Change Management Arabic

The Impact of Change Management in Enhancement of

Shareholding Companies Effectiveness at the State of Kuwait

! "
401110012 : # $%
"
'
() *

+ $%
,-
*
. / #

2013
‫ب‬
‫ج‬
‫د‬
‫ ‪
4‬‬
‫ ‪ ()* + ' $‬‬

‫‪% & # !
"#‬‬
‫
‪
0 $
"
1 &+# (,'

-

./ &0 +‬‬
‫
'‪ (&/
- $ . (
3./ 4
" '5 $2‬‬
‫ ‪./
0 (

( 67 $‬‬
‫ ‪9"

7-
:'# ';
.;
0 &+# $#‬‬
‫
; <&
‪"
:'# &

.;
0 1
"
($
$‬‬
‫

‪3./ " :
+ &-'5 ( &/

+
-‬‬
‫
‪.%+
&-<2 :
0‬‬
‫ ‪ %- $ (

& $ 0 +
" &+# $# #‬‬
‫

‪"
? &- (
3./ =
>; 12‬‬
‫
‪!
@# $# 0 2 (/+ $
1 2- $ $ 3# (+‬‬
‫‪.
11
* &- 9
1‬‬

5+

:
6
+ ;
+A

- $ 0
7 89:
B 5

$ 4 ).
$
0
7 ;9:
7 2*0 &-/

5
&2# .
0
4
4 <4
:;
;
, 0

3./ 1 0
$
& $ 0
‫و‬

=8
:! >)
#
$

C
=5
D "

+
"
3 :
/

E-
B

7
";
7
)
F G*
H 1
F G*
* 4 :,- ,!:

2 - 1J1
3 -7#

" 2J1
5

4
/# 3J1
5

/# 4J1
6

' 5J1
7

D. 6J1
8 4
7J1
10

8J1
4? 9 + : ,!:
12 9 + :,- @?
12 -
13 F

0 F
&-5 1J2
15 F
4
/# 2J2
17 F

0 /# 3J2
‫ز‬
18 F

C# 4J2
21 F
C # 5J2
22 F
R
# 6J2
23 <
F
# 7J2
28 F
S
B
8J2
30 <
9J2
32 5
E *
10J2
42 4? : @?
43
F

:#
50 1
F

: A
56 +

$

1 :A A

#8 :@ ,!:
58

S- 1J3
58

, 2J3
59
3J3
60
F
E

# 4J3
61

F 5J3
62 7

C # 6J3
63

, C # 7J3

B< :A? ,!:
65

G7* 1J4
67

F 5
:
S7 2J4

' *
S7 3J4
75

! B< :=C ,!:
84 S7
1J5
88
2J5
‫ح‬
/( A#
90
F ,

96 1
F ,

99
/
"
:# (1) & 9
105

(2) & 9
111

.
:
(3) & 9
,# <%
:! ,# ' ,#
56 +

+

1 (1J2)
59 '*

1

R (1J3)
60

F A
2 (2J3)
65
"
$
$

,1 (1 J4)
F
F

68 ( 2 J4)
+A
-
F

69 ( 3 J4)
<
F

70 (4 J4)

71 &-
F

( 5 J4)
9+ "Y

72 ( 6 J4)
4
/
"Y

73 ( 7 J4)

'
"Y

74 ( 8 J4)
5<
‫ط‬
, 4
"Y

75 (9 J4)

7
(One Sample KolmogorovJSmirnov test) *
76 (10 –4)
( 5
) ,
F
(F

) +
F
F

0
F A@

*
S7
76 F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) (11 J4)
5
11 (&-
F
(
F
) F

0
F A@

*
S7
77 (
F
(<
-
F
(+A
(12 J4)
5
11 (&-
F
Stepwise Regression

S7
80 (13 J4)
5
F

5
;
A# *
0 5 (One Way Anova) $
S7
81 (14 –4)
$
G7* n1

,- <%
:! , ' ,
7

D. (1J1) "
‫ي‬
DC*

)1

6 4 :
0
$2'

:4
"0
(+A
F
) 3@ F

0 A@ 4

3./ /
11 (&-

F
(
F
(<
-
F
/
"
, $

, $ (

/
"
# $
? (280) $
# (" (180) / o

C7 (& ) "

3.-

$
$
$ ?7
? (360)
.(
p
("

0 (&

70 . A@ :/1# S7
$ 0

F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) 3@ F
.

/
"
11 ( &-

(
( +

:-/#
$
?

G*" 2* $ H . (F

B 11 $# - @" $

(

' .F

- G $ -+ "
n 4'
+
+

F
:' (/
"

.*

*
‫ك‬
Abstract
The Impact of Change Management in Enhancement of
Shareholding Companies Effectiveness at the State of Kuwait
Prepared by: Yousef Alanzee

Supervised: Dr. Ali Dalain
This study aimed to identify the impact of change management

dimensions (change in culture, a change in the organizational structure,
change in technology, and the change in the tasks) to enhance the
effectiveness of public shareholding companies in the State of Kuwait, the
study population consisted of all Kuwaiti public shareholding companies of
(180), while sample consist from (280) Director from (360) of managers
working in senior management (general manager, deputy general manager
and director of human resources, director of research and development).
The study found a number of results, most notably: the presence of a
statistically significant effect of the change management dimensions
(change in culture, a change in the organizational structure, change in
technology, the change in the tasks) to enhance the effectiveness of public
shareholding companies in the State of Kuwait .
The study provides a number of recommendations, including: the
provision of legal requirements, social, policy and economic development
that will enhance the success of the process of change, and by diagnosing
strengths and weaknesses of the company and the corresponding
opportunities and threats after the change process. And the need to study
and analyze the strategies adopted in the joint-stock companies, in the light
of internal and external changes .
,- ,!:
* 4
- 1J1
-7#

" 2J1

4
/# 3J1

/# 4J1

' 5J1

D. 6J1
4
7J1

8J1
2
,- ,!:
* 4

8 1E1
$' - ( A ( ' <

F

qF
@q (q- AYq
n+
-
-# # # <
p
0
9q q #

7

F #
:2

."

r
0 5

q+
.q*
&<

$ 0 4- < - A F
$0
qA q/ .q

&q
&
*
9 $ 7
$ 1
2 9*
C <
-
&+
/
7+
F 4-
0
q7
7-

F
-'5

, 4
,

,
.(78G (2010 (+

)
+A

q2
$q *
/ $ $ ?5 ?
?< Y
&<

$rq
.q (n*# - $
7
$ (- $ 7'# $
q n*;
5
<

?F p 5
< ;
# F )# p
(2002 ($
"q )
q;
q<
++

1
25
&<
.(46G
*

F A
R :/ $# $ <
F
1
q -q &q # - 0 n /" <

*
p 9 ).
q 0 )Yq ).
A
<
,

9+ # *
7
, 5
4
/# 0 A ( +
#
# 4
/;
n .
F p
0
# .<
s H .
$
' & (
1 F
(
9q < *

7
p 9 ).
*
F
- A
R
(q*
7
$ :1 - ; <
*
0 + &A 7 #
n $ #
q Hq . -< (

F
$ R

.-
0
/
q<
(qY
q $ +
*
$ 5
- (*

AY
42q*
(q+A

F (

AY
("
$
+
(
)

# +

F (
F (

4<
.(121G (2010 (C/
8*< * 2E1
/

/:+ 0 C
'
+
? ? "

+ E

"
- S &/# (
1 7
F
"
&# 6# F
p
0 H . t
n

n
/
"
n 4" $

" $# .0 ./:+ $'

F
A

F

- 2* $ H . ("
3./ AY

H . - -/ $ (- 4

-
+
C ;

+
.* "
0 )+
)

u F
.
F
p
12
"q
q 11 F

0 A# /

3./ $ =F
$0
$
2* $

3./ $ =F
9+ $ .

/
:v
Y
q qF
(+A
F
) 3@ F

A@ / :,- =
< ,F
/
"
11 (&-
F
(
F
(<
-
:/ 5
7;
$ Y

./ $ 9A w

/
"
11 +A
F A@ / :,. : ,F
w

11 <

-
F A@ / : : ,F
w

/
"
"
11
F A@ / :@ : ,F
w

/
"
11 &-
F A@ / :A? : ,F
w

/
q q

0 70
. 9 / : =
< ,F
q
n1

/
"
11 F

0 A@
w(*

(
/Y
(
(E
) $ *"
" 3E1
: 0

3./ 4-
.

/
"
11 +A
F
A# J1

/
"
11 <
-
F
A# J2
.

/
"
11
F
A# J3
.

/
"

$
:
u J4

C

H . ("
11 F

0 A#
.

./ "
$

4
H . ( 5
3./ $

4E1
F

0 / ;

0 &- R' - $

/# @
E &+ - # .-

<
&#

(<

.- &+

/
"
F

0 ,

+
).* $ .
-
& - -<

3./ /# $0
$ ."

-
/# 9+ 2* $ - 11 / (A
"
?
7

# ;

3./ )A 4 n*#
9

"
, $
-+ -7 ?*

.-7 $ 5

9
x

) 5E1
'5
> $ r -
7;
"

3./ y
:

(0.05≥α) n 70 . A@ :6-
<
):
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) 3@ F
3./ $ 9A .

/
"
11 (&-

: / '5

$ '5
n 70 . A@ :6.

:
):
.

/
"
11 +A
F (0.05≥α)
n 70 . A@ :

:
):

/
"
11 <
-
F (0.05≥α)
.
n 70 . A@ :

:
):

/
"
11
F (0.05≥α)
.
"
11 &-
F A@ : ?
:
):
.

/
q q

0 70
. 9 :

<
):
q
n1

/
"
11 F

0 A@
.(*

(
/Y
(
(E
) $ *"
GH 6E1

F
A

-
/# 0

3./ $ =F
9+
?

3.- G* D. & p
& + (,
F
+
.
F
3.- D.
" 6' (1-1) &
"
.+
;

A?
*4

4

:

9 ,
8?

". /
4 E
# # E
:
9 ) E
, <
? A "
E
#

$8

(1E1) $% ,
GH
(Jiaqin & Huei, q

: K
L AK# 6* 5? @? ' , :!
((2005) (
+

((Cooper, 2004)
((2002)

(2002)
.(2012) (

((2011) (

(Beer & Eisnstat, 2009)

8
*!? "
7E1
q
+q

qF
, 5
& +

3./ =
>;
q q q#

6 C H . (- *

: (

$q 0 ,

0 '
,

$ <
/ :

q C # Rr

;
( " S- 9 9
q
q+5
$ - & .(Cisco, 2004: 7) A
0

F
11
:v

F
2* $ H .
q+A :q /

+
&+ F
- + : 4

p
q;
q

1
$ $
+
&+
3./ Y
.(Al Sardieh, 2012, p: 8) ;

3.- &+
9
*

# q

+
F
" $# - + :
9 ,
8

.(361 :2007 (+

) =
-' ,

S #

q

F
" $# + :
#

C q# q<
"q ;
$' /
F p
0
q

# ($
- $# C

-
/1
.(317 :2003 ($

)
F
H , 5

q 5<
& 9 F
" $# + :$K8

Yq
&q qF H .q (&q-
"q ;
R (
:
# +
9
q
2
(:
;
*
$ 5

;
(2

(Cisco, 2004: 7)

4< " (5<
-
*q
2q* $ n
4
/;
9+ <
/ :
:

-
6 A@

. (- n+
$1
E
-

- & .(104 :2010 (+

) <
-

(&+
:v

"Y
2* $
+5
$
$ -
/# " )# 9+ # H

A / :"- /
4 E
.(10 :2011 (
) F
&+
2*
q
$ n * &+ # <
D 0 / :# # E
).
" -72 > :
- 2* $ $ (1
' E+ 2* $ H . & (&-

'
9+ (&- , 95
.(17 :2009 (+

) - 1
5 0 (*
&+ #
D 5

B 3" A 5 *
E0 / ::
9 ) E
Rq S ).
(-
-
1 2* $ > R"
.(10 :2011 (
) &-
$ 5< + 5
' $
q &*q

5<
'
E+ 5
-
E+
.

q
p
q;
, ,
4
"
/ :, <
? A "
E
4q
9q

F

0 $ $0
7
.(334 :2003 ($

)
:+
- $ -
10
9q

/
"
, / :

q q
q "
, &1 ).

9
;
$ C

q- 9q .0 (
9
-

# B - &
$q

"
) " (180) / o
:
"
, --#
.(2012 (
9
x
9
8E1
:

A
.

/
"
:
E1
"
3./

$
$
$ *
& :
? E2
pq
q ("

0 (& C7 (& ) C $F" $.
.(

;

5
/ $
$

3./
0 9F
:
E3
.2013J2012 A

F
) q A
F

0

" :(
)
* E4
5
(&-
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A

, 4
(5<
'
(
(4
/;
9+ ) :/
"Y - &
.(7
11
,!:
4? 9 +
9 + :,- @?
-
F

0 F
&-5 1J2
F
4
/# 2J2
F

0 /# 3J2
F

C# 4J2
F
C # 5J2
F
R
# 6J2
<
F
# 7J2
F
S
B
8J2
<
9J2
5
E *
10J2
4? : @?

