Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 67

MUSEUMS AND LGBTQ

An analysis of how museums and other exhibitors


can highlight lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender
and queer perspectives
QTBGL DNA SMUESUM
srotibihxe rehto dna smuesum woh fo sisylana nA
rednegsnart ,lauxesib ,yag ,naibsel thgilhgih nac
sevitcepsrep reeuq dna
Museums and LGBTQ
The Swedish Exhibition Agency (Riksutställningar) has the
task of promoting development and cooperation among
museums and other exhibitors. This includes providing the
exhibition sector with international analyses, advice and test-
ing, for the introduction of new technology and approaches,
and various subject-related courses, conferences and news-
letters. The Agency also regularly produces in-depth analyses
and development proposals on specific issues or subjects.
Within the scope of this activity, the following survey and anal-
ysis of how museums and other exhibitors highlight LGBTQ
perspectives, with proposals on improvements that could be
made in this field, was undertaken in 2014. The results are
presented in this report, published in 2015.

Please do not hesitate to contact the Swedish


Exhibition Agency!
Telephone: +46(0)498-79 90 00
E-mail: info@riksutstallningar.se
Website: www.riksutställningar.se
Visiting address: Artillerigatan 33A, Visby
Postal address: Riksutställningar – Swedish Exhibition
Agency, Box 1033, SE-621 21 Visby, Sweden
You can also find us on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube,
Instagram and in Podcasts.

Illustrations: Emma Virke


Graphic design: Cathrin Emdén
Printed by iVisby Tryckeri AB, 2016
Preface
THE INITIATIVE FOR THIS STUDY of LGBTQ perspectives in continue focusing on the issues that make museums a place
exhibitions and museums was carried out within the frame- by, with, and for everyone, today and in the future.
work of a national Strategy for equal rights and opportunities
regardless of Sexual orientation, gender identity or gender The surveys on which this report is based show that Swed-
expression. This strategy marks an important stand made by ish museums in general are positive to working with LGBTQ
the government: Sweden should be a good country to live in issues, and a majority have experience of incorporating
for LGBT persons – not to say, the best country in the world, LGBTQ perspectives in their activities in one way or another.
as the then Minister of Integration, Erik Ullenhag, put it at the The surveys also show that these efforts are often tempo-
kick-off conference for the Strategy. A national strategy is rary rather than long-term, and that a great deal remains to be
crucial; research shows that health problems are more com- done to give LGBTQ aspects a firm position in the museums’
mon among LGBT persons than in the overall population. internal programmes for value systems, and in their policies
Moreover, LGBT persons are still subjected to violence, and strategies.
discrimination and other abuse in Sweden.
Internationally, the report found that Swedish museums are
So how can museums contribute to a better society for relatively far ahead in applying LGBTQ perspectives in their
LGBTQ people? As creators, managers and communicators exhibitions and museum activities. If Swedish museums suc-
of knowledge and the collective image of social development, cessfully strengthen their work in this field, we believe the
museums have an enormous potential to make a positive Swedish exhibitions sector could break new ground and show
contribution. As this report demonstrates, LGBTQ people the way for other countries. This is already possible thanks
all over the world can be regarded as an unhistoried part of to the openness of many Swedish museums to international
the population. Shame and taboos underpin this unneces- partnerships on LGBTQ-related themes.
sary invisibility. Rootlessness and an absence of visible role
models are one direct consequence. Museums can choose to Consequently, the Swedish Exhibition Agency believes that
be the platforms building bridges between various problems Swedish museums can look forward to an exciting future, if
and constructive possibilities, where visibility leads to a right they continue to integrate the LGBTQ perspective with their
to exist, greater understanding, respect and more openness activities, thereby contributing to openness, visibility, under-
in society. Museums can thus become better at helping to standing and increased respect – in our society and interna-
achieve something that concerns us all. tionally.

Focusing on norm criticism in general, and LGBTQ perspec-


tives in particular, is one definite step towards highlighting
human experiences even more throughout Sweden’s muse-
ums. By being relevant and welcoming to more people, the
role and significance of museums to society at large will be Rebecka Nolmark
enhanced. At the Swedish Exhibition Agency we intend to Director-General, Swedish Exhibition Agency

5
Summary
THE REPORT “Museums and LGBTQ – An analysis of how undertaken within the framework of the assignment, as a
museums and other exhibitors can highlight perspectives on complement to the in-depth interviews.
lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer persons” was
published in 2015. It was the result of a government assign- The overall picture is positive. In Sweden, LGBTQ in muse-
ment to the Swedish Exhibition Agency for 2014. The objec- ums is an area with great potential. Our survey shows that
tive of this assignment was to perform a study of how the 82 per cent of Swedish museums strive to include LGBTQ
LGBT perspective was highlighted in the field of exhibitions, issues in their activities. However, most museums consider
and to propose opportunities and methods for the sector to themselves to have no more than a basic expertise in LGBTQ
develop the LGBT perspective. The assignment was carried issues. 87 per cent respond that they need to enhance the
out within the framework of a joint, long-term national strategy museum’s expertise, while less than half include this perspec-
for equal rights and opportunities regardless of sexual orien- tive in their in-house training. A great deal remains to be done
tation, gender identity or gender expression. to give LGBTQ issues a firm position in the museums’ inter-
nal programmes for value systems, and in their policies and
The Swedish Exhibition Agency chose to expand the assign- strategies.
ment beyond the concepts of “exhibition field” and “exhibi-
tion medium” to include museum activities in general. This Efforts are often made within the museums’ public activities,
expansion particularly concerned taking a long-term, overall as in exhibition production and activities relating to visitors
perspective, since the various activities of museums are hard and programming. The in-depth interviews and dialogue
to separate and interdependent. Moreover, the Agency opted meetings revealed that efforts are often temporary rather
to expand the concept of LGBT to also embrace Q for queer; than long-term. External partners are commonly used. For
i.e. into LGBTQ. This is mainly because queer is a commonly instance, several Swedish museums offer queer guided tours
used concept in norm criticism, also within Swedish muse- during the local Pride festival. Moreover, the integration of
ums. LGBTQ perspectives in the work with the collections is a
relatively new field that needs attention and resources in order
We have looked for knowledge, experience and best prac- to develop.
tices in Sweden and globally. The report has primarily built on
in-depth interviews. Dialogue meetings were also organised The assignment also found that Swedish museums and
for qualified discussions on the subject. Moreover, a national exhibitors are fairly advanced internationally in their work on
survey targeting Swedish museum through phone calls was LGBTQ perspectives. Sharing experiences with other coun-
tries is a good way of developing this area. This is already pos-
sible thanks to the openness of many Swedish museums to
international partnerships on LGBTQ-related themes. Overall,
in Sweden and globally, sexual orientations, gender identities
and gender expressions that do not comply with the local and
contemporary norm are usually excluded from historiography.
The lack of history that permeates the LGBTQ perspectives is
a major challenge to address. Here, Swedish museums and
exhibitors can lead the way.

The report is basically divided into five chapters, beginning


with an introduction. This is followed by the chapter “Why
LGBTQ?”, which discusses the relevance of integrating these
perspectives and puts them in context. The third chapter deals
with “LGBTQ in Sweden and internationally” and covers the
standing of these issues in our society and variations in other
countries. It also provides an overview of how Swedish muse-
ums highlight LGBTQ perspectives, and gives more detailed
examples from museums and exhibition initiatives around the
world. The fourth chapter summarises the results of the sur-
vey conducted as part of this assignment. The presentation
of “The development LGBTQ perspectives in museums” is
divided into sections on exhibitions, visitor and programming
activities, collections, internal organisation, and external col-
laborations. The fifth and final part of the report, “The present
and the future – concluding reflections”, sums up the current
situation and looks ahead.

7
Contents
05 Preface
06 Summary
09 Contents
11 Prologue

13 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N
13 A national strategy
13 The assignment of the Swedish Exhibition Agency
13 The Agency’s interpretation of its assignment
14 LGBT+Q
14 Method
14 The report and its disposition
15 Terminology

19 2 . W H Y LG B TQ ?
19 Whose history?
20 LGBTQ perspectives
20 Heteronormativity
20 Queer
21 Norm criticism
21 Intersectionality
21 Crowded perspectives
22 The role of museums

25 3 . LG B TQ I N S W E D E N A N D I N T E R N AT I O N A L LY
25 The standing of LGBTQ issues in Sweden and the rest of the world
26 LGBTQ in Swedish museums
28 LGBTQ in museums internationally
28 Australia
28 Brazil
29 India
29 China
30 Norway
30 Poland
30 The UK
31 South Africa
31 Germany
32 USA

35 4 . T H E D E V E LO P M E N T O F LG B TQ P E R S P E C T I V E S I N M U S E U M S
35 Exhibitions
41 Visitor activities and programmes
45 LGBTQ in collections
49 LGBTQ in the internal organisation
53 LGBTQ in collaborations

57 5. THE PRESENT AND THE FUTURE – CONC LUDING REFLECTIONS

61 S O U R C E S

9
Prologue
THE HISTORY OF A SOCIETY is a patchwork of many people and
events. Often, however, only one or a few patches feature in
what is considered to be our common historiography. High-
lighting LGBTQ perspectives in exhibitions and museums is
not about enhancing the already established picture. It is a
matter of showing more pieces of the patchwork and allowing
more colours to shine. It is about challenging the norms until
they expand and include.

This report offers a patchwork quilt of narratives, experiences


and insights from people who have worked actively to intro-
duce LGBTQ perspectives in exhibitions and museums, in
Sweden and internationally. We also hope that this report
will provide knowledge that encourages more museums and
exhibitors to make new efforts in this endeavour.

11
CHAPTER 1

1. Introduction
A national strategy
Even if the rights for LGBTQ people and their opportunities for perspective within the exhibition medium. The results of the
a good life have improved considerably in Sweden in recent assignment shall be presented to the Government Offices no
decades, LGBTQ people in Sweden are still exposed to vio- later than 15 February, 2015 (to the Ministry of Culture, with a
lence, discrimination and other abuse. LGBT people were copy to the Ministry of Employment).
found to have poorer physical and mental health than the
population in general. Transgender people are a particularly The Agency’s interpretation of its assignment
vulnerable group. Based on the description of the assignment, the Swedish Exhibi-
tion Agency has studied how the LGBT perspective is featured,
The government has therefore identified the need for a cohe- and searched for opportunities and methods for the sector to
sive long-term national strategy. Based on the United Nation’s develop the LGBT perspective. We have looked for knowledge,
conventions on human rights, a strategy on equal rights and experience and best practices in Sweden and globally.
opportunities regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity
or gender expression was adopted in January 2014. The Agency chose to expand the assignment beyond the
concepts of “exhibitions sector” and “exhibition medium”
At the kick-off conference for the strategy in Stockholm on to include museum activities in general. Partly because the
24 April, 2014, the then Minister of Integration at the Ministry Agency’s task is to support museums and other exhibitors,
of Employment, Erik Ullenhag, stated that the intention was and also in view of the ambitions of the national LGBT strat-
to make Sweden’ the world’s best country for LGBT people egy to achieve change in the long term. This would be hard
to live in. Five strategic government agencies were selected to accomplish without a comprehensive approach, also within
for the strategy: the Equality Ombudsman, the Public Health the museum sector.
Agency, the Swedish Arts Council, the Swedish Agency for
Youth and Civil Society, and the National Board of Health and In particular, the assignment was interpreted to take into con-
Welfare. sideration that many exhibitions are produced by museums,
and that the various activities of a museum are difficult to sep-
The strategy focuses on a set of problems, but aims towards arate from each other, since they are interdependent. What is
“equal rights and opportunities”. The assignment given to the shown, or not shown, in an exhibition relates to the museum’s
Agency is to identify opportunities. approach to objects and collections, interacts with how the
museum works with visitor activities and programmes, and is
The assignment of the Swedish Exhibition Agency preceded by and developed in harmony with the museum’s
In the appropriation directions from the Ministry of Culture for in-house approach to norm awareness. Moreover, attempts
the financial year 2014, the Swedish Exhibition Agency was to highlight LGBT perspectives in exhibitions are often based
given the assignment to “survey the LGBT perspective in the on collaborations, since museums today rarely have the full
exhibitions sector”. The assignment was formulated as follows: expertise internally to address these perspectives (and
inversely: LGBT activists in civil society rarely have the exper-
“The Swedish Exhibition Agency shall perform a separate tise or resources to produce an exhibition themselves).
study of how the LGBT perspective is highlighted in the exhi-
bitions sector. This study shall be based on an international One common way of working with LGBT perspectives at
analysis. The scope of the assignment includes presenting Swedish museums today serves as an excellent illustration
opportunities and methods for the sector to develop the LGBT of the case: in connection with local Pride Festivals, some

13
museums adapt their activities and offer museum visitors views were conducted via video link (Skype) or telephone.
queer guided tours. These queer tours often involve applying A small number of interviews took place via e-mail, mainly to
a queer theoretical perspective to the existing exhibition or avoid misunderstandings caused by language barriers.
collection. If the required expertise is not at hand internally,
someone with an alternative viewpoint is recruited externally. The respondents were people with experience of working with
In some cases, this impels the museum internally to develop LGBTQ perspectives in exhibitions or other museum activi-
its norm-critical approach, to build expertise and strategies ties, or of collaborating with museums or otherwise actively
on how to reach and include new potential visitor groups, and encouraging others to engage in efforts relating to LGBTQ
to develop systems for cataloguing their objects also accord- perspectives. The respondents are active in Sweden and/or
ing to an LGBT perspective. Consequently, it became obvi- internationally. Most of the data has been collected in Swe-
ous that the assignment’s report should describe how LGBT den, with some additions from all continents, with a special
perspectives are highlighted not only in exhibitions but in the emphasis on countries where we found a great deal to learn.
museum collections, in visitor activities and events, in external We found the respondents mainly through the networks that
collaborations and internally. we developed gradually by requesting the people we met or
interviewed to suggest other relevant interviewees. To some
LGBT+Q extent, we also found people, organisations and projects
The description of the assignment refers to developing the through the internet. We also issued an international call via
“LGBT perspective”. As stated in Chapter 2, this actually an extensive e-mail list, which garnered a few useful sugges-
involves highlighting several perspectives. LGBT is an abbre- tions. Many people have also contributed to the assignment
viation for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender persons. by contacting us and sharing their experiences.
Other letters are often added to LGBT. In this report, we
have chosen to add the letter Q for queer. Queer represents To get a broad idea of Swedish museums’ attitudes to, and
something that does not adhere to norms. This often relates experiences of, working with LGBTQ perspectives, a tele-
to norms for sexuality, gender identity or gender expression. phone survey was performed within the framework of the
Some suggest that a Q should be added to LGBT, for a more assignment. The Swedish Exhibition Agency developed a
inclusive approach, while others maintain that Q is too difficult questionnaire that was used for telephone interviews. It was
to define, making it unreasonable to include it in discussions done together with the company Exquiro, which performed
and strategies. the survey in May and June 2014.

We have chosen in the report hereafter to write LGBTQ In addition, extremely valuable input was contributed to the
(except occasionally when referring to sources focusing spe- assignment through the discussions we organised in Swe-
cifically on LGBT) and will often use the term queer. The rea- den, and at an international Queer Lab. Moreover, the data
son, as mentioned previously, is that Swedish museums today obtained at a few conferences have also been valuable.
frequently organise queer tours as one way of working with
LGBTQ perspectives. Moreover, queer is a collective term The assignment has also been greatly assisted by research
that cropped up continuously in our discussions and inter- and other literature in the field, and by documentation of pre-
views in the course of the assignment. Also, the word queer vious projects by museums and other organisations. A com-
in its broader meaning is relevant to this assignment, since plete list of resources is found at the end of this report.
Swedish museums interested in integrating LGBTQ perspec-
tives usually do this within the framework of their norm-critical The report and its disposition
work. Read more about the term queer in Chapter 2. This introductory chapter is followed by the chapter “Why
LGBTQ?”, which discusses the relevance of integrating these
The Swedish Arts Council, as the strategic government perspectives and puts them in context.
agency for LGBT issues, has also chosen to include the term
queer, partly because it is a basic concept in norm-critical the- The third chapter deals with “LGBTQ in Sweden and interna-
ory, partly because cultural expressions focusing on LGBTQ tionally” and covers the status of these issues in our society
issues are often referred to as queer, and also so as not to and variations in other countries. It also gives an overview of
exclude persons who define themselves as queer.1 how Swedish museums highlight LGBTQ perspectives, and
gives more detailed examples from museums and exhibition
Method initiatives around the world.
The principal method for this assignment has been to conduct
interviews. Most of these have been performed face to face The fourth chapter summarises the results of the study con-
with the respondent. For geographical reasons, some inter- ducted in this assignment. The presentation of “The devel-

1 Swedish Arts Council. (2014). Redovisning av Kulturrådets arbete 2014 som strategisk myndighet för ökad öppenhet och mångfald avseende hbt-frågor.
opment of LGBTQ perspectives in museums” is divided into to as opposite sexes. Women and men are expected to be
sections on exhibitions, visitor activities and programmes, different; feminine and masculine respectively. Moreover, the
collections, internal organisation, and external collaborations. hetero norm assumes that everyone is heterosexual and wants
monogamous couple relationships. To comply with, and not
The fifth and final part of this report, “The present and the visibly deviate from, the norm is associated with economic,
future – concluding reflections”, sums up the current situation political and social advantages.
and looks ahead.
Homosexual
The report was written by the research officer Evelina Wahl- A person who has the ability to fall in love with, be attracted
qvist, global perspective analyst at the Swedish Exhibition to, or aroused by persons of the same gender. In Swedish law,
Agency, in consultation with specialist Dennis Josefson, mar- homosexuality is defined as one of three sexual orientations.
keting officer at the Agency.
Homophobia
Terminology A value, opinion or ideology, sometimes linked to fear, that
Below is a glossary that may come in handy when reading this expresses a negative attitude to homosexuality and/or homo-
report or studying these perspectives in general. It is based and bisexuals. Homophobia sometimes overlaps with biphobia.
mainly on the definitions in the glossaries of RFSL (the Swed-
ish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersectionality
Queer Rights). 2, 3 This is a perspective that is applied to study how different
forms of oppression are interlinked, and how identities are
Biphobia constructed on the basis of categories such as religion, eth-
A value, opinion or ideology, sometimes linked to fear, that nicity, gender, sexuality, class and age. How these various
expresses a negative attitude to bisexuality and/or bisexuals. aspects are linked varies depending on the person, group and
Biphobia sometimes overlaps with homophobia. context.

