Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

BJA Education, 17 (1): 22–27 (2017)

doi: 10.1093/bjaed/mkw028
Advance Access Publication Date: 14 May 2016
Matrix reference 1I02, 2A07,
2A12, 3A10, 3I00

Disaster management in a low-resource setting: the role


of anaesthetists in international emergency medical

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on December 17, 2016
teams
M Walmsley BMed1 and P Blum MBBS FANZCA2,*
1
Senior Registrar, Department of Anaesthesia, Royal Darwin Hospital, Mt Everest Base Camp Doctor, Himalayan
Rescue Association, PO Box 41326, Casuarina, NT 0810, Australia and 2Deputy Director, Department of
Anaesthesia, Royal Darwin Hospital, PO Box 41326, Casuarina, NT 0810, Australia
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel. +61 8 8922 8713; Fax: +61 8 8922 8325; E-mail: philip.blum@nt.gov.au

Sudden-onset disasters
Key points
A disaster can be defined as a serious disruption to the function-
• Hundreds of millions of people are affected by ing of a community. SODs occur with little or no warning, leaving
sudden-onset disasters (SODs) each year. insufficient time for the vulnerable population to be evacuated.
There are widespread human, material, economic, and environ-
• Anaesthetists, as members of international emer-
mental impacts on the social and cultural wellbeing of the com-
gency medical teams (EMTs), are called upon to
munity.2 The scale of the impact exceeds the ability of the
assist low- and middle-income countries experien-
affected community to cope using its own resources. Outside
cing a disaster event.
teams are often called upon for assistance.
• Previous disasters have seen some teams arriving un-
prepared and unable to provide effective assistance.
• There is increasing focus on the professionalism of Type of disaster
EMTs. The overall disaster assistance required, and also the specific
• Health providers need to undergo training specific medical needs, will vary in accordance with the type of natural
to working in the austere environment of an SOD. disaster (Table 1).

Earthquakes
Sudden-onset disasters (SODs) such as earthquakes, tsunamis, Earthquakes may cause many deaths and injure a large number
and tropical storms affect millions of people annually. Over the of people, often due to destruction of homes. The number of cas-
past 20 yr, there has been an increase in both the number of nat- ualties will depend on the type of housing, the time of day of the
ural disasters and the number of people affected by them, with earthquake, and the population density. Secondary threats exist
268 million people affected annually between 2002 and 2011.1 in the form of flooding, landslides, and contamination of water
The number of international medical teams responding to such supplies. The mortality is usually greatest closest to the epicentre
disasters has also increased.1 Anaesthetists may be part of an and the demand for both search and rescue and emergency
emergency medical team (EMT) working in a low- or middle-in- health services is great during the first 24–72 h. Survivors often
come country in the aftermath of a severe event. In recent have complex ortho-plastic peripheral limb trauma. For example,
years, there has been a focus on ensuring such teams are ad- an analysis of 3177 injuries suffered during the 2008 Wenchuan
equately prepared and respond to disasters with appropriate re- earthquake in China found that 46.5% of the injuries were
sources, training, and expertise. fractures.3

© The Author 2016. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the British Journal of Anaesthesia. All rights reserved.
For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com

22
Disaster management in a low-resource setting

Table 1 Expected health effects of a natural disaster6

Effect Type of disaster

Earthquakes Tropical Tsunamis/ Slow-onset Landslides Volcanoes


storms flash floods floods

Potential deaths in the Many Few Many Few Many Many


absence of preventive
measures
Severe injuries requiring Many Moderate Few Few Few Few
extensive treatment
Increased risk of Potential risk after all major disasters ( probability increasing with overcrowding and deteriorating sanitation)
communicable diseases
Damage to health facilities Severe (structure and Severe Severe but Severe Severe but Severe (structure
equipment) localized (equipment localized and equipment)
only)

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on December 17, 2016
Damage to water systems Severe Light Severe Light Severe but Severe
localized
Food shortage Rare (may occur due to Common Common Rare Rare Rare
economic and logistic
factors)

low-lying populations. Contamination of water supplies may


lead to outbreaks of infectious diseases such as cholera.