F

:#
1
F

: A
+

$

1 :A A
12
,!:
4? 9 +
(q/# (q
/# (q-5 (F +
&/5 ?' 5

./ $'
+ (F
- B 5 $ (
F
C# '# (
( #
.

F
3# *
(<
.F
.F

r

. 1

+

9 + :,- @?

8
"

(7-
+

&+
0 <
F
# "

/<
(+

$ 5
< (

<
-" +* 3./ (-
0 <
" A#
( 9 -- $ -

v

;
$ p #
H . (
3./ - 9
9+ <
-

v
<
F
9+ R <
$ 3
F (;
& ?
? -5
$# $ ?2
(;
&
B
$ 2
? ' (

./
9
.

R

p

7
/ <
F
4+ $# , - (

:+ ;
< H . :
10
4<
/# H
< .
" R
F
&# A
13
(/ & F

$r / ( (F '* 6 ? >
(&) $/

-' < $# # 4
, " -
.(281 :2003
$ r (F $1 - <

<

/:+ $'

F
*0 ( 3 0 /
' F
$r H . .(83 :2006 (
)

4

.
/

<
:+

$8: 1E2
F

* n
" # <
F
4
3Y'# - H" + 2"

G*" C# H . $ * +
.(306 :2004 () "
#

4
/# 2 p
0 @ H . <
F
4%
&# &<
R'# :2 0 :/ $# # - <

$ )#
$ ?+ ?+ < 9+ " #

0 C # < R'# p

.(49 :2009 ()1

) />
<
$ n
- " @ <
F
4
7
s
" p
0 2* $ H . & $# - (2"
# " H . t-

1 G* 1 , (<
.(161 :2002 ($/

) "
; <
:'# , + ).
F
*
14
0 R
{
4/ + F " @ <
F
4
A# < 0 +

$' *
*

7
4
9+
.(292 :2009 ($) "2"

0 "
$ (';
/F #

4- F
&-5 $0

;
/ (F
, R
(F

/#
.(392 :2004 (&) B

+
-

5

-
2* $ 9

- @ 4 F

0 #
1 &# &# &# "

&
*

@ 2* "

+
,

0
,

$ :5
:2006 (
) 5 - # @ Y

;

.(95
.$
/ - * < +
0 / F
$# p
n

4<
, 5 < / F /< -"
<
$#
-
(D
C # $ - F
A# $@ (-
C #
9 &/5
&+
$ ($
2 $ (
n
./>
5

-
2* $ 9

/ F

0 $# p
n
(( 1 ( (" )

&
*

| @ % 2* "

% +
,

0
,

$ % :5
.5 - # @ Y

;
}
15
" 2E2
? > <

-- )
0 F )# $0 0 (356 :2010 (+
) "
,q 4q
q# $ &+ )
'
F 0 (<
0 - 4-
$
Cq
A2A H / $r E;

./ ($
+
# 9
R'@ -
4<
:/ (F
$ 4- 7
.* &# *

:

4<
, 4
J1
.<
<

p
0 # $ J2
.? $ A
# J3
$q $q- $/ 0 (Pattanayak & Mishra, 2009: 57) " H .
:/ (F
4
/#
.
D
- # -<0 <
$
6 J1
."
4
/;
9+ - (<
,
J2
q/ ($12 $/ <

)

F $@ (453 :2000 (

) $%
&# ).q
F
$0 .- $
-7 <
$ $1

9+
9q+ q# $q <

"
#
# $ 0 4-
.(369G (2007 ( R"

) ';

S7
q" qA# $ $# $ F

4
/# $# n (34 :2005 (
+
) #
q# $q q- *0 <

)
/

F

4
/;
C
9+ (:
;
n :+
A (<
5
# 9+

q
q (q
$
(5<
$

+ ($
$
16
q
C;
&
*
(+5
" (
7
, $1

0 (
"
nq
4
/;
$ /> <
H
# ) (2"

.- ' <
(q<
F
4
/# $ (46 J45 :2002 (
) #
:/ (<
$ 0 4-

)Y F
$# $ ?2
(
7
<
$ $1

$ 9+ .1
-

4<

F
7
, &@
<
+ 1 0
.:+

4/ 9+
0 )5

$ + t

F
" $
H F .2
.(
9)

+
F
B 12
2
:
0 <
0 A

*0 .3
.<
.<
$
$ $

2
+ .4
.- - " <

:
0 .5
.R

$
+ 1 .6
(q

:
0 $ :
;
$ / ++ &- F
$# p
n
q 11 (

R

$
," (Y
$
5
$
.$
n
+

-
$ 2' (<
17

3E2
qF
C q# R (A &
;
= F
/#

-
F
p
0 $
$
C .0 (
5*
9q
0 F *
$
H
"0 (
G5
2F (
.(Talley & Martinez, 2008) 0 # $ 1
&+

C ).
;
(9
<
A F
/#
Cq q q
1
$-
C C
<
, &
n
(Hill <
-/ <

0
F '
.and Jones, 2010)
).q
q
:"
$@ n - (<
*
C@ F
/# $
q $q
$
7- $
. ("F
" / $1
n
? ?A +
q qA
(

4<
< F
+
<
q
q2*# Yq $ - 9
$ R "
0
.(De Cenzo, 1997) H . =5

7

F
$ />
F
p
0 *
$ - $ F
/# 1
(Paton & McCalman, 2010, P: 168J 169) :

3./ $ <
9 * 1 1 $# - *

4
/;
9+ "5
.1
.9
E
, 2
($
* ;
:
q0 Cq q
(- +
*

:
0 0 A
+
*0 .2
.-
*
$+0 $
/@ C -/# (
F
18
F
/# 1 (*
-7 + -
<
F
.3
q*

qF
,q ,q 4
+

@

./
.<
'5
($q

;
H A@
F
/# - 1

.4
.?'# F :
*v
n
A0 F
p
r :
q
q<
(:+

2 <
/ F
/# $# p
n
Cq

$ H / (? "5
/ 6 " F
p
0 "5
q q " F

& $# $ .0 (F
B 0 # $ - &/
.0 .<
*
H

+
& $ $
($
$
5
9+ (
$1

<

&/# $ F
$#
.<
$' 12
'
&/# $ $1

A
$
? ? 4E2
q*
Cq# n+ /
$ p <
F
$0
qF
q q *

n+
$ #
? *
n+
C (*

/

"Y
$ A F
H / ."
4q<
q-
0 (<
-
$' *
C; 0 $
(F
:
(361 J358 :2010 (+

) :v

3./ A (
*
./ (+
4
/;
:F 0 # 4
/# '0 0 &'
: 9 "
.1
.<
)

F
*0 C
19
q /q (q
$
+
"

F / :'
4
.2
q q
"
$
+
, " 4 -
0 %F $# <
.
# : -5 =
,q <
D
:- C# $ F

./ S : 9* $ ,
.3
q+ # -* ,# "

$' -5 71 <
& # n*# <
.
F'
* # S )# B
? -
# <
E $# $ :/H- N
.4
$
.0 ( > ," (H-
9. - $# $'
*q $# q<
q $r E;

./ (9
> *
# S
.9

/ $' 12

F
nq
F
*0

$0 :# .5
.*
D
$ ;
.5 - # $ <
)"
)
Rq5 $
n
B
=5*

"Y A :
O P:C .6
=5*
CF C
F
p
0 C (
#
5
.-

$
B
*
,
3./ F
& :4 HC
* QC # .7
q Cq

+
.*
$

+ & # -7
+
.*

q12
'

0 * &- & # C

.
+
.*

20

4 0 ' )Y

4 $0 :?.
# D4 .8
.F
, +
/
Y
$r (<

(q
5<

n0 "
4' C :.!. ") .9
.?+ .

& 7
5<

$ )# " $0 :
:
9 .# ,: .10
q (-

$' 3:

C;
F &+ $# <

.-72 -
# *
:/ (F
C# $# 0 (100J98 :2006 (
) "
q
q
'
R2
$0 :

#. ?- .1
$q - # ( 5 5*

F
p
0
? 2
? $ -

. Au $ - S Y

$

5

*
(7
*

r $
& :
!%. ?- .2
("q
-7 #
- ? > &
(

F
C
'
.-+0 # - CF

$ +

q
&# B5
, $#

$0 :
4
# ?- .3
q 5 q

&-
1 0 $ :1 6#
+ &
* (A
+
.#
q :
q0 0 )Y
C;
$# (283 J282 :2003 (&) n $
:/ ($7 $ $' ,+ F
21
q# q

F
(
:"
#C R4 ' # ?- .1
q
"
$
+

0 (7

F
(
R';
(

q q
-q
F'
1
(<
$
E
(
.7 * 1# p (<
- q q<

4
q/# q q%F :"
*C R4 ' # ?- .2
&< *0 (

n+
(
1-# *0 (-'
>#
q q (5<q
$
q
R5
(n*# < , S
(
.B;
(7 *
1# p ($

5E2
q-
q;
$q F
<
3 ).
C;

C q# &q+ $ 0 (106 J105G (2006 (

) " (F
B
:/ (7 C # A2A 0 F
=q5* # q
$ 4- F
C;

./ & :#

.1
(A 1 $' & @ C;

./ 1 ($5<
# +5
.
;
$ # H" (7 +
1 9+ # $ ).

F
0

<
@ :H#
.2
pq q5 @ C;

./ 1 (+
:+
# $ # B;
$
.
9
;
0 *
* <

0 2
? " ?2+
22

,
$ $ $;
$ D1 $
@ :'
?*- '
? G .3
S
q
q :
& (<
, ). F p
0 3

q5 9 F

& $1
$ #
E5 (
. ;
C
4<

F
$
> 6E2
:2002 (q
) : F
&*

F
R
# 4
(45 J44G
q qF
qA# # 1

./ :< #
,
.1
# vq q<
$
C # :1 F
$
.r (<
q q r (<
C
"
.0 # 71 F r (1-;
Rq )# p
0 & / 71
, + "
F
0 $ (" F
.71
E A
0 <
$1

& # *
$
q pq ).
F
H . )
F
" :

.2
)q
# ($
$
? <

:
0
;
v
n
.315 #
H F "
?q qA# :q

Dq
F
$ :#

A

.3
.F
C>; 4<
& $ 5
,
$ ?*
:/ ($# $ 0 <

F
&+ $
23
q & ).

)

C;
@ *
F
4 :C
.1
( R"
)
/ $ n*# 0 /

- $ <
q
q
q- 'q *
F
C .(370G (2007
(q* &# q*

:
(<

F
, (

0 ( =

+ E 4-
S
*
F
(q<
q qF p
q0 (7

F
+ < /
.(342G (2006 (&) ,

B
9+ F
p *

7+ " ).
F
/ :(P) C
V
.2
(2007 (q R"q

) .- )# $ &/
7
" * ->#
.(370G

9
? 7E2
qq q5 &q<

q
- ;
< $0
F q (- "

-7 G , 5 q -q (qF
q (4-q q*u ,' 0 &7 ,' $ q<

H '+ /<
# #

(+ ' 7

:+
- $'
: / (<

F
: 4
:.
(q-+ :
;
&< (&<
/ (
;
H " / F
q<
+ (
7

F , 4
5
=F H . (

24
# F

./ 4+0 $ 31 + ?7+ F /
<
= $# +*
: . $
9 ;

.n*;
/
<
= * $# (3 &
$q q * $# $ $ ).

A

# (:";
; "F
"
q 0 "q q - '#

F 2 p
*
-
2*
.(12 :2004 ($

) "F
" &-5
$q
q q q-
A
&/5
$ F
+A &-5 '# +
2
*
E
*
= p + (&-5

./ A
(
&q-5 ($q-5
$ ?/ ? H / $# <2 $# F H . (+A
F
&-5
"+A
F" &-5 (';
0 ,

F &/ +A $# "F
+A"
qF n*# +A + C

+A
+ $ *

.(Tibbs, 2011: 20)

# q5 :
q (q/;
qF F
+A $# (12 :2004 ($
) n
:- ,
5
- - (,

n1F +A F
$' 5
.1
.-:2 n /A@
q+ q q- 0 &q (&+

+A
0 #
+
;
1 .2
.F

$'
, *" , 9
7

,
5 5
C .3
.$*v
'
25
qF
q "q
< 2* $ 35 =-
5
.4
.+A
q ,
'
F
-
Y ,
< Y .5
+A

Y -
&+

, 5
.,
:
9 ,
8
:

&q+ q0 2* $ <

-
$ ).
F
$ R

./ $
$q
H . AY (n*#

0 S #

0 p
0 )# t

.q/ & "

(
,
4
"
9 (
7 *

;

/ #
* F # /YF 0 # <
:" 0 $
# 5<

# <

*
F # Y
.(334 :2005 (

)<
*
& 47<
# :
;
- <
#
<
, $# (460 :2000 (
) n
9q
&) 9
H -" " <
-2" = F (
(&;
= Y , $ $# 0 -
F
$0 )# ((
#
A# <

6 4
"
9 , 0 (

G+ 0
> 1 $

1 A#
:
0
9 $ (
#
.
+
.*
, 1
q
-
'+
$ < )

&<
$# (299 :2004 (F
) n
(q<
H B AY

$
) &<
$0 .0 ($-
F"
26
q :

;
$ 5*
2
(

) -

&<
) ($ # " # & &# +# &# # 2
3./
./
=5
0 7

9
&-
H . 5<
0
;
,
1
-
F

q- 2* $q

/ &<
5< .<
5< '

#
/ -' R"

4
/# 9+ , ('

"
# 4*
:q5 &q- :
# $ &-

&/1 $/Y

; F"
(338 :2005 (

) :/ &<
5< &/# $0 .0 (
.5
7
4
/;
.1
.4
/;
9+ '
"
# .2
q
$q qA
5
< / -' "
, .3
.)"
. &/1 " &+

:5
).

