life-
of Pediatrics, Ahmed Maher Teaching Hospital threatening event. As part of a group of investiga-

123
124 Value of Endotracheal Aspirate Cultures Versus Blood Cultures

tions to rule out septicemia in newborn infants and Exclusion criteria:


in patients of neonatal intensive care nurseries, - Full term or preterm newborns on nasal CPAP.
blood culture collection is a common event [5] .
- Full term or preterm newborns with a stay of less
than 7 days on mechanical ventilation.
There are few reports about the value of serial
endotracheal tube aspirate culture in predicting - Full term or preterm newborns with distress of
sepsis in ventilated newborns. Researchers reported non respiratory causes e.g. congenital heart dis-
50% of sepsis occurrence among infants who had eases, CNS anomalies, etc
respiratory tract colonization. They also found that
none of the neonates who had no colonization, had All the neonates were subjected to the following:
sepsis. ETA culture is less invasive and results • Full maternal history and antenatal care with
appear earlier than blood culture [1] . stress on any prenatal hazards as pre eclampsia,
PROM, antepartum hemorrhage or intrapartum
Many infants are screened for infection and fever.
treated with antibiotics. While others, blood cultures • Detailed perinatal history including gestational
and other investigations such as a full blood count age, mode of delivery and method and mode of
were done. The clinical practice is that infants who resuscitation.
are <48h of age at time of blood culture collection
• Complete general and systemic examination to
(early septicemia), and who remain clinically well,
confirm inclusion and exclusion criteria.
cease antibiotic treatment 36h after blood culture
collection. Many neonatal units will wait for blood Score interpretation: Minimum 0, maximum
cultures to incubate for at least 48h before deciding 7, <2 sepsis is very unlikely, >3 sepsis is likely,
to stop antibiotics [6] . the higher the score the greater the likeless of
sepsis.
Aim of the work:
This study was conducted to define the pattern • Investigations conducted for every case including:
of respiratory tract colonisation in neonates intu- - Laboratory investigations in the form of automated
bated and ventilated for longer than seven days complete blood count (CBC) with the differen-
and to assess the value of serial cultures of endot- tional count done on leishmanina Giemsa stained
racheal tube aspirates (ETA) in predicting patho- peripheral blood film and C-Reactive Protein
gens of sepsis in comparison to the results of blood (CRP) done using latex agglutination test.
culture. - Imaging studies as Chest X-Ray to confirm the
respiratory cause of distress.
Patients and Methods
- Cultures:
This prospective study was conducted on 60 a- Endotracheal culture (routinely done for in-
full term ( >_ 37 wks) and preterm ( < 37 wks) neonates cluded cases at day 3 and after day 7 of ven-
who were admitted during their first day of life in tilation) using sterile endotracheal suction
the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) of Cairo catheter during the technique of sampling
university children hospital during the period from from endotracheal fluid.
3 rd
January 2010 to December 2010. All the babies b- Blood culture (performed in the day of
were presented with respiratory distress and applied life) using BACTEC Peds blood culture bottles
on mechanical ventilation according to NICU and the BACTEC-9050 instrument.
protocol.
Statistical methods:
Inclusion criteria:
Data manegment and analysis were performed
- All ventilated preterm or full term newborns with using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences
prolonged stay on ventilator (more than 7 days). (SPSS, version 15). The graphs were done using
- All ventilated preterm or full term newborns with Microsoft Word. Numerical data were summarized
clinical evidence of sepsis e.g.: Poor Moro, poor using means & standard deviations. Categorial
suckling reflex, poor capillary refilling, abnormal data were summarized as percentages. Comparison
tone, convulsions etc , confirmed by labo- between groups with respect to numeric variables
ratory evidence of sepsis according to the Hema- was done using the X 2 test and independent t-test,
tological Scoring System for diagnosis of neonatal respectively. The Fisher’s exact test was used when
sepsis [7] . applicable.
Laila H. Mohamed, et al. 125

The level p<0.05 was considered the cut-off Table (5): Blood culture for studied cases.
value for significance.
N %

Results Blood culture +ve 44 37.3


–ve 16 26.7
All results are illustrated in the following Tables
and Figures.
Table (6): Prevalent organisms detected by blood culture.

