Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ARCHITECTURAL ENGINEERING
a
Building, Civil and Environmental Engineering Department, Concordia University, Montreal, Canada
b
Young Researchers and Elite Club, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
KEYWORDS Abstract A sustainable building is constructed of materials that could decrease environmental
Building information model- impacts, such as energy usage, during the lifecycle of the building. Building Information Modeling
ing; (BIM) has been identified as an effective tool for building performance analysis virtually in the
Energy consumption; design stage. The main aims of this study were to assess various combinations of materials using
Energy efficient building; BIM and identify alternative, sustainable solutions to reduce operational energy consumption.
Sustainable building; The amount of energy consumed by a double story bungalow house in Johor, Malaysia, and assess-
Environmental impacts; ments of alternative material configurations to determine the best energy performance were evalu-
Annual lifecycle assessment ated by using Revit Architecture 2012 and Autodesk Ecotect Analysis software to show which of
the materials helped in reducing the operational energy use of the building to the greatest extent
throughout its annual life cycle. At the end, some alternative, sustainable designs in terms of energy
savings have been suggested.
2014 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Ain Shams University.
investigated since it has the main proportion of operational building in terms of its thermal aspect of energy consumption
energy consumption of the buildings. Every building is made in the operational stage by using BIM, as well as by assessing
up of a series of component, which have a role in thermal the configurations of local, alternative materials to determine
dissipation. The rate of energy dissipation in each of these those that have the greatest impacts on building performance
building components depends on design and environmental by reducing the annual usage of operational energy, thereby
conditions. But due to their sensitivity, they follow a improving the energy efficiency of the building.
proportion. So, actions done in order to promote the quality
of buildings in terms of heat exchanges can lead to significant
energy saving. Using appropriate thermal insulation can 2. Literature review
reduce heating and cooling loads that not only leads to help
to the family economy, but also causes a reduction in Many researchers have focused on the promotion of energy
greenhouse gas emissions by reducing energy consumption. efficiency in buildings. For example, Short et al. [10] reported
The thermal building insulation materials and solutions that natural ventilation was an effective strategy for enhancing
constitute one of the key fields [6]. the energy efficiency of buildings. Jones-Lee and Loomes [11]
Green buildings often include measures to reduce energy showed that a prior strategy with a benefit–cost ratio measure
consumption – both the embodied energy required to extract, can lead to energy savings. Many of the previous studies
process, transport, and install building materials and the oper- concentrated mainly on technical or design strategies [12].
ational energy, i.e., the energy consumed during the in-use Peippo et al. [13] used a numerical optimization procedure to
phase of a building’s life to provide necessary services, such determine the optimal, building-design variables that would
as heating, cooling, and providing power for equipment. To result in the lowest lifecycle cost given certain project specifica-
reduce the thermal aspects of energy consumption in the oper- tions and an energy consumption target. They showed the
ational stage, high-efficiency windows and insulation in walls, importance of considering the building as a complete system
ceilings, and floors increase the efficiency of the building. to optimize the design variables simultaneously, since design
Reducing the use of operational energy should be the main options are strongly coupled.
concern of architects who wish to design and build ‘‘green’’ In daily practice, architects must meet the demands of their
buildings. clients and future building occupants for energy efficiency.
One of the relevant issues is implementing the traditional Moreover, most industrial countries now have building regula-
planning environment in which energy and performance anal- tions that enforce at least a basic set of energy conservation
yses of buildings typically are performed after architectural measures. Sometimes, significant efforts are made to encour-
design has been completed and construction documents have age building design teams to do better than just meeting the
been produced. minimum requirements [14].
Analysis of the energy consumption of buildings is a diffi- Several methodologies have been developed for estimating
cult task, because it requires considering the detailed interac- energy consumption. Some of them are based on statistics,
tions between the building, the HVAC system, and the while others are based on simulations [15]. In general, it is
surroundings (weather), as well as obtaining mathematical/ accepted that weather data must be given careful attention
physical models that are effective in characterizing each of and consideration in forecasting the energy consumption of
those items. The dynamic behavior of the weather conditions buildings [16]. Papa et al. [17] proposed a normalized energy
and building operation and the presence of multiple variables use index (NEUI) based on a temperature function. They dis-
require the aid of computers in the design and operation of cussed the influence of weather variables, such as solar radia-
buildings that have improved performance from the stand- tion and air velocity, and concluded that the ambient
point of reduced energy consumption. The disadvantage of temperature has the greatest effect on energy consumption.
