Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
JERRY AUTH1ER
University of Nebraska Medical Center
Abstract
Psychoeducation is a therapeutic approach under which the psychological
practitioner's functioning is viewed not in terms of abnormality (or illness)
diagnoses prescription — therapy -•» cure; but rather in terms of client
dissatisfaction (or ambition) -•» goal-setting — skill-teaching -•> satisfaction or goal
achievement. The contemporary roots of psychoeducation are traced from an early
era serving to set the stage for psychotherapy as an educational process, to the
behavior modification era, to the community mental health era. Content of
psychoeducation is discussed in terms of general skills (i.e., communication skills,
interpersonal skills, relationship skills, etc.) and specific skills (i.e., coping with
frustration, sexual satisfaction, handling aggressive impulses, etc.). It is concluded
psychoeducation content is limited only by the imagination of the persons seeking
help and by the ability of the psychological practitioner to be innovative and creative
enough to design a systematic program for teaching clients the psychological self-
help that will make their lives more fulfilling.
Résumé
La psychoéducation est une approche thérapeutique qui n'aborde pas la démarche
du psychologue dans une optique d'anormalité (ou maladie) -* diagnostic
recommendations - thérapie —- gucrison, mais plutôt dans l'optique du client
insatisfait (ou ambition) -»• choix de buts-»- enseignement d'habiletés — satisfaction
ou l'atteinte du but. On trace l'évolution de la psychoéducation depuis le temps où
elle servait de fondement à la psychothérapie en tant que processus éducationnel, à
travers l'époque de la modification du comportement jusqu'à l'ère des services établis
pour promouvoir la santé mentale de la communauté. On élabore le contenu de la
psychoéducation selon des habiletés d'ordre général (i.e. les compétences alliées à la
communication et aux rapports interpersonnels) et des habiletés d'ordre spécifique
(i.e. faire face à la frustration, à la satisfaction sexuelle, au contrôle d'élans aggressifs,
etc.). On conclut que le contenu de la psychoéducation ne peut être limité que par
l'imagination des personnes en quête d'aide ou par l'habileté du psychologue à être
assez innovateur et créateur pour élaborer un programme systématique qui amènera
les clients
Before discussing theàcontent
se suffire et à poursuivre
"taught" under anune vie solve
où règne l'épanouissement.
present and future psychological problems and
educational model of counselling, which is the to enhance his satisfaction with life. (p. 277)
theme of this issue of the Canadian Counsellor, it The psychoeducation model, therefore, views the
seems appropriate to define psychoeducation, role of the psychological practitioner not in terms
trace its contemporary roots, and discuss its of abnormality (or illness) diagnosis
reasons for coming into being. A definition seems prescription therapy cure; but rather in
especially important since many rather diverse terms of client dissatisfaction (or ambition)
definitions now exist. The definition promulgated goal-setting skill-teaching satisfaction (or
by Guerney, Stollak, and Guerney (1971), who goal achievement). Likewise, the client is viewed
were among the founders of the psychoeducation as a pupil rather than a patient.
movement, appears most fitting. They suggest the The roots of the psychoeducation movement
following: have been delineated elsewhere (Authier, Gustaf-
The practicing psychologist following an educational son, Guerney & Kasdorf, 1976); thus, I refer the
model is one whose work would derive directly or reader to that article for a more detailed
indirectly from a concern not with "curing" neurosis discussion. Suffice it to say that counselling and
and not with eliminating symptoms (or complaints) psychotherapy have been construed as
and not with intellectual growth per se but rather educational processes for many years, but only
with the teaching of personal and interpersonal within the last decade has a concentrated effort
attitudes and skills which the individual applies to
16 JERRY AUTHIER
been made to bring the counsellor's role in line More recently, others have questioned the
with its educational base. Early proponents of utility of the medical model for dealing with those
psychotherapy as education (Shoben, 1949; who are considered "emotionally disturbed".