Bisexual Genderqueer (GQ)


A person who has the ability to fall in love with, be aroused by, Persons who identify themselves as being in between or out-
or attracted to, people of any gender. In Swedish law, bisexu- side the gender binary, i.e. who do not adhere to the traditional
ality is defined as one of three sexual orientations. identities of being exclusively female or male. This does not
relate to what thebody looks like, but to the gender they feel
Cisgender and define themselves to be (gender identity).
Cis is derived from the Latin prefix cis-, meaning “on this side
of”. It is used to describe a person whose legal gender, bio- Intersexual/intersexualism
logical gender, gender identity and gender expression are lin- ‘Inter’ means ‘between’ in Latin, and ‘sexus’ means ‘sex’. Inter-
ear, i.e. match and have always matched and complied with sexual thus means ‘between sexes’. The term covers a variety
the norm. Cis can be, for instance, a person born with a penis, of conditions and diagnoses. In short, it describes a person
who sees himself as a male and is registered as a male in pub- born with atypical sex chromosomes, gonads (testicles or ova-
lic records. The word relates to gender identity and gender ries) or genital development. Opinions differ as to whether or
expression and has nothing to do with sexual orientation. not intersexual individuals should be regarded as trans­gender.

LGBTQ Gender
An umbrella term for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transsexual per- Gender is a social construct used to categorise people as
sons and other persons with queer expressions and identities. either women or men. Gender can be subdivided into four
functions:
Heterosexual Biological gender – defined according to external and inter-
A person who has the ability to fall in love with, be attracted nal genitals, sex chromosomes and hormone levels. Biological
to, or aroused by persons of a different and/or opposite gen- gender or sex is determined by the characteristics of the phys-
der. In Swedish law, heterosexuality is defined as one of three ical body.
sexual orientations. Legal gender – the gender registered in public records, pass-
ports or ID documents. The legal gender is also indicated by
Heteronormativity the penultimate digit in Swedish ID numbers. Sweden has
The hetero norm is based on the assumption that a human only two legal genders: male and female. All children are given
being is either female or male only. These two are referred a legal gender based on their biological gender.

2 Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. Glossary. Accessed on 19 January, 2015. http://www.rfsl.se/?p=410
3 RFSL Ungdom & Living History Forum. (2011). BRYT! ett metodmaterial om normer i allmänhet och heteronormen i synnerhet, 3rd edition.

15
Gender identity/experienced gender – a person’s experi- ate from the gender norm. There are many sub-categories,
enced gender is the gender a person feels like. No one can and it is possible to be transgender in a variety of ways, for
determine this other than the person themselves, and each instance as a transvestite, drag king/drag queen, transsex-
individual has the right to determine their own gender identity. ual, gender­queer and intersexual. Transgender persons may
Gender expression – how a person expresses their gender, identify themselves as being men, women, both, or neutral,
for instance, with clothing, body language, hair, make-up, regardless of biological gender and legal gender. Transgen-
social behaviour and voice. der persons may also prefer not to define their gender at all.
The word relates to gender identity and gender expression
Norms and has nothing to do with sexual orientation.
Tacit rules, expectations and ideals relating to what is consid-
ered positive, desirable and advantageous, and what is not. Transsexual
Norms change over time, depending on the situation, and are Persons who experience that they are not of the legal gender
shaped by power structures. that was attributed to them at birth, and who want to change
their body fully or partially with surgery or hormone treatment
Queer or other methods. Transsexualism is a medical diagnosis that
A broad term with a broad range of meanings. Basically, involves a transition phase for some individuals, prior to reas-
queer challenges heteronormativity. Many people regard their signment. Others continue to define themselves as trans­
gender identity and/or sexuality to be queer. Queer can com- sexual, or previously transsexual, even after reassignment.
prise a will to include all genders and sexualities, or not being
required to identify/define oneself in those terms. Transvestite
A person who occasionally or always, totally or partially,
Sexuality wears or uses clothes and/or other attributes associated with
A term that is often used to categorise people based on who another gender.
they have the ability to fall in love with, be attracted to and/
or aroused by. In Swedish law, this is referred to as “sexual Transphobia
orientation”. In Swedish law, people are defined as hetero-, A value, opinion or ideology that expresses a negative attitude
homo- and bisexual, but individuals may define their own sex- to transgender persons or persons whose gender expression
ual orientation in other terms, including asexual. does not comply with the norm. Transphobia sometimes over-
laps with homophobia.
Transgender
Transgender is an umbrella term that usually denotes people
whose gender expression and/or gender identities devi-
17
CHAPTER 2

2. WHY LGBTQ?
Two-Spirit
For centuries, or even millennia, the indigenous North Amer- to conform to traditional gender roles. Being discriminated on
ican tribes have recognised people who went by the name dual grounds is hardly easy. In the 20th century, homophobia
of ‘two-spirit’.1 This became the common term for those who became rife within America’s indigenous populations, thanks
were not only woman or man but somewhere on the scale to the growing European-Christian influences. Those who did
between what was defined as feminine and masculine. In the not fit in chose to go underground and live inconspicuously.
North American tribes, these individuals were generally not Some even committed suicide. It was not until the 1960s that
merely accepted but also respected. Since everything that they slowly began to regain respect through the growing civil
existed was regarded as emanating from the spiritual world, rights movement. The story continues.3
two-spirit people were doubly blessed, since they had both a
female and a male spirit. Therefore, they often had the role of Whose history?
spiritual leaders or teachers. Similar religious traditions have Whose history is it we convey, and why? The European per-
been practised by indigenous people on the southern Amer- spective on American history usually starts with Christopher
ican continent, and in Siberia and many parts of central and Columbus accidentally discovering America and the subse-
south-east Asia. quent European colonisation. The version that is repeated
is the history of men, the conquerors, the victors. We rarely
This does not imply that gender roles were considered to mention what was lost. Nor do we hear much about that which
be inconsequential in North American indigenous societies. does not enhance the image of the myth or legend that is
But there was a flexibility in who could assume these roles. retold. We also prefer to suppress subjects that are linked
In some cases, two-spirit people were married. A ‘feminine with shame or taboos.
man’ who preferred the household chores that were consid-
ered to be women’s work could even be expected to wed a So what happens when we reveal these taboos? Most proba-
‘masculine man’ who devoted his time to hunting and fighting. bly, we will find things that we need to talk about. It is likely that
Likewise, a ‘masculine woman’ was often expected to marry we will find things that need not be shameful. Hopefully, our
a ‘feminine woman’. A story that is still told today is about a discussions will be more candid and open-minded. We know
strong female chief and hunter2 who was so capable that she that today’s taboos did not always exist and need not continue
provided for as many as four women and their offspring. In to exist in the future. We have the right to change our views. To
some groups, for instance, the Navajo, it was considered to make new choices. To include more people.
be economically beneficial to have a ‘nadleeh’ (“one who is
transformed”) in the family. Two-spirit persons could assist Attitudes to LGBTQ people vary in different cultures and
with caring for their siblings’ children and their older relatives. regions. They also vary over generations. What LGBTQ peo-
They also often stepped in and adopted homeless children. ple all over the world share today is that they have been prac-
tically excluded from our collective historiography. The history
Early French explorers in North America called two-spirit peo- of LGBTQ is rarely mentioned as part of a collective social
ple ‘berdache’. The word relates partly to homosexuality, but history. In the cases where LGBTQ people are highlighted his-
it also implies someone who is a slave. The British colonis- torically, we can assume that facts about their gender identity
ers in North America, and the Spanish settlers in Latin Amer- or sexual orientation are omitted. Where the norm is strongly
ica, deplored two-spirit people and called them sodomites. emphasised in historiography, obvious facts risk invisibility.
Christian missionaries and government officials forced them Contexts and people are made invisible. Unnecessarily.

1 Roscoe, W. (1991). The Zuni man-woman. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
2 Hieatt, T. E. Two-Spirits in American Indian Culture. Youtube. Accessed on 9 January, 2015. http://youtu.be/39EWTnS05Ww
3 Williams, W. L. The ’two-spirit’ people of indigenous North Americans. The Guardian. 2010-10-11.

19
The experience of being historyless leads to rootlessness, of norms when someone or something goes against them.
loneliness and questions about identity. The blind spots in Thus, by revealing norms we uncover things we take for
historiography affect individuals, groups and entire societies. granted. Awareness of prevailing norms, and how they affect
Today’s museums have a big potential here to make a valuable us, should be in everybody’s interest. The norm in this con-
contribution, as narrators of history, conveyors of knowledge, text, the hetero norm, is practically universal in today’s society,
and portals of understanding. Yesterday’s version of history even if there are quite a few people who deviate from some or
may need to be shared in a different light; blind spots need fill- many of its aspects.
ing in. Tomorrow’s new historiography is being compiled now;
it may require a wider and deeper awareness of norms. This Heteronormativity is based on the principle of hierarchic
is an important task for the museums of today. And the task difference, where some bodies and lifestyles are privileged
is not uncomplicated. Basically, it involves conveying a larger while others are presented as deviating or less acceptable.4
part of the truth. This report will suggest ways of achieving In short, heteronormativity assumes that heterosexuality is
this. the normal state; that men are sexually attracted to women
and vice versa. Other sexual orientations require explanation
LGBTQ perspectives and discussion, whereas heterosexual persons do not need
In the course of this assignment, we have repeatedly encoun- to “come out” or explain their orientation. Heteronormativity,
tered the need for respectfully making visible the existence in turn, generates many notions of how we should behave as
and life conditions of LGBTQ people in society. We have men and women respectively. These notions lead to expecta-
come across many constructive proposals for how exhibitions tions that can, of course, restrict us all.
and museums can contribute to this effort. And yet, we have
also often been confronted with the question of whether it is In the course of our dialogue meetings,5 participants asserted
“right” to focus on one group and one perspective. “Won’t that that it was just as important to discuss the hetero norm as the
take place at the expense of other groups and perspectives?” LGBTQ perspectives in relation to museum priorities.“Heter-
is a common question. First of all, it should be emphasised onormativity is not an objective truth.” “Enforcing the status
that LGBTQ does not represent only one perspective or one quo is also a choice,” as the participants pointed out. Several
group. LGBTQ is a collective abbreviation that includes a of them also mentioned that more exhibitions on queer themes
wide diversity, heterogeneity, many perspectives and groups was not all that was needed: “It’s about time that we get to see
– groups that by themselves could hardly represent the entire an exhibition about the hetero norm.”
LGBTQ spectrum. Therefore, it is up to each museum, prior
to every new project or venture, to pay attention to these per- Queer
spectives, to define what and whom to focus on in a particular “Queer is a trendy word. I read online that we’ll all be queer in
context. ten years,” said Magdalena Dziurlikowska in 2006 in an article6
where she interviewed the pioneers of queer tours at Swedish
LGBTQ stands for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and museums, Anders Karnell and Patrik Steorn. Perhaps most of
queer. Queer is a broad collective term that will be discussed us are queer in the sense of not adhering to the characteristics
more closely below. With regard to the first four letters, LGBT, attributed to society’s current underlying norm of educated,
we should start by differentiating between sexuality and middle-aged, white cis male – perhaps hardly even the men
expression – that is, between actions and identities. Homo- who fit that description. The word queer is an essential part
sexuality and bisexuality denote sexual orientations, and are of the vocabulary, but it is a complex term due to its enormous
contrasted to the heterosexual norm in society. Transgen- content. Queer does not only mean a person who deviates
der is an umbrella term relating to gender identity and gen- from the hetero norm. It can denote everything or everyone
der expression. It contrasts to the norms for how bodies and who deviates from social norms. This is, of course, fluid, geo-
expressions are associated with one of two genders. It is also graphically, temporally and contextually.
contrasted to society’s prevailing binary gender norm. His-
torically and geographically, however, the binary gender sys- Dziurlikowska’s interview discusses whether the concept of
tem is not a preordained paradigm, as the story of Two-Spir- queer ten years ago had already culminated and was being
its indicates. Some countries, including Argentina, Germany, watered down. Patrik Steorn, then a researcher and now the
India and Pakistan, have a third legal gender today. director of the Thiel Gallery, answered that it would be a long
time before the queer perspective had become an organic
Heteronormativity part of the general mindset. “People are killed in broad day-
The norm is what we talk least about. Norms are often taken light for their sexual orientation, so the queer discussion is
for granted, even though they change, and therefore there is not over.” 7
always a risk of norm-blindness. Usually, we are only reminded

4 Bromseth, J. in Bromseth, J. & Darj, F. (eds) (2010). Normkritisk pedagogik: Makt, lärande och strategier för förändring. Centre for Gender Research. Uppsala.
5 The participants in the dialogues are listed in the sources above.
6 Dziurlikowska, M. “A Queer Teaches Here” – Interview with Anders Karnell and Patrik Steorn. Paletten No 4, 2006.
7 Dziurlikowska, M. “A Queer Teaches Here” – Interview with Anders Karnell and Patrik Steorn. Paletten No 4, 2006.
This is a vital point of departure for the active integration of The Swedish researchers Tina Mattsson and Sara Edenheim12
LGBTQ perspectives and other norm critical perspectives; as also emphasise that it is vital not to forget the power perspec-
long as there are groups in society who do not always feel tive when working with intersectionality as a broad concept.
welcome, and who are not always able to be open about who They have found that intersectionality is often used to examine
they are, we need to continue highlighting the perspectives the discriminating category, while making the normative cate-
and conditions of particular groups. Knowledge about others gory invisible.
breeds understanding – not only of others but of ourselves.
We exist in relation to each other. The more understanding museums have for humanity in all its
complexity, the better the interchange. The more museums
Norm criticism strive for understanding, openness and a welcoming attitude,
Norm is a term denoting the generally shared expectations the more important they will be as meeting places, and the
on behaviour that are embedded in a community or society. more people they will reach with their exhibitions and activi-
Being queer is to challenge the norm. Many Swedish muse- ties – and, conversely, be influenced by. However, if a museum
ums engage actively in relating to norms. The term museums wants to be for everybody, should everybody be invited at
often use to describe this practice and this approach is ‘norm once? Or is it better to welcome different sections of the pub-
criticism’. Another expression that has come into use is ‘norm lic on different occasions? Should the public be segregated
awareness’.8 It could be claimed that museums are political,9 or integrated? Is it possible to make room for everyone and
in the sense that they produce norms, values and images of everything at the same time?
society.
Crowded perspectives
A museum that consciously and actively works with norm-crit- There are obviously many different perspectives we need to
ical perspectives challenges not only the world, but itself consider when working with equal rights, equal treatment
first and foremost. Norm criticism can be naturally integrated and equal opportunities. We want to offer arts and culture
in the organisation and all its work processes, if it makes a to everyone. We want everyone to be able to experience the
conscious choice and works on it. Constant awareness and museums. And ‘everyone’ consists of differences. Our society
questioning requires courage. This can be awkward at first. is a formidable patchwork quilt of many colours, patterns and
But a museum where it becomes natural will often integrate structures.
LGBTQ perspectives as a matter of course, along with other
perspectives. To return to the question of focusing on the prerequisites of
one group or perspective at the expense of others, the answer
Intersectionality may be that the groups need not be mutually exclusive. Soci-
Different perspectives do not exist independently of each ety is already diversified, regardless of how we choose to
other. The LGBTQ perspectives coexist with other issues work and approach the issue, and the understanding of a
relating to identity, power and discrimination. These combi- group’s prerequisites can help to build bridges for under-
nations vary depending on the individual, group, context and standing other groups. We will probably need to take specific
situation. “Intersectionality” denotes a broad approach that measures for particular groups, at least until the day when
takes into account how different power structures are related the group in question has become the natural, thriving part of
to each other, and how identity is constructed. The word was society it deserves to be. Nevertheless, we must never disre-
coined in the late 1980s. It grew out of the second wave of gard the broader intersectional context, for that would be to
feminism, which introduced race and class as important ana- ignore the complexity of both society and the individual.
lytical dimensions in relation to gender.10 Today, further cate-
gories are often added to the concept, such as faith, age and At our dialogue meetings within the framework of this assign-
sexuality. ment, it came to light that many of the people engaged in
introducing LGBTQ perspectives in exhibitions and museums
“LGBTQ issues need to be analysed from an intersectional often encounter concerns and hesitation among colleagues
perspective,” said several of the participants in the dialogues and partners with regard to how to prioritise the many pos-
we organised, pointing to the importance of looking at all sible perspectives and groups. One participant stressed,
seven factors defined in the Discrimination Act. One vital however, that the plethora of perspectives must never be an
argument for why museums should have an intersectional excuse for not living up to human rights. “The alternative is
approach with multiple perspectives is that intolerance often invisibility and a return to the 1940s.” Perhaps we all sim-
focuses on more than one phenomenon.11 ply have to accept that we need a multitude of perspectives

