Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Contemporary Physics
Publication details, including instructions for authors and
subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tcph20
To cite this article: B. Crossland & A. S. Bahrani (1968) Fundamentals, of explosive welding,
Contemporary Physics, 9:1, 71-87, DOI: 10.1080/00107516808204394
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the
“Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,
our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to
the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions
and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,
and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content
should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources
of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,
proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or
arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms
& Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/
terms-and-conditions
CONTEMP. PHYS., 1968, VOL. 9, NO. 1, 71-87
1. Introduction
Welding can be defined as the process of joining two or more materials, often
metallic, by localized coalescence or union across the interface. The essential
conditions for any form of welding are that the two surfaces prior to welding
should be absolutely clean and uncontaminated and that these surfaces should
be brought into intimate contact with one another. It is impossible to produce
such surfaces by normal mechanical or chemical cleaning processes. However,
under conditions of high vacuum it has been reported by Bowden and Tabor
(1954) and Keller (1963) that nearly perfectly clean surfaces can be produced.
If surfaces produced under and maintained at high vacuum are brought into
contact then adhesion will occur between the asperities. The adhesion of
harder and less ductile materials will be considerably reduced due to the
rupturing of the junctions by elastic recovery when the load is removed.
With softer and more ductile materials the junction will probably not be
ru2tured when the load is removed, and the adhesion measured will be
appreciable. If in addition to the normal force a tangential force is applied
which is not sufficiently great to produce macroscopic sliding, then it is found
that the adhesion is greatly increased even with the harder metals and it is
found that the adhesion force can reach values well in excess of the normal
load applied. The effect of a tangential force has been satisfactorily explained
by Bowden and Tabor (1950) as being caused by the increased area of contact
at the asperities as a consequence of the reduction of normal load required to
cause yielding in the presence of a tangential stress.
Even though the importance of the presence of an oxide frlm is demonstrated
by the work carried out under high vacuum, nevertheless this still does not
provide a basic understanding of the nature of the adhesion force. If two
perfectly clean and atomically flat surfaces of the same metal are brought
together, interatomic repulsive and attractive forces will come into play and
equilibrium will be reached a t the equilibrium interatomic distance for the
metal concerned when the potential energy of the system is a minimum as
shown in fig. 1. The strength of the bond will depend on the crystallographic
misorientation across the interface and the diffusion and recrystallization
72 B . Crossland and A . S . Bahrani
- interatomic spacing 4
There are basically two welding processes and there are many variants of
each. Firstly there is fusion welding in which the surface of the two metals
are melted by the application of heat and the contaminant surface layers are
brought to the surface of the melt pool. Additional metal in the form of a
filler rod may be added t o the melt pool. Heat for fusion welding can be
provided by several methods which have been developed mainly during this
century. A very usual source of heat is that produced by an acetylene oxygen
flame formed by a fine gas jet. Another method which is used extensively is
t o employ an electric arc which is formed between an electrode and the metals
being welded. Frequently this arc is formed in an inert gas shield, such as in
the a,rgon arc process in which a shield of argon is used, to prevent excessive
oxidation in the region of the weld. More recently electron-beam welding has
been introduced in which the work-piece is placed in a high vacuum system
and bombarded with a dense and focused stream of high velocity electrons.
Even more recently focused laser (light amplification by stimulated emission
of radiation) beams have been employed for welding.
The second basic welding process is pressure welding, in which the surfaces
t o be joined do not attain their melting temperature, A fine example is
Fundamentals of Explosive WeMing 73
2. Explosive welding
During the First World War it was observed that fragments of the steel
shells of bombs occasionally stuck to metallic objects in the vicinity of the
explosion. This, had it been realized, was an example of explosive welding.
explosive charge
ing
9
di e holder
I n 1954 Allen, Mapes and Wilson found when right circular cylinders were
fired obliquely into thin plane lead targets, that above a certain critical angle
which depended on the velocity the surface of the front of the cylinder was
marked by a series of ridges or ‘ waves ’. Abrahamson (1961) who discussed
the formation of these waves, gave some photomicrographs of the junctions
between a steel bullet and a copper target and a steel bullet and a steel target
which showed that welding had occurred between them.
Welding between metals was observed in explosive-forming experiments in
1957. I n explosive-forming an explosive charge is detonated under water
(see fig. 2) and the shock wave generated imparts momentum to a sheet-metal
blank clamped above a die, thus forcing the sheet metal into the die. It was
noted that if a metal die was employed and an excessive explosive charge was
used, then the metal sheet became welded to the die. This discovery gave rise
to an interest in the possibility of using high explosives for welding processes
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
and during the last few years such processes have been actively examined in
many countries and industrial use is now beginning to be made of such processes.