Dollard & Miller, 1950; Murray, 1954; Mower, Rioch (1970), for example, specifically questioned
1950; Rotter, 1954) appeared more content to whether traditional psychotherapy was ap-
theorize than to put their theories into practice. In propriate for treating a person suffering from an
fact, several years elapsed befor theoretical emotional disturbance. She noted that the medical
principles were applied to clincial problems (e.g., model lacked respect for the patient in that it
Wolpe, 1958, 1965, 1969; Lazarus, 1960, 1961, didn't call for patient involvement; yet she
1963; Krasner, 1962a; Krasner 1962b; Ullman & suggests that patient involvement is most crucial
Krasner, 1965). In contrast to the earlier when helping someone who is emotionally
theoretical era, psychotherapy as an educational disturbed. Operating from a more empirical base,
process during the clinical application era was Ulmer and Franks (1973) suggest that many of the
characterized by a series of techniques, such as assumptions of the medical model are inap-
counter-conditioning, adversive-conditioning, propriate when caring for people who are socially
operant-conditioning, behavioral control, incompetent. They state:
stimulus control, etc., all of which were designed Proponents of this model believe that someday
to remove patient symptomatology. This long deviant physiochemical processes will be understood
awaited practical application of learning prin- and that treatment will be based upon the applica-
ciples to clincial problems served as the first force tion of suitable medical techniques. But to date there
of the psychoeducation movement, but because of
is no clear evidence that the vast majority of
its narrow emphasis on the "patient","symptom
alleviation", "cure", and, in essence, adherence to emotional disturbances are related primarily to
a medical model, this behavior modification era "organic malfunctioning", (pp. 95-96)
for the most part seemed to avoid consideration of Such imperfections as noted above may in fact
the cognitive, emotional and interpersonal be the variables responsible for researchers failing
domains of the client. Indeed, an adherence to the to find traditional approaches of psychotherapy to
medical model prevented the behavior modifiers be effective. Eysenck's (1952) now classic study,
from conceptualizing their roles as teachers with for example, demonstrated that only 44 percent of
ability to educate their "patients" in these latter all patients undergoing traditional psychoanalysis
domains. However, despite their failure to speak improved as compared to 72 percent who were
of themselves as teachers, it is readily apparent only treated custodially by general practitioners.
that the teaching function of behavior modifiers A few years later, Levitt (1957) in working with
ranges in complexity from explaining the children likewise found the "cure rate" for
rationale and application of a procedure to untreated populations to be about equal to those
serving as a consultant or program coordinator to treated by more traditional psychotherapeutic
the client via directly instructing him/her in self- approaches. He concluded: "The results do not
control techniques. Of course, the latter approach support the hypothesis that recovery from
epitomizes the therapist as a teacher in that it neurotic disorder is facilitated by psychotherapy"
embodies learning how to learn, the final goal of (p. 195). It was this kind of conclusion drawn from
most educational processes. Behavior modifica- this kind of data, therefore, which led to the
tion thus simultaneously highlighted therapy as an growing disillusion and dissatisfaction with the
educational process and the deficiency of a medical model and which provided the second
medical model for such an endeavor. major force for the psychoeducational movement.
Indeed, the inadequacy of the medical model, A third and the most contemporary — and
especially in the area of preventive mental health, perhaps the most prominent — force of the
was obvious and perhaps comprised the second psychoeducational movement has been the com-
force leading to the adoption of a psychoeduca- munity mental health movement. Hobbs in 1964,
tion model. Although behavior modification and again in 1966 with Smith, was among the first
raised the issue indirectly, Szasz (1961a, 1961b, to state the virtually unanimous conviction that
1966) was among the first to directly question the the psychological practitioner's long range answer
appropriateness of a medical model for treating to psychosocial problems lay with prevention
the "mentally ill". In essence, he noted that the rather than with remediation. If prevention was to
medical model was used to instill societal and be accomplished, it was obvious that a more direct
cultural values, and in so doing, he made helping teaching approach would need to be taken, not
professionals aware of the danger of foisting their only in terms of providing more manpower by
own value systems on others in the guise of teaching paraprofessionals counselling skills, but,
making them mentally healthy. An educational as will be discussed later, more directly teaching
orientation, which includes the student's right to those in need of help the kind of psychological
choose what he/she will learn can only benefit content necessary for them to help themselves.
