Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
225
Jurnal Ners Vol. 12 No. 2 Oktober 2017: 225-232
226
The Elderly’s Satisfaction with the Service Quality... (Nursalam Nursalam et.al)
Table 1. Cross tabulation between service quality of IHSPE and satisfaction level of elderly
Sub Service Quality Satisfaction Level Total
Variable Category Frequency Percentage Category Frequency Percentage (%)
High 83 30.0
Excellent 215 77.6 Moderate 132 47.7
Low 0 0
High 3 1.1
Input Fair 36 13.0 Moderate 33 11.9 100.0
Low 0 0
High 0 0
Poor 26 9.4 Moderate 0 0
Low 26 9.4
High 85 30.7
Excellent 232 83.8 Moderate 147 53.1
Low 0 0
High 1 0.4
Process Fair 19 6.9 Moderate 18 6.5 100.0
Low 0 0
High 0 0
Poor 26 9.4 Moderate 0 0
Low 26 9.4
High 80 28.9
Excellent 136 49.1 Moderate 56 20.2
Low 0 0
High 6 2.2
Outcome Fair 115 41.5 Moderate 109 39.4 100.0
Low 0 0
High 0 0
Poor 26 9.4 Moderate 0 0
Low 26 9.4
0.000 (<0.05) and r = 0.750, which means that knowledge, considering the values believed by
H1 was accepted, in which there was a strong each elderly person. The assessment of the
correlation between the quality of the process quality process was based on the first question in
and the satisfaction of the elderly. Meanwhile, the questionnaire regarding patient safety, in
the quality of the outcome had p-value = 0.000 which the officers always disposed of the used
(<0.05) and r = 0.766, which means that H1 was needles in the safety box prepared by the
accepted, in which there was a strong correlation officers after blood sugar and cholesterol
between the quality of the outcome and the checking, so that it would not cause any harm to
satisfaction of the elderly (table 3). the elderly after the check-up.
Question number 2 and the satisfaction
DISCUSSION questionnaire question numbers 3 and 4 were
According to the study, there is a strong about the dimensions of reliability and
correlation between the quality of process and assurance, while question number 5 was about
the satisfaction of the elderly. In the quality the information delivery from the cadres and the
service process, 147 respondents (53.1%) officers when conducting health education and
perceived that the process quality was excellent, promotion activities. The elderly are always
with a fair level of satisfaction. The service involved in determining the theme for the
quality process of the IHSPE is a process of promotion by their needs; thus, they will have
interaction between the elderly and the PHC’s aims when coming to the programme. The point
officers, as well as with the cadres by providing of question number 3 in the process quality
services according to their professional questionnaire and number 2 in the satisfaction
227
Jurnal Ners Vol. 12 No. 2 Oktober 2017: 225-232
Table 2. Frequency distribution based on satisfaction dimension of the elderly in the IHSPE
Satisfaction Level
Quality Dimension
Low % Moderate % High %
Reliability 11 4.0 193 69.7 73 26.4
Assurance 28 10.1 151 54.5 98 35.4
Tangible 32 11.6 141 50.9 104 37.5
Empathy 31 11.2 153 55.2 93 33.6
Responsiveness 18 6.5 184 66.4 75 27.1
Table 3. Data tabulation of correlation between service quality and elderly’s satisfaction
Correlation
Quality R p Results
Strength
Input 0.705 Strong 0.000 Significant
Process 0.750 Strong 0.000 Significant
Outcome 0.766 Strong 0.000 Significant
questionnaire in the assurance dimension relates form of the work integration, work ethic, and
to the honesty of officers in conveying the work culture according to the vision and mission
check-up results to the elderly people and the of the organisation in order to convince people
satisfaction questionnaire in the responsiveness about their service and performance.
dimension was an indicator of the excellent The quality of process questionnaire
service in the service process of the IHSPE. The number 3 and satisfaction questionnaire of
results of the check-up were always conveyed assurance dimension number 3 and reliability
honestly to the elderly about their health dimension number 5 contained the accuracey
condition and further examination if necessary, and skill of the officers in providing IHSPE
either in the PHC or hospital. The officers also services, which means that the officers delivered
explained what kind of services would be could satisfaction to the elderly by showing their skills
be conducted in the hospital for the elderly so in medical examination and treatment by
that they would understand the limitations of the providing the appropriate prescription and drugs
service and would not have inflated expectations to the elderly in accordance with the results of
of the health services in the IHSPE. The quality the examination so the elderly perceived the
of input question number 5 was about the officers as having given a good performance.