8 Bromseth, J. & Darj, F. (eds) (2010). Normkritisk pedagogik: Makt, lärande och strategier för förändring. Centre for Gender Research. Uppsala.
9 Furumark, A. (ed.) (2013). Att störa homogenitet. Nordic Academic Press. Lund.
10 Puar, J. (2011). ‘I would rather be a cyborg than a goddess’ Intersectionality, Assemblage, and Affective Politics. European Institute for Progressive Cultural Policies.
Internet source: http://eipcp.net/transversal/0811/puar/en
11 Furumark, A. (ed.) (2013). Att störa homogenitet. Nordic Academic Press. Lund.
12 Swedish Secretariat for Gender Research. Intersektionalitet söker hem. 27 January, 2015. Accessed on 28 January, 2015.
http://genus.se/Aktuellt/nyheter/genusflodet/genusflodet-detalj//intersektionalitet-soker-hem.cid1262944

21
to make progress. Perhaps we should also stop seeing our to have attempted suicide at some point.13 These differences
well-intentioned efforts as a part of a zero-sum game. Maybe in health may be caused by exclusion and marginalisation,
progress for one group and one perspective can pave the way which, in turn, can derive from norms and attitudes in society.
for others. For us all. Museums could make a difference by showing the diversity
of sexual orientations, gender identities, gender expressions
Sometimes, a new square is added to the patchwork quilt. and ways of life – now and in the past. This should be done in
Sometimes, we step back and look at the how the pieces inte- ways that give people the opportunity to challenge prevailing
grate with the bigger picture. norms dictating that certain sexualities and gender identities
and expressions are more desirable and more entitled to exist
The role of museums than others. Being able to identify with the narratives about
In the course of writing the report, we have listened to ideas the lives of others is also essential. Heterosexuals and cis per-
regarding the obstacles to implementing LGBTQ perspec- sons (especially those who fit into the norms for functionality
tives at museums. Museum staff, and LGBTQ people who and skin colour) expect to be able to reflect themselves in the
have collaborated with museums, told us how they encoun- narratives presented in our museums. By also highlighting
tered various arguments from their staff against working with LGBTQ experiences and narratives, the museums can give
LGBTQ issues at the museum. We have also heard at least as more people the same opportunity to be reflected, build iden-
many thoughts and arguments in favour of featuring LGBTQ tities and feel a sense of community with others.
perspectives in the museums.
As several respondents pointed out in our meetings, LGBTQ
An obvious starting point would be the museums’ democratic perspectives at museums do not only concern LGBTQ peo-
assignment of serving all citizens. Another point of departure ple. Making gender and sexuality norms visible in museums
is that LGBTQ people in Sweden, despite their legal rights is just as much a matter of giving all people – regardless of
and the widespread social acceptance compared to many sexual orientation, gender identity and living conditions – the
other countries, nevertheless have poorer health than non-LG- opportunity to think about how these norms have changed,
BTQ people, according to surveys. Mental health problems and can change, and how they affect society and each and
and attempted or fatal suicide are over-represented among every one of us as individuals.
homo- and bisexuals. One in five transgender persons reports

13 Swedish National Institute of Public Health (FHI). Hälsa på lika villkor? – hälsa och livsvillkor bland hbtpersoner (FHI 2006:08).
23
CHAPTER 3

3. LGBTQ in Sweden and internationally


The status of LGBTQ issues in Sweden and combat discrimination on seven accounts: gender (including
internationally persons who have changed or are intending to change their
The situation for LGBTQ people varies considerably around biological gender), gender identity or gender expression, eth-
the world – politically and legally, and also socially and cul- nicity, religion or other belief, disability, sexual orientation, or
turally. In the countries that are the most advanced in promot- age. Although the Act exists to prohibit discrimination, we can
ing LGBTQ rights, same-sex marriages or partnerships are also choose to take active preventive measures against these
generally accepted, and LGBTQ people are protected by forms of discrimination.
anti-discrimination laws. Moreover, transgender persons are
also entitled in many countries to change their legal gender, If we look more closely at the development of LGBTQ rights,
and the law also ensures access to health care for transsex- they have been promoted by a strong activist movement and
uals. However, homosexuality is still classified as a disease political pressuring, which have contributed to creating aware-
and a criminal offence in many countries. The punishment for ness of issues and aspects that became recognised in legis-
the criminalised behaviour can vary depending on the coun- lation. Here are a few milestones in Swedish modern history:
try, ranging from prison and corporal punishment to capital 1944 Homosexual relations between adults was decriminal-
punishment, and some countries have laws against so-called ised.
“homosexual propaganda”. There are also considerable differ- 1972 Sweden became the first country in the world to offer
ences between countries with regard to how openly matters sexual reassignment treatment and a new legal gender.
of sexuality and gender identity can be discussed, and the 1979 The classification of homosexuality as a disease was
taboos surrounding the subject. Information on the situation abolished.
in specific countries is available, for instance, in the Swed- 1987 A law prohibiting discrimination against homosexuals
ish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and was introduced.
Queer Rights (RFSL) national reports.1 1995 Registered Partnership was granted.
1999 A Discrimination Act was introduced to prevent dis-
As mentioned, the Swedish Government’s strategy for equal crimination in working life on account of sexual orientation; an
rights and opportunities regardless of sexuality, gender identity ombudsman for issues of discrimination on grounds of sexual
or gender expression is based on the United Nations’ human orientation, HomO, was introduced.
rights conventions. Human rights are sometimes referred to as 2003 A law was introduced giving couples in registered
a Western phenomenon. Likewise, in some countries homo- partnerships the right to apply for adoption; also, a law was
sexuality is considered to be a Western phenomenon, and the passed granting equal rights to unmarried same-sex and het-
LGBT movement is viewed as a part of Western cultural col- erosexual couples living together.
onisation.2 However, although the concept of LGBT is funda- 2005 A law was introduced giving women living together the
mentally Western, same-sex sexual activities, and transgender right to assisted insemination.
identities and expressions are, of course, found throughout 2009 A gender-neutral law on marriage was introduced.
history and throughout the world. 2011 A prohibition against discrimination based on sexual ori-
entation was added to the Swedish Constitution.3
In addition to human rights, it is essential to highlight causes
of discrimination, and the legislation surrounding them. The Transgender rights are the most neglected area in need of
purpose of Sweden’s Discrimination Act 2008:567 is to more attention in the future. In 2009, transgender identity or

1 Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. RFSL:s landrapporter. Accessed on 28 January, 2015. http://www.rfsl.se/?p=2517
2 Swedish Federation for Lesbian, gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights (2008). Hbt i utveckling: en handbok om hbt-perspektiv i utvecklingssamarbete.
3 Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. Lagar: Milstolpar för hbt-personer i Sverige. Accessed on 28 January, 2015.
http://www.rfsl.se/?p=2840

25
expression was added to the areas covered by the Discrimi- We also asked in what areas the museum had introduced
nation Act. The same year, the National Board of Health and LGBTQ issues in the past or present. The diagram below
Welfare abolished its definition of transvestism as a disease.4 shows the result. The museums focus on LGBTQ issues
Although sex reassignment has been legal since 1972, the mainly in “exhibition activities/production and content” (72 per
requirement to undergo sterilisation was not abolished until cent), “events and programming activities” (68 per cent), and
2013. In January 2015, the government published its report “guided tours and visitor activities” (66 per cent).
on a minimum age for sex reassignment, proposing that the
minimum age for changing legal gender should be lowered Asked to assess the level of their museum’s knowledge and
from 18 to 12, if the guardians consent, and that applications skills in LGBTQ issues, 20 per cent replied excellent, 68 per
for change of legal gender can be made from the age of 15 cent replied basic, while 9 per cent considered their muse-
without parental consent. It also proposes that the previous um’s knowledge to be poor. 87 per cent stated that their
law be replaced with two new ones: a law on legal gender museum needed to improve its knowledge in LGBTQ issues.
change, and a law on sex reassignment surgery.5 We also asked about guidelines and policy documents. 26
per cent of the museums responded that they have guidelines
Local, regional and national conditions will, of course influ- or policy documents on LGBTQ issues that they would be
ence if and how museums and exhibitions include and pres- willing to share with the Swedish Exhibition Agency. 59 per
ent LGBTQ perspectives. In this chapter, we will study the cent had none, and 15 per cent did not know.
Swedish approach to LGBTQ perspectives, before moving on
to the status of LGBTQ perspectives in museums and exhibi- Our travels around Sweden, doing in-depth interviews with
tions internationally. people working with LGBTQ perspectives in museums, or with
exhibition and museum activities, has also given us a greater
LGBTQ in Swedish museums understanding of the obstacles and opportunities in this field.
In order to obtain a broad idea of Swedish museums’ attitudes Moreover, we learned more about the structure and content
to, and experiences of, working with LGBTQ perspectives, of such efforts. The results will be presented in more detail in
a telephone survey was performed within the framework of the next chapter, divided into various fields of museum activi-
the assignment. The Swedish Exhibition Agency developed a ties. In conclusion, the results of the telephone survey, shown
questionnaire that was used for telephone interviews. It was in the diagram above, corroborates our previous assumptions
done together with the company Exquiro, which performed and the conclusions we drew from our in-depth interviews and
the survey in May and June 2014. For more information on dialogue meetings. Below is a summary of our findings:
selection procedures and methods for this survey, we refer to
the report ‘Resultat av enkätsvar – Museerna och hbtq’, which There are some examples in Sweden of exhibitions on the
can be downloaded from the Swedish Exhibition Agency’s theme of LGBTQ perspectives. There are also examples
website.6 In short, 109 museums and organisations in Swe- where LGBTQ perspectives have been integrated with other
den were selected for the survey, including 27 national muse- perspectives in an exhibition. We found that LGBTQ perspec-
ums, 24 county and regional museums, and 58 municipal tives are highlighted in visitor activities and events, often as
or other museums/organisations of special interest. At each temporary initiatives, and in joint projects with external part-
respective institution, the person responsible for LGBTQ ners. The most common partnership seems to be with local
issues (or the person who would be, if the museum was not Pride organisations, when museums in different cities in
currently actively working on these issues) was contacted. Sweden offer Pride tours, workshops and discussions during
The response rate was 70 per cent, or 76 interviews. The a Pride festival. Pride tours are occasionally offered in con-
response rate was possibly higher among those organisations nection with temporary exhibitions. More commonly, however,
that were actively involved in LGBTQ work. a queer theory perspective is applied to existing permanent
exhibitions, or used to highlight parts of the collection that can
Asked whether their museum actively included LGBTQ issues be seen from a queer perspective.
in their operations, 82 per cent replied yes. 2 per cent said
no, but added that they had actively addressed LGBTQ per- So far, however, the work with queer perspectives at Swed-
spectives in the past. 16 per cent replied that they had never ish museums is temporary. The reason for this appears to be
worked actively with LGBTQ perspectives. 13 per cent were that they are dependent on enthusiastic individuals who pro-
planning to do so in the future, while 5 per cent had not worked mote these perspectives outside their regular duties at the
actively with LGBTQ issues in the past and had no plans to museum. The museums that have taken steps for a more long-
do so in the future. term and comprehensive integration of LGBTQ perspectives
stress that this needs to be given high priority by manage-

4 Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. Lagar: Milstolpar för hbt-personer i Sverige. Accessed on 28 January, 2015.
http://www.rfsl.se/?p=2840
5 Lundberg, A. Håll isär transbegreppen. SVT Opinion, 26 January, 2014. Accessed on 26 January, 2015.
6 Survey on behalf of Riksutställningar (2014). Results of survey on museums and LGBTQ.
What aspects of LGBTQ is your museum working on / has your museum worked on previously?
– Base: all respondents

In exhibition activities/
production and contents 72 9 18

In events/programmes 68 10 22

In guided tours and


visitor activities 66 8 26

In external communications, on our


website, and in marketing 45 11 37 8

To target LGBTQ people as 43 14 38 4


visitors

In international collaborations and 41


intercultural exchanges 6 50 2

In-house staff training 40 13 42 6

With existing objects


and collections 33 8 44 15

In collecting, documenting
and preservation 30 5 42 23

Recruitment
22 7 51 20

0 10 20 30 40
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 50 60 70 80 90 100
Currently Previously Never Don’t know
involved

The diagram shows a detailed presentation of various


LGBTQ-related activities on which the museums are
working or have been working previously.

27
ment. Time and resources are required, and the integration of In places where we could not find any museums engaging in
LGBTQ perspectives has to be an explicit priority. LGBTQ perspectives, we have instead sought out contempo-
rary artists who could contribute towards changing attitudes
Often, these perspectives are included in the overall norm by featuring queer perspectives in their art.
critical efforts. In order for this to be successful, the entire
staff should be involved, for instance through in-house train- Note that this report is by no means comprehensive. There are
ing, wide-ranging work on value systems, and policies. Both further examples all over the world. In Europe, we selected a
the museum directors and enthusiastic individuals we talked few countries with a high degree of activities in this field. Out-
to seemed to agree on this. Some directors doubt that it would side Europe, we have focused primarily on larger countries
be possible to get their entire staff to wholeheartedly engage (including Brazil, India and China), or countries where there
in this. But common ground can nevertheless be created, and was relevant information at hand (such as South Africa). As
the process kept alive. the approach to LGBTQ perspectives in the exhibitions area
needs to be seen in relation to the specific national context,
Altogether, Swedish museums today appear to be working we will start by giving a short description of the situation for
more actively on LGBTQ perspectives aimed at the public LGBTQ people in each respective country.
than internally. The question is, where should they start? The
reply we usually got in the course of this assignment, was Today, there are three established museums dedicated to
that work needs to be conducted simultaneously in minor and LGBTQ history in the world: Schwules Museum* in Berlin;
major areas, and step by step. the GLBT History Museum in San Francisco; and Museu da
Diversidade Sexual in São Paulo. In addition, there is the Les-
With regard to applying LGBTQ perspectives to objects lie Lohman Museum of Gay and Lesbian Art in New York City.
and collections, we found preliminary efforts at a few muse- Writing about the potential that is created by a museum such
ums in Sweden and internationally. These included collect- as the GLBT History Museum, Koskovich (2014) concludes
ing LGBTQ-related objects as a basis for future collections that: “By critically representing the stories of LGBT history in
– both physically and digitally. Others concerned reviews of the setting of a museum, we not only create a foundation for
catalogues and signs for existing collections, to establish to greater social acceptance today; we also help open the way
what extent, and how, these can be categorised to represent for LGBT and non-LGBT people alike to imagine a future of
the LGBTQ perspectives. This includes adding facts or nar- greater dignity and equality.”7
ratives that were previously ignored or suppressed. On the
whole, this has to be considered pioneering work that is both Join us in our meetings and discussions with these institutions,
interesting and relevant to monitor. and also with “mainstream museums”8 and artists around the
world!
Swedish society and Swedish museums have a considerable
potential for developing their approach to LGBTQ perspec- Australia
tives. From an international perspective, Sweden has made In Australia, the legal rights differ from one state to the next.
more progress in this field than many other countries. Swedish In general, same-sex partnerships have the same legal status
museums are also contributing by participating in international as heterosexual marriages. Gender identity and sexual orien-
collaborations that highlight LGBTQ perspectives. These tation are covered by the laws against discrimination since
projects demonstrate that we can share our attitude and our 2013. A court ruling gives legal support for a third gender,
knowledge with other countries, but also that we can learn and legislation regulating sex reassignment for transgender
best practices from the many examples and methods in other people is progressive.9 79 per cent of Australians believe that
parts of the world; we can especially learn from the courage homosexuality should be accepted in society.10
required by institutions and individuals who promote LGBTQ
issues and human rights in places where these matters are Several museums in Australia, especially in Sydney, have
more controversial than in Sweden. hosted a variety of temporary exhibitions and events on
LGBTQ themes. Like many examples from Sweden and other
LGBTQ in museums internationally countries, a number of these coincided with Pride festivals.
As part of the assignment, we have studied cases from all con- There is also a handful of cases where LGBTQ perspectives
tinents, with the purpose of finding examples of how museums had been applied to the collections. The national museum
and other exhibitors approach LGBTQ perspectives – alter- organisation has had an active LGBTQ network, which is now
natively, to understand why they refrain from doing so in cer- dormant.
tain countries – and to get a picture of the circumstances.