from this increased awareness. The former point was highlighted in Miller's
THE PSYCHOEDUCA TION MODEL 17
(1969) presidential address to the American choeducational model is that the content (i.e., the
Psychological Association (APA) when he stated: skills to be learned) is limited only by the
"There simply are not enough psychologists even imaginations of the persons seeking help and by
including non-professionals to meet the need for the ability of the psychological practitioner to be
psychological services. The people at large will innovative and creative enough to design a
have to be their own psychologists and make their systematic program for teaching his/her clients
own application of the principles that we what they want to learn. The description which
establish" (p. 1071). This notion ofgiving psy- follows, therefore, is not an exhaustive list, but
chology away" has been voiced more recently and rather a discussion of a few of the more common
with greater frequency by Guerney (1969, 1970, psychoeducation models and the content which
1971), Carkhuff (1971), Ivey (1974), Alschulerand they emphasize. Since the content of most skill
Ivey (1973), and Lincoln (1975). Of these, the training programs can be classified as general or
latter two are particularly significant as they specific, this discussion will follow that format.
discuss teaching psychological self-help in the General skills training programs are those
classroom, thus epitomizing an eventual goal of which emphasize counselling skills, communica-
psychoeducation. tion skills, interpersonal skills, relationship skills,
As alluded to above, an offshoot of the need for etc. These programs are often mere extensions of
preventive mental health was the paraprofessional counsellor training programs. Two of the more
movement. This movement had a most significant common counsellor training programs which have
impact on the psychoeducation movement as we been adapted to the psychoeducation model are
know it today, since it called upon counsellors to those developed by Carkhuff (1969a, 1969b) and
develop methods for training paraprofessionals in Ivey (1971). Carkhuffs program has been adapted
counselling skills. To accomplish this goal, it was by several practitioners in order to teach the
necessary to design effective short-term training interpersonal skills of empathy, respect, con-
programs with wide applicability. A major creteness, genuineness, self-disclosure, confronta-
strength of the training programs which were tion, and immediacy to such diverse groups as
developed to meet this need was their structured psychiatric inpatients (Pierce & Drasgow, 1969;
emphasis on systematic experiential exercises Vitalo, 1971), parents of emotionally disturbed
designed to teach specific interpersonal skills. children (Carkhuff & Bierman, 1970), college
Psychoeducation, quite logically, follows from students (Berenson, Carkhuff & Myrus, 1966),
systematic counsellor training in that if Head Start Teachers (Bierman, Carkhuff &
paraprofessional counsellors can be taught the Santilli, 1969), groups consisting of teachers and
interpersonal skills which are often seen as parents representing different races (Carkhuff &
attributes of good mental health (Maslow, 1955; Banks, 1969), and others. Ivey's (1971) program
Jahoda, 1958) then certainly these skills can be has been used to teach similarly diverse pop-
taught to the public and perhaps even to those ulations — psychiatric inpatients, (Donk, 1971;
labeled as "psychiatric patients". Ivey, 1973; Orlando, 1974), students (Dimattia,
Research evidence demonstrating the effec- 1970), psychiatric outpatients (Haase, Forsyth,
tiveness of psychoeducation with the latter Julius & Lee, 1969; Gormally, Hill, Otis & Rainey,
population, considered by many to be the most 1975; Galassi, Galassi & Litz, 1974)—but
difficult to teach, will be discussed later. For now, emphasizes less global communication skills, such
suffice it to say that both behavior modification as attending behaviors, open-invitation-to-talk,
and the more directly conceptualized forms of paraphrasing, minimal-encourages-to-talk,
psychoeducation have demonstrable effectiveness reflection-of-feeling. To detail the adaptations of
as therapeutic modalities. These positive research these two counselling training programs to the
findings constitute a strong endorsement of the various patient training programs is not
psychoeducation model. This is especially true in warranted here. However briefly, adaptations of
light of the questionable effectiveness of more both involve teaching a variety of communication
traditional therapies. Moreover, a now classic skills by explicit instruction and feedback in
study which compared a psychoeducation model graded practice. The "therapistV'role is, therefore,
with a more traditional approach including conceptualized as that of a teacher who uses
chemotherapy found the psychoeducation model behavior shaping with emphasis on verbal
to be superior (Pierce & Drasgow, 1969). In reinforcement. Often, role playing in dyads or
conclusion, then, various research efforts suggest triads is used and both programs use audio and/or
a psychoeducation model for "teaching"behavior video feedback as an additional teaching modali-
change even for the most "recalcitrant" is a viable ty. Clearly, then, the programs as adapted
therapeutic alternative. Cumulative research for"patient" populations is psychoeducation in its
findings also are a confirming force in the truest form.
