Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 24
BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 A: Dobppi neve, ysaxaembie pysba! Ceronua Haw se6uHap nocasuyéH TeMe Kak OcBOBOAMTS CBN 6uBHEC M CeBA NMUHO OT AONFoBOrO 6pemenn, COxpaHMTb NPM 3TOM aKTHBbI M M3GeXKATe PUCKOB CYGCMAMAPHON OTBETCTBEHHOCTH. 3ecb Peub MA@T 0 KPeAMTOPCKON 3aNOMKEHHOCTH Nepen KOHTPAareHTAMH, Nepen 6IOAKETOM M BaHKOM. A: Banepa, npegoctasnaio cnoso Tebe, Kak BenyLleMy. B: Npexpaco, no6pbi Zeb, Roporve Apy3ba! Cerogua pan npisercraosars Bac Ha Hatem Be6uHape. Anekceli npaBunbHo o3Byunn ero TeMy. OHa 38y- uur: «Kak neranbHo OCBOSOpMITb CBON BUSHEC Mt Ces NMUHO OT 3aMKEHHOCTeM Nepen KOTPareHTAMN, FocymapcTaeHHbim opraHaMn nuBo nepen GaHkamu» Hemborxko pacckarky 0 Hac. Mul aansemca napTHépamn HayMoHanbHo npeMnn «BusHec ycnex> 4 pani npefocTasMTe onpese- JABHHYIO NoNb3y sANA BCeX YUACTHMKOB STOO BENUKOFO KOMBIOHUTY. SAnpeactasnaio Mockoackni dbunwan rpynne| KoMnaHMi «buaHec-TapaHT. Mu! oSbequusem pecypcur, kak npaaunbHo cKazan AneKcelt, Gonee 220 coTpyAHMkos, pacnomoxeH- Hix Camape, Tonbsitru, Mockae u Cankt-Metepbypre. Bnaropaps Tomy, uTo HalWM cneuManMcTel TeppHTOPHANbHO HAXOAATCA B PABHEIX yronKax POCcHM, MBI MO>KEM COKPATHTb CeBECTOMMOCTS, TAKMM O6pa3oM HalUM yCAyrH KPaMHe KOHKYPeHTHbI. Mux npe- ocTaansem BoNbUMHCTAO HaWiMx yCAyr Ha TeppuTOpMn Bced CTPaHI No NocTonnaTe. HeMHOKKO 3aneprkyCb Ha 3TOM nlonogpobuee. 370 BBbICKAHMe 3aO/KEHHOCTeN C ONNATOA ToNbKO NOCHE usMuECKOrO NONyYEHMA AeHEKHEIX cpencta o6parHo. 3T0 ocaoboxsAeHMe OT 3aOMKEHHOCTeN, conPoBOxAeHE cropos C HanoroBOH, PeuleHve aceBosMOXKHbIX NPOBNeM, CBAIAHHBIX C 3THM, AOHAUMCAeHNe HaNoroB, OcnapHBaHne M pe- ieHHe, ConpoBOxKAeHNe BbIezqHOM KaMepanbHOH NpoBepKN, Tinioc nukennauna npoGnemHbix dupM, Aanaiire nonoppobuee ocTaHoBMMca Ha ycnyre ocBOBOXKAeHMe OT 3anOMKEHHOCTeH. 370 yoke TpeTHA M3 OBLYerO LINkna BeBMHApOB, NOCBALYEHHEIX TOM TeMe. Mol Bv.qum rny6oKylo vATHMHOCTS 3TOM npOBNeMb! H NOHMMaeM, UTO 3a4aBaT BONPOCEI, CBAIGHHBIE C Te- Mol se6viHapa kpaline Henpocto. Tem He meHee, mbt nonyunnn oT aac Bonee 80 sonpocos m HaneeMcs, uTO AneKcel CMODKeT rpaMOTHO M MpodeccnonansHo NpeAOCTABUTS Ha HiNx OTBETHI, JIMUHO A B 9TOM He COMHEBAIOCD. Dasaiire sepHemca k KOHKpeTHBIM TemaM, PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT Cea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Boi MoxkeTe Takoke NVICaTb CBOM BONPOCEIB UATE, A C YAOBONECTEVEM Mx 3ap;4M AneKCetO. B: 91 cnbiwy, uro Anekceii cnbiwiuT Hac, eMy BKMIOUNAM Mo; ronoc. AneKcel, oTpearupyth A: Cefiuac 38yk HacTpownu, ace xopowo. B: Npexpacio. 3ameuaTenbHo. Mbl ycTpaHunn ace TeXHMUeCKHe HENONapKM, NPUHOCHM 3a Hx HBBMHeHNA w fasanre nepeninén k neny, noToMy uTo y Hac Bonee 80 sonpocos, HanomHM, ocTapaeMca OTRETHT> Ha Hux ace. Bol MO>KETe MCAT CBOM BON|POCEINPAMO B LaTe, 1'f C YAOBONBCTENEM O3BYUY Hx HALeMy Cru kepy. Anekcei, npowy Te6a pacckazaTb HaM HeMHOxKO O ceBe. Pacckaxn HALIM CnywiaTensM, KTO C TO- 60H ewe He 3HaKoM. A: Jo6ppi net, yeaxkaembie Cnywarenn ewe paa. A AaNAIOCe NpAKTHKyIOWWMM IOpHCTOM, PyKOBOAMTENEM fopmamueckon dupe! rpynnbi KoMnaHN «BvaHec-T apalT». AanAioce apouTPAKHEIM ynPABNAIOWWMM, Bepy MPoUeAYpY GaHKPOTCTHA, KaK C eNbIO BIbICKAHHA NEHEKHEIK CpeACTB, TAK MC YeNb!O OCBOGOKAEHMA OT gonros. B.51 61 xoTen 3aate Te6e Bonpoc 43 ByKBaNbHO nocneAHeM npakTaKu. Kak Toi 3HaeUb, HesABHO K Ham o6paTuncs OfMH W3 HALIMX KAMeHTOB y KOTOPOTO GbiNa 3aOMKeHHOCTe Nepen GaHKaMM B He CKONbKO COTeH MMNAMOHOB py6ned, NoscHH, NoxkanyiicTa, Kak NONYUWNOCe Tak, UTO ero GUBHEC, KO- Topbili reHepupyer UACTOrO apeHAHOTO NoxoAa Ha cymmy 15 MunnMoHOB py6nen B MecaL,, npeACTa- BUTeNeM OAHOFO M3 KPyNHEAUINK BaHKOB yAaNOCb OL|eHMTS ero BCero & 300 MannuoHos pybnel Ben Moi nonmmaem, ecnu 6uaHec npHHocuT 15 MUMOHOB 8 Mecay 9TO 180 # ron, AaxKe ero OpHeH- ‘TupoBounaa croMMocTe 1 MunnwapA 800 Mn. Ero.Ke oueHMnM 8 300 MAnnMoHOE M MHMMMpoBaE npouenypy GaHKpoTcrsa, y KNMeHTa OTHANM. Morn 661 861 npokoMMeHTuposaTb 3Ty CHTYALIMIG, A AyMalO, ITO OHa MHOrMM cnywiaTenaM ByneT noneska. A: 3necb Bonpoc OTHOCHTCA BonbUNe K NPEANPMHUMATEN’CKON, a He OPMAMUECKOI TeMe. Ecnm BcnomuHatt WMeHHO TOT Chyuali, TO MsHaVaNbHO AOrOBOP 4 CTOMMOCTS UMYyWNeCTBA BbiNa COrnaco- Bava AOroBOPOM 3anlora HesABHOKUMOCTH MNOTEKH. Vi, cooTeeTcTBeHHo, npu oBpaueHMn BabickaHiA, oHa 9TH OOBEKToI HEABMNKMMOCTH UCTeU-BaHK npocun yka3aTb MMeHHO OT OBODHYIO CyMMy ANA PeaTuBauMih THX OBBEKTOS HEABMKUMOCTH, UTO BbITO KpaliHe HeBbiroHo COBCTBeHHIKY, Viana saunter HapyweHHbxx npas Mbl HaaHatiann cyebHyIo aKcnepTH3y, KoTOpAA yCTaHOBMNA, uTO CTonMOCTe 3TOFO MMyU4eCTBa Kak pas NPHBNMKaeTCA K MUNnMapAY pyBnett Vi ronbko nocne Toro, kak Mbi rlonyunnu peaynbTar cyae6Hon akcnepTH3bi, Gakk nowén Gonee OxOTHO Ha NeperoBopby, W KANEHTY yslaNOCb PeCTPyKTYPUPOBATe CBOM KPeAUTHbIM Aon. Celiac OH YCreWHO 3aHM- MaeTCA ero norawieHeM no npvemneMbIM eMy YCnOBHAM. PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT Cea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Oretun Ha sonpoc, Banepa? B: 3ameuatenbHo. A AyMalo, uTo sone. Homepom of 3HaunTca Bonpoc OT HaluMx CnywaTened. ITO PeKOMeHAayMA {ANA MHBECTOPOR B He- ABWKUMOCTE, KaK OBeR0NACHTE Cebs (kK COxaNeHMIO, ABTOP BONPOCA He NOACHAN B KOMMEpUECKYIO TMGO B AKUNYIO HEABKUMOCTH, HO sAaBaM paccMOTPAM Ha NpHMepe KUNOM HEABMKMMOCTH) KaK MO>kHO O6e30NACUTb CBON MHBECTMIAMM, A: 3gece 8 nepayio ouepenb NOAKMOUAIOTCA HOpMb! [paxKAAHCKOrO 3aKOHOMATENbCTAA, KOTOPbIE NO3BO- svOT OBecneunsaTe BbINONHeHHe OBAZATENBCTB, TO ECTe BOIBPAT BNOMEHHDIX, MHBECTHPOBAHHBIX AEHEX- HbIx CpeACTB. 30eCb NPABMNA NPMMEHAIOTCA NPaKTHUECKM KO BCEM BNOKEHMAM, HEBAYKHO 3TO 3a/iMbI, KDE UTEI, KaKMe-TO CDUHAHCOBbIE BNOKEHMA MHBECTALMOHHIe. 3eC> MOXKET GbIT NOpyuNTeNbCTBO NMWHOe OT COBCTBeHANKA GuBHeCa Kya BbI MHBECTHPYeTe, 3ANOF MX MMYLAECTBA KAK LBMKHMOTO, TAK MW HEABIDKM- Moro, M KOHEUHO YCrOBNe, KOTOPOE NO3BONAeT BAM KOHTPONMPOBATS Kya PACKOAYIOTCA AEHEXHbIe Chenctaa, Kakaa BanoBas npuBbine NOCTyNaeT M COOTAETCTACHHO, UMeTb BO3MOKHOCT KAK-TO Ha 3TO annate, YcnoBMsMM DOTOBOPA MOxKHO NPEAYCMOTPETe NEPHORMUECKyIO OTUETHOCTe TOrO MMLia Kya Bb wHBecTHpyeTe AeHor, nepen BaMN, Kak Nepen M4BecTOpaM Ee pas o6pauiaio Baie BHUMaHie, cn pe3IoMMpoBAT, BakHO NPABMNbHO CornacoBbIBaTb ycnoBKA M oBecneunsars ceon oBrsaTenbCTea No BOSBpATy. B: Ycnbiwan Te6a,Pacckaku, noxkanyiicra, NonoAPOGHee Npo OAMH H3 3HAMeHUTEIX KeMICOB OcBO60- >kMeHNe OT 3aROMKeHHOCTeN nepen CbepGaHKoM Ha cymMy B 300 MunnMoHOs pybnei. Ha cKONbKO A NomHio, Tam Jeno Oboumnoce Nake 6e3 MHMUMALMH NPOLeAYpE FaHKPOTCTEA. A: Tam curyauna Bina cneayiowan, Onna v3 KpynHemUnx CTpoMTenbHbKX KoMaHNit B Camape 3akniounna TOCKOHTpaKT M BbINONHANA pa6oTeI No CTOMTeNbcTBY OAHOTO U3 KPYMHEMWMX OBbeKTOR, 3aka34NKOM Guin MnnncrepcTeo crpomTenscrea CamapcKoi oBnactu, Obin reHnoppAAUMK u Bon NoRPAAUMK B MMe Hawero knueHTa CoorseTcrseHHo, Korna pa6oTbl HaLMM KnMeHTOM BbINH BbINONHeHbI, 3aKa3uNK- MuHICTepCTBO CTPOM- Tensctea CamapcKoit Ob acTH, nepeuMicmMin DeHEXHbIe CpenCTBa 3a BbINOMHeHHbIe cbakTHUecKM PabOTHL reH.NoApAgUUky. Tpw 2ToM, rex.noppaqunk cpaay nepesén never HaweMy noppaAUnKy. Boone Ha nepabid Barnap aCe NO- 2OMbHE, NOTOMY UTO Mlony4NNH NPHUNTAIOUAECA MM 3apabOTAHHbIe NeHeXKHbIe CpeACTea. Ho NH TOM HE GbINo yuTeHo, UTO reH, MloAPAAUNK B MOMeHT NepeuNCTeHMA REHEXKHEIK CPeACTS HAXODMNCA B NpeABaHK- ‘TPOTHOM COCTOAHMN, WB NOCReAYIOWWMM, Korma HavaNace npoUeAypa BaHKpOTCTAA ITOT NnaTEx Ha 300 MH py6new Hauanu ocnapnBaTb Kak npegnourexve no oTHoWeHHio K pyr KpeAUTOPAM. MoToMy UTO y reH. MlonpARUNKa BbiNo eWe MHOrO APYTHx KpeRMTOPOB C KeM ELE He PACCUMTANMck, B TOM UMICNe OCHOBHEIM KEAUTOPOM Ka LMNPA py6nelt c nuwHnm Bin CbepBaKk. CooTaeTcTBeHHO, CbepBank Kak OpIMH 3 KDeRMTOpOB, KOTOPEIM OBNa- QaeT GonbWMHCTBOM ronocos VNMUMMpoBan NpoWenypy OcnapuBAHNA ITOH CAENKH. PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 ApOuTpaxubid cya nepaon wHCTAHAMN OCnOpHn ITY CAeNKy H asbICKaN c Hawero NogpARUNKa 300 Mn py6neii 8 KOHKypCHyio Maccy AANA TOTO, UTOBbI 3TH AeHErH PasfenHTe & KOHKYPCHON Mace Bonee cnpa- Benue. Ha aToMt crag k Ham oBparinca KnMeHT, No CYTH, ANA Toro, 4TOBbI Mbi NoMOrnH eMy He ONNaUKBaTS eMy meHexHole cpencTea Ha MOMeHT, KOrAIa KNMeHT k Ham OBpaTunca” y Hero Goins Apyrue vcnonHAeMBIe o6azaTenscTBa nepen 6iog»KeTOM. OH y>Ke 3aHMMANCA CTPOMTENBCTEOM TpaMBaiiHbx nyTen Yuquana, CTpouTenscTBoM pasBs30K Ha MOCKOBCKOM WWOCCe, MOH NOHMMaN, TO eC v3 OBopOTa BYAYT BabICKaHLI, vabaTbi 300 mnk py6neit, oH MpOCTO He CMOXET MCTONHUTS CBOM OBAZATENBCTBA, He CMOKET HOCTPOHT o6eKT. M HaM ynanoce Ha aTane OB KaNOBAHHIA B anennaLMOHHOM, a 3aTeM MB KACCALMOHHOM NOpARKe oKa3aTb, UTO 3TH OBAZaTeNbCTBA BIN TeKYLAMMM HTeM CaMbIM OTMEHHTb PeUleHne cya, OCBOBODMTS knweHTa oT gonroe 8 paamepe 300 mnk py6nen. pw TOM, uTo pewleHMe cyfla epson MHCTAHUMM ye BbI- no QnA Wac OTPMUATeNbHbIM. B. Ewe pas nosgpaanaio c 3TmM KeriCoM. Tepemmém k sonpocam oT Haunx spree”. Pacckaxku, noxkaNyiiCTa, BOT Tbl YNOMAHY:, 4TO 3auacTyIO cbupma BaHKPOTHTCA M Kak B TAKOM Crywae MOXHO BAbICKATD C HEE MeHEXHbIe CpeACTEA. Mpokommentupyii, Noxkanyiicta, UTO AeNaTb, ECM AOMKHMK Kayan npouenypy SaHKkpoTcTBa. A: fla, BepHo, npouenypa BaHKPOTCTBa Kak MHCTPYMEHT