Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
August 2000
Prepared by:
The software described in this document is furnished under a license and may be used or copied only in accordance with the
terms of such license.
VSS:/Helpdev/Manuals/Fcdist/Fcdist.doc
Page
Page
FCDIST Page v
Chapter 1 Introduction
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 GENERAL
The FCDIST program calculates fault current distribution in multiple terminal transmission line and
distribution line networks. FCDIST uses a simple set of data concerning the network and has been
implemented with ease of use as an important design criterion.
A representative model of the soil structure in which the grounding system is located.
An accurate estimate of the fault current actually flowing into the grounding system.
FCDIST addresses the second of these key requirements. By providing the user with an accurate estimate
of fault current distribution, and hence the actual fault current flowing into a grounding system, FCDIST
makes it possible to avoid over-design of the grounding system due to otherwise necessary conservative
assumptions regarding the fault current entering the grounding system under study. This can result in
significant time and financial savings.
There are computer-based modeling methods available which can produce more accurate and realistic
calculations of the fault current distribution. Three such methods are described below, in increasing
order of sophistication:
Model the network under study as a simplified ladder network consisting of the transmission line
series and shunt impedances for each span. This type of model ignores inductive coupling between
the transmission line phases and the neutral wires.
Make a computer model of the transmission line network incorporating a single phase wire (which
can be used to represent all three phases), and a single (possibly bundled) neutral conductor. The
transmission line parameters are assumed to remain constant across all the spans in any given arm of
the transmission line network. This model accounts for coupling between the phase wire and the
neutral. Structure ground impedances are assumed to be equal for all structures in any arm of the
network. This is the approach taken by FCDIST.
Make a complete computer circuit model of the transmission line right-of-way. This model accounts
individually for the self and mutual impedances of every phase and neutral conductor, as well as
other non-energized conductors. Varying parameters, including the structure ground impedances, can
be specified for each section (or span) of the network. This approach is taken by SPLITS, which is
distributed with the MultiGround+, MultiFields+ and CDEGS software packages.
Section 3.5 of Chapter 3 shows how to enter FCDIST data using the command mode approach.
i) For most convenience, use the Output Toolbox or the SIRPS report and plot generator to extract
information from the machine-readable database file. SIRPS (which is used internally by Output
Toolbox) can extract a summary of the most important results and display it promptly on your
screen or save it in a report file for subsequent printing. SIRPS can also prepare customized
reports and plots, for immediate display on your video screen or subsequent hardcopy printing.
See the Getting Started manual and the SIRPS User's Manual for details on how to use
SIRPS. Consult the various How To… manuals for more details about the Output Toolbox.
ii) Edit or print the user-readable printout file which contains complete computation results. Note
that this file can be quite long, so verify its length before printing it!
Note that no results are automatically displayed on your screen or on your printer when a FCDIST run
ends. In order to view your results, proceed as described above.
Complete information on how to prepare input files for the program in a command mode session, a
dialogue mode session, and a menu-mode session is presented in the SICL user's manuals and in various
How To… manuals. Information on how to produce graphical output using the interactive output
processor is given in the SIRPS User's Manual and in the How To… manuals.
Chapter 2: provides an explanation of the input data required by FCDIST and how this data is used
to create a circuit model of the transmission line network.
Chapter 3: describes the FCDIST input command file, and how to prepare an FCDIST input file
using the SICL input processor.
Appendix A: specifies the default values used by the program when the user does not specify a
particular value for a given parameter.
Appendix B: explains the assignment of the files created and used by FCDIST.
Appendix C: explains the relationship between the relative permeability of a conductor and its GMR
or reactance at 1 foot spacing. This appendix also explains the relation between resistivity and AC
and DC resistance.
Note that while this manual presents all necessary background material for running FCDIST and
provides examples of how to prepare FCDIST input files, it does not describe all available commands in
full detail. A list of these commands is printed in the small booklet entitled SES Input Command
Language Reference Guide. A full description of each command is located in the SICL/CSIRPS
Structured Command Help Reference (available from the program in the form of Windows help, and
via the SICL/CSIRPS command prompt by typing HELP).
References
1. Janos Endreyni, "Analysis of Transmission Tower Potential During Ground Faults," IEEE
Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-86, No. 10, October 1967.
2. F. Dawalibi, D. Bensted, D. Mukhedkar, "Soil Effects on Ground Fault Currents," IEEE
Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-100, No. 7, July 1981, pp. 3442-3450.