psychoeducation movement. Step Group Therapy (Authier & Fix, 1977),
Perhaps the major beauty of the psy- which blends group therapy with a behavior
18 JERRY AUTHIER
course this is a major thrust of the psy- most adults have not had the advantage of
choeducational movement. psychoeducation during their school years.
The examples above have focused mainly on Moreover, Adkins' approach appears to combine
specific skills taught to psychiatric impatient the roles of teaching and counselling thereby
populations. Obviously, other psychoeducation epitomizing what psychoeducation is all about.
models have been employed to teach specific skills Adkins (1973) states:
to non-psychiatric populations. Hunt and Azrin In many respects, the life skills program employs a
( 1973) for example, working with alcoholics use a combination of methods regularly used by excellent
psychoeducational approach to teach specific teachers and counsellors which are not often
skills such as those required for getting a job. The faithfully carried out by average teachers and
assertive training program developed by Rathus counsellors relying solely on their own resources . . .
(1973) to train volunteer college women is still therefore, through life skills, an effort is made to
another program with a specific skills emphasis.
This program teaches such specific behavior as provide a series of pre-planned but open-ended
talking about oneself, accepting compliments, structured learning experiences which with accom-
looking people in the eye, greeting, and others. panying materials can be implemented by typical
Specific psychologocial skills taught in the adult education teachers or counsellors, (p. 3)
classroom is one of the most promising Adkins goes on from here to list the characteris
developments within the psychoeducation move- which he believes a fully developed life skills
ment. Gum, Tamminen and Miller (1973) are curriculum would have. If psychoeducators keep
among the founders of this phase of the psy- these criteria in mind when developing psy-
choeducational approach and epitomize the chological self-help programs designed to meet
counsellor as a teacher of psychological self-help their trainees' specific needs or desires then
especially as it pertains to the developmental tasks certainly "pure" psychoeducation as a therapeutic
of children and adolescents when they state: modality will occur.
. . . counsellors should spend less time in "putting out It would be an injustice not to mention at least a
fires" and should attempt to become a force for the few of the rather classic specific skills training
facilitation of the full development of persons within programs that closely approximate a psy-
the school environment . . . doing all they can do .. .choeducation model. Masters and Johnson (1970)
facilitate change (such as promoting) the full training designed to increase sexual satisfaction is
one such program. Maultsley's "ABCY'adapta-
development of individual students, (p. 647) tion of Ellis' (1961, 1963) Rational Emotive
In this vein these authors have designed Therapy to teach people about their specific
"Developmental Guidance Experiences"designed irrational thoughts and how to modify these
to teach specific skills ranging from learning thoughts is another such program. Krumboltz and
physical skills necessary for ordinary games for Thoresen (1969) and Mahoney (1974) adapt a
the six year old to learning to discuss feelings psychoeducation model to teach specific skills
about sex roles for the adolescent. Other specific such as a strategy for controlling problem
skills taught in the classroom using a psy- behavior and problem solving and decision
choeducation model have been achievement making. D'Zurilla and Goldfried (1971) have used
motivation (McMullen, 1973) mastery in language a psychoeducational approach to teach specific
(Palomares & Rubine, 1973) and awareness problem solving skills. Meichenbaum's (1969)
(knowing our feelings, thoughts and actions); methods of teaching schizophrenics "healthy talk"
mastery (self-confidence) and social interaction is still another rather classic psychoeducational
(knowing other people) (Bessell, 1970). approach deserving mention. Essentially,
Psychoeducation has also been used in work Meichenbaum uses operant conditioning to help
with the same age groups in a more social context. the schizophrenic give himself spontaneous
Specific skills related to race and sex for example, instructions such as "be coherent," "be
are emphasized through psychoeducation relevant,""give healthy talk," etc. Finally, still
workshops with young adults (Anderson & Love, other specific skill training programs are those
1973; Delworth, 1973). As previously suggested, developed to help people cope with frustration
then, it is apparent that the specific skills (Giebink, Stover, & Fahl, 1968), handle aggressive
emphasized and the populations taught under a impluses (Gittelman, 1965), depression (Lewin-
psychoeducation model are limited only by the sohn, Weinstein & Shaw, 1969; Libert & Lewin-
imaginations and creativity of the participants sohn, 1973) and even to fight fair within the
involved. marital relationship (Bach & Wyden, 1969).