7 Koskovich, G. (2014). “Displaying the Queer Past: Purposes, Publics, and Possibilities at the GLBT History Museum”. QED: A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking 1.2 (2014): 61–78.
Michigan State University Press. p. 71.
8 With “mainstream” museums we refer to museums whose main objective is not to present LGBTQ perspectives – i.e. most museums.
9 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Australia. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Australia
10 PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
As in many other parts of the world, a large part of the LGBTQ that want to be better at integrating LGBTQ perspectives in
efforts in Australia were operated by LGBTQ organisations their activities. Their advice is to dare to let go of the norm as
themselves. There is no museum dedicated to the theme, but a starting point (white, heterosexual, male, and so on) and to
the Australian Lesbian & Gay Archive organises exhibitions embrace other audience sectors whenever possible. Another
and events. Efforts are also under way to start an LGBTQ recommendation is to think in terms of accessibility when pro-
museum in Sydney. It began as a pop up museum by LGBTQ moting diversity. One concrete example is to provide gender-­
activists at the Sydney Pride Festival in 2013, and funding is neutral toilets.15
now being sought in order to make this a more permanent
feature.11 India
In India homosexual acts were criminalised during British colo-
Brazil nial rule. The law was abolished in 2009, only to be reintro-
In several Latin American countries, a majority of the popula- duced in 2013, after extensive discussions.16 The nation has
tion believes that society should accept homosexuality; in Bra- a growing LGBTQ movement, with Pride festivals in the major
zil, for instance, 60 per cent think so.12 Same-sex couples can cities.17 Traditionally, in India and many other countries in south
marry and sex reassignment for transsexuals is a legal right.13 Asia, transgender people, hijras, who have been excluded and
São Paulo has one of the world’s largest Pride parades.14 stigmatised, live and organise themselves in separate commu-
nities.18 In 2014, India acknowledged a third legal gender for
São Paulo also has one of the world’s three existing muse- transgender people.19
ums devoted to LGBTQ history, Museu da Diversidade Sexual
(Museum of Sexual Diversity). Its target group is the LGBT Our search for Indian museums with an implemented LGBTQ
community and the general public. It opened fairly recently perspective was fruitless. Eventually, we came across QAMI,
and is currently formulating its future mission. This will include the Queer Arts Movement India, and interviewed the founder.
a plan for the expansion and management of the museum’s QAMI is a young network which was started in February 2014
collection. The museum is now producing exhibitions and and is based in Bangalore. Its purpose is to highlight queer
related activities. It is also highly visible in social media, in its artists publicly. To achieve this, QAMI arranges events where
attempts to build relations with the public. artists gain access to a forum where they can meet their audi-
ence. The activities so far have included poetry, dance and
Notable exhibitions include Diversidade Futebol Clube (Diver- music. They are also seeking to organise exhibitions of pho-
sity Football Club) in connection with the World Cup in 2014. tography and visual arts. We asked if they knew of any exhibi-
The current exhibition in 2014-15 is Todos Podem Ser Frida tions of queer art at museums in India. Their answer was no.
(Everyone Can Be Frida), a photographic exhibition of Camila QAMI’s founder believes that this is partly due to intolerance
Fontenele de Miranda, inspired by Frida Kahlo. An exhibition against subcultures, and partly because not enough queer art
in memory of the celebrated author Caio Fernando Abreu, 20 has been produced in India.20
years after he died of AIDS, is planned for 2016.
China
We asked what the advantages are of having a museum Life has become somewhat easier for LGBTQ people in
focused entirely on LGBTQ history. The answer was that its China in recent years. Gay clubs have opened in major cities.
key role is to highlight LGBT people who are made invisible Homosexuality is no longer classified as a disease.21 Today,
despite their contributions to the history of the community, or transgender people can obtain legal and medical sex reas-
obscured with regard to their sexual orientation and gender signment.22 LGBTQ perspectives, however, are far from a
identity. The museum’s mission is to shed light on the history given part of activities in China, where the regime chooses to
of these individuals, to provide a powerful instrument against censor films, books and websites that mention homosexuality.
prejudice and discrimination, and to help create a better soci-
ety based on respect for diversity and human rights. The way to changed attitudes could well go through activ-
ists and artists in China, according to Si Han, curator at the
We also asked what advice they could offer other museums Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities in Stockholm. When plan-

11 Vu Tuan Nguyen, doctoral student, Museum Studies. University of Sydney. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.
12 PewResearchCenter. (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
13 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Brazil. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Brazil
14 Gay Pride Brazil: São Paulo. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://www.gaypridebrazil.org/sao-paulo/
15 Franco Reinaudo, Executive Director. Museu da Diversidad Sexual, São Paulo. 5 January, 2015. Interview via e-mail.
16 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in India. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_India
17 Ghosal, S. Celebration of liberty: Rainbow groups gear up for pride parade. The Times of India. 11 July, 2012.
18 Khaleeli, H. Hijra: India’s third gender claims its place in law. The Guardian. 16 April, 2014.
19 BBC News India. India court recognises transgender people as third gender. 15 April, 2014. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-27031180
20 Masoom Mohammed Hanif Parmar, Co-Founder. Queer Arts Movement India. 28 January, 2015. Interview via e-mail/Facebook.
21 Levine, J. In China, LGBT citizens seek acceptance. CNN. 28 June, 2013. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://edition.cnn.com/2013/06/27/world/asia/china-gay-lesbian-marriage/
22 Sun, N. Shanxi Permits Transgender Persons to Change Gender Information. All-China Women’s Federation. 9 January, 2014. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://www.womenofchina.cn/womenofchina/html1/news/china/16/8827-1.htm

29
ning the exhibition Secret Love, which opened in 2012, he consisted of several parts. One of these was called Pride
spent two years studying the uncharted terrain of contempo- and featured powerful photographic art by Lill-Ann Chep-
rary Chinese art incorporating queer perspectives. The exhi- stow-Lusty28 accompanied by descriptions of homosexual
bition was created through building relationships and trust. rights from 1972 to the present day.
Since NGOs are permitted in the health sector, he found a
channel through the activists engaged with AIDS-related Poland
issues. In this way, he made contact with Chinese artists, who, Poland stands out in our study as the only EU country where
in turn, shared their networks generously. He met with some more people answered no than yes to the question of whether
40 artists and was eventually able to select 150 works with society should accept homosexuality – 46 per cent compared
queer perspectives. Most of the featured artists experienced to 42 per cent.29 Although homosexuality was never against
it to be an important recognition to be exhibited by a Swed- the law in Poland, same-sex couples do not have the same
ish national museum. Only two artists declined because they legal rights as heterosexual couples. There are legal and med-
were hesitant about taking part in an exhibition with a distinct ical opportunities for sex reassignment.30
LGBTQ theme. In China, people do not yet feel comfortable
discussing art from a queer theory perspective. A crucial One of the few major exhibitions in the world on an LGBTQ
effect of this project was that the participating artists from theme at a national museum was shown in Poland: Ars Homo
all over China got to know each other. It also opened the way Erotica 31 in Warsaw in 2010. Ars Homo Erotica is the only
for Swedish students and activists seeking collaborations in large exhibition on such a theme ever in Eastern Europe. Prior
China. Secret Love is shown in Amsterdam in 2015.23 to its opening, a handful of art galleries in Poland had hosted
explicitly LGBTQ-themed exhibitions. Ars Homo Erotica was
Norway curated by Dr Pawel Leszkowicz and filled nearly half of the
Norway was the first country in the world to adopt an anti-dis- museum’s exhibition space with 200 works spanning from
crimination law that protects homosexuals. Marriage and ancient to contemporary art. It was made possible partly
adoption has been legal for committed same-sex couples thanks to the then museum director Piotr Piotrowski’s vision of
since 2009, and artificial insemination is available for lesbi- a museum to reflect important social issues, and by a curator
ans. Norway in general is characterised by liberal attitudes to who was experienced in and committed to these questions.
LGBTQ people.24 The exhibition got wide media attention, in Poland and interna-
tionally. It sparked disputes in Poland and was a contributing
In recent years, a few interesting LGBTQ-themed exhibi- factor to the museum director’s subsequent resignation. Nev-
tions have been held in Norway. We visited Oslo to find out ertheless, Leszkowicz claims that the exhibition contributed
more. The Natural History Museum in Oslo offered the public to making queer culture mainstream and less controversial in
something new in 2006, when the exhibition Against Nature? Poland.
opened. This exhibition showed that homosexuality is natural
and occurs frequently in the animal kingdom.25 The UK
76 per cent of the population in the UK are of the opinion that
The Intercultural Museum, which is part of the Museum of society should accept homosexuality.32 Same-sex marriage is
Oslo, engages actively in highlighting the situation for minority permitted (except in Northern Ireland, which has partnership
groups. The project Si meg hvem du elsker... (Tell me who you laws). Legal and medical sex reassignment is available for
love...) from 2009 attempted to discuss what it involves to live transgender people.33
as a homosexual – or a heterosexual, for that matter. Photos
and personal stories were collected in an anthology and a film. Many interesting LGBTQ-related activities are pursued at
The purpose of the book and film was partly to encourage museums in the UK. We asked ourselves why this was so.
discussions, and partly to create material with high mobility.26 Richard Sandell,34 professor of Museum Studies at the Uni-
versity of Leicester, explains that efforts to increase diversity
In 2014, the Museum of Cultural History27 in Oslo celebrated are deeply ingrained in the profession at British museums. The
the 200th anniversary of the Norwegian constitution with the background for this lies in the museums’ active involvement
exhibition Ja, vi elsker frihet (Yes, we love freedom), which in ‘audience development’ – engendered by the 1990s arts

23 Si Han, curator. Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities. 20 January, 2015. Telephone interview.
24 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Norway. Accessed on 12 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Norway
25 Petter Bøckman, assistant professor, Geir Søli, senior assistant teacher, Arild Johnsen, professor, Cecilie Webb head of department. Naturhistorisk museum. Oslo. 15 October,
2014. Interview in Oslo.
26 Ingrid Szük-Hanson, project coordinator, Daniella Wennberg, head of department. Interkulturelt Museum, Oslo Museum. 14 October, 2014. Interview in Oslo.
27 Tone Cecilie Simensen Karlgård, museum lecturer. Exhibitions and visitors section. Kulturhistorisk museum, Oslo University (KHM). 13 October, 2014. Interview in Oslo.
28 Lill-Ann Chepstow-Lusty, Senior Engineer. Exhibitions and visitors section. Kulturhistorisk museum, Oslo University (KHM). 16 October, 2014. Interview in Oslo.
29 PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
30 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Poland. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Poland
31 Pawel Leszkowicz, PhD, curator Ars Homo Erotica. Poland. 14 June, 2015. Interview via e-mail.
32 PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
33 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in the United Kingdom. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_the_United_Kingdom
34 Richard Sandell, Professor of Museum Studies. University of Leicester. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.
policy and aimed at making the arts accessible to everyone. ern38, Queer Britannia was a huge popular success – a pres-
It involves reaching out, welcoming and establishing rela- entation of works from the museum collection from an LGBTQ
tionships with new audiences. It also includes maintaining perspective. The Victoria & Albert Museum (V&A)39 has also
long-term relationships with existing audiences. The diversity been successful with its events and exhibitions on LGBTQ
efforts gained even more momentum with the introduction of themes. A project has also begun at the V&A, looking at the
the new anti-discrimination law, the Equality Act, in 2010. collections from an LGBTQ perspective.

As in Sweden, we found that LGBTQ issues at museums South Africa


were promoted primarily by enthusiasts. Audience develop- Homosexuality is illegal in many parts of the African continent,
ment and anti-discrimination laws serve as tools and motiva- and LGBTQ rights are hard to promote. South Africa is the
tional factors in their work. Some museums, however, focus most progressive African country, and 32 per cent of South
regularly on LGBTQ issues, and in some cases even incor- Africans replied that homosexuality should be accepted in
porate them continuously in their programmes. Some major society. In countries such as Nigeria, Ghana and Kenya, the
museums have an LGBTQ network in-house. Moreover, there corresponding percentage was between 1 and 8.40 LGBTQ
is an active nationwide LGBTQ network for museum staff. people obtained legal rights in South Africa in connection
As in other countries, special projects are launched in con- with the new constitution that was adopted after the apart-
nection with Pride festivals, but the UK also has a Gay and heid regime was ousted. However, activists describe South
Lesbian History Month35, which is celebrated in February and African culture as conservative, patriarchal and religious, and
acknowledged by many museums. practices such as ‘corrective rapes’41 of lesbian women occur.

In addition to programme activities at some museums, there GALA42 is a seemingly unique South African organisation.
are examples in the UK of temporary exhibitions on LGBTQ GALA stands for ‘Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action’ and
themes. Moreover, there are a few cases of database catego- was started in 1997 to raise awareness of LGBTQ rights. One
risation and “queering the collections”. There also some work way is to promote LGBTQ perspectives through the country’s
on finding and exhibiting queer objects and stories in the col- museums.
lections. However, Professor Sandell says that it is still possi-
ble to visit most museums in the UK without seeing any traces So far, GALA has produced three touring exhibitions. The first
of anything LGBTQ-related. Sweden and the UK differ with was Balancing Act: South African Gay and Lesbian Youth
regard to the type of content that can be shown. In the UK, Speak Out; the second was Home Affairs: About Love, Family
museums are considerably more cautious about displaying and Relationships; and the third was Jo’burg Tracks: Sexuality
material that can be perceived as not being “family-friendly”, in the City, which was shown for three years at Museum Africa
and exhibitions with LGBTQ perspectives are occasionally in Johannesburg, while the former two were originally exhib-
considered controversial. ited at the Apartheid Museum, before going on tour. In 2015,
an exhibition is being produced together with the Apartheid
In June 2014, a conference on The Un-Straight Museum was Museum on the theme of religion and homosexuality. GALA’s
held at the Museum of Liverpool, in connection with the muse- greatest success so far was to be invited to develop part of
um’s work on an exhibition about April Ashley and the his- the basic exhibition on human rights at the Apartheid Museum.
tory of transgender people in the UK. The conference also This is the first time anything of the kind has taken place in an
attracted international participants. African national museum.

Alongside Liverpool, London stands out for its museums with We asked Anthony Manion, director of GALA, about what
in LGBTQ-related activities. The exhibition Gay Icons at the they had learned about touring LGBTQ exhibitions, and what
National Portrait Gallery in 2009 is regarded as a starting the key to success is. He replied that there is a need for staff
signal for the incorporation of LGBTQ perspectives – at this training at the host museum prior to the exhibition opening,
and other museums in the city. The National Portrait Gallery36 particularly the museum guides. They often organise prepara-
today has a continuous LGBTQ programme. When organis- tory workshops. It is important that the museum staff are on
ing events, they often cooperate with artists such as Sadie board and that they feel that they own the exhibition. Aware-
Lee and Tim Redfern, who have wide networks in the LGBTQ ness-raising and improved vocabulary are also vital to being
community that the museum wants to attract. At Tate Mod- able to answer questions and deal with any disturbances.

35 A national history month dedicated to LGBT history.


36 Thomas Knowles, Learning Services Assistant. Fiona Smith, Adult Programmes Officer. National Portrait Gallery. London. 21 October, 2014. Interview in London.
37 Tim Redfern, performer and museum consultant. 20 October, 2014. Interview in London.
38 Marcus Dickey Horley, Curator of Access Projects. Tate Modern. 22 October, 2014. Interview in London.
39 Zorian Clayton, Assistant Curator of Prints. Victoria & Albert Museum. 23 October, 2014. Interview in London.
40 PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
41 Human Rights Watch (2011). “We’ll Show You You’re a Woman”, Violence and Discrimination against Black Lesbians and Transgender Men in South Africa.
42 Anthony Manion, Director, Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA), South Africa. 15 December, 2014. Skype/telephone interview.