1) Central Site. This is a node which connects to all arms of the network. The user must specify the
central site ground impedance (i.e., shunt impedance). Typically this site represents a faulted
substation or transmission line structure and the shunt impedance is set equal to the ground
impedance (resistance) of the faulted site. Only one central site can exist in a given FCDIST run.
2) Terminal Stations. At least one, and possibly several, terminal stations may exist in each
FCDIST model. The terminal stations consist of a specified ground impedance representing the
impedance of the terminating station ground network, and a current source which energizes the
transmission line. The data specified by the user is as follows:
• Terminals: each arm of the transmission line ends in a terminal section. The user enters the
terminal ground impedance and, optionally, the terminal name.
• Sources: each arm of the network is energized by current sources whose current can be
specified with an arbitrary magnitude and phase relative to each other (i.e., as a complex
number). Each source is connected via a lead with a specified series impedance to the
transmission line neutral. This lead also has a mutual impedance with respect to the phase
wire.
3) Transmission lines. The transmission line is modeled as a single phase wire and single bundled
neutral conductor. Each transmission line is made up of sections (i.e., spans) which are all of the
same length. Each span is terminated by a ground shunt connected to the neutral bundle. This
represents the ground impedance of the transmission line towers connected to the neutral lead.
Each section of the neutral has a series impedance and mutual impedance with respect to the
phase wire. Data entered by the user is given below:
• Phase Wire: the location of the phase wire is specified in terms of its cross sectional location
in the right-of-way.
• Neutral Wire Bundle: The FCDIST model also includes a single neutral (i.e., ground) lead.
The neutral lead can be a conductor bundle composed of several conductors regularly
arranged on the perimeter of a circle. Location of the bundle is specified in terms of the
position of the bundle centre and the number of conductors, and the position of the first
conductor. See Section 2.3 for more details. The neutral lead has a series impedance and a
mutual impedance with respect to the phase wire, which can be calculated by the program or
specified by the user. More details are provided in Section 2.3.
• Section Shunt: Each section (or span) of the transmission line has a ground shunt impedance
located at its extremity, away from the central site. The section shunt represents the ground
impedance of the transmission line structures. This ground shunt is a complex valued
quantity which is the same for all structures in a given arm of the transmission line network.
• The user must also specify the span length and the number of spans in each transmission line
arm.
Note that terminal, source, neutral, section and phase parameters must be specified separately for each
transmission line arm.
To fully describe the transmission line network it also necessary to specify the electric characteristics
(resistivity and permeability) of the soil in which the network is located. A uniform soil model is used.
The user must also specify the power system frequency.
All conductors should be in air. If any conductors are in soil, the program prints an error message and
terminates.
For the neutral conductors, the program accepts self and mutual impedances in one of two modes. The
first is the impedance mode: the equivalent self impedance and mutual impedance of the reduced neutral
bundle is specified directly by the user. For a bundled neutral conductor, the equivalent self impedance
and mutual impedance are given by the following equations:
FG ∑ Z IJ
Zse = Zs +
n
H K i=2
m li n
F n
I
= G∑ Z J n
Z me
H K
i=1
m Ai
where
Z m Ai is the mutual impedance between each conductor in the bundle and the phase conductor
(in ohms).
Zse is the equivalent self impedance (in ohms).
Z me is the equivalent mutual impedance between the bundle conductor and the phase
conductor (in ohms).
The second available mode is the characteristics mode. When this mode is selected, the program
calculates the equivalent self impedance and mutual impedance of the bundle after reduction based on
the physical characteristics and configuration of the conductors. The required input data is described in
the following points.
The span length. The span length is the same for all sections in a given arm of the transmission line
network. When the impedances are specified directly, the span length is not used.
Required data for the neutral conductor bundle:
Relative permeability of the neutral conductor(s). Alternatively, this value can also be specified as
the geometric mean radius or the 60 hertz reactance at 1 foot spacing of the conductor (the option
selected depends on the setting of a flag specified by the user).
Relative resistivity of the neutral conductor(s). Alternatively, the user can specify this parameter in
terms of the conductor dc resistance or the conductor ac resistance (the option selected depends on
the setting of a flag specified by the user).
External radius of the neutral conductors.
Internal radius of the neutral conductors, in the case of hollow conductors (this is 0 for solid
conductors).