The life skills education course for adult It is obvious from all of the above that the
learners developed by Adkins (1970, 1973) quite psychoeducator model can no longer be denied.
aptly demonstrates this point. His approach is Indeed, it is beginning to permeate every phase of
particularly important since it highlights psy- life, from the child to the adult, from the normal
choeducation as a preventative measure in that to the "abnormal". The growth of the psy-
20 JERRY AUTHIER
choeducation model promises to meet the city pre-school teachers and family workers. Journal
demands of the public and the call for "giving of Applied Behavioral Sciences, 1971, in press.
psychology away" since the most effective way to Bizer, L. Parent program in behavioral skills. Un-
help people is to teach them to help themselves. published manual. Amherst, Massachusetts, Regional
Ulmer and Franks (1973) best summarize the Public Schools, 1971.
movement of psychoeducation as a way of Carkhuff, R. Helping and human relations: A primer for
meeting the public demand in mental health lay and professional helpers. Vol. I. Selection and
facilities when they state: training. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1969.
Traditional insights into psychotherapy and the (a)
medical model have little relevance to mental health Carkhuff, R. Helping and human relations: A primer for
facilities viewed as essentially social training in- lay and professional helpers. Vol. 2. Selection and
stitutions for disturbed and disturbing persons with training. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1969.
limited social competence. If training for community (b)
living is indeed the major function of so-called Carkhuff, R. Training as a mode of treatment. Journal
mental health facilities, it would be as well to change of Counselling Psychology, 1971, 18, 123-131.
their name to behavior-social training programs, (p. Carkhuff, R. & Banks, G. Training as a preferred mode
95) of facilitating relations between races and generations.
While these authors are only suggesting an Journal of Counselling Psychology, 1970, /7,413-418.
integrated four-level training program ranging Carkhuff, R. & Bierman, R. Training as a preferred
from state and community mental hospitals at mode of treatment of parents of emotionally disturbed
level 4 to an out-patient clinic at level 1, the children. Journal of Counselling Psychology. 1970,
psychoeducational tone is there and all that need 17, 157-161.
be added are levels beyond outpatient clinics, such Collins, J. The effects of the conjugal relationship
as self-growth clinics for the "normal" population, modification method on marital communication and
psychoeducation classes for school-age children, adjustment. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. The
and finally, continuing education in various life Pennsylvania State University, 1971.
skills. In conclusion then, the answer to the query: Cowen, E., Gardner, E. & Zax, M. (Eds.) Emergent
approaches to mental health problems. New York:
"What are the skills, knowledge, values, and
Applcton-Century-Crofts, 1967.
moral norms that are important for the counsellor
Delworth, U. Raising consciousness about sexism.
to 'teach'?", is whatever content will help the Personnel and Guidance Journal, 1973, 51. 672-674.
trainees' to lead more fulfilling lives. DiMattia, D. Personal communication. Amherst,
References University of Massachusetts, 1970.
Adkins, W. Life skills: Structured counselling for Dollard, J. & Miller, N. Personality and psychotherapy.
disadvantaged. Personnel and Guidance Journal. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1950.
1970, 49. 108-116. Donk, L. 1969, personal communication. In A. Ivey,
Adkins, W. Life skills education for adult learners. Microcounselling: Innovations in interviewing train-
Adult Leadership. 1973, 6. 1-7. ing. Springfield: CC Thomas, 1971.
Aldrige, E. & Ivey, A. The teaching of communication D'Zurilla, T. & Goldfried, M. Problem solving and
skills to junior high school students. Canadian behavior modification. Journal of Abnormal Psy-
Counsellor, in press. chology. 1971, 78, 107-126.