taking this approach is that the use of computer simulations Computer-aided design (CAD) is the use of computer sys-
requires considerable amounts of detailed, input data and tems to assist in the creation, modification, analysis, or optimi-
time, even for experienced users [7]. zation of a design [18]. BIM systems are the latest generation
The most effective decisions related to the sustainable of object-oriented, CAD systems in which all of the intelligent
design of a building are those that are made in the pre-con- building objects that combine to make a building design can
struction and/or construction stages. Obviously, decisions coexist in a single ‘project database’ or ‘virtual building’ that
made after these stages lead to the inefficient and expensive captures everything that is known about the building.
process of retroactively modifying the design of the building Although BIM was developed in the mid-1980s, only recently
to achieve a set of performance criteria [8]. In order to realis- has its popularity increased within the architectural, engineer-
tically assess the performance of a building in the early design ing, and construction (AEC) industries.
and pre-construction phases, access to a comprehensive set of In 1986, Graphisoft introduced its first ‘‘Virtual Building
knowledge of a building’s form, materials, context, and techni- Solution’’ known as ArchiCAD [19]. This revolutionary
cal systems is required. new software allowed architects to create virtual, three-
Since Building Information Modeling (BIM) allows multi- dimensional (3D) representations of their projects instead of
disciplinary information to be superimposed within one model, the standard two-dimensional (2D) objects found in compet-
it creates an opportunity for sustainability measures and ing CAD programs of the time. This was important because
performance analysis to be performed throughout the design architects and engineers then were able to store large
process [8,9]. amounts of datasets ‘within’ the building model. These data-
The main purpose of the study was to identify several sets include the geometry of the building and spatial data, as
sustainable designs that can have positive effects on energy well as the properties and quantities of the components used
saving and to evaluate the annual lifecycle performance of a in the design.
Reducing the operational energy demand in buildings using building information modeling tools and sustainability approaches 43
Although BIM technology is still relatively new, those who The alternative changes in material compositions in the
have used it have indicated that the creation of a 3D model mentioned components of the case study building were
with associated information reduces design errors, improves examined to evaluate their effects on reducing the building’s
design quality, shortens construction time, and reduces con- annual operational energy use. Subsequently, some alternative,
struction costs significantly [20]. Due to these initial findings, traditional, sustainable designs that could reduce energy
the popularity of BIM has grown tremendously in the past dec- consumption were identified using 3D Max software. Fig. 2
ade, and, as the popularity of BIM increases, the demand for illustrates the hierarchy of the study. According to Fig. 2, after
well-trained designers and construction managers with skills providing the drawing plans and materials specifications of the
in BIM technology also has increased [21]. case study building, the building is simulated in Revit
Since 2007, the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) Architecture 2012 software. After simulation, for integrating
has required the use of BIM on all major projects, and, between Revit and Energy Modeling tool (Autodesk Ecotect
although not required at this time, GSA is encouraging ‘‘exact Analysis software), zones must be formed for creating various
energy estimates in the design process’’ [8]. These regulations, parts of the building. Without creating zones in Revit architec-
which often are implemented to reduce lifecycle costs, also can ture, energy of the building’s various spaces cannot be mod-
have potentially significant financial implications for the eled. In fact, the file cannot be exported to Ecotect software.
design, construction, and operating costs [22]. After creating zones, for exporting the simulation file from
Ecotect, owned by Autodesk, Inc., is ‘‘a complete building Revit to Ecotect, the gbXML based export way explained in
design and environmental analysis tool that covers the full range the next parts must be used. This is the way that can export
of simulation and analysis functions required to the true under- all building’s specifications defined in Revit to Ecotect. By
standing of how a building design will operate and do’’ [8]. The choosing gbXML based export, some basic and necessary
analysis capabilities of the primary program include energy assumptions for energy modeling such as location and types
analysis, thermal analysis, and lighting/shading analyses. of the building must be established. After considering essential
The present study focused on the methods implemented assumptions, the file is exported to the Ecotect software for
through the design phase with the aid of BIM to evaluate var- energy modeling and analysis. In Ecotect, after establishing
ious building components with different materials to mitigate some additional assumptions, such as activity, type of system,
energy losses from the building, improve the building’s and environmental temperature range for comfort of the
performance in terms of annual operational energy consump- building the baseline building annual operational energy use
tion, and identify some alternative, sustainable designs for is calculated. Then, some alternative materials to evaluate their
the case study building in terms of energy savings. effects on annual operational energy consumption are
examined to establish a set of energy efficient materials. In
3. Research methodology the next step, some alternative, sustainable solutions are rec-
ommended for achieving a higher energy efficient building.