Required phase conductor data:
For the phase conductor, the coordinates of the faulted phase must be specified when the
characteristics of the conductors are specified in order to calculate the mutual impedance between the
phase wire and the neutral wire. When the impedances are entered directly by the user, the phase
coordinates are not used.
The program accepts source currents in cartesian or polar notation. By default, the program uses the
cartesian notation.
3.1 INTRODUCTION
The data specifying the transmission line network parameters required by FCDIST is contained in a
command file. The command file is a plain-text file which is composed of English-like commands and
is essentially self-explanatory. The command file is processed by FCDIST, which extracts from it all
necessary engineering data and run control data. FCDIST then calculates the required parameters based
on the data contained in the command file. The FCDIST Command Language is explained in Section
3.2, while Section 3.3 explains the hierarchy of FCDIST commands. Section 3.4 shows a template
command input file which can be used as a model for all FCDIST command input files. The mechanisms
for preparing this input data using the SICL input processor is explained in Section 3.5. This section uses
a sample study to illustrate the different input methods.
At the top of the FCDIST command hierarchy is the Program Command ("FCDIST") which is unique.
Below this level are the Module Commands, then commands belonging to each module, and then the
subcommands belonging to each command.
It is important to note that if an input file is created interactively using the SICL input preprocessor, or if
a manually prepared input file is to be read by SICL, it is possible to skip certain command levels in the
hierarchy. In SICL, any command which takes no qualifiers or variables, and which only serves to
introduce subcommands can be omitted in the input file. SICL will prompt the user to resolve any
ambiguities, or SICL will fill in the command itself, if the default SICL setting is used. If the input file
is to be read directly by FCDIST (or any other engineering program), it must include all commands in
the hierarchy.
If the input file is prepared using the SMILS input processor, it is not necessary to specify all commands.
Like SICL, SMILS will fill in missing commands and supply default input values. Likewise, if an input
file is read in using SMILS, many commands can be omitted from the input file, and SMILS will fill
them in as necessary. Since the SIDS input processor is dialogue-driven, it will prompt the user for all
necessary input data, and provide appropriate default input values as required.
Note also that it is possible to specify the different modules of an FCDIST input file in any order, but
certain error and warning messages may be adversely affected if a logical order is not respected for
certain commands. Consider, for example, the command UNITS of the OPTIONS module; any data
specified before the UNITS command will be assumed to be in METRIC units for the purposes of error-
checking, whether metric or British units are specified by the UNITS command. Within a given module,
commands which are logically independent, for example the commands RUN-IDENTIFI and UNITS of
the OPTIONS module, can be specified in any order. In general, however, you should follow the order
set out in the sample input files of this chapter when specifying most types of data, since many
commands within a module must follow each other in a specific order. Note that if a non-cumulative
command such as UNITS is specified more than once, then the setting specified by the last appearance
of the command in the input file will be retained.
3.5.1 Introduction
Alternative methods exist for preparing the input data required by FCDIST. The prefered method is to
use the Input Toolbox. This is outlined in the Getting Started manual and described in details in various
How To… manuals. This chapter describes the command mode of data entry using a typical engineering
problem which is described in detail in Section 3.5.2.
A 230 kV line-to-ground fault occurs at Substation EAST CENTRAL. There is a double circuit
transmission line between each terminal and the substation. The fault occurs on Phase A of Circuit 1.
Each tower has two neutral conductors of the 7 No. 8 alumoweld type and the phase wires are 795 MCM
Drake. The GMR and the average AC resistance for the neutral wires are 0.002085 feet and 2.785
Ω/mile, respectively.
The ground resistances of the transmission line towers in the GREENBAY-EAST CENTRAL arm of the
network, which are 1/5 mile apart, are all assumed to be equal to 10 Ω. The towers in the HUDSON-
EAST CENTRAL and NEWHAVEN-EAST CENTRAL arms, which are also 1/5 mile apart, have a
higher resistance of 28 Ω.
The ground resistance of all three terminals is assumed to be constant and equal to 0.2 Ω, 0.3 Ω and 0.3
Ω for the GREENBAY, HUDSON and NEWHAVEN terminals, respectively. The ground network
impedance at the fault location (Substation EAST CENTRAL)is assumed to be proportional to the local
soil resistivity ρ. Calculations have shown that for a soil resistivity of 100 Ω-m, the resistance of one
possible grid design is equal to 0.32 Ω.