31
Germany
LGBTQ people in Germany have roughly the same legal rights pants together to discuss LGBTQ perspectives. The AAM’s
as in Sweden, with same-sex marriage, anti-discrimination network for LGBTQ issues, the LGBTQ Alliance, worked hard
laws and the right to sex reassignment.43 87 per cent of the in 2014 to formulate a proposal on how LGBTQ perspectives
population replied that society should accept homosexuality.44 and LGBTQ practices could be incorporated in the AAM’s
In 2013, Germany was the first European country to introduce standardised guidelines.49 The proposals range from more
a third legal sex.45 The capital, Berlin, has a history as a refuge welcoming approaches to LGBTQ staff, to how the museum
for LGBTQ people, not least in the 1920s, and has long had a can reach out to the LGBTQ community.
highly active LGBTQ movement.
San Francisco has long had a large contingent of LGBTQ
The Schwules Museum* in Berlin is the world’s first museum people, which has influenced the city’s cultural scene. We
of LGBTQ history. Michael Fürst at the Schwules Museum* chose to visit this city, since we assumed that this impacted
describes it as something in between a political institution and on how museums in the region worked. San Francisco also
a museum. In the early 1980s when the museum opened, it has one of the world’s three museums of LGBTQ history:
required courage to turn ideas into reality. It all began with the The GLBT History Museum. The museum was founded by
production of the Eldorado exhibition in 1984. Activists con- the GLBT Historical Society and officially opened in January
tacted Märkisches Museum with a proposal to create an exhi- 2011. It offers permanent and temporary exhibitions and has a
bition on homosexuality. The museum was favourable to the busy calendar of events.
idea. When the museum received hate mail and lost its spon-
sors, the director responded by providing even more exhibi- Our visits to the GLBT History Museum,50 the Yuerba Buena
tion space for the project. The exhibition was a success and Center for the Arts51 and the Cartoon Art Museum52 showed
the actual starting point for Schwules Museum, which was that they had one distinct feature in common: They have all
founded in 1985. Since 2004, it features an exhibition show- developed a highly advanced capacity to reach out to, coop-
ing 200 years of homosexual history. The museum also hosts erate with, and organise visitor activities for specific target
temporary exhibitions and is an important centre for documen- groups in the local community. The Yuerba Buena Center for
tation, research and communication relating to LGBTQ his- the Arts, for instance, engages with the local Latina transgen-
tory. A large share of the work is done by volunteers. In spring der community, among other groups, rather than addressing
2015, the major exhibition Homosexuality _ies, produced the LGBTQ community in general.
jointly by Schwules Museum* and Deutsches Historisches
Museum, will be shown at both museums simultaneously.46 The Leslie Lohman Museum of Gay and Lesbian Art is located
in New York. It is run by the Leslie Lohman Gay Art Founda-
The US tion, a non-profit foundation which was started in 1987, and
In USA, there are both large cities with immense freedom and has been at its current premises in Soho since 2006. In 2011,
tolerance, and other areas with more conservative attitudes to it was officially declared a museum, and thus became the
gender and sexuality. This is manifested, for instance, in opin- world’s first museum dedicated to LGBTQ art. Its mission is
ion polls and surveys: 60 per cent of Americans believe that to preserve and exhibit LGBTQ art, and to assist artists who
homosexuality should be accepted in society, while 33 per create LGBTQ art. Today, its collection comprises more than
cent say that it should not. This can be compared to Canada, 22,000 objects. The museum features six to eight exhibitions
where 80 per cent were in favour of acceptance.47 The legal per year, screens movies, organises lectures, panel discus-
rights for LGBTQ people also vary from state to state; same- sions, poetry readings and public talks with guest curators
sex marriage is permitted in a majority of states, but less than and artists.
half have anti-discrimination laws that cover LGBTQ people.48
The director of the Leslie Lohman Museum, Hunter O’Ha-
In the course of our study, we visited museums and met nian53, describes the purpose of the museum as threefold: To
museum professionals and other exhibitors in San Francisco, show art that appeals to the LGBT community, that has a high
New York City and Seattle. We also attended in the 2014 aesthetic value, and that is normally rejected by “mainstream”
annual conference of the American Alliance of Museums museums. O’Hanian claims that mainstream museums all too
(AAM), where several items on the agenda brought partici- often hide the truth instead of talking about a person’s sexu-

43 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Germany. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Germany


44 PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
45 SVT Nyheter. I dag erkände Tyskland tredje kön. 4 November, 2013. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://www.svt.se/nyheter/varlden/i-dag-erkanner-tyskland-tredje-kon
46 Michael Fürst. Schwules Museum*. 14 June, 2014. Interview in Liverpool.
47 PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
48 Wikipedia. LGBT rights in the United States. Accessed on 1 February, 2015. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_the_United_States
49 Annette M. Gavigan and Renae Youngs. The LGBTQ Alliance, The American Alliance of Museums (AAM). 21 May, 2014. Interview in Seattle.
50 Jeremy Prince, operations manager, Elisabeth Cornu, board member and museum advisor. GLBT History Museum. 6 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
51 Kathy Budas, Marketing & Communications Director, Joël Tan, Director of Community Engagement, Betti-Sue Hertz, Director of Visual Arts. Yerba Buena Center for the Arts.
5 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
52 Summerlea Kashar, Executive Director. Cartoon Art Museum. 5 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
ality when it does not comply with the norm. As an example, memory of his artist colleague and lover Peter Hujar, who had
he mentions the Whitney Museum of American Art’s exhibi- died of AIDS-related illnesses in 1987 – be removed from
tion Paul Thek: Diver, a Retrospective from 2010, where they the show. The museum management gave in to pressure and
refrained from mentioning that the legendary artist Thek was removed the work.55
bisexual, and that he died of AIDS-related complications in
1988, aged 54. Since the purpose of museums is to educate, In reaction to the museum’s act of censorship, and the silence
this should be done earnestly and honestly, says O’Hanian. of other museums, Ryan decided to issue an invitation to a
Asked how he would act if he were the director of a main- show in the Brooklyn loft where he was living. The opening
stream museum, he replies that he would instruct the curators was on 14 January, 2014, and friends and acquaintances
that sexual orientation is a relevant fact to present in the exhi- exhibited works on LGBTQ themes. More than 300 visitors
bitions, and he would also occasionally have LGBTQ-themed had welled into the apartment to see the show, before the
exhibitions, and works on the programme of events to intro- police turned up and closed down the event.
duce LGBTQ perspectives, through film screenings, lectures But Ryan was thirsting for more. He was tired of waiting for
and panel discussions. the mainstream museums to break through their homopho-
bia. He wanted to create a place where queers could share
The Pop-Up Museum of Queer History queer history, as told by other queers. Going from word to
It’s an overcast, rainy day in May 2014. I am making my way action, he launched the Pop-Up Museum of Queer History.
along the crowded pavements of Harlem, New York City. I The exhibitions and other events rely on collaborations with
have an appointment with Hugh Ryan, founder of the Pop-Up local LGBTQ communities, and partnerships with whoever
Museum of Queer History. Our meeting is inspiring and con- can provide a venue. The latest show took place at the New
tinues to generate ideas. My talk with Ryan doesn’t end there. York Public Library. The popularity of these events continues.
It is still ongoing.54 The main disadvantage of a pop-up museum without a build-
ing, according to Ryan, is that they can’t build a collection.
The Pop-Up Museum of Queer History is exactly that – a The works and other objects return to the respective artists
pop-up museum. Born out of frustration, it was catapulted into when the show ends.
public success from the start and continues to create exhibi-
tions and events that are audience-magnets, without its own The Pop-Up Museum of Queer History is now working on for-
premises or any real resources. This pop-up museum is run mulating its concept. The idea is to spread the model to people
by volunteers. in other parts of the world who want to host a pop-up museum
of queer history. The principles and guidelines include ideas
It all began with the anger over events in connection with the on how to relate to history, stressing that history is a question,
Hide/Seek exhibition at the National Portrait Gallery in Wash- not an answer. If you are unaware that you have a history, it
ington in late 2010. This was an exhibition about homosex- is hard to believe that you have a future. Queer people are
ual love and was considered to be courageous, important, not the only ones whose history is full of misunderstandings.
and the first of its kind. But Catholics and other conservative The first step towards understanding history is to really see it.
groups were incensed and demanded that David Wojnarow- When we discover our own history and share it with others,
icz’s video work “A Fire in My Belly” – which he had made in we will realise that history is a constructed reality.56

53 Hunter O’Hanian, Museum Director. Leslie-Lohman Museum of Gay and Lesbian Art. 15 May, 2015. Interview in New York.
54 Hugh Ryan, Founding Director. The Pop-Up Museum of Queer History. 16 May, 2014. Interview in New York.
55 Gopnik, B. National Portrait Gallery bows to censors, withdraws Wojnarowicz video on gay love. 30 November, 2010. Column, The Washington Post.
56 Ryan, H. (2014). Notes on the Pop-Up Museum of Queer History. QED: A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking 1.2 (2014). Michigan State University Press.

33
CHAPTER 4

4. The development of LGBTQ perspectives in


museums
Revealing Queer
On 14 February, 2014, the exhibition Revealing Queer opened activities. In particular, the study focuses on exhibitions, visitor
at the Museum of History and Industry, MOHAI, in Seattle. activities and programmes, collections, internally in the organ-
In May 2014, we took the opportunity to see the results of isation and in external collaborations. Examples have been
the museum’s efforts to create this presentation of Seattle’s selected from projects at museums in Sweden and interna-
LGBTQ history. Erin Bailey1, who had been hired to curate tionally. The purpose is not to provide a comprehensive report.
and manage the project, gave the process the working title
‘Queering the Museum’. She opted to consult closely with the This chapter also discusses aspects that appear to be more or
community, to capture and give life to their stories. As a result, less successful in the interviewees’ experiences of integrating
people are now donating objects to the museum, whose col- LGBTQ perspectives with museum activities. It should also
lection of LGBTQ artefacts is growing. Objects include cloth- be noted that these different parts of the activities can some-
ing, such as biker jackets, posters from gay clubs, newspapers times be hard to distinguish from each other, since they are
and magazines, etc. Baily tells us that the museum in general mutually dependent in the same working process. The exhibi-
is changing in the process of creating this show; today, they tion at MOHAI in Seattle, described above is one example of
give more consideration to what groups and perspectives are this; the exhibition project impacted on the museum’s internal
absent in their exhibitions and collections. Their collaboration knowledge and priorities, and their approach to collecting,
with civil society has developed. collaborating and activities for visitors and programmes.

In late December 2014, the project and its impact on the Exhibitions
museum, and on Seattle at large, is summarised. It is noted There are many ways to make LGBTQ perspectives visible
that the exhibition built capacity for the museum, and con- in exhibitions. It is essential to include previously invisible
tributed to the LGBTQ community. Among other things, King groups, and this is often welcomed by groups who have felt
County made 14 February – the opening day of the exhibi- unrepresented by an institution. Occasionally, however, we
tion, its official LGBTQ history day. The museum noted a 17 have come across individuals and institutions with a longer
percent increase in activity on its digital channels and 2,405 experience of working with LGBTQ perspectives, who are in
new followers in social media, in addition to lively traffic on a position to look critically at their own previous exhibitions.
Twitter and Instagram. While the exhibition was on, an initi- In hindsight, they find that they have sometimes spoken for
ative was taken to actively expand the museum’s collection people, rather than allowing them to speak for themselves.
of LGBTQ-related objects. LGBTQ-related events attracted In some cases, they realise that they have contributed to
1,000 participants over the year. The museum continues to reproducing stereotypical images of certain groups. This is
reach out to the LGBTQ community with public events on a learning process that requires being open to criticism and
queer themes.2 prepared to start over. Sharing one’s experiences is a way of
helping one another to move forward.

In this chapter, we give a detailed account of what we found With regard to LGBTQ perspectives in exhibitions, we found
through our discussions and interviews with museums on how that LGBTQ perspectives are featured and integrated in differ-
they integrate LGBTQ perspectives into various parts of their ent ways. A show can target an audience that already has an

1 Erin Bailey, Curator of “Revealing Queer”, Museum of History and Industry (MOHAI), Seattle. 21 May, 2014. Interview in Seattle.
2 Queering the Museum. 2014 has come and gone, now what? 29 December, 2014. Accessed on 9 January, 2015. http://queeringthemuseum.org/

35
awareness, or the general public. Often, however, it needs to of the organisation’s activities and processes. The Maritime
have an address that includes both those with previous knowl- Museum & Aquarium now includes queer narratives in its
edge and those who are encountering these perspectives for basic exhibition. It is a feature in the overall historiography of
the first time. One example of the latter was the above-men- Gothenburg as a seafaring city.8
tioned exhibition at MOHAI in Seattle. Since it presents the
city’s queer history, it is relevant to everyone. Other Swedish examples of how LGBTQ perspectives were
integrated naturally in exhibitions on other themes are Swed-
Creating an LGBTQ-themed temporary exhibition is a good ish Sin at the Museum of Spirits9, and an exhibition about
way for a museum to improve its expertise in this field. Virtually breast-feeding at the Museum of Work in Norrköping. The
any kind of museum can produce an exhibition on an LGBTQ men raising their glasses in the pictures at the Museum of
theme. In October 2006, the Natural History Museum in Oslo3 Spirits are not all heterosexual, and not only heterosexual
opened its exhibition Against Nature?, on the theme of homo- women are shown breast-feeding at the Museum of Work. By
sexuality in the animal kingdom. Based on scientific observa- integrating the voices of diverse LGBTQ people, and diverse
tions, they demonstrated how homosexuality is found naturally LGBTQ perspectives, a broader and more nuanced picture is
among many species. In this way, the museum was contrib- given of what it entails to be LGBTQ. In this way, the exhibition
uting towards dedramatising homosexuality. The exhibition represents and reflects society more adequately.
was on for just under a year. The museum had not anticipated
the huge public success it was, attracting attention from both The permanent Viking exhibition at the National Historical
Norwegian and international media. Museum in Stockholm also integrates LGBTQ perspectives
naturally. The display has been reviewed and processed from
Occasionally, LGBTQ perspectives are included as part of an a norm critical perspective, focusing especially on gender.
exhibition on a broader theme. One example is the exhibition The queer perspective is present especially in the presenta-
JAG identitet – makt – sexualitet (SELF identity – power – tion of Odin. This leader of the Asa gods is the epitomy of
sexuality) at Sundsvalls museum in June-September 2014. male strength. But he also engaged in sorcery together with
This was an interdisciplinary, norm-critical exhibition featuring his wife Freya and the norns. Sorcery was considered to be a
eight artists, along with selected works from the museum’s female occupation, and he was thus combining his masculine
art collection, on the theme of ‘Who am I?’. Among the explo- energies with feminine.10
rations of the borderland between identity, power structures
and sexuality, the queer perspective was naturally represented Sometimes, the museums simply need to look more closely at
in some of the works. One transgender person who was por- what they already have. Art museums with collections span-
trayed in a photograph in the show held a spontaneous, mov- ning several historic eras will inevitably have queer perspec-
ing speech at the opening; one effect of creating visibility.4 tives in many of their works, whether or not they are aware
of it. Queer theory perspectives and awareness are required
If a museum has already made considerable progress in inte- in order to utilise these assets. We will talk more about this
grating LGBTQ perspectives, these may already be present in below, in the sections on visitor activities and collections.
one way or another in all exhibitions, regardless of the over-
all theme or purpose. It is still rare, however, that a museum An inclusive and broad LGBTQ perspective when producing
has come this far in incorporating these perspectives, but the exhibitions does not necessarily mean working with all groups
issue is being raised by an increasing number of institutions. and perspectives at once. Instead, the institution can strive for
The Yerba Buena Center for the Arts in San Francisco5 has diversity over time, or in relation to what aspects of society the
come a long way in the inclusion of LGBTQ perspectives as a museums reflect. Occasionally, additional focus is required on
natural part of all their exhibitions, be they about local artists or perspectives that have previously been neglected. The GLBT
Indian contemporary art. The museum does not produce sep- History Museum in San Francisco11 collaborates with a vari-
arate LGBTQ exhibitions, claiming that they have transcended ety of local groups when producing exhibitions about differ-
“exhibiting identity”. ent parts of the LGBTQ community. Bisexuals and LGBTQ
In Sweden, the Maritime Museum & Aquarium6 in Gothenburg people with roots in the Asian Pacific region are two groups
and the Museum of Work7 in Norrköping stand out as insti- whose perspectives have been highlighted in exhibitions in
tutions where norm criticism is implemented in many parts 2014. Their stories were previously missing in the museum.

3 Petter Bøckman, assistant professor, Geir Søli, senior assistant teacher, Arild Johnsen, professor, Cecilie Webb head of department. Naturhistorisk museum. Oslo. 15 October,
2015. Interview in Oslo.
4 Daniel Unnis, head of exhibitions and events. Sundsvalls museum. 5 September, 2014. Interview in Sundsvall.
5 Kathy Budas, Marketing & Communications Director, Joël Tan, Director of Community Engagement, Betti-Sue Hertz, Director of Visual Arts. Yerba Buena Center for the Arts.
5 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
6 Emma Having, head of exhibitions and learning. Maritime Museum & Aquarium. 3 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
7 Johanna Övling, ethnologist, Marinette Fogde, research manager. Museum of Work. 9 April, 2014. Interview in Umeå.
8 Linda Noreen, Exhibitions & Learning. Maritime Museum & Aquarium. 5 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
9 Nadja Karlsson, head of tastings. Museum of Spirits. 3 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
10 Li Kolker, events manager, Lotta Fernstål, chief antiquarian, early Iron Age. JÄMUS project, National Historical Museum. 23 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
11 Jeremy Prince, operations manager, Elisabeth Cornu, board member and museum advisor. GLBT History Museum. 6 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
Since LGBTQ people can have several simultaneous identi- reported by transgender people, they approached the museum
ties, and sometimes combine several norm-challenging iden- with a proposal for cooperation, where the museum would
tities, they run the risk of dual invisibility. This has been pointed serve as a “safe place” where hate crimes could be reported.
out by Swedish organisations such as Blattequeers12 in Altogether, the exhibition drew large audiences and boosted
Stockholm, Gays In Angered (for young LGBTQs in the Goth- the museum’s PR immensely.
enburg suburb Angered, and Homan (for Muslim LGBTQs in
Gothenburg), and it is also highlighted in the Queering Sápmi Other groups under the rainbow flag are also appealing to be
project, which is now a touring exhibition. The production of heard, including I for Intersexual, GQ for Genderqueer, and A
Queering Sápmi had an impact far beyond the exhibition itself, for Asexual. The list keeps growing, and it can sometimes be
since this was the first time queer Sápmi people organised. It practical to use the terms sexual orientation, gender identity,
also triggered the world’s first Pride festival arranged by an and gender expression, and to look at the norms themselves
indigenous people. around gender and sexuality. The Swedish National Museum
of World Culture (Världskulturmuseet) used this approach,
Bisexuals, transgender people and queers have been fight- for instance, in its forthcoming exhibition Playground, which
ing for increased visibility both within the LGBTQ movement seeks playfully to encourage secondary and upper second-
and in society, ever since the advancement of gay and lesbian ary school classes to reflect on norms, regardless of gender
rights. This is also evident in the range of exhibitions, and an identity, expression or sexual orientation. Similarly, the Royal
influence on museums. In response to external pressure, fol- Armoury in Stockholm based its exhibition on Queen Chris-
lowed by internal discussions, for instance, queer and trans- tina16 on norms relating to gender and sexuality, rather than
gender perspectives have been increasingly included at the on contemporary terms used to describe different identities.
Schwules Museum* in Berlin and the Leslie Lohman Museum
of Gay and Lesbian Art in New York. At Schwules Museum*, People with long experience of working with LGBTQ perspec-
the added asterisk after the name symbolises an active stand tives in the museum sector stress the importance of moving
on including more groups and perspectives beyond gays on from temporary exhibitions on LGBTQ to integrated work.
(“schwules”). In Montreal, Canada, the first exhibition of art Richard Sandell17, professor of Museum Studies at the Univer-
exclusively by transgender persons opened in 2014. The sity of Leicester says that one of the major obstacles to diver-
curator, Ianna Book13, says that the queer and transgender sity efforts at museums in general is that they are insufficiently
movements are beginning to have an effect on institutions integrated with the everyday operation. A project is completed
but that transgender issues are not yet represented in Cana- and then they move on to the next issue. He emphasises the
dian institutions. In Sweden, the transgender perspective has importance of starting with simple solutions, interweaving dif-
been featured in a couple of smaller specific shows, and was ferent perspectives in all the museum’s activities. Small alter-
included in exhibitions that highlight the norms around gender ations, from new wall texts to occasional objects in existing
and sexuality. exhibitions, can have a strong and effective impact with time.