CnonbayeTcA KaK AANA OCBOBOKAeHNA BONroS Tak WC UeNbIO aKTMUECKOrO B3BICKAHIAA HEHEXKHBIK CpeNCTB. ECM MBI rOBOPUM CevtUaC 0 TO! CTopOHE BonpOca, KOAa HaM BAKHO BSbICKATH ACH. CPeNCTAA, BAXHO KTO NePAbIA MAMUMUPyeT NPoLeAYPY BaH- kpoTcrsa. Kora Halieli 3anaveli ABNAETCA B3bICKAHMe 3af)0/KEHHOCTH HAM BAKHO NepBbIMM VHMUWApO~ BaTb npouenypy SaHkpOTCTBa MM HaBHAUMTS ynpaBNAIOLWerO. Korna ato yxke npova0wino, Takoro NpeHMyLeCTBA, K COXKANEHHIO, HeT. VI Hy>kHO paa6ypaTece a CAMO Tpouenype 6akkporcTea, 8 neiicTaMAX apbuTpaxHoro ynpaBnAIOW.erO. ApbuTpaxkkbil ynpasnmiouni nenaeT ceoio paSory. MonbIrarbcapasobpareca He ABnaeTCA nu npoWeRy- pa 6aHkpoTcTsa 3aKa3HO/. VI, ecnm ynpaBnAIOWMiA UTO-TO He AOMeNbIBAeT, be3nevicTayeT, MM He Ocnapu- BaeT KaKMe-TO CAENKM, TO BAKHO VAMUMPOBATS NUBO OB KanoBaHNe AeVCTENE UNM BesnerIcTeMe apbuT- paxoro ynpasnaiowsero ‘DIv6o, ecnu npouekt ronocos 8 peecrpe TpeBoBaHiii KpeUTOPOB No3BONAeT CaMMM MHMUMMpoBATS OC- TapuBare 3TUx CReNOK, 3HaNNT CaMHM STAM 3aHUMATECA BaxkHoe 3HaUeHMe MMeCT B TaKIMX CHTYALIMAX HACKONKO BeNMika CyMMa oNra nepen BaMM CO CTOPOHbI OMAHMKa W HaCKONKO BbI MOKETe MeWaTE NiaHaM CaMOrO AOMKHMKa NO COBCTBEHHOMy BAHKDOTCTBY, mo cyt Ecru eauia cymma gonra Wa ocHoBe peecTpa Tpe6oBaHii KpenMTOpOB HeBonbUAA, TO WaCTO BbIBaeT, uTO AOMKHNK unr Ha ONNaTy TakOrO HeGONbUIOTO AONTA No CPaBHEHMIO C OBUMM PeecTPOM ANE Toro, UTOBbI BbI NPOCTO He Mewanv 3aBepWaTb NPoUeAypy HaHKpOTCTBa. PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Eca cyMma 3a0/)KeHHOCTH Ha oBLeM dboHe KDeANTOPCKON 3aNOMKEHHOCTH B PeeCTPE OLUYTHMO Hy DOMKHIAKa HET BO3MO>KHOCTH ee 3aNNATHMT®, TOF a KOHEUHO OCHOBHOM ynlop HOMKeH BbITb cAeNaH Ha NO- TOMHEHNE KOHKYPCHOM Macchi M ONYUEHIO NPUUNTAOLUMXCA BAM B NPONOPUVIAX AeHEHBIK CDEACTS 43 3TOM KOHKYPCHOM MaCCbI MoxkHo paccmarpusars Ha npHmepe cBoel KomnaHini unl cea nMuno. B KaKMx rocopraHax MOET BbrTb 3aperucTPHPOBaHO MMyLeCTBO, 8 NepaYIO OUepesb 3TO HaNoroBaA MACTeKUMA, PACUMpOBM Banana, OcHoBHbIe cTaTbn Banakca, FBI, Pocpeectp no HeABinKHMOCTH, ToCTeXHaA30p, TeXHINKa, BOIMODKHBIE ocriapneaeMible cAenki, BaxHO CMOTpeTb 3a (bopMymMpOBKAMM B 3anpocax apBUTPAXKHOrO ynpaBNRIOUe- ro, Uro of sanpaumeaer nuBo TonbKo TeKyULyIo MAdOpMALIMlo, UTO ECT eMac, a 3a4aCTyIO OBbILHO HMUerO HeT Ha MoMeHT 3anpoca, n460 OH 3anpALUMBAeT MAcopMaLMiO 3a NPOWeAWMIA NepHon, 3a npoweAWHE 3 Toma M UMeeT BOaMOKHOCTe aHANMaMPOBATb ITH CAeNKN. Baxkhoe sHaveHne uMeIoT cpoKit ANA OCnapHBAHIMA 3THX CAeNOK. Bo-nepabix, ynpasnaiolemy BaxHO He TOMIbKO BLIABMTS 3TH CAeNKH, HO COBparb ononHUTeNbHbIe OKA 3aTenbcTea, 3anpocuTe uAbopMaLiNio y Bakka 06 onnaTe, y OMKHIKa NoTpeBoBaTb McnonHeHHe Mn OC- TapHBarina CAenku, M NOTOM TONbKO OBpauiarbca B CyA, M Ha BCE 3TO 3akOHOMATENbCTBOM npemOCTaBNA- eca 1rof.c MoMeHTa yTBEp>KAeHMA KOHKyPCHOrO ynpasnatowyero. Ha nepsbil B3rnAL, roA KadKETCR AO BONSHO ANHTeNbHEIM BpEMeHEM, HO KOT Aa Mbl HaUIMHaeM HayuaT CneuMduKy paboTss, 3anpocey, nony4e- Hue OTBeTOB, AOMONHUTeNbHbIe 3anpOCb|, TO BAKHO 3TOT CPOK He NPONYCTHTs, Have CaM Nponyck 3TOrO Cpoka w no ym aBHOCTH ANA OcnapuBaHHR ABnAeTCA OCHOBAHMeM ANA OTKaza AANA OCRapMBAHAA CRen- Kn B: Uro menarb, ecnm Heuem pacnnatHTbca no BankoBckoMy Kpe~UTy? OcoBeHHo npowly oceaTHTS Caaab lopmAMUECKOrO W usMuECKOrO NMYA. 51 BIN KEANT B BaHKe Ha lopuAMUECKOe NML4O, HO NPA 3TOM A sIBNAIOCS AMPEKTOPOM M yupeAMMTeNeM, K npUMepy, Kak CKOPO MHe, rpy6o roBop—A, npMNeTUT kak buanueckomy nuuy. UTo fenaTe B CHTyAYMAX 3anoMKeHHOCTH Nepen BaHKOM A: YacTo, ocoBeHHo B NocnegHee BpeMs, NPM NONyYeHWN KpenMTAIOPMANUECKMM AMUOM, Bce yUpenMTeNN UW pyKOBOAMTeNb NDUBNeKAIOTCA B KaYeCTBE NlopyuuTeneli K TOMY AOroBopy KpemMTa. CooTBeTCTBeHHO, 3/1eCb Hy2KHO paccmaTpuBaTe: Tlepaoe, kak MMAHMMaHpOBATS PUCKH, CARBAHHbIe C OBLECTBOM K BTOPOE, Kak OBe30NACHTd ceBA NMUHO, Tlepaoe ouém bi noroBopim ~ 06 oprakvsaunm. 3ec> BaKHOE 3HaveHNe MMeIOT APyrHe OBecneveHHA, KoTopbie Beinv no AoroBopy KpemMTa. K npuMepy, BbIN nM 3aNor MMYWNeCTEA, NBMKUMOTO, HeABIDKUMOTO A np. , CooTBeTCTBEHHO, eCnM MMyL\eCTBa HeT, a KDeRMT Goin BbIAaH log OBopOTHbIe cpencTea NHB No ocTaTkw Ha cknafe, KOTOPBIe NO CyTH HeBO3MOXHO PeaNMaOBaTe B CUT ynnaTel KPeAMTA, TO 3eC> HeOO- XOAMMO HayuaTb UCTOpHIO 3a 3 nocneAHNX ropa, BIN 1M KakMe-To Cenk 3a noWeAUIMe 3 FORA NO BbI- Boni akTHB08, PO) Pores atten Seuss GeO ELT BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 ecnu Bin, To vayuaTe KaKAyIO CReNKy: MO KaKOM ewe: pbIHOUWAA, HIDKe pbIhKa, acddunpOBAHHIM NHL, POACTBEHHNKaM, Uni Ce6e, K NpUMepy. B 3aBMCHMOCTH OT KOMMUECTBA JTHX CAENOK HY KHO MpaBMbHO CO- crasnTe {o6pbi8} CIM ECTb BO3MOKHOCT CEMUAC NOBbICUT CTOUMOCTS PbIHOUHY!0, MOBbICMTS M NPOBECTH eH. cpeACTEa 110 6aHKOBCKMM CueTaM TeM caMbiM yOpaB Cpenky OT PUcKOB OCnapMBAHHA. Tlouemy msi nena nopyunTenscrao Mt pick, noToMy To NopyunTenbcTBO B peaynbTare BaHKpoTCTBa us. ita MOXKET BbITS crMicaHo KaK OCHOBHOE {OBpbIB CBA3} cyBCMAMApHAR OTBETCTBEHHOCTS Ec WacTyna- €7, ona He cnucbiBaeTca B peaynbTare BakKpoTCTea, To ecTb 370 HekOe iCKNIOMeHMe W3 NpaBHN Tlostomy 3T0 cosepwieHHo ga pasHbix oBAsaTenscTBa, cyECHAMapHaA OTBETCTBEHHOCTS M Nopy4HTen- CTBO No KakMM-To KpeAMTaM. Mo3TOMY BAKHO M3YUMT MCTOpMO OprakwzaLin 3a NocnepHMe 3 rona, W3y- UTS npABMNbHOCTH BeseHHA BUBHECA, MBYUUTS OCTATKH, KOTOPBIE ECT B Banakice u aKTHUECKHe, NOTOM, CNM 3TH CTaTbM He COOTBETCTAYIOT AEMICTENTENbHOCTH, KaK WACTO BoIBaeT, Ha BaNaHce sanacel wCNATCA, a Dak TMUECKM Mx HET, B2KHO NPABMNHO BBIMTH M3 9TON CHTYALIMM, UTOBbI B NOCNeAYIOWWEM He HbiN0 OCHO- BaHHA LNA BAbICKAHMA YOBITKOB MM CTOMMOCTH 3THX 3aNaCOB.C TOTO MMLa, KOTOPOE MX NPOBOAMN B KOM- mani. Vi, cooTBeTCTBEHHO, ECM HIiKaKHX PHICKOB, CBABAHHEIK C NPOLUNBIM OPraHM3a\Ah HET, TO MOXkHO NoproTO~ BTCA K NPOLIEAYPe BaHKPOTCTEA, MMHMMUSHPOBATS BOIMODKHBIE PHCKM M CaMMM ee MHMLUMMpOBATe. Kak TOBOpMN paHee, BAYKHO KTO | MHMUMMpyeT, KTO Nepabii yTBEPKAaeT ynpaBneHya, M 3TO No3BoNAeT one- PegMTb kpeAVTOPOS B MHUKMUpOBAHMN Npoyenypb! baHKPOTCTBA, Celiuac MOCTATOUHO NpocT onyOmMKo- Bab CBesAeHNA NO NpeACTOAWEM BaHKPOTCTRE B EAMHOM cbeepanbHOM PeecTpe CBemeHMI O BAHKPOTCT- Be, 3T0 MATepHeT pecypc 3a 15 ave W3aTeM yxe BaHK UMeeT NpaBO NoAaBATe Ha BaHKPOTCTEO. Toatomy y Ganka ecTe & TOM npeMMyU{eCTBO, CpoK, TO ECT eMy AOCTATOUHO 15 AMEN NOC. A ana Toro, urobbi H4nYMMpoBaTe NPOUeAYPy HAKKPOTCTBA CAMOCTORTENbHO M NPABNDHO, 3a4aCTYIO Mogroroaka 3aHnMaeT Mecaya 25-3, B: Pacckarkn, noxkanyficTa, y Hac NOABMAMCe BONPOCHI B UaTe, CAAIAHHBIe OTUACTH C BaHKPOTCTBOM M BSbICKAHMeM 3aOMKEHHOCTH, ero NPUMeHEHMeM, CuTyayMA ChepyioUlas, Kak NuWeT HaM Cepreii: Haanauen 6bin apSuTparkiibii ynpasnaloUMnis, He CO CTOpOHbI KpepMTOpa, ECTS MHcopMayuA, TO B npoueaype 6axkpoTcTea KPeAMTOD NDA yCnOBMN, UTO OBUYAA CyMMa ero TpeBOBAH K NOMKHIKY coctasnser He meee 10 % oF Ob ujelt CYMMbI, OTPAXEHHBIX B PeecTpe MMeeT NpaBo OCrapHBATb caenku, TaK nH 30. A: BakHo npexkne em ocnapuBar caenky npasinbHo NoroToBMTbCA K OCnApHBaHNO, NoTOMy uTO 3TOT sonpoc paccmaTpmBaeTcA cyoM ofNH pas. U4, ecni sanBneHne 06 OcnapneaHMn BysIeT npeExneBpeMeH- bin, 663 DOMKHBIX OKABATENbCTB, TO Cy OTKAXKET B BALE TpeboBaHHH 06 ocnapwBAkinn Cenk, NOTO- My UTO BEI MANIA C NoMOWIbIO APB. ynpaBNAIOUerO He CMOrNM AOKa3aTe, TO 3Ta CHEnKa NoANeKUT ocnapH- BaHnio. B nocnenyiouseM k 3TOMy BoNpOCy Henb3A ByAeT BeEpHyTeCA. [o3sTOMy, ECT CPOKM saBHOCTH (rO- ‘AMUHbi) NosBonseT cobpare fon, AOKa3aTeNbcTEa, TO Nyuue CHavana BCE COBpATe, TLaTeNbHO NoprO- TOBUTBCA M NOTOM YKe CTABMTb BONPOC No STON CHenke nepen cygom. PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 B:MuTepechbii Bonpoc noctynun o BabickaHnn 3anomKeHHOCTH Cc FMBLLL W wbx rocTpyKTyp, TO ecTb He cBoGOxKAeHMe OT NONroB Nepen HaNoroBOH, K NPHMepy, a BIbICKaHNe JonroB c [MBL B Ta0eH npakTHkn Gtinu cny4an, KorAa C rocysAAPCTBA YAABANOCh BIbICKATE Ia|OMKEHHOCTH? }0-TlepBbIX, XOTeN Go| OBPATHTS BHUMAHMe, TO BIBICKMBATE C eRePANbHbIK FOC. CTPYKTYP HECNOKHO. K npwmepy, ana eabickanna cTVIBLL poctarouko cobpatb HeobxopMMBIA NakeT NOKyMeHTOB, NpeAyCMOT- PeHHbIM H1OD>KETHBIM KOKCOM MM CA|aTb Ka3HAUeNICTBY. ¥ HUX @CTb CPOK, MaKCUMaNIbHbIli Cpok CocTaBnAeT 3 mecaua Ans ucnonHeHns TpeboBakiA STOrO ObABATeNBCTEA, STOTO MCNONHUTeNbHOTO NMICTa PeWeHMEM cya. OBsiuHo c 3THM NpoGNeM HuKOrAa He GbIBaeT. Dpyre svpbi roc. cTpykTyp, aAMMHVCTPAUIMM pavioHos, ropogos u obnacTeM, 3neCcb CuTyAayIMA HeMHOTO CAOXKHee, NOTOMY “TO, NO cyTH, ITO APyrOH ypoBeHe Sogxera, Ecnu[MBL orseuaer cbenepanbHbih 610\KeT, TAM MODKHO B3ICKATb CTOKOMTHO, TO BSbICKAHMe C MyHHUMNaNbHOrO BiogKeTA TO TaM cHTyALMA nove, M nocne nonyueHiA naKeTa NOKYMeHTOB, OHM CAAIOTCA No CYTH, ECM AOMKHUKOM ABNAETCA ADMMAUCTPALMA B CaMy ADMMKUCTPAUNIO, TONbKO BIbMK. OTAEN M 3TOT uHOTAeN C MOMeHTa NonyueHHA cyme6Hbix oBn3ak CoBeplaTe pA MeponpHATHi Cornacko blomKETHOMY KOAeKCy, KOTOpbIE NOSBONAIOT Taw Ke B TeUeHMe 3x MeCAL.es ODECTIeUMTD BIbICKAHNE AEHer WM HNOKMPOBATE AeATENLHOCTE MO CyTH agMnnncTpaunn. JIM60 ova paccunTblBaeTCR No CBOMM OBAZaTEMBCTBAM, NBO HEBOSMOXxHa AeATENS- HOCTb B TOM Hucne BbinNnaT 3apa6oTHO! NnaTel pabOTHHKAM aNMMANCTPAUMM. BAKHO UMETb BO3MOXHOCTS KOHTPONMpOBATE, 3a4ACTYIO AQMMHMCTPALIMA He COBEPWWAeT BCeX MeVICTANM, KOTOPbIE NPeAYCMOTPEHbI 6i0AYKETHEIM KOMEKCOM M 