*
.4
&< E@

4* $ 2
$ "
$
9+ .5
. 5

:
#
:
3.q/ C .0 (*

&+

C #

A AY
3.q/ $0 0 (q q# 7 97

*0 F
:2 $ A
q/ q# q

+ $; (
? , " & &
1 #
A@
<q
# $ t + &
*

/ $
(4-
27
(

, Rr

&+ .0 (
:+
#

2* A

F
$r H . ( :5 4-
0
# $ H .

0 < #
$ &
<
C># '
+
.(350: 2003 (

)
F
&-
$ <
=F <
$

# 4*

<

' $0 (186 : 2002 ( ) n
$# - " $
F
3./ $# <

F +

/< (

$
1 (F"
:5
=-
# 9

/1# < F
1
A# $

$ C
./ .? +
p

7 $
&
*
2* $
2* $

*

- 0 <
(187 : 2002 ( ) :=F

, C - F *
1q

. q q- *
9
;
6 $ n+
5
.1
.
.C
9

C # +
5
0 .2
# $ ? +

C # +
5
0 .3
.
@
15
&< 2* $ 0 5
+
5
2* $
q &q/# $ $

(-
' 5
"
.4
.
E
28
:$8
:?
q # -' , " # S # " ;

# ;

F
"
"q (/:F 0 # - # <

F
(7 # :F 0
q
9
F #

:
0
+
+

:
0 9 F
.(361 :2007 (+

) ;
.5 -

$'
- .5
q71
-
q/# 1 0 $ <
$
<
F
" H .
Rq (q
:
# q+ q 5<
& 9 '# " (

*
$ 5

;
(2
Y
& F H . (&-
" ;
q 0 q'0 (q

4< " (5<

2
(:
;
F

9+ F 0 )Y
C #
:
0 F
p
0
(Cisco, 2004: 7) 5*

C #
:
0 5 H"
B? O# , 8E2
S7 7
5 <
R
n 9A # " F
B
S
+
+ Y5
B p $ $ $
(F

S
q Bq
"Y 4* .
3.- $7 &/ $ $ 7 &/" $
(Balogun and $q .$

7+
? n*# 0 < $ F
Bq nq AY
7

$ Hailey, 2009, p: 165J 166)
:/ (F
29
q .5
0 Y &-+ ,+ $.
(:
* # :
$ :
5( .1
.F
q
1 q (B
, ? ? F
C :
# .2
. B 9+ C

$ $ <
*
F
/q # q 1
5
$ " 2 H / :
@+
: .3
. F
$ $# (F
B $
$ (&/1 # &-

# &-+A :'
*? !C - P??
%( .4
.F $
+
1 # ;
3./ F
q F
A# 12
E+

#
3

:
$
4 .5
.<

&q+ $# $

$ 0 (58 :2002 (
) "
:/ (F
B / <
.F

$' $

$ @
&

.1
.' F
+ ).
&
s

.2
<
=F F
5
5

-
F
:
* :2 H $# .3
.-* $ # <
*
$

.0
. )F
S
B *

$
H
"0 .4
.F
:

C;
,

6' .5
.F
C

7
5
6' .6
.<
"
G*" F
R2
.7
30
. 31
F
+
.8
. 5

"

.9
C

$ H / $@ (234 J238G (2005) $' n
:/ (F
B 0 /

$ /.*#
.-5 '

$ $# $
:
5 A .1
.<
$ $# '
F
Y H / $ $# C :
F .2
.<
&-
E# # ).5

0 $ ).
:
* <% # .3
.+ F $

G*";
H
"0 $' : .4
&q q
?q ? ?'

;
$
$ $# $ :,!. .5
. 6'

" F
.F

+
&- $ $
C :
.6
.
4<
< 1 :
@ $+ $.
G*";
11 :
.7
9
9E2
<
:
#
-
'
n0 <
A
B &- :
?
0 /< 5
&-5
p (-
/# 9+ -
- =
0 5
&-5 = (- ; -@ <
" #

- # <
0 < .9
"
3 p $ 5
<

? ?
*

(
(
("

&
* 5
.(328 :2010 ( R"

)

4
4
/;
9+
31
6
.r ("
4
/;
9+ B
+
0 5
&-5 "
9 5
$r
./ ($ &- @ $5 &- r @"
4
/# 9+ $
.( 10 :2000 ($*u *) *

S7

-
<
$# (Johnson & Scholes, 2002 :198) n
.$ D 0 # :r

:
+
H / (- 5
G5
2F
<
n ,4
/;
9+ 5

$ +

.

$ -
7
-
5
n0 (+
;
4
/;
9+ ) B
A p ,-"
&1 5
9+ $# ).
(
;
4
/;
9+ n

(
) 5
9+ ' B
$ (
$
9+
.(16 :2008
/ , + ;

:
# (Samman, 2004 :1) 5

Y H / $ 9+ 5

$ H . ,
:5
(+
$ :5
9+ , &

4
/# '

nY
$ :5 H / $ H . (
0 &< * H /
$ (:5 & , -++ $ 4
/;

.4
/;
B' $ $ 1 ;
$
2
0 " :5
$0 .0 (:5
&-5 $ 5
&-5 4*
9+ 0 <
2* $ +
2*
0 *
)# tS7

$ + &* $# " 5

&-5 &12 :5
&-5 $# (-
/#
32
E+ - 5

# .* $ -
/# 9+ - # )# Y5 - ( <
:5
$ ( 5
&-5 $+ :5
&-5 .n
E+ :5
n

.0 2*
0 *
2* $ 4
/;
9+ 9 $ )
0 "
.(122 :2010 (+

)
/
-
/# 9+ <
C

: =
% ,C 10E2
E - 2* $ $

"Y
$

3./
&
: / ( 5
"- /
4 :.

E 9 $ & ).
"
4
/# 9+
$ 9+"
# 4"
- 2* $ & "
4
/# 9+ (? 2
?
G
* /# &-
)
R"
"

"Y

&7
+
$ D* 2* $ H . .R"
F"
" ;
(Wheelen, and

+
.*
H .
"Y
3./ &
*
& n*#
.Hunger. 2009: 230)
*
1 0 $ 9+
;

n0 "
4
/# 9+
&A -++ C

4
/;
S7 5
:
;
+
3./ &+ ('
6

+
.*
S7
&+ &+ /

.F

.(83 :2008 (") 7*

33

"

0 &+ -
" ;
# "
4
/# 9+ A
2* $ $ $0

+
S7
+ "
:
;
5
:
;
$ $

$ .*;
(12

:
0
+ ;

*
, :

$ $' :
;
< B
C
$ :1 - #

3./ 0 < .- 95

n - #
:
;

./ &+ $# (-
/# 9+ ("
" ; /

" ;

(

.*
-7' &
"Y :
+

6
3
/ $

@ # -

"
-
.(4J3: 2010 ($

) >
4
/;
9+ 1

- ? - - " 4
/;
,'
$
$5<
?15 -
+
) $# C " )# 4
/@
$# C 5
H / (&- : A# &- # C -' $ $5<
$ $#
'
$ $# C "
4
/@ +
"
4
/# *
5
$# / $# $
, , =F
$

$ *
$# H" 2 & $0 $# C
;
*
/ 3./ (-
@*

./ A $# (
4
/;
=F

/ $ $5<
*u 0 9 $ 4
/;
&- 4* p 5*

$ &
0 )Y ? >
.(86 :2008 (")
$ & E - C# $

./ E+ $ $# C 4
/;
E+ > 4

/# ,' ("
$

:
# E ?'# - 4-
34
9+ 4
/;
$ $# )'
$ (&+
2"
$ A
C
C 9+ +

> 4
/; (:
;
$ $
$5<
15
C H . .) > &- $#

#
.0
$
5 &- ;
95
4- D
* $
2
? A $ 2 2
. + 4
/;
$ $#
$
C - 9 -/ $ $# C
0 2
? A 9

&

0 C 2
? A
2
$ :2
' # +
&-2
$# C .
"
:
#

C

#
2 + 9 4-
9+ C $1
$ $# C $1 4
/;
$
p &12
$ # # :*
p &12
$ # 4-
9+ $1 $
(Wheelen, and 4-
9+ $
$5< ?F' C

.Hunger. 2009: 232)

4
/;
9+ "
$# H"2 4-
G
*
H .*#
.0

(
, "
:
#
$
- ($
/* A;
&
*
D
, &
*
+
H /
.* &+
/ H . (3
# " n , > ,
9+
5
# 9+ )# (-

$ $ @ 4
/;
- 9+

+

$ ) :1
5 (Effectiveness 5
Efficiency
(
$ (Outputs) *

.5 (Inputs ) 2*
$ 2
0 "
(*) :5 A#

(2*
E5
$ *

1

.(10 :2000
35
# # :

<
C>#
1 &/ p

R' <

/; *
&# -
:
<
3./ -
$# * (&
: #

<

B2
0 <
(:
;
&+ --0 n
$ $ - <
B # 2 " # (*
*

.9
, 9+ (

2F
G7*
5
A
$# (4 :2007 () n
'0 . S

6 / ($71
+
S

.+

&-> &- , " / ($71 5 $

$
n * &+ # <
D 0 (&
/
, 95 ).
" -72 > :
- 2* $ $ (1
D 5 ' E+ 2* $ H . & .&-

'
9+ (&-
.(17 : 2009 (+

) - 1
5 0 (*
&+ #
1 ;
(+A
*v /2 $-5
6
< - : / $ ($71

1 A
* # $ :
S

($71
< - :/ $< $ 0 <
C
$# 1 5*
/
(&
H-
< - $ .S
< -

S
G7* A
:
;

. ( 5*
;
G7*
$
&
.0
S
$# .0 (
0 ' $71
R 0 0 -
&

# .
:
$
F
C
9+ $ r 3 $
36
*
5
+
$ /
+

$r S
(5
H . (+ R'
& + # *
# S
$ p (&
$#
.- ( 5 S
$
.0 ; t'5* D
5 $ $# - S
$r

+
$# .0 (
+
9+ $ ; $71
' $ 3
./
3
S
$ - 4
5
($71
S
5 $ + $
.(Kotler&Keller, 2009 :161)
, +

$ ( Karahasanovic & Lonn, 2007: 1 ) n
$# C
&<
$0 )# t:"

.
5

( A
. ?+ '
5
?+ D
$ C}
+ }
:2008 (2
)
6 G 0 )#
& $ 2
? '
.(34
$ 4- "
# Y
/
$ ( 3 :2007 ($2 ) +
($71
> 9+ (
&
(4
+ (:
;

-* $ - 3./ :

+ (95
B
(9

:$# $+
.5
+
.#
:

Juran $

& /* # 9
9+ R"0 .C
.Fitness for Use &

*2
# 5*

;
<
$# 0 (Atem and Yella, 2007: 14) "}
+ S
G7* $# p (
x 5*

+ < 5*
<
37

+ :5 A
.
$ $# C ($71
'
.$71
-

.
$# ( Evans and Collier, 2007: 12) Y
=5 $# < $}

$ 2
? ' ($71
' 9+ <
} $ &-
.$71

. &+ #
#
&+ $ <
$ $#
$# ( Slack, et. al, 2004: 45 ) 6'
* ( ) H-

' + - $ 1 * #
" # 2* $ 1

&- <
)'
$ 6 H . (,
, 9 D-

(

+
(
-
(
:5
2F
(+
+
$ (

1 $ <
$ ( (
, &:2 &+ :";

:
# 0 "
(-

1
.&-> $71

$> $71
$0 0 ( Krajewsky and Ritzman, 2003, p: 62 ) "
# -
G7*
/ (&- $
G7*

($71
> &+
" ($2
- /"
.
H B
:+
$ $ &-
+
<
$0 $
Y ( Heizer & Render, 2001: 36 ) #

$ &-> $71
- C - , C

.-++

38
2q* $ ;
& <
B 17 $ % }
} $# p
n
.q/ &/q0 &A $ (&-7' $71

95 # 9+ 5
&+
q 4 & $ &>

.9
"
1
11 &-}
:$' /
$# - H" 5
3./ $# 0 95
.+

$71

.1
.$71

H . F
&7
&-5
$# .2
.*
" n
+
&-5 .3
.$1 - $1

$ # /
$# .4
:
9 ) :
qA
"q .0 (q<
2
0 #
)"

A
qA
1-;

.<
D
*
&+ ;

++
(q- q-
0 )"

0 + /+ / F -

@ ( ,
H / $ &
.0 :5 $# $ )"

q
-
Av
C &/
1
$
.5<
'
- $

/;
$

5<
'
R' :0 -# $

.(25 :2001 (=)

*
Y
5
/
$' (;
&-5 / 5<
'
$# =
n
&q (
:21
(

("
4
"
(<
A - #
39
q> # q

$u /
3./ , $ $# )'
$ E (5<
.(254 :2007 (R"

)
q # q q 5<

' 5 ,' $# (19 :2006 (
)

$
>

R"
# (B
+ 5
"
"

AY

, ( :
:
+A
, (
7 (5<
n) 5
-'q $
:"# $ , 5<
'
$# .2

. *
*

7
(117J116 :2006 (

) :/
q
:

q
q<
($Y
:Y
:21
, 2 :, <
? .1
.H .
9

q+ (q -q ( (&- ( 7 $ ' :;: , .2
.5 *" 4

.:''

(pA;
(4
(:' :,?
"9 .3
.n*

1

C

A :
.4
. ,
4
"
C# A :
4 *- .5
q* q7
3.q/ q :
:;: ,?