manners and appearance of the cadres of the Question number 7 in the quality questionnaire
IHSPE programmes; all of the health cadres and satisfaction questionnaire in assurance
always show good manners and communicate dimension number 4 was about the
well with the elderly in the IHSPE programme. disadvantages arising from the IHSPE towards
The results of this study correspond with the elderly. During the IHSPE activities, the
those of the study conducted by Desi Suci elderly have never felt disadvantaged, either
(2014) in Jakarta, which showed that the morally or materially. Officers were always
majority of the respondents stated that the cadres well-behaved when interacting with the elderly,
were well-behaved in the IHSPE programmes, such as using polite word choices and making no
paid attention to the elderly, were friendly, and distinction regarding grade, class, religion, or
invited the elderly to communicate with them. ethnicity so that the elderly people felt the
These results show that the elderly were satisfied officers respected them according to the
with the performance of the IHSPE cadres. question number 5 and 6 in the service quality
Parasuraman in Nursalam (2015) process questionnaire.
described the assurance dimension in the The results correspond with those of
concept of the service quality RATER, whereby Donnabedian in Nursalam (2015). The aims of
a service provider organisation guarantees that ISO 9001: 2000 ensures the suitability of the
the service quality will provide satisfaction and service process about the requirements that are
high work commitment in accordance with the specified by the customer and agency service
228
The Elderly’s Satisfaction with the Service Quality... (Nursalam Nursalam et.al)
229
Jurnal Ners Vol. 12 No. 2 Oktober 2017: 225-232
provide satisfaction to the elderly, as the service This result corresponds with those of a study
received by them was lower than their conducted by Zarniyeti (2011), which stated that
expectation about the quality of outcomes. The the respondents who benefited from IHSPE had
quality of outcome questionnaire question a more positive attitude towards the IHSPE
number 1 about blood pressure and blood activities compared to the respondents who did
glucose condition was one factor to do with the not benefit from IHSPE, causing a negative
low rating of service quality of the IHSPE attitude towards the existing services of the
outcome. The elderly people who come upon the IHSPE.
IHSPE treatment activities will be reliant on Personal experience could affect
medication to maintain their blood glucose level someone’s attitude; something that has
and blood pressure. Some health promotion previously happened or is currently happening in
activities that are held in the IHSPE educate the our lives will influence our appreciation of the
elderly people about how to control their blood stimulus. Little or no experience of an object
pressure and blood glucose levels in other ways tends to form a negative attitude towards the
besides medication, such as a healthy diet, object (Anwar, 2008). Elderly people who rarely
physical activities, stress management and come to the IHSPE activities and only come
routine control. The expectation of the elderly during treatment activities are likely to show a
about their treatment and medication in the negative attitude towards the IHSPE activities
IHSPE can lead to them providing a poor because they cannot perceive the benefit of the
assessment of the quality level because they may IHSPE activities. Some of the elderly people just
not understand that there is another alternative to came because of necessity, for a health check-up
keep their blood glucose and blood pressure and for the treatment of their disease. This is in
under control due to their absence in several line with Parasuraman’s statement in Nursalam
IHSPE sections. These results support the (2015), that the rating related to the quality and
research conducted by Kristina B W (2015), satisfaction depends on the personal needs in
who found that respondents with less experience which the customers’ expectations vary,
in IHSPE activities have less appreciation of the depending on the individual’s characteristics and
benefits of IHSPE activities, and end up giving a the circumstances that affect their personal
low rating because of their negative attitude. needs. Elderly people who only expect treatment
Based on the demographic data, most of in the IHSPE are likely to provide a low rating
the elderly still had routine activities or work for the quality of the other IHSPE activities
numbering 186 respondents (67.1%). One factor besides the medical check-up and treatment, and
preventing the respondents from attending the do not perceive any benefit (outcomes) resulting
IHSPE routinely was their routine activity; for from the IHSPE overall.
example, working as traders, either in the home
or at a market. The elderly assumed that their CONCLUSIONS
activities were more important than coming to The service quality among the three sub-
the IHSPE because they had no financial variables encompassing input, process, and
benefits from the IHSPE so could not establish a outcome could determine the elderly people’s
positive attitude. The results of this study level of satisfaction towards the IHSPE service.
support Hutabarat (2012)’s statement that the The good quality of input increases the elderly
respondents who gained a benefit from the people’s satisfaction through the development of
IHSPE showed a positive attitude because of human resources, cost and facilities as well as
their good experience towards the benefits they the implementation of modern technology in the
perceived, so the elderly stated that the IHSPE IHSPE service. A good quality of process can
was very important for both healthy and sick increase the elderly person’s satisfaction through
elderly people. Among the respondents who did upholding service ethics encompassing a good
not benefit from the IHSPE, most had a negative attitude, non-maleficence, respect for the
attitude towards IHSPE. They assumed that elderly, and the right to justice in the IHSPE
IHSPE activities were not useful because the service. A good quality outcome can increase
doctors never performed a medical check-up.