Since conventional bungalow houses are popular in Malaysia
due to its tropical weather, a double story bungalow house 4. Case-study building
located in Johor, Malaysia, was simulated by using Revit
Architecture 2012. It is the house’s annual operational energy As mentioned, a double story bungalow house was chosen as
consumption was calculated through Ecotect Analysis. Since the case study. It consisted of 400 m2 of a functional area,
Malaysia is a tropical country, no heating load was considered including six bedrooms, five bathrooms, and two kitchens. It
in the calculation of annual operational energy consumption. was located in Johor, Malaysia. The construction material
Those building’s components that have most impact on energy was in situ, reinforced concrete, and the exterior walls were
dissipation have been investigated. Fig. 1 shows the amount of plastered brick walls. The windows were double-glazed glass
energy dissipation in different parts of the building [23]. with aluminum frames. Table 1 shows the components and
As shown in Fig. 1, some components, such as wall, win- types of materials used, and Fig. 3 shows the building’s floor
dows, door, floor and ceiling can lead to the most energy plans and orientation. These materials are considered as the
dissipation. study’s baseline design.
5. BIM simulation
Integrating BIM tool with Energy Modeling Tool Large and high terraces with brick
(Autodesk Ecotect analysis) and/or straw reticular wall
Energy Modeling and analysis of the building through Using bamboo shade on the windows
Ecotect Analysis software
Reduction of the amount of windows
Calculating the building annual operational energy use to 15%
Examining some alternative materials to evaluate their Using Unilateral wind deflector
effects on annual operational energy consumption
Establishing a set of energy efficient materials based Achieving a higher energy efficient building
on investigated materials
Figure 8 Solar energy absorption by surfaces of the building used to replace the baseline design to investigate their impacts
orientation. on reducing and/or increasing energy consumption. Finally, a
set of higher-performance materials was recommended for the
purpose of reducing the energy consumption of the building,
due to various limitations, such as adjacent building position which will lead to decreases in the embodied energy and in car-
and the environmental situation. bon dioxide emissions.
For the case study, this action was not applicable due to its
position and also to its being in the construction stage, but 6.2.1. Baseline design cooling energy consumption
considering it in this study can take the benefits of BIM into As mentioned, the baseline design of the case-study house
account. Figs. 8 and 9 show the degree of solar energy absorp- involves brick plaster for the wall, double-glazed aluminum
tion by surfaces of the building in the specified orientation and frames for the windows, metal deck for the roof, concrete
position, and the best and worst orientations of the buildings ceramic tile for the floor, and hollow-core plywood for the
for solar energy absorption are shown in yellow and red lines, door. Fig. 10 shows the heating and cooling load required
respectively. As shown in Fig. 9, the best and worst orienta- for each month of the year. By considering all months, it
tions were 37.5 and 127.5 from the north respectively. This is seen that the energy used throughout the year to keep
means that, if the building were rotated 37.5 from the north, the building’s temperature between 22 and 26 C based on
it would absorb the most solar energy which could be so effi- these materials was 17,600 kW h. As shown in Fig. 10, there
cient when it is needed in providing a proportion of building’s is just a cooling load for all months of a year due to the
necessary energy. location of the building in Malaysia, which is a very hot
and humid area. In Fig. 10, the blue and red colors repre-
6.2. Analysis of annual operational energy consumption sent the cooling and heating loads, respectively. It obviously
shows that there is just a cooling load for this building. In
In conducting the analysis, a few assumptions related to the fact, all months are warm in Malaysia. As can be seen,
building zones were made. The building was divided into 20 the highest amount of energy consumption occurs in Decem-
zones, including five single bedrooms, one master bedroom, ber, January, and February. On the other hand, energy con-
two kitchens, five bathrooms, one dining room, and two family sumption in June and July is the lowest, at about 7000 and
rooms. It also was assumed that four people were going to live 10,000 W, respectively. In fact, all of these analyses are
in the building. The HVAC system of the building was a single- based on a strong database in Ecotect analysis software in
room cooling system. For each zone, including bedrooms, which the weather specifications of all regions around the
master bedroom, living room, family room, and kitchen, sepa- world have been established.
rate air conditioning systems were to be installed. Table 2 Conduction is a factor that may have a large impact on the
shows various essential assumptions about each zone that were loading values for the building. A breakdown of the passive
considered for calculating the energy consumption of the gains was acquired from Ecotect as a visual sign of the contri-
building with four inhabitants. After considering all assump- bution of each part of the building in load losses and gains.
tions and conducting the analysis of energy consumption, a Fig. 11 shows the impact percentages of various factors on
calculation was done to determine the amount of cooling load losses and gains. It was calculated that, based on the base-
energy required to keep the temperature of the building line building design, the role of conduction in load losses was
between 22 and 26 C. The energy consumption was deter- about 90%. It is clearly evident that conduction has the largest
mined based on the baseline design, including current material impact on load losses. It might be possible to reduce this to
specifications of the building. Then, alternative materials were some extent by changing the materials.
