Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
net/publication/267924220
Article
CITATIONS READS
2 582
4 authors, including:
Elena I Nica
University of Toronto
6 PUBLICATIONS 270 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Elena I Nica on 01 April 2015.
A B S T R A C T
C
The drug treatment of affective symptoms in borderline personality disorder (BPD) has been the subject of four recent meta-analyses of
randomized controlled studies (RCTs). This paper reviews the current evidence-based recommendations for the psychopharmacological
LL
treatment of the affective symptoms in BPD: affective instability, anger, depression, and anxiety. There was not enough data on affective
instability as an outcome measure to make a good conclusion. Most of the evidence point to a large reduction of anger with mood stabilizers
and antipsychotics. Mood stabilizers are also moderately effective against depressed mood and anxiety. Contrary to prior guidelines, selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) were shown to be minimally effective against depression in BPD. Omega 3 fatty acids helped reduce
depression. These results suggest that clinicians should raise their threshold for prescribing medication for affective instability, anxiety, and
depression, but not for anger. Clinicians must also weigh the benefits of medication over their side effects in the neurologic and metabolic
al,
domains. The meta-analyses were limited by the heterogeneity in methodology, by the small number of RCTs for each drug and small sample
sizes, and by the exclusion of patients with comorbidities that are common in this population.
Keywords: borderline personality disorder, affective instability, emotion dysregulation, anger, anxiety, depression, drug therapy, evidence
dic
based practice
Correspondence: Elena I. Nica, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, St. Michael’s Hospital, 30 Bond Street, Shutter Wing, Room
2010d, Toronto, Ontario M5B1W8, Canada. Tel.: 416 997 1605; Fax: 1 416 864 5996; e-mail: irina.nica@utoronto.ca
Me
Affective instability is part of the core pathology in border- psychotropic medication is higher in BPD than in major
line personality disorder (BPD; alongside other symptom depressive disorder or other personality disorders.1416 In a
domains such as impulsivity, unstable interpersonal relation- sample of 130 participants recruited from the community in
ships, and cognitive defects), and the underlying cause for an American study, patients with BPD had an average lifetime
severe clinical manifestations such as impulsive behaviors, use of 3.58 psychiatric medications. This medication usage
self-injury, and suicide.14 is the highest when the BPD group is compared to groups
as
As a DSMIV diagnostic criterion for BPD, affective with other personality disorders (1.58 medications), with
instability is described as ‘‘marked reactivity of mood (ie, depression (1.07 medications), or of healthy controls (0.03
intense episodic dysphoria, irritability, or anxiety usually medications).14 In a prospective 6-year US study of 290
lasting a few hours and only rarely more than a few days).’’5 patients with BPD, 70% were taking three or more psycho-
uc
The DSMV revision of BPD diagnostic criteria proposes tropic medications at 2-, 4-, or 6-year follow-up after
describing affective instability as ‘‘rapidly changing, intense, discharge from a hospital admission.16 The Canadian data
unpredictable, and reactive emotions’’ including shifts into are similar. In a one year Canadian study of 180 patients with
extreme anxiety, depression, and anger.6 This definition BPD, the average number of psychotropic medications used
nL
shares the view that affective instability is a dynamic process was 2.33, with 64% of the patients being on one or more
characterized by multiple parameters: intensity of affect, medications (most often antidepressants and antipsychotics,
frequent shifts in affect, magnitude of mood change, rapid followed by mood stabilizers and sedatives).17
raise emotion time with slow return to baseline, reactivity to In spite of the wide use of medications to treat patient with
external triggers, and reactivity to endogenous stimuli.710 BPD, there are no up-to-date clinical guidelines on drug
Sa
Given the complexity and the clinical significance of therapy for the core symptoms of this condition. The NICE
affective instability, the treatment of patients with severely guidelines13 only recommend psychopharmacological treat-
dysregulated affect is challenging. While psychotherapy is ment of comorbid depression, post-traumatic stress disorder,
considered the standard of care for the management of and anxiety. They advise against the use of medications
BPD,1113 many patients with BPD are treated with psycho- for BPD or for individual symptoms, including for affective
tropic medications. Most of the data on treatment utilization instability. They also specifically recommend against the use
comes from US studies, and they show that the use of of antipsychotics for the moderate or long-term management
of patients with BPD, but allow for the use of short-term drug One placebo controlled RCT (n 38)23 showed a significant
therapy during an acute crisis. The 2001 APA guidelines11 on decrease in rapid mood shifts after 6 weeks of treatment with
the other hand recommend the use of antidepressants (SSRIs fluvoxamine (150200 mg/day). The effect was maintained at
being the first-line) to treat affective disturbances. Newer 24 weeks. Mood shifts were defined as a change from a
meta-analyses1821 however seem to suggest a switch from neutral mood to a negative mood.