The Museum of Liverpool’s14 exhibition on the transgender One of our respondents18 told us about his strongest LGBTQ
icon April Ashley, which includes the history of the transgen- experience from a museum visit. The permanent exhibition at
der movement in the UK and a multitude of voices from local the Museum included a machine used for “electro aversion
transgender individuals, is perhaps the largest venture to date therapy”. The wall text explicitly explained what behaviour the
presenting transgender perspectives both to a broad audi- electric shocks were used for. Sometimes a simple measure
ence and to people who identify as transgender. The exhibition can be enough to add new perspectives.
was created in partnership with local LGBTQ and transgen-
der organisations. A close collaboration between the museum There are also a few examples of museums that have created
and LGBTQ organisations/groups is often mentioned as “trails” – describing and labelling objects and works in the
being vital to a successful exhibition that manages to deliver a exhibition from an LGBTQ perspective, which visitors can
nuanced and many-sided picture of the group or perspective choose to follow if they want. The British Museum in London
it portrays. Moreover, the exhibition is a testimony to the fact has one, and the Walker Art Gallery in Liverpool is develop-
that museums that address these issues can have a direct ing its own. An alternative to trails may be guided city tours
impact on society. The exhibition instructs visitors to contact beyond the museum walls. In association with the University
the police if they have been victims of hate crimes. When the and local LGBTQ organisations, the Amsterdam Museum has
police noted a sharp increase in the number of hate crimes developed a city walk app called PinkPerspectives.

12 Emilia Mirani. Blattequeers. 24 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.


13 Ianna Book, artist / curator “Trans Time” exhibition, Montreal. 1 December, 2014. Interview via e-mail.
14 Kay Jones, Curator of Community History. Museum of Liverpool. 14 June, 2014. Interview in Liverpool.
15 Bianca Leidi, exhibition producer. National Museums of World Culture. 29 January, 2015. Telephone interview.
16 Malin Grundberg, director. Royal Armoury. 24 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
17 Richard Sandell, Professor of Museum Studies. University of Leicester. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.
18 Vu Tuan Nguyen, doctoral student, Museum Studies. University of Sydney. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.

37
Finally, it is worth noting in the context of exhibitions with an
LGBTQ perspective, that it is crucial that the entire staff is
trained and prepared for representing the exhibition and its
message. The more controversial the exhibition may be per-
ceived, the more important this is. But openness, a welcom-
ing attitude and being service-minded should consistently be
high on the agenda. Exhibition production and visitor activities
go hand in hand here.

CONCRETE TIPS:
• Are you planning an exhibition on an LGBTQ theme? Bring
in an external partner with experience if your organisation
lacks the expertise; this is a good way of letting a group
speak for itself instead of speaking on its behalf. See it as
an excellent learning process. Make sure the entire staff is
involved in the process. Everyone needs knowledge and
understanding about why we are doing this, and how it
should be shared with the public.

• Make small alterations and additions. Review the perma-


nent exhibition to see how the LGBTQ perspective can be
included in it. Invite researchers or an LGBTQ organisation;
perhaps the permanent exhibition already includes queer
perspectives that have not yet been identified.

• When producing a temporary LGBTQ project – consider


whether separate elements in the project/exhibition could
be extracted from the project and made into a permanent
feature.

• Add LGBTQ perspectives to the checklist for all new


exhibition productions. How can LGBTQ perspectives be
included in the new exhibition, even when this is not the
overall theme?

• Adopt a norm-critical approach and avoid stereotypes!


How are people portrayed in the exhibition? Who does the
exhibition address, and can everyone in the target group
feel that the exhibition is made with them in mind as visi-
tors?

• Take responsibility for the quality of co-produced exhibi-


tions. The external group provides its expertise and expe-
rience of the subject. The museum is the expert on how to
present and narrate this knowledge.
39
Visitor activities and programmes
Visitor activities and programmes range from the open, Visitor activities need to address the issue of how to be a
engaging and welcoming attitude the museum often wants museum that is relevant to everyone. By diversifying the
to achieve and represent, to the more formalised meetings, groups for programmed activities and creating activities tar-
forums and arenas created through planned programmes and geting special fields, the museum can reach different visitor
events. Programmes can include special guided tours, work- categories at different times and thereby be relevant to more
shops, lectures, talks or debates on particular themes. By vis- people. At the museums we visited in the UK, working with
itor activities we mean aspects such as reception, hosting, audience development was a matter of course. The princi-
visitor services, communication and work on target groups. ple is to segment the audience and create targeted events
Tim Redfern19, an artist who is often consulted by museums in to attract new groups. The next step is to maintain relations
London to organise workshops on LGBTQ themes, stresses with these audience groups. Some Swedish museums apply
that these events should not target LGBTQ audiences exclu- a similar approach. At first glance, they may appear to be seg-
sively, but also their relatives and friends, and others who may regating their audiences. However, the more audience groups
be interested in these issues. This means that they are actu- the museum welcomes, the greater the potential, hopefully,
ally addressing a large potential audience. to achieve a heterogeneous meeting place in the long term,
where exciting new encounters can take place.
Being welcoming and inclusive, however, is not just a matter
of attitudes and content. It also requires accessibility. There The V&A in London20 engages actively in reaching out to peo-
are many aspects to accessibility. One is to show in external ple of different ages and backgrounds in the LGBTQ com-
communication that the museum is accessible and relevant to munity, through targeted activities during the LGBT History
LGBTQ audiences and visitors. Simple things like displaying Month21 and Black History Month. The Yerba Buena Center
rainbow flags have important symbolic value. However, those for the Arts22 also emphasises the importance of differenti-
with experience of flying the rainbow flag at their institutions ating LGBTQ in their work, and to understand how privilege
point out that this comes with an obligation; the flag symbol- impacts on the LGBTQ community as well. In their programme
ises both that the museum has knowledge and that it offers activities, for instance, they collaborate with a group of Trans-
a friendly reception. Another aspect of accessibility is purely latinas, transgender women with Latin American roots, and
spatial. Countless times in the course of this study, we have with homeless queer youths.
met people who emphasise the importance of gender-neu-
tral toilets, to make the museum feel safer for transgender Programme activities also provide potential for dialogue
people. Several museums engaging actively in LGBTQ per- between groups and on issues that may be considered sen-
spectives have implemented gender-neutral toilets, including sitive. Örebro County Museum and Örebro Pride held joint
the Museum of Spirits, and the Museum of World Culture in seminars on religion and LGBTQ, with support from the
Gothenburg. Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender
and Queer Rights (RFSL) and the Muslim adult education
A vital bridge between exhibition activities and visitor activ- centre Ibn Rushd. Another example is Tensta Konsthall, which
ities is to stress that the entire staff should be trained and invited the artist Sofia Hultin to hold lesbian city walks in Ten-
prepared prior to an exhibition with LGBTQ perspectives. sta. The content of the city walk was developed together with
Many of the people we interviewed for this study agree that residents in Tensta and local organisations.
this training should not only include educators and guides,
but all museum staff. Receptionists, shop staff, janitors and One fairly common approach today at Swedish museums is
others need to be well-informed and prepared to receive and to modify activities during the local Pride festival, for instance,
handle questions and reactions. It is important that everyone by offering workshops, lectures, etc. One phenomenon that
can represent the museum’s current exhibition. Our interviews has become widely spread in recent years is guided queer
showed that the more controversial the exhibition may be per- tours of exhibitions; this concept was introduced in Sweden
ceived, the more important this is. This is always important, in 2005. One of the first to offer queer tours was Anders Kar-
however, if a welcoming reception and good service are high nell23 at Moderna Museet, closely followed by Patrik Steorn at
on the agenda. Exhibition production and visitor activities are the Nationalmuseum. A queer tour involves applying a queer
interlinked with the organisation’s internal operations, as dis- theory perspective to the exhibition that is being shown24. It is
cussed below. hardly a coincidence that the country’s first queer tours were

19 Tim Redfern, performer and museum consultant. 20 October, 2014. Interview in London.
20 Zorian Clayton, Assistant Curator of Print. Victoria & Albert Museum. 23 October, 2014. Interview in London.
21 LGBT History Month, a nationwide event held annually.
22 Kathy Budas, Marketing & Communications Director, Joël Tan, Director of Community Engagement, Betti-Sue Hertz, Director of Visual Arts. Yerba Buena Center for the Arts.
5 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
23 Dziurlikowska, M. ”A Queer Teaches Here” – Interview with Anders Karnell and Patrik Steorn. Paletten No 4, 2006.
24 Patrik Steorn, curator and director. Thiel Gallery. 19 August, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.

41
applied to art collections. Art history offers a wide array of
people and human interaction portrayed through a myriad of
lenses.

One of the most memorable experiences in the course of this


study, was when Marcus Dickey Horley at Tate Britain25 gave
a queer tour of centuries of art. Queer perspectives can be
applied to many famous works through the ages and offer
entirely new angles on Europe’s, not to say world, history.
On a few specific occasions, Tate Modern has offered queer
tours, which were widely appreciated by the public and drew
hundreds of people to the shows. This, of course, encour-
aged the museum to pursue its LGBTQ-oriented work.

Following up on their queer tours of exhibitions in connection


with Pride festivals, some Swedish museums have started
offering queer tours all year round. At the Royal Armoury26, for
instance, tours with a queer perspective are always available.
Some museums also offer queer tours without mentioning this
explicitly in their programme. In some cases, this is because
norm-critical perspectives are an integral part of the work at
the museum. More often, however, this is because it is up to
the individual educator to decide how s/he chooses to per-
form the guided tour.

CONCRETE TIPS:
• Make the museum accessible to LGBTQ people. It is
important to signal accessibility in every way, from commu-
nicating LGBTQ-related events to offering gender-neutral
toilets on the premises.

• Partner with external LGBTQ experts, both individuals and


organisations. This can raise the quality of events aimed at
the public and expand your target group network, so that
more people find their way to the museum.

• Remember that LGBTQ-themed programme events do not


target LGBTQ people only. Visitors may also be the kin of
LGBTQ people, or interested in norm criticism in general.

• Take a stand and get involved in the programme for your


local Pride festival. If the museum offers queer tours during
the Pride week, why not all year?

• Work on your communication, symbolic value and accessi-


bility. Communicate the museum’s LGBTQ events proudly
and naturally. Fly the rainbow flag for its symbolic value.

• Remember that there are obligations attached to what you


communicate. It is good if the entire staff has the expertise
and capacity to stand up for the importance of working with
LGBTQ perspectives.

25 Marcus Dickey Horley, Curator of Access Projects. Tate Modern. 22 October, 2014. Interview in London.
26 Malin Grundberg, director. Royal Armoury. 24 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
43
LGBTQ in collections
When it comes to reviewing existing collections from an objects. Steorn, who is currently the director of the Thiel Gal-
LGBTQ perspective, and initiatives for new collections of lery, is a scholar who has practical experience of distinguish-
LGBTQ artefacts, the initiatives in Sweden and globally are ing queer perspectives in works of art in connection with the
few and most are only in the early stages. LGBTQ in col- queer tours he created for the Nationalmuseum. In an article
lections is thus an enormous untapped potential. The fact from 2010, he offers critical reflections on how museums can
that this aspect is still largely neglected is, by all accounts, apply an LGBTQ perspective to their collections, emphasising
intimately related to the limited historiography, and to those partly that applying terms such as homo, hetero, bi and trans-
whose privilege it has been to interpret history. This field is in gender to collections would be to categorise history accord-
dire need of innovation and more sharing of knowledge, both ing to temporary views, which is not entirely unproblematic,
in coding and cataloguing existing collections, and in creating since categories can be limiting instead of offering flexibility.
new collections of LGBTQ artefacts. He also notes that museums, when endeavouring to introduce
queer perspectives, must bear in mind that they are part of the
But what is an LGBTQ artefact? In her Master’s dissertation power structure and creators of norms and meanings. There-
at Uppsala University, Charlotte Lendi studied how cultural fore, Steorn advises museums to invite the LGBTQ commu-
history museums have implemented LGBTQ perspectives nity to participate in their process, to be innovative in how they
in their collections.27 Lendi describes how museums risk present their collections, and to spearhead research.30
enhancing stereotypes when collecting objects representing
a particular group. However, this should not deter them from Further innovative solutions that involve the LGBTQ com-
trying to find ways. In her study, Lendi concludes that despite munity could thus be needed, with inspiration from the
the progress of LGBTQ perspectives in Swedish museums, above-mentioned MOHAI museum in Seattle, which invites
the collection departments are lagging behind. Her inter- the local LGBTQ community to contribute objects to its grow-
viewees seem to agree that the museum collections probably ing LGBTQ collection. Another inspiring project is the Örebro
contain an unknown quantity of LGBTQ material, but that this County Museum’s project in partnership with the local RFSL
information was not recorded at the time of acquisition and organisation (the Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisex-
has therefore been lost. ual, Transgender and Queer Rights), of gathering stories from
the local LGBTQ community.31
The problem of including LGBTQ perspectives in the col-
lections was discussed at the annual museum congress in Efforts to collect oral accounts with the aim of preserving
the Netherlands. Here, as in many other contexts, searches LGBTQ history have been made and are pursued very actively
for LGBTQ-related concepts in museum collections were by LGBTQ archives and other such NGOs in Sweden and
fruitless. One vital question that was raised was when it is internationally, for example, the LivingStories Project in Wash-
relevant to categorise objects linked to LGBTQ individuals ington, which seeks to set up a national collection of oral sto-
as being LGBTQ. How, for instance, should the Groninger ries in the form of an online exhibition. It is carried out as part
Museum handle its collection of works by Andy Warhol? of the campaign for a national LGBTQ museum in the USA.
There is a need, in other words, to find new ways of catego-
rising objects.28 In 2005, the Victoria Museum in Sydney appointed a queer
historian to research the collection for a short period. The pro-
There is also a need for re-classifying the collections, and for ject resulted in an increase from less than ten to more than
saving more information from various sources relating to the one hundred hits when searching the database for LGBTQ-
objects. This aspect was explored, for instance, in the Swed- related terms. This type of alterations in the collections is vital
ish History Museum’s research project Polysemantiska berät- in preparation for including LGBTQ perspectives in exhibi-
telser (Polysemantic Narratives). The LGBTQ network at the tions. Australia also has Community Heritage Grants enabling
V&A in London29 has initiated a proposal for reviewing existing communities, including LGBTQ organisations, to apply for
concepts relating to gender and sexuality in the museum’s funding or practical assistance in their own work to catalogue
database, and suggested a list of new terms. and preserve their artefacts.32

Patrik Steorn claims that knowledge and an experienced eye Yet another innovative effort to collect LGBTQ objects is
are needed to distinguish queer perspectives in art and other underway digitally via The Unstraight Museum33, an NGO

27 Lendi, C. (2014). Varför är det så svårt? – En studie av kulturhistoriska museers arbete med hbtq-perspektiv i samlingar. Master’s dissertation. Dept. of Archive, Libraries and
Museum Studies. Uppsala University.
28 de Wildt, A. Queering the collection: Bestaan er homoseksuele objecten? Amsterdam Museum. 16 October, 2014.
http://hart.amsterdammuseum.nl/91256/nl/queering-the-collections
29 Zorian Clayton, Assistant Curator of Print. Victoria & Albert Museum. 23 October, 2014. Interview in London.
30 Steorn, P. (2010). Queer in the museum: Methodological reflections on doing queer in museum collections. Lambda Nordica 2010: 3-4.
31 Anna Furumark, project manager, Norm, nation och kultur. Örebro County Museum. 3 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
32 Vu Tuan Nguyen, doctoral student, Museum Studies. University of Sydney. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.
33 Nicolas Hasselqvist, project manager, Ulf Petersson, initiator. The Unstraight Museum. 14 March, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.