3TO RBNAETCR OCHOBAKMEM NO VCTeUeHAM MaKCHMaNbHOTO cpoKa, 3 MeCALA, ANA o6paujeHne 8 apbuTpaxHbil cya 3a NPHBNeveHHe K OTBETCTBEHHOCTH 3a HEMICONHEHHe M0 PeLIEHHIO Cy- na, Tawoke, Cin pag DeliCTBMiA He COBEPLEHbI KOHKPETHBIMM NMLIAMU 3TO ABNACTCA OCHOBAHMeM sa NpoBe- evs AOCNeACTBeHHOR npoBepKi no cr. 315 yronoBHoro KOfeKca, 3TO HeviConHeHna cya. B: Alva cnpawmeaeT, MOKHO NM NepepaT> MMyU4eCTAO B CUT MMeIOWWerOcA ONTa. ECAM fa, TO KaKOBbI ycnoaus npoueaypht A: KoHeuHo, ecnm y oprakHzaymn OT KOTOPOR NepenAeTCA MMYLECTBO HET HixKAKUX OBAZaTeNbCTE Nepen, Apyrumm KPepMTOPAMN, TO NepemaT> MO>KHO NO TOM YeHe, NO OTCTYNHOMy, No KOTOPOH OH CornacoBaH MexAy CTOpoHaMM, CCIM BO3MONKHO OT OBOPUTECA. ECNM BOSMOXKHOCTH LOTOBOPIITBCA HET, TO 3aKOHOfA- TeNbCTBOM NPeAYCMOTPeHA OTAeNbHaANpOLeAYpa OGpalijeHMA B3bICKAHUA Ha 3TO MMyLeCTBO. K npume- py, ecru Mbi He Bepém npoueaypy GaHkporcTea, a BepéM TONbKo peuleHHe cya M NpMHyAWTENDHO ero VicnonHeHne co CTOpoHb! CyAebHOrO NPHCTaBa, To CyMeHbIM NUCTaB OeHMBAeT MMyULeCTEO, npuBNeKa- TCA CneUMANHICT ANA OLEHKN, yrBePIKNAeTCA CTOMMOCTE. ECAH He COrNACHbI C STOMA CTOMMOCTEIO, e6 Mo2kHO OCTOpuTb B CyAe. OKOHUaTeNbHaA CTOMMOCTe yTREPXKAACTCA W 3aTeM nepeAaeTCA Ha PeannsaLiNo Uepes cyeGHbix NpNCTABOR, ECT HEAEMKUMOE MM 3ANOKEHHOE MMYLUCCTBO, TO OHO NPOAAeTCA uepe3 OTKpBITBII KaHan. ECniA 3TO APYTHe BAI MMyULeCTBA, TO OHM NPOMBIOTCA Uepes CneUMANKsMPOBAHHEIe opraHvaaiii Ha pbllike. COoTBeTCTBeHHO, nponaéTca cHauana No NepsoHavanbHOH LieHe, KOTOPAA yT~ Bep>kmeHa CyAeGHbIM NPNCTABOM HuNH CyAOM, 3aTeM ECT NepBAA NONAKa He COCTOANACE, UeHa YMCHS- ujaerca Ha 15%, m ocyuyecTenaerca 2aq nonbiTkKa NPOLANKH, M ECM HMYLeCTBO He NPOAIaHO, TO NpeANA~ TAeTCA B3bICKATENIO CO CTOPOHEI CyAeHOrO NpCTaBa 3a6PaT 3TO UMYLECTBO NO YeHE Ha 25% HYDKE MepaoHavanbHo yCTaHOBNeHHOM CTOMMOCTHL Y BabICKATENA ECTb NPABO ~ COTNACTECR UNM OTKABATECA, PO) Pim atten Seuss GeO ELT BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Ecn sabickaTenb OTKasbIB2eTCA, TO UMyU\eCTBO BOBpALaeTcA AOMKHMKY. Vi pabora nner c ApyruM MiMyLeCTBOM, eciM OHO ecTb. A eC APyroro MMyLKeCTBa HET, TO cyAeBHbI” NpUCTaB BOsBpALLaeT NOKy- MeHTDI B3bICKATEMIO B CBAIM C HEBO3MO>KHOCTHIOBSbICKAHIA Ecam 970 npowenypa 6aHKpoTCTEa, K npMMepy, ECM B3bICKATeNb He COrNACMACA Mn He CTAN AAT NOK TpycTas oTpaBoTaeT MMYU{eCTBO, TO B BaHKPOTCTRE OUeHS NOXOXKAA NPOWeAYPA, YTBEPXRAeTCA NONOKe- Hive 0 TOprax, O NPODAKe, YTREPKAAeTCA CTOMMOCTE M NO MMHMMaNbHON WeHe He Mposako, To npegnara- eTCA KDeAUTOPY B3bICKATE, B: Kak pa6oraTb c npucTapaMi B paMKax HcnonHMTeNbHOrO NPONsBOACTBA, UTOBbI B3bICKMBATH C AOMKHNKOB 3aOMKEHHOCTH A: Dlanibili Bonpoc ove pacnpocTpaHEHHbI, KOPOLUMA, H CBABAH C TEM, UTO y CyeBHbIK NpUCTABOB oueH» Bonbuan Warpyaka, OHa HECOMSMEpIMa C Mx PeanbHbIMN BOsMOXHOCTAMH M NOITOMY cyAebHbIe TpMCTaBLI vaCTO AONYCKaIOT ynylueHMNA. Eco BbI NPOCTO cAaéTe MCNOMHMTENbHBIA MCT HW KOETE KaKOTO- To pesynibrara, TO BEDOATHOCTb B3bICKAHIMR HiaKa, BCE 3aBUCHIT OT cyBbeKTa, Harpy3Ki CysAeGHOFO Npu- aba, OF permoHos, Kora Takne Kpynibie ropona Kak MOcKBa, OUeHb CNOAKHO KAT OT CysAeBHbKX NpU- cTaB08 KaKOro-To pesynbTata, Nake NyTeM COseMCTENA MbI NaneKo He BCerfa Nonyuaem pesynbTar. CI Mb ToBOpUM o BIQMOAeNICTAMM C CymeBHOIM NPMCTABOM {ANA TOFO, UTOBbI NoBBICUTb ac>cbeKTVB- HOCTb, BAKHO NOHMMATe Mx CeLMduKy PaBOTDy, 3HaTb e, okazbIBATe ComeNiCTeMe cyAeOHOMy NPUCTABY, TloMoraTe B paccbinke 3anpocos re HET 3MekTPOHHOTO AOKYMeHTOOBOpOTA, KOHTPONNpOBATe NonyueHNe OTBETOB, HanOxeHHe CBOEBEMeHHOTO apecTa Ha UMYLLECTBO, Ha NEHEKHbIe cpesCTBA. Y KaxKDOTO B3bI- ckaTens ect mcbopmayinn 06 MMyLLeCTBe ROMKHHKA, K PUMEDY, OTUET O CUETAX, HO 3aaCTYIO, BBBICKA- Tenb, Kora NpeAbABNACT AOKYMEHT CyAeSHOMy NDMCTaBy NpeAOCTABHTS PeKBNSMTHI, UTOBbI CyNeOHbI pMcTaB OnepaTHBHO HanOKNN apecT Ha 3TH CueTa, A cyAAeBHbIM NPCTABAM UTOBbI yaHATS 0 TMX CUETaX HyPkHO CAlenaTb 3anpOC B KanoroByiO MICTeKUMIO H MloNyuNTb OTBET, Ha 3TO TPeByeTCA BpeMA, 3a CUET CO- BelicTana addextusHocTs ynyuwaerca. Hor ga npwxoguTcA o6>KanowaT’ AelicTEne, GeamelcTane cy- jeBHOrO NpAcTaBa, HO B mioBOM cnyuae addeKTHBHOCT NoBbIWAeTCA, ECni BbI NpOCTO NepenaéTe M knee pesynbrar, cbexTHBHOCTe Kpaline HiaKaR. [Ini0C, fA B3bICKAHHA Mil MCTIONb|yeM He TONbKO AaHHbI/i MHCTPyMeHT, NOTOMY UTO ECT APYrNe BO3MOXKHOCTH. K NpMMepy, NapasINenbHO MHULAMMpOBaTh mpoueaypy GaHkpOTCTAA, 3TO NOIBONAET COKPATHTD CPOKN NOnyYeHHA AeHer MM NOBBICHTD adeKTVE- HocTe. MoaTomy BakHO MCToNbs0BATb BCE MexXaHHaMbs, KOTOPbIe NPEAYCMOTPeHb| 3aKOHOMATENbCTBOM. B: Nposcuu, noxkanyiicTa, Tako MOMeHT. BonbUIMHCTAO HaLWMx KnMeHTOB OBNaqaeT pecypcom UTaTHbIX OPMCTOR. [Ae NPOXOAMT Ta rpakb MexAY KOMNeTeHUWeM IOPHCTA B LITATE W KOFAa HY>KHO obpauatocs k cneunanncTam no pabore c 3aoMKeHHOCTHIO. KakoBa pone IOpHCTa B uITaTe? Fl aC To NpOBOxy aHANOrMio, UTO IOPHCT B W!TaTe ~ 3TO HeKMi TepaneBT, KOTOPbIA He3yCOBHO HYKEH A Noneze, Ho, K npuMepy, 3a Onlepauen No yAaNeHMO anneHAMUMTa K TepaneBTy He XO;AT, TAK 1M aT0? [Ae NPOXOAWT rpaHMya MexAY KOMMETeHUMeM WTATHOFO OPHCTa W KOrAa HY:KHO NpHGeraTs cBoespeMeHHo K NOMOWIM cneyManucTano paboTe c 3af1O/KEHHOCTHO. A: 3ecb BaxHoe 3HaveHMe MMeeT KBaNMEUKALIAA lOpcTa. AI ceMuAC He TOBOPIO O TOM, KTO Nyse, WTaT~ Hoi OPMICT MM JOpMCT ayTCOPCMHTa, 31eCb BAYKHO YMeeT NM OH paboTaTb B AAHHOM CneyMdukw. Bend fopucnpypeHUA ~ To OSUIMpHAR OBNACTo, IOPMCT B LUTATe MOXeT BbITb KOMMETEHTeH B CNeUMEpnKe Ba- lei AeATENSHOCTH, ECNH B3bICKAHNA AONTOR B er0 OnbiTe He BEINO, TO 3eCe MOET BbITE HEIieKTHE- Han pabora. K npumepy, oH XOPOWWMiA CNeUMANNICT B MOTOBOPHOM NpaBe, COCTABNAET MOrOBOpbI, MOET Hx PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 KOHTponMpOBATe, MOKET NPOBECTH Cy Abs, HO Kak CTONHATS NPMHYAMTeNbHOe peweHne cya He 3HaeT, KDoMe npemABNeHiMA AOKYMeHTOB CyRebHOMY NPNCTaBY M3neC> BaxHa KOMAHAHAA paboTA. ¥ HAC, K TpMMepy, ECTS CNeUMANNCTbIB PasHbX CeyNANKZaL|MAK, KTO-TO 3aHMMAETCA AOTOBOPHLIM MpaBOM, KTO-TO xopoIwo Beer CyAb|, KTO-To YOPOLWO 3aHUMaeTCA pabOTON C CyAeBHLIMM NPHCTaBAMH, a e KTO-TO 3aHt- MaeTCA npoueAyPOn GaHKpOTCTBa. 30eCb BAKHA KOMAHAHAA paboTa, Mory npneectu npumep, ana 3¢cbexTHBHOro BabICKAHMA CNOKHOTO AONTa HeOBXOAUMO MHMUMMpOBATS Npouenypy GaxkpoTcrea, a ANA Toro, uTOGb e& MHMLUMNPOBAT B KOMAHAe AOMKEH ObITe apouTPAXKHbIA ynpaBnsiounii, co BCeMU paspeLeHMAMn, yMeIOLi paboTaTb Co CBOE KOMaHAON UM NPoUee. VI, BAXKHO, UTO BbI eMy MoxeTe AOBEpATS, Benb, auactylo, paBora KoMaHbi no BabICKaHNIo AONTa 3TO PeaynbTaT KOTOpHIM BbI NonyuaeTe. Boi Nomy- uaeTe CyMMy fonra, NOTOM UaCTb M3 3TON CyMMBI AONTa, NDOWIEHT, NepeUNCcAAeTe HaM B KAUECTBE BOSHA- TpaxkfeHMA, a Mbl yKe COOTBETCTBEHHO, Henum Mexkay CBOeh KOMaHAON. MW 3feC BaKEH yPOBEHb NoBe- it, KOrfa Bce paboTAIOT Ha PeaynbTAT, HOMKANK KOTOPOTO Bb! HAHKPOTUTE C YeNbIO BabICKAHNE, 3a4aC- Tyo npeanaraer ynpasnaioujemy Gone BbIroAHble YCNOBMA, M ECM BbI He AOBepAETe aDOUTPAXHOMY ynpasnsouemy, paboraeTe c HMM Bnepable Hn He 3HaeTe CneUMEnky ero paBOTbI M He MOXKETE 3a HAM MPOKOHTPONMPOBATS KOHKPETHBIE AEVICTEMA, NOHATH re OH BAC MOET NOgBeCTH, TO Npouenypa { O6pbIB cana} Pesiomnpys oTeeT Ha BONpOC BaXHO B KOMAHTE CeUMANMCTOB METS TeX CeyMANUcTOB KTO 3HaeT M yMeer pa6oraTs 8 kaxKNOM NpoUeAype B3bICKAHMA: Cyl, paboTa c cyAeBHbIMM NpUCTaBaMM, NpOWeAYPA GanKpoTcTBa W BaXHO AOBEDATS yuACTHMKaM KOMaH ABI. ECM y WTATHOTO IOPUCTa HeT AOCTATOUHO pe- CYPCOB Ml 3HaHMi, TO CTOMT pacCMOTPeTb, Kak MMHUMYM KOHCYMbTALIMIO CO CneuMancTOM Ha ayTCopce, a TOTOM npMHHMaTb BIBEWIEHHOE PeLIEHHe, BEd CaMa KOHCYNbTAWMA HKAK He OrpaHHUMBAeT M He OBRbI- BaeT 3akniouNT AoroBop. FlonyunTe HAcopMaLiNio, KOTOPAA NOSBONUT BaM CReNaTS NpaBMNbHBIM BbISOP Ans nonyueHna npMUMTaIOUWIKCA DeHer. B: Mp1 HeMHOro OTOLIAM OT TeMbI B CTOPOHY B3bICKAHIIA 3a90/KeHHOCTH. HanoMHio, UTO OCHOBHON TeMolt se6uHapa AaneTcA Kak OCBOBORMTECA OT AonroBOro BpemeHM. MOcTYNHN BONPOC, MOXKHO NM BbIBECTA vg Nog 3anora Balika HeNBKUMOCTS, UTOBbI MBI MOF NPOAATe PbIHKy NO MaKCUMaNbHOM YeHe, NO- Tomy To ecnin Bank 3a6upaer anor u peanuayer ero, To ByeT Peanwa0BbIBATb ero No MMHMMANS- Holt ueHe. §1TaK NOHHMAIO, MOOKHO NM ero BbIBECTH ¥3-nog 3anora UTOGeI OTAATe, NposaTb? A: 3nece, 8o-nepabix, O6paujeHie K B3bICKAHMIO Ha 3aNOrKEHHOe MMyLYeCTBO NpAKTHUECKM BCerga OCyLLe- cTanseTca 8 cyAeGHOM nopanKe. V, ech CTOpoHbl He OCapMBAIOT CTOMMOCTe 3aNloroBOrO UMyWeCTEA, KoTOpoe ycTaHOBNeHo, NpeAyCMOTPeHO NOTOBOPOM JaNor—a, TO Cy yCTaHaBNNBaeT ee B KaueCTBe NepEO- HavanbHol eH! Ha Toprax. ECT eCTe Cop NO NOBOAY CTOMMOCTM 3TOrO MMYWIeCTBA, TO Cyn HasHaUaeT akCepT¥ay # KCNepT yCTaHaBNueaeT nepaoHavanbHylo CTOMMOCTb 3TOTO 3anOrOBOTO MMyLYeCTBA, HO MMHYC JMCKOHT, KOTODbIM NPeyCMOTPeH 3aKOHOM O 3anore. Vi,coorBercTBeHHo, ecTs B03MOxHOCTS, UTO Ha Toprax 37a CTOMMOCTb ByAleT NoBBILIaTECA, NOTOMY UTO Topri- KTO NpemNorkuT BonbWe TOT MW roKynaeT. flea BapHaHTa OBPAULeHIMA BIbICKAHMIA Ha 3TO 3aNlODKEH- Hoe umyulecTso. Mepace, uepes cysAe6HOro MpHcTaBa, Mb Ke TOBOPMNM O TOM, TO KasHaUaeTCA NepabIE PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Toprn, BTopbIe TOPTH, 3a BBIUeTOM 15%, ecru nepable He COCTOANHC®, 3aTeM NpeAMATAeTCA 3anoropepxa- Temio 3TOrO myujecTaa 3a CueT NoraeHnAa AoNra Ha 25% HiNKe OT CTOMMOCTH NepaoHavaNbHoH, nV60 370 uepes