When a fault occurs on phase A at Central Site, the currents in each phase are as follows:
In the circuit model, only a single phase wire is specified, which carries the vector sum of the three phase
wire currents under fault conditions. The location of this single phase corresponds to the location of the
faulted Phase A of Figure 3.3.
The location of both neutral wires is specified. They are considered to be a pair of bundled conductors,
with the bundle centre 115 feet high, at the midpoint of the transmission line tower. The radius of the
neutral bundle is half the distance between the neutral wires, i.e., 24 feet.
1. Determine the distribution of the fault current between the ground wires and the ground network at
the fault location.
2. Determine the magnitude of the current which returns to the power source via the terminal grounds.
3. Determine the influence of the mutual impedances between phase and ground wires. This manifests
itself as a "trapped" current in the ground wires.
A printout of the results file for the sample problem is stored in file FCDISOUT.PUT which is shipped
with the software.
Interactive input sessions using SICL are explained in detail in the SICL User's Manual, and also in
Chapter 6 of the Getting Started manual.
FCDIST
TEXT,SAMPLE TEST OF FCDIST
TEXT,MULTIGROUND ANALYSIS
OPTION
RUN-IDEN,FCDIST_INPUT
UNITS,INCH_RAD
PRINTOUT,DETAIL
OUTPUT,BOTH
!,
SYSTEM
AVERAGE_SOIL,100.0
FREQUENCY,60.0
GRID,EAST CENTRAL,0.32,0.0
!,===================================================
TERMINAL,GREENBAY
EARTH,0.2,0.0
SOURCES,CARTESIAN,1225.88,-5013.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0
SECTION,66,1056.0,10.0,0.0
PHASE,16.0,92.5
BUNDLE,0.0,115.0,24.0,0.0,2
NEUTRAL,0.002085,2.785,.1925,0.0,2,3
!,===================================================
TERMINAL,HUDSON
EARTH,0.3,0.0
SOURCES,CARTESIAN,722.02,-6452.57,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0
SECTION,27,1056.0,28.0,0.0
PHASE,16.0,92.5
BUNDLE,0.0,115.0,24.0,0.0,2
NEUTRAL,0.002085,2.785,.1925,0.0,2,3
!,===================================================
TERMINAL,NEWHAVEN
EARTH,0.3,0.0
SOURCES,CARTESIAN,744.90,-5678.771,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0
SECTION,35,1056.0,28.0,0.0
PHASE,16.0,92.5
BUNDLE,0.0,115.0,24.0,0.0,2
NEUTRAL,0.002085,2.785,.1925,0.0,2,3
ENDPROGRAM
APPENDIX A
DEFAULT SETTINGS
The default setting is the value used by the program when the command specifying a given parameter is
not entered by the user. The default parameter values are as follows:
SOIL CHARACTERISTICS
=====================
Average soil resistivity : 100.00 Ohm-meter
Soil relative permeability : 1.00
CENTRAL SITE
============
Central site name : CENTRAL SITE
Central site impedance : 0.10 + j 0.00 Ohms
Number of terminals : 1
TERMINAL
========
Name : TERM_n (n is the terminal number)
Earth Impedance : 0.10 + j 0.00 Ohms
Source Current : 10000.0 + j 0.00 Amp.
Neutral Connection Impedance : 0.00 + j 0.00 Ohms
Mutual Impedance : 0.00 + j 0.00 Ohms
Number of Sections : 1
Span Length : 1000.00 Meters
Shunt Impedance : 10.00 + j 0.00 Ohms
Phase Conductor
===============
X Coordinates (Xp) : 0.00 Meters
Y Coordinates (Yp) : 25.00 Meters
APPENDIX B
The input file (Unit 5) contains all the information you need to supply. The main output file (Unit 9)
contains a formatted summary of the input data and all pertinent computation results. The database file
(Unit 21) contains all pertinent computation results in a format accessible by the SIRPS plotting and
report-generation software.
APPENDIX C
Relative Resistivity = K 2 * R DC * R 2
or
Relative Resistivity = K 2 * R AC * R 2
Where:
What is your general reaction to this manual (format, accuracy, organization, etc.)?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
Additional comments:
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
Mail to:
Safe Engineering Services & technologies ltd
Software Products
1544 Viel
Montreal, Quebec
Canada, H3M 1G4