45
based in Stockholm. The Unstraight Museum is known in and
outside Sweden for setting up an online museum devoted
to LGBT history in various forms. Their website is designed
as a forum for stories and for museums. It was spawned by
the need for a hub for sharing stories and narratives with an
LGBTQ perspective. They wanted to stop these narratives,
such as the accounts of AIDS in the 1980s, from disappear-
ing from historiography. The development of this website is an
ongoing process. Here, museums and the public can contrib-
ute to building LGBTQ history.

CONCRETE TIPS:
• Ensure that you have access to queer theory knowledge
when the museum is working on LGBTQ in its collections.

• Review your codes and categories carefully, so that they


are both distinct and flexible.

• Make sure you don’t just collect stereotypical material.

• Invite LGBTQ organisations or communities to participate


in the process.

• Be innovative. Learn by trial and error. Share your experi-


ences!
47
LGBTQ in the internal organisation
Throughout the interviews and dialogues conducted in this following a resolute initiative by its then director. An external
study, we repeatedly found that LGBTQ at Swedish muse- educator was called in, and all staff participated in training
ums is primarily a concern for enthusiasts. Staff with a spe- programmes and the ensuing process of change. The norm
cial interest in these issues handle the LGBTQ perspectives critical approach was incorporated in the policy documents
outside their regular work, making it an onerous and lonely that were formulated jointly. Maintaining a constant awareness
task. The absence of directives from management seems to and challenging themselves and each other with regard to the
be the reason why LGBTQ perspectives become the subject norms they represent, or forget to represent, has become a
of temporary measures rather than being integrated into the matter of course in the museum’s everyday operations. It is a
museums’ long-term goals and processes. The JÄMUS pro- collective effort.
ject34 organised seminars targeting staff at various museums.
At their events, it transpired that many museum employees A very concrete aid is to set up a checklist for every activity
want to focus on a variety of perspectives – diversity, gender, and project within the organisation, to support the process
LGBTQ and norm criticism – but that this is given low priority of making visible and welcoming diverse perspectives and
unless management indicates that it is important. groups. Bohusläns museum, for instance, has a clear check-
list, with the subheading ‘to promote rights-based work36. It
We found that where the approach to norm critical work was is used as a tool in their activities and planning, in order to
integrated into and permeated the entire organisation, with the include the rights perspective in the day-to-day work. The
conscious inclusion of LGBTQ perspectives in all activities, rights perspective consists of equality, inclusion, transpar-
the staff listed the same key to success: these perspectives ency, legal rights/clear responsibilities, and non-discrimina-
were considered to be a management issue. Time and other tion. The seven forms of discrimination covered by the Dis-
resources had been allocated. This work was regarded as a crimination Act (see Chapter 3) are noted. Moreover, the
living, long-term process involving the entire staff. museum must consider the social and economic resources
of their visitor groups, along with aspects such as language
In our talks with museum directors who want to make a differ- and education. When planning each project, and in the ongo-
ence and are involved in incorporating LGBTQ perspectives, ing work, they review which perspectives are given priority or
however, we uncovered a variety of experiences. Some direc- disregarded, and why. They also ask themselves specifically
tors are committed to involving the entire staff. Others say that who is the narrator, whose story is being told, who the target
they have to accept that some staff members take longer to groups are, who is represented, and what partners to consult,
engage; it is okay to let some move on ahead of the others in along with other questions.
order to make progress in this respect. The museum manage-
ment also has to address other things relating to the govern- Diplomas and certifications are two other tools, in addition
ance and priorities of the operation. Partly, distinct political to the previously-mentioned ones, for promoting in-house
goals need to be reached; and partly, management has to LGBTQ expertise. With regard to diplomas, an LGBT diploma
look to the relationship with other interested parties, includ- programme will be launched in autumn 2015 for all museums
ing the museum’s friends associations, funders, visitor groups in the City of Gothenburg and the City’s Arts Administration,
and local organisations. Sometimes, there are fears that these as part of the City of Gothenburg’s “Plan for Equal Rights and
groups will object to new initiatives at the museum, especially Opportunities 2015”37.
if it is considered controversial or in some way different from
the museum’s traditional approach. In our dialogue meetings, RFSL– the Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual,
several people have noted that it is vital that museums do not Transgender and Queer Rights – has offered LGBT certifi-
censor themselves because they think an external party may cation since 2008. The certification process is estimated to
object. It is better to ask and to engage in dialogue. take six to eight months for any organisation wishing to certify
its operation. The purpose is to provide a sound working envi-
Work in the organisation on norm criticism in general, and ronment for employees and a respectful attitude to patients/
LGBTQ issues in particular can be done through various clients/users with regard to LGBT issues. Certification also
means, from in-house training programmes to clear guide- involves announcing that the organisation is making strategic
lines and involving the entire staff in the formulation of poli- efforts in this field.38 Several Swedish libraries have recently
cies. The Maritime Museum & Aquarium in Gothenburg35, for embarked on acquiring LGBT certification. The project man-
example, has been focusing for years on including norm crit- agers at the libraries report that the certification process has
icism as a natural part of the museum’s everyday activities, been a positive experience.39

34 Li Kolker, events manager, Lotta Fernstål, chief antiquarian, early Iron Age. JÄMUS project, National Historical Museum. 23 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
35 Emma Having, head of exhibitions and learning. Maritime Museum & Aquarium. 3 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
36 Bohusläns Museum.‘CHECKLISTA – ett stöd i rättighetsbaserat arbete’. Compiled by Bohusläns museum’s MR team in spring 2014. Bohusläns museum.
37 City of Gothenburg“Plan för lika rättigheter och möjligheter 2015”.
38 Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. LGBT certification. Accessed on 2 January, 2015. http://www.rfsl.se/?p=4960
39 The Swedish Library Association’s network of experts on LGBTQ issues. 15 December, 2014. Meeting in Sollentuna.

49
Recruitment is another means of influencing the organisation
from within. Whether LGBTQ perspectives can be introduced
in museums via recruitment, however, is a question with two
answers. To employ someone based on their sexual orienta-
tion, gender identity or gender expression would probably be
unviable in Sweden. A person’s sexual orientation or gender
identity does not determine their values or skills. However, a
museum that has decided to include these perspectives as a
natural part of its activities, could recruit someone with spe-
cial expertise in this field.

CONCRETE TIPS:
• Avoid delegating LGBTQ only to the enthusiasts in your
museum. Make it a management issue. Allocate time and
other resources to it.

• Give the entire staff training in norm critical approaches in


general, and LGBTQ specifically.

• Consider LGBTQ diplomas, certification or similar accred-


itation, to enhance in-house expertise.

• Incorporate norm awareness in the museum’s overall goals


and policies.

• Make sure staff are aware of the seven forms of discrimina-


tion covered by the Swedish Discrimination Act, and pres-
ent proposals on how to prevent discrimination.

• Formulate a concrete checklist before and during each pro-


ject. Define the perspectives to be included, the groups to
be represented, and the issues to be addressed by the pro-
ject.

• Maintain an ongoing dialogue within the museum, and help


each other to detect preconceptions based on prevailing
norms.
51
LGBTQ in collaborations Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. The
Örebro County Museum has also hosted a series of seminars
Welcome! on “how to disturb homogeneity”, led by Anna Furumark46.
Back in 2006, the first LGBT Gothenburg (later renamed This was an opportunity for museum professionals and others
West Pride) was about to start. A rainbow flag was hoisted from all over Sweden to meet and discuss norms, diversity
for the first time outside the Röhsska Museum of Fashion, and discrimination.
Design and Decorative Arts. The then director, Ted Hessel-
bom, recalls one of the more memorable encounters at the When museums enter into partnerships with LGBTQ organ-
museum: isations, they need to be aware that one sub-category alone
cannot represent the multitude of perspectives and groups
An old lady came up to him, greeted him warmly and thanked within the LGBTQ community. Sometimes, therefore, it may
him for the museum’s stand and the signals sent by the rain- be necessary to approach several groups, or to work with ref-
bow flag. Her only regret was that her partner had died and erence groups representing several perspectives. One exam-
could not be there to experience this magnificent day. They ple of how an organisation addresses this complexity is the
would often visit Röhsska together, but passed themselves City of Gothenburg’s LGBTQ council, whose members are
off as friends. They didn’t know if their truth and their love was selected to represent different LGBTQI identities, while at the
welcome at the museum. But now she knew.40 same time representing a plurality based on the seven forms
of discrimination.
As in the above example, museums all over Sweden are now
collaborating with local Pride organisations during the annual If a museum initiates a relationship with a group through joint
Pride week, offering special guided tours and other activities. projects, the group will expect this relationship to continue.
What makes West Pride41 special is that its forerunner, LGBT The same applies to visitors who experience that the museum
Gothenburg, was started by Blå stället in Angered42 together has suddenly started to address them as LGBTQ persons.
with the Röhsska Museum of Fashion, Design and Decorative Perhaps, new visitor groups have been drawn to the museum
Arts, the Museum of World Culture, Gothenburg City Thea- by the LGBTQ initiatives. How should these relationships and
tre and Pusterviksteatern. In other words, the arts institutions expectations be maintained after a temporary project has
founded the local LGBT festival themselves, in response to an come to an end? In the UK and USA, museums have spe-
identified absence of, and need for, an inclusive forum. “But cial professionals with responsibility for the museum’s work
even Pride can be slightly excluding,” Ted Hesselbom points and relationships with different groups in the local community.
out. “The next crucial step is to join arms with the rest of soci- They can have job titles such as community manager, com-
ety, to grow stronger.”43 munity engagement officer, or curator of community history.
In Sweden, there may be scope for professionalising the cor-
In conjunction with the festival, the Museum of World Culture44 responding positions in museums. Maintaining a relationship
has been exceedingly active in partnering with local LGBTQ after the end of a joint project may otherwise sometimes rely
groups and with artists, to organise exhibitions and events. entirely on the available time and inclination of individual staff
Over time, more museums in Gothenburg have joined in. The members, rather than on the organisation’s plans and deci-
Gothenburg Museum of Art45 has organised queer guided sions.
tours in connection with West Pride, and has also found ways
of presenting queer perspectives throughout the rest of the A few museums in Sweden have opted to collaborate with
year. One of these is to collaborate with artists who introduce the above-mentioned NGO The Unstraight Museum47. The
a queer perspective in their interaction with the museum’s col- Unstraight Museum was spawned by the touring exhibition
lection and in their encounter with visitors at public events. Article 1, named after the UN Declaration of Human Rights,
which highlighted the often ignored LGBTQ perspectives.
The Örebro County Museum lists examples of other forms of The project was managed by the Nobel Museum, the Mari-
cooperation. In one project to collect stories from the popula- time Museum, the Army Museum, the Ethnographic Museum,
tion in Örebro County, it was decided that the material should the National Historical Museum, the National Museum of
include accounts by LGBTQ people. To reach out to these Science and Technology, the Police Museum, the Swed-
groups, and to broaden the museum’s knowledge, they part- ish International Development Cooperation Agency and the
nered with the local chapter of the Swedish Federation for Swedish Exhibition Agency. The Unstraight Museum’s most

40 Ted Hesselbom, director. Sigtuna museum, formerly of Röhsska Museum of Fashion, Design and Decorative Arts. 2 April, 2014. Interview in Örebro.
41 Tasso Stafilidis, events manager, Göteborgs Kulturkalas. Göteborg & Co. Formerly events manager for West Pride. 4 April, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
42 Aurora Cederholm, consultant. Formerly of Blå Stället in Angered and the LGBTQ Festival in Gothenburg. 2 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
43 Ted Hesselbom, director. Sigtuna museum, formerly of Röhsska Museum of Fashion, Design and Decorative Arts. 2 April, 2014. Interview in Örebro.
44 Karl Magnusson, director. National Museum of World Culture. 4 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
45 Freja Holmberg, art educator, and Philippa Nanfeldt, curator, education and learning. Gothenburg Museum of Art. 7 April, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
46 Anna Furumark, project manager, Norm, nation och kultur. Örebro County Museum. 3 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
47 Nicolas Hasselqvist, project manager, Ulf Petersson, initiator. The Unstraight Museum. 14 March, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.

53
recent project is called Unstraight Perspectives. It twins
Swedish museums with LGBTQ activists in a local com-
munity somewhere in the world where the opportunities
for LGBTQ activism are different. The Swedish museum
and the local community produce an exhibition together.
One example is the Museum of World Culture’s collaboration
with activists in Hanoi, a project that was pursued in 2014-
2015.

Obviously, museums can also partner with each other to


promote their integration of LGBTQ perspectives. National
LGBTQ networks for the museum sector have been started
up in the USA and UK. Several UK museums also have
in-house LGBTQ networks48. An LGBTQ network initiated by
the Nationalmuseum and National Historical Museum in Swe-
den is under way, starting in 2015. It will serve as a forum to
discuss and share experiences of working with LGBTQ issues
in museums.

CONCRETE TIPS:
• Cooperate with local LGBTQ organisations. This enhances
knowledge, inspires, and probably makes the process more
enjoyable.

• If the museum’s activities are suitable, invite a queer artist to


work on LGBTQ perspectives in a more innovative way.

• Collaborate with other museums on integrating LGBTQ


perspectives. Sharing experiences with each other pro-
motes skills and progress.

• Remember that joint projects can include all types of part-


ners and that partners need to consolidate their different
approaches.

• Joint projects do not need to take place in the vicinity of the


museum; they can also involve partners in other parts of the
world. You can make a difference in other places.

48 Marcus Dickey Horley, Curator of Access Projects. Tate Modern. 22 October, 2014. Interview in London.
55
CHAPTER 5

5. 5. The present and the future


– concluding reflections
THE PICTURE THAT EMERGED after working intensely on this Comparing different fields within the museums, 72 per cent
study for a year, is that LGBTQ perspectives in museums replied that they include LGBTQ perspectives in the produc-
are often something over and above the ordinary. We found tion and content of exhibitions; this is a higher percentage
that although the threshold for getting to work on LGBTQ than for any other part of the operation. The corresponding
perspectives is low, these perspectives rarely get integrated percentage for events and programmes, and guided tours
into the museum’s daily activities. Many temporary and pro- and visitor activities were 68 and 66 per cent respectively.
ject-based efforts are made. In order to move towards reflect- Here, our interviews and discussions with museum profes-
ing and representing society as it is outside the museum, it sionals around Sweden showed that programmes focusing on
is vital to increasingly integrate LGBTQ perspectives into the LGBTQ issues were often run by enthusiasts, and that it was
day-to-day operations of museums. This should be carried frequently up to the museum educators themselves to include
out with an awareness of the diversity within LGBTQ, which queer perspectives in their guided tours.
includes many different identities with regard to sexual ori-
entation, gender identity, and gender expression, and unique The fact that LGBTQ issues are clearly delegated to enthu-
individuals with a broad spectrum of other identities. siasts at Swedish museums explains why LGBTQ-related
initiatives often end with temporary initiatives and separate
Nevertheless, there is an excellent potential for engaging in projects. Long-term inclusion of LGBTQ perspectives is still
LGBTQ perspectives in exhibitions and museums in Sweden. uncommon in Swedish museums. There is a huge untapped
82 per cent of museums who responded to our telephone sur- potential here.
vey answered that they are working actively to include LGBTQ
issues in their operations. Asked to assess their basic skills Queer tours seem to be a successful concept at Swed-
in the field, 68 per cent replied that they have basic skills, ish museums. It is often based on a temporary initiative, but
and 9 per cent that they are weak. 87 per cent stated that can lead to more long-term results. The initiative for queer
their museum needed to improve its skills in LGBTQ issues. tours is often taken in connection with local Pride festivals.
Integration of LGBTQ issues in museums has a great devel- This appears to be a fairly common first step for museums
opment potential. The research on which our report is based to approach LGBTQ perspectives. There are currently some
gives us clear indications as to where this potential lies. More- 20 annual Pride festivals in Sweden. Since these appear to
over, we can identify a number of possibilities, as well as prob- be important partners to Swedish museums, we need to ask
lematic aspects on the road to becoming LGBTQ-conscious ourselves how we can ensure that the development of LGBTQ
museums and exhibitors. perspectives at Swedish museums is not limited to a handful
of major cities. We need to find approaches that work region-
We note that museums are better and more active in their ally and locally throughout Sweden. One way could be to
external activities than in-house, when it comes to working on take after the UK and USA by introducing an annual official
LGBTQ perspectives. This indicates that Swedish museums LGBTQ history month. Another could be to cooperate with
are committed to reaching out to people and influencing the local LGBTQ organisations to produce events and to collect
public. But we also need to ask ourselves: what happened to local history.
the idea that all change starts with yourself? Among our inter-
viewees and dialogue participants, we found many, however, Only 33 museums in Sweden have worked with LGBTQ
who are convinced that it is good to work on several fields perspectives in their existing collections; only 30 per cent in
simultaneously. These need not be mutually exclusive. their collecting activities. As the facts presented in this report
demonstrate, this area is not entirely unproblematic. There