npouienypy SaHKporcTaa 3necb BaxHa TROPUECKAA COCTABNAIOUIAA, KaK MOXKHO CaMMM BbIKYNMT 3TO 3anoroBoe MMyLecTBO. Kak Cpenate Tak uTOBbI 30 3aNOxKEHHOE HMYLYCCTBO HbINO MHTePECHO TONbKO BAM, a He BCeMy pbimKy. Ecrt Mb| FOBOPHIM 0 ABMKUIMOM HMyLLECTBe, KOHEMHO, ero COCTOAHME B MOMEHT NPOA|KM MOXKET BbITb pazHbiM WHeOBasaTeNbHo UTO OHO ByAeT MHTepECHO BCeMy pbIKiKy. OHO MOMET BbiTb MHTepECHO KOHKDETHOMY KPYTY AML UNM KOHKpeTHOMy UenoBeKy. OH NOKyNaeT 3TO MMYLUeCTBO M NPMBOAMT BopapoK. Ecnu 370 HeABIDKHMOE HMyLECTEO, KOHEUHO TAM CMOOKHEe, HO NPM 3TOM BCE 3aBUCHT OT CEUMDHKH H OUCH BaK- Hoe 3HaueHe MMeeT NonoxeHHe o Toprax. Korga paapabarbisaeTCA nak pabOTEIC THM 3anoroBbIM iMyeCTBOM M Kak MAKMMNZHPOBATS PUCKH ero NoTepy, a HadHopOT paboTaTe Han ero OCTABNEHMEM y cea. BnonokeHAi o Toprax BaxHOe 3HaveHHe UMeET YCNOBHe ero NPOAAKN, CTOMMOCTS, 3NeKTPOHHbIe TOprM umeWoT CBOM CneUMc>uK. CooTBETCTBeHHO, 370 8 BONBLIMHCTBE Cnysaes No3BoNAeT c yMepeHHbIMM 3aTpaTaMM OCTABMTb KNMEHTY 3a COON 3TO MMYLL\ECTBO, B KOTOPOM OH 3aMHTepecoBaH. Hanetoce, a cymen packpbiTb cneumduky sToro Bonpoca. lepexonum k cheayiouemy Bonpocy. PACcKaXKH 0 MeXaHMaMe W PHCKAX NpoAAXKM AoNroB. Al xouy He BSbICKMBATE 3AOMKEHHOCTS, a XOUY NPOAATS. MHOTMe KNMEHTEI CTANKMBAIOTCA C TEM, UTO MM NPeA- Alaraior BbIKyN AONTa, B TOM UMCHe M Mbl 3aHMMaeMCA NOAOBHON AeATeNbHOCTHWO. Co croponibi knueHTa Kak npasinbHo ConpOBORMTb aTy CAeNKy, Kak NPOCKOAHT cam MexaHiIaM NpORAaKM ceoero nonra. A: BakHoe aHauieHe ana npepnpunumarenen umeeT cpokM nonyueHHA seHer, Ha KOTOpbIe ORM paccun- TeiBaoT. Mo cyTis, Cr Mbi TOBOPUM O6 OBUeM MopARKe BIbICKAHMA eHer, CKOMEKO BPEMEHH 3TO MOET 3aHMMaTb, CHauana Hy>KHO COBMOCTH NpeTeH3MOHHBIM NOPALLOK, Hy2KHO CMOTPETb YCNOBMA BaLero fOrO- sopa. Cypbi AnATCA OT 3.0 6 MecALes, 8 3aBMCHMOCTH OT NOaMAMM AOMKHNKa, OTBETUMKa NO Aeny, ByAeT 1M OH BOSpAKATS, BaTATMBATS NPOLECC, o®kanoBaTb peweHne cysla Ao NepBol MHCTaHUMu Vi NpoUee. 3aTeM NPUHY_UTeNbHOe McnonHeHMe pe- leHUa cya, M 3neCb BCé 3aBNCIT OT CnoxKHOCTH. KOHEUHO, KOFa KOMMAHA KPyNHAA, AOCTATOUHO Byer MeCAL-NONTOPA ANA TOrO, “TOG CNUICaTS NEHeXKHbIe CDeACTEA NPMHYAUTENHO Yepe3 BaHK C PACuETHO- ro cuéra, Ho Kora cuTyauA Bonee CoxkHaA, BIbICKaHMMe MOKET 3AHMMaTS LOMONHUTeNbHO Nocne BCTYN- TeHINA peUIeHUA B IaKOHHYIO Cuny eUe OT 4 MecALIeR H BONee. COOTEETCTAEHHO, NPEAMETHO MBI NONyUa- em oKono 10 MecaljeB apeMeHu Ha CaMOCTORTeNbHOe BSbICKAHNe eHeF HN C NpMBNeUeHHEM OpuCTA, KO- ‘Topbiii OKaSbIBAeT NOMOLLD. Tenepe mbi cpaskneaem faHible nepcnexTvBbl C BO3MOKHOCTHIO NpomATe ONT, EcnM Mb FOBOPMM O NPO- axe fonra, Tora OBbIUMO AeHETM, HO C AVCKOHTOM, ONMaUNBA‘OTCA B TeueHHe 5-10 pabounx AHH CO MoMeHTa 3akmOUeHMMA LOroBOpa YCTYNKH Npaga, YeccHn, KOHeUHO, eCAM YCTPaNBaTe AVCKOHT, 3eCe BAX- Ho npasinibHo PO) Pim atten Seuss GeO ELT BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 NofiTw no ycnoBnaM MoroBopa YCTYNKH Nasa, YECCHM, M MbI NPHBIKNM, Kora BbIKynaeM AONTH, UTOBbI KAMeHTb! ObiNM COKOFHb|, UTO NPaBa NepeBONST ToNbKo MOCe Toro, KaK Mbl ONNATHNH NpeAYCMOTPEH- yl Rorosopom cymMy,. Moi 3akniouaen 0roBop, Nony4aeM BCe AOKYMeHTHI OT KNMEHTA, ONNauNBaeM KNMeHTY MeHbrH n3aTeM HaUMHaeM 3aHMMATECA B3DICKAHMIEM B CAOIO Nonbsy. BAXHO NOAXODMTE MaKCMMaMbHO NPOAYMaHHO, B: Cnacu6o 3a oTaer. NHTepechbii Bonpoc noctynmn. B cbepe paborb! B2B, Kak He MCnOpTHMTb OTHO- UIeHHs C KNMeHTAMM, ECM BOSHKKNA AEGUTOPCKAA 3aNOMKEHHOCTS. 34eCb OT CebA NPOKOMMEHTU- pylo MoMeHT Ans Halunx cnywaTenel. He Tak AaBHO ObuaNca C NpepCTABHTeNAMNM C OAHON HI kpynvemuunx opraHwaauni B POccMn, OHa BXOAMT B TON 3M y HHX OfHAM 13 3aKa3UNKOR sIBNAeTCA komnania NIVEA, onHAM m3 Kmouesbix napTHépos, BosHiKna AeOMTOPCKaA 3a MOMKEHHOCTE Ha UTO 3TO areHTCTAO, He TepAA HM CeKyHAbI, Cepaa COCTaBMNO NpeTeHaMM, a NOTOM NofaNO B CyA, BIND 3aKMOUEHO MMpOBOE COrNAleHHe M UTO BAKHO, JeNOBbIe OTHOWIEHMA MCNOpUeHDI He GbINM, Jpyroii npumep, y onvoro u3 MoMx Apy3ei OAHHM 13 KMeHTOB ABsETCA BaHK «PyccKMl CraHpapT> WTOUHO Tak xke, 3a YaCTb NOCTaBOK He BINH NloNyueHb MeHExHbIe CpenCTBA M POBHO TawKe Boia vunyMMposana npoueAypa pas6upaTenbcTea, Takxke GbINM HanMcaHbl NpeTeH3MM W NopaHbi 3asBNe- Hua B cy, Bbino ROCTUTHyTO MMPOBOE COrnaLIeHNe W ACHETM Beinn BOSBPALeHbI NPM TOM ONATS xe ‘Tak, AeNOBbIe OTHOLICHMA OCTANMCb Ha XOPOLIeM yPOBHE H OHM NPOAOMKAIOT PasBMBATHCA HNO cen pene, Anekcei, npokoMMeHTupyi Ty CHTYayMIo, NOTOMY UTO AeMICTAMTENbHO MHOrMe KNMEHTBI KAYT 0 NocnesHero, a NOTOM y>Ke M B3bICKMBATD HEC KOTO M Heuer. HACKOMbKO eNoBAR 9THKa, Ha TBOK B3rnAg, NosBoNAeT TpeboBaTe CBOs. [edcTAMTeNbHO, MbI NPenOcTaaMnu ycnyrn Mbo NocTaBMnA MaTepwant, HaM LOMKHE! AeHBrH, HO LeHbrH Mp 3TOM He NNaTAT, Kak He BOATECA MCNOPTHT OTHO- UIeHMS HW Kak 3TO MaKCHManbHO NOsbHO CHeNaTe, A: Me noHaTeH sonpoc. 3fecb k TeM npuMepaM o KOTOPEIX roBOpUM xoTeN Bt! AOGaBHTe CBOM NUMepEs, KoTOpbie ceiiuac BknioUaIO. KnenTb! HecaoeapemenHo onnaunBaioT CyMMbI BOSHArpaXxsAeHN, AeHEI 3a BIbICKAHKA NOAyUMTM, HAM NpHUNTaeTCA %, HO OHM 3aTAMBADT C ONNATOM, M 3AeCb BadKHbI AOFOBOPEHHOCTH. ECAM CTOPOHB! AOrOBO- pa Mpyanu kakue pelicTeus 6yayT pu Heynnare, 4 OHM HOpManbHo Ha HavanbHoM 3Tane 3TO cormaco- BbIBAIOT, TO H¥Kakux npoBNeM C HanpasneHvem NpeTeHsMiA Make MCKOBOrO 3aRBNeHINA A HE BYKy. ¥ HAC OTHOUICHMA C TaKHMM KTIMeHTaMM COXpaHAIOTCA, Ml XOPOLUO HeNaeM CBOIO PaBOTY, M OHM HE XOTAT MCKATS Koro-To Apyroro. {oBpbie censu} KoHeuno, 3neCb HET HiNKaKMx rapaHTHi, NOTOMY UTO NOAH M NPeANPUHAMATeNM BbIBAIDT PasHle MW NO3TO- My 3f1eCb Hy KeH KaKoM-To BanaHc. Ect oTHoU.eHita BaM NOPOTH, MOPanbHO NoATOTOBUTe YenoBeKa, HANOMHHT, UTO HauNHaeTCA NOCpOY- @, ByRly BbIHYkAAeH HaNpaBMTb NpeTeHSHO, MHe KY)KHbI AeKEr, ByAY BbIKYKAeH NponaTe AON MnK pH BN IOPUCTOB ANA B3bICKaHMMA MHaUe Moi BU3HEC NOCTPAgaeT, M KOF Ma BbI NOITANHO OUeHb ONepATHBHO PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT Cea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 TOTOBHTE BaKHOTO KNMEHTA NO BO3MOKHOMY B3bICKAHMIO NPMUMH ANF Toro, UTOBbI HapyWiMT B3aMMozeri- CTBVe MN OTHOLEHHA & He BIDKy. ¥ HAC NO KpaliHeli Mepe KpaliHe PeNKO KNIMHTbI M3-3a NPeTeH3Mi Np Npocpoukax nepecaioT GbiTb HaLUMMM KnueHTaMn, B: Boaapauasich k TeMe B3bICKaHA 3a|OMKEHHOCTH, A TAK NOHMMAIO OHA HaXOAMT MaKCHManbHBI OTKAK 8 CepqUaX HaLIMx ChywaTeneH. OSbenMHiO Wea BoNpOCA B OAMH. MTAK, y bUpMbI AOMKHMKA OTCYTCTAYIOT eHeXkHbIe CPeACTBA Ha CUETAX, HO NPM 3TOM PyKOBOATeNb ABNACTCA TaKOKE PykOBO- AuTenem Apyron dupMbs, y KOTOPO AeHExHBIe Cpe”CTBA ECTS. BOIMOKHO MM BIbICKAHMEB ITO cayuae. VW eropon oven noxoxknit Bonpoc, TO KaK BIbICKATb IaOMKEHHOCTH C KOMNAHMM, ECM OHA Npe- kpaTuna CBO AeATeNbHOCTb M He MMeeT MMyLYeCTBA M AKTHELI, [o CTH, NepeKNMKaIOWMeCA TMB A:SloTeeuy no-pasHoMy Ha 37H aga sonpoca. Ha nepsbiii 3T0 Kora y OpraHWiza\yV, 8 Tak NOHMMAIO, HeT HMMKAKMX AKTHBOB, HO CTb AMPEKTOP, KOTOPBIM PabOTAeT 8 APYTON KOMNAHMM My KOTOPOTO eCTb aKTUBbL Hanpsimyto B3bICKaHie C APyroli KOMNAHM HEBO3MO>KHO. HY>KHO MOHMMaTb SBNACTCA JIM OH yUpenMTenem KOMNaHMM, 8 KOTOPON ABNAETCA AMpEKTOPOM. VI 3feCb, ECM OH NPOCTO AMPEKTOP, TO Hy>KHO YepeE3 KOM- NaHiNio Ges akTBOB CHaUaNa BbIITH Ha CyBCHAVapHyI0 OTBETCTBEHHOCTS KOHKPETHOTO AMpeKTopa. A 3TO 3aUACTYIO TOKE He TaK NPOCTO, KaK KaKETCA, TO ECT Mbl AOMKHI OKA3ATS, UTO OH HenpaBinbHo BEN esTenbHOCTb NpepbIAYLUeN KOMNaHMM, UTO NpuBeNo ero K BAHKPOTCTBY MN HEBO3MO>KHOCTH McnonHe- Hua oBazaTenbcTe HeynnaTel Aonra M NPMBNeUb ero K CyHCUAMApHOM OTBETCTBEHHOCTH, 3aTem, KorAa OH NMUHO ByAeT ROMKEH BAM, HaYUUTS BO3MOMHOCTH BIbICKAHNA AONTaC Hero NMUHO. ECA OH ABNRETCA COBCTACHHMKOM KOMNAHI M AMPEKTOPOM, TO B ITOM CNyUae MOXHO BbIAENATE MMYLYECTEO B KOMMAHMN C aKTHBaMI Ha AONM M ObpalliaTs Ha Hero B3bICKAHMA, TO ECTb 3TO OTAENbHEIe CysAeGHbIe NPO- LeCCbI, KOTOPbIE NO3BONAIOT KOHKPETHOE MMyLUECTBO 6paTb M NPOMABATb C BbINTATON MEHEKHBIX CPEACTE. Ecaw ke oH nPOCTO RaNAETCA AMpeKTOPOM, TO EAMHCTBEHHOe UTO MOKHO BymeT CenaTe BpesynbTaTe |SbICKAHNA MMUHO C 3TOTO AUpeKTOpa 3TO OBpATHTe BBbICKAHMe Ha 50% ero AOxoAa. MosToMy 3nece Hy kHO pas6upaTaca B HioaHcax Takxke Hy kHo 6yfleT W3yUaTe, ECM MbI FOBOPUM 0 BO3MOKHOM NPMHYAWTENBHOM B3bICKaHMIM, © BOIMOK- HOM 6aHkpOTcTBe, CBAIKM MexKpY 3THMM KOMNAHVAMM, ech BbINK Cpenkn Mexpy 3THMK KOMNAHVAMN, TO MODKHO B3bICKMBATb He C KOHKPeTHOFO YenoBeKa. Kora PyKOBOAMTeNb ONMH M TOT Ke, KakMe-TO CAeNKM 6biBa10T MeKAY 3THMM KOMNaHMAMM, ECT OfHa KOMMAHiAA, KOTOPAA AOMKHA AMUHO BaM, AKTMBOB HET, TO MO2KHO B3bICKMBATb C APyrOM KOMNAHMM B PaMkax NPOLeAypbI HaHKPOTCTBA M OCNAPMBATb 3TH CAENKM. Bropoit onpoc, kak B3bICKaTE C KOMNAHHN, y KOTOPOH HHUerO HET. ECAH KOPOTKO, HUKaK, BaxkHoe aHaLe- Hive MMeeT CBOCBPEMEHHOCTb NPMHATMA NPUHyANTeENbHOrO BSbICKAHMA. ECM cefuac y KOMNaHMM HMUerO HeT, MoxkHO NOCMOTpeTs, a UTO GeiNo 3a NOCNeAHHe 3 roa, ECTM BPeMA He yNYLNeHO, TO MOXKHO HAMLIN PoBaTb Npoyenypy 6aHKPOTCTBA Hi NonbITATbCA OCNOpUTb CAeNku 3a NPoWeAWMe TPM roga, NpuBNeUb py- koBopiTens K OTBeTCTBEHHOCTH, Ho, ecnw axe v 37H Tp ropa ynyweHb\, 4 3a nocnegHe 3 roma OUeBMAHO,UTO y KOMNAHIA He BbiN0 ak- ‘TwBOB M CesiuaC HeT, Tora BePOATHOCTS NPHBNeUEHMA K CYECMANAPHON OTBETCTBEHHOCTH pykOBOAUTENA Toke Kpaive Mana PO) Pim atten Seuss GeO ELT BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 370 