7/4/2018 Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code: Conflict of interest in resolution plans may erode IBC credibility - The Economic

dibility - The Economic Times

Business News › Industry › Banking/Finance › Banking Search for News, Stock Quotes & NAV's

04:05 PM | 04 JUL CLOSED ெசன்ெசக்ஸ் நிஃப் 50 ேகால் (எம் எக்… எஸ் /ஐஎ… CREATE ஈ- CHOOSE
மார்க்ெகட்ஸ்… LANGUAGE
PORTFOLIO
MARKET STATS 35,645 266.80 10,769 70.00 30,575.00 82.00 68.75 0.18 TAM

Conflict of interest in resolution plans may erode IBC

credibility
BY SANGITA MEHTA, ET BUREAU | UPDATED: JUL 04, 2018, 02.09 PM IST Post a Comment

In February, a resolution plan for Sharon Bio Medicine was approved by a bankruptcy
Big Change:
court wherein lenders would receive Rs 230 crore against dues of Rs 702 crore. Ideally,
The end of Five-Year Plans: All you need to know
secured lenders should have rejoiced, considering if it had gone into liquidation, they
would have received just about Rs 175 crore.

A closer look at the resolution plan shows that of Rs 230 crore, only Rs 10 crore would be paid up front, but over 6-8 weeks after all
regulatory approvals. The remaining was to be paid over 10 years. That’s not all. There would be moratorium of 12 months on interest
payment and 24 months on principal payment. Lenders would have to swap Rs 300 crore into equity and write off the balance loan.

For unsecured creditors with exposure of Rs 188 crore, the settlement amount was Rs 184 crore, although all of it was swap of debt into
equity. The haircut was minimum and they had equity upside. Yet, 93% creditors approved the plan — an even bigger surprise. The plan
so skewed in favour of unsecured creditors is mainly because one of them, FCCB holder Peters Beck & Partner, had submitted a
resolution plan that was approved. FCCB holders contributed 28% to the vote and themselves voted in favour of the plan submitted by
them.

Requirement for a proposal to be supported back in February was 75% of votes in favour of a plan. Thus no other plan would have
sailed through without them endorsing it. Also, they were not solo bidders. There were seven non bidding bids and four shortlisted. This
clearly shows conflict of interest where bidders have the veto power to approve or reject a plan by virtue of being a member of the
committee of creditors.

Experts say that if many such cases keep coming up, the credibility of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code will be questioned and many
cases could face litigation, delaying resolution. “The resolution professional (RP) or RP’s counsel should have discretion to determine
conflict of interest. But where there are instances of allegation against the RP itself, these should be decided by the committee or
creditors or appellate authority,” said Eshwar Karra, CEO of Phoenix ARC.

Conflict of interest occurs when an entity is in a position to exploit its official or personal capacity in some way for personal or corporate
benefit. The regulator, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI), has so far not issued any guidelines or a code of ethics on this
matter yet. The most recent case of conflict of interest was the Adani-Wilmar-Ruchi Soya deal where Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas
(CAM) was the legal counsel for both the resolution professional and bidder Adani Wilmar, which was eyeing the bankrupt edible oil
company.

As a midway solution, CAM resigned as advisor of Adani Wilmar and lenders appointed their own counsel Luthra & Luthra to ring fence
against any allegations of being imprudent. “We don’t have a say on whom the RP wants to appoint as their legal counsel, but we can
have our own counsel to advise us,” said a bank official.

Similarly, there have been instances where four bidders were advised by the same legal counsel in a recent case that is mired in
litigations. There are other cases where lenders have provided interim finance to one of the bidders and there is yet another case where
a subsidiary of a lender is advisor to a bidder.