<
? F "9 .6
(5<
s
) *

7

((

)
.(
(q
)
*"
5 5 (4<
) $ 9 / :
H .7
.(5*

(3:. ( (
40
&+ <
H B + &/# $ <
$ 5<
'

$q 5
:'
1
+
0 +
5
+ (- $
0 -*
q*
q+ q q
(

./ :+
,

1
.(243 :2006 (

)
R"0 G+
# R"
n $ $1

$ 5<
'
4
)Yq $ $# A
$ .R"

/# 9+ 5
2* $

* /

7* 5 :
(?" 2
?
$# # (q &/
# 31
>
3+5 $# - @" $

(7
#

# 4<
Y
H . $
.0 n 3- ,' 0 @ 3"
.(27 :2001 (=) <

&-q q

5
&-/
- E

;
5
(*
5
H -
$
AY -
"
*
Hq q :

./ -<

1
$ :
"
q
0 )Y '
& (
$ 3*@ 1 # *u $ A 5
&q*
$q H / $# (
;
H 3 E ).

+

q
C
5<
' .&+

CF
E2*
R
1

(q
$
=5* / A

x
C

3.- (<
q
- "# 42*
,
7

1 +
)# (CF
/< +
q1 (q
:
# q 4A - . 5
E
1 + 5< $ 5
-
41
3"q Dq
)# (
$ '
3" D /
:
; 5

(22 :2006 (

) R"r
, <
? A "
:?
.q* $# q- 2* $ 5
, 5 @ 4
4
Eq5 q C

3./ (5*
4

:2 A# C #
4q

q $q ).
5
1
4<
,
1q &q+ '# C (5 5<

- 2* -

.(81 :2005 (

) '# *v
3
# q7 $q :
(4<
$
7 4< , 4
$0
1

(

"

, 4 $# C (:
Y
q
q
,q 4q $# C ($Y
<
C $
$ <
4
/;
*
F

?A
$# H" (<
7 * $# , r 4<

# .# - . C

$ + (

&# # 5<
- , ("
q> q E7

./ ,

(H . > # ? 5
# ? 7
# q* ,q Cq q # + # 5<

- $ .
q
Y 4<
n $ (
#
S (*
q/ q Rq

> *u
* ;
1

&

.(48 :2005 ($*u

'*
)
42
( , 95 < ?

4<
$r *u C $ (C $
./
q*

+
* (

+
.*

"0 & <
$ 2/ #
q
<
7

$ # (5<
- E # *"
+ ++ > $5<

$

$ + H . 0 '0 ( > -
q0 # $ $# # (/> 4

"
C
$

>
.(139 :2003 ()

) 72
+ 9 1 $ $5<
, G5
, &-' (4

@ $5<
$ H / $# .

q Cq q t4

*v
=
( - 4

, 4 $#
+q
Cq7
9+ q q5* 5 - S ?F'
q
(
4

, 4
5 C 4<
$r
. .C

q $# (? $ $# C (

# $ $# (5 E + -
.(115 :2002 (+

) #
7 F
$#
.
q

3.*

- 0 < $# C
:";
&/# $ $# p
n
7q C F

, 4

;

$# ( @
3.- 2
# 2*;
#
&+
4 * $ &
.0 *

. 4 - > $
.<
4? : @?
= $
(

3./ R' +

6 p
&
:

3./ $

R' 2 -

43

? *? :.
K

9 4 > 6* '
*
Q # =
% :$
(2001) (&

J
.
9
*

#

C.
q<

q+
R
q # $
A@ 0

3./ /
q (
>

F
= -2 (<
F

0 *
q q

S7 -<# .
"
$
$

#

q+
H . 4<
:
@ 9

+
$

; ,5 A@
9q q &q # 4q' $ B

A@ .
&+ +
q .C

1 *
$ 5

$
n+
,1

+
q $q 5<q

1

n
$ 70
.
Cq

q1 5<

$
A "
n+
" G*

+

n
1 "
H
A@

1 p *
$ 5

$q
B
A@
42*
$ .
*
5<
#
q5<

$
$# $ &>
:5<

$ 9
&- $ $#

$ $
$# 0 * &
$
n*;
/
q*"
2q+

q*
q+
:
q0
"
&- & &/A@
( #

# 5<
4<
$
0

q<
q
p
q0

$ 75
H ,

./
&-< # &-
0 C
44
6K* K
4
? "

4
-" :$
(2002)

J
.
-
$q (qF

r -2 +
C ;
4
0

3./ /
q (q ;

/
"

/# F

4
2*

q
$ - $ C ;
3./ $ 2
4
0 ? '# 4-
q+
$0 :q-/# $ S7
$ 0

.n*# - $
/# F
q-
F

0 $# p ("
4
/# 9+ ?-
? C

("
n F )# 9+ *
+
C ;
42* 4* $
42q*
&q> q
.?'q# +
C ;
42* 4* A@ F
4
/# $#
q

;
?+ H / $# 0 *u ) C# $ )/
3./ 5 p (<

) 5
<
0 &
2* $ H . 5 $
Hq / $# $ .

4

4<
2* $ 5*
+
C ;
/<
pq $q *v C# $ 4* +

C ;
$# 70
. 2
C q;
$# q 70
. 2 H / H . .F

-2
q+A A

3# F
4
/@ -2 p $ *v C# $ 4* +
.

<
K K K
9
K '

#" :$
(2002) &
1

J
"

[
- .!.
q
q
$q

q $
< - 0

/
q q

1 p ( ;

" <
F
&-/

45
C q;

;
(q<
-

(4
/;
:
7

$q
, $

, $ .
n+
(2
+

7
"q q *
& p (319) &/ o

$# q

3.q/ q- 0
S7
&/# ,
$ (%40.8) - F
(3.6) oq <

F

? > # $A
q<
qF
$
/
$#

.*
E+

4
/;
:
G* (3.50 J2.51)
+

$'
C ;

;
: ? (
n+
+
<
-

.(3.71) 2
(3.57)
K '

#.

9
":$
(2002)

J
K8# OK# K?* % A ? 9

+
"
9

q< q

$
/
0

3./ /
&/# 2* $ (<

F
- B ,

n $ (
<
7

<
F

n+
.7

<

F
p 5 (5
<
F

q
7
q
q / n <
F
&/# $ 0 '0
$q $ Y

)5
:
;
$ ,
$#

S7 -<# .A
"# p (
<
7

<
F

n+
&/#
# /
<
4
/; A
5<

/
H / $# 0 S7
46
7

<
F
$
.&-
/# 9+ $5<
; tA

q

&/# $ (/ $ 9
<
7
q
<
F
1# $ $ (5
<
F

4' &A F
S
$
, " 4' :
<
9q+
& F
S
)

&
F

,' 11

.F
4
/; 9
K
* A% "
9

" :$
(2005) $'
J
.
9

;
< --

D.
0

3./ /
q<
3./ F
+ C# F
p
G*
&
$+

q
q+
$ 0

3./ (
>

F
= -2
$ 4"

3./ / (F
+ -2 <
3./ F

$

.- AY

$ <
3./ 7
F

9" 4 9" $ G* R 161 & R 159 1 2
? 320
S7q
$q 0

.7
" + /*
& 3 G
.<
F

r +

D. - p $ ;
< 4* :-
F

D. &
R+
=5* ;
< $# $

4' # 0 S7
"# H . .G*
R+
<
(3.5
<
F * 9 G*;
(
<

.q Eq# C F
* > 7
"
* F
&

&
47
qF
+ -< 4* & (;
< F
+ /# $

0 q qF
+ F /# G*
R+
# &
R+
< $
1
*
$

F $ 0 2 $ # $ 2' .<
F
.F
+ $ 5<
K K K
+ K# O# ," :$

(2005) (
+

J
."'- .!.
(qF
4
q/@ qF

7
C

4
0

/
H .q ($;
q
" F

Av
F

Bq

(F
S
$
B

&/# 4
,q $ .A

"
$
B

+ ("
(q" (29)
q / o
$;

" , $

$q (%17.24) q )# +

C@ " E* 6 # *
& p
( (H (& ( ;

:/ "
3./ (
"
R
$
$ &
A > +

,1 & (
"
&/q o
*
E*
"

"

$
$ (%23.2)
" 5 (116)

F p (500)

q#

B

$# :

S7 -<# .
$
(q

& (

:/
$ 4 @ A
<
-
qA;

/ (C
($
' (
(
< ;
(

q
. 9q q &

-<# .A
E*
<
$
?

48

0 # @ 9 A
<
$ (0.05)
n 70
qF q+
n+
(F
R
# (F
(F
4
/@ A
F
q-<# ).q
F
n : A F
Au (F

0 9 (-
9
7q0
. 9 &

-<# H . .H " 6 ?

qF n1q qF

0 q#

# /
$ (0.05) n
q-<# .q*
q ()

n
(
/Y
(
(E *"
.70
. / F

0 # $
, $#

?# :,- 9
:$
(2010) ()

J
[#H
:
q
$# $

%
= B 0

3./ /
q C

7
%

+
.*
F
# &-% $5<

$ (

-

F 5
S-

&*
.7
"
3./ - 0

S7
&/# .D. 1

,
<
2"
%

- /% Y C F
$
% #

q*

F

- $
% 0 /1 '

*
,'
/ 2 .

H . *} -
/# 9+ - -5 7+
q (
q A

$ C # @ F
# +
C ;
&
*
$q q+ "q $ } ,

% p
0 +
/ F
$# S7

)
% "
qqqq " / +

/# 9q+ '
F
2* $ 9

/ F

0 $
.q
| q
1% + R
{

49
(q (")

&
*

5

-
2q* "q

% +
,

0
,

$ % :5 (( 1
.5 - # @ Y

;
}
| @ %
: 9
* \
9

:$
.(2011) (

J
.' !? #

! 6*

"
<

F
A
4
0

3./ /
$
$
$

, $ ($

,
&
*
& (" (84) / o
"
3./

.
5
7
C ;
$
? *
(
<

F A@ (/1# $ S7
$ 0

.5<
'
4
/;
9+ -
"Y $

"

F
A2A
/@ <

F
$#

S7 -<#
H / $#
$ n <
+A F
&<
" F

*;
B "
*"
Y
Y *
&
n ?
?A#
$
/
5<
n E
A@
&
$

.<

F
9 ?.

9
:$
((2012) (

J
.
*
*

:
< # .!. 9 '
* 9 8# '

*

<
F
4
0

3./ 4/
(( ) 7
1
2
(7
1

) 7
1

<
50
&
*
&

4
/# 9+ (- $
< - $ (7
1
& &
#
& (5 (75) / o

# $
, =F

?
(
(SPSS)
& 7
1
&
*
:/1# $ $ S7

$ 0

(/>

F 5 $
"
*
<
F &

$#
; A

#
$# (*

"
+A /
<
F
?