FOBOPHT O TOM, TO BbI NOCTO yNYCTHN BOIMOKHOCTH a¢bdeEKTHBHOTO AabICKAHUA, COOTAETCTBEHHO, cama npouenypa BabiCKaHNA M BaHKPOTCTBA MOET NPMBECTH K PACKODAM, HO He K aKTHUECKOMY B3bI- CkaHo, NOBTOMY NPM NOCTYNNeHMM 3aABOK, Mb WayYaeM LOMKHMIKA, HACKOMBKO IebibEKTHBHbI C HETO BabI~ ckatns, Ecru c Hero nepcnexTMBHbI B3bICKaHIA, Ha CepyIOWleM 3Tane Mbl V>Ke NepeXOAMM K VayUEHINO oKyMeHTos. Da, BeiBaer Takoe, TO BabICKAHHe He NePCNeKTMBKO HM TPaTHITb BIaUMHOe BPEMA yxe BeCroNesHo, B: Hanomiio, uTo Ana yuacTHinkos CooBLYeCTAa «BU3HEC yCTex» MBI NPOBOAMM BecnnaTHyio aHANHTHKy, 2am JOCTATOUHO NpUcNaTe MHH AOMKHNKA M CyMMy AONTA, Bepvémca k aonpocy kTo MOKeT MHMUMMpOBATH NpMBNeUeHMe K CyECUAMAPHOH OTBETCTAEHHOCTH M Pacckaxkn, noxkanylicTa, nopPoGHee 06 3TOM TepMMHe, NOTOMY UTO B XOAAe CBOeH AeATENbHOCTH A O6uaioce ¢ GonbUIMM KONMUECTBOM NPEANPHHUMATeNeH, M MOTY CKazaTb, UTO OTHOCHTENbHO TepMn- Ha cyScHAMApHAA OTBETCTBEHHOCTb ECTb HEKM MHcpOPMaLMOHHBIA BaKyyM.FnaBHEIA BONPOC, KTO MOXKET MHMYMMpOBATE NPHBNeUeHHE K OTBETCTBEHHOCTH M 3a4eM, UTO MOXxHO Enaropaps 3TOMY no- ayant. A: Cy8cuquapan oTBeTCTBeHHOCTb—3T0 RONONHHTeNbHbIM BMA OTBETCTBEHOCTH ro OBABaTeNbCTBaM KOMTIaHMM, TO ECTS KOHKDETHOE (UBMUECKOE NMLIO OTBEUAET 3a KOMNAHIMIO MC Hero MOET BbiTb BIbICKaHA 37a cymma. A 3auacTylo OCHOBaHNeM ANIA NpMBNeueHMA K ITO CyYECMAMAPHON OTBETCTBEHHOCTH CY KUT HenpaBunbHoe He3aKOHHOe BEAEHHE CAENOK, KOTOPOe NPMUMHAeT YULep6 CAMO KOMNAHMM Mn e& Kpe- auTopam. K npumepy, 8 Tevene npouemypel BaHKPOTCTBa MayUAeTCA DEATENbHOCTH KOMNaHMM 3a NocnepHMe 3 rO- fa. Vecnie Tevenne atux 3x ner 6bin npnunHés ape caMor KOMNaHilt Anu KPeAMTOPAM, K NpMMepy, NPO- BaBANOCb VMYLECTBO NO 3aHM>KEHHOM CTOMMOCTH MN He NpeANpMKMMaNncb AelicTBMA no cbopy Aebn- TOPCKOM 3AOMKEHHOCTH UNM B3aMeH STOTO VMYLECTBA HE NONYYMNHC ACHE XHBIe CpesCTBA, Nepe- odopMnanoct uMyLecTao Ha CeBA NMUHO, COBEPLUANNICb HanoroBbie NPAaBOHapYIWeHA, He BeNacb HaN- Te KALLMM O6pasom ByxranTepcken OTUETHOCTH W NPOUee. 3TO CAYKUT OCHOBAHHEM K CYECMAMAPHON OT- BeTCTBEHHOCTH. 3a npusneuexnen Kk CyHcuAvapHOn OTBETCTBEHHOCTH MoryT OpalaTbCA B paMKax NpoLeAypb! BaHKpoT- Ta apbuTpakHble ynpaanmioune nvGo KPeAMTOPEX, ECM y HX AOCTATOUHO MOKasaTeNbCTB. TO eCTe mioG0H v3 KPeAMTOPOS MOXKET OBPATHTECA, Tanke K CYOCMAMAPHON OTBETCTBEHHOCTH KPOMe NPOLEAYPEI GaHKpoTcTea mOryT OBpATHTECA KPeAUTOEK, HO 3TO No OBLAMM NpasunaM Ges NpOUeAYPb! GaHKPOTCTEA. Tlouemy 3T0 He npakTukyeTcs, noTOMy 470, coBpaTe AoKasaTeNbCTBA BMI KOHKPETHOTO YenoBeKa 6e3 Mpouesype! BAHKPOTCTBa OUeHE CNOXHO, NpaKTMUECKM HEBO3MOXHO. [OSTOMY OBBIUHO STHM Nonb3yeTCA HaMorOBaA MHCMeKLIMA y KOTOPOM ECT» BO3MOXKHOCTS 3ANpALLMBAT MHOpMaL|MO & FOC OPraHaX, B BaHKax, KOTOPbIe KakMM-TO O6Pa30M MOryT COBpaTb AOKasaTeNbCTBa NHBO 3TO NPOMCKOANT Yepe3 NPoUeAYDY GanxporcTea ‘aKoll BONPOC MHTepecHbi NoCTyniAn, ByKBANbHO. PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Uro HykHo nponucatb B AoroBopax, 4TO6bI Ae6uTOpHI NOHMMaNH W BoANMCb OTBETCTBEHHOCTH? Cnacyt nv qorosopnbie oBszaTenscrea oT NebuTOPCKOA 3aOMKeHHOCTH? EcTb MM KaKas-TO BON- wie6Has cbopyynupoBKa? A: BonuieGHixx cbopmynupoBox Ha CaMOM pene HeT, MoxkHO MHHAMHaMpOBATE PUCKHK, CBRBAHHBIE C Noy UeHMeM NPMUNTAIOLANXCA BAM AeHer. 3aKOHOMATeNbCTAOM NPEAYCMOTPeHbi Pa3nMUHIe BAPNAHTHI. B Nep- ayio ouepept, 2TO ycnoBVA DoroBOpA, KOHEUHO, YCNOBMIA HOTOBOPA AOMKHb| NOSBONATE B MMHMMANBHO BOSMOXKHBI CPOK MaKCHMANBHO deKTHBHO AOKAzATH, TO BAM AOMKHbI NeHer. K NpUMepy, aKTBI OKA- 3aHHbIX BAMM CYT, BLINONHEHHBIX pa6OT, Kak 3TO NPOMCXOAMT, B KAKOM CPOK BAM OS>KHbI 3a HX OTBE- TuTe, 8 KaKMX CHy4aRX OHM CUNTAIOTCA NPHHATEIMY, ECM BAC MrHOppyeT 3aKazUMK W NpOUee. MuHMMUIM- PoBaTS CpoK npeTeH3MoHHOro yperynuposakia copa. K npAMepy, 3aKOHOM NPeAYCMOTPEHO 3 AHA, a BbI MoxkeTe NpepYCMOTPETe M060! APyrol cpoK, HanpuMep, 1 AeHe. Bako BoBpema npuiHMMaTb AeMcTBMIA,BOBPEMA PearnpoBaTe Ha BOIMOXKHOe HapyWeHne BALK Npas eFo NPMHYAMTeNbHOFO BabICKAHMA Tak>ke 3aKOHOAATEMLCTBOM NPEAYCMOTPEHb! BOZMOKHOCTH Ha DO NonhuTenbHoe obecneueHve. K npuiMepy, Bbi MoxkeTe B CUT VCONHEHHA OBABaTeNbCTB B3AT NOpyUMTE- Fle KOHKpeTHEIX nloge” 6 opraHvazauuin, yupenuTenel, pykOBOpMTeNs BaWero saKaaUiKka MAM NoNyuaTe~ nis ToBapa Baste 8 3aN0r KaKOe-TO UMyLUeCTEO, REMKUMOE HTM HERBMKMMOe, OCOBeHHO 3TO KACAeTCA KPYNHBIX CAe- ‘TOK. TOTOBEI NM Bb! PHCKOBATH C yUETOM COCTOAKMA KOMNaHHM u NpoUee. {O6pEIs} Cefiuac sauactywo Gepyt nopyunTenamn pykosoguTenel opraHuzaUii, KoTOpbIe nonyualor ToBAp. TaKMM 06pa30M, pbiHok TpaHcibopmupyerca, YacTo KpynHble KOMMaHMM — NocTaBLUMKH— npovasoaNTeNH Ke Hauan 6parb 8 3a/10r HeNBMKMOe UMyLAeCTEO, KOr Aa OCYLECTBNAIOTCA KPYNHbIe NOCTABKHY, ITO UaLye Hauano BCTPeUaTECA. 3MaHViA NPOMBBOACTBEHHBIE, CKNA/CKMe, OHM FOTOBLI NOCTABNATS C OTCPOUKON Na~ Teka, HO NOcHe Toro, Kak NOTOBOp UNOTeKM 3anora HeABHYKUMOCTH GyAeT 3aperHcTpMpOBAH, Vi Tem cambiM oN MMHHMUHpYIOT PCH HeynnaTbI ROnra, B: ¥ Hac aonpoc or Maromeg Maromesona, Kak npeACTaBMnca uenoBeK, # AYMaIO, Mbl OTUACTH OTAeTHNH, Ho TeM He meHee. 3To KoMNaHMM OOO nocne oTKaza OT KaaHaYeMICTEA ObpaTHNMce B AAMMHUCTPALMA 0 BabICKAHMM 3a0NKEHHOCTH, OAHAKO, AAMMHMCTPALMA HE BBINONHACT MCNONHMTENbHbIA NUCT MY HaC HeT pbluaroB BMAHMA KpoMe Kak GECKOHeUHO O6palaeMca B NPOKypaTypy, 0 CUx Nop He MO- KEM AOBMTBCA B3bICKAHMA 3a/OMKEHHOCTM, KaK HaM BEITE. A: Kak a yoke roBopin pave, 3eCb BAXHO NOHMMATS AEMICTANA, KOTOPEIe AOMKHA COBEpUIATE ADMMHMCT- pau 3pec eLe BAKHBIM ACTEKTOM ABNACTCA KTO AOMKHMK, CaMa AQMMHMCTPALAA MN OAKO M3 MMHICTepCTB 9 TOM aAMMHUCTPALWN. VI, COOTBETCTBEHHO, KPOMe NPeANPUNMMaeMbIx BAMM NeicTEViA A HbI NocoBeTOBAN o6>kanoBaTb B cyneBHOM nopRaKe nocTaHoBneHie 06 oTKase BOIBYKAEHMA yronoBHbK pen. MoToMy uTO OueBIAHO, UTO B TeueHe 2x NeT He VCONHFeTCA peweHne cya. A 3feCb KpoMe NpoKypaTypbI NogcNen- CTBEHHOCTS cny>KBbI CyebHbIK NPHCTaBOB HECMOTPA Ha TO, UTO y Hix HeT MCronkuTenbHoro NpoW3BoR- Ba, HO AOCNeNCTBEHHAR NOBEpKA HOMKHI NDOBOANTS VMEHHO OHM, He NPOKyparypa, a cry»x6a cyneO- Ho0x npHCTaBoB, cnyk6a AOsHAHIA, M BaDKHO PasbUpATECA B ITHX HiOaHCAX PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Tinioc, kykHo oBparuTeca B apBHTpAXHbIM Cy C 3aABNEHMeM O NPUBNEUEHIM k OTBETCTBEHHOCTH KOH KDeTHBX IML, aAMMHMICTPALINN, 2 3TO rasa ABMMHUCTPALUNN, PyKOBOAUTEN. >uHAHCOBOH Chy>K6bI, KOTO pan o6a3aHa coBpepwaTb pan AeMIcTBHiA Ana vcnonHeHna peweHua cya. V\ kak pas B cyge OHM GypyT f0- Ka3bIBATb, UTO OHM COBepLANM BCe AENCTBUA, NPEAYCMOTPEHHbIe HOMKETOM 3aKOHOMATeNbCTBOM. Viecnu oni He nokaxkyr, TO 370 OCHOBAHNE K NPMBNeUEHMNO K OTBETCTBEHHOCTH, a MMeHHHO Wrpady 3a He~ vicnontenne pewiehna cyfa. Mn0c KOHeUHO Hy>KHO NOKaSbIBATS ALMMHUCTpAUMM, UTO OnnaTa sTOrO AONrA HeobparuMa, BabICKMBaeTCA HeONNaUeHHBIA NepnoR WITPAdHbINM| CAHKUMAMM, M KOF@ BCE 9TO OCyLYeCTE~ SIAETCA B COBOKYMHOCTH.. OBbIUNO 3TO MaeT CBOM pe3yNbTaT Ha KOTOPbIM BbI PaccuMTbIBAeTe. KOHUEHO K, CAM BbI NPOCTO NPEABABHTN AOKYMEHTHI B AAMMHUCTPAKMIO H NPOCTO xanyeTecb 8 NPoKypaTypy, ckopee Bcero euyé CTONbKO Ke BPeMeHH NPOHNeT, a pesynbTaT, a He OysAeT. Kcratu, Take fonru Moryt Got’ MHTepecHbl ANA BbiKyna HPyrHM opraHMzaymAM. ECnK NOHATe CneuMe- Ky C AVCKOHTOM, HO, 10 CYTH, 3TO MHTePECHO PBIHKY, ECM BbI CaMM HHUeTO He Cena He MOKETE, C DUC KOHTOM 50% Bb MOOKETE NPOAATb ITO KOMY-TO, KTO MOET 3THM 3aHNMATECA Bone a¢>cbeXTHBHO, B: Bonpoc of Hii. Bank HenpasomepHo cnucan AeHeXkHBIe CpesCTEa, cynebHoe peweHne obs3ano Ganik BepHyts AeHbrH MIN. Bak He ucnonHser. Cyfe6HbIe NPHCTaBbI CCbINaIOTCA Ha NMCMO OT 6aHKa 06 orcyrcTamn cpencte. Yro pena? }o-NepebIx, BaKHOE 3HaveHHe UMeIOT cbopMynHMpOBKH B peweHMn cyfa. Kakne ToeBoBaHHA OH pac- CMaTpupaeT. CoBepLEHHO pa3Hbii NOPAAOK VCNONHeHMA B3bICKAHMA NDUHyAMTeNbHOrO XapakTepa Bonee O6WNPHO. MO>KHO BabICKHBATE Bonee a¢b¢peKTHBHO. ‘DIu60 Bei o6paruniice 3a OB sSaHMIeM 8 Bank BepHyTb BaM AeHETH, NOPAAOK HcONHeHKA PeWeHMA, Ae yka- 3aHo OBA3aTb OH HaMHorO CnOXKHee ANA CymebHOro NpUCTaBa. VI ckopee BcerO cneuK>Ka y BAC C 3THM ceagana. | Tam, KOHeUHO, y CyAe6HOrO NPMCTaBa ero Me/CTBMA OrPaHMUEHbI, M HYKHO NOAYMATS, Kak v3~ Meni’ bopMynnpoBki 8 pewieHil cya. To eCTb BIRT AOKYMEHTDI Y CyebHoro NpUCTaBa M OBpaTHTECA 8 cyf.3a vaMeHeHMeM Cnocoba HcnonHeHiA peuleHinA cya. Ecru xe ® peWieHH ace ykasaHO NPABMNbHO, M yka3aHo BSbICKATH C KOHKPETHOTO Balika QeHbrY, TO BabI- kale OBpaulaeTCA OueHb NPOCTO. B OCHOBHOM, B Ka3HaveMICTBE Ha KOPPECNOHAEHTCKOM cueTe y BaHKa BCErNa CCTb AHbri,, MMeHHO B Ka3HaUeLICTBO NPEALABNAIOTCA UCNONHUTeNbHbIe AOKYMeHTbI PELIEHNA cyoe ana B3bickaHin, Ecn Tam eCTe AeHbr, TO OHH B3bICKBAIOTCA. VI He HYKHO BIAMMONeNCTBOBATS HM C KEM LPYTUM, Hit C Cy QeSHbIM NPUCTABOM, KasHAUEMCTBO 3TO NPMHYAMTeNbHO 3TO MCnONHseT. Ecru xke, KOHEUHO, BCE YCNOKHAETCA OTSbIBOM NHLICHIMM Kt BaHKPOTCTBOM CaMOrO Balika, TO 3AeCb HY HO BKMOUATHCA B peecTp TpeboBaHni KpeAMTOpOB. Tam npeaycmoTpena oTmenbHaA npoUeAypa, KY KHO areHTCTBY No CTpaXOBAHio BKNa;I08, KOTODBIM AB ATCA yNPABNAIOWIMM B XOAE NPOWeAYPb| BaHKPOTCTBA NOAKMIOUATECA B PEECTD UM 3aHMMATHCA NBO KOHTpONeM, nMGO _NOCTO OKHAaHNEM NonyYEHHA NPKUTAIOUINXCA BAM AeKEr. PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 B: CooBuyeHve Ana Bcex yuacTHMKOB M 3puTeNeA BebuHapa O TOM, UTO MbI M3BAHACMCA 3a BO3MOKHBIC. Mpobnembt Co 3AyKOM W NpeROCTaBM 3anCb BeGMHApA BCeM 3aperMCTPHPOBAHHEIM yUACTHHMKAM NO ero OKOHUBHI. Bonpoc @ uate: caazaH OH C MOCTATOUHO pacnpOCTPAHeHHBIM CPeACTAOM NNKBMAALMM (bUPM, a MMEHHO c TMKeNpAUMeN Yepes odxpwl0p. OueH» MHOrO KOMNaH NO Acel POCCMM 32HIMAIOTCA 3THM MOMEHTOM 1 3aUaCTYIO HALIM KIMEHTaMM CTaHOBATCA Te, KOTOPBIM NpMNeTeNo Nocne NogOGHON NuKeM_aUMM. Bonpoc: abi ron, Ha3an npopann KOMnaHitio TPeTBMM MMl4aM, ITO Gia MHOCTpAHHaA odd>wopHaA komnanna, Ceauac MBI ony4nnH BbI30B H3 CHleACTeHHOTO KOMMTeTA NO 3aABNeHMIo PHC no ynnare Hanoros no HAC 3a 2015-2016rr Ha ocHoBaHMn HanoroBod npoBepKi. Mbi Ke He nonyuann 3anpoct He KoHTaKTMponann B HC, He npemocTaBnann ef HAKAKMe AOKYMEHTEI, HOBbIe COBCTREHHMKH TO- ke. Kakne pMCKM Ha Hac NeKAT MW NOUEMY BbIBbIBAIOT MMEHHO Hac? A: Que xopowit Bonpoc u pacnpocTpAHEHHbIl B NlocneAHee BPEMA. 