I n 1963 the first serious work on explosive welding to be disclosed in Great
Britain was started in the Mechanical Engineering Department of the Q,ueen’s
University of Belfast.
detonation f ro n t
I
I
I
I
the charge is detonated the detonation wave moves down the explosive charge,
and when it reaches the apex of the liner it subjects the outer surface of the
cone to a very high pressure which causes its walls to collapse. The pressure
produced in the metal in the region where the walls of the liner collide (see
fig. 3 (b) ) is extremely high, probably of the order of los atmospheres which
is much higher than the shear strength of the metal. Consequently the
material in the region of impact behaves as an inviscid fluid and the laws of
fluid mechanics can be applied to the situation. It can be shown that the
liner material divides into a high velocity metallic jet ’ and a slower moving
slug as shown in fig. 3 ( b ) . This high velocity metallic jet has remarkable
penetrating powers, and the hollow charge in fact forms the basis of the
bazooka weapon used so successfully in the last war against heavy armour
plates on tanks.
I n explosive welding we shall see that the forming of a metallic jet is essential
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
to achieve welding. Fig. 4 illustrates the set-up commonly used for cladding;
the top or flyer plate ’ is supported with a minimum of constraint at a small
angle of incidence relative to the stationary or ‘ parent plate ’ which is supported
on a relatively massive anvil plate. The top surface of the flyer plate is covered
ch8et explosive
detonacof
I \
1
Fig. 4. Set-up for explosive cladding.
with a prot.ective buffer such as rubber or polystyrene, and above that the
sheet of high explosive is laid which is detonated from the lower edge. As
shown in fig. 5 the detonation of the explosive imparts a velocity V to the
flyer plate which collides with the parent plate at an increased angle of
incidence /3. It will be seen from fig. 5 that
u sin 4 = u sin (8- a)
v= (1)
where U is the detonation velocit8yfor the explosive sheet used and a is the
initial angle of incidence. It will also be noted that as the flyer plate collapses
on to the parent plate it moves at every instant as though it is hinged at S.
76 B . Crossland and A . 8.Bahrani
&S=Vbt
& P = U 6 I
V i U sin +I
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
As the flyer plate collides with the parent plate it suffers a rapid retardation
and an extremely high pressure is generated in the region of impact a t S. As
in the hollow charge, the pressure is so high compared with the shear strength
of the materials involved that they behave for a very short interval of time in
a similar manner to inviscid fluids.
It is convenient t o change the coordinates of the system shown in fig. 5 so
as to bring point S t o rest. To do this it is necessary to apply a backward
velocity of VJsin /3 to the parent plate as shown in fig. 6. If this backward
r parent p l a t e
5
-PV
I - sin
- -
Fundamentals of Explosive Welding 77
velocity is applied to the system, then the velocity of the flyer plate is ?/'tan /3
towards S. As the metals at the point of impact are behaving as inviscid
fluids, the system becomes equivalent to a liquid jet of velocity V/tan /3
impinging on a stream travelling at a velocity of V/sin /3 at an angle of
incidence /3.
The liquid jet impinging the stream at S is deflected into a horizontal
direction still travelling at t h e same velocity, but this implies that the con-
servation of momentum in the horizontal plane has not. been satisfied.
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
Consequently it must be concluded that the jet divides into salient and re-
entrant jets as shown in fig. 7.
Applying the conservation of momentum to the configuration in fig. 7 gives
V V V
m- cos /3 = m8- - mr-
tan /3 tan /3 tan /3
or
m cos /3=ms-mr
where m is the mass of the jet, m, is the mass which is diverted into the salient
jet, m, is the mass diverted into the re-entrant jet and V/tan /3 is the velocity
of the jet. It will be noted that
m =Wb,+Wbr (3)
and this, coupled with eqn. (2), gives
m
m, =-(1-cos/3)
2 (4)
m
ms = -
2 (1 + cos /3). (5)
detonation velocity of 6500 m/sec and if the weight of charge is such as to give
a velocity to the flyer plate of 500 m/sec, then from eqn. (1)
sin @-a) = -
500
6500
or
P-a =4" 25'.
If 01 is 10" then is 14" 25', and from eqn. (4)
mr = 0.01568 m,
or 1.5 per cent of the flyer plate is diverted into the re-entrant jet. So for a
flyer plate thickness of 5 mm, a layer 0.078 mm thick will be ' peeled ' off t o
form the re-entrant jet, which will have a velocity from eqn. (6) of 3950 m/sec
or a Mach number of 11.5. The velocity of the point of impact is V/sin or
2000mJsec which is considerably lower than the velocity of sound in the
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
parent plate, so t,hat deformation will spread into regions of the parent plate
ahead of the point of impact. Consequently a hump develops in the parent
plate ahead of the point of impact due to the action of the jet.