Volcanic eruptions
The timing of volcanic eruptions is unpredictable. Populations
often settle in close proximity to volcanoes as the volcanic soil
produces ideal agricultural conditions. Volcanic eruptions can
cause complete destruction of everything in the path of super-
heated gas, ash, mud, or lava flows. Fractures are common and
are caused by falling rocks and other debris and building collapse.
Other injuries include burns and respiratory difficulty caused by
gas and ash.

Landslides
In general, landslides cause high mortality, but relatively few in-
juries. Health structures in the path of the landslide may be se-
verely damaged or destroyed.5 6

Timing of need for medical services post-SOD


The need for emergency trauma surgery will be greatest in the
initial 48 h after an SOD. It is in this time period that life and
Fig 1 Cyclone storm surge: reproduced with permission from the Australian limb-saving treatment from injuries caused directly from the
Bureau of Meteorology.4 SOD can be performed. This early treatment, such as manage-
ment of major head, chest, and abdominal injuries, is performed
Tsunamis and flash floods using local resources or EMTs from neighbouring countries.7 8
Tsunamis and flash floods cause many deaths but leave relative- During days 3–5, the need for follow-up medical care, such
ly few severely injured. Most deaths are caused by drowning. In- as treatment of trauma complications and wound infections,
juries occur from battering by debris and searching through will increase. Presentations as a direct result of the disaster
damaged buildings for belongings or loved ones. Structures and decrease.7 8 Medical, obstetric, and surgical emergencies unre-
infrastructure including healthcare facilities, and also crops, live- lated to the disaster add additional burden to a damaged and
stock, and fishing boats, can be damaged. stressed healthcare system. Unmet elective surgical and other
healthcare needs will accumulate in the weeks after the disaster
Tropical storms event. The delivery of healthcare may be further hindered by in-
Tropical cyclones (also called hurricanes or typhoons depending jury or loss of local healthcare workers.7 8
on geographical location) cause relatively few fatalities, but there In 2003, the WHO-PAHO published guidelines for the use of
may be numerous casualties requiring hospital treatment. Injur- foreign field hospitals (FFHs).7 Three uses were identified, corre-
ies are usually caused by flying debris. Tropical cyclones may sponding to the timing of healthcare needs: early emergency
cause an increase in sea level, known as a storm surge4 (Fig. 1). care, follow-up care, and acting as a temporary healthcare facil-
The storm surge can be particularly destructive and increase ity. Essential requirements, such as self-sufficiency, appropriate
the death toll significantly, similar in effect to a tsunami on standards, and time frames to become operational were given.

BJA Education | Volume 17, Number 1, 2017 23


Disaster management in a low-resource setting

However, deployment times in recent SODs have been much International standards for safe practice of anaesthesia have
longer than these recommendations. For example, the peak been published and should be followed by international
number of operational EMTs after the 2013 Typhoon Haiyan in EMTs.14 There is also an increasing focus on research, quality
the Philippines occurred 22 days after the storm. The average and safety, accountability, and transparency. However, account-
time from team arrival to commencement of activities was ability continues to be both poorly defined and poorly enforced
3 days.9 among health providers.1
EMTs are classified according to their level of care, capacity,
and capability.
Emergency medical teams
EMTs are groups of health professionals and supporting staff EMT type 1: outpatient emergency care
working to provide healthcare to disaster affected populations. A type 1 EMT is an outpatient only service that is able to provide
An FFH is a mobile, self-contained, and self-sufficient healthcare initial emergency care of injuries and other significant healthcare
facility. It should be capable of rapid deployment and able to needs. It should be capable of: triage, assessment, and first aid;
meet emergency requirements for a specified period of time. It stabilization and referral of severe trauma; and definitive care
can be set up in an existing structure or in a temporary structure for minor injuries. Type 1 EMTs are open during day-time hours
such as a tent, brought into the country by the EMT.2