? H / $# .5 ?'# : <
*

# 0

.('
( +
()

) <

&
n 70
. 2 # 0 '5
*
$ ?2

R *
<
*

<
F
$ (0.05 ≥α)
.
? +

2

./ (%86.9) o
$# H . (7
1

*#. *? :

:$
(Jiaqin & Huei, 2002)
J
Identifying Key Factors for Successful Joint Venture in China

q@ ("q
,"q q7
B

$ 0

3./ /

9 ;
A
* F
+
F A
-
$# C 7 B

* & /

< ;
$'
q
9q
B
9+ (/
$' - &- ;
A
-
q

(

(+A

(

(

:/
q
,1 & 7
*

? 2
? (27) '0 &

51
S7q q-<# . $ E* "

,"
$ R" (300)

32 (%42) /;
p $

+ $

$#

q

?q*# (%8) +A
&A (%13) )

&A ((%32) )
$q <

F

2
$# $ .(%5)
.70
. 0 2

:$
(Baulcomb, 2003)
J
Management of Change Through Force Field Analysis

0 /
5"
# &
'

3./ #

q- $q q<
5
9+ F
F :
B+ &+
, $ .
3./ '

# 1 *

&-
* $'
:
q* $q $q' :# $ &
' $
, $

D. p
&*
.,

./ $ 5 (100)
& o ( '
.q q'
n+
F

n+
1 p F

0 (Lewin)
> (*
&+ $ 9+ A F

n+
$#

5"
5
(=
-
,'
(
&< r
;
q
( Y
;
> (
# 2+

.R;
-
:$
(Cooper, 2004)
J
Organizational Change: from Public to Private Sector A UK Based

Reflective Case Study
52
. G*

&
$+
<
F
&+ 0

3./ /
q
2*

Y
4"
2* $
&+ F

<
+A 9 G*
&
+
$
q

( D $
S

q $# q 0

S7 "# .$+

u H
6'
q q )' # F

$0 $ . " $ $# $ F
)'q
q
q++ $q - (
& $
6# (Y
q+ q
1 (Y
" # , 9

F
(
q
q' - C (5 < # 7 , - # Y
('# 7
/A#
$ .*@
/ +
Y
(
4

, 4
4/ :+

4/ F

.- 9+ $# # $ (+ 6
.- AY
7

F
$ - :2
(&@
7
:$
(Stewart & Kringas, 2005)
J
Change Management-Strategy and Value in Six Agencies from the

Australian Public Service

q
q
$ F

0 #
0

3./ /
q
2q+
q
C#

*

*

(72) q )#

? (12) + & p
, F +7A
2* $ F
B n F
$
)# +

, & (+

0

* .
"

$
-1 &

q<
q qF
S7 0 +
"

$

53
(q

& (5
+

(F
C D.
:/ A

# $q
@q &/
(<
+A
&

(

("

q q # -

--# F
$
.F
.5
q

0 H . D (
4
/;
9+ ' "
Y )# B $# $ .B F

0 , - p

q
9q+ ).q
/

F
$ (&7+
,'
<
D .H . 9
:
0 F

+ - # )# (B

$# *
, - p
F
0 0
./
.B F

0 +
$ +
#
5 (C# )@ F
&
:$
(Jimmieson; White & Peach, 2006)
J
Employee Readiness for Change: Utilizing The Theory of Planned

Behavior to Inform Change Management
H
< &
* F $5<
1/ 0

3./ /
1/ &-5 )< r *

H
< &
*
2* $ .

F *
q<
n0 $ 4< (149) $ 4 @ 2* $ H . (F $5<
$# q 0 q

S7q q"# .

1 n

q &
?/

-<
F
p
0 $
# $.
$5<
q " $ 5 F

$5<
" $# (F
$0 q 0 5q
q
S7 -<# .n*# $# 0 &-+ &-
+ ?+
? 5 <
*

+ $A

9 0 0

# $
95
"
3./ 5
54
.
F :
r "
& 2* $ <
*
4
-q' (q<
-/

- A
C
< # *0
(-q* &
F :
0 (

u &- $
Y5 S

q 4- + 9 *r - (*

- : 9
$q 1 R
*

:
S
,' 0 - ($71
, -2
= -+ (- 71 : 1 -* $ S
G* , (-

.
- 1 F
:$
(Cata, 2008)
E
Critical Success Factors for E-Service: An Exploratory Study of

Web-Based Insurance Companies
$ "
" &
*
0 )Y

0

3./ /
2q* $q +
$@
*
B

4
0 (F
"#
q q & .# $@

*
<
,
&q
(" 0 , :/
;
< B

&q (q 0 q# * (;

($1
B 0 (<
+ &
* $@
" $# - S7
$ 0

<

q $# $ .# :5 ; &+ -72 '# * &+
,
.n*# <

$
&
*
q
$q
,
" ;
B $# S7
-<#
.*
<

7
$'
B
55
":$
(Beer & Eisnstat, 2009)
J
Why Change Programs Does not Produce Change?

qF
:
q 5*
<
,
C;
0

3./ /
q

# .<
F

./ 9+
5*
7
<
$# q 0

3./ .
390 $ / <
) $
9
q;
-

/ <
F
:
<
, ).
7
C
q<
qF
9+ 5*
7
$
H / $# .
1

F
$
q+

:
q

$ +
: / :5
q"# $q q " <

.(

) 9'
&+

q Cq

;
p -
<
&<

q

q- .5
-+ ,+

9 +
$ Y
G*"
&
1q
6#
)
B5
C
"
n*# $ .5*
F
$# $ .
$ 9
;
"

+ *

F H / $0 (< *
7
, 4
+
(q5<
&-
q/# $

F
A (* /#

$ &<
4-

C # < ;
-

F

.+ 2# 6 $# 4*

56
4? '

:
. (1-2)
+

, +

1 6'
( 1-2) $% ,#
4? ? 4

4? ,#
4q
0

/ q1/ q 4q
0 / "-
q 11 F

0 A# q
2q* $ F $5<
/
"
<

F
#

"
5
S-

#8

7
/:
0 & ? " 5* 7 # <
?
>
? # ?
q- q $ $ $q q
R $ $% A#
*

.
+

57
@ ,!:

#8

S- 1J3

, 2J3

3J3

F
E

# 4J3

F 5J3
7

C # 6J3

, C # 7J3
58
@ ,!:

#8
.0 (

3.- &+
p
-*

- 5 5

./
-A
,
# H .

,

R 5 $'
.
7
C ;

,
9
$' (-
B8 1E3
(
5
C;
p
- ,

$

3./
q q q
/
"
11 F

0 A# 4
4-
q $
$
:
# 4
- 2* $ &

2* $ H . (
$q

F +

& .0 ("
3./

q-
4- H . (E+
F 0
>
F
2*
.

S7 $ '5
*

A# 2E3
(180) / o

/
"
, $

, $
((2012 &q q
"q
q
2
&
9
x
9) ("
."
3./ :# $ 9
(1) 9

r $

$
$
, $ $

#

,
+

9 $" $.
("
3./ F
$ * & .0 (p

"
-
F

59
("q

0 (& C7 (& ) C $F" $ $ A
$
"q
q

, A
"
$ " $ (
p

R1q
q
6 (
9
x
9

/
q+

q
r $ &
( 285) - p
, .0 (
(360)

q q> - (5) $

1 ("
= $ & C
q q'*
q
q +
> -
+ = $
Rq q
&q
q
6q' (1J3) &

(280) 7
. '*

1

( 1E3 ) ,#
,
** )C ?. >#
)C ?. ?. ?.
<!+ ,
** '
? ' '
? 6*
280 285 360

%77.7 %79.16 %100
< ?

3E3
/q
"

$
$
$
$
(&q ) C $F" $.

[
9
x
9

.(
p
("

0 (& C7
60

=
% 4E3
q
D. $ 9
(2) & 9
('5
>
p
&
:/
*
-'*0 & .1 &
nq $q @ -'

7;
4 H . :9 /! ?C :.
q*
). q -q' &q .0 (-Y

4
/# E -0 9
(
,
@ -2 n &

.# $ $ 7/ G*

q q q-1 $*

.;
$
$ +
2
:
0 &
.
.;
:# $ 9
(3) & 9

q12
q
,q
@
2 n $ @ :- ? ?C :

(5 # s &

*
,
#
n *
&

q q / (0.773) 5 # s C

3./
F
%60 q/

3./ A S7 & +

$# p (

3./ S7

F , A
2 6' ( 2J3 ) &
(Malhotra, 2004, p: 268)
.

(2E3) ,#

? (
%
: ]?
4: ,*
%70.52 +A
F
8J1
%76.64 <
-
F
17J9
%77.46
F
25J18
%74.67 &-
F
33J26
%72.68 4
/;
9+ 38J34
%71.90
43J39
61
%71.23 5<
'
50J44
%74.01
7 , 4
55J51
%77.3 ?* $ , 55J1

9

3./ -

9 #
p2A p
+ +

-

D.

F
:v

?: (=5* ( (,5) /

/( ;

– ;

) = 75

:
$ H . .1.33 = 3/4 = 3/(1J5)
2.33 $ # J1 $ '5* A@
3.67 – 2.34 $ A@
.5 0 3.68 $ 5 A@

5E3
:v
;
2* $ & :(
) ,4

:.
.

(8J1)

& :+A
F
J
q
q (17J9)

& :<
-
F
J
.

.

(25J18)

& :
F
J
.

(33J26)

& :&-
F
J
:v

"Y
2* $ - & :(
:) A?
:

.

(38J34)

- & :4
/;
9+ J
.

(46J39)

- & :
J
62
.

(51J47)

- & :
J
.

(58J52)

- & :5<
'
J
.

(63J59)

- & :*
7
, 4
J
9
,2 5 " 9
) *
E+ p
&*
:$C =
4 :
.(
2 " 9
> ,$2 9
> ,2 3 0 9
,2 4

?* <!+ ,
*
6E3
$q' q

2* $ -

*r p
&
Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) q

&q 7
1
pq
&*q

q (q

=> 9+

*
9 - /
:
C ;
4q H . (7
C

A :
=
4 .1
( q
q
q

/#

F

:
u
.
- $
" n $ )
4

H .
q2
*

$ H . :(Multiple Regression) C . ,
* .2
.,
F
+

F
$
q A@ *

# $ H . ( Simple Regression )
? C . ,
* .3
.,
F
+ F
q
. 9q q n * H . :( Anova ) - '
? ,
* ?C .4
q
,
F
+

F
$ $

0 70
.A
5<
*"
5 n1
63
,
#
n * H . (Cronpach’s Alpha) :: ]? ?C .5
.

- "

F
E *

@ (One Sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test) "

" ?C .6
.(Normal Distribution)

,1 R
$
'q# ,' H . :(Stepwise Regression) #

. ?C .7
Eq+

D. F

0
F ,' )# (

F $
.n*# $ 5

/# - A@
*

? A#
7E3
q ;
q
q/
$ $

3./
&
: A

q* q

q0 2q* $ -
&

/ :
-
? :.
.

-

'5
Y
> p (

3./ R'
q
0 R
2* $ -
&

H / :

? :

: " (

3.- )<

,' H . (+

5*

0 Rq' p
H * (

p;

C .#
. 5
F
. 5
F

0 R' p

7 .C

"q
+
5
F

0 R'
*

.D
.

/
"
$
64
A? ,!:

B<

# G7* 1J4

F 5
:
S7 2J4

' *
S7 3J4
65
A? ,!:

B<

D<!C 1E4
:- 0
&
S7
$

( 1E4) ,#

'

'
A

%
< ?
<:

83.6 234 . =#
16.4 46 A #
4.3 12 30
21.8 61 35 J 31
56.1 157 40 J 36
9.3 26 45 J 41
8.6 24 A@ 46
25.0 70 &
* ,F
60.0 168 E
10.3 29
4.7 13 3

12.5 35 @
5 ?C
32.1 90
10 J 6
43.2 121 15J 11
12.2 34 A@ 16
%100 280 * >#
: ( 1 J4 ) & 9

$ 6'
66
& 0 $ %16.4 p

F % 83.6 F .
$# :=# .1
7"
$# (
,
p
.
95 5 $ (
$# q .
9 * ,

* 2 ,# . 6
q q

/
"
-
;
p
"
.
, + B
n $
1

9
x
9
$# q (q

q
;
7
;
&/ .
/ C
q
$;
#
D* <5
C"
>
+
.
5 1
D* / C
36)

75
$1
$
$ ;

# $0 : .2
q

75
&A (

0 $ % 56.1
" ( 40 J
( q 45 J 41)

75
&A (%21.8
" ( 35 J 31)
(%8.6 q q

" (A@ 46)

75
&A (%9.3
"
,1

./ 5 .%4.3
" ( 30)

75

*#
q- E * &-

$
$ &-># $# <2 r
C

q q q; &+
/
75
3./ ()

$q

# EY , $ &- 0 .0 (
9

"
7

)
D'
$
?
$@ &- $ ( #

# $# 0
3./ " ."
3./

;
n
).q

)5
/.
"
$ $
75
3./

.H-
# 9/
C E
$ &7
" $ &-
67
A;
&/ ( E
) ;

-"
$0 $ :
* ,F .3
-" &A (% 60.0 F (? (168) &/ o p (

(% 10.3
" (
-" &A (% 25.0
" &
- $@ 5

./ .% 4.7
" 3

:
*#
$ &> (
9
* 2 ?# ? # &
0
,
n 1 /@ u <

0

-"

.,

.-
/@
75
$1

$
$ ;

* $# :?C .4
q75
&A (

0 $ %43.2
" (( 15J 11)

q 16)

75

*# (%32.1
" (
10 J 6)

$ E@
? H / $# ,1

./ 5 .% 12.5
" (A@
3.q/
+
$' ).
&-
* $ $
Cq
q $# pq
n .'# *
*

- "
*
$# $
:Y/ & ).
"
3./ *
5<
4

.+
C
0

:! 5!+ B< 2E4
: 4
? 4* B< :.
: (+A

F

0 &
68
( 2 E4) ,#
4

.
?
R
".