It is now possible to explain the mechanism of welding. The high velocity
re-entrant jet sweeps the surface of the parent plate and it picks up by surface
traction a thin layer from the top surface of the parent plate. Effectively the
lower surface of the flyer plate has been peeled off and the top surface of the
parent plate has been scraped off, leaving two absolutely clean and uncon-
-----
-
sin p
c. -
Fig. 8. Flow configuration in region of collision.
taminated surfaces which are brought together under pressure at the point of
impact. The essential conditions for welding are achieved without melting
or the need to plastically deform the metals to break up the oxide or contamin-
ant film on the surfaces. As a consequence the limitations imposed by fusion
or pressure welding do not apply to explosive welding. Fig. 8 shows the flow
configuration in the region of impact. If sections DBA and EFG are considered,
then layers BA and E F are removed and points F and B will be brought
together as shown by D'B'F'G'.
The inclined plate technique shown in fig. 4 is necessary in order to get the
velocity of the point of impact less than the speed of sound in the material
of the parent plate, even though the detonation velocity of the explosive may
Pundamentals of Explosive Welding 79
be higher than the velocity of sound, and in order that a fluid metal jet is
created. I n most metals the velocity of sound lies within the range 4000-
5500 m/sec, while most explosives have a detonation velocity in excess of this
range. However, there are a few powder explosives such as Trimonite which
have a much lower detonating velocity, and it is then possible to use a parallel-
plate technique such as that shown in fig. 9. It will be seen that the velocity
of the point of impact is equal to the detonation velocity of the explosive and
an oblique collision is achieved where the effective angle of incidence is
= sin-1-
V
U'
If the velocity of the plate is 500m/sec and U for Trimonite is 3900m/sec,
then 3
/ = 7' 22'. The spacing between the flyer and parent plates is unimportant
as long as it is sufficient t o allow the flyer plate to accelerate to its terminal
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
velocity.
.exDlwive
buffer
flyer plate
parent plate
( o 1 before detonation
I_-; -r
7 - - - - - -
parent plate
4. Experimental investigation
Fig. 4 shows the general arrangement of the inclined plate technique and the
actual set-up is shown in fig. 10. I n the particular experiment shown the flyer
plate is stainless steel and the parent plate is mild steel, the area of the plate
is 2 f t x 1 f t and the weight of explosive sheet is about 3 lb. The detonatioii
of this charge is shown in fig. 11. The parallel-plate technique has also been
used with Trimoiiite powder which is more difficult to handle than Metabel
sheet explosive, but the experimental set-up is otherwise simpler and it would
80 B. Crodand and A . S . Bahrnni
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
ease the task of handling very large plates. There is no reason t o prevent very
large areas of cladding being done by this method, except that the weight of
explosive charge will be correspondingly very large and there are very few
sites sufficiently far away from human habitation and yet close to centres of
industry where such large charges could be detonated.
Up to date it has proved possible to explosively weld stainless steel to steel,
copper to stainless steel, copper to steel, brass to stainless steel, brass to steel,
titanium to steel, aluminium to steel, etc. The mechanical strength of these
various combinations has been exhaustively tested, and it has been found
possible with correct adjustment of the angle of inclination and weight of
explosive charge t o obtain welds of great strength. Frequently the weld is
stronger than the weaker of the two materials being welded, and failure occurs
well away from the joint in the weaker of the two materials. For optimum
strength it has generally been found that the initial angle of inclination should
be 5" or thereabouts.
Fig. 12 shows how the parallel-plate technique can be applied to welding
tubes into end plates, which is a problem of very great practical value in
engineering; for example, in the construction of condensers, feed-heaters,
boilers, etc. I n order to locate the tube, the tube plate is bored to the outside
diameter of the tube, and then for most of the thickness counterbored t o give
a clearance of 1 mm. The ' explosive pack ' is made up out of dental WAX
which also forms the buffer, and ends are fitted with wood plugs with a wood
spigot which can be varied in diameter t o suit the weight of charge needed.
A detonator can be inserted in a hole provided in one of the wood end plugs.
Such a pack is shown being inserted in a tube in fig. 13.