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on December 17, 2016
and should be able to assess a minimum of 100 patients per day.
After an SOD, a large number of international medical teams As they are light and portable, the team should be able to arrive in
can arrive in the country to provide emergency care. Experience the fastest time possible—ideally within the first 24–48 h and be
has shown that in many cases, medical team deployment is not prepared to stay for at least 2–3 weeks.2
based on appropriate needs assessment. There has been a wide
variation in team experience, competence, and adherence to EMT type 2: inpatient surgical emergency care
professional ethics. The Sphere project was launched in 1997 by
A type 2 EMT provides acute inpatient surgery, obstetric, medical,
a group of humanitarian NGOs and Red Cross and Red Crescent
and paediatric care. The team should be able to provide: surgical
workers.4 This project recognizes and promotes minimum
triage, assessment, and advanced life support; definitive wound
standards across all areas of humanitarian aid—water supply,
and basic fracture management; damage control surgery;
sanitation, and hygiene; food security and nutrition; shelter,
emergency general and obstetric surgery; inpatient care for
settlement, and non food items; and health action.10
non-trauma emergencies; basic anaesthesia, X ray, blood trans-
Despite these early guidelines, disasters such as the 2004
fusion, laboratory, and rehabilitation services.
tsunami in Indonesia and 2010 Haiti earthquake continued to
Type 2 EMTs should be able to provide after-hours services
see well intentioned but poorly equipped responders with a
and have a minimum of one operating theatre and 20 inpatient
limited skill set arriving uninvited, without adequate food,
beds. The team should be able to perform at least seven major
water, transport, and medical supplies. Some teams were unvac-
or 15 minor operations per day. Type 2 EMTs are useful from
cinated and both physically and psychologically unprepared.11
day 1 post-onset of disaster but in reality may take several days
This placed an additional and unnecessary burden on a country
to become operational in the field. The team should be available
already struggling to provide basic necessities for its own
to stay for at least 3 weeks.2
population.
The Haiti earthquake demonstrated a wide range in clinical EMT type 3: inpatient referral care
practice, most notably limb amputation surgeries ranging from
<1% in one FFH to over 45% in another. Stump revision surgery A type 3 EMT provides complex inpatient surgical care and in-
was required in 30% of amputees, compared with a rate of around cludes an intensive care unit (ICU). In addition to type 2 services,
5% in high-income countries.12 Some medical practices per- it is able to provide: complex reconstructive wound and orthopaed-
formed during the Haiti earthquake have been labelled a ‘medical ic care; more complex paediatric and adult anaesthesia; intensive
shame’. There were reports of ‘disaster tourists’ performing care with 24 h monitoring and ventilation; and high level radiology,
inappropriate procedures on patients who were inadequately blood transfusion, laboratory, and rehabilitation services.
consented and lacked appropriate psychosocial support and The facility should be open both day and night and have at
follow-up.13 least two operating theatres, 40 inpatient beds, and four to six
The World Health Organization (WHO) convened a Foreign ICU beds. The theatre team should be able to perform a minimum
Medical Team Working Group in response to issues raised after of 15 major or 30 minor operations per day. Type 3 EMTs should
the Haiti earthquake. The resulting document, a Classification be offered immediately and deploy without delay, but are unlike-
and Minimum Standards for Foreign Medical Teams in SODs, was ly to be operational in the field for at least 1–2 weeks. Owing to
published in 2013.2 This document sets out, for the first time, their role in receiving referrals and managing complex cases,
minimum standards for EMTs, and classifies them into three the service should deploy for a minimum of 2 months.2
types, with a mandatory set of requirements for each (see
Additional specialized care teams
below). The classification system focuses on the type of service
provided by the EMT rather than the physical structure in Additional specialized care services may be provided within
which the services are provided.2 International EMTs wishing a type 2 or 3 EMT. Examples include: burn care, dialysis, maxillo-
to work with the WHO during SODs agree to comply with this facial surgery, orthoplastic surgery, intensive rehabilitation,
set of standards and principles. Minimum standards cover all maternal health, and neonatal and paediatric care.2
facets of hospital function, including staffing, equipment, in-
patient and outpatient capacity, sterilization, diagnostic services,
record keeping, and audit.
EMT preparedness
There is now a greater focus on the professionalization of A priority of sustainable aid should be to improve disaster pre-
disaster response and teams are required to be adequately paredness within low- and middle-income countries that are at
prepared and trained to function in a resource-limited setting. a high risk of natural disasters. As this need is unlikely to be