antidepressants to mood-stabilizers and antipsychotics as the
medication of choice in affective instability. This paper brings ANGER
to focus the current evidence for the psychopharmacological
Mood stabilizers as a class had the largest effect on
treatment of the symptoms of emotional dysregulation
reducing anger in all four meta- analyses.1821 For example,
included in the DSMV for BPD: affective instability, anger, the pooled data from seven RCTs (n 230) showed a very
depression, and anxiety. large effect of mood stabilizers (carbamazepine, valproate
Data on the effectiveness of drugs in the treatment of semisodium, topiramate, and lamotrigine).19 The evidence for
emotional dysregulation in BPD were obtained from the four selecting one mood stabilizer over another is based on single
most recent meta-analyses of placebo-controlled double- studies or small studies and is therefore weaker. It seems to
C
blind randomized controlled studies (RCTs).1821 They looked suggest that lamotrigine, topiramate, and carbamazepine had
at the effectiveness of antidepressants, mood stabilizers, and the largest reduction in anger for the short-term (610 weeks)
compared to a placebo. Side effects and tolerability should
LL
antipsychotics at treating specific symptoms of BPD. The
largest meta-analysis is the Cochrane systematic review of 28 also be considered. The large effect of topiramate was shown
RCTS of drug treatment for BPD published by 2009.18 The in a group of 42 male participants and separately in a group
second meta-analysis looked at placebo-controlled double- of 85 female participants from three RCTs. Topiramate was
blind RCTs of drug effectiveness for symptom clusters in accompanied by weight loss compared with the placebo.18
severe BPD and/or schizotypal personality disorders, includ- Lamotrigine was shown to reduce anger in one RCT (n 18)
al,
ing affective dysregulation (depressed mood, anxiety, anger, and carbamazepine was shown to reduce anger in one RCT
affective lability).19 The third meta-analysis looked at 18 (n 25).20 Valproate semisodium was effective after 10 weeks
placebo-controlled double-blind RCTs of drug effectiveness of treatment in a small RCT (n 16), but the effect was lost at
for depression and anger symptoms in BPD.20 The fourth 12 months and 24 weeks in another two larger studies.18,20
dic
meta-analysis looked at 22 placebo-controlled, double- The effect of mood stabilizers on reducing anger is com-
plemented by their effect on reducing impulsive behaviors.19
blind RCTs of drug effectiveness for specific symptoms in
BPD including affective instability, anxiety, depression, and Antipsychotics as a class showed a small to moderate effect
anger.21 The four meta-analyses overlap greatly in terms of on anger in the short- and medium-term, in the meta-analysis
of six RCTs (n 274 participants)20 and the meta-analysis of
Me
prolactin, changes in blood cell count, and decrease in blood instability without a major mood disorder.1820 Only mood
calcium.18 stabilizers had a moderate effect on depression, as showed by
a meta-analysis of five RCTs (n 148) on carbamazepine,
There was no effect on affective instability with ziprasidone
valproate, and topiramate.19 Antipsychotics and antidepres-
in one RCT.18 sants had no significant effect. Furthermore, haloperidol was
One placebo-controlled RCT (n 27) showed that lamotri- found to worsen depression.20 Supplementary omega 3 fatty
gine was also effective in reducing affective instability.18 acids were found to reduce depression.18
In terms of effect on anxiety, mood stabilizers were shown changes in mood faster than weekly retrospective measures
to have a moderate effect and antidepressants a small effect.19 of mood, and allowed the collection of information related
Among antipsychotics, olanzepine and aripiprazole were to other variables such as motor activity, experience of side
shown to improve anxiety in single RCTs, but the pooled effects, and adherence to treatment.8 This methodology has
effect size was not significant.19,20 not yet been implemented in drug RCTs for BPD but should
In summary, the four meta-analyses highlight general be considered as an outcome to include in future trials.
effects of major classes of drugs on emotional dysregulation. For interested researchers, Trull and Ebner-Priemer31 and
They are limited in their conclusions on individual drugs due Ebner-Priemer et al32 offer a good overview of the ESM’s
to the small number of trials for each drug. In meta-analyses advantages and strategies to implement it in research
of combined trials of lamotrigine, carbamazepine, topira- programs of affective instability.