“Ideally, in the first meeting, all the participants- the committee of creditors, the resolution professional, the counsel for the RP and the
lenders- should make upfront disclosures about their links with the company if any in the past and their interests. Similar disclosures by
the bidders should be made in the later stage as well,” said M R Umarji, former executive director of the Reserve Bank of India and
architect of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/finance/banking/conflict-of-interest-in-resolution-plans-may-erode-ibc-credibility/printarticle/648… 1/2
7/4/2018 Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code: Conflict of interest in resolution plans may erode IBC credibility - The Economic Times

“This way everyone is aware about the interest of the other party in rejecting or accepting a plea. This is followed in some jurisdictions
overseas and it could be a good start here as well,” he added. Inadequate disclosure can be a strong dent on the reputation of the
company involved. In the recent days, ICICI Bank CEO Chanda Kochhar had to proceed on forced leave on grounds that adequate
disclosures about her husband, Deepak Kochhar, dealing with loan defaulter Videocon were not made.

Lenders said that for resolutions under IBC, there will be many more instances of conflicts of interest, particularly at the RP level. For
large accounts, most banks prefer an RP who is backed by large firms since they have to adhere to strict timelines. Since there are a
handful of large consultancy firms such as EY, Delloite, BDO, KPMG and RBS who have been auditors and advisors for very long time
are now dabbling as administrators for the bankrupt companies, there will be conflicts as some who acted as auditors are now acting as
administrators investigating if there were diversions of funds or related party transactions.

Veteran banker K M Jayarao, who is executive chairman of Ambit Flowers ARC and was senior general manager of ICICI Bank, said:
“The buck stops at the committee of creditors. They should be taking a final call on how to sort out conflicts among parties without
prejudice.”

Stay on top of business news with The Economic Times App. Download it Now!

Live Market Industry About Us

News Newsletters Create Your Own Ad
Portfolio Commodities Advertise with Us
Powered by Mobile Speed Terms of Use & Grievance Redressal
Live TV Blogs Privacy policy
Biz Listings RSS

Download it from Download it from Download it from

FOLLOW US APP STORE GOOGLE PLAY Windows Store

Other Times Group news sites Hot on the Web

इकनॉिमक टाइ | ઈકોનોિમક ટાઈ સ | Pune Mirror | Bangalore Mirror | Ahmedabad Mirror | Share Market | GST | Income Tax Slabs | Aadhaar Card | IFSC Code | Mutual Funds |
ItsMyAscent | Education Times | Brand Capital | Mumbai Mirror | Times Now | How to save Income Tax | Sensex Today | Nifty Bank | Sensex | Income Tax Calculator
Indiatimes | नवभारत टाइ | महारा टाइ | ಜಯ ಕ ಟಕ | Go Green | AdAge India | FIFA World Cup 2018
| Eisamay | IGN India | NavGujarat Samay | Times of India | Samayam Tamil |
Samayam Telugu | Miss Kyra | Bombay Times | Filmipop | BrainBaazi | BrainBaazi APP Services
Book print ads| Online shopping | Matrimonial | Astrology | Jobs | Tech Community |
Living and Entertainment Property | Buy car | Bikes in India | Free Classifieds | Send money to India | Used Cars
Timescity| iDiva | Entertainment | Zoom | Healthmeup | Luxpresso | Gadget Reviews | | Restaurants in Delhi | Remit to India | Buy Mobiles | Listen Songs | News |
Titanium & Platinum Credit Card | Online Songs | MensXP | Hotels | Travel TimesMobile | Real Estate Developers | Restaurant Deals in Delhi | Car Insurance |
Destinations | Cricbuzz | Recipes | Gaana | Happytrips | Getsmartapp Gadgets Now | Free Business Listings | CouponDunia | Remit2India | Techradar |
AliveAR | Getsmartapp App | ETMoney Finance App | Feedback | Auto
Interest Network
itimes

In Case You Missed It

All about PNB Fraud Income Tax Calculator

Home Loan Calculator Walmart Flipkart Deal

Reliance Jio Bajaj Finance

Education Loan Calculator Income Tax

Indian Railways Dubai Emirates

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code IFSC Code

Copyright © 2018 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/finance/banking/conflict-of-interest-in-resolution-plans-may-erode-ibc-credibility/printarticle/648… 2/2