24 BJA Education | Volume 17, Number 1, 2017


Disaster management in a low-resource setting

adequately met, the need for international assistance will remain ‘deployment ready’ criteria are set, such as pre-departure health
a reality into the foreseeable future. In recognition of the great checks and vaccination, in country codes of conduct and a post-
unmet need for essential life-saving surgical and anaesthetic deployment psychological debrief.5 11 16
care in low- and middle-income countries, the Lancet Commis- Pre- and post-deployment psychological training and debrief
sion on Global Surgery was launched in 2014. The report, pub- is recognized as an important part of both pre-departure pre-
lished in 2015, outlines five key messages to improve access to paredness and in managing the homecoming phase of a mission.
timely, safe, and affordable surgical care by 2030. The report EMT workers are exposed to stressful situations. This can range
noted that by integrating surgery into district hospitals, the hos- from working in an unfamiliar environment and being faced
pitals’ ability to provide other complex healthcare services is in- with ethically challenging situations to being exposed to critical
evitably increased. Thus, by strengthening basic surgical care, a incidents such as a serious threat to one’s own life.5 The Antares
hospital will be better equipped to deal with a range of health Foundation and the Centre for Disease Control examined stress
challenges, including those faced in the aftermath of a natural and adjustment disorders among aid and development workers.
disaster.15 Approximately 30% of international staff from five agencies sur-
veyed reported significant symptoms of post-traumatic stress
disorder on return home.17
EMT staff

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on December 17, 2016
Health professionals and medical logisticians deployed to SODs EMT equipment and systems
must undergo specialized training in delivering care in austere Along with a prepared team, a cache of pre-packed medical and
and resource-poor environments. Ideally, they should have ex- personal equipment should be stored and ready to use immedi-
perience in areas such as disaster management, humanitarian ately. To enable EMTs to deploy promptly and to be maximally ef-
relief, public health, travel, and field medicine. fective on arrival, the practicalities of the day-to-day running of a
The UK International Emergency Trauma Register (UKIETR) self-sufficient field hospital should be planned well in advance.
Anaethesia Training for Austere Environments (AAE) and the This will include:5 18
Australian Medical Assistance Team Training (AUSMAT) run by
the National Critical Care and Trauma Response Centre • Means of power generation: for both hospital equipment and
(NCCTRC) are examples of essential pre-deployment courses. personal use, e.g. generators, batteries, solar devices.
These courses focus on issues such as safety and security, nego- • Equipment: should be portable, light-weight, and robust. It
tiation, transport, cultural awareness, team dynamics in the field, should have back-up battery capability for use in the event
stress management, ethical dilemmas, and familiarization with of power failure. Team members should be familiar with
equipment. The courses include high-fidelity simulations in equipment and have a plan to deal with malfunction. A
which team members are responsible for the set up of a field hos- means of sterilizing surgical equipment and providing per-
pital and management of casualties (Table 2). sonal protective equipment should be planned.
UKIETR and AUSMAT ensure deployed personnel are appro- • Oxygen supply: decision to use oxygen concentrators, oxygen
priately trained to meet international standards. To ensure a con- cylinders, or both.
sistent and predictable response to disasters, pre-deployment • Medications: pharmacy supplies for use on deployment need
to be stored in appropriate conditions. Medications such as
insulin, vaccinations, and most neuromuscular blocking
Table 2 Further resources agents require cold storage. The cold chain must be main-
tained during deployment. The preparation of medicines
EMT courses
should be considered. For example, thiopental and vecuro-
UK International http://uk-med.humanities.
nium are prepared in powdered form, giving the advantage
Emergency Trauma manchester.ac.uk
of being lightweight and having a long shelf life. A system
Register (UKIETR)
to ensure supplies are kept in date should be developed, for
Australian Medical http://www.nationaltraumacentre.
example, rotation of stock with a local hospital in the donor
Assistance Team Training nt.gov.au/what-we-do/disaster-
(AUSMAT) management/ausmat country between deployments.
New Zealand Medical https://www.health.govt.nz/our- • Blood availability: consideration of a living donor bank and a
Assistance Team Training work/new-zealand-medical- means of ABO typing and screening for infectious diseases.
(NZMAT) assistance-team • Food, water accommodation, waste, and sanitation: for staff,
Humanitarian Response http://hhi.harvard.edu/education/ patients, and patients families. For surgical procedures,
Intensive Course (USA) workshops/hric Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors without Borders) guide-
Developing world anaesthesia courses lines recommend 100–300 litre water per patient per surgical
Developing World http://www.rcoa.ac.uk/education- procedure.18 A means of sterilizing and storing drinking
Anaesthesia Course (UK) and-events/developing-world- water should be pre-planned.
anaesthesia • Clothing: uniforms need to be climatically appropriate,
http://dwasouthwest.org protect staff from injury in the field, and facilitate easy identi-
Real World Anaesthesia https://www.asa.org.au fication of teams.
Course (Australia/ New
Zealand)
Global Outreach Course http://hhi.harvard.edu/education/ Disaster response and deployment
(Canada) workshops/hric
Response to an SOD should be co-ordinated at a national level.
Anaesthesia in Developing http://www.ndcn.ox.ac.uk/study/
The WHO-PAHO recommend that EMTs should be deployed
Countries (Uganda) continuing-professional-
development/anaesthesia-in- only after a declaration of emergency and invitation from the
developing-countries host country.7 National teams should be available to depart
with 12–24 h notice and be able to be deployed for at least 2–3