Table (1): Hematological scoring system of sepsis (rodwell %


scoring system).
Klebsiella 43.75
Items Abnormalities Score Strept. viridians 18.75
Staph. aureus 12.5
Total white blood <5000 per micro L 1 Blood culture
Staph. epidermidis 6.25
cell count Or >25000 per micro L at Candida 6.25
birth Staph. coag. 6.25
Or >30.000 per micro L at Citrobacter 6.25
12-24h.
Or >21.000 per micro L at
D2 onward Table (7): Early endotracheal tube culture for studied cases.

Total PMNL count No mature PMNL seen on 1 N %


blood film –ve
Early endotracheal culture 34 56.7
Increased or decreased +ve 26 43.3
Immature PMNL Increased 1
Immature/total Increased 1 Table (8): Prevalent organisms detected by early endotracheal
PMNL ratio (I/T) culture.
Immature/mature >0.3 1 N %
PMNL ratio (I/M)
Strept. viridians 1 3.8
Platelets counts <150.000 per micro L 1 Klebsiella 18 69.23
Early endotracheal Staph. coag. 2 7.69
Degenerative >3+ for vacuolization, toxic 1 culture
changes in PMNL granulation or Dohle Pseudomonas 2 7.69
bodies Acinetobacter 3 11.53

Table (9): Late endotracheal culture of studied cases.


Table ( 2): Demographic data of studied cases.
N %
Minimum Maximum Mean SD
Late endotracheal culture –ve 44 73.3
Gestational age 30.00wk. 35.00 33.67 ± 1.36 +ve 16 26.7
BW on admission 1.00 Kg 2.40 1.73 ±0.36
Table (10): Prevalent organisms detected by late endotracheal
culture.
Table (3): Signs of sepsis of studied cases.
N %
Clinical signs of sepsis N %
Staph aureus 1 6.25
Poor Reflexes 27 45 Srept. viridians 2 12.5
Poor capillary filling 12 20 Late endotracheal Klebsiella 10 62.5
culture
Sclerema 15 25 Staph. coag. 2 12.5
Pseudomonas 1 6.25

Table (4): Duration of stay on M.V.


Table (11): Duration of hospital stay of studied cases.
Minimum Maximum Mean SD
Minimum Maximum Mean SD
Duration of stay 7.00 days 69.00 10.45 ±9.14
on MV/days Postnatal age 7.00 103.00 28.37 ± 18.19
126 Value of Endotracheal Aspirate Cultures Versus Blood Cultures

Table (12): Comparison between organisms of early endotra-


Sepsis is very
cheal culture results (in the 3 rd day of life) versus
likely 15%
the results of blood culture in the study.

Blood culture Early ETT


Organism
(+ve) culture (+ve)

Staph. aureus 2 –ve


Srept. viridians 2 1 Sepsis is
Sepsis is very possible 23%
Klebsiella 4 18 unlikely 62%

Candida 1 –ve
Fig. (1): Hematological classification of sepsis for studied
Staph. coagulase 1 2 cases.

Pseudomonas –ve 2

Discussion
Table (13): Sensitivity and specificity of early endotracheal
culture.
Sepsis is a common complication in the Neo-
natal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). It is most com-
Sensitivity Specificity PPV NPV mon in the smallest and most premature infants,
in whom the clinical presentation can be subtle
Early endotracheal 62.5 82.4 62.5 82.4
and nonspecific. The incidence of neonatal sepsis
culture
is 1-5per 1,000 live births, and its mortality rate
is 5%-20%, Disseminated intravascular coagulation
Table (14): Comparison between organisms of late endotracheal and thrombocytopenia are well-known complica-
culture results (in the 7 th of life) versus the results tions of sepsis.
of blood cultures in the study.
Hospital acquired infections (nosocomial infec-
Blood culture Early ETT tions) are the most common complications encoun-
Organism
(+ve) culture (+ve) tered in the neonatal intensive care unit. They
Staph. aureus 2 1 generally manifest 48 hours after hospitalization
or in 48 hours after discharge, especially preterm
Klebsiella 4 10
and low birth weight newborns who are more
Candida 1 –ve vulnerable (20 to 33%) to nosocomial infections.
Staph. coagulase 1 2 Mechanically ventilated babies face a particular
Pseudomonas –ve 1 risk because artificial airways bypass the body’s
defense against inhaled pathogens and offer new
routes for non air-borne pathogens. Intubation
Table (15): Organisms detected only by late ETT. associated lesions of the pharynx and trachea lead
to bacterial colonization by the deterioration of
Organism N % the swallowing reflex and the ciliary functions.
Staph. aureus 2 20.00
Subsequently, these babies may develop pneumonia
and sepsis [1] .
Staph. epedermidis 1 10.00
Srept. viridians 3 30.00 In our study, there were no statistically signif-
icant differences between body weight (BW) &
Klebsiella 3 30.00 incidence of sepsis. Birth weight of cases ranged
Citrobacter 1 10.00 between 1000gm and 2400gm. This is in discor-
dance with [8] who found that the incidence of
Total 10 100.00 sepsis is significantly higher in infants with very
low birth weight (<1000g), at 26per 1000 live
birth, than in infants with birth weight of 1000-
Table (16): Sensitivity and specificity of late endoracheal
culture.
2000g, at 8-9per 1000 live birth.