mate, and valproate semisodium, mood stabilizers had a While the tendency is to choose drugs that worked in
large effect on anger and moderate effects on depression and treating axis I symptoms, it is important to think of the
anxiety. In a meta-analysis of combined trials of haloperidol, pathophysiology of affective instability in its own right when
olanzepine, and aripiprazole, antipsychotics showed a guiding our choice of drug treatments. Recent reviews of
C
moderate effect on anger, also maintained in single RCTs neuroimaging findings in BPD9,33,34 suggest that affective
of these drugs. The SSRIs were shown to be minimally instability is accompanied by underlying structural and
effective against depression in BPD. Omega 3 fatty acids functional changes in brain systems responsible for attention
LL
helped reduce depression. and perception of negative or ambiguous social information,
These meta-analyses are limited in their conclusions by as well as for emotion regulation.
significant factors. First, the studies are heterogeneous in On one hand, when compared with healthy study partici-
their assessment instruments, outcome measures, and sam- pants, people with BPD show greater activation of amygdala,
ple sizes. Second, there was a limited number of studies per temporal cortex, and occipital visual cortex when presented
al,
drug assessed and RCTs on one drug often came from the with emotional faces35 or pictures depicting social interac-
same research group, making it challenging to make a strong tions.36 The increased activation of visual and temporal cortex
conclusion as to its effects. There was also a limited number is an expression of increased processing of visual stimuli
of drugs investigated, especially among the antipsychotics. perceived as potentially dangerous. On the other hand, the
dic
Third, the exclusion criteria for most studies limit the up-down modulation of this exaggerated emotional response
applicability of the results to the clinical context: most is impaired. People with affective instability have difficulties
studies excluded participants with substance use disorders, engaging brain regions (prefrontal cortex, cingulate cortex,
axis I comorbidity, or suicidal ideation. Fourth, the duration and parietal cortex) that help dampen emotional response,
of the studies varied between 6 to 10 weeks, and only on
Me
of affective instability correlate poorly with measures of not reflect the evidence-based psychopharmacology of the
affective instability derived from real-time daily recordings latest meta-analyses. There is no doubt that psychotherapy is
of mood taken with experience sampling methodology the standard of care for treating BPD. However, as the
(ESM).10,26 Also referred to as ecological momentary treatment utilization data in the United States and Canada
assessment, ESM uses signaling devices such as telephone show, clinicians often make use of psychotropic medications
Sa
beepers, pagers, or handheld electronic units to sample to help treat symptoms in this patient population. The
peoples’ internal states, external events, and reactivity to following conclusions would be helpful in assisting clinicians
external events as it occurs in real time in the individual’s choose appropriate treatments. As shown by the most recent
natural environment, thus eliminating recall bias.2730 The meta-analyses, psychotropic drugs have a modest effect on
ESM seems to also have an advantage over traditional depression and anxiety in the context of BPD. There was not
measures when it comes to capturing response to treatment enough data on affective instability as an outcome measure to
in depression: daily diary measures were shown to detect make a conclusion. Contrary to prior guidelines, SSRIs were
shown to be minimally effective against depression in BPD. Disclosure: Paul S. Links has received an unrestricted educational
Omega 3 fatty acids helped reduce depression. Most of the grant from Eli Lilly Canada Inc. and the views expressed in this
evidence point to a large reduction of anger with mood publication are the views of the authors and do not necessarily reflect
stabilizers and a moderate reduction in anger with some the views of the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care.
antipsychotics (olanzepine, aripiprazole, or haloperidol).
These results suggest that clinicians should raise their REFERENCES
threshold for prescribing medication for affective instability, 1. Linehan MM, Kehrer CA. Borderline Personality Disorder. New York: Guilford
Press; 1993.
anxiety, and depression, but not for anger. Mood stabilizers
2. Paris J. The diagnosis of borderline personality disorder: problematic but
seem to have the best effect for overall emotion dysregula- better than the alternatives. Ann Clin Psychiatry. 2005;17:4146.
tion in BPD. As a class, they are particularly effective in 3. Yen S, Shea MT, Sanislow CA, et al. Borderline personality disorder
reducing anger and impulsive behaviors, and they are also criteria associated with prospectively observed suicidal behavior. Am J
moderately effective against depressed mood and anxiety. Psychiatry. 2004;161:12961298.
4. Links PS, Eynan R, Heisel MJ, Nisenbaum R. Elements of affective
However, the recommendations for individual mood stabi-
instability associated with suicidal behaviour in patients with borderline
lizers are based on the results of a limited number of small
C
personality disorder. Can J Psychiatry. 2008;53:112116.
studies. Clinicians should be aware that these recommenda- 5. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
tions should be considered in conjunction with other clinical Mental Disorders. 4th ed (text revision). Washington, DC: American
information. According to the current and limited evidence, Psychiatric Association; 2000.