BJA Education | Volume 17, Number 1, 2017 25


Disaster management in a low-resource setting

weeks. Needs and expectations of the host country, local author- delivery device and understand any potential limitations.
ities, and local healthcare providers should be clearly defined. For example, draw over vaporizers are robust, portable, and
On arrival in country, EMTs need to register with the host do not rely on a pressurized gas supply. However, they are
country.2 7 19 The EMT must provide information on the level of wasteful of volatile agent, the presence of a self-inflating
care they are able to provide, bed capacities (outpatient, in- bag makes spontaneous ventilation more difficult to observe,
patient, surgical), team composition (number, specialities, level and scavenging is cumbersome. Training in the use of draw-
of experience), time to deployment, estimated time to be oper- over is required before deployment. Plenum machines with
ational, and logistics and support required. EMTs should agree circle circuits use less volatile agent. However, when com-
to adhere to the minimum set of professional and ethical stan- pared with drawover, they are generally expensive, fragile,
dards, including carrying out only those procedures for which bulky, heavy, and require monitoring of inspired oxygen con-
they are accredited in their own country. A plan for collaboration centration and a means of absorbing carbon dioxide. A well-
with local healthcare providers, local and national authorities, regulated high-pressure gas supply is also needed.
and other EMTs should be agreed upon to improve complemen- • Total i.v. techniques: include propofol and ketamine-based
tarity of healthcare services. It is hoped that in the future, all EMT techniques, which can be used to provide sedation or general
provider organizations will be pre-registered on an international anaesthesia. Benefits of a propofol-based general anaesthetic
database to allow better matching of supply and demand and include rapid wake up and recovery time, low rates of post-