3TO KAK PAB OANH VB PUCKOB, K KO- TOpOMY AOMKHb Spite FOTOBbI MOAN, KOTOPEIe NepeoopMnsioT KOMNAHWNO Ha KOTO-nHI6O. Vl He BaXKHO, odsbuiop un npocTo Kakue-To HOMMHanbHbIe nya, B Uém 3aKmoUAeTCA CeuMbuKa AaHHOTO BoNpOCA M Bo0bue, GrTyaLM 8 UenOM. Boi npofaere KomnaHiio, Ho KoMnaHiA OcTaeTCA cywecTBoBaTs, HanoroBar MHCTeKUMA HaLeneHa Ha va- MeHeHUA B CTPyKTYpe 3TO KOMNAHIN, OA BAN, UTO Tya BXOAMT KAKOE-TO HOMMHANEHOR NYO, ObD- Wop unu KTO-To Apyrof. Oa MAMUMMpyeT BHenNaHoBylO Unni Dake nnaHoByio npoBepky Ha cneAyIOWN Top. BaxkHO, YTO Ace M3BeLYeHHA HANPABNAIOTCA NO IOpMAMUECKOMY anpecy KOMNAHMM WNM AenCTAYIOWIe- ro aupextopa Tlonyuaiot onn ay KoppecnoHpeHuio uni He nonyuaioT, 30 PUCKH, KOTOPbIe NPEAYCMOTPEHb! ANA KOM- TaHAM KanoroBbIM KOLeKCOM. He nonyuaior, KoppecnoHmeHuns BosEpALyaeTCA, NMYO CUNTAeTCA HaANEKaLUMM O6pasoM WaBCLIEHHEIM, To ectb y HanoroBol, ckopee Bcero, Bce NpoLeAYPHBIe BONPOCH GbINH COBMIOpeHbI. 3aTeM BLIHOCUTCA peweHve, TK. 2OKyMeHTBI HikeM He NpenOCTaBNAOTCA, HanoroBaR GepéT OTUETEI NO HLC, sanpawneaeT BBINMICKH NO GaHKOBCKMM CUeTAM M NoNb3ysCb 3TOM NPOBEPKO!, NONB3ysCb STHMM AaHHBIMA NMHMMAeT peweHne, KoTOpoe TakoKe OTNPABNAeTCA No MaBECTHBIM aNPECAM, NO akTYabHbIM anpecaM KOMNAHMM 1 HbIHewHero AupeKTopa, AevicTayIoUero AUpeKTOpa. VI HauNHaIOT TeUb CPOKH AIA BOSMOXKHOTO O6KAND- BaHV{A, NOHATHOE eNO, UTO HUKTO 3TO PeWeHHe He OBKanyer. Mlocne Toro Kak 370 pelleHne BCTyNAeT B cuny, HanoroBaa NpMMeHAeT ApyrHe MexaHNaMe! AABNeHUA. O6paulaetca yxxe B CNEACTBEHHDI KOMMTET 3a (PaKTOM TOFO, UTO ECTb PeEWEHHe HaNOrOBOn MHCNeKLMN, OHO BCTynMno B cuny. CaM HanoronnaTenbuuMk KOMNaHMM ero He oB)kanoBan, NOKaNyiCTa, AaliTe OUeHKy eNICTBMAM pyKOBOACTBA 3a BEC Nepvog HeynnaTbl. A ecnu 8 2015-2016r ynpasnanu KoMnaHuel Bol, TO (ANA BAC NMUHO HaCTYNAIOT PUCKM, BEITEKAIOLMe M3 ITOH NPOBEpKu. W tam ects puck cyScHAMapHO! OTBETCTBEHHOCTH, NOHATHO, UTO CCAM HUKAKMX KPUMMHANbHBIX NeViCTBMIA nu GeapericTani npv Bauem pykoBo,{cTBe He Gino, To yronosHoro fea He GyAer ckopee BCerO, HO BO3MO>KHO NpMBNeveHHE K CYOCMAMAPHOM OTBETCTBEHHOCTH PICK OUEHb BbICOKMN B LAHHOM cuTyAL\An PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Peusene of:kanogaro yxke He nonyunTcA, OHO BCTYNMMO B cMny, BCE CpOKH McTeKnIK, Bac NepCoHaNbHo HinkTO He Bbin O6ABaH H3BCUIATS, 3a BALU NepMON PYKOBOACTBa BOSHNK NON, ECT PeUeHKe HanorOBOH wHcneKuui. B: Bonpoc of EneHti Kop. Kak noracuTb kpenMTopckylo 3anomkeHHocTe Ges ener. Kakwe ecTe HHCTPyMeHTbI. Be3 npuaneue- Hua CheyManncra, NO HHCTPyKUWAH B MHTepHETe, A: To 3akony, eAMHCTBEHHAA BO3MOKHOCTe NOralLIeHMA AONTa, UNM Kak 3aKOH FACT: ONT ABNAIOTCA ToraueHHbimy, OcyulecTENAeTCA B NoueAype BakkPOTCTBA. Bo BCEX OCTANbHBIX CNyMARX ONT OCTAeTCA, B cnyuae BakkporcTea, Aon cnMicbiBaeTCA Mn CUMTAeTCA NOraLeHHbIN Ecnn npouenypa 6aHKpoTcrea npousna npasunbHo, nonomUTeNBHO. Ho, camocTosrenbHo nposectu npoueaypy 6aHKpoTcTBa, He HMeR OBpazoBaHiA W He sHaR CneyMeMKM HeBoaMoxHO. Kak MMHUMyM HyDKHO AOrOBOpHMTeCA ¢ APSUTPAXKHEIM yNPABNAIOLAMM, M HAAeATECA Ha TO, UTO OH Bac He nogpenér. Ho 8 niobom cnysiae, 3aTparbi By ay BosHNKaTb. 3arparol Ha CaMy npoUeAypy BakkpOTCTEA, bakTHuECKIA TOHeCéHHBIe PacxosAb,COCTaBNAIOT SOTbIC OpMEHTHPOBOUKO, a 3apa6OTHAA Nara ynpasnA\OULero B 3aBK- CHMOCTH OT NpOBNeM Bae KOMNaHMM He ByneT MeHee 100 TBC, NPM nioboM packnane. T.K.npoweRypa GankpoTCTBa BECTH ROBONbHO ONTO, M pabOTATe 3a TaKylo MMHMMANbHYIO CyMMY, R AYMaIO, He BCe Corna~ carca. MloaTomy Hy:kHo BbiTb roToBbIM K ynnaTe 150TbIC py6neli Ana He npoBNeMHON KoMMaHiN B: Cnogo 6aHikpoTcTBo HOCHT HeraTHBHbii XapakTep, Kak 6b! Tbl Mor OBbACHMT ¢bpasy, To 6aliKpor- CTB0 He CTpawsHo MW He BonbHO, a ecnH Bonee KOHKPeTHO cka3aTb, To KakMe nlocnesCTBHA OT Bal KpoTcTea, 8 nepaylo Ouepepb Kak MHCTPyMeHTa OCBOBOXKAeHMA OT NoNToB, To ecTb HeraTHBHBIe ¢bakropbi ect Ana KnieHTa, M BTOpaA YacTb BoNpOCa — B KaKMX Cnyvanx BaHKPOTCTBO He Cracer. }0-epabix, npoLIeAypa 6aHKPOTCTBA 3TO MHCTPYMeHT, KOTOPbIM MOKHO NONbIOBATECA KK MHOBbIM CTpyMeHToM, Kak HanpviMep raeUHbIM KMKOUOM, NGO YMeTb MM NONb3OBaTECA NMGO He YMETb M NPAUKHMTS ceGe apen Kakoii-T0, Vl ecnu 3HaTb Kak ero UCNOMb3OBATb, TO NPM NONOXKUTENbHOM BaHKpOTCTBe 370 NpM- BonT K CnucaHiio ponros. Mo cyTu, KoMMaHNa norHBaer, M NMUHO ANA pyKoBOAUTeNei HM yupeauTeneh KOMNaHMi 3TO NMUHO HAKAKMx NoCcnenCTBM He HeCéT. oToMy UTO Nepen BaHKPOTCTBOM OHA MeHAIOTCA Ha Apyrx NMu, KOTOpbIe C STO KOMNAHMeN BXOMAT B NPOUeAYPy SaHKpOTCTBa M HECYT NPOLeECcyaNbHbIe puckit HeKoTopbie. To ecTb ana caMux KnMeHTOB PUCKOB HeT, eCnw HeT HeraTHMBHOl UCTopui 3a nocnenHie 3 ropa. Henbsa YMCHBLUMTS PUCKY, ECM 6biNM HenpasomMepHble AeNICTENA, HeynnaTa Hanoros, HeBeAeEHNe HaNoroBor OT- UeTHOCTH, 3aKMIOUeHNe KAKMX-TO CHENOK, Mx HeNb3A NepeseCTH M3 KaTErOPM NOsAOSPMTENbHEIK 8 HOP- manbHyto. {Opps caA3n} K npnmepy, ecrt BMaHo, uTO KnMeHT MoxeT Bore npnBneuéH k CYBCHAKAPHON OTBETCTBEHHOCTY, HYDKHO CaMoro KnMeHTa roTOBHT», UTO6 C Hero HeBO3MODKHO BbiINO 3TH AeHExHBIe CpenCTeA BabICKaTe.Mocnen- PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT Cea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 CTBUR HE 3aHMUMaTBCA CAMOCTOATENBHO NPOLEAYPOM HaHKPOTCTBa, a KMaTb, UTO eé MHMLIMMpyeT KPEDV- Top nocne HanoroBoH HHCeKLMM, MOryT BbiTb CaMbiMiA paHeIMu CaMOe NPOCTOe 9TO NPUBNeUeHHIE K Cy6~ CunmapHon oTseTcTBEHHOCTH, NaNee PUCK BOSHMKACT YrONOBHOM OTBETCTBEHHOCTM. 3A}eCb MOFYT ObITb HeckonbKo CTaTeM yronoBHoro Kopexca: NPEpHAMEpeHHOE, (bUKTHBHOE GAHKPOTCTBO, BOSMOXKHAR Heyn- ‘fara HanoroB, COKpbITHe HaNoro MW npovee. 3anaua KEAMTOPA W apGUTPAKHOTO ynPABNAIOUYerO, KOTO- pili paBoTaer cbakTHUeCKM NPOTHS BAC 3TO He AONYCTHTb CRHCAHWe NONTOB M MaKCHMANbHO BC B3bI- cKare. Tlotomy uro 3a aabickalHble cpegcTaa nonyuaioT BO3HarpaxmeHMe BCE YUACTHIKH, 3@Cb KOHEUHO BaKHO paGoTaTe Ha onepexxeHne, a NOCNeACTANA MOTYT BtITS CAMBIMM Pa3HBIM, KAK MMIHIAMYM 3TO HEBOIMOMK- HOCTb BeA|eHNA NPeANPUHMMaTeNbCKON NEATENBHOCTH, NOTOMY UTO ECTb NDAMBIe 3aNpeTI B 3aKOHE O GaHKPOTCTBe, 3TO BHECEHME B PEECTP HANOTOBOM MHCNEKUNA HOMMHANbHBIX NML MAM QUCKBANMduKAUMA unpouee, 8 3aBMCMMOCTH OT Tex HelicTBMii Munn Ge3qencTBNA, KOTOpbIe BbI COBepWasIM Np ynpaBneHMNn komnanver. Ewje xoTen o6pariTb BHUMaHMe Ha TO, UTO CYCMAMApHaA OTRETCTBEHHOCTE He OAMHAKOBA Ansa pykosonuTens u yupequTened Komnanuu. K cy6cugMapHoii OTBETCTBEHHOCTH MoryT BbITb NpuBne- UeHbI NY, KOTOPbIE BVHOBHE! B BaHKPOTCTBe KOMMaHN CBOMM AeCTAMAMM Winn BeanencTanaMN, Ha~ npwmep, ecnu yupeauTenn Aasann ykasaHie, KoTOpOe ObAzaTeNbHoe AMPeKTOPAM MAW NMAMMANH yea cTve 8 Kpynibx Cenkax, NOANMCBIBANH peLeHiiA, NPOTOKONE, TO ECTe PICK K NpMENeueHINO K cyBCHY- PHO OTBETCTBEHHOCTH. Ecru 8cem ynpasnan TonbKo AUPeKTOP M HNkaKoro OAOBpeHNA OT yupeAMTENel He NONyYan, TO ANA yu Pesyrenedi pucKoB NpakTHMUECKH HET. B: Yeakaemble CnytwaTenn 3apaHee M3BNHAEMCA 3a TOT (bakT, UTO HE Ha BCe BONPOCbI CMODKEM OTBETHTS 80 Bpema Hawero npaMoro 3oupa. Ho, npowy Bac 3anonHNTe bopMy no ccbinke, A npopyBnupyio eé UAT, UToBsI rapaHTupoBaHHo NonyuMTs pas6op BaLe CUTYAL\MH, ECM BbI He NONyUANH OTBETOB B Xone BeEM- Hapa. Onora Powxuna cnpaumeaer, bunuanom DCC PO nporeseda auiesqHan nponepka npasHnbHocTH VICUMCTeHNS, NOMHOTEI H CBOEBPEMEHHOM yruaTbI NePeUMCHeHMA CTPAXOBbIX BIHOCOB Ha OBs3aTeN- Hoe CTpaxoBanne OT HeCUACTHEIX Cny“aes Ha NPOMsBOACTEE M NpodeccnoHanbHbIx 3a6oneBAHIA, Tpnusto pewenne o npuaneueHnn k oTBeTCTBEHHOCTH, BbICTABNeHO TpeboBAHMe O BabICKAHAM NHK wurTpada, O6wecTaom nopala xanoba B ynpasnenne DCC PO. Uro HeoBxoAMUMO CAenaTb 0 Toro, UTObbI Ao paccMoTpeHus KkaNObEI YnpasneHem OCC c O6ujecTaa He BSbICKANM CYMMY HEAOKMKM No Tpe6oBaHno. A: 311m pewennem, KoTopoe abl OO kanyeTe, Onbra, yCTaHOBNeHO, UTO PykOBOAMTeNb HENpABHNbHO VC- uncnan Hanori u v3-3a 3Toro OBuJecTBO NpMBneveHO K OTBETCTBEHHOCTH. Cemuac BaxkHo WayuNTe BCIO MCTOPHO C TOTO MoMeHTa, Kora OBLeCTBO Hauano HeNPaaMnbHO MCHMCNATS 3TH B3HOCH|, CRENATb TAK, UTOGbI ACA 3Ta NEATEMHOCTD GbiNa OBbIUHOM, TeKYLNeN, NPABMNEHO COBEPLLMTE CAeNKH No BbIBOAY aKTHBOB, CMM OHM ecTe,a ECA 3TO yoke NPOMZOLUNO, TO NeBpaTHTE M3 HeNPABMNBHbIX CAENOK 8 NPABUNHBIe, TO ECTb MOpAaboTaTb Ux M 3aTeM y>Ke NepefaBaTb KOMNAHMIO B yNpasneHue Apyrum JAMWaM, NepenaBas akTHBbI Tak uM NaCCMBbITeM CaMbIM MAHVMMM3MpyA PUCK NpvBneueHna kK cySCMANApHON oTaeTcTaeHHocTH, PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 KoHeuno 8 faHHom cnyuae Henb3e