Sensitivity Specificity PPV NPV In our study, there were no statistically signif-
icant differences between gestational ages (GA)
Late endotracheal 37.5 77.3 37.5 77.3 & incidence of sepsis. Our study agrees with [9]
culture and [10] who reported no statistically significant
Laila H. Mohamed, et al. 127

difference between sepsis and non septic groups Blood culture is the gold standard method for
as regards gestational age. isolation of the organisms; blood culture should
be obtained before the initiation of antibiotics [18] .
This is in discordance with [8] who found that
the incidence and severity of sepsis is inversely In this study, blood culture yielded +ve results
related to the gestational age of the infant. Also in 44 cases (73.3%) of ventilator associated pneu-
our study disagrees with [11] who found that the monia cases while 16 cases (26.7%) revealed a
premature neonates in particular have a relatively culture –ve output. Klebsiella was the most com-
permeable mucosal surfaces that allow for the monly detected organism (43.75%), followed by
trans-epithelial passage of bacteria and other patho- Strept. Viridians (18.75%), whilest Staph. Aureus
gens. Also loss of protective maternal antibodies, was detected in (12.5%) of cases. Staph. Epider-
as well as nonspecific alterations in macrophage midis, Candida, Staph. Coagulase and Citrobacter
phagocytes and clearance of invading pathogens, were equally detected in (6.25%) of cases each.
impaired T-cell and B-cell responses and altered
This comes in agreement with the study of [19]
production of complement and antibodies. Addi-
tionally, premature infants are at higher risk of in which nearly half of the positive blood cultures
grew Klebsiella pneumoniae. Also, the study done
progression to sepsis or severe sepsis and adverse
by [20] revealed that the isolated pathogens included
outcomes [12] .
Klebsiella pneumoniae (47.5%), Pseudomonas
In our study, the chief clinical presentations aeruginosa (20%), E.coli (10%), Candida albicans
were poor Moro’s reflex and poor suckling as well. (10%), Staphylococcus aureus (>7.5%), and En-
This is in agreement with [13] who described the terococcus (5%).
same clinical presentations as early signs of sepsis. Our results are in disagreement with a retro-
On the other hand, our study is in disagreement spective study done by [21] who studied the prev-
with the result of [14] , who reported that chest alence of different organisms causing septicemia
manifestations in the form of respiratory distress and the antibiotic susceptibility pattern. The most
are the most common and occurring in up to 90% common organism isolated was Staphylococcus
of infants with sepsis. Also [15] , found that 90% aureus (42.75%) followed by Klebsiella (18.32%),
of newborns with neonatal sepsis had respiratory E.coli (12.21%), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (6.11%);
distress in addition to symptoms of gastrointestinal also Enterobacter spp. Was isolated in (9.23%),
disturbance and poor perfusion. Acinobacter (4.62%), Streptococcal spp. In (7.69%)
In our study, we found 37 cases (62%) with a and Neisseria gonorrhea in (1.54%).
Rodwell Hematological Scoring System of sepsis In our study, 26 cases (43.3%o) showed +ve
of <2, denoting absent sepsis, 14 cases (23%) with early endotracheal tube culture (performed on day
a score of 3 denoting that sepsis is likely and 9 3), while 34 cases (56.7%o) showed –ve early ETT
cases (15%) with a score of (4-7) denoting that culture. Among the culture +ve cases, again Kleb-
sepsis is eminent. siella was the most commonly detected organism
(69.23%).
In our study, we found a significant correlation
between the duration of stay of neonates in NICU, In our study, 16 cases (26.7%) showed +ve late
prolonged stay on mechanical ventilation & inci- endotracheal tube culture, while 44 cases (73.3%)
dence of sepsis. This is in concordance with [16] showed –ve late ETT culture. Among the culture
who found that ventilator-associated pneumonia +ve cases, Klebsiella also was the most commonly
in critically ill patients is associated with longer detected organism (62.5%) followed by Strept.
ICU stays, and prolonged mechanical ventilation. Viridians, Staph. Coagluase, each detected in
(12.5%), whilest Staph. Aureus & Psendomans,
Also, this is in concordance with [17] who each detected in (6.25%) of cases.
concluded that intubation is associated with bacte-
rial colonization of the respiratory tract and, there- In the current study, If blood culture is consid-
fore, may increase the risk of acquiring an infection. ered as gold standard for diagnosis of VAP, accord-
The infection may prolong the need for mechanical ing to [22] , early endotracheal culture showed
ventilation and increase the risk of chronic lung sensitivity of 62.5% and specificity of 82.4% to
disease. The use of prophylactic antibiotics has blood culture and late endotracheal culture showed
been advocated for all mechanically ventilated sensitivity of 37.5% and specificity of 77.3% to
newborns in order to reduce the risk of colonization blood culture. Therefore early ETT culture showed
and the acquisition of infection. higher diagnostic indices than late ETT culture in
128 Value of Endotracheal Aspirate Cultures Versus Blood Cultures