Reducing the operational energy demand in buildings using building information modeling tools and sustainability approaches 47
MONTHLY HEATING/COOLING LOADS - All Visible Thermal Zones Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
W
4000000
3000000
2000000
1000000
1000000
2000000
3000000
4000000
5000000
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Heating Cooling
6.2.2. Wall modification (Modification 1) block render, double brick cavity plaster, and framed plaster-
Brick plaster was replaced as the wall component of the building board to identify a material with better performance while
by alternative materials, such as concrete block plaster, concrete retaining the original structure of the building. Table 3 indicates
48 M.V. Shoubi et al.
GAINS BREAKDOWN - All Visible Thermal Zones 1st January - 31st December %
Wh/m2
9.9%
9.9%
5600
4200 40.0%
2800
24.0%
1400
15.3%
0
1400
Overall Gains/Losses
2800
90.1%
4200
5600
7000
14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th 14th 28th
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Conduction Sol-Air Direct Solar Ventilation Internal Inter-Zonal
Figure 11 Breakdown of passive gains of the building based on the baseline design.
the amount of energy used annually based on the baseline design Table 4 shows that, by using double-glazed glass with tim-
and the use of alternative materials as the wall component. ber frames instead of double-glazed glass with aluminum
Table 3 indicates that Double Brick Cavity Plaster and frames, the annual operational energy consumption will be
Reverse Brick Veneer as alternative materials would provide decreased by about 800 kW h. Although the conductivity
the greatest reductions in annual operational energy consump- impacts of both types are nearly the same, it indicates that
tion, i.e., about 1000 kW h, if they were used instead of brick the timber is more energy efficient than the aluminum in reduc-
plaster as the wall component. So, based on the data obtained, ing the amount of energy consumption. Fig. 13 shows the sec-
double brick cavity plaster and reverse brick veneer are more tion of double-glazed glass windows with aluminum frames.
energy efficient than the other alternatives, and framed plaster-
board is the least effective in terms of operational energy con- 6.2.4. Modification of the floor (Modification 3)
sumption. Fig. 12 shows sections of each wall used in this In this study, two alternative components are contemplated for
study. It shows that using a layer of insulation, such as fiber- the floor, i.e., Concrete Floor-Timber Suspended and Timber
glass or rock and slag wool along with a thin layer of wood, Floor Suspended. So, the Concrete Floor-Tiles Suspended
will have positive impacts on reducing energy consumption. was replaced by these types of materials to investigate their
capability for reducing energy consumption. Table 5 shows
6.2.3. Modification of the windows (Modification 2) the annual operational energy consumption used based on
As mentioned before, the windows component used for the case the three types of constituents used for the floor. As shown,
study was double-glazed glass in aluminum frames. In this step, there was about 1000 kW h difference between the baseline
other types of materials, including double-glazed glass in timber floor and the two alternative floors. So, in terms of energy con-
frames, single-glazed glass in aluminum frames, and single- sumption, it is apparent that the tile material is more energy
glazed glass in timber frames are considered to investigate efficient than timber in this composition.
how much this manipulation affects the overall operational As mentioned, it can be seen that, by substituting timber
energy consumption of the building in a year. Table 4 demon- instead of tile as an alternative in the study, the operational
strates the amount of operational energy consumption based annual energy consumption increased. So, the baseline compo-
on the alternative materials that can be used as window nent of the floor was more energy efficient than the alternative
components. materials. Fig. 14 indicates that the section of concrete
Table 3 Impact of the use of alternative materials of the wall component on the amount of operational energy
used annually.
Material Annual operational Annual electricity
energy consumption (kW h) price (USD)
Baseline Brick plaster 17,600 1770
Alternative Concrete block plaster 17,360 1730
Concrete block render 17,530 1750
Framed plasterboard 20,600 2070
Double brick cavity plaster 16,600 1670
Reverse brick veneer 16,600 1670
Reducing the operational energy demand in buildings using building information modeling tools and sustainability approaches 49
(c) Concrete block render wall (d) Framed plaster board wall
(e) Double brick cavity plaster wall (f) Reverse brick veneer wall
Table 4 Impact of alternative materials as window components on amount of annual operational energy usage.