roBOpUTS 0 100% wabaaneHnn oT cyEcuAMAPHOM OTRETCTBeHHOCTH, HO MUIHVIMV3MPOBATE, CLENATS PUCK MAHMMANbHO BO3MOKHEIM ~ MOKHO, M TeM CAMbIM BAKHO BOBPEMA MHMMpoBATS NPOUeAYPY BaHKPOTCTEA, NOTOMY UTO ECAH ee MHMLUNNpyeT HaNOroBaR MHCTeKUMA, DCC He MOXKeT HHNLMMpOBaTe NPOLeAYPY HAHKPOTCTAA, OH 3TO NeNaeT Yepe3 HanoroByIO cny»KBy. BaxKHO O- ka3aTb, UTO DeATeNbHOCTe bina TeKyLYeH, UTO OWMOKa Bbina TeXHMYeCKOM, TO ECT KOTOpAA He aNeueT NepcoHanbHoii OTBETCTBEHHOCTH AUpeKTOpa. Korna 8 npouenype GaHKporcTaa BiomkeTHEIe OpraHt 3aHMMaiOT Bone NonoBMHt, NonoBHHY uM Bonee KPeAMTOPCKOM 3a10MKeHHOCTH, 3TO NOANANAeT Nog MCKNIOUMTeNbHbIe NpaBMNa, M34eCb NpeAMonaraeT- cA eva NocnegHero yuacTHMnka AUPeKTOPA M Te PyKOBOAUTENM, KOTOPBIe GbINH B MOMeHT ObpasoBaHnA ONTa, NOKa OHM He AOKAKYT CBOIO HEBMHOBHOCTE. TO ECT 3TO TaKOe MCKMIOUeHHe M3 NPABHN, KoTOPOe Hauano penicTaoBaTe ¢ 2017 roma-3aKOHO.. WTaM OUeHD BaKHO NPABMNBHO NOBFOTOBUTECAK 3TOR npouezypy M AoKa3zaTb, UTO BaLUel BMHbI HET. B HekoTopbix cuTyalima He BCerfa Cpa3y MbI MHULMMpyeM npouegypy GaHkKpoTCTBa, MHOr Aa CTOMT NopO- >A aT», BPK AAT GesonacHble CpOoku, UTO6 No CTH, NGO OTYACTH NepenodXMTb BKHY Ha KOrO-TO Apyroro, Ha HOBBIX yUpenUTeNeM v PyKOBOAUTeNeM, HOMMAHANHO NGO MCKMIOUNTe Bally BHHy BOOBLIe. B: Kak qo6uTbca y AOMKHUKOB onnaTbI, He OBpaujanc B cyn? Kakue ecTb paboTaioulMe MHCTPYMeH- ‘Tol AA NOMOGHbIX MeACTBMAP A: 3TOT CRUCOK ECT, OH KpaliHe orpaniueH. Bcera Ky:KHO COBmiofaTb onpegenéHHbili nopAROK ypery- pOBAHINA CopoE, M Ha CTARMM COBNIOAeHNA aTOTO NOPANKA MOMKHNK OMKEH YausACTP HEMIBOKHOCT BbICKaHIMA C HeTO AeHEF, TO ECT HYMHO NOKA3aTb NOMKHNKY CBOM PeWIMTeNbHbIe eNACTBNA: HaNpABUTS eMy npeTeHSMIo BOMOXHO NO3BOHHITS, NOBeAR NeperoBOPbI M NOKazATb eMy nepcneKTHBY B Cnywae He- ynnaq, a 3TO B3bICKAHNe HEYCTOMKM, B3bICKAHMe PACKO/OB Ha JOPUCTOB, BO3MO>KHO HeraTMBHaA MCTOPHIA B OTKDBITEIX HCTOURMKAX 0 TOM, HTO C AOMKHMKOM HavanHice CygbI M NpoUee. Vl eC aHHbIe NocNeACTBMA QOsDKHMNKa NYTaIOT, MOH YBEPEH B BALIN PELUMTENbHbIX MEMICTBMAX, TO 3TO MOKET NPUBECTH K NOsOxA- TenbHomy pesynbTary. B APYTUx CUTYALIMAX, KOHEUHO, HeT. Mory CkaaaTb M3 ONbITa, UTO aNeKO He acerna axe Takne fevicTBa NpUBOAST k NonoxKUTeNbHOMy pesyNnbTaTy, onnaTe MeHer. 3auacTYIO Hy>KHO NOKA- 3aTb CBON AeNCTAMA, OBPATHTECA B CyA, CReNaTb Tak, UTOObI CYA NMA K NOMSBOACTBY peWeHHe MTA, B TaKWX CUTYALLMAX AOMKHINK Ke HE NPOCTO Tak He NNATHMT, OH He NATH NoTOMy, TO y Hero RedDHUMT Re- Her W oH HauAHaeT BbIOUpaTe MexaY KDeRUTOPAMM, KOMY NNaTHTb KOMy He NnaTiMTe.V B TakMK cHTYALMAK OH npexpacko npeACTasnAeT NOCNeACTENA, eMy He Hy:KHO PasbACHATb, UTO BbI ByAeTe NeNaTb, OF, TAK, ToMMaeT. OH NpOCTO NnaTHT TeM, KTO 3arHan ero B yron, TeM KTO y>xe OBpATHNCA B CyA, nonysnn pewe- He cya, TeM, KTO 6nlokupoBan cueTa, HanomMnapeCT Ha VMyLWeCTBO HM NpOUee. OH BUIKYDKAEH BbIGOOU- Ho KOMy-TO NNaTUMTb H ee NPODOMKAT OCYLLECTENATS DEATENBHOCTS, MAE MODKHO OBAHKPOTUTS CBOIO >e KOMMAHIN. B: Bonpoc or Cepres, opHOrO 13 CaMBIX aKTHBHBIK YUACTHHKOB UaTa HackonbKo peanbHbl pHckn HanoroBod NpoBepKH NpH MHMUMMpOBAHMM NpoueAypb! GaHKpoTCTBa? M kak ONONHEHVe K TOMY BONPOCY, BO3MO>KHO JM 3aKPbITb KOMNAHMIO Yepes NPOWeAypy FaHkpoTcTBa Np HesaaepuléHHOA HanoroBon npoBepKe? PO) Pim atten Seuss GeO ELT BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 A: Orseuaio Ha nocne@Hii Bonpoc, fa, BO3MOXKHO MHMIMMpOBATS GaHKPOTCTBO, Kora UAeT HanoroBaA nposepka u eé 3aBepLUMTb. XOTA 3auACTYIO Cy OXMAaeT PeLEHHE 3TOM HaNoroBO! NPOBEPKN, HO, No cy- Tw, 370 HitkaK He BNWReT. B 9Tux cTyauMax MANUMMPOBAHNE MPOWeAYpE BaHKOTCTEA Nake B BONbWIMKCTEE CUTyALIMi, OHA NONO- >KUTENHO B/MRET Ha HaNOrOByiO NPOBEPKy, NOTOMy UTO y Ha/lOrOBOHA MHCNeKLMM ECTS 3af1a4a MOHAUC- nitTb CyMMy no MpoBEpKe M ObecreunTe eé nocTynneHHe B Biome. OAHO 6e3 Apyroro He paboTaeT nvGO paGoraer 8 MuHyc ana HanoroBoi MHCneKUMM. ECM OHa HACUMTBIBACT, HO HE B3bICKMBAeT HaUMCNeHMA, TocTynmeHia B BiOgKeT, TeM CaMbIM NOPTHT CBOK NoKazaTenn. MY, coOTBETCTBEHHO, KOrAa HanloroBaA NPM poBepKe BHAT, TO MAKUMMPOBAKA NpoLIeAYa BaHKPOTCTBA, ITO ABNACTCA CUTHANOM K TOMY, UTO CyMMa HeAOMKH, KOTOPYIO OHM HaUCNAT He BysAeT B3bICKaHA, M OBLIUHO BakKPOTCTBO NONOMMTeNbHO BHAT Ha PpeweHne pesynbTata Hanorosod npoBepKn. Y Hac Obinn cuTyaUnn, Kora WanoroBaA MHCTeKUMA rposMNace AOHAUUCHMTe BonbUIy!O CyMMY HeROUMKM, Ho B peaynbTare, Kora BUpeNa, UTO NPoueAypa GakkpoTCTBA yoke HaUaTA, Myke lOLXOAMT K CBOeMY NO TMMeCKOMy 3aBePWIEHINO, OHa HaUMCNaNa MMHAManbHyiO pa3yMHylO ANA KNMeHTa CyMMy HEDOMMKH, KOTO pan npocro onnauneanace M ace Bin LOBONbHbL Vicxona v3 macbopmaynu, KoTopyio s npepocTasun B nepsov uaCTM CBOErO OTBETA Ha NPeAbIAYLANI! BO- Npoc, Hanorogaa MHCNeKUMA OBbIUHO He MHUUMMpyeT NpoBEpKM, KOrMa HauaTa NpOWIeAypa HaHKpOTCTBA, MoTOMy WTO 3TO CurHan k ToMy, uTO HanoroBaA WMCTeKLNA He NONYUNT KENaeMBIX Neer Ml VCOPTHT CROW noxazaTenn, Korma HauaTa npouenypa 6aHKpoTCTsa, OBBI4HO HanoroBbIK NOBEPOK He GbIBAeT, HO aXe ECM OHH MPOXOAST AO HACTORLErO BPEMEHM OHM 3aBePUIAIOTCA BNaronoNYUHO AANA HAC, ANA KNWeHTOB, 370 MM60 He QOHAUMICNAIOT, NGO HauMICARIOT KaKYIO-TO PaayMHylO CyMMy, KOTOPAA BbINNAUNBAeTCA, NGO HAUCAA- 10T, HO 8 peaynbraTe BaHKpOTCTEA CNMICbIBAIOT, BadkHO YCNeTS MHMLWAMPOBATS BaHKPOTCTEO AO HaNOrOBOA NpoBepku, OSTOMY BAKHO OUeHb ONepaTHBHO AeMCTBOBATS. [moc Cama NPoueAypa GaHkpOTCTBA, KaK A Ke CKazaN, He ABNAETCA NPHUNHOM ANA HanOrOBOM NPOBEPKHY, TO ECT OHa He NPOBOWNPyeT HaNoroBy!O Mposepky, HO APyrHe CnocoBb! NNKBMAALINK, TakHe Kak NPOCTO BeneHHe AOBPOBONBHON AUKBMAALWN MM 60 BepeHiie KaKOrO-TO HOMMHaNbHOrO yKOBOAMTeNA, yuDEnMTeNA, Od>duOpa KNM NpOCTO HOMMHAN, OHM Kak pa3 AANAIOTCA NPOBOKALMeN ANA HANOrOBOH ANA Hauana HanoroBO! NPOBEPKU. B: Anexcem npegocraaun Ham npexpachyio O6paTHyio cBAR», UTO TeMa BeGuHapa HACTONBKO FopALA, UTO K HaM Bo Bop 3aexann ax ZNOKapHEIe MaLIMHbL OBouNocb. Hapelcb, uTO BCE XOPOULO, Bonpoc wutepecibil noctynun. 3af0/KeHHOCTb eCTb y NOTeHUMANbHOrO KMeHTa NO apeHAHLIM NnowansM npn oTcyTCTANM rocyAAPCTAeHHOM perMcTpayMn CO CTOpoHb apeHonaTens. [oroBop Huikak He 3aperHcTpMpOBAH, HO OH 3af}OMKaN NNaTeKU No apeHse. YTO MbI MOXKEM NOCOBETORATE B aHHom cnyuae? A: Ech y Bac HeT B3aMMONOHNMAHNA C apeHAOLATENEM UNH Bb C HUM He ATOBOPUNHC®, To CKOpee Acero Bam NpETCA CbexaTb UNM Aep»xaT> OBOPOHy B CBOEM apeHAYEMOM NoMeUeHHM, NoTOMY 4TO apeHAOLA- Ten 6e3 BaLIErO COrMACHA NO CyTH He MODKET BAC NPHHYAMTENSHO BbIrHaTe Bes PeWeHHA cya PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Tlostomy ecn Bo3MoxkHO BeseHHe RERTENbHOCTH C TAKUM OKONONPABOBbIMU MeTORAMM AaBNeHHA Ha BaC, Hy, K NPMMepy, CCTM 3TO He TOproBbiii LEHTP, Tyla HENb3A NYCKATb, TO KOHEUHO MOXKHO He NslaTUTb, ep Kae OBOPOHY MK AAT PeLIEHHE Cyfa, HO, ECIIM 3TO HEBO3MOKHO, K COKaNeHHO, BaM NPHAETCA Cbe- XaTb C 3TOrO apeHAYEMOro NOMELYCHHA. 3aOMKEHHOCTS apeHAOAATEN By.RET BbIKYKACH B3BICKHBATE B cyne6viom nopanke. Vl ovens pacnpocTpakéHHan cuTyauNA, Kora AOTOBOP 3aKNiouaeTCA Ha CpoK MeHee 12 MecayeR, MeHee Tofla M NpepyCMOTPeHb! YCNOBUA ero NPONOHTAaLIMH M TeM CaMbIM 3TOT MOrOBOp eNCTByeT Bonee roma. CooTseTcTBeHHo, sec NpOUCKOpUT cyAeGHOe pasGupaTenbCTEO, C ORHON CTOPOHEI, ITOT NOrOBOP He Nognexkut rocperucTpaliwn, HO C APyrov CTOPOHbI, EcTb cyseGHaR NpakTHKa, KOTOPaA perysMpyeT OTHO- uleHHa C NoBObHbIMM xUTPOCTAMM, Ecn waHauanbHo, CoBoKynHOCTb YCnOBIAA npv nponoHrayMM, 3aHMaeMBbIit CPOK >TOM NnoWaAN apeH- AYEMON NPeBbiLIZeT Fop, TO MO>KHO GINO HOroBOP apeHAbl PervicTpNpOBATE MB STOM Chyuae CYA MOXKET NPMATU K BbIBOAY, UTO LOFOBOP ABNATCA He 3aKMIOUeHHIM. ITO OAHA M3 BAMALIM, ECM Bbl HaXOQUNMCh 8 370M NOMeWJeHHM Bonee ropa. B 3TOM Cnyuae 3TO He ABNATCA OCHOBAHWeM {NA TOrO, UTOBbI He B3bI- ckaTe C Bac apeHpHyio nnaty Ockosanmem Byer He foroBop apeHabi, 8 KoTOpOM npenycMoTpeHa apeHAHaA nara, a HeOCHoBaTeNb- Hoe oBoraueHne, abi Ke JaHNMANH NROWWAAS, BI HOMKHEI 3a He’ ONauNBaTe, TO eCTb TYT NPUMEHAT Te >ke CTaBKHY, KOTODBIe NPeAYCMOTPEHEI BaLLMM OT OBOPOM, ECM 3TO BoINO ANMTeNbHOe BpeMA, NpOCTO UC XOAA V3 ICTOPIMM, 3TO Tak, NHOO ECM NOMeHANCA PbIHOK UNM ECT APYTMe OCHOBAHUR, TO MOKET ObITb NpvBNeueH CreuMANNcT NO OLIEHKE M OH OLYeHUT HEOCHOBaTeNbHOe OBoraLeHve C BALM CTOPOHbI, HO, NO CyTH, 3TO apeHma 3a onpegenéHHbii nepnon, To ecb ecnn 6yner peweHneMm cya BabicKaa KakaR-TO CyMMa foMtra C BaC 3TO HE36EKHO, HO Hao no- yMaTb kak NOBOpOTECA 3a yMeHBUIEHHE ero 8 Cysle NuBo NoAyMaTe Kak He NNaTHTS ee B PesynbTaTe BaH- KPOTCTBa, © U8M MbI TOBOPMNI UyTb pakee. B: Anekceli, npoKOMMeHTIpyii BONPOC, KOTOPBIlA NOCTYNMN y>KE OT EFICTBYIOUIUX KMMEHTOS, A Hx 3HAIO SMUHO. Mai 3anenaem c To60H, uTO Mii pa6oTaeM 3a NPOLeHT OT CYMMbI AONTa NPM paBoTe CO B3bICKAHHE 3a- gomkenHocTH. To ecTb Mul nony4aem KOMMCCHIO TONBKO B Cmyae NONHOrO BOBpATA NeHExHEIX CpencTA Ha CURT Halero KMeHTA. 3a4aCTyIO MbI TOBOPUM O TOM, UTO KaK MMHUMYM UaCTb WM STMX PaCKO;OB MbI MOxeM KoMnencuposary, TK Haula AesTeNBHOCTE NoANapaeT Non cyfeGHENe pacKost. KakoB % OT CTON- MOCTH HaLLMX YCHyr Mbt MO>KEM KOMFIEHCHPOBATD 3a CHET JOMKHNKA M KAK UACTO 3TO BO3MOKHO caenats? A: 3gecb oTBeuaa Ha BonpoC, OBpaljaio BHUMAHMe Ha TO, WTO cymeBHaA npakTHMka pasMepoB BAbICKAHHA cyme6Hs0x pacxonos Wa lOpHcToB u NpeACTaBHTeNA, NeEDHOAMUECKH MEHRETCA PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT Cea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Heckonbko ner Hasaf, cy. B3bICcKMBaN 6 pasyMHbIK npenenax. I TeM CaMbiM yMeHbUAN TpebyeMyio CyMMY cyme6HbIx pacxofos Ha NpeACTaBMTeNA C yUeTOM CHeNOK, COBEPUIaeMbIx MEMICTBNAA, NOe3AOK C cypebHbIM sacegaHiem v npouee. Bceraa ova Obina MupMBMpyanbHa. 