LL
6. American Psychiatric Association. DSM V Development. Available at: http://
lamotrigine and topiramate seem to be good first-line
www.dsm5.org/ProposedRevisions/Pages/proposedrevision.aspx?rid17#.
treatment choices for anger. For example, lamotrigine was Accessed on September 24, 2010.
shown in a placebo-controlled RCT37 (n 18) to reduce 7. Ebner-Priemer UW, Kuo J, Kleindienst N, et al. State affective instability
anger in doses titrated from 50 mg to 200 mg over an 8- in borderline personality disorder assessed by ambulatory monitoring.
week course of treatment. A placebo-controlled RCT (n 27) al,Psychol Med. 2007;37:961970.
8. Ebner-Priemer UW, Trull TJ. Ecological momentary assessment of mood
showed that lamotrigine in daily doses ranging between 25
disorders and mood dysregulation. Psychol Assess. 2009;21:463-475.
225 mg (mean 106.7 mg) was also effective in reducing 9. Koenigsberg HW. Affective instability: toward an integration of neu-
affective instability.38 The side effects of lamotrigine should roscience and psychological perspectives. J Pers Disord. 2010;24:60-82.
be closely monitored: rash, sedation, confusion, headache, 10. Links PS, Eynan R, Heisel MJ, et al. Affective instability and suicidal
dic
dizziness, ataxia, tremor, insomnia, and irritability.37,38 ideation and behavior in patients with borderline personality disorder.
J Personal Disord. 2007;21:7286.
Likewise, three small trials of 8 and 10 weeks duration 11. American Psychiatric Association. Practice guideline for the treatment of
showed that topiramate in doses titrated from 25 to 250 mg patients with borderline personality disorder. American Psychiatric
(mean daily doses of 200250 mg) led to a large reduction in Association. Am J Psychiatry. 2001;158:152.
anger in both men (n 42) and in women (n 85). The 12. Paris J. The treatment of borderline personality disorder: implications of
Me
weight loss associated with topiramate may be a factor to research on diagnosis, etiology, and outcome. Annu Rev Clin Psychol.
2009;5:27790.
consider when selecting this drug over another. While 13. National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health. Borderline Personality
topiramate is associated with side effects at the higher Disorder: Treatment and Management. Full Guideline. Clinical Guideline
doses used to treat epilepsy (eg, acute myopia, angle closure 78. NICE. 2009. Available at: http://guidance.nice.org.uk/CG78. Accessed
glaucoma, urinary tract stones, and cognitive difficulties), it on September 24, 2010.
seems to be well tolerated in the doses used to treat anger in 14. Ansell EB, Sanislow CA, McGlashan TH, Grilo CM. Psychosocial
as
These meta-analyses summarize the current state of evi- with personality disorders. Am J Psychiatry. 2001;158:295302.
dence for pharmacological treatment of emotional dysregula- 16. Zanarini MC, Frankenburg FR, Hennen J, Silk KR. Mental health service
tion and inform the clinical decision making, but they should utilization by borderline personality disorder patients and Axis II
be regarded critically. The lack of systematic investigation of comparison subjects followed prospectively for 6 years. J Clin Psychiatry.
nL
C
spective recall. Psychol Assess. 2009;21:425436.
27. Larson R, Csikszentmihalyi M. The experience sampling method. New Dir
Methodol Soc Behav Sci. 1983;15:4156.
28. Csikszentmihalyi M, Larson R. Validity and reliability of the experience-
LL
sampling method. J Nerv Ment Dis. 1987;175:526536.
29. Nica EI, Links PS. Affective instability in borderline personality disorder:
experience sampling findings. Curr Psychiatry Rep. 2009;11:7481.
30. Ebner-Priemer UW, Kuo J, Welch SS, et al. A valence-dependent group-
specific recall bias of retrospective self-reports: a study of borderline
personality disorder in everyday life. J Nerv Ment Dis. 2006;194:774779.
31. Trull TJ, Ebner-Priemer UW. Using experience sampling methods/
ecological momentary assessment (ESM/EMA) in clinical assessment
and clinical research: introduction to the special section. Psychol Assess.
al,
2009;21:457462.
32. Ebner-Priemer UW, Eid M, Kleindienst N, Stabenow S, Trull TJ. Analytic
dic
strategies for understanding affective (in)stability and other dynamic
processes in psychopathology. J Abnorm Psychol. 2009;118:195202.
33. Dell’Osso B, Berlin HA, Serati M, Altamura AC. Neuropsychobiological
aspects, comorbidity patterns and dimensional models in borderline
personality disorder. Neuropsychobiology. 2010;61:169179.
34. Mauchnik J, Schmahl C. The latest neuroimaging findings in borderline
Me