Material Annual operational energy Annual electricity
consumption (kW h) price (USD)
Baseline Double-glazed glass with aluminum frames 17,600 1770
Alternative Double-glazed glass with timber frames 16,800 1680
Single-glazed glass with aluminum frames 19,650 2000
Single-glazed glass with timber frames 19,200 1920
floor-tiles suspended is a more energy efficient component for the were considered as substitutes for the hollow-core plywood
floor. One thin layer of ceramic tiles and plaster board were used door. Table 6 indicates the various values of annual opera-
for the inside and outside layers of the floor, respectively, and a tional energy consumption based on these various materials.
thick layer of concrete and an air gap were used in the floor. There was very little difference in terms of energy consump-
tion for the materials. Nevertheless, the glass sliding door
6.2.5. Modification of the door (Modification 4) produced an annual savings of about 50 kW h, so it can
Four different options, i.e., solid core pine timber, solid core be deemed to be the most energy efficient of the alternatives.
oak timber, glass sliding door, and Foam-Core Plywood In these situations, various issues, such as economics and
50 M.V. Shoubi et al.
personal preference may be considered in making the choice. consumption based on two different compositions of materials
The other matter is that using polystyrene foam in the foam- in the ceiling.
core plywood instead of the air gap in the hollow-core ply-
wood door would not be effective in reducing energy 6.2.7. Modification of the temperature of the HVAC system
consumption. (Modification 6)
If the temperature of the HVAC system is adjusted properly, it
6.2.6. Modification of the ceiling (Modification 5) can be one of the most effective ways of reducing the building’s
By using insulation in the ceiling, the annual operational energy consumption. Even raising the set temperature by only
energy consumption was reduced by about 1500 kW h, consid- one degree can reduce the number of kilowatt-hours used
erably more than reductions achieved by the other modifica- annually by a significant amount. Table 8 indicates how
tions. Table 7 demonstrates the annual operational energy increasing the set temperature by just one degree higher than
Reducing the operational energy demand in buildings using building information modeling tools and sustainability approaches 51
the set temperature in the baseline design can reduce the Forms that move in contrast to the natural surroundings
annual energy consumption by 2350 kW h. will have to expend extra energy, much like a fish that is
swimming against the flow of the stream.
6.2.8. Overall modification
After investigating the modifications of each component, the 8. Some effective, sustainable solutions for the case-study
implications for annual operational energy consumption building in terms of energy savings
resulting from the combination of all of the modifications were
investigated. Table 9 shows the annual operational energy con- According to Köppen climate classification system [26],
sumption based on the combination of all of the modifications, Malaysia is in group A, tropical rainforest climate where all
i.e., that the combination has the potential for saving about 12 months have average precipitation of at least 60 mm and
4750 kW h annually. time of lower sun and shorter days may have more rain.
The climate is warm with high humidity and stable air.
7. Architectural measures to achieve the best energy savings Since the humidity is usually as high as 90%, the ‘hot and
humid’ title can be used in this area.
The strategy used for choosing and deploying insulation in The case-study building, which had an annual operational
the building and its relation to the comfort of the occupants energy consumption of about 17,600 kW h, demonstrates the
requires careful consideration of the ways that energy is importance of developing a principled design that includes,
transmitted, including its directions and intensity. This may for example, opening standards, proper ventilation, and
change during the day and/or from season to season. shadowing.
Among the relevant issues, materials used rank high, but These aspects have been considered in the traditional archi-
the most significant issues are the proper design and combi- tecture of this region for achieving comfortable space in houses
nations of these materials, where they are placed, and their and buildings. And the indigenous people have found solutions
application on forms that are suitable and consistent with that have allowed them to achieve appropriate space in this
the climate. In this way, we are able to achieve the most effi- region over a long time. Sometimes, tradition offers the best
cient way possible for insulating the living space and making design solutions and uses local materials in the most efficient
it comfortable for the residents. To achieve a sustainable and effective manner. And, in the present day, it is more
form, we must, to the extent possible, ensure that harmony important than ever that we pay attention to these solutions
is established between the forms of materials that are used and architectural patterns if we are to achieve sustainable
and the surrounding, natural environment. Forms that are buildings.
harmonized and aligned with the natural environment can The following solutions can be used in the architectural
obtain some of their energy from nature, allowing harmoni- phase of the development of this building to help save energy
ous co-existence of people, their dwelling places, and nature. when the building is completed:
52 M.V. Shoubi et al.
8.1. Using large and high terraces and brick and/or straw occurs through the reflection of the sun from glossy and semi-
reticular walls to create shadows, particularly in front of the sun glossy objects around the windows. Green plants can be placed
in the shade to absorb and reflect sunlight, thereby preventing
In this building, we see terraces on the east and west sides of it from heating the space. Fig. 17 shows how a window shade
the building. The east and west orientation is due to the fact can affect the penetration of sunlight into the space inside the
that the low angle of the sun on the horizon has warmer air building during warm and/or cold seasons.