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on December 17, 2016
improved co-ordination, integration, standards, and time to operative nausea and vomiting, and agent familiarity. Disad-
deployment.2 7 19 20 vantages include the need for additional analgesia and the
A clear exit strategy, hand-over process, and plans for follow need for equipment such as infusion pumps with adequate
up and rehabilitation must be made in co-operation with the battery life or reliable power supply. Ketamine is well de-
host government and local healthcare providers.11 19 20 scribed as a useful anaesthetic agent in low- and middle-in-
come countries. Its advantages include the provision of both
Anaesthesia in an FFH analgesia and anaesthesia, stable cardiovascular effects, and
Anaesthetists deployed as part of an EMT, when considering the relatively little respiratory depression. Disadvantages to be
most appropriate type of anaesthetic, must be cognizant of the considered in an FFH include a longer recovery phase and
specific issues raised when working in a resource-limited envir- the potential to induce hallucinations and delirium in
onment. Outside theatre, they will be call upon to manage acute a patient who has recently experienced a traumatic event.
and chronic pain, assist trauma or neonatal resuscitation, and in Combination i.v. techniques such as adding ketamine to
the evacuation or retrieval of patients where necessary. propofol (‘ketofol’) are documented.23 The ratio of dosage of
propofol and ketamine within these infusions must be con-
Type of anaesthetic sidered with regard to supply of medication, analgesia, recov-
ery time, and number of recovery nursing staff.
Patient, environmental, equipment, and postoperative factors
will all influence the type of anaesthetic performed in an FFH.
Adequate oxygen supply by oxygen concentrator or cylinders, a
Additional anaesthetic considerations
means of providing ventilation, suction, and for monitoring
oxygen saturation, arterial pressure, and end-tidal CO2 must be Other aspects to consider when performing anaesthesia in an
available. FFH include: availability of translators, appropriate preoperative
assessment, limited investigations, limited blood supply, con-
• Regional anaesthesia has been recognized as a beneficial sent, documentation, antibiotic selection, management of com-
technique in developing countries and austere environments. plications, postoperative analgesia, appropriate postoperative
Spinal anaesthesia is simple, reasonably predictable, allows care, and follow-up.
the patient to breath spontaneously, provides good initial
postoperative analgesia, and has a relatively uncomplicated Ethical considerations
recovery. It is useful for most procedures below the umbilicus.
Complex regional techniques such as peripheral nerve blocks EMTs deploying from high-income countries are accustomed to
and nerve catheters have been described in situations such as working in a resource-rich environment. They will face ethical di-
the care of the wounded combat soldier. In this situation, local lemmas when arriving in a country with limited equipment, pa-
anaesthetic blocks and infusions allow for both intraoperative tient capacity, and treatment options. Ethical decisions will
anaesthesia and analgesia during the postoperative and re- include patient triage, which patients to accept for active treat-
trieval phase. They may be useful in reducing the incidence ment and limits of patient care in an attempt to best utilize avail-
of persistent postoperative pain.21 22 The anaesthetist in an able resources such as operating theatres and ICU. During the
FFH will need to consider the benefit of such a technique, Haiti earthquake, the Israeli field hospital set up an ad hoc ethics
equipment availability, and the difference between war committee consisting of three senior clinicians not directly in-
zone injuries and those caused by disasters. Peripheral volved in the care of the patient. The treating doctor presented
nerve catheter-induced infections and complications are like- ethically challenging patients to the committee and was relieved
ly to be low in injured soldiers who are able to be rapidly of the burden of determining the patients’ fate.24
removed from the battlefield and have a low incidence of co-
morbidities. Complications may be more likely in patients
Conclusion
with comorbidities such as diabetes with delayed presenta- Anaesthetists have a set of skills and attributes, meaning they
tions for management of wounds and secondary infections can be valuable members of an EMT responding to an inter-
caused by SODs. national disaster. However, each individual has a responsibility
• Inhalational anaesthesia: some presentations will be unsuit- to ensure that they and their team have the appropriate training
able for regional procedures. If inhalational anaesthesia is and preparedness to work successfully in an austere environ-
to be provided, the anaesthetist must be familiar with the ment. All teams need to be familiar with the recognized

26 BJA Education | Volume 17, Number 1, 2017


Disaster management in a low-resource setting

minimum standards and to be prepared to work closely with 10. Greaney P, Pfiffner S, Wilson D (eds). The Sphere Project.
local teams to ensure effective care is provided. Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards in Humanitarian
Response, 3rd Edn. Rugby, UK: Practical Action Publishing,
2011. Available from http://www.sphereproject.org/handbook/
Declaration of interest (accessed 16 March 2016)
11. Coatsworth N. The Australian medical response to Typhoon
Dr Phil Blum has provided volunteer anaesthetic services for the
Haiyan. Med J Aust 2014; 201: 632–4
Australian NCCTRC on international deployment.
12. Mathuna D, von Schreeb J. Ethical dilemmas with amputa-
tions after earthquakes. UNISDR Scientific and Technical
Advisory Group Case Studies, 2015
MCQs 13. Van Hoving DJ, Wallia LA, DocratF, De Vries S. Haiti disaster
The associated MCQs (to support CME/CPD activity) can be tourism—a medical shame. Prehosp Disaster Med 2010; 25:
accessed at https://access.oxfordjournals.org by subscribers to 201–2
BJA Education. 14. Merry AF, Cooper JB, Soyannwo O, Wilson IH, Eichhorn JH.
International standards for a safe practice of anaesthesia
2010. Can J Anaesth 2010; 57: 1027–34