-
? ?
5 1
+
&+ F
0 "
1
.6259 4.122
Y
+A : /

5 3 0 -+A 2* $ "
2
.7025 3.973
.$
n Y
+A
5 2 .7225 4.008 .-

4
/x ?+ "
+A F & 3
5 5
0 "
+A 4
.6656 3.766 .H . ?+ /F &

5 4 $ 9+ -+A $ "
5
.7695 3.856 .:2
+A , 9

&
5 5 +A 9
"
+A &
6
.6656 3.766 .,
7 * 1 +A ? "

.8130 3.631 7
.-
8 9 p
; F
0 "

.7397 3.577 8
-
: .7130 3.837 $
n
$
+A
F
F $# 0 (2J4)
"
6 : (3.577 – 4.1228 $

- F (
n
,5
(2) (1) &;

.
+5
/ A@
$ ,5
n +A
F
$
+

n +A
F
F $
+5
+ : $ (6) (5) (4) (3)
,5 n 0

" .(8) (7) &;

.
+5
/ (A@
$
- $

/
"
11 +A
F A@ $
69
o + )
4

# ( 3.837) &
R

o p (
<
.(.7130)
:
9 ,
8
? 4* B< :

( 3 E4) ,#

9 ,
8
*

.
?
R ". ?

-
?
"
<
-
F &
,5 3 .6887 3.8267 9
- 47< # &# p

?+ <
-
"

,5 4 .7640 3.7614 10

-/
"

7 .7640 3.6484 11

<
<
-/
F "
p
,5 2 .7640 3.8684 12

,5 1 .7225 4.0088 <
-/ "
&+ 13
,5 6 .8060 3.7281

F "
p 14
$
* "
&+
8 .8060 3.6281 15
-#
,5 5 .7614 3.7018
<
-/ &+ "
&+ 16
9 .8014 3.6277 =
-' ,

S "
&+ 17
0.7642 3.7554 $
5 <
-
F
F $# 0 (3J4)
"
: 3.6277 – 4.0088 $

- F (A@
p $ n
(10) (9) (12) (13) &;

.
+5
/ A@
$ ,5
n
+5
n <
-
F
F $
+5
+ : $ ((14) (16)
.(17) (15) (11) &;

.
+5
/ (A@
$
70
11 <
-
A@ $ ,5 n 0

"

o p (

< - $

/
"

.(0.7642) o + )

4

# (3.7554) &
R
:
#
? 4* B< :
( 4 E4) ,#

#
*

.
?
R ". ?

-
?

1-;
F 0 "

,5 4 .8399 3.8333 18
.
F
C
/ *

7 &+
C
"

,5 1 .8170 3.9737 19

C ;
p# *0 0 "

,5 5 .8263 3.7947 20
.
*

:2 -* &+ C # F "

&+
6 .8132 3.5738 21
.
&
*
&+
&
*
"

,5 3 .7896 3.8509 22
:2 -*

*
"

7 .8296 3.5571 23
.

" :2 -+

2-
"

8 .7511 3.4561 24
.$

S

F 0 "

,5 2 .6740 3.8596 25
-A *
A: 0.7925 3.7374 ?

$

F
F $# 0 (4J4)
"
(3.4561 – 3.9737 $

- F (
n

n

.
+5
/ A@
$ ,5
n
F
$
+ 5 :
71
$ 24 +5
23 +5
21 & +5
: $ 25 22 20 18 19 &;
0

" .A@
$
n
F
F

/
"
11
F A@ $
n
)
4

# ( 3.7374) &
R

o p (

.(0.7925) o +
:$8
? 4* B< :?

( 5 E4) ,#
$8
*

.
?
R ".

?

-
?
& 9 F 0 "

,5 3 .8011 3.859 26
5<
,5 1 .8008 4.000

:
# + "
27

&-
" ;
R F "
&+
8 .6944 3.638 28
$
0
Y
&
F "
p
,5 5 .8151 3.745 29
2

4< " F 0 "

,5 2 .6940 3.877 30

$ 5

;
F
"

,5 4 .7805 3.749 31
:
;
*
2

F "
p
7 .8440 3.658 32
5<

-

0 $

7 "
65
,5 6 .8251 3.736 33
.5*
A: .7818 3.782 $

n &-
F
F , $# 0 (5J4)
"
$
+ 6 : 3.638 – 4.0000 $
- F (A@
$ ,5
72
26 30 27 &;

.
+5
/ A@
$ ,5
n &-
F
&-
F
F $ 28 +5
32 & +5
: $ 33 53 31
.A@
$
n
11 &-

A@ $ ,5 n 0

"

o p (

< - $

/
"
.(.7818) o + )

4

# (3.782) &
R

: :A?
? 4* B< :C
$
;

9 7;
$ E* F

./ $'
7q;
$q
A

9 (4
/;
9+ "Y 38J34
+5

+5
&' / A A

# (
"Y 43J39
+5
"

q
7 , 4
"Y

&' 5<
'
"Y 9 50J44

v

$ $ .55J50
+5
&'
: ( 5

"Y
"- /
4 F E1
( 6 E4) ,#
"- /
4 F

.
?
? $%
R ".

?

-
?
,5 5 .44229 3.9632 9+ +

4
/;
,' "
34
4
/# "
4
/# $ E 9 H /
,5 3 .50190 4.0015 35
- $
,5 2 .49095 4.0053 + < "

/
4
/;
, 36
73
- $
4
/;
$

0 "

,5 4 .48451 3.9684 37
7
5
4
/;
;
+
"

,5 1 .48682 4.0228 38

A: 0.4812 3.9922 "- /

4 F $
3.9632 –4.0228 $
4
/;
9+ "Y

$0
# ( 3.9922) &

R

o p (

+5
,
.( 0.4812) o + )

4

# # F E2
( 7 E4) ,#
# # F

.
?
? $%
R ".

?

-
?

5
"
9+
,5 3 .05060 4.0000 39
(1v
)
,5 4 .50590 3.9737 - "
&+ 40
:2
:
u R2 "
&+
,5 2 .3192 4.1140 41
-
,5 1 .3192 4.1240 :2
' "
&+ 42

* - "
,'*
,5 5 .7477 3.8599 43

.3885 4.0143 # # F $
3.8599 –4.1240 $

"Y

$0
# (4.0143) &

R

o p (

+5
,
.(.3885) o + )

4

74
:
9 ) F E3
( 8 E4) ,#
:
9 ) F

.
?
? $%
R ".

?

-
?

C# $ B $
"
,5 4 .7283 3.8912 44
."
*
,
$
> $
} "
$0
,5 1 .6171 3.9940 45
$

$ &

+ $
"
,5 6 .7288 3.8758 46
." $
:Y
:21
" $
G
,5 2 .6618 3.9702 47
."
D* *

AY " $
+
67

9
,5 5 .7242 3.8843 48
."
$
B

$
, "

0
,5 3 .7058 3.9526 49
.5"

"
"

0 &-
,5 7 .7281 3.8617 50
."
D* *
$
0.6991 3.9185 :

9 ) F $
3.8617–3.9940 $
5<
'
"Y

$0
# (3.9185) &

R

o p (

+5
,
.(0.6991) o + )

4

75
, <
? A "
F E4
( 9 E4) ,#
, <
? A "
F

.
?
? $%
R ".

?

-
?
, 4
+
"
H
,5 2 .66407 3.9684 51
7
4<
:2

, "
4
,5 1 .62253 4.0088 52

,5 3 .67069 3.9481

9
, "
4 53
7 *

F
, "
4
,5 5 .71146 3.9118 54
*

7

F
, "
4
,5 4 .70146 3.9277 55
*
.67404 3.9529 , <

? A "
F $
–4.0088 $

7 , 4
"Y

$0
(3.9529) &
R

o p (

+5
, 3.9118
.(.67404) o + )

4

#

) ?C B< 3E4
,1
R0 $ @
& + (

' *
9 :

((One Sample Kolmogrov test) *

&
* (Normal Distribution)
:- 0
&
S7
$ ;

76
(10 E4) $% ,#
(
) ,4

* (One Sample KolmogorovESmirnov test) ?C
(
:) A?

. ?C
‫ا‬

<!+ (One Sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test)
0.791 1.121

0.493 0.229
:
One test) * 7

$# (10 J4) &
$ $
(0.791) F (F

0) +
F (Sample KolmogorovJSmirnov
(7

n $ # / (0.493) F ( 5
) ,
F
G
1
1
<
?
.
,1
$ $F
2 $#

,1 $r ((σ2) $ (¦) (30) $ #
& $
.0
.(223G (2004 (-

)
,1
$ C+

:6-
<
): ?C :.
n 70 . A@ " :

'5
3./ G
F
(<
-
F
(+A
F
) 3@ F

(0.05≥α)
."

/
"
11 (&-
F
(
( 11 E4) ,#

[ 4
)

Q . ?C B<

:
($8
[
#
[
9 ,
8
4 F F
R2 Sig. *4

<!+
# ? R

= 3.84 7.65 .659 79.2 .000 F

0
F
77
(7.65) /
F $# ( 11 J4) 9

$ 6'
(q'5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+ ((3.84)
- F
q q
'5
= & r H . (
+
$

+
$# $
qF
) 3@ F

70 . A@ "
G

'5
11 (&-

F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A

3Y
./ ("

< - $ H .

/
"
3.q/ q F

0
F 5 (%5 $ # - 0 p (?
5 F
(Sig.)
q q $# S7q

-< . 5
,
F
$ $ ( .659)

(% 79.2 qF *

q
9
$
*

9
$ (r)
#
n 70
. () 3

. 2
3./
.(0.05)

n $

q
&
*
& + 3 5
F

0
F A# $ 9+

$ 6' (3 ' * Simple Regression
:-

&
S7

( 12 E4) ,#

[ 4
)

Q
? . ?C B<

:
($8
[
#
[
9 ,
8
4 T
? T R2 Sig. ,4

<!+
#
= 1.648 6.87 .417 .000 4

= 1.648 7.27 .428 .000
9 ,
8

= 1.648 4.11 .334 .000

#

= 1.648 5.69 .402 .000 $8

78
: ( 12 J4) 9

$ 6'
((1.648)
- F ( 6.87) /
T $# S7
-<# .1

+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G

'5

'5
= & r H . (
+
$
+A
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $# "
(Sig.)
F .0 ("

/
"
11

3./ +A
F
F 5 .%5 $ # /
?5
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .417)
((1.648)
- F ( 7.27) /
T $# S7
-<# .2

+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G

'5

'5
= & r H . (
+
$
-
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $# "
F .0 ("

/
"
11 <
3./ <
-
F
5 .%5 $ # /
?5 (Sig.)
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .428)

((1.648)
- F ( 4.11) /
T $# S7
-<# .3

+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G

'5

'5
= & r H . (
+
$

F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $#"
(Sig.)
F .0 ("

/
"
11
79

3./
F
F 5 .%5 $ # /
?5
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .334)
((1.648)
- F ( 5.69) /
T $# S7
-<# .4

+
$# $ ('5
3./ *
- 0
&
&+
+
G

'5

'5
= & r H . (
+
$
&-
F (α = 0.05 ) n 70 . A# H / $# "
(Sig.)
F .0 ("

/
"
11
( .402)

3./ &-
F
F 5 .%5 $ # /
?5
.,
F
$ $

&
* p
&

F $ '# ,'

D. F

0
F ,' )# (Stepwise Regression )
D. $
.0 ( $ 5

/# - A@ E+

$ (

) 2
6' -
&

# $ @
$ S7
= :
$ ( 5
F

0
F
@ (F

5
;
$ (Multicollinearty) *

"
) ((variance inflation factor) $ &*' # C p
&
5
;
$ *

" 5 $ # / ( VIF= 1.881
AY p

. - 7 A
&
./ (F

S7 ++ > /

D.
A@

+
.(13 J4) &

-<
80
( 13 E4) ,#

: ?- ?C. Stepwise Regression #
. ,
* B<

:
+
Sig* Sig* (R2)
β DF F (R) ‫ا‬
‫ى‬01‫ﻡ‬ ‫ى‬01‫ﻡ‬ )‫ﻡ‬$+‫ﻡ‬
‫ار‬,.6(‫ﻡ) ا‬$+‫ﻡ‬ /‫ی‬. ‫ت ا‬$3‫در‬ /#01. ‫ا‬ ‫ط‬$%‫ا(رﺕ‬ "#$ ‫ا‬
/ (, ‫ا‬ / (, ‫ا‬ ,‫ی‬,. ‫ا‬
.000 0.039 ‫اف‬,‫ ا(ه‬9:.‫ﺕ‬ ;#
1
.000 0.034 "‫ﻡ‬$< ‫ا‬
‫ت‬$<= ‫دة ا‬03
0.000 2.29 . 20 .447 / $+A ‫ا‬
.000 0.051 ?AB0 ‫ ا‬$C ‫ا‬ 279 ?@‫ا‬0% ‫ا‬
.000 0.044 /EEEF# "EE‫ ﻡ‬GEEH ‫ا‬
280 ‫ع‬0< ‫ا‬
)+ ‫ا‬
(α ≤ 0.05)

‫*אא‬

0
F $@ (13 J4 ) 9

-<

S7 "
F
) /@ F

0 5 $# 5
A@
/# - F
2*2 ( &-
F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A
(F =2.29) F D.