and dazzling light. For this reason, it is difficult to sit comfort-
ably in this place. To make it more comfortable and usable, 8.3. Reduction of the amount of windows to 15% of the building
reticular walls can be used to create shadows in this space
and to cause the wind to blow, cooling the area somewhat. The windows are elements of the building that facilitate the
Fig. 15 shows the form of the reticular walls designed for the ventilation of the building, allow light to enter, and provide
terrace of the building. a way for the occupants to see outside the building. And com-
mensurate with the value of the building, the type of glass and
8.2. Using shade on the windows to decrease the penetration of the way it is framed can contribute to wasting energy in build-
sunlight into the living spaces ings. On average, 10–20% of the energy loss in a house is
attributable to the windows [27]. For minimizing energy waste
This projection was made of bamboo, which is abundant in and providing common lighting, having the windows make up
this area and is a light and traditional material of this region. just 15% of the area of the building is adequate [27]. Consid-
Fig. 16 illustrates the form of these shades for the windows. ering that the test-case building had an area of 400 m2, the win-
Sunlight penetrates into space in two ways, i.e., directly and dows should occupy about 60 m2. However, as designed, the
indirectly. Direct penetration occurs in the form of the sun- windows in this building occupy about 30% of the area of
light’s entering the space directly without any intermediate the building, i.e., about 120 m2. Thus, this excessive area
obstruction or buffer to prevent its entry. Indirect penetration devoted to windows can cause increased energy consumption.
Figure 17 Use of window shades to reduce the penetration of sunlight into the building in different seasons.
Reducing the operational energy demand in buildings using building information modeling tools and sustainability approaches 53
8.4. Proper ventilation in the interior space due to high humidity building was estimated. The modifications included various
of this region components, such as the walls, windows, door, ceiling, and
the indoor temperature. Also, the individual modifications
Wind deflectors can be used to provide ventilation and air flow were combined to determine the overall effect of all of the
in buildings in this region. Different types of wind deflectors modifications, and this effect was compared with the results
are used for different weather conditions. Unilateral wind acquired in the baseline design. The annual amount of energy
deflectors for the suction of internal air are one of the best used for baseline design was determined to be about
types in use in this area. The opening of this type of wind 17,600 kW h. The results of the study indicated that the use
deflector is placed upwind to offer suction properties so that of alternative materials, such as double-brick and reverse-
air will enter the building. Fig. 18 shows the position and shape brick veneer, timber, concrete floor-tiles, plaster insulation,
of the wind deflector. and glass in the components of the walls, windows, floors,
Because of the high ceiling in this space, hot air, due to its ceilings, and doors, respectively, was more energy efficient
lower density rises and exits from the building. The part of the than the other materials investigated. Thus, they could have
wind deflector that opens is composed of two components, i.e., a significant, beneficial role in reducing the building’s opera-
a movable panel and mesh. The movable panels are controlled tional energy requirements. It was apparent that the annual
electrically by residents, and they can be closed when the air is amount of the building’s energy could be reduced to
not needed. Metallic or plastic mesh is installed after the panel 12,580 kW h by replacing the baseline design with a carefully
to prevent the entry of animals and foreign objects into the designed, alternative design. In material modification, the
space. Fig. 19 illustrates how the wind deflector works. economic aspects are one of the most important issues that
must be taken into consideration by contractors and/or cli-
ents. In doing so, considerable energy can be saved during
9. Research analysis the building’s lifecycle, resulting in reducing operational
energy usage and CO2 emissions, thereby contributing to
The main purpose of this paper was to investigate the potential the achievement of a sustainable, green building.
of BIM in assessing the effectiveness of different combinations Concerning architectural design, it became apparent that
of materials in various components of the building to decrease we could increase the comfortable space available in the build-
the annual operational energy consumption of the building. ing by using some of the traditional patterns of this region that
The paper also suggested some sustainable solutions that have have been developed by the indigenous people over many dec-
been proven to be effective in reducing the energy consumption ades. This comfort is considered as a strategy in sustainable
of the building. In fact, this study showed that considering tra- architecture, so it can be concluded that we can achieve sus-
ditional practices, as well as new technologies, can be an effec- tainable architecture and also achieve sustainability by inte-
tive approach. grating the traditional patterns of this region with the
After the essential data required for the simulation had architecture of the building. As shown in this paper, these tra-
been gathered and after importing the data to the energy ditional patterns use large, high terraces with brick and/or
analysis software, the building was simulated using the straw reticular walls, bamboo shade on the windows, reduce
BIM tool, and the annual energy consumption of the the area of the windows to 15% of the total area, and use
54 M.V. Shoubi et al.
unilateral wind deflectors, many of which could be beneficially [7] Zhu. Simulation of miscible liquid–liquid interactions. In: ACM
applied to the case-study building, making it more sustainable. symposium on virtual reality software and technology, Newport
Beach, CA; 2006.