37a NpakTuKa WMeHIANACE. Hy To ecb ecni cy parbue cam aanvanponan, paayMHaA nM 3TO CyMMa MnM HepaayMHa, TO NOTOM cy- e6HaA NpakTuKa CKazANA ~ Cy ITM He JOMKEH 3aHUMATECA, a HEPASYMHOCTH ITMX PaCKOAOB DOMKEH ‘OKa3aTb OTBETUNK, a UCTEL AOMMKEH HOKARaTE, UTO OH NPOCTO Wx NOHEc, HO AOTOBOP uNnaTexkHOe Nopy- UeHme 06 onnare k npumepy. V cyp Haan B3bICKHBaTb OrPOMHbIe CyMMbI PACXOAOB Ha NpepCTaBHTENA. Ana wac aToT nepiog Gein oueHb xopoLUMM, NOTOMY UTO KNMeHTbI NONHOCTbIO KOMMeHCMpoBANM BCe pac XOfbI Ha HAC, MOC NoNyuaNH KaKOe-TO AONONHUTeNbHOe BO3HarpaxpeHwe, 3a CUET BIbICKAHMNA CyMeOHbIX pacxogos, Ho Ceviuac NpakTHka CHOBa MlOMeHANACE, M YK CHOBA Cy aHANVSMPYeT PasyMHOCTb ITUX pac- xO /108, Cemuac, K COKANEHINO, CY{AbI CYLLECTBEHHO YMeHbLaIOT CyMMBI pacxofOB Ha NpeACcTasuTenen. Bo- flee Toro, L1NA TOTO UTO 6bI Cys PACCMATPMBAN ITOT BONDOC, Hy>KHO CHavaNA 3TH PACXOA! NOHECTH, TO eCTb 3aNNaTHTb, 2 BNPeAb HALEN PaboTe, Ha MOMEHT KOFAa MbI CYAMMCA C LOKHMKOM, Halu KMMeHT eLye 3TH pacxoptel He NOHEC No AOrOBOpY, M NOSTOMY KOFa Mb CYAUMCA C LOMKHMKOM, MbI He MOXKEM HX BO3~ JIOKUTS Ha OTBETUNKA. ZaKOHOMATENEM CeMUAC CPOKH B3bICKAHIAA CyAeHHbIX PACKO{OB C MOMeHTa NPUHA- Twa nocnenHero cyfeGHoro akTa, a 3TO COCTaBNAeT LECT MecALLeB. COOTAETCTACHHO, ecru B TeUeHHe 6 MeCAL{e8 Mb| CMON B3bICKATS AeHBrH B NOMb3y KNMeHTA M KAMeHT CMOr HaM ONNNATHTe, Ml B OTAeMbHOM NopARKe MoxKEM ObpaTHTbCA B CYA W B3bICKATH KAKME-TO CyMMbI Ha NpemCTaBTeNA. ECT Xe Mbl He yNO- KUNG 8 3TH LECT MECALIe®, BOT, K NUMEpy, CreUMbNKa BabICKAHHR BbiNa Bonee CROOKHOM M HAM NH XOAMNOCE B3bICKMBATE 3a CET NPOUEAYE! BAHKPOTCTBA, TO, KOHEUHO, KAMEHT YRYCKaeT BO3MOKHOCTE B3bICKHMA BOT 3THX CyebHbI pacxosoB Ha NegCTaBuTeNA. Bonee Toro CopmeHTupyio NpocTO no cym- Mam, uTO6bI Gbino NoHMMaHMe. B apbuTPAXKHOM cyme MocKab! n MocKOBCKoN ObnacTu cevuac paayMHble CyMntbl cyeGHbIx pacxooB COCTaBNAIOT NpUMepHO 0 100-150 TaIcAu pybneN. B permoHax, KNPHMePY, B Camape, 8 ap6uTpaxe CamapcKon oBnacTH Cyfbl yMeHEWIaIOT [0 50 ThICAY pyBnen, Name B HeKOTOPLIK cuTyaynax MeHbiLe. MoaToMy 3TO OpMeHTUpEI AINA TOTO, UTOBbI BbINO NOHMMaHMe KaKMe CYMMbI CY: MOKET HONONHMTeNbHO BIbICKHBATE. B: CnacGo 3a oTBer. BoT 8 TeMy OTHETCTACHHOCTH, 8 TeMy HEKOTOPBIX HeraTMBHbIX MoMeHTOB NpoBeAe- Hua npouenype! GaHKPOTCTAa, XoTeNOCe Gb! UTOBbI Mil HALLAM NOTEHUMANbHbIM KMEHTAM M YuACTHIKaM coobwectaa «Busec Ycnex» pacckazann peanbHo 060 acex acnekTax, HMuerO He ckpbiaaA, BonpOC no- cTyNun QOCTaTOUHO MHTepecHbili. BbI Cka3zaNnM, UTO NPM HaHKPOTCTBe MeHAeTCA AUpeKTOp M yupenM- Tenb, TO 3TO NaéT ANA MeHA KaK ANA AMpeKTOpa? CMory NM A Ma6EXaTb TakMX NocNeACTAMI KaK aanpeT 3aHMMaTb PYKOBOAALIMe AOMKHOCTH HM GbITb yupeaMTeneM B APyrux OOO? My, cooTaeTcT- BeHHO, UTO HYKHO leNaTb B NPOTHBHOM cnyuae, A: Bo-nepabix, 3To OueHb Ge30nacHbil Toro, UTO Bb| CMOXeTe JaHIMATb PYKOBOAPLANE NOCTHI B OpraHH3a- uv u 6bITb yupeauTenem KOMNAHM, NOTOMY UTO 3meCb Peub He MAST O ANCKBaNMd>uKaLWN, BO-BTOPEIX, BaxKHO AINA uero 3TO MeNAeTCA, Jina HoBbix HOMMHaNbHbIX NL MBI AeNeM aCe, UTOGbI Mx Take He AUCKEANMdnUMpoBANM, JIna uero 270 nenaetca? B MoMeHT npomaxu KOMNAHMM BCe AKTHBBI M NACCHAbI, B TOM 4ACNe 3anaCbI, KO- Topple OBBIUHO He BCerfa B peanbHOCTH, fa M He B NOMHOM OBbéMe, MOry Tak Cka3aTb, BbI NepemaéTe HO- PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 Bomy niuy. HoBoe nuyo y>Ke NpeANPUHMMaeT MepbI M NPM Hem HauMHaeTCA NpoueAypa BaxKpoTCTBa. Co- OTBeTCTReHHO, aac HiiKYAa He A€praior. Bo aCe CyAebHbIe NPOL.eCCHl, TPebOBAHMNA ROKyMeHTO®, COBPAHHe KPeANTOPOB, ACE OCYLeCTENAETCA HOBLIM MMLIOM, a BbI Y>KE CTIOKOMIHO 3aHHMAeTECD CBOeH APYTOM NeA- TenbHOCTbIO. Mpu TOM, Ha CTaQMM NOATOTOBKH K GaHKPOTCTBY, Mbl HMBENMpYeM BCe PUCKM, CBAZAHHBIe C TPOUINbIMN HeNpaBMNBHBIMM AeMCTEUAMM, ECT 3TO BO3MO>KHO, M NPespaUlaeM HeNPaBHbHbIe CENKM B MpasunbHble. Ho 8 mi06om cny¥ae, BCe NPOLECCYANbHbIe PUCKHY KCTATH, ORHMM 3 OCHOBAHM, AUCKBANN- ouxauns unu npveneueHie k cy6cHAMapHOn OTBETCTBEHHOCTH ABNAeTCAHe MpeqocTasneHne BCerO o6veMa AOKyMeHToS KoMNaHMMN 3a nocnegHMe 3 rona. AHOrna ux HeBo3MOxHO COBpaTe. Mnoc HeNpenoc- TaaneHile BCex akTHBOB KOMNAHMN apEUTPaXHOMY yNPABNAOU{eMY, a ECM HET ITHX aKTHBOE, KAK Bb WX mpegoctaauTe. KoHeUHO, no 3THM pUCKaM OTBeUAET yKe HOBBII YeNOBeK, rinioc 3auACTYIO 8 BanaHce Man B AesTenbHocTu GbieaeT Te akTUBLI, KOTOPEIe HeXKeNaTeNbHO TporaTa K npuMepy, AeGUTOPCKaR 3anON- >eHHOCTS Nepe APYrHMM APY>KeCTBEHHbIMM KOMNaHMaMM, Ecn Bbl nepenaére 3TH AoKyMeHTel ap6UT- PaXHOMY YNPABNAOUIeMY, TO OH BbIMY:x/AeH 3aHMMATECA B3BICKAHMeM C APYTHX KOMMAHMIA, C BALK xe, BO3MOXKHO KOMNAHIAM, ALIEN Ke BO3MOMHO KOMNAHHN, BSbICKAHMEM NEBHTOPCKON 3a f0MKEHHOCTH. V, KO- HeUHO, He BCera B 3TOM ECT 3aMHTEPECOBAHHOCTS, M 3a 9TM PUCKH OTBEUAT HOBBII PyKOBOAUTENS, B: Cnac6o 2a Teer. Noctynun sonpoc, 8 o4epenHor pas CaAZaHHbIT Cc apeHAHEIM GuaHEcoM, Kak MOKHO o6esonacuTb ce6a OT BOSHMKHOBEHUA AeGUTOPCKON JanOMKeHHOCTH B Chyuae, eCNM y MeHA apeHA- bit 6uaHec. Kakne BO3MOXHO BKMOUTb YCNOBMA AOroBOpa, OFecneuMTeNbHbIA NNaTé NAGO foro Bop c nlopyuntenscTaom AMpeKTopa 000, KOTOpEIM GyAeT 3aHMMaTb apeHAYeMOe NoMeLeHHe, MO- eT ObITb ecTb Gonee acbcbexTHBHble MHCTPYMeHTHI Tloschio sonpoc, Ha awe npaKTHKe, MbI CO CTOpOHbI KNMeHTa NopXOAMAM K 3TOMY BONpOCY, OTKPEI- aa odbc B Mockee, Kak pa3 8 pykOBOACTBO HUBHEC YeHTpa, Fe Mbl HAXORMMCA, y Hac BbiN NoATO- TOBNeH NPOTOKON o pasHOrnacnax, ecnn He OUIMBaIoce Ha BM AMCTAX, TO eCTb OHM nepecTpaKoBa- nce. C Moeii TOUKH 3peHIAA, MMECT CMBICN TOBOPHITS O JONONHMTEMHbX MHCTPYMeHTAX, ec Bae TomeuleHve AanAeTCA NpMBNeKaTenbHbIM. [Ina NoTeHUMaNbHbIX apeHAaTopoR. NoTOMy TO y MeHA eCTe NpMMep M4 OBpaTHaA CTOPOHa, Kora MOM APY3bA y KOTOPBIX ECTS KOMMEpUeCKaA HeEABHKA- MOCT», CMWKOM yBNeKNMCb COCTABNeHNEM NOMOBHEIX OTOBOPOB, MULYT KNMEHTOB MHOr NaH n10 Tlonroma. Tem He Meviee, Bo3BpaU4ance k BONPOCY Kak MOKHO OBe30NACHTb, NPeNCTABMM, LTO y KnM- eita, KoToporo 3oByt Anekcel SIbIcbix, NoMeUeHKe NpMBNeKaTeNbHOe. UTO OH MOKET BHECTH B yC- noBuA OroBOpa, 1TOGbI OBe20NacTb CebA OT BOIHMKHOBEHIA NeBMTOKN, A: Bonpoc nowaTeH, Mel Ha 3TOT BonpoC OTBeTHAM UTE pale. BkpaTue pacckarxy. {O6pbIa} Banor moxkHo Mcnonb3oBaTb, Ecnh Mbl roBOPHM OBECneUMTeNbHbIE NNaTeXKN, KOHEUHO, MOKHO NpeAY- CmoTpeTe oBecneumTenbHbie nnaTexkm, KOTOPIe BHOCATCA 3aGnaroBpeMeHHo, 3a 2 MecALa, 3a MECAL, B 3aBMCHMOCTH OT CneuMENKH NOMELIeHA M ynpaBneHnA THM noMeUeHMeM. VY, KOHeYHO, nyuuue 6par> apanc Ecaw asalicom onnara nomeleHia He NpONCXOAMT, yAepxnEaeTe OBecneuMTeNbHBIA NnaTéx U CooTET- CTBeHHO OcBOboxAaTE NoMeWYeHHe Nog apeHAaTopa, CaMBble HANEKHbIe BAPHAHTE: MOKHO BbILeNUTS GaHKOBCKHe rapaHTMM, HO OHM Ha PbINKe Mamo iCONBAyIOTCR, ale Ha PEINKe HCOMb3yIOTCA NOpytM- TenbCTBO, ObecneunTenbHbIe NNaTeXxM 3a HecKONbKO MecalieB, HEOBXOANMO yuNTEIBATe cneyMEKy yNpasneHus AaHHbIM apeHpHbIM BUSHECOM. OfHO eNO, Kora Bbi B apeHAY nepepaeTe NoMeULeHHe B OD- HOM 32M, Ha OOM 3Taxke, Take TAM xe yNPABNAeTe OxpaHO!, K NPUMepy, MO>KeTe OrPAaHMUMBaTh PO) atten Seuss GeO ELT hea BVBHEC | CBA3/1 #7 (499) 490-18-82 TAPAHT | PELUAIOT BCE +7 (800) 707-51-98 AOCTYN K NoMeLeHMIO MnH He OrpAHHUNBATe, AbIHOC MMyLYeCTAA M NpOUee. 3TO OAKO AeNO. Korma abi NpO- To nepenann umyuecTao 8 apeHAY uNpakTHMUECKH He CneAMTe, He yNPABNAeTe 3THM MMYLECTBOM, a NO cyTW, ocTaBunn acé apeHpaTopy, TaM cneumdnka HeMHOrO HAR, TaM KOHEYHO MyULUe NOMBIOBATECA obecneunTenbHbIMn NnaTexkaMn, Ho OBs3aTeNbHO NOCMOTpHTe 3anMCb Be MHapa O YEM Mb FOBOPHNM YyTb pane. B: Cnac6o, Anexcel, apems ae6iiapa nogxoANT k KOHUY. Y Hac OCTaNOCe Napa MMHyT, eUé pas NOBTO- ploce, 8 uaTe cemuac npoRySAMpyto CcbINKy ANA 3anONHeHUA opMbl OBpaTHoN CasaM, JanONHNe KOTOPYIO BbI rapaHTMpOBAHHO NonyuuTe pas6op MMeHHO Bale NepCOHANbHON CuTyALMM. OHO 3aTOUeHO Nos OCBO- GoxkNeHNe OT AONTOR, HO Hero He MeWiaeT HancaTe B rpacbe- ONMCaHMe CHTYALIMN ~ BaLLY TEM O B3bI~ CKaHMN 3aOMKEHHOCTH. Hanomiio, uTo Ana npeneapuTenbHon aHanuTHkH HaM DOCTaTOUHO MHH AOMKHNKa u cyMMa Aonra, ecrM 370 KaCAeTCA BSbICKAHNA C KOPHAMYECKOTO MLA NBO NACNOPTHEIX HaHHbIx MW CyMMbI AONTA, ECT 3TO Ka~ caeTca cbvanueckoro nua, KoHTaKTo BbI BADHTe Ha CoeM 3KPAHE. MpOUly BAC TAKXKE B OTBETHOM NUCEMe Ha paccuinky «CooBjecTao npemus Buskec Ycnex» npemocTasiT O6paTHyio CBAab OTHOCUTENbHO MHTe- peca k NoOMOBHON Teme. BosMOKHO, HaM CTOUT CenaTb UK BeGMHAPOB, NOTOMY UTO A BIDKy, UTO TeMa Monb3yeTCA CNPOCOM H Hy>KHb BALM NOKENAHMA M LONONHMTeNbHEIe BONPOCHI, UTO eLsé MBI XOTENM Bb PaCkpbiTe aMeCTe C BAM, A: Dpysbe, cnacu60 3a yuactue 8 Haulem BeBnMHape. OueHb Hasteiocb, uTO OH Soin nome3eH sANA BAC, C yO- BonCTBMeM OTBETHM Ha KaKNe-TO AOTIONHMTeNbHbIe Hh Bone KOHKPETHbIe BONPOCEY, NOTOMY UTO He ace XOTAT, uTO6bI CUTYALINIO pasbupANK NyBNHMUHO, HO B MIOBOM Cnyuae OMIT M KONMUECTBO yuaCTHMKOB se6nHapa He OleHb MMnOHNpYeT. BonbUoe cnacH6o, Syay 6naronaped 3a OBparhyio CaA3b. Lo HOBEIX acrpeu, Haneioce. Ynaun scent! PO) Pores atten Seuss GeO ELT