Fundamentals of Explosive Welding 81
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
So far it has proved possible to weld cupro-nickel and aluminium brass tubes
to brass tube plates; and stainless steel, mild steel and titanium tubes t o mild
steel tube plates. The weld achieved is typical of an explosive weld and its
strength is expected to be similar to that found for the weld between one plate
and another. There remains the question of how many tubes can be welded
simultaneously into a tube plate and if there a.re any problems of interaction
between the shock waves originating a t the same instant from various centres;
this problem is being investigated a t the present time.
F C.P.
82 B . Crossland and A . 8.Bahrani
Fig. 13. The explosive pack ready for insertion into the tube.
between titanium and steel, and the white layer is an intermetallic compound
of titanium and steel. The micro-diamond identations which can be seen are
an indication of hardness and it will be noted that the intermetallic compound
is extremely hard, in fact much harder than the hardest of steels. This layer
is not only hard but also extremely brittle and consequently the weld is weak.
However, with the correct welding conditions the intermetallic compound is
not produced except,in the centre of the front vortex as can be seen in fig. 14 (e).
There is still an immense amount of work to be done on the metallurgical
aspect of this work, including electron microscopy and x-ray examination.
0 0010"
0 .005"
0 0.010"
(c) Stainless steel welded to mild steel.
0 0.005'
( d ) Titanium welded to mild steel when the welding conditions are not properly
adjusted leading to the formation of hard brittle intermetallic compound
at the interface.
86 B. Crossland and A . S. Bahrani
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
0 0.005"
I I
(e) Titanium welded to mild steel when the correct welding conditions are used.
The waves noted at the weld interface are similar to those noted on the nose
of right circular cylinders flred a t lead targets reported by Allen, Mapes and
Wilson (1954). Abrahamson (1961) suggested a mechanism of wave generation
which depended on the salient jet (see fig. 7). From the analysis it will be
seen that the salient jet has a thickness very nearly equal to the thickness of
the flyer plate, and yet waves with a wavelength of 0.05 mm have been noted
in an experiment where the flyer plate was 2 mm thick. It is hardly conceivable
that waves could be laid down a t about 1 Os waves/sec by a mechanism involving
the entire thickness and momentum of the salient jet. Bahrani, Black and
Crossland (1967) have suggested a mechanism of wave generation which is
dependent on the re-entrant jet. For the numerical case given in $ 3 the
re-entrant jet had a thickness of 1.568 per cent of the flyer plate, or for a 2 mm
thick flyer plate a thickness of 0.03 mm which could conceivably give waves
having a wavelength of 0.05mm. They have also provided experimental
evidence which provides strong support for the mechanism they propose.
6. Conclusions
The generation of a high velocity fluid metal jet in the explosive welding
process provides a satisfactory explanation of the mechanism involved in
removing the contaminant surface layers, which is an essential of any welding
process. This process enables strong welds to be produced between metals
which it would be difficult or impossible to weld by any other means. It can
also be applied in situations where conventional welding methods are not,
Fundamentals of Explosive Welding 87
REFERENCES
Downloaded by [Tulane University] at 09:53 12 January 2015
ABRAHAMSON, G . R., 1961, J . Appl. Mech., Trans. Amer. Soc. Mech. Engrs., 83
(series E), 519.
ALLEN,W. A., MAPES, J. M., and WILSON, W. G., 1954, J . Appl. Phys., W,675.
BAHRANI,A. S., BLACK, T. J., and CROSSLAND,B., 1967, Proc. Roy. Soc. A, 288,123.
BIRKHOFF, G., MACDOUUALL, P. P., PUUFI,
E. M., and TAYLOR, G . I., 1948, J . AppZ.
Phys., 19, 563.
BOWDEN, F. P., and TABOR, D., 1954, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids (Oxford
University Press).
KELLER, D. V., 1963, Wear, 6,353.
The Autlwrs:
B. Crossland served an engineeriug apprenticeship with Messrs. Holls Royce Ltd. He graduated
in Mechanical Engineering from Nottingham University. Subsequently he became an Assistant
Lecturer, then Lecturer and finally Senior Lecturer in the University of Bristol. He was appointed
to the Chair of Mechanical Engineering at the Queen’s University of Belfast in 1959.
A. S. Bahrani was born in Baghdad and received his primary and secondary education there.
He came to the United Kingdom in 1948 to study Mechanical Engineering a t the Queen’s University
of Belfast where he graduated B.Sc. wilh honours in 1952 and M.Sc. in 1953. From 1954 to 1962
he was employed by the Iraqi Ports Administration, Basrah, in various capacities. He returned
to the University of Belfast in 1062 to carry out research on high rate forming and welding of
metals. H e was awarded a Ph.D. in 1965 and was appointed Lecturer in Mechanical Engineering
the aame year.