Alschuler, A. & Ivey, A. Getting into psychological Ellis, A. Reason and emotion in psychotherapy. New
education. Personnel and Guidance Journal, 1973,5/, York: Lyle Stuart, 1963.
682-691. Ellis, A. & Harper, R. A guide to rational living.
Anderson, N. & Love, B. Psychological education for Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1961.
racial awareness. Personnel and Guidance Journal. Ely, A., Guerney, B. & Stover, L. Efficacy of the training
1973, 51, 666-671. phase of conjugal therapy. Psychotherapy, Theroy,
Authier, J. & Fix, A. A step-group therapy program Research and Practice. 1973, 3, 201207.
based on levels of interpersonal communication. Eysenck, H. The effects of psychotherapy: An evalua-
Small Group Behavior. 1977, 8, 101-107. tion. Journalof Consulting Psychology, 1952, 16, 319-
Authier, J., Gustafson, K., Guerney, B. & Kasdorf, J. 324.
The psychological practitioner as a teacher: A Galassi, J., Galassi, M. & Litz, M. Assertive training in
theoretical-historical and practical review. Counsell- groups using video feedback. Journal of Counselling
ing Psychologist, 1976, 5, 3150. Psychology. 1974, 5, 390-394.
Bach, G. & Wyden, P. The intimate enemy. New York:Giebink, J., Stover, D. & Fahl, M. Teaching adaptive
William Morrow, 1969. responses to frustration to emotionally disturbed
Berenson, B., Carkhuff, R., & Nyrus, P. The interper- boys. Journal of Consulting Psychology. 1952, 32,
sonal functioning and training of college students. 366-368.
Journal of Counselling Psychology, 1966, 13. 441-446. Gittelman, M. Behavior rehearsal as a technique in child
Bierman, R. Carkhuff, R., & Santini, M. Efficacy of treatment. Journal of Child Psychology and Psy-
empathie communication training groups for inner- chiatry, 1965, 6. 251-255.
THE PSYCHOEDUCATION MODEL 21
doctoral dissertation. The Pennsylvania State Univer- Ullman, L. & Krasner, L. (Eds.). Case studies in
sity, 1971. behavior modification.. New York: Holt, Rinehart &
Rathus, S. Instigation of assertive behavior through Winston, 1965.
videotape—mediated assertive models and direct Ulmer, R. & Franks, C. A proposed integration of
practice. Behavior Research and Therapy, 1973, //, independent mental health facilities into behaviorally
57-65. oriented social training programs. Psychological
Rioch, M. Should psychotherapists do therapy? Reports, 1973, 32, 95-104.
Professional Psychology, 1970, /, 139-142. Vitato, R. Teaching improved interpersonal functioning
Rotter, J. Social learning and clinical psychology. as a preferred mode of treatment. Journal of
Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1954. Counselling and Clinical Psychology, 1971, 35, 166-
Shoben, E. Psychotherapy as a problem in learning 171.
theory. Psychological Bulletin, 1949, 46, 366-392. Weiss, R., Hops, H. & Patterson, G. A framework for
Smith, M. & Hobbs, N. The community and the conceptualizing marital conflict: a technology for
community mental health center. American Psy- altering it, some data for evaluating it. In L.
chologist, 1966, 21, 499-509. Hamerlynck, L. Handy, E. Mash (Eds.), Behavior
Szasz, T. The myth of mental illness: Foundation of a change: Methodology, concepts and practice. Cham-
theory of personal conduct. New York: Hoeber and paign: Research Press, 1973.
Harper, 1961(a) Wolpe, J. Psychotherapy by reciprocal inhibition.
Szasz, T. The uses of naming and the origin of the myth Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1958.
of mental illness. American Psychologist, 1961(b), 16,Wolpe, J. Conditioned inhibition of craving in drug
59-65. addiction: a pilot experiment. Behavior Research and
Szasz, T. The mental health ethic. In A.J. DeGeorge Therapy, 1965, 2, 285-288.
(Ed.), Ethics and Society. New York: Doubleday, Wolpe, J. The practice of behavior therapy. New York:
1966. Pergamon Press, 1969.