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on December 17, 2016
15. Meara JG, Leather AJ, Hagander L et al. Global surgery 2030:
References evidence and solutions for achieving health, welfare, and
1. Tan YSA, von Schreeb J. Humanitarian assistance and economic development. Lancet Comm 2015. Available from
accountability: what are we really talking about? Prehosp http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60160-X (accessed
Disaster Med 2015; 30: 264–70 12 February 2016)
2. Norten I, von Schreeb J, Aitken P, Herard P, Lajolo C. 16. Smith Z, Hughes A, Craven R. Anaesthesia for austere
Classification and Minimum Standards for Foreign Medical Teams environments. RCoA Bulletin 2015; 91: 39–41. Available from
in Sudden Onset Disasters. Geneva: World Health Organisation, http://www.bmsc.co.uk/wpcontent/uploads/2015/06/Austere
2013 Course.pdf (accessed 8 February 2016)
3. Lu-Ping Z, Rodriguez-Llanes JM, Qi W et al. Multiple injuries 17. Managing Stress in Humanitarian Workers. Guidelines for Good
after earthquakes: a retrospective analysis on 1871 injured Practice, 3rd Edn. Antares Foundation. 2012. Available from
patients from the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake. Crit Care https://www.antaresfoundation.org (accessed 10 March
2012; 16: R87 2016)
4. Bureau of Meteorology. Storm surge preparedness and 18. Chackungal S, Nickerson JW, Knowlton LM et al. Best practice
safety. Commonwealth of Australia. 2016. Available from guidelines on surgical response in disasters and humanitar-
http://www.bom.gov.au/cyclone/about/stormsurge.shtml ian emergencies: report of the 2011 Humanitarian Action
(accessed 16 March 2016) Summit Working Group on Surgical Issues within the
5. Norten I, Trewin A (eds). Australian Medical Assistance Team Humanitarian Space. Prehosp Disaster Med 2011; 26: 1–8
Training, 2nd Edn. National Critical Care and Trauma 19. Registration and coordination of foreign medical teams
Response Centre, 2011 responding to sudden onset disasters. The way forward.
6. Natural disasters. Protecting the Public’s Health. Washing- Foreign Medical Team Working Group. 2013
ton, DC: Pan American Health Organization, 2000. P 1–10. 20. Hilarie H, Cranmer MD, Biddinger PD. Typhoon Haiyan and
Scientific Publication 575 the professionalization of disaster response. N Engl J Med
7. WHO-PAHO guidelines for the use of foreign field hospitals 2014; 370: 1185–7
in the aftermath of sudden impact disasters. Washington, 21. Scott DM. Regional anaesthesia and analgesia on the front
DC. World Health Organisation and Pan American Health line. Anaesth Intensive Care 2009; 27: 1008–11
Organization, 2003 22. Lippert SC, Nagdev A, Stone MB, Herring A, Norris R. Pain
8. Von Schreeb J, Riddez L, Samnegard H, Rosling H. Foreign control in disaster settings: a role for ultrasound-guided
field hospitals in the recent sudden-inset disasters in Iran, nerve blocks. Ann Emerg Med 2013; 61: 690–6
Haiti, Indonesia and Pakistan. Prehosp Disaster Med 2007; 23: 23. Andolfatto G, Willman E. A prospective case series of single
144–51 syringe ketamine–propofol (ketofol) for emergency depart-
9. Brolin K, Hawajri O, von Schreeb J. Foreign medical teams in ment procedural sedation and analgesia in adults. Acad
the Philippines after Typhoon Haiyan 2013—who were they, Emerg Med 2011; 18: 237–45
when did they arrive and what did they do? PLOS Curr2015, 24. Merin O, Ash N, Levy G, Schwaber MJ, Kreiss Y. The Israeli
doi:10.1371/currents. field hospital in Haiti—ethical dilemmas in early disaster
dis.0cadd59590724486bffe9a0340b3e718 response. N Engl J Med 2010; 362: e38

BJA Education | Volume 17, Number 1, 2017 27

Вам также может понравиться