detecting +ve infection (as diagnosed +ve by blood racheal cultures for detection of organisms in
culture). patients with ventilator associated pneumonia,
as tracheal aspirates may be useful track changes
This is in concordance with [1] who found that in bacterial flora at neonatal intensive care units.
blood and endotracheal cultures showed the same
organisms only in 17.6% of the patients. There References
was no relationship among 86.4% of the patients.
1- BOZAYKUT A., IPEK I.O. and KILIC B.D.: Predicting
The rate of culture positivity increased as the birth neonatal sepsis in ventilated neonates. Indian. J. Pediatr.
weight decreased, gestation week got smaller and Jan., 75 (l): 39-42, 2008.
the duration of intubation prolonged. 2- POLLACK and ANDREW: Nosocomial infections, rising
threat of infections unfaced by antibiotics, New York
Also [23] , found that the most common bacterial Times, Feb., 27, 2010.
isolate from ETA of VAP patient was Klebsiella
spp. (32.87%); E.coli and Acinetobacter were the 3- AYESHA MIRZA M.D., CHIEF EDITOR and RUSSELL
W. STEELE: Hospital Acquired Infections, Medscpe
other two common organisms. Jornal, 2010.
Also, our study is in agreement with [24] who 4- CHANDRAKANTH C., ANUSHREE and VINOD A.:
found that the practice of routine cultures of en- Incidence of ventilator associated pneumonia, International
Journal of Medical and Clinical Research. ISSN: 0976-
dotracheal aspirate and cultures obtained from 5530 & E-ISSN: 0976-5549, Vol. 1, Issue 2, pp. 11-13,
multiple body sites is an expensive proposition 2010.
with low yield. The sensitivity of this test is at best
5- ANDRESON-BERRY A.L., BELLIG L.L., et al.: Neonatal
50% and all studies report a very low positive Sepsis. WWW.e medicine.Medascape.com/article/978352,
predictive value. The specificity of this test is 80%, 2006.
hence its role is mainly limited to identifying 6- TALLUR S.S., KASTURI A.V., NADGIR S.D. and
infants who are at low risk for sepsis. KRISHNA B.V.S.: Clinico-bacteriological study of neo-
natal septicaemia in hubli. Indian. J. Pediatr., 67: 169-
This is in discordance with [23] who found that 174, 2006.
the endotracheal aspirate of the patients on venti- 7- RODWELL R.L.: Hematological scoring system. Pediatr.,
lator should be sent routinely for culture sensitivity 112: 761-7, 1988.
and if the patient develops VAP, antibiotics should
8- BELLING L.L.: Neonatal sepsis. J. Pediatr., 155: 120-
be changed as per report. 126, 2004.
Conclusion and Recommendations: 9- MAHIEU L.M., De MUYNCK A.O., DE DOOY J.J., et
al.: Prediction of nosocomial sepsis in neonates by means
• Blood culture is still the gold standard for detec- of a computer-weighted bedside scoring system (NOSEP
tion of organisms in neonates with ventilator score). Crit. Care Med., 28: 2026-2033, 2000.
associated pneumonia; Endotracheal tube culture 10- FERGNANO S., SHARLAND M., KAZEMBE P. and
has a lower sensitivity & specificity. MWANSAMBO C.: Heath PT. Neonatal sepsis: An inter-
national perspective. Arch. Dis. Child Fetal. Neonatal.,
• Early and appropriate antimicrobial treatment of 90: F220-4, 2005.
patients with VAP significantly improves outcome
of patients. 11- POLITIS I.C.R.: Milk peptides and immune response in
the neonate. Adv. Exp. Med. Biol., 606: 253-69, 2008.
• Minimize the duration of stay of prematures 12- STEPHEN B. and THACKER M.D., M.Sc.: Prevention
especially on mechanical ventilation which sub- of perinatal group B Streptococcal Disease November,
sequently reduces their period of stay in the 19, Vol. 59/No. RR-10, 2010.
NICU and hence reduces the incidence of noso- 13- KLIEGMAN R.M., BEHRMAN R.E., JENSON H.B. and
comial infections. STANTON B. Eds.: Nelson textbook of pediatrics. Sepsis,
septic shock and systemic inflammatory response syn-
• Once mechanical ventilation is indicated, it drome. 18 th ed. Philadelphia, Pa.: Saunders Elsevi-
should be applied under the direction of a trained er;133981928-3/0/1608/514.0-B978-1-4160-2450-
physician who understands the technical aspects 7.50178-X- cesec6_4006, 2007.
of management of artificial airways, mechanical 14- CLOHERTY, ANN R. STARK, ERIC C., JOHN P. and
ventilators, and humidification systems. J. EICHENWALD: Bacterial and fungal infections. Man-
ual of Neonatal Care, Chapter 23: p. 291-295, 2004.
• Universal Standard Precautions of infection
15- KAREN M. PUOPOLO: Epidemiology of neonatal early-
control as described by the Centers for Disease onset sepsis. NeoReviews, 9: e571-e579. DOI: 10.1542/
Control are necessary and should be employed. neo.9-12-e571, 2008.
• Further studies including large number of patients 16- MOHR A.M., SIFRI Z.C., HORNG H.S., et al.: Use of
are recommended to evaluate the role of endot- aerosolized aminoglycosides in the treatment of Gram-
Laila H. Mohamed, et al. 129