230
The Elderly’s Satisfaction with the Service Quality... (Nursalam Nursalam et.al)
the elderly people’s satisfaction through their Kecamatan Ciomas Kabupaten Bogor
health status, behaviour and the attitude of the Tahun 2012 Dan Faktor Yang
elderly in the IHSPE. Berhubungan, Jakarta. Fakultas
This study can be used by the PHC as a Kesehatan Masyarakat Program Sarjana
reference to enhance the quality of input, Kesehatan Masyarakat Universitas
process, and the outcomes of the IHSPE service. Indonesia.
This study also provides an insight for the Diana, S., 2010. Manajemen Pemasaran Usaha
elderly on how to give an appraisal of the IHSPE Kesehatan 4th ed., Yogyakarta: Nuha
service, allowing the elderly to contribute to Medika.
maintaining and enhancing the quality of the Dinas Kesehatan Kota Surabaya., 2016. Profil
IHSPE service. Further study is needed to Dinas Kesehatan Kota Surabaya Tahun
conduct an internal study of the service quality 2015, Surabaya: Dinas Kesehatan Kota
of the PHC and IHSPE programme so that it can Surabaya.
be compared to the external study of the Dinas Kesehatan Provinsi Jawa Tengah., 2016.
perceptions of the elderly, as currently Profil Kesehatan Kabupaten dan Kota
conducted by the authors. di Jawa Tengah Tahun 2015, Semarang:
Dinas Kesehatan Provinsi Jawa Tengah.
REFERENCES Dony, S., 2013. Hubungan Pelayanan Posyandu
Aaker, D, A., 1996. Measuring Brand Equity Lansia dengan Tingkat Kepuasan
Across Products and Market. California Lansia di Wilayah Kerja Puskesmas
Manajemen Review, 38, pp.102. Sukorambi Kabupaten Jember. STIKES
Angga, D, S., 2014. Pengukuran Tingkat Bhakti Negara Jember.
Kepuasan Pelanggan Terhadap Kualitas Fitrah, W., 2010. Memahami Kesehatan Pada
Pelayanan Dengan Metode Servqual Lansia 3rd ed., Jakarta: CV. Trans Info
“Studi Kasus Pada Pusat Oleh Oleh Media.
Harum Manis.” Universitas Brawijaya. Green, L W., 1980. Health Program Planning
Anggri, V., 2011. Analisis Kepuasan Pelanggan An Educational and Ecological
Terhadap Kualitas Pelayanan Jasa Pos Approach, Marshall W. Kreuter: Rollins
Express Di PT. Pos Indonesia Cabang School of Public Health of Emory
Surakarta. Universitas Sebelas Maret University.
Surakarta. Herdining, W, P., 2013. Faktor-Faktor Yang
Azwar 2008. Sikap Manusia, Teori dan Berhubungan Dengan Frekuensi
Pengukurannya 2nd ed., Yogyakarta: Kehadiran Lanjut Usia Di Posyandu
Pustaka Pelajar. Lansia. Jurnal Ilmiah Kebidanan, 2(4
Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan Juni 2013), pp.1
Kesehatan., 2012. Riset Fasilitas Hesti, W., 2010. Analisis Faktor-Faktor Yang
Kesehatan, Jakarta: Kementerian Mempengaruhi Pemanfaatan Posyandu
Kesehatan Republik Indonesia. Lansia di gantungan - Makam Haji
Christine, H., 2012. Studi Kulaitatif Surakarta. Universitas Muhammadiyah
PemanfaatanPosyandu Lansia di Surakarta.
Wilayah Puskesmas Sarudik Kabupaten Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia.,
Tapanuli Tengah. FakultasKesehatan 2010., Pedoman Pengelolaan Kesehatan
Masyarakat Universitas Indonesia. di Kelompok Lanjut Usia, Jakarta:
Desi, S, A., 2014. Hubungan Antara Kinerja Direktorat Bina Upaya Kesehatan.
Kader Posyandu Terhadap Kepuasan Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia.,
Lansia di Kelurahan Rempoa Timur 2009. Undang - Undang Kesehatan
Jakarta. Universitas Islam Negeri Syarif Nomor 36, Jakarta: Kementerian
Hidayatullah. Kesehatan Republik Indonesia.
Dewi, E, H., 2012. Pemanfaatan Pos Pembinaan Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia.,
Terpadu Oleh Lanjut Usia Di 2013. Pedoman Pembinaan Kesehatan
Usia Lanjut., Jakarta: Direktorat Bina
231
Jurnal Ners Vol. 12 No. 2 Oktober 2017: 225-232
232