*
:0 $# ((R2)=( 0.20 ) F 5
G*
A@
$# (% 0.05 $ # / 0.000
n
Sig $#
. +
t & 0
?
) F

0
F $
:

<
): ?C :

q q

0 70
. 9 : '5
3./ G
q
n1

/
"
11 F

0 A@
.(*

(
/Y
(
(E
) $ *"
F q
.0
'5

'5
= #
+
G
.05 $
Sig.
n
F $

81
( 14 E4) ,#
D<!C R
?# %:* (One Way Anova) '
? ,
* B<
'
?
#

n F F R $
F
Sig

df
1 .251
$ =#

.363 3.84 .829 279 127.585
*

280 127.836
$
5 1.464
$

275 126.373
*

.305 3.84 1.213
280 127.836
$
4 2.346
$ ,F

276 126.295
*
*
.325 3.84 2.289
280 128.531
$
4 3.440
$

276 124.396
*
?C
.443 3.84 2.312
280 127.836
$
: ( 14 J4) 9

$ $
((3.84)
- F $ (.829) /
F $# :=# .1

./ (
+
$

F $# 6' - +

0 70
. 9 & G

'5
n1

/
"
11 F

0 A@
.%5 $ # / ((.363)

n 3Y
./ (" E
((3.84)
- F $ (1.213) /
F $# : .2
=
./ (
+
$

F $# 6' - +

. 9 & " G

'5

'5
82
"
11 F

0 A@

0 70
((.305)
n 3Y
./ . n1

/
.%5 $ # /

- F $ (2.289) /
F $# :* ,F .3

./ (
+
$

F $# 6' - + ((3.84)

. 9 & " G

'5

'5
=
"
11 F

0 A@

0 70

n 3Y
./ .
/Y n1

/
.%5 $ # / ((.325)

- F $ (2.312) /
F $# :?C .4

./ (
+
$

F $# 6' - + ((3.84)

. 9 & " G

'5

'5
=
"
11 F

0 A@

0 70

n 3Y
./ .*

n1

/
.%5 $ # / ((.443)

83
=C ,!:

! B<
S7
1J5

2J5
84
=C ,!:

! B<
q5

.q/ $r (

,

5
& ).

:'

&
S7
3./ :' (p
- 0
S7
?'
:

S7 &/# G* $ (
$
&+ & - 0
B< 1E5
:

'5
*

S7 G* $
F
) 3@ F

70 . A@

S7 -<#
11 (&-

F
(
F
(<
-
F
(+A

qF $0 (

< - $ H .

/
"
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .659)

3./ F

0
q-<# + + 3 5
F

0
F A@ 9 #
: S7
: 4
? 4* B< :.
11 +A

F 70 . A# H / $# S7
-<#
F (?

5 (Sig.)
F .0 (

/
"
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .417) +A
F
n : +A

F
F $# 0

S7 "# H .
< - $

/
"
11 A@
$ ,5
85
./ $0 (-+A : /

+
&+ F
0 "
$# $ .0 (
0 -+A 2* $ "

$# (-
4
/x ?+ & +A
F
.$
n Y
+A
, 9

&
$ 9+ -+A G "
$# '# $
0 / (,

+A 9
& "
+A $
(:2
+A
.H . ?+ /F &

:
9 ,
8
? 4* B< :

11 <

-
F 70 . A# H / $# S7
-<#
(.428) <

-
F
."

/
"
. 5
,
F
$ $
<
-
F
F $# 0

S7 "# H .
$

/
"
11 A@
p $ n
5

F p - 0 <
-/ &+ "
$# $ .0 (

< -
.

<
-/
(- 47< # &# p

<
-
F &+ "
$# '# $
<
-/ &+ &+
?+ <
-
/
.

:
#
? 4* B< :
11

F 70 . A# H / $# S7
-<#

F
F ("

/
"
. 5
,
F
$ $ ( .334)
86

F
F $# 0

S7 "# H .

/
"
11
F A@ $ ,5 n

7 7-
&+
C
"
$# $ .0 (

.-A *

S

F 0
(:2 -* &+

" &
*
"
$# '# $
/
F
C
/ *

1-;
F 0 "
$

.
*

C ;
p# *0 0
:$8
? 4* B< :?
11 &-

F 70 . A# H / $# S7
-<#
&-
F
F ("

/
"
.,
F
$ $ (.402)
n &-
F
F $# 0

S7 "# H .
< - $

/
"
11 A@
$ ,5
F 0 '#

:
# + "
$# $ .0 (

.5<
& 9 F

4< "
/ (:
;
*
$ 5

;
F
"
$# '# $

7 65 (2
Y
&
F p
0
.5*
-

0 $
87
'

*
!C ,? 4* B< :C
: S7
-<#
F

0 A@

0 70
. 9 & .1
E n1

/
"
11
F

0 A@

0 70
. 9 & .2
. n1

/
"
11
F

0 A@

0 70
. 9 & .3
.
/Y n1

/
"
11
F

0 A@

0 70
. 9 & .4
.*

n1

/
"
11
88

! 2E5
5 0 -

$ &+ $ (

S7 :'
:
3./ (

/
"
11 F

0
11 $# - @" $

(
( +

.1
-+ "

n 4'
+
+ G*" 2* $ H . (F
B
.F

- G $
(/
"

' .2
.*

*

F
:'
C
' $
@- $# - @" $ * & /
"
& .3

F :
0 (<
-/ :F 0 # (p

F
, ,
5
2"

6 , (

.
.:2 *
&+ +

&- 0 2* $
&- "

/@ /
"
& .4

Y

3./ " 4A (* C
.F
5*

* $ 52

*

/# & F $A@ $.

$

;
H
"0 .5
.F
C

7
5
$ , (3.5
(/
"
<
+A
:2
1
.6
.&- &- ?+

/ & $

89
&* $# (- '

0 /
"
$# .7
.4-
-
0

3./ $'
7
$ 1 9+ /

"
0 A

7 *0 .8
.5

;
"
7

,

/
"
5 $
.9
.*

*
4<
4

-

/
"
+ 11 .10
.4<
4

3./ , 4
(7
+
1v

-" 4* /
"

.11
.-
&
*
<
F

n*#
F
" + p :
0 .12

3./ +0 0
(

, C #
.n*#
90
A# <%

? *? A# :.
K
4
? K :

4
- .(2002) "" " (
J
:q ;
q
(" > (
- 6*
.$;
($
. K*# (q q

5<
'
((2002) (&
: $*
J
.91G (2002 ($A2A

$A

(9

(

(!%.
r* (( 2005) ($ (/<

(
/ # (3 (# (" (:
'*
J
.$;
($ R (5
E+

" ( ;

(
9
$
/

<
F
.(2002) & # $@ (
J
F
- B ,

<

.(88)
(+ *# ,<
.$ ()5
( ;

(,- 9
9 ((2002) (# ($/
J
.C> (/+

(. . r* ((2006) ( (
J
(
qF (,K. 6*
? . s? ((2007) ($ * R"
J
.*
("

( 9
9 ((2010) (&< + ( $ * (R"
J
.,1
"

:$
91
:$ ((3) ( 9

9 .(2007) &< '* ( t$ * (R"
J
."

(/+
(,1
" Y (1 [
9 r* .(2005) ( (
J
.
5

(
( (;*
,
* , .(2007) ( (
J
.

+
R
# $
A@ E .(2001) F
$ !
(&
J
.(85)
(+ *# (<
F

* <

1-
$
,
((2006) ( (
J
.
(=
(

- (p

(

9 ?.

9
((2006) )+ (

J

[
*
*

:
< # .!. 9 '
* 9 8# '
&
&
(
C " ,

Y
0 +

:A
<
<
F
R

Y
(
.7
1
(2012 19J18 $ 5
2* +
( C
.!.
9
'

# .(2002) 1 (&
1
J
.$;
(0 :H
(" > (
-
[! 9

9 + r* .(2004)
(4
J
.)#
, :$
92

?# :,- 9
(2010) (

$
:- ()
J
.H
;
(

&
& (" > [#H
(
*
!

((2006) $

4 $ (
J
.,1
"

:$ (

" 9"

[( # : r*) [ 9 r* ((2003) ( (
J
.$;
$ ( ;

,1

( * # + *

#8 6 ,C ((2009) (5 (+
J
." 7

:$
7

:$ (#
? :
? ((2010) (5 (+
J
.,1
"
p

0 (

:/+
(
9 r* .(2003) (&/
0 ()
J
.

(q A
q
(,- 9
9 r* ((2003) $ ($
J
.$;
(7

($
" 9"

:$ [$
9 9
9 .(2010) & (+
J
.,1
9 # : +

9 r* .(2002) (& (+
J
.9"

($ ( A

[
+
.!.
+ # O# , .(2005) (

+
J
.$;
($ :
$ (" > 3
# ('-
93

( ;

(K
* ! $9
4 ((2008) & $> (2
J
.$;
($ (,1
" :
A
("

(
$
:

9
.(2009) ()1
J
.,1
" 7

:$
( ;

[
(+ r?
#
+ + (B5

(F
J
.300J299 :G(2004 ( (
- H

.2012 (
9
x
9 $

"
J
7

(
+ $*
<!+
- ((2004) ($ $
B2 (-
J
.$;
($ ("

"q

:$ ((1) (* 9 ,- .(2000) " (
E
.,1

.,1
"

:$ (

(
9 r* .(2004) $ (& J
((2) (,K 5#

9 ,
8 [ 9 $
! .(2006) $ (& J
.,1
"

:$
.,1
"

:$ (

(9 ((2003) $ (& J
C

(, ,!- 9 $* ((2009) ( ($ J
.
("

.$ (" :5

$ (
9 r* ((2002) (&< '* ( J
94
+
(
(+
! C # ,
* ((2007) ( $
( J
1

(p A

Y
($ 2
4

.7
1
(
(;
<

9 [L
*? #*

-
((2007)

n ($2 J

C
v
:
E
Y
[#H
t ?# A%
.
- (
(;

&
$'
:$q ( , "/

C :? ? O(!+" ((2006) (
, ' J
.

1
K
* AK% K :
9

.(2005) & ($' J
:9"q :9" (" > 3

# (
9

.
: 9
\
9

.(2011) (C.

Y - (
J
> [' !? #

! 6*

.$;
(
:+
:+
("
.2012 &
"

2
& (
9
x
9 J

: [ + [(2008) (11
&/
0 (" J
."

(q< q5
&+ < ((2008)
$
(
J
.54J33 G (1
(+ (+
95
:/+
((1) (O# /
6* C , /
5? .(2010) (C/
J
.2
"
,1

("

(
9 r* s? ((2005) ($
B2 (
J
.