[8] Schueter A, Thessling F. Building information model based
10. Conclusions
energy/exergy performance assessment in early design stages. J
Autom Constr 2008.
A study of the application of BIM for the case-study building, [9] Krygiel E, Nies B. Green BIM successful sustainable design with
which was a sample of single, residential, house, was con- building information modeling. Indianapolis (IN): Wiley Publish-
ducted. The results of the study will be useful to architects ing; 2008.
and building designers as they use the BIM concept to develop [10] Short CA, Lomas KJ, Woods A. Design strategy for low-energy
ventilation and cooling within an urban heat island. Build Res Inf
more energy-efficient buildings in the future with the goal of
2004;32(3):187–206.
achieving sustainable development for society. Government
[11] Jones-Lee M, Loomes G. Valuation of safety. In: Hensher DA,
should provide incentives for designers and engineers to use Button KA, editors. Handbook of Transport and the Environ-
the BIM tool, specifically in the pre-construction stage, to ment. Oxford: Elsevier Science; 2003 [chapter 24].
investigate problems that are likely to occur in the future so [12] Yilmaz Z. Evaluation of energy efficient design strategies for
they can deal with such problems in the preliminary stage. different climatic zones: comparison of thermal performance of
Education and training also are significant factors that should buildings in temperate-humid and hot-dry climate. Energy Build
be taken into account by government for improving BIM in 2007;39:306–16.
each society. [13] Peippo K, Lund PD, Vartiainen E. Multivariate optimization of
Building simulation and investigating the performance of design tradeoffs for solar low energy buildings. Energy Build
1999;20:189–205.
the building virtually in the pre-construction and/or even dur-
[14] Bosselaar OH. The Netherlands policy for stimulating the use of
ing the construction stage will help decision makers, designers,
passive solar energy. In: Konttinen, Lund, editors. North Sun
engineers, and architects to select specifications with the least 1997, 7th International conference on solar energy at high
detrimental impact to the environment. In the building con- latitudes, Espoo-Otaniemi, Finland, June 9–11; 1997. p. 27–
struction sector, BIM can be beneficial to building designers 30.
in determining the best building orientations and designs. In [15] Westfall LA, Nanduri M, Taylor G. Estimating the impacts of
the design and pre-construction stages, the Building Informa- voluntary programs: results from a recent study on the Canadian
tion Model (BIM) should be taken into account as a compre- industry program for energy conservation. In: Proceedings of the
hensive simulation method that can be used to create 2003 ACEEE summer study on energy efficiency in industry, vol.
opportunities to assess and improve the performances of build- 6. Washington, DC: American Council for an Energy-Efficient
Economy; 2003. p. 253–260.
ings. This integration of the BIM concept into the design stage
[16] Hernandez P, Kenny P. Defining zero energy buildings. A life
can and be used to select the best green building designs and
cycle perspective. In: Proceedings of the PLEA 2008 – 25th
reduce the need for later design modifications that require conference on passive and low energy architecture, Dublin,
extra time and cost. Efforts to prevent adverse environmental Ireland; 2008. p. 22–4.
impacts and to minimize energy costs are beginning to show [17] Papa Pietra R, Jota Da silva, Assis, Sad E. Energy index
beneficial effects in terms of more efficient and sustainable evaluation of buildings in function of the external temperature.
building designs, improved building performance, and minimi- Proc: Build Simul 2007:1890–4.
zation of environmental risks. In addition to BIM technology [18] Narayan K Lali. Computer aided design and manufacturing.
as an effective solution, the use of various architectural New Delhi: Prentice Hall of India; 2008, p. 3. ISBN:
solutions can be helpful in reducing energy consumption. So, 812033342X.
[19] Kmethy, Greg. ArchiCAD versions – ArchicadWiki. FrontPage –
BIM planners and architects should cooperate in the pre-
ArchicadWiki (2 Oct. 2008. 23 Aug. 2009). <http://www.archic-
construction stage to achieve the best sustainable solutions.
adwiki.com/ArchiCAD%20versions>.