57
are many aspects that need to be considered. The current politicians and the public. But what if we are obscuring the
efforts with regard to LGBTQ in collections, in Sweden and truth every time we censor ourselves?
internationally, are still in the pioneering phase. Therefore, we
need an encouraging dialogue on the topic, rather than dis- With long-term perspectives and integrated norm awareness
couragement. We need an accepting attitude, where projects in mind, we believe that Swedish museums would benefit by
are welcomed, and where you have the right to experiment, raising these issues to a higher level in their organisation and
create and innovate. We are learning something new, whether incorporating them internally to a larger extent, while maintain-
we are shaping tomorrow’s history or attempting to reinterpret ing their LGBTQ-related work aimed at the public.
the history of the past.
Even if there is a huge demand for skill-building in LGBTQ –
What makes the process of applying LGBTQ perspectives to 87 per cent of responding museums said that they needed
collections and collecting relevant is, obviously, that LGBTQ this – only 40 per cent are currently building their skills with in-
people have been made invisible for many years. We are talk- house training. Only 26 per cent of museums responded that
ing about a part of the population that is largely unhistoried. they have guidelines or policy documents on LGBTQ issues
Everyone needs roots. Therefore, this is a dual process. Firstly, that they would be willing to share with the Swedish Exhibi-
we need to dispel prejudices and reveal taboos. Secondly, we tion Agency. 59 per cent had none, and 15 per cent did not
need to show people and their stories just the way they are. know. Museums in Sweden have a huge potential in-house to
The process of incorporating LGBTQ perspectives in exhibi- strengthen organisational values, to increase their knowledge
tions and museums is fundamentally a matter of being honest and awareness of LGBTQ issues, and to acknowledge the
and earnest about the way things are and have been. We may seven forms of discrimination defined in the Discrimination Act
think we have come a long way in Sweden. And relatively, this in their policies, strategies and continuous checklists. If they
may be true. In our dialogues and interviews, however, the start by implementing this in-house, and via their entire staff,
question of self-censorship comes up time and time again. It’s this would have an enormous ripple effect throughout the
only human to be afraid, and museums often worry about what museum and spread to society in general – and back again.
others will think - colleagues, friend organisations, sponsors,
59
Sources
INTERVIEWS
• Louise Andersson, arts expert. Swedish Association of Local Authorities and Regions. 3 March, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Erin Bailey, Curator of “Revealing Queer”, Museum of History and Industry (MOHAI), Seattle. 21 May, 2014. Interview in Seattle.
• Ianna Book, artist/curator “Trans Time exhibition”, Montreal. 1 December, 2014. Interview via e-mail.
• Kathy Budas, Marketing & Communications Director, Joël Tan, Director of Community Engagement, Betti-Sue Hertz, Director of Visual
Arts. Yerba Buena Center for the Arts. 5 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
• Petter Bøckman, assistant professor, Geir Søli, senior teaching assistant, Arild Johnsen, professor, Cecilie Webb head of department.
Naturhistorisk museum. Oslo. 15 October, 2014. Interview in Oslo.
• Aurora Cederholm, consultant. Formerly of Blå Stället in Angered and the LGBTQ Festival in Gothenburg. 2 April, 2014.
Interview in Stockholm.
• Lill-Ann Chepstow-Lusty, Senior Engineer. Utstillings- og publikumsseksjonen. Kulturhistorisk museum, Oslo University (KHM).
16 October, 2014. Interview in Oslo..
• Zorian Clayton, Assistant Curator of Prints. Victoria & Albert Museum. 23 October, 2014. Interview in London.
• Marcus Dickey Horley, Curator of Access Projects. Tate Modern. 22 October, 2014. Interview in London.
• Michael Fürst. Schwules Museum*. 14 June, 2014. Interview in Liverpool.
• Anna Furumark, project manager, Norm, nation och kultur. Örebro County Museum. 3 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Annette M. Gavigan and Renae Youngs. The LGBTQ Alliance, The American Alliance of Museums (AAM). 21 May, 2014.
Interview in Seattle.
• Malin Grundberg, director. Royal Armoury. 24 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Si Han, curator. Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities. 20 May, 2015. Telephone interview.
• Emma Having, head of exhibitions and learning. Maritime Museum & Aquarium. 5 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
• Nicolas Hasselqvist, project manager, Ulf Petersson, initiator. The Unstraight Museum. 14 March, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Ted Hesselbom, director. Sigtuna museum, formerly of Röhsska Museum of Fashion, Design and Decorative Arts. 2 April, 2014.
Interview in Örebro.
• Freja Holmberg, art educator, and Philippa Nanfeldt, curator, education and learning. Gothenburg Museum of Art. 7 April, 2014.
Interview in Gothenburg.
• Kay Jones, Curator of Community History. Museum of Liverpool. 14 June, 2014. Interview in Liverpool.
• Tone Cecilie Simensen Karlgård, museum lecturer. Exhibitions and visitors section. Kulturhistorisk museum, Oslo University (KHM).
13 October, 2014. Interview in Oslo.
• Nadja Karlsson, head of tastings. Museum of Spirits. 4 March, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Summerlea Kashar, Executive Director. Cartoon Art Museum. 5 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
• Thomas Knowles, Learning Services Assistant. Fiona Smith, Adult Programmes Officer. National Portrait Gallery. London. 21 October,
2014. Interview in London.
• Li Kolker, events manager, Lotta Fernstål, chief antiquarian, early Iron Age. JÄMUS project, National Historical Museum. 23 April, 2014.
Interview in Stockholm.
• Bianca Leidi, exhibition producer. National Museums of World Culture. 29 January, 2015. Telephone interview.
• Pawel Leszkowicz, PhD, curator Ars Homo Erotica. Poland. 14 June, 2012. Interview via e-mail.
• Karl Magnusson, director. National Museum of World Culture. 4 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
• Anthony Manion, Director, Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA), South Africa. 15 December, 2014. Skype/telephone interview.
• Emilia Mirani. Blattequeers. 24 April, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Eleanor Moffat, curator of maritime collections. Merseyside Maritime Museum. 13 June, 2014. Interview in Liverpool.
• Catherine Morris, Sackler Family Curator. Elizabeth A. Sackler Center for Feminist Art, Brooklyn Museum. 15 May, 2014. Interview in
New York.

61
• Vu Tuan Nguyen, doctoral student, Museum Studies. University of Sydney. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.
• Linda Noreen, Exhibitions & Learning. Maritime Museum & Aquarium. 5 March, 2014. Interview in Gothenburg.
• Hunter O’Hanian, Museum Director. Leslie-Lohman Museum of Gay and Lesbian Art. 15 April, 2014. Interview in New York.
• Masoom Mohammed Hanif Parmar, Co-Founder. Queer Arts Movement India. 28 January, 2015. Interview via e-mail/Facebook.
• Jeremy Prince, operations manager, Elisabeth Cornu, board member and museum advisor. GLBT History Museum.
6 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
• Tim Redfern, performer and museum consultant. 20 October, 2014. Interview in London.
• Franco Reinaudo, Executive Director. Museu da Diversidad Sexual, São Paulo. 5 January, 2015. Interview via e-mail.
• Hugh Ryan, Founding Director. The Pop-Up Museum of Queer History. 16 May, 2014. Interview in New York.
• Richard Sandell, Professor of Museum Studies. University of Leicester. 10 December, 2014. Skype interview.
• Frank Smigiel, Associate Curator of Public Programs. SFMOMA. 7 August, 2014. Interview in San Francisco.
• Tasso Stafilidis, events manager, Göteborgs Kulturkalas. Göteborg & Co. Formerly events manager for West Pride. 4 April, 2014.
Interview in Gothenburg.
• Patrik Steorn, curator and director. Thiel Gallery. 19 August, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Ingrid Szük-Hanson, project coordinator, Daniella Wennberg, head of department. Interkulturelt Museum, Oslo Museum. 14 October, 2014.
Interview in Oslo.
• Daniel Unnis, head of exhibitions and events. Sundsvalls museum. 5 September, 2014. Interview in Sundsvall.
• Ulrika Westerlund, president. RFSL – Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. 24 April, 2014.
Interview in Stockholm.
• Jake Yuzna, Director of Public Programs. Museum of Arts and Design (MAD). 16 May, 2014. Interview in New York.
• Anders Öhrn, Project Manager, Performing Arts. Swedish Institute. 3 June, 2014. Interview in Stockholm.
• Johanna Övling, ethnologist, Marinette Fogde, research manager. Museum of Work. 9 April, 2014. Interview in Umeå.
DIALOGUE PARTICIPANTS
• Berndt Arell, director. Nationalmuseum. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Emelie Arendorff Runnerström, art educator. Gothenburg Museum of Art. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Karl Arvidsson, head of visitor section. Gothenburg City Museum. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Elfrida Bergman, cultural studies expert. Queering Sápmi. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Ardeshir Bibakabadi, head of activities Homan. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Tanya Charif, BSc social studies. GUTS / Gays in Angered. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Nadja Duffner Ylvestedt, librarian, books for children and young adults. Håbo Library. 21 November, 2014. Visby.
• Sandra Ehne, chairman. Stockholm Pride. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Mikael Eivergård, director. Örebro County Museum. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Catherine Flood, Curator. Victoria & Albert Museum. 21 November, 2014. Visby.
• Si Han, curator. Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Ted Hesselbom, director. Sigtuna Museum. 21 November, 2014. Visby.
• Sofia Hultin, artist. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Li Kolker, events manager. National Historical Museum. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Charlotte Lendi, student. Uppsala University. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Kristina Lindholm, antiquarian, project manager. Bohusläns Museum. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Camilla Löf, project manager, Queer Kids. City of Malmö. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Karl Magnusson, director. National Museum of World Culture. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Bongi McDermott, project manager, LGBT issues. Swedish Arts Council. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Carrie Ann Newman, Artistic Director. Found Arts Limited. 21 November, 2014. Visby.
• Ola Nilsson, project manager. Living History Forum. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Ellie Nordfeldt, deputy chairman LGBTQ council for City of Gothenburg, consultant for Majority. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Christian Penalva, curator/exhibition producer. Gothenburg City Museum. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Hugh Ryan, Founding Director. The Pop-Up Museum of Queer History. 21 November, 2014. Visby.
• Karolin Röcklinger, communications officer, LUJ (Länsstyrelserna utvecklar jämställdhet). County Administrative Board Gotland.
21 November, 2014. Visby.
• Tasso Stafilidis, events manager, Göteborgs Kulturkalas. Göteborg & Co. Formerly events manager for West Pride. 16 December,
2014. Gothenburg.
• Patrik Steorn, curator and director. Thiel Gallery. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Fredrik Svanberg, head of research. National Historical Museum. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Britta Söderqvist, department manager, exhibitions & learning. National Museum of World Culture. 16 December, 2014. Gothenburg.
• Zafire Vrba, artist, educator. 12 November, 2014. Stockholm.
• Emil Åkerö, arts consultant. Add Gender / Kuppproduktion. 21 November, 2014. Visby.

63
ARTICLES, BOOKS, REPORTS AND OTHER DOCUMENTS
• Bohusläns Museum.“CHECKLISTA – ett stöd i rättighetsbaserat arbete”. Compiled by Bohusläns museum’s HR team in spring 2014.
Bohusläns museum.
• Bromseth, J. & Darj, F. (eds) (2010). Normkritisk pedagogik: Makt, lärande och strategier för förändring.
Centre for Gender Research. Uppsala.
• Dziurlikowska, M. “A Queer Teaches Here” – Interview with Anders Karnell and Patrik Steorn. Paletten No 4, 2006.
• Survey on behalf of Riksutställningar (2014). Results from survey on Museums and LGBTQ.
• Furumark, A. (ed.) (2013). Att störa homogenitet. Nordic Academic Press. Lund.
• Gopnik, B. National Portrait Gallery bows to censors, withdraws Wojnarowicz video on gay love. 30 Nov., 2010.
Column, The Washington Post.
• Ghosal, S. Celebration of liberty: Rainbow groups gear up for pride parade. The Times of India. 11 July, 2012.
• City of Gothenburg “Plan för lika rättigheter och möjligheter 2015”.
• Human Rights Watch (2011). “We’ll Show You You’re a Woman” Violence and Discrimination against Black Lesbians and Transgender
Men in South Africa.
• Khaleeli, H. Hijra: India’s third gender claims its place in law. The Guardian. 16 April, 2014.
• Koskovich, G. (2014). “Displaying the Queer Past: Purposes, Publics, and Possibilities at the GLBT History Museum”. QED: A Journal in
GLBTQ Worldmaking 1.2 (2014): 61–78. Michigan State University Press.
• Swedish Arts Council. (2014). Redovisning av Kulturrådets arbete 2014 som strategisk myndighet för ökad öppenhet och mångfald
avseende hbt-frågor.
• Lendi, C. (2014). Varför är det så svårt? – En studie av kulturhistoriska museers arbete med hbtq-perspektiv i samlingar.
Master’s dissertation. Dept. of Archive, Libraries and Museum Studies. Uppsala University.
• Leszkowicz, P. (undated). Against All Odds. Queer Exhibitions Explode in Eastern Europe.
• Nguyen, V. T. (2013). Towards a Queer Intersectional Museology. Dissertation, Master of Museum Studies. University of Sydney. Sydney.
• PewResearchCenter (2013). The Global Divide on Homosexuality: Greater Acceptance in More Secular and Affluent Countries.
• Puar, J. (2011). “I would rather be a cyborg than a goddess” Intersectionality, Assemblage, and Affective Politics. European Institute for
Progressive Cultural Policies. Internet source: http://eipcp.net/transversal/0811/puar/en
• RFSL (2008). Hbt i utveckling: en handbok om hbt-perspektiv i utvecklingssamarbete.
• RFSL Ungdom & Living History Forum. (2011). BRYT! ett metodmaterial om normer i allmänhet och heteronormen i synnerhet, 3rd edition.
• Roscoe, W. (1991). The Zuni man-woman. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
• Ryan, H. (2014). Notes on the Pop-Up Museum of Queer History. QED: A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking 1.2 (2014). Michigan State
University Press.
• Swedish National Institute of Public Health (FHI). Hälsa på lika villkor? – hälsa och livsvillkor bland hbtpersoner (FHI 2006:08).
• Steorn, P. (2010). Queer in the museum: Methodological reflections on doing queer in museum collections. Lambda Nordica 2010: 3–4.
• de Wildt, A. Queering the collection: Bestaan er homoseksuele objecten? Amsterdam Museum. 16 Oct., 2014.
http://hart.amsterdammuseum.nl/91256/nl/queering-the-collections
• Williams, W. L. The “two-spirit” people of indigenous North Americans. The Guardian. 11 October, 2010.
INTERNET SOURCES
• BBC News India. India court recognises transgender people as third gender. 15 April, 2014. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
https://www.riksutstallningar.se/content/27031180
• Gay Pride Brazil: São Paulo. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://www.gaypridebrazil.org/sao-paulo/
• Hieatt, T. E. Two-Spirits in American Indian Culture. Youtube. Accessed on 1 September, 2015.
http://youtu.be/39EWTnS05Ww
• Levine, J. In China, LGBT citizens seek acceptance. CNN. 28 June, 2014. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://edition.cnn.com/2013/06/27/world/asia/china-gay-lesbian-marriage/
• Lundberg, A. Håll isär transbegreppen. SVT Opinion, 26 January, 2014. Accessed on 26 January, 2015.
http://www.svt.se/opinion/article2625729.svt
• Swedish Secretariat for Gender Research. Intersektionalitet söker hem. 27 January, 2015. Accessed on 28 February, 2015.
http://genus.se/Aktuellt/nyheter/genusflodet/genusflodet-detalj//intersektionalitet-soker-hem.cid1262944
• Queering the Museum. 2014 has come and gone, now what? 29 December, 2014. Accessed on 9 January, 2015.
http://queeringthemuseum.org/
• Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. Glossary. Accessed on 19 January, 2015.
http://www.rfsl.se/?p=410
• Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. LGBT certification. Accessed on 2 January, 2015.
http://www.rfsl.se/?p=4960
• Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. Lagar: Milstolpar för hbt-personer i Sverige. Accessed on
28 January, 2015. http://www.rfsl.se/?p=2840
• Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rights. RFSL:s landrapporter. Accessed on 28 January, 2015.
http://www.rfsl.se/?p=2517
• Sun, N. Shanxi Permits Transgender Persons to Change Gender Information. All-China Women’s Federation. 2014-01-09.
Accessed on 1 February, 2015: http://www.womenofchina.cn/womenofchina/html1/news/china/16/8827-1.htm
• SVT Nyheter. I dag erkände Tyskland tredje kön. 4 November, 2013. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://www.svt.se/nyheter/varlden/i-dag-erkanner-tyskland-tredje-kon
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Australia. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Australia
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Brazil. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Brazil
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Germany. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Germany
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in India. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_India
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Norway. Accessed on 12 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Norway
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in Poland. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Poland
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in the United Kingdom. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_the_United_Kingdom
• Wikipedia. LGBT rights in the United States. Accessed on 1 February, 2015.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_the_United_States

65

Вам также может понравиться