: q
[
# $
# ,C :5- $
4 .(2010) 9 ($

J
.
'-
+A

1 (
9 r* 9 ((2004) ("
( J
.$
(: (

q

1 (
? F

% (( 2004 ) ($Y ($
J
.$;
($ (&

(/q+
(=:K $K* 5K) , @ ( (2001) ( E (= J
.4
. ;
C
1 ($ (

+ $
: ((2000) ($ (* J
HC
C
)
+ ? ((2010) ( (
( J
.
(

[5- $
4 ?% 4
" $5

:$ (/
?
9 '
? + .(2002) (C+ ($
" J
.,1

96

*#. *? A#
- Al Sardieh, Eid. (2012), Transformational Leadership and Organizational

Culture in Small Scale Industries in the Governorate of Mafraq”,
European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences,
ISSN 1450-2275, 45, pp.1-2.
- Atem. Tongwa Ivo,and, Yella. Gilbert Ncheh, (2007). Continues Quality
Improvement: Implementation AND sensibility.
- Balogun, J. & Hailey. H. V. (1991) Exploring Strategic Change.
London: Prentice Hall.
- Baulcomb, J.S. (2003). Management of Change Through Force Field
Analysis. Journal of Nursing Management. 200, 11, pp: 275- 280.
- Beer, M. , & Eisenstat R., (2009). Why Change Programs Does not
Produce Change?, Harvard Business Review, No 1. Dec.
- Cata, T. (2003). Critical Success Factors for E-Service: An
Exploratory Study of Web-Based Insurance Companies. PHD
Dissertation, Unviersity of Nebraska, USA, Digital Dissertation,
- Cisco, A. (2004). Change Management: Best Practices White Paper.
(on-line). Pp: 1-13. Avaliable: file://A:\Cisco-Change Management Best
Practices White Paper.mht.
- Cooper, David, (2004). Organizational Change: from Public to Private
Sector A UK Based Reflective Case Study, The Journal of American
Academy of Business. 61(3).
- Evans. and Collier, (2007). Operation Management an Integrated Goods
and services, Approach, Thomson, South, western, U.S.A international,
student edition, www.swlearing.com.
- Heizer. Jay and Render. Barry (2001). "Principles of Operations
Management".4 rd ed, Prentice Hall: New Jersey, U.S.A.
97
- Hill. G, & Jones, R. (2010). Organization Theory: Text & Cases. Third
Edition. Prentice Hall.
- Jiaqin, J. and Huei, L. (2002). Identifying Key Factors for Successful
Joint Venture in China. Industrial Management and Data Systems.
102/2, pp: 98-109.
- Jimmieson, N.; White, Katherine, & Peach, Megan,(2006). Employee
Readiness for Change: Utilizing The Theory of Planned Behavior to
Inform Change Management, Academy of Management. California:
USA.
- Johnson, Gery & Scholes, Kevan (2002), Exploring Corporate Strategy,
6th edition, Prentice Hall International.
- Karahasanovic. Ermin, and Lonn. Henrik, (2007). Selecting the best
strategy to Improve Quality, Keeping in View the Cost and Other Aspects
Valj den basta Strategic for at for battra Kvaliten med Hansyn till kostnader
och andra as pekter, Department of Terotechnology, School of
Technology and Design.
- Kotler. P. and Keller. K.L, (2009) .Marketing Management. New Jersey
.Pearson : Prentice Hall.
- Krajewski. Lee, J. & Ritzman. Larry, P. (2003) .Operation
Management: Strategy and Analysis, 5th edition, Wesley Publishing Com
USA.
- Malhotra, N. K. (2004), Marketing research, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
- Paton R.A. and McCalman J. (2001). Change Management: A Guide to
Effective Implementation. Second Edition. Sage Publications.
- Pattanayak, B. and Mishra P.K. (1999). Change for Growth:
Understanding Organizational Development. New Delhi: Wheeler
Publishing.
- Simons. Robert. (2000). Performance Measurement: Control Systems
for Implementing Strategy. Prentice Hall – new Jersey. U.S.A.
98
- Stewart, J. and Kringas, P. (2005). Change Management-Strategy and

Value in Six Agencies from the Australian Public Service. Public
Adminstration Review. Vol. 63, 6, pp: 675- 688.
- Tibbs, Hardin, (2011), " Changing Cultural Values & the Transition to
Sustainability", University of Oxford, UK..
- Wheelen l .Thomas. and Hunger, l. David (2009) .Strategic
Management and Business Policy: Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River NJ.
99
(1) $% /*

5
<2 "
&
&
r? >%

H .1
;
9"

H .2
H.&. $ H .3
S*
H .4

H .5

)
H
.6
$ H .7

/;
H
.8

.9
. >%
A2
"
.10
'+

," " .11

9
;
" .12

1
.13
A

" .14
*
A
.15

# " .16
A

"
.17
A

" .18

2-
" .19
A2 /;
"
.20

A
" .21
A2 ;
9"

" .22
A2 $;
" .23
A
$# " .24
A2
*
"
.25
('+
) 5
" .26
'+

" .27

"
" .28
A

" .29
100

9
;
.30
A2

.31
A2 ;
"
.32
A2 $ " .33
A

"
.34
('+
)

"
.35
A2 5
" .36

A
" .37

A
" .38

"
.39
A
4 .40
A2
" .41

A
.42
;

A

," " .43
H.&. $
" .44
'+
$ " .45
'+
< " .46
A2 " .47
'+
9

" .48
A
$
" .49
'+
H " .50

.51
A

" .52
'
>%
$
" .53

$
0 " .54
$ S*
" .55

$ ;
"
.56
$ /;
"
.57

$ 9A " .58
$ " .59
5+ 4 >%

+ " .60
+

Y Y " .61
101
+
6
" .62
+

1 0 .63
+

"
.64
'+
+

"
.65
+
n
"
" .66

+
" .67
+
$
" .68
+

"
.69
+
$
1 " .70
+
& " .71
'+

1
" .72
)+
A

" .73
+

"
.74
A
"
"
.75
+
: v
" .76

)+
:
" .77
+
$# " .78

+

" .79
)+
A2
" .80
+

"
.81
-
+
# " .82

" .83

"
.84
+

A2 + " .85
'+

A
" .86
+

$# " .87
+

" .88
+
," " " .89
'+
*
9;
" .90
)+
" .91
+

$;
" .92
)+

" .93
! >%
('+
)

.94
102
7-

2 S*
" .95

"
" .96

" .97

,"
" .98
* *
"
.99
E

"
.100
5
*
C v

"
.101
$5
: +A
-

" .102

$
" .103
$ " .104
4F

"
.105
'+

" .106

$+
" .107

# " .108

*
+
" .109

C
" .110
D1
S*
" .111
:

"
.112
'+
" .113

s
" .114
$1*

" .115
2 # " .116
*
*
" .117
2-
# " .118
:

" .119
E

2-

"
.120
C >%

" .121
($1) +

" .122
4<
"
.123
+
2
"
.124

*
"
.125
'+
E#
" .126
/;
&
" .127
103

A2 *
.128
v
5 $ " .129

1
D *
" .130
'+
D
;
" .131

9 ;
.132
2 " .133
+ " .134
4
2 " .135

7
@ :
"
.136
'+
H 5
" .137

9 5 5
" .138
'+
*

1
" .139
¨
"
.140
'+
5
" .141
+

:
"
.142
+ S*

" .143
7
.F

$ 1 " .144
'+

" .145

9 5
" .146
(
)
$1*
" .147
'+

.148
'+
" .149
15

"
.150
¨
"
.151
'+
$/ " .152
'+
4 " .153

;
4 " .154
+ "

" .155
+
4" " .156
'+

" .157
2
+
" .158
/1
"
.159

&+
" .160
,1 v
"
" .161
104

S
* " .162

*
,"
" .163
'+
$
" .164
$
"
.165
+
$
5 " .166
'+
G*
,"
"
.167
+
;
& E0 " .168
v
< v
" .169
$1*
+
" .170
+

" .171

9
;
" .172

" .173
1
$
" .174

HV- >%
"

+ " .175
7
.F

" .176
7
.F
.177
7
.F
5

" .178
$

"
.179
(
) .>x
"
.180
.2012 (
9
x
9 $

"
:!
105
(2) $% /*
;?
- / #
,-
*
+ $%
&
$
!
&
(((
*#
(((C
*#
(((+ &

:‫!ل !"!ع‬$ ‫ا‬

"
11 F

0 A# 4
0

3./ 4-
$
# (

R' &# /; (

/

+ (×) "0 ,' H . (
3./

7;

p
=
>; 4 - $

$ (&# C
.+

3./
$ u
@?
! "

!C
? :,- $4
106
:=# E1
A # .
: E2
35J31 @ 30
45 – 41 40J36
A@ 46
:
* ,F E3
E &
3

:?C E4

10 –6
5
A@ 16 15 J11
107
.
, * : $4
q q &# $ -:
(

F A 7+
3./

. .

(x) "0 ,' H . (-

: *4

V /

V /
/ 6 / ?
/ ?
?
4

/

+
&+ F
0 "

1
Y
+A :
+A
0 -+A 2* $ "

2
.$
n Y
.-
4
/x ?+ "
+A F & 3
&

0 "
+A
4
.H . ?+ /F
&
$ 9+ -+A $ "

5
.:2
+A , 9

.,
+A 9
"
+A & 6
.- * 1 +A ? "
7

9 p
; F
0 "

8
-

9 ,
8

p

"
<
-
F &
9
- 47< # &#
?+ <
-
"

10

<
-/
"

11

<
-/
F "
p
12

108
<
-/ "
&+ 13

F "
p 14
-# $
* "
&+
15

<
-/ &+ "
&+ 16
=
-' ,

S "
&+ 17

#

1-;
F 0 "

18
.
F
C
/ *
7 7-
&+
C
"

19
.

C ;
p# *0 0 "

20
.
*
:2 -* &+ C # F "

&+
21
.
&
*
&+
" &
*
"

22
.:2 -*

*
"

23
.

" :2 -+

2-
"

24
.$

S

F 0 "

25
.-A *
$8

5<
& 9 F 0 "
26

:
# + "
27
0
&-
" ;
R F "
&+
28
$
Y
&
F "
p 29
109
2

4< " F 0 "
30
*
$ 5

;
F 0 "

31
:
;

2

F "
p
32
5<

-

0 $

7 "
65
33
.5*

: :A?

V /

V /
/ 6 / ?
/ ?
?
"- /
4
9+ +
4
/;
,' "
34
4
/# "
4
/# $ E 9 H /
35
- $
+ < "

/
4
/;
,
36
- $
4
/;
$

0 "

37
7
5
4
/;
;
+
"

38

# #
(1v
)
5
"
9+ 39
- "
&+ 40
:2
:
u R2 "
&+
41
-
:2
' "
&+ 42

* - "
,'* 43
110
:
9 )
$
C# $ B $
"
44
."
*
,
> $
} "
$0
45
$

:Y
$ &

+ $
"
46
." $

:21
" $
G
47
."
D* *

B
AY " $
+
67

9
48
."
$

$
, "

49
.5"
$

"
"

&-
50
."
D* *

, <
? A "

4<
, 4
+
"
H
51
7

:2

, "
4 52

9
, "
4 53

7 *

F
, "
4
54
*

*
7

F
, "
4 55
& &
"
-
111
(3) $% /*
;? H- 5
# $. ,*
;
9"
F

.;
1

)
1
&
.;
2

>
B
.;
3
;
9"

4
;
9"

p
5
2
&

6
/;
$ / C-

7

Change Management Arabic

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Change Management Arabic

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

 

  

The Impact of Change Management in Enhancement of

401110012 :  # $%

. / #

‫ ‪   ()*   + ' $‬‬

‫ ‪ %- $   ( 

B  5 

7 2*0  &- /

*  4 :,- ,!:

9+ "Y 

Stepwise Regression 

  

 11  (&-

C7  (& ) "

G*" 2* $ H . (F

Prepared by: Yousef Alanzee

This study aimed to identify the impact of change management

*  4

*  4

$' - (    A (  ' < 

9q q # 

qA q/ . q

.(78G (2010 (+

q - q & q # - 0 n   /" < 

9q  <  *

q Hq . -< ( 

.(121G (2010 (C/

8*<  * 2E1

H . -   -/ $   (- 4

 11  <

 " 3E1

E & + - #  .-

.-  &+ 

 $ . " 

3./ $ 9A  .

:  / '5

 n  70  . A@   :6.

 n  70  . A@   :

 n  70  . A@   : 

 GH 6E1

(1E1) $% ,

(Jiaqin & Huei, q

q q q# 

$q  0   ,

q C # Rr

.(Al Sardieh, 2012, p: 8) ;

.(361 :2007 (+

.(317 :2003 ($

(Cisco, 2004: 7) 

- & .(104 :2010 (+

' E+ 2* $ H . & (&-  

.(17 :2009 (+

q & *q

.(334 :2003 ($

  8E1

4?  9 +

9 + :,- @?

4?  : @?

4?  9 +

9 + :,- @?

 " 

  (   9 -- $ -  

4+ $# ,  - (

401110012 : # $%

. / #

‫ ‪ ()* + ' $‬‬

‫ ‪ %- $ (

B 5

7 2*0 &-/

* 4 :,- ,!:

9+ "Y

Stepwise Regression

11 (&-

C7 (& ) "

G" 2 $ H . (F

* 4

* 4

$' - ( A ( ' <

9q q #

qA q/ .q

.(78G (2010 (+

q -q &q # - 0 n /" <

9q < *

q Hq . -< (

.(121G (2010 (C/

8< 2E1

H . - -/ $ (- 4

11 <

" 3E1

E &+ - # .-

.- &+

$ ."

3./ $ 9A .

: / '5

n 70 . A@ :6.

n 70 . A@ :

n 70 . A@ :

GH 6E1

(1E1) $% ,

(Jiaqin & Huei, q

q q q#

$q 0 ,

q C # Rr

.(Al Sardieh, 2012, p: 8) ;

.(361 :2007 (+

.(317 :2003 ($

(Cisco, 2004: 7)

- & .(104 :2010 (+

' E+ 2* $ H . & (&-

.(17 :2009 (+

q &*q

.(334 :2003 ($

8E1

4? 9 +

9 + :,- @?

4? : @?

4? 9 +

9 + :,- @?

"

( 9 -- $ -

4+ $# , - (

(/ & F

$ r (F $1 - <

$8: 1E2

3Y'# - H" + 2"

.(306 :2004 () "

$ ?+ ?+ < 9+ " #

.(49 :2009 ()1

# " H . t-

.(161 :2002 ($/

A# < 0 +

.(292 :2009 ($) "2"

.(392 :2004 (&) B

1 &# &# &# "

@ 2* "

(( 1 ( (" )

.5 - # @ Y

" 2E2

? > <

.* &# *

q/ ($12 $/ <

9q+ q# $q <

.(369G (2007 ( R"