[20] Eastman C, Teicholz P, Sacks R, Liston K. BIM handbook: A
References guide to building information modelling for owner, managers,
designers, engineers, and contractors. New Jersey: John Wiley and
[1] Junnila S, Horvath A. Life-cycle environmental effects of an office Sons, Inc.; 2008.
building. J Infrastruct Syst 2003:157–66, 9_4. [21] Underwood J, Isikdag U. Emerging technologies for BIM 2.0.
[2] Zabalza Bribián I, Aranda Usón A, Scarpellini S. Life cycle Constr Innov: Inf Process Manage 2011;11(3):252–8.
assessment in buildings: state-of-the-art and simplified LCA [22] Autodesk, Inc. Building information modeling for sustainable
methodology as a complement for building certification. Build design. Autodesk, Inc., White Paper. <www.autodesk.com>.
Environ 2009;12:2510–20. Understanding Revit Terms [help.autodesk.com/.../Revit/.../
[3] Operational Energy Use-wikicommon language. <http://www. GUID-2480CA33-C0B9-46FD-9]; 2005.
sccommonlanguage.eu/index.php?title=Operational_Energy_ [23] Haringey Council. Energy, save energy – together we can make a
Use>. difference. <http://www.haringey.gov.uk/energyadvice.htm>.
[4] U.S. Energy Information Administration, Emissions of Green- [24] Architecture Design Tool. <http://www.autodesk.com/products/
house Gases in the United States. <http://www.eia.gov/environ- revit-family/features/architectural-design/all/list-view>.
ment/reports.cfm?t=176>. [25] Understanding Revit Terms. [help.autodesk.com/.../Revit/.../
[5] Heat loss in your home and what you can do about it. GUID-2480CA33-C0B9-46FD-9].
<www.nigelsecostore.com>. [26] Köppen climate classification. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
[6] Jelle Bjorn Petter, Gustavsen Arild. The high performance K%C3%B6ppen_climate_classification>.
thermal building insulation materials and solutions of tomorrow. [27] Energy Efficiency and Traditional Buildings. <http://www.dar-
Buildings 2010, <http://web.ornl.gov/sci/buildings/2012/2010% lington.gov.uk/Living/Planning/ProtectionControl/Conservation/
20B11%20papers/132_Jelle.pdf>. Energy+Efficiency+and+Traditional+Buildings.htm>.
Reducing the operational energy demand in buildings using building information modeling tools and sustainability approaches 55
Mojtaba Valinejad Shoubi was born in 1985 in Dynamics and Earthquake engineering, Structural Health Monitoring,
Iran. He graduated with B.S. Degree in Civil Infrastructure Rehabilitation, Finite and Boundary Element Methods,
Engineering at Ghaemshahr Azad University, and Computer Aided Design and Engineering. Dr. Bagchi is a licensed
Iran in 2008. After receiving bachelor, he Professional Engineer in Ontario, Canada and affiliated to CSCE,
worked about 2 years as concrete building ASCE, CAEE, and ISHMII. He has authored/coauthored more than
designer, project manager and site engineer. seventy articles in technical journals and conferences, two patent
He received his master degree in the field of applications, and a number of technical reports for academia and
construction management from University industry.
Technology Malaysia in 2013. He is currently
a PhD student of civil engineering at Con-
cordia University of Montreal Canada. His research interests include Azin Shakiba Barough was born in Iran in
Infrastructures sustainability, Structural Health Monitoring, con- 1984. She graduated at B.S. degree in Civil
struction materials, Building Information Modeling (BIM), energy Engineering at University of Mazandaran,
modeling, sustainable and green building, application of nanotech- Iran in 2008. After receiving bachelor, she
nology in construction building, project management, and safety in worked about 2.5 years as a civil engineer in a
construction. He has authored fourteen international publications, building company. She received her master
including six international conferences and eight international degree in the field of construction manage-
Journals, and two national patent applications. His Phone number ment from University Technology Malaysia in
is +1 4389357002. 2013. Her research interests include infra-
structure sustainability, decision making in
construction projects, sustainable and green building, construction
Masoud Valinejad Shoubi was born in Iran in materials, application of nanotechnology, dispute resolution, ergo-
1989. He graduated with B.S. Degree in nomics and safety in construction. She has authored/coauthored more
Architectural Engineering at University of than thirteen articles in technical journals and conferences.
Tabari, Iran. He received his master from
Central Azad University of Tehran, Iran. He
is the author of four international Journals,
two national patent applications. His research
interests are sustainability in buildings, green
building design and energy efficiency in the
buildings.