negative ventilator-associated pneumonia. Surg. Infect. 20- De BENEDETTI F., AURITI C., D'URBANO L.E., et al.:
(Larchmt), 8 (3): 349-357, 2007. Low serum levels of mannose binding lectin are a risk
factor for neonatal sepsis. Pediatr. Res., 61: 325-8, 2007.
17- INGLIS G.D.T., JARDINE L.A. and DAVIES M.W.:
Prophylactic antibiotics to reduce morbidity and mortality 21- SHAW M.J.: Ventilator-associated pneumonia. Opin.
in ventilated newborn infants. Cochrane Database of Pulm. Med., 11 (3): 236-241, 2005.
Systematic Reviews Issue 3. Art. No.: 14651858.
CD004338. DOI: 10.1002, 2008. 22- ROBERTS I. and MARRAY N.: Thrombocytopenia in
18- SAINI, SOURABHDUTTA, PALLABRAY and ANIL the newborn. J. Curr. Opin. Pediatr., 15 (1): 17-23, 2003.
NARG: Short course versus 7-day course of intravenous
antibiotics for probable neonatal septicemia. Volume: 48, 23- SHALINI TRIPATHI, MALIK, AMITA JAIN and NEERA
January, 17, 2011. KOHLI: Study of ventilator associated pneumonia in
neonatal intensive care unit: Characteristics, risk factors
19- DZWONEK, AGNIESZKA B., et al.: The role of mannose- and outcome. January, 5 (l): 12-19, 2010.
binding lectin in susceptibility to infection in preterm
neonates, Volume 63, Issue 6, pp. 680-685, 2008. 24- HARI BHASKAR: Indian. J. Pediatr., 65: 79-